FidelityConnects

Denise Chisholm argues market internals, inflation data, and historical election patterns support continued equity upside.

28 min Listen to the original Episode page
Market InternalsInflationGDPLabor MarketTechnology SectorMidterm ElectionsFederal ReserveValuation

Summary

Fidelity's Denise Chisholm argues that despite negative headlines, the market has climbed the wall of worry because recession fears were unfounded. She highlights that aggressive VIX spikes, when credit spreads are stable, historically predict better 12-month returns. Chisholm distinguishes between headline inflation and core CPI excluding shelter, which she views as a shock, stating that core CPI ex-shelter is around 2% across multiple timeframes. She notes that 'final sales' (GDP excluding imports) is accelerating, which historically is the best predictor of accelerating GDP and strong stock market performance over the next year. Chisholm asserts that the technology sector's aggregate free cash flow exceeds capital expenditures, indicating no underlying anomaly in profitability. She concludes that the stock market has advanced 100% of the time in the five years following midterms since 1930, suggesting divided government reduces policy uncertainty and benefits stocks.

Episode sections

  1. 0:57 – 2:49

    Market Internals and Volatility Patterns

    Denise Chisholm explains that despite negative headlines, the market has climbed the wall of worry because recession fears were unfounded. She highlights that aggressive VIX spikes, when credit spreads are stable, historically predict better 12-month returns. She notes that since 1962, the S&P 500 has declined 5-15% in 60% of years but ended higher in 75% of those years.

  2. 2:49 – 4:34

    Defensive Rotation and Valuation Signals

    Chisholm identifies a defensive rotation into consumer staples, healthcare, and utilities, noting that such rotations often peak when defensive valuations become expensive relative to the broader market. She argues that high defensive valuations serve as a contrarian indicator, with a strong historical correlation to positive market returns over the following year.

  3. 4:34 – 6:53

    Underlying Inflation and Fed Policy

    The speaker distinguishes between headline inflation and core CPI excluding shelter, which she views as a shock. She states that core CPI ex-shelter is around 2% across multiple timeframes, suggesting underlying inflation is not a persistent problem for the Fed. She estimates rates may need to rise ~75bps to align with nominal growth but argues slow hikes are absorbable.

  4. 6:53 – 9:49

    GDP, Final Sales, and Economic Health

    Chisholm argues that quarterly GDP data shows no discernible trend due to seasonality, while year-over-year real GDP growth is ~2% and slowing. She highlights that 'final sales' (GDP excluding imports) is accelerating, which historically is the best predictor of accelerating GDP and strong stock market performance over the next year.

  5. 9:49 – 12:30

    Labor Market Inflection and Hiring Boom

    The speaker describes a 'jobless recovery' where corporate profits led but hiring lagged. She notes that leading indicators like durable goods orders and the Conference Board's Jobs Plentiful Survey are inflecting positively. Historically, when consumers perceive jobs becoming plentiful, payroll growth confirms this trend over the subsequent year.

  6. 12:30 – 14:58

    AI, Productivity, and Labor Supply

    Chisholm cites a Federal Reserve paper concluding AI has not caused the jobless recovery, attributing it instead to remote work. She argues that labor demand increases are often matched by supply increases (e.g., rising labor force participation), mitigating wage inflation risks. She asserts there is no consistent data pattern linking accelerating growth to accelerating inflation.

  7. 14:58 – 20:21

    Technology Sector Fundamentals and Valuation

    The speaker asserts that the tech sector's aggregate free cash flow exceeds capital expenditures, indicating no underlying anomaly in profitability. She notes that lower starting valuations correlate with higher upside risk, even if earnings decline, as the market often prices in bad news. She suggests investors should ask what could go right rather than focusing solely on CapEx ROI concerns.

  8. 20:21 – 28:18

    Midterm Election Patterns and Sector Leadership

    Chisholm highlights that the stock market has advanced 100% of the time in the five years following midterms since 1930. She argues that divided government, which often follows midterms, reduces policy uncertainty and benefits stocks. She uses healthcare in the mid-90s as an example where feared legislation led to sector outperformance as the market discounted the negative news in advance.

Assets discussed

AssetKindStanceContext
S&P 500indexbullishSo I'm not saying like the market's bottomed here. I'm not saying that it bottoms into three months. But if you look over the course of one year, the only time the S P 500 has been negative when defense has been this expensive is the dot com bubble.

“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.

Claims worth verifying

Since 1962, the S&P 500 has declined 5-15% in 60% of years but ended the year higher in 75% of those years.

Denise Chisholm ·1:57

How to verify: Calculate S&P 500 annual returns from Yahoo Finance or S&P Dow Jones Indices data for the period 1962-present. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Core CPI excluding shelter is around 2% over the last year, six-month, and three-month trends.

Denise Chisholm ·5:14

How to verify: Check US Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) CPI data, calculating Core CPI (CPI ex-food and energy) and then excluding the shelter component. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The stock market has advanced 100% of the time in the five years following midterm elections since 1930.

Denise Chisholm ·20:41

How to verify: Identify US midterm election years from 1930 to present; calculate S&P 500 total return for the five-year period following each election using Federal Reserve Economic Data (FRED) or S&P data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Since 1960, the S&P 500 has been negative over a 12-month horizon only during the dot-com bubble when defensive valuations were at their highest relative to the market.

Denise Chisholm ·23:09

How to verify: Calculate relative valuation multiples (e.g., P/E) of Consumer Staples, Healthcare, and Utilities vs. S&P 500 from 1960-present; correlate with subsequent 12-month S&P 500 returns. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Consumer discretionary sector has 77% odds of outperforming when job growth is weak, versus 30% odds when job growth is strong.

Denise Chisholm ·24:55

How to verify: Define 'weak' vs 'strong' job growth thresholds using BLS payroll data; calculate relative performance of Consumer Discretionary Index vs. S&P 500 in subsequent periods. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Consumer discretionary stocks underperformed by almost 3,000 basis points over the last year.

Denise Chisholm ·25:55

How to verify: Compare total returns of a Consumer Discretionary Index (e.g., XLY) against the S&P 500 for the trailing 12-month period ending Nov 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

A Federal Reserve paper concluded AI did not cause the jobless recovery, attributing it to remote work.

Denise Chisholm ·15:15

How to verify: Search Federal Reserve Board publications or working papers for studies linking remote work prevalence to hiring trends and AI impact on employment. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Divided government follows midterms 80% of the time since 1980.

Denise Chisholm ·20:56

How to verify: Check US Congress party control data from 2026 to present; calculate frequency of divided government (one chamber majority different from President) following midterm elections. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Core CPI ex-shelter is 2% over the last year.

Denise Chisholm ·5:14

How to verify: US Bureau of Labor Statistics CPI data; subtract shelter component from headline CPI and calculate year-over-year percentage change. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Technology sector aggregate free cash flow exceeds capital expenditures.

Denise Chisholm ·15:55

How to verify: Aggregate financial statements of major technology companies (e.g., via S&P Capital IQ or Bloomberg) to compare total Free Cash Flow to total CapEx. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify S&P 500 historical performance data for years with 5-15% declines using FRED or S&P Global data.
  • Check current Core CPI ex-shelter trends via Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) releases.
  • Review Conference Board's Jobs Plentiful Survey historical data for correlation with subsequent payroll growth.
  • Analyze Fidelity's or other sources' data on Technology sector free cash flow vs. capital expenditures.
  • Confirm midterm election market performance statistics from 1930 to present using historical market data providers.
  • Assess labor force participation rates and remote work trends to evaluate labor supply responses.
  • Review Federal Reserve papers on AI and productivity impacts on employment.
  • Monitor defensive sector valuation multiples relative to the broader market to identify contrarian signals.
Full transcriptexpand

0:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Hello and welcome to Fidelity Connects. As we look ahead to 2027, US hiring is holding up, inflation remains elevated, and the Fed is keeping rates steady. At the same time, swings in tech stocks are raising a question about how much investors are paying today for the promise of AI. As market leadership continues to shift and investors look for more defensive opportunities, what should they be watching next?

0:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We're

0:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): joined by Director of Quantitative Market Strategy, Denise Chisholm, to discuss market dynamics, sector leadership trends, and opportunities that may emerge in the coming months. Welcome, Denise. It's great to have you joining us today.

0:43Denise Chisholm: Great to be back.

0:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

0:45Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): we've seen a lot of volatility in market headlines recently, but just wanted to start our conversation today with taking a step back from all of the news and really hear your thoughts on how you're viewing the underlying market and the economy today.

0:57Denise Chisholm: Yeah, I think it's interesting. When you think about the equity market, I think that we've over the last let's call it four years, have just been bombarded with slews of negative headlines. And somehow, some way, the market has managed to sort of climb the wall of worry through whatever. those concerns were going to be, partly because it didn't end up in some sort of recessionary event. So, with all of the headlines, you never really can discern. I mean, I'm a quant, you certainly can't discern like what is actually going to impact the market from a fundamental perspective because the market will discount in advance. So, one of the things that I do is look at the internals of the market and that has actually been very patterned historically. So things like really aggressive spikes in the VIX, especially when credit spreads have been fairly mitigated, is usually a better setup when you look over the course of the next 12 months than a worse setup, which is not to say that markets don't correct. I mean we always say you know corrections are normal and healthy and they happen. until, of course, they happen. But you know, to give you some numbers with that, 60% of the year since 1962, the market, the SP 500, has gone down anywhere between five and 15%, which we're not even down that yet. Which, you know, between five and 15%,

2:17and still ended the year higher in 75% of those years. So that's sort of the math behind by the dip. And if you look at the internals of the market, when you see that volatility and see those patterns consistently, they usually point to opportunity rather than the opposite.

2:34Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): That's a great reminder and a reframe for everyone. Curious to hear your view on overall sentiment or pessimism. Of course, we know that markets will price in certain negative news before it actually happens in the market or economy. Do you think the markets are pricing in too much bad news today?

2:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

2:50Denise Chisholm: this is the interesting thing from a defensive rotation perspective. So we've seen a sharp rotation away from technology into consumer staples, healthcare, and you know, uh utilities and the old telecommunication services, which is skewed defensive. And those baskets usually outperform substantially in recessions, but we do get these sort of normal events where there's a normal defensive rotation. And then there have been more defensive rotations. in credit events like 97, 98, and even in you know in 2018 that we saw. And we're right in the middle of those. So we've seen already a bulk of a defensive rotation. Now the interesting part to that pattern is: is there a pattern between the starting point on valuation, meaning how expensive defense is, and then how the SP ends up the year later? And there is. The more expensive defensive stocks become relative to the rest of the market, the more likely the market is to be up over the course of the next year. It's almost like it's an internal litmus test of how paranoid investors are. Now, this doesn't mean over any six-week period or every three-month period, but it does mean that if you are willing to look over a one-year time horizon and potentially look past a trough or a correct correction, there's usually opportunities. So by the time investors have been paranoid enough to crowd into defensive

4:09sectors to bid up those defensive valuations, you usually are long in the tooth in terms of being well on the way towards the end of that defensive rotation, not the beginning.

4:20Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): That's a good reminder as well. Let's bring inflation and interest rates into the conversation. Should how do you uh really view if if it if rates and inch and inflation stay higher for longer, should investors be worried about that?

4:34Denise Chisholm: So as it relates to the consumer, inflation is always and everywhere a problem, right? So I don't want to, you know, uh uh dismiss any of the angst the about the real incomes being negative for the consumer because they are. As it relates to inflation being a problem for the two things, one, the federal Reserve, and two, the market overall, I think that you have to look at core inflation. And I think that you have to look at X shelter. And when you look at core inflation as the CPI and you take out shelter, right now we're looking at everything else, presumably that the Fed has some control over, right? So this is sort of why they think about that's the underlying rate of inflation, X these past shocks in terms of oil, and I would call shelter a shock. When you look at that, the core CPI X shelter over the last year is around 2%. And when you look at it over a six-month trend, it's 2%. And when you look at it over a three-month trend, you see some elevation, but you see the stochatic pattern back and forth. Meaning that, look, I'm unconvinced when I look at the data that underlying inflation. is a continued problem as it relates to the Federal Reserve. So to the extent, and we'll see whatever ends up happening, when these shocks roll off, that is what you're looking at for your underlying inflation, which might mean the Federal

5:53Reserve has less to do than the market thinks. Now, it it does look like relative to nominal growth, they're a little too low, right? Which means that, you know, when I've I drop it into a scatter plot, they probably need to hike by about 75 basis points, one down, potentially two more to go. Has that been a problem for the market? The answer is no. Two reasons. One is because it's most often consistent with growth, and we can talk about all the leading indicators that say 27 is going to be Maybe a better year than 26 for the broad economy. Or two, or N2, and two, is that the rate rises are uh slow enough to be easily absorbed by the overall economy. And I think that that's the setup that we're looking at as we approach 2027.

6:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So you have so much data available at your fingertips, Denise. And I'm curious when we're hearing good news coupled with bad news and maybe seems like the bad is outweighing the good, how do you decide what to really focus on and to create your view? of the health of the underlying economy?

6:53Denise Chisholm: Well, it you know, it's interesting because I get this view like the questions all the time is that, you know, the economy is too hot or the economy is too weak, and it just depends on which data points you look at, right? So we can aggregate the data points together and GDP is the I you know, the ultimate, you know, arbiter of the entire economy. And I think one of the things that the chair said, uh Chair Wars said, was that you know it's it's pretty hot coming into this quarter. Now, the interesting part, when I look at the data, and you can go back on my LinkedIn and you can subscribe to the newsletter, or you can sort of scroll through and see the charts, when you look at the quarter on quarter that the chair was referring to, it's just this entire pattern of back and forth every quarter on a seasonally adjusted basis, on an annualized basis, for literally the past three and a half years. So there is no difference. discernible trend in quarterly data. The only way that you can discern a trend is by looking at the year-on-year. Now, here is kind of where I think it's interesting. So year-on-year, real GDP growth is still 2%, and in fact, slowing. It's kind of like inflation, right? It's 2% and actually slowing over the over the last quarter. And that was partly a function of imports, which we'll get to in a second. But that 2% is below median levels. So, yes, there are some hot areas to the US economy, there are some slow areas to the economy, but overall, the US economy is not in contraction, but certainly far from

8:13boom-like conditions. Now, the interesting differentiating factor that I do think the chair was referring to is let's strip out trade and imports because we're talking about GDP in terms of the product, the product and the production, which imports detract from. And just let's think about all consumption. That's called final sales. So we can look at that measure. Now that did accelerate. And it's still below median levels, but is accelerating. So you say, okay, is there a pattern here? Can we take anything from this? Should we learn anything as investors? You're talking about all this data, Denise. If you're looking at the differences between GDP growth accelerating or final sales accelerating, or both accelerating or both decelerating, this situation is the better setup. So final sales is almost the tell on what GDP will do over the course of the next year. So it's the best setup historically for accelerating GDP. Maybe we'll get to above median levels in 2027 and accelerating stock market as well, meaning that it usually produces the best gains in the stock market. So again, I think it's been a very stochatic, uneven recovery, but I think 2027 is looking a lot better than

9:242026. And it's, you know, no small part because I think hiring, all the indicators that we've been talking about over the course of the next year, are sort of coming to fruition and you're finally starting to see an inflection in the labor markets as well.

9:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Well, that's tremendous to hear Paul. positive outlet for 2027. Uh, labor markets are another data point, and I'm curious to s to hear what you think of uh labor markets and jobs data heading into 2027 as well.

9:49Denise Chisholm: So we've been in a no-firing, right, but no hiring economy. So it's almost like been a jobless recovery, which I always talk about because that's when I kind of came of age in the labor force in the mid-90s, and jobless recoveries, they feel worse than in some ways I just told you they are on paper, like GDP growth is fine, right? Well, that doesn't feel fine if you're really struggling getting a job, uh, and then layer over real wage growth being negative more often without a recession than any other time in history, and you've got a pretty aggravated consumer. But that jobless recovery, when you look at all the leading indicators that go into it, you go, okay, as much as it's uncomfortable that corporate America. is incredibly profitable while real incomes are weak, this is usually the setup for better hiring trends over the next 12 months. And so you see this pattern over and over again where corporate profits lead hiring booms. And that isn't to say that the boom will look anything like what we've seen in prior booms because we didn't really have the recession that went along with it, but it is to say that that's usually a really good risk. reward for the labor market improving. Then all of a sudden, you started to see a lot of indicators point in the same direction, like durable goods orders, CapEx points the same way. And now you're finally starting to see it in the surveys to the consumers themselves. They see it first almost before you see it in

11:08payrolls, and payrolls are you know one of the most heavily revised data. So I always look at the conference boards. jobs plentiful survey, which is their consumers' perception on are jobs easy to get or hard to get? And we've seen, despite all this bad news that we're bombarded with on a daily basis, we're seeing an inflection that we have not seen in the better part of two years from a downtrend that has been sustained for the last four years. So if this inflection holds, what you have seen historically is consumers get it right. When they actually see the inflection, payroll growths usually confirm over the course of the next year. So this is a good setup because if you're wondering, like, what's going to stimulate the economy, how can it get any better? You know, you never see growth coming for reasons like this. Because when you have more hiring, more bodies, more wages, that is the virtuous cycle that is the US economy that generates better profits, which also generates more demand for labor. So this is sort of the cycle finally getting going.

12:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So historically, when we've thought about growth and higher jobs data, of course, bringing inflation back into the conversation, that can be a worry for investors. Is it different this time, or is there anything that could offset those inflation? worries, or is it inevitable to come through again?

12:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So,

12:30Denise Chisholm: what do they say? It's never different this time. I find this irony. This is the irony in the data. If you look at the data, you say, okay, GDB growth is accelerating, job growth is accelerating. You can look at those two variables and you can say, okay, what happens to inflation next? If you're if everybody's thesis is right, then I should be able to see this in the data. When that accelerates, then CPI accelerates, or core CPI. accelerates, or the PCE deflator accelerates, something accelerates consistently. There's no consistent pattern. And in fact, if anything, it's slightly the opposite. So this is true for not only the CPI, which kind of you would guess, right? Because that's got a shelter component, it's got a goods component, and that's just wages driving services, right? So let's look at wages. You can measure it with average hourly earnings, you can measure it with ECI. which is trying to get around like the, you know, same, like the next shift. You can measure it any which way. You do not see a consistent pattern. Look, and I think that there's an interesting answer along with it. If you say, well, wait a minute, you know, when you have a pickup in labor demand, how can that not generate higher

13:32wages? It's because it's often matched with an increase in supply. And you see this over and over. again. If you want to look at the data, go to the note, you can pull it up. You can see that labor force participation actually rises after you see what the consumer said, like, hey, jobs are getting a little bit more plentiful. It calls people back to the workforce. It's almost like that, you know, field of dreams reference. Like if you build it, it will come. And if you are worried that, but it's different this time because there isn't enough labor. force out there because the decline in immigration, the decline in population, because the unemployment rate is too low. Look, I'll tell you, you don't need a big inflection in terms of payroll growth, right? You're talking about something that could be just double the average that it has been. We still have enough labor on the sidelines from the unemployed ranks, from those people who said that they weren't in the labor force, just back to the pre-COVID lows. So there is supply. And again, if history is a guide, I think supply actually starts to match demand. And inflation is much less of a risk in the historical data than you might think as an investor.

14:36Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Mm-hmm. Lots of questions for you on my mind. Of course, we need to bring AI into the conversation and we've seen a lot happening throughout this year as it's become such a large investment theme. But of course there's been a recent sell-off some shakeup in the industry. Why don't we start off? I'm curious if you're seeing AI influence JobsDAT at all. And secondly, want to hear your thoughts on the investment in technology going forward.

14:58Denise Chisholm: So, no, on any influence in terms of jobs so far. And the Federal Reserve actually did a really good paper about whether or not AI was actually creating the jobless recovery. And they came up with the answer: no, actually, it was more driven by remote work. Uh, Remote work. did more for creating this angst around employers to hire younger people. So it's worth a read, but I think that there are many ways to slice the data. So far, the productivity advancements we've seen from AI in terms of the software space hasn't really been an impact to jobs. And there are a lot of people who've written about that. As it relates to AI overall, again, I'm a data person, right? So it's always going to be different. You're going to get a fundamental person's different opinion. When I look at the aggregate free cash flow and the aggregate capex of the technology sector, you still have more free cash flow than CapEx. So as much as you have idiosyncratic issues, and we can all the name name the companies, what you look, what you see is a pretty cohesive uh sector where there isn't any under. underlying anomaly issue in terms of earnings growth, in terms of profitability. Now look, these two technologies don't go hand in hand, which is the irony of the angst for me, the angst about

16:14whether or not this CapEx will have an ROI. Usually CapEx and ROI or ROE in and the aggregate version actually are positively correlated, meaning that they usually go together. which is not to say that every incremental spend of dollars is going to be accretive, but it is to say that usually some of the, especially technology companies, have produced enough capex and generated enough flu cash flow in other areas that the aggregate entity is actually positive. So as much as the AI buildout build out will happen in stages, it's not clear at all that incremental negative ROIC needs to translate back to the parent companies. And we've seen that over and over again. But so when I look at that, so you say, okay, there's no anomalous data in terms of excessive build out right now, that we can debate about whether or not the fruitions will come true or the um uh the The projections predictions will come true in terms of capex. But when you see that and when you look at, okay, if you don't know, what's the first thing you lean on as an investor is what is valuation pricing in? Do you see a consistent pattern in terms of how the stocks behave in bad news when your starting point is different? And you do in technology. You do even in semiconductors. So the lower your starting point in terms

17:34of valuation, the more you have upside risk in the stocks. even if earnings decline, even if margins decline, which is kind of a mathematical way of saying, look, are you pricing in some bad news even if it actually happens? And the answer is historically speaking, yes, this sector has done that over and over again. Could it be different this time? Absolutely. But when I look in the data, I think at these valuation levels, you start to have to flip the question. Instead of asking what could go wrong, I think you have to start asking, like, what could go right? And what if numbers don't come down that much? What if technology does grow earnings next year? And then what's your upside risk? So for me, that's still why technology is a pretty interesting risk reward.

18:19Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Mm-hmm. That makes sense. And I wanted to ask if you have seen any signs that we're maybe approaching an inflection point or a point where companies are able to get more for their spend on CapEx. Is there any efficiencies there with the spend going into AI?

18:33Denise Chisholm: That's actually a good question. I haven't looked at the exact data. So far, I mean, I think that so far the answer is probably not yet. But

18:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

18:42Denise Chisholm: do think we should always think about that's the historical pattern in technology. And I think you highlighted the point of why I'm very reluctant to make those cap. CapEx projections like pop them in a model. Because we know technology doesn't stay constant and we know you get those efficiency gains. So what does technology companies do? They make something that's scarce and expensive, and they make it cheaper and they make it more abundant. And that happens over and over again at a quicker pace. So what if CapEx is actually lower next year, two years from now? But what if also it's more productive, CapEx, in terms of additive to ROI? And also what if at the same time it's not nearly as circular as you thought in terms of there's more use cases for semis than just the throughput into CapEx and data centers, which is again what we've seen historically. So it's one of those situations where I always like to say, like, you got to be careful in terms of like the more visible something is, like a CapEx slowdown or a CapEx cliff, don't always assume that you actually know the answer because more often than not, you might get that part right. You know, if I had a nickel for every time an investor said, Well, I got the macro backdrop right, but I got the stocks wrong. And it's because the equity market is just this tangled web of a discounting mechanism that

20:01frustrates the maximum. amount of investors.

20:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Of course. And we have another layer of complexity to bring in. Of course, recently we had the midterm elections in the US and so many headlines coming out since then. What do you specifically look at around the around the time of midterms? And is there anything to take away from that that investors should be taking into their portfolio considerations?

20:21Denise Chisholm: Yeah, the interesting thing is that the quirky pattern about midterm elections is that it the year five. following midterms, you have 100% odds of the stock market advancing since 1930. And that's on a total return basis, not necessarily on a price return. So it doesn't like guarantee a gangbuster a year. But what you do see is historically, and look, I think that this pattern actually applies, is that usually going into a midterm, you have very high levels of uncertainty. And after that midterm, 80% of the time since 1930. 1980, we've actually shifted back from either a sweep or more unilateral power to divided government. And that divided government tends to be the best case outcome for stocks because it tends to grind change to a halt, meaning that the stock market has more certainty, which is not to say it has certainty, it just has less uncertainty. But so I think you we'll know, see. I tend to think that for me as an investor, midterms and changes in government and what government policies do predict much less of what you would expect, both at an aggregate stock level and more importantly, even at a sector level. I mean, think back to, you know, and we'll see if it relates to technology like this, but think back to healthcare reform in the mid

21:35mid-90s. 90s. Going into the mid mid-90s, 90s, healthcare stocks. underperformed because there was going to be legislation that was very clearly onerous to future margins. And it was true, the legislation was passed, it was onerous to future margins. And then every year for the next five years, healthcare stocks led the market. So it's kind of a very clear example of if things are visible, be careful. The market may discount it well. in advance and actually make the upside skew more than the downside for negative stuff.

22:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): That is fascinating how the markets work in that sense. Let's talk about defensive sectors. You've done some work highlighting that defense in a portfolio has perhaps become more expensive recently. I'm curious if that means like are investors overpaying for safety and perhaps missing out on opportunities elsewhere, or how are you looking at the defensive area within portfolio? portfolios today?

22:28Denise Chisholm: Yeah, so back to the relative valuation argument. So if you look at consumer staples, healthcare, and utilities, let's just take those three sectors and you look at the data on a relative multiple basis, right? So relative forward earnings, and you look at it going back to 1962, you will see that defensive sectors have not been more expensive except for 5% of the time. Now, when you look at that, what that means to the market, that's sort of that pattern recognition. There's this linear, monotonic, stair-step pattern. The more investors are paying for defense, the more likely the market is to go higher. So look, it's 90% odds at this top 5% where we are. It's not 100%, but the only time since 1960, where if you're willing to look over the next 12 months, it's is a time horizon, right? So I'm not saying like the market's bottomed here. I'm not saying that it bottoms into three months. But if you look over the course of one year, the only time the S P 500 has been negative when defense has been this expensive is the dot com bubble. So could it be

23:29different again in a different way? Absolutely. But what I see is an increasingly positive risk reward. And it's back to that what was, I think the famous quote by Peter Lynch, you know, the stock market has discounted nine of the last four recessions. So every time that you see things like this, I think that, you know, you again, I think you're paid as an investor who looks over a one-year time horizon to say, with all the bad news, why don't we focus on the right question, which might be what can go right into 2027?

24:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): That's an excellent. segue into my next question as we get close to the end of our show today, Denise. Could you rem uh leave our audience with your highest conviction ideas or most uh I guess favorite areas of opportunity heading into 2027?

24:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,

24:16Denise Chisholm: so we've talked about tech a lot and it's mainly around the aspect of what's already priced in in terms of valuations, but what's coming up the ranks in terms of sectors, and we've talked about like nascent parts of the consumer. discretionary sector, but consumer discretionary sector is the sector that's been statistically levered to that job recovery. So again, profits leave jobs, we're finally starting to see it in the consumer data, and we're starting to see an inflection in year on your payroll growth from low levels. This is the exact situation against linear pattern between like the worse job growth has been, the more you want to look at the consumer. discretionary sector. 77% odds versus 30% odds when jobs are actually growing quite strongly, which again tells you what you kind of know as an investor is look, by the time it's already been like, yes, there's no job growth, it actually changes enough such that that negative job growth has been priced in and you're gonna set up for the other side. So I think that there's some angst over if there is a struggle within. technology and communication services, what will lead the market higher? And I do think that, you know, even despite the weight, which is kind of the same weight we saw energy industrials and materials be in the 30s through the 60s, it's never weighed on the market returns that much because there's usually the stochatic pattern over different sectors taking leadership. And

25:35for me, I think that's what I'm talking about more and more, which is consumer. discretionary as an aggregate sector, especially when you put it together with potentially lower underlying inflation. If we ever get rid of all these shocks, that that's the role to underlying inflation. Maybe rates, maybe the Fed has to do less than the market thinks at the exact same time where consumer discretionary stocks have, I think, underperformed by almost 3,000 basis points over the course of the last year. And that's usually the mean reversion trade to buy them at that point because who doesn't know that it's been a tough market for the consumer?

26:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So,

26:11Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Denise, is our final question today as we're heading into 2027, what do you think could be what investors get the most wrong heading into next year?

26:20Denise Chisholm: I would say that the low growth continues that we are seeing this year. I mean, as much as you know, technology are an earnings has been dominant, you haven't seen dominant earnings from any other sector. So it's been fairly narrow. And I think that there is just the thought that there is no stimulus for a more cohesive aggregate recovery. And I look in the data and I see the exact opposite. So I think being continually Continue like I think being bearish on the overall economy. is the thing that investors are most likely to get wrong.

26:54Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Well, thank you very much for sharing your thoughts. As always, Janice, while we could talk all day, we are at time, but thank you very much. And thank you to our audience for tuning in today. I'm Lauren Gardy.

27:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Thanks for watching or listening to the Fidelity Connects podcast. Now, if you haven't done so already, please subscribe to Fidelity Connects on your podcast platform of choice. And if you'd like you what you're hearing, please leave a review or a five-star rating. Fidelity Mutual Funds and ETFs are available by working with a financial advisor or through an online brokerage account. Visit Fidelity.ca slash how to buy for more information. While on Fidelity.ca, you can also find more information on future live webcasts. And don't forget to follow Fidelity Canada on YouTube, LinkedIn, and Instagram. We'll end today's show with a short disclaimer. The views and opinions expressed on this podcast are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of Fidelity Investments Canada ULC or its affiliates. This podcast is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as investment, tax, or legal advice. It is not an offer to sell or buy, or an endorsement, recommendation, or sponsorship of any entity or securities cited. Redefunds prospectus before investing. Funds are not guaranteed. Their values change frequently, and past performance may not be repeated. Fees, expenses, and commissions are all associated with fund investments. Thanks again, we'll see you next

28:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): time.

This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights