LATAM Stocks Podcast

Analyst Alejandro Fuchs contrasts Tiendas 3B's high-growth hard discount model with Walmex's strategic challenges and valuation discount.

58 min Listen to the original
Mexican EquitiesRetailTiendas 3BWalmexConsumer DiscretionaryHard DiscountEmerging Markets

Summary

Alejandro Fuchs, Head of Mexican Equities at Itaú, outlines a Mexican consumer macro environment defined by high minimum wages and remittances, noting a recent slowdown but expecting 2027 improvement. He highlights Tiendas 3B's rapid expansion, driven by a hard discount model with 60% private label penetration and negative working capital that funds growth internally. Fuchs argues Tiendas 3B's moat is difficult for competitors to replicate due to supply chain maturity. Conversely, he criticizes Walmex's in-house e-commerce strategy for bloating SG&A and notes its valuation remains discounted despite management changes.

Episode sections

  1. 0:01 – 1:57

    Introduction and Speaker Background

    Alejandro Fuchs introduces himself as Head of Mexican Equities and Strategy at Itaú, noting his Venezuelan origin and nine years of experience in Mexico City covering consumer names.

  2. 1:57 – 4:26

    Mexican Consumer Macro Overview

    Fuchs describes a post-pandemic consumption boom driven by high minimum wage increases and doubling remittances, followed by a recent slowdown in 2025-2026 due to geopolitical caution and slower growth in formal employment and real wages.

  3. 4:26 – 6:33

    Mexico's Informal Economy and Credit Dynamics

    The speaker highlights that Mexico remains a cash-based economy with 55% of jobs in the informal sector and low credit penetration, meaning interest rates and consumer debt levels have less impact on spending compared to Brazil or Chile.

  4. 6:33 – 8:43

    2027 Consumption Outlook

    Fuchs expects consumption to improve in 2027, potentially growing 100-200 basis points faster than 2026, driven by USMCA clarity, renewed investment, and continued government support for minimum wages.

  5. 8:43 – 13:59

    Tiendas 3B Business Model and Growth

    Tiendas 3B is a hard discounter with ~3,700 stores aiming for 14,000, featuring a limited assortment of ~900 SKUs, 60% private label, and high inventory rotation that generates significant working capital.

  6. 13:59 – 25:21

    Private Label Strategy and Consumer Trust

    The company overcame consumer skepticism of private labels by offering a full money-back guarantee, which is used by less than 1% of customers, effectively removing the risk of trying cheaper store-brand products.

  7. 25:21 – 29:36

    Financial Efficiency and Self-Funding

    Tiendas 3B generates negative working capital of approximately 37 days due to low inventory days (10) and standard payment terms (60), allowing it to fund aggressive expansion with minimal external debt or equity raises.

  8. 29:36 – 31:39

    Capital Allocation and Future Outlook

    Fuchs notes that while the company is currently self-funding growth, it has signaled future intentions to return capital to shareholders via buybacks and dividends once growth normalizes and free cash flow accumulates.

  9. 31:39 – 33:19

    Hard vs. Soft Discount Models and Tiendas 3B's Competitive Edge

    Fuchs distinguishes hard discounters like Tiendas 3B from soft discounters (e.g., Bodega Aurera, Supercito) based on assortment size, private label penetration, and e-commerce presence. He notes Tiendas 3B's model lacks e-commerce and perishables, focusing instead on extreme value and negative working capital to fund expansion.

  10. 33:19 – 38:44

    Tiendas 3B Valuation and Growth Trajectory

    Fuchs maintains an outperform rating on Tiendas 3B, acknowledging its high valuation (100x P/E, 30x EV/EBITDA) but arguing it is justified by 60% EBITDA growth and rapid store expansion. He emphasizes that the stock's performance relies on the market believing in sustained high growth and upward estimate revisions.

  11. 38:44 – 44:40

    Defensibility of Tiendas 3B and Competition with Walmex/OXXO

    The speaker argues Tiendas 3B's moat is its 60% private label penetration, which competitors like Walmex struggle to match quickly. He contrasts Tiendas 3B with OXXO, noting they serve different needs (price vs. convenience) but Tiendas 3B is eroding OXXO's share by offering cheaper staples like beer.

  12. 44:40 – 49:47

    Walmex Management Changes and Strategic Shifts

    Fuchs highlights a complete C-suite overhaul at Walmex, with new leadership focusing on smaller formats (Bodega Express), SKU reduction, and faster store openings. He views these changes as positive but notes the execution speed and sense of urgency are still catching up to the threat posed by Tiendas 3B.

  13. 49:47 – 52:12

    Walmex E-commerce Strategy and SG&A Pressure

    Walmex's decision to build its own e-commerce infrastructure in-house, rather than partnering with third parties like Uber or Rappi, has led to bloated SG&A expenses. Fuchs contrasts this with competitors who use partners to keep margins stable, noting Walmex's e-commerce growth is modest (10-15%) relative to its high fixed costs.

  14. 52:12 – 58:20

    Walmex Valuation Gap and Investment Outlook

    Walmex trades at 16x P/E, a significant discount to its historical 27x multiple and current US Walmart valuation of 35x. Fuchs maintains a neutral rating, suggesting the stock is a good company but not yet a compelling investment at current prices, waiting for further valuation compression or clearer growth signals.

Assets discussed

AssetKindStanceContext
AmazonAMZNequityneutralyou have the e commerce competition is very tough with Mercado Libre, with Amazon, with some of the Asian players, right?

“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.

Claims worth verifying

Remittances in Mexico doubled from $30 billion to $60 billion annually.

Alejandro Fuchs ·3:06

How to verify: Bank of Mexico (Banxico) remittance statistics; World Bank migration and remittance data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Minimum wage increased by 20% per year over the past eight years and ~12% in the last two years.

Alejandro Fuchs ·2:37

How to verify: Mexican Ministry of Labor (STPS) official minimum wage decrees; INEGI wage surveys. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

55% of jobs in Mexico are in the informal sector.

Alejandro Fuchs ·5:06

How to verify: INEGI Encuesta Nacional de Ocupación y Economía (ENOE); World Bank labor statistics. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Tiendas 3B carries ~900 SKUs, with 60% being private label.

Alejandro Fuchs ·10:11

How to verify: Tiendas 3B (TBBB) investor presentations or earnings call transcripts; company website product listings. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Tiendas 3B generates ~3 billion pesos of free cash flow over the last 12 months.

Alejandro Fuchs ·27:17

How to verify: Tiendas 3B (TBBB) audited financial statements (Cash Flow Statement); SEC filings. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Tiendas 3B pays suppliers in 60 days while holding 10 days of inventory.

Alejandro Fuchs ·25:46

How to verify: Tiendas 3B (TBBB) financial notes on working capital; calculation from Inventory Turnover and Days Payable Outstanding in SEC filings. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Tiendas 3B store-level ROIC is around 60%.

Alejandro Fuchs ·26:17

How to verify: Tiendas 3B (TBBB) investor presentations detailing store-level economics; analyst reports verifying ROIC calculations. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Tiendas 3B opened 141 stores in the last quarter.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·8:43

How to verify: Tiendas 3B (TBBB) quarterly earnings release or press update. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Tiendas 3B IPO'd two years ago (2024).

Alejandro Fuchs ·12:10

How to verify: Tiendas 3B (TBBB) S-1/F-1 registration statement date; NYSE listing history. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Tiendas 3B has approximately 3,700 stores and aims to reach 14,000.

Alejandro Fuchs ·31:39

How to verify: Company investor presentations or SEC filings (Form 20-F) for store count and guidance. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Soft discounters have 1,500 to 2,000 SKUs per store with 25-30% private label penetration.

Alejandro Fuchs ·32:19

How to verify: Company operational reports or industry analysis of Chedraui and Walmex store formats. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Tiendas 3B stock price increased from $17 to $61 over two years.

Alejandro Fuchs ·33:39

How to verify: Historical stock price data for NYSE: TBBB. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Tiendas 3B trades at 100x P/E and 30x EV/EBITDA excluding share-based payments.

Alejandro Fuchs ·34:19

How to verify: Financial modeling using company income statements and enterprise value calculations. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Tiendas 3B's EBITDA is growing at 60%.

Alejandro Fuchs ·34:39

How to verify: Company quarterly earnings releases and SEC filings. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Tiendas 3B opened 600 stores per year for the past three years.

Alejandro Fuchs ·37:18

How to verify: Company store count updates in quarterly reports. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Walmex has a complete C-suite change, including new CEO, CFO, CMO, and COO.

Alejandro Fuchs ·45:00

How to verify: Walmex press releases or SEC filings (Form 8-K) announcing executive appointments. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Walmex plans to open 500 more stores in five years (approx. 100 per year).

Alejandro Fuchs ·45:34

How to verify: Walmex investor presentations or strategic outlook documents. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Walmex trades at 16x P/E, down from 27x five years ago, while Walmart US trades at 35x.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·52:55

How to verify: Current market data for NYSE: WMT and BMV: WALMEX. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Walmex is net cash with a 22% ROE.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·52:12

How to verify: Walmex balance sheet and income statement in latest quarterly or annual report. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify Tiendas 3B's store count and expansion targets against Itaú's latest equity research reports and company filings.
  • Compare Tiendas 3B's private label penetration and SKU count with competitors like Bodega Aurera and Supercito using retail industry reports.
  • Analyze Walmex's SG&A expense trends relative to e-commerce revenue growth in their quarterly financial statements.
  • Check Walmex's current P/E ratio against its historical 27x multiple and US Walmart's 35x valuation as cited by the analyst.
  • Assess the impact of 55% informal employment on consumer credit penetration and spending resilience in Mexico using INEGI data.
  • Review Tiendas 3B's free cash flow generation and working capital cycle metrics to validate the self-funding expansion claim.
  • Investigate Walmex's new C-suite leadership and their stated strategic priorities regarding smaller formats and SKU reduction.
  • Compare Tiendas 3B's growth profile against other emerging market disruptors like Mercado Libre and Nubank for capital allocation context.
Full transcriptexpand
0:01
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hi
0:02
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Alejandro, how are you?
0:03
Alejandro Fuchs: Hello, Patrick. Doing well. And yourself?
0:06
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Good, thanks. I've been looking forward to this conversation. So today we're gonna talk about Mexican retail stocks. We're gonna cover tiendas 3B and Walmax. But before we we start diving in, can you just maybe introduce yourself to listeners?
0:20
Alejandro Fuchs: Yes, absolutely. So first of all, thank you for for hosting me. So I I am Alejandro Fuchs, I am the head of Mexican equities for Itaú, based in Mexico City. I cover the food and bet and consumer names for Mexico, but also some part of the coverage outside of Mexico. So for
0:40
Alejandro Fuchs: example, I covered the beverage businesses in Chile, some stocks like Arcos Dorados, which is the McDonald's franchisee of uh LATAM in mostly Brazil, right? And I'm also the head of Mexican equity strategy for the bank. I've been working at Itaú for almost nine years. I'm not Mexican myself, but I've been living in
1:00
Alejandro Fuchs: Mexico for the past nine years. So I think I get a good sense of the local also flavor base in Mexico City. And yeah, that that's a little bit about about myself.
1:09
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Cool.
1:10
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Where are you from originally?
1:11
Alejandro Fuchs: Venezuela.
1:12
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Ah, nice. So
1:13
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
1:13
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): moved from Venezuela and about nine years ago to Mexico City?
1:16
Alejandro Fuchs: Yeah, so so I did my undergrad. Uh you said that you study abroad. I also study abroad. I went to the US. You know,
1:23
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
1:23
Alejandro Fuchs: stu I studied in the US for four years, came back to Venezuela, uh worked there for around five years, uh at two banks and one buy side family office kind of firm. Okay. Uh and then moved to Mexico in two 2018 thousand eighteen. and be working at Itaú since 2018 uh once I moved to
1:43
Alejandro Fuchs: Mexico.
1:44
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Okay. Interesting. So before we dig into the companies then can you maybe just you know lay the groundwork, explain the Mexican retail industry, the current state of the Mexican consumer, just kind of give a macro overview.
1:57
Alejandro Fuchs: Yeah, absolutely. So so I think that we have gone through I would say a uh interesting phase. Let me go back a little bit, let's say after COVID, right? Because I think a lot of things have changed ever since, in the sense that Mexico came out of the pandemic a little bit in a good position because for good or bad, I would say the
2:17
Alejandro Fuchs: macro was kind of healthy, no, in terms of the consumer where you know debt levels were. And we saw we have seen the last I would say eight years of very high minimum wage increases in the country, a lot of social programs being you know enacted and a lot of spending on the
2:37
Alejandro Fuchs: population. So to have an to for you to have an idea, the past eight years a minimum wage salary has increased by 20% per year. And
2:46
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
2:46
Alejandro Fuchs: past two years it's is around 12. So it's it's a big increase I would say the past eight years. Um, so with that, I would say the consumption coming out of COVID, people wanted to maybe spend a little bit more. They were in pretty good health in terms of debt, they had higher income and purchasing power coming from not only remittances, which is a uh
3:06
Alejandro Fuchs: a part of the consumer segment that doubled. It's It it used to be $30 thirty billion dollars per year in remittances, today it's is closer to $60 sixty billion. dollars. So between remittances, higher minimum wage, and a pretty healthy, I would say, environment, together with, you know, formal employment growing, the consumption dynamics for Mexico were pretty good for let's say tw
3:26
Alejandro Fuchs: from two thousand and twenty one until twenty three, twenty four. And then I would say end of twenty four, two thousand and twenty five and twenty twenty-six, six, we have seen a slowdown. Okay. Which I I believe should have been expected, right? I mean things never go perfect forever. Um, but maybe the pace of the slowdown has been a little bit harsher than anticipated. We have
3:46
Alejandro Fuchs: seen some companies maybe, you know, in general in Mexico, not necessarily my coverage, but in Mexico, companies being a little bit more cautious with investments, no, a little bit more cautious with Capex, given the geopolitical tensions around the world and so on, and that has made a little bit of a slowdown in. terms of some of the key areas, you know, and variables that
4:06
Alejandro Fuchs: we follow for consumption, which are mainly formal employment, real wages, growth, remittances, consumer confidence and consumer credit. So you have seen those grow at a slower pace. Let's call it that way. And this year, you know, uh and we'll we can get into that a little bit more, but has been one where consumption is a little bit tougher
4:26
Alejandro Fuchs: in my opinion. Okay. When you look at Mexico, it's a little bit different than other countries. We all always like to compare it to Brazil because it's the largest economies route in the region, but it's a very different type of environment. In Mexico, cash usage continues to be quite relevant. Okay. Uh it's almost mostly a cash economy.
4:46
Alejandro Fuchs: Um the the size of informality is still pretty relevant around a quarter of the GDP is informal, and fifty-five percent of jobs are in the informal market today. So informality has been, let's say, coming down in terms of uh share from the number of jobs that they have, but that has been for the last
5:06
Alejandro Fuchs: 20 years going from around 59% to 55. five. So four percentage points in 20 years. It's a slow process, right? The formality uh of the content. country. So with that, when you look also at any metric in terms of credit penetration in the country, it's also on the penetrated, right? So between no low
5:26
Alejandro Fuchs: penetration of credit, mostly informal economy, and kind of a consumer that, you know, is it's not highly leveraged and so on, it's just a very different dynamic when you look at other parts of the region, mainly Brazil or mainly Chile, for example. Uh so for example, give you an example, rates don't affect the
5:45
Alejandro Fuchs: consumer as much as they affect in other regions. Why? Because they're not penetrated in credit, they don't have high, you know, uh uh a leverage. Um so
5:55
Alejandro Fuchs: that's the reason why sometimes it's a little bit difficult to understand and compare, you know, different countries in the region when it comes to consumer.
6:03
Alejandro Fuchs: Um, but that's kind of how we see it today. A little bit of a slowdown after pretty good years in the past, uh, not necessarily a lot of leverage, you know, when we look at consumer debt, uh, and also I would say an environment where people are being a little bit more cautious.
6:18
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Interesting. I think that that's a a great overview. So what would you expect then if I asked you to look 12 twelve to 24 twenty four months out? More of
6:26
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
6:26
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): same? I guess you're not gonna see you know, the cash economy isn't gonna suddenly go digital in twelve months, but what what would you expect moving forward?
6:33
Alejandro Fuchs: Yeah, it's interesting because we're seeing two different dynamics. One is there is a little bit more of an incentive from the government to try to push the digital agenda. That's true. That is happening at a slow pace, but it's happening in the country. Things, for example, like toll roads being only paid, you know, by cart is one
6:51
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
6:51
Alejandro Fuchs: things like, for example, paying at gas stations without cash only by card. So they're slowly trying to push this, right? Uh uh a little more the uh less cash usage in the country, uh which I think is interesting. But also when we look 24 months, twelve to twenty-four months, we do expect a little bit of better consumption dynamic. Why uh our team
7:11
Alejandro Fuchs: expects g real GTP GDP growth to be a little bit faster, to grow a little bit faster than in the let's say last 12 months. So that's gonna help a little bit more. Um a lot of discussions this year has been surrounding the USMCA negotiation between the US and Mexico, right? I think any uh type of
7:31
Alejandro Fuchs: clarity around that, either coming from a little bit lower tariffs or any uh visibility that we might have could bring investments back to the country.
7:39
Alejandro Fuchs: It's not that there's no investments, but the pace has slowed down a little bit of what it was before. So if we bring back a little bit more investments, that would make formal job creation grow a little bit higher, plus the economy grow a little bit faster, and we're still gonna have this support from the local government in terms of minimum wage increases and so on. Uh So we do
7:59
Alejandro Fuchs: expect with all of that, let's say, basket of variable. variables happening um for consumption to be a little bit better, you know, 2027 probably than it was in 2026. It's not gonna be a material shift, but we do think that you know the growth could be maybe a hundred to two hundred bips
8:19
Alejandro Fuchs: faster than what we'd have seen, let's say, the these past twelve months.
8:23
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Sure. Okay, great. So I think that sets the stage pretty well to start. diving into to the two retailers. So let's start with Tienda's three B, because when I dug into them a little bit, they're growing like crazy. It's a it's a really interesting company. The numbers are are somewhat hard to believe. I think last quarter they opened 141 stores. So they're opening more more than a
8:43
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): store a day, which is insane. But can you just maybe give an overview of the company, tell listeners what they do, what their business model is? etc.
8:52
Alejandro Fuchs: Absolutely. So tiendas 3B and the 3B stands for bueno, bonito y barato in Spanish, right? Which which is you know uh uh very funny but uh it's a hard discounter and we'll we we can talk a little bit more about what a hard discounter is right but hard discounters uh are let's say a type of grocery store that has been very popular
9:12
Alejandro Fuchs: in other parts of the world especially Europe you know when you look at discounters, if you've been to Europe recently, most European countries have a very high penetration of discounters, name it, you know, uh Poland, Spain, the UK, and so on, right? And this trend is kind of coming to Latin America. Uh especially, I would say that
9:32
Alejandro Fuchs: they probably the country with the most penetration of discounting in terms of food retail is Colombia. Um, and then you're starting. to see this, you know, happening in Mexico, in Chile, and in Peru to a lesser extent. Uh so what is Tiendas 3B? Tiendas 3B is a discounter that focuses, it's a
9:51
Alejandro Fuchs: small store around 300 to 400 square meters that is very austere in its outlook. Okay, it's not like a super flashy store that focuses mainly on a very limited assorption of SKUs, around nine hundred SKUs, focusing on your daily needs, inserts around eighty-five percent of your
10:11
Alejandro Fuchs: daily needs, uh let's say on the basket of staples that you y you would need, you know, to to survive, right? Uh what's the beauty of this? Sick around sixty percent of their SKUs are private label. So labels owned by the company. So it's a small store very convenient, very well located, where Capex is kind of
10:31
Alejandro Fuchs: small, right? Because it's not a very flashy store that focuses on very high rotation SKUs, mostly owned the brands by the own company. And this is super key to the investment thesis. Why? Because between the low capex, the very high rotation of inventory.
10:51
Alejandro Fuchs: okay, since these guys only sell 900 SKUs, rotation per SKU is pretty massive if you look at the days of inventory. So these guys generate a lot of free a lot of working capital. Okay. So with very little capex, a lot of working capital generation, they can have very good returns with low margins. So the beauty of this is
11:11
Alejandro Fuchs: that the private label, since they don't have to spend money on marketing. and so on, their prices will always be better and lower than the brand products. So if you find a mix of a good quality private label with, let's say, a pretty decent price gap between the branded product, that's a very interesting value proposition. This is what
11:31
Alejandro Fuchs: has, let's say, shifted the the the market in a lot of parts of Europe where these discounters countries today have 60% of market share. right? People like uh Mercadona in Spain, BIM in Turkey. Think about uh the guys in Poland, Biedronka, Dino, and so on, right? So we're seeing that coming to Latin America.
11:50
Alejandro Fuchs: Entiendas 3B, let's say, is the leading hard discounter uh in Mexico. It's not a new company. I mean they started, I think the first uh store was opened in 2005. two thousand and five. So it's been 21 twenty one years, right? But it's new to the public markets because they IPO'd two years ago. So they're new to the public market, but they've been there for quite some time trying to
12:10
Alejandro Fuchs: fine tune the business model. And you were mentioning the growth. Well, it took them twenty years to figure out the standardization. Standardization is the key in this industry, and this that's the reason why they can open a hundred and forty stores per quarter and probably this year six hundred and thirty stores per year
12:30
Alejandro Fuchs: because it's exactly the same store in any part of Mexico that you go to. It's almost exactly the same assortment. The the regional managers only have like ten SKUs that they can play with depending
12:41
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): on
12:41
Alejandro Fuchs: let's say seasonal uh taste, you know, in Mexico. But everything else is as standardized as it gets. Okay. So um that's let's say a little bit of of what they are. This company was founded by Anthony Hatoum, which is uh American Lebanese executive that came to Mexico twenty-three years ago. He used to
13:01
Alejandro Fuchs: work and was very close to the BIM operation in Turkey, which is the largest discountry in Turkey. And he said, Look, where where can I replicate this model? Let's say find a country that is similar to Turkey in terms of informality, you know, size, and so on, that this might work. And he chose Mexico. Okay. So he came to Mexico and and started the company
13:21
Alejandro Fuchs: from scratch. Uh and now is probably one of the, in my view, one of the best growth stories in Latin America, uh and one of the most differentiated, you know, uh retail companies probably out there at the moment.
13:35
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So ha I mean how how much growth can there still be ahead of them? How penetrated are they? Because you mentioned kind of a slight slowdown in the consumer the last two years, which would seem like a very favorable macro setup for their business model, right? So I mean how how much more growth? How often can they grow, how many more quarters can they grow forty
13:55
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): percent, you know, and open six hundred stores?
13:59
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That
13:59
Alejandro Fuchs: that that's a very good question, right? Because growth has been massive the last two years. Uh their guidance is to reach fourteen thousand stores. Today they have three point seven thousand. So that would be multiplying this by four, basically, right?
14:13
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): A lot of
14:13
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): stores.
14:14
Alejandro Fuchs: Yes. When you look at Mexico, um, since we commented that quite informal still today, right? Food retailing is no different. So Mexico continues to be around fifty percent, you know, when you talk to some of the industry experts, around fifty percent of the food retail industry in Mexico today continues to be informal. So when you think
14:34
Alejandro Fuchs: about space, there is a lot of white space to open stores, right? And and it's true that when macro is a little bit tougher, people would tend to downtrade and maybe the value proposition of the discounters resounds more with the consumer, but we think this is a long long-term term trend. We don't think it's only because the macro being a little bit tougher this year,
14:54
Alejandro Fuchs: right? Why? Because you already saw this happening in other parts of the world. That's number one. Number two, uh, when these guys have been able to break a myth, which is that private label doesn't work in Mexico. Yes, it does. Yes, it does. And you've been seeing this not only with three people, but you've been seeing this with Kirkland of Costco, with Great Value of Walmart, with
15:15
Alejandro Fuchs: membership mark from Sam's Club, right? There has been a little bit more focus into private label, and the way that 3B was able to break this myth was very interesting. They
15:27
Alejandro Fuchs: they got rid of the opportunity cost of being wrong on private label, and this is key to the thesis. Okay, what do I mean by that? If you go to the store and you see a a cookies, cookies, you wanna buy cookies, right? And you see that these cookies, the branded product costs 10 pesos and these cookies cost five
15:47
Alejandro Fuchs: pesos, right? And they look pretty similar.
15:51
Alejandro Fuchs: But since you don't know the brand, you know, and you earn that say minimum wage, you don't want to risk being wrong. Because if you're wrong, you're gonna have to wait a month until you can buy the cookies that you like. Tiendas 3B has this poly. policy in place where if you don't like the products on the private label side that they sell, they will give you your money back
16:10
Alejandro Fuchs: without questions asked. It doesn't matter if you have the ticket, if the if the uh a packet is empty, if it's halfway there, they'll give you your money back. So what you do by that is saying, Okay, I'm Hey, gonna try this. And if I don't like it, it doesn't matter. I'm gonna get my money back, and then I can buy the cookies that I owe. always buy. And what happens when you buy those private label and
16:30
Alejandro Fuchs: you save 50% of what you're gonna spend and the quality, let's call it decent, no? And then you do that by 900 products that you used to buy: water, rice, beans, etc. So you're saving 50% less on your groceries for the month. It's massive, right?
16:50
Alejandro Fuchs: So so they were able to break this myth also in a moment where the consumption has been a little bit weaker. And I I have tried some of these products myself, of course, living here. I have to say, you know, they're they're okay. They're okay. So this is the reason why it's resonating so well with clients. Uh people, which is
17:10
Alejandro Fuchs: another interesting how much growth can this last? It could last, it could last. for a number of years, in my view, right? And this has been kind of the analysis, a little bit of the uh underestimating the power of the company, in my view. Everybody has a normalization at some point. I mean, it could grow faster for quite some years before
17:30
Alejandro Fuchs: seeing this normalization. No, and and one more thing. These guys on their ticket, average ticket, they sell five between four and five SKUs per ticket. So today, even though it's a grocery replenishment store, people are using it as a convenience store a little bit, right?
17:47
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): They
17:48
Alejandro Fuchs: go and they buy four things they buy an ice cream, water, ice, and a chocolate. I mean, that doesn't seem like your replenishment, right? So once the brands start to be known more, once the penetration of the number of stores continues to grow and so on, you're gonna see higher
18:06
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
18:06
Alejandro Fuchs: number of SKUs at the ticket. More more SKUs on the ticket. The mix is gonna change. And if you add one more SKU when you have, let's say, five, that's a twenty percent increase in the average ticket. You add to that the number of stores and so top toplane lane growth could be material for a number of years, right? And I
18:26
Alejandro Fuchs: I said that they serve like eighty five percent of your daily needs. They don't have everything. They don't have all of the products that you need. Today, the for example the penetration of fresh products is quite limited. You're not gonna find the perishables, you're not gonna find the tomatoes, you know the meat. You're gonna have some frozen products, yes, but the fresh has been a little bit more difficult.
18:46
Alejandro Fuchs: Why? Because management is obsessed with standardization. So they want the same quality of tomato in south of Mexico than in the center than in the north. That's not very easy to do, right? But if they're able, which it seems that the pilot test is working very well, if they're able to have the perishables and then you can have ninety-nine
19:06
Alejandro Fuchs: percent of your daily needs, then it could be even more material, the growth of this company. So so it's very interesting because this is not a technology company it's not a business that is, let's say, a very AI driven. This is a grocery small store that focuses on value. That's it. But you have massive growth, it's a
19:26
Alejandro Fuchs: disruptor in Mexico because it's taking share from supermarkets, hypermarkets, and you're seeing the same trends happening in Chile. You have now people entering on the hard disk discount on site in retail opening stores in Chile, SencoSut Senko Suit opening hard discount concepts in Chile, and then in Peru in retail with tiendas más is also a very relevant player. So this is happening
19:45
Alejandro Fuchs: across Latin America. And if Europe serves as a let's say uh a mirror of what could happen in the future, well, the Aldi's, the little of this world, and so on, I mean, those guys probably control you know the market in their own countries. Uh so it's it's very a interesting. and you can see why let's say people are very
20:05
Alejandro Fuchs: attracted to the investment case and they actually reported y yes yesterday, you know, the results and it was a very impressive quarter.
20:13
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, I want to go back to a point you make 'cause I think it's so interesting. I've never heard of a food retailer that offers a full money back guarantee if you eat the cookies. I think that's probably a pretty powerful marketing tactic, right? So
20:24
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): absol
20:24
Alejandro Fuchs: absolutely. And and people are the the employees at the stores are trained
20:29
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): to
20:29
Alejandro Fuchs: say this.
20:30
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): To to just give it to them and say, don't make 'em feel bad, just give it to them and they write it off like it's a marketing expense, right?
20:36
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Correct.
20:36
Alejandro Fuchs: So and and what they found is that not many people do it. I
20:40
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): was gonna ask, well, I mean, what percent really does it? Maybe one or two percent? You know,
20:44
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): less probably
20:45
Alejandro Fuchs: less than one percent. Less than one.
20:46
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): If they do it, they
20:47
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): do it once, but no one does it once a week. That's embarrassing, right?
20:50
Alejandro Fuchs: Correct. Correct. So it's not just let's say marketing for the sake of marketing. No, they're trained to do it and they will give you your money back. And I have seen it myself. I've I've gone with clients for them to see the stores, right? And then when we try and we always buy it, you know, we're gonna buy the chocolate because you have to try the product, right? To see to see if it's good.
21:10
Alejandro Fuchs: Um without me saying anything, the cashier, oh you're buying this product, let me know. if you like it. Because if you don't, we'll give you your money
21:17
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): back.
21:18
Alejandro Fuchs: So they're trained to do that, right? Um, and what the company has found is that since not many people ask for the money back, it's a policy in place that they feel very comfortable having. Yeah, that also talks about quality of products being you know quite decent. And
21:35
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
21:35
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): isn't
21:35
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): gives them
21:35
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): just asking gives you credibility too, as a discount retailer. It makes you seem like you're confident in your product.
21:41
Alejandro Fuchs: In the price gap with other retailers, this is the other interesting part. These guys, I told you that they have a very uh limited number of SKUs, 900 SKUs, let's say, per store, right? That probably is gonna grow a little bit, maybe gonna reach a thousand once they put the perishables and maybe more frozen product, but it's Is gonna be a limited assorbent always. Why?
22:01
Alejandro Fuchs: They need this to rotate. fast. So if you go to a big retailer, you're gonna find, let's say, 10 different types of ketchup, right? The big one, the small one. When you go to a hard discounter, one type of ketchup. What's the one that sells the most and rotates the most? That's the one I'm gonna have. I'm not interested in the other ones. I'm interested in this one.
22:21
Alejandro Fuchs: And then I'm gonna have my own brand, which is gonna be 30 to 40 percent cheaper. So you can choose. the branded product or my product. You have both. But it's always going to be the one that rotates the most in order to generate this freak this working capital and in order for inventory levels to be quite low, right? So so that that and then
22:41
Alejandro Fuchs: when you look at price gap with other retailers, I mean it's massive because 60% sixty percent of private label being 30 thirty to 40% forty percent cheaper, when you do a basket of products, you're always gonna be the cheaper option. And the cheaper option with a decent quality of products. And the beauty is that with the limited
23:00
Alejandro Fuchs: assortment, these guys they channel check six hundred SKUs on a weekly basis compared to the competition. So they know how much they have of a difference of price on sixty 60% percent of their your sales. Imagine a big box retailer, 50,000 SKUs. There's absolutely no
23:20
Alejandro Fuchs: human way that you can know 60% of your SKUs how you're comparing to the market. You take a sample of 500 SKUs, which is what 3B does, but for them, that's half of the sales, right? So they can switch things around, turn things around very quickly, very, very quickly. And if it's always very
23:39
Alejandro Fuchs: decentralized, right? I mean, yes, you have a headquarter
23:42
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): here
23:42
Alejandro Fuchs: in Polanco in Mexico City, but you have regional managers which are experts in the region. So that's a way that you can have real estate bidder availability, where the stores are gonna be located. So the decision making is also quite decentralized. So that makes this fast growth uh be very difficult to replicate
24:02
Alejandro Fuchs: by any other retailer where most of the decisions are being very centralized in the headquarters. No, uh so the problem with 3B today is probably that you grow so fast that human capital is one of the bottlenecks because you need more regional managers, you need to be able to hire people at the distribution centers and so on. And since I was telling you that these guys live
24:22
Alejandro Fuchs: on efficiency, the way that they grow is very smart too. They're not gonna open one store in Mexico City and then go to Tijuana to the border, right? And open one store there. No, they they grow uh as a stain, no? So they have one distribution center, 150 to 160 stores on a radius, and then they open
24:42
Alejandro Fuchs: the next distribution center very close. No, so they grow like this, so people get to know the their brand. When you open a new one, the maturity curve is fast. faster, right? So it's actually quite smart also the way that they expand. Um, so it's very differentiated without being a revolutionary, let's say, business today.
25:01
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Interesting. So let's talk a bit about the finances then, their financials. How are they financing this rapid growth? I think if I read correctly when I was looking to them. so you mentioned the working capital, are they financing this growth effectively? with like supplier financing because their turnaround so quick and then their payment back to suppliers is is much longer?
25:21
Alejandro Fuchs: Correct. So so it's not longer than other players is the same.
25:26
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
25:26
Alejandro Fuchs: since they have ten days of inventory and the other ones have thirty, I generate more cash, right? So these are let's say ro round numbers. Uh accounts receivables, the days on receivables is like let's say two to three days at max because you pay a lot of cash, obviously, right? So let's say the receivables you don't have much, then you have 10 days of inventory. So between those two, you have
25:46
Alejandro Fuchs: 12 days, and then you pay on 60 days, like everybody else. Actually, when you look at the competition, they pay faster. The other ones are 65, 68. These guys are 60 days. So I pay you five days faster, and I generate negative 37 thirty seven days
26:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of.
26:03
Alejandro Fuchs: working capital while the rest of the retailers is still negative, right? But it's maybe ten days, you know, maybe maybe 15 days. So at some point, and this is why you have a ROIC per store in the sixties.
26:17
Alejandro Fuchs: Right? Because the CapEx is so small that when you account for the working capital that they you generate, the invested capital per store is quite quite small. And with a margin, let's say of five to six percent at the operational level, you have sixty percent return per store. Massive. Right? So it's it's very important to not
26:37
Alejandro Fuchs: focus only on the margin. You're gonna see margins which are four, four percent, and other retailers it's eight, eight, nine. Oh, so these guys is better. No, no, no, no. Look about the returns, the return per store, or the return the ROE, the ROIC per store. That's where the beauty here is. So, how do they finance this? By working
26:57
Alejandro Fuchs: capital. This is a company that has not needed money outside money. I think this since 2012, 13, 14 years. And they grow their store base by 20 to 25% every year. It's so this year they have generated around three billion. pesos of free cash flow with
27:17
Alejandro Fuchs: opening on the last 12 months around 600 stores. So so the reason why they did an IPO and so on was mostly secondary. The primary part of this is almost inexistent. So everything gets funded by the working capital generation of the company, and that's why it's key that those 900 SKUs they
27:37
Alejandro Fuchs: earn their space. at the shelf. If one SKU starts to rotate slower, you're out. And we replace it with somebody else, with something else. But you need the high rotation. So self funded the growth.
27:51
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Interesting. So is there no debt on the balance sheet then? Very
27:54
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): small.
27:55
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Okay.
27:56
Alejandro Fuchs: Very small. Uh And if you look at that depth, debt, uh, it's not necessarily a uh depth debt with banks like financial debt. Uh what is there is that the accounts payables that you have with suppliers, those suppliers do factoring and they sell those to the bank. So now you you owe the bank,
28:16
Alejandro Fuchs: but it is your normal course of operation. If you don't pay the bank, you would pay the supplier. But the auditors, since now you owe uh a financial institution, you need to account. that as debt. But but
28:29
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): it comes at
28:29
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
28:29
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): top line revenue, not yeah.
28:31
Alejandro Fuchs: Correct. So so so and it's not that you ask for a line of credit. No, it this
28:35
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is
28:35
Alejandro Fuchs: your but this is honestly part of your working capital. It's not sure debt that you have. And you will see, let's say, now with IFRS sixteen and so on, all of the stores are leased, right? And again, standardization. They have the exact same list contract on three 3,700 stores. Exact same terms. If not, they don't open the store. So
28:55
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): they don't even they don't negotiate. They don't have time because they're opening more than a store a day.
28:59
Alejandro Fuchs: This is what I offer. These are the terms. Do you accept or not? And if not, I'll ask for another location. But they they it because they need standardization. They need this to be as simple as possible in order to be able to grow so much. No. But since all of them are leased, you're gonna see. let's say, a lease liability that is big, right, or on the
29:19
Alejandro Fuchs: balance sheet, but it's not financial debt. It's your rent that you owe, you know, to the landowner or to that that is very common right on other retail companies. But it's almost no financial debt.
29:30
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And you think they can continue to finance up to 14,000 fourteen thousand stores just like this? I mean there's
29:36
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): no
29:36
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): reason they need to go out and raise capital. You don't expect them to to do a debt offering or anything. They should
29:42
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): just
29:42
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): continue to grow at this clip.
29:50
Alejandro Fuchs: Okay. Why? Because they are still the fastest to pay the suppliers. Since private label is quite relevant, they work with very small suppliers that are their partners for the last 20 years and that have grown. with the company, right? Imagine a supplier of rice. That guy used to sell you for 10 stores and now sells you for 3700
30:10
Alejandro Fuchs: stores. The guy's pretty happy too, right?
30:13
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So so
30:13
Alejandro Fuchs: so you are also kind of uh growing a part of the economy that was kind of muted, you know, in the past. So I think it's a win-win situation for many people. Uh so I I don't see a reason why Dash. that should change, but it's a very good question because if anything on the working capital changes, it changes the investment
30:33
Alejandro Fuchs: thesis. So working capital is key for these guys. No, but but so far today, I I see no reason why uh uh they could not be continue to be able to do this uh as they grow. And the big question mark is what happens when growth slows down? What are you gonna going to do with all of the money that you generate, right? You're
30:53
Alejandro Fuchs: going to generate massive free cash flow. And they've also been very vocal. That's going to take a long time. But once they reach a level where
31:02
Alejandro Fuchs: working capital is big and maybe your your growth has slowed down, remodeling is not a very big part of the Capex because the stores are austere looking, right? Um, Well, they they have already said that they were going gonna to do buybacks and pay. dividends. You know, they're gonna give capital back to shareholders, which is on a capital allocation perspective, very appreciated in Latin
31:21
Alejandro Fuchs: America. Um, so very outspoken also about priorities, right, of capital allocation even today. But yes, I I I think actually if you look at my model,
31:31
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
31:31
Alejandro Fuchs: at some point, CapEx and working capital is almost the same amount. So it's like la it's as if you were investing zero.
31:39
Alejandro Fuchs: because the CapEx that you put in, you get compensated by the net uh working capital that you generate. So so it's um it's a very interesting business. And and a lot of people ask me, Oh, if this so if this is so good, why cannot be replicated? Why cannot other companies
31:59
Alejandro Fuchs: come into Mexico, you know, and have competition? It's not the only hard discounter we have in the country. We have tiendas Neto, which is another hard discounter that is not public. Um, and then we have soft discounters, okay? Which is the difference between hard and soft discount? For me, it's mostly assortment. The soft discount has a little bit more
32:19
Alejandro Fuchs: SKUs, let's say one point five thousand to two thousand SKUs per store, less penetration of private label around twenty five to thirty percent, but they offer you perishables, they offer you e commerce, right? You have no e commerce at Tinder. So it's kind of the opposite of where the world is going, which is you know quite quite
32:39
Alejandro Fuchs: interesting, right? No e commerce and nothing online, right? Well for example, if you look at soft discounting, make for example a bodega Herrera Rera of Walmix, a Supercito of Chadrawi, you do have a window into that, let's say, new world, right? With delivery, e-commerce, and so on, but very different, you know,
32:58
Alejandro Fuchs: return profiles. And when you are wanting to look at the cheapest, let's say, option and value for the money, that's where the hard discount you know is is more attractive.
33:10
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So,
33:10
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): what do you think about value then from an investor perspective? What do you think of the company's value? valuation now? The stock, where is it trading? Do you
33:17
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): like
33:18
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): it now?
33:19
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
33:19
Alejandro Fuchs: so we continue to have an outperform rating. I like it. Okay. Uh as you can tell, I believe that this story is quite differentiated in Latin America and I am very positive on the stock. The stock came to the market at seventeen dollars, today it's at sixty one. So it has multiplied by three in the past two years in dollar terms, which is you know pretty material, right?
33:39
Alejandro Fuchs: The the big question mark is and and this is gonna sound a little bit naive the comparison, but if you are only concerned about valuation from a multiple standpoint, you're gonna miss the trade. Sure. Okay. Think about again, this is gonna sound naive, but think about the tech companies in the US, the Amazons, the Microsoft of the world. Yes, at some point you were paying a
33:59
Alejandro Fuchs: hundred times earnings, right? But if you believe the growth stopped. story, those hundred times were gonna be fifteen times in three years, right? So it's kind of similar the case here. If you exclude the share-based payment, because this is another interesting point, management gets compensated a lot in sh number of shares, and we can discuss this.
34:19
Alejandro Fuchs: Why is this relevant? But if you exclude that non-cash, you're paying a hundred times earnings today. A hundred times in And around around thirty 30 times. times EV to EBDA, which is, I mean, very high for a retailer, right? But what's the cash? Well, that the EBDA is growing 60%. So when you look on an EV EBDA
34:39
Alejandro Fuchs: to growth basis, you're paying less than one time for growth. And when you look at the earnings, these guys multiply by three their earnings this quarter. So okay, you're paying a hundred times PE, which in two years is gonna be 18 times PE if you look at it today. But you need to believe in the growth story. If you
34:59
Alejandro Fuchs: don't believe in the growth story, the stock is not gonna make sense. Okay, you need to believe that these guys can continue to have semester sales in the mid to high teens, that they can continue to grow six 600, hundred, seven 700, hundred, eight 800 hundred stores per year. If you believe all of that, the model. will make sense. Now, one more thing, or two more
35:18
Alejandro Fuchs: things. Every quarter, it seems that the market is revising estimates upwards every quarter. Every quarter is three, four percent better top line, a couple of points better on the margin. So every quarter you have them doing it better, better and better. So everybody, maybe myself included, I think we're underestimating a little bit the story.
35:38
Alejandro Fuchs: Because for the past two years, in eight quarters, we find ourselves all the time increasing numbers, increasing numbers, increasing numbers, right? That's number one. Number two, the the management today is not focused on margins, on profitability. No. They want to continue to take market share, continue to grow, and they know
35:58
Alejandro Fuchs: that with the scale and the value proposition, the profitability will come. That's they don't they don't manage the business in terms of margins. They manage the business in terms of value for the client, rotation of inventory, and all of that ends up with a margin. Okay? And why is this very relevant? Because it seems that even though that's
36:18
Alejandro Fuchs: the case, the operational leverage, the efficiencies are coming sooner than expected, in my opinion. So you're seeing both things materially. materialize at the same time, which is very hard to do. It's very hard to grow and be profitable at the same time. You have to choose normally, right? These guys are today seeing both things happening. Um
36:38
Alejandro Fuchs: so so I I think that that that makes it, I would say, v very different. A very different story. So valuation is high, 30 times CBDA, a 100 hundred times press earnings, but when you look at the growth, it makes sense. And people need to revise their off estimates probably upwards every single quarter, right? And if you reach 13 to
36:58
Alejandro Fuchs: 14,000 stores with the a this is another interesting point. When you look at the sales per store, remember remember that opening 600 stores per year, the past three years, you're talking about 1.8,000, let's say raw numbers. Uh on a total of 3,700. So half of the
37:18
Alejandro Fuchs: stores have been opened the last three years. The mat when you look at sales divided by stores and you look at a sales per store basis, that's not correct. A lot of those stores are not even mature yet.
37:30
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
37:30
Alejandro Fuchs: Right?
37:31
Alejandro Fuchs: So a lot of people are underestimating the top-line top line capacity, the operational leverage capacity, the differentiation.
37:39
Alejandro Fuchs: And I don't think that when the macro in Mexico improves, which again is slowly pointing to that way, right? I don't think people were up trade and stopped shopping at the end of the 3B. If you are somebody that saw your cost for the groceries be cut by half and the products are
37:59
Alejandro Fuchs: good, why would you spend 50% fifty percent more buying? beans and water and rice? No, I I'll I'll have that money to do something else. I'll go on a trip with my family. I'll you know, I'll do something else. But so I I think it's very sticky going forward, right? I I don't think you're gonna see like a lot of fluctuation uh once GDP
38:19
Alejandro Fuchs: grows two and a half percent and And then you know we see employment and so no no no I think that the the story is quite defensive in that scenario too.
38:27
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Interesting, perfect. You mentioned defensive. So I'm gonna transition now to ask you about Walmax, but I want to ask you then let's just talk quick how defensible is Tienda's business model then? Because you mentioned you know the soft discounters, but also you mentioned like it's four or five SKUs, the average ticket, right? And
38:44
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): people
38:44
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): are going in for you know eggs. So they're also competing with Osho, right? Who's another giant retail gross story? i in in Mexico I know Walmax also has is it a soft discounter brand is it is it bodegas or
39:00
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): yeah so what how defensible is the saw or the hard discount model and then I guess talk about Walmax then and then contextualize their competitor.
39:08
Alejandro Fuchs: Yeah no it's it's a very good question. I think that the value proposition is a little bit different, right? Because the the name of the game is penetration of price private label. Right. So if you want to compete with tiendas 3B and the basket of products is going to have the same price, you need to have 60% private label in your store. If not, it's going to be impossible for you to compete on price. Okay.
39:28
Alejandro Fuchs: Um, so when you look, let's say, at Bodega Aurera from Walmex, I think they can compete. I think Walmex I
39:33
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): think
39:33
Alejandro Fuchs: Womix has a very good brand. Bodega is a very well managed brand, you know, that is very liked by the local community. What's the problem? That when you buy 10 things, those 10 things in 3B, the comparison, the price gap is gonna be 15%.
39:48
Alejandro Fuchs: Because you have a higher penetration of private label in one than in the other, right? But for example, you cannot do all of your shopping at 3B. You can go to Bodega and you can buy the pervisables in Bodega or in Supercito, right? So they can coexist today. What's kind of some of the worries that I have with Walmex? And I'll touch the OXO point in a little bit. But
40:08
Alejandro Fuchs: um the problem with me is that
40:13
Alejandro Fuchs: there's a lot of white space. Who's filling that white space today? Tiendas 3B. So if you don't open faster number of stores, the the other retailers Chadrawi, Walmex, Soriana, and so on, the space is gonna be filled. filled by this guy by Tendas 3B. So you need to open more stores at a faster pace,
40:32
Alejandro Fuchs: right? So you can compete, but in 10 years, these guys are gonna put in 10 years 9,000 stores. And you're gonna put 1,000. It's a problem. Right? So you it and this is why it has taken 3B 21 years, right? When people say, okay, how defensive is this? Well it takes 20 years to
40:52
Alejandro Fuchs: create the supply of private label to reach 60%, to have the right partners. So it's not like you can come in and do it from scratch. It took them 20 years to be able to do that, right? So it's not as easy to be done. And actually, what's happening today is that now you have companies uh in Mexico
41:12
Alejandro Fuchs: that would be unheard of that to make private label in the country doing private label for 3B. Some of the largest branded products in Mexico doing private label because they see that this is kind of where the market is going as well. So I do think WalMex can compete. I think they have a good brand, but they need to grow faster.
41:32
Alejandro Fuchs: Do it, do it a have more penetration of private label, have more stores, focus more on the small forums. format, not the big format. No? So I think there's some fine-tuning to be made. And you are correct on OXO. The difference of OXO is that OXO is a convenience store, right? So prices on convenience stores are higher
41:52
Alejandro Fuchs: normally than on grocery stores. Why? Because they're convenient. They're right there next to your house. So if you go to the supermarket and you forgot X, and then your wife tells you, Patrick, you need to buy the X, you say, I okay, I'm not gonna drive. You know, okay, I'll go to the convenience store, I'll pay a little bit more, right? It is what it is. So if you're looking for the best
42:11
Alejandro Fuchs: price, convenience store is gonna be higher. So so I do think even though the pricing occasion is a little bit different in terms of impulse, convenience, and the grocery, I do think Tienda Tiendas 3 3B is also competing a little bit in some scales, you know, relative to Ox. OXO. And I'll give you an example. Beer. In
42:30
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in
42:30
Alejandro Fuchs: OXO you find many brands of beer. At 3B you find three brands of beer. If you want the cheapest beer, Tiendas 3B. If you want other types of beer, you can go to the OXO, right? And they're gonna be very close to each other because this is a small format grocery, right? It's very big. It's gonna be close
42:51
Alejandro Fuchs: to you as well. But it depends on what you want. Do you want the price or do you want the assortment? No, but they are most likely taking away some people absolutely from OXO. That's the reason why OXO this year has been focusing a lot on the value side of the business, changing the mix of the store, right? So
43:11
Alejandro Fuchs: you see everybody trying to do this, and I I feel that a lot of retailers are playing catch up a little bit, right? That they kind of underestimated private label in Mexico. I remember talking to a lot of people five, six years ago, private label will never work in Mexico, right? I remember this type of comments. And now that it's working, one guy
43:31
Alejandro Fuchs: is very well ahead and the other ones are, let's say, ah I need to build this mass which takes time, right? And Um think about a Walmakes. They have a very good brand, right? Great value and so on. But yeah, you need to fill the 3400 stores and the six million square meters. Who can do that? Yeah, okay,
43:51
Alejandro Fuchs: maybe the Coca-Cola's of this world, and maybe the Bimbos, right? But who else? There's no independent producer of products that can give you those kind of volumes in six months. Very difficult. right? So so so this is why it takes time. So it it is it is quite defensive. It is quite defensive in my opinion. And it's a little bit
44:10
Alejandro Fuchs: different, I would say, than the OXO, maybe more relatable to to the soft discounters.
44:16
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Interesting. So I mean you you cover both companies. So if you were working at Bodegas Aurora and other than try and outgrow them, I
44:24
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): mean
44:25
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): which you probably can't do, right? You're not lean, you're a big company. I guess could you compete on individual SKUs? You know, could you just over discount on the ten biggest products that uh Tianzas 3B sells and just take the loss on them and try and slow them down?
44:40
Alejandro Fuchs: It's a very good question. And and we have seen a lot of changes at Walmix recently, right? I mean, it's probably the first time in almost nine years that I see let's say, all of the management, all of the C-level team change almost the same year in Walmix. You have a new CEO, a new CFO, a new CMO, a new head of Wall of SAMS Club,
45:00
Alejandro Fuchs: a new COO. Everybody's new.
45:03
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
45:03
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): You
45:03
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,
45:03
Alejandro Fuchs: in their position at Walmix. Okay. So the changes that the new management is bringing are positive, in my opinion. I think that they're doing a better job. Okay. What's the speech? They want to go to they
45:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): want
45:14
Alejandro Fuchs: to focus. on bodega. They want to focus on the smaller bodega express, it's called they want to open more stores per year. They said 500 more stores in five years. So let's say a hundred stores per year, give or take. No. Um they are lowering the number of SKUs. What does that mean? That means that instead of having
45:34
Alejandro Fuchs: let's say 10 brands of cereal, you're gonna have seven, right? The ones that sell the most
45:39
Alejandro Fuchs: That makes you have more volume on those seven brands. You can get better commercial terms, you can have lower prices. Right? So you wanna compete on price, you wanna compete on the smaller format, open more form. So it's pointing into the right direction, in my opinion. What's the problem? The speed, the sense of
45:59
Alejandro Fuchs: urgency, in my view, is still not there, it's still not hundred. 100% there. But I do think that they're going where, again, the market believes that the company needs to go, right? And the other thing is that the company has been very focused on e commerce the past few years, right? Why? Because this is what's growing in the US. This is
46:19
Alejandro Fuchs: what Walmart, you know, is doing so well in the US with this. So they want to try to replicate this, which I don't necessarily disagree with. The problem is that you kind of um took your eyes away from the store. No?
46:35
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And and
46:35
Alejandro Fuchs: now you have somebody turning the corner,
46:38
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): right? And then doesn't even have an
46:40
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): internet connection, right?
46:41
Alejandro Fuchs: And the store is ninety-two
46:43
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): percent of your
46:43
Alejandro Fuchs: business. E-commerce
46:44
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is
46:45
Alejandro Fuchs: eight, right? So so so and then I do also have some comments on the e-commerce e commerce part, right? Um but but I do think that at least today there's a recognition that some things need to change. There's people in charge that are pointing into that direction, but it's gonna be a slow process. Because as you said, Walmix is a very big company, so it takes
47:04
Alejandro Fuchs: time for the company to move, no. But I do believe that WaltMex Walmix has a good brand that they can compete, that at some point, you know, this could be a good investment, the Walmex stock, right? Today we have a neutral recommendation, which has been the case for the past two years. I think that has worked very well. But the number one question we think we get asked
47:24
Alejandro Fuchs: today is when is time to buy Walmix? That's the number one question that we ask today, right? So a lot of people want to do it because it's a good company. But they're going through some things that I don't want to say structural, but the market is shifting. The market is shifting. right? The good news is that fifty percent of food retailing in Mexico is informal. So er
47:44
Alejandro Fuchs: everybody can grow, but what happens in ten, twenty years?
47:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
47:50
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): do you expect them to just grow closer to the the Mexico average if if Mexico's retailers are growing one point five, consumers growing one point five, you know?
48:01
Alejandro Fuchs: Yeah. No, I I think they can they can outgrow the market. I think that you have other players on the public side which are going through a very tough momentum. Like for example, Soriana is the second largest
48:13
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): food
48:13
Alejandro Fuchs: retailer in Mexico, fourteen percent market share. They have been going through a tough time for the past eight years. So Walmex is taking share away from Soriana, is growing a little bit ahead of Chadaragui, Chedrawi, right? I mean I
48:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): mean
48:25
Alejandro Fuchs: Walmex Walmix continues to kind of defend itself and also taking some share from the informality, right? So so that's why they sometimes they they don't like the comparison with 3B because it's not only 3B, you have a way more players, right? So so Walmex is trying to do it. The thing is that you have 50% market share on the formal side on Walmex.
48:45
Alejandro Fuchs: So if somebody's gonna lose share, normally it's the guy with 50% fifty percent market share, no? Um but again, I mean, I do think that the strategy they're doing, you know, a better job right now with with the CEO, Christian Barrientos. You know, he has a good strategy, the team, you know, has been doing a better job. Uh, but ca can they go back to
49:05
Alejandro Fuchs: growing top line seven, eight percent? It seems difficult because you are investing in price, people are done trading, right? It's not only that you uh are gonna let's say have a better semester sales, is that maybe the consumer that used to buy beef now buys chicken. That affects your your average ticket, right? It's not only that you're not losing traffic, but you
49:25
Alejandro Fuchs: your ticket mix might be different. No? So so um it seems difficult that they're gonna grow I I in my model I expect them it to grow mid single digit six
49:36
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): percent
49:37
Alejandro Fuchs: maybe top line. And what's the problem with the company? SGNA grows faster than that. That's the
49:43
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): problem. So a little bit
49:45
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): bloated, I guess. Which is
49:47
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
49:47
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): opposite of Tienzas 3B, which is
49:49
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): having
49:49
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): trouble hiring, right?
49:51
Alejandro Fuchs: And and Mexico has as I was telling you about the minimum wage increases, right? So you have seen a higher SGNA pressure for all of Mexico the past years, right? What what's the problem? That since the in this this is my opinion, but since the company has been very focused on e commerce, they decided to do everything themselves. They
50:11
Alejandro Fuchs: did not partner with anyone. Not not with Uber to Uber Eats, not with Rappi in Latam, not with I'm gonna do everything myself because I don't want to share my client, data from my client. That makes sense if you expect top line of e-commerce to go to 20% of sales.
50:29
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Sure.
50:30
Alejandro Fuchs: So you need to hire a lot of the data scientists, the engineer. Those are very, let's say, more expensive labor, no, more specialized labor. So if you don't have the top line, because the top line, let's say, stays at 8% of sales, the e-commerce, and you don't it's not really growing 60, 70%, it's he's
50:49
Alejandro Fuchs: growing 10. 15, no. But you have the pressure on the SGNA because you decided to do everything yourself, it's a problem. What did other retailers do? Which so far today, it seems that that that has been maybe the correct answer. Maybe in 10 years we talk again, and Womek has 20%
51:07
Alejandro Fuchs: of sales online, and that was the correct answer in hindsight. But today, all of the other retailers have partnered. They didn't have to hire everybody, do everything in house. They work with Uber, they work with Rapi, they work with Didi. So they don't have the pressure on the SGNA. So so margins are much more stable,
51:27
Alejandro Fuchs: let's say at the Chedrawis and so on, than at WalMex, even though Walmix grows faster. So it's a difficult that's what I'm saying that to solve the problem, it's not easy. It's
51:39
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): not
51:40
Alejandro Fuchs: easy. And and it seems to a lot of investors that you're getting attacked in many fronts. You have the store under pressure, you have the e commerce competition is very tough with Mercado Libre, with Amazon, with some of the Asian players, right? So you're getting a lot of competition everywhere, everywhere. Um so it is not an easy task to
52:00
Alejandro Fuchs: solve today.
52:01
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
52:01
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you have them in neutral at though. Are there any other red flags other than just the the growing expenses from from selling general administrative? Is the balance sheet the debt sleeve reasonable? They've got cash.
52:12
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Net
52:12
Alejandro Fuchs: cash. Net cash. This company is net cash. That's so this is a it's a good company, net cash, ROE of twenty two percent, right? They don't grow much, but they have fifty 50% percent market share, one of the most liquid stocks in Mexico. The problem is that this stock was trading at 27 times earnings five years ago. 27. Why? Because again,
52:32
Alejandro Fuchs: it's a very, very well-run company with good balance sheet where the world is shaky, people hide in Walmex, right? It used to be uh a company that people saw as a standard for food retailer in the world, not in Latin America. It used to be the darling of the Walmart group, right? I mean, Walmart. WalMex used to trade at 27 times earnings
52:52
Alejandro Fuchs: and Walmart US at 15.
52:55
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah.
52:55
Alejandro Fuchs: Now Walmart US trades at 35 and Walmex at 16.
53:00
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So the
53:00
Alejandro Fuchs: valuation gap is massive today, right? Um but no no the I wouldn't say like a red flag. It's just that the the market is shifting a little bit and and and we thought that maybe they were a little bit slow. to react and to accept this shift. But now I think it's a little bit better.
53:21
Alejandro Fuchs: A little bit better. And that's the thing. When you go to your Bloomberg and you see valuation and you see that the average is 23 times PE, today 16. The company has been an underperformer in Mexico for the past five years. Okay, when it's time to buy it. you know, uh At some point it makes sense. But then we discuss, you know, the specific specifics of the industry, why this has
53:41
Alejandro Fuchs: changed. Then you need to be a little more careful because while Mex has never traded as a Latam stock, when you go to any other part of Latin America, Brazil, Chile, Peru, I mean food retailers, ooh, the the average valuation no uh between let's call it between ten 10 and fifteen 15
54:00
Alejandro Fuchs: times in discount. this country Full trading at twenty 27 seven. because it was a standard of international, an international standard. No, now is closer to a LATAM you know stock. Now is that deserved or not? What would make this re rate or not? Right. So so there's a very interesting conversation around WalMex.
54:21
Alejandro Fuchs: Uh and and I do believe that at some point it will be a good investment. If you buy the stock, I I like always to separate between good companies and good investments, right? Uh
54:32
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of course.
54:32
Alejandro Fuchs: Good company doesn't mean a good investment. So so I'm not talking this about being a good or bad company. No, it's a great company. I'm talking about do you make money for your clients or
54:41
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): not
54:42
Alejandro Fuchs: with this investment? No. I do think there's gonna be a time where if you buy Walmak shares, you're gonna make money. Okay? Is that gonna happen at fifty pesos, fifty one pesos today? I'm not that certain. I'm not that certain. I think you need to buy a little bit lower in terms of valuation and so on. But we're getting close. We're not that
55:01
Alejandro Fuchs: far away. Okay.
55:03
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, it's a very interesting company. It's a smart company to follow too, because you get the whole global retail you follow Walmart as a part of it too. It's the whole Mexican, it's the discount, it's everything.
55:15
Alejandro Fuchs: And I mean these are not let's say I I don't want to throw myself under the bus, but this is not very hard business to understand. It's a food retailer, you know? I mean it's quite simple, right?
55:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Even e commerce,
55:25
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): right? Everyone kind of knows how it works at this point.
55:28
Alejandro Fuchs: Absolutely. But that people also like that. They like simplicity. They don't want to spend a hundred hours doing the model and so they want simple businesses, right? Uh They have limited time. So
55:39
Alejandro Fuchs: the problem is what would make re rate when things turn around the other one, and then everybody compares it to the other one, to the growth company.
55:48
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Of course, right?
55:52
Alejandro Fuchs: And you don't you don't have those stories in Latin America. Think about what companies can sustain Sustained at 40% top lane line growth in Latam that are not material companies today or petrochemicals that are enjoying higher prices of oil, copper. Think about domestic businesses, banks, industrials, and so on. There are not many.
56:12
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): It's difficult.
56:13
Alejandro Fuchs: Mercado Libre, Nubank, maybe, right? And then you know you're running out of options. So Mexico, which is a kind of a mature market, big companies, high market shares, there that are more. stable. We don't have many growth stories. And in LATAM also we don't have many, no?
56:33
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
56:33
Alejandro Fuchs: these guys are and and when you compete for attention from a emerging market perspective, who are you competing against? South Korea,
56:43
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Taiwan,
56:44
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): right?
56:44
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Whatever the
56:45
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): emerging market of the month is. Right
56:46
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): now
56:46
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): it's Indonesia, but yeah.
56:48
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Indonesia or
56:48
Alejandro Fuchs: or or India a couple of years
56:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): ago, right?
56:51
Alejandro Fuchs: And those companies are growing 80, 100, 120%. So when we talk to some clients and they say, Okay, I like your stocks, but what's the growth? Ah, 12%. Well, I have this company in Taiwan that grows 50%. So it's difficult to compete. Tiendas 3B is one which can compete with the growth
57:11
Alejandro Fuchs: stories in the region and in the emerging markets. So that's why it's getting a lot of attention.
57:15
Alejandro Fuchs: And again, it's a people tend to joke when I say this, but I like to compare them to disruptors. Disruptors. They're disrupting the food retail market in Mexico, no? And which are the disruptors? Mercado Libre, Nubank, right? These are the disruptors in the region. So I I put them kind of in the same basket of disruption.
57:35
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Very interesting. I think that's a perfect place to leave off. So where can I send listeners to connect with you, follow your work, reach out
57:43
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if
57:43
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): they have questions?
57:44
Alejandro Fuchs: Yeah, look, I would say that in LinkedIn is a good place. You know, I'm not as active as some other people, to be honest, on on there, but I'm super happy to chat with people, to to share thoughts. You know, I I think there are a lot of very bright people that know the sectors maybe even better than myself. Uh so I'm super open of hearing other opinions. I'm not very active on Twitter or
58:04
Alejandro Fuchs: X, honestly, but I would say LinkedIn is probably the place. You know, I'm also pretty available to to have discussions and super happy to you just chat, you know, about my sectors or Latin America.
58:15
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All
58:15
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): right. Thanks so much for doing this. I appreciate it.
58:18
Alejandro Fuchs: Thank you, Patrick. Have a good one.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.

More from LATAM Stocks Podcast

All insights