Rock Stock Channel

CRU's Max Reed argues sodium-ion's cost advantage is offset by system-level inefficiencies and LFP dominates stationary storage

51 min Listen to the original Episode page
Battery TechnologyLithium-IonSodium-IonEnergy StorageEVsCRUManufacturing Costs

Summary

Max Reed of CRU explains that while sodium-ion cathodes are cheaper than LFP, lower energy density increases system-level costs, making it less competitive for general storage. He notes LFP's 10,000-cycle life secures its dominance in 20-year stationary storage projects, whereas EV markets may shift to Lithium-Rich Manganese-Rich (LMR) chemistry for higher energy density. Reed highlights that solid-state batteries face insurmountable cost hurdles for mass-market EVs, finding niche potential only in robotics and space. The discussion also covers how US tariffs and tax credits influence local manufacturing economics compared to Chinese imports.

Episode sections

  1. 0:00 – 0:29

    Lithium Price Reversal and AI Data Center Battery Requirements

    Lithium prices have doubled in 2026, reversing a 20-year decline. Sodium-ion may handle over a third of power consumption in AI data centers due to high-frequency demands despite low capacity share.

  2. 0:29 – 0:51

    Lithium Metal Anodes and Solid Electrolytes

    Using lithium metal anodes and solid electrolytes triples lithium content per cell, increasing material abundance but significantly raising costs.

  3. 0:51 – 3:21

    CRU Introduction and Max Reed Background

    Max Reed, head of CRU's battery costs team, joins the show. CRU acquired Xawatt three years ago to cover downstream clean technology.

  4. 3:21 – 7:02

    Lithium-Rich Manganese-Rich (LMR) Chemistry for EVs

    LMR technology uses manganese to reduce nickel content while maintaining high energy density (600 Wh/L), potentially saving $10/kWh versus high-nickel NMCs.

  5. 7:02 – 10:32

    LMR Commercialization and Manganese Purity Requirements

    Ultium is piloting LMR with mass production expected in two years. High-purity manganese is required to prevent dissolution and ensure cycle life.

  6. 10:32 – 12:34

    LFP Dominance in Energy Storage vs. EV Markets

    LFP is expected to dominate the energy storage market due to its 10,000-cycle life and 20-year duration, while EV sales have plateaued.

  7. 12:34 – 15:21

    US Tariffs and Southeast Asian Manufacturing

    US tariffs may boost Southeast Asian battery manufacturing, but Chinese technology export restrictions keep these facilities a generation behind.

  8. 15:21 – 33:53

    EU Recycled Content Mandate and Localization Costs

    The EU's 6% lithium/nickel and 16% cobalt recycled content mandate by 2031 is achievable and will add only $1-2/kWh to cell costs.

  9. 33:53 – 35:44

    Tin and Anode-Free Sodium-Ion Anodes

    Tin is a viable conversion anode for sodium-ion at low TRL. Anode-free sodium iron chemistry faces challenges with cycle life and manufacturing complexity.

  10. 35:44 – 39:01

    Solid-State Battery Cost and Market Reality

    Solid-state batteries will likely never close the cost gap with lithium-ion for EVs. The primary commercial opportunity is high-margin, low-volume sectors like humanoid robots and space.

  11. 39:01 – 42:04

    Lithium-Ion Cost Floor and Raw Material Sensitivity

    Manufacturing costs for lithium-ion cells are nearing a floor. Western gigafactories have significant cost advantages to gain by reducing capital expenditure, which is currently five times higher than in China.

  12. 42:04 – 46:18

    Emerging Chemistries: Niobium, Sulfur, and LMO

    New technologies include niobium-based anodes for data centers, sulfur cathodes for EV disruption, and a resurgence of LMO enabled by semi-solid electrolytes.

  13. 46:18 – 51:23

    Capital Misallocation in Defense and New Materials

    The defense sector is a misallocation of capital for new battery entrants due to small volumes. New material entrants face high barriers due to long qualification timelines.

Claims worth verifying

Lithium prices have doubled for the average of this year (2026).

Unidentified speaker ·0:00

How to verify: Check lithium spot price indices (e.g., Fastmarkets, S&P Global Platts) for 2026 average vs. 2025 average.

Average sell cost is higher in 2026 than 2025, reversing a 20-year decline.

Unidentified speaker ·0:02

How to verify: Review battery cell cost reports from CRU, BloombergNEF, or SNE Research for 2025 and 2026 averages.

In AI data centers, sodium-ion may provide 5-10% of total storage capacity but meet a third or higher of power consumption.

Unidentified speaker ·0:12

How to verify: Review CRU's published article on sodium-ion in data centers or technical specifications of AI power backup systems.

Lithium metal anodes with solid electrolytes triple the lithium content per cell compared to traditional liquid-based cells.

Unidentified speaker ·0:29

How to verify: Compare technical datasheets of solid-state battery cells vs. liquid electrolyte cells from manufacturers.

CRU acquired Xawatt three years ago.

Unidentified speaker ·2:31

How to verify: Check CRU's corporate press releases or acquisition announcements from 2023.

LMR technology could compete on costs with LFP in the US context.

Unidentified speaker ·3:39

How to verify: Review CRU's modeling notes on LMR vs. LFP cost structures in US manufacturing environments.

LMR has an energy density of 600 Wh/L compared to LFP's 400 Wh/L.

Unidentified speaker ·5:05

How to verify: Check technical specifications of LMR and LFP cells from manufacturers like LG or Ultium.

LMR saves approximately $10 per kilowatt hour versus high-nickel NMCs and LFP in the US.

Unidentified speaker ·5:58

How to verify: Review CRU's cost modeling data for battery chemistries in US gigafactories.

LFP has a cycle life of 10,000 cycles, suitable for 20-year energy storage.

Unidentified speaker ·11:49

How to verify: Check manufacturer datasheets for LFP cells (e.g., CATL, BYD) regarding cycle life and warranty periods.

EU's 6% lithium and nickel recycled content mandate by 2031 will add only $1-2 per kilowatt hour to cell costs.

Unidentified speaker ·16:36

How to verify: Review CRU's analysis on EU recycled content mandates and their impact on battery manufacturing costs.

Goshen High-Tech released anode-free sodium-ion technologies this year for drones and niche markets.

Unidentified speaker ·34:27

How to verify: Check Goshen High-Tech press releases or product announcements from 2026.

Solid-state batteries are more expensive per order because they use expensive ceramic electrolytes with slower throughput than liquid filling.

Unidentified speaker ·36:27

How to verify: Review technical papers or industry reports on solid-state battery manufacturing processes and throughput rates.

Solid-state cells using lithium metal anodes and solid electrolytes contain more lithium than traditional liquid-based EV cells.

Unidentified speaker ·36:56

How to verify: Calculate lithium content by mass in a typical solid-state cell design versus a standard NMC/LFP cell using material specifications.

Samsung SDI is commercializing solid-state batteries next year (2027) primarily for humanoid robots.

Unidentified speaker ·38:00

How to verify: Check Samsung SDI investor presentations or press releases regarding solid-state battery commercialization timelines.

Lithium prices doubled for the average of 2026 compared to 2025.

Unidentified speaker ·40:38

How to verify: Consult CRU, S&P Global Commodity Insights, or Fastmarkets lithium price indices for 2025 and 2026 averages.

Chinese gigafactory capital expenditure is close to $20 million per gigawatt-hour, five times cheaper than five years ago.

Unidentified speaker ·41:28

How to verify: Analyze CRU or industry reports on gigafactory construction costs in China over the last five years.

Western gigafactories have capital expenditures around $80-100 million per gigawatt-hour.

Unidentified speaker ·41:41

How to verify: Review financial filings or industry reports on new gigafactory projects in North America or Europe.

Niobium titanates are emerging as an anode material for data centers, with companies like Echion and Niobolt developing this technology in the UK.

Unidentified speaker ·43:02

How to verify: Check company websites or press releases for Echion and Niobolt regarding niobium-based battery technologies.

Qingtao Energy commercialized LMO technology for the SAIC MG4 using semi-solid electrolytes.

Unidentified speaker ·44:53

How to verify: Verify SAIC MG4 battery specifications and Qingtao Energy press releases or partnership announcements.

The US DoD requires only a couple of hundred megawatt-hours of battery capacity, mostly for lead-acid batteries.

Unidentified speaker ·47:18

How to verify: Review US Department of Defense procurement reports or studies on military electrification and battery requirements.

Do your own research

  • Verify CRU's battery cost models and assumptions regarding system-level BOM costs for sodium-ion vs LFP.
  • Check current US Department of Energy tax credit eligibility and landed cost calculations for domestic vs imported cells.
  • Review Ford, GM, and LG's progress on LMR commercialization and manganese purity requirements.
  • Analyze Chinese export restrictions on battery technology and their impact on Southeast Asian manufacturing capabilities.
  • Assess the technological readiness level and cycle life data for anode-free sodium-ion and solid-state batteries.
  • Compare capital expenditure reports from Western gigafactories against Chinese benchmarks ($20M/GWh).
  • Investigate sulfur cathode and niobium titanate anode commercialization timelines and partnership announcements.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00
Unidentified speaker: Lithium prices have doubled for the average of this year.
0:02
Unidentified speaker: That has resulted in the average sell cost being higher in 2026 than 2025, which is effectively reversing that really dramatic decline that we've seen for the past 20 years.
0:12
Unidentified speaker: When you're looking at an AI data center, you might get maybe 5-10% of the total storage capacity being sodium iron, but in terms of the power consumption, it's meeting maybe a third or higher of the actual power because of this short-term high frequency power consumption requirement.
0:29
Unidentified speaker: If you're using a lithium metal anode, a solid electrolyte, and a typical cathode, you might get three times the amount of lithium in your cell than you do for a traditional liquid-based cell.
0:40
Unidentified speaker: So you're getting huge abundance of lithium in your cell, which is obviously not a cheap material by any standard.
0:51
Unidentified speaker: Hello, uh, good morning.
0:53
Unidentified speaker: Welcome to the Rockstock Channel.
0:55
Unidentified speaker: It's Wednesday, the 28th of October, and I'm delighted to welcome Max Reed, who's head of CRU's battery costs team, uh, to the show for what promises to be a really interesting conversation today.
1:07
Unidentified speaker: Uh, before we start, I should note that this conversation is for educational purposes only, and nothing we discuss on this call should be construed as investment advice.
1:17
Unidentified speaker: And I'd also like to thank our sponsor, Clean Elements, an investor group focused on providing growth capital for critical minerals developers in the energy transition.
1:27
Unidentified speaker: Clean Elements has invested over $30 million to date and is currently the largest shareholder of two brine projects in Argentina.
1:34
Unidentified speaker: Before we start, I'd like to flag CRU's Critical Minerals and Energy Security seminar, which will take place in Washington, DC on the 1st of December.
1:44
Unidentified speaker: There's some going to be some great speakers there, including Max and also Simon Price, who's also a fascinating guy to listen to.
1:51
Unidentified speaker: So I'd highly recommend it.
1:53
Unidentified speaker: And we'll put a link into the show notes.
1:55
Unidentified speaker: So, Max, uh, welcome to the show.
1:58
Unidentified speaker: Thanks very much for joining us today.
2:00
Unidentified speaker: Um, for our listeners, could you just give a quick introduction to CRU?
2:04
Unidentified speaker: Uh, talk a little bit about what your team does, and sort of give a quick background to yourself as well.
2:11
Unidentified speaker: Um, thanks, Matt.
2:12
Unidentified speaker: So, CRU is a commodity research uh unit started in 1969 in mainly copper, but diversified into steel and aluminium.
2:22
Unidentified speaker: Um, so you know, quite hefty beasts in terms of the commodity markets.
2:26
Unidentified speaker: And then about 10 or so years ago, really started into the battery space.
2:31
Unidentified speaker: Um, so covering obviously the metals markets, and acquired Xawatt three years ago to cover the downstream side, so solar energy storage as well.
2:40
Unidentified speaker: Um, so as a company now we cover across the main metals, fertilizers, and now clean technology, so pretty well suited.
2:48
Unidentified speaker: And for my role in it, I joined 18 months ago to lead the technology and cost research at COU.
2:54
Unidentified speaker: So I started my career as a battery scientist um before moving into um coverage around the battery supply chain.
3:02
Unidentified speaker: Um, and as I say, join join crew just to cover the the tech and cost side given my um my background.
3:09
Unidentified speaker: Um so yeah, fantastic uh to be on the on the on the show and looking forward to to the questions.
3:15
Unidentified speaker: Great.
3:15
Unidentified speaker: Well, hopefully I won't disappoint.
3:17
Unidentified speaker: Um I guess let's start off with with this one.
3:21
Unidentified speaker: Uh, one of the things I've seen you post on recently is this LMR technology that Ford and GM and LG are developing.
3:28
Unidentified speaker: Um you put some quite interesting modeling in your note to suggest that in the US context that the technology could actually compete on costs with LFP.
3:39
Unidentified speaker: Um can you tell us a little bit about that and also suggest how far out that that tech realistically is?
3:46
Unidentified speaker: Um sure.
3:47
Unidentified speaker: So LMR is a chemistry that I think I've been banging on about or at least championing for quite a few years.
3:54
Unidentified speaker: It was uh first touted, I think Tesla or VW, kind of back in the day, the 2021 period, when prices went went skyward, around how we can reduce costs whilst maintaining a good enough energy density and good enough performance.
4:11
Unidentified speaker: And LMR really suits that.
4:13
Unidentified speaker: So it's a lithium-rich and more importantly, manganese-rich chemistry.
4:17
Unidentified speaker: So you're reducing your nickel content um significantly, replacing with obviously much more affordable manganese um and um maintains a good enough energy density.
4:30
Unidentified speaker: So it is a tricky chemistry um because of the high manganese content, you get manganese dissolution and a short cycle life.
4:38
Unidentified speaker: I mean, that's the primary difficulty with it.
4:41
Unidentified speaker: But because it is a low uh material cost and a high energy density, it means your cell costs can be competitive with LFP.
4:49
Unidentified speaker: Now, this is mainly for regions like the US or markets like the US, where they're relatively high cost in terms of capex, labour, um and that.
5:00
Unidentified speaker: So maintaining a high energy density is really critical to reducing costs.
5:05
Unidentified speaker: So our modeling shows um that you've mentioned um so switching to LFP is actually not really as um, I suppose, affordable as you would have thought, that the same as what's happening in China, primarily because you're only getting maybe 400 watt hours per litre out of an LFP cell and 600 out of LMR, and even higher for the you know, the high nickel NMCs.
5:28
Unidentified speaker: So, in terms of your throughput through a gigafactory, you're getting much more gigawatt hours out of these nickel chemistries than than LFP, which means that your high capex costs and high labour rates in the US are effectively intensified by LFP, so potentially 50% higher for those chemistries.
5:48
Unidentified speaker: So when you look at this on a sort of full cost of goods sold basis for batteries, you're actually getting LFP basically the same cost as your high nickel NMCs.
5:58
Unidentified speaker: Um and with LMR, because of that savings on the material side, you're maybe saving $10 or so per kilowatt hour versus those those two other chemistries.
6:08
Unidentified speaker: So so your contention is that because the labour cost and operating cost in the US is so high, it actually makes more sense to make higher energy density batteries in the US.
6:20
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, um precisely.
6:22
Unidentified speaker: Whilst also maintaining you um a lower materials cost is key to that.
6:27
Unidentified speaker: I mean, we'll we'll probably touch on it around solid state, but there's a lot of misnomers around or myths around solid state and and the cost competitiveness of that.
6:36
Unidentified speaker: But certainly for LMR, you know, it it is really what maybe not the holy grail, but it's something more towards that I see as um you know good enough to power EVs for 500 kilometers range plus um than we know the US needs you know long long range cars um for for electrified products to really compete.
6:58
Unidentified speaker: Um and so LMR you know suits suits both both worlds in that sense.
7:02
Unidentified speaker: And and the um manganese content of of those cells, what what is the what could be the raw material?
7:09
Unidentified speaker: I mean, do we need to use high purity HP MSM like we use in China for NMC, or do we need could we get away with HPEM or or could we get lower lower quality manganese?
7:21
Unidentified speaker: Does it need to be battery-grade manganese or or could it be lower quality?
7:26
Unidentified speaker: Well, it's an interesting question because so I I suppose I didn't touch on it in terms of the commercialization of it, and it's still, you know, um so Ultium is the I suppose the champion for the cat tech, and they're really starting to roll out pilot um sales this year, in a view for two years' time to roll out um mass production scale.
7:46
Unidentified speaker: There's a lot of uncertainty still on the exact process that they will use to produce LMR, so whether it's LG Chem feeding into Ultium in Tennessee or uh um or it's the Postco's come out with LMR, EcoPro, kind of all the Korean CAM producers have certainly some interest in LMR tech, and they can use different techniques.
8:08
Unidentified speaker: So, one is looking at using metal um for your metal constituents, so nickel manganese as well.
8:14
Unidentified speaker: So obviously that's different to your um high purity um MSM.
8:19
Unidentified speaker: Um, in general, I would say you'd need really high quality uh manganese because of that cycle life issue that I mentioned before.
8:27
Unidentified speaker: You don't want um um some impurities to get in the way of your cathode structure and create a you know a doorway for manganese to leak out into electrolyte.
8:37
Unidentified speaker: So you know, purity really is key.
8:40
Unidentified speaker: And something that I looked at was a patent that I think LG Energy Solution or maybe LG Chem came out with around spray drying cathode, so you get really small particle sizes, and this might be another view to um yeah, improving the performance, and I think that used like nitrates um as the metal um feedstock.
9:00
Unidentified speaker: So, yeah, there's a real mix that it could be.
9:03
Unidentified speaker: Um so we kind of had to wait until the material is produced on a kiloton scale to really see what is the predominant um um feedstock route.
9:11
Unidentified speaker: Okay, so potentially very interesting news for high purity manganese um producers and developers.
9:16
Unidentified speaker: Okay, and and and can I assume then that you would sort of take that across to Europe as well and assume that LMR might be a better technology for the European market to focus on because of the high costs?
9:28
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, it's certainly an interesting one.
9:30
Unidentified speaker: Um on paper, yes.
9:32
Unidentified speaker: I mean, obviously, Europe is a slightly different market.
9:35
Unidentified speaker: Your probably more affordable batteries are most likely going to be met by imports from China or by Chinese producers in the market.
9:43
Unidentified speaker: So that does free up a bit more space for the premium um EVs to be met by local high-nickel content um batteries.
9:52
Unidentified speaker: So it's less of an issue to really look at affordability in the EV space because that is likely to be met by by LFP in China.
10:00
Unidentified speaker: But if the you know European startups who are kind of European operated um can get a hold of LMR tech, then obviously it could see an increase in market share for the likes of FECO, ACC, and uh you know Powerco and all those other brands that are emerging in the space.
10:19
Unidentified speaker: So it's similar, yeah, similar opportunity um in that space, but obviously a different market.
10:24
Unidentified speaker: Okay.
10:25
Unidentified speaker: Um slight, I mean you've slightly answered this question already, but but I'm just gonna go ahead, forge ahead and ask it.
10:32
Unidentified speaker: So um for now, I think that a lot of cell manufacturers outside China seem to be pivoting to LFP.
10:39
Unidentified speaker: Um do you think that potentially they could be dropping millions of dollars, potentially billions of dollars, into the wrong chemistry um in seeking to develop LFP outside China?
10:53
Unidentified speaker: Um, well, I mean, everything I've talked about really now has um so up until now really been on the EV market.
10:59
Unidentified speaker: But I mean LFP is really going to win out in the energy storage space, which yeah, as as you and your listeners will know, is the really booming market this year.
11:08
Unidentified speaker: Um so EV sales have slightly plateaued, particularly in China.
11:12
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, Europe's seen some some strong growth in the couple of uh months prior to this, and obviously North America is has has flatlined or declined.
11:20
Unidentified speaker: But energy storage, certainly production and installations have really boomed, and LFP is going to be the dominant chemistry in that for the foreseeable future.
11:29
Unidentified speaker: I mean sort of 10 years time as well.
11:32
Unidentified speaker: This is primarily from the cycle life.
11:35
Unidentified speaker: So you get your um yeah, you get your ben uh your benefits in terms of the economic side of a project if you're you're storing energy for 20 years or so and maintaining a high capacity.
11:48
Unidentified speaker: And LFP can do that.
11:49
Unidentified speaker: You can have your 10,000 cycles as a cycle life, whereas you can't with your nickel-based chemistries, your LMRs, your your NMCs.
11:58
Unidentified speaker: So for that reason, it's certainly not a um a mistake to shift to LFP that you know we've seen the Koreans and others do in in the US and also in in Europe um to meet that market.
12:10
Unidentified speaker: The question is really around the EV side for LFP, what will win out?
12:14
Unidentified speaker: And obviously, we've seen divergent strategies between even GM and Ford in the US for for its EV business.
12:20
Unidentified speaker: So um yeah, LFP is still going to have its place.
12:24
Unidentified speaker: Okay, I'm gonna come back to LFP and energy storage in a minute, um, but I like to just talk a little bit about the tariff environment in the US.
12:34
Unidentified speaker: Um obviously we've we've seen the US bring in quite substantial tariffs along the battery supply chain.
12:42
Unidentified speaker: Um, do you think that there's a danger that that tariff environment is simply creating a Southeast Asian cell manufacturing industry rather than a US one?
12:52
Unidentified speaker: And I sort of asked this with the view that uh obviously we've seen a huge increase in battery projects, uh, mostly Chinese joint ventures in Indonesia, Thailand, Malaysia.
13:02
Unidentified speaker: Uh we're seeing Chinese graphite being uh white-label uh out of Indonesia um to get around the tariff environment.
13:11
Unidentified speaker: So, so you know, is it is are we seeing tariffs sort of backfiring here?
13:17
Unidentified speaker: I mean, it's certainly we are going to see a lot of growth in output from from the Southeast Asia region, um, but we've already, I suppose, counter to that, you know, we've seen the Korean LFP supply chain really ramp up um this year in terms of the off-take agreements to SK and Samsung, obviously LG taking LFP cathode from from Indonesia as well.
13:40
Unidentified speaker: Um, so there is a strong opportunity there to feed into the US market, but they are now going to be competing with kind of integrated supply chains for for the Korean industry.
13:51
Unidentified speaker: So by no means will it kind of overhaul um total supply for the US market.
13:57
Unidentified speaker: And also, you know, Southeast Asian producers, or at least producers operating in the Southeast Asian region, are up against the technology export restrictions that China's putting in place as well.
14:09
Unidentified speaker: So, in terms of producing anode, cathode material and cells, effectively these chemistries and technologies will be potentially a generation behind what's being produced in China.
14:22
Unidentified speaker: Um, and so you know, at least we think that is going to keep um you know rapid growth or at least an overhaul of the market at bay um for that side.
14:32
Unidentified speaker: You know, obviously China doesn't want to lose let its lead um lose its lead in in the battery space by letting you know joint ventures and therefore technology kind of slippage occur in the Southeast Asia region.
14:46
Unidentified speaker: So potentially we'll see you know third gen NFP meet some of the uh energy storage demand in the US and particularly you know export to the rest of the world as as well.
14:56
Unidentified speaker: You know, we're seeing a lot of um good adoption rates in in India, Latin America, at Africa for EVs and energy storage, which can be met by um kind of these third gen products out of Southeast Asia.
15:10
Unidentified speaker: But otherwise, you know, it's it's certainly becoming an increasingly competitive space on the supply side of batteries outside of China, which is obviously very interesting.
15:21
Unidentified speaker: Okay.
15:21
Unidentified speaker: Um I guess we have to talk about the EU's minimum recycled content mandate for cells.
15:28
Unidentified speaker: Um I guess the first question is is this even achievable?
15:32
Unidentified speaker: Uh and if it is enforced, how much could it potentially increase European cell manufacturing costs, do you think?
15:40
Unidentified speaker: We see it, it it certainly is achievable in terms of the amount of um yeah, scrap batteries turned into black mass that will be available on the market, even within Europe.
15:52
Unidentified speaker: I mean, that's avoiding kind of the elephant in the room, which is there's no sort of processing capacity to turn it into battery chemicals and you know your electrode-active materials.
16:03
Unidentified speaker: So um, you know, assuming that gets solved, which is obviously not going to uh be as easy as that.
16:09
Unidentified speaker: There in theory should be enough material for that.
16:13
Unidentified speaker: Um so um this is primarily because the regulations put in quite I suppose quite low or achievable rates, so 6% for lithium and and nickel in 2031, so five years away from now, um, and 16% for cobalt, which is obviously being you know thrifted out of chemistries um for for now.
16:33
Unidentified speaker: So certainly is achievable.
16:36
Unidentified speaker: Um the impact on a cell cost is not as high as you would have thought.
16:41
Unidentified speaker: So we've done a lot of work on LFP recycling in particular in the past year or so, because it's you know a major topic for the European um region.
16:50
Unidentified speaker: And we see that because of that 6% lithium content as the target, actually, even if you're paying your recycler, um you're basically paying them to break even and operate at a certain margin, that impact on a newly installed EV cell in 2031 is only going to be about one or two dollars per kilowatt hour on a cell cost.
17:12
Unidentified speaker: Um, and at that point, we we see that being beneficial for the OEMs to to kind of sink that cost into their margins uh to achieve that target.
17:22
Unidentified speaker: Um so uh I I did mention around obviously the logistics of um you're procuring recycled content, and actually we do see that it's going to incentivize you know even more, I suppose, uh precursor sourcing from China, because obviously you know the industry is so much more mature, the access to scrap is is far larger, and the localization rules don't require precursor to be you know produced in in the union um as of now.
17:52
Unidentified speaker: So we could see you know a shift to to kind of more concentration on on PCAM sourcing from from China, um, and those will be relatively low cost as well, so so actually not too much of an impact on cell costs that we that we see.
18:06
Unidentified speaker: Okay.
18:07
Unidentified speaker: And and do you think these moves to localize the supply chains in in Europe and the US are actually going to make batteries more expensive?
18:15
Unidentified speaker: And and and and at what stage do you think they they actually start to undermine the the climate targets that are in place?
18:22
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, it's uh it's certainly a fascinating one because obviously you um battery costs in Europe are are certainly larger than China.
18:31
Unidentified speaker: And I mentioned at the at the top, there's really not many trade barriers against importing sales and batteries from China as of now.
18:39
Unidentified speaker: Obviously, there are localization rules.
18:41
Unidentified speaker: It's not a strict mandate, it's certainly for EVs to access some public um um subsidies um in the EV space, so it's not the whole market either.
18:54
Unidentified speaker: If you are to localize completely in terms of cathode and cell production, you're probably looking at $80 to $90 a kilowatt hour in today's money versus an imported cell price of maybe $20, $30 lower than that, um, maybe similar on the Euro basis.
19:10
Unidentified speaker: So it would increase um your battery cost, whether that's offset by whatever subsidies are available in that time frame.
19:18
Unidentified speaker: Um that's obviously up to the policymakers to see that.
19:22
Unidentified speaker: We've already seen a lot of public money sunk into these gigafactories in Europe to get them to a state where they should be economical in terms of steady state production.
19:34
Unidentified speaker: Um, but yeah, there's obviously no going around that it will be a higher sell cost.
19:39
Unidentified speaker: But the theory is that that will be offset by um yeah, the public subsidies available.
19:44
Unidentified speaker: So your end user price should be the same, which is what we've seen in the US with the tax credits.
19:49
Unidentified speaker: You know, cell production and localization is worth $35 a kilowatt hour, which is yeah, huge, it's a third of sell cost.
19:57
Unidentified speaker: It's interesting that one company, one country's tax credits are another country's subsidies.
20:02
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, yeah.
20:04
Unidentified speaker: No, it's uh yeah, it obviously has needed a lot of state um sort of handholding uh to say the least to get the the the industry you know kicked off.
20:14
Unidentified speaker: So um and and if we take that those sort of calculations to the US, um how um how competitive realistically can the US industry be with China?
20:28
Unidentified speaker: I mean with those tax credits, then very competitive.
20:31
Unidentified speaker: You know, we see landed prices for sales to be cheaper from sourcing locally, then imported from China.
20:37
Unidentified speaker: We make it a lot of people.
20:38
Unidentified speaker: That's including tariffs, yeah.
20:40
Unidentified speaker: Yes, which is the current tariff regime, which is up to uh maybe the 38 or so percentage, depending on if it's EV or ESS sales.
20:49
Unidentified speaker: Um but actually the current lowest source price for sales in the US is Southeast Asia that you went mentioned before.
20:58
Unidentified speaker: Um so so that's still beneficial even with the tax credits um for local production.
21:04
Unidentified speaker: But certainly, you know, those tax credits have helped shift towards localization, which as I say, we've seen with with shifting to LFP and the Korean LFP supply chain reaching new levels of maturity this year and and next year uh because of that.
21:20
Unidentified speaker: Okay.
21:21
Unidentified speaker: Um we said we would talk about it earlier, so so uh let's get on to uh the big white elephant in the room, which is sodium iron.
21:29
Unidentified speaker: Um you guys published a really interesting article recently that suggests that data centers could actually provide the first commercially viable market for sodium iron in the West.
21:39
Unidentified speaker: Uh, can you talk a little bit about that article before we sort of go on and uh address some of the key areas?
21:45
Unidentified speaker: Sure.
21:45
Unidentified speaker: It's uh I mean, so so my research when I was an academia actually started off in sodium iron.
21:51
Unidentified speaker: So it's been uh I suppose a pet um chemistry of mine for quite some time now.
21:58
Unidentified speaker: And I feel like I do give off quite bearish sentiment, even though actually for CIU we're quite bullish on sodium iron as you know absolute demand in in gigawatt hours terms.
22:09
Unidentified speaker: But um I as I say I think there's a lot of myths around the technology that it can replace LFP and lithiumine chemistries.
22:17
Unidentified speaker: And so this piece that we we published um recently is looking into effectively how sodium mine is going to power applications that's difficult to power with lithium ion technologies.
22:28
Unidentified speaker: So data centers is one where, particularly where AI is involved, where you get a requirement for really high power um consumption in very uh kind of bitty um um sort of frequencies uh um through through um through even a day or an hour.
22:46
Unidentified speaker: And and so you get really rapidly changing kind of power demand in from your batteries, which sodium iron is better to handle than LFP because you get these kind of low density but really high kind of um porosity and and vacancy materials, which means your sodium ions can go in and out rapidly without really disrupting the uh structure.
23:09
Unidentified speaker: So when you're looking at um an AI data center, you might get maybe 5-10% of the total storage capacity being sodium ion, but in terms of the power consumption, it's meeting maybe a third or higher of the actual power, so the electrons going in and out of that um project because of this kind of um short-term high frequency power consumption uh requirement for that.
23:32
Unidentified speaker: And also, you know, sodium ion is safer.
23:34
Unidentified speaker: So when you're getting something that is really project critical, like having kind of in-server or in-rack batteries, you know, you're really going to need a safe system or a safe technology.
23:46
Unidentified speaker: And the third aspect is you know, it's a project or a sector that is relatively agnostic to costs.
23:54
Unidentified speaker: And something that we see with sodium ion is that yes, you get you know, maybe cheaper cathode materials because you don't have lithium in it, so you're saving you know $3 a kilowatt hour on the cathode level.
24:05
Unidentified speaker: But on a cell level, you're really you know getting much higher costs of your foils, your separators, your casing because of the low energy density and on the anode side.
24:15
Unidentified speaker: And then this is exacerbated when you get to the system level.
24:19
Unidentified speaker: So we see sodium ion as a system level cost being higher than LFP for the next five years.
24:25
Unidentified speaker: But for things like data centers, as I say, cost agnostic, you're going to be able to afford your 10% higher cost or so for a battery for that long cycle life, high safety and high power um capability for it.
24:40
Unidentified speaker: So you know it's a it's a application that really suits sodium ion, but it's certainly not replacing LFP, and I say only 10% or so of the actual installed capacity at the system at the project level.
24:51
Unidentified speaker: I mean, I I guess the big question is the the the bulk of the data center build-out is going out on the next uh in the in the next four or five years.
24:59
Unidentified speaker: Um there's very few Western manufacturers of sodium iron currently, so so realistically, is that going to be able to take market share um given that you'd be relying on Chinese batteries primarily?
25:14
Unidentified speaker: Yes.
25:14
Unidentified speaker: Well, uh Chinese batteries and certainly at least Chinese materials.
25:18
Unidentified speaker: So the yeah, the question around the meat stream that um I think hopefully everyone's mostly aware of is that this bottleneck in the battery supply chain is turning your chemicals into active materials, and that's the technical challenge as well as the you know the the the um kind of volume and scale challenge as well.
25:37
Unidentified speaker: And sodium iron is actually more concentrated in China than lithium ion at the moment.
25:42
Unidentified speaker: So if you're looking to switch to sodium iron, you're s you're kind of shifting to a supply chain that is even more reliant on you know China for now.
25:50
Unidentified speaker: So um you're right, it is um at the moment, I mean, most companies are just re-badging Chinese cells and calling it um something else because of because of that uh you know lack of production capacity outside of China.
26:05
Unidentified speaker: So probably good news for Chinese data centres, but not quite such good news for US data centres.
26:10
Unidentified speaker: Well, I mean, until your tariffs um I don't believe are as high for sodomine at the moment as for a lithium mine, which is you know maybe a loophole in the regulatory space that potentially might be closed if if it becomes significant.
26:24
Unidentified speaker: So we have seen you know growing interest in sodomine in in the US for data centers.
26:30
Unidentified speaker: Also, you know, as I say, it's a cost agnostic space, so tariffs are not going to be you know a make or break for your procurement strategy.
26:38
Unidentified speaker: Um, so there is opportunity for soda mine in that, particularly with safety.
26:43
Unidentified speaker: And we've seen you know a few residential battery developers also look at sodium mine because of the safety aspect as well, and cycle life.
26:51
Unidentified speaker: So it has opportunities there, as uh as I say, in kind of the cost agnostic spaces, but these markets are you know smaller than utility scale energy storage, which is going to be the you know the dominant one and the LFP um dominated one as well.
27:06
Unidentified speaker: And it and is the duration of a sodium ion cell comparable to lithium ion?
27:11
Unidentified speaker: I mean, lithium ion you've got like a two-hour duration.
27:13
Unidentified speaker: Is it is sodium ion comparable to that?
27:15
Unidentified speaker: Um certainly comparable.
27:17
Unidentified speaker: I mean, there's no there's no stark differences.
27:20
Unidentified speaker: I mean, lithium ion is going to four, even there's some eight-hour cells on the market now.
27:26
Unidentified speaker: Um, and sodium ion can do the same.
27:29
Unidentified speaker: Um, but probably up to eight hours is going to be the limit.
27:32
Unidentified speaker: There's kind of your economics becomes more unfeasible if you're getting to you know 10, 16 hours for for using any of lithium or sodium.
27:40
Unidentified speaker: So that's not going to be uh you know a uh anything to dispute between the two uh technologies.
27:47
Unidentified speaker: Okay.
27:47
Unidentified speaker: And and I mean you touched on it earlier, but can we sort of drill into it in a little bit more detail?
27:53
Unidentified speaker: Uh we obviously hear a lot from people who don't really know what's going on in the market that sodium iron is going to replace lithium ion because it's so much cheaper to produce.
28:01
Unidentified speaker: Um you touched on the higher costs um inherent in sodium iron earlier, but can you just sort of go into them in a little bit more detail, words of one syllable, so that that our listeners can understand what's actually involved in that?
28:16
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, so as I've mentioned, so sodium ion cathodes are maybe you know three or three to five dollars per kilowatt hour cheaper than LFP, so that's the saving that you get.
28:27
Unidentified speaker: Um, but in terms of a cell level, if you're getting um, so for for LFP, maybe $30 to $40 per kilowatt hour is your passive materials and your manufacturing costs, so your plastic separators, your casing, and then obviously all the throughput through a gigafactory.
28:44
Unidentified speaker: And this is where sodium mine really falls down.
28:46
Unidentified speaker: So because your energy density is about 250 watt hours per litre versus LFP's 400, you're effectively getting you know 50% um or sorry, two-thirds the throughput um through a gigafactory, so 50% higher manufacturing costs.
29:03
Unidentified speaker: So that already makes up for that saving at the cathode level, despite uh sorry, not even touching on, then you need 50% more separator material per kilowatt hour, 50% more casing material per kilowatt hour, um, and even your anode material costs are higher per you know kilogram and per kilowatt hour than a graphite um anode for for LFP as well.
29:27
Unidentified speaker: So a lot of the market obviously focus on your cathode, it's the most interesting, I suppose, or you know, the most sexy material in in batteries, but your actual saving is is pretty small on a kilowatt hour basis, and then kind of the unsexy materials, your your separators, your electrolytes, etc., you're just having to buy so much more volume of this for your gigafactory that it really offsets that cost saving.
29:52
Unidentified speaker: So we do see you know the cell cost parity being achieved in 2028 or so, depending on lithium prices.
29:58
Unidentified speaker: You know, this is something that obviously you um is relatively up in the air at the moment.
30:02
Unidentified speaker: I know next year's lithium prices uh is going to be quite an interesting space to look at.
30:07
Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
30:07
Unidentified speaker: So um the cost parity does depend on that slightly.
30:11
Unidentified speaker: Um but um at the system level, when you're looking at things like inverters and your containers for your energy storage, this is where you know the your cost disparity gets even even larger.
30:23
Unidentified speaker: So I mean your average sort of sodium ion sort of uh container is about a two megawatt hour unit, and now your average LFP is about five or six megawatt hour, is it?
30:33
Unidentified speaker: Well, we're seeing so our energy storage team tracks kind of all the latest generations in tech, and we see kind of the up end of sodium ion is actually about three, three and a half megawatt hours, and then some of the LFPs at six and a half, um, so around half the the capacity, which means for a certain project, you know, for a 100 megawatt-hour project, you need double the number of containers, and therefore you're doubling your installation costs, doubling your maintenance costs there as well.
31:01
Unidentified speaker: So there are all these, as I say, kind of underappreciated costs that go into uh your battery in a system, um, whereas everyone's focused on the cathode material, you know, it's these that really make or break your actual economics of a of a project.
31:16
Unidentified speaker: And you know, this is exactly what we look at as a company and advise our clients on.
31:22
Unidentified speaker: Okay.
31:22
Unidentified speaker: And and when you talked about the cathode, um, sorry, the anode, Freud didn't slip there.
31:27
Unidentified speaker: Uh you talked about the anode, um, hard carbon for sodium iron uh versus graphite for um lithium iron.
31:34
Unidentified speaker: Um, I think one of the big issues for me is the viability of building out a large hard carbon uh supply chain.
31:43
Unidentified speaker: Have you got any thoughts about you know how viable um that is and and what the costs involved uh with the manufacture of hard carbon are compared to sort of synthetic and natural raffi?
31:57
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, so uh for now, obviously I mentioned before it's China dominated as a supply chain.
32:03
Unidentified speaker: And they've largely been using biomass um uh uh from organic material that's kind of imported from Southeast Asia, so like coconut shell husks, which is you know, uh you wouldn't have thought that's a battery material, I suppose, when you're looking at a coconut tree.
32:17
Unidentified speaker: Um but the Chinese market is is shifting towards kind of coal-based feedstock sources, partly because your quality of animaterial or hard carbon is is slightly being compromised from from these coconut shell husk kind of sourced um roots.
32:35
Unidentified speaker: Um, and obviously China's got a you know a good market for coal already into its energy.
32:41
Unidentified speaker: Lots of access supply.
32:43
Unidentified speaker: Exactly.
32:44
Unidentified speaker: So that makes sense.
32:45
Unidentified speaker: And obviously, with you know huge volumes and huge scale in terms of refining kind of carbon-based materials to anode material is where we see the market shifting.
32:56
Unidentified speaker: And at the moment we see anode prices at about seven or eight dollars per kilogram for hard carbon.
33:02
Unidentified speaker: You're obviously getting less of a voltage out of it and less of a capacity out of it than than you do for graphite for lithium ion.
33:09
Unidentified speaker: So your dollars per kilowatt hour is is slightly worse than that um on a on on a per capacity basis.
33:15
Unidentified speaker: Um so whereas whereas synthetic graphite for LFP is getting to four or five dollars, we've been um uh uh yeah, so so in terms of that competitiveness is is always going to be slightly higher, we expect, than lithium-ion added materials.
33:34
Unidentified speaker: Um but uh yeah, we see them the market moving towards that say coal-derived and basis.
33:40
Unidentified speaker: And this might be outside your bailiwick, and if it is, I apologise.
33:43
Unidentified speaker: But um one of the big game changers in lithium ion has been obviously the incorporation of um uh silicon in the graphite um anode over the last couple of years.
33:53
Unidentified speaker: Is that going to be viable um in sodium ion, or is that miles and miles out on the horizon, or is that not viable at all?
34:01
Unidentified speaker: I mean, that there's certainly companies looking at tin.
34:03
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, tin is another conversion anode um similar to silicon um that um is is viable with sodium.
34:11
Unidentified speaker: I've seen a few kind of uh low TRL or kind of academic studies into tin as an anode material.
34:18
Unidentified speaker: Certainly possible there.
34:20
Unidentified speaker: Um something that perhaps is maybe going to leapfrog that is the anode-free chemistry or technology or architecture.
34:27
Unidentified speaker: So Goshen high-tech, which is uh uh a leading cellmaker in in China, released a number of anode-free technologies this year this year, looking at things like drones and kind of these niche markets.
34:41
Unidentified speaker: It means you can compete on an energy density basis with LFP that uses graphite as an anode, so it's really interesting from that perspective.
34:50
Unidentified speaker: If they can you know really develop it and commercialise it, then anode-free could be a really viable chemistry for sodium iron.
34:59
Unidentified speaker: The difficulty is the cycle life that you you do get with anode-free technologies because you have to nucleate and grow an anode from nothing effectively, um, and that's quite difficult to have without huge external pressure applied to your cell, um, which then brings complexity into your design.
35:20
Unidentified speaker: Um, but you know, Goshen's looking at it, which is obviously a positive sign because they are you know operating at really large gigawatt hour scales in in their battery business.
35:30
Unidentified speaker: So I think that's potentially or has more of a potential than things like um yeah, tin tin anodes for sodium.
35:38
Unidentified speaker: Okay, okay.
35:40
Unidentified speaker: Um great.
35:41
Unidentified speaker: Um really interesting on sodium iron.
35:44
Unidentified speaker: Um let's move on to solid state very quickly.
35:47
Unidentified speaker: Um it's been about 10 years out for the last 15 years.
35:51
Unidentified speaker: Um you've suggested that solid state may never close the cost gap with lithium ion.
35:58
Unidentified speaker: So is the industry, um potenti particularly the EV industry and some of these other uh very downstream industries overestimating the potential commercial importance of solid state cells?
36:11
Unidentified speaker: I'd say historically, meaning for five years ago, certainly yes.
36:16
Unidentified speaker: Um, but now the realization that solid state really isn't going to compete with the current technologies for EVs or energy storage, I think is well understood.
36:27
Unidentified speaker: Um, but solid state, so solid state is always going to be more expensive on a picket order basis because you're using the same caffeine materials, you're using a more expensive electrolyte that has a much slower throughput in a gigafactory because you filling a you know a can with liquid is much easier and cheaper than you rolling out a solid film of ceramic material, and you're then pairing it with a high cost anode potentially, so lithium metal or silicon.
36:56
Unidentified speaker: Um, and actually another myth, I suppose, in the solid state business is that if you're using a lithium metal anode, a solid electrolyte, and a you know a typical cathode, you might get three times the amount of lithium in your cell than you do for a traditional liquid-based cell that's you're using in current EVs because you're obviously having a load more lithium at the anode side, your electrolyte is actually a higher lithium content than liquid electrolyte, and then you're using the same cathode.
37:25
Unidentified speaker: So you're getting huge abundance of lithium um in your cell, which is obviously not a not a cheap material by any standard.
37:33
Unidentified speaker: Um so that's one reason why the costs are going to be higher.
37:36
Unidentified speaker: And then the second reason is, as I say, the throughput through a gigafactory is so much slower.
37:40
Unidentified speaker: So it means your capex and your depreciation costs are that much higher, and things like labour and energy are much higher as well.
37:48
Unidentified speaker: So the realization that's not going to meet the EV market should be there.
37:52
Unidentified speaker: But the humanoid robot and kind of the physical AI market is really interesting.
37:56
Unidentified speaker: Space.
37:56
Unidentified speaker: We've seen Toyota recently come out with robots towards that.
38:00
Unidentified speaker: Samsung SDI are commercializing all solid state batteries, I think, next year or the second half next year, primarily looking at humanoid robots.
38:10
Unidentified speaker: So I think when we think about solid state, we really should be thinking about these small but really high value or high margin at least markets like um yeah, humanoid robots for use for solid state because you need the high energy density, the high safety for those types of applications.
38:29
Unidentified speaker: And you know, who knows what how big the humanoid robot market could be in 10, 20 years' time.
38:34
Unidentified speaker: We've released a study on it, but um I think obviously it's it's still so much uncertainty around um adoption of it.
38:41
Unidentified speaker: Okay, well, I think that's a fascinating perspective, uh, particularly you know as it um applies to EVs.
38:48
Unidentified speaker: I think uh there is still a you know a widespread uh expectation in the market that solid state will take over from lithium iron at some point in EVs, and um I think that's a really interesting perspective.
38:59
Unidentified speaker: So great.
39:01
Unidentified speaker: Okay, uh let's talk a little bit about costs and battery prices.
39:04
Unidentified speaker: I think one of the things that's put lithium iron on the map in the past 10 years has been this massive drop in sell and pack costs, which has made both EVs and ESS economic in a way that we'd never even envisage 10 years ago.
39:18
Unidentified speaker: Um obviously there's been an almost exponential drop in prices.
39:22
Unidentified speaker: So can these cost improvements continue, or are we practically at the end of the road in terms of cost improvements for lithium iron?
39:31
Unidentified speaker: Uh and if if that's the case, does that mean that future sell prices are going to be much more linked to raw material price cycles than they have been in the past?
39:42
Unidentified speaker: Um so sell costs really, as you say, have really dramatically come down, and we do see that the manufacturing side, or like the non-material costs, are reaching close to the floor that they can be.
39:55
Unidentified speaker: So if we're thinking about say labour and energy costs, so a lot of the Chinese gigafactories are getting to kind of net zeros, so having their own renewable grids associated with that, which is really reduced energy prices, you're getting really high automation.
40:09
Unidentified speaker: So your work is in your gigafactory instead of you know thousands, you're getting only hundreds required.
40:16
Unidentified speaker: Uh, and this you partially offset the uh the rising wage costs in China, that is actually also, I think, underappreciated or underreported for now.
40:26
Unidentified speaker: So, in terms of the manufacturing costs, yeah, we see really that closing in on the floor, which then obviously means that the material side is really going to have a much greater impact on your actual sell costs.
40:38
Unidentified speaker: So, what we've seen this year, where certainly lithium prices have doubled um for the average of this year, that has resulted in the average sell cost being higher in 2026 than 2025.
40:50
Unidentified speaker: And we expect the same, you know, around similar prices or sort of certainly costs to sustain to next year, which is effectively reversing that really dramatic decline that we've seen for the past 20 years, you know, aside from obviously the previous kind of price cycle in the 2022-2023 period, um, that we might expect to see um in the future as well.
41:12
Unidentified speaker: So the simple answer is yes, we will see cell costs closely linked to raw material prices from that, particularly obviously it's baked into a lot of the you know the the the the um off-take price um for your cell as well.
41:28
Unidentified speaker: And I mean for China at the other cost is obviously depreciation, and we're seeing that CapEx has got to you know close to $20 million per gigawatt hour, which is about five times cheaper than it was maybe five years ago.
41:41
Unidentified speaker: And this is really where you know Western gigafactories have got a lot of um space to make up, they're still around the $100 or $80 million per gigawatt hour basis for kind of new gigafactories, so they're far behind what CATL is achieving um in China.
41:58
Unidentified speaker: Um, so so that's where a lot of cost can be made um outside of China, uh we see.
42:04
Unidentified speaker: Okay.
42:04
Unidentified speaker: And obviously, one of the other areas where we've we've saved a lot of money in terms of costs is new cathode and anode technologies um around manufacturing, but also within um the cathodes and anodes themselves.
42:17
Unidentified speaker: Are you monitoring any uh really interesting techs coming through at the moment that could further improve the economics of uh lithium-ion cells?
42:26
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, so so part of part of my team's role is is looking at these exact things, emerging chemistries and emerging applications.
42:34
Unidentified speaker: And I think when we think of things like data centers, which have uh are emerging uh and kind of nascent, um, so the high power capability that I talked about with sodium ion can actually be met by a new anode material, or maybe it's not new anymore, but the niobium titanates or niobium-based anodes, which are really safe, really high cycle life, and really high power capability that are paired with an LFP or a nickel-based cathode, is emerging.
43:02
Unidentified speaker: So in the UK, you've got Echion and Niobolt who are really um developing this technology.
43:10
Unidentified speaker: And again, this is where I see actually competition for sodium ion um in that space.
43:14
Unidentified speaker: I think not exactly a common material though, not common, but there's certainly enough coming out of Brazil for for you know gigawatt hour level cell production.
43:24
Unidentified speaker: So, and as I say, it's if it's cost agnostic, then that's not so much of an issue.
43:29
Unidentified speaker: So we've modeled some cell costs, and you know, it's it's above $100 per kilowatt hour, so it's not competitive with EV cells, but it could be really useful for something like data centers.
43:42
Unidentified speaker: Um for something that really could impact the market is sulfur cathodes.
43:46
Unidentified speaker: I think we've not really well the market's really stopped talking about it for some time, but there's been some really interesting development from um I think Julyan is the company where they're looking at um like a carbon-coated or encapsulated sulfur, and this is where your cathode costs are really, really low.
44:05
Unidentified speaker: So even though you might have to use you know new additives to get over cycle life issues, we see that that could really disrupt the EV space, and obviously sulfur is really abundant.
44:15
Unidentified speaker: Um using a lithium metal anode potentially or a silicon anode, so slightly higher costs on the anode side, but at a cell level, this is really interesting.
44:25
Unidentified speaker: So um we we we not hopefully but expecting that if it were to be commercialized and scaled, it really could be disruptive.
44:37
Unidentified speaker: So those are the kind of the two active materials that that um you know are quite interesting um for now.
44:43
Unidentified speaker: I think something that potentially we're at the forefront of looking at is maybe a potential resurgence for LMO, kind of this historic chemistry.
44:53
Unidentified speaker: And this has been commercialized already in the MG4 from um uh SAIC.
45:00
Unidentified speaker: We and it's been enabled by the use of semi-solid um technology.
45:05
Unidentified speaker: So you're getting um you know a longer cycle life LMO, it's about the same price as LFP on a dollars per kilogram basis.
45:14
Unidentified speaker: You've got a higher voltage than LFP, but a slightly lower capacity, so it's similar on a per kilowatt hour basis, and you can get some better um power capability out of it.
45:24
Unidentified speaker: You can get thicker cathodes, so it can be cheaper than LFP on the cell cost, if your semizar electrolyte can be cheap.
45:32
Unidentified speaker: And we've seen so Qingtau Energy um is the startup in China that's commercialized this for the MG4, but we've even sept, um, which is a larger sort of tier one, tier two cell producer, has started talking about this in its financial filings.
45:50
Unidentified speaker: Um, and it can be a high throughput um um technology that um you can basically treat it like a liquid electrolyte, so pump it into a cell and then cure it after cells being produced.
46:03
Unidentified speaker: So I think this could be a really interesting space as well.
46:06
Unidentified speaker: So potentially uh you the resurgence of LMO.
46:09
Unidentified speaker: Okay, that's interesting, because I thought that had gone to the scrap heap of history.
46:13
Unidentified speaker: So had everyone.
46:14
Unidentified speaker: But uh yeah.
46:15
Unidentified speaker: Okay.
46:15
Unidentified speaker: Uh we're keeping a close eye on it.
46:18
Unidentified speaker: Okay, and and and just to finish up, um, are there any areas of the industry at the moment where you think that capital is being stupidly misallocated?
46:26
Unidentified speaker: If it was you, you wouldn't touch them with a barge pole.
46:29
Unidentified speaker: Stupidly is obviously a very strong term.
46:32
Unidentified speaker: Strong word.
46:33
Unidentified speaker: And but NGO would use it for something like the defence industry.
46:37
Unidentified speaker: It is it is all the rage these days, but in terms of absolute volumes, it is really small.
46:42
Unidentified speaker: Um, so you can meet and and also I'm thinking about kind of the new the startups or the new entrants to the space who are looking at the defence sector.
46:52
Unidentified speaker: You obviously there's a lot of conflict happening at the moment in the world, which is uh, and it's a space that is becoming rapidly electrified.
47:00
Unidentified speaker: So not just drones, but also everything in your military bases, your your vehicles, all now requiring you know electric uh electrification.
47:08
Unidentified speaker: So huge opportunity in theory, but in terms of absolute procurement volumes, it's not even really reaching the gigawatt hour level for the DOW in the US.
47:18
Unidentified speaker: I think they released a study it's only a couple of hundred megawatt hours that that that they require, and it's still mostly lead-acid batteries for their for their vehicles.
47:26
Unidentified speaker: So that can be turned you LFP and your you know compliance supply chains that that meet NDAA um regulations.
47:34
Unidentified speaker: But really, for most of this, it could be met just by contract manufacturing kind of current gigafactories in Korea or so that kind of have you know low utilization rates.
47:45
Unidentified speaker: So if you're looking at starting up and trying to try to supply into this space, I think it's already really competitive.
47:53
Unidentified speaker: Um, and a lot of like the silicon anode or the solid state guys who were looking at the EV space five years ago now have already matured to a level that they can meet um defense.
48:03
Unidentified speaker: So it's yeah, not great news for new entrants.
48:06
Unidentified speaker: Um so certainly that's one.
48:08
Unidentified speaker: And then the other one, which I think is really important to touch upon, is anyone developing like brand new materials or even brand new supply chains.
48:15
Unidentified speaker: So, as part of our work, we've really seen that these guys have struggled um to qualify materials with your EV cell or ESS Cell producers because your qualification timelines are so long, you know, a couple of years at least, where they need up to kiloton volumes.
48:34
Unidentified speaker: And as a new entrant to the space, you're really going to burn through cash, trying to scale up through pilot plants, so kilogram to ton scale, and then ton to kiloton.
48:44
Unidentified speaker: And then you really need to be incredibly kind of a step-changing cost saving or performance improvement for these before for your customers to really want to choose your material.
48:56
Unidentified speaker: So, even with LFP, you know, we've seen some new LFP cathode producers really struggle to get offtake with kind of the major producers because they're using different feedstock materials.
49:06
Unidentified speaker: That has changed your performance and even your I don't know, so even like your performance on a coating level for your cathode materials.
49:15
Unidentified speaker: And for these guys who are taking you know tens to hundreds of kilotons material, there's no incentive for them to take a couple of kilotons from a new entrant to the space.
49:24
Unidentified speaker: They'd rather take a hundred kilotons from a you know a new Korean cafe producer who can supply those volumes.
49:32
Unidentified speaker: So I think there's certainly a lot of expectation that if you're producing a brand new material, um, and there are you know new cafe materials coming out, like convergent materials like sulfur, that you could you displace the whole market.
49:47
Unidentified speaker: Um, but as I say, the qualification timelines are so lengthy and so costly that it's a real difficult and a challenging space to get into.
49:56
Unidentified speaker: So I wouldn't bank on it.
49:57
Unidentified speaker: So things like data centers, humanoid raybots, these are really emerging, high margin, really high opportunity spaces to feed into.
50:05
Unidentified speaker: So I'd maybe look at these spaces more so than defence or the EV space.
50:10
Unidentified speaker: Okay, that's brilliant.
50:11
Unidentified speaker: Um, Max, thanks very much indeed.
50:14
Unidentified speaker: Uh fascinating call.
50:16
Unidentified speaker: Um, if people want to follow your work or or um access your work or subscribe to it, hopefully uh through CIU, what should what should they do?
50:25
Unidentified speaker: Well, uh certainly reach out to us at our company website or you know approach me on LinkedIn, happy to to to set up a call.
50:33
Unidentified speaker: As I say, our our work at CIU kind of spans on the whole battery value chain from you know typical commodity research analysis into metals markets, lithium, nickel, cobalt, through to the downstream side, so solar, energy storage, and then my work in technology and costs.
50:50
Unidentified speaker: So something in particular we're looking at is you know all these new supply chains in Southeast Asia, Morocco, and how affordable cathode anodomaterials coming out of these regions are going to be.
51:01
Unidentified speaker: Um, and this is something that that we put data and and analysis to you.
51:06
Unidentified speaker: So reach us at you know CIU group at uh uh dot com, I think is the website.
51:11
Unidentified speaker: But uh yeah, give us a search engine lookup.
51:15
Unidentified speaker: Okay, that's excellent.
51:16
Unidentified speaker: Max, uh, thanks very much for your uh for your time this morning.
51:19
Unidentified speaker: That was uh great.
51:20
Unidentified speaker: Nope, thanks Matt.
51:21
Unidentified speaker: Uh it's great to chat to you.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-GGUF:UD-Q4_K_XL. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.

More from Rock Stock Channel

Rock Stock Channel

NioCorp: EXIM Targets 65% Financing Yet Trading Near Cash? | Mark Smith

Episode discussion: NioCorp CEO Mark Smith discusses EXIM financing progress, offtake agreements, and valuation disconnect for the Elk Creek project.

Speakers’ claims: NioCorp CEO Mark Smith outlines the Elk Creek project's critical mineral production, highlighting binding take-or-pay agreements with ThyssenKrupp and Traxxis to secure EXIM financing. He emphasizes the project's high recovery rates for scandium and niobium, geopolitical supply chain risks, and strong community support in Nebraska. Speakers contrast NioCorp's advanced financing stage with competitors like Sunrise Energy Metals, arguing that the market undervalues the company relative to its cash position and project potential. The discussion covers the technical feasibility, financial metrics from an August study, and the strategic importance of EXIM's credit requirements.

Critical MineralsMiningEXIM Financing
56 min0 assets20 claims to verify
Rock Stock Channel

US Antimony: The Pentagon's Only Qualified Antimony Supplier | Gary Evans

Episode discussion: Gary Evans details U.S. Antimony's government contracts, vertical integration, and critical mineral supply chain role

Speakers’ claims: Gary Evans, CEO of U.S. Antimony (UAMY), describes the company as the only qualified supplier for U.S. government antimony stockpiles, leveraging a five-year Defense Logistics Agency contract worth up to $245 million. He highlights China's dominance in antimony smelting and the strategic impact of its 2024 shipment cutoff, which created demand for domestic production. Evans outlines the company's vertical integration strategy, including new mining assets in Montana and Alaska, and a joint venture with America's Gold Silver to build a $150 million hydromet processing facility. The discussion covers margin improvement goals, regulatory tailwinds from executive orders requiring U.S.-origin materials, and the company's debt-free financial position.

Critical MineralsDefense ContractsAntimony
52 min1 assets20 claims to verify
All insights