AI data centre impacts, off-the-plan risks, Sydney discounts, and buying vs renting costs
Summary
Speakers discuss the strain of Canberra's new AI data centres on the ACT's renewable energy grid and water supplies. They highlight financial risks for off-the-plan buyers, including potential negative equity and cash shortfalls if valuations drop. Data from Coallity reveals significant vendor discounts in Sydney and other Australian suburbs. Finally, an analysis compares the upfront costs of buying versus renting, suggesting ownership is more expensive in the first 5-10 years.
Key takeaways
- 1 Canberra Data Centers is constructing a 40 MW facility in Baird, exceeding 5% of the ACT's peak energy usage, with a second proposed 84 MW center.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) · 1:09
- 2 Buying off-the-plan carries the risk that if the market falls during construction, the bank may value the property below the contract price at settlement, forcing the buyer to cover the shortfall in cash.
Simon · 5:39
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 4:47
AI Data Centres in Canberra
Speakers discuss the massive electricity and water demands of new data centers in Canberra, specifically citing Canberra Data Centers' projects in the suburb of Baird. Concerns are raised about the strain on the ACT's 100% renewable energy grid and potential conflicts with drinking water supplies during droughts.
- 4:47 – 9:29
Risks of Buying Off-the-Plan
The segment shifts to Melbourne buyer's agent Mario Borg, who highlights the financial risks of buying off-the-plan properties. Key issues include potential market drops during construction leading to negative equity and the requirement to bring additional cash if bank valuations fall short of the contract price.
- 9:29 – 14:18
Expat Returns and Sydney Discounts
Simon introduces a listener moving from Dubai to Sydney due to geopolitical tensions and exchange rates. Craig then discusses data from Coallity showing significant vendor discounts in Sydney suburbs like Killara and Glen Haven, as well as other areas in Victoria, NSW, and Queensland.
- 14:18 – 18:41
Cost of Buying vs Renting Analysis
Lacey Philipitch from Money School analyzes the upfront costs of buying an average Australian home, including a 20% deposit and stamp duty. He compares mortgage repayments to rent across capital cities, noting that owning is generally more expensive than renting in the first 5-10 years.
Claims worth verifying
Canberra Data Centers' first data center in Baird has a total capacity of 40 megawatts, which is more than 5% of the ACT's highest recorded peak energy usage.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·1:09
How to verify: Check the ACT Energy and Water Regulation Authority (AEWRA) or the ACT Government's energy usage statistics for peak demand figures and compare with the announced capacity of the Canberra Data Centers project. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
A proposed second data center by Canberra Data Centers would have a capacity of 84 megawatts, representing more than 10% of the ACT's peak energy usage.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·1:29
How to verify: Verify against the ACT Government's peak energy usage records and the publicly available development applications or press releases from Canberra Data Centers regarding the second facility. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The ACT government has projected a 30% reduction in river flows under a moderate climate change scenario and a 45% reduction under an extreme scenario.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·4:11
How to verify: Search for ACT Government climate change adaptation reports or water security strategies published between 2026-08-21 and 2026-11-21 that detail river flow projections. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
An off-the-plan apartment in Parramatta sold for just over $784,000 in 2016 and resold for $635,000 in the current year (2026).
Simon ·7:39
How to verify: Check PropTrack's property price index data or NSW Land Registry Services (NSW LRS) transaction records for specific apartment sales in Parramatta between 2026 and 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceKillara is one of the top suburbs for vendor discounting, with an average discount nearing 10% on a median house price of $2.7 million.
Craig ·11:51
How to verify: Review the Coallity survey data or real estate agency reports for the Killara suburb for the period 2026-08-21 to 2026-11-21 to confirm median prices and discount percentages. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Everton Park in Brisbane came in at a 9.5% average discount in the vendor discount survey.
Craig ·12:46
How to verify: Cross-reference with Coallity's survey results or local real estate market reports for Everton Park for the relevant 2026 period. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
On an average Australian loan of $730,000, a 20% deposit plus stamp duty and other buying costs could require more than $206,000 upfront.
Simon ·16:12
How to verify: Calculate using current average loan-to-value ratios, stamp duty rates for the relevant state (likely NSW or VIC based on context), and typical legal/inspection fees for a $913,000 property price. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
For a $730,000 loan at 6.24% over 30 years, repayments are just over $1,000 a week.
Simon ·17:07
How to verify: Use a standard mortgage calculator with the principal of $730,000, interest rate of 6.24%, and term of 30 years to verify the weekly repayment amount. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceDo your own research
- Verify ACT government climate projections and water security plans via official ACT government publications.
- Check Canberra Data Centers' project approvals and environmental impact statements for the Baird facility.
- Review PropTrack's historical off-the-plan price data for specific suburbs like Parramatta to assess negative equity risks.
- Examine Coallity's vendor discount reports for current market conditions in Sydney, Brisbane, and regional areas.
- Calculate total upfront costs (deposit, stamp duty, legal fees) versus rental yields for target properties using local council rates and bank calculators.
- Assess personal liquidity to cover potential valuation shortfalls when buying off-the-plan.
- Monitor exchange rates and geopolitical factors influencing expat return trends to Sydney.
- Review lenders' mortgage insurance (LMI) thresholds and costs for different deposit sizes.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Well, if we're building these data centers and they require such huge amounts of water, what happens in the next drought, which will be inevitable here in the territory? Will people be sacrificing their drinking water or they water their gardens because all of the water is being taken up by these huge data centers instead?
0:18Craig: It's your real estate breakfast type of fair side with Craig and in Lamorden the morning across Australia.
0:29Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): It's the Real Estate Podcast, brought to you by ANZ Home Loans for financial well-beings.
0:36Simon: As AI explodes, these data centers are multiplying across Australia, yet the average Aussie knows virtually Actually, nothing about them. This morning we're going to attempt to pull back the secretive curtain on Australia's massive unregulated digital boom and find out what is really happening. And in this case, we're talking about Canberra and the suburb of Baird could gulp down five percent of Canberra's peak electricity. I mean, that is extraordinary.
1:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): You're correct. There's a company here in Canberra Canber called Canberra Data Centers currently constructing their first data center in this suburb called Beard, which is out to the east of the city, and it's expected to have a total capacity of 40 megawatts, which is more than 5% of the ACT's highest recorded peak energy usage. They're actually also proposing a second data center right next door, which would have a capacity of 84 megawatts, which is more than double that. So that would be 10% of our peak energy usage. So that's a huge energy demand from two. buildings. And something that we're very concerned about about what impact that is going to have on our grid, on our electricity supply. And in here in the ACT, given that we have 100% renewable energy, whether this is going to put strain on our ability to maintain that commitment.
1:53Simon: That is just mind blowing. So if if you were somebody that is in Canberra and you're miles away, and you might be thinking, well, I'm okay. You know, this data center, it's nowhere. is near. As Simon has just said, that highlights the problem because with two of these, that is going to be ten percent of Canberra's peak electricity. The other point here, Simon, is data centers have historically flown under the radar Are due to tight security. And because they operate so secretly, most of us have got absolutely no idea how fast they're multiplying right now in backyards around the country without proper rules and checks on them.
2:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, that's right. And I think that uh there's a major concern growing in the community about the explosion of data centers, and they're they're exploding because of the growth of AI. These are often presented as a you know a great chance for increased economic. activity in the city. Our ACT government here, led by the Chief Minister Andrew Barr, has tried desperately to tamper down any concerns. But when we're looking at the energy usage, the water usage that of these centers, also the impacts they have on local communities for things like noise, they are of real concern to many community. And I think we need to stop just allowing these things to be rolled out and instead have proper conversations about whether this is what we want to. prioritize in our cities. And I think that's particularly true given the impacts that they have. You know, for example, do we feel like we want more than 10% of our energy being directed towards data centers? Or do we feel like we, you know, have higher priorities than that?
3:30Simon: Yeah, you mentioned drinking water. I mean, this Because AI requires intense cooling, and many data centers rely heavily on our drinking water to keep servers from overheating. And with climate change threatening our river flows, we might soon be facing a choice between tech and our taps. What do you think?
3:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, and this is a a major, major concern for us. Data centers use a huge amount of water, and that's because they produce extreme amount of heat and they need water to cool them down so that they don't get too hot and they can use millions of litres of water every day to to maintain this. And here in the ACT, the own our ACT the ACT government itself has projected that we're likely to experience a thirty percent reduction in flows under a moderate climate change scenario, or you know, forty five percent reduction in river flows on the most extreme climate change scenario. So we may be losing a significant amount of water security here in the territory due to climate change. And so we're gonna be asking this question of well, if we're building these data centers and they require such huge amounts of water, what happens in the next drought, which will be inevitable here in the territory? Will people be sacrificing their drinking water or their water their gardens because all of the water is being taken up by these huge data centers instead?
4:47Simon: We are going to highlight this morning buying off plan properties. Is it good? Is it bad? Is it risky? Something that you would entertain or would you stay away from? Let's head off to Melbourne to catch up with Mario Borg, a buyer's agent there. And welcome on to the real estate breakfast. Yes, as I say, different deposit sizes, different property cases. categories, bigger borrowing capacity. You're dealing with all of this on a daily basis, aren't you?
5:20Craig: I sure am, Craig. Absolutely. There are some headwinds at the moment when it comes to issues like borrowing capacity, because naturally you being able to qualify for a loan today doesn't mean you're gonna qualify qualifying in two or three years' time when settlement appears.
5:35Simon: Yeah, well let's just talk about that because many people have a problem. with buying off the plan. You can agree on a price today, for example, but you might not be settling for another two to three years. If the market falls during construction, the finished apartment could be worth less than you agreed to pay. That is a very nasty surprise when the bank values it below your contract price. And you've seen that happen.
6:06Craig: I have seen that happen 19 times. In fact, the issue there is, I mean, if you're a cash buyer, then you don't have as much of a problem because it just means you've got to front up more cash. But if you are relying on finance, the bank's going
6:20Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): to order an independent valuation for the particular property that you've bought at the time or near complete. completion to ensure that the value of the property stacks up with comparable properties in the surrounding areas. And the issue you've got is that if the property is valued less at that time because the market has swung against you, then the bank's going to limit the LVR, the loan to valuation of what they agreed to lend you based on the revised valuation, not the actual contract price. So in that instance, you've got a shortfall, you've got a problem, you've got to come up with more cash. And a very quick example on that is if you bought a property today off the plan and the contract price is let's say 800,000, and in two years' time the bank values that property at 720. At an 80% loan to valuation, the bank's only going to advance $576, being 80% of the $720, as opposed to $80,000. 80%
7:15Craig: of the contract price. You've got a shortfall there in that example of $64,000 that you've got to come up with somehow for the bank to advance the uh the loan in the first place.
7:24Simon: And just to highlight that, here are some numbers from Prop Track. One Parramatter apartment sold for just over seven 784 hundred and eighty-four grand. This is an off plan. That was back in two 2016, thousand and sixteen. then resold for, and this is the price in this year, 635,000. That is nearly 150,000 less. After a decade of ownership, which is highlighting your point, buying new doesn't automatically mean that your property is going to grow in value. And just sort of highlighting that. you know, this negative equity, it's a real factor right now. You're in Melbourne. Have you got some of those cases at the moment where they're selling, they're in that negative equity, they're taking a hit?
8:18Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Not off the plan, because I generally tend to steer away from off-the-plan type purchases other than smaller boutique type developments. I have seen examples where valuation and off-the-plan does come in lower. As I said, not specifically for myself for clients, but I have seen it. And again, the issue there is
8:36Simon: having to front up more cash, right? So that's that's the absolute um issue. Whilst there's a risk of the property being valued less at a future point, and we all know what the property market's been doing over the last six to twelve months, if the market does swing the other way and recovers or has a an upturn between now and settlement, you can actually make money because the property is now worth more into the future. A lot of property sprukers are gonna promote
9:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
9:04Craig: fact that you know property can only go in one direction.
9:09Simon: Good morning, Wade from Dubai. You have emailed through you say that. you have been living in Dubai for five years with your wife and your three-year-old daughter. You say that you've had the hard conversation about moving because of potential Middle East tensions continuing and looking at Sydney for stability. However, you say the exchange rate ain't great. Moving to Dubai five years ago, you say that you had some savings. But since then, being in Dubai, you have accumulated two properties and will lose a lot in the exchange rate. The market, you say, thankfully being down in Sydney is going to allow us to scrape in with something modest in the way of a house with some land. If you can identify with what Wade is saying, drop us an email. We would uh love to hear from you. It is a Thursday, November the 19th. Let's take you off to Brisbane. We are catching up with Zorin Zelano. He is the president of Reba. Gee, I just want to circle back to Wade there in Dubai. Has decided to make the move. The grass is greener, it seems, in Australia.
10:25Craig: Yeah, for sure. I can definitely see. you know, there's a driving interest or an increasing interest in Aussie expats coming back to Australia. So it's definitely a phenomenon that we're starting to see.
10:35Simon: And how far and wide are they coming from?
10:39Craig: We're seeing expats relocate back to Australia from various areas, a lot coming back from the Middle East due to obviously the conflict that's occurring with no real end in sight. We're also seeing people coming back from Europe. as well, from London looking to make the move back for obviously weather, but also a lot of immigration issues throughout Europe stimulating that move as well.
10:59Simon: Now, buyers, they are getting right now serious discounts. And I know that you're across this with a survey that you did. Imagine negotiating uh over $271,000 off property. in Sydney's upper north shore. Well, that's the latest figures being suggested, and one of the areas is Kalara that we're going to talk about. With more homes sitting on the market, sellers, some of them, have decided finally to meet the market.
11:31Craig: Yeah, that's for sure. So what we did is teamed up with Cotality, pulling data from around the country, identifying the top 20 suburbs. where vendor discounting is reaching high amounts. Yeah, you're in fact right there. Kalara is one of the top suburbs coming in at number six, with a vendor discount on average nearing 10%. And when you've got a median house price of 2.7, you're talking a large discount in price for sure.
11:56Simon: Another area is Glen Haven. Maybe just uh rattle off a couple more of these areas. where there have been big discounts with people buying.
12:06Craig: Yeah, we're seeing a mix of locations across the country, most of which at the moment we're identifying in Victoria, New South Wales, and Queensland. Obviously, suburbs typically with that higher median house price is where we're starting to see that softening occur. Also, some regional areas like Charters Towers are starting to see some significant vendor discount on. opportunities. Again, being rural, we always see those areas fluctuate higher than more of the blue chip inner and middle ring suburbs. But some areas on the Gold Coast such as Paradise Point, Merrimack and Ashmore made the list. Also in Brisbane, Everton Park came in at 9.5% average discount. So we're seeing examples across Southeast Queensland and also across the country as well.
12:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): You're listening to Craig and friends in the morning on the Asse Real Estate Podcast.
12:59Simon: And this is a first for us, Dwayne. You have emailed us a poem. Nobody has ever done that in the years that we've been operating. And it is entitled I'm Choosing Life, Not Property. And it goes like this. The houses climb, the prices soar, I read the news, then read some more. The endless noise, the endless chase, another year gone without a trace. It ages you, it drains your soul, while owning bricks becomes the goal. I'm done with scrolling, done with stress, done chasing dreams that leave me less. So I'm packing the bags, unlocking the door. There's a great big world beyond the floor. Let others chase what they can't afford. I'm choosing life, I'm off abroad. Wow, that is fantastic, Duane. I feel like coming with you. It can be draining all of this property talk. And if you would like to send us an email our email. address is myrealestatepodcast at gmail.com. Thank you for that, Duane, and uh good luck as you head off overseas. Do you agree with Duane or disagree? It is a Friday, November the
14:1820th. Let's right now catch up with Lacey Philip Philipitch from Money School. And first reaction there, Lacey, what did you think of Dwayne's poem writing?
14:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Well, first of all, very impressed. Bravo Duane. I couldn't wrangle words that way. Very impressive, but I understand the sentiment and I think it's something I'm hearing a lot from my students through money school. People being increasingly frustrated just watching those prices go up. I know we've got an upset at the moment, but it's been a long time of prices rising, frustration, and uh certainly with the CGT changes. people have been upset about that too. So the overseas sentiment I relate to too. I've heard a lot of that.
14:55Simon: Now, this is the first time that we have spoken to you. You're from Money School. Why don't you tell us and set that up a little bit in terms of what you are offering?
15:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Oh, thank you for the opportunity. My business is called Money School, and like it says on the label, I teach people about money. So everything from how to save and budget all the way through to portfolio management. I've been doing it for 16 years. And I did it because I thought people didn't learn enough about money at school, which certainly was the case when I started money school back in 2010. We didn't have financial literacy in the curriculum. We do now, it's not going great, and certainly there's still lots of adults that need my help. So I'm still doing it.
15:33Simon: Yes, probably never a more valid time to be teaching people all about money. Now let's talk about exactly where we are right now because I want to break this down. For instance, on an average Australian loan of $730,000, you've done the maths here. A 20% deposit works out roughly at around $182,000, putting the property price at $913. $913,000. Then you say you've got to add stamp duty and other buying costs, and you could need more as a result than $206,000 up front. It's a lot of money.
16:17Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): It sure is. It's a big chunk of change. And look, I know there are opportunities to get lower deposit loans. We've certainly got government options for that. There are banks that will take lower deposits, but really the deposit is about protecting the bank and making sure they don't lose money. That's why they set that 20%. And it helps you avoid lenders' mortgage insurance. And that's desirable because it's an extra cost you don't have to pay. So that's why you need that big chunk of change just to make sure that you're not having to pay an extra cost you don't need to, but it means saving 200 grand plus, which is a lot in this market.
16:47Simon: Is it ever? Now let's look at some other numbers here. On a seven hundred and thirty thousand dollar loan at six point two four percent over thirty years, repayments are about well, it's just over a thousand dollars a week, depending on the suburb. That could be one hundred and forty-one to four hundred and ninety per week more than renting the same sort of home. This will be of interest to a lot of people.
17:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
17:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Well, uh to work out these numbers. I looked for a comparable suburb to 913,000 purchase price in all of the capital cities. They ended up being suburbs that were between sort of $870 and $950,000. And then I was looking at the average rent for a house. And I did use houses for this rather than apartments just to keep it consistent all the way through. And so that's where those numbers come from. It turned out that Darwin had the smallest gap. between renting and the mortgage. So apparently that one's probably the closest. But the others were a wide wider spread. But at least a couple of hundred bucks a week, you're talking about paying more in a mortgage versus renting a comparable property.
17:51Simon: You won't be making any friends in the real estate sector, will you?
17:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Look, I don't think this is controversial myself. I've always held the view and certainly seen the evidence that if it is generally cheaper to rent than own the same property, certainly in the first five to ten years. And obviously that changes over time as you your mortgage stays the same because it's fixed in today's prices, but the rent goes up with the market. But certainly when you choose to own something, it's normal for the mortgage to be more, and particularly when you add in the on costs, to be more than you would pay to rent. And that's just the way it's been. I've been investing. in property uh for 25 years now. It's always been that way.
18:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): We connect you to the best real estate information across Australia, the Real Estate Podcast.