Speakers discuss Roth conversion strategies, tax arbitrage, and estate planning benefits for retirement income.
Summary
Jason Parker and Tim Tenbrink discuss the sustainability of current low tax rates given the $40 trillion national debt and recent legislative changes. Tenbrink identifies the period between retirement and Required Minimum Distributions as a 'golden window' for Roth conversions to engage in tax rate arbitrage. The speakers detail the mechanics of converting funds, including the impact on Social Security taxation and Medicare IRMAA, and emphasize paying conversion taxes with outside funds. They also address estate planning implications, beneficiary distribution rules under the SECURE Act 2.0, and the importance of maintaining account diversification for cash flow flexibility.
Episode sections
- 0:23 – 6:03
Gratitude and Thanksgiving Exercise
Jason Parker shares a personal anecdote about resetting his baseline for gratitude during a trip to Africa and introduces a two-week journaling exercise where listeners write one thing they appreciate about their spouse daily to improve relationship dynamics.
- 6:03 – 7:47
National Debt and Tax Rate Context
Parker cites a national debt of $40 trillion and references the 'One Big Beautiful Bill Act' extending the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, arguing that current low tax rates may not be sustainable given deficit spending.
- 7:47 – 11:57
Roth Conversion Strategy and Lifetime Tax Planning
Tim Tenbrink explains that tax planning aims to reduce lifetime taxes rather than just current-year liabilities, considering factors like the 'widow's tax trap' and beneficiary tax burdens.
- 11:57 – 13:55
The 'Golden Window' for Conversions
Tenbrink identifies the period between retirement and Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) as the ideal time for conversions due to typically lower income and tax brackets.
- 13:55 – 15:46
Tax Rate Arbitrage Mechanics
The speakers define tax rate arbitrage as converting funds when in a lower bracket (e.g., 12%) to avoid higher future brackets (e.g., 22%) triggered by RMDs.
- 15:46 – 24:40
Complexities: Social Security and Medicare
Conversions increase taxable income, which can cause more Social Security benefits to become taxable under provisional income rules and trigger Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amounts (IRMAA) for Medicare.
- 24:40 – 29:16
Paying Taxes with Outside Funds
Tenbrink recommends paying the conversion tax with outside savings rather than withholding from the converted amount to maximize the tax-free growth potential of the Roth account.
- 29:16 – 30:23
Beneficiary Distribution Rules (SECURE Act 2.0)
The speakers clarify that non-spousal beneficiaries must distribute inherited accounts within 10 years, with Roth distributions being tax-free while traditional IRA distributions are taxed at the beneficiary's marginal rate.
- 30:23 – 31:21
Roth Conversions as Estate Planning Tool
Tim Tenbrink describes Roth conversions as a method to gift taxes to beneficiaries by paying taxes now rather than later. This is particularly effective if the beneficiary is in a higher tax bracket or at the peak of their career when they inherit the funds.
- 31:21 – 31:41
Prioritizing Cash Flow Over Tax Optimization
Jason Parker argues that tax planning should not dictate all financial decisions, emphasizing that retirement cash flow security is the primary goal. He warns against sacrificing future plan security solely to minimize taxes.
- 31:41 – 32:27
Diversification of Account Types for Flexibility
Parker advocates for diversifying across taxable, tax-deferred, and tax-free accounts to create optionality in withdrawals. The goal is to pay a fair share of taxes but no more, allowing flexibility to manage tax brackets in retirement.
- 32:27 – 33:26
Building Financial Flexibility for Life Events
Tenbrink highlights that financial plans must accommodate unpredictable life events, such as expensive trips. Having a mix of account types allows retirees to fund these events without being forced into unfavorable tax situations.
- 33:26 – 34:23
Gratitude and Comprehensive Planning
Parker expresses gratitude to listeners and Tenbrink, framing tax planning as a component of a holistic financial plan. He suggests that optimizing taxes is a beneficial addition to ensuring clients are not just 'okay' but financially secure.
- 34:23 – 37:13
Professional Guidance for Tax Complexity
Tenbrink acknowledges that tax planning is complex and overwhelming for many. He positions Parker Financial's services as a solution to help clients navigate tax codes and avoid pitfalls, ensuring their retirement savings are not eroded by unnecessary taxes.
Claims worth verifying
The US national debt is $40 trillion.
Jason Parker ·6:23
How to verify: US Treasury Department daily debt clock or Treasury.gov data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-11 through 2026-11-11. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Giving away $1 million every day takes 2,700 years to pay off one trillion dollars.
Jason Parker ·6:42
How to verify: Mathematical calculation: 1,000,000,000,000 / 1,000,000 / 365 = 2,739.7 years. For recent events, verify 2026-08-11 through 2026-11-11. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The 'One Big Beautiful Bill Act' extended the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act and made SALT deductions available.
Jason Parker ·7:02
How to verify: Search for 'One Big Beautiful Bill Act' in US Congressional legislative records or IRS publications regarding SALT deductions. For recent events, verify 2026-08-11 through 2026-11-11. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceIndividuals born after 1960 must start RMDs at age 73 or 75.
Tim Tenbrink ·12:36
How to verify: IRS Notice 2026-30 and SECURE 2.0 Act provisions on RMD ages. For recent events, verify 2026-08-11 through 2026-11-11. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The ability to undo a Roth conversion was eliminated.
Jason Parker ·23:42
How to verify: Internal Revenue Code Section 408A(d)(4) and IRS Publication 590-B. For recent events, verify 2026-08-11 through 2026-11-11. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Non-spousal beneficiaries must distribute inherited accounts within 10 years under the SECURE Act 2.0.
Tim Tenbrink ·29:32
How to verify: SECURE Act 2.0 text and IRS guidance on inherited IRA distribution rules. For recent events, verify 2026-08-11 through 2026-11-11. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Tim Tenbrink is a CFP® and advisor with Parker Financial.
Jason Parker ·33:46
How to verify: Check Parker Financial's website (parker-financial.net) for staff profiles or the CFP Board's public database for Tim Tenbrink's certification status. For recent events, verify 2026-08-11 through 2026-11-11. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceParker Financial is an independent fee-based wealth management firm located at 9230-Bayshore Drive Northwest, suite 201, Silverdale, Washington.
Jason Parker ·36:41
How to verify: Verify the physical address via Google Maps or business registration records; confirm fee-based status via the SEC's Investment Adviser Public Disclosure (IAPD) website using the firm's name. For recent events, verify 2026-08-11 through 2026-11-11. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceThe Retirement Budget Calculator is a tool developed by Parker Financial.
Jason Parker ·35:51
How to verify: Visit retirementbudgetcalculator.com or Parker Financial's website to view the tool and its attribution. For recent events, verify 2026-08-11 through 2026-11-11. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Jason Parker is the president of Parker Financial LLC.
Jason Parker ·36:41
How to verify: Check the SEC IAPD database for Parker Financial LLC's Form ADV Part 2A, which lists principal officers. For recent events, verify 2026-08-11 through 2026-11-11. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceSound Retirement Radio is produced by Parker Financial.
Jason Parker ·35:32
How to verify: Visit SoundRetirementPlanning.com to view the podcast's about page or production credits. For recent events, verify 2026-08-11 through 2026-11-11. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify the current US national debt figure and recent legislative changes like the 'One Big Beautiful Bill Act' via Congressional records or Treasury data.
- Confirm RMD age requirements (73 or 75) based on birth year using IRS Publication 590-B.
- Calculate the impact of Roth conversions on Social Security taxation and Medicare IRMAA brackets using IRS provisional income rules.
- Review the SECURE Act 2.0 provisions for inherited IRA distribution timelines and tax treatment for non-spousal beneficiaries.
- Assess personal tax bracket arbitrage opportunities by comparing current marginal rates to projected future rates including RMDs.
- Determine if paying conversion taxes with outside funds is feasible to maximize tax-free growth in the Roth account.
- Evaluate account diversification (taxable, tax-deferred, tax-free) to ensure withdrawal flexibility for unexpected life events.
- Consult a tax professional regarding the elimination of Roth conversion recharacterizations under the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:03
- Jason Parker: Welcome back, America, to Sound Retirement Radio, where we bring you concepts, ideas, and strategies designed to help you achieve clarity, confidence, and freedom as you prepare for and transition through retirement. And now, here is your host, Jason Parker.
- 0:21
- Jason Parker: America.
- 0:23
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Welcome
- 0:23
- Jason Parker: back to another round of Sound Retirement Radio. I love this time of year. I think Thanksgiving may be one of my all-time favorite holidays. I had the good fortune to bring Tim Tenbrink, certified financial planner. He works here at Parker Financial back onto the program today to talk all about Roth conversions. This is the time of year, October, November, when we're sitting down with a lot of people and
- 0:43
- Jason Parker: evaluating whether or not Roth conversions make sense. And so I wanted to share with you what that process looks like and some of the questions you need to be thinking about as you're trying to decide whether or not you should be doing Roth conversions. But before we get started, I like to start the day by renewing our mind. This is verses from 1 Thessalonians chapter 5, verses 16 through
- 1:02
- Jason Parker: 18. Rejoice always, pray continually, give thanks in all circumstances, for this is God's will for you in Christ Jesus.
- 1:11
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 1:11
- Jason Parker: then, of course, something fun to share with your family as you're sitting around the thing. Thanksgiving table this year. What do you call a running turkey? Fast food.
- 1:21
- Jason Parker: Why did the turkey join a band? Because he had drumsticks. And what do you call a turkey the day after Thanksgiving? Lucky.
- 1:35
- Jason Parker: All right. Without any further ado, here's my conversation with Tim. Tembrink about Roth conversions. It's my good fortune to have Tim Tembrink, certified financial planner, back on the program with me this morning. And today we get to talk about Roth conversions. And I'll tell you, this may be some of the the next couple of years may be some of the most important years ever when it comes to this topic of Roth conversions.
- 1:55
- Jason Parker: This is the time of year, the end of the quarters when we're thinking about Roth conversions. It's the time when we do a lot of conversions for people, and we'll get into all of the mechanics and some of the things you want to be thinking about. But Tim, um, before we get into the Roth conversion conversation, I thought we could start the morning by talking about gratitude.
- 2:13
- Tim Tenbrink: Yeah, that sounds great, Jason.
- 2:14
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You know,
- 2:15
- Jason Parker: we've got Thanksgiving right around the corner, and it's about two weeks away. And one of the things that we want is when we're walking Talking life with people, we want to help them have a lot of that we want to help them have clarity about what's most important in their life. We want them to have confidence to know that the numbers are gonna work. And then when they have those two things, they get to experience freedom. But one of the things I found is that
- 2:34
- Jason Parker: it's really easy for your baseline to get set and and then you stop remembering just how good your life is. And this happened to me recently. I was traveling, I was in Africa, and I'm sure we'll do another podcast in the future to go in more detail on that. But several of the days that we were there, we ran out of water. at the place that we were serving. And so there were no showers, 95
- 2:54
- Jason Parker: degree weather. And after two days of working in this hot and not having a shower, on the third day, they finally got the water flowing again, and we were able to get, and by the way, there's only cold water. There's no hot water there. On the third day, we got a cold shower. And I have to tell you, Tim, my baseline was totally reset. Like when I wake up in the morning in Washington State, I've got hot water
- 3:14
- Jason Parker: every morning. But when I got that cold shower after a couple of days of not having any water, boy, I tell you, it was the second best shower I have ever had, second only to the one that I had when I got got home from that trip. And so we um when our baseline gets reset, when we become more aware of the people that we love and what
- 3:34
- Jason Parker: we love about them, it just changes the dynamic of our life. It makes our life richer. Um, you know. we we our life goes in the direction of the things that we focus on. And so we want people to focus on having a great life. So several years ago, I started this practice. And this is a really good short-term practice for people about to enter into Thanksgiving, where you take one person, usually I
- 3:54
- Jason Parker: recommend it's your spouse or your significant other. And for the next two weeks, um, you get a journal out, and you can do this on your phone too, just in the notes app on your phone. And every day, write down one thing that you recognize about your spouse that you just love. And the idea is every day for the next two weeks, write something different. The temptation here
- 4:14
- Jason Parker: is to say, Well, we've got all these people coming over for Thanksgiving, so I'm going to write down one thing about each person. And I I really want to encourage people not to do that. I want them to just focus on one person because what happens is the first day of the journal, it's easy. The second day, it's easy. The third day, it's easy. But as you start going through these two weeks, you really have to focus. You really have to
- 4:33
- Jason Parker: become more aware of the things that you love about this person. Because the idea is you don't want to just write the same thing every day. And what ends up happening from my experience is your heart changes and you just become much more
- 4:49
- Jason Parker: grateful for that relationship. in your life. And then I would encourage you, after you've written it down, it doesn't make sense to love someone and keep it a secret. So when we get to Thanksgiving, hand that notepad over to the person you love and just let them know all of the things that you appreciate about them. And I am pretty certain that if you've never done this exercise and you
- 5:09
- Jason Parker: do this for the next two weeks leading up to Thanksgiving, you are about to have one of the best Thanksgivings of your life. So that's a little tip, just something I wanted to talk about. Today we're going to talk about Roth conversions, but anything you want to talk about when it comes to gratitude or your thoughts there?
- 5:22
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
- 5:23
- Tim Tenbrink: I love that just practical exercise. And um, I think as you were talking about that,
- 5:28
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): when
- 5:28
- Tim Tenbrink: I when I think about relationships, there's a tendency to just recognize what people Will do or don't do for us. And what you've challenged us with is to go beyond that.
- 5:39
- Tim Tenbrink: just surface level of whether someone's doing for us what we want them to do or not, and think about who they are and what we can appreciate about them for who they are, not just the benefit of the things that they do for us.
- 5:52
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Especially in
- 5:53
- Tim Tenbrink: a marriage or in our family relationships. We can we can lose sight of that. So thank you for the the practical challenge. And I think uh it's a really good exercise that I'm gonna do over these next couple of weeks.
- 6:03
- Jason Parker: That's gonna be good. Well, let's get into this conversation about Roth conversions, because this is the time of year that we do Roth conversions. Before we get into the topic, though, like the mechanics, one of the things we need to talk about is the national debt. So I've got the US debt clock pulled up. Right now it's showing me national debt of $40 trillion. $40 trillion. Let me put that in perspective for
- 6:23
- Jason Parker: our listeners. Many of them have never heard this, but if you were to give away one. $1 million every day, a million dollars every day, the question is, how many, how long would it take you to give away one uh one trillion dollars if you're giving away a million dollars every day? The answer is two thousand seven hundred
- 6:42
- Jason Parker: years if you were gonna hit just one trillion. We've got forty $40 trillion dollars of national debt. The other thing that we need to be aware of is that when President Trump, in his first term with the Republican House and Senate, they passed one of the strongest tax relief acts ever, the One Big Beautiful Bill
- 7:02
- Jason Parker: Act. It extended the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act. It made things like the new senior enhanced senior deduction available, made salt available, state and local uh taxes deductible. We've got this opportunity. right now where we have these all-time really low income tax rates, a national debt that's currently $40 trillion.
- 7:22
- Jason Parker: And the question I think a lot of people are asking is is that sustainable? You know, is it possible to keep tax rates at this all-time low and continue to just go deeper and deeper in debt as a result of the deficit spending that we're doing? So that kind of sets the stage about why a lot of the people that we serve are in interested Roth conversions, why we take this very seriously. What are
- 7:42
- Jason Parker: your thoughts, Tim, as we get into this conversation on Roth conversions? Anything else we should be thinking about?
- 7:47
- Tim Tenbrink: Yeah, well, there's definitely when it comes to taxes, these are very comprehensive. The tax code is not simple. And that's why one of the things we do is just help people navigate that through tax planning. And I think some of what you mentioned, I'm I'm glad you brought it up. because the reality is there are a lot of headlines out there, whether
- 8:07
- Tim Tenbrink: it be the national debt, and we're just thinking about some that even are tailored to retirees, the ticking tax time bomb, or you know, I've heard it referred to as the RMD success penalty. And while these represent realities of the tax code and how it works, the real mechanics of it.
- 8:27
- Tim Tenbrink: Um, it's so important to have a good plan so you're not in a frenzy just making emotional decisions when it comes to um decisions like whether to convert to Roth or how much to convert. And so that's that's one of the things we do is recognize the reality of okay, there are very real concerns and aspects that we want
- 8:47
- Tim Tenbrink: to be thinking of, but we want to be strategic and you wanna have want a plan to in. place. If you don't have a plan
- 8:53
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
- 8:53
- Tim Tenbrink: you're trying to do tax planning, if you don't know what your current tax rate is and what your future tax rate is, then you're just kind of guessing and um making decisions based on, again, emotion and not data. So
- 9:06
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that's
- 9:06
- Tim Tenbrink: one of the things that as financial planners, we really help people do is make good decisions when it comes to taxable liabilities, things that they need to take care of. And so and that tax planning that we do, essentially, what are we trying to do? Objective number one, reduce lifetime taxes. Okay.
- 9:26
- Tim Tenbrink: We're not just saying, does this reduce your tax liability this year? We're looking at the lifetime tax bill and saying, are there ways that we can reduce that over your lifetime? That's objective number one. Second Secondary day. objectives, sometimes as we work with people, would be
- 9:43
- Tim Tenbrink: to make a taxable situation better for a surviving spouse. You know, we'll talk about the widow's tax trap or something like that. Or some people are concerned about their beneficiaries and saying, okay, I want to leave an inheritance, but I don't want to leave a big tax bill with it. And so those are some other maybe second, third objectives that we accomplished. accomplish through
- 10:03
- Tim Tenbrink: tax planning. And some of that morphs into estate planning as well. But that's the big goal that we're trying to do is say, okay, how can we look at where you're going tax-wise, make decisions on an annual basis that is going to reduce that over your lifetime. And today the the strategy specifically that we're talking about
- 10:23
- Tim Tenbrink: that we consider doing that is Roth Conversions. We've been um working through a bunch of our clients. It's been a very busy season because this is the time of year where many of our clients were having the conversation of what's the income like for the year? Does this make sense for your financial plan? Looking at future tax rates and saying,
- 10:43
- Tim Tenbrink: Okay, let's pull the trigger, let's make this happen.
- 10:46
- Jason Parker: One one thing I I would do wanna want to say as we get into this deeper into this conversation is um this is not advice for anybody to go out and make a decision today based on this conversation. You know, we you have to have that, like you were saying, you have to have that comprehensive plan. And we don't want somebody to make a financial mistake because there's a lot of interconnected moving parts here
- 11:06
- Jason Parker: that if you're not aware of them, um there's things that could sneak up and cost you a lot more in taxes than and you may not be aware of. So don't don't leave the stop listening to this. podcast today and go convert all of your money to a Roth. That's another thing I I want to make people aware of is v sometimes it makes sense, but very rarely does it make sense to convert all of your qualified assets in a single year. So um
- 11:26
- Jason Parker: that's not something that we generally recommend. We're usually looking at this, like you said, strategically on a year by year basis. And we have to think through all of the implications. But one of the things you just talked about was the idea that
- 11:39
- Jason Parker: when we're planning for people, we want to consider the taxes that they're going to pay, not just in the current year, but over their lifetime. And you mentioned things like widows' taxes. So what are some of the other things that we need to be thinking about as we're trying to make decisions about uh tax planning for people?
- 11:57
- Tim Tenbrink: Well, as we work with folks, depending on what season of life they're in, um, you know, we work with folks. that are still working and are several years from retirement. And so um maybe some of tax planning with them is determining not necessarily Roth conversion, but should they be deferring taxes or should they be contributing to a Roth? So that that is kind of
- 12:16
- Tim Tenbrink: pre-retirement. And then when people t typically what we see when people retire is their tax rate comes down. They're not earning as much as they used to be. And that opens kind of the gold golden window or the ideal time between retirement and in the future when required minimum distributions start, or what's referred to as RMD.
- 12:36
- Tim Tenbrink: So that if you're born after 1960, that's gonna start at age 73.
- 12:41
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): If
- 12:41
- Tim Tenbrink: you're born after 1960, that's gonna start at age 75. And um it can make sense to do con conversions outside of that, but typically that's the window. where we're really pursuing um we've got a lower tax rate environment or uh season of life that we're looking at taking advantage of.
- 12:59
- Jason Parker: Um, one of the things that a lot of people don't think about, but just the decision on when to start Social Security can play into um does it make sense to do Roth conversions? But you're right, this golden window that you call it, this um this period of time from the time that you retire, your income drop. drops way down until the time that the RMDs have to start. And the RMDs
- 13:19
- Jason Parker: used to be easier to understand. You know, everybody had to start at 70 and a half, and then it changed to 72 and then 73 and then 75. So kind of depending on when your birthday is determines when you have to begin taking the mandatory distributions out of those accounts, those minimum distributions out of your accounts. But let's talk about some of the mechanics. You know, there's a
- 13:39
- Jason Parker: lot of moving parts. There's things we have to be concerned with, like income related Medicare adjustments for Medicare, getting phased out of the enhanced senior deduction. So what are some of the things that when you when we're doing planning with people that are are things that we're looking at consistently?
- 13:55
- Tim Tenbrink: I think number one, when we're looking at should we be converting an amount to Roth, how much should we be converting to Roth? The first thing we're doing is looking at what's referred to as tax rate arbitrage. In other words, just to give a simple example, let's say somebody is in their mid-60s,
- 14:15
- Tim Tenbrink: current taxable income keeps them in the 12% tax bracket. But looking forward to the future, when RMDs kick in, maybe they've done a great job saving, they've got a lot of money tax deferred, and they're going to jump up into that. 22% tax bracket. So at a very simple level, it's can we fill up the 12% tax bracket, knowing that when
- 14:35
- Tim Tenbrink: you turn 75%, you're going to have to take money as an RMD at the 22% tax bracket. That's called tax rate arbitrage. And that is the simplest way to say, okay, should or we should we or should we not be converting? Is being able to take advantage of a lower rate. You pay the money
- 14:55
- Tim Tenbrink: when you can pay at a lower rate. And that's that's kind of the idea of if I can pay less now in taxes, why you know, take advantage of that than paying more in the future. And now the money that has been transferred to the Roth account is gonna going to grow tax free for the next maybe decade of their life. from
- 15:14
- Tim Tenbrink: 65 to 75. So that's that's kind of the simple kind of no-brainer way, at least to us, it seems like a no brainer. That's the slam dunk Roth conversion scenario that doesn't get into some of those other things. But beyond that, that's where we start looking into more complexity in a sense of we want to convert and we're looking at marginal
- 15:34
- Tim Tenbrink: rates. What What what's your marginal tax rate? But then we're also looking at does this cause my Social Security to go up? You know, that's taxed at a little bit different than just your regular marginal rate.
- 15:46
- Jason Parker: Oh, and when you say tax your Social Security to go up, what you're talking about is how much of your Social Security becomes taxable because of the provisional
- 15:53
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): income
- 15:54
- Jason Parker: rules with Social Security, not every dollar from Social Security is necessarily taxable. And so depending on all of your income sources, determines how much. of your Social Security is taxable. So just to clarify, and one other thing, Tim, that sometimes I think as advisors, like you said, it things seem obvious to us because we're in these numbers all day. But most people aren't in this
- 16:14
- Jason Parker: world of tax planning and financial planning and retirement planning and cash flow planning and investment management. So let's just back up just a tad bit and just at a very basic level, why why do do people like Roth conversion? conversions? So, like what makes them a attra attractive? What why do why are Roths attractive in the first place?
- 16:30
- Tim Tenbrink: Yeah, let's just talk about what we're doing with the Roth conversion. So you've got money that's tax deferred. That could be a traditional IRA, that could be a 401k. You got money that while you were working, um you were able to defer the taxes.
- 16:44
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
- 16:44
- Tim Tenbrink: when that money comes out of that account in the future, you know, you retire, you're gonna going to take distributions, if you don't touch the money, when you hit required minimum distributions, you've got to start taking money out. Then every dollar coming out of those accounts, because it's been deferred, is now going to be taxed. So what we're doing with the Roth conversion is we're transferring
- 17:04
- Tim Tenbrink: money from those traditional tax-deferred accounts to the Roth account. We're going gonna to realize those taxes in the year we make the transfer.
- 17:13
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 17:14
- Tim Tenbrink: we've increased. taxable income the year that we do the conversion. We wouldn't have had that tax otherwise. But now that money is in a Roth account and now it can go tax free for the rest of your life. It's not gonna be subject to required minimum distributions. For your beneficiaries, there's the advantage of they could leave the money there and
- 17:33
- Tim Tenbrink: distribute distributed it out over 10 years. They're not gonna going pay to tax on it. So if we think about someone maybe 20, 30 years of retirement, we've moved money to that Roth account and all that appreciation can happen in the Roth account versus the tax deferred account, which means there's going to be more money that's going to need to pay tax on down the road.
- 17:52
- Jason Parker: Yeah. That's
- 17:53
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what
- 17:53
- Tim Tenbrink: we're aiming to do.
- 17:54
- Jason Parker: And for our younger folks that have the opportunity to contribute to Roths, um, it's one of the things we love. I one of the best analogies I ever heard is said it's kind of like
- 18:03
- Jason Parker: having an apple orchard. And you can either choose to pay tax on the seed or pay tax on the harvest. So when you plant your initial apple tree, you're paying tax on the seed. That's the Roth. And then you never pay taxes again. On the deferred accounts, you don't pay taxes when you plant the seed, but every apple you pull off that tree for the rest of
- 18:23
- Jason Parker: your life is taxable. So you're paying taxes on the harvest versus paying taxes on the seed. And obviously, most of most of the people that we serve, not everybody, most people say, you know, Jason, if I could pay less money in taxes over my lifetime, that's something I'd definitely be interested in doing. And let me also just say that there's a big difference between
- 18:42
- Jason Parker: tax planning that's legal and some of these weird things that people get into where they're really playing this game about gray area with that. the IRS. At our firm, we don't like the gray area. We like black and white. And and Roth conversions is a very black and white area of the tax code when it comes to planning.
- 19:01
- Tim Tenbrink: Yeah, we're not talking about cheating on taxes. We're talking about legal aspects of the tax code and just using it to advantage. And one of the big things that we do with tax planning is just helping manage, you know, taxable income on any particular year, just estimating and managing that, realizing income if it's it's if it's possible, like a Roth conversion. You
- 19:21
- Tim Tenbrink: know, that's money that you wouldn't be paying tax on this year, but we've accelerated the taxable income in the into this year to do a Roth conversion because it's going to be lower, or there's advantage to doing it now versus waiting till later. And so um,
- 19:36
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah.
- 19:36
- Tim Tenbrink: But
- 19:37
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a lot of a lot of our kind
- 19:38
- Jason Parker: a lot of our clients are experiencing this. But but for people out there that may not know what this looks like, taught walk us through like what the expectations are. What what happens when you're doing this type of planning? So you start with the financial plan, um, you're looking at how much they're going to pay in taxes this year, how much they're going to pay in taxes over their lifetime. You're considering things like the
- 19:58
- Jason Parker: enhanced senior deduction, income-related Medicare adjustments, um, get and then once we once we get the big picture financial plan built, right? So now we have a big understanding of like what the implications are for taxes over their lifetime, then we get very specific with our tax planning software, which is separate from our the financial
- 20:18
- Jason Parker: planning software that we built. And then that's where we really try to optimize for the current year's taxes. This, you know, we're looking very granular. granularly at w how much they paid in taxes last year. We're making uh estimates about dividend and interest and capital gains. And that's why I a lot of people may not realize this. One
- 20:38
- Jason Parker: of the reasons we wait until the end of the year to do this type of planning is we really want to have a comprehensive understanding of what people's full tax picture looks like. So trying to get this done in October, November is why it makes a lot of sense because then we we have a better picture of what their tax situation looks like. But anything else that you you can think of as we just kind of help people understand the
- 20:57
- Jason Parker: process that they should experience and expect.
- 21:00
- Tim Tenbrink: Yeah. Well those are certainly the two challenges. And you know it it seems like, okay, yeah, Roth conversions, that's great. Let's do it. The two challenges that we face is number one, being able to estimate where your taxes are going to be in the future. and and knowing okay here's your future cash flow future income being able to do that that's where having a good plan
- 21:20
- Tim Tenbrink: it helps us with that and then number two estimating what's your income this year and that's where we're looking at okay what are all your distributions if you've still been working what are taxable what are your capital gains looking like for this year if you've got a brokerage account interest on savings accounts I mean all of those different aspects where we're basically working through
- 21:40
- Tim Tenbrink: your taxes before you have to file them in a sense to figure out okay, where are you going to be at the end of the year? And um that that's the piece that is is really crucial because you have to know, okay, where am I at for the year? And so that you can make a good decision again. What we don't want to do is say our whole objective is to reduce lifetime taxes, and
- 22:00
- Tim Tenbrink: we're just again guessing,
- 22:02
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
- 22:02
- Tim Tenbrink: then in the process of guessing, we've actually increased lifetime taxes. And so rather than accomplishing our objective, we've done the opposite. We've said, okay, we've we've added your tax bill this year when you wouldn't have paid maybe taxes. Or you've mentioned the idea of Medicare and Irma. You know, you go over uh uh there's a cliff there. If
- 22:22
- Tim Tenbrink: you go one $1 dollar over the IRMA threshold, now you've got to pay an additional amount for Medicare for. that particular year that's going to be coming up. And so a lot of different aspects. But in our process, we want to know where you're going. And then we want to estimate what let's get a good feel of what's the income for this year looking like. So now we know how much it's going to make
- 22:42
- Tim Tenbrink: sense to convert before we go into that next marginal tax bracket, or we know this is what's going to cost you your Social Security to be taxed more. or cause that increase in Medicare. I mean, those different aspects that all are impacted by how much income you realize in this year. And then from there, then we're going to, you know, make a good
- 23:02
- Tim Tenbrink: decision.
- 23:02
- Jason Parker: Yeah. And the mechanics are because a lot of people remember when they're working, they have until April fifteenth of the following year to make contributions for the prior year to their IRA accounts. But that's not the case with Roth conversions. You have until December 31st. You can't this isn't something we can push back after the first of the year. After the f you know, after December 31st, it's too late for the current year to
- 23:22
- Jason Parker: do Roth conversions. And um, the other thing that people really want to make sure they're aware of is that it used to be that you could undo a Roth conversion, like you can change your mind after the fact and say, I don't, I don't want to do this anymore. Well, they eliminated that. That's no longer the case. So once you do the Roth conversion, you're locked into it. So you really want to just take the time, move slowly, make sure you understand what all
- 23:42
- Jason Parker: of the moving parts are, how this is gonna um you know, when when a dollar hits your tax return, it it flows through that tax return. It impacts a lot of different areas. And so that's why you can't just say, well, I'm in the 12% bracket, it's gonna cost me 12% taxes. It's not that simple because um a lot of there's a lot of moving
- 24:02
- Jason Parker: parts. in a tax return.
- 24:04
- Tim Tenbrink: Exactly. That's where the again, the Social Security, if you start a Social Security, the portion that's taxed is can go up. And now you've changed your effective tax rate, not just the marginal bracket, but what you're actually paying through your effective tax rate has gone up. And again, now now maybe you haven't noticed it because you're just looking at, well,
- 24:24
- Tim Tenbrink: what's my top bracket that I'm paying? And haven't looked at your overall tax bill has actually gone higher than what we would have expected it to be in the future. We've we've shot ourselves in the foot of what we're aiming to accomplish.
- 24:37
- Jason Parker: Talk to me about paying the actual tax.
- 24:40
- Tim Tenbrink: Yeah. So what we normally recommend is if it's feasible for you to do this, we want to pay for the additional tax with an outside account. Um, what we mean by that. if you're let's just use a simple example, you're doing a Roth conversion of 10,000, you can have tax withholding on that 10,000. If you're in the 12% tax
- 25:00
- Tim Tenbrink: bracket, maybe you withhold 12%. Now you've only got 8,800 that's going into the Roth. Well, the Roth money is your most valuable money. Like we said, that's got the tax advantage of it's it's not going to be facing RD, it's not going to be. taxed as you make any trades in that account, and it's not going to be taxed when it's distributed. So
- 25:20
- Tim Tenbrink: it's got a lot of tax advantages to the Roth money. So we want to maximize, you know, every dollar that you can keep is Roth. So when we look at maybe if you've got a savings account, you pay that extra twelve hundred in tax out of your savings account, you've got that full $10,000 going into your Roth account. And what I like to explain to people is in a sense, you can think
- 25:39
- Tim Tenbrink: of that $1,200, you might have had it in a savings account. Some people, you know, they they might have that in a high yield savings account. They're earning 3.5% currently. And now they're paying tax on that interest every single year. Well now by moving that $1,200 out of that account and keeping it in the Roth, you've created a little bit of a tax shelter. And so that
- 25:59
- Tim Tenbrink: $1,200 from now on, you're not going to be getting taxed on. where you would have been if you just kept it in the
- 26:06
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): high
- 26:06
- Tim Tenbrink: yield savings account. So, you know, those are all the different pieces that that we kind of work through and help people. So if you can afford it, that's the way you're going to get the best bang for the buck with the Roth conversion.
- 26:17
- Jason Parker: Yeah.
- 26:18
- Tim Tenbrink: Um it can it can still make sense to do a conversion and do tax withholding if you don't have outside funds that you can pay for it. Um, But it does diminish a little bit. the advantage of it.
- 26:28
- Jason Parker: The bottom line is we're starved for well, we're not really starved for tax revenue. We we just spend too much money. That's the real problem. But um eventually that money's got to come from somewhere. And the concern is with forty trillion dollars of debt, is it possible that taxes could go up in the future? And so you know when when we're doing our projections and we're trying to say, okay,
- 26:48
- Jason Parker: is this going gonna to help you pay less money in taxes over your lifetime? we're only doing that based on the current tax rate. We're not taking into consideration the fact that if taxes do go up in the future, how much that increases your the benefit to you. And the reason that we do it that way is because we like to say hope for the best, plan for the worst.
- 27:04
- Tim Tenbrink: Sometimes when I'm talking with a client and
- 27:07
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
- 27:08
- Tim Tenbrink: they're going, should I do a Roth conversion? And we look at their future taxes and based on current tax rates, they don't really go up, they don't go down. They just stay in the same bracket for the rest of their lives. They don't hit Irma charges, or maybe they're in the same tier of IRMA. So there's not a change there. And the question then is, okay, should I convert or
- 27:28
- Tim Tenbrink: should I not convert? Is there an advantage?
- 27:30
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 27:30
- Tim Tenbrink: I think that's where there's two advantages I think I see if it if it's just a wash. You know, if you're saying, okay, I'm in this tax. bracket, I'm gonna stay in this tax bracket. Does it make any sense? Is there an advantage? You already mentioned one, and that's well, what if tax rates go up? Um, by kind of locking in the tax rate now, we've said, okay,
- 27:50
- Tim Tenbrink: we've given a hedge that tax rates could go up in the future, but I've already paid some of that and and and locked in my rate today. The other thing, too, that um, you know, as we work with clients over decades. is what's referred to as the widow's tax trap. So something changes in your taxable situation. If one of the spouses passes away,
- 28:10
- Tim Tenbrink: you go from um married filing jointly to single. And so you you know, you're gonna get less of a standard deduction. And um and now your tax rate is up if you still got inherited, but you know, are if you've got RMDs RMBs across all of the accounts. because you inherited them all. And so um now your tax rate has gone up,
- 28:31
- Tim Tenbrink: where jointly it was maybe going to be in the same bracket. Now it's in a higher bracket. So that's another hedge as well of just well, what if one of you were to pass away and the other spouse has a good number of years that they're gonna live, but now they're paying it in a higher tax bracket. So one other reason that maybe if it's uh a you know, looking at a Roth conversion and we don't we're see not an seeing
- 28:51
- Tim Tenbrink: escalation in taxes, but it can still make sense to to give that protection. You know, this could be if there's a large difference in age between husband and wife or um you know one of them maybe is going to be expected to live longer, then that can be another reason to say, okay, let me just get the tax situation done.
- 29:11
- Tim Tenbrink: Let me move toward lowering that tax bill in the future and lock locking in the rate.
- 29:16
- Jason Parker: Yeah. The other thing I think would be great is if you could provide some clarity around the inherited required minimum distribution and then how the Secure Act changed that from lifetime distributions to the 10-year distribution and how we need to take that into consideration.
- 29:32
- Tim Tenbrink: Yeah, no, that's a good point. Um Secure Act 2.0 kind of outlined what the distribution rules are. So now there's a 10 10-year window and that's going to be the same if we're talking a traditional IRA versus a Roth IRA. You still have 10 years. The money's got to be distributed at the end of that 10th year. But the difference between the for the beneficiary
- 29:52
- Tim Tenbrink: and again we're I think I'm well I'm going with the route of a non-spousal beneficiary. You've got options as a spouse if you inherit that account to transfer it to your own. But if we're talking um you know uh a a child or someone else that's not a spouse, you've got that 10-year window. But if it's an inherited Roth account, when that money comes out, it's not going to be
- 30:12
- Tim Tenbrink: taxed at all. If it's a
- 30:15
- Tim Tenbrink: if it's a tax-deferred account, then you're gonna have 10 years, but it's gonna be taxed at whatever their marginal rate is, whoever's the beneficiary. And
- 30:23
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): so,
- 30:23
- Tim Tenbrink: you know, for for us as we talk with clients, that certainly is a conversation of you can almost think of it as gifting the taxes to your beneficiary. If, you know, you're doing a Roth conversion and you this is money maybe you're never going to touch in your lifetime, when they receive it, you've already taken care of the tax bill for them. And that's kind of a way of passing that to them.
- 30:43
- Tim Tenbrink: You know, that can be really effective if you're thinking about what's their marginal rate. Like maybe you have a child that is a high income earner and the potential of them being at the peak of their career when they receive these accounts. Just I I think when we talk about the idea of stewardship, it's thinking about okay, do we lower your lifetime taxes? But then thinking
- 31:03
- Tim Tenbrink: too, what happens to the money afterwards? So from a stewardship standpoint, that can make sense of, okay, I've got a son that's a doctor or an attorney that make h uh a good bit of money, and I'm in a lower tax bracket. Well, maybe I want to do Roth conversion so that they're not seeing a lot of that money eaten up in taxes once once I pass away.
- 31:21
- Jason Parker: Yeah. I think a key here is we don't want to let the tax tail wag the dog. Right. This isn't something where we make all of our financial decisions solely based on taxes. Like taxes are important, but in retirement, the most important thing is cash flow. It's making sure you're not going to run out of money in retirement. So we wouldn't would never want to do Roth conversions and
- 31:41
- Jason Parker: sacrifice the security of your future plan. You know, we got to get the priorities straight. The other thing, just like we always talk about diversification being the only free lunch and investing, this usually isn't an all or nothing equation. This is usually can we diversify the different types of accounts that we have so that we have some taxable, some tax deferred, some
- 32:01
- Jason Parker: tax-free? And then that gives us flexibility for taking future withdrawals. And it just um we're just trying to create options. We're trying to create optionality. We're trying to create, we we always tell people we want them to pay their fair share of money in taxes, but not a penny more than their fair share of money in taxes. And that's the reason behind tax planning and specifically
- 32:21
- Jason Parker: this season that we're end of doing Roth conversions. Anything else you want to make sure we touch on, Tim, before we finish up today?
- 32:27
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
- 32:27
- Tim Tenbrink: Well, I like the word that you just said of flexibility. We don't do a financial plan that is just perfect on paper. People's lives don't work that way. And so, you know, folks decide, hey, we're in having our 40th anniversary. We're going to do this once in a lifetime trip. And at that point, you want to be able to make a decision to accomplish, you know, what what you want to do in life
- 32:47
- Tim Tenbrink: and not have to think about, man, all I have is taxed. tax deferred money and I'm going to get whacked on taxes for us to take this trip. And so, you know, one of the things that we like to be able to do as a financial is how can we build flexibility so that if you have some goals that you want to accomplish, they're going to cost more. We've taken
- 33:07
- Tim Tenbrink: advantage of some tax opportunities earlier on so that you're not just getting punished later on while you're just living and doing the things that you want to be able to do. enjoy with your life. So that that's a key word and part of a good financial plan is being able to build in that flexibility to the different account types that you've got that give you different levers to pull when you need to.
- 33:26
- Jason Parker: Yeah, I think that's great. Well, as we head into the Thanksgiving year, I just want to tell all of our listeners that I'm grateful for them. I'm grateful for the opportunity to get to walk life with you and help you on this retirement journey. Tim, I'm grateful for you. I'm grateful that you are uh an advisor, a financial planner with Parker Financial, and that you just do an excellent job. And people really
- 33:46
- Jason Parker: appreciate you and they appreciate the wisdom and the thoughtfulness that you bring to it. So um, again, just entering this season with a heart full of gratitude and um grateful for the people in our lives. And um, we get this really unique opportunity to walk life with people and help them offer. optimize. You know, it's one thing to be able to say, yeah, you're going to be okay. And then it's another
- 34:06
- Jason Parker: thing to be able to say, how do we um not just be okay, but really think through the implications of all the different moving parts in somebody's lifetime and taxes is a big part of that. So if we can help them pay less money in taxes, that's great. You know, it's kind of like the cherry on top of a really good financial plan.
- 34:22
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well
- 34:23
- Tim Tenbrink: Jason, thanks for letting me work with you. And I it's a joy for me to be able to serve the clients that we get to help. And maybe as you're listening today, you maybe you find enjoyment and keeping tabs and all the changing tax codes and deductions and everything that is represented as a part of that. But maybe there's some folks listening and you can think of a
- 34:43
- Tim Tenbrink: thousand different things you'd rather do with your time than
- 34:45
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): be
- 34:45
- Tim Tenbrink: and paying attention to your taxes. Maybe you're feeling overwhelmed or you know, you're just not interested. in the meticulous nature of it. Um, it is complex work when it comes to tax planning and overall financial planning, and that's where we can help. So um it starts with having a good financial plan that gives you confidence. We want to make sure that your hard-earned retirement savings
- 35:05
- Tim Tenbrink: aren't going to be eroded by taxes more than they need to be. And so maybe you're hearing this and you could um be helped with some professional guidance. I'd encourage you to reach out to us and um you know so you can move forward with confidence that you've got a good financial plan in place, that you can avoid those um tax pitfalls that might be coming your way. And
- 35:25
- Tim Tenbrink: um just just move forward with clarity and confidence.
- 35:28
- Jason Parker: Awesome. Thanks so much, Tim. Appreciate you.
- 35:31
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Thanks,
- 35:31
- Tim Tenbrink: Jason.
- 35:32
- Jason Parker: Thank you for tuning in to Sound Retirement Radio for articles, links, and resources from today's show, visit Soundretment Planning.com. If you enjoy the podcast, share it with a friend and give us a five-star review. Ready to kickstart your retirement planning? Head over to
- 35:51
- Jason Parker: retirementbudgetcalculator.com. Need assistance with investment management? Explore our services at parker-financial.net.
- 36:01
- Jason Parker: Information and opinions expressed here. are believed to be accurate and complete. For general information only, and should not be construed as specific tax, legal, or financial advice for any individual, and does not constitute a solicitation for any securities or insurance products. Please consult with your financial professional before taking action on anything discussed in this program.
- 36:21
- Jason Parker: Parker Financial, its representatives, or its affiliates have no liability for investment decisions or other action. actions taken or made by you based on the information provided in this program. All insurance-related discussions are subject to the claims-paying ability of the company. Investing involves risk. Jason Parker is the president of Parker Financial LLC, an
- 36:41
- Jason Parker: independent fee-based wealth management firm located at 9230-Bayshore Bay Shore Drive Northwest, suite 201, Silverdale, Washington.
- 36:49
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): For
- 36:49
- Jason Parker: additional information, call 360-337-2701 or visit us online at Sound Retirement Planning dot com.