
Talking Real Money - Investing Talk
Don McDonald
Financial talk radio veteran, Don McDonald and former host of Serious Money on PBS, Tom Cock, join forces to talk about real money issues. In each episode, they solve real money problems, dole out real investing (not speculating) advice, and really explain the financial issues that effect all of us. Plus, it's actually fun! Talking Real Money is a podcast designed to provide the real help we all need to enjoy a really great future. Call in with your questions anytime at 855-935-TALK (8255).
Ep. 2022: The DIY Dilemma
Episode discussion: DIY investors face emotional pitfalls; fiduciary coaching and MYGA risks discussed
Speakers’ claims: Don and Tom argue that DIY investors often underperform due to emotional mistakes, citing Dalbar and Vanguard data showing significant behavior gaps. They recommend hiring an 'always-on' fiduciary advisor primarily for behavioral coaching rather than market timing. The hosts also compare Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuities (MYGAs) to CDs, noting MYGAs offer higher yields but carry insurer risk and early withdrawal penalties. Finally, they discuss book recommendations and a podcast hijacking incident.
Ep. 2021: Enough to Retire?
Episode discussion: Hosts address retirement readiness, tax strategy, and fund selection for listeners.
Speakers’ claims: The hosts discuss a recent market decline, advising global diversification and value tilts to mitigate losses. They confirm that a $5 million portfolio is sufficient for retirement at age 66 given Social Security benefits. The hosts recommend a mix of Traditional and Roth IRA contributions to manage current tax brackets and future uncertainty. They favor federal money market funds over FDIC sweeps for safety, citing Treasury backing. Finally, they criticize high-expense target date funds, suggesting low-cost, diversified alternatives for young investors.
Ep. 2020: When the Meme Stock Took Off
Episode discussion: GameStop volatility and tax-efficient account allocation discussed
Speakers’ claims: Speakers analyze the 2021 GameStop meme-stock frenzy, contrasting passive index funds with rules-based factor funds like Dimensional that automatically sold the stock. They highlight that DFA Small Cap funds outperformed the Russell 2000 during this period due to diversification and disciplined selling. The discussion shifts to tax optimization, advising listeners to hold equities in Roth and taxable accounts while placing bonds in traditional IRAs. Finally, they clarify the withdrawal rules for 403(b) versus 457(b) plans and explain spousal rollover procedures for inherited 401(k)s.
Ep. 2019: The Easy Money Trap
Episode discussion: Hosts warn against high-cost Merchant Cash Advances and discuss small-cap fund selection and 401(k) PCRA benefits
Speakers’ claims: Don McDonald and Tom Cock discuss the dangers of Merchant Cash Advances (MCAs), citing extreme APRs and unregulated practices that can trap small businesses in debt. They suggest alternatives like SBA loans, local banks, and SCORE counseling, while advising business owners to assess viability before taking on high-cost debt. The hosts also address a caller's question on asset location across account types, recommending treating all accounts as one portfolio. In the second half, they compare the SCHA and AVUV funds for small-cap exposure and explain the benefits of using a PCRA within a 401(k) for investment flexibility and ERISA protections.
Ep. 2018: All Gas, No Brakes
Episode discussion: Hosts critique 100% stock retirement portfolios and Dave Ramsey's advice using Monte Carlo simulations
Speakers’ claims: Don and the hosts discuss academic studies advocating for 100% stock portfolios in retirement, arguing they ignore sequence risk and emotional stress. They critique Dave Ramsey's investment advice for relying on high-cost funds and unrealistic return assumptions. The speakers present Monte Carlo simulations showing that even with optimistic return assumptions, high withdrawal rates often lead to portfolio failure due to sequence risk. They also address listener questions regarding split-dollar insurance and tax implications.
Ep. 2017: The Eggs-in-One-Basket Conundrum
Episode discussion: Don and Tom discuss diversification risks, emergency fund strategies, and Vanguard fund conversions
Speakers’ claims: Don and Tom introduce Rule 17 from the Book of Financial Physics, arguing that owning stocks in different industries does not provide true diversification and that investors face significant risks from individual stock failures like Enron or WorldCom. They emphasize the necessity of diversifying across asset classes, including small-cap, value, and international equities, citing the S&P 500's decade-long loss period from 2000 to 2010 and Japan's Nikkei index peak in 1990. The hosts advise against adding micro-cap funds due to lack of robust evidence for excess returns and warn against withdrawing from retirement accounts for emergency funds, suggesting rebalancing instead. They clarify that converting Vanguard mutual funds to ETFs defers but does not eliminate capital gains taxes, as the original cost basis carries over. Finally, they cite Bureau of Labor Statistics data showing that approximately 12% of Americans over age 70 remain employed, highlighting the need for long-term retirement planning.
Ep. 2016: Five Questions, Clearer Choices
Episode discussion: Don addresses annuities, ETF conversions, and Roth IRA strategies for young investors
Speakers’ claims: Don responds to listener questions on retirement income, fund structures, and savings vehicles. He contrasts immediate annuities with self-managed withdrawals, highlighting the lack of inflation protection and heir benefits in standard annuities. He advises converting specific Vanguard mutual funds to ETFs to avoid capital gains distributions without reducing dividend income. For a 20-year-old, he recommends a Roth IRA with small-cap and value tilts like AVGE or DFAW. Finally, he analyzes promotional high-yield savings accounts as marketing gimmicks that may not be worth the logistical hassle.
Ep. 2015: The Smart Money Myth
Episode discussion: Carthage College indexing outperforms elite endowments; low-cost ETFs preferred over complex alternatives
Speakers’ claims: Speakers argue that elite university endowments often underperform simple public market indices despite hiring expensive experts, citing Carthage College's 9.5% annualized return versus a 7.7% average for peers. They validate simple two-fund portfolios using VT and BND, suggesting Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) as a rebalancing tool. The hosts recommend low-cost ETFs like AVUV, VOO, and VT over higher-fee alternatives such as LCRX, SPY, and AVGE, emphasizing the importance of expense ratios and diversification.
Ep. 2014: The Inflation You Feel
Episode discussion: Speakers analyze sector-specific inflation trends and compare international index fund fees and performance.
Speakers’ claims: Hosts John McDonald and Tom Cock discuss how inflation impacts different sectors, noting that healthcare and education costs have far outpaced general inflation while electronics prices have dropped. They argue that the S&P 500 has served as a superior inflation hedge compared to cash since 1990. In listener Q&A, they address bond yield sustainability against inflation and compare international index funds from Fidelity, Vanguard, and Avantis. The hosts conclude that Avantis's rules-based approach may justify its higher fees through historical outperformance.
Ep. 2013: Betting Against Your Future
Episode discussion: Hosts critique Gen Z gambling trends and mock standard retirement withdrawal advice as unoriginal
Speakers’ claims: Don and Tom discuss a Betterment survey showing Gen Z investors withdrawing funds for sports gambling, contrasting the -25% expected return of betting with the ~10% historical return of equities. They argue that the opportunity cost of gambling is the lost compound growth of capital over time. The hosts also satirize recent media coverage of retirement withdrawal strategies, such as the 4% rule, as stale advice that lacks innovation. They emphasize the importance of low-cost index funds, diversified portfolios, and flexible Investment Policy Statements with cash buffers to manage sequence-of-return risk.
Ep. 2012: The Price of Free
Episode discussion: Hosts critique hidden insurance fees and explain bond fund mechanics while addressing listener retirement planning questions.
Speakers’ claims: The hosts critique the financial services industry for obscuring costs, specifically highlighting how insurance companies embed advisor commissions into high-fee products like annuities and target-date funds. They contrast these with lower-cost alternatives from providers like Vanguard and emphasize the importance of fee-only advisory models. The episode also addresses listener questions regarding retirement income strategies, including Social Security timing and 72(t) distributions, and clarifies the mechanics of bond ETF yields versus price performance.