The Mineral Rights Podcast: Mineral Rights | Royalties | Oil and Gas | Matt Sands

Matt Sands answers listener questions on NARO credits, shut-in wells, and Louisiana mineral servitudes

35 min Listen to the original Episode page
Mineral RightsRoyaltiesOil and GasLegal ComplianceTexas Railroad CommissionLouisiana LawNARO CertificationTitle Verification

Summary

Matt Sands addresses listener inquiries regarding NARO certification credits, the implications of shut-in wells on lease terms, and the distinction between selling land versus leasing. He advises on recovering unpaid royalties through contingency fee litigators and calculating interest in Texas allocation wells using Railroad Commission filings. The discussion highlights the complexity of Louisiana's mineral servitude system, urging owners to verify title history and check for unclaimed funds. Sands emphasizes the necessity of written agreements and proper title documentation before engaging legal counsel.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    Um it's really got to be in writing for it to be enforceable.

    Matt Sands · 34:24

Episode sections

  1. 2:21 – 4:39

    NARO Certification Credits

    Matt Sands explains that his Mineral Management Basics course awards four hours of continuing education credit toward NARO certification, requiring submission of a certificate of completion and an affidavit of attendance.

  2. 4:39 – 7:30

    Shut-In Well and Lease Status

    Matt clarifies that if a shut-in gas well produces in paying quantities, the lease enters its secondary term held by production, and advises waiting for a division order.

  3. 7:30 – 8:39

    Selling Land vs. Leasing

    Matt references a previous episode covering the implications of selling land outright, distinguishing it from surface use agreements or standard oil and gas leases.

  4. 8:39 – 13:39

    Recovering Royalties from a Mentor

    Matt suggests consulting a litigator on a contingency fee basis for recovering royalties and warns against investing without receiving legal title documents.

  5. 13:39 – 18:50

    Calculating Interest in Allocation Wells

    Matt explains the Track Participation Factor (TPF) based on lateral length and advises checking the As Drilled Plat (ASDRIL) filed with the Railroad Commission to verify calculations.

  6. 18:50 – 25:55

    Landman Ethics and Attorney Conflicts

    Matt advises clarifying expectations and scope of work upfront, recommends verifying landman credentials through the AAPL, and reporting ethical violations to their committee.

  7. 25:55 – 32:01

    Louisiana Mineral Servitudes and Unclaimed Funds

    Matt explains Louisiana's unique mineral servitude system, which can expire after 10 years of non-use, and suggests checking parish clerk offices for title history.

  8. 32:01 – 33:23

    Louisiana Mineral Rights and Unclaimed Funds

    Matt advises checking lacashclaim.org or missingmoney.org for unclaimed royalty payments and consulting a Louisiana mineral attorney for chain of title issues.

  9. 33:23 – 34:01

    Importance of Title Documentation

    Speaker 2 and Matt emphasize gathering existing title documents and searching parish office deeds before consulting an attorney to establish a starting point for legal analysis.

  10. 34:01 – 35:13

    Episode Conclusion and Disclaimer

    The hosts conclude the segment, highlighting the unique legal aspects of different states and stating that enforceable agreements must be in writing, with a standard disclaimer that the content is not investment, legal, or tax advice.

Claims worth verifying

The Mineral Management Basics course awards four hours of continuing education credit toward NARO certification.

Matt Sands ·2:51

How to verify: Contact NARO registrar or review NARO-US.org continuing education requirements. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

NARO offers a $25 discount on the first-year introductory membership using the code MRPodcast.

Matt Sands ·4:11

How to verify: Visit NARO-US.org and apply the code during membership checkout. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

In Texas, signing and returning a division order is required to receive royalty payments.

Matt Sands ·6:56

How to verify: Review Texas Railroad Commission division order regulations or operator payment policies. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The Track Participation Factor (TPF) in allocation wells is based on the productive lateral length going through the mineral tract relative to the overall well length.

Matt Sands ·15:11

How to verify: Review Texas Railroad Commission allocation well rules or University of Texas papers on pooling and allocation. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

As Drilled Plats (ASDRIL) are publicly available filings with the Texas Railroad Commission showing well bore locations.

Matt Sands ·17:10

How to verify: Search Texas Railroad Commission online database for ASDRIL plats. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Louisiana mineral servitudes can expire after 10 years of non-use, reverting to the surface owner.

Matt Sands ·28:11

How to verify: Review Louisiana Revised Statutes regarding mineral servitudes and prescription. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The American Association of Professional Landmen (AAPL) has an ethics committee and guidelines for landmen.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·25:35

How to verify: Visit AAPL website and review their Code of Ethics and disciplinary procedures. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Reputable mineral funds typically structure investments as limited partnerships with formal legal paperwork.

Matt Sands ·12:11

How to verify: Review SEC filings or offering memoranda for public mineral funds. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

lacashclaim.org and missingmoney.org are websites where unclaimed royalty payments can be found.

Matt Sands ·32:40

How to verify: Visit lacashclaim.org (Louisiana State Treasurer's Unclaimed Property) and missingmoney.org (National Association of Unclaimed Property Administrators) to search for unclaimed funds. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Louisiana mineral law is more complicated than other states.

Matt Sands ·33:20

How to verify: Compare Louisiana mineral code provisions (e.g., regarding mineral servitudes and prescriptive periods) with statutes from other major oil-producing states like Texas or Oklahoma via state legislature websites. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The Mineral Rights Podcast should not be construed as investment, legal, or tax advice.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·34:47

How to verify: Review the podcast's website (MineralRightsPodcast.com) or the show notes for the full legal disclaimer text. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify NARO certification requirements and continuing education credit submission procedures on the National Association of Royalty Owners website.
  • Check the Texas Railroad Commission website for well status and division order requirements.
  • Review the As Drilled Plat (ASDRIL) filed with the Railroad Commission to verify Track Participation Factor calculations for Texas allocation wells.
  • Search lacashclaim.org and missingmoney.org for unclaimed royalty payments to identify potential unclaimed interests.
  • Consult the Louisiana Treasurer's office resources on unclaimed property and mineral servitudes.
  • Search parish office deeds to determine the current status of mineral ownership and identify gaps in the chain of title.
  • Verify landman credentials through the American Association of Professional Landmen (AAPL) and report ethical violations to their committee.
  • Consult a qualified attorney for legal advice on title disputes, probate, or contingency fee arrangements.
Full transcriptexpand

0:00Matt Sands: This episode is brought to you by SSNC Mineralware. Are you managing mineral assets and feeling overwhelmed?

0:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Unsure

0:07Matt Sands: if you're getting paid what you're owed? SSNC Mineralware is here to simplify the management of your minerals, royalties, and non-operated working interests. Mineralware's out-of-the-box features give you the tools you need to visualize and keep track of all of your assets in one place. Mineralware lets you know in seconds where your interests are, what's active, what acreage is open for lease, and if you're getting paid what you're owed. With mineralware, you can even automate your revenue and jib processing and eliminate tedious manual data entry, allowing you to focus on more pressing issues. Thousands of mineral owners rely on mineralware to keep their mineral management simple, automatic, and all in one place. Take control of your mineral assets today with SSNC Mineralware. To see a demo, you can visit their website at www.mineralware.com. That's M-I-N-E-R-A-L W-A-R-E.com.

1:08Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Are you ready to make the most of your oil and gas mineral rights? Welcome to the Mineral Rights Podcast. Get the knowledge and resources you need to manage your minerals and royalties. Here is your host, Matt Sands.

1:22Matt Sands: Hello and welcome to the Mineral Rights Podcast. I'm your host, Matt Sands, and I'm joined by my co-host, Justin Williams, and we're here to help you make the most of your minerals and royalties. In this uh latest episode of the Mineral Rights Podcast, we're going to answer your listener questions for November of 2026. Justin, after this, we've got uh one more set of listener questions for the year.

1:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um

1:45Matt Sands: hard to believe we're already in November. I know uh as we're recording this, Halloween's just a couple of days away. Leaves are falling off the trees. It's cool and uh fall is definitely in the air here.

1:56Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): It is, and it's just amazing how fast time goes. I feel like it was just last month we were saying this last year.

2:01Matt Sands: Yeah, but we're uh we're slowly working our way through here. This is uh mostly these are questions that we received in June of 2026. So thanks if you submitted a question for your patience. As always, if you have a question you'd like us to answer, you can send it to feedback at mineral rights podcast.com. So without further ado, let's dive into the first question here.

2:21Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): All right, First question here is from HB. HB says, Hi Matt, how many hours credit does Nero give for your course? And he's referring to Matt's mineral management course, which Matt, the program awards four hours total for uh the certificate that you give after you complete the course.

2:39Matt Sands: Yeah, that's right. After you complete all of the lessons, um you'll get a certificate of completion. Within the National Association of Royalty Owners, there's the mineral management program. And so that's what HB is referring to is that mineral management program requires continuing education credits to maintain your certification. There's the certified mineral manager and then the registered mineral manager. And if you take the mineral management basics course, you get four hours of credit because that's the length of the all of the videos that comprise the course, not to mention the amount of time that it would take if you actually went through the lessons and did the work for your mineral tract or your mineral interests. It would take longer than that. But at minimum, you know, just the credit for the time that you it takes to watch the videos and go through the lessons is four hours. So you get that at least that much credit when you submit an affidavit of attendance for uh completing the course. And then again, you know, you'd want to get that certificate of completion, that PD. PDF file, and send that in with uh with your uh request. So yeah, thanks for the question. That's a great point. And again, that was it's been some time since we reviewed that with uh Patty West, who was the registrar at the

3:51time, and uh that's what that was the termination at that point. But uh yeah, so if you have not heard about the National Association of Royalty Owners or the Mineral Management Program within NARA. NARO, definitely check it out. You can go to NARO-US.org. If you're not a member, use the code MR Podcast. It's all one word to get $25 off your first year introductory membership. So definitely check it out.

4:19Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Absolutely Matt. Yeah. And it the intent of the program is to to bring you in and have you walk away understanding how to manage your minerals. And Um then the program uh hopes to ensure that you stay up to date on the latest changes as well. And that's that's what our conventions at Nero are all about. We have a lot of experts who come in and talk about what's changing, what's on the forefront, and what's coming. All right, Matt. So our next one here is from Linda. Linda says uh she's a mineral rights owner in East Texas on lease renewable year three with a two-year two year renewal option, and that she sees through the Texas RCC online that there's been a shut-in shut in gas well. drilled, but new on the lease option is in July. She hasn't heard anything from the leasing company. What should she do now? Yeah,

4:58Matt Sands: this is a great question, Linda. It sounds like um as of when you wrote us, you were still within the primary term of that lease. In other words, within the first three years. And so that means that the the lease is still in effect. Um The fact that there has been what they call uh you see is a shut in gas well drilled, that means that your lease now, assuming that they um have production and paying quantities from that gas well, um, then your lease would go into the the uh secondary term, in other words, it'd To be held by production by that well. So you won't hear from the leasing company in terms of the lease. You should hear in terms of a division order once uh that well has started producing. So the fact that it shows a shut-in status on the railroad commission website shows that it's being completed or has recently been completed, and uh they're just getting things set up to to start uh selling gas in this case, since it's a gas well. So uh congratulations on that and definitely be on the lookout. for a division order and uh you should get that you know in a couple of months after that well has started producing. So definitely be on the lookout for that. If you have questions specific to exactly when you know that well started producing or when you know they're

6:17processing division orders or just to make sure that everything's in Things order with respect to your interest, I'd recommend reaching out to the uh the oil and gas company that drilled the well and ask them for more information. You can find the owner relations contact information. Usually, if you just do a Google search for the company name and go to the owner relations section of the website and then find their email address, and you can send them an email and ask uh for a status update. But uh sounds like everything's on on track and in progress. Uh so yeah, I don't think you really need to do much other than wait. for that division order. And in Texas, you do have to sign and return that division order in order to get paid royalties. So uh make sure that you uh turn that around in a timely manner. And also if you have questions about your decimal interest that's shown on the well, you know, it's always a good idea to confirm that that calculation is correct, at least from your information that you have, you know, the number of net acres you own, the the size of the unit. those types of things. And you can calculate your decimal interest. If you have questions about that or need help, uh feel free to reach out to me. I'm happy to help uh as I uh provide consulting to to clients on on those very questions. So uh yeah, good luck.

7:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All

7:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): right. Our next one from Cheryl. Cheryl says, um, hi, we just joined your site. Couldn't find anything related to gas compressor stations. Uh, she says the gas a company wants to. purchase some of our land and she wanted to hear uh our thoughts about it. And Matt, this was a a really great topic she brought up because we realized we we hadn't covered this or really talked about uh what to do in this situation.

7:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,

7:49Matt Sands: that's right. And that's really what triggered episode three thirty seven, which is what to do when an oil company wants to buy your land. And so that's generally why we uh addressed that topic was based on your question, Cheryl. So thank you for that question since we hadn't covered the concept of selling land, um we've talked about surface use agreements and, you know, oil and gas leases, so the the leasing side of things, but the sale of land outright, you know, adjacent to or part of a larger parcel that you own and you know the implications of you know what you need to think about. So that was all about um that episode. And so definitely check that out if you haven't already, because we went into more detail into that topic. So yeah, thanks again for your your question.

8:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Thanks,

8:32Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Cheryl. We always love suggestions like that. We haven't considered it helps us to to come up with new things to talk about and uh new things to explore for folks.

8:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay,

8:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): our next one here Matt is from a listener uh that is been in the industry. So he says, I'm a landman and a minor owner and I'm then grateful is was given the opportunity to get my foot in the industry's door. His biggest challenge right now is determining the best way to proceed and attempting to recover royalties owed to him back to 2005. Uh he worked for somebody for over 20 years and unfortunately sounds like he found out there were some unsavory business practices going on um and has left him in a situation maybe with a a clouded title on these minerals. And th he mentioned some working interests and other things, but Matt, this sounds like a really complicated situation where it sounds like an attorney is probably going to be his best option going forward. This is a terrible situation to find yourself in and have to navigate through, though I'm sure with the help of some trusted advisors, you certainly can.

9:26Matt Sands: Yeah, this is a tough situation because uh this listener trusted someone that they were their mentor, they worked for that person, and then found out that you know what what they perceived as as doing some things that were not above board. And, you know, in terms of the practice, was they were getting elderly people to invest money to buy oil and gas wells or buy minerals. And rather than giving them title to those interests, he kept the title and then paid them distribution. So they had a distribution rate. report with a payment. So he did at least pay them something, but um, according to this listener, they they claim that they that person didn't pay those investors correctly, and then that he did the same thing to them, as well as what they call quote unquote under other questionable things. So um they mentioned I think you kind kinda of answered your question in your email where you say it seems like an attorney would be the most reasonable.

10:27option. It's probably not a huge amount to recover unless punitive damages can be included.

10:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,

10:31Matt Sands: I definitely think that talking with an attorney that's licensed in the state where you are, where they where that person, uh the investor is, would be my first course of action. And it probably would be a litigator you need to go and and talk to, not just a normal like uh state law oil and gas type attorney that does. doesn't specialize in litigation. You would really want to go to somebody that is uh experienced with you know the process of going after the damages because what you would be looking at is trying to build your case and demonstrate the damages that you would be owed based on any uh potential wrongdoing, and then uh your attorney can help build your case and then understand, you know, is it worth going after? They might be able to do it on a contingency. fee basis. In other words, kind of what I see as a common thing is they would take a 30% cut of whatever damages you can recover. So if there's enough there to recover, then they might take your case on on just a contingency fee basis, you know, other words, success basis if if your case was strong. So yeah, good luck. I uh, you know, fortunately don't really have much else to say then than then definitely talk to an attorney and get some help there. But I think the the moral of the story here is, you know, that uh concept of trust but verify. And when it comes to oil and gas interest, if you're investing in oil and gas and you're not getting title to those interests,

11:51then that's a very risky position to be in because you're putting all your trust in that company that they're going to be doing the right things. Now there are very reputable companies out there that have mineral funds. and non-operative working interest funds that you definitely can invest with, and it's all on the up and up. They have all kinds of legal paperwork that explains the risks and the benefits and your rights. And it's typically structured as a limited partnership. So you would have some legal relationship with that company. In that case, where where where this person is describing, it doesn't sound like that at all. It sounds like they were just handing over money and then just getting a distribution report, but they probably didn't have, you know, they weren't a limited partner and this person that was, you know, swindling the the elderly out of their money wasn't the general partner in that relationship. It was just, you know, a a handshake type of a deal, which is very risky in in any business, let alone oil and gas, uh just because of the the other additional risks that come with it. You know, if the investment doesn't pay out. But uh yeah, good luck with everything. I hope that um hope it goes in your favor.

12:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,

12:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I think you summarized it well, Matt. I if you're if you believe you're buying ownership and not receiving those title documents, that's certainly a red flag. Um and you've really got to trust the company that you're giving money to and and it can't just be on a handshake. You know, these are a pr pretty much a regulated thing when it comes to any kind of uh reputable fund. So you should you should expect to see the formality of those the paperwork, the process, and all those different things. All right, Matt. So our next one here from Melissa. Melissa says in episode three or four, you mentioned uh resources for calculating interest for allocation wells. Can you please point me in the right direction? She says her biggest struggle right now is that a set of allocation wells the company she works for has an interest in, according to the title opinion, is being calculated off. of the net and gross acres, which is 1280 gross acres, and using a TPF is also being used for the allocation well. Is this correct? And what is the best way to find out the dedicated acreage an operator is going off of if they will not share title? Uh she says you worked in New Mexico and gas prior to the job, and allocation wells had have big my biggest struggle. Uh you're not alone, Melissa. Uh that is at allocation wells. certainly change it up. And then any resources you have on this topic would be appreciated. So, Matt, this is not an uncommon area to have problems in, that's for sure.

14:11Matt Sands: Yeah, this whole concept of allocation wells is unique to Texas. And we like uh Melissa mentioned, we covered that in episode 304, which was understanding Texas allocation wells and pooling. And the first thing um I did I see that there was a link that was broken. I had a link to a University of Texas paper that described allocation wells uh and the legal framework and all of that. And and for whatever reason, they moved that document and that link broke. So I'll I'll try to find that document. I have another uh a couple of other resources that I'll post in the show notes to this episode and then go back to that episode 304 and post it there. as well. Just to answer your question in general, the way that you calculate an allocation well interest, you mentioned the track participation factor, and that is generally based upon the productive lateral length going through either your unit or your actual mineral tract

15:11relative to the overall productive lateral length. So in other words, if it's a 10,000 foot well, it's a two-mile uh long horizontal well, with 10,000 feet being from the first take point to the last take point. And you have, let's say, just for ease of calculating it, let's say you have 5,000 feet going through your mineral tract, you would have one half, that would be your track participation factor in that allocation. Well, based on that portion. Now of course you have to consider your you know interest in that one half, you know, the the half of that unit. In other words, that if it was a section or a 640 acres, in this case out of the 1280 for the total, then you would have to figure out how many um net acres you had in and your mineral interest in that 640 six hundred and forty acres. that fraction, and then considering the fraction again, one half between the your mineral tract and then the overall length of the well. You know, that multiplied by your royalty rate. Now the tricky part about all this is it's very fact specific and depends exactly where that well bore goes. So sometimes you see it on a situation where there um have have not been any pooled interest. There's not a pooled unit that's

16:30actually part of it. When you have allocation wells it can actually span multiple pooled units. That's can all also can be an allocation well, but then there's times where it's just a you know a an assembly of different mineral tracts that are grouped together and they're allocating production based on how much of the well bore board goes through each tract. And so they it really just totally depend depends on how they're treating that. The way to find out the dedicated acreage that the operator is going off of, if they won't share title, well, you can go to the plat, and in other words, the drilling permit, they have to file a plat and that will show you at least the initial. You know, you'll have to look at the as drilled plat to see is the exact lengths, because it can change slightly depending on exactly where that well board goes. But based on the plan, you can see exactly where that well board is going to go, how many feet go through your tract versus the overall, and then you can use that to confirm the calculation that is being presented to you. And again, if you don't have the ASDRIL plat, you can ask the operator for it have if it hasn't been filed with the Railroad Commission yet. But uh yeah, that's definitely the thing to do is this is publicly available information and I'd say ninety nine percent of the time that's the way that you go about confirming this. On the off chance that they don't have those those lengths shown on the plat, you could ask them for that

17:50information. That that is something they should be able to give you because that isn't proprietary, right? That's that's just uh something they have to file with the railroad commission. Uh but did you you want to make sure for sh sure that you're using those correct uh lengths when you're calculating your uh your allocation. So God good luck there. This is not for the faint of heart for sure when it comes to calculating your your net revenue interest with an allocation well.

18:13Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, you said it mattered. And I think the best thing you could do, Melissa, if the operator is not uh really working with you a lot, is to ask very particular questions. question. So if you ask them what factor, what calculations or what numbers they're using in their calculation calculations, that can often get you further. And that way you can start to get some clarity here. Matt, let's say Melissa doesn't have any success hearing back from the operator. I would say, you know, sending a certified letter probably would be step one. Um and then step two, you could get with an attorney. Cause as you said, Matt, this is information uh they should be able to give you. But sometimes it it takes some saber rattling to get to the right person who can give you the information. Yeah,

18:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): no,

18:50Matt Sands: that's a that's a really good point. I think asking for their, you know, how they calculated your interest, you know, get their calculation to compare to yours as well. So you can then see those numbers, you can ask clarifying questions, just you know, you gotta be very specific. You know, just asking for title, you know, they're not gonna share that nine out of ten times just because that's proprietary information. Um, you might be able to get them to share a redacted part of the title opinion just for your interest. if there's a dispute or if there's a question. Sometimes they'll share that, sometimes they won't. But yeah, that's that's definitely a great tip as well. And then the last thing is to learn more about allocation wells and how to calculate your ownership. That is actually something that we cover within the National Association of Royalty Realty Owners in the Mineral Management Program that we referred to before. That is part of the curriculum. So you you know if you want to learn how to do that yourself, definitely check that out because that is something that you can learn. Both we we kind of highlight it and do a light touch on it in the uh introduction to mineral ownership course. But then definitely when you get into the mineral management program itself, that is part of the curriculum. So yeah, hopefully that helps.

19:55Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): All right, man. Our next one here uh is from Greg. Uh Greg says he's been a longtime listener and appreciates the podcast. He thinks he has a situation. that would make an interesting discussion. So Greg goes on to say he's been negotiating an oil and gas lease with a landman over royalty rates and bonus payments. Towards the end of negotiations, he felt uh the landman wasn't being truthful. He claimed that other family members had already signed and returned their leases, uh, but Greg knew for a fact that they hadn't. Because of that, they switched to working with another landman who he believes is reputable and negotiated a better offer and are now defending. down to the final details. We also have a mineral rights attorney representing us. Just before we're ready to sign, the first landman, the one we no longer trust, cocktailed us and said that he was working with our attorney and wanted to speak with us about the final negotiations. Greg says that immediately raised concerns, and they also learned at one point that their attorney met privately with the second landman, and he doesn't know why yet, doesn't know what was discussed, but made him wonder whether the attorney was communicating with multiple partners. parties uh without their knowledge. Greg's question is this: if we remain uh if we retain the attorney to represent only our interest, is it a potential conflict of interest for that attorney to communicate or negotiate with multiple landmen without our authorization? Even if there isn't an actual conflict, is that something that should concern us from an ethics or fiduciary point of view? On another note, that attorney is communicating with both landmen, um and

21:15he's also um it sounds like billing them for the time to do both. So Matt, this is uh obviously an interesting question. And uh, you know, I think it's a lot more maybe about ethics than that there is an actual conflict of interest going on here. Uh but, you know, having these discussions on how you expect the attorneys to handle negotiations is important as well um so that you have that that precedent set up front. So this is an unfortunate situation and and to feel like uh you've been jaded or or done wrong by somebody.

21:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.

21:45Matt Sands: And you, you know, it's uh I would just talk to the attorney to find out the circumstances um because it very well, you know, based on the behavior from that first landman that had made the lease offer, I would not be surprised at all that he caught wind that you were working with your the attorney and so then they reached out to the attorney to try to make a deal. So it it's likely not the attorney that's going around your wishes or whatever. It's probably that he got a cold call out of the blue from this other landman. And so then you know he had to discuss, okay, yeah, we're we're interested in a lease and you know he's representing your interests and I think that if that second person said, well I'm going gonna to send you over an offer, well they, you

22:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,

22:25Matt Sands: they're going to gonna, you know you know, communicate that to you and say, Hey, here's what this person contacted me about and, you know, what they are saying. But, you know, really it just needs to be a conversation with your attorney to find out what happened and, you know, what the the situation is. And then the other thing too is when you, you know, retain an attorney, you know, ask you know, just be clear about what your expectations are for them, you know, what you want them to do specifically, that it's not a blank check that you want them, you know, you'll identify who you're wanting to negotiate with and you want them to review the language or do the final negotiations, or you might just say, hey, you know, just go and negotiate this for us, in which case they're you know likely going to try to get multiple offers and perhaps get contacted by other people that are interested in leasing your interest. And so I think that really starts up front when you hire the attorney as you know, what do you expect them to do? What do you want them to do and what do you not want them to do? Just from a you know limiting the expenses standpoint, and just be clear, you know, if you just need them to review language and that you're gonna go and obtain the lease offers, and you know, you just need to find out who's gonna do what, roles and responsibilities, make sure you're on the same page. Because if not, then there's a chance there can be a

23:37conflict there when the attorney's not doing anything wrong. necessarily, they're just, you know, trying to to represent your interests. And, you know, the fact that they're spending time is a is is a outcome of that. You know, it's going to cost you more if they're working on multiple offers or contacting multiple people. And so I wouldn't say that he's double billing you because, you know, he's he sounds like he's just doing what you asked him to do, but you know, you just don't need to be clear about expectations. But uh yeah, it sounds like you got a great um outcome though. Um, you know, I know Greg and I met offline and sounds like he had a uh a good lease offer. His other family members are on the same page and they're kind of negotiating as a team, which is a great place to be because you have more bargaining power when you have uh larger net interest that you're speaking on behalf of and and the other family members. And you know, I think it's uh a good call to move on from that uh landman that's not being truthful um and claiming that the other members had already signed and returned their leases when you know that they hadn't. You know, if that guy's lying to you, then you know what else is is going on there. And so for sure, you know, it's a good good time to to move on. And you know, y when you're working with a landman, you can do some research. If they're members of the American Association of Professional

24:56Landmen, generally those folks are more in line with certain ethical practices. And certainly if they're a registered professional landman or certified professional landman, then they have agreed to abide by certain ethical standards. And so those are the types of landmen you should be seeking out to work with. because uh you know they're the ones that are doing the right things and you know definitely gonna um treat you fairly and and follow those ethical standards. And there's a recourse as well. If you find that somebody did violate ethical standards, um then you can report that to the APL because they have means and an ethics committee and they can, you know, work and deal with that situation as well. So

25:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I think that's that's great advice, Matt. And if if you're not sure um, you know, if what they're doing is it goes against ethics, um you can certainly take a look. AAPL is kind of the United States at least industry standard for landman practices. And AAPL has ethics guidelines available on their website, Matt, and we can include a link in the show notes. But this will give you an idea of of you know what are the expectations on landman. Are they violating those expectations Um, just so that you can have an informed conversation. as well. All right, Matt, our next one here from James. Trillium production has been going on for about twenty six years, plus in my section now, and I never signed a lease. Uh, where do the funds go uh for those who never signed and never received any funds? And Matt, one of the most important sentences here is a at the end is thanks in Louisiana, uh, which changes everything.

26:23Matt Sands: Yeah, that's right. Yeah. Louisiana is is uh totally different. from a legal perspective. James, without more information, we can't say with certainty what's likely happening. I can we can talk through some of the different possible scenarios that you might be dealing with. Um, you're gonna have to do more research to find out more about uh your title to your interests and you know which of these uh situations. you might fit into. And then I would also, before we get into it, just reach out to the operator and find out who they you know say, hey, I think I have an interest in this mineral tract here. It's part of this lease and this unit. Why have we not gotten any funds? And they can tell you specifically what the

27:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh

27:11Matt Sands: the title opinion says and and who owns your tract specifically. if it's not you. Um and the thing that's unique about Louisiana is there's the concept of a mineral servitude. So it's I think probably a good idea to refresh on that that term, which is a very different concept than other states. So when you sever minerals from the surface in other states, those generally you have the title to the the separate mineral interests, interest, and that is in perpetual. perpetuity. In Louisiana, that's not the case because the landowner owns the surface, and then the mineral servitude is a separate right carved out of that ownership. And it is the right to use those minerals, and it's not right to the uh ownership in the minerals themselves. So the mineral servitude owner can drill, produce, lease, and receive proceeds. It can be sold lease leased, or inherited. but then it can expire from a non-use. So this is similar to the concept of dormant mineral statute in some states, where after a certain period of time, if you don't develop those minerals or if you don't exert your right to the ownership of those minerals, then it can expire and go back to the surface owner. And that can happen in Louisiana. So if the servitude is extinguished,

28:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): those

28:26Matt Sands: minerals will revert to the surface owner. And in that situation, the mineral ownership can change hands without any sale. Now, one thing that will stop the clock on that 10 years is if they establish production. And so that'll basically put it on hold as long as the land stays in use. In other words, as long as those minerals are being produced, you'll get royalties. You know, if you're a mineral servitude owner. But um if there is no production production, then that is uh something that it could expire. But since you mentioned that there has been drilling and production going on for 26 years now, it's uh possible that if you weren't leased, that you were force pooled, it was it part of a compulsory unit. I'm not totally sure, so definitely do some research on Louisiana, but um it may be that you're subject to a risk penetration. penalty and you're a non participating owner and you know that doesn't necessarily apply to minimum servitude owners, but you know, that concept of force pooling and you know getting a risk penalty could apply. Um so it could be in suspense, maybe there's um issues with uh still needing to reach payback. More likely it could be that there's a title

29:39issue.

29:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um

29:41Matt Sands: maybe there was uh the owner that you inherited these from still has title to the the interest, you know, wasn't ever conveyed to you, so you'd have to go to unclaimed property site to look for your relative's name to see if there were royalties being paid to that person and it was just cheated to the state. Or, you know, if it's again i they weren't able to. contact the current owner because it wasn't properly probated or transferred to to the heirs. Another concept to think about is you mentioned surface ownership or you mentioned ownership in um in your section. If you're the surface owner and there was a mineral servitude that was was separated prior to when you purchased your property, it may be that you don't even own the um the oil and gas rights, the the minerals. You know, it's the servitude owner that would be getting paid the royalties. And so that is a possibility. So again, where um the minerals were sold or reserved prior to your ownership. And so you have surface rights, but then you don't own the uh underlying royalty, and so that's why you're not getting paid there. Another scenario could be that again, you were the servitude owner and it was extinguished by prescription resulting from non use for over

31:00ten years, you know, prior to

31:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to

31:02Matt Sands: that time period. So that could be a situation where, you know, you had the mineral servitude, it reverted back to the surface owner, that's why you're not getting paid. It's really hard to say. I guess the the the moral of the story here, 'cause here, there's because there's all these different possible scenarios, is that you do I would highly recommend checking the title. So you can search at the parish clerk offices to find out the deeds and leases and see the chain of title. So that was where you would search for your name, So f search for your predecessors of interest. So that's where you'd look for your relatives' names or wherever you bought the interest from. and see what happened over time. Can you find if there was a point in time when in which somebody reserved the minerals and sold the surface? And and that can trace down exactly what's going on. That's really the only way to figure out exactly what's going on. The next thing is to again identify the unit and the operator and then contact the operator's own relations department to ask them for more information about your interest. Do you believe you should have an interest in this well or this unit? You know, what information do you need from me to put it into pay status? And it might be if you are a rightful owner, they'll say, Oh, yeah, we need to get an updated deed that shows you're the, you know, conveying the interest to you. Um, and so you might need to get an attorney to go through probate, help you go through probate to get

32:20those interests transferred into your name. And then the other thing is to look for any funds that might have been a student as to. due to the state. That could be an indication that the interests are also still in a relative's name, is if you see royalty payments that were attempted to be paid to your relative, deceased relative, and those uh are sitting out there on the Louisiana website. I think it's lacashclaim.org, or you can go to missingmoney.org Missing money.org as well. And then, you know, questions about any of this stuff if you need to get things. transferred to your name or questions about chain of title, you know, contact a Louisiana mineral attorney. So that's uh you know probably the best um advice that we can give, you know, given what little information we have. Um we'll put links in the show notes as well with uh some more information about Louisiana and uh unclaimed named property and the Louisiana treasurer, um, mineral servitude and ins and outs of all of that. So you can research uh and find out more there. But uh yeah, Louisiana is very different and usually a little more complicated than other states.

33:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,

33:24Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I think you summed it up well, Matt. A lot of different angles to take a look at there. But uh you know, even if you can just collect the documents or the title that pertains to you and uh that's a great starting point to go have a conversation with a an attorney. Um, you know, I think mineral owners can find themselves kind of in a a s situation where they're stuck if they go to an attorney and they don't have any title work or or anything to provide the attorney to point them on the right track to help them.

33:47Matt Sands: Yeah, that's a great point. I think that's you know, the first step is to go to the the parish office and search for those deeds and figure out what's going on there. And then uh that should get you in the right point it in the right direction and then a attorney can help fill in the gaps as well. So good luck.

34:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well

34:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Matt, I think that's that sums it up for November.

34:04Matt Sands: Yeah, really good questions this month. I you know, a little bit different angle to some of these these concepts, different states than we've talked about in in much uh depth at least. And um, you know, good things to take to heart when it comes to investing in anything, regardless, you know whether it's oil and gas or other things, is you know trust but verify, have have legal paperwork. don't rely on somebody's um you know what they're what they're gonna tell you. Um it's really got to be in writing for it to be enforceable. So hopefully that uh is a good way to end the episode. And as always if you have a question you'd like us to answer, you can send it to feedback at mineralrightspodcast dot com. Thanks again for listening. Thanks, Justin.

34:47Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Thanks Matt.

34:47Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Thanks so much for listening to the Mineral Rights Podcast with your host, Matt Sands. Don't forget to subscribe and share at MineralRights Podcast.com. The Mineral Rights Podcast should not be construed as investment, legal, or tax advice. All information is believed to be from reliable sources. However, we make no representation as to its completeness or accuracy.

This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights