Investing Unlocked

Speakers analyze UK budget, ISA changes, and pension tax shifts amid economic uncertainty

42 min Listen to the original Episode page
UK EconomyPension TaxISA AllowancesInheritance TaxFiscal PolicyUK PoliticsGovernment DebtTax Rates

Summary

Joe Mayes and Brian Byrnes discuss the UK government's fiscal discipline, noting that Chancellor Rachel Reeves halved her fiscal headroom to avoid market shock. They critique recent ISA policy changes, arguing that frequent tinkering undermines public confidence in savings products. The conversation shifts to pension reforms, highlighting the upcoming 2027 changes that will subject unused pensions to inheritance and income tax. Speakers also address the political sensitivity of inheritance tax and the 'hundred grand' tax trap affecting high earners. Finally, they assess the UK's economic outlook, citing G7 growth leadership and potential AI-driven productivity gains.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    Markets can end a Chancellor's tenure if they react negatively to policy decisions, citing historical precedents.

    Joe Mayes · 0:12

  2. 2
    The marginal tax rate for earners over £100,000 can reach 62% or higher due to loss of allowances.

    Brian Byrnes · 30:45

Episode sections

  1. 0:00 – 3:02

    Market Power and Economic Outlook

    Joe Mayes describes the UK economy as struggling with high energy bills and potential geopolitical escalation, noting that markets hold significant power over government decisions and can end a Chancellor's tenure. Brian Byrnes adds that frequent government changes to savings products undermine public confidence in investing.

  2. 3:02 – 6:25

    Budget Details and ISA Changes

    Brian Byrnes outlines key budget measures, including the reversal of the planned cut to the Cash ISA allowance, which remains at £20,000. He also notes the introduction of a new Starter Investment ISA and First-Time Buyer ISA, alongside tweaks to Lifetime ISA rules for properties over £450,000.

  3. 6:25 – 15:45

    Government Debt and Borrowing Costs

    Joe Mayes explains that the UK's £3 trillion debt and rising bond yields, driven by energy prices and inflation, have halved the Chancellor's fiscal headroom. He states that Chancellor Rachel Reeves maintained fiscal discipline to avoid market shock, keeping borrowing costs manageable despite high interest rates.

  4. 15:45 – 25:00

    Pension and ISA Policy Critique

    Joe Mayes and Brian Byrnes discuss the failed attempt to force investment by cutting Cash ISA limits, arguing it confused rather than motivated savers. They suggest the government should simplify the tax code and avoid short-term tinkering, advocating for a long-term plan to restore confidence in savings products.

  5. 25:00 – 26:28

    Pension Tax-Free Cash Withdrawals and Inflation Risk

    Speakers discuss the trend of investors withdrawing tax-free cash from pensions due to speculation about future rule changes, noting that once withdrawn, the money is often lost to inflation if held in cash. Brian Byrnes highlights that this behavior undermines the tax-efficient growth potential of pension wrappers.

  6. 26:28 – 28:29

    Inheritance Tax Changes for Unused Pensions in 2027

    Brian Byrnes explains that rules changing in April 2027 will subject unused pension funds to inheritance tax and income tax for beneficiaries, creating a double taxation burden. He criticizes the administrative nightmare this creates for executors managing multiple pension pots.

  7. 28:29 – 29:52

    Inheritance Tax Politics and Wealth Definitions

    Joe Mayes and Brian Byrnes discuss why inheritance tax is politically sensitive despite affecting less than 7% of estates, noting it is avoided by the super-wealthy through trusts. They highlight the political pressure to abolish it versus its role as a significant revenue source for the Treasury.

  8. 29:52 – 30:45

    Taxing the Wealthy vs. Income Tax Reliability

    Joe Mayes argues that taxing the wealthy directly is inefficient due to capital mobility and the risk of wealth exodus, making income tax and capital gains tax more reliable revenue sources. He suggests the government may redefine 'wealthy' to capture more revenue through these standard taxes.

  9. 30:45 – 31:39

    The 'Hundred Grand' Tax Trap and Fiscal Drag

    Brian Byrnes describes the 'hundred grand tax trap' where salaries over £100,000 face marginal tax rates up to 62% due to fiscal drag and loss of allowances. He notes that many in London earning this amount do not feel wealthy due to high costs and tax burdens.

  10. 31:39 – 32:32

    Political Constraints and Early Election Speculation

    Joe Mayes suggests that Chancellor Keir Starmer (referred to as Burnham) may call an early election to gain a mandate for radical economic changes, as the current Labour manifesto restricts his ability to adjust income tax, VAT, and national insurance rates.

  11. 32:32 – 34:44

    UK Economic Outlook and EU Relations

    Joe Mayes identifies a bullish case for the UK based on G7 growth leadership, AI-driven productivity, and stable public finances compared to France. He also speculates that Starmer aims for closer EU ties, potentially rejoining the single market or customs union, which could boost investor sentiment.

  12. 34:44 – 41:51

    Business Costs and Energy Prices

    Joe Mayes notes that business groups criticize the budget for failing to reduce hiring costs or industrial energy prices, which are seen as major barriers to reindustrialization. He explains the government's constraint: cutting welfare or raising other taxes is politically or economically difficult.

Claims worth verifying

Markets are so important and powerful that they can end a Chancellor's time if they get on the wrong side.

Joe Mayes ·0:12

How to verify: Check historical records of UK Chancellors who resigned or were replaced following market sell-offs, such as Liz Truss in 2026 or George Osborne in 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The government increased bank taxes by three percentage points for 15 months.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·2:25

How to verify: Search the Autumn Budget 2026 spending documents or HMRC press releases for the specific levy on bank profits and its duration. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The Cash ISA allowance was supposed to be cut to £12,000 from April 2027 but is now staying at £20,000.

Brian Byrnes ·3:02

How to verify: Compare the initial Autumn Budget 2026 statement with the subsequent correction or budget responsibility document published by HMRC. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The UK government has about £3 trillion in debt.

Joe Mayes ·6:25

How to verify: Check the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) forecast or HM Treasury debt management reports for the total public sector net debt figure. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Debt interest payments are getting up to somewhere around £100 billion a year.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·8:29

How to verify: Review the OBR's fiscal forecasts or the UK Government's debt interest payment data for the current fiscal year. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Gilt yields are at their highest since 1998.

Joe Mayes ·8:47

How to verify: Check the Bank of England's gilt yield data or Bloomberg/Reuters historical yield charts for UK government bonds. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The government's fiscal headroom was halved to £15 billion.

Joe Mayes ·7:25

How to verify: Read the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook report published alongside the Autumn Budget 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The UK domestic stock market has been in the doldrums.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·16:15

How to verify: Analyze performance data of the FTSE All-Share or FTSE 250 indices over the past 5-10 years compared to other global markets. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The tax code has become large due to successive chancellors adding reliefs for interest groups.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·19:13

How to verify: Review the history of UK tax legislation and specific reliefs introduced by different Chancellors, such as Norman Lamont or George Osborne. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Jeremy Hunt introduced 'full expensing' allowing businesses to deduct capital investment from tax bills.

Joe Mayes ·20:13

How to verify: Check the UK Corporation Tax legislation regarding 'full expensing' introduced in the 2026 Budget and its current status. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Tax-free cash withdrawal limit is £260,000 plus a few pence.

Brian Byrnes ·25:17

How to verify: Check HMRC pension rules on tax-free cash limits for 2026/2026 tax year in HMRC manuals or MoneyBox guidance. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Unused pension funds will be subject to inheritance tax and income tax from April 2027.

Brian Byrnes ·27:08

How to verify: Check UK Government legislation regarding pension inheritance tax changes effective April 2026 via gov.uk or FCA regulatory updates. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Less than 5% of estates pay inheritance tax, rising to ~7% with spouse transfers.

Georgie Frost ·28:24

How to verify: Check HMRC 'Inheritance Tax Statistics' annual reports for the relevant tax years. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Marginal tax rate can reach 62% for earners over £100,000.

Brian Byrnes ·31:05

How to verify: Calculate using HMRC tax calculators for 2026/2026, factoring in 40% income tax, 2% National Insurance, and loss of Personal Childcare Allowance. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

UK had fastest G7 growth in first half of 2026.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·33:24

How to verify: Check ONS (Office for National Statistics) GDP data for Q1/Q2 2026 and compare with IMF/OECD G7 growth forecasts. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Keir Starmer (referred to as Burnham) aims for closer EU ties, possibly single market/customs union.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·32:42

How to verify: Review Keir Starmer's conference speech transcripts and Labour Party policy documents for 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Industrial energy costs are high and killing manufacturers.

Joe Mayes ·35:54

How to verify: Check British Chambers of Commerce or Confederation of British Industry (CBI) surveys on energy costs for 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify the current Cash ISA allowance and the status of the 'Starter Investment ISA' via HMRC.gov.uk.
  • Check the specific inheritance tax thresholds (£325,000 standard, £500,000 with home) and the April 2027 pension rule changes in the UK Finance Act or HMRC guidance.
  • Review the UK Office for National Statistics (ONS) data for G7 growth comparisons in H1 2026.
  • Confirm the UK government's debt interest payments and fiscal headroom figures using the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) forecasts.
  • Investigate the 'hundred grand' tax trap mechanics, including the loss of personal allowances and childcare vouchers, via HMRC tax calculation tools.
  • Assess the political feasibility of an early election by reviewing the Labour Party manifesto and recent polling data.
  • Check the current industrial energy prices and business tax rates to evaluate the government's impact on reindustrialization.
  • Verify the historical precedent of market reactions forcing political changes, such as the 'Liz Truss moment' in 2022, via financial news archives.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00
Georgie Frost: How stuffed are we as a country? Yeah,
0:02
Joe Mayes: it's not looking great, I must say. A lot of what the government's stance right now is a fingers-crossed policy.
0:07
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So,
0:08
Georgie Frost: how much power do markets have over government decisions? The
0:12
Joe Mayes: markets are so important, so powerful, and they can end your time as Chancellor if you get on the wrong side.
0:16
Georgie Frost: We're asking people to save and invest for decades, yet governments keep fiddling about.
0:24
Brian Byrnes: These consistent changes that the government is making. to these various products is undermining confidence.
0:29
Georgie Frost: If you threw it all out and started again, how would you do it?
0:33
Joe Mayes: Well, I think one thing I'd prescribe is actually scrapping the budget in its entirety.
0:42
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): John
0:42
Georgie Frost: Ely delivered his first budget. Now what? What happens next for Britain's economy and our money? This is Investing Unlock, sponsored by Pension B with me, Georgie Frost.
0:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
0:50
Brian Byrnes: I'm Brian Burns from Moneybox.
0:52
Georgie Frost: And joining us today is Joe Mays, UK politics reporter at Bloomberg and author of Can You Run the Economy? Joe, a very warm welcome. Thank you for coming.
1:00
Joe Mayes: Thank you for having
1:01
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): me.
1:01
Georgie Frost: But first, Brian, reckon you can run the economy and deliver us a better budget than what we got?
1:07
Brian Byrnes: I think one day we we all think that we can, but I'm not so sure after reading Joe's book, if I'm perfectly honest. I think the Chancellor does have a probably tougher job. than we give him credit for in terms of all of the books that need to be balanced. But I think if I was Chancellor and if it looks specifically at things like saving and investing in pensions, and we'll get into the details
1:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of all
1:25
Brian Byrnes: this later, the one thing I wouldn't insist upon is more of a long term plan and less of this short term changing of things like products and limits. But we'll get into all of that juicy stuff.
1:34
Georgie Frost: Joe, just um the nice, easy question. How stuffed are we as a country?
1:39
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
1:39
Joe Mayes: it's not looking great, I must say. John Healy tried his best at the budget to alleviate some of the pain that's coming for all of us, but that higher energy bills is gonna be the big thing we're facing this winter. And you have the prospect of an escalation in the US Iran war after the midterms. And if that happens, then we are really quite cooked, I think. And what John Healy He was trying to
1:59
Joe Mayes: do was preserve us from some of that damage that's coming. But ultimately it is out of our hands in terms of the global economic storms that he talked about. So a lot of what the government's stance right now is a fingers crossed policy of let's just hope that hostilities end in the Middle East, the straight up women's open soon and energy prices come down. So if they don't, yes, we are rather, rather
2:19
Joe Mayes: screwed.
2:20
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
2:20
Georgie Frost: where does this budget then, Joe, leave us as a country between now and the end of the parliament?
2:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It
2:25
Joe Mayes: leaves us, I think, in a holding pattern. I think that
2:27
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what
2:27
Joe Mayes: the Chancellor has done is make these small changes here and there, help on energy costs, increasing bank taxes by three percentage points for 15 months. Notice how none of these are permanent measures. These are things for now and then we're waiting and seeing how the economy develops. We have this big 10 year plan Andy Burnham's going to announce at the end of the year. I think that's going
2:47
Joe Mayes: to be the moment where we really get a sense of like where does Burnham where does Healy want to take the country? And until we get to that, we're
2:54
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): still
2:54
Joe Mayes: a bit of a wait-and-see moment.
2:56
Georgie Frost: How about for us, Brian, a quick rundown of what was in there for savers and investors?
3:02
Brian Byrnes: Yeah, there was quite a lot. So I'll try and work through it in some
3:05
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): sort
3:05
Brian Byrnes: of kind of sensible order. I think the big one for savers and investors was a reversal of the cut to the Cash ISO allowance. So from April 2027, twenty twenty seven, the Cash ISA ISO allowance was supposed to be. cut to twelve thousand pounds, and all sorts of complex rules were supposed to be coming in on the stocks and shares ISA to basically make that work. Thankfully
3:22
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): get
3:22
Georgie Frost: us investing, right?
3:23
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): To get us investing.
3:24
Brian Byrnes: So thankfully all of that is gone because quite frankly it was misguided to start with. People are not not investing in this country because of the ISA limits
3:31
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and how they're
3:31
Brian Byrnes: set up. It's much more complex and deeper of why people aren't investing as much as they they should be. So the big one is the cash ISO ISA limit will stay at twenty £20,000 and ISAs will thankfully stay nice and simple. Other news is we're going to get two new ISAs. Um so we are going to get something called a starter investment ISA. Very little detail of what that kind of looks like. There's going
3:51
Brian Byrnes: to be a consultation in the coming months. There's going to be a new first-time buyer ISA. It's not going to come in until April 2029. And there's also been some tweaks to the lifetime ISA ICER rules where you don't get penalized with any of your own money if you're buying a house over £450,000. So those are the big ones, but quite a lot to digest.
4:10
Georgie Frost: So good news, I think, on stopping the cash ICE move. More ICE is introduced. It feels like George Osborne, Mark II here. He loved a good ICE, didn't he? No guarantees on the amount that you can take tax-free from your pension. That feels like something that just keeps coming up. That and changes to capital gains taxes. tax as well.
4:28
Georgie Frost: We're asking people to save and invest for decades. And we know, Brian, the statistics show we're not investing enough and we're not saving enough for retirement. Yet governments keep fiddling about.
4:43
Georgie Frost: Do you think all this tinkering about does somewhat undermine our confidence in this, these savings products, in this in this system?
4:51
Brian Byrnes: Th there's absolutely no doubt that it does. These consistent changes that the government is making to these various products is undermining confidence. Now, I would say with this budget, I think with a lot of these products, they've probably ended up in the right place, but this has to be it. They have got to draw a line under the uncertainty of these products that they're trying to
5:11
Brian Byrnes: get people to use to save and invest and uh invest for their retirement.
5:16
Georgie Frost: Joe,
5:18
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): could
5:19
Georgie Frost: they not have just sacked off the budget this year? You know, and I I thought actually to a certain extent, Keir Starmer and Rachel Reeves's first budget, I felt like they rushed things really quickly. We've got to have loads of changes, loads of measures that some have been unwound, some have been found wanting, particularly wanting. Could we not just leave it for the year and, you know, move on? Nothing to see.
5:38
Georgie Frost: here.
5:39
Joe Mayes: Well, that's almost what they were going for in terms of
5:41
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
5:41
Joe Mayes: political impact of the budget.
5:43
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Especially
5:43
Joe Mayes: for markets. They wanted markets to see the budget and say, oh, nothing to see there, really. You know, guilts will stay the same, the pound won't fall. You avoid their Liz Trust moment. But I think they couldn't afford to just completely do away with it entirely because they did need to show they were doing something to help voters with what is this big kind of pain coming down the track, especially on energy bills. So, you
6:01
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,
6:01
Joe Mayes: the Chancellor's phrase was breathing special. space. Andy Burnham's talked about, you know, all these in our heads, this is the t the Tesco government, every little helps. Burnham's trying to do little bits here and there, and that's why they had to do it. Um But yeah, from markets perspective, that's what they wanted to be completely looked through this budget, nothing to see it.
6:17
Georgie Frost: Explain to me in more detail markets perspective. How much power do markets have over government decisions? Yeah,
6:25
Joe Mayes: so just taking a step back. So the government has about three trillion pounds in debt. This is debt that is amassed to pay for public services because the government obviously raises money in tax, but what it doesn't have to cover public services, it has to borrow from international markets. So that's why hedge funds, pension funds, the holders of government debt are very important actors for the government. And
6:45
Joe Mayes: they charge interest on that debt. And that's what you call the yield, yields, the government, uh the bond yield. yields. And we've seen those borrowing costs surge over the last year, primarily driven by the impact of the US Iran war, because that's increased energy prices because the closure of the straight up fall moves. When energy prices rise, central banks have to respond to that to keep a lid on
7:05
Joe Mayes: inflation. So interest rates rise. Higher interest rates means higher borrowing costs for governments. And so the big problem that Healy had at this budget was that because that huge stock of debt Britain has, borrowing costs have gone up. significantly. So the debt interest payments of the government had gone up significantly to the point where he had seen his fiscal headroom, it's called the buff that he had had halved from where it was from where
7:25
Joe Mayes: Rachel Reeves had begun. So markets were looking at Healy at this budget and say, wow, you're under pressure here. Don't don't s shock us with a big increase in borrowing at a time
7:34
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): when
7:34
Joe Mayes: borrowing costs are this high. Show us that you understand the need of fiscal discipline and Healy did that, right? He he kept the fiscal headroom at a reasonable number, 15 billion pounds, and he didn't go on a big borrowing spree. And recognize that for Andy Burnham, that was the risk in the minds of markets when he became prime minister. Is this a guy who said we're in hockey bond markets and didn't
7:54
Joe Mayes: sound like he liked that? Is he going to suddenly lead a very left-wing socialist government which racks up borrowing? Healy did not do that, right? So that's
8:01
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): why we saw
8:02
Joe Mayes: relief on markets. no negative hit. Um but yeah that's why the the the markets are so important, so powerful. They can they can end your time as Chancellor if you
8:10
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): get on the
8:10
Joe Mayes: wrong side. As we saw in recent history before. And that's what again they wanted to avoid that at this budget and they did.
8:18
Brian Byrnes: Yeah so I'd agree with everything that Joe said and I think the last time I looked the interest payments are getting up to somewhere around a hundred billion a year. So the cost of servicing this debt is um fairly astronomical.
8:29
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): More than we spend on the
8:30
Joe Mayes: MOD, more than we spend on education, huge sums.
8:32
Brian Byrnes: And that's changed a lot over the last five years, right? Because interest rates on on GILTS for ten or twelve years after the global financial crisis were pretty low. So you're talking about zero to one percent, maybe a little bit higher. So the cost of servicing that debt at that time was significantly lower than it is today. Yeah.
8:47
Joe Mayes: And They're now the at highest since nineteen 1998, ninety eight, in multi multi-decade decade highs, it's completely a different interest rate environment than we have, like you say, in in recent years.
8:54
Georgie Frost: Is there anything that we can do to change that? Of course, there's the impact of inflation and the war in Iran, and then we had the moron premium of the Liz Truss, uh debacle, mini budget, whatever we've called it. What can change
9:11
Georgie Frost: to almost fix that, turn it around? Anything?
9:14
Joe Mayes: I think you can just have a very credible, consistent track record of budgets where you are reducing your deficits, where you're reducing debt, and that requires you to run budget surpluses, right? So have uh spending be lower than your tax take. You know, the government's fiscal rules require them to have a balanced budget by 2029-30. They're meeting that target. But
9:34
Joe Mayes: Healy slightly unwound it at this budget. Borrowing will be higher in the next few years than. was previously planned. But you can see what I'm saying here. If you had a Chancellor who managed to perhaps significantly cut welfare spending, um, and like I say, have a surplus, budget surplus, as
9:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
9:50
Joe Mayes: Osborne agenda was. If you had that for many years, then you bring down the debt, right? But the political cost of doing that is obviously very high. So that's the dilemma Chancellors chances face.
9:59
Georgie Frost: Anyone who's got a credit card though with a lot of debt and is paying a lot of interest. knows just how difficult it is to actually pay down the genuine debt, not just the the interest.
10:07
Brian Byrnes: Yeah, absolutely. And the other factor, of course, is inflation as well, which is what investors are are looking at. And inflation in the UK seems to be stickier than some of our um kind of global counterparts, which is one of many reasons why it seems like global investors are charging Britain more at the moment to to borrow on global markets.
10:26
Joe Mayes: And just one final point on this, which is that the metric that people care about is what is your debt compared to the size of your economy, the debt to GDP ratio. And you can reduce that by growing GDPs. That's the
10:36
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that's the other way out.
10:37
Joe Mayes: If you have think of an economic growth, then the numbers suddenly look a lot better for you. That's why when Gordon Brown was chancellor, he talked about this a lot. Rachel Reeves, too, increase the size of the denominator in that
10:46
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): equation.
10:47
Joe Mayes: Get growth going, up to 3% if you can. Obviously, no sign of that coming. anytime soon, but that'd be the dream for a Chancellor.
10:53
Georgie Frost: All that was gonna I was gonna ask, is there um were there levers pulled to get that going? Were we
10:58
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): firing
10:58
Georgie Frost: up the engine at this um budget?
11:00
Joe Mayes: At this budget, you'd struggle to point out many measures that did that. One thing that Healy did announce was £20 billion of extra investment in the National Wealth Well Fund funded and British Business Bank. But crucially, this was only happening in two or three years' time, not immediately. And the reason why I think they time lagged it is because they recognize that that extra money for the business bank is borrowing
11:20
Joe Mayes: and you don't want to be borrowing now. Because to the point we've talked about, borrowing costs are so high. So again, it comes back to my original point. They're hoping that the US Iran war ends sometime soon, global financial conditions improve, and then growth can get going again.
11:34
Georgie Frost: Brian, higher yields can cause problems for the economy, of course, but can any investors benefit? from that?
11:39
Brian Byrnes: Yeah, absolutely. We've we've talked about guilts in a big kind of macro picture,
11:43
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): right,
11:43
Brian Byrnes: in terms of what it means for the government, what it means for borrowing costs, right? But a guilt is effectively just an IOU to the government. And the government issues guilt to pension funds, it issues guilts to international investors. It also issues them to retail investors like you and I as well. Anybody can um invest in guilts. guilt. And as we've mentioned, the rate of return that you
12:03
Brian Byrnes: get on that is now over over and above kind of five percent effectively. And you're lending to the British government who have never defaulted on those guilt. So it's a relatively risk-free way of saving uh and investing. So um and
12:15
Georgie Frost: no capital gains to pay?
12:17
Brian Byrnes: No capital gains to
12:17
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): pay.
12:18
Brian Byrnes: So typically without going too much into the kind of financial advice side of things, the people that usually look at guilt are people who have already maxed out their ICEs, for example. It can be a very tax-efficient way of getting 5% plus returns on your money.
12:31
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Georgie, today we're gonna talk about our pensions and retirement. I wanna know how often you think about retirement.
12:38
Georgie Frost: The actual act of retirement, I don't think about it really at all. I think about it some nebulous future. But my actual pension, I think about that a lot.
12:50
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): So who, where is your pension and how do you actually check it?
12:54
Georgie Frost: So my pension is with pension be, it's on my phone, it's an app, and I just whenever I'm feeling either motivated or inspired or wanting to frighten myself to put in more as a freelancer because this is what you got to do. Um that's when I check it.
13:07
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Great minds, that's exactly what I do. I've also got the pension be B app on my phone. Let me explain to you how we do this. So with Pension B, you can combine old pots into a single, easy to use online plan. Then you can view your balance, you can top up your pot flexibly as and when you like, and you can keep on top of your pension
13:28
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): and know what you've saved for the future. Now you can also use Pension B's pension calculator to see what your savings could potentially be worth when one day you come to access. your pension pot. All you have to do is add your current age, your pot size, what your ideal retirement age will be, and what your annual
13:47
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): income is. And the calculator then shows you what you project to have and how long it could last.
13:54
Georgie Frost: Let's go into more detail about the decisions that are made basically. Can we run the economy? Um, I read your book and the answer was. a resounding no. It would appear I can neither run the economy nor have anyone like me as I do it. But I just want to get into the nitty-gritty of the kind of decision making process,
14:14
Georgie Frost: how hard it is to be a chancellor, and why you wrote the book.
14:19
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
14:19
Joe Mayes: I think in terms of why I wrote the book, I remember for Bloomberg, I was writing lots of articles about the budget, and there's always this kind of meaty section in the middle of the article. where you have to try and explain what the constraints are that a chancellor faces, why they occur, what the fiscal rules are. And frankly, it's quite a boring part of the article.
14:34
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
14:35
Joe Mayes: have to write it every single time. But you can much more quickly convey that important section by just putting the reader in the position of having to make the decisions and seeing the numbers go up and down. and so on.
14:46
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Do you know I'm just
14:46
Georgie Frost: write read my book? C book.
14:48
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, exactly. Okay, I
14:49
Joe Mayes: wish. Um and then and then a publisher's we we made a game out of the budget online first for Bloomberg. And that was seen by a publisher who said, Joe, would you like to you know write a book about the Treasury? I
15:00
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): said,
15:00
Joe Mayes: Yes. Should we do the fun version or the boring version? The boring version would just be like the Treasury 101, but no, this is the better version, right?
15:06
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): This
15:06
Joe Mayes: is the much more interesting, and frankly, I hope it's quite a stressful book to read because at every moment you're making a choice where option A and option
15:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is a B.
15:15
Joe Mayes: B are both pretty bad, but those are the options you face. And
15:18
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that's
15:18
Joe Mayes: what it's like to be Chancellor.
15:20
Georgie Frost: So you either, you know, people hate you, um, or you lose money. And I I found I did both essentially.
15:26
Joe Mayes: What the book is trying to explain is the central concept of the tightrope. You're always walking as Chancellor between things that are gonna be politically popular but economically costly, and things that are gonna going to be economically beneficial to you, like raising a tax but politically unpopular. And can you survive by walking that tightrope in the best way possible? Yeah, that's what I tried to convey in the book.
15:45
Georgie Frost: So let's use Rachel Reeves cutting the cash ISA limit as an example. The entire say industry or industry was shouting from the rooftop saying this is a car crash, I think was the term they used. What's the process behind I mean? maybe that was an unfair, because maybe there wasn't a lot of thinking
16:05
Georgie Frost: behind it. But you know, what goes into that?
16:09
Joe Mayes: Well, Rachel Reeves had made it clear that economic growth was her priority as Chancellor. That's the point I made earlier. She knew
16:15
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that
16:15
Joe Mayes: that was the best way to get the public finances on a sustainable footing. So go to treasure officials. What ideas do we have for how we can boost growth? Ah, we noticed that the UK domestic stock market has been completely the doldrums. What can we do to encourage more investment in the UK domestic stock market? Oh, hold on. There's lots of money held in cash ISIS. What if we cut the allowance to twelve thousand pounds? People have to then invest in stocks. You can see like the it sounds
16:35
Joe Mayes: great in theory, right? But then obviously Brian will be able to tell us chapter and verse on why in practice it was not liked Trevor
16:40
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Burrus.
16:40
Brian Byrnes: Well, I think it w it was pitched to her as a very simple solution to a very complex uh
16:44
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): problem.
16:45
Brian Byrnes: And it was basically if you are the Chancellor and uh after going kind of through Joe's book, as he says, there's no there's no great um there's no great answers out there, but you try and follow where the money is, and there is an awful lot of money in this country in cash ICEs. And we need to do a better job of making people feel more confident to invest that money. But the City of London did a very
17:05
Brian Byrnes: good job of convincing Rachel Reeves that one of the ways to do that was a relatively simple, on the face of it, cut to the cash ISA uh allowance, but a lot of other people were quite rightly telling her, look, that's not actually going to convince people to invest. It's just going to confuse and scare people. Aaron
17:20
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Powell
17:21
Georgie Frost: Is there any way we can use the government, well, I certainly hope so, use the ISA system to encourage people to invest. Now I know that we don't know a lot of information about the starter. Is that what it's called?
17:32
Brian Byrnes: Starter investment ISA. There was basically two lines in the
17:35
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): budget
17:36
Brian Byrnes: document. So we don't have an awful lot to go to on. But
17:38
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
17:38
Georgie Frost: in your experiences or combining, I know that there's been a lot of uh organizations that are are pumping for just one simple ISA where you can do a bit of everything and all of it.
17:47
Brian Byrnes: I think there's a there's a couple of points there, right? One is we already have a stocks and shares lifetime ISA. So whenever we have this conversation, people always say, wouldn't it be great if there was some sort of government incentivized investing product? We already have one and
17:59
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it is
18:00
Brian Byrnes: getting more and more and more popular every single year. Now, it's not perfect, but the government have fixed some of the issues with it.
18:07
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): There's an age limit, isn't
18:07
Brian Byrnes: it? There is an age limit. And maybe with the starter investor I said, they won't look at age limits. So there there is already a product out there, and you could not behaviorally design a better product when it comes to incentivizing investing because it pays you a government bonus on a monthly basis. It gives you a 25% bonus. So we've got a very good product. out there that they
18:27
Brian Byrnes: should either build on or take all of the lessons from the stocks and shares lifetime ISA and bring it over into the starter investment ISA.
18:34
Georgie Frost: Which goes into complexity. And one of the things, and ISA's a one example, but the tax system, we have that ludicrous situation at 100,000 where you start losing your personal allowance. Wouldn't it have been lovely if we'd have really taken a cold high hard look at simplifying the tax system, simplifying the ISIS
18:54
Georgie Frost: system, but the tax system, what would that involve? How much work would be required to go into that? And is there a fundamental problem with economic policymaking that you spoke earlier about the 10-year plan, but it seems like we've never really had long-term planning, and we could probably do with it?
19:13
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
19:13
Joe Mayes: I think a couple of things. The first is that. when researching the book, uh speaking to former chancellors, and we talked about why is the tax code as complicated and as large as it is. And one of the chancellors, Norman Lamont, said, Well, when you're a chancellor, you have to have something to say at your budget. So when you have just successive years and years of budgets, every chancellor will have, oh, I'll I'll make a relief for this interest group. And But I'll make
19:33
Joe Mayes: it. and then as you can imagine, after 50 or 100 years of budgets, you have a very large tax code of all the giveaways you've given to these various. industries. But notice also to get rid of those reliefs, you end up having to upset the interest group who wanted it in the first place. So that's partly why we have such a large tax code with all these different reliefs, all these different cutoff thresholds, and so on. In terms of long-term planning, again, this is a point made in
19:53
Joe Mayes: the book by Jeremy Hunt, who said the hardest trade-off as Chancellor is between the long-term Term and the short term. That's to say you face constant short-term short term pressure from your MPs, from the Prime Minister themselves. to deliver wins that will help you win the election, which is obviously within a five year time period at best, but often shorter. And what you really want to be doing is economic policies that will grow the economy over five, 10,
20:13
Joe Mayes: 15, 20 years. And the Hunt case is a very telling one because he brought in this policy called full expensing, where businesses can deduct capital investment from their tax bills. And who is benefiting from that policy? Not Jeremy Hunt. It's this Labour government. which has seen
20:27
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): an
20:27
Joe Mayes: increase in productivity thanks to a Conservative Party long-term tax change. But the Conservative Party lost the last election. Hunt could have used that money for a short-term tax break, which could have helped him and Richard Sunack perhaps stay in power. So yeah, you're right. Why doesn't long-term planning happen? Well we have e we have election cycles, we have democracy as it stands. Yeah, it is it's it's a massive question. Aaron
20:47
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Powell
20:47
Georgie Frost: Is there anything that we could do, either of you, just to, and I mentioned at the start, the tinkering about, you know, if you make a change to let's say pensions, you have to keep it for 10 years.
20:59
Brian Byrnes: There used to be an office for tax simplification. I may
21:01
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): have gotten that
21:02
Brian Byrnes: name wrong,
21:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but this
21:02
Brian Byrnes: is more in your wheelhouse, Joe. But there we used to have that, and that was abolished.
21:07
Joe Mayes: That's right. Yes. Yeah.
21:08
Brian Byrnes: Yeah. So maybe bring that back might be uh step number one. And it may be a question of okay, if you're going to bring in a relief, you've got to abolish one. Uh you can't make the tax code longer because in this budget, they have introduced another one, which I fear is going to get very, very complex, where they've said pensioners who only have the state pension as their income will not pay
21:28
Brian Byrnes: income tax, which looks okay for 2027, but that is going to get progressively more complex and more expensive year after year after year. Aaron
21:36
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Powell
21:37
Georgie Frost: So yes, complexity is something that can be sorted. out. Who was your favourite Chancellor?
21:42
Joe Mayes: I think that from the interviews I did for the book, I interviewed Kwasi Kwatang, Philip
21:46
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Haber,
21:46
Joe Mayes: Norman Lamont, Jeremy Hunt, Rachel Reeves herself while she was Chancellor. I particularly enjoyed talking to Jeremy Hunt. I thought he was very perceptive on the challenges that faced. Norman Lamont was obviously exceptionally interesting, having been Chancellor in 1992 during the Sterling crisis. He brought lots of wisdom on that. He was saying how just before he became Chancellor, he told, was Did you? know you're about to become the most unpopular man in Britain? And that
22:06
Joe Mayes: came true, right? You need to be out of very thick skin to be Chancellor. So he was very good on that. So yeah, I think uh Jeremy Hunt and Norman Lamont were my favourite interviewees for the book for sure.
22:14
Georgie Frost: I'm actually reading Jeremy Hunt's first book, I believe, How to Make Britain Great, I think it is. And the next one is How to Make Britain Rich. Which It's quite a bit about himself and his experience, and he's got vast experience, obviously, but I don't I always had this idea that people who became chancellors, I don't know, had PhDs in finance. And it didn't come across that
22:34
Georgie Frost: way, that that was the case. So
22:36
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): where
22:37
Georgie Frost: are they getting their information from?
22:39
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
22:39
Joe Mayes: it's a great point. I mean, um, I interviewed George Osborne for the update for the book, and he made the point that chancellors historically, more often than not, have not been economists. They have been politicians, and he thinks that is better. It is better for the chancellor to not be an economist. And his reasoning was that if you look at a case of someone like Rachel Reeves, who is an economist by training, the danger is that you end up running the treasury with a very
22:59
Joe Mayes: economic lens, but the risk is then that you end up with a policy program that is politically very unpopular and you end up losing your position, right? So you'd have this balance between the politics and the economics. And yeah, Osborne's view was that your role as Chancellor is actually as ally in chief of the Prime Minister of the domestic political agenda of the government. And Osborne was
23:19
Joe Mayes: like that, you remember?
23:20
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
23:20
Joe Mayes: anytime there was an announcement, George Osborne would be standing there.
23:23
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): He enjoyed it though, didn't he?
23:26
Joe Mayes: Him and Cameron worked very well together, right? And there was a real sense of unity at the very top of government.
23:30
Georgie Frost: What do you think? If you threw it all out and started It again, how would you do
23:35
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it? Well,
23:36
Joe Mayes: I think one thing I'd prescribe, and this was a Lamont's recommendation for the book, is actually scrapping the budget in its entirety and only making policy on like a rolling basis. Because the problem with these moments is that so much speculation in the months ahead, people start drawing down their pensions. It builds up as this huge crescendo of Derby Day when
23:56
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
23:56
Joe Mayes: budget's going to be announced. And if instead policy was just made perhaps on like a every few months, we made little changes here and there in response to circumstances. you dedramatize the whole thing, perhaps reduce some of the real world economic harms that do occur around budgets? Aaron
24:07
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Powell
24:07
Brian Byrnes: Every every few months, but as part of a long term plan. So I think what we're gonna get at some stage before the end of the year is uh the Prime Minister's ten year plan for Britain.
24:16
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So if
24:16
Brian Byrnes: you had as many of those as possible across the Treasury and all various different departments that we could all plan long term for, then yeah, maybe there is an argument for scrapping the set piece budget. Because I think for this one, they did a reasonably good job at dampening the speculation, certainly compared to previous years, but still to a certain extent, certain areas of the economy
24:36
Brian Byrnes: and people do just stop for six to
24:38
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): eight weeks
24:39
Brian Byrnes: before and just say, Oh, I might just wait and just see if there's any changes that are going to impact me in the budget, and then I'll do X, Y, or Z afterwards. It
24:45
Joe Mayes: happened on capital gains tax. We saw wealthy people were cashing in sale of businesses to lock in. the twenty four percent rate and the treasury had to come out and be
24:53
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): like,
24:53
Joe Mayes: Oh, by the
24:53
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): way,
24:53
Joe Mayes: guys, we're not changing the c so please stop doing that. It's not necessarily
24:57
Brian Byrnes: it's happened for the last three or four years on
24:58
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): tax free cash from from pensions.
25:00
Brian Byrnes: That's the classic example where people just are worried about the speculation, quite rightly. Don't want to seem foolish of not having done something when there was speculation before
25:08
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): election.
25:09
Georgie Frost: Explain that, would you? So you can take up to twenty 25% five percent out of your pension tax rate up to the limit of 260,000.
25:16
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): 268,000
25:17
Brian Byrnes: and a few pence.
25:18
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
25:18
Georgie Frost: something.
25:19
Georgie Frost: And there was speculation, wasn't there? Particularly the last couple of budgets, not this one, but the previous two, that that would be reduced to maybe £100,000, I think it's so we saw people take money out, and there's not really a lot you can do once you've done that.
25:32
Brian Byrnes: No, absolutely. And I as I say, I think they did a reasonably good job. There wasn't that much speculation about that this time, but you can see from all of the FCA figures, there's been a massive increase of people taking out their tax free, uh, tax free cash from their pensions. And a lot of that has to be based on speculation. And you're right, you can't put that back in. And the fear that I have is that when it's in
25:52
Brian Byrnes: the pension wrapper, it's invested, it's growing tax free, it's a brilliant place for it. But I worry that people are taking it out of their pension and just leaving it sitting in their bank account being a road. eroded by inflation.
26:03
Georgie Frost: Yeah, exactly. Obviously, these are things that came in with the budget, but we have some big things coming down the line that we knew anyway. One thing that people are talking about a lot is, of course, fiscal drag. That is the big tax take that, well, I was gonna say no one talks about, but well, we talk about it quite a lot, don't we? Another one, you When mentioned mention their pensions,
26:23
Georgie Frost: unused pension funds getting into the inheritance. tax net.
26:28
Brian Byrnes: Let's go back to the start a little bit on this one. Pensions were never designed to be a method of tax-efficiently passing on wealth and avoiding inheritance tax. Basically, the rules changed effectively about 15 years ago, which made it very, very efficient to leave your money in your pension. And then if you died before the age of 75, you could effectively pass the money
26:48
Brian Byrnes: on tax-free tax free uh to your children. So basically, all of the financial advice for the last 15 years has been leave your money in your pension, leave your money in your pension for as long as you possibly can do so that it passes on tax efficiently. That is all going to change in April 2027. Um, and money, unused money that is within your pension will be
27:08
Brian Byrnes: subject to inheritance tax, and it will also be subject to income uh tax from the beneficiaries as well. So you're effectively looking at double taxation on unused money left in the pension.
27:18
Georgie Frost: For people over seventy five.
27:20
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
27:21
Brian Byrnes: um now that's a problem from a policy perspective. I don't think it's a very good policy. It's also going to be an absolute nightmare from an administration perspective, because suddenly executors are going to be responsible for working out how much inheritance tax they need to pay. People have multiple pensions all over the place. Am
27:37
Georgie Frost: I right in thinking you've got six months? before interest starts paying? And we've we've had so many stats recently about lost pension pots. Billions in lost pensions. So if you can't find it, your relatives probably aren't gonna be able to either.
27:48
Brian Byrnes: But people are also going to be going through this at a horrible period in their lives. And there is going to be so much jargon, so much paperwork, so so much pensions to try and track down and work out how much you owe all within six months. So I'm very concerned about this coming in next year. Aaron
28:03
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Powell
28:03
Georgie Frost: Inheritance Tax is such a weird one, isn't it, Joe? I mean, uh the statistics show that less than 5% pay of estates pay it. But of course, your money passes on inheritance tax-free to your spouse. So actually, when you draw that in, it's probably closer to seven. And then we've got the pensions going in, which means it's going to go up, fiscal drag, house prices rising. But still,
28:24
Georgie Frost: not that many estates pay it. But it is all always called the most hated tax.
28:29
Joe Mayes: Yes. I think it's just so emotive. And that's why, because just the concept that at the point of probably the most tragic point in your life, the taxman then arrives seeking to take a huge sum of money from you, which may require you to liquidate the family home or something. Just immediately you can see why that just sounds absolutely abhorrent. And yet, nevertheless, it's kept by the government because it does raise significant sums and is seen
28:49
Joe Mayes: as a way of equal. equalizing wealth and opportunity. You know, so we know all the arguments, but and I I think it's why someone like Kemi Badenok has come out and said that she would look to abolish inheritance tax. It's long standing and Conservative Party wish if they have the money they'd
29:03
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): look to get
29:03
Joe Mayes: rid of it, right? Because of that emotive argument. Um yeah, it raises so much for the Treasury.
29:08
Brian Byrnes: And you mentioned the point of it's one of the most hated taxes, but very few people pay it. I think one of the reasons it's um as hated as it is, I think there's a tactic acknowledgement that super wealthy people don't pay inheritance tax, right? And people who have assets under 325,000 or 500,000 when you're incorporating the family home, um, they don't pay it either, right? So
29:28
Brian Byrnes: it's just the people that are caught in the middle. Whereas the people who are extremely wealthy, they can take financial advice, they can do funky things like trusts, all that sort of stuff. And I think that's one of the reasons why it's as hated as it is. Aaron
29:38
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Powell
29:39
Georgie Frost: I want to talk a little bit about wealth, because there has been this emphasis that those with the broadest shoulders should bear the greatest burden. But the question is of who is wealthy has become somewhat muddled, I think, a bit.
29:52
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
29:52
Joe Mayes: I think so. I think the the tax drag point is key. But I think also the problem is that for the Treasury, if you want to raise huge sums of money, the basic rate of income tax, those rates, they they do do a large amount of heavy lifting. And the problem being, if you want to target the wealthy, so to speak, then that is a less efficient, reliable way of raising tax revenue
30:12
Joe Mayes: because of the problem of wealth exodus, because of the mobility that there exists, because of the competitiveness of other countries' tax regimes and so on. So you're constantly in this battle of trying to get as much money as you can from these people without scaring them off. It's very much like a laugh laugher ago. curve principle.
30:27
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): There is an
30:28
Joe Mayes: optimum rate at which you can tax the wealthy and it might not be that high, right? So that's the constant challenge. I think I so therefore the solution for the Treasury is kind of basically define the wealthy as uh you know at a lower point and tax them through measures such as income tax, such as CGT. Uh, these are more reliable ways of raising funds.
30:45
Brian Byrnes: The hundred grand tax trap is a classic example of that, right? Because 20 twenty years ago, uh 100,000 pounds. of a salary was a lot of money. It is still objectively a lot of money today. But when you talk about tax drag and and the stealth taxes of more and more people being dragged into that, you talk about the marginal rate of tax that people are paying when they earn over a hundred thousand pounds, which
31:05
Brian Byrnes: can be sixty two percent or even higher if they lose their kind of childcare allowances. People living in London in the South Southeast East on a 100,000, hundred thousand, they don't feel particularly wealthy. with all of this tax drag and also cost of living as
31:17
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): well.
31:18
Georgie Frost: Here's one of the big problems that the best way of raising tax, the government basically tied its hands together with its manifesto, which was, of course, income tax, national insurance, or VAT. I'm just thinking, listening to you both talk about a 10-year ten year plan, and we're not in danger of binding ourselves in a similar way with something else.
31:39
Joe Mayes: Yeah, I think for me with a ten year plan,
31:41
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
31:41
Joe Mayes: does speak to me the idea that Burnham is looking to call an early election, because I don't see how he has a ten year plan with radical ideas for Britain transforming the economy as the way he said, and yet deliver that within the constraints of the manifesto that you just described. So that's why I'm in the kind of early election camp. Because for me the Labour manifesto was election was a manifesto to win power, but
32:01
Joe Mayes: not for power, because when in power, you do want to be able to touch the rates of income tax, you do want to be able to touch VAT and national insurance and so on, because they
32:08
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): are the big
32:08
Joe Mayes: revenue raisers that reliably raise money without having distorted economic effects the way that other tax risers do. So yeah, I think that if Burnham wants to have a successful ten year plan, he needs to win a new mandate from an election,
32:19
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
32:19
Joe Mayes: that's for my view likely to happen in say the middle of next year.
32:22
Georgie Frost: What's the vision? I sense reindustrialization. is on the cards. I'm just thinking from an investor's perspective, and if you are to look to Britain, where would you
32:31
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): look?
32:32
Joe Mayes: Yeah, I think a key part of the vision increasingly seems to be the EU and the closer relationship with the EU. Burnham is really seeming to go pretty much.
32:40
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Are we going back into
32:41
Georgie Frost: the EU? Is that the
32:42
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I think
32:42
Joe Mayes: that's what Burnham wants. That's the indication. Or at the very least, single market and customs union, basically some more significant, closer ties with the EU. Otherwise, he wouldn't be doing all
32:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that.
32:51
Joe Mayes: this stuff of you know saying that he's going to set out the options, making a big part of his conference speech. This man is going for it.
32:57
Joe Mayes: This is the body language of someone who is going for it. So if you're an international investor looking at the UK, you might think, wait a second, in five, ten years' time, this country could be back in you know one of the biggest trading blocks on the planet, and you know, suddenly we might take a different view on the UK. You can see why he he is it's a big gamble, but the economic payoff could be quite significant. So yeah, I think that's where he's heading.
33:14
Georgie Frost: Can we look at this objectively and say, in terms of investment in Britain, can you find them the data points that suggest good, bad?
33:24
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
33:24
Joe Mayes: I think the bullish case you'd make for Britain is that yes, the economy had fastest growth rate in the G seven in the first half of this year, supported by the fact that the public finances are in a an improved state. Yes, the tax rises from Vachuries veterans were hated by the public, but they did stabilize the situation for Healy, and he's benefiting from that. You saw positive data on
33:43
Joe Mayes: productivity improvements, investment coming in, AI, the uh rollout of AI seems to be fueling a lot of the growth as well. So you look at those fundamentals and say, well, the UK looks pretty good compared to peers, right?
33:53
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We
33:54
Joe Mayes: look at the situation in France. Political unrest, can't pass a budget. You know, th there are difficulties that other countries face. The UK does not face them. So you can see why by the relative play looks fairly decent for the UK at the moment. But obviously, this international context is what's really hurting everyone. Um so it's still still a difficult one to call.
34:09
Brian Byrnes: We're also very, very good at creating companies in the UK in starting up companies and growing them. What we're less good at uh compared to the US, for example, is scaling them into multi-billion pound or multi-billion dollar uh companies. In the budget, there was an entrepreneurs' package as well that will encourage and incentivize people to further grow their companies and potentially list them in the UK,
34:29
Brian Byrnes: which would be a boost to the UK stock market. I
34:31
Joe Mayes: think you say the biggest levers the government has at its disposable to encourage investment are things like the tax environment businesses face. What's your corporation tax rate? What's your cost of employing a person? These are all things the Treasury can directly control through tax rates.
34:44
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And the
34:44
Joe Mayes: balance they have is yes, we could make those ex exceptionally attractive to business, but we'd obviously lose tax revenue, say, on national insurance. for example. And so the Rachel Reeves argument was always we have to prioritize stability in the public finances first. And once that's in place, then the growth can come. Because we saw what happened when we lose control of the finances, the Quarting Trust era. So that was always the sequencing from Reeves. Healy seems to
35:04
Joe Mayes: be keeping that. And now it's a case of hold tight, hope that economic conditions improve elsewhere, and then the business investment will come uh through that mechanism. So yeah, it's always a risk as chancellor. How how how business friendly do you want to make your tax environment when it comes at a cost of public finances?
35:21
Georgie Frost: Well, a couple of things you mentioned there is the cost of staff essentially, and that's gone up. We've seen employee national insurance go up, minimum wage going up.
35:32
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
35:32
Georgie Frost: how business friendly, I I mean, mean.
35:35
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
35:35
Joe Mayes: mean, the business groups have come out and criticized this budget. They've said you have not taken significant steps to reduce the cost of hiring. We had the big national insurance increase from Rachel Reeves. You've done nothing to alleviate that. But crucially, secondly, industrial energy costs are still so, so high. And that's what's really killing us as like manufacturers. If you want to reindustrialize
35:53
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Britain,
35:54
Joe Mayes: as is your plan, you need to start helping us out on the energy costs. So from that perspective, it's been a thumbs down from business for this budget. And they could have done more there to help. But again, that would have come at a cost, right? They could have said we're gonna have a big package to reduce energy costs for businesses. Sure, but how are you going to fund that? Okay, uh the clear not willing to take the big decisions on cutting welfare spending, for example, at this point. Um, where else was
36:14
Joe Mayes: the money gonna come from? They could have raised some taxes elsewhere, that could have a negative effects on business. They can't touch income tax for the reasons
36:19
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): we talked
36:19
Joe Mayes: about. So these are these are the binds, these are the handcuffs you find yourself in as Chancellor.
36:23
Georgie Frost: Obviously, the government wants us investing, the government ideally wants us. investing in Britain.
36:29
Georgie Frost: Those the sort of two not necessarily two separate things, but they're certainly not the same thing. Yeah,
36:34
Joe Mayes: I thought there'd be more in the budget on doing things like perhaps removing stamp duty on shares and so on, all these little things that you can do which would add up to investing more in the in the UK. Um they didn't do them. I don't know why. Um maybe still to come.
36:45
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
36:45
Brian Byrnes: I think uh I'm torn a little bit on this because I do think that we as individual investors, our responsibility is towards our financial goals and doing the right thing for our finances, which for most people is a diversified portfolio of not just UK stocks, not just US stocks, European ones as well. But I think we all benefit when the UK stock market is doing well and there's healthy and thriving kind of UK companies.
37:06
Brian Byrnes: I do think the government's role in that is creating the environment for more UK companies to flourish, more exciting companies to come to the UK stock market.
37:15
Brian Byrnes: that will capture people's attention. All of these big IPOs that are happening over it in the US, we just haven't had those. We haven't had that pipeline in the UK over the last kind of five, 10, 15 years. If we can generate those companies, that will get people interested, that will get people excited, and it will up their allocation naturally to UK stocks. I think that's the government's responsibility
37:35
Brian Byrnes: and their role in this, rather than dictating what your or my asset allocation in my ISA or pension should be.
37:41
Georgie Frost: So we we spoke about the stamp duty on shares. Brian, what's your thoughts about this? Because there were some calls ahead of this to uh to get rid of it.
37:48
Brian Byrnes: Yeah. So I think a couple of contradictory things can be simultaneously true here, right?
37:52
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): One
37:53
Brian Byrnes: is it's absolutely ridiculous that UK investors pay a 0.5% charge to invest in UK companies and not in US companies. That just doesn't make any sense. Now what the government will always say is they'll tend to agree with you, but they'll say, yeah, it raises 4 billion a year. And as Joe has pointed out today, it's all about choices, right? So if you want to get rid of stamp duty,
38:13
Brian Byrnes: where's that 4 billion a year going
38:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to come from?
38:14
Brian Byrnes: Now, what they could do is remove it for ISA and SIP investors. And I think that would be significantly cheaper. So maybe in a future budget.
38:23
Georgie Frost: With your wealth manager. hat on,
38:28
Georgie Frost: looking over the budget,
38:30
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh is
38:31
Georgie Frost: there anything that we should be doing now?
38:34
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
38:34
Georgie Frost: mean, obviously, lots of different policies affect lots of different people's in lots of different ways, but is there something more generally that we could be doing that's changed since the budget, or is it just the good old basics, really?
38:46
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
38:46
Brian Byrnes: it's quite a boring answer, but it is the basics.
38:49
Brian Byrnes: I think
38:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
38:50
Brian Byrnes: very
38:52
Brian Byrnes: important thing is to do there is no knee-jerk reactions that anybody needs to make to this to this budget. But then you do just go back to the basics of okay, do I have my emergency fund? Have I started to invest? Could I start investing from uh from a pound or rounding up my spare change, for example? Should I be consolidating my pensions? None of that has changed from
39:12
Brian Byrnes: from from this budget.
39:13
Georgie Frost: Finally, Joe. I always ask a would you rather to our guests at the end. So would you rather very simply be the Prime Minister or the Chancellor?
39:21
Joe Mayes: Prime Minister, official Chancellor, too stressful. Prime Minister, also very stressful, but not as stressful.
39:26
Georgie Frost: All right then. I don't mean this particular Prime Minister or this particular prime.
39:29
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Just in general.
39:32
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So it's an easy,
39:33
Georgie Frost: easy job, Andy. No problems. Brian's bottom line.
39:36
Brian Byrnes: Brian's bottom line.
39:38
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It will be
39:38
Brian Byrnes: would a tenure. 10-year retail investing strategy. Currently, um, the responsibility for retail investing is across the Chancellor, the City Minister, the FCA, Department for Work and Pensions, lots of different disparate areas. Having a 10-year plan that pulls all of that together, I think, would be very helpful. That's not to be naive and say that they couldn't deviate from that, but at least a direction of travel of this is what we are
39:58
Brian Byrnes: trying to achieve with ISA's pension savings accounts. I think that would will give a lot of people. a lot more certainty.
40:03
Georgie Frost: Brian Joe, thank you so much for your time. And thank you for joining us. If you want to get in touch with us, you can find us on social or email us. Remember to hit subscribe so you don't miss an episode. And make sure to tell your friends about us too. Before you go, just a quick reminder that everything you've heard on this podcast is for information and education. Only it is not personal financial advice. Investing involves risk. And if you're unsure,
40:24
Georgie Frost: it is best to speak to regulated financial advisor. Until next
40:26
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): time.
40:27
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Grocery shopping, utility bills, petrol for the car, paying your mortgage. Once you've done all that, it's no wonder if you feel like you just want to fly under the radar or fly to the other side of the world or take up surfing. I may be projecting a bit there. There's nothing wrong with treating yourself. But before you do, there's one more
40:47
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): essential bill that you might want to add to your list. contributing to your pension. It might not be as glamorous as a trip around the world, but paying into your pension could help you catch the flights you want in later life, and building it is one of the non-negotiable expenses that can help you stick
41:07
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): to saving, even in those months when it feels a little bit tighter. With pension B, you can contribute easily and flexibly via the app or the website. Your savings will be invested for your future, you'll get a tax top-up on eligible contributions, giving your payments a healthy boost.
41:26
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Sign up with Pension B today and you can start your saving for tomorrow. Remember with investing, your money is at risk, and don't forget to book that flight and that surfing lesson. You'll thank yourself later.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.

More from Investing Unlocked

All insights