Speakers analyze UK small-cap opportunities and risks, highlighting Thruvision, CML, and Tracsis while warning against Pulsar and Gear4Music.
Summary
Paul Scott and Paul Hill discuss UK small-cap stocks, identifying Thruvision, CML Microsystems, and Tracsis as undervalued opportunities with strong fundamentals. They warn against chasing Hays' rally due to high valuations and slow sector recovery. The speakers express strong concerns over Trifast, McBride, Flowtech, and Gear4Music due to profit warnings and poor business models. They also review ME Group, PayPoint, Eagle Eye, Restore, and Volex, offering mixed views on their valuations and risks. The episode concludes with positive notes on Watches of Switzerland, Zotefoams, and James Cropper, while advising against investing in Pulsar.
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 5:15
Market Volatility and IPOs
Speakers discuss recent market nerves, citing the Anthropic IPO and NVIDIA results as factors causing UK small-cap volatility. Paul Scott views the sell-off as an opportunity to buy underpriced stocks, noting that panic selling is creating bargains.
- 5:15 – 12:00
Thruvision (THRU)
Paul Scott discusses Thruvision's H1 results, noting strong sales momentum in Asian airports and prisons but highlighting a need for short-term bridging finance. He views the stock as high-risk with significant upside potential if financing is secured.
- 12:00 – 14:45
Hays (HAS)
The speakers analyze Hays' profit upgrade, which drove a sharp share price increase. Paul Scott warns against chasing the rally, citing high valuations and a slow, gradual recovery in the recruitment sector rather than a V-shaped rebound.
- 14:45 – 20:40
CML Microsystems (CML)
CML reported a return to profit and strong revenue growth. Both speakers like the stock due to its net cash balance sheet, niche low-power chip technology in aerospace/defense, and potential for sentiment-driven upside.
- 20:40 – 27:50
Tracsis (TRCS)
Tracsis is discussed as an undervalued rail software provider following a major acquisition. Speakers highlight its dominant market position, high client retention, and potential for international expansion, viewing the current low valuation as a buying opportunity.
- 27:50 – 29:33
Traxxas (Tracsis)
Paul Hill describes Traxxas as a software provider for railways, noting 45% recurring revenue on £75-76m turnover. Paul Scott suggests it is a watchlist candidate, advising against buying on spikes due to illiquidity.
- 29:33 – 31:14
CT Automotive
Paul Scott exits CT Automotive after a fourth profit warning, citing lost confidence in management's forecasting and financial distress. He criticizes the CEO's AI claims as garbage and notes the company has agreed to lower prices in cost-down contracts.
- 31:14 – 33:25
Trifast
Trifast issued a profit warning, lowering operating profit guidance from £19m to £14.25m due to soft demand and Saudi disruptions. Paul Scott expresses disappointment, noting the miss undermines the bull case, though Richard Staveley added to his position.
- 33:25 – 38:17
McBride
McBride issued a profit warning due to energy costs it cannot pass on for three months. Paul Scott remains forgiving, retaining a 4/5 star rating, expecting margins to recover as oil prices fall. Paul Hill remains unconvinced about long-term margin sustainability.
- 38:17 – 42:11
Flowtech Fluidpower
Paul Scott dislikes Flowtech, citing poor business models, lack of moat, and inefficient balance sheets with high inventory. Paul Hill agrees, noting the sector is not aligned with electrification trends and the company faces working capital risks.
- 42:11 – 46:10
Gear4Music
Gear4Music issued a brutal profit warning with like-for-like sales down >10% and H1 profit plunging 63% to £1m. Paul Scott calls the update terrible, questioning the business model and suggesting previous profits were one-off gains from competitor exits.
- 46:10 – 51:00
FRP Advisory and BTG
Paul Scott highlights FRP and BTG as cheap, counter-cyclical insolvency plays with low PEs and yields. Paul Hill warns of AI disruption potentially reducing total fees paid to insolvency practitioners, even if margins are maintained.
- 51:00 – 55:59
ME Group
ME Group is discussed as an incredibly cheap stock (PE ~7, yield ~7%) with a strong balance sheet. Paul Scott likes the self-funding laundry business and argues the photo booth business is not dying due to security requirements, suggesting a sum-of-the-parts valuation.
- 55:59 – 1:29:45
PayPoint
Paul Scott discusses PayPoint, noting a 13% drop in H1 profit but an increase in EPS due to debt-funded buybacks. He expresses concern over the balance sheet and the Impost parcels division, though he views the share price drop as an overreaction to a trading update that was broadly in line with expectations.
Claims worth verifying
Anthropic raised $100 billion in its IPO, described as potentially the biggest ever.
Paul Hill ·1:26
How to verify: Check SEC filings or press releases for Anthropic's IPO prospectus and total proceeds raised. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceThruvision's H1 results were in line with expectations, and the full-year outlook was reiterated in line.
Paul Scott ·6:59
How to verify: Review Thruvision's H1 2026 financial results and trading statement filed on the company's investor relations page or regulatory news sources. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Thruvision requires short-term bridging financing in the next six months.
Paul Scott ·7:38
How to verify: Check Thruvision's H1 2026 results announcement for the specific disclosure regarding financing needs. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
CML Microsystems H1 revenue was up 34% and it returned to profit after a loss last year.
Paul Scott ·15:42
How to verify: Review CML Microsystems' H1 2026 trading update or financial results for revenue growth and profit/loss figures. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
CML Microsystems has approximately £11 million of cash, with 20% of its market cap being net cash.
Paul Scott ·16:14
How to verify: Check CML Microsystems' latest balance sheet in its H1 2026 results and current market capitalization. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Tracsis trades at a forward PE of 11.6 times.
Paul Scott ·22:29
How to verify: Calculate Tracsis's forward PE using its current share price and consensus analyst estimates for next year's earnings, or check financial data providers. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Cordell was bought out by Voest-Alpine of Germany at six times sales.
Paul Hill ·24:41
How to verify: Search for historical press releases or news articles regarding the acquisition of Cordell by Voest-Alpine and the transaction multiple. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Tracsis is the number one software provider into UK train operating companies, ahead of Hitachi and Siemens.
Paul Hill ·25:07
How to verify: Review Tracsis' investor presentations or annual reports for market share claims, or check industry reports on UK rail software providers. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Great British Railway is creating its own front-end website to replace Trainline for ticketing.
Paul Hill ·27:40
How to verify: Check official announcements from Great British Rail or UK government press releases regarding the new ticketing platform. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Traxxas has 45% recurring revenue streams out of £75-76m of revenues.
Paul Hill ·28:24
How to verify: Company investor presentations or annual reports; check revenue breakdown for software vs hardware. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
CT Automotive has issued four profit warnings.
Paul Scott ·29:41
How to verify: Company announcements on regulatory news services (e.g., RNS) or company website investor relations section. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Trifast lowered operating profit guidance from £19m to £14.25m for the March 2027 year end.
Paul Scott ·32:07
How to verify: Trifast profit warning announcement or interim/full-year results filing. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceMcBride has a three-month lag before recovering loss margins from customer price rises.
Paul Scott ·34:36
How to verify: McBride earnings call transcripts or investor presentations detailing pricing mechanisms. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Flowtech Fluidpower had a cost of sales of £71m and inventories of £31m.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·41:50
How to verify: Flowtech Fluidpower latest annual accounts or interim management statement filed with Companies House. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Progressive Research dropped Gear4Music earnings forecast by 80% to 4p.
Paul Scott ·43:36
How to verify: Progressive Research analyst notes or press releases regarding Gear4Music. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
FRP Advisory had net cash at December 2026.
Paul Scott ·47:18
How to verify: FRP Advisory interim or annual financial statements for the period ending December 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
ME Group PE and dividend yield are both about 7.
Paul Scott ·52:00
How to verify: Financial data providers (e.g., Bloomberg, Refinitiv) or ME Group investor relations page for current valuation metrics. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
ME Group is self-funding the expansion of its outdoor laundry machines.
Paul Scott ·52:13
How to verify: ME Group annual report or management commentary on cash flow and capital expenditure. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
PayPoint H1 profit was down 13%, but EPS was up due to aggressive buybacks funded by debt.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·56:25
How to verify: Check PayPoint's Half-Year 2026 Results announcement on the company's investor relations page or via a financial data provider like Bloomberg/Refinitiv. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
PayPoint's full-year outlook for March 2027 was broadly in line, which Paul Scott interprets as about 5% below expectations.
Paul Scott ·57:11
How to verify: Review PayPoint's H1 2026 trading update released in November 2026 for guidance on the full-year March 2026 results. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
PayPoint shares sold off 22% following the H1 results.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·57:31
How to verify: Check historical share price data for PayPoint (PAY) around the date of the H1 results release in November 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Eagle Eye won two new contracts, one with Carrefour in Europe.
Paul Hill ·59:25
How to verify: Review Eagle Eye's AGM trading update released in November 2026 for details on new contract wins. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Eagle Eye shares dropped 3% on the day of the trading update.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·59:38
How to verify: Check historical share price data for Eagle Eye (EYE) on the day of the AGM trading update release. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Paul Hill claims employees at SpaceX and Anthropic have accumulated millions in shares/cash which they are spending on luxury items like watches and cars.
Paul Hill ·1:22:45
How to verify: Check SpaceX and Anthropic employee compensation reports or press releases regarding equity vesting schedules and liquidity events; cross-reference with luxury retail sales data from Watches of Switzerland or LVMH. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify Thruvision's order book visibility and bridging finance terms via its latest interim report and investor presentations.
- Check Hays' recruitment volume trends and competitor guidance to assess the 'slow recovery' narrative.
- Review CML Microsystems' book-to-bill ratio and backlog details in their H1 results announcement.
- Analyze Tracsis' client retention rates and recurring revenue split in its latest annual report.
- Examine Gear4Music's inventory levels and same-store sales trends to validate the profit warning's severity.
- Confirm Zotefoams' customer concentration, particularly Nike's order pipeline, via its Q3 update.
- Assess James Cropper's PVT growth drivers and David Sterling's strategic plan from its H1 results.
- Check Pulsar's shareholder loan terms and equity fundraise results to evaluate balance sheet risk.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Ahead of every big idea, Staples Print helps Canadian businesses bring their brands to life with professional printing services that help you launch, promote, and grow. From posters and flyers to decals and menus. Staplesprint makes it easy to get your brand noticed with quality printing and support from local print experts. Shop online at staplesprint.ca or visit your nearest staples store with full service solutions to support all your business needs. Staples Business has your back. Find every business, there's Staples Business.
0:32Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): The Vox Markets Podcast. Nothing in this podcast is intended as investment advice, and the people in this podcast may hold positions in the stocks they talk about. Do not buy anything based solely on a tip or recommendation. Please do your own research.
0:45Paul Hill: Welcome back everyone to Vox Box Markets Live. My name is Paul Hill, and I'm delighted again to be able to speak to Equity Analysts analyst and stock markets commentator Paul Scott to discuss all things uh small caps. So uh big welcome, uh Paul.
0:57Paul Scott: Thanks, Paul, and hello to everyone. Great to be back. I hope you're not doing as badly as I am this week, that's for sure.
1:03Paul Hill: Yeah, it's been a pretty eventful week, hasn't it? Uh what
1:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): with
1:06Paul Hill: uh we've had mellow for two two days in the middle, which was fantastic meeting investors. Plus, we've had uh NVIDIA's uh quarterly results on. Tuesday, then the big IPO of the year, probably the biggest ever actually, with Anthropic last night, um 1.5 um trillion dollars. Um, have you do you see any link at all between because anthropic raised a hundred billion dollars? And it seems a bit coincidental that it that basically the markets have been pretty downbeat this week. Has it sucked any air out of you know you've seen the rotation, you've seen people putting some money, selling things to then put some money into at the margin, into anthropic. Because a hundred billion dollars isn't is isn't a small piece of change.
1:50Paul Scott: Yeah, it could be. I don't really know is the uh only honest art support. But I I just just anecdotally, amongst my um investing friends, I think quite a few now are are stagging these uh these big IPOs and pretty much selling on the open because it's uh well so far anyway it's been free money isn't it so uh but the but the spikes see up seem to be getting shorter and shorter and shorter, don't they? Uh but no I mean I I don't have a I don't have a huge view over that well I think this week particular we've really seen a return of nerves in in UK smaller small and mid-caps that's really what I mainly focus on. I do vaguely follow what's going on in America too, but we're definitely into a nervous patch this week. Obvious panic, uh distressed selling in some UK stocks. This is your time to get your cash to work, in my view, for things where there's nothing company specific. It's just dropped 10%, you know, for absolutely no reason, or more than 10% in some cases. This is the time to buy, isn't it?
2:49Paul Hill: Yeah, the most dangerous words. in the lot in the vocabulary are free money because uh it doesn't usually last very long, does it?
2:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So like
2:58Paul Hill: once once everybody gets onto that sort of like gold trade, it sort of like chugs out and and falls off the track. So
3:05Paul Scott: it's only a matter of time before one of these big IPOs in the US
3:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): flops,
3:08Paul Scott: isn't it? But there again Facebook flopped after its um IPO and was low for a long time afterwards and then it's something like Tempac. So, you know, who knows? As always, the market just keeps throwing random stuff at us, and we we're left flailing to try and work out what's going on.
3:23Paul Hill: Yeah. What was your take on Mello? The what the vibe for investors was it upbeat, downbeat, sort of neutral? How did you sort of read it? Because obviously you were there really at the cold phase for two days.
3:34Paul Scott: Yeah, I think um very mixed. Uh um I mean, we've had uh you know, we had Octo uh I think September, October, November were very, very good, weren't they? Certainly my portfolio was up until last Friday hitting um v you know significant new highs for the year, especially my trading account. Um I mean, you know, we we had a very, very good patch before you know in as I say in the lead up to mellow. And so generally people were pretty upbeat but that that uh certainly but by by Wednesday I certainly had people asking me, well, what do you think about this sell-off and everything? But I mean, to me, it's just normal market volatility. When you're in equities, you know they're gonna do this, you know, particularly the smaller, less liquid stuff. So um in macro terms, but guilt yields now seem to be, you know, settling a bit. Um, France is rapidly catching up with the UK and in the yield. So, you know, maybe a a Eurozone crisis is more likely than the UK. a UK crisis. You've got or the oil price coming down significantly, so that should neutralize some of the inflationary pressures. I I don't think there's a reason to panic personally at all. I I just take these these this volatility in my stride.
4:40Paul Hill: Yeah, no, I'm with you. I mean, it's obviously been pretty painful across the patch this week, but um I do think there's a bit of coincidence, there's a bit of linking at the margin. A hundred billion dollars is massive and um if
4:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): somebody's just
4:51Paul Hill: a bit nervous, people are basically reallocating funds, I think. And you probably find you probably find a lot of the a lot of the actual outflows have just been fund managers again, whether it's you know basically just having to sell to to reallocate out. But um anyway.
5:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, I mean the
5:06Paul Scott: redemptions, the small account redemptions thing is very much still a big issue. But this is what's providing us with the bargains, and of
5:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): course,
5:13Paul Scott: private equity and private buyers come in and just pick off these things one by one at big premiums. You know, it's an opportunity more than a more than a risk, I think, when things are just clearly underpriced. And I mean, we're I'm seeing lovely bargains again this week in particular, and this morning. You can think there's no reason anybody should be selling, say, likewise, you know, and there's two to three times upside on it if you're patient. I mean, stuff
5:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): like
5:38Paul Scott: that. I think that these are great buying opportunities, but selectively, obviously, not just across the board. Yeah.
5:44Paul Hill: Yeah. Okay, let's go on to some actual stocks. We've got two people actually asking about um we've got the ARB and we've also got Dieselhead asking about your views on um on through vision, which came out.
5:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yes.
5:57Paul Hill: Was Is it was its first half results this this morning?
6:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): First
6:00Paul Scott: half results. Firstly, the good bits. Uh well, I should discuss. disclose this is an oversized position for me. So I've had a particularly unpleasant morning, but never mind. You know, you
6:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it's it's full
6:09Paul Hill: scanners, isn't it, for sort of like uh
6:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): high scanners. High high
6:13Paul Hill: throughput sort of like areas, things like prisons and railway stations and border control.
6:19Paul Scott: Airports as well. Yeah. I mean And it's globally it's selling globally, it's got good sales momentum. It's a serial disappointer, but The track records terrible, and I'm not in any way going to gloss over that at all. But I bought it around between uh, well, I bought below a penny actually. My average buy price is about a penny because I could see the momentum was starting to improve. On the sales momentum has been excellent this year. They've won in particular a group of Asian airports where they're putting this stuff in. They've also won prison contracts. So you've got really it's only six million market. cap today. But um so the H1 figures were in line, the expectations. The full year outlook was also reiterated in line, but they need a big H2 waiting. But about half of what they need to achieve in H2 is already in the bag, already in the order book. So for bull, this is a glass half full or glass half empty stock, you know. And I like to give people both sets of uh uh views on this. So so for the bulls line. like me, you know, um the story's intact and uh quite quite exciting actually, and it's incredibly low market cap. For the Bears, it did uh the cash position has become a worry again. It did do um a fundraise last summer, I think. It's still got cash in the bank and no debt, very small, unutilised unutilized debt facilities. But in the detail, it did say today we're gonna going to need some short-term bridging on.
7:38financing in the next six months. So talking about loans, management say they think they can organize that. I believe that because it's such a you're not talking a big amount here because they've slashed the cash burn and the costs. It's genuinely just. And the balance sheet overall is fine. You know, the net current assets position is fine. So this is not a distressed Stressed financial position. I think it needs low single digits in bridging financing. um, which I think they'll be able to secure. So I'm personally not bothered about that, but I totally understand why, given the history, some other less risk-averse investors might be worried about that. And there was a going concern um
8:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
8:17Paul Scott: material uncertainty statement as well today. Again, not particularly surprising, but it uh particularly in in a in a weak wobbly market like this, I think you're gonna get some. relatively small-scale um panic selling, maybe, or people just wanted to bank their profits who bought near the lows. So I think you just for me personally, I'm not concerned. I think this is probably gonna be all right. But I do want to flag this is high risk, it's not for widows and orphans. So, you know, if you want to be able to sleep at night, don't follow me into this.
8:55Paul Hill: Neither
8:55Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): of us sleep very well. In fact, uh, I've been up for 10 hours already. This is uh this is
8:59Paul Hill: I've already done it.
9:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I've already done it, eh?
9:01Paul Hill: But just playing devil's advocate on uh through vision. If it was if it was easy to get financing, working basically they're asking for working capital financing, which should
9:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): be you know
9:12Paul Hill: trade finance. If it was easy to get, they wouldn't have to make an announcement. My only concern. My only concern is that they're gonna have to go to then outside the bank, basically. The bank's probably
9:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): said
9:27Paul Hill: and and what that means is that they're looking for, hoping for a they've got the order cover, I'm pretty sure, to hit this
9:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): big
9:34Paul Hill: second half. But without the financing, they're not gonna going be to able to deliver it. They can't because these are made to order products. They're not going to be able to buy the chips, the actual equipment, and do to fund the debtors. So
9:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): essentially, your
9:47Paul Hill: H2 depends on speedy getting it getting this agreement, this bridging finance quickly. Because remember, if you think about it, I think their year end is March. Is that right? Something like that.
9:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, so
9:59Paul Hill: they've got so basically they've got to basically pay their suppliers for the parts, they've got to put it together and then they've got to dil ship it and deliver it to the customer in the Far East before the 31st of Ma before the 31st of March. And
10:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I would
10:12Paul Hill: say if they haven't got funding, I I I I I I I think that you know, I mean I know it'll fall into 2027, it should do, but I think the only reason why they've uh you know basically erased it with you put it into the statement is that actually this is not a slam dunk. They will get it, but I think I actually think that's the biggest, I think the funding is the biggest danger for this second.
10:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh,
10:37Paul Scott: yeah, yeah, it always is with these types of shares, isn't it? But
10:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): as I
10:40Paul Scott: say, it's smallish amounts. Um, I think the funding, you're right, it won't come from banks, will it? Um, because they're not into risk lending. It'll come probably from major shareholders. But the question is what um and and probably from management as well, because the chairman's got quite a bit of skin in the game in this. You know, if he puts in say two or three hundred K, then goes to the major shareholders, which I think Pentland is one of them, they've got some quite noteworthy major shareholders. So yeah, I think they'll you know, million, million and a half is probably what we're
11:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): talking
11:07Paul Scott: about here. And when you've got such strong sales momentum and a bulging order book and a lot of potential, I personally uh don't see um a major risk of, say, for example, ruinous dilution. I mean, you know, it like we've seen that tends to happen where you know the the business is is just basically a basket case and no one wants to put money in, and and it's the lender of last resort, isn't it, who just names their price. So I'm hoping we can get through on this, but I fully accept the points you make and people are right to be a bit nervous about this because they should have got that funding thing buttoned up before putting this statement out. So yeah, that the there are risks, definitely, quite quite high risks. You know, I don't want to, I'm not in any way glossing over that. But there's also five-bagger potential, I think, if they hit the numbers and and then they reach breakeven neck. Do you know what I mean? So it's still,
12:00Paul Hill: yeah. Yeah. So
12:02Paul Scott: but very high remote. reward if this and and they're very, very positive signs, as I say, from the order intake. And it's a genuinely brilliant product.
12:09Paul Hill: Yeah. It's like it's like going it's like betting on the Grand National, isn't it? Rather than go for the favourite at seven
12:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
12:16Paul Hill: seven to one. You go you go for the fifty to one shot who's coming up on the rail, you know.
12:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
12:21Paul Scott: I don't see
12:23Paul Hill: No,
12:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
12:24Paul Scott: wouldn't. I don't think that's a very good innovation. inner.
12:26Paul Hill: Okay, yeah.
12:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): no,
12:27Paul Hill: I'm probably pulling your leg there. Okay, let's go to uh we got much better news at a massive profit upgrade. Peter asking about recruitment company Hayes this week, which
12:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): frankly
12:36Paul Hill: took the market just absolutely by surprise, uh upgraded its profit expectations considerably. And I think even after a recent bounce, the shares absolutely just rocketed. So, um, what was your take on this one and whether we have actually had have now reached a major turning point for the recruiters?
12:55Paul Scott: I think it's definitely green shoots, isn't it, for sure? But I've been looking, I mean, this we flagged pre 8 a.m. on the day of the announcement and said this is the one to look at. Something exciting's happening here. So for people who bought, you know, on the opening bell or something, I know things gap up, but it just carried on rising. End of the day up forty 40 odd percent or something. about like that i think um uh oh uh oh i mean um yeah that's right
13:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that's right yeah
13:21Paul Hill: that's the share the share price is in green so it went down went down to about i don't know i
13:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): think
13:25Paul Hill: cottony rebel bought it at about 30p and then it it spiked up to 75 went
13:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): down to
13:30Paul Hill: 55 and has come back all up to 75
13:33Paul Scott: Coop the whole a lot in one day didn't it no
13:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): i mean
13:35Paul Scott: this was a really really good update
13:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): no
13:36Paul Scott: doubt about that but a lot of it is cost cost-cutting cutting as well Remember, they're stripping out a ton of costs. Um, but they said um H1 operating profit will be at least um 35 million. This is haze, isn't it? We're talking about
13:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yes, haze,
13:50Paul Hill: yeah.
13:50Paul Scott: Yeah. Um materially above current consensus, but it needs to be because of course the forecasts, you know, uh on the existing forecast, the PE was over 30, so it had to. produce uh significantly ahead, which it did. So I think this is very is positive for the sector. But I've been looking at some of the others, and I think there's too much um there's too much built into the prices now, you know, because we've heard from a couple of uh CEOs in the sector, they're saying don't expect a V shape recovery, you know, in in staffing. This is going to be slow and gradual.
14:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
14:26Paul Scott: for me, I think maybe I certainly wouldn't be buying now. Um, is all I'm saying. Um, I think I've
14:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I've
14:33Paul Scott: I did catch a bit of a move on one of these things. I think it was S3 that I caught a nice little profit on, but I just banked it and I want to wait and see because as I say, I don't see um a V shape recovery here, but they are super operationally geared. That is the the upside case. So I can I I understand. the ball case. Yeah.
14:52Paul Hill: Yeah, it seemed to be um, I think it was Germany, wasn't it, which is their biggest market,
14:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): sort of
14:56Paul Hill: like um overperforming. Um, but you're right on valuation, I would be the same because you know I've put the new numbers in the revised figures, and it's sort of like you know, oh well over 20 times PE, which already bakes in huge improvement, doesn't it?
15:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
15:10Paul Hill: um
15:10Paul Scott: obviously
15:11Paul Hill: people have got very excited. Okay, okay, good. Let's go. to another one which came out with an upgrade on Monday. We got CML Microsystems.
15:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): John John John
15:20Paul Hill: Jackson was asking about it last week. Um they came out with I think was it first half results? I I can't remember. So or four year results, but uh positive statements and seeing growth across the across the patch. These guys basically do low power communication chips that go into quite niche applications. Um, but um, they seem to be doing pretty well. What was your take?
15:42Paul Scott: Yeah, very relieved. Um, this is one of my holdings. It's a nice mix of a value share and a garb, growth at reasonable price share. So H1 revenue was nicely up 34%. Um, and it moved back into profit after an H1 loss Lost last year. Not very much, only uh a quarter of a million quid. Um, but uh it the yeah, the outlook was good for March twenty-seven. Uh it said, quote, likely to result in a year-end outcome ahead of current market expectations. Um it's it's a nice um, as I say, you've got a lovely net cash balance sheet. About 20% of the market cap is net cash, genuine net cash, not not just a timing effect. I think it owns the freehold of the business park where it works, and it's been developing that and subletting and selling bits of that. So I think speculative upside on this one, but but copper bottomed balance sheet. And I like situations like that. Um we're talking to management later today, which I'm really looking forward to, because also the chips that it designs seem to be in pretty hot sectors. So can I pass the bat on over to you, Paul? Because you know more about the tech than. I do.
16:51Paul Hill: Yeah, I I just on the um on the balance sheet, it's got about eleven million pounds of cash. But I think some of that w they sold their spare surplus property, I think. So um when it comes to some of the parts you add the cash and you add obviously the underlying chip business. But but essentially what the this these um silicon wafers, what do they they're basically designed for customers in things like aerospace and defence. defense, um geospatial satellites, um, 5G backhaul, um all kinds of different sort of like, you know, low digital radios where there's a where there's a real requirement for low power but very fast or or fast uh community sort of cations. And they've had a couple of headwinds wins r over the last few years in fact industry de des stocking in certainly for for things like Internet of Things. But now and that trading update, which I thought was fab, where they had their built book to bill ratio was well above one, they said they didn't actually specify how much it was. And it was confident looking forward. So I think they're going to basically do what you know
17:52they're they've upgraded or their brokers upgraded, but I actually think they will Well, they've underpromised and they'll exceed going forward and they've got a wind in their sales. sails. And uh
18:01Paul Scott: we'll
18:02Paul Hill: wait let's wait let's wait and see. But I mean, I when it comes to valuation, I can't see any less than four pounds eighty compared to about 330 at the moment. And then it is a fairly illiquid stock, no doubt,
18:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): about
18:13Paul Hill: it to buy. But I wouldn't be surprised if somebody puts a bid on these kind of guys because uh it's really
18:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): quite
18:19Paul Hill: interesting technology they have. And in fact, facts the th th the the trading update or the results impressed me so much. I I topped up my position because I'm a holder as well. this week. So I've added to my um but uh but I like it and I I I I'm with you. It's a very solid underlying you know, balance sheet business with very interesting technology in some pretty damn good areas, like uh obviously you know, uh satellites, aerospace, and defense, drones particularly, um whether that's aerial or whether it's it's sub, you know, basically on the land or or even I don't know whether they do any sort of like um submarine type ones as well. But um
18:56Paul Scott: well that was one of the things that attracted me to this share. I mean, I followed it for donkeys years, it's been around a long time. And you had, say, for example, in Encylica, which is another chip designer, which has no history of profits, um, and the market jumped on it and took the share, doubled the price of the shares because they're doing chip design in hot. sectors. Well, so is CML, which has a much longer history and of certainly profitability, good profitability most years. Um so I think I just think it's off people's radar, CML. And I'm hoping it might suddenly, you know, people might jump on it and say, oh, actually, this thing's in really exciting areas too, but it's completely overlooked. So that's my I'm kind. kind. of thinking half my position might be a trade for a sudden, you know, sentiment driven upside. And the other half probably long term.
19:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): No, don't say trade. This
19:49Paul Hill: is not a trade. This is basically let the be patient, let this one go. I mean, I I would I could actually see if they overachieve, which I'm we'll wait let and see what they say, but I think this I think this could easily double from current. levels without
20:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that's
20:04Paul Scott: what I'm saying I think
20:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
20:05Paul Scott: could as well I think fifty to a hundred percent upside I'd happily chop out half and run the balance that's that's what I meant but uh
20:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): no run it
20:13Paul Hill: run it
20:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): run it
20:14Paul Scott: Paul you don't like that do you
20:15Paul Hill: no I don't I will well I've running mine I can tell you because I think they're they've they're basically haven't um you know they've been lagging the market in chips for for ages and now
20:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yes
20:24Paul Hill: and now they're hitting their strides and I think there's lots and lots of potential. I don't want to overplay this, okay, because it's been hasn't gone much for the last three years, but uh
20:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they
20:33Paul Hill: had they had got they they bought a company out in California, right?
20:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
20:37Paul Hill: there was a gig there was a guy who owned it who already who who basically swapped some of his um stake into shares. He's done it twice. Uh it's basically the the debt he got, the loan notes. And rather than actually getting the loan notes, he basically he's bought shares twice and it's we're talking multi-million.
20:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So you know
20:55Paul Hill: I mean
20:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): somebody
20:56Paul Hill: who knows it is on the board has been buying shares now you know that's got to be a good sign to me. He's been increasing his position. But um anyway
21:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah
21:03Paul Scott: no we both like it that's uh that's that's good. Let's hope we uh we're we're right. Yeah
21:08Paul Hill: I know yeah okay another one which I think we both like Ben Sharman's asking about uh Traxis Traxxis that came out with uh was it results this week? Uh prelims,
21:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I think.
21:17Paul Hill: Um
21:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): all in they
21:19Paul Hill: kept yeah, these guys are all tech specialists in software, hardware. They've got sort of two divisions. They may basically do software for the train operating companies. That's the front front office and the back office. So things like train scheduling, staff rotor management. They also do software for rail. uh network rail, sort of like doing um maintenance safety planning. Um, they do the signalling um communications as well. So they've got lots of fingers implies in rail tech and they do sort of like um they do data analytics and stuff like that. Anyway, what was your take on it? Because they've they've sort of really changed, they've sold their old events business and then they've they doubled up on the software by buying um a business called. Mr. Oll on the um front office um for the train operating companies for 48 million quid.
22:09Paul Scott: Yeah, it was a substantial acquisition, wasn't it? I feel sorry for management here because they've done everything that the market and investors asked them to do. They've got rid of the you know the lower margin um diversified stuff, they've focused on their core activities, they made a big acquisition, and the market's given giving them absolutely no credit for it whatsoever. So we're scratching our heads. I mean, we concluded this was yesterday actually on Share Ideas. My my colleague Dave looked at it and he we've concluded it's on a forward PE of 11.6 times, which um for a quality um software business with very high client retention and high margins and whatever, we just we just don't understand why the market is pricing this. so low. But the shares, I think the market's just fallen out of love with it. It was a highly rated growth stock a few years ago. I think it's now just seen as a bit of a backwater dead-end stock, which I think is unfair. I think um I think this is um I think it's a nice stock. I don't own any any personally, but I certainly um think it's you know it's on my watch list for something to maybe maybe this is another one. where drip drip selling from for small cap redemptions could be holding it back. I don't know.
23:21Paul Hill: Yeah, I mean I I own the stock I before the results and I topped up as well after yesterday's um numbers and I spoke to the actual management and I spoke to the management team and they're pretty confident that uh But this rails rail software technology business, it's only gone through a bit of a hiatus because of this creation of the Great British Railway, which has mean there's been lack of investment capital in the in expansion and in improvement. There's only been sort of like just maintenance capital, which has put the whole industry under a bit of a bind over the last three years. But that's gonna catch up, okay? Um, you know, in order flow, and that should start next year. But regardless of that, this business should be able to do double-digit double digit top line growth and 25% e-bit dar margins, which says to me that it will be valued at 12, 14 times e bit da and probably about three times sales. And so it's absolutely masses to go at. And this data analytics has got some good geospatial geolocation stuff that also is has got has got synergies with the train side of it in terms of doing vegetation and and um track, you know. sort of clearance and this sort of and track repairs. So quite an interesting little business there as well. They've got a bit of debt to pay off, but actually, I mean, I can't I think even at five quid it's flipping cheap. And we've all we've seen this movie before because
24:41Cordell got bought out by Voslo of Germany on six-time sales, and these guys are trading
24:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): less
24:47Paul Hill: than less than two time sales. So I I and that and it's a better business. than than than Caudle because Cordle wasn't actually profitable at the time. So I think that they've done exactly the right thing. As you rightly say, they haven't actually been rewarded at all by the market. And I can and I can see this is going to be an area where people are gonna are going to try and get in, certainly over the next 12 months. I mean, they are now the number one software provider or technology provider into the UK. uh train operating companies. Okay.
25:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): They're
25:17Paul Hill: ahead of Hitachi and also uh Siemens. So they so when they so when it comes to actually the formation and deciding who to use as your software supplier, you know, by Great British Rail, well, they're going to migrate to the biggest and the best sort of like solution providers. And and then then the other opportunity is lift lifting and shifting their technology into the state. states where they're hoping to win one or two contracts a year. Plus going into places like Germany where they've already got a beachhead. And and just remember I mean you know we're still getting a lot and foot tragically a lot of rail accidents. We had two on the same high speed railway line in Spain. Now I you know I asked the guys you know I know it's not your sort of like your area you'd go into in in a country wise, but you know is it is it something that they could do could benefit from your software? And they said absolutely. And you know, they'll be they'll be looking at potential channel partners to access opportunities around the world, particularly where the safety has been, you know, is not is not up to where it should be. So I'm very happy that I've got a position and I as I say, there it's not it's again it's quite illiquid. Liquid. So I I added a you know a few couple of thousand shares and stuff like that um yesterday. yesterday. But um I'm holding it. It's uh to me that's the it's the same sort of thing as CML. It's uh buy it, hold it, and let it and let it run for two or three years and see where we get to.
26:36Paul Scott: Yeah, I agree with all of that. I mean it's not currently in my portfolio, but I'm back on a heavy margin call now, so I've had to stop buying and had to actually start trimming a few positions to to reduce the margin call, unfortunately. Um, but yeah, I think track. Traxis uh I was at a city event not long ago, and somebody asked me about Traxis, and I said we think it's very good. And they kind of the mood amongst the brokers seemed to be it's not actually very good business. And I well, we think it is. You've
27:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): got
27:05Paul Scott: these incredibly sticky clients. And I remember from one of our Zooms with Manafram, Matter from because we've had several over the years, they were saying that the the the whole regulation. regulatory and the trade union, and you've got decades and decades of complexity where things have been changed constantly. So to replicate that
27:24Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): track
27:25Paul Scott: software from scratch would be nigh on impossible. Um so these are very, very embedded because of that That's very high level of history and complexity. Um so yeah, I like it. I think it's unreasonably cheap. Yeah.
27:40Paul Hill: Yeah. And also with with Great British Railway, they they have announced they are doing their own sort of front-end website to replace train line for the ticketing, etc. That
27:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is
27:50Paul Hill: absolutely that is absolutely nothing what Traxxas does. It doesn't do any of that. But what it does underneath that that website, it does all the tap as you go software that hasn't basically is going to be rolled out next year to all of the regional. rail railways. And that should just
28:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): be
28:04Paul Hill: pure sort of 80-90% sort of profit. So it absolutely isn't in competition with Great British Railway. But but obviously people like Train Line Ars. I just think people don't understand the business, but it's a matter of time before you start seeing those results. And I asked them also To what visibility is like, and you know, with the estimates, and uh they've got now 45%. our recurring revenue, software recurring revenue streams um out of that at 75 million or 76 million of um of revenues. And I think they're just they're they're basic it's like you know, I got the impression basically again it's an underpromise, over deliver. They hope to they're that the the worst they hope to meet, put it that way, for this year. Um, and if we
28:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): do
28:46Paul Hill: get a series of upgrades, it it brings it sucks people in. The thing is, a lot of fund managers, because it's illiquid like CML, can't get into it because it's
28:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): frankly
28:54Paul Hill: difficult to buy chunks of chunks of stock. It really is.
28:58Paul Scott: Yeah, no, all very sensible, I think, Paul. So I've I think this is one definitely for a watch list. You just wait to drift down because the dribble of sellers, you know, what what what I personally wouldn't do is sort of buy on a spike up. I'd
29:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): just
29:11Paul Scott: wait to to to carry on coming down and hope that nobody puts a bid on it while I'm waiting.
29:16Paul Hill: Yeah. Well, unfortunately, along with some uh upgrades and some good results like Hayes and uh CML, we've had a flurry, unfortunately, of profit warnings this year, sorry, this week, and uh none worse, unfortunately, than uh CT automotive. And we've got Michael asking about
29:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.
29:33Paul Hill: Basically, these guys do interiors and stuff like that. It was always cheap, but it was cheap for a reason, and we found out why. What was your take on it?
29:41Paul Scott: Well, I I I cut the cord on this one on the last profit warning. I think this is now the fourth profit warning. Um, I've completely lost confidence in management here, their ability to uh forecast. Uh so I mean I'm sorry that I was uh apologize to everyone for being uh bullish on this because I got I just got it wrong. Um I think it's a good lesson for me or a reminder, really, that when you get a P of two or three times forecasts on a nanocap, it's probably the forecasts that are wrong, not the valuation. Uh so I'm not gonna go after any of these two and three P things anymore. It just It just doesn't work. Um, very tough sector, obviously, and they're also telling us this week. which was the killer blow, really, that they're financially distressed effectively. They're um they're in problems, they've got problems with their working capital. Uh they can't forecast, they've got no idea what profit they're going to make, is this is now completely clear. And they're supplying into they've got these cost down contracts where they have to re actually they've agreed up front to lower the price, the selling price to the customer. Uh All this AI stuff that the CEO was spouting, I think, is garbage. So I'm afraid I just don't trust them. And I'm I've c I won't be investing in this again at at
31:01any price.
31:02Paul Hill: Yeah. Yeah, and I mean it's that classic sort of like um filter on quality first before price before.
31:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): No, you're absolutely
31:09Paul Scott: right. You've always said that and you you're right. So
31:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): lesson
31:12Paul Scott: learned for for for me, definitely.
31:14Paul Hill: Okay, let's go to another one. We've got um Robert asking about TriFast, these sort of fasteners and screws and bolts
31:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): business
31:21Paul Hill: that supplies again, unfortunately, to I think it's about thirty, forty percent into the automotive sector. They've seen a bit of um extra competition from China, I think, in sort of appliances, plus obviously automotive has been um pretty slow and they've had higher sort of energy costs and uh other incost costs and stuff like that. Came out with a bit of a profit warning, shares were down. What was your take?
31:42Paul Scott: I was very disappointed with this because Trifast, um, I mean, the Harvard guys, Nick Mills is on the board, and this was his top stop for the year. So I was expecting better things of it. And it was, we had a very good Zoom with management, where it was uh a successful turnaround over the last couple of years, where they've been gradually increasing that operating margin. So this really came out of the blue. Profit was up 10%, but they then said they've set a profit warning, they've seen a further softening in demand, and they've lowered the uh operating profit guidance quite a lot from 19 million to 14 and a quarter million at the midpoint. And Zeus dropped its earnings forecast by 35%. This is for the March 27 year end. So they seem to have really hit a bit of a brick wall, don't they? Umft automotive demand and disruptions in Saudi Arabia. I don't know
32:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what
32:39Paul Scott: that's about. So, no, very disappointing, I think. It looks like a hefty profit miss, which has kind of undermined the bull case, I think, on this.
32:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
32:48Paul Hill: it was quite interesting actually afterwards. I think Richard. Staveley has bought some shares and it's he's out was added to position. Yeah, I think so. I mean it it is it is cheap, but it isn't, you know, massively cheap, is it? In fact, um I was just looking at the um is it seven.
33:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, it looks price
33:05Paul Scott: about right from your um subject.
33:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
33:07Paul Hill: yeah, yeah. Yeah. No, I was just wondering whether I'll they'll just take that down. I I don't think it's um for some reason it was picking up uh oh it is the current sh share price. is 70p, isn't it? Yeah, that is right. It is right. Yeah, it looks about right to me, but hey ho, wait and
33:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): see. I
33:19Paul Scott: mean I'm sure they'll get through this, but it's just uh I didn't find the explan explanations particularly convincing. Um
33:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
33:28Paul Scott: I mean I suppose it's only given back the the the rally that started in July, isn't it? It's back to where it was priced um in the first half of this calendar year. So I mean, very disappointing for holders. Yeah, it came a little bit out of the blue as well, that one. So bad luck to to any holders. I don't think you people should particularly beat themselves up over this one. This was a little bit of a of a surprise profit warning, I thought.
33:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
33:53Paul Hill: okay. All right, let's go to private label uh producer. We've got Greg asking about McBride. Basically, these guys do sort of cleaners and deodorants deodorant to all the big supermarkets around uh Europe. They came out with a second profit warning, actually. Um and it was basically uh due to higher energy costs, not being able to pass it on to the big supermarkets. Um what was your take?
34:17Paul Scott: I'm a bit more forgiving on this one because i in a way this probably shouldn't have surprised people because we already knew and we've seen before that the business BIS McBride uses a lot of petroleum-based products. So and then they have a three-month lag before they can recover loss margins from customer price rises. So that is a known factor. So the fact and we've heard this from them before. So the fact that But um I'm actually quite forgiving on this one because we knew that was um uh uh uh uh an element with McBride. And they can they then go back to the supermarket to say, well, isn't he said it was a three-month negotiation, didn't he, when we when we talked about this with the CEO. So this should be a temporary factor. So squeeze on their margins, three months' time, the margins should be coming back up. Then, of course, I mean the oil price has been falling quite a lot lately. So you'll then get a recoup period where the higher selling prices are potentially. pertaining, but the input co input costs are dropping. So I could see a three-month benefit um uh for McBride, the other side of this. So I'm actually quite forgiving of this. I'm staying, I'm I've retained my four out of five star uh view of McBride. And I think you know, if it was on your watch list as of something you
35:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): want
35:35Paul Scott: to buy, a fairly predictable and short-term short term uh um profit warning, you know, for something fixable and not completely out of the blue, could be providing you with a a reasonable entry point. So yeah, this one I'm quite forgiving on. Uh what
35:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what's
35:49Paul Scott: your take, Paul?
35:50Paul Hill: Yeah, I mean it I w I would say of clearly their results depend on commodities, okay, as we've just seen and the timing of that. And it cut the key investment question comes down to how sustainable is their eBit margins? Can after three-month lag, can they maintain that six and seven percent EBIT margin um and pass that cot that price, that cost inflation on to the customers and and keep
36:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
36:14Paul Hill: going? And and the answer to that is I I I don't know. I still don't, I still not 100% convinced. I mean, we spoke to the CEO many a time and he's absolutely convinced he can do that. But uh, I mean, I used to work in the industry and into to you know. for brands, and um these you know, a lot of the private labels used to be up the vo the margins used to be up and down like anything. Admittedly, they have got some tailwinds because they are doing more sort of like uh contract manufacturing for the brands. They that that old wreck it Ben Kezer business, I think it was Vestacy they bought, they basically are doing that big production for. And I did see just overnight. Proctor and Gamble deciding to reduce their work, their their manufacturing workforce and logistic workforce, but I think it was 40% or 25%. It was an enormous number anyway, which means they're probably going to lean more on the guys to outsource, like Wreck at Ben Keyser. So they have got a tailwind Whirlwind behind them, this industry. But does it mean they've, you know, that basically the industry's industry very is tight and they can push those costs on? Well, we'll wait and see, I guess, to a certain extent.
37:19Paul Scott: Yeah, I mean that that's an interesting point because that was always my reservation. I missed
37:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the bit the
37:24Paul Scott: huge rally in in uh McBride um that happened previously because I wasn't sure they could maintain the six-seven percent operating margins. That was always my fear that the that the supermarkets would just erode those margins away. Um, but management did. I think convince me that uh the margins were sustainable but here we see that actually in the short term anyway they're not. It also did mention some own goals. It said something about operational challenges which is not a macro factor is it? I didn't read all the detail but I think this um yeah it the the sheen has come off this a bit but on balance I think I'm probably prepared to give them the benefit of the doubt. You know, I've been certainly more willing to buy now at one pound thirty than when it was knocking on the door at two quid.
38:13Paul Hill: Okay, good. We've still got lots of profit warnings unfortunately. We got
38:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Kate
38:17Paul Hill: asking about flow tech fluid power. These guys are specialist distributor in hydraulics and pneumatic parts. Um and they've had a really tough period. I think again they've had sort of delays and stuff like that. What was your take? The shares now are really back to their all-time lows, I
38:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): think.
38:36Paul Scott: Yeah, I don't like this one. I've never been convinced by this this company. I've followed it since it floated. It seems to be permanently restructuring and attempting a turnaround. And
38:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
38:48Paul Scott: know, there comes a point where you have to ask the question is this the thing actually any good? You know, um, they've done acquisitions, but they don't seem to have added value. Um, I should add, one of my colleagues, one of my co-writers, is much more bullish on it than me. And he does proper deep dives on things. So he says he reckons I'm missing something on flow tech fluid power. But for me, um no, I mean it just doesn't pass that basic requirement that I usually have. for things I want to invest in of being, you know, a good business model with a moat. I just don't see that it does. And it's a it's embarked on these large bridge projects, which is completely different to um supplying, you know, pneumatic hoses and things and tens of thousands of SKUs. So I don't understand why it's branched out into doing these bridge uh complex large bridges. bridge repair contracts, you know, for all the hydraulic rams and things. I think it's a lifting bridge in Ireland or something. And of course they've had weather delays on it.
39:48I just uh I I personally I don't like it, but I don't want to set off my co-writer Dave because he uh gets upset with me when so it's not a we have differences of opinion within my team, let's just say.
40:00Paul Hill: Yeah, I mean I you know, they're both of just a just they are a distributor a bit like trifast okay and to be a good distributor you've got to have really rapid stock turns and the
40:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and the
40:11Paul Hill: sort of the killy's heel for trifast is that effectively it has to hold a lot of slow moving stock right
40:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): for its
40:19Paul Hill: customers okay and with likewise with fl flu with fluid uh flow tech fluid power it has a big inventory you know big stock listing listings. And I think that
40:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): again
40:28Paul Hill: has to it has to hold a lot of stuff that frankly, you know, just as on an emergency for its customers for that goodwill. And that means they've got pr fairly inefficient balance sheets. And the other s thing that, you know, the other side of the coin, which I've never really been comfortable in, you know, all the action in the world is on electrification. It's actually on building data centers and powering up with electrics. It's not pneumatic. pneumatics and hydraulics, it's not air compression or water compression. It's it's but it's
40:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): elect
40:56Paul Hill: it's electrics, you know. So they're in to me, they're in not in the growth, the growth area. If they're a distributed electrical parts, the likes of TT electronics, RS, um maybe even you know, solid state and these kind of guys, then I'd say they're in the right places, you know. It's obviously things like aerospace and defense defence and putting rugged electronics together. But I mean, you know, pneumatic, I mean I don't I just I it all depends on GDP. You know, it all comes down to, you know, are you going to sell more air compressed valves and you know hydraulic systems? And the answer to that is well probably not. I don't know. You know, I mean it's
41:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): not electric anyway. I mean
41:34Paul Scott: all all the diggers though digging up the sites and building the data centers use hydraulics. don't they? But I mean I've just looked at the balance sheet while you were talking, Paul, and the last annual cost of sales was 71 grand, uh 71 million, and the inventories are 31 million. So
41:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that is
41:50Paul Scott: what five months plus inventory cost. So that yeah, you're right. Also, the risk is with this type of business that you end up being a bank for your customers. So
41:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you have a
41:59Paul Scott: one great load of receivables and they take ninety 90 or a hundred 120 and twenty days. days. So you're you're right. I mean, it's got very clear uh yeah, balance sheet optically looks okay, but it's a there's a lot tied up in working capital for sure.
42:11Paul Hill: Yeah. Okay, good. We got a fifth and final profit one in thank God. We got Mary asking about gear for music. Uh these guys are online uh musical instrument providers
42:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and sellers.
42:22Paul Hill: They'd been doing pretty well, but that's it's a lot of their competitors had had gone busted. I
42:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): think
42:26Paul Hill: they'd bought. the stock from one of their competitors a few bit we uh years back and done very well. Anyway, they came out with a pretty brutal profit warning ahead ahead of the Christmas period where they said like for like sales had decreased I think by less by more than ten percent. Anyway, what was your take on it?
42:42Paul Scott: I was really disappointed with this. I thought oh it's finally come good you know they're they're performing well with after a a long um is was this share but I've I've I've I've got a soft spot for it because it paid for my penthouse in Bournemouth. I eight or nine bagged on it and and I I sold them and bought a bought a penthouse. So uh I got a picture of the founder CEO behind my front door so on the wall. So I do um but no, this was a terrible update. H1 results were poor, profit uh plunged down 63% to onium. only a million pounds in H1, but it does have an H2 waiting for um grandparents who want to antagonize their children, buying the grandkids um drum kits and and clarinets and recorders and things. But um yeah, so no, this was a really bad profit warning. And they they talk about eBit DAR, but it's one of those companies where there's a gulf between eBit eBITDAR DAR and PBT. So Progressive, um who are commissioned. research of course, dropped the earnings forecast by 80, 80, 80% to only 4P. So I think this really calls into question the whole business model. And I think it's starting to look as you alluded to that the the big surge in profitability over the last year or two
43:56probably was one off in nature from the them you know competitors exiting the market and get and so losing a competition and gear for music, buying the stock cheap and making exceptional profit, as in you know, not to be repeated profits. So I think it calls into question the whole thing. I'm sorry to say. Um
44:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they
44:14Paul Hill: were
44:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): saying
44:15Paul Hill: they were saying in the thing in their statement that they hadn't got their um at you know their marketing right, their promotional spend online because they'd got the wrong side of all of those this changes in search, you know, from basically doing A AI
44:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): AI
44:28Paul Hill: answers rather than um normal Google search and stuff
44:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): like that. And 'cause
44:33Paul Hill: they spend a lot. I mean, the other the other side is that is that going to impact other people in sort of like, you know, who have total online models? People like, I don't know, Victoria Plum, you know, plumbing, you know,
44:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that they're
44:43Paul Hill: because I think they spend like forty, fifty 50% percent of their revenues just on marketing and bringing people to the website to then send out the actual you know bathroom fittings and stuff. I I would just be I would be cautious because I don't think this is the I think this is the canary in the coal mine. I think uh you know, unless they were just they got their marketing director was just totally off key, which I don't believe. I think they're probably pretty astute. I think you'll probably see some other heavy online models also taking a bit of a bath on this.
45:10Paul Scott: You could be right, yeah. I mean
45:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that's
45:12Paul Scott: above my pay grade, really. But I mean I should add. one of my team, Dave, is a semi-professional musician as well. And he says, I don't get it. He's consistently said that uh over the last two years, he's been part of my team. Uh, I always get him, I often get him to look at gear for music because he knows the sector. He just said it's got no competitive advantage. He doesn't understand why people buy gear from them. Uh, as you know, he's saying that as a musician musician himself. I did say maybe it's the next day delivery. He said, well that's not not that important. If I'm buying a high end guitar, you know, I don't care if it's going to take three or four days to arrive from Toma in in Germany or whatever. But I think maybe for smaller items, a lot of things when you order online if if if you're not an expert and you need a specific model, you do want it straight away, don't you really? I mean I I I I I don't know. It's um I think really the business model has has is now a lot more questionable than it was a week ago. So although the shares have dropped a hell of a lot, um I kind of think based
46:12on what they've told us that's justified, I'm afraid I'm sorry to say.
46:16Paul Hill: Yeah, and hey, they're doing another moment of truth heading into the Christmas period, isn't it? Because uh unless
46:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
46:21Paul Hill: actually can make you know it's supposed to be your biggest three month sales and uh they've just had a bit of a hiccup, so they've got to turn their marketing round very, very quickly. Um and um is it they're under the black they're under the uh or behind the black ball, aren't they? That's pretty tough uh snooker they've got there. But anyway.
46:38Paul Scott: Yeah, it's a tough one, isn't it? Definitely. Yeah.
46:41Paul Hill: Okay, we've got Clark Sean asking about the insolvency groups. Uh we had FRP uh coming out with um some numbers today, I think. Um what was your take on the what's your take on the insolvency industry in the UK? There's there's uh Bigbees trainer BTG as well.
46:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
46:57Paul Scott: Begbeys, I think, announced yesterday or the day before, I think, and FRP announced today. All in line with FRP. I didn't actually look at it. My colleague John, my other co-writer, he looked at this one this morning. Um we like the balance sheet at FRP. It actually had net cash at December 26. twenty six. Um uh it it it it's got costs, it did mention cost pressures, pay rises, debt servicing costs, supply energy, um suppliers and whatnot, but on track to meet the fuller expectations. I mean, these insolvency practitioners are counter cyclical, so obviously they benefit when um more more companies are going bust and they're dirt cheap at the moment. I mean, FLP is only on nine 9.7 point seven times PE. and you get a 5% yield. So I think it's really, really good, green. But John did flag to me in our chat room this morning, pre-market open, he said there's some stuff in the commentary that's making me a bit nervous here. Apparently, they took the FLP was talking about AI disruption. So that is something I haven't looked at it, but I'm just flagging it to the audience. Maybe that's something you want might want to check out. Maybe this is why they're cheap. And Begpeas, again, looks dirt cheap, really does. Similar sort of valuation. Um, so no, uh they're counter-cyclical, which if you're gloomy about the economy, you might like. So I can't, yeah, I think I think they're cheap, both
48:17of them.
48:18Paul Hill: Yeah, I I would be hesitant in terms of the you know the AI play here because it's the AI is moving on so much. If you're in a professional white white-collar collar. services uh group providing into corporates, you're going to get massive heat over the next two, three years on pricing. And if you've been able to charge on a on a you know a daily rate beforehand, well, good luck with that next time because uh you know you you basically you've got to you'll be your your competitors who are putting in AI, etc., et cetera, will be able to take out a shed load of costs. We've already started seeing it in all. audit. I just don't, I think we're going to see it in insolvency as well. So if
48:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you're a bank,
48:55Paul Hill: if you're a bank, you have to go to an insolvency practitioner.
48:59Paul Scott: But
48:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
48:59Paul Hill: just basically play each one off, all the financial all the insolvency practices, you just play one off against the other. Who's going to reduce their fees? Because they can do it. They should be able to, if they've got their AI, they should be able to cut out a shed shed load of lower level work. Just keep the
49:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): top guy guys to
49:12Paul Hill: are signing
49:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): off.
49:13Paul Scott: I take your point, Paul. and I don't know what the future holds, obviously, but I'm a little bit skeptical about that because the insolvency practitioners market is really stitched up with by a very small number of people. It's incredibly difficult to qualify, and that is deliberate. They make the exams almost impossible to pass, so that there's only a small number of qualified insolvency practitioners who can charge extortionate fees. So it's a bit of a closed shop, maybe even um, you know, price. No, I shouldn't say that, should I? They'll sue me. But uh no, but
49:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): there's a lot of
49:48Paul Hill: there's a lot of insolvency. I mean, all the accountancy boys, the E and Ys, PWCs, Deloitte, all these guys doing solvency. They've all
49:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah, but
49:56Paul Scott: very few but actual natural partners. That's the thing. They keep that so restricted so that they can charge they own about a million pounds per. partner or something.
50:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): No, I know,
50:04Paul Hill: and they
50:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): can still do
50:05Paul Scott: they'll
50:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): strip
50:05Paul Scott: out costs and they'll pay themselves more. I don't know that the banks actually are that uh negotiate much on fees um because banks are notoriously I mean if they've got a security all they want is to get their their money back and they don't really give a damn about the fees, I think.
50:21Paul Hill: Yeah, I don't know. I mean I okay that's a leap of faith. I would say if you've if you can basically improve the efficiency of that whole process, you keep the partner, he takes home his million, but you take out a shed load of the you know the the grunt work associated with insolvency, stock takes and all that kind of stuff, then then frankly the the actual figure the the the amount of income coming to the company is going to gonna go down. So I I'm I'm with what um FRP
50:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): said
50:49Paul Hill: today.
50:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But Actually
50:50Paul Hill: I I could see I could see them being some disintermediation with AI because it's it's happening all round in white collar. All around.
50:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I don't
50:58Paul Scott: think it will be disintermediation. I think it'll be a productivity tool that they can um that'll flatten their profit margins even further. So I don't know. We'll see. But I
51:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): bet
51:08Paul Scott: you they'll maintain their profit margins one way or another.
51:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): No
51:11Paul Hill: I think they'll maintain the profit margins but the actual amount of money paid will be less. So rather
51:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): than
51:17Paul Hill: paying
51:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): them
51:18Paul Hill: 50 million quid, they'll pay them 25 million quid. Just because they the the efficiency's taken out so much cost.
51:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I don't
51:25Paul Hill: know.
51:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Anyway we'll
51:27Paul Scott: have to wait
51:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
51:27Paul Scott: see. We don't know do
51:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): we?
51:29Paul Hill: Yeah, no I'm uh okay. Right. Okay, let's go to uh consumer service. You've got Nick asking about uh ME Group that is the uh photo
51:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): booth and
51:37Paul Hill: the washing machine business. I think they they came out with um
51:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
51:41Paul Hill: think it was an inline first half, but it does assume they've got a big second half, I
51:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): think. It
51:48Paul Scott: this looks so cheap, doesn't it? This was um 16th of November. What's the share price now, Paul? It's only about a quid, isn't it?
51:54Paul Hill: Yeah,
51:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): let me
51:55Paul Hill: just get it up. Uh what is it?
51:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh I
52:00Paul Scott: mean, this one I think you've got to the cut. call. I mean, it's incredibly cheap. Low PE. The yield, I think the dividend yield is now about the same as the PE. They're both about seven. And it's got a strong balance sheet with a bit of net cash. And it's self-funding the expansion of the laundry, the outdoor laundry machines, which is a nice uh good high margin growth business, but it's the photo booth business. I mean, people have been telling me. for over literally 25 years. Investors have been telling me that the photo booth business is is dying and and yet it's still going strong and still very profitable. But they do have issues in Germany and Japan. So I think this is ideally suited to one of your sum of the part slides, Paul. I don't know if you've done one on this
52:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah I probably
52:46Paul Hill: have actually let's have a look at it. Yeah
52:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): can probably I'll read it. want to
52:48Paul Scott: put the the the photo booths business on a low But the laundry business on a higher multiple, uh, it is owner-managed as well. Um,
52:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
52:58Paul Scott: mean, I think at a quid it's got to be worth a punt. I really do. And the photo booth business is not necessarily dying because I think they're connecting it too directly to passport or or whatever, you know, identity card government departments. So the the photo can't be tampered with, you see. Whereas if you let people submit selfies, anything could could be done with that photo. You don't know that it's a true likeness at all. So uh and and I think they're doing sort of eyeball or retina identification or something. I wouldn't be surprised if Me Group manages to stay um ahead of the legislation and ahead of the competition. So I think but I don't know. That's just a total guess. And meanwhile you've got the growing laundry business, which as I say is is is is proven and doing very well, um, that that's growing and hopefully taking up any slack. So I think on balance at this price, I've got no axe to grind. I don't have a position in it, but I think it's looking it's looking really attractive for a punt. Maybe a punt for a twenty or thirty percent bounce and maybe you know, maybe a longer term thing if the if the news flow improves. So it could be a bid for it as well, the bidder could come back, which I think might have been the family actually from from memory. The family plus private equity, I think, tried to buy it. So I think oh on balance, risk
54:17broad, I like this. I think this is but you've got to have nerves of steel Deal with this type of thing, haven't you? To because you know it could lurch down again and these value things, as you always say, um, you know, often just continue to get cheaper. But this is a good quality cash generative business, I think.
54:34Paul Hill: Yeah, I think if they decided to actually spin off or sell the photo booth business, you'd see a total re rating of the company. Because people, people like myself, I don't like the photo booth business. I think it's a melting iceberg. But the but the washing machine business is very good and it's working, and you see the footprint, and it's it's got the big competitive barriers to entry. So that'd be
54:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): something
54:57Paul Hill: I you I would invest in. But there's I think there's quite a few people like me who don't like the mix, and there isn't any synergy between the two. There is a bit, but not much.
55:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh, I
55:06Paul Scott: think there's quite a bit of synergy because they are just they have so much expertise in designing machines to operate remotely that can do all sorts of things. Remember, they've done, you know, they've they've got a very innovative RD department, I think. So, you know, what what could they come up with next? I mean, I've never been to Japan, but apparently in Japan they have automated machines for everything you can think of, you know,
55:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): on
55:27Paul Scott: the on the streets. So these guys have got they were doing banking terminals, I think, weren't they? They've tried out lots of things, pizza machines, um, which I think they saw su they try things out with their in-house expertise and then close them or spin them off if they don't work. And it's a bit like like a mini Amazon. And then but then like with the laundry thing, that worked and they then really focus on it and roll it out. So um but I can I
55:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): can see
55:53Paul Scott: Bull am bear points, yeah.
55:55Paul Hill: Okay, you'll have to buy some shares there, Paul. All right.
55:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay, we've got we've got
55:59Paul Hill: we've got here Ian an another one, another company that is a bit disappointed a bit. We've got Ian asking about PayPoint, which is basically a
56:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it does
56:06Paul Hill: obviously those sort of it it the network system with the um the yi the little yellow signs that go into convenience uh stores. It does a bit of postal stuff as well, so like parcel collection. Also does um I think uh some s it's got love shop, has it? An online gifting
56:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): business. Love to shop,
56:24Paul Scott: yeah.
56:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, love to
56:25Paul Hill: shop, yeah. What was your take anyway? The shares went well basically dropped about a quid actually.
56:30Paul Scott: Yeah, I didn't think it was that bad actually. The H1 profit was down 13%, but EPS was up because I think they're doing aggressive buybacks, but they're using debt for that, which I don't agree with. I don't think buybacks should be funded by debt. Um, although I think maybe you can get away with it when you're on a very low PE. But uh yeah, this so is the balance sheet is my main concern here. I should add, we again have disagreements within my team about this. So um my team are much more bullish than I am on this one. Um, um, yeah, it flagged some issues in the division that's called Impost, which I think is a parcels division. That seems to be the problem area at the moment, but it said that was offset by growth in love to shop and digital payments. So I thought, well, okay, that that that broadly washes its face. And the fullier outlook for March 27 from PayPoint, this was yesterday in um uh its H1 results, was broadly in line. So it's about maybe 5% below, isn't it? That's what broadly in line means. But the shares sold off 22%,
57:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um,
57:32Paul Scott: which I thought was a savage reaction. However, if you look at the chart, um it's only given it it did a bit. big um kind of spurious, as it turns out, rally uh over the last couple of months. So it's just given back that recent gain and is back to where it was in the summer, really. Yes, there you can see it there. So in that context, maybe it's now maybe it got ahead of itself with that rally there. Uh often momentum buyers just look at things breaking out and going up, don't they? And they buy regardless of the fundamentals. Uh and then the fundamentals come out and they think, ah, okay, no, that wasn't justified at all. So it's given it back. I suspect it might kind of settle at around this level. I don't see any anything particularly bad in that update that justifies, you know, it it continuing to plunge. So it doesn't really interest me. I don't think personally. I'm not convinced the stuff they've bought is actually any good.
58:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
58:26Paul Scott: think it's kind of. a bit it's all right, but nothing nothing grabs me about this to say that.
58:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): No, it's
58:32Paul Hill: I mean the big question is where's the growth coming from, isn't it? Really?
58:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah. Because
58:35Paul Hill: you've got a payments business that is probably a melting iceberg,
58:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and then you've got
58:40Paul Hill: you've got gift gifting, you know, basically gift vouchers. Well, that isn't growing much, is it? You know, I mean very profitable, but it's not growing hugely. It's only the post side, which is you know, collecting parcels. Well, frankly, a lot of people. do that. But
58:52Paul Scott: yeah, I I think that's right. There's not really any particular mode, a core business melting iceberg. Why should it be any higher than this? And people say, Oh, well, the shareholder returns are so generous, the division and the buybacks, but they've run up a load of debt. So you nah, not for me, but uh as I say, within my team, we do have differing opinions on it. So uh yeah.
59:12Paul Hill: Okay, good. We've We got um who was it? basically? Um, I think it was Helen, wasn't it? Who was the uh yeah, Helen asking about Eagle Eye, the uh software business that came
59:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): out
59:21Paul Hill: with was it a trading update? It was an AGM trading update.
59:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): These guys do
59:25Paul Hill: they're the experts in the world for all sort of supermarket promotions and using AI. They said they'd won, I think, uh another two contracts, um, one with Carfour out in Europe and stuff like that. What was your take?
59:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
59:38Paul Scott: was reassured. by this. Um the shares did in Eagle Eye did drop three percent yesterday, but I think that was uh I think on a more normal, you know, not a savage down day in the market, it probably wouldn't have changed. So I don't think that 3% loss was actually driven by this statement, which I found quite reassuring. It said confident of delivering in line for June 27 uh with a return to double digit growth. So I know you've radically changed your views on this one. So, but I personally I'm sticking with it. So I've got a standard position size in Eagle Eye. It's not cheap, but the growth I think does look impressive. And personally, I doubt whether you'll see AI disintermediation because it's just what they do, I think is too complex and too specialist. And uh very, very sticky clients once they're once they're in. And and we're waiting to see. what further contract wins they win uh they get from the SAP partnership. That's really probably the main reason I'm sitting tight on this. But uh over to you, Paul. I know we're uh we have different takes on this now.
1:00:39Paul Hill: Yeah, I mean it was an inline statement. I mean, I like the business, I think it's high quality, got excellent blue chip customers, no There's doubt about it.
1:00:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
1:00:46Paul Hill: I think the reason why the shares sold off a bit was people were hoping that they're they'd have signed some SAP channel partner contracts before Christmas. Because uh I think the year end for SAP is in December. So it clearly this next three months is when their sales team will have really been hitting the ground trying to get their bonuses. Um and without a without any SAP news, then people were are probably thinking, okay, well it's in line, but would have liked to have seen some SAPs. That's probably just why it it sold. off.
1:01:15Paul Scott: Could be, yeah.
1:01:16Paul Hill: Um, I mean, I as I say, I I haven't radically changed my view. I'm still very positive on the company, but the reason why I sold was because I think AI, effectively, you know, um OpenAI's codex or ChatGPT codex and also Anthropics Claude, the actual systems to be able to write code has improved human. hugely over the last sort of six to twelve months, which has meant that their customers and the likes of SAP, who thought previously they could never do something like this, and now may, like Nat West did with ActiveOps and Palantir did with Salesforce, believe that they've they have actually got the power that they can have a shot at this because they've got they've got big budgets, they've got big IT teams, they can that have a go. Now that is just total guesswork, okay. Um that's why I sold mine. But I genuinely like the company. They're the probably the best in the world at this. Hence, you know, SAP. We went with them. Um clearly it's going to come down to execution, but I wish them all
1:02:17the best. I mean I I really want this to do well and I and I and I think there's this significant upside on it. And I I reserve my right to buy in again. I
1:02:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): can promise you. Because
1:02:27Paul Hill: I I think it's this is this is absolute quality, but because I had such a black eye from ActiveOps only
1:02:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): about a month
1:02:35Paul Hill: ago,
1:02:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that's it was the it was
1:02:36Paul Hill: the sec my my decision to sell Eagle Eye was was a sector thing and and a a lack of conviction by me in that whole sector rather than a statement of the company, which I do think is excellent.
1:02:51Paul Scott: Yeah, no, that's really good that you clarified that. Um and uh yeah I just think it's so specialized as well. I think it's the not not just the coding but the actual know-how um buried within eagle eyes teams is I just think something that would be incredibly difficult to to replicate. Um But anyway I'm gonna stick with it. We'll see what happens and uh yeah.
1:03:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay,
1:03:15Paul Hill: we've got Drew asking about restore, which I think you own. It basically says
1:03:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): any thoughts on
1:03:19Paul Hill: their trading up there. These guys do uh document storage, both physical and electronic. Um they got basically big boxes of uh government and corporate uh documents in uh in silos under the ground. Uh what was your take on it?
1:03:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I think
1:03:34Paul Hill: the shares
1:03:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): run went
1:03:35Paul Hill: pretty well actually.
1:03:36Paul Scott: This was reassuring. Um update on the seventeenth of November, year to date trading update. Uh strong H one, H two also going well. Done a buy, done nearly half of the buyback, good cash generation, year in net debt to be in line. So yeah, that's all all fine. And then the outlook, it said, Oh, this is good. A fully readjusted PBT at least in line. Well, that's telling us they're gonna going to beat a bit, isn't it? Which we kind of suspected, I think. when you and I looked at this one previously. So if we up the forecast from 27p to maybe near a 30p, you're on a PE of 10. It does have a fair bit of debt, but management chastised me for saying, uh, for flagging the debt last time, they don't think it's a lot. He basically said to us that the banks are throwing money at them because they've got this super reliable recurring revenue that they actually can give. gear the thing up a bit. It was about 1.9 times when last um uh oh I've just seen a typo that might be a typo, but I think it's a quality business underappreciated by the market. It's not a melting iceberg because there are good reasons why certain businesses like farmers and particularly pharmaceuticals, as in, the um government department
1:04:47Paul Hill: I'm talking about people on tractors though.
1:04:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
1:04:49Paul Scott: know, yeah. There there's good reason they have to keep some of these boxes for 40 years or more in case of future legal claims, you know, if a drug goes wrong or something. And the cost of digitising
1:05:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
1:05:02Paul Scott: is vastly more than the cost of just paying, you know, a quid or £1.50 or something to store the box. So that's the reason why these boxes, I mean, what what is is this the best business model ever? People give for you people pay you money for 40 years for doing nothing.
1:05:19Paul Hill: Yeah.
1:05:19Paul Scott: Just having
1:05:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
1:05:20Paul Scott: box on the floor. I mean,
1:05:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah, it's a good idea. And I think
1:05:23Paul Hill: that's what's attracted. There's a there's a quite a big hardwood contingent in this, isn't it? And uh eventually eventually it's likely to be bought out by private equity because it's a bit of a cash machine, I think. And
1:05:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): as you rightly
1:05:34Paul Hill: point out, it's it's still trading very reasonably. It's not it's not expensive, there's no bid premium in that for sure.
1:05:39Paul Scott: No, not at all. I think 50% upside, and I'd be happy to sell on a on a on a on a takeover bid. You
1:05:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,
1:05:44Paul Scott: I don't want to hold it forever. And the new, the old management who were very successful, came back two or three years ago, have really sorted out all the problems. And they're now doing lots of bolt-on acquisitions, which again is a very they only buy stuff they know inside out. You know, a mom and pop type document storage operator will make a low margin. but so they don't have to pay very much for them. Stick it onto the restore uh network, you know, distribution network and whatnot, and the margins go from that to that. So
1:06:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that
1:06:12Paul Scott: the actual multiple they're paying for the bolt-on acquisitions once they're uh restructured is is extremely low, and and it's just rinse and repeat, isn't it? So, yeah, I I think it's great. So, but I would say that because uh you know, I've I've got a uh looking at it. I've got a two-thirds size position. So it's not you know it's not a massive commitment in my portfolio, but um I'm happy to hold. Yeah.
1:06:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
1:06:35Paul Hill: it's not risky enough for you, is it really? Because you
1:06:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): like you like you like your through
1:06:38Paul Hill: visions. I
1:06:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): like a
1:06:41Paul Scott: selection, shall we say?
1:06:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay,
1:06:42Paul Hill: yeah, right. Okay, we've got Alec chain sectors, we've got Alex Jones asking about concurrent technologies, the defence defense electronics business. He says they're basically they've basically done a big funding round at £2.50. If you held the shares and were given the opportunity to buy some, would you consider adding at these levels?
1:07:00Paul Scott: Not really, because they're already very expensive, the shares are because it's a quality business. And the placing was only a six and a half percent discount. So that shows that it was well supported, you know, 35 million quid if institutions and high net worths are providing. prepared to pull in. And that is a decent chunk for a smaller, smaller cap, 35 million. Um, that shows you the strong demand, I think, for the shares. So I think that's very encouraging actually. And it makes sense when your PE is over 30 times, it makes sense to issue more expensive paper and use it to buy up things that you can buy on a much, much lower multiple. Then you get that beautiful um uh you know virtuous circle, don't you? If issuing expensive paper, buying cheap acquisitions, suddenly your earnings go like that. It's yeah, I think provided it's called versal logic. So I haven't looked at what this versalogic business does or anything about it. But I I think concurrent management are very good and very prudent. I think I think you know you've got to trust them that they've made
1:08:00a decent acquisition. So I'm bullish on the company, but it's too expensive for me. And funnily enough in my last podcast with Lord Lee, he um mentioned that he's top-sliced his holding. I think he sold about a third of them. He's made millions on it over the years. So I think it made sense for him to lock in some profit. But overall I wouldn't be perturbed at all by this placing. I think it's a uh actually uh for acquisitions very sensible, I think.
1:08:28Paul Hill: Yeah, no, good. Okay, let's move sectors again. We're gonna go to Financial. We've got Lemon Physical asking about uh River Global B shares that uh put out an announcement recently. They've only got one asset, which is they own 30% of this um Parmenian IFA um platform that's doing really well and has been valued at somewhere between fifty five P and seventy five p I think. Anyway, they've basically decided to delist and then to eventually to sell that particular stake and then give it back to shareholders. Any any thoughts on what you would do with this one and whether you were tempted to play that arbitrage, but it would be mean you've you d you you couldn't hold it in your ICE because it'd have to be ki kick it it's gonna be a delisted share soon.
1:09:12Paul Scott: No, this is a special situation clearly and it's not one I've looked at. So no, I'm not gonna blag it. I I I don't know anything about this, I'm afraid.
1:09:20Paul Hill: Yeah. I I mean, I I know a bit about it, uh, Lemon Physical, because I I used to own it and I sold at about 40, 41p. And the reason is is simply because I don't really want to hold a delisted stock waiting for this event. And somebody like Christopher Mills of Harwood, I mean, that's his bread and butter, and he's very happy to hold a share six months. 12 months who are D listed. But uh I just thought I'd take my money and run, to perfectly honest. But um it's an interesting, it's definitely an interesting arbitrage because if you buy at that current price at about 38,
1:09:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
1:09:49Paul Hill: I suspect the actual valuation range they've talked about with Parmenian is a conservative figure. So you you could could you could probably easily do 50% fifty percent upside, if not 100% a hundred percent upside, by holding it for 12 twelve months. So it's not a stupid. thing, but don't hold it in your ISA because it will come out of your ICER immediately because uh they could not you can't hold um, you know, um those shares. Okay, good. Let's go to um Dieselhead. He's asking about uh Volex, which I think do you own Volex or you've been thinking about
1:10:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): buying these are
1:10:18Paul Hill: the optical and electrical cable boys doing brilliantly to supply 'em supply them into data centers and electric vehicles.
1:10:25Paul Scott: Yeah, I like remember. we're we're long-term bulls on the company. Um, the fundamentals, very well run by Nat Rothschild, I think, doing good acquisitions and so on. I wanted to wait for it to when it got up to about seven pounds twice this year. I thought, well, I'm not going to pay that for it. So I've been waiting for it to come down to five pounds. I jumped the gun a bit on this because as I had some spare cash burning a hole in my pocket after uh a bull run. in my portfolio a few weeks ago that's now a distant memory so I overpaid for mine as it turns out I paid about £5.30, £5.40. It's now £4.79. Really good fundamentals, very um modest P now. I think it's only down to about 12 times or something. I just think that's the wrong price. I think this is a great buying opportunity for Volex. Why is it falling? Well possibly concerns over the AI data center rollout slowing. But as one of my readers pointed out this morning, it's not actually that large a part of Volex's group. You know, it's um and um it's got growth in other sectors, like it does a lot of wiring cables for electric vehicles. You know, it's got growth, several
1:11:35growth growth areas. It's nicely diversified. So yeah, I think it's very attractive at this valuation. Not advice or recommendation, just my personal opinion, as always. So yeah, I'll be but I can actually get off margin call. I'll buy some more.
1:11:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
1:11:48Paul Hill: no, I think you're right. I mean, given the growth and the secular growth themes, yeah, the actual behind it, then yeah, 12 times PE, 7.3 times Three EBITDA just doesn't that's miss price, isn't it?
1:12:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It
1:12:01Paul Scott: does seem that way. I haven't looked at the company. comp competition, but apparently, um, if you compare it with valuations on um presumably larger companies that are similar in America or in Europe, apparently they're on much, much higher valuation. This does look great value to me, I have to say.
1:12:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
1:12:19Paul Hill: Amphol Knoll is on an unbelievable valuation, which does
1:12:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): similar
1:12:22Paul Hill: sort of thing, yeah. Okay, we're gonna come back to um balance sheet. sheets uh do matter because we've got uh Amanda asking about Pulsar that does um software for the communications and PR businesses. So it basically helps brands, I think, uh get sentiment about how their products are performing against other uh that scrapes the internet. Anyway, they had to do I think that's you meant you you you highlighted it perfectly, saying you're a bit worried about the funding. Do you want to take us through from now? Because I think they've got absolutely they've got nailed, haven't they?
1:12:55Paul Scott: Yeah, well, I'm pleased to say on my website, um, shareideas.uk, we've reported on this eight times in the last two years, and every time we've been negative, um read or or even read, we're currently read, because the balance sheet is terrible. Um and um and the most recent. update we thought was diabolical. This was this week on the 17th. It said there was insufficient interest in another equity fundraise. So it's agreed a 5.5 million conditional loan with the largest shareholder and some others at an interest rate of 17.5% per annum. I mean, honestly. And then it says it's uh one and a half million of that will be used to support cost reductions, and the rest is to quote, is to reduce quote stretched creditor levels. I
1:13:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): mean,
1:13:45Paul Scott: this is just blooming awful. Um I mean, they're more or less telling us that the equity is practically worthless, aren't they?
1:13:53Paul Hill: Yeah. So Yeah, the 17.5%, seventeen point five percent, I think, is the default rate. I think they're they've signed it at twelve and a half percent.
1:14:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh, sorry. And if they fail to
1:14:04Paul Hill: pay the interest, then but twelve and a half percent is still terrible. It
1:14:10Paul Scott: is, isn't it? I mean it is just this has just got all the look if look if the biggest shareholders prepared to support it uh um and nobody else is, then they might as well just um you know, they might as well just do a do a fundraise at naught 0.1p point one P and dilute everyone out of sight, which they if they're the only people prepared to put money in, they can do.
1:14:29Paul Hill: Yeah.
1:14:29Paul Scott: So, andor delist it. You'll probably see convertible loans cropping up here as well, which is usually when things are getting into a death spiral. So I can't see any reason to get involved here.
1:14:41Paul Hill: No, you had the same scenario, didn't you? About I don't know, a year ago, nine months ago, when Harwood owned that um life sciences business out in California and
1:14:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it got into just
1:14:50Paul Hill: distress levels and Howard was the only people gonna basically put any money into it. So they just delisted it and took nine, they took the whole business basically away. So I think as you rightly say, if you're unfortunate shareholders, you'd probably just want to get out at any price, I think, because
1:15:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I think so.
1:15:05Paul Scott: And I
1:15:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): mean
1:15:06Paul Scott: the the the problem as well is as a small shareholder, you've got no say in this.
1:15:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
1:15:10Paul Scott: So you might be prepared to support a a a retail offer, but but if management can't line up some institutions to sort of um to cornerstone fundraises, then you're just going to get wiped out. I think the worst thing is being a small shareholder in these type of financially distressed situations. It's I I think it's nearly all I can't think of any of them who actually come out of this uh smelling of roses and where you get a good recovery on your investment. You just I think it's better to pull the plug early, you know. I mean, well, certainly not early here, but before things spiral down into these situations. And you know, we've been warning people on my site for for two years that this was a dead loss, which started off at 50p and they're now down at 10.5p. So this again, I think, was an avoidable mistake where it was totally clear in all the numbers and the statements that this was uh very likely. to be a poor investment. But for some reason, some people just buy into the story and ig and ignore um all these factors. That's why it's good to consult my notes on these things because I go through all the balance sheets, I look at the cash burn, you know, I look at all the numbers. But a lot of investors, small investors are not really that au fait with balance sheets and cash flows. So we do it for you and warn you um of the risky situations. So yeah.
1:16:28Paul Hill: Yeah, no, it could be the next one could be CT automotive, couldn't it?
1:16:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It's got all the hallmarks.
1:16:34Paul Hill: That one is who's gonna
1:16:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): put who's gonna put the marginal money
1:16:37Paul Hill: into it? Yeah,
1:16:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah, they've
1:16:38Paul Scott: already said they're tight for cash. So want to put any fresh equity into it.
1:16:42Paul Hill: Okay, good. We've got a really topical question. Jacob asking about uh frontier developments, the um gaming software business. Obviously, we've had uh the big news this week that uh grand theft auto six has been released by i can't remember who it is um take two was it and then we've also had another one i think putting out a big Ubisoft or something like that has been put out a big one just behead of Christmas what's your take on on gaming shares have done pretty well actually
1:17:09Paul Scott: yeah well uk gdp is probably gonna going to spike down because apparently so many people are bunking off work
1:17:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it's
1:17:16Paul Scott: to play this uh GT game. Uh what was the question again? Oh yeah, frontier development. We like it. We've amber green on this consistently for quite a long time. Yeah, yeah, ever since I started the site. So two years we've reviewed it about 10 times, amber green every time. And um the shares have done very well. They've they've doubled since January 2025 when we first flagged it. as a share we like. So yeah, we think it's very good. The most recent news wasn't uh um was was September, I think, unless something's slipped through that we haven't spotted. But uh so we haven't got but the figures were great, the the full year results to May. PBT doubled to 25 million. You got net cash on the balance sheet. Um and uh yeah, it looks very good. Um we like it, yeah.
1:18:04Paul Hill: Yeah, I I th before buying, I will all just just be comfortable that um heading I mean it Christmas is a very, very important time for games,
1:18:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): okay? It's where most
1:18:12Paul Hill: of them actually make money. And the m where's the marginal money gonna be put into? Well, clearly it's gonna go into Grand Theft Auto, isn't it?
1:18:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh, that's a good point. Yeah, you
1:18:20Paul Hill: know, so you might find it's that sucks in the and there is another big one which another big franchise has just been released about a month ago. like a massive global one so um just be careful that uh you know you're not going to get caught on the wrong side of that because
1:18:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
1:18:34Paul Hill: could see some gaming corp uh gaming companies who are trying to reach their numbers suffering because the money has gone to other franchises for Christmas but um
1:18:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that's a
1:18:44Paul Scott: really good point actually my my colleague Dave is also an expert on the gaming sector and he actually flagged that in one of our recent company reviews. And I took it out because I thought it was just a minor detail. But he was he I
1:18:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): was
1:18:57Paul Scott: wrong. He should I should have left it in. So uh yeah, very interesting.
1:19:01Paul Hill: Okay, we've got um JFDV asking about JD Sports, basically the sneaker retailer. Large, it's got a big position out in the States, I think. In fact, I might have made an acquisition some time ago. Um, but clearly trainers and sneakers are not selling great. You just look at um on holdings, Nike and all these kind of guys suffering a bit. But actually the shares haven't been doing too badly.
1:19:25Paul Scott: Yeah, we've been we've been sort of perma bulls
1:19:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): on
1:19:27Paul Scott: this, maybe on on valuation basis. And it does have an amazing long-term track record of acquisition uh-driven uh driven growth. Um, so I I I do think it's a good business, but certainly having a not not a great year for selling trainers. Um excuse me, we had a Q3 trading update yesterday. I thought it was a bit un I I described it as uninspiring. Q3 Life for Light sales were down two point six percent, which is a steady rate. It was the same figure, give or take a decimal point for year to date. So things are not getting any any worse. And the company's uh JD Sports said it was in line with expectations. They narrowed the guidance range, but the top, it was that 700 million, 800 million. It's now 700 million, 750 million, and that's PBT guidance. So the top end has come down. Is that a profit warning? It kind of is, and it isn't. Do you know what I mean? But anyway, I thought the shares would drop more than they did yesterday. They dropped four percent, about ninety P. I don't see it as compelling value anymore at that level. When
1:20:32it was 70 P, you know, uh and the PE was six, we were more enthusiastic on it. But with the lack of growth and the fact that it has gone up to about ninety P now, um, it's certainly not expensive, but I think you'd need to see uh you'd need to see uh sales accelerating again, really, wouldn't you? So I'm still uh moderately positive, amber green on JD.
1:20:54Paul Hill: Okay, good. We've got um it's still in the in this in the consumer sector, but going a bit more at market. We've got Alison asking about watches of Switzerland, which came out with a ridiculously positive trading update for selling very expensive Rolex watches about two weeks ago. How'd you see this one? I mean, is this really the US wealth effect? This is the people like the shareholders of Anthropic. or all the employees who just like made millions from the uh the listing decided to go and splash out on jewelry and fast cars.
1:21:23Paul Scott: It could well be. I mean, that sounds credible to me. Yeah, it's obviously it's an international business, as you say, big big business in the UK and in USA. Yeah, strong. Here we are, 10th of November, strong H1, revenue up 15%. And they talked about quote, enduring demand for luxury watches at and jewellery. Slightly ahead of expectations, profit. Now the net debt came down a lot, a hell of a lot in the last year. So that's a really good sign. And uh on the Outlook, it did the opposite of JD Sports. It said its guidance has narrowed to the upper end. So it's done that. So it looks very good, I think. Um What are the shares now, Paul? There was £7.47 when we looked. at it.
1:22:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
1:22:03Paul Hill: £7.71. Yeah. Others carried
1:22:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): on going up.
1:22:06Paul Scott: I think it's very good. I mean, I'm not I don't think it's something I would want to own because I'm just not I think too much relies on the supply relationship in particular with with Rolex. Um uh so um yeah, I mean why people buy these ridiculous watches, I do not I do not know. If you wander around London wearing one, you probably get murdered for it. You know, I my tip of the day, £15.99 Casio.
1:22:34Paul Hill: Yeah.
1:22:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You can overpay, you're overpaying mine
1:22:37Paul Hill: was you're overpaying, mine was six quid Casio.
1:22:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
1:22:40Paul Hill: I do
1:22:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I actually
1:22:41Paul Scott: tell the time. They tell the time, fine, and you're not gonna get
1:22:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): much
1:22:44Paul Scott: for this, are you?
1:22:45Paul Hill: No, I don't. I actually do think there's a leak link between all of the money that's made out in Silicon Valley. with likes of SpaceX, because all the employees will have gone away, even the receptionists will go away with literally millions of dollars worth of shares that they can sell
1:22:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): at the
1:23:00Paul Hill: open. And all the employees from Anthropic have and the open AR just le and so consequently they've they've just got so much money and they've never been able to buy anything of luxury. So they think,
1:23:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): right, well, okay,
1:23:09Paul Hill: I'm gonna have a watch, I'm gonna have a fast car, I'm gonna go on a nice holiday cruise. And I think because the most I think most of the trading performance has been in America. Um, and I'm sure it's basically because this is a high value discretionary item, isn't it? I mean,
1:23:24Paul Scott: yes,
1:23:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah,
1:23:25Paul Scott: no,
1:23:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that
1:23:25Paul Scott: that's I mean,
1:23:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
1:23:26Paul Scott: don't know how you know how large a percentage of the sales that that would actually be. But I mean, there are so many wealthy people in America who'll
1:23:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): stop
1:23:35Paul Scott: on up to start with. But yeah, no, I mean it look, it it looks a really good business trading well. So yeah, I like it. Amber Green on that one.
1:23:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay,
1:23:43Paul Hill: right. We've got to go for a last one. We've got Stuart asking about Zote foams that I think came out with some results. Was it a couple of weeks ago that were in line? They basically these guys do the specialist foams. I think they're moving now more to industrial sort of lightweight uh foams for those types of applications rather than the foams that go into the insoles for nice. Nike shoes, etc. Um, how did you how did you see this one?
1:24:07Paul Scott: We think we've been again long-term bulls on this, sort of permanently frustrated by the valuation. But um it looked this looked all right. The Q3 trading update was on the 4th of November, about three weeks ago. Um, yeah, year-to-date Year to date revenues up 18%. Um, I think the footwear thing is holding it back, isn't it? Because this exclusive relationship with Nike, which is by far its biggest customer. So, but that had been telegraphed in advance that there was an expected slowdown there. And Fourier expectations unchanged. And that would put it on a P for next year's P 20 to 27, of only just over um just under 11 eleven times, which we think is is very uh good value. So yeah, we like it. We we're staying fully green on this. Five out of five stars on our system debts, fine. Um yeah, we like Zophomes. Yeah. How about you Paul?
1:25:00Paul Hill: Yeah, no, I think it's a good uh good solid business. And we had a chat didn't we to their CEO about a year ago, Roland Cox, and we were both came away pretty impressive. I mean it's it is a bit heavy on Capex because you have to build factories
1:25:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to make
1:25:11Paul Hill: it. But frankly it's quite niche sort of stuff and you get in into long product life cycles, particularly in aerospace and defense and this sort of stuff. And
1:25:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it's
1:25:20Paul Hill: you basically you just like it's a repeat type of a water it's it's a class
1:25:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it's the
1:25:24Paul Hill: right the reason why you you build a factory because you've got a product revenue for the next 10-15 years. And I think I I think he knows what he's doing. In fact we'll just go through a bit of a sort of like a a final final because on the subjects subject of ZOP Zoap foams you've got Brian asking about um uh James Cropper because the previous CEO for Zoap Foams, David Sterling, went to James Cropper. And since he's arrived, the shares have just like taken off. These guys do sort of like high high sort of fine papers, coloured papers was there for Heartland, but they've gone into this advanced material stuff that really is doing fabulously advanced coatings. How do you see this one?
1:26:00Paul Scott: Well, I have to say they appeared at Mello and I think this was probably, from what I could gather, the most talked-about stock from people. I think it was standing room only at their presentation. So it's a very popular company. We turned positive on James Cropper on the 15th of July, uh, when it put out uh really impressive results. And um uh I think it's upgraded a few times. Uh yeah, it's done ahead of expectations. updates on 20th of October. Seems to be doing very, very well. For my sins, I'm afraid I haven't looked at this one in detail myself. But at least one of my team, I think two or even three of my team went to the presentation. So we'll be publishing our notes from the Mano presentation on James Cropper Um at some point next week on shareideas.uk. So um it's it seems to have the windows. wind in its sails, doesn't it? And on the 11th of November, the H1 results were were fantastic. PVT up 176%. So whatever they're doing, and it seems to be, as you say, these advanced materials, um, especially, you know, it's not just writing paper now anymore, is it? All this all this advanced material stuff seems to be really taking off, doesn't it? So um, but as I say, I don't have any detailed knowledge on it. So have you looked at the uh the detail on it, Paul?
1:27:16Paul Hill: No, I mean I'm just I'm just stunned to perfect honest. It was it was a stock
1:27:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that
1:27:20Paul Hill: obviously people ignored for a long time, and then you know, as soon as that Dave Sterling came in from Zoe Foams, the share started to take off, and people
1:27:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): started to
1:27:28Paul Hill: realize they've got a crown jewel in that uh advanced materials business.
1:27:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I think it
1:27:32Paul Scott: did dis it did disappoint quite badly, didn't it, a while back? Was it something to do with hydrogen?
1:27:37Paul Hill: Oh,
1:27:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that's
1:27:38Paul Hill: right, yeah. yes. Hydrogen.
1:27:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
1:27:40Paul Scott: so it had blotted it and it all seemed to have gone all awful and flat. But so look at the long-term chart, it's been it's been absolutely terrible. It lost about 90% of its value. But um uh it's since five or six packs from the low point in um 18 months ago. So that's been a fabulous recovery. So very well done to people who spotted uh um the potential there. Uh as
1:28:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
1:28:04Paul Scott: say we were a bit late to the party from my analysts, but we we we caught it um you know what once it was started moving strongly up. So yeah. But for me personally, I don't know why, but I never really personally focused on it. Um
1:28:18Paul Hill: well you've wet my appetite to read that report anyway from Bellow. Mello. Is it gonna be John is it or Dave or something like that, right?
1:28:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah I think
1:28:24Paul Scott: I think um or our bell our our um app designer. Yeah, I think they I think they all went to see Cropper and and every it was buzzing. Everyone was talking about James Cropper. So it seems to be yeah, have a lot there's a lot of interest.
1:28:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Absolutely.
1:28:38Paul Hill: All right, great. Well we've been going for an hour and a half. Thanks everyone for your questions. We've got through masses again as usual. Uh hope everybody hasn't had too a painful week. I mean, as I say, the markets are down four or five percent this week, so it has been pretty tough. But uh you might find they they're bound what we normally get is a bit of a Santa rally. So uh with a bit of luck in sort of the back end of November and December, there'll be a bit of jingle bells singing and then we'll start.
1:29:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
1:29:01Paul Scott: and
1:29:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I think these
1:29:01Paul Scott: pullbacks, these corrections are actually a healthy market. You don't want a market going up vertically because then you get a crash. So these zigzags it it you know it lets weak holders out, it gives you buying opportunities if you're sitting on cash. I think this is all actually. part of a healthy market.
1:29:16Paul Hill: Yeah. Even if even if it's painful during the process.
1:29:20Paul Scott: It's horrible, isn't it?
1:29:21Paul Hill: I know, yeah. All right, thanks a lot, guys. Same time, same place. Uh next week.
1:29:26Paul Scott: Thanks everyone. Bye.
1:29:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
1:29:29Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Vox Markets Podcast. Nothing in this podcast is intended as investment advice, and the people in this podcast may hold positions in the stocks they talk about. Do not buy anything based solely on a tip or recommendation. Please do your own research.