Phil Mobley explains why office rents rise despite high vacancy due to supply constraints and K-shaped recovery
Summary
Phil Mobley of CoStar argues that national office vacancy, while high at 13.6%, is stabilizing due to a lack of new supply rather than strong demand. He describes a K-shaped recovery where vacancy is concentrated in older buildings, while premium properties remain tight. Mobley attributes rising rents to supply constraints that prevent large tenants from relocating, forcing smaller leases. He also claims AI has positively impacted office demand by increasing hiring and augmenting workforces. Finally, he forecasts continued cap rate compression for office assets, contrasting with flat or expanding rates in industrial and multifamily sectors.
Key takeaways
- 1 Absolutely. So in historical terms, our national vacancy rate is still a hundred basis points higher than the previous peak, which was right after the Great Recession. So we are at about 13.6% thirteen point six percent. by the CoStar reckoning as of today. That is down 50 basis points over the past 15 months. So we are unequivocally in a recovery. But yet we do have sort of a structurally higher level of vacancy than we've measured before. So it is it an interesting time to be studying the second. sector for sure because we're functioning under sort of a different equilibrium than we once did.
Phil Mobley · 1:47
- 2 National office attendance has stabilized at 70-80% of pre-pandemic levels, with little change over the past 12 months, suggesting the market has found a new normal for utilization.
Phil Mobley · 11:32
Episode sections
- 1:33 – 2:55
Office Market Overview and Vacancy Trends
Phil Mobley states national office vacancy is 13.6%, down 50 basis points over 15 months but still 100 basis points above the Great Recession peak. He describes the market as being in a recovery but functioning under a structurally higher equilibrium than before.
- 2:55 – 8:08
K-Shaped Recovery and Building Quality
Mobley explains that vacancy is increasingly concentrated in high-vacancy buildings (25%+ vacancy holds 80% of vacant space, up from two-thirds historically), while best buildings hold only 4%. He calls this a K-shaped recovery driven by location, amenities, and tenant base rather than just Class A/B/C labels.
- 8:08 – 10:18
Lease Sizes and Supply Constraints
Lease sizes are 12-15% below pre-pandemic averages because limited new supply prevents large occupiers from relocating, leaving smaller gaps filled by smaller tenants. Transaction volume has recovered in deal count but not in total square footage due to smaller deal sizes.
- 10:18 – 18:59
Workforce Attendance and AI Impact
National office attendance has settled at 70-80% of pre-pandemic levels, with significant regional variation. Mobley argues AI has been unambiguously positive for office demand so far due to hiring by AI firms and AI acting as an augmenter rather than a displacer of employment.
- 18:59 – 24:54
Investment Sales and Cap Rates
Office sales volume was up ~10% year-over-year through Q3 after a 20% price correction. CoStar forecasts office cap rates to continue compressing, unlike industrial or multifamily which are expected to hold flat or expand, due to a compressing risk premium and limited new supply.
- 24:54 – 35:03
User Buyers and Future Forecast
User buyers have fallen from ~30% of trades back to 20-25% as institutional investors return. Mobley forecasts vacancy will drift lower but stay above 13% through the end of the decade, driven by shrinking supply rather than new demand, with landlord capital being the deciding factor for the next five years.
Claims worth verifying
National office vacancy rate is 13.6% and is down 50 basis points over the past 15 months, but remains 100 basis points above the Great Recession peak.
Phil Mobley ·1:47
How to verify: CoStar office vacancy reports; compare current vacancy rate to historical data from the Great Recession period (2026-2026). For recent events, verify 2026-08-11 through 2026-11-11. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Buildings with at least 25% vacancy now hold about 80% of all vacant space, up from two-thirds historically, while buildings with less than 10% vacancy hold only 4% of vacant space.
Phil Mobley ·4:15
How to verify: CoStar office market reports analyzing vacancy distribution by building quality/vacancy tier. For recent events, verify 2026-08-11 through 2026-11-11. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Lease sizes are 12% to 15% lower than pre-pandemic averages.
Phil Mobley ·9:28
How to verify: CoStar leasing data comparing average lease size in recent quarters to pre-2026 averages. For recent events, verify 2026-08-11 through 2026-11-11. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
National office attendance is 70% to 80% of pre-pandemic levels.
Phil Mobley ·11:32
How to verify: CoStar attendance data or third-party workplace analytics firms (e.g., Gensler, JLL) reporting on office utilization rates. For recent events, verify 2026-08-11 through 2026-11-11. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Office transaction volume was up about 10% year over year through Q3.
Phil Mobley ·19:46
How to verify: CoStar transaction volume reports for Q3 2026 compared to Q3 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-11 through 2026-11-11. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Office prices corrected by an average of 20%, which took nearly four years to complete, compared to a 30% correction that took two years during the Great Recession.
Phil Mobley ·20:25
How to verify: CoStar price index data tracking office property values from the trough to the present and comparing to Great Recession data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-11 through 2026-11-11. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
CoStar forecasts office cap rates to continue compressing, while industrial and multifamily cap rates are forecast to hold flat or expand.
Phil Mobley ·22:06
How to verify: CoStar cap rate forecast reports for office, industrial, and multifamily sectors. For recent events, verify 2026-08-11 through 2026-11-11. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
User buyers accounted for about 30% of office trades a year ago, but have fallen back to 20% to 25%.
Phil Mobley ·25:14
How to verify: CoStar transaction data analyzing buyer type (user vs. investor) share of office sales volume. For recent events, verify 2026-08-11 through 2026-11-11. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Rents increased 2.5% over the last 12 months, the highest year-over-year rate since the pandemic.
Phil Mobley ·31:07
How to verify: CoStar rent index data tracking effective rent growth in the office sector. For recent events, verify 2026-08-11 through 2026-11-11. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Job growth is forecast to be 0.3% to 0.5% year over year for the next five years, compared to ~2% in the previous decade.
Phil Mobley ·30:17
How to verify: CoStar or Oxford Economics economic forecasts for employment growth. For recent events, verify 2026-08-11 through 2026-11-11. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify CoStar's national office vacancy rate of 13.6% against their latest quarterly market reports or CBRE/JLL vacancy data.
- Check the specific definition of 'Class A' vs 'Class B' buildings used by CoStar to assess the 'K-shaped' vacancy claim.
- Review the latest U.S. Census Bureau or BLS data on office attendance and hybrid work policies to validate the 70-80% utilization figure.
- Analyze CoStar's cap rate forecast methodology and compare it with independent REIT filings or NCREIF data for office assets.
- Investigate the hiring trends of major AI companies to verify the claim that AI is a net job creator in the office sector.
- Check the transaction volume and price correction data from CoStar against public records or other real estate data providers like Trepp.
- Assess the risk premium assumptions in CoStar's forecast versus current interest rate environments and lender appetite for office debt.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:13
- Michael Bull: Welcome to America's Commercial Real Estate Show, your source for market intel, forecasts, and strategies. Hello, I'm Michael Bull. Thank you for being with us. Our show today is brought to you by TCN Worldwide. Look if you need brokered brokerage services anywhere in the world or in the U.S. check them out for acquisitions, dispositions, property management, site selection, or
- 0:32
- Michael Bull: consulting. Visit TCN Worldwide.com. Well, let's get to our show today. I think uh the office sector is always kind of interesting to me, especially where we are today with everything that's happened in the office world. But what's happening now? You know, it's been a while since we've had COVID. We've seen some
- 0:50
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of the things that we've got to
- 0:51
- Michael Bull: buildings converted to other uses. We've seen some buildings torn down. We've seen new supply really kind of dry up. And we're seeing some office users looking for Class A really nice space, having some struggles. But yet the headlines are office is
- 1:11
- Michael Bull: dump. don't Office is terrible. Stay away from it. Let's find out. what's really happening. Please welcome my guest. It's Phil Mobley. Phil is National Director of Office Analytics at Coast Star. Phil, good to see you.
- 1:22
- Phil Mobley: Good to see you too, Michael. And after that introduction, I mean I I think you've got it. I'm I'm not sure that I'm necessary here. You've got the the key themes, but no, I'm I'm sure we'll dig into those as we go through here.
- 1:33
- Michael Bull: Well, thank you. Uh you guys, your information is always uh really welcome by our our uh audience. So thank you. So overall, you know, how is the office market performing? Uh is vacancy still kind of high, right, overall?
- 1:47
- Phil Mobley: Absolutely. So in historical terms, our national vacancy rate is still a hundred basis points higher than the previous peak, which was right after the Great Recession. So we are at about 13.6% thirteen point six percent. by the CoStar reckoning as of today. That is down 50
- 2:07
- Phil Mobley: basis points over the past 15 months. So we are unequivocally in a recovery. But yet we do have sort of a structurally higher level of vacancy than we've measured before. So it is it an interesting time to be studying the second. sector for
- 2:27
- Phil Mobley: sure because we're functioning under sort of a different equilibrium than we once did.
- 2:33
- Michael Bull: We know those commercials, I think they're beer commercials that the guy the most interesting man in the world kind of thing. I think you're the most interesting man in commercial real estate analytics to do an office.
- 2:44
- Phil Mobley: Yeah, absolutely. I mean uh he he raises rents while vacancy is still high. You know that that's exactly what we've got going on, is that that sort of interesting situation.
- 2:54
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
- 2:55
- Michael Bull: are there certain um classes of uh office doing better than others?
- 3:00
- Phil Mobley: There are, and I I think one of the things that's really interesting about the sector, and frankly, something that has been true for a few years now, is that it's not as simple as just saying, you know, class A good, class B and C bad. There's a lot more nuance to that. There are still plenty of
- 3:20
- Phil Mobley: nominally Class A buildings that are struggling to backfill the space that they lost during the aftermath of the pandemic. On the other hand, there's some Class B buildings that are doing just fine. So it varies by market, by potential. particular
- 3:39
- Phil Mobley: sub-market,
- 3:41
- Phil Mobley: but what we typically are seeing is that the most desirable buildings are getting increasingly occupied, right? So uh if you go 10 years ago and you divide the entire set of inventory up into kind of high vacancy, medium vacancy,
- 4:01
- Phil Mobley: low vacancy. Well, it's always been the case that vacancy is concentrated in those high vacancy buildings, right? So call it 20% of buildings that have uh vacancy of at least 25%.
- 4:15
- Phil Mobley: Historically, they have housed about two-thirds of all vacant space. Now it's more like 80% of all vacant space. And meanwhile, the high occupancy buildings, you know, those that are less than 10%.
- 4:27
- Phil Mobley: vacant, those historically have housed maybe 10% or so of all vacant space in the entire market. And today it's more like 4%. So they have become increasingly occupied. And we're seeing the market sort of pull apart. It's the office sector's version of the K K-shaped shaped recovery.
- 4:47
- Phil Mobley: And it's uh created this winner and loser market.
- 4:51
- Phil Mobley: where, you know, yes, the sector is recovering, but there are a lot of dimensions along which that recovery is fractured. And one of them is what I'll call eye of the beholder quality, right? Not necessarily about class A B C. It's it's a lot about location, it's about amenities. It's frankly a lot about where all the other tenants
- 5:11
- Phil Mobley: are going. So it's a lot about sub-market neighborhood. Um so uh the market is telling us what's competitive and what isn't. Uh and in that competitive space, what we're seeing is really strong leasing activity, really strong rent growth, uh, and really high occupancy uh in a way that's
- 5:31
- Phil Mobley: maybe a little bit different than what we have observed before.
- 5:34
- Michael Bull: Good point. And I'd add to that um buildings where tenant reps feel comfortable with the ownership and the capital stack, right?
- 5:43
- Phil Mobley: That's a great point. That the ability to invest in the space, you know, whether that means doing sort of lobby or common air area renovations, or more commonly right now, in suite buildouts. build outs, You know, and that can be part of a lease deal with a generous TI package or it
- 6:03
- Phil Mobley: can be before you go to market, you pre-build a spec suite. Those are getting a lot of traction from some of the smaller occupiers in the market, especially as we have, as you alluded to earlier, and we'll talk more about this, but as we have limited new supply coming online, that's leaving
- 6:23
- Phil Mobley: smaller gaps available in these most desirable. buildings. And so one strategy to fill those smaller gaps is you pre-build out the suites and lease them to tenants that have uh a need for speed to market. For example, you know, an AI tech startup uh that might want to move in really quickly. And
- 6:43
- Phil Mobley: so that's something that we're observing as well.
- 6:45
- Michael Bull: Phil, are you starting to see a trickle down uh where these maybe five five-star star buildings? are uh getting really high
- 6:53
- Michael Bull: and the fours is trickling down to fours and threes? Are you seeing some of that in some markets?
- 6:58
- Phil Mobley: It depends on where you are. So in uh in Midtown Manhattan, the answer is absolutely yes. Uh, you know, I I tell people as a thought experiment, would you rather be a class B building on Park Avenue or Madison Avenue, or would you rather be a class? A building sort of on the outskirts of
- 7:17
- Phil Mobley: San Diego or Denver? And I think the the answer is obvious. Right now, we where you want to be is Manhattan because that's where the activity is. So there is trickle-down demand in select sub-markets. Um, on the other hand, there are still some markets that are struggling to backfill that lost
- 7:37
- Phil Mobley: occupancy. Uh, and at the market level, it's Washington, DC that has had a lot going on with the federal workforce. It's Chicago, it's Los Angeles, um, both of which have some sort of local uh economy issues in terms of uh employment growth that are They're just
- 7:57
- Phil Mobley: struggling in general, although even within those markets, there are some well-performing submarkets. So uh there are, as I said, multiple dimensions of the market being a little bit fractured right now.
- 8:08
- Michael Bull: We're talking with Phil Mobley with CoStar about the office market. And Phil, what do you see for tenant traffic and kind of square footage trends?
- 8:17
- Phil Mobley: Well, the I mentioned the uh lack of available new supply coming online.
- 8:24
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): One
- 8:24
- Phil Mobley: thing that is doing, it it is it is consuming. constraining the ability of large major, you know, Fortune 100 type companies to move. So if they might have otherwise been inclined to relocate from a space that they've been in for 10, 20, 30 years, they really have limited
- 8:44
- Phil Mobley: ability to do that right now. There are some exceptions. You look at New York and you look at what American Express is doing in uh you know, essentially pre-leasing a two million square foot tower at two world trade. Um, so that would be an exception to this trend. Not everyone is American Express that and wants to put up that kind of commitment. So,
- 9:04
- Phil Mobley: what that means is that the uh the likelihood of these large occupiers staying in place has risen. And therefore, the market is more open to smaller occupiers. And that is one reason that we have seen lease sizes remain well below what we
- 9:23
- Phil Mobley: observed before 2020. About
- 9:28
- Phil Mobley: depending on the quarter, you know, it's been 12 to 15% lower than that pre-pandemic average. And what that means is that even though we have had essentially a full recovery in the number of lease deals getting executed, what we haven't yet seen is leasing volume get back up
- 9:48
- Phil Mobley: to that pre-pandemic level. So you have the same number or even a little more transactions, but those deal sizes are on average 15% smaller. And that results in volume that hasn't quite fully recovered. Frankly, I expect that. to continue for a while for exactly the reason I just mentioned. They're just you can't lease
- 10:07
- Phil Mobley: availabilities that don't exist. And so uh with with availabilities being constrained, especially in the best buildings, I think we're going to continue to see those deal sizes remain smaller.
- 10:18
- Michael Bull: Phil, is the back to office trend still happening, or are we kind of where we are?
- 10:25
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 10:25
- Phil Mobley: think we're mostly where we are. And what I'll say about that is where we have ended up so far, and things could change. Um, you know, I think the most interesting place to be on the lookout for is is the Bay Area, which still has an elevated level of remote work compared to the rest of the country. But uh where
- 10:45
- Phil Mobley: we have ended up so far is that there is a different level of attendance across the country. So you get higher attendance in a New York or a Miami. Some of that is based on the industry mix, I I believe. You know, the financial services companies that have placed
- 11:05
- Phil Mobley: a greater emphasis on attendance. Some of it I think is just culture, some of it is transit. Um
- 11:12
- Phil Mobley: On the other hand, you have a place like uh Austin, Texas, or San Francisco, or a Seattle, where we just haven't recovered attendance nearly as much as in some of those other places. Nationally, the figures that I'm looking at, um, I look at a variety of sources, they all show somewhere around
- 11:32
- Phil Mobley: 70 to 80 percent of the typical weekly attendance that we would have expected. before the pandemic. And that hasn't really changed a lot, maybe one or two percentage points over the past 12 months. I the way that I think about this is that Office has always been
- 11:52
- Phil Mobley: a low utilization asset. Now that doesn't mean it's a low value asset, right? Um, if if you're like me, you have a car. A car is also a low utilization asset, uh, but it's pretty handy when you need it, when you want to take that trip to the store or uh or to the mountains for the weekend. So uh
- 12:12
- Phil Mobley: whether you are using your office 10 hours a day, five days a week, 50 hours a week, 50 out of 168 is 20 something percent, or whether you're using that office,
- 12:24
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
- 12:24
- Phil Mobley: call it three days a week, 30 hours. 30 out of 168 is a little less than whatever the 50 out of 168 is. Bottom line is you're still using that office less than half the time, but that doesn't mean you're not getting value out of the time that you are using it. So I think once we've gotten to this level of
- 12:44
- Phil Mobley: 70 or so percent of the historical attendance, what it appears occupier occupiers is. are doing, whether they're thinking of it in these terms or not, is that they are realizing that we get the full value out of the office in the time that we are using it. That value of being together
- 13:04
- Phil Mobley: for purposes of collaboration, for purposes of mentorship. And frankly, you know, one of the untold stories of the pandemic era or undertold stories is. that there is a portion of the knowledge labor force, maybe ten or fifteen percent, that just never was able to work effectively out of
- 13:24
- Phil Mobley: the home for whatever reason, whether that's distraction, whether it's a lack of physical space, whatever. Uh and so you combine that group with everyone else who benefits from having the team together, you know, even if that's three days a week, that that's that still still means that there's value to the office. Now I'm sure the sandwich shop on the first
- 13:43
- Phil Mobley: floor uh prefers five days a week in the office as opposed to three. But in terms of demand for the office space itself, I think two things. One, we we probably are where we are for the most part. Um, but two, that's probably enough to to essentially reconnect office demand with job growth. Uh of
- 14:03
- Phil Mobley: course,
- 14:04
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
- 14:04
- Phil Mobley: bad news going forward is that job growth doesn't look too strong. So we can dig some more into that if you'd like.
- 14:10
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
- 14:10
- Michael Bull: well, let's do that. Um yeah, I'm one of those ones who didn't work well at home or doesn't. It one is too close to the refrigerator.
- 14:18
- Phil Mobley: Yeah, that's right. You don't get as many steps walking to lunch when that's a you know a hundred foot trek to the refrigerator, and then uh you tend to I at least if you're like me, you tend to keep going on that hundred foot track.
- 14:30
- Michael Bull: And then the separation. I kind of like the separation of being working and then not working and being at home. When I worked at home, it's like, well, when do you stop? It's like I can't I don't know when to stop. Um, one of the questions I think our audience has for you, Phil, is the tr current trend and what you expect moving forward on employment uh
- 14:49
- Michael Bull: related to AI. Because when I look at our company as as uh one little tiny example, we're using AI a lot and it's it's it's helping uh with productivity. We're also having to watch it and make sure things aren't aren't isn't being used and it hurting. Uh but but we're using it a lot. But and it's made us more
- 15:09
- Michael Bull: efficient in a lot of ways. But we've hired just as many people. So we're we're doing different things, but we've actually hired more people and we're more efficient. So we didn't use AI and drop people, but I have some clients who have been are using AI and have less employees. What do you see?
- 15:28
- Phil Mobley: Well, I I think there are a few ways to approach answering that question. And the first is to say that thus far,
- 15:36
- Phil Mobley: the impact of AI on authors. office demand has been unambiguously positive. And that is, of course, because of the AI firms and sort of adjacent tech firms themselves have uh hired people, have leased space even in advance of expected hiring of people to sort of build out
- 15:56
- Phil Mobley: AI capabilities. And then I think there's the impact that you talk about, which is AI as an auger. augmenter rather than a displacer of employment. Um, I think there's that's a there's at least a rational case that that's happening to some scale. Uh there is
- 16:16
- Phil Mobley: evidence that at least at the entry level, companies are not hiring workers at the pace that they once did. How much can you attribute that to AI? in real practical terms versus maybe the expectation that AI will enable existing employees to do more?
- 16:36
- Phil Mobley: I'm not sure. I think the jury is still out on that. There's a school of thought out there that says we will probably not see much of a disruption in hiring related to AI unless and until there's a sort of broader recession. And that, you know, let's
- 16:55
- Phil Mobley: suppose we go through something, hopefully we don't, to anything like the scale of the Great Recession. But if there are
- 17:03
- Phil Mobley: conditions that produce large-scale layoffs in the knowledge workforce that's sort of, you know, perhaps related to AI, perhaps not, that's that then we might see the real impact as companies recover from that, but then don't hire back the workers that they laid off. So that
- 17:23
- Phil Mobley: that case kind of makes sense to me. Uh the good news is we we don't see um a recession in our base case, which is based on the Oxford economics economics-based base case forecast for the economy. So we don't currently see an elevated risk of that
- 17:43
- Phil Mobley: kind of recession. Um, but it could happen. I think the the longer-term impact is just so unknown because as we discover more and more what these tools can do, and as companies Is adopt them and integrate them into their processes and change their processes to account for
- 18:03
- Phil Mobley: the capabilities of these AI tools. Well, then we're going to see the impact and we could see, we could see job displacement, we could see just new ways of doing knowledge-oriented work that we haven't conceived of yet. And um, and you know, the I think
- 18:23
- Phil Mobley: the error bars are wide in terms of what that means for design. demand for office space.
- 18:28
- Michael Bull: Yeah, I mean you look at our industry of commercial real estate and you look at uh a lot of our clients and and our firm, I mean I I do see more analysts uh they're having trouble finding work uh and uh and some marketing folks. Um, you know, in our situation we just use them to do other things and it's made us more productive. But
- 18:48
- Michael Bull: uh yeah, I think that is interesting. Well let's let's turn the discussion, Phil, to um sales, uh investment sales, uh properties trading. Uh what do you see there uh in the marketplace?
- 18:59
- Phil Mobley: Yeah, it's interesting. I was looking at some numbers earlier today because this is the ten year treasury. So over the last thirty days, um it's down twenty 25 five to thirty 30 basis points. As we sit here and record today, it's it's under 5% again. On the other hand, it's still
- 19:19
- Phil Mobley: 25 to 30 basis points higher than it was 60 days ago. So around Labor Day. So that kind of volatility, um
- 19:29
- Phil Mobley: I wouldn't be surprised if that sort of does a number on transaction volume for the end of this year. What we've observed so far is that at least. as of Q3, office transaction volume was still up year over year, about 10%.
- 19:46
- Phil Mobley: Um, but over the past few months it's been relatively sideways. Um I do think that the volatility in um with with the 10-year 10 year with borrowing rates is a big part of that. Uh we've also seen the
- 20:06
- Phil Mobley: pricing correction. So we saw prices correct on average about 20%, which you know uh is less than at one time we were forecasting they would correct. Just by comparison, that during the Great Recession, the correction that we reported was 30%. Now that correction took two years. This one took um
- 20:25
- Phil Mobley: almost four.
- 20:27
- Phil Mobley: So there's a difference there. But we over the past year and a half, so the first 12 months of that past 18, we saw roughly a five percent rebound from the trough. And then over the past six months, pricing has moved essentially sideways. So you could
- 20:47
- Phil Mobley: read that as um sort of increasing. illiquidity again, related to the volatility of borrowing costs. So, you know, one way to think about it is when you have volatility, then what trades are the extremes, right? The basically bond in a box, you know, highly leased core type assets, or the ones that are clearly a
- 21:07
- Phil Mobley: low basis repositioning conversion type play. Um, and then that stuff in the middle is the most uncertain. You could also read that what we've seen in terms of prices flattening out instead of continuing to recover is that actually what's becoming investable has broadened, and that there's
- 21:26
- Phil Mobley: more price discovery on some of those buildings in the middle. And that actually could be a healthy thing for recovery. You know, more price discovery means more buildings are trading at their true value. Um, there's less kind of pretending what what these values are, there's less holding on. Um, I think the the
- 21:46
- Phil Mobley: time will tell over the next few months which of those is really the driver. Um, I will say that our forecast in the office sector for cap rates is for them to continue to compress. So the peak in cap rates was at about the same time as the peak in vacancy.
- 22:06
- Phil Mobley: So that's mid-2025. And we've seen them come down uh over the past 15 months or so. And we are forecasting them to continue to compress, which is a little different than our forecast forecasts for, say, industrial or multifamily, where we're forecasting, you know.
- 22:27
- Phil Mobley: either sideways cap rate movement or or slight expansion of cap rates over the next uh year or so. So um there's a lot going on because of the volatility. It makes it really hard to sort of interpret in real time. Um but but again I I think the
- 22:47
- Phil Mobley: the healthy news for the office investment sales market is that there is more clarity on kind of what makes an office building investable for what purposes. Uh and that's really fundamentally what's behind our forecast for cap rates to continue to compress.
- 23:04
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
- 23:05
- Michael Bull: and I think some of the listeners and viewers might
- 23:08
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): be uh
- 23:09
- Michael Bull: surprised to hear a forecast of office uh cap rates potentially uh going down, but is some of that based on kind of the lack of news supply in some of these markets you're gonna have increased demand?
- 23:20
- Phil Mobley: Well that's certainly uh a part of it. I w the way I would think of it conceptually is you've got um you know you've got sort of your risk-free return baked into your cap rate, so you will use the 10 year as a proxy for that. And then you've got a risk premium.
- 23:36
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
- 23:36
- Phil Mobley: know, I I need to be compensated for taking on the risk of purchasing this asset. Over the past five years, it's been so difficult to understand
- 23:47
- Phil Mobley: office demand that that risk premium has been very high. And so, as a consequence of that, you know, you have we have in the uh 10 year moving all around over the past few years, but that risk premium for office in particular has. been pretty high. Whereas with industrial and multifamily, it's been pretty low, right?
- 24:07
- Phil Mobley: I mean, we've been seeing cap rates that are with very tight spreads to the 10 year. Um, and so now what's happening is, and as you say, part of the answer is less new supply coming online. Uh, and that means kind of a finite universe of investable office. There is more.
- 24:27
- Phil Mobley: clarity about what the risk profile of a given office building might be. And so therefore, that risk premium is compressing. And there is room for it to compress even with some upward volatility in the 10 year. And that's kind of what's behind our forecast there.
- 24:43
- Michael Bull: Phil, how much of the sales are you guys seeing uh on office properties that are to users or partial? users uh compared to what used to see in the past?
- 24:54
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
- 24:54
- Phil Mobley: I'm glad you asked that question. It's an important trend. So pre-2020 users would have accounted for maybe 12 to 15 percent of asset trades, office asset trades. That went up to about 30% a year or so ago. It has come back down.
- 25:14
- Phil Mobley: And I think the main reason it has come back down is because institutional investors uh have started coming back in. Uh and you know, my take on that is they are the ones who are deciding, okay, um, we're not gonna wait for rates to come down in you know
- 25:34
- Phil Mobley: some unicorn type scenario, number one. But number two, we now at least understand what the game is in Office. Uh, and therefore those who who are going to come back in and become Office buyers again have chosen to do so over the past twelve months or so. Uh, and so as a as
- 25:54
- Phil Mobley: a result of that, we've seen the share of trades going to space users to occupiers come back down toward its historical level, but not quite all the way there yet. So they're still buying twenty to twenty-five percent of office buildings. I think for the same reason, right? That it's um in many cases
- 26:14
- Phil Mobley: their balance sheets may give them an effectively lower cost of capital. It may make sense for them to uh purchase a building at a basis that is going to be more attractive to them in the long term. than paying rent on that building.
- 26:30
- Phil Mobley: They may also be,
- 26:33
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
- 26:33
- Phil Mobley: know, sort of taking the reins on how the space build-out um needs to be to align with their brand and everything. So I think there are still reasons why uh space users are somewhat more active, but that is normalizing a little bit as the sort of broader. investment sales market recovers and as the
- 26:53
- Phil Mobley: traditional players have come back in.
- 26:55
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
- 26:55
- Michael Bull: I'm still a proponent of office. I think it's the buy of the decade. I think when you look back, uh it'll be that trade that uh you're really glad you made on most situations. And I like what you're saying about, you know, some uh investors and users look into buy now regardless of the rates. And uh uh I heard a saying uh uh recently
- 27:15
- Michael Bull: date uh date the rate, marry the deal. Right. So
- 27:20
- Phil Mobley: well, and and that point is an important one, right? Because you know, it's not really about sectors, it's about assets. And I think in this environment, it is a generally riskier environment because of what we talked about at the beginning. But That we have structurally higher vacancy now than we than we ever. have had
- 27:40
- Phil Mobley: before. And so that being the case,
- 27:45
- Phil Mobley: I agree with you that there is opportunity out there on the investment side, but you better know what you're doing and you better have a plan for that asset, and you better understand its economics, its market, its potential tenant base.
- 27:58
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
- 27:59
- Phil Mobley: And if you if you don't, and you're just sort of buying, hoping for the right rising tide to to bring office values back up, well that's that's a strategy, but that
- 28:09
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 28:09
- Phil Mobley: don't know that that strategy necessarily fits current market conditions.
- 28:13
- Michael Bull: Sounds like hope is the strategy there you're talking about
- 28:16
- Phil Mobley: hope is definitively not a strategy. That's I've I've been told this many times. I'm a college football fan, so hope is my strategy.
- 28:23
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): What am I
- 28:23
- Phil Mobley: saying?
- 28:25
- Michael Bull: So the forecast for valuations for cap rates in office may be uh that they do uh uh go down some. And your forecast for occupancy into twenty twenty-seven is what?
- 28:38
- Phil Mobley: We are forecasting a sort of long slow decline in the vacancy rate, um, but flattening out and staying over that thirteen 13% percent level. in the long term. And by that I mean sort of end of this decade and beyond. So number one, that would still be
- 28:58
- Phil Mobley: higher than that great recession era peak. So when I say structurally higher vacancy today, that's what I mean. Um number two, what's going to bring down that vacancy rate in our forecast is really more the uh the contraction in supply
- 29:17
- Phil Mobley: rather than a resurgence in demand. Now we are in the midst of a recovery in demand for sure, and we forecast that to continue for the next few quarters. Um, there was some fiscal stimulus in the One Big Beautiful Bill Act that is still working its way through the system and supporting hiring and and um investment
- 29:37
- Phil Mobley: that is carrying over. into the office sector. On the other hand, what we've seen over the last year or so is about 20 million square feet in positive absorption. Uh compare that to maybe 60 million square feet in a typical year in the 2010s. So we've seen a a recovery that by historical tan standards has been fairly
- 29:57
- Phil Mobley: tepid, not to mention geographically fragmented as as we were discussing earlier. Um longer term, just because demographics suggest we're not going to see much job growth, you know, somewhere on the order of, in the base case, three tenths to five
- 30:17
- Phil Mobley: tenths of a percent year over year in the coming five plus years, as opposed to something that was much closer to 2% year over year in the previous decade.
- 30:27
- Phil Mobley: Um, so we don't really expect much of a resurgence in demand, um, but we do expect a contraction in supply to bring down the vacancy rate. So I think two things to say about that. Number one is uh even without a resurgence in sort of aggregate demand, I think
- 30:47
- Phil Mobley: this game of uh premium building. buildings and and taking uh placing a bet on the best building and then attracting occupancy to that best building is uh it is likely to produce an environment where we see rent uh growth accelerate. Uh
- 31:07
- Phil Mobley: we saw rents increase two 2.5% and a half percent over the last 12 months, which is the highest year year-over-year over year rate that we've seen since the pandemic. So I think we'll continue to see an active market that produces real effective rent growth, uh, even in the sort of uh
- 31:23
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
- 31:23
- Phil Mobley: know flat demand environment. And number two, that contraction in the vacancy rate, the numbers will look maybe a little bit better. I don't think that's terribly relevant to lease economics. And it's because of what I just said, the the desirable space is what matters, not the total space, the desirable
- 31:43
- Phil Mobley: availability rather than the total amount of availability. So, you know, when you remove space from inventory, whether you knock the building over, whether you convert it to something else, whatever you do with it, definitionally that space was non-competitive. So you can remove as much of that space as you want. Um, that's not going to have an impact on lease economics. Occupiers that are out
- 32:03
- Phil Mobley: there today looking for space are already feeling a market that is much, much tighter than it might appear to be based on that sort of structurally high headline vacancy rate.
- 32:14
- Michael Bull: Phil, what would you leave our audience with to think about for opportunities maybe in existing buildings or markets uh uh around the U.S.?
- 32:23
- Phil Mobley: I think you said it earlier that um the position of the landlord and and specifically the capital of the landlord is key and is maybe king uh so there are a variety of ways to attempt to deploy that capital um whether that's building out
- 32:43
- Phil Mobley: suites whether that's holding capital in reserve for TI allowances whether that's doing whole building renovations whether that's a acquiring a building at a at a low basis, and then putting some investment into it to try to make it competitive with the best of the market. You know, there are a variety of ways to approach that. That's probably going to be the
- 33:03
- Phil Mobley: crucial feature of the market uh over the next five years.
- 33:07
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
- 33:08
- Michael Bull: I agree with that. Um I'm selling a a building and it has a lot of vacancy and but effectively it was off the market for years. because no tenant rep would bring someone there, even though it was c sort of on the market, no tenant would bring someone. And I think when a new owner gets in and the tenant reps feel comfortable that, you know what, this is a stable building now. It's a stable
- 33:28
- Michael Bull: stable owner with a stable capital stack that can pay commissions, pay tenant uh improvement allowances, uh things can turn around pretty quickly. So I I love that idea. And Phil thanks for uh being on the show. Great information as usual. Appreciate it.
- 33:42
- Phil Mobley: Absolutely. Thanks for inviting me back. All
- 33:44
- Michael Bull: right and thanks for joining us around the country. Uh check out uh CoStar, the CoStar group for more information. And hey, if you will, please sh share the show. Pay it forward, will you? Connect with us on your favorite social media. And until next week, be sure that you always lead, learn, and laugh and join us for America's Commercial Real Estate. Show.
- 34:04
- Michael Bull: America's Commercial Real Estate Show is brought to you by TCN Worldwide Real Estate Services. Sales, leasing, and property management anywhere in the U.S. Visit TCN Worldwide.com. And Commercial Agent Success Strategies, Cloud Access Commercial Agent Training Video videos to power
- 34:23
- Michael Bull: Ymercial your commercial Agent Business. Visit Commercial CommercialAgen Agent Success. Success.com. And Bull Realty, Southeast U.S. Commercial Brokerage Services, Bull Realty Headquartered in Atlanta as part of TCN Worldwide. Visit BullRealty.com. You're also invited to visit
- 34:42
- Michael Bull: CREShow.com for more show podcasts and videos, and to subscribe to our weekly email announcing the show topic. Thank you for watching. listening, and sharing America's Commercial Real Estate Show.