Finerate

Taber siblings discuss intentional giving, charity selection, and 2025 tax law changes

23 min Listen to the original Episode page
Charitable GivingTax LawFinancial PlanningPsychology of WealthNonprofit Efficiency

Summary

Bill and Anastasia Taber discuss the psychological and financial aspects of generosity, citing research that links giving to increased happiness. They advise integrating charitable giving into annual budgets and selecting charities based on personal values and efficiency ratings from CharityWatch.org. Anastasia Taber details tax implications under summer 2025 legislation, including new deduction limits for non-itemizers and income floors for itemizers. The speakers emphasize that giving should be sustainable, value-driven, and integrated into broader financial planning rather than driven solely by tax benefits or emotional appeals.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    they show a link, but they might not be proof, right, that doing these experiments. exact things would make you happier. But I think it's important to keep in mind is this actually does have an impact on your well being.

    Anastasia Taber · 3:09

Episode sections

  1. 0:00 – 1:48

    Introduction and the Psychology of Giving

    Bill Taber shares a mentorship story about generosity, leading into a discussion on why giving feels good. Anastasia Taber cites Yale research and an Obama firm study showing that spending money on others increases happiness more than spending on oneself, regardless of the amount.

  2. 1:48 – 6:23

    Defining Generosity and Wealth Dynamics

    The speakers define generosity using Webster's dictionary and discuss the 'Dead Sea' analogy, where Bill Taber argues that wealth requires both inflow and outflow to avoid stagnation, suggesting that giving sets a 'law of prosperity' in motion.

  3. 6:23 – 9:50

    Budgeting for Giving and Pro Bono Impact

    Bill Taber advises creating a charitable line item in annual budgets to ensure sustainability. Anastasia Taber highlights the impact of pro bono financial planning, citing a couple in San Antonio who benefited from mortgage assistance and financial education provided by a volunteer planner.

  4. 9:50 – 12:55

    Selecting Charities and Personal Values

    Anastasia Taber recommends using CharityWatch.org to verify charity ratings (A-D) to ensure funds are used effectively. Bill Taber suggests focusing on two or three personal values, such as health or education, rather than giving to whoever asks first.

  5. 12:55 – 16:46

    Tax Implications of Charitable Giving

    Anastasia Taber explains tax law changes from summer 2025: non-itemizers can deduct up to $1,000 (single) or $2,000 (joint) for cash contributions, while itemizers face a 0.5% income floor on deductions. She emphasizes that tax breaks should be a side benefit, not the primary driver.

  6. 16:46 – 18:18

    Characteristics of Effective Givers

    Bill Taber observes that clients who give well often gift appreciated assets, live full lives, and give without expectation of return. He notes that these individuals radiate confidence and are perceived as fun and meaningful to be around.

  7. 18:18 – 23:13

    Building Intentional Giving into Financial Plans

    The speakers advise making giving sustainable by integrating it into a budget and potentially cutting back on discretionary spending (mental accounting) to fund it. They conclude that generosity should be planned, value-driven, and can include time and talent when cash is tight.

Claims worth verifying

Anastasia Taber cites a Yale study where participants handed $5 or $20 spent on others were rated happier at the end of the day than those who spent on themselves.

Anastasia Taber ·2:29

How to verify: Search for 'Yale Science of Well-Being happiness spending study' or 'Yale course on happiness experiment spending money on others' to find the original research paper or course materials. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Anastasia Taber references a study of employees at Obama, a Boston firm, where profit-sharing bonus spending on others mattered more for happiness than the bonus size.

Anastasia Taber ·2:49

How to verify: Search for 'Obama Boston firm profit sharing happiness study' or 'Obama & Associates employee well-being study' to locate the specific corporate study or press release. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Bill Taber states the Dead Sea has no outflow, only inflow, causing stagnant water where nothing grows.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·5:54

How to verify: Verify via geographic or hydrological sources such as Britannica or USGS regarding the Dead Sea's hydrology and salinity levels. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Anastasia Taber mentions a Financial Planning Association conference in National Harbor where a couple from San Antonio spoke about mortgage assistance.

Anastasia Taber ·7:32

How to verify: Search for 'Financial Planning Association conference National Harbor San Antonio couple mortgage assistance' or check FPA conference archives/press releases from the relevant year. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Anastasia Taber states that under legislation from summer 2025, non-itemizers can deduct up to $1,000 (single) or $2,000 (joint) for cash charitable contributions.

Anastasia Taber ·13:34

How to verify: Check IRS Publication 526 or the Internal Revenue Code for the specific tax year following the 2026 legislation to verify the standard deduction charitable contribution limits. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Anastasia Taber states there is a 0.5% income floor for itemizers, meaning the first 0.5% of income is not deductible.

Bill Taber ·14:07

How to verify: Verify against IRS Form 1040 Schedule A instructions or IRS Publication 526 for the specific tax year to confirm the percentage floor for charitable deductions. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Bill Taber cites Joseph Campbell's definition of money as an energy facilitating force or flow.

Bill Taber ·15:48

How to verify: Search Joseph Campbell's works, such as 'The Power of Myth' or his essays on mythology and money, for the specific quote regarding money as energy. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify the specific text of the summer 2025 tax legislation regarding charitable deduction limits for non-itemizers and itemizers.
  • Check CharityWatch.org ratings for any charities mentioned to assess administrative cost ratios and program spending efficiency.
  • Review personal tax situation to determine if itemizing deductions is beneficial given the new 0.5% income floor rule.
  • Research the Yale study and Obama firm study cited to understand the methodology and limitations regarding causation in generosity and happiness.
  • Confirm the details of the Financial Planning Association case study regarding pro bono work outcomes for veterans.
  • Assess personal budget to ensure charitable giving does not compromise essential expenses like housing or food.
  • Look for conflicts of interest if the speakers recommend specific charities or financial planning firms.
  • Compare the tax benefits of cash donations versus gifting appreciated assets to determine the most efficient giving strategy.
Full transcriptexpand

0:00Bill Taber: As a young man working in the financial services industry, I was mentored by an older attorney, a community leader, a wise man, unselfish in his time with me, principled in his approach to life, and full of personal integrity. He told me that I could do anything that I set my mind to, and he made me believe it. That was life-changing.

0:23Anastasia Taber: And not just for you, but for everyone else you passed his message. along to, too. And now this podcast. Welcome to Feneret. I'm Anastasia Tabor, a certified financial planner. And I'm here with my dad, Bill, who has spent forty-five 45 years as an investment advisor.

0:51Bill Taber: Today's topic is one that is on a lot of minds this time of year. Giving. How do you give generously in a way that fits your values and your budget?

1:01Anastasia Taber: As always, this episode is general education, not personalized financial investment tax or legal advice. Tax rules vary by situation, so you can talk to a CPA about yours or consult. a qualified professional on your personal situation. Let's get into it.

1:19Bill Taber: Great.

1:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): This

1:27Bill Taber: is uh this is a very good topic, particularly this time of year when Thanksgiving and Christmas are upon us.

1:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Mm-hmm.

1:33Anastasia Taber: Yeah, we s we start getting in the giving mindset. Yeah.

1:36Bill Taber: So let's start by asking why does giving feel good? And what does research say about generosity and well-being? Can I first give you a definition of generous?

1:48Anastasia Taber: Yeah, let's do it. This

1:49Bill Taber: is from Webster's, not not Google.

1:51Anastasia Taber: Okay, not from AI.

1:53Bill Taber: Definition of generous is free and unselfish in And giving, munisfent, muniscent, large, ample, bountiful, noble in the spirit.

2:04Anastasia Taber: So both abundance and giving to others, being unselfish.

2:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Mm-hmm.

2:09Anastasia Taber: Yeah, so and we talked about this in our two-parter, The Science of Wellbeing. I would definitely check that out or re-listen to it. If it's been a while and there were so many great points, if I do say so myself, but it was also I had taken the Yale course. on happiness, how to how to be happier, science-backed research ways to be happier. In one experiment, participants were handed five dollars or twenty dollars and told to spend it by the end of the day, either on themselves or someone else. And the people who spent it on other people were rated as happier at the end of the day. There was also the this study of employees at Obama. a Boston firm who received profit sharing bonuses, measured how people spent the money on others versus themselves, and found out that mattered more than the size of the bonus, the amount of money they were given. So it's important to say that these experiments are, you know, they show a link, but they might not be proof, right, that doing these experiments. exact things would make you happier. But I think it's important to keep in mind is this actually does have an impact on your well being. Being able to give freely to other people within reason, which we'll also cover in this

3:29episode, but it can really not just help other people and impact other people, but it has the reverberation back on you.

3:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The

3:38Bill Taber: fact that of spending money on other people other than not yourself is kind of counterintuitive, I think, to young children. Um say they're four, five, six years old. I wonder at what point that people are able to make that crossover.

3:53Anastasia Taber: Well, it's definitely not age four because my daughter is still upset when she has to share a toy with her brother and there is fighting and sometimes the fighting gets a little more intense. So um it's not age four, but I bet, you know, as kids get older they start developing this sense, you know, it's called theory of mind where you realize that other people exist and have thoughts and feelings outside of you. That oh yeah, like empathy. I mean, not to say like my children do have empathy, but it's you know, it's like a seed right now, and it's developing over time. Um, but yeah, that would be an interesting question. I'm sure someone has figured it out, some researcher.

4:45Bill Taber: Yeah, and it's not always doesn't always carry through to all adults.

4:49Anastasia Taber: No, no, but then also like what has been modeled to you. Like you talked about your mentor in the beginning of this episode. I mean, he is a powerful example of what it's like to have not even like a parent, but someone who's older than you in your life who has these really wonderful values and they can become sort of a moral exemplar for you.

5:12Bill Taber: Mm-hmm. Yeah, point well taken. What I've seen about Jen. generosity towards others is that it can set a basic law of prosperity in motion. Give and you will receive. Like attracts like. Too often people may desire prosperity and wealth, but not be willing to pay the price. And what is the price? It is giving, sharing, loving, and caring. Prosperity or wealth needs an inflow and an outflow, just like any bod any body of water needs,

5:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if

5:47Bill Taber: it is to remain clean and fresh. Otherwise stagnation often results.

5:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The

5:54Bill Taber: Dead Sea falls into this category. It does not have an outflow, it only receives, and so the water becomes stagnant.

6:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Almost

6:02Bill Taber: like nothing grows there. People are like that too. If they only receive and not give of their money or their talent, which is a life energy, they can become stagnant and stop growing.

6:15Anastasia Taber: That's a really interesting analogy with the Dead Sea. How do you decide how much to give when your own finances feel tight?

6:23Bill Taber: Well, if you're accustomed to developing a budget each year, uh you can make a charitable gift giving line item in your expenses. And this allows you to determine how much of your income that you can safely sustain towards giving without impacting your ability to pay for other necessary expenses like food, clothing, and rent or a mortgage. If you're tight on money, but giving still matters to you, you can give of your time. Say volunteering to help. at a food bank, providing meals to the homeless, or participating in charitable organizations in your community. For me, money was tight when we were raising our family of four children. And so I gave freely of my time and professional expertise to a variety of groups church, public hospital, schools, community, and government agencies.

7:12Anastasia Taber: Yeah, that's what I really like about my professional. profession is that it's such a useful skill to help others with. And in our profession, there's been a big push towards pro bono hours, just like in the lawyer profession. I have really enjoyed providing valuable advice to people who couldn't otherwise afford it. At the recent Financial Planning Association conference that I went to last week in National Harbor, one of the last speakers of the conference was this couple who lived in San Antonio. The husband had been injured in the Iraq War and lost his leg. They had three children at home, fell behind on bills. But there was this program available where we can get you mortgage assistance if you also work with this financial. planner for a year. They spoke at the conference saying that that year had such an outsized impact on their family and their future. They learned so much through this woman who just gave of her time was volunteering for this organization in her off hours. And I think that is something that is kind of amazing and can have a huge impact, not just on the person you're helping, but also all of the people around them too, who rely on them. Like she changed not just the

8:31wife's life, the husband's life, but also the children's lives. I

8:35Bill Taber: view it kind of like mentoring. It's like it's impossible for you to give something like that out in the way of information and service without getting something back.

8:43Anastasia Taber: Mm-hmm.

8:44Bill Taber: It benefits you to bet to help other people.

8:46Anastasia Taber: Yeah. And I actually got to talk to this couple after the conference wrapped up. And she mentioned like she has started a bookkeeping business. She has realized to what extent people in her area are getting bad tax advice. And so this is creating an even bigger impact, I feel like. Now this woman has started this small business which is growing and really helping to serve people who are running into issues with taxes. Yeah, I mean it's just kind of amazing that something like that can have such an outsize impact. So another note that I wanted to mention in this question was just the fact that the gift doesn't have to be big to be meaningful. It can be a small recurring gift. And that's also easier to sustain, just like Dad, you were talking about making it a line item, making it sustainable within your cash flow.

9:39Bill Taber: I I agree. Anastasia, how do you choose where to give so it reflects your values and not just whoever asks first? Which is something that can happen this time of year.

9:50Anastasia Taber: Yes. Because a lot of people are asking right now. There's a lot of pressure and urgency around year end. So one of my smartest friends, it's really important in your life to have people who are smarter than you.

10:04Bill Taber: It's advisable.

10:07Anastasia Taber: And one of my friends who is, you know, knocks my socks off every time I talk to her. She had given me this perspective years ago when I talked about it with her that it's really important when you are giving to charities to look into how good they are at using the money to actually make an impact. And there actually is this nonprofit website called charitywatch.org that rates all of the charities in organizations from you know A, B, C, D, and gives you a breakdown essentially of how good they are at actually diverting your funds to make a positive impact. Because not all charities. are created equal, not all charities are good at using your dollar to make an impact. Sometimes they spend a little bit too much on the people who are running the organization. So that was something that she had told me is when I'm giving, make

11:07sure that the charity is A-rated. A rated. My advice also would be if you're starting out, I would just pick one or two causes that matter to you personally. That I think is gonna make more of an impact on your well-being than just saying yes to whoever asks first.

11:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Mm-hmm.

11:27Bill Taber: Well, I I agree with you about picking, you know, two or three causes that really matter to you personally. This can make gift giving more satisfying. Personally, my top values are health, nature, and family. I've given time or and or money to the community hospital and the region's recreational park system, but money gifts to family have been a bit more nuanced. Uh I avoid helping them do or buy things that they could or should do or buy for themselves.

11:58Anastasia Taber: And we had a whole episode on that too.

12:00Bill Taber: We did.

12:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

12:01Bill Taber: I gift money more freely. for educations because that helping them sharpen their abilities to provide for themselves.

12:09Anastasia Taber: Beyond cash, what other ways can people give?

12:12Bill Taber: Well some of our clients routinely give appreciated assets to religious organizations, universities, and nonprofit organizations that are doing disease prevention research. They may have gotten a tax break for doing it, but they gift give the money mostly because they're passionate about the work the organization does. It makes them feel good and that they are making a difference.

12:34Anastasia Taber: Yeah, I've heard of the giving appreciated assets as a tax strategy.

12:39Bill Taber: Mm-hmm. Yep. Can be a win-win situation. Giving can also be tax smart. What should a listener know about how giving works at tax time? And how do you make sure that the tax benefits benefit doesn't drive the decision about who or how much to give?

12:55Anastasia Taber: Yeah, that second part I think is really important because in tax advice, in tax law, and tax world, people can get really absorbed in okay, exactly how much of a tax break or tax benefit does this offer to if I proceed with charitable giving? I think at the end of the day, you're still gonna need to give that money. away. It's more like, is there a cause that you are really passionate about? There have been a couple of tax law changes with the major legislation that came out in summer of 2025. So beginning this year, if you do not itemize on your tax return, your US tax return, you can deduct up to a thousand dollars if you're a single filer or two thousand if you're filing jointly for your cash contributions to certain qualified organizations. If you do itemize, then you have the slight change, which is just this is what keeps the tax preparers in business, honestly. Is all of these tiny little changes and nuances. There will be a 0.5% of income floor.

14:07Bill Taber: Okay.

14:07Anastasia Taber: What this means is if you say your income was $100,000 and you're gonna give a thousand dollars to a charity and you itemize, and you itemize, then the first five hundred dollars of that you cannot deduct. So you can only deduct five hundred. dollars. Honestly, I just why? Why do we have to make the tax code so complicated? And this I'm saying this as someone who is currently studying for her tax planning certificate. It is an incredible amount of education

14:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that you

14:43Anastasia Taber: need.

14:43Bill Taber: Well, maybe the people making these changes should uh be forced to communicate what they are and to people that n need to do their tax returns.

14:53Anastasia Taber: Yeah. The biggest thing to take away from this is so I would say like vast majority of people are taking the standard deduction on their taxes. The thing to know is that if you do actually contribute cash to charity, you can get a small tax break on your tax return that you file at the beginning of next year. So something to keep in mind. Yay.

15:18Bill Taber: Small amount, not all of them.

15:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

15:20Anastasia Taber: mean it's a thousand

15:22Bill Taber: for

15:22Anastasia Taber: single filers, two thousand for joints. So it's more than it was during the pandemic. Remember they had that one like if you contributed $300, you get a deduction or $600 if you're a joint. So this has kicked it up a notch.

15:35Bill Taber: Okay.

15:36Anastasia Taber: Yeah. So if you were thinking about contributing to charity and you know you're going to take the standard deduction, this is like an extra incentive to do that this year.

15:44Bill Taber: Great.

15:44Anastasia Taber: What do you see on tax motivated giving?

15:48Bill Taber: Well, we honestly don't have any clients that give money solely to receive a tax break or a write-off. Money, according to our friend Joseph Campbell, the mythologist, is an energy facilitating force or a flow in the life of others. Given to the right causes for the right reasons, it can help an organization flourish. And thoughtful giving like that makes that happen.

16:11Anastasia Taber: So we're saying don't focus on the tax breaks. They're just a side benefit. Focus on the feeling that you get from making these donations. To qualified charities, I have to also caveat that. They have to be qualified.

16:25Bill Taber: And the definition of qualified is

16:27Anastasia Taber: The IRS says yes. We accept this. Okay. SA qualified charity. There is a website you can use for tax exempt organizations. Search. Dad, what have you seen in 45 years of working with clients about the people who give well? And what do they have in common?

16:46Bill Taber: Interesting question. I I've seen a pattern of clients gifting appreciated ad. assets, which allows their estates to continue growing, but gifts a portion of their financial success to worthy causes and organizations. People that give well live full and connected lives. They give with no thought to receiving anything back in return. The more they give, the more they seem to get back out of life. They seem to radiate a confidence that draws a greater good into their lives. Their service to others releases energy which can bring deeper meaning into their lives. And particularly what I've noticed the most is that they are great people and just plain fun to be around.

17:27Anastasia Taber: I think your last point is interesting because it's not just, okay, it's having an internal impact on them and how they feel about their lives and themselves, but that is changing how others perceive. them. Like you said, it's all an energy.

17:42Bill Taber: Mm-hmm. And you know, the the definition of generous again is unselfish and giving, large, ample, bountiful, noble in spirit. I mean, who would not want to be around a person like that?

17:54Anastasia Taber: Yeah, those sound like pretty nice people to be around. For these clients, did it matter what the amount was, or did it matter more how intentional? they were about what causes or how they gifted?

18:06Bill Taber: It was definitely the intentionality of it.

18:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That

18:09Bill Taber: it was it was heartfelt.

18:10Anastasia Taber: Yeah.

18:11Bill Taber: How do you build giving into your plan so it's intentional? And what's one step that a listener can take before the end of the year?

18:18Anastasia Taber: I think it's really important, and this is definitely my planner perspective, which is why you guys are all here, right? Is you need to have a sense of what where your money is going, how much money is going to which pot, and be able to create a sustainable percentage or amount that you are then giving to charity. Because the last thing that you want to do is give too much in a way that now you need to take on debt. It's good to be generous. I think that is also deeply connected to people's values, like what their family taught them. I can think of an example a friend shared with me. Her grandma used to give whenever she saw a homeless person, would give them money. That was just a value that she passed on. And it was really important to honor her grandma. I think that is a beautiful way to honor someone you love and to live the values that you were taught. If it becomes like a regular practice, that's when the planner in me is like, let's build it into a budget. Let's make sure that it's sustainable. If there's a particular charity that you'd really like to give to, if you regularly contribute to your church, do so in a way that is sustainable for your cash flow that allows you to continue building

19:37up your wealth because. if you give sustainably while also saving, like if you're able to have sustainable cash flow throughout your life, then over time you're investing, your assets grow. And as you get older, you can contribute even more to these charitable causes and these causes organizations that really matter to you. So I think that's number one is make it sustainable. You know, you can also do some what you call mental accounting, right? Maybe if I don't even have that much to give this year, maybe I'll cut back on something else that I could go without. Like I think of people who go through Lint and they they give up something that they live without for six weeks. What if it's going to a coffee shop? or going out to eat or some entertainment expense? Something that you could reasonably cut back on for this period of time. And instead of just like in that exercise that we said at the beginning

20:39of this podcast where people were given five dollars and twenty dollars and said either spend it on themselves or spend it on other people, you could easily do something like that where you're just cutting back on this one area of your life. for a time, a period of time, and then contributing that amount of money to a cause of your choice. And seeing like how much of an impact that has on on how you feel and if that does improve your outlook and your sense of well being.

21:05Bill Taber: Mm-hmm. I believe it will. And in addition to what you're saying, I think if money is tight and you can't take that certain percentage that's sustainable, then the cycle decide on a commitment to provide a certain amount of your time and talents to benefit others.

21:19Anastasia Taber: That's true.

21:19Bill Taber: And that can work just as well.

21:21Anastasia Taber: Yes, there are lots of organizations out there that are always looking for volunteers. And it can be in any sort of pursuit that you love. Like I had volunteered at an animal shelter. I helped mentor ESL learners one year. I have gone to retirement communities and spent an hour socializing with seniors who live there and were looking for, you know, social companionship. There are lots of organizations out there that would love to have some of your time. So if you have, if you can't spare the money, but you can spare the time, that's absolutely an excellent option to pursue. Generosity doesn't have to wait until you're wealthy. When it's built into your plan and based on your values, it can make a meaningful difference, not just for others, but for your life too.

22:19Bill Taber: The act of giving, either my time or my money, has had a hugely positive impact on my life, allowing me to feel like my life has purpose and that I've made a meaningful difference. Giving is a flow of energy that as you give it out, it then returns to you, bringing you more love, more abundance, and more prosperity.

22:39Anastasia Taber: If this episode made you think of a cause that matters to you, start there. One cause, one amount this year.

22:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

22:47Bill Taber: if you'd like to keep going, join the Fineret Feneret wait list at the link in the show notes.

22:53Anastasia Taber: Thanks for listening and Happy Thanksgiving.

22:56Bill Taber: Happy Thanksgiving to you.

This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights