Speakers argue Roth conversions often reduce total wealth due to lost compounding and complex tax variables.
Summary
Tessa Hall and Larry Post from Baltimore Washington Financial Advisors discuss the complexity of Roth conversions, arguing that simple tax bracket comparisons are insufficient. Post explains that Congress originally restricted conversions to accelerate revenue collection, but universal access now requires multi-factor analysis. They highlight that inflation-adjusted brackets, IRMAA premiums, and spending needs significantly impact outcomes. Post notes that paying taxes early reduces compound growth, often resulting in less total wealth at death despite immediate tax savings. They recommend using financial planning software to analyze 13-14 factors, including realistic life expectancy, before deciding.
Key takeaways
- 1 Congress wanted to collect tax now. So that means they didn't have to cut spending. They didn't have to raise taxes. They could just make people accelerate the tax and collect the money.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) · 0:55
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 0:35
Introduction to Roth Conversion Complexity
Tessa Hall introduces the topic, noting that Roth conversions involve more than just comparing current and future tax brackets. She highlights factors like Medicare premiums, spending, life expectancy, and inheritance goals as critical variables.
- 0:35 – 1:15
Historical Context and Congressional Intent
Larry Post explains that Roth conversions were initially restricted to those with under $100,000 of AGI. He states Congress allowed universal access to accelerate tax collection, deferring the fiscal impact of future IRA withdrawals to a later date.
- 1:15 – 1:49
The Flaw of Single-Factor Analysis
Post critiques the common practice of judging conversions solely on marginal tax rates (e.g., moving from 22% to 24%). He argues this ignores future variables like inflation-adjusted tax brackets and IRMAA premiums, which can negate perceived benefits.
- 1:49 – 2:03
Inflation and Bracket Creep
Post asserts that tax brackets increase with inflation. Therefore, even if nominal withdrawals grow, the effective tax rate may remain similar to today's rate if brackets are not extrapolated for future growth.
- 2:03 – 2:23
IRMAA Premium Lag and Growth
Post explains that Medicare IRMAA premiums are based on income from two years prior. He warns that failing to account for the growth of both income and IRMAA brackets in future years leads to inaccurate calculations.
- 2:23 – 3:02
Spending Needs and Cash Flow
Post emphasizes that spending requirements dictate withdrawal necessity. He states that if money must be withdrawn for spending, the tax timing becomes moot, and conversions should not be analyzed in isolation from cash flow needs.
- 3:02 – 3:55
Life Expectancy and Software Analysis
Post notes that longer life expectancies favor Roth conversions. He mentions using financial planning software that analyzes 13-14 factors, including realistic life expectancy (noting most clients do not live to 100), to determine viability.
- 3:55 – 6:18
Net Asset Impact vs. Tax Savings
Post shares that new software analysis often shows Roth conversions result in less total wealth at death due to the early tax payment. He cites cases where clients saved $300,000 in taxes but lost over $500,000 in assets due to lost compounding on the tax payment.
Claims worth verifying
Roth conversions were initially restricted to individuals with less than $100,000 of AGI.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·0:55
How to verify: IRS Revenue Procedure 98-50 or historical IRS guidance on Roth conversion eligibility prior to the Taxpayer Relief Act of 2026 implementation details. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Congress allowed universal Roth conversions to accelerate tax collection and avoid cutting spending or raising other taxes.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·0:55
How to verify: Congressional Record or legislative history of the Taxpayer Relief Act of 2026, which established Roth IRAs. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
IRMAA premiums are based on income from two years prior to the premium year.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·2:03
How to verify: CMS (Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services) Medicare Part B and Part D Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount (IRMAA) guidelines. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
BWFA uses a life expectancy of 100 for cash flow purposes in financial plans.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·3:15
How to verify: BWFA financial planning methodology documentation or client engagement letters describing their planning assumptions. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Most clients do not live to age 100.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·3:55
How to verify: U.S. Social Security Administration Period Life Tables or CDC National Vital Statistics Reports. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
A client saved $300,000 in tax but had $500,000 less in assets at death due to a Roth conversion.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·4:15
How to verify: This is a specific anecdotal example; verification would require the specific client's financial plan or tax return data, which is private. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Charitable beneficiaries receive tax-free Roth assets, making Roth conversions inefficient if the primary goal is charity.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·4:55
How to verify: IRS Publication 590-B regarding distributions from Roth IRAs and estate tax implications for charitable bequests. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify current IRS tax bracket thresholds and inflation adjustment formulas for the relevant tax year.
- Check Medicare IRMAA premium tables and confirm the two-year lookback rule for modified adjusted gross income.
- Review personal spending needs and cash flow requirements to determine if withdrawals are necessary regardless of tax timing.
- Compare the immediate tax cost of a conversion against the long-term compound growth lost on the tax payment using a financial planning calculator.
- Assess life expectancy using actuarial tables rather than arbitrary high ages to model portfolio depletion accurately.
- Evaluate estate goals: determine if charitable giving is a priority, as Roth assets may be less efficient than traditional IRAs for tax-free bequests.
- Consult a tax advisor to model the impact of conversion income on Social Security taxation and Medicare premiums in future years.
- Review the specific financial planning software used by BWFA or similar tools to understand the 13-14 factors they analyze for conversion viability.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:00
- Tessa Hall: A Roth conversion is all about playing the tax game. And it seems pretty straightforward to pay the taxes now, move it into a Roth, and potentially avoid taxes on qualified withdrawals later. But deciding whether a conversion actually makes financial sense involves a lot more than just comparing your tax bracket today with the one you expect in retirement. I'm Tassa Hall,
- 0:20
- Tessa Hall: and in this episode, senior tax and planning advisor Larry Post explains why factors like Medicare premiums, spending, life. expectancy, and even who ultimately inherits your money can change the calculation.
- 0:35
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): There are probably thirty plus factors that come into play in determining a Roth conversion. Every meeting I go to, it's like I want to do a Roth conversion, I want to do a Roth a Roth conversion, conversion I or want to do a Roth conversion. Why do you want to do a Roth conversion? I pay the tax now and then I get free tax money. I said, okay. I said, you know, I understand. So we say, first of all, Roth conversions weren't always
- 0:55
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): allowed. When they first started allowing Roth conversions, couldn't make more than $100,000 of AGI. Then all of a sudden they said, hey, we're going to allow Roth conversions for anybody. Congress wanted to collect tax now. So that means they didn't have to cut spending. They didn't have to raise taxes. They could just make people accelerate the tax and collect the money. And you know what?
- 1:15
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): 30, 40, 50 years from now, when there's less IRA money and more Roth and they need money, they'll have to deal with it then. So having said that, we've talked with clients about Roth conversions. And typically what everybody does is they look at the marginal rate
- 1:29
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
- 1:29
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): they say, hey, I'm in the 22% bracket. Let's go to the top of the 22% because I'm going to be in the 24% someday and I'm going to pay less tax. Or I'm going to be in the 32% someday. Or I'm I want to pay the tax now. I'm in the 22 or 24. My kids are in the 32. And when they inherit it, they got this accelerated 10 years that they have to take the money out. That's all well and good
- 1:49
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): in theory, but you can't tell me what the future holds. Number one, people don't take into account the tax brackets caught by inflation. So the amount of money you're taking out today at the 10, 12, 22, and 24 goes up.
- 2:03
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 2:03
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): if your IRA grows, but the brackets grow, you actually may be taking it out at the same rate today and in the future. But people look at the bracket and say, Well, I'm gonna be taking more out. Well, of course you are. But the bracket goes up. And if you don't extrapolate the bracket, you've done nothing. You've made a really bad decision. They talk about I don't want to
- 2:23
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): take money out, I have Irma premiums, I'm gonna going to have to pay more Medicare. Well, guess what? IRMA brackets go up, their IRMA premium goes up, but they don't base it on this year's income. They base it on the income two years before. So unless you calculate all these numbers of the brackets going up, tax brackets, IRMA
- 2:42
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): brackets, all these things. And then the other big factor that comes in is what is your spending? If you're spending excess money and you have to take the money out, it's a moot point if you're taking it out because you have to. What we've determined, and what I've read more and started to really get in deep, is you can't look at one factor,
- 3:02
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): marginal brackets. And we have clients who call us and say, This is how much I want to take out. I'm staying in the 24% bracket. I said that's a bogus analysis. I'll do it for you. I'll take it, but I'm not recommending it. There are probably 30%.
- 3:15
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): plus factors that come into play in determining a Roth conversion. You have to do an analysis from today until your life expectancy, whether that's 80, 90, whatever you choose, the longer you go out for life expectancy, the better a Roth conversion looks. Now we use 100 for cash flow purposes when we do your
- 3:35
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): financial plan. We don't want you to run out of money. A Roth conversion. has to be reversed. I have to assume you die earlier, or at least you die at the life expectancy age of eighty two, eighty three, eighty-four. Maybe I go to eighty six, eighty seven, eighty-eight. If I go to age one hundred and everybody's Roth conversion, everybody looks like a superstar. But I can tell you that half of our clients, probably
- 3:55
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): three quarters or more, are not live into a hundred. So you gotta got to be realistic in your analysis because if you don't use realistic analysis, it's no good. We've started to use some software, we're just getting into it now that probably uses 13, 14 factors. So I'm not even getting to the full tilt. And what I've done is the couple Roth conversions
- 4:15
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): for people that have done in the past, I've now used this new software. And in most cases, I've determined it's not worth doing Roth conversions anymore. So it's an unusual circumstance where we're really looking at it because what's happening is we may save tax, but most cases the clients have less money at death. If you want to leave your kids or whoever
- 4:35
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): more efficient money, maybe we do the Roth conversion. But I've said some cases where a client was going to save 300,000 in tax, but have a half a million or more less of assets. So you just lost a couple hundred grand. And why? Because you're paying tax to the government early. You can't earn on that. anymore. That money is gone. But you have to take into account spending,
- 4:55
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): current salaries, pensions, where are they getting their money to spend? It's not from the IRA, but it will be. So when you do all this analysis, you realize hey, this really doesn't make sense. I have a client we did it for and realized realize most of her money is going to charity when she dies. So doing a Roth conversion just
- 5:15
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): spends more tax money because she's leaving it to charity. There's no tax when she dies. So why would I give the government money? You just can't look at the marginal rate. That's the issue we have now with Roth Conversions, is looking at one factor. And you're not changing that factor for future growth of the brackets, which is even worse. You know they're gonna go up and then you ignore it. So
- 5:35
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I think you need to do a lot more analysis, and I think more people
- 5:38
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): are going to be able to do that.
- 5:39
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): do them than shouldn't.
- 5:45
- Tessa Hall: Thanks for listening. For questions, more information, or to schedule a conversation, please contact Baltimore and Washington Financial Advisors. Past performance is no measure or guarantee of future returns. Investing in securities Insecurities involves involve risk, including the risk of principal. The securities and services mentioned here may not be suitable for every investor. You should discuss
- 6:05
- Tessa Hall: these with your advisor prior to making a final determination based on your risk tolerance, your investment objectives, and your financial situation. Baltimore Washington Financial Advisors is a registered investment advisor.
More from Baltimore Washington Financial Advisors Podcasts
Roth vs. Traditional 401(k): Which Should You Choose?
Episode discussion: Tessa Hall and Speaker 1 discuss Roth vs Traditional 401(k) choices based on tax bracket arbitrage and RMD management.
Speakers’ claims: Tessa Hall introduces the topic of Roth versus Traditional 401(k) accounts, questioning whether deferring taxes today creates larger problems later. Speaker 1 discusses 'Roth convergence,' advising individuals in lower tax brackets to contribute to Roth accounts to avoid paying out at higher future rates. He highlights clients in their seventies with large IRAs facing higher future tax brackets than their current income, suggesting they stop traditional contributions. An example of a client with $6 million in an IRA illustrates the tax drag of Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs). Speaker 1 argues taxable accounts offer long-term tax efficiency due to lower capital gains rates. The episode concludes with a disclaimer and direction to Baltimore and Washington Financial Advisors.
How Much Can You Afford to Give Your Kids in Retirement?
Episode discussion: Podcast advises prioritizing retirement security over lifetime gifting, using tax-deferred compounding to maximize inheritance.
Speakers’ claims: The speakers argue that retirees must prioritize their own financial security over lifetime gifting to avoid depleting funds before age 90. They recommend treating gifts as a budget item within a comprehensive financial plan that projects resources through age 100. A case study illustrates that withdrawing from a Traditional IRA to gift money triggers income tax and Medicare surcharges, making it inefficient. Instead, preserving tax-deferred assets allows wealth to compound, potentially growing $1.5 million to $8 million. The speakers conclude that immediate gifting is only justified if children have an urgent financial need, otherwise deferring the gift maximizes the total inheritance.