Janney's Crook sees risk-on market until economy cracks; focus on BDC ROE
Summary
Michael Crook of Janney Montgomery Scott characterizes the current market as risk-on, driven by healthy income growth and AI infrastructure spending, though he warns of potential economic cracks. Chris Acito of Gapstow Capital Partners introduces a credit-centric approach using closed-end funds and BDCs, emphasizing Return on Equity (ROE) as the key valuation metric. The speakers analyze specific BDCs, noting that discounts to NAV are often rational reflections of lower ROE, while premiums validate superior capital efficiency. They highlight Main Street Capital and others trading at premiums, while questioning the deep discounts on OBDC and SLRC.
Key takeaways
- 1 Jaffe suggests SLRC's >30% discount to NAV may be excessive for a firm with a 7-8% NAV return, potentially representing an opportunity if driven by investor unfamiliarity.
Chuck Jaffe · 50:51
- 2 Jaffe views OCSL's 20% discount to NAV as rational given its lower 5-6% NAV return relative to the 9-10% benchmark.
Chuck Jaffe · 51:51
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 16:01
Intro and AI Agent Survey
Chuck Jaffe introduces the show, mentioning the Anthropic IPO valuation and his trading restrictions. Allison Hadley discusses a survey on consumer use of personal AI agents, noting high privacy concerns despite widespread adoption for tasks like holiday shopping.
- 16:01 – 33:55
Michael Crook on Economic Outlook
Michael Crook, CIO at Janney Montgomery Scott, discusses the US economy, highlighting healthy aggregate income growth and comparing the AI infrastructure build to historical projects like railroads. He notes market rotation away from mega-cap tech and expects modest gains in 2027.
- 33:55 – 35:21
Chris Acito on Credit Markets
Chris Acito, CEO of Gapstow Capital Partners, debuts on the show to discuss his credit-centric approach using closed-end funds and business development companies (BDCs).
- 35:21 – 39:01
ROE as a Valuation Metric for BDCs
Chuck Jaffe introduces Return on Equity (ROE) as the primary metric for evaluating Business Development Companies (BDCs) and closed-end funds to avoid value traps. He defines ROE as the cash-on-cash return generated by the underlying loan portfolio, distinct from share price volatility or dividend rates.
- 39:01 – 42:33
ROE Benchmarks and Premium/Discount Dynamics
Jaffe asserts that listed credit funds should target a 9-10% ROE. He notes that funds trading at a premium typically have mid-teens ROE, while those trading at significant discounts often have ROE around 5-6%, suggesting the discount is rational rather than a value trap.
- 42:33 – 44:17
Alternative Credit vs. Municipal Bonds
Chris Acito explains that alternative credit investments require high single-digit to low double-digit return profiles to be relevant in a portfolio, distinguishing them from municipal bonds which offer lower returns but serve a different diversification role.
- 44:17 – 45:36
BDC Credit Quality and Liquidity Premiums
Acito describes BDC loans as below investment grade (junk) but notes they are often private, narrowly distributed, or bilateral. This illiquidity and origination effort confer an additional yield pickup beyond the standard high-yield premium.
- 45:36 – 49:24
Top-Performing BDCs Trading at Premiums
Acito identifies six BDCs trading above par with a 30% average premium to book value: Main Street Capital (MAIN), Capital Southwest (CNA), Trinity Capital (TRIN), Capitol Federal Financial (not explicitly ticker but implied context of peers), Hercules Capital (HERO), and Sixth Street Specialty Lending (TSLX). He notes these firms generate mid-teens ROE.
- 49:24 – 50:31
Blue Owl Capital Corp (OBDC) Analysis
OBDC is highlighted as having a 9-10% historical NAV return and a 12% yield, yet it trades at a >20% discount to NAV. Jaffe finds this discount surprising given the ROE, speculating it may relate to market concerns over Blue Owl's technology/software investments.
- 50:31 – 51:47
SLR Investment Corp (SLRC) Analysis
SLRC focuses on asset-backed lending (e.g., equipment finance) and trades at a >30% discount to NAV. With a 7-8% NAV return and 11% yield, Jaffe suggests the discount may be excessive if driven by a lack of understanding of its unique business model.
- 51:47 – 1:01:44
Oaktree Specialty Lending (OCSL) Analysis
OCSL makes senior loans similar to Blue Owl but has a lower 5-6% NAV return. Jaffe views its 20% discount to NAV as rational and appropriate given its lower ROE relative to the 9-10% benchmark.
Assets discussed
| Asset | Kind | Stance | Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| S&P 500 | index | neutral | And that's for the S P 500 earnings growth for 2027 versus 2026 is expected to be up 17%, but that's down. from call it 25% growth between last year and where we likely will end up this year. |
| Blue Owl Capital CorpOBDC | equity | neutral | He wants to know about OBDC. That's Blue Owl Capital Corp. |
| SLR Investment Corp.SLRC | equity | neutral | Javier in Wilmington, North Carolina. wants to know about SLR Investment Corp. That's SLRC. |
| Eagle Point Income CoEIC | equity | neutral | Eagle Point Income EIC, well, maybe a qualified buy, certainly one that's going to be. |
“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.
Claims worth verifying
Anthropic's IPO values the company at approximately $1.5 trillion.
Chuck Jaffe ·2:14
How to verify: Check SEC filing S-1 for Anthropic's IPO prospectus for the final offering price and shares outstanding to calculate market cap. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary source21% of consumers surveyed use consumer-facing AI agents.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·8:00
How to verify: Review the survey report commissioned by Howdy.com and conducted by Digital Third Coast. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
64% of AI agent users gave their agent access to their inbox.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·8:59
How to verify: Review the survey report commissioned by Howdy.com and conducted by Digital Third Coast. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
40% of AI agent users are willing to sacrifice data privacy for convenience.
Chuck Jaffe ·9:58
How to verify: Review the survey report commissioned by Howdy.com and conducted by Digital Third Coast. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
13% of users found their agent made an unauthorized purchase.
Chuck Jaffe ·11:25
How to verify: Review the survey report commissioned by Howdy.com and conducted by Digital Third Coast. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Aggregate income growth in the US is around 4.5% as of last month.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·18:02
How to verify: Check Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) data for Average Hourly Earnings or Federal Reserve Flow of Funds accounts for aggregate compensation. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
SP 500 earnings growth for 2027 is expected to be up 17% versus 2026.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·25:15
How to verify: Check consensus earnings estimates from Bloomberg, FactSet, or Refinitiv for S&P 500 index. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
35-36% of stocks in the S&P 500 are in a 20% drawdown or more.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·27:39
How to verify: Calculate using S&P 500 constituent price data from a financial data provider (e.g., Bloomberg, Yahoo Finance) relative to their 52-week high. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
20% of stocks in the S&P 500 are more than 30% off their highs.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·27:59
How to verify: Calculate using S&P 500 constituent price data from a financial data provider (e.g., Bloomberg, Yahoo Finance) relative to their 52-week high. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
BDCs and closed-end funds are currently trading at discounts, some very significant, to their net asset value.
Chuck Jaffe ·36:01
How to verify: Check current NAV and market price data for major BDCs (e.g., via SEC filings or financial data providers like Bloomberg/Refinitiv) to calculate the discount/premium ratio. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceListed credit funds should earn a 9-10% return on equity (ROE) to justify trading at NAV.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·39:01
How to verify: Review historical financial statements of peer BDCs to calculate their 5-year average ROE and compare to their trading price relative to NAV. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceSix BDCs trade above par with an average 30% premium to book value and have a 5-year ROE in the mid-teens.
Chuck Jaffe ·40:59
How to verify: Identify BDCs trading above 1.0x NAV and calculate their 5-year average ROE using quarterly earnings reports filed on SEC EDGAR. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary source10 or so BDCs trade at 60% of book value or less with an average 5-year ROE of 6%.
Chuck Jaffe ·41:32
How to verify: Screen for BDCs trading below 0.60x NAV and calculate their 5-year average ROE using SEC filings. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceBlue Owl Capital Corp (OBDC) has a NAV return close to 10%, a 12% yield, and trades at a >20% discount to NAV.
Chuck Jaffe ·49:24
How to verify: Check OBDC's latest quarterly report for NAV per share and dividend yield; compare to market price to verify discount. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceSLR Investment Corp (SLRC) has a NAV return in the 7-8% range, an 11% yield, and trades at a >30% discount to NAV.
Chuck Jaffe ·50:31
How to verify: Check SLRC's latest quarterly report for NAV per share and dividend yield; compare to market price to verify discount. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceOaktree Specialty Lending (OCSL) has a NAV return of 5-6% and trades at a 20% discount to NAV.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·51:47
How to verify: Check OCSL's latest quarterly report for NAV per share and dividend yield; compare to market price to verify discount. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceEagle Point Credit (ECC) has a negative internal core ROE, a yield over 40%, and trades at ~50% of NAV.
Chuck Jaffe ·53:23
How to verify: Check ECC's latest quarterly report for internal rate of return (IRR) or ROE metrics and dividend yield; compare to market price. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceEagle Point Income (EIC) has a 15% yield and a NAV return of 6.6%, trading at a ~20% discount to NAV.
Chuck Jaffe ·55:10
How to verify: Check EIC's latest quarterly report for NAV per share and dividend yield; compare to market price. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceGapstow Capital Partners runs the GapStyle Private Credit and Alternative Income Index which includes ECC, OBDC, ARCC, ARIES, MAIN, and TSLX.
Chuck Jaffe ·57:27
How to verify: Visit Gapstow Capital Partners' website or investor relations page to view the constituents of the GapStyle Private Credit and Alternative Income Index. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceDo your own research
- Verify Janney Montgomery Scott's full economic forecast for 2027 and specific 'crack' indicators mentioned by Michael Crook.
- Review Gapstow Capital Partners' closed-end fund and BDC holdings to assess concentration risk in below-investment-grade loans.
- Calculate the trailing 5-year Return on Equity (ROE) for MAIN, CNA, TRIN, HERO, and TSLX using their SEC filings (N-1A or 10-K) to confirm mid-teens performance.
- Compare OBDC's NAV history and technology investment disclosures against its current discount to determine if the market is pricing in specific software risks.
- Analyze SLRC's asset-backed lending portfolio composition and liquidity terms to assess if the >30% discount is justified by structural risks.
- Check CLO equity (ECC) portfolio valuations and internal ROE calculations to evaluate if the high yield is a value trap.
- Read the latest 10-K filings for OCSL and Blue Owl to compare loan origination volumes and default rates against peer averages.
- Investigate the 'private, bilateral, or narrowly distributed' nature of BDC loans to understand the illiquidity premium versus credit risk premium.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00Chuck Jaffe: Coming up on money life.
0:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Bold markets don't die of old age, and we are in a risk-on environment until something cracks in the economy. As we've discussed, there are plenty of positive signs in the US economy today. Despite high inflation, despite some of the struggles that that creates for households, there is some stability in our economic growth. My expectation for next year is that that continues all although the returns that we've seen over the last few years, that's going to be hard to replicate.
0:34Chuck Jaffe: That is Michael Crook, Chief Investment Officer at Jenny Montgomery Scott. And in today's big interview, he's cautiously optimistic about how the market's going to receive anthropic, Topic, about how it is rotating but not dropping off as leadership changes. about how heightened volatility won't be too painful and more. But we start with Alison Hadley here talking about survey work she did for howdy.com that looked at consumers using personal AI agents and found that the vast majority have privacy concerns, but a whole bunch of them are still gonna give their agent access to. everything anyway. Plus, in the market call, Chris Acedo, chief executive officer at Gapstow Capital Partners, makes his debut talking alternative credit markets, business development companies, and closed end funds.
1:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Come on, it'll be fun.
1:34Chuck Jaffe: Yes, it will be. So come on, because we're gonna have. a great time living the money life for November the 19th. Thank you so much for joining me. My name is Chuck Jaffe, and I am your host here on this show. And Money Life is independent personal finance talk. We are dedicated to looking smartly at a wide range of approaches and opinions on investing. And we're around the news and talking about the news without necessarily covering the news on a hard hard-level basis, which is important on a day like this one because it's Anthropic Day, and Anthropic's IPO has valued the company basically at one and a half trillion dollars. Yeah, we're waiting to see if it'll get there and actually do that, but Anthropic seems to have won investors over with its growth rate. It hasn't won. David Trainer over, hasn't won a number of other folks over, but we'll see what the market says. And then when the market says it, I know by the way, it hasn't won all of you over because a couple of you sent emails after we had our discussions about Anthropic a day ago. But again, you can get a wide range of opinions on what's been happening with Anthropic and more here on. this show. And I'm not going to tell you which one's right because I
2:54don't know. You hear me say all the time, like, wow, interesting stuff, because I find it all interesting because I like looking at markets and and watching them. I'll also point out where you get your stuff from, where you get your information from, really important. You may know or may recall, I'm a board member for the Society for Advancing Business Editing and Writing. And I was actually sitting in on a meeting yesterday on a committee that I'm in, and we were talking about business journalism ethics and how people don't disclose what they do anymore, even in our world, which they should. So I'm just going to give you a quick reminder. I'm not allowed to make any new moves and securities we discuss on this show for 15 trading days after we discuss them. And that's actually from when we do the recording to 15 trading days after the interview airs. So if, for example, Chris Asito gives out a great investing idea today and I was to go, that'd be a good thing to add to my portfolio. I can't do it until 15 trading days after the date when the show airs. And that prohibition starts actually before the show airs because it's when I know that we're going to be talking about it. Anything I buy for my own portfolio, I've got to hold for six full months, and I'm not allowed to sell anything short. And we will disclose when there is something that
4:12basically could have influence on any of the comments or where you might want to know that something was covered by it. It is not like you're going to say, oh, wait, hold it. If you've got an S P 500 index fund, you should be disclosing that whenever you talk. about the S P 500, that would be wasting time. It's not like you can have, as a journalist, any of us can have a significant influence on it. We'll be different if we were big-time money managers or what have you, but that's not where you're at. But if I was talking about a stock and it comes up in conversation, yeah, you might want to know, wait, hold it. Why is he pushing back on this expert? Maybe he's doing it because he owns it.
4:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Things
4:50Chuck Jaffe: along those lines. So that's a thing. And it's important for you as you go through this to go, how much do I trust somebody coming out with an opinion? Because you may sit there and hear somebody say, I don't know, whatever it's they're going to say about anthropic. You might believe David Traynor, because you don't want to think this is going to be a great IPO. Or you might believe Brett Winton because you think, yep, I believe it's going to go gangbusters. But you wanna want to go, what source do I trust? and why do I trust them? And go from there. That's how you can best use this show when it comes to some of that stuff. And we'd like to make this show useful. ChuckitMoneyLifeshow.com is how you reach me if you've got suggestions for doing that. But right now, I'm going to get out of the way because we're going to let these interviews run. Our lineup, Allison Hadley talking about AI agents. And yeah, it's going to bring up some of my skepticism. Michael Crook from Jenny Montgomery. Scott with the big interview, and Chris Acido with a really cool market call, stuff that we don't always cover. That's coming up. It starts when we come back from this break.
5:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now,
5:50Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Money Life looks at what the survey said.
5:55Chuck Jaffe: Yes, this is the survey said on MoneyLife, Money Life, where we dig into surveys, studies, polls, any kind of research or data day that's going to help us understand. what people are doing for, with, and about their money. And today, well, it's not directly about your money, but it is about some of the things that people are doing when it comes to artificial intelligence and how they are using personal AI agents, which does have impacts on their money. It also has big impacts on their life. The survey we're talking about was done for howdy.com. If you want to find it, look at our show notes today where there is a direct link. Allison Hadley did the research on behalf of howdy.com. Allison, great to have you back on Money Life.
6:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Always good to see you, Chuck.
6:38Chuck Jaffe: Okay. I know that most of my audience will by now know what an AI agent is. But this is sort of this next wave, and how do we make everybody more productive and do a whole bunch of
6:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): things?
6:51Chuck Jaffe: And while it can do great things, and we'll discuss maybe some of the things it can do. There are also some concerns about well, you know, when you tell your AI agent to pay your bills or to do whatever, you're suddenly giving away, you know, you're giving them the combination to your personal safe, as it were, and you don't quite know what's going to happen. And yet people don't seem to worry about their privacy a whole lot when it comes to I can do things that are convenient, right?
7:20Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Absolutely. So just to kind of take a second to define how I'm approaching AI agents because that's used in a few different ways right now. So you have AI agents that work in the guise of things like Claude Code, which might go off and do things for you in a workplace setting. What this survey is about is the advent of what I would call consumer-facing AI agents like Meta's Muse, OpenAI's Dots. I believe Claude just came out with Duet. There's also other startups like Instinct. And the idea is through usually a messaging app. So whether it's your text messages or WhatsApp in the case of Muse, you text your little robot friend and it will go off and do things for you. So when I surveyed a thousand consumers nationwide, about 21% indicated that they use those types of agents. And, you know, they use it for a lot of different things. About half uh use it for searching for information. So you just text your little robot friend, like, you know, any question that might be top of mind. Others summarize emails, uh, finding deals online, generating images. coordinating schedules, and looking at calendars. And some even use it to buy groceries, make restaurant reservations, even track their health information to like charter workout plans, right? With this, you know, the
8:39conceit is the more access you give this agent, in theory, the more it can do for you. So I asked consumers who use AI agents what they've actually hooked their agent up to or like given. it permissions to access. And 64% gave it access to their inbox, 38% said social media accounts, 37% said shopping accounts, 27% said financial information, 20% said medical information. And even over one in 10 Penn gave access to medical logins and financial logins, which is really the keys to the financial cast. castle, if you think about it. Now, since these agents have really been marketed to consumers, there's been quite a few stories across a variety of outlets about privacy concerns, or uh there was a journalist who uh piloted Meta's Muse specifically, and it was reading his text messages through the notifications pop-ups and not necessarily the messages apps. So there's a lot of tricky privacy things here, which accounts for why 85% of those who use AI agents are very concerned about data privacy. What I found was really shocking about the survey, though, is that of those AI agent users, 40% fully admitted they were willing to sacrifice their own data privacy for the sake of the convenience that these agents offered.
9:58Chuck Jaffe: Yeah, that's the part I don't understand. That's the part where you're just asking for trouble, or you're just you're somehow assuming you're gonna wind up beating the system that's designed to beat
10:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you.
10:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Mm-hmm. And like I think it's interesting that, you know, with some of this adoption, there's still a fair amount of ignorance. Like nearly a third don't know if their agent is run locally on their own computers or off site. So for instance, the way Meta's Muse is set up is it's uh an agent. that is like its own closed computer system run by Meta. Other agents are like designed or installed locally and that has a different degree of privacy interface. But you know, one in five caught their agent accessing prohibited information. And what I thought was really telling was 42% said that they actually reduced their agents access to information since they first started using it. So if we consider, say, the 14% who gave full disk access to their agents, which means like the keys to everything, right? If we consider that, you know, even there, over one in 10 of the people who use these are willing to give that much access, nearly half dialed it back after a short amount of time, which shows that, you know, maybe
11:11there isn't quite the understanding of what full disk. access can really implicate. Also, you know, interestingly, 13% found that their agent had made an unauthorized purchase for them, which, you know, can be concerning.
11:25Chuck Jaffe: And what were there agents buying that was unauthorized? And was it actually going to them, or because there's a huge number of people using agents to like shop for gifts and whatever was like the AI agent going, oh, and while we're at it, I'll send this to your Uncle Joe or the guy who developed me's Uncle Joe.
11:47Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): You know, I didn't have time in the survey to really dig that granularly into the data um just because there's only so many questions I can ask. But what I will say is, you know, about over three in five are planning on using their AI agents to assist in their holiday shopping, right? So I would not be shocked if, you know, as people sort of discover what it looks like to have these agents do things on their behalf, there's probably going to be a little bit more uh opportunity for people to discover that perhaps they should be a little bit more stringent with their agents before things get out of hand.
12:22Chuck Jaffe: Okay. So we're going to use our AI agents to buy our holiday gifts. Does that mean we're going for more warmth than you can get from a gift card? Or does it mean that the AI agent is going to go, just give them a gift card?
12:36Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): I mean, I think it depends again how much. So with all of these, how much you put in really determines how much you get out, right? So there was a Time magazine article recently that got a handle on the source code of Meta's Muse that discovered that if you give it access to messages, uh part of its source coding was to create what people would call like dos gays on the friends and acquaintances that you text with. Right. And that, you know, in the not creepy interpretation of that, that means that it'll have really good insights into things that could be customized towards that person. You know, I think again, people sort of forget how. much information they put out there even through very basic interactions, right? Like click on an ad once and you'll see that ad follow you for the rest of your life. And these AI agents are just another iteration of that. Let us not forget that Meta owns Instagram, it owns Facebook, it owns WhatsApp, and there's a lot of advertising spend that goes into that. And there's a lot of customer data that comes with that. These agents are another way for Meta to gather data, but they're also a way to take a little bit of the cognitive load off of very basic admin tasks. There's been coverage of um parents saying how it makes life a lot easier when they can just schedule grocery deliveries, things like
13:56that. Very understandable, right? Like in modern society, you don't always want to have to think about going to the coffee shop. and like getting the usual when you could just have your agent like fire off the order and you pick it up. That's a good use case. On the other hand, there's also the risk of a lot of your data and like your very intimate actions because people don't always think about what they put into their phone, what they're searching on their phone, anything, with the conversations they have with AI. You know, there's a level of personal exposure there. that I, to my mind, is a little bit different from anything that's come before.
14:31Chuck Jaffe: Yeah. And if they're not thinking about how they might be compromising themselves, well, they're making a compromise. I mean, that's ultimately the lesson here, right? Is that ultimately those folks who are most aware are trying to do the right thing, usually, but again, convenience sometimes wins out over everything.
14:50Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Yeah. I think as with anything on the smartphone and anything with uh the internet generally, like all of your actions are being tracked in some way, shape, or form, whether it's the very basic step count that your iPhone can do for you, or it's you know, you're pathing on the internet. And AI agents are not any different from that, you know. Uh, and with that in mind, I think every everyone needs to decide what their comfort level is for how much they want the technology to know them.
15:21Chuck Jaffe: Yeah. It's only the numbers are only going up from here, right? It's still less than half of people using AI every day, but it won't be long till it's way above that number. Allison, I know you'll be watching it. You do some interesting work for a bunch of different people. So we'll talk to you again soon, I am sure. Thanks for coming back to Money Wild. Life.
15:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Thanks, Chuck. Always a pleasure.
15:41Chuck Jaffe: That's Alison Hadley. She's an analyst at Digital Third Coast, which did this research for Howdy.com. So again, howdy.com, the website, but there's a direct link in today's show notes if you want to learn more. And speaking of more, well, there's more to go on today's edition of Money Life. So settle back and relax. We'll take a quick break. And it'll be us here. It won't be AI. We'll be back. Not our agents, us when we come back in a month. Welcome to the big interview on the November 19th edition of Money Life. Joining me now, Michael Crook. He is Chief Investment Officer at Jenny Montgomery Scott. If you want to learn more about him and the firm, Janny, J A N N E Y, Janny.com. Michael Crook, great to have you here on Money Life.
16:36Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Thank you, Chuck. It's great to be here.
16:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm
16:38Chuck Jaffe: going to want to move us through a couple of different things. It's like let's big picture towards smaller picture. So let's start big picture with the economy, because it does overarch everything. And I know right now everybody's anxious to talk about this. the stock market and what's going on, but the economy underpins it all. So let's just take a look as you're starting to to formulate what your outlook's going to be for 2027 at where you think we are economically speaking right now.
17:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): So uh two things that we'd focus on with the economy right now. The first I will start with is what I call core GDP. And um you know if you think about one way to calculate GDP, it's it's what a economists call the income approach. The core part of that is the aggregate income that workers are taking home in the economy on a week to week, month to month basis. And that really forms the backbone of the US economy, even with the AI infrastructure build going on today. And it's a metric that we pay a lot of attention to. That is still quite healthy. We went through a period over the last really twelve months where aggregate income growth, so all of the dollars that that US workers take home over any given period was roughly equal with inflation. So zero real income growth, which is okay, but not a great spot to be in. More recently we've seen that accelerate again. As of last month, aggregate income growth is once again around four. and a half percent for the US. That's a that's a very healthy number, and it means that the labor market is still very strong, and that despite higher inflation, households should be able to continue to pay their mortgages, continue to pay their car loans, and continue to consume as we've seen uh drive the economy
18:22over the last few years.
18:24Chuck Jaffe: What everyone is saying about the economy is it's all about the CapEx. That's going to continue to drive things, et cetera. And they wind up invariably, if they're big supporters or very much on the AI train, saying, well, we can't really compare this to anything else. We've never seen growth like this. We've never seen whatever. Is there a fair comparison to you? Because if you compare it, you invariably start to look and go, well, it feels a little bubblish over here or there, or it whatever. But is there a fair comparison or is this you take a little bit from the internet bubble and you take a little bit from before the great financial crisis and maybe a little bit from 1929 and whatever? Like, what's the reference point that people should keep in mind here?
19:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): The reference point is a little bit of all of those historical events. The artificial intelligence infrastructure build-out is likely to be the biggest physical infrastructure project that we've seen in the United States in our history. So it's difficult to come up with an exact parallel. And it's also primarily a digital impact. And some of the other big infrastructure builds, you know, the closest parallel probably was the railroad build-out after the Civil War. They're a little bit different because they were entirely physical build-outs. But the estimates right now, and frankly, these come down a little bit over time, or they have been coming down a little bit over time, is that over the next five years or so, um, maybe decades. decade, that AI infrastructure as a percentage of GDP, the investment as a percentage of GDP will be around three percent. And so that's that's higher than the fiber build out, which was around one percent of GDP. If you go back to electrification, that's half a percent of GDP over that period. Railroads were above two 2% percent of GDP. There's a massive build out. And so that's the closest parallel that we have. I think the key there for from an investment standpoint is
20:34if we make it through that infrastructure build out without a surplus, without a GLUT, it will be the first major physical infrastructure build out that that's actually happened uh for. So it's typically if you have this huge infrastructure build, primarily. due to a lot of demand, uh whether it's railroad transport or compute today, but at some point you end up with an excess of compute. And that's one of the big questions that investors have to think about.
21:03Chuck Jaffe: Let's move from that to the market, because if that's one of the takeaways that people have to think about, they also need to be thinking about do I want to be pursuing more of this? Do I want to get defensive? What is the appropriate way to look at it? So how do you think this plays out and where does it have you leaning when it comes to the market right now?
21:21Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Let's stick with the railroad analogy for a second. If when when we were building the transcontinental railroad, but it was really after that that we had the massive investment in railroad infrastructure. You know, there are a number of spots along that value chain that investors could get involved. And that would start with building the railroads themselves. Second part of that is supplying the build, uh, the rails and the ties and the labor for the build. Uh, the third part of that value chain is operating the railroads and monetizing the transport. And then the fourth, the last part is is using the railroads. The analogy today for data centers and AI fits relatively cleanly along those same lines. You're building data centers, you're supplying what goes inside the data centers, the semiconductors, you're trying to operate them and monetize that operation. That's a lot of the hyperscalers today. And then finally, the firms that are going to use AI
22:22to uh to benefit themselves. Um, what we see is investors have a lot of exposure to the middle part of that AI uh value chain, the the supplying, the semiconductors and so forth, and then also the operating and attempting to monetize the models. Uh, where they tend to have less exposure is at the beginning, the data center builds themselves, and at the end of the value chain, the firms that are going to be able to use AI to substantially increase profitability. There's a lot of noise in the midterm election around data center builds. We happen to believe that most of those data center builds will continue to go through. Many of them have are scheduled out for two or three years now in terms of of that construction. So there's still an opportunity there for investors. And frankly a little bit of headwind from the political side can actually improve that investment proposition a bit. And then on the use side, that's also where there's a lot of opportunity for investors to identify companies that are going to benefit from AI and try to get ahead of the changes in those firms or the industries that will be impacted.
23:39Chuck Jaffe: Looking at current events, because this is the week where we've got Anthropic coming out, et cetera, how much do you think the market takes a look at this IPO
23:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
23:51Chuck Jaffe: other current events involving NVIDIA and the rest and moves to the next take? Because there's two different ways to look at this. One is if this IPO goes gangbusters, great. That just means it's kind of normal conditions. It's sort of what happened with SpaceX, where they got the initial IPO pop, they went up, then they came down, and then they've sort of normalized out. If that happens, I don't think anybody worries. But there are people saying that, you know, anthropic is the ultimate cash out here, that they're only going public because nobody else wants to give them any more money. If this goes poorly, if the market winds up backing away from this, is there a bigger signal there? Like and if we don't wind up seeing OpenAI come out on time as a result, is there a bigger signal or takeaway for you?
24:36Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): The signal's really been in the market since the summer, around June of this year. Market has started to discount earnings for AI-related Related firms. You can see that pretty clearly in the Ford PE multiples. They're low, and that's mainly because the market is discounting earnings expectations over the next year and saying maybe we can't continue at 40-50% earnings growth on a year-over-year basis. And that's for the S P 500 earnings growth for 2027 versus 2026 is expected to be up 17%, but that's down. from call it 25% growth between last year and where we likely will end up this year. So there's already a bit of a question mark in the market from a single firm perspective, like anthropic. That's obviously a a really big IPO event. And I think it would be a mistake to read too much into either irrational a rational exuberance from from that. because there are few and far between IPOs available for innovative companies that are part of this artificial intelligence build out. But also the uncertainty that the market has had about AI is has existed for a while and I would be surprised if
25:55that goes away anytime soon. We're gonna going to live with that uncertainty in terms of exactly what earnings potential's potential is out there for a while.
26:03Chuck Jaffe: All of this has been masking a lot of what's going on with the market because you've got a market where mostly it has been lackluster for a while right now. I mean, the Mag 7, I know that people still use that title, but they've been the lag seven basically since the start of 2025. I mean, only two of the the lag seven stocks have beaten the S P 500. basically over the last two years. Is there a point where the market recognizes that like the Emperor's got no clothes here? That this has not been the good market we think it's been?
26:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): The market architecture has been pretty interesting. The dynamics underneath the top level S P SP five hundred 500 return. This year, we've seen more stocks than not in the SP. 500 outperform the index. That's a little bit of an unusual experience. Most years, a majority of individual equities underperformed the index itself. And certainly over two, three, four, five years, that's almost always the case. It's one of the reasons that indexing has become so popular and that active stock picking is challenging, is unless you pick one of the when winners, which are typically few and far between over the long term, you're going to struggle to even keep up with the market. This year is the exception though. The average stock or the the median stock in the S P 500 has outperformed the index by about one and a half percent. And we have at the same time, if you look underneath the hood a bit, you have about 35
27:3936% of the stocks in the SP 500 are in a 20% drawdown or more. And I I believe about 20% of the stocks in the SP 500 are more than 30% off their highs. So there's a lot of dispersion in the market. And it is remarkable. As much as w we all talk about AI, the parts of the market that have done the best tend to not do be the AI related stocks. But that's really a a near-term phenomenon when we look over two, three, four years, still have very high gains in most of the hyperscalers and and the AI related stocks. It wasn't that long ago that uh the commentary was all around how narrow the market was being driven by the Max seven. 7. And it's a simple rotation. And it's uh it says something about the health of the overall economy and the overall market that the rest of the index has been able to support the stock market as the largest companies have struggled.
28:40Chuck Jaffe: Let's move from stocks to bonds. We've gotten to where yields are north of 5% five percent or hanging around at 5%. five percent. People are worried that if the next move is up, that could become a problem. But in the meantime, you're getting paid to wait. So where are you on what people should be seeing out of the bond market right now?
29:05Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): It is a bit of a novel phenomenon that um investors were relatively happy to own bonds when interest rates were one or two percent. on say the 10 year treasury. And now that rates have moved back up uh to, like you said, over five percent, uh, a lot of investors look in the rear view mirror and they they see negative returns and they're increasingly worried about bonds. But we have a lot of protection built into bonds today because of that higher yield uh associated with uh with with bonds. And um from a asset allocation standpoint fixed income is much more competitive with equities than it was uh really over the last 10-15 years the post-financial crisis period so from a bond market standpoint uh in general uh bonds have a much larger role to play than they have uh over most parts of of the last 10 years the what I I I would add that one of our concerns and one of the concerns most investors should have is a sharp rise in interest rates, the 10-year Treasury moving up towards six percent. That's one of the big risks that we face from an economic standpoint. That could happen because the uh the market realizes
30:23that the Fed is behind the the ball in terms of inflation as is and it's going to have to continue to hike rates, or quite possibly because the Fed isn't willing to hike to the extent that it needs to. And um and inflation is going to be uh you know remain high along with this these drivers of economic growth that we've talked about. Um that can create a scenario where the 10-year tenure treasury starts to move back up towards six 6%. percent from an equity market standpoint. that's certainly a risk. Uh you're we'd expect to see a decline in equities if the 10-year treasury moved uh moved towards 6%. But for now, uh our expectation is that we're really going to stay in in this range that we've been in for a while. Tenure Treasury could move back down a little bit below 5%, a little bit above 5%, but economic data is stable. enough that there doesn't seem to be a strong catalyst one way or the other.
31:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Bull
31:20Chuck Jaffe: markets don't die of old age. This one going into its fifth year. From the sounds of it, we haven't spent a lot of time talking about volatility. You expect to see more volatility in some of those things. But if you and I are talking again at this point next year, will we be going, can't wait for this year to be over? What a miserable hard. horrible ride this has been, and whatever, or will we be going, wow, wonder if it's going to get to a sixth birthday?
31:45Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): You're right that bull markets don't die of old age. And we are in a risk on environment until something cracks in the economy. As we've discussed, there are plenty of positive signs in the U.S. economy today, despite high inflation, despite some of the struggles. that that creates for households, there is some stability in our economic growth. My expectation for next year is that that continues, although the returns that we've seen over the last few years, that's going to be hard to replicate. 15% per year or more in the equity market, that's been an unusual environment. It's been a pricing in of earnings. growth that has been realized across the SP 500 and other equity markets, but that won't continue forever. And investors priced a lot of what we will continue to see next year into the market already. So we'd expect moderation. I I think it's the best way to say it for next year. It would take something cracking tracking in and the market or in the economy to really see a substantial downturn. And those by definition, those events are difficult to predict. Perhaps a large company coming out and saying that they are cutting their AI spend, their AI investment, because they haven't seen the results that they were
33:04looking for. That's the type of catalyst that really could put a cloud over the industry. But until that happens, we expect continued growth and continued support for the bull market.
33:15Chuck Jaffe: Michael, really interesting perspective. It'll be fascinating to see if we get that kind of a thing. And we'll be watching. We know you will be too. So we'll check in with you again down the line. But thanks so much for joining me today on Money Life.
33:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Thank
33:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): you, Chuck.
33:28Chuck Jaffe: That's Michael Crook. He is Chief Investment Officer at Jenny Montgomery Scott, which is online at Jenny, J A-N-N-E-Y A N N E Y dot com. Up next, it's market call time. Chris Aceto from Gapstow Partners. He'll be here talking closed-end funds and BDCs when we come back in a flash. This is Money Love. Chris Aceto, Chief Executive Officer at Gapstow Capital Partners, is here. We're talking credit markets, closed-end closed funds, end and business market. development companies. Now on the Money Life Market Call. Welcome to the Market Call, the part of the show where we talk with experienced money managers about how they do their job, what they look for that determines their buys and sells, what they see happening broadly on the market, and how they put it all together. And making his debut today on the show, Chris Acido, Chief Executive Officer at
34:31Gapstow Capital Partners, online at Gapstow, Gap S T O W Gapstow.com. He is a credit-centric manager, meaning we're looking at credit markets. He does it with closed-end funds, but not all closed-end funds. There are parts of the credit market that are not really his focus. And he does it with business development companies. So we're going to discuss all of that now. Chris Acido, great to have you here on Money Life.
34:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Chuck, it is great to be here. Thanks for having me.
35:00Chuck Jaffe: We always start with methodology. You've got an approach that drills you into certain parts of the credit market, kind of keeps you away from the others, but also the things that you are looking for, you're pretty specific in what you want to see. So help us understand. how it works.
35:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Happy to, Chuck. Um, I think you introduced GapSell very well. Just to say it again,
35:21Chuck Jaffe: we are a credit-centric fund investor. And that's an important part to talking about the methodology for our audience. We're investing in funds, not individual stocks. And to me, it's it's an interesting question. You you always like to think of a money manager as you want to evaluate. their process and their people. And all of the things are very important. But I think for the audience today, I want to tell you there's one metric that I really hone in on as sort of a good first step for whether or not a fund is something we want to be taking a look at from a valuation standpoint. And as you know, this this is an interesting time to be talking about. this because people were familiar with the fact that BDCs and closed end funds are trading at discounts, some very, very significant. How do you make sure that you're not in a value trap? How do you make sure that you're not just drawn to a very high yield? So my first and foremost Most uh metric to look at is return on equity. Um, And I can dive into that, Chuck, if you want. What is return on equity? Coming back to funds, the funds that we look at, and BDCs included within that, are portfolios of loans. That's what they own.
36:40And so you would think that uh the portfolios would more or less be valued at what their net asset value is. But as we know, in the listed fund world, sometimes those funds can trade away from net asset value, premium or discount. But if you focus on how well that actual portfolio of loans is performing, that is what ROE is. That's what return on equity is. Did the portfolio of loans maintain its value, add some interest to that, uh, the dividend to it? and that's what the return on equity is. Different than what the share price return is, and uh different than what a dividend rate is, it's the total return associated with owning that portfolio. To summarize slightly differently, I've given this manager a dollar. Are they doing a good job with it from a cash on cash return to the underlying? portfolio? And maybe that share price goes through volatility swings, maybe premium, maybe discount. That's somewhat out of a manager's control. Are they doing a good job with investing the capital within that fund structure?
37:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): When you look at current markets,
37:55Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): you're
37:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): credit centric. Rick, We have seen interest
37:59Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): rates rise,
38:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
38:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): for a long time now, whenever rates have gone up
38:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and people have
38:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): said,
38:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): well, you know, rates go up, we're going to see more defaults and things along those lines. We haven't had waves of defaults. But for you as an investor, do rising rates change the game significantly?
38:16Chuck Jaffe: Um, rising rates will change the game over time, um, particularly on valuation, if you're holding fixed income-oriented underlying investments, rising. rates will pinch the valuation of those holdings. Sometimes, though, some of these funds are holding floating rate obligations that will actually increase in value with a rising rate environment, or at least directionally so, and certainly pick up on the dividend yield standpoint. So depending on the underlying collateral, rates will really have an environment. And I think you you've you've transitioned to a really interesting point, Chuck. which is, you know, what what's a good return for that ROE I was talking to you about? Um, and I'll give you my metric if if you're so interested. I I think
39:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): these
39:01Chuck Jaffe: funds I think these funds should be earning a nine to ten percent return on equity. Listed funds, they apply some leverage, they take risk with their underlying collateral. That strategy should be. able to over time produce 8, 9, 10% return on equity. And if they are not doing that, then I think there is some concern with is the manager doing a good job portfolio, and potentially they can do a little bit higher. And I think if if you want to assess where we are in the marketplace, everyone is asking right now. uh, BDCs are trading at 80% of book value. Should I jump in? That seems like a terrific opportunity. Question is, um, how do I know it's not a value trap? Think about ROE. And I'm gonna beat this, I'm gonna beat this drum throughout this podcast, Chuck. R O E, R O E, R O E. To give you an example, you know, if if something is trading at a nine to 10% ROE, I think it should trade more or less at NAV. These are obviously directional rules, but uh a good starting point. If you are looking at a BDC or a closed end fund that's generating a 5% return on equity, I don't think it should be a surprise to people
40:20that that probably needs to trade at a discount. That's not an irrational discount. That's saying I will pay less than a dollar for this net asset value in order for my return on my own invested capital to creep back up to that nine, 10%. Similarly, there are some BDCs right now who trade at a premium. Why would a premium make sense? Why would I pay more than net asset value? Well, those are BDCs and close closed in funds that generate a return on equity that's measured. kind of in the meat mid teens. Let's let's be really specific. There are 38 more or less listed BDCs right now. The six BDCs that trade above par, and they on average have a are trading at a uh 30% premium to book, have a five year return Your on equity measured in the mid-teens. mid teams.
41:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
41:12Chuck Jaffe: Chris's back of the envelope says a nav-oriented price should be uh nine to ten percent. Um, no surprise that a fund that is trading at a premium has a much higher roe. The other end of the spectrum, though, the 10 or so BDCs that trade at a 60% of book value or less have a five-year ROE of six 6% percent um on average. So well below. Chris's back to the envelope for what a good position should be. I know we're going to talk some specific names later on, but I'm going to use this directional rule on an ongoing basis to establish whether or not there is a value trap. So we can uh we can get into it.
41:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): One of the other things is you're looking for that ROE. There are parts of the fixed income and credit markets that you really don't get into, like you're not into Munibonds and things along those
42:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): lines, which I know because we've talked in the past, not for the show, but for the active investment company alliance roundtables that we've we've appeared at together. Is that a market call or is that an investment share class? In other words, is is this an asset class that you don't want to be in? even though you're looking for credit, or is it a call on I'd be there, but this is not the time to be there?
42:33Chuck Jaffe: Yeah, it's an asset class, almost an asset class definition, Chuck, which is for alternative credit investing, which is Gapstau's specialization, we need to look for return profiles that are in the high single digits, if not low double digits for credit investment. instruments. That is what we focus on definitionally because that's what credit investors demand as having a role of credit in a portfolio. That is to say, they need that return profile to make it relevant. That's very different than Munis or traditional fixed income, which have a very different return profile. They play a different role within the portfolio. They diversify from equity as credit does, but they do it in a way that uh produces a lower return profile. It's one of the reasons people are so interested in credit over the last decade or so, which is how do how do we re-intro how do we introduce into our portfolios equity diversifying asset classes that don't have a low return profile?
43:36Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Well, looking for the higher return profile, you know, historically high yield has been considered junk bonds, and yet they haven't been junky for a long time. And so there seems to be this sliding scale. While the public still thinks of them as junk bonds, now it might be private credit or something else that like that maybe should earn the level. So I'm curious
43:58Chuck Jaffe: because you are looking at alternative credits and you're looking at things like BDC. BDCs. Are you basically what would now be considered sort of the junk investor? Or is the credit quality still good enough that no, there's there's something a little further out there that fall qualifies as junk net. Yeah. Well, it it is all all junk. I I like not to use that. I like to it is below investment grade, all of these in instruments. The BDCs are different in that the below investment grade loans that they own are typically private, um, that is to say, not broadly syndicated, they are narrowly uh distributed, sometimes even bilaterally negotiated with a client. As a result, these are less liquid instruments, and so in addition to getting paid the high yield premium, uh, which is available, there's also an illiquidity and an origination premium that come along with these loans as well. So they uh they are like high yield rated uh below triple B, you know, so double B, single B, triple C. But but the less liquid nature of the BDC-oriented BDC oriented loans um could confer an additional uh yield pickup
45:17as well.
45:18Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): So while we're going to talk
45:20Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): some specific names when we get to my audience's picks in the lightning round, what is a name or two that's kind of the poster child for you right now? Like this is the space that I like to be in. This is the kind of fund or BDC that really is an exemplar of what we want to do.
45:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
45:36Chuck Jaffe: well, I I think we need to turn to those. using my metric here. You know, who are those BDCs to stick here that are trading well above book value, who are generating those above average returns on equities? You know, the six firms I referenced earlier include Main Street, Capital Capitals Southwest, Trinity Capital, Capitol, Hercules, Sixth Street, you know, Aries is pretty. close to uh a NAV or a premium as well. Um, those are it that's a heterogeneous group. It is interesting that between the smaller end of the market and the larger end of the private credit market, these firms have been able to uh generate those higher returns on equity relative to uh the peer group right now.
46:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And a
46:24Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): lot of people
46:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): will hear
46:25Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): this and go, wait, did he just say that the poster child for the methodology are the things that are trading at premiums? Because almost every time we talk to a closed end fund investor, it's all about the discount. This is distinctly not discount capture, but that is what you said,
46:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): right?
46:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Like the poster
46:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): children are all the ones
46:41Chuck Jaffe: that are at premiums. Well, I got I think there's a good argument for why the higher quality um return on equity metrics, so no value judgment. here. Just are you returning a higher rate of return? Are the ones that are being rewarded with that premium. And again, we we can now get into is the premium too much or not enough? Uh but in terms of the the not being a value trap, those are ones. And good pickup, Pick up, Chuck. That uh uh, you know, there's some in the middle that we I think we're gonna talk to in a in a few minutes that uh maybe are trading below where they should be, but uh don't don't ignore the ones with the premium.
47:20Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): And is that ultimately what winds up making you sell? Is that fundamentally it's just if the ROE is not good enough, that's gonna be the sell discipline?
47:31Chuck Jaffe: That is a very large component. And it's it's not the the ROE is important because not only is it going to be difficult to push the discount back to par, there are other components to it which are if you're not earning a big enough ROE, are you generating enough income in order to keep a dividend level stable? Do you begin to get into a bit of a vicious circle which is um having to cut dividend dividends, which then doesn't attract more investors, which pushes share price down even a little bit more. You know, that's that's where you know ROE is important as well. Not you're doing a good stewardship, but we also know this is a very dividend-oriented investing universe. And so, you know, cutting dividends is a is another downside to uh not being able to continue to produce a good ROE.
48:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
48:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): now we're gonna get your quick and dirty take on some BDCs and closed end funds my audience is particularly interested in. Quick
48:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
48:36Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): dirty.
48:39Chuck Jaffe: Why doesn't somebody tell me what they think is going on
48:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): here? Yes,
48:43Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): it's quick and dirty. That's what we call our lightning round here in the market call. And we're doing it today with Chris Acido, Chief. Executive Officer at Gapstow Capital Partners, Gapstow, G A P S T O W Gapstow.com.
48:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): If you want to learn more about Chris and the firm and what they do. You know how quick and dirty works, but if you want to get in on closed-end funds and BDCs, make sure you send your requests for those too to Chuck at MoneyLifeshow.com. Newlifeshow.com Include the tickers and your hometown. We're going to start today with a request. from Al in Orchard Park, New York. It's one of three BDCs we're going to discuss. He wants to know about OBDC. That's Blue Owl Capital Corp.
49:24Chuck Jaffe: OBDC, nav returns close to 10%, 9 to 10% historically. Yield 12%. Okay, Chris's metric should mean that should trade closer to par. In fact, Blue Owl, Al, and these are all as of uh last. week, is trading at a more than 20% discount to nav. Um, I find that interesting. What could potentially uh arrive at that conclusion? You know, Blue Al has been associated with a greater degree of technology investment and software investment. That's not necessarily true of this BDC, but maybe there is an overall concern with the name in that. regard. But you would think that uh at least the uh the gap style simple back of the envelope, it's interesting that they're trading at uh you know more of a discount than the ROE would would lead one to believe.
50:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): When you hear the word go, you just try to grab it. So, given that situation, that's a buy on OBDC Blue Owl Capital Corp. Javier in Wilmington, North Carolina. wants to know about SLR Investment Corp. That's SLRC.
50:31Chuck Jaffe: So SLR, SLRC. A little bit of a different BDC, unlike Blue Owl, which focuses on senior loans to corporations or private equity companies. SLRC has a unique business model in which the bigger part of their portfolio is oriented towards asset. back lending. For example, um, equipment finance. So a little off the beaten path for a typical BDC investor, if in fact they're focusing on the business model. Gap sale back of the envelope, nav returns in the seven to eight range, so maybe a little bit below where we thought, strong yield at 11%. Trading at a big discount, more than 30%. of a discount as of as of last week. So, you know, is this a you would warrant a little bit of a nav return discount, but 35, 30% discount for an interesting firm, maybe a little bit much. Maybe it's being hurt by the fact that people don't understand the business model as well as they should.
51:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Could we please buy now? So back of the envelope says. yes, that would be a buy
51:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): on SLR Investment Corp. SLRC.
51:44Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): And Peter
51:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in Wesley
51:46Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Chapel, North Carolina, wants to
51:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know
51:47Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): about Oak
51:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Tree specialty lending. That's
51:50Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): OCSL.
51:51Chuck Jaffe: Good three choices. They're very, very different, um, at least in terms of situation. Oak Tree is similar to Blue Owl in that they make primarily senior loans. But of the group lowest nav returns over the last few years, more in the five to six percent, and they're trading at a 20% discount. That's interesting. That one seems to indicate that uh, you know, this is not an irrational discount for ROE type measures relative to its its peer group. If it's well below that nine 9% to ten 10% percent heuristic, that uh perhaps a a discount is appropriate here.
52:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, so the discount being appropriate means the back of the envelope saying not so fast
52:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): on OCSL Oak Tree Specialty Lending. We're going to finish with two closed end funds. They are sister funds, so we'll lump them together. They also came from the same audience member. Dave in Jacksonville, Florida, wants to know about Eagle Point Income. That's EI. EIC, and then Eagle Point Credit, that's ECC.
52:55Chuck Jaffe: Yeah. So both funds focus on CLO investing, collateralized loan obligations. CLOs are themselves funds that own broadly syndicated loans for the most part. There are two ways to invest in a CLO. to either provide debt financing to the CLO or own the lowest tranche in the securitization, which gives you the broadest and deepest and riskiest exposure to that underlying portfolio. EIC focuses on the debt. ECC focuses on the equity of CLOs. Let's start with the equity. Um, That's a really difficult. situation. Um, CLO equity over the last 12 to 30 months has had a very rough go of things. Um, that for the most part, CLOs have been underperforming with yields coming in. Perhaps no surprise then that ECC has had an internal
53:59core return on its portfolio, ROE. that's actually slightly negative. And even though its yield is hold on to your horses over 40%, that might attract a few people. The price to nav is around 50% right now. So again, what might seem very, very attractive right now, price to nav a 50 cents a book, a yield that's very, very high. and yields are measured relative to uh the current market price. So, you know, 42 at a book value of 50 is maybe not crazy, but it's it's an eye-catching number. But one needs to understand that right now, um, and has been for the last five years or so, ECC has been a portfolio that has been shrinking in value over time. So a really interesting situation based on the heart of the market that it it focuses on. Eagle Point income, that's I think in the uh uh we can go back to our our usual metric. Uh you should know it by now, Chuck. 15% yield nav at 6.6, which is a little bit below. I bet you're gonna guess a
55:10PE discount of 20% makes sense in this case. And lo and behold, directionally, that's that's about right. Um, probably uh the the CLO mezzanine investing and CLO debt um has been actually a a pretty attractive space over the last few years. And as a result, uh mezzanine-oriented funds like EIC have done reasonably well. I might argue the NAV return is a little bit low relative to. what your expectations for such a fund would be, and we've made throughout this discussion. Um so maybe, maybe in a situation where a nav discount is is warranted.
55:49Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Yeah, so we we finish Eagle Point credit. That's that's a hard pass on that one on ticker symbol ECC. Eagle Point Income EIC, well, maybe a qualified buy, certainly one that's going to be. on the watch list, not necessarily a goodbye, just one that could that people can look for to see if it's going to pass their back of the envelope
56:12Chuck Jaffe: test. And speaking of goodbyes, well, we've gotten to the point where we have to say ours, Chris, but this has been great. I really appreciate you coming on the show. Hope we'll do this again down the line. Chuck, thank you for having me. Enjoyed Enjoy the discussion. That's Chris Assido. Acido. He's chief executive officer. at Gapstow Capital Partners, Gapstow.com to learn more about the firm. We'll be back to wrap up this show, but don't give up now or you won't cross the finish line, and then you might just feel like a loser. This is Money Life.
56:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We're
56:55Chuck Jaffe: back to wrap this one up, and before we do, well, beyond thanking you for being here all the way till the end, a little something that came up when Chris Assido and I had finished talking, which is he said, you know what, hey,
57:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
57:07Chuck Jaffe: was thinking I should maybe have done disclosure. And the reason that he was thinking that was not because he necessarily has positions in some of the stocks that we're talking about, but because they have positions in the index. So one thing we didn't really discuss is that GapStow runs the GapStyle private credit and alternative income index. And when we finished, he said, look, there are five issues that we discussed there that are currently included in that index, GapStyle Gap style Private Credit, and Alternative Income. And they are. ECC, which we discussed at the end, and OBDC, which we also discussed at the end, then ARCC, ARIES, MAIN, Maine, and T S L X. Those those BDCs basically were in that index. Also, super interesting compared to so many folks who say, hey, I'm looking for discounts and I wouldn't pay a premium. He's actually talking about. paying a premium. Tomorrow on this show, John Cole Scott from Closed End Fund Advisors
58:07will be here. So we'll have a little bit more closed-end fund talk. Plus, we've got Shiraz Mian, director of research at Zach's Investment Research, and more. I think we're gonna be starting like our a contest unlike any we've ever done, because it's got bonus prizes. I think that's coming tomorrow too. But with so many things happening on the market, I reserve the right to change my mind because I got an interview that I think we're going to use, but yeah, we're moving a lot because there's a lot of moving pieces. There's also a lot to celebrate today, and some of it's actually important. It is the great American smoke out. It's
58:43Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): like I picked the wrong week to quit smoking.
58:44Chuck Jaffe: Well, you did quit the wrong week to quit smoking if you are still smoking, in which case you want to celebrate the great American smoke. out and give it another try. It is World Pancreatic Cancer Day. It is Equal Opportunity Day, National Play Monopoly Day.
59:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): This isn't Monopoly money we're playing with.
59:03Chuck Jaffe: Actually, it would be if you're playing Monopoly. It is Use Less Stuff Day.
59:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Boy,
59:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): this stuff is terrible.
59:10Chuck Jaffe: It's not terrible, it's just like too much, and you don't need all that stuff, so use less stuff. It is World Philosophy Day, which interestingly coincides with World Toilet Day. You know, maybe that's intentional because some of us do our philosophizing on the toilet.
59:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): That's a real stroke of philosophic genius.
59:34Chuck Jaffe: I think that may be it. It's also have a bad day day.
59:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Things are about to go from bad to worse.
59:40Chuck Jaffe: National Blow Bagpipes Day, National Camp Day, and there's no food, there's just drinks. It's National Carbonated Beverage with Caffeine Day.
59:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Also
59:51Chuck Jaffe: National Macchiato Day and Beaujolais Nouveau Day. My guests today were Allison Hadley, an analyst at Digital Third Coast. The study was done for howdy.com and it's linked in our show notes. Michael Crook, Chief Investment Officer for Janny Montgomery Scott online at Janny.com. And Chris Acido, Chief Executive Officer at Gapstow Capital Partners, Gapstow, G A P S T O W dot com. Thanks to them. Thanks to Rob Floyd, my producer. Thanks to Maho, my dog. But mostly thanks to you for being here, because you make this special and worthwhile for me each and every day.
1:00:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
1:00:32Chuck Jaffe: Money Life quote of the day comes from Benjamin Graham. And no, he wasn't around for anthropic to start trading, but
1:00:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah,
1:00:39Chuck Jaffe: this one's appropriate for that too, because he said a hot stock like a hot stove should be handled with care. Yeah, think about it. Handle it with care, keep it in perspective, and remember. until we do this again the next time, the best thing you could do for your money is not worry too much about it. Have a great day, everybody. Stay safe, cool, and calm. We'll see you here on Money Life again tomorrow.
1:01:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): The people who appear on Money Life are here for your and their own entertainment. Don't take advice from us or any other podcast without doing more research and Andor or consulting your financial advisor. We believe our guests provide reliable information, but we can't and don't guarantee the accuracy or completeness of their statements. Opinions expressed on Money Life are those of the host and guests only, and reflect their personal thinking. They're not representative policy or strategy of any employers or sponsors. This show is produced by Money Life Radio, which retains all rights to the content. If you want to use any part of this show for your own purposes, be they good or evil, you must get our written permission first. And remember, with great financial information comes great responsibility. Please act responsibly.
1:01:41Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): We are officially over.