Regulators lack accountability systems; AI and judicial rulings proposed to fix customer grievance mechanisms
Summary
Sucheta Dalal argues India's financial regulatory framework suffers from a 'zero trust' culture that burdens honest customers while failing to prevent fraud. The episode highlights bureaucratic failures in mutual fund transmissions for surviving joint holders and bank account freezes triggered by minor suspicious credits. Judicial interventions, including rulings by the Rajasthan High Court and Supreme Court directives, have begun to address indefinite freezes. Dalal advocates for AI-driven accountability systems, citing Maharashtra's FDA as a successful model for traceable complaint resolution.
Key takeaways
- 1 SEBI's July 2026 circular standardizes transmission procedures but explicitly excludes cases where only one joint holder has died, leaving a regulatory gap for surviving spouses.
Sucheta Dalal · 3:34
- 2 You have not made a claim for seven years, so all interest and dividends get to IEPF. Subsequently, the company is wound up, but you cannot make those claims because dividends from wound-up wound up companies totaling 4.3 crore. remain with IEPF as of March 2023,
Sucheta Dalal · 6:34
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 1:10
Introduction: Regulatory Systems vs. Rules
Sucheta Dalal argues that India's financial regulatory problem is not a lack of rules, but a lack of systems that allow officials to exercise judgment and take responsibility. She claims the current system is 'zero trust,' adding bureaucratic layers that hurt honest customers while failing to stop fraud.
- 1:10 – 3:14
Case Study: Mutual Fund Transmission for Surviving Joint Holder
The host details a case of a 93-year-old man unable to access jointly held mutual funds after his wife's death. Despite SEBI's centralized death reporting mechanism, the surviving holder faces repetitive verification demands (PAN, Aadhaar, notarization) for each scheme, with costs estimated at ₹20,000–₹30,000.
- 3:14 – 5:21
Regulatory Gaps: SEBI and RBI Directives
SEBI's July 2026 circular standardizes transmission only when all joint holders die, leaving gaps for one survivor. RBI's September 2025 directions mandate banks settle deposit claims within 15 days without succession certificates if a nominee exists, but branches often ignore these due to divergent practices.
- 5:21 – 7:04
IEPF Authority Inefficiencies and CAG Audit Findings
A CAG audit of the IEPF Authority found that only 3.87% of approved claims were disposed of within 60 days, with 56,689 rejections. A major gap exists where investors cannot reclaim dividends from companies that were subsequently wound up, as the company no longer exists to verify claims.
- 7:04 – 9:56
Bank Account Freezes and Cyber Fraud Investigations
Dalal discusses how small suspicious credits (even ₹1) can trigger blanket debit freezes on innocent customers' accounts. She cites a Times of India report and Delhi Police figures showing thousands of grievances, noting that the distinction between a lien on disputed amounts and a full freeze is often ignored.
- 9:56 – 11:28
Judicial and Regulatory Responses to Freezes
The Rajasthan High Court ruled in August 2026 against indefinite blanket freezes, requiring a prima facie link to the offense. The Supreme Court directed RBI to frame standard operating procedures on August 4, 2026. RBI's September 2026 draft directions propose a 60-day maximum for temporary holds, effective April 1, 2027.
- 11:28 – 12:47
Accountability and AI Solutions: Maharashtra FDA Example
The host argues that regulators lack accountability for outcomes. She cites Maharashtra's FDA under Tukaram Mundhe as a success story, using an AI-enabled system with automatic 48-hour escalation for officials to ensure traceable and accountable complaint resolution.
- 12:47 – 15:26
Call for Centralized AI Portal and Conclusion
Dalal references a 2022 PIL for a centralized unclaimed assets database and criticizes the Finance Ministry's 2026 'unified portal' as merely a landing page. She proposes using AI to consolidate KYC and death reporting across banks, insurance, and EPFO to eliminate repetitive verification.
Claims worth verifying
A 93-year-old man was unable to access investments held jointly with his late wife due to bureaucratic verification requirements.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·1:10
How to verify: Check MoneyLife News archives for the letter from 'Mr. Kali' or similar case studies published around Nov 2026; verify via CAMS/KFinTech transmission guidelines for surviving joint holders. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
SEBI implemented a centralized death reporting mechanism effective January 2024.
Sucheta Dalal ·3:34
How to verify: Search SEBI circulars and press releases for 'centralized death reporting mechanism' dated January 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
SEBI issued a circular in July 2026 standardizing transmission procedures, but it applies only when all joint holders have died.
Sucheta Dalal ·3:54
How to verify: Locate SEBI circular dated July 2026 regarding 'transmission of securities' or 'death reporting' and review its scope regarding joint holders. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
RBI issued directions in September 2025 stating banks must not insist on succession certificates for nominee claims and must settle within 15 days.
Sucheta Dalal ·4:33
How to verify: Search RBI official website for 'Master Direction on Deposit Accounts' or specific circulars issued in September 2026 regarding nominee claims and timelines. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
RBI directions on bank account practices were to be implemented by March 31, 2026.
Sucheta Dalal ·4:53
How to verify: Check the specific RBI circular from September 2026 for the implementation deadline clause. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The CAG audit of the IEPF Authority found 37,060 claims approved up to March 2023, with only 1,433 (3.87%) disposed within 60 days.
Sucheta Dalal ·5:32
How to verify: Access the CAG Report on the IEPF Authority for the year ended March 2023, available on the CAG India website. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
56,689 IEPF claims were rejected, and reasons were not recorded in the data provided to the CAG.
Sucheta Dalal ·5:52
How to verify: Cross-reference the CAG audit report figures for rejected claims and the section on data quality/record keeping. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
₹4.3 crore in dividends from wound-up companies remained with the IEPF as of March 2023.
Sucheta Dalal ·6:51
How to verify: Check the IEPF Authority's annual report or the CAG audit report for the figure of unclaimed dividends from wound-up companies. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Delhi Police disposed of 4,820 out of 5,833 GRM requests and resolved 15,077 out of 17,336 by October 19, 2026.
Sucheta Dalal ·9:36
How to verify: Search Delhi Police press releases or official statements regarding the Grievance Redressal Mechanism (GRM) for cyber fraud around October 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The Supreme Court issued an order on August 4, 2026, directing the RBI to frame standard operating procedures for temporary debit holds.
Sucheta Dalal ·10:35
How to verify: Search Supreme Court of India cause lists or judgments for orders dated August 4, 2026, related to RBI and bank account freezes. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify SEBI Circular dated July 2026 regarding transmission of securities to confirm exclusions for surviving joint holders.
- Check RBI Draft Directions on account freezes (September 2026) for the proposed 60-day maximum hold and April 1, 2027 effective date.
- Review CAG Audit Report on IEPF Authority for data on claim rejection reasons and disposal timelines.
- Examine Times of India reports and Delhi Police figures on bank account freezes to assess the prevalence of blanket freezes for minor suspicious credits.
- Consult Rajasthan High Court judgment from August 2026 on the legal standard for prima facie links in account freezes.
- Investigate the Maharashtra FDA's AI-enabled system under Tukaram Mundhe for implementation details and global recognition metrics.
- Check the Finance Ministry's 2026 'unified portal' functionality against the 2022 PIL for a centralized unclaimed assets database.
- Review SEBI's centralized death reporting mechanism procedures to understand current limitations for joint holders.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:00
- Sucheta Dalal: Hello and welcome to Money Life. This is Sucheta Dilal. This week we're going to discuss something that all of us face, which is why is it that our regulators, even when they are changing the rules and improving things, still make institutions not answerable to customers and our problems remain unchanged.
- 0:20
- Sucheta Dalal: So India's regulatory problem is not a shortage of rules, it's the absence of systems that allow officials to exercise informed judgment, resolve genuine cases quickly, and take responsibility for outcomes. So regulators design elaborate safeguards against fraud, misuse, and litigation, but pay
- 0:40
- Sucheta Dalal: too little attention to their impact on the ground. In fact, they don't trust either the customer or their own officials. Otherwise, the officials will be empowered and responsible. So every intermediate intermediary ends up adding a document, every institution, another verification, and this leads to a system that's tough on the honest, but
- 0:59
- Sucheta Dalal: still not foolproof against the dishonest because we have endless frauds. Now consider these three situations. Based on a letter that was received by MoneyGuive last week,
- 1:10
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
- 1:10
- Sucheta Dalal: 93-year-old man was unable to access investments held jointly with his. late wife.
- 1:16
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): A
- 1:16
- Sucheta Dalal: bank customer's account is frozen because a small credit is linked to a cybercrime investigation which he has no part of, but can't access his funds. The family of a deceased shareholder spends months trying to recover what is rightfully theirs. These expose a Was compliance culture that puts institutional
- 1:36
- Sucheta Dalal: protection ahead of helping us the citizens. Now, I told you about the letter that Money Life received. It was from a chartered accountant. I've changed the name, so I'm going to call him Mr. Kali. Mr. Kali's 86-year-old mother passed away, leaving mutual fund investments that are jointly held by her and his
- 1:55
- Sucheta Dalal: 93-year-old father. His father was a the firstholder first holder in some of them, and the mother was a nominee. while it was the opposite in some others. Now his father at ninety three can no longer sign and he has a medical certificate to establish this. This should have been straightforward. The
- 2:14
- Sucheta Dalal: deletion should have happened of the deceased joint holder's name, but it became a bureaucratic ordeal. Although the registrar and transfer agents, CAMS and KFINTEC KFINTech, have common forms, Mr. Kali says he had to submit a separate application form for each mutual fund scheme with documents
- 2:34
- Sucheta Dalal: and confirmations relating to PAN, Aadhaar, bank details, nomination, and whatever else is required for know your customer mandates. Some asset management companies demanded notarization, others did not. Now, since his father used his thumb impression, it had to be
- 2:54
- Sucheta Dalal: separately verified by a bank or notary for each one. So he estimates that verification costs alone would amount to 20 to 30,000, even when the holdings are small, apart from the time and effort involved. These are small amounts, but because of the thumb impression, this is a rule.
- 3:14
- Sucheta Dalal: Now, SEBI has set its change rules. This has been going on for the last four years. Money Life has reported it. SEBI has put in place a centralized death reporting mechanism, effective Jan 2024. It requires intermediaries to inform surviving joint holders within five days about the
- 3:34
- Sucheta Dalal: transmission procedure. Yet it does not provide a single consolidated. claim across houses. SEVI now has a July 2026 circular, which has since standardized transmission procedures and documentation, but applies only when the sole holder or all joint holders have died. It does not cover
- 3:54
- Sucheta Dalal: Mr. Kale's situation where one joint holder survives. The gap between regulatory intent and customer experience remains stark. stuck. Why should the same thumb impression require repeated verification when one properly authenticated document should be enough? Because we are a zero trust
- 4:13
- Sucheta Dalal: society. The same problem appears in bank deposits and lockers. This comes from Reddit and elsewhere, even when the RBI tells us we have changed rules. So RBI in September 2025 issued directions which state that when a registered nominee or survivorship clause exists, banks must not insist on succession certificates, probate,
- 4:33
- Sucheta Dalal: or indemnities irrespective of the amount. The prescribed documents are a claim form, death certificate, identity proof of the nominee or survivor, and banks must settle complete deposit claims within 15 days. For lockers, they must initiate the inventory process in the same period. The directions which banks had to
- 4:53
- Sucheta Dalal: implement by 31st March 2026 were issued because, and we have played a big role in this in bringing to RBI's attention repeatedly, with examples, that each bank had its own practices, and RBI acknowledges it in the circular that banks follow divergent practices despite earlier
- 5:12
- Sucheta Dalal: instructions. Yet the rules alone cannot prevent branches from adding their own demands. Now let's come to the Investor Education Protection Fund. Another illustration how verification becomes an end in to itself. We're not saying this. The audit of the Controller and Auditor General, twenty twenty five of the IEPF
- 5:32
- Sucheta Dalal: Authority found thirty-seven 37,060 thousand and sixty claims approved up to March twenty 2023, twenty three. of which only 1,433, that was just 3.87% were disposed within the stipulated 60 days. More than 76% took 180 days.
- 5:52
- Sucheta Dalal: In 65.6% of the cases, or rather 56,689, 6,689 were rejected. Reasons for rejection were not recorded in the data that was provided to the CAG. We, of course, don't get any information. IPFA claims to have streamlined its systems after the PMO got
- 6:12
- Sucheta Dalal: involved, but
- 6:13
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): people
- 6:14
- Sucheta Dalal: who deal with IEPF tell us that problems, it's better, but problems are not yet over.
- 6:21
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
- 6:21
- Sucheta Dalal: CAG audit also found that investors could not reclaim shares or unclaimed dividends. transferred to IEPF if the companies were subsequently wound up. Now think about this. The company is not wound
- 6:33
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): up.
- 6:34
- Sucheta Dalal: You have not made a claim for seven years, so all interest and dividends get to IEPF. Subsequently, the company is wound up, but you cannot make those claims because dividends from wound-up wound up companies totaling 4.3 crore.
- 6:51
- Sucheta Dalal: remain with IEPF as of March 2023,
- 6:55
- Sucheta Dalal: and there is no system of verification because the company no longer exists. CAG has mentioned this as a basic gap
- 7:04
- Sucheta Dalal: in returning unclaimed deposits. Now you have to create a mechanism. The most alarming manifestation of this is in cyber fraud. And believe me, anybody could be. a victim. Stolen money can move through several bank accounts in minutes. We know this. We think that if you're not involved, you've not given your account as a mule account, which
- 7:24
- Sucheta Dalal: is allowing money to be passed through your account for a fee, then you're safe. But no, it doesn't work like this. If somewhere you have dealt with somebody, you know, paid by UPI, and that person's account is being investigated for cyber fraud, it could freeze your account. Banks and police
- 7:44
- Sucheta Dalal: must act quickly to prevent it from disappearing? Yes, we agree. They should freeze accounts, we agree. But if you are an inadvertent victim because somebody else upper chain is being investigated, can your entire account be debit frozen for a small spurious credit?
- 8:03
- Sucheta Dalal: say some 500 rupees because there's some transaction? It's just happening all the time and in tens of thousands.
- 8:11
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): A
- 8:11
- Sucheta Dalal: report in the Times of India on 5th November, very recently, has investigated this. It quotes a deputy commissioner of police, Anyesh Rao, explaining that money from cyber fraud can reach bona fide fcount account holders, could be you and me. through a fourth or fifth layer of transactions. They may have received it for legitimate
- 8:31
- Sucheta Dalal: goods or services. So the guy who's selling legitimately is also involved in cyber fraud. So he gets investigated. You have bought something legitimately, your account is affected. He says a suspicious credit of even one rupee can trigger restrictions on your entire account. The distinction between a lien on a
- 8:51
- Sucheta Dalal: disputed amount, which could be one rupee, fifty rupees, five hundred rupees, and a complete debit freeze could be lakhs of rupees, is critical. It can block your salary, it can block business receipts, savings, money needed for essential expenses, maybe paying an EMI, paying your children's fees.
- 9:10
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 9:10
- Sucheta Dalal: they have the money restoration module and grievance redress redressal and mechanism. mechanism
- 9:15
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): for
- 9:16
- Sucheta Dalal: reviewing this, but it does not eliminate the hardship caused by the freeze. The scale of the problem is so much that look at just Delhi police figures. By 19th October, it had disposed of 4,820 out of 5,833 requests to the GRM and
- 9:36
- Sucheta Dalal: resolved resolve 15,077 out. of 17,336. Just look at the number of people affected. And when it's resolving them, these it means that these are innocent people who have had their entire account debit freezed. This has gone to court. So in August 2026, the Rajasthan High Court ruled against
- 9:56
- Sucheta Dalal: indefinite blanket freezes based on vague or unverified communication. It said investigators must. establish a prima facie link between the account or transaction and the alleged offense. Where the disputed amount can be identified, the restraint should be limited to that amount, and a wider
- 10:15
- Sucheta Dalal: freeze requires proper recorded reasons. Ask any bank and they will tell you the police just asks for an account being frozen and it's frozen, the bank doesn't apply. its mind. It says you go fight it out. The Supreme Court has issued an order on 4th August 2026. It has directed the RBI to
- 10:35
- Sucheta Dalal: frame and circulated circulate standard operating procedure for such temporary debit holds on suspected money mule accounts. In fact, RBI's BS September 2026 draft directions propose that a bank notify customers, seek an explanation. and examine it within defined time limits. Whether a bank can do
- 10:55
- Sucheta Dalal: anything or a policeman has to clear it is again anybody's guess. In the absence of contrary instructions from law enforcement and a competent authority, a temporary whole would be subject to a maximum period of 60 days. It's supposed to be over. But sixty 60 days for a whole account is still unreasonable.
- 11:15
- Sucheta Dalal: The draft is not taking effect just now. 1st April 2027, another six months or earlier if a bank chooses to implement it. Until then, we are exposed to uneven practices.
- 11:28
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
- 11:28
- Sucheta Dalal: biggest problem in all this is accountability. Regulators issue circulars, institutions frame instalicies, technology vendors build portals and frontline. employees have checklists. When something goes wrong, the customer is sent running from pillar to post, one institution to another. Nobody takes
- 11:48
- Sucheta Dalal: responsibility for ensuring that relief is granted in a specific time with least harassment. Today's systems can be redesigned around the citizen by using artificial intelligence tools and followed up by making official. officials accountable for outcomes. Consolidating claims and KYC records while enabling
- 12:08
- Sucheta Dalal: complaint tracking with automatic escalation can happen. It has been done. And who's done it? Maharashtra's food and drug administrator, Tukara Mundei, has shown how quickly it's possible to build a whole system and his work has got global recognition. In fact, Maharashtra's FDA. has built an AI
- 12:28
- Sucheta Dalal: enabled complaint lodging system with automatic forty-eight hour esc escalation. It uses AI co-pilot to help officials identify rules, suggest action, and draft notices. The key factor is not mere speed, but using AI to make the process traceable and making officers answerable. So in
- 12:47
- Sucheta Dalal: forty-eight 48 hours, if they don't answer, it gets automatically. escalated with consequences to the official who hasn't responded. So what stops RBI, SEBI, IEPF, and the Finance Ministry from redesigning their system? We talk about AI, we don't use it to make life easier. Ease of living, they say, but it's
- 13:07
- Sucheta Dalal: not used to make life easier for us. In fact, in 2022, I filed a public interest litigation in the Supreme Court with the help of Advocate Prashant Pushan, which sought a centralized publicly searchable database for unclaimed assets, including dominant bank deposits, shares, dividends, mutual funds, insurance
- 13:27
- Sucheta Dalal: proceeds, and what have you. The objective was to help nominees and legal heirs discover and reclaim assets. Now, bill has been going from tariq to tariq, but changes have happened. Transmission rules and claims procedures have improved. RBI, IEPF, SEBI, all of them have filed affidavits to the Supreme Court to say how they've improved their
- 13:47
- Sucheta Dalal: systems, how they've introduced Udgam. In May 2026, there was a big one. The finance ministry said how it had launched a unified portal for giving you access to all the regulators at one place. As it turned out, it wasn't a unified portal, it was just a landing page.
- 14:07
- Sucheta Dalal: But AI can still convert this so easily into a single place or this finance ministry portal where you put your KYC data, the death reporting and what have you in one place, those notarized thumb impressions, whatever, so that you don't have to do it over and over again. not
- 14:27
- Sucheta Dalal: just within mutual fund schemes, as Mr. Kali suffered, but across your bank deposits, your insurance, your PF, your EPFO, and what have you. Can the Finance Ministry do it using AI? Yes, they can very quickly. If Mr. Tukaram Monde can do it in the FDA, the Finance Ministry with more resources can
- 14:47
- Sucheta Dalal: do it just as fast. Fraud prevention is the same. essential. It cannot become an excuse for making genuine customers pay for poor investigation, cumbersome procedures, and bureaucratic risk aversion. India does not suffer from a shortage of rules or technology. It suffers from a failure to make them work for us,
- 15:07
- Sucheta Dalal: the people, whom it's meant to protect. If you agree, make some noise, subscribe, share so that people are aware of what can be done and what we are putting up with. Thank
- 15:18
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you.