Buy or Sell

Hosts debate buy/sell ratings for listed fund managers Regal, MA Financial, Pinnacle, and WAM Capital

23 min Listen to the original Episode page
Asset ManagementPrivate CreditListed Investment CompaniesValuation MultiplesDividend PolicyAlternative Assets

Summary

Hosts James Gerrish and Luke Larative analyze four listed asset managers, offering divergent views on their investment merits. Gerrish favors Regal Partners and MA Financial for their low valuations and diversification, while Larative sells them due to valuation concerns and sector headwinds. Both hosts agree on selling Pinnacle Investment Management and WAM Capital, citing high multiples and poor performance respectively. The discussion highlights the risks of illiquidity in private credit and the sustainability of dividend policies in listed investment companies.

Episode sections

  1. 0:00 – 1:17

    Introduction and Disclaimer

    Sponsor read for Ninja Slushy Twist and disclaimer from EquityMates regarding Australian Financial Services License 540697.

  2. 1:17 – 6:49

    Regal Partners Analysis

    Discussion of Regal Partners ($11.5bn AUM, 41% decline), founder retirement, and divergent buy/sell views based on valuation multiples.

  3. 6:49 – 12:02

    MA Financial Analysis

    Analysis of MA Financial (48% decline), private credit sentiment, gating mechanisms, and split between asset management and lending.

  4. 12:02 – 16:26

    Pinnacle Investment Management Analysis

    Evaluation of Pinnacle's boutique manager stakes, flow dependency concerns, and valuation relative to peers.

  5. 16:26 – 22:33

    WAM Capital Analysis

    Critique of WAM Capital's underperformance, dividend cut, and trading below NTA, leading to a sell consensus.

Claims worth verifying

Regal Partners has approximately $11.5 billion in funds under management (FUM).

Unidentified speaker ·1:43

How to verify: Check Regal Partners' latest annual report or investor presentation for AUM/FUM figures.

Regal Partners' share price is down 41% over the last 12 months.

Unidentified speaker ·1:24

How to verify: Calculate the percentage change in Regal Partners' (RGP) share price over the trailing 12-month period using market data.

Regal Partners recorded $670 million in inflows in the September quarter, including $400 million from PM Capital.

Unidentified speaker ·3:48

How to verify: Review Regal Partners' quarterly performance report or investor update for the September quarter for flow data.

Regal Partners trades at a multiple of 4-5 times earnings, while Pinnacle trades at 20 times earnings.

Unidentified speaker ·4:53

How to verify: Calculate the Price-to-Earnings (P/E) ratio for Regal Partners (RGP) and Pinnacle Investment Management (PNI) using current share prices and trailing earnings.

MA Financial's share price dropped from $11.50 to $4.50, trading at 8.5 times earnings.

Unidentified speaker ·8:14

How to verify: Check MA Financial's (MAF) historical share price data and current P/E ratio using financial data providers.

MA Financial's asset management business constitutes 60% of its total business.

Unidentified speaker ·9:33

How to verify: Review MA Financial's annual report or segment reporting for revenue or profit contribution breakdowns.

Metrics is a $40 billion manager and an affiliate of Pinnacle Investment Management.

Unidentified speaker ·13:19

How to verify: Check Pinnacle Investment Management's investor presentations or annual reports for details on affiliate AUM and specific managers like Metrics.

WAM Capital cut its dividend due to depleted profit reserves after underperforming the benchmark and losing money over the last 12 months.

Unidentified speaker ·18:42

How to verify: Review WAM Capital's (WAM) dividend announcements and performance reports for the relevant period to confirm dividend cuts and performance relative to benchmarks.

WAM Capital traded at a 20% premium to Net Tangible Assets (NTA) before falling to trade below NTA.

Unidentified speaker ·19:25

How to verify: Compare WAM Capital's historical share price to its reported NTA per share to verify the premium/discount status.

Mark and Rafi (from L1) made $560 million in personal fees last year.

Unidentified speaker ·6:24

How to verify: Review L1 Capital's annual report or proxy statement for director and key management personnel remuneration disclosures.

Do your own research

  • Verify Regal Partners' current AUM and net inflow/outflow data in its latest quarterly activity report.
  • Check MA Financial's latest earnings release for details on lending performance versus mortgage aggregation expectations.
  • Review Pinnacle Investment Management's portfolio holdings to confirm stakes in Metrics, Hyperion, and Plato.
  • Analyze WAM Capital's latest financial statements to confirm the dividend cut details and current Net Tangible Assets (NTA) discount.
  • Research peer valuation multiples for GQG and Pinnacle to contextualize Regal's 4-5x earnings multiple.
  • Examine MA Financial's fund documents to understand the specific terms and history of redemption gating mechanisms.
  • Assess the impact of Phil King's retirement on Regal Partners' strategic direction and operational stability.
  • Compare WAM Capital's historical performance against its benchmark to quantify the 'perpetual underperformance' cited by speakers.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00
Unidentified speaker: Hey there, it's Dr.
0:02
Unidentified speaker: Jody Carrington, host of UnLonely.
0:04
Unidentified speaker: We were never meant to do this whole life alone, and some of the best connection happens around a table.
0:10
Unidentified speaker: The Ninja Slushy Twist uses slush assist tech to make two frozen drinks at once or twist them together.
0:16
Unidentified speaker: No ice, no blending, no guesswork, but just good times on tap around a kitchen table.
0:22
Unidentified speaker: Visit SharkNinja.ca.
0:25
Unidentified speaker: And thanks to SharkNinja, you can now find I'm lonely on the Roku channel.
0:36
Unidentified speaker: Everything you're about to hear is for education and entertainment purposes only.
0:39
Unidentified speaker: Whilst we are licensed when not aware of your personal financial circumstances, any advice is general advice.
0:45
Unidentified speaker: EquityMates operates under Australian Financial Services License 540697.
0:51
Unidentified speaker: I just don't know why anyone would still own this.
0:53
Unidentified speaker: It's been absolutely whacked, so it's a why.
0:55
Unidentified speaker: For me, I just see this as an absolute layup.
0:57
Unidentified speaker: While we may not be a fan of the fees charged by fund managers here at EquityMates, there's no denying that funds management is a hell of a business.
1:04
Unidentified speaker: High margin, scalable, with sticky recurring revenues.
1:07
Unidentified speaker: So should you invest in a listed manager?
1:10
Unidentified speaker: That's what we're discussing today on this episode of Buy or Sell with the help of Luke Larative from Seneca and James Gerrish from Market Partners.
1:17
Unidentified speaker: First up today, we have listed alternatives business regal partners.
1:20
Unidentified speaker: They've had a bit of bad press recently.
1:22
Unidentified speaker: Plus, the founder, Phil King, is retiring.
1:24
Unidentified speaker: The business is down 41% over the last 12 months.
1:27
Unidentified speaker: Is that one a buy or sell?
1:30
Unidentified speaker: I've got it as a buy, but a cautious one.
1:32
Unidentified speaker: Okay.
1:32
Unidentified speaker: Buy from me, Reddit or Rock.
1:35
Unidentified speaker: Okay, rock and roll.
1:36
Unidentified speaker: Why are you buying, James?
1:38
Unidentified speaker: I'll give you the the quick rundown.
1:39
Unidentified speaker: It's uh, you know, a a large alternative asset manager.
1:43
Unidentified speaker: Um, within the hedge fund space, though, the equities trading space, they've got about 11.5 billion in fum.
1:49
Unidentified speaker: They've had a a dismal last 12 months in terms of performance.
1:52
Unidentified speaker: So that's that's one thing.
1:54
Unidentified speaker: Um we haven't seen any outflows yet, though, um, because what generally happens from Regal is when they go through crappy periods, they bounce back really hard.
2:02
Unidentified speaker: They do that by uh increasing their leverage within portfolios after um you know downturns in performance.
2:09
Unidentified speaker: From what I understand, they're not they're not f finding the opportunities out there to increase the leverage at this point in time.
2:15
Unidentified speaker: So they're not as confident in bouncing back in the short term.
2:19
Unidentified speaker: So whilst I'd I'd I'd anchor it to we haven't seen outflows, flows follow performance.
2:24
Unidentified speaker: With Regas, it's a little bit different because they generally bounce back hard.
2:28
Unidentified speaker: If they don't bounce back hard this time, uh then you've got some concern that there will be outflows at a time when you know Phil King is the you know the backbone of this business for the last two decades is announcing his retirement.
2:40
Unidentified speaker: I don't think that's necessarily a a hugely negative thing.
2:44
Unidentified speaker: I think that the optics aren't that uh great, but it's probably a natural progression for the business.
2:48
Unidentified speaker: So I wouldn't hang my hat on that, uh, but it all comes down to the bounce back in performance because otherwise flows will start to move out the door.
2:55
Unidentified speaker: So no Magellan Exodus style thing happening.
2:58
Unidentified speaker: No, I don't think so.
2:59
Unidentified speaker: I think it's been a it's it's a pretty waterly executed exit.
3:03
Unidentified speaker: A lot of time um uh provided to the market to get used to it.
3:07
Unidentified speaker: Uh they've got a deep team, they've got they're they're also a lot more diverse than they ever were.
3:11
Unidentified speaker: So you know, they used to just be an equities trading house.
3:14
Unidentified speaker: They've got heaps of different um alternative assets in the stable, and that's been a that's been a really you know smart strategy.
3:21
Unidentified speaker: So, you know, diversify your business across management um uh in terms of uh strategies and the managers running those strategies, and then you get more blended performance over time.
3:31
Unidentified speaker: But still, you know, these equity strategies are still you know 50% of their farm, and when performance has been weak, it puts pressure on it, particularly a high fee type operation like Regal.
3:41
Unidentified speaker: Okay, over to you, Luke.
3:43
Unidentified speaker: Why are you buying Regal?
3:44
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, I think James sort of hit the nail on the head.
3:46
Unidentified speaker: I think for starters, the inflows are good.
3:48
Unidentified speaker: They did 670 million bucks of inflows into the September quarter.
3:52
Unidentified speaker: So that was that was kind of fronted up by 400 mil to PM Capital, Paul Moore's fund.
3:58
Unidentified speaker: Which is going really well.
3:59
Unidentified speaker: Which is cranking, right?
4:00
Unidentified speaker: So he's doing really well at the moment.
4:02
Unidentified speaker: So it's not like every part of Regal is ASX small cap or long short exposed.
4:08
Unidentified speaker: Traditionally, like if you think about Regal, you think about Phil King, you think about Regal long short, right?
4:13
Unidentified speaker: But over time, it's become kilt of water, it's become mining royalties, it's become a proper diversified alternative manager with global exposure, with exposure to uncorrelated assets.
4:27
Unidentified speaker: Um, and from my mind, you're buying it on the same multiple as GQG.
4:33
Unidentified speaker: But GQG have got outflows after outflows after outflows every month.
4:36
Unidentified speaker: This is a business that's got net inflows every month, diversified across asset classes that GQG's not.
4:43
Unidentified speaker: And I suppose, you know, everybody's kind of getting all excited about our uh Pinnacle because they've got Play-Doh and Play Doh's everyone, the flavor of the month, and everyone wants to be in Play-Doh.
4:53
Unidentified speaker: And it's like, well, PM Capital's doing pretty much just as well, got just as good sort of flows on a farm adjusted basis, yet Pinnacle's on 20 times earnings and Regal's on five or four.
5:05
Unidentified speaker: So for me, I just see this as an absolute layup.
5:07
Unidentified speaker: It's one of the biggest positions in our small cap fund at the moment.
5:10
Unidentified speaker: It's also in our large cap fund.
5:11
Unidentified speaker: Um, can't see how I lose money here on a seven or eight percent dividend yield on a four times earnings.
5:16
Unidentified speaker: It's interesting if you think about other players in the space that could look at Regal as well.
5:20
Unidentified speaker: So acquiring, you know, you rewind the tape six months ago, Regal was on the acquisition path.
5:26
Unidentified speaker: They were trying to grow, and they have grown by buying private businesses but haven't had a a lot of luck buying larger public players.
5:33
Unidentified speaker: Um, I wouldn't be surprised if someone, you know, another manager trading on a a lot higher multiple is keen to buy Regal as well.
5:40
Unidentified speaker: If you're Rafi at L1 on 15 times earnings, and I don't know what they're going to launch next, but they just can't continue just to launch gold fund after gold fund.
5:50
Unidentified speaker: So I'd just go and buy Regal.
5:51
Unidentified speaker: No Phil King there.
5:53
Unidentified speaker: Register looks a bit more open.
5:54
Unidentified speaker: I think Paul Moore owns more stock than anybody now at Regal.
5:57
Unidentified speaker: Um so yeah, I I would be seriously thinking about that if I was over at L1.
6:01
Unidentified speaker: And also diversifying L1s, the concentration they're all equities, they're Regal Old School.
6:06
Unidentified speaker: Exactly right.
6:07
Unidentified speaker: And they're they're they're the old school being, you know, backing two really intelligent smart guys who have absolutely killed it.
6:13
Unidentified speaker: But if I was, you know, if I'm in a position where my equity equity is worth you know 15, 17 times and I can use that equity to go and diversify my business after a really good run, that's what I'd be doing.
6:24
Unidentified speaker: I mean, Mark and Rafi made 560 million bucks PA last year just on their own personal fees.
6:31
Unidentified speaker: So between the two of them, they could buy Regal at the current market cap almost with cash.
6:36
Unidentified speaker: So I just don't really see how the markets think that this is efficient pricing.
6:41
Unidentified speaker: Um, it just makes it it is one of the more boggling things I've seen in my career.
6:44
Unidentified speaker: Not even joking.
6:46
Unidentified speaker: Okay, let's move on to private credit and real estate manager now.
6:49
Unidentified speaker: MA Financial.
6:50
Unidentified speaker: Obviously, private credit has been out of favor this year.
6:53
Unidentified speaker: This one's down 48% over the last 12 months.
6:56
Unidentified speaker: Is MA financial a buy or sell?
6:58
Unidentified speaker: It's a sell for me, but it is starting to look good.
7:01
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, it's a buy for me, and it's only it it's been absolutely whacked.
7:04
Unidentified speaker: So it's a buy.
7:05
Unidentified speaker: Okay.
7:05
Unidentified speaker: Why are you selling, Luke?
7:06
Unidentified speaker: Look, private credit, I don't need to be, you don't need to be a rocket scientist to figure out why that's got outflows.
7:11
Unidentified speaker: Um, I think um, you know, this business has done private credit pretty well over the journey.
7:17
Unidentified speaker: Um, but I I think the tide is moving out on this stuff.
7:21
Unidentified speaker: And as GQG have found, and as James sort of mentioned, uh flows follow performance.
7:26
Unidentified speaker: And I think there's just a bit more negativity to go.
7:29
Unidentified speaker: I think MA also got a bit unlucky or you know, duality of things happening at the confluence of things happening at the same time.
7:35
Unidentified speaker: You know, the SIV stuff, significant investor visa stuff really wound up, and they were quite big in that.
7:40
Unidentified speaker: It's really profitable business to be in.
7:41
Unidentified speaker: Um was a really profitable, profitable business to be in, I should say.
7:45
Unidentified speaker: Um, so I think on nine times there's probably some um opportunity here.
7:49
Unidentified speaker: I'm not saying it's not cheap.
7:51
Unidentified speaker: I think it is, um, but I think that it's not without earnings risk.
7:54
Unidentified speaker: So um my issue here isn't the price for the current consensus earnings.
7:59
Unidentified speaker: It's I think consensus earnings are probably a bit too high.
8:01
Unidentified speaker: Okay.
8:02
Unidentified speaker: Why are you buying right now?
8:03
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, I reckon it's it's not without risk.
8:05
Unidentified speaker: So, first of all, we've all read the hot headlines in property.
8:08
Unidentified speaker: Um, you know, MA is very exposed to property, but the stock price has gone from like $11.50 down to $4.50.
8:14
Unidentified speaker: So um now eight and a half times earnings.
8:17
Unidentified speaker: So it's priced for a fair amount of risk.
8:19
Unidentified speaker: The business's the business's three key areas.
8:21
Unidentified speaker: It's um asset management, which is the private credit, the alternative assets like marinas and stuff.
8:26
Unidentified speaker: Um you've got lending and technology, which is like you've got a non-bank lender in there, then you've got a mortgage aggregator, and then you've got the corporate side, which is a small component.
8:36
Unidentified speaker: So it is diversified, but it it is highly um correlated to to property.
8:41
Unidentified speaker: I think when you go out there in the private credit space is obviously in the in the headlines, it comes down to like the earnings power of a business relative to the multiple that you can buy it at now.
8:51
Unidentified speaker: So I think the risks are there, but I think on the multiple that it's trading at, it's probably under underappreciating the diversification within their business lines and how sticky the firm uh will prove to be, whether that's through gating, which they've done on one of their funds, which is a very poor look.
9:08
Unidentified speaker: And that's one thing I think is gonna happen right across the private credit space uh more broadly.
9:14
Unidentified speaker: We've just exited our property-backed private credit that we've had in portfolios, not because we've seen any deterioration um at the headline numbers, um, but I think there's real risk now of gating of funds in that space.
9:26
Unidentified speaker: So I think you've got to be careful in that space, but it's all born through a an earnings multiple that's quite depressed.
9:33
Unidentified speaker: So um, you know, they they provide an update yesterday, um, which to me on most part, so the asset management side, which is 60% of the business, is performing in line with expectations.
9:44
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, the mortgage aggregation business is a little bit lower than expectations, but the the the non-bank lender money me is ahead of expectations.
9:52
Unidentified speaker: So I think there was enough in that result to stay reasonably positive on MA financial, but bearing in mind that it's gonna be a tougher, you know, six to twelve months, right?
10:01
Unidentified speaker: You've got to have a a a medium-term view on this stuff in my mind.
10:06
Unidentified speaker: You like, you know, okay, so you gate they gate these funds.
10:10
Unidentified speaker: Do you feel like it's gonna be a sort of once burned, the investors never really want to go back?
10:15
Unidentified speaker: I can't ever see a fund getting gated or a business gating its funds, anyone ever wanting to go into another product with those guys ever again.
10:24
Unidentified speaker: Um I feel like it's gonna almost tarnish the brand, maybe not from an institutional perspective, but I think certainly, and an MA has focused on that kind of advisor market.
10:34
Unidentified speaker: You know, it's not been a they haven't been getting money from Singapore pension funds.
10:37
Unidentified speaker: You know, so it's been a whole high net worth market.
10:39
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, high net worth market.
10:40
Unidentified speaker: So I'm a bit worried that it's kind of just once bitten, twice shy, I think, with these investors.
10:46
Unidentified speaker: And that's why I think there's a bit of earnings risk here.
10:48
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, no, I I I I can't I couldn't argue with that fact.
10:51
Unidentified speaker: I think gating is like you know, gating is for the benefit of all unit holders in a fund, right?
10:56
Unidentified speaker: So that you don't have to um have fire sale of assets and and whatnot.
11:00
Unidentified speaker: So you only gate when you've got pressure on to sell because you've got those uh redemption requests coming through.
11:07
Unidentified speaker: You know, we speak to private credit managers, and there's no doubt that there's redemption pressure coming through.
11:12
Unidentified speaker: And then when you think about the underlying assets they hold, they don't have the liquidity in the underlying asset.
11:17
Unidentified speaker: So therefore, you need to gate.
11:19
Unidentified speaker: But I think you know, investors should recognize that risk.
11:22
Unidentified speaker: Like before going into these type of products, you've got to be really conscious of that that money can be locked up and it can be locked up for for however long they would like it to be locked up.
11:33
Unidentified speaker: So having, you know, I'm a big proponent of liquid assets that are more vanilla in focus, and that's where the majority of funds should be in a portfolio.
11:41
Unidentified speaker: You can get better returns by having um you know, locking your funds up or having the potential to get them locked up.
11:47
Unidentified speaker: And I'm not saying private credit's been a good, has returned really good numbers over um the last few years.
11:52
Unidentified speaker: So I don't want to knock private credit while it's down, but investors going to that space just need to go with their eyes open.
11:59
Unidentified speaker: Okay.
11:59
Unidentified speaker: Speaking of private credit, next up we have Pinnacle Investment Management Group.
12:02
Unidentified speaker: They uh they're one of their affiliates is Metrics, which did have, I guess, some gating of redemptions recently.
12:08
Unidentified speaker: That's been in the headlines, but they also have various other um investment managers that they work with, like Plato, which you mentioned before.
12:16
Unidentified speaker: Is that one a buy or sell?
12:18
Unidentified speaker: Uh it's a buy for me, Allie.
12:20
Unidentified speaker: Uh sell for me, Allie.
12:22
Unidentified speaker: Okay.
12:22
Unidentified speaker: Um let's start with you, James.
12:24
Unidentified speaker: I'm gonna defend the like so.
12:27
Unidentified speaker: Going to bat for the interest.
12:29
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, I don't I don't I'm not buying everything.
12:31
Unidentified speaker: So I don't want people to think I'm just uh an outright buy in this space.
12:35
Unidentified speaker: But I think there's uh that there's been so much carnage in this area, it's been a graveyard for investors over the last year.
12:40
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, this one's down 26%.
12:42
Unidentified speaker: It's done a lot.
12:43
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, and probably rightly so.
12:45
Unidentified speaker: Like there's been a fair bit of pressure in the space.
12:47
Unidentified speaker: So uh Pinnacle were like the you know the the the early mover in this strategy of um you know aggregating different fund managers, buying stakes in them, um, and then distributing and marketing their their products.
13:00
Unidentified speaker: It's a really good like good business model.
13:02
Unidentified speaker: That's a really good business model.
13:03
Unidentified speaker: So and it's worked really well.
13:05
Unidentified speaker: So what what what multiple is right to be paying for Pinnacle for the stable of managers they've got.
13:11
Unidentified speaker: They've got some really good managers in there.
13:13
Unidentified speaker: Um they've they've got some uh managers that are struggling right now.
13:16
Unidentified speaker: So you mentioned metrics, um, Hyperion's struggling.
13:19
Unidentified speaker: So metrics are you know, they're a $40 billion manager.
13:22
Unidentified speaker: You know, um Pinnacle have about $230 billion of affiliate farms, so it is a large part of their business, but not you know, that not as large as it once was.
13:32
Unidentified speaker: So if I'm thinking about a bullish thesis on on Pinnacle, it comes down to A, the diversification they've got now across their affiliates.
13:39
Unidentified speaker: So it's you think about it like a like creating a portfolio.
13:43
Unidentified speaker: You want a balance between um you know growth equities, international growth equities, you want um some fixed income in there, some Aussie equities in there, you want diversity of managers, etc.
13:53
Unidentified speaker: That's how Pinnacle think about it, right?
13:55
Unidentified speaker: In terms of the managers that uh they go on ultimately buy into and then distribute their funds.
14:00
Unidentified speaker: So I think they've got a really good balance.
14:02
Unidentified speaker: And I think they're not I I don't think they're they're hugely risky in that space because of that balance.
14:08
Unidentified speaker: So um, you know, I've got them on, you know, if I I um close one eye and turn around twice, about 14-15 times earnings, like if their performance fees kick in in the next couple of years, which I think they could.
14:21
Unidentified speaker: Um so I don't think it's hugely expensive and I think it's got reasonable growth.
14:26
Unidentified speaker: Um, would I buy MA or Pinnacle?
14:29
Unidentified speaker: I'd probably buy MA before Pinnacle.
14:31
Unidentified speaker: Okay, over to you, Luke.
14:33
Unidentified speaker: Why are you selling Pinnacle right now?
14:35
Unidentified speaker: It's really just next best alternative.
14:36
Unidentified speaker: I just think Regal is such a better deal here.
14:39
Unidentified speaker: I think even GQG is such a better deal here.
14:41
Unidentified speaker: If you're like I do and you think this semiconductor AI trade's gonna roll over um and cause a few tears and a bit of deconcentration of major industries, I think GQG could be a real beneficiary of that.
14:52
Unidentified speaker: That's how they're sort of positioned, from what I understand.
14:54
Unidentified speaker: So, you know, 16% dividend yield on GQG, 8% dividend yield on on Regal.
15:00
Unidentified speaker: I've still got to pay 15, 16, 17 times earnings, I think, on for Pinnacle.
15:05
Unidentified speaker: Not sure how um I suppose their flows go over the the near future.
15:10
Unidentified speaker: Flows will be the important thing.
15:12
Unidentified speaker: I mean metrics ain't gonna get many flows, Hyperion's not gonna get flows, but there are others that's been a yeah, Plato's been the one for them.
15:21
Unidentified speaker: Um and it's important to realize that Pinnacle don't have the same distribution agreement or the same relationship with each of the boutiques that they kind of work with.
15:30
Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
15:30
Unidentified speaker: Um, you know, I know Metrics has got almost a special deal essentially on what they've carved out for themselves.
15:35
Unidentified speaker: Um so look, I'm not uh I'm not saying that Pinnacle's on a decent business model.
15:41
Unidentified speaker: I'm not saying that um Pinnacle's gonna go into bankruptcy or anything like that, right?
15:46
Unidentified speaker: It's fine, it's a decent business.
15:48
Unidentified speaker: Um I just think at 16 times, say, it's not a distressed valuation.
15:54
Unidentified speaker: You can if you want to go hunting in private credit, there's plenty of stuff you can you can you can go and get a lot more leverage to a turnaround.
15:59
Unidentified speaker: Oh, I wonder if they'll be annoyed at um going in and buying the extra 10% of metrics just before all these things.
16:07
Unidentified speaker: I'm um came to I probably suspect that if you had your time again, you wouldn't make the same decision.
16:12
Unidentified speaker: But I've got plenty of examples of that in my life, James, so I'm not gonna uh be sl throwing too much fruit.
16:16
Unidentified speaker: But yeah, look, I think not the worst business in the world.
16:19
Unidentified speaker: Just think you can get stuff on one third the multiple that's probably better.
16:22
Unidentified speaker: Last up today we have Wham Capital, it's not a listed fund manager per se.
16:26
Unidentified speaker: Um Jeff Wilson is the founder, he runs various listed investment companies on the ASX.
16:31
Unidentified speaker: This one is its main fund or its biggest fund, Wham Capital, which invests in mid-caps.
16:36
Unidentified speaker: Is that one a buy or sell?
16:38
Unidentified speaker: I've got it on a sell, but it has uh been hit.
16:41
Unidentified speaker: Sell.
16:42
Unidentified speaker: Easy.
16:42
Unidentified speaker: Okay, why are you selling, Luke?
16:44
Unidentified speaker: Like it's a fund manager that underperforms perpetually, doesn't report performance, doesn't report after fees.
16:51
Unidentified speaker: Um I just don't know why anyone would still own this.
16:54
Unidentified speaker: Um there is so many good, high quality, active Australian farm managers that you can invest in, yet people continue to pay a premium to NTA to own WAM.
17:05
Unidentified speaker: Not anymore.
17:06
Unidentified speaker: Not anymore.
17:06
Unidentified speaker: Not anymore.
17:07
Unidentified speaker: But yeah, but I I just don't really understand it.
17:10
Unidentified speaker: Um I don't have a I know there's a lot of uh consternation about licks in the equity mates community.
17:16
Unidentified speaker: I'm less of you know less averse to to licks.
17:19
Unidentified speaker: I think there's nothing wrong with them per se.
17:22
Unidentified speaker: Um, but I think you still need to be a good active manager at the end of the day.
17:26
Unidentified speaker: Your job is to outperform, and um, even when you don't outperform, you should still transparently report your performance after fees.
17:33
Unidentified speaker: And these guys do none of those things.
17:35
Unidentified speaker: So I've got a I've got an issue with how they report uh in terms of their performance.
17:39
Unidentified speaker: Like you go and look at a monthly update and you can't see the monthly performance figures.
17:43
Unidentified speaker: So that's that's always uh a red flag for me.
17:47
Unidentified speaker: In terms of the listed investment, listed investment company structure.
17:50
Unidentified speaker: So uh and Wham's been Wham has been the pioneer of this, and yeah, he Jeff's a phenomenal marketer.
17:56
Unidentified speaker: There's no no two ways about that.
17:58
Unidentified speaker: He's got a huge band of um uh people that uh like him, trust him, and invest with him.
18:04
Unidentified speaker: He's done that for a long period of time.
18:06
Unidentified speaker: And the the thing with that generally those investors like is a growing stream of dividends.
18:11
Unidentified speaker: So the way you do that in a listed investment company, you do you have some really good years and you top up the um the capital reserves, the retained earnings within the if you think about it as a jug of water, you're you're putting that, you know, you're refilling it into good years.
18:25
Unidentified speaker: Um and then in leaner years, you're you're able to top up the dividends so that you've got this nice trend of dividends moving higher.
18:32
Unidentified speaker: The issue is if you have multiple years where you're paying out more than you're putting in, so you're taking more water out than it's going in, ultimately the jug will get empty to a point.
18:42
Unidentified speaker: And that's what we've seen in the last 12 months, where their performance has been really poor, they've underperformed the benchmark and lost money over that time period, and now they don't have the proper profit reserves, so they've had to to cut the dividend.
18:54
Unidentified speaker: They should have been they should have been doing that earlier.
18:56
Unidentified speaker: So that the dividend should have been more reflective of their dividend yield, the actual yield they receive from the investments.
19:02
Unidentified speaker: Exactly.
19:02
Unidentified speaker: So um there you can top up with retained with with with retained earnings and things, and that's a common thing to do.
19:09
Unidentified speaker: And that's probably one of the reasons because they've been successful doing that, and they're a great marketing machine, huge marketing machine, then they've been able to trade at a premium to NTA.
19:20
Unidentified speaker: So a premium to NTA is when you I go out and pay a dollar twenty for a dollar's worth of value.
19:25
Unidentified speaker: Now I don't know who who would do that, and that's it's ludicrous to think that.
19:29
Unidentified speaker: I it it it baffles me why that would take place.
19:32
Unidentified speaker: Um but that's the case at Wham.
19:35
Unidentified speaker: And then when you get these things happen that is not what you're expecting, they cut the dividend, then you've got the share price has got further to fall.
19:42
Unidentified speaker: So it goes from a dollar twenty, which was twenty percent premium, to NTA to now trade below NTA.
19:48
Unidentified speaker: So that's a big difference in in in share price performance.
19:52
Unidentified speaker: So it's gone from a dollar ninety to a dollar, is and it's meant to be this you know, safe secured income uh dividend income producing listed investment company.
20:01
Unidentified speaker: So I think they've got some challenges there, and I think there's going to be challenges for the next few years around how they um you know the dividend's gonna be lower and it's gonna be more volatile unless they have some killer years from here.
20:14
Unidentified speaker: But that it really now comes down to investment performance, and if their track record is a guide, then I I wouldn't be wouldn't be that comfortable.
20:21
Unidentified speaker: But I mean Jeff hasn't run stocks for a very, very, very long time.
20:24
Unidentified speaker: Um, you know, there's a team of people at Wham who run each of these portfolios, but if you never give any equity away, you know, other managers pay more, you're not going to be able to retain people.
20:33
Unidentified speaker: And there's a stable of they have been very stable.
20:35
Unidentified speaker: The team there has been incredibly stable.
20:37
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, but if you look about So for like Chris I was gonna say Chris Stock went to 18 and then my uh Matthew Kidman.
20:43
Unidentified speaker: Um, yeah, that was a long time.
20:45
Unidentified speaker: It's been very consistent.
20:46
Unidentified speaker: But those star managers that drove those really good numbers for a while, I think a lot of them have left from what I can see.
20:52
Unidentified speaker: But that was a long time ago.
20:53
Unidentified speaker: So yeah, I don't know.
20:55
Unidentified speaker: I'm just bit of a look, I don't want to get I I I know Jeff, and I think he's a great guy.
21:01
Unidentified speaker: Um uh from you know, but I think there's some shortcomings in the model, and I think there's some discrepancies between what gets promoted and what gets delivered.
21:10
Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
21:10
Unidentified speaker: And that's that that's my fair criticism.
21:14
Unidentified speaker: I agree.
21:15
Unidentified speaker: Okay, well, thank you both so much for your time today.
21:17
Unidentified speaker: That was a lot of fun.
21:18
Unidentified speaker: I really enjoyed that episode.
21:19
Unidentified speaker: It was awesome to talk about all the fun managers in the industry, a lot of them that, you know, people our audience would be invested in.
21:25
Unidentified speaker: I hope you enjoyed that episode of buy or sell as much as I did.
21:28
Unidentified speaker: If you did, please like and subscribe wherever you get your podcasts.
21:33
Unidentified speaker: This podcast is intended for education and entertainment purposes only.
21:37
Unidentified speaker: Any advice is general advice and has not taken into account your personal financial circumstances.
21:42
Unidentified speaker: Before acting on general advice, you should consider if it is relevant to your needs.
21:46
Unidentified speaker: If unsure, speak to a financial professional.
21:48
Unidentified speaker: The host of this podcast and their guests may have positions in the companies mentioned.
21:52
Unidentified speaker: EquityMates Media is part of the BetaShares group, but maintains editorial independence and operates under Australian Financial Services license 540697.
22:05
Unidentified speaker: Your education experience should be yours to create.
22:08
Unidentified speaker: At Athabasca University, we offer personalized pathways to achieve your goals.
22:13
Unidentified speaker: We recognize your previous education and work experience to get you that much closer to completing your goals and a timeline that works for you.
22:21
Unidentified speaker: Open your options with a more personalized online degree.
22:24
Unidentified speaker: And choose an education that works for you, not the other way around.
22:28
Unidentified speaker: Find out how at Athabascu.ca slash options.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-GGUF:UD-Q4_K_XL. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.

More from Buy or Sell

All insights