Retire With Style

Wade Pfau and Alex Murguia discuss Tax Map Challenge results and warn against blindly filling tax brackets.

35 min Listen to the original Episode page
Tax PlanningRoth ConversionsSocial SecurityACA SubsidiesRetirement IncomeTax Map Challenge

Summary

Wade Pfau and Alex Murguia recap the Tax Map Challenge, where over 9,000 tax maps were generated by participants to test retirement planning scenarios. Pfau argues that the goal should be managing effective marginal tax rates rather than simply 'filling' tax brackets, as doing so can trigger higher taxes on Social Security or loss of ACA subsidies. The hosts highlight specific risks, such as the 'tax torpedo' effect and the stacking of preferential income rates. They also announce upcoming community challenges and future episodes focusing on non-financial retirement topics.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    Over 9,000 tax maps were run by approximately 900 independent individuals during the challenge, averaging 10 runs per person.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) · 0:41

  2. 2
    So in particular, with that, like we're focused on Roth conversions and beans harvesting, and that has to be done by December 31st. You it's too late if you're waiting until the following April.

    Wade Pfau · 5:22

  3. 3
    The tax map concept, developed by Joel Sasser, plots how each dollar of income is taxed, including interactions with Social Security, capital gains brackets, ACA subsidies, and Medicare surcharges.

    Wade Pfau · 6:15

  4. 4
    12% bracket, not only are you paying income at 12%, but you're before you get to the end of the year bracket, you pushed all of your long-term capital gains and qualified dividends from their 0% rate into their 15% rate. And so you're really paying a 27% marginal tax rate.

    Wade Pfau · 8:29

Episode sections

  1. 0:00 – 2:15

    Introduction and Tax Map Challenge Overview

    The hosts introduce the episode as a recap of the recent Tax Map Challenge, noting over 9,000 tax maps were run by participants. They discuss the high engagement levels and the purpose of the challenge in educating retirees on tax planning strategies.

  2. 2:15 – 5:22

    Challenge Philosophy and Mechanics

    Alex Murguia explains that the challenge was designed to move beyond superficial financial planning by having participants actively work on their tax maps. He highlights the interactive, scalable nature of the event and its goal to foster a community of informed retirees.

  3. 5:22 – 9:37

    Tax Map Methodology and Effective Marginal Rates

    Wade Pfau explains that the challenge focused on Roth conversions and tax-loss harvesting, emphasizing the importance of managing effective marginal tax rates rather than simply filling tax brackets. He details how the tax map accounts for various tax interactions like Social Security taxation and Medicare surcharges.

  4. 9:37 – 20:43

    Participant Engagement and Feedback Analysis

    The hosts report that over 2,000 people registered, with roughly 1,200 attending and 912 individuals running tax maps. Feedback indicated high satisfaction, with 89% finding explanations clear, and participants expressing interest in future challenges.

  5. 20:43 – 25:22

    Lessons Learned and Future Improvements

    Wade Pfau notes that the initial three-day format was too rushed, suggesting a four-day structure with split presentations for beginners. He mentions plans to automate labels on tax maps to explain specific tax spikes like the Social Security tax torpedo or NIIT.

  6. 25:22 – 30:45

    Case Studies and Tax Planning Scenarios

    The hosts discuss specific case studies, including the Affordable Care Act subsidy cliff at 400% of the federal poverty line and preferential income stacking. They highlight how managing tax brackets can inadvertently trigger higher taxes on qualified dividends or loss of subsidies.

  7. 30:45 – 32:04

    Upcoming Funded Ratio Challenge

    Alex Murguia announces a future challenge focused on the funded ratio, targeting participants within 10 years of retirement or post-retirement. He notes that over 2,000 people registered for the previous challenge and encourages early sign-ups for preparation videos.

  8. 32:04 – 33:06

    Community Building and Pickleball

    Murguia and Pfau discuss attending the pickleball world championships in Dallas, where Pfau watched professionals and Murguia won a gold medal. They highlight community engagement by inviting participants to a barbecue at 'Heart Eight' after the challenge's Q&A.

  9. 33:06 – 35:20

    Future Episodes and Closing Remarks

    Wade Pfau mentions upcoming special episodes featuring Kevin Lyles, Fritz Gilbert, and Mike Drak, focusing on non-financial aspects of retirement. Murguia thanks listeners for their participation in the challenge, emphasizing the shift from passive listening to practical community action.

Claims worth verifying

Over 900 independent individuals ran over 9,000 tax maps during the challenge, averaging 10 runs per person.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·0:41

How to verify: Check the podcast show notes or the Retire With Style website for the official challenge results summary. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The Tax Map Challenge took place from November 2nd to 4th.

Alex Murguia ·1:54

How to verify: Verify via the Retire With Style website archives or social media announcements for the event dates. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

More than 600 written questions were submitted by participants during the challenge.

Alex Murguia ·1:54

How to verify: Check the Retire With Style website or challenge summary for participant feedback statistics. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The challenge originated from the Retirement Income Style Awareness (RESA) tool and the hosts' book.

Alex Murguia ·2:55

How to verify: Verify via the Retire With Style website's 'About' section or the book 'Retire with Style' by Wade Pfau and Alex Murguia. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The tax map concept was developed by Joel Sasser.

Wade Pfau ·6:15

How to verify: Search for Joel Sasser's publications or presentations on tax mapping, or check the Retire With Style website for guest contributor credits. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Filling the 12% tax bracket can push qualified dividends and long-term capital gains from the 0% rate into the 15% rate, resulting in an effective 27% marginal tax rate.

Wade Pfau ·8:29

How to verify: Verify using IRS Publication 17 or a tax calculator to model the interaction between ordinary income, qualified dividends, and capital gains tax brackets. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The Affordable Care Act subsidy cliff occurs at 400% of the federal poverty line.

Wade Pfau ·25:22

How to verify: Verify via the IRS or Healthcare.gov publications on ACA subsidy phase-outs. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Over 2,000 people registered for the challenge, with roughly 1,200 attending.

Alex Murguia ·9:37

How to verify: Check the Retire With Style website or challenge summary for participant registration and attendance statistics. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

89% of participants found the basic explanations around how taxes work to be clear.

Wade Pfau ·17:02

How to verify: Check the Retire With Style website or challenge summary for participant feedback statistics. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The tax map accounts for interactions with Social Security, capital gains brackets, ACA subsidies, and Medicare surcharges.

Wade Pfau ·6:15

How to verify: Verify using IRS Publication 917 (Social Security) and Publication 590-A (IRA contributions) to understand the taxation rules, or use a tax calculator to model these interactions. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The next challenge will focus on the funded ratio and is planned for the front end of Q1.

Alex Murguia ·30:45

How to verify: Check the podcast show notes or McLean Asset Management website for announcements of the 'Funded Ratio Challenge' scheduled for Q1 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Over 2,000 people registered for the Tax Map Challenge.

Alex Murguia ·31:39

How to verify: Review the 'Retire With Style' podcast show notes for Episode 255 or the McLean Asset Management website for registration statistics. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Wade Pfau and Alex Murguia are principals of McLean Asset Management.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·34:05

How to verify: Search the SEC Investment Adviser Public Disclosure (IAPD) database for 'McLean Asset Management' to confirm registration and principal status. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

McLean Asset Management is an SEC registered investment advisor located in Tysons, Virginia.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·34:05

How to verify: Verify the firm's Form ADV Part 2A filing on the SEC EDGAR database or the IAPD website for the firm's physical address and regulatory status. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Alex Murguia won a gold medal at the pickleball world championships.

Wade Pfau ·32:18

How to verify: Check results from the 2026 Pickleball World Championships (or relevant year) for Alex Murguia's medal standings. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Wade Pfau attended the pickleball world championships in Dallas.

Alex Murguia ·32:04

How to verify: Verify the location and dates of the Pickleball World Championships hosted by the International Federation of Pickleball (IFP) for the relevant year. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The barbecue venue was called 'Heart Eight'.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·32:48

How to verify: Search for 'Heart Eight Barbecue' in Dallas, Texas, to confirm the existence and location of the restaurant. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Upcoming episodes will feature Kevin Lyles, Fritz Gilbert, and Mike Drak.

Wade Pfau ·33:18

How to verify: Check the 'Retire With Style' podcast schedule or McLean Asset Management blog for episodes featuring these specific guests. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Wade Pfau is a Retirement Researcher.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·34:05

How to verify: Review Wade Pfau's professional biography on the McLean Asset Management website or his LinkedIn profile. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The podcast is 'Retire With Style'.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·34:05

How to verify: Check the podcast listing on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or the McLean Asset Management website for the show title. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify the 'tax torpedo' mechanics by reviewing IRS Publication 915 on Social Security taxation.
  • Check current IRS brackets for qualified dividends and long-term capital gains to confirm the 0%/15%/20% thresholds.
  • Review the Affordable Care Act subsidy cliff rules at 400% of the federal poverty line.
  • Confirm the definition and calculation of the Net Investment Income Tax (NIIT) under IRC Section 1411.
  • Read Joel Sasser's original work or documentation on the Tax Map methodology.
  • Check the specific dates and registration requirements for the upcoming Funded Ratio Challenge.
  • Review the RESA tool documentation to understand the underlying assumptions of the tax maps.
  • Verify the hosts' disclosures regarding any conflicts of interest with the RESA tool or their book.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
0:00
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): purpose of Retire with Style is to help you discover the retirement income plan that is right for you. The first step is to discover your retirement income personality. Start by going to retirewithstyle.com slash style and sign up to take the industry's first financial personality
0:20
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): tool for retirement planning.
0:41
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Fair warning: by Alex's own admission, today's episode is a bit of an infomercial. But this is Retirement Retire with Style. Over 900 people ran over 9,000 people. tax maps during our tax planning challenge. That's about 10 each. Even though Alex suspects there might be one person who could have run 100, you know who you are.
1:01
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Wade and Alex have the full breakdown.
1:04
Wade Pfau: Hey everyone, welcome to Retire with Style. I'm Wade and I'm here with my trusty co-host Alex. And we're ready for another exciting episode for you. Hey Alex, how are you?
1:14
Alex Murguia: I'm well, Wade. How about yourself?
1:17
Wade Pfau: Doing good, doing good. Still recovering from our big tax map challenge that we had just not last week, but the the week before. It's but still recovering.
1:26
Alex Murguia: No, no, Wade, you did yeoman's work so much so that, like I said, I think I made a comment at in in the last session where we did a big QA where you just you just went through, you just planned. plowed through what two hundred two hours worth of questions back to back. And uh I I what did I say? Like you should be cool on America's Got Talent and just
1:46
Alex Murguia: have Simon zing you with tax questions and see what happens. No, you you were amazing, man. Seriously.
1:52
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Good job.
1:54
Alex Murguia: Yeah.
1:54
Wade Pfau: Yeah. Yeah. We had probably more than six hundred 600 written questions coming in that week. So it was tough to keep up, but on that final day with our bonus QA, we we did get through it all. But yeah, we're we're getting a little bit ahead of ourselves. So the November 2nd to 4th, we did the tax planning challenge. And can you give us some of the
2:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): final
2:14
Wade Pfau: data that you had?
2:15
Alex Murguia: Exactly. But before then, just to give folks a sense of what what the tax map challenge is, because we've we we had a ton of emails come in after we finished the challenge asking when's the next one? What is this about? And so we wanted to take a you know time in this episode just to give everyone a lay of the land of what we do and the philosophy
2:35
Alex Murguia: behind retire with style. Again, retire with style started from the RESA. We wanted to promote the retirement income style awareness uh tool that we created to help folks identify what preferences they have with regards to sourcing. retirement income. And from there the podcast grew and grew so
2:55
Alex Murguia: much so that uh, you know, you had published a book. And so we've gone through the arc of your entire book, item, you know, discussing all the detailing all the chapters and and how they have, you know, how they are all interrelated with retirement income plan. And along the way, we started doing something called challenges. The idea there was like, you know, at the beginning of the year, how
3:15
Alex Murguia: you have these juice challenges and things like that. And so we wanted to take a flyer off of that and see if this could generalize to financial planning topics, in which there are these challenges that we run, they're not necessarily superficial challenges. They're they're hardcore, Or, you know, roll up your sleeves, let's
3:35
Alex Murguia: get to work, and let's actually start uh working on a financial plan for you. Simply because we thought that that would be kind of cool and we would learn a lot as uh, you know, we have an advisor for McLean Asset Management, and we have Retirement Researcher, which functions as our, if you will, masterclass for all things retirement income
3:54
Alex Murguia: planning. And so these challenges actually is a way that Wade and I can
4:01
Alex Murguia: go into our audience. members and actually interact with them in a manner that's scalable because it's hard for Wade to talk to the 2,000 people plus that had registered for it. You know, it's it's the sort of one-to-many approach. But in that, we get so much feedback on things that we could be doing and and we learn. You know, we we provide value, but we also To learn.
4:21
Alex Murguia: And so these challenges have taken off. We started with the retirement income challenge where we go through the research. RESA and a funded ratio. And so after three or four days, everyone actually has created a financial plan. And we wanted to, after doing that for a, I don't know, let's say two years, like once a quarter or
4:41
Alex Murguia: something like that. We uh we wanted to see if there are other things that people would be interested in, and we wanted to do a tax map challenge. And that really is about tax. preparation for next year. How to begin to think about uh tax planning. You don't want to wait till April 14th, and all of a sudden you realize, man, this is a big tax bill. I could have done things
5:01
Alex Murguia: differently, which I'm sure it happens to everyone on occasion. And so we thought if we do something with regards to tax planning at, you know, towards the start of the the fourth quarter, I think that would give people enough time to become. begin to make us adjustments by year end to make sure that they can make the their tax season more
5:20
Alex Murguia: palatable.
5:22
Wade Pfau: So in particular, with that, like we're focused on Roth conversions and beans harvesting, and that has to be done by December 31st. You it's too late if you're waiting until the following April.
5:32
Alex Murguia: Yeah, exactly. And so what we did is we have, you know, Wade has said, we did three live days from November 7th. 2nd to the 4th built around the tax map calculator that Wade created. Because in our view, you want to see your lifetime tax picture, not necessarily this generic tax bracket. And Wade,
5:52
Alex Murguia: you know, he one of the things he he preaches is you don't want to manage to brackets. You want to manage to your effective rate and and the the effective marginal rate. But Wade, you take it from there and maybe give a little one-minute explainer of what the tax map does so people know what we're talking about as we go into the
6:11
Alex Murguia: challenge uh
6:13
Alex Murguia: post analysis.
6:15
Wade Pfau: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah. So it it's thinking about do you have we have to pay taxes, but looking for opportunities to do at the lowest possible tax rates. And we had Joel Sasser on the show last week. He's really the developer. of that concept of tax maps where you actually plot out with each dollar of income you generate, how is it taxed, not just in
6:35
Wade Pfau: terms of the federal income taxes, but does it cause Social Security to be taxed more? Does it push your preferential income, your long-term capital gains and qualified dividends into higher tax brackets? Uh, do you are you using the Affordable Care Act and are you losing some? subsidies for the Affordable Care Act health insurance? Are you having to pay
6:55
Wade Pfau: Medicare surcharges because your income exceeds certain thresholds? How's the net investment income tax fit into that? And now, especially after tax uh last year's new tax legislation, there's like eight different below-the-line Below the line deduction phaseouts phase outs to keep track of as well. Now that's kind of crazy. But the tax map puts that all together. it
7:15
Wade Pfau: And yeah, this is something that I've been using in my book. And we've had the tax map calculator
7:22
Wade Pfau: and using with people who understood the concepts better in advance. So it was a new challenge with the tax planning challenge. We had more than a thousand participants out of the 2,000 registrants. And uh some folks, this is the first time they've ever seen the tax maps. So there was more of a learning curve, but it was real interesting to work through that. And it's really this
7:42
Wade Pfau: idea that you fill tax brackets is so ingrained into the population that it's really hard to fight that. That's kind of one of the big lessons I took from the week of
7:52
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
7:52
Wade Pfau: idea. If you say, I want to fill my 12% tax bracket, that's probably the most dangerous one out there because that's not really what you want to do. If you want to manage a 12% marginal tax rate, that's not the same as filling your 12% tax bracket. Because in particular, with that one,
8:09
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if
8:09
Wade Pfau: you've already claimed Social Security, you might be pushing through the tax torpedo where you're not only are you paying income at 12%, but you're causing more of your social security benefits to be taxed at a 12% rate. And then the big one after that, too, is if you have any qualified dividends or long-term capital. gains, when you're filling that
8:29
Wade Pfau: 12% bracket, not only are you paying income at 12%, but you're before you get to the end of the year bracket, you pushed all of your long-term capital gains and qualified dividends from their 0% rate into their 15% rate. And so you're really paying a 27% marginal tax rate. And so filling the 12% tax bracket would
8:49
Wade Pfau: be a huge mistake. And I think that's lessons that kind of wrapped my head around for a while. But for the general population, so many questions coming in. Really, we're not they're not internalizing the idea that managing an effective marginal tax rate is quite different from filling a tax
9:09
Wade Pfau: bracket. So we're really doing kind of cutting edge stuff in terms of helping people understand. really how to think about tax planning.
9:17
Alex Murguia: And that's that's as close to that's as close as you're gonna get to Wade patting himself on the back and and being effusive of what he created, which is you know, I I can do it for him, which is phenomenal. For yeah, I'd be even more so, but everyone here gets the joke. And so just to give you
9:37
Alex Murguia: folks a sense of it, if you're ever thinking about of doing a future challenge here, this the participation was off the charts. We had over we had roughly 2,056 people registered. And of that, 1,222 people showed up. So that's roughly 60% of the people who signed up showed up. You know, and
9:57
Alex Murguia: and we did this, you know, if you folks are thinking you need a push, you know, even an eagle needs a push at some point, right? We had 1100 people in day one. And all the way through today, day three, we still had 690 people working through their tax plan. And so Wayne and I were through the moon simply because,
10:15
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
10:15
Alex Murguia: this is the podcast, and we, we, we speak and we put it out there in the ether. And sure, we can look at our our numbers of downloads and things like that, which, you know, continues to climb. But when we see people out actually have something tangible coming out of the information that that we but largely Wade speaks about, it really gives
10:35
Alex Murguia: us purpose, frankly. It makes us feel good that we're we're doing something here. You were actually moving the needle. And the reality here is that
10:45
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
10:45
Alex Murguia: know it it it it almost caught wildfire towards the end, where 900 963 people registered somewhat late and 302 signed up the same day while the while the challenge was going on. And so that means there was some virality to it. You know, it was spreading while it was happening. And so what we really want to do this is it gives everyone
11:05
Alex Murguia: a sense of keep your eye out for future challenges because we definitely think there is value just based on what we've seen and everyone you know reacting to it. So in the show notes, we'll have that as well. You know, and you can go to retirewithstyle.com forward slash challenge if you want to be on our wait list for future ones. We do think with the number of people that
11:25
Alex Murguia: showed up, we are gonna have to probably put a ceiling on it simply because the number of questions that come in are just untenable, frankly, for Wade and myself, and again, largely Wade, to answer simply because the volume of questions. And we like to keep it intimate because part of this is we want to provide value, but we also want to learn from it. And
11:45
Alex Murguia: sometimes if 10,000 people show up, it's it's just gonna be hard for us to absorb all of that. And you know, there it is from that. And we what we also do, the importance of signing up earlier rather than later, is that we have prep videos for it. Uh, we did three videos.
12:03
Alex Murguia: explaining what we just said at the very beginning of this podcast, talking about the below the line deductions. Maybe some of you folks are wondering, well, what is that? You know, things like that. And so there's a little bit of an orientation that we provided before the challenge just to get people's uh fluid, you know, working here. And so from that,
12:23
Alex Murguia: we had roughly rough almost 650 people watching. watch the preparation videos before day one. And all of those folks that did it
12:33
Alex Murguia: were able to go along much clearer in terms of the content that they ran. Now, wait, since you have the numbers in front of you,
12:42
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): how
12:42
Alex Murguia: did it go? How many people did the maps? How many people used your creation to actually
12:47
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
12:48
Alex Murguia: give themselves a sense of where their text tax planning uh you know year 2026 would look like. And the only caveat I would say beforehand
12:56
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is we're
12:58
Alex Murguia: we're we're advisors, we're not tax professionals. And so everyone was always instructed at the end of the day, run it through a tax professional, but now you have a semblance of what you're working with. Wait.
13:09
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
13:09
Wade Pfau: yeah. So of the the over 1200 twelve hundred people who showed up at least one of the days and were particularly. participating, actually nine hundred and twelve independent individuals ran a tax map. So that means they inputted their information and and ran to see what their tax situation looked like, what their taxes were right now, and if they
13:28
Wade Pfau: generated more income, what that would do in terms of federal income taxes, Medicare surcharges, potentially the loss of Affordable Care Act subsidies and and so forth. So 912 unique individuals running tax maps. But beyond that, 9,137 tax maps were run, which
13:48
Wade Pfau: means for on average, each person was updating their information on average about 10 times just to look at different planning scenarios. So there really a lot of engagement with you kind of start with, okay, this is my situation now, but do I want to test different situations? And some of the case studies we looked at too, even if it's not for Roth
14:08
Wade Pfau: conversions, if you're still working, do you want to contribute to the Roth account or to the tax-deferred account? Uh so you're rerunning numbers looking at different scenarios. But yeah, more than 9,000 tax maps are run across over 900 unique individuals.
14:25
Alex Murguia: And you know, that's a value. That's a value not just in the information you have, but in this if you were to go to an advisor, frankly, and have them run this for you, you would be charged uh easily a a thousand plus dollars for something along those lines, especially the quality of the of the software
14:45
Alex Murguia: that we did. So yes, this is a software that helps us in our membership site. uh, retirewithstyle.com. But the reality is this is something that
14:55
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
14:56
Alex Murguia: know we're proud to. We're proud to have provided this kind of value out there in the in the wild, so to speak. Obviously, you know, we always hope that people pay it forward and and all of that kind of stuff. But nonetheless, it
15:09
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
15:10
Alex Murguia: we I I'm proud, Wade, uh of what you did here. I I had no idea we'd had so many folks.
15:15
Alex Murguia: you know, really uh getting this much value out of this in such little time. I I can't stress enough. Uh it's this is in a few days. And we let this run a week. I I think as we looked at our numbers on retirement researcher, I I think we're by 15,000 or so runs on this thing. So it's it's really cool to see on on
15:35
Alex Murguia: many, many levels and the ability of we know they're engaged. simply because of the what if scenarios and seeing, okay, if I do this, if I do that, how does it look, and the like. But uh what what did we hear from uh attendants in terms of we do think this is not for
15:53
Alex Murguia: the intro folks. This is folks that are somewhat do-it do it yourself first, or frankly, or collaborators in that sense and maybe even validators, but this. is not necessarily for delegators. Delegators may actually just have an advisor do something like this for them. By the way, I fall into the delegator category and as you can see, Wade would
16:13
Alex Murguia: be,
16:13
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah,
16:14
Alex Murguia: you're kind of self-directed slash collaborator, is what I would guess you are. I I can't imagine you do your taxes by yourself, right, Wade?
16:21
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
16:21
Wade Pfau: do, yeah.
16:22
Alex Murguia: Yeah, yeah.
16:23
Alex Murguia: I help
16:23
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): make sure and that
16:24
Alex Murguia: was a rhetorical question. No.
16:27
Alex Murguia: Yeah. But uh for the folks that were attending,
16:30
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
16:31
Alex Murguia: know, we have some stats here. What did they tell us about the lessons and and the like?
16:37
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
16:37
Wade Pfau: it I think, yeah, I'm that's we had a lot of folks who it really helps if you understand what like the basic structure of your 1040 in advance. Like if if you're not even clear about the different components of filling out your tax form, that does make it really difficult to understand what the tax maps are telling you
16:57
Wade Pfau: as well. But uh yeah, in terms of the feedback from the surveys, 89%
17:02
Wade Pfau: said that our basic explanations around how taxes work were clear. Uh 73% said the same about understanding
17:13
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): like
17:13
Wade Pfau: just what kind of tax. rate you fall into. And to a comment you made earlier, like if you asked an advisor to do this for you, this is still somewhat cutting edge. I don't
17:22
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know what the
17:23
Wade Pfau: breakdown would be. A lot of advisors can understand tax maps and use it, but you might still be talking to an advisor who's still using that old logic of filling tax brackets. Which this
17:33
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I already is
17:33
Wade Pfau: explained is as the exactly wrong way to do things. But a lot of advisors would still be doing that.
17:37
Alex Murguia: I would say two too weights. Wade, some of that has to do with the softwares that they use. There's some there there's software out there, actually for consumers as well, but there's also softwares that advisors use. And they don't they're they're they're stuck in the world of only Monte Carlo, and then everything that every other solution set around that
17:57
Alex Murguia: kind of is is not is not a priority. And so frankly, that's why they manage. the brackets. It's just much easier to code. And advisors don't think twice about that. And yes, I'm speaking in general out generalities, but I think I'm more directionally dire correct than not. And from that standpoint here, uh, you know,
18:17
Alex Murguia: we also asked members, hey, would they be interested in doing,
18:21
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
18:21
Alex Murguia: another challenge? And uh this was we thought this was going gonna to be somewhat of a labyrinth of a challenge. We didn't know what to expect because it was the first one we did that had to do with tax planning. And that being said, close to 75% of them are open to redoing another challenge. And no one said, No, I'm not gonna do another challenge.
18:41
Alex Murguia: So we we I think this is something that we can do on a recurring reoccurring basis next year around this time, in addition to the other challenges that we're still. going to be having about once a quarter. I I know we want to we're gonna do another, you know, retirement income challenge, which is more of a financial planning challenge, but I can see us doing social security, et cetera, et cetera, going
19:01
Alex Murguia: forward. And here uh we had when we did a how would you rate this? We didn't do a net promoter score or anything like that. We're not as fancy as big corporations, but uh 8.4 out of 10. were likely to recommend this to another. So I have to think that's pretty good. And we even threw in a final because we had so many
19:21
Alex Murguia: questions, a deluge of questions, just about how to use the system and the like. And since they started getting deep into the weeds and scenarios for themselves, they started asking us about scenarios. And uh we had you know 82%
19:35
Alex Murguia: of bonus QA watchers w wanted sort. of this extra bonus and every challenge where it was almost like an office hours, which is what better way to get a hold of us than through an office hours where it's just one to many. So we we learned a lot. And this is something we're we're we're doing this episode simply to let folks know that it's not that we're
19:55
Alex Murguia: we're gonna start trying to have these sort of outreaches and keep an eye out on them because they're they're well received. and frankly we we enjoyed doing them.
20:06
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): If
20:06
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you're hearing about the tax planning challenge for the first time, we're sorry to say that this one's already underway. The good news is that Wade and Alex always have another one right around the corner. And joining the wait list now means you'll hear about the next one first. You'll get a heads up before we even open registration. So you can save the date and come ready to work for your own numbers. Join the wait list now at
20:26
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): retirewoodstyle. retirewithstyle.com slash challenge. And you can also find that link in the show notes below. We'll see you at the next
20:32
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): one.
20:34
Alex Murguia: But uh you know, we we've learned what what did we learn here about the tax map? You were alluding to it earlier, Wade, but in all candid in all candor,
20:43
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
20:43
Alex Murguia: do you want to share some stories of of folks and what what certain reactions were and what we can start doing to to even make this one better?
20:51
Wade Pfau: Yeah, yeah. So well, usually in the past, we've always our retirement income challenges have been for the funded ratio, which is the general financial plan. Are you, do you have enough assets to meet your retirement goals? And that's best to do early in the year to make the most sense out of the annual calculations. So that'll we'll probably return to that early next year. But yeah,
21:11
Wade Pfau: we're we're thinking about
21:13
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): doing
21:13
Wade Pfau: the tax planning challenges. challenge again, um, social security claiming challenges. There's different possibilities we're looking at. But yeah, in terms of what I learned this time, we thought this one might be a shorter challenge. Our funded ratio challenges were always four days. That, oh, three days is enough for this. It turns out we should probably make this a four-day challenge as well. And the
21:33
Wade Pfau: presentation I did on day one for people who are brand new to tax maps, it was just too overwhelming, I think. So the day one presentation really needs to be split into two days with more examples. Uh we I did introduce the calculator on day one, but that was near the end. And it probably would work better if it was brought up
21:53
Wade Pfau: sooner and used throughout at a slower pace so that folks could really understand how to interpret the tax maps. That was probably the best. biggest lesson coming out of it. We did get a lot of feedback on suggestions for making improvements and things, some more practical than others, but a suggestion I've already been working
22:13
Wade Pfau: on internally was labeling the details of the tax map so that it can be automated, so that when you're looking at your tax map, you can see, oh, this spike is because of the Social Security tax torpedo. That spike is because of Irma. This jump over here is because of the net investment income tax. And so yeah, internally now I've I've
22:33
Wade Pfau: updated so that I can make a table of all the discrete changes in your tax map, as well as a verbal ex or not verbal, but yeah, verbal, written, a written explanation of what those mean. So I've got like, oh, here's the 10% tax bracket, but you're in the social security tax torpedo.
22:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And that's
22:50
Wade Pfau: probably all that'd be happening at that point. But then later on, it's like, oh, you're in the 12% bracket, but you've got the preferential income stacking, and you're already losing the age 65 plus bonus deduction in terms of its phasing out.
23:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
23:03
Wade Pfau: yeah, a lot of great feedback. And
23:05
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
23:06
Wade Pfau: biggest lesson again was just let's let's spread this out more, have an actual four-day challenge and have more time to we which actually this ended up being a four-day challenge. with our bonus QA. But
23:17
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): maybe in that
23:17
Wade Pfau: regard, it has to become a five-day challenge.
23:20
Alex Murguia: Yeah, but and and again, if folks are thinking about doing the these tax maps, uh yeah, there is a little commercial here, frankly, uh on retirementresearcher.com.
23:32
Alex Murguia: It's a membership site. If you log in, you can trial it actually. You can trial it for seven days, but there we have all these calculators in place and we have recordings of our challenge. So you could potentially,
23:45
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
23:45
Alex Murguia: know, see it as a recording. And that's there on the site. But the reality here is for three days of attention plus another QA, which was almost like office hours, attendees got a personal text Tax map that any planner would usually build in a paid engagement. So it wasn't like a dink. dinky town calculator or something like
24:05
Alex Murguia: that. It was a full-fledged tax preparation for the upcoming year that
24:11
Alex Murguia: current
24:11
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): year.
24:11
Alex Murguia: Yeah, current year, I'm sorry, that was well worth it. And the other piece is you you didn't watch somebody else's examples. We, you know, Wade did give case studies and On the like, but the idea behind the case studies is if you pick most common denominator case studies, everyone can see. themselves in it, right? But we went beyond that in the sense of you
24:31
Alex Murguia: were able to run your own numbers. And frankly, not only did they run their own numbers, they ran it about 10 times each on average. I'm sure there was maybe one guy that did a hundred of them, or maybe throws off our numbers because you know there's always one in there. But the reality is,
24:48
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
24:48
Alex Murguia: know, people did various scenarios, even if it's three. each. You
24:51
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,
24:51
Alex Murguia: I d I don't know what the median is offhand, but that's what the average would be 10 per. But yeah, I'm I'm sure there's an 80 20 rule behind that. Uh but you right way, don't you think? There's always one, right? You'd be the one that would be like, huh, let's remove weights from the
25:05
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): power
25:05
Wade Pfau: users.
25:06
Alex Murguia: Yeah, yeah. I'm sure there were a few power users. Now uh what what are some scenarios in those most common denominator things that you may have run into that uh you know people can identify with that,
25:17
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
25:17
Alex Murguia: they know for next time. Oh yeah, I have this. I want to make sure that I don't miss this next time around.
25:22
Wade Pfau: Mm-hmm.
25:24
Wade Pfau: Well, the what the if it if it applies to you, it's hugely important. It's not something that applies to everyone. But with the Affordable Care Act now, the subsidies have that very significant cliff where your subsidy drops to zero as soon as you're one dollar over 400% of the federal poverty line. And so we were looking at
25:43
Wade Pfau: some case studies on that, including one where the couple's still working. And
25:48
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if
25:49
Wade Pfau: they were just managing a tax bracket type scenario, they would fill their 12% bracket. Uh, they would make a Roth contribution with their their con their savings for the year, but then they wouldn't get any Affordable Care Act subsidies. So it was a clear case where by making a an above-the-line deduction
26:09
Wade Pfau: by contributing a into their tax-deferred employer plan account, they were able to save a significant amount of their subsidies. So that was one of the important examples we saw. Uh, beyond that, it's just this preferential income stacking, it's not a a common term yet. in terms of the widespread,
26:28
Wade Pfau: widespread parlance, but it's
26:30
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I thought that's on
26:31
Alex Murguia: your vanity plate. Isn't that your vanity plate on your car?
26:35
Wade Pfau: Sounds like a a pickleball term. Uh
26:39
Alex Murguia: actually you're right. Yeah, you're you're absolutely right. It could be. Yeah,
26:42
Wade Pfau: I learned about pickleball that weekend too, with the world championships, but uh that's a different story. Uh but yeah, the the preferential income stacking that's it's like people don't realize they're inadvertently pushing all their qualified dividends from the 0% rate into the 15% rate when they're doing things. And and so we looked at some case studies
27:02
Wade Pfau: around that and
27:04
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
27:04
Wade Pfau: variety of case studies. Some only apply to wealthier individuals, like with the the phase out of the state and local tax deduction that doesn't start until after $500,000. of income. So it's not one of those everyday cases. But we we looked at that. There's so much we looked at to just really, again, identify
27:24
Wade Pfau: opportunities to do tax planning where you're voluntarily paying taxes because you're able to do so at a lower rate than you might have to pay in the future, especially either after either after Social Security begins andor and or especially with report. required minimum distributions beginning in your seventies on your tax deferred accounts.
27:45
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
27:45
Alex Murguia: And and so it like
27:47
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): like
27:48
Alex Murguia: we said earlier, we wanted this episode to to really be listen, there's some things that we're offering that we really want folks to take advantage of. And for folks that could be listening and and be telling themselves, Hey, I still got time before the year end ends. And it does me no good to wait until next year to do this. You know, the FOMO's building up, if you
28:08
Alex Murguia: will. Feel free to check us out at retirementresearcher.com. And there's there's a, you know, we'll have a free seven-day trial. And from there,
28:17
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
28:17
Alex Murguia: know, you can get in and check out the tax map. If this is something that's still salient for you, if this is something that you want to make sure you don't miss out on future challenges, we'll have. in the show notes a link for it where you can put your name and you know, we'll we'll put you on the waiting list because we we will most likely have to cut this off at at some point simply
28:37
Alex Murguia: because the numbers are are getting beyond us, which is a good problem to have, but it's still a problem from the standpoint of we really want everyone to get in. But by the same token, we don't want to hire, you know, 50 ways to
28:51
Alex Murguia: run through it. That's just there's only one way, if you will. But that being the case,
28:58
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
28:58
Alex Murguia: is it something that's productive? Yeah, like we said, we had 9,100 tax maps done.
29:04
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
29:05
Alex Murguia: know, about 10 per person, if you really look at it. You know, but it's good to be prepared for this. You know, 300 people signed up the day it started, which is great. but those 302 people were playing catch up, you know, with the videos and all of that. So you don't want to be the one that hears about this challenge on day three and the like.
29:25
Alex Murguia: You know.
29:26
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
29:26
Alex Murguia: other piece is,
29:28
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
29:28
Alex Murguia: know, people people found out certain things. You know, someone found out that wow, I have a tax spike that's gonna happen five years out. How can I prepare for that now? And you wanna do that. before it just shows up, you know, from that standpoint. And again, the attendees that showed up, no one said, Hey, this is not something I would do again.
29:47
Alex Murguia: Everyone kind of, you know, gave a positive thumbs up behind that. So why while you wait, you know, Roth conversions are in the air, things like that. You wanna make To sure that you have a tool to help you with that. And we have that with the tax map. That's kind of me sort of pitching this, but it's really more from the standpoint of we
30:07
Alex Murguia: don't want you folks to miss out when we have these. And so what better way to promote it than on the podcast like we're doing right now? So if this is something that's of interest, please, you know, hit us up on the wait list so we can put you in our mailing list when we do push this out there.
30:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Wade,
30:26
Alex Murguia: anything you want to add? add?
30:28
Wade Pfau: No, I think that covers it pretty well. Yeah. Hope hope folks will join us at future challenges. And right, if you didn't want to review the challenges in for Academy members, it's in there as a recording. And so you can sign up for that trial and check it out and see if you want to stay with us as part of the academy.
30:45
Alex Murguia: Yeah. Yeah. And so we definitely will have a a a an an upcoming challenge. The next one will be on the funded ratio, which is planning. And that's, you know, everyone's getting their new year's resolutions in. And what better time to have a financial planning challenge, if you will, than quarter one. So we'll probably try to do that on the front end of Q1, but we don't have a date yet. We're still looking at our calendars because it
31:05
Alex Murguia: it takes a team. And Wade and I pretty much take out about a week of our time. And that that becomes a difficult proposition. And so we want to make sure that uh there's an all-score all's clear on that one. Again, who's it for?
31:18
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): If
31:18
Alex Murguia: you're within 10 years of retirement or you know, after retirement, this is something that I would definitely look into, you know. But if you sign up now, you know, sort of putting yourself on the wait list, then you know, we'll have prep videos and things like that to make sure that we hit the ground running when the challenge comes. All right. Again, even though we have
31:39
Alex Murguia: had, you know, thousands of people sign up,
31:41
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
31:42
Alex Murguia: a good handful signed up very close to that uh opening night. And so we want to make sure that we can prep people accordingly. So that's my urgency for trying to just get your name in there. And again, everything will be in the show notes. As long as you bring your numbers, you know, we'll we'll see you there.
32:00
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now
32:00
Alex Murguia: wait, what about this pickleball world now? No, never
32:04
Alex Murguia: no, but Wade, Wade and I actually I went to Dallas. We visited Wade on the on Friday and uh we saw the pickleball world championships. So Wade was able to see professionals live. And as an aside, what'd you think, Wade?
32:18
Wade Pfau: It was impressive. I saw the the best pickleball players in the world, and then I also got to watch you win a gold medal. So
32:23
Alex Murguia: uh enough about me. What about the chat? challenge? No. Yeah, no, no. It was it was really fun. I was very fortunate. But even, you know, building a sense of community. Uh Wade uh we during the challenge, after the QA on Friday, we we were so hungry, we just posed to the crowd hey, whoever wants to go eat barbecue with Wade tonight,
32:43
Alex Murguia: join us. And you
32:44
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know, we had a
32:45
Alex Murguia: taker and we went to one
32:46
Wade Pfau: taker.
32:47
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Heart eight.
32:47
Alex Murguia: What's it called?
32:48
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
32:48
Wade Pfau: heart eight, heart eight ate barbecue. barbecue.
32:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah. Yeah,
32:50
Alex Murguia: the heart eight barbecue. So as you can see, we're trying to build out just a good sense of community with that. So uh who knows? Maybe we'll have uh impromptu lunch as well, where Wade and I show up and you just zing us with whatever you want.
33:04
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
33:04
Alex Murguia: Wade, that's that's about it, right?
33:06
Wade Pfau: Yeah, yeah, that'll do it. And then next week we're gonna have I a couple two weeks of special episodes with uh about the non-financial aspects of retirement with Kevin Lyles, Fritz Gilbert, and Mike
33:18
Wade Pfau: Drak. Mike
33:20
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Drak.
33:21
Alex Murguia: There we have it.
33:22
Wade Pfau: Yeah.
33:23
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All
33:23
Alex Murguia: right, everyone. Well, thank you for listening to us. And again, we know it was a bit of a
33:28
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I don't
33:29
Alex Murguia: know, infomercial, but it is what it is. We wanted to get the word out and we wanted to show everyone actually who's listening and did the challenge, you know, thank you for taking us up on it. Congratulations on on doing your stuff. But that
33:42
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): we're
33:42
Alex Murguia: we're actually tickled pink that, you know, from a podcast, we turned it into sort of a a community thing where people are actually practically doing things, not just listening to this sort of esoteric wisdom, if you will. So thank you for for pushing through. Really appreciate it on our part.
34:00
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay.
34:01
Wade Pfau: Thanks, Caroline.
34:02
Alex Murguia: Take it
34:03
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): easy.
34:05
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Wade
34:05
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and Alex are both principals of McLean Asset Management and Retirement Researcher. Both are SEC registered investment advisors located in Tysons, Virginia. The opinions expressed in this program are for general informational and educational purposes only and are not intended to provide specific advice or recommendations for any individual
34:25
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): or on any specific. securities. To determine which investments may be appropriate for you, consult your financial advisor. All investing comes with a risk, including risk of loss. Past performance does not guarantee future results.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.

More from Retire With Style

Retire With Style

Episode 254: Tax Maps Explained: How to Make Smarter Retirement Tax Decisions with Joe Elsasser

Episode discussion: Joe Elsasser explains tax maps, Social Security claiming, and Roth conversion strategies for retirement planning

Speakers’ claims: Joe Elsasser, founder of Covisum, discusses how tax maps and effective marginal tax rates provide a more accurate framework for retirement planning than nominal tax brackets. He argues that Social Security serves as a foundational floor for income strategies and that delaying claims remains optimal even under projected benefit cuts. Elsasser prioritizes Roth conversions over capital gains harvesting for heirs due to tax-free growth benefits, while advising against Roth conversions for clients with charitable beneficiaries. The episode also covers the MAP exercise for defining retirement goals and warns against over-reliance on AI in financial planning due to potential errors.

Social SecurityTax PlanningRoth Conversions
49 min0 assets16 claims to verify
Retire With Style

Episode 253: Required Minimum Distributions Explained: How to Avoid Costly Tax Surprises

Episode discussion: Podcast explains Required Minimum Distribution rules, penalties, and tax strategies like QCDs and QLACs for retirement planning.

Speakers’ claims: Hosts from Retire With Style explain that Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) are actuarial spending strategies for tax-deferred accounts like IRAs and 401(k)s, excluding Roth accounts. They detail that the starting age is 73 for those born in 1959 or earlier and 75 for those born in 1960 or later, with a 25% penalty (reducible to 10%) for non-compliance. The episode highlights tax mitigation tools such as Qualified Charitable Distributions (QCDs) for those over 70.5 and Qualified Longevity Annuity Contracts (QLACs) to defer taxable income. Speakers note that RMD calculations rely on IRS life expectancy tables, with specific aggregation rules allowing multiple IRAs to be combined but not mixed with employer plans.

Retirement PlanningTax StrategyRequired Minimum Distributions
30 min0 assets13 claims to verify
All insights