Super funds shift offshore amid currency hedging limits and regulatory scrutiny
Summary
James Kirby and David Bell discuss the structural shift of Australian superannuation assets offshore, noting that half of the eight largest funds now hold significant foreign exposure due to domestic market size constraints. Bell highlights that traditional currency hedging strategies relying on the Australian dollar as a 'cyclical currency' may have broken down, creating new risks for funds. The conversation covers the operational challenges of derivatives, including the need for credit ratings to secure hedging capacity and the systemic risks posed by currency settlements during market crashes. Finally, they address regulatory responses to scandals like First Guardian and the ongoing lack of transparency in unlisted asset valuations.
Key takeaways
- 1 Well, it might look like that, but I wouldn't say that's the case because you can manage your currency risk through hedging. And so you need to say, well, how much unhedged currency exposure does that fund have? And it may not, that those 60% and 40% numbers may not remain the case once you look look through the hedging programs that those funds have.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) · 9:36
- 2 The supply of hedging capacity from Australian banks is finite and subject to exposure limits; as super funds grow, they may face higher costs or inability to hedge domestically, forcing them to seek offshore banking relationships.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) · 15:21
Episode sections
- 0:09 – 4:01
Introduction and Scale of Superannuation
James Kirby introduces the topic of Australian superannuation funds shifting assets offshore, noting the system's size is approaching $5 trillion, or 160% of GDP. David Bell of the Conexus Institute confirms the scale is driven by demographics and market performance, viewing the large pool of savings as beneficial for the nation.
- 4:01 – 11:09
Offshoring Trends and Asset Allocation Differences
Kirby highlights that half of all assets in the eight largest super funds are now held offshore, with some funds like REST holding 60% and UniSuper only 40%. Bell explains this shift is due to the domestic market being too small for such large capital pools and notes that performance depends more on growth asset exposure than just the offshore percentage.
- 11:09 – 16:00
Currency Hedging and the 'Cyclical Currency' Regime
The discussion turns to currency risk, with Bell noting that traditional hedging relied on the Australian dollar acting as a 'cyclical currency' that rose when global markets fell. He warns this relationship may have broken down, citing the US 'Liberation Tariff Day' event, and notes that banks are imposing limits on hedging capacity for these massive funds.
- 16:00 – 18:53
AustralianSuper's AAA Rating and Derivatives Exposure
Bell explains that AustralianSuper obtained a AAA credit rating to manage credit exposure limits with banks for derivatives used in hedging. This allows funds to access larger hedging capacities from both domestic and offshore banks as their portfolios grow.
- 18:53 – 22:17
Transparency, Labeling, and Unlisted Assets
Bell criticizes the lack of standardized labeling for super fund options (e.g., 'balanced' vs 'growth') and the difficulty in comparing unlisted asset valuations. He notes that while regulators like APRA are raising valuation standards, the lack of daily market pricing for unlisted assets creates significant valuation challenges.
- 22:17 – 28:43
Gold Allocation and Systemic Risk
Bell explains that super funds rarely hold physical gold because it produces no income and is viewed as speculative, though some hold gold producers. He also discusses the systemic risk of hedging: if markets crash and the AUD falls, funds may owe large settlement amounts on currency contracts, forcing asset sales at inopportune times.
- 28:43 – 33:56
First Guardian Scandal and Regulatory Response
Kirby and Bell discuss the First Guardian collapse, attributing investor losses to a false sense of security provided by the superannuation system's regulatory framework. Bell notes that APRA is introducing measures to tighten lead generation rules and require platforms to hold capital to refund victims in future similar events.
Assets discussed
| Asset | Kind | Stance | Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gold | commodity | neutral | Some big super funds, for instance, don't have any gold. Though we have someone like Morgan Stanley saying up to 20% twenty percent could be held in gold by very wealthy investors. |
“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.
Claims worth verifying
Australian superannuation assets are approaching $5 trillion, representing approximately 160% of GDP.
James Kirby ·2:18
How to verify: Check Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA) quarterly superannuation statistics for total industry superannuation funds (ITSF) assets. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Half of all assets in the eight largest super funds are held offshore, with an aggregate of 48% overseas.
James Kirby ·6:35
How to verify: Review the Commonwealth Bank of Australia (CBA) report on foreign exchange activity of big super funds, or individual fund annual reports for the eight largest funds. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The Australian dollar is a 'cyclical currency' that rises when global markets fall.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·13:17
How to verify: Analyze historical correlation data between the AUD/USD exchange rate and global equity indices (e.g., S&P 500) over the past few decades. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
APRA is proposing regulations requiring super funds to hold capital to refund victims in future similar events.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·32:18
How to verify: Review APRA's consultation papers or final determinations regarding the First Guardian scandal and consumer protection measures. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Macquarie and Netwealth voluntarily refunded victims of the First Guardian scandal.
James Kirby ·31:52
How to verify: Check press releases or investor communications from Macquarie and Netwealth regarding refunds for First Guardian investors. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
ASIC is focusing on growing Australia's capital markets.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·5:14
How to verify: Review ASIC's annual reports or public statements regarding capital market reform and growth initiatives. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceDo your own research
- Verify the current offshore allocation percentages for the eight largest super funds via their annual reports or APRA data.
- Check the credit ratings and derivatives exposure limits of major super funds like AustralianSuper through their financial statements.
- Review APRA's recent regulatory updates on lead generation rules and capital requirements following the First Guardian collapse.
- Analyze historical AUD performance during global market downturns to assess the validity of the 'cyclical currency' hedging strategy.
- Compare valuation methodologies for unlisted assets across different super funds to identify transparency gaps.
- Investigate the availability and cost of currency hedging capacity from major Australian banks for large institutional investors.
- Look for counter-arguments regarding the stability of the AUD as a hedge against global equity volatility.
- Check for any conflicts of interest in the Conexus Institute's research or the speakers' affiliations with super funds or banks.
Full transcriptexpand
0:09James Kirby: Hello and welcome to the Australians Money Puzzle Podcast. I'm James Kirby. Welcome aboard, everybody.
0:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
0:16James Kirby: know, apart from the family home, the majority of Australians now have most of their wealth in super superfunds. funds.
0:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
0:24James Kirby: many of our listeners would have. substantial money in big superfunds. And the question is emerging: what are the big funds actually doing with your money? But more to the point, where have they put your money and your savings? There is a huge shift taking place as Australian super savings move offshore. Everything. not just shares, shares, bonds, private equity, property, all of these assets are increasingly shifting offshore. And it's a trend that isn't going to stop. But I wonder is it safe? What are the risks to your super? My guest today is David Bell. He's the executive director of the Conexus Connexus Institute, which is a super superannuation and retirement think tank. Hi David, how are you?
1:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hi
1:19Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): there, James. I'm really good, thanks. And love this topic. So very happy to be here.
1:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
1:25James Kirby: talk to David quite regularly, folks, on this issue. So I'm delighted to have him on the show. And we both saw a a report recently, which gave us certainly gave me a a window into super that I'd never seen before. And it came from Commonwealth Bank of All People, and its nature was that it was a report about foreign exchange activity of the big funds. And now that they are so enormous, they actually could affect, not kidding, they literally could affect the course of the dollar, of the Australian dollar, because there's so much money now in super. But the first thing I want to explain to listeners is I wonder, David, do people realize, first of all, the scale of Super? I mean, we're coming up on five trillion dollars, 160% of GDP. Is it po is that a positive? I mean, by that I mean it's reaching a scale unprecedented, perhaps even by the architects, the original architects of it. And is it useful that our super is now so big and also that it's increasingly concentrated in a handful of gigantic funds?
2:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Big question to start off with, James, and many parts to it. But um the size, you're right. We may not get to five trillion dollars by the end of the calendar year. Obviously, that what the markets do is a big determination. determinant of that. But the demographics of Australia means there's still inflows going into the system. And then you get market performance is actually the biggest driver of the increase in size. And if you think about the last four or five years since COVID, it's been a really good run for markets. And you're right, that that measure of GDP or super versus GDP around that 160% number. is a bit quirky comparing an asset with an economic output measure. But I think if you think of how big is super relative to the size of the economy, it just shows you that it's a huge asset that Australia has there. And so you're right to ask, well, is this actually a healthy thing? Is it in the national interest? And my answer would be yes. Great. If I was offered a situation where we had a significant pool of retirement savings as a country, or the alternative scenario that we didn't, I'd I'd definitely take that scenario.
3:50James Kirby: Yes, of course. Yeah. I I I and I don't disagree at all. But so it's the fourth biggest pension and retirement system in the world, folks. In the world.
4:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now
4:01James Kirby: here's, you know. the traditional trope always was: well, Australia is only 2% of global markets, and what are you doing with 90% of your investments in Australia? Sure, that all makes sense. On an individual basis. But are there dimensions, David, that perhaps will raise new issues when our super Supersystem, system or all it it already has, and I'm again reading directly from the CVA. report, half of all assets are now already offshore, and it's going to grow and grow. So there's a huge gap, right? We only we have 2% of the global markets roughly, but we have more than half of our money, which is going to dictate our retirement offshore. So are there issues that perhaps weren't obvious in the early days starting to form here?
4:54Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, it's it's there are. And that's because the size of our supersystem has grown far faster than the size of our capital markets. And there's been lots of other research. For instance, ASIC's been having a large focus on how to get our capital markets growing again. But in the meantime, once you become too large in your local market, you start to dominate that market, you lose the ability to move your portfolio around if you're if it's just like-minded people holding the same pot of money. And so the natural position was to go offshore. And your stat on the 50-50 split between domestic and international is true. If we come back in a year's time, it will be even more in the favor of international because our domestic market. markets aren't growing, but our and so that just leads you offshore. So the numbers I hear are that in some cases 70%, some cases even higher, all money going into the system now is going offshore.
5:53James Kirby: Going offshore. I wonder though, that I mean, I understand the logic that the funds are so big that our market was too small for them. I understand that. But I wonder if is it necessarily a positive? That means they move offshore. I just want to read out something, folks. This is really interesting. It depends on which super fund you're in. And as you know, you know, there's eight funds really. The eight huge funds, and they have the vast majority of superannuation savings of everyone listening in their in their books, on their books. So so this report showed that just now, 2026, among the eight largest big superfunds, okay, the aggregate money overseas is about 48%. But if you look inside, the biggest funds, the really big funds, often hold much, much more. REST, for instance, which is one of the bigger industry funds, has 60% offshore. Host Plus has 58% offshore. And you say, all right, okay, well, all the big funds have a lot of money offshore. That's the trend.
7:01But then UniSuper, the fourth biggest fund, has only 40% offshore. It holds materially less of its assets overseas. Now, David, my simplistic journal brain says if one fund has 60% offshore and the other fund has 40% offshore,
7:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): one
7:24James Kirby: of them is wrong. Right?
7:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It
7:28James Kirby: seems to me that one of them has either got too much or too little. What do you think? I mean, why is there such disparity? And if I was in one of those funds, should I,
7:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): how
7:37James Kirby: should I react to? that? Should I feel better that one fund has more or less offshore? Unisuper has 40%. Am I in it? And they're perfectly good. Their results are probably broadly similar, actually, to the other funds, right? But their balance is quite different. So be watching this, what does it tell us?
7:54Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): First of all, I would say that's what makes a market. The fact that you have got different participants and different chief investment officers constructing different portfolio. portfolios. I don't think you can just look at that 40%, 60% type number offshore because it's what assets your money is going into, which are particularly important. And so for instance, if one of those funds that has more offshore is doing that through fixed income, well, that's probably not as meaningful as if they got their offshore exposure into global equities, which have been where all the performance has been. So there is a little bit of nuance there to tease out. And so my framing would be that the biggest decision a CIO or chief investment officer has to make is how much exposure they have to growth assets rather than defensive. And then it is, well, do I get my growth exposure domestically or do I get it offshore? So some of the funds have done really well. have been ones who've overweighted their listed equity exposure into global markets and less less domestically.
8:58James Kirby: Absolutely. And some, as you know, as everyone would know, some funds have shot the lights out due to that exposure to growth equities. And that's all fine. But here's, I mean, just very simply, if I have one fund that has 40% of its asset. assets offshore, I have another fund that has 60% of its assets offshore. I'm thinking of choosing between these two funds with my money, my life savings. One thing I know for sure is that the fund that has much, much less offshore has much, much less currency risk. Isn't that for sure? Isn't that a risk on the table?
9:36Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Well, it might look like that, but I wouldn't say that's the case because you can manage your currency risk through hedging. And so you need to say, well, how much unhedged currency exposure does that fund have? And it may not, that those 60% and 40% numbers may not remain the case once you look look through the hedging programs that those funds have. So this is where our industry struggles a little bit to provide the right transparency. to consumers around what the real exposures are. So it always so but you're right to call it out. And then you have to ask that extra question to find out.
10:12James Kirby: Well, folks, in the next part of the show, we're going to take a look at this issue about whether your fund has enough or more than enough or too much offshore. And crucially, with this trend, have they insurance insured your money? Have they hedged sufficiently? This report, by the way, suggests that industry as a whole may not have
10:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a message.
10:49James Kirby: Hello, welcome back to the Australians Money Puzzle Podcast. James Kirby here talking to David Bell of the Connexis Institute. We're talking about your money in super and the enormous change that's slowly happening. It's sort of like gradually, then suddenly, in some respects. And this is because there has been a shift offshore of super money, which has been happening on a strategic basis, if you know what I mean, for some time. But of course, the tremendous profits made by the super funds in offshore equities particularly has been lifting this trend considerably in recent times. Now, one of the things we've just been talking about in the first segment was it introduces a change to your super, and it means your fund. has more money offshore. And the issue is that as safe really as having it onshore? Now, David, traditionally, I mean the textbooks always said the same thing about hedging. Roughly 30% should be hedged. That's what the textbooks used to say. And as we look at the big super funds, we find that's roughly it, maybe 30%
11:59or so. This is very broad of all big super funds. have have about 30% of their money offshore hedged. And that was all fine in the old days, if you know what I mean. But this the the point now is that there is so much offshore.
12:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
12:15James Kirby: of course, fixed income that has to be the the funds need to completely hedge that if they want to sort of set basically send a guarantee returns for people. It's more important that they are hedged. So could you explain to us what used to happen and why they need perhaps to spend a lot more on hedging than they're doing?
12:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah
12:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): it's a really interesting dynamic. So when you look at the historical analysis, you're correct James to highlight that you traditional practice has been to fully hedge offshore fixed income investments and even assets that have secure cash flow flows like unlisted infrastructure, you might hedge that to a pretty high degree. But then you look at your global equities book, which is actually now the biggest asset class for most super funds. And this is where the hedging decision is really difficult. And historically, you would have done the analysis and you would have identified that Australia has a currency which you call a cyclical currency. which means that when markets are going strong, the Australian dollar is typically going up. But then when the market crashes, if US stocks crash, the Australian dollar tends to go down sharply as well. So to some of the major crises, that's done really well. And what that means is that you get this offsetting effect that equities fall, but the Australian dollar value of those equities actually goes up because the currencies fallen. And so the natural position for many funds was to have very low hedging levels or potentially moderate hedging levels.
13:51That's the history of it.
13:53James Kirby: Because they safely assumed this would happen each time. But this there's question now whether this will continue to happen. What's the risk here?
14:03Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Well, the it's probably what I would call some sort of a regime change. So there's many decades of looking at this relationship and you have to be careful, you see something happen, then you try and s explain it away after the event, some sort of confirmation bias. But so we should always be asking, Well, could this change? And we had a little taste of that change last year with the liberation. Tariff Day in the US when the markets fell in the US, but the Australian dollar sort of fell, but then it bounced back reasonably quickly. So that relationship broke down a little bit. And so the question could be well, it might get a little bit noisier, but is it permanently now a changed relationship? And that's what a lot of CIOs and currency strategists would be thinking. about when they're trying to determine what's the appropriate hedge level going forward.
14:56James Kirby: And by inference, the question, is it too low? But that's the question, isn't it? Is it too low? Yeah.
15:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yes, that's right. Now, you would think, is it too low is the main question, but there's also this fascinating dynamic, and that is that the ability, the supply of hedging is isn't infinite. So generally, the funds are dealing with the big Australian banks. They have limits of exposure to each fund. And as these funds get bigger and bigger, at some point it might become more costly to hedge, or banks say, look, we just can't deal with you beyond this limit. And so that's actually a pressure to the to hedging less. And that's it's there's interesting dynamics both. ways.
15:39James Kirby: That's really interesting. Because again, this is the thing: victims of their own success that they are so gigantic. Tell me, is there a a solution if that occurs?
15:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I think there is a solution to the bank banks and the availability to hedge. And that is that funds start to have more constructive relationships with offshore investment banks and start to and and perhaps there the recent announcement by Australian Super that they had a triple A credit rating.
16:11James Kirby: They went and got a credit rating. So you might tell listeners what happened there and why it matters. So folks if you're in Australian Super, which is the biggest super fund, and by the way, this will be copied by all the big funds very soon, I'm sure they went and they got a credit rating. And they got a triple A, which is better than it's better than Victoria. Wouldn't be hard. Some people might say. Okay, but the point I want to make is they went and got a credit rating, triple A credit rating. God is an enormous exercise to do this for the super fund. And people are saying, why did they do that? And they're trying to get an explanation. Oh, you know, they need them for derivatives and all that. But you might articulate, David. how that could be useful down the track.
16:55Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, so that's correct. You've framed it up well, James. So a a super fund might do all these activities with banks, and they a lot of them are derivatives. So hedging your currency involves derivatives, for instance. And then when you hedge your currency, every time it moves, it creates exposure like the bank mayo. may owe the fund some money, or the fund may be on the hook to settle that contract. And that's what's known as credit exposure. And banks will have credit exposure limits. And then they'll say, well, we'll have a bigger limit for a fund that has a higher credit rating. And so you can sort of see why it makes sense to go out there and get a credit rating. And then as funds have to have, because of their size and increase. increasing size, they have to have a larger range of banks. They'll have to all those funds will have to start introducing themselves to offshore banks. And they say, Well, well what is it? What are these Australian superannuation funds? And then
17:51James Kirby: That's right. They say, Well who are you? It's not like they're known. They may be known in
17:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): business,
17:55James Kirby: but they they it's a different thing to a dealing where you're asking directly for commercial relationships. So that's why they got this credit rating and it was AAA, which is fascinating. AAA, obviously, folks being the best. It's fascinating, I think, that we know so little really about some of the big funds. And a point I think, which is personally I find disgraceful, is that you can't even attend some of these big fund meetings, like CBUS, for instance. I tried to attend a CBUS. AGM. And I was told that unless you're a member, you can't attend. Fortunately, my wife, I happen to be in CBUS from her once upon a time journalist superfund. And so I attended as her guest. But the point I'm making is there these funds are so important, but they don't have the transparency or answerability or the demands placed upon them just yet that. big companies have. Do you think that would change?
18:53Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): It's interesting. So, some as you're saying that statement and proposition, I'm sort of nodding my head, but I'm also shaking my head a little bit because the regulatory requirements on funds is really significant. There's a lot of disclosures that they have to provide. And the APRU is the primary prudential regulator for Super. They do make a lot of. information available, but not everything. So some of it's data capture that just remains for them to do their risk work and so forth. So the question you're really asking is do consumers and researchers have access to sufficient information? And
19:30James Kirby: what is it you can't get?
19:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
19:32Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I'd like to know exactly what's happening in portfolios. And the challenge there is that you want that information in the same way. And obviously, funds communicate and define things differently to each other. And that makes comparisons really difficult.
19:46James Kirby: Absolutely. Before we go to the break, I wanted to ask you that. The whole thing about the balanced fund, that they can each define it differently. I mean, I think that's misleading to consumers. What's your view?
19:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Look,
19:58Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): it's been a topic that's upset me for years. I've I actually ran a project for nearly five years to try and get standardization in the labeling. So both, and it's not so it's the way a fund is labeled. So a growth and a balance and a conservative and so forth. But there's also the issue of how you actually define the growth exposure of the underlying assets. And here the funds have different practices to each other as well. So I feel like I nearly got there on that one to try and get this industry to step forward. But ultimately, that was a bit of a fail on my side. I'm so disappointed about that. Every time you do something that improves transparency, there'll be winners and losers. And there might there is an agency there for the funds that may not come out looking good to push against that. And that's just the nature of the superannuation. system and probably any competitive system.
20:54James Kirby: Okay, folks, we're going to take a short break and we're going to look at some of the things. I know you're always asking the preference about unlisted assets in a superfund. So what's going on there? Also, what don't they have? Some big super funds, for instance, don't have any gold. Though we have someone like Morgan Stanley saying up to 20% twenty percent could be held in gold by very wealthy investors. Why not? It hasn't hurt them perhaps this year, but will it hurt them in the future? We'll be back in a moment. Hello, welcome back to the Australians Money Puzzle Podcast. I'm James Kirby. I'm talking to David Bell of the Connexus Institute, C-O-N-E-X-U-S Institute. That is one of the few sort of policy think tanks around on retirement and super. David and I go back a long way. I've talked to him for many
21:57years. He's got a terrific view, big picture of the super system and the retirement system, and he can talk. on any dimension of it. And I thought what I would do, David, I've collected some questions from our own listeners. Basically, I haven't listed them by name, but what I've done is I've picked up the topics that have come through on our questions about super. And you, if you would be so good, I'm going to throw you some random questions that have come up basically this year on Super that I'm sure many listeners want to know about. So but just to finish off where we were talking about the big funds, there was a couple of when gold was running hot, which was actually the end of last year, there was a lot of talk about why don't the big superfunds have gold. Of course, now that gold has been doing nothing for uh a few months, there's no questions about it, but they'll return when gold gets strong again. So that seems a strange exception with super funds considering central bank. banks are great buyers of gold. Is there some sort of bias against it inside super, big super?
22:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): It's interesting and it's a tough one to get to the bottom of. But what I would say is that gold has historically been a very difficult asset for super funds to allocate to. And I think it's partly because physical gold doesn't really produce any income. And so they're saying, look, I can even put my money in a bank account and earn X, or I can put it here. And it feels through that trustee lens like a far more speculative asset, even though it's really there to help you in certain economic scenarios. So it's actually, for me, you can think of it as a risk management role as well. So I know some funds are interested in it, but they find it difficult to allocate to. And I'm aware some funds get their gold exposure through listed gold producers, but that introduces different things like production costs and
23:48James Kirby: that's not gold in the sense that we're talking about it, yeah, as a commodity.
23:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, pure exposure is not not too common.
23:55James Kirby: Right. Okay. So that's obvious by its absence among the big super funds. Retail and industry?
24:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yep. I mean you might find little bits here and there, but there's not a lot of um dread gold exposure.
24:07James Kirby: That's interesting. We've often had questions about that. We often have questions too about the unlisted assets. I think that there was always concern about the unlisted assets in super in that basically they didn't have clear market pricing in them. I think that's cool to some degree because it's been so successful. What's your view about the unlisted assets? Do they tell us enough? Do they price them properly and rapidly enough to be to tell us anything useful?
24:36Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I think what has happened over that time is that APRA, who's a prudential regulator, has really raised the bar on valuation practices. And I think that is still being raised further. And it so they set some standards, they engage with the industry. and then they push a bit harder and give feedback. So that's definitely ongoing. And I've seen ASIC do the same thing. They're the other regulator who looks at superannuations. So the industry's on a curve there of improving valuations. But it is a really difficult and fundamental question because if a listed version of a very similar asset dropped 10% on a day, would you really? be confident to devalue your unlisted asset by that price? Because it may well bounce back the next day. And that's really the essence of the challenge. So it's not just how do you view unlisted assets? It's nearly
25:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): are
25:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): listed assets truly that efficient when they bump around so much day to day?
25:33James Kirby: Very good. I mean, like next DC, it fell 40% in a week and it and then it went up by 35% the next week. And if it was unlisted, you would be asking them to do yeah, to revalue twice. Okay, I get your point. Very interesting. Look, one thing I should have asked you on the hedging front was if it's the case that it would seem almost certain that more assets will go offshore. And if it's the case that traditional natural hedging strategies, by that I mean not doing any and letting the markets solve your problem may not work in the future, then the funds will have to hedge more. And this CBA report actually literally identified how much and how much more they should hedge. But it would increase their costs, wouldn't it? And if it increased their costs, would it pinch their returns?
26:18Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Um the cost of currency hedging, not necessarily costs. There can actually be a return that comes with it. It just depends what the interest rates are in different countries. That's the way you price a currency hedging contract.
26:30James Kirby: Now what I mean is would it literally increase their costs?
26:34Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Well it's hard to say to any significant degree. As their footprint becomes bigger all those frictional costs become a little bit higher. But I think we're talking basis points, not anything too significant. What also increases is systemic risk. So just give me 10 seconds to try and explain that. If there's a huge fall in a market crash, a huge fall in the Australian dollar, funds are protected, but they actually owe a lot of money to settle their currency contracts. And that's actually a big need for them to have to sell assets. And that's sort of it something that the RBA and the regulators really focus on a lot, what we might call a system. systemic risk event. So that's actually another incentive for funds not to over hedge their books because that raises that that risk event there. It's a really complex issue.
27:27James Kirby: It's a dilemma for the big funds. If they hedge, then in theory they protect your super savings more than they had previously. But then in reality, again, because they're so large that to actually execute those hedges at a time of crisis could create a systemic risk inside the system. Is that basically what's on the table?
27:53Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, that's right. There's that scenario. We don't think we've done the modeling ourselves, and we're very comfortable that the system hasn't reached that point. But You can just sort of see all the issues that are at play when you might say, Oh, yeah, we should do more of this. Well, there's two or three other issues on the other side that you have to balance out.
28:12James Kirby: Again, it's they're all issues of just how large they are, huh? But again, it's that victim of their
28:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): own success.
28:17James Kirby: And they're not their ch not their decision to move our money offshore. But they had to. They were compelled to. They couldn't keep investing in. the ASX. They could buy the ASIC several times over. Is this basically how it in reality isn't it? All right. I wanted to ask you one or two other quick questions that have come up. This is a fascinating one about the first Guardian affair, which is the worst thing that has happened in super for a long time, possibly ever. And it's still playing out. But the fascinating point is that typically people took money out of established superfunds. super funds that we're talking about, big super, they put it elsewhere, they were seduced into doing this by lead generators. And many have lost some or all of their savings. What strikes me, David, is how many people thought that their super, because it was super, that they couldn't lose it, that it was super, because they were forced by government mandatory savings,
29:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): there
29:19James Kirby: was there seems to have been a belief, if you like, across the market that somehow super was safe. Why do you think that that formed? Because it's not, right? Let's just put all the two. It's not. So why do you think people had that view?
29:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): We've clearly seen scenarios where people have lost a lot of their superannuation. And so I haven't interviewed any of those really tragic, unfortunate victims of Shield and First Guardian, but I can actually empathize with their situation. So, because there's two layers, or even three layers, of things happening here. One is that they all were provided financial advice, and they would have trusted that advisor and trusted the advice they were given and took comfort from. the fact that there's regulations and policy that sits over the practices of advisors. And then, secondly, they invest through a super fund, and super funds are highly regulated entities. And they may not be thinking the words legislation and regulation, but I think sitting in the back of their minds is well, these are all areas where I have trust, and there's institutional settings. designed to protect me.
30:29James Kirby: They drew comfort from the institutional settings, but it let them down.
30:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Those multiple layers let them down.
30:36James Kirby: Is there anything to stop this happening again, David?
30:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, there's a huge amount of work going on. The Minister, Dr. Daniel Molino, announced a range of a large range of measures which are tightening up at the financial advice level. particularly through what you call lead generation. And then secondly that super platform level, which is where it's funds that offer a significant amount of investment choice. And that's where Shield and First Guardian were on some of those platforms. So there's a lot of practices going in there. So for me, James, it's actually submission time at the moment. We're writing submissions on all these things to try and help contribute to that.
31:14James Kirby: Is there anything you're asking for that's a priority?
31:17Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): No, we think APRA's done a really good job in what they're proposing. You just have to, you always have to be a little bit careful to think well, if I do something over here, does that affect reshape the whole system? And so we're doing a little bit of work on that, thinking if things get a little bit more tighter and safer. for platforms to protect consumers from that scenario ever happening again, does that mean that money might flow elsewhere? And is that healthy or dangerous? It's those types of things that we spend a lot of our time thinking about.
31:52James Kirby: It was interesting how Macquarie and Netwealth voluntarily refunded people who were caught in the First Guardian. Equity trustees didn't in and our are actually pursuing it through the courts. And somebody else, I think, have I forgotten someone?
32:07Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Um yeah, uh maybe Diversa.
32:11James Kirby: Do you think they will ultimately voluntarily refund their cases?
32:18Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Oh, I don't have any insight into that, James, but it's actually proposed in the regulations by APRA that funds do have to refund in the future and they'll have to keep capital aside to show that they've got the capability of funding these shortfalls should they occur again.
32:36James Kirby: That's very interesting. We might leave it at that. That was a very interesting, terrific to talk to you, David, and to give us different windows into the supersystem which so many people have so much money in, but we still know so little about in many cases. Thank you very much. for coming on today.
32:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Pleasure. Thank
32:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you.
32:54James Kirby: That was David Bell, folks. He is the executive director of the Connexus Institute and basically one of the real policy thought leaders in Super and Retirement Savings. We don't really have many of them, that is, that work independent of the big funds themselves. So it's great to have him on the show. Thanks for listening. Keep the emails rolling. Themoneypuzzle at the Australian.com.au. Thank you very much for those Google reviews. Love to see them. Thank you very much for putting some new reviews on. We really appreciate that. And today's show was produced by Leah Samaglu. Talk to you soon.