Speakers analyze divergent Australian property price corrections driven by investor lending collapse and regional supply dynamics.
Summary
Pete Wargent and Chris Bates discuss how Australian property markets are experiencing uneven downturns, with mid-sized capitals like Perth and Brisbane seeing sharper declines than Sydney and Melbourne. They attribute this divergence to a post-budget collapse in investor lending, which disproportionately affected lower-quartile prices in regions that experienced speculative booms. The speakers note a significant supply imbalance, with Melbourne facing a listing shortage while other cities see increased stock levels. Additionally, they highlight challenges for first-home buyers and developers, citing high interest rates, construction costs, and regulatory buffers as key factors shaping market viability and future price trajectories.
Key takeaways
- 1 Investor lending has collapsed post-budget, with some areas seeing drops of 90-100% in investor lending activity.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) · 0:40
- 2 Melbourne listings are down 30% year-on-year, creating a supply shortage, whereas Brisbane, Adelaide, and Perth have seen stock levels increase by over 50%.
Pete Wargent · 2:48
- 3 it really depends on what you buy, not the price you pay. And that's um, or the amount of debt you're taking on. Uh, it's really what happens to the asset value. And the biggest risk is the asset value falling. Yes, cash flow is a problem, but the asset value falling is basically losing everything a first sale buyer's got. Um, and that's the biggest risk first sale buyers need to avoid.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) · 37:29
Episode sections
- 0:30 – 1:13
Market Price Corrections and Regional Divergence
Pete Wargent reports that Perth, Brisbane, Adelaide, Sydney, and Melbourne are all down from their peaks, with Sydney and Melbourne having peaked earlier while mid-sized capitals are now experiencing rapid downturns. Chris Bates notes that investor lending has collapsed post-budget, with some areas seeing drops of 90-100%.
- 1:13 – 4:08
Listing Supply and Market Timing
Chris Bates describes a reduction in new listings heading into Christmas, predicting a dire period between now and February as stock is pulled and re-listed. Pete Wargent observes that Melbourne listings are down 30% year-on-year, creating a supply shortage, whereas Brisbane, Adelaide, and Perth have seen stock levels increase by over 50%.
- 4:08 – 5:29
Price Performance by Quartile and Asset Type
Wargent cites Cotality and CBA data showing that Sydney's upper quartile is down 13% while the lower quartile is down less than 5%. In Perth and Brisbane, the lower quartile has fallen significantly (around 8%), indicating a broader market correction compared to Sydney and Melbourne where the bottom end remained stickier.
- 5:29 – 9:22
Investor Lending Collapse and Budget Impact
Bates attributes the crash in lower-tier prices in Brisbane and Perth to the sudden withdrawal of investor lending following the May budget. He contrasts this with Sydney and Melbourne, where the lower end did not experience the same speculative boom and thus did not crash as hard.
- 9:22 – 16:12
First Home Buyer Challenges and Affordability
Wargent notes that first home buyer loans have declined double-digit compared to the previous year, failing to plug the gap left by investors. He highlights that while nominal prices are falling, high interest rates and reduced borrowing capacity are keeping affordability stretched, particularly in markets like Perth and Brisbane where lower-tier prices rose sharply.
- 16:12 – 22:05
New Home Construction and Developer Viability
Wargent reports that Westpac data shows new home loans fell 30% in volume terms. Developers cite soaring costs and high interest rates as making projects unviable, leading to a drop in new supply despite housing shortages. This undermines the government's strategy of using investors to drive new construction.
- 22:05 – 26:00
Interest Rate Cycle and Consumer Sentiment
Wargent discusses Westpac's view that the RBA cash rate has likely peaked, citing falling oil prices and moderating inflation forecasts. He notes that consumer spending is slowing, as seen in real-time card data, and markets are pricing in a hold for the next rate decision with cuts likely in 2027.
- 26:00 – 30:52
AI Data Centers and Construction Impact
Bates highlights a massive data center construction project in Marsden Park, questioning if AI investment will cannibalize residential construction resources. Wargent argues that while data centers are significant, they are not comparable to the mining boom in scale, and residential construction is falling due to lack of developer profit margins rather than just competition for resources.
- 30:52 – 34:57
APRA Serviceability Buffer and Financial Stability
Pete Wargent explains that APRA's 3% serviceability buffer is a contingency for various shocks, not just interest rates. He argues the buffer should be reduced to 2.5% as current conditions no longer justify the higher stress test, citing high bank capital ratios and lower household leverage compared to pre-2007 levels.
- 34:57 – 37:49
Risks for First Home Buyers and Market Dynamics
Speaker 2 discusses the potential for banks to lower buffers for first-home buyers, noting that the biggest risk for these buyers is asset value falling rather than loan size. He highlights that investor-driven apartments carry higher risk than established homes due to oversupply and lack of scarcity.
- 37:49 – 43:15
Long-Term Holding vs. Selling Investment Properties
A listener asks whether to hold negatively geared properties in Mandurah and Geelong. Wargent advises holding due to the long time horizon and high transaction costs of selling, while Speaker 2 warns against anchoring bias and suggests diversifying if growth is subdued.
- 43:15 – 46:34
Geelong Market Specifics and Buyer Strategy
Speaker 2 cautions against buying in Geelong based solely on affordability, noting that growth is driven by specific pockets with local demand rather than the broader regional market. He suggests that many fringe areas may see subdued growth compared to aspirational locations.
Claims worth verifying
Perth is down 8.9% from the peak, Brisbane's down 8%, Adelaide's down 4.5%, Sydney is down 10% from the peak of the cycle, and Melbourne down 8%.
Pete Wargent ·0:30
How to verify: Check Cotality or SQM Property price indices for peak-to-trough percentage changes for each capital city. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Investor lending is absolutely dead, with some areas seeing a 100% or 90+ percent drop in investor lending post-budget.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·0:40
How to verify: Review Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) Housing Finance data for investor loan approvals and volumes, comparing pre- and post-May 2026 budget periods. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Melbourne listings are down 30% from a year ago.
Pete Wargent ·2:48
How to verify: Check realestate.com.au or Domain listing data for Melbourne, comparing current active listings to the same period one year prior. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Stock levels in Brisbane, Adelaide, and Perth have increased by more than 50% since a year ago.
Pete Wargent ·3:28
How to verify: Check Domain or realestate.com.au stock on market data for these cities, comparing current inventory to the same period one year prior. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Sydney listings are down twenty seven percent from a year ago.
Pete Wargent ·3:28
How to verify: Check Domain or realestate.com.au listing data for Sydney, comparing current active listings to the same period one year prior. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Sydney upper quartile for homes peaked in November 2025, down 13% so far. Lower quartile prices kept rising until March 2026 and are down by less than 5%.
Pete Wargent ·9:22
How to verify: Check CBA or Cotality price indices for Sydney, identifying peak dates and percentage changes for upper and lower quartile price bands. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
If Perth prices were to fall 18% peak to trough, prices would only go back to where they were in September 2025 and would be 124% above January 2020 levels.
Pete Wargent ·10:02
How to verify: Calculate using Perth median price data from ABS or major property indices to determine the price level corresponding to an 18% drop from the peak and compare to Jan 2020 and Sep 2025 levels. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
First home buyer loans have declined by double digits compared to a year ago.
Pete Wargent ·9:42
How to verify: Review ABS Housing Finance data for first home buyer loan approvals or volumes, comparing the current quarter to the same quarter one year prior. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Westpac reported loans for new builds have fallen by 30% in volume terms.
Pete Wargent ·17:11
How to verify: Check Westpac Housing Finance Monitor reports for new home loan volume changes over the past 12-18 months. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Oil prices are about 19-20% lower than they were six months ago, the lowest level since July.
Pete Wargent ·22:44
How to verify: Check Bloomberg or Reuters data for crude oil (e.g., Brent or WTI) prices, comparing current prices to prices six months prior and to July of the same year. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
APRA applies a three percentage point serviceability buffer for borrowing assessments.
Pete Wargent ·30:52
How to verify: Check APRA's Prudential Practice Guide CPG 223 (APG 223) or current APRA statements on serviceability buffers. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The serviceability buffer was increased to three percentage points in October 2021.
Pete Wargent ·32:12
How to verify: Review APRA press releases or announcements from October 2026 regarding serviceability buffer changes. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
At the time of the buffer increase, more than twenty percent of loans were at more than six times the borrower's income.
Pete Wargent ·32:32
How to verify: Check Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) or Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) housing loan data for 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
APRA and the Council of Financial Regulators reviewed the buffer one, two, three, four times, most recently in May 2026, and announced the buffer stays at 3%.
Pete Wargent ·32:52
How to verify: Search for joint announcements by APRA and the Council of Financial Regulators in May 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
UK has a one percentage point serviceability buffer.
Pete Wargent ·34:51
How to verify: Check UK Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA) or Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) guidelines on mortgage affordability. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Arrears rates have gone up recently.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·35:17
How to verify: Check ABS or RBA data on mortgage arrears rates for recent months. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Listener purchased property in Mandura (Mandurah) for $280k in 2021.
Pete Wargent ·37:49
How to verify: Verify via ABS median house price data for Mandurah, WA for 2021. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Listener's Mandurah property reached a peak value of around $800,000.
Pete Wargent ·38:09
How to verify: Check ABS median house price data for Mandurah, WA for the peak period. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Listener's Mandurah property is now valued at about $640,000.
Pete Wargent ·38:09
How to verify: Check ABS median house price data for Mandurah, WA for the current period. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Listener purchased a second property in Geelong in 2025.
Pete Wargent ·38:09
How to verify: Verify via ABS median house price data for Geelong, VIC for 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify current property price indices from Cotality and CBA for Sydney, Melbourne, Perth, and Brisbane to confirm quartile divergence claims.
- Check APRA's official serviceability buffer guidelines and recent bank capital ratio reports to assess the validity of the 3% vs 2.5% argument.
- Review Westpac's latest housing loan data to confirm the 30% volume drop in new home construction.
- Analyze ABS (Australian Bureau of Statistics) listing and sales data for Melbourne, Brisbane, Perth, and Adelaide to verify supply/demand shifts.
- Examine RBA cash rate forecasts and inflation data to validate claims about rate peaks and 2027 cut expectations.
- Research specific developer viability reports and construction cost indices to assess the impact on new supply.
- Check local council planning approvals and data center construction permits in Marsden Park to evaluate competition for residential resources.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Customer expectations are always shifting, and the pricing model that worked last year may not work today. With Stripe Billing, you can launch subscriptions, usage-based pricing, or hybrid pricing fast and automate the billing operations behind it. It's part of why 61% of SaaS companies already charge or plan to charge based on usage. 86% of the Forbes AI-50 AI 50 run on Stripe. Learn how you can power any business model at Stripe.com/slash. billing. Stripe is built for whatever comes next.
0:30Pete Wargent: Perth is down 8.9% from the peak, Brisbane's down 8%, Adelaide's down 4.5%, Sydney is down 10% from the peak of the cycle, and Melbourne down 8%.
0:40Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): We can see it from a pre-budget and then post-budget, and then what's happened over the last six months now since. And investor lending is absolutely dead. And so I reckon in some areas it's a hundred percent drop or 90 plus percent drop in investor lending.
0:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hey
0:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): there. Here's a quick note. This podcast contains general financial information only. That means it's not specific to you, your needs, goals, or financial objectives. So don't act on the information until you've spoken to your financial planner. You'll find our full disclosure, disclaimer, and link to our financial services guide in the show notes.
1:13Pete Wargent: G'day, welcome to the Australian Property Podcast. I'm Pete Wargent from Alan Wargent Property Buyers. I'm here with Chris Bates from the Alcove Group Mortgage Specialist. Chris, how's your week been?
1:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh,
1:25Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): it's been well, Pete. We just got back from um, you know, a very fast trip to Dubbo and back. I wouldn't recommend it for three nights. It's a lot of driving just to go to a zoo. But um, the boy loved it for his fifth birthday. And um, it's probably the last week of listings that we we've sort of seen come on, head-ups what you've seen up in Brisbane, et cetera. But it's really the last week to sort of get it on the market prior to Christmas. And so now we're just going to see this real reduction of new listings. And I reckon, I mean, agents are saying it's, you know, it's 365 days a year now. It's not those sort of typical sort of sales cycles. We just list when we're ready to list right now. Um, But then, you know, you've always got people trying to time their sales. And I reckon between now and sort of February, it's going to be really dire. And I think, you know, when I'm talking about sort of Sydney, Melbourne, other cities have got different issues. Um, and I think that, you know, between now and then, all that good stuff's going to get soaked up and a lot of stuff's just going to get pulled off the market and re-listed out as an investment property, um, you know, et etc. cetera. So yeah, it's it's that sort of final week of of listing. listings. How you been, Pete?
2:28Pete Wargent: Yeah, very good. Yeah, thanks. Yeah, I've I've observed the same thing. You're right though. It's um there's different things going on around the country. And um yeah, particularly actually in Melbourne. And this is why uh we were talking about this last week, that Melbourne um is the one market that seems like it's at a bottom of the cycle already. I think if you look at um Brisbane and Perth and to a certain degree Adelaide, they're right in the thick of it now. Um the record downturn or record speed of downturn. But yeah, Melbourne listings, if you look at them um over uh sort of the uh recent period versus a year ago, they're down 30%. So very few people are listing. Actually, one of my followers on Twitter said I've been closely following uh the sort of inner northwest of Melbourne, and there is it's he's just said there is zero new supply coming on. It's completely unprecedented. You know, maybe uh one or two three three to four better is coming on the market, you know, totally unheard of. So uh Sydney to a lesser degree uh listings are down twenty seven percent from a year ago. But yeah, I think if you actually look at the total stock on the market, well it's it's it's really exploded in Brisbane, Adelaide and Perth. Well, up, you know, more than 50% uh increase in stock since a year ago. So um I think it's it's worth saying that the stock levels we've been saying what on this podcast for
3:48a few years. There's there's just been nothing for sale in those cities, and suddenly uh there's a release valve, and um, yeah, and vendors are now cashing out um in those cities, and you can see the prices come down. But I think if you look at what Cotality uh have said, basically, uh Melbourne's pace of decline has noticeably moderated. Asking prices are actually up over the past quarter in Melbourne on SQM's index. But then if you look at the mid-sized capitals, they're now leading the downturn. Perth is down eight point nine percent from the peak, said Cotality, Brisbane's down eight percent, Adelaide's down four and a half. Um, so it's almost like the downturn has gone through. two phases. First, uh Sydney is down 10% from the peak of the cycle, and Melbourne down eight percent. Uh but Melbourne seems to be flattening out. But now it's sort of handed off, and it's Perth, uh, Adelaide, Brisbane are seeing their really quick sort of retracement. I think um I um had a look at um CBA's analysis. Trent Saunders uh from CBA
4:48did a brilliant deep dive on all the stats and it I think what's really noticeable is that if you look around the different segments of the market, they've behaved so differently over the past five or six years. Some of those sort of real cheap markets had an explosion in prices doubling. Uh parts of Brisbane saw prices double. But of course, you know, where you start sort of makes a difference. And some of those markets are now coming back down to earth with a bump, also Perth per to a certain extent. So yeah, I think it really depends. I suppose this is always true, but it really depends on where you are in the country, what type of property you're talking about, and uh particularly it seems in this cycle, the price point, uh the upper parts of the market behaving quite differently to the lower price points.
5:29Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Oh Pete, I I I do really like to see that CBA research when they're bringing it they bringing bring out some good stuff I find in recent times. And um one of the things that I love on there their research is the upper quartile versus the middle part of the martyr and the lower quartile. And um, you can see in that the Brisbane and Perth, the lower quartile went absolutely ballistic from 2022 to 2026, basically, when the budget sort of came. So it basically had four years and you know, it probably went up, you know, like an extra 40 to 50 percent, let's call it, then than the middle and the bottom end. And I think that was driven by the investor boom, which we all spoke about for many years prior to the budget. And, you know, as soon as the budget came out, you and I were covering it and we're saying this is a, you know, huge issue for future investment demand. We're gonna see investor lending fall completely off a cliff, and we're gonna see investors also want to bail. And I think that's gonna going to really challenge markets that have been driven up by the investors over the last few years. And that's basically what's happened. So you can see the Brisbane and the Perth sort of lower tier markets coming off just as fast as the medium and the top end. But that didn't happen in sort of Sydney and Melbourne. The bottom end stayed a lot more sticky. It just sort of stayed a lot more, it hasn't dropped anywhere near as much. If you sort of look at um, you know, Sydney here, it it's shopped say
6:49five percent um versus the top end's drop 13% but if you look at Perth and and Brisbane well the bottom end's both fallen 8% let's call it versus the top end so it's completely across the whole market and I think that's to me is the biggest sort of warning side. Those markets have already run really hard and I think you know the second point Pete on this investor lending I mean the data's just come out this week but you know as a broker we can see it from you know a pre budget and then post budget, and then what's happened over the last six months now since, and investor lending is absolutely dead. And so, you know, we've seen a 50 plus percent decline in investor lending, but that's that's across the whole market. And investors don't go where they live, they go wherever they want to buy. That's obviously what's happened over the last five years. We've moved from a home buyers to a borderless buy wherever sort of mentality. And so that 50% of investors is probably that are still in the market from a lending point of view and not buying where they were prior to the budget. So I reckon in some areas it's a hundred percent drop or 90 plus percent drop in investor lending and almost zero investors versus say potentially pre-budget, there was a lot of investors. And so um I think it's a huge sort of shift in this market. And um, you know, we talked about Melbourne last week. We got a lot of heat on the sort of YouTube comments and we weren't talking about Sydney. We were saying that the rate of decline in
8:09Sydney was absolutely dropping, and I wouldn't be surprised if it does find a flaw sometime early next year. But we were just sort of thinking about Melbourne. I just think that that sort of real urgency, you know, with sellers and having to meet the market, very little demand. And um, I thought that was probably the best buying would be late. 2026. And you know, you're starting to see that come through. We're just going to see what happens in 2027. I mean, the oil prices dropped a lot, Pete. Um, you know, that's probably good news. Um, bond yields have sort of spiked a little bit over the last week, so that's probably not good news. What else have you seen?
8:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
8:43Pete Wargent: I think uh, well, the thing uh that really jumped out to me, I was reading um in Trent Saunders' piece, and I almost had to do a double take when I read some of these. numbers because I thought, wow, that you know, I had to almost go back and sense check it, 'cause the um the the way in which markets have moved so differently since the pandemic. So uh just to summarize his uh very good research paper, which we'll link to. So he said higher price properties have seen larger d declines than cheaper homes so far in this cycle. Detached houses have fallen further than units, and capital cities have weakened more than the regions. But particularly in Sydney and Melbourne, it's the price points that have made a difference. So in Sydney, the upper price quartile for homes uh peaked in November 2025, down 13% so far. But in the lower quartile, prices kept rising all the way through until March this year and are down by less than 5%. So if you're a first home buyer, and you actually mentioned the lending for figures there, Chris, the first time buyer numbers, yeah, okay, as a share of the total is higher. But actually, there's fewer first home buyers buying uh than a year ago by quite some margin, double digit decline. So we're not really getting more first time buyers into the market as a result of policy, at least so far. Uh partly because mortgage rates are up, partly because confidence is down, borrowing capacity is down. Um
10:02but also uh the the things that really um really took me back is reading these numbers, it said if Perth prices were to fall 18% peak to trough, prices would only go back to where they were in September 2025. There would be 124% above where they were in January 2020. So you can see now why with that froth getting blown off, suddenly prices have uh are dropping so quickly in Perth. because they've had a phenomenal increase since 2020. I mean, Brisbane to a lesser extent, but if prices fell 18% peaked a trophy in Brisbane, they would only go back to where they were in June 2025, and they'd still be roughly double where they were at the start of 2020. So yes, affordability is improving in terms of nominal prices, but obviously with interest rates where they are, affordability is still. stretched for a lot of people. Um and to the extent that interest rates stay high for longer, that's going to keep impacting affordability. So yeah, I think um yeah, I would also had a look at the lending numbers and I think even, you know, some of the downturn for investor loans hasn't even happened yet. You know, you get, you know, better than anyone. The mortgage process takes quite a long time sometimes to flow through. And I don't think we'll see the actual bottom of the, you know, the the depths of those figures truly until the years out. And um, yeah, in
11:22some people are buying new homes, but um you can start to see the news articles from banks and developers saying, Well, come on, guys, this is stuffed like the market's dead. Um, so the confidence isn't there to drive new dwelling supply now. Um and the first home buyers aren't stepping up. So everything's down. Stamp duty takes down, sales volumes are down, there's no first home buyers sort of coming through to plug the gap. Um so yeah, I mean, I suppose if you're thinking about it, um uh the the real opportunity is for somebody uh wanting to buy their first home or potentially to upgrade. Investors have really stepped back, except to the extent that they're buying commercial properties. property, or I've seen some people are buying cheapo units in Melbourne to try and time the time the cycle. But um yeah, I think you know for home buyers, I guess that's where the opportunity is because um it's the one place you can get a capital gains tax free increase in your wealth and um it's far, far less competition than there was a year ago.
12:22Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah I just wonder if those that still isn't hasn't understood though. The the budget was massively pro home ownership. You know, it doesn't um incentivize sort of downsizing, you know, because you're gonna and there's already a caps on sort of super, it sort of means you know, sell your investment properties because you're gonna have more capital gains tax from July. So it's very much just put all your wealth into your home, all your wealth into your super. Um, and if you've got anything in these sort of tax structures, just you know, you're not gonna get any free wins there in trusts, etc. And then for younger generations. well, don't buy, don't rent vest, buy a home. Um, it'll grow tax-free. If you're a sort of a 30, 40-year-old, you know, um release equity to buy shares, don't do that to buy um, you know, put more money into your super and upgrade your home. So it's not really I can't see this sort of investor market come back. I mean, yes, you could see the 2028 sort of election do a flip and negative gearing could come back, but I think people are gonna going be to still quite um. restricted in terms of borrowing capacity, still quite nervous to do so. Um, but yeah, you might get a little bit of a, you know, an increase of sort of those people who wish they had an investment property sort of enter. Maybe you reduce a lot of investors starting to sell because they unwind the capital gains tax. But unless that happens, you know, I think you're gonna going see to that a lot of people just naturally move towards home ownership. I think that this rental crisis isn't. understood now because it's just so uh quick since
13:42the sort of uh the May budget. And I think what people are gonna realize is well, actually, every time I go to rent something in that suburb, it was already pretty hard to rent. But those 10 or 20 houses for sort of rent in the area, well, five or six of those have now sold to home buyers. And now there's only 15 fifteen houses available. I think you're gonna going to find that um the ability to rent, particularly for family. families, is is just going to get uh much harder. And so people are going to still have a desire to own. The issue they've got now is Joe, is just their fear around interest rates. And I think um even Steve uh Chris Joy, you know, made a comment in one of his uh articles in the AFR. Basically at the end he said as soon as sort of buyers feel like the interest rate hikes are over and that they're going to start coming down the other side, I think he he kind of assumes that you know home buyers will come back into the market. And I think that it's kind of a true point. I feel like it's just that interest rate story. Yeah, I mean, there's job concern with AI, et cetera. But, you know, I think ultimately it's coming down to where interests are the higher we went with interest rates, the quicker that cut's going to come. And I think obviously the oil price is one good thing to say that inflation inflation's is getting under control, but um the the markets don't believe it yet because. the three year bond yield's still quite high.
14:53Pete Wargent: Hmm yeah, I think the the rental market, I think there's gonna be some respite for a little while yet, because I g I guess if you rewind the clock to the end of the tax year, thirty June, there was a record number of homes under construction all around the country and um not necessarily in the center of the capital cities this time around, very spread out. Um but I guess you know it's already not November, so a lot of those uh dwellings are now hitting the market, already have hit the market. So uh for uh for the time being at least, there's a bit more choice for renters. But I think if you sort of wind the clock forward, I mean the types of uh property which are going to become harder to rent is is generally family-friendly friendly homes, good school zones where the the supply is basically fixed and um there's fewer renters um able to find the place they want investors are stepping back and then home buyers are moving in. I don't think it's um going to be so much the case for just a generic unit in some of these sort of higher density areas. There's there's you know to some degree uh there's always going to be uh available rentals but I think it's those um sort of more sought after rentals and that that's where the shortage will start to uh to buy, but that won't be I guess for some time yet. So I guess we've got two main news stories to cover off this week and then stick around because
16:12we'll do your listener QA segment at the end where we go through some of your uh questions that you've sent in. So well the first uh story was um actually we've already touched on a little bit on the lending figure. So as Chris already said investor loans uh crashed in the September quarter. First home buyer uh loans haven't plugged the gap. I think um when you dig into the numbers a little bit, um, well, firstly, Domaine said uh property investors have run for the hills, a bit of a uh an Iron Maiden reference, maybe at a record pace, uh, but first home buyers haven't filled the gap. But also new home sales have dropped. And I think I think that's the that's the real challenge, isn't it? I think you know the the policy was sold on the basis that, okay, well, we don't need investors in established housing. Uh we can get them to encourage new supply by buying new homes. And yet uh that just hasn't happened. Um Westpac said uh loans for new builds have fallen by 30% uh in volume terms, uh despite the national housing shortage, and um Westpank Westbank CEO Anthony Miller called for break glass measures to fast track approvals, but he said that soaring costs have made projects unviable. So he said the 30% drop has occurred over a 12 to 18 month period. So it's not all about the budget, it's partly because interest rates are higher.
17:31Government spending has uh it's kind of kept inflation higher than it is in most other developed countries. Uh So yes, we've got the oil price, but so does everybody else. Um but yeah, I guess you the question is well the policy's not, you know, working if it's not getting getting first home buyers into the market, um, just yet anyway. And if it's not actually uh getting investors to buy new builds, well, you know, round and round and round we go with the cycle, we'll be back in a housing shortage in two 2028. thousand and twenty eight. So yeah, I guess that th those are the main sort of takeaways uh from uh the lending numbers for me anyway. The investor lending we expected to drop. Uh investors have uh stepped back almost entirely from the established market, but no sort of increase in first time buyers and new homes, lending for new homes has just dropped away quite dramatically over the past year to 18 months.
18:23Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, I mean the first time home buyers, um obviously the budget. was pro first home buyers. Um, so that's the five percent deposit schemes there. But if you think about since May, what we've had well, five rate increases. Um, and that's hit borrowing capacities 10 to 15 percent. You know, every one percent de increase in rates reduces borrowing capacity around 10%. So for a first home buyer that was maybe able just as around numbers, able to spend a million dollars um in May, we'll probably spend 850 to 900. And they'll also have to pay a much higher mortgage rate. So they're a bit more nervous in terms of, you know, how much um obviously they're a smaller loan, but then a higher rate. So yeah, I mean that but prices at that end haven't dropped 10, 15%. So that's the thing just to remember. And I think in Sydney and Melbourne, we're down maybe under 5% for the bottom end and 10 to 15% for the sort of top end. And Brisbane, Perth, and Adelaide, they're obviously the low end has risen the most. And so if you're a first home buyer in those markets, you'd be the most nervous, I would
19:23say. But you know, we had we had three first home buyers buy on Saturday. Um, we've had three others that have got offers in, you know, over the weekend as well. Um, and you know, they are there. So they just are very nervous and they're struggling to find good assets that, you know, are protected from the investment. investor market. So even if we wind back to listening to us prior to the budget,
19:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
19:43Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): if you went back and listened to any of the content we produced over the last 10 years, we always said for first hand buyers, avoid where investors are going, buy an owner occupier suburb, something that you can grow into, you know, buy an older unit, not a newer unit, not a high density thing where investors play. Um And so that but the problem is that a lot of those are owned by owner occupiers. And so in this market, they all just sit on their hands. Um and so the markets get frozen up and stock gets really tight. And so they are there. Um the AFR's got an article today saying, you know, the bank of mum and dad stopped wanting to lend to their kids. I think it's true, like they they are sort of wap wrapped up in the sort of media spin, right? So when Channel Nye's news is fear-mongering and et cetera, uh I hope I don't get done for defamation for that, but you
20:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,
20:24Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): in all the news article, uh Channel Nine
20:26Pete Wargent: so
20:26Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): pushing um the market down with fear, um, they, you know, you know, that's what they watch, right? Um, and so they're gonna be saying to their kids, why would you buy now? It's the worst time ever, biggest crash ever. Um, and so, you know, it's so hard to step away from the herd. And obviously, a lot of first home buyers need the help from mum and mum and dad. Like they absolutely do, because that gap is just there. Like uh, and also the upgrades needed need as it well. The the couple that have had, you know, one little investment property hasn't made that much money, but they really need to, you know, life's got on, the kids are getting to the school ages, they just want to get something. They um and they need the help. And a lot of parents just don't want to do it. And their equity's dropped a bit as well, particularly because they're often got the more 25, the higher end of the market. And so they'd also see the the negative wealth effects here as well. Like A in their spending, but B in what they want to give. to their kids and then their parents as well. They're um, you know, maybe in their 80s. Well, maybe their inheritance isn't going to be as much as well. So um I think that's obviously playing out right now.
21:24Pete Wargent: Hmm. Yeah, I wouldn't worry too much about the uh the TV channels. I I've been on enough episodes of four corners and sixty minutes in every property downturn. That's the thing. They never never phone me up um when prices are going up. They want the the soundbite. sound bites, you know. But then I guess I've I guess over time I've seen eight property downturns. In Australia, this is the eighth one anyway. And um yeah, in every single cycle, it always feels like it's gonna go on forever. That's just the way these things go, because the headlines follow um the sentiment lower. Uh but at some point, yeah, things turn around. Um yeah, Melbourne, it feels like it's already happening on the ground a little bit, but um yeah, far less so, I guess. uh so far in Perth and Brisbane. So yeah, let's have a look at this second uh news story. An RBA peak of greater conviction, says Lucy Ellis of Westbank. So I mean Lucy Ellis said we already believed that the RA RBA cash rate would peak, um, but now it seems um you know i they've they've got more conviction on that view, I guess, based on what's happened in recent weeks. So the
22:24RBA delivered its fifth hike of the year. Uh oil prices have uh fallen well, they're about 19-20% now, lower than they were six months ago, lowest level since July. Uh so yeah, I think um yeah, the inflation rate is forecast to peak in the October numbers at 3.7% for the trimmed mean inflation number. Uh so markets are pricing near enough 100% likelihood of interest rates being on high. hold next month. So yeah, I think then things will sort of push out until the next year. But I think if you just sort of watch closely, you're just starting to see um a a a turn, I suppose, in consumer sentiment. So um consumers, I guess, have been spending quite hard in recent years, but it's just starting to turn now. Westpank West Bank gets some real-time real time indicators on on this anyway. I guess, because they've got uh their card tracker and they can see these transactions ahead of time for versus the rest of us. Um, but yeah, you can start to see it in the uh ASX updates of uh consumer facing businesses. They're starting to see consumers are just less keen to spend, they're building up a bit of a buffer or higher mortgage
23:34rates are biting. So, yeah, Westbank, West Bank, just to wrap up, said so we can't fully rule out a high. hike in February 2027, but it's looking less and less likely given all the data in the business surveys and the data that they're seeing. So yeah, um yeah I guess if you look at market pricing, they broadly broadly agree. So it's a sort of a peak of the interest rate cycle uh more or less imminent, but uh potentially only a steady glide lower next year, uh depending on what happens. Um but yeah it's always hard to know when you get reached the turning point um things can change pretty quickly. Uh but uh yeah I thought I thought it was interesting. Uh Chris in the context of uh what that means for any borrowers today. I guess um you're not seeing anybody taking fixed rate mortgages these days um since they're very low rates. But um anything that a borough borrower would borrower would need to think about in this environment?
24:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Look I
24:26Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): think if you're in a really strong position in terms of if your borrowing capacity is dropped, but you've still got enough to go and buy the asset that suits you and your family, and you know, potentially whether you're upgrading or your first time buyer, you're in a really fortunate position because all your competition often right now, um, A, they're nervous, and B, they can't borrow enough or they they don't want to just because they're worried about something, right? And so the the issue you find now is that borrowing capacity is the tightest it's ever been by far. I'm gonna rewind back to 2013. It's just chalk and cheese how much of a difference it is, how much someone can borrow today versus then and also versus the COVID boom. And so if you do get this world where interest rates have peaked and then there are rate cuts, well every time there's a rate cut you go to an open home as soon as that someone's borrowing capacity is going to have an extra two and a half percent. So on a million dollars, the next week you're gonna have extra 25 grand. What do you think is gonna happen to prices? Um, and you know, particularly if confidence comes back and prices have come down a bit. So you don't want to buy in that market. You don't wanna buy in a rate cutting. Um and we have sort of, you know, gone up the sort of uh the I guess we've gone up pretty quick. Um, who's to say that we don't cut pretty quick? I mean, um they reckon the neutral cash rate might be sort of three. something.
25:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
25:40Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): if we say like there's one to two percent of rate cuts at some point, um, then you know, you don't want to be buying in that market. And every time you get more borrowing capacity, you're gonna have to spend it. So if you are in a position now where, you know, you have got the ability to get a good asset, I think you're missing a trick if um, yeah, if you don't use it, particularly in sort of Sydney, Melbourne, I would say Brisbane, Perth, Adelaide, I'm a lot more. sort of nervous. Pete, um, you saw uh I mean one of the things I saw yesterday though, around the AI that you know, I I guess I was a bit shocked is I was going through Marsden Park. We went through back from Dubbo and we up, went up through uh Bilpin and sort of Richmond, etc. And it was eight cranes in the sky. My I'm looking at that, and my wife's I saw it on the way up and I I sort of came back and I was just blown away because you just don't see that many cranes. a usually in one site but um it's a massive data center you know someone might uh make a comment to prove me wrong I was trying to chat GPT while I was driving but um you know that that was huge like I think it's a three billion dollar investment out there and um I just wonder Pete you know obviously uh Nvidia was a big story last week um you know and what does that mean with a new CEO for um and the whole AI world, you know, built on handshake agreements and you kick the CEO out? What does that mean for um the AI industry? Does that also mean that the one thing that was
26:59probably likely to have the biggest investment? Um, do we start to see projects get shelved and this sort of build out just isn't as big as we sort of thought? And people take a bit of a pause because that to me is the sort of the big issue, right? The elephant in the room is if we, you know, yes, we can slow down, you know, resie construction and commercial construction. And but if we are going to build billions and billions of dollars of um data centers, that might mean as this you know investment rolls off from roads and metros that we um maybe don't build into these data centers, which is which has definitely been happening in the last couple of months.
27:34Pete Wargent: Yeah. And I think um, yeah, when you compare the uh investment in data centers versus say the mining boom, uh it's nothing, it's nothing like as comparable. Uh it might be in terms of the impact, but in terms of the actual construction, uh some phenomenal uh expenditure through the resources construction boom, uh particularly on some of the LNG projects and ILO and coal. Um but yeah, I mean data centers, yeah, targeted um expenditure in certain locations. But um yeah, there's there's some question marks about the scale of it, I suppose. But um yeah, I mean to a certain extent that does take some of the uh materials and labour away from the resie market, where I think what developers are finding is that there's just no profit. I talking to uh some developers and they're saying, gee, Wiz, I've sometimes even if I have the land for free, I still can't make some of these projects work. Um the current uh cost of capital, current cost of labor and materials. So um I think it's pretty inevitable that housing construction is going to fall away anyway over the next few years, just because it's just not viable or profitable for developers to build. So yes, we can push for more approvals, but you know, who's going to be building if there's no profit in it? Um it's just a risk you don't need to take on. So yeah, I think I'll be I'll be following it with a lot of interest. Of course, there's a lot of NIMBYism in Australia anyway, but I think
28:54there particularly will be when it comes to data centres. Um a lot of scare stories about noise and disruption and um you know, even housing values, you know. So uh yeah, that'll be uh pretty interesting to follow. So yeah, I think um you know, is AI inflationary in the first instance? Possibly because of the build out, but I suppose in the medium term probably. deflationary. And certainly I already see firms laying people off, financial services, uh as people are saying, well, AI is gonna take away uh some of these white collar jobs. So yeah, definitely gonna be an interesting one to track.
29:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
29:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I think um Warren Hogan went on Mark Boris's podcast last night. Um,
29:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I've
29:34Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): had I've spoken to Warren a few times on the elephant, uh, and he was always the one that was sort of the the black sheep off to the side, not because he was his views were wrong, not at all, but he was the one that was sort of predicting interest rates to be much higher than where they were, that the RBA needed to be much more aggressive in tightening, that inflation would be way more sticky than it is, that people were expecting, um, particularly things like rental Mental inflation. I remember him saying something on a pod, and I just didn't grasp it at the time. And it wasn't two years. till later. I just think, yeah, that's what Warren was talking about. That's, you know, how this is so hard to bring down. And,
30:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
30:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): he went out on Mike Boris's podcast last night. So that would be probably the one to check out, um, to be fair, because, you know, you know, I guess you always got this echo chamber and this confirmation bias that we're all sort of guilty of. Um, and you know, Warren's sort of the one that's been willing to stick his head out. Um, and he actually got it right. You know, the the sort of uh peak in RBA uh rates, he I think he got it at four point three five or something when everyone else was thinking it was a lot lower. Um he was calling rate increases when there was rate decreases, I think. Um and then he's you know that's obviously been right as well. We cut too early. We should have kept him higher for longer. Um and now he's expecting rates to even go higher. And so um yeah maybe no not don't ignore Warren because um he's a super smart guy.
30:52Pete Wargent: Hmm. Yeah, well let's um take a look at a couple of these listener questions before we wrap up for the week. Uh so this first question from investor hawk. Um APRA still has a three percentage point serviceability buffer applied for the borrowing assessment, but there seems to be little interrogation from the media on this. Can you provide some insight as to how they determine this number? and what data might be required for them to relax this buffer? Well, yes, I guess um uh yes, just in plain English, if you're not familiar with the jargon, if Chris writes a loan or helps um a borrower to take on a loan at a mortgage rate of let's say six and a half percent, the lender's going to stress test that at a mortgage rate of nine 9.5% and a half percent just to make sure the um payments or the repayments are comfortably affordable, even in the event that interest rates were much higher. Now, I think it's worth pointing out that APRA says uh the serviceability buffer actually provides a contingency for a range of shocks, not just interest rates going up, but also what if your in what if your income goes down, for example, um, or what if the cost of living increases dramatically. or what if you're ill, or you know, what if the labor market softens a lot. So yeah, it's not just about uh the mortgage rate, but um, yeah, I think if you rewind
32:12the clock, the guidance was called APG two two two three and it said, well, we want a buffer of at least two and a half percentage points. But it was, if you remember rightly, Chris, uh the buffer was increased in October two thousand and twenty-one to three percentage points. because interest rates were so low at the time. People um at one stage were borrowing uh mortgage rates of two percent or sometimes even lower. So um I think at the time there was a concern of financial stability risk. Um at one stage more than twenty percent of loans were at more than six times the borrower's income. And I think at the time it was sort of well, this is a risk, and therefore we need the three percent. percentage points buffer. But that's been reviewed now uh one, two, three, four times, most recently in May this year, and every single time uh APRA and the Council of Financial Regulators have announced that the buffer's staying where it is. Now, I suppose the second part of the question is um what would be required to bring that down? I mean, I think the thing is if you look at Australia's banks, nothing like pre-2007. Our capital ratios are very high compared to where they were, uh some of the best capitalized uh banks in the world. I I guess um, you know, what would uh the regulators need to see? Well I suppose um yeah slower credit growth that has happened um sort of less elevated
33:32household leverage that has happened to a certain extent as well but also the the we haven't got the excessive high debt to income or loan to value ratio lending that we did have. There's one exception to that. It's the first home buyers who are using the uh government's five or two percent deposit schemes. I mean, ironically, those schemes came in right at the peak of the market. So uh thanks very much to the government for luring in the first home buyers and then immediately changing the tax laws. Uh so that's probably put a lot of uh first first-time time buyers. in negative equity, which is never a fun place to be. Uh so yeah, I mean, I'm I'm too old to mince my words. The buffer should go back uh to two and a half percentage points because at this point, having a stress test like that is actually increasing the financial stability risk. You're putting more people into negative equity with the downturn, it's not helping new housing supply and so on. But um, yeah, nobody listens to me. anyway, so it's kind of irrelevant. But um yeah, I guess if I was the regulator, the things you'd be looking for is uh so something that Cotality actually tracks every month, and that it's um, you know, the loans that are written at higher than six times income or with low deposits. And yeah, the low deposit stuff is really just government subsidized. So yeah, to be honest, there there's no real justification in my book to have a three percent percentage
34:51points buffer now. UK has one percentage point, you know. So what do you reckon?
34:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Oh, they're being pretty stoic on keeping it high. Um, I think you're going to see a lot of uh rental uh rate cuts to sort of stimulate them to say, well, we really need to do everything we can to support the property market. We believe that we need to increase credit growth. Um, it's a complete backflip on where we are today, I guess. Um the banks will absolutely want that. Um, I mean, arrears rates have gone up recently, but I mean makes sense, right? You know, uh five years now, let's call it, of you know, or say four years of really high rates, um, potentially four and a half. And um, you know, rates are likely to stay high for another two, three years. Let's call it. And so you can see that people are absolutely struggling. And so uh they have all these non banks that offer you know lending and they can do their own assessment buffer off to um sort of lower at 1%. But those mortgages are sort of dollar for dollar refinances, and you know, a lot of people um you know potentially got to pay higher high rates to get that, um,
36:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
36:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): know, potentially because you know you're on a really low rate and then there's no benefit, so you can't do it. And so, yeah, I think it's one of those things that, you know, the banks would love it. Um, obviously the property market would love if that assessment rate got sort of cut. But
36:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
36:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): don't know, they don't want to have that. No one wants to sort of sign off on that and then believe that they were sort of responsible for putting people into mortgage stress. I think there's just little incentive for them to do it uh, unless they know it's an absolute safe bet and people are calling for it and they think that um they might do it for first time buyers. I think that's not a bad shout. Is you say they're at the start of their sort of earning capacity, if you can sort of um, you know, do that, potentially that will give first time buyers a little bit of an extra win, but it won't for upgraders, it won't for sort of investors. I think that sort of makes sense. And they've already started to make changes around hex for first first-time time buyers. buyers. So I wouldn't be surprised if there's sort of, yeah, okay, you're able to do this if you're a first-hand buyer. But arguably they're the ones that are also taking the biggest risk. Everything they've got is going into the property. Um and so limiting, but you know what what the biggest risk for first time buyers is what they buy off often, not so much the loan size. I think that's often misunderstood. It's like you you get it's more risky going buying a very um high density, not scarce. Investors investor-driven apartment that is 800,000 versus a lower rise established apartment, you know, and a quieter street at 600,000, um, or you know, the vice versa, at 800,000 versus 600,000. You know, um,
37:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it's
37:29Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): it really depends on what you buy, not the price you pay. And that's um, or the amount of debt you're taking on. Uh, it's really what happens to the asset value. And the biggest risk is the asset value falling. Yes, cash flow is a problem, but the asset value falling is basically losing everything a first sale buyer's got. Um, and that's the biggest risk first sale buyers need to avoid.
37:49Pete Wargent: Yeah, fair call. Okay, just time for one more question before we wrap up. So from Aussie Expat, I'm 28, I've got a small Aussie property portfolio. Got my first property in Mandura in Western Australia in 2021, and a second one in Geelong in Victoria in 2025. I purchased in Mandura for 280k. At its peak, it reached a value of around 800,000, but it's now come back to about 640,000. Both properties are negatively geared, but I can comfortably afford to hold them, including under the proposed tax changes. I'll be moving back to Australia next year from the US. My original strategy was all. always to hold both properties for 10 plus years and let time and capital growth do their thing. But with the market uncertainty, I'm questioning whether holding is the right move. My question is: if you're young and you can comfortably service your negatively geared investment properties, you don't need the equity immediately. Is it better to ride out the downturn and hold for the long term? Or is there a case for taking profits and reallocating? that money elsewhere? So basically, am I being too attached to long-term property ownership, or is this the time when a long-term investor should be staying put? So, yeah, I mean, normally the advice is if someone's 28, they can comfortably service the mortgages. Um, you've got a very long time horizon,
39:08so the stronger case is normally uh to hold rather than sell into a weaker market. So you said you can come. comfortably afford uh the the gearing under the new rules. So that's I mean that's one of the practical pressures that's forcing a lot of people out under higher interest rates and they're selling into the bottom of the market. So I guess at twenty eight you've got such a long time horizon. You could stay in the market for ten, twenty 20 years. I think the the thing with selling you're gonna crystallise crystallize capital gain stacks even if you've got properties that were bought before the rule changes. Uh so you get the 50% discount. But you've also got the real estate agent to pay, marketing costs, legal fees, and then you know, as and when you come to buy again, there's probably another five percent in stamp duty. So I think the most of the people who are selling now are the ones who just can't afford to hold. I suppose the the flip side, you know, what's the benefit of selling? Um Uh well, the market could have further to fall, obviously. Um, you know, some forecast for another five-10% declines. Uh, but also just, you know, I suppose you could sort of sell to become uh less concentrated in real estate and diversify. That would be the benefit. Um, if you're not sure, obviously speak to a financial advisor. But yeah, I mean, I guess your original plan was long-term long term hold um and the the the low. locations sound pretty
40:28uh sort of reasonable, I guess, uh based on the info you provided anyway. So I don't think it's too irrational to continue thinking of a long term time horizon. But uh what do you reckon, Chris?
40:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): So that Rockingham Endura part of Perth was probably one of the hottest investor spots. Hence why you're saying your property went from 300 to 800.
40:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um that's
40:49Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): almost tripled let's say two and a half times.
40:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
40:53Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): and it's come back now dramatically. Well, it's come back because investors are basically bailed. Not only new investors buy, but people like you as deciding to, you know, take your money and run. That's also that negative price drop. Locals are gonna be like, Well, yeah, I wasn't, you know, I I was it's only worth three 300,000 hundred thousand five years ago. Now it's six 600. hundred, It's still gone up a lot. A lot of investors and
41:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): locals, home buyers will be saying, Well, why would I buy now? I've got heaps of choice. Listing numbers over there would be dramatically higher and they wouldn't be selling. So I think not only are you finding that, you know, investors are listing, you know, the ones who have to meet the market are selling at 600, but
41:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
41:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): lot of them probably aren't meeting the market and they're getting relisted out. Um, so there's a huge pent-up pent up demand uh supply, I reckon, in those markets of investors that'll be keen to sell. And so holding something, you know, for the potential for it to get back to some price in a in a massive investment boom is sort of anchoring bias. So what you're saying is, you know, I you know, I could have sold it for X. I want to sell it for 800 again because I would have, I don't lose any money. I could the problem is a lot of investors will be thinking like that. You've got in quite early, I would say. So that's good news for you. You got in there before the party started, and you know, and everyone was buying a 400, 500, 600, 700. So you're in a much better position. But a lot of other people will be saying, well, I I can't afford to hold it. I'm I'm in negative equity. I bought it for 600 and now it's worth 580. Um, and I don't want to hold this. Um, and so I reckon, you know, personally, if the but uh the census comes out and you'll see that investors investor lending was off the charts there, and you would know that anyway, um, I would be worried that, you know, you you're basically gonna hold an asset for the like, you know, because you can from a cash flow point of view, because you bought really early, but it just potentially doesn't go up much in value um or potentially even drops further in value. Um you can't go back in time um and wish you sold it at eight 800. hundred. Um, but I guess going forward.
42:50are you going to wish you sold it in 2027 versus holding it to 2032 and just not seeing much growth or potentially going down in value? You're also a bit young. Your life plan's going to change. I think you're probably going to at some point have to sell. It's not like you're probably going to hold it for 30 years. You're probably going to want to use that equity to buy a house one day to live in. Just assuming. Um, And so it's really just a story store of capital in there. And I wonder if you could store that in better places. Um, Geelong's an interesting market. Um, I actually did a pod on it last week with Vicky Whitaker down there. Um, and she he's uh been a buyers agent for you know 15 years, but down in Geelong market, even pre COVID, um she saw the crazy buying that was happening over the last few years in different pockets of um Geelong. So it really depends where you bought. I mean, some parts are driven real. really by the locals that have grown up in Geelong or they've gone to Melbourne for work and then they've moved back to Geelong or the local money in Geelong. There are only certain pockets that they really want to live. And while those places look more affordable on the fringes of Geelong, they're not
43:55driven by the same market as you know, people on the higher incomes or the family wealth in Geelong. It's completely different. And so I'd be really careful where. you own that down there personally. Um, because just buying Geelong isn't going to work. Um, that doesn't really work with any regional town. But so are you really going to buy own an asset down there that looks great on paper, but ultimately the growth is going to be subdued because it's really just an affordability play rather than an aspirational play in that market. Um so yeah, hopefully that helps.
44:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
44:26Pete Wargent: Yeah. And if you're not sure, of course, speak to an advisor. Um yeah, I used to have a property in Geelong West myself, but exactly as you say, Chris, uh
44:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): life
44:34Pete Wargent: changes and then I needed the money for something else, so I cashed it in. But um, yeah, it's a lovely part of the country, of course, uh to be. So uh thanks for joining everyone this week. Send any questions for our listener QA. Chris, any plans for the week ahead?
44:48Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): No, nope, staying at home for a while now. But uh yeah. Uh boy's birthday party next weekend. It's uh he's still at a reptile party, so they they couldn't um two weeks after his birthday, which I'm not sure that's going to work. But anyway, he'll love all his presence. But uh yeah, that's that's that's for us, Pete.
45:04Pete Wargent: Good stuff. Okay, thanks for joining and uh look forward to seeing you next week. Cheers.
45:08Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): See you, see you, Pete.
45:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Thanks
45:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): for tuning into this Rask RASC podcast. As a reminder, this episode contained general. financial information only. It's not personalized financial advice like you get from a financial planner. So don't act on the information until you've spoken to one. And if we've mentioned things like financial products, they come with something called a product disclosure statement or PDS and a target market determination or TMD for short. These documents are essential to read and understand before you acquire or dispose of that financial product. You'll find our full disclaimer. a link to our financial services guide, and a range of free education by following the links that are available in your show notes. Thanks for tuning in to this RASP podcast. Don't forget to share this episode with a friend or family member that we can help. This podcast is proudly brought to you by Perla, the official brokerage platform of RASC. With Perla, you can effortlessly automate your money, whether you're investing in ETFs or shares from Australia or the US stock market, whether you're a grandparent or setting up a kids' account or your own account. You can do all of that with full automation on
46:24Perla.com. If you want to learn more, head to perla.com slash rask and of course before you invest in anything be sure to read the legal documents like the PDS and FSG.