Everything Property

Renee Roumanos outlines legal risks in developer collapses, contract variations, and insurance pitfalls for property buyers.

47 min Listen to the original
Property LawDeveloper InsolvencyOff-the-Plan ContractsHome InsuranceConstruction Defects

Summary

Renee Roumanos discusses the legal implications of developer insolvencies like Bathla, emphasizing the distinction between voluntary administration and liquidation. She warns buyers against relying on consumer AI for legal advice and stresses the importance of verifying deposit trust accounts and Homeowners Warranty Insurance certificates. Roumanos explains that developers generally cannot rescind off-the-plan contracts due to market rises, but buyers face risks from easement shifts and settlement delays. The episode highlights the necessity of pre-settlement inspections to identify defects before transferring leverage to the vendor. Finally, Roumanos shares a personal experience of underinsurance, advising buyers to use specialized brokers and Quantity Surveyor reports to ensure adequate coverage.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    It should always be transferred into trust, and no one has. authority to debit money from trust except the person who put the money in there. Okay, so if I bought something and I gave you $50,000 for that purchase, that money is held in trust until settlement can occur and then the money is released. Unless there's a sneaky special condition.

    Renee Roumanos · 10:39

Episode sections

  1. 0:00 – 5:06

    Market Sentiment and AI in Legal Practice

    Renee Roumanos reports a market slowdown driven by fear regarding borrowing capacity and government policy changes. She warns against using consumer AI tools like ChatGPT for legal advice, noting they cause confusion, while acknowledging professional AI tools like Harvey and Claude are useful for legal research.

  2. 5:06 – 10:05

    Developer Collapse and Contract Types

    The discussion centers on the collapse of developer Bathla, which entered voluntary administration. Roumanos distinguishes between off-the-plan apartment contracts (conditional on construction and subdivision) and house-and-land packages, which may involve split contracts for land and build.

  3. 10:05 – 18:36

    Deposit Protection and Insurance Requirements

    Deposits for off-the-plan purchases must be held in a trust account until settlement. Roumanos emphasizes that buyers must verify where their deposit is held and ensure the developer provides Homeowners Warranty Insurance certificates before any money is released or construction begins.

  4. 18:36 – 24:49

    Sunset Clauses and Developer Rescission Rights

    Roumanos explains that under current laws, developers cannot automatically rescind off-the-plan contracts due to market rises; only buyers have the right to rescind at the sunset date. Developers may attempt to persuade buyers to exit via plan variations or delays, but cannot simply cancel the contract without a Supreme Court order.

  5. 24:49 – 27:19

    Settlement Risks and State Law Differences

    Developers may withhold notice of completion to force buyers into default. In New South Wales, time is not of the essence until a notice to complete is served, whereas in Queensland, time is of the essence, making penalties and contract termination harsher for buyers who miss settlement dates.

  6. 27:19 – 30:30

    Variations and Defects in Construction

    Contracts typically allow for minor cosmetic variations and up to a 5% difference in size. However, substantial changes, such as unexpected structural columns, may entitle the buyer to compensation or rescission if they can prove they would not have purchased the property had they known about the variation.

  7. 30:30 – 32:01

    Easements and Contract Risks

    Renee Roumanos explains that off-the-plan land contracts often contain proposed easements that can move, shifting the burden of adjustment onto the buyer. She warns that these contracts are heavily developer-friendly and may waive purchaser rights, making comprehensive legal advice essential before signing.

  8. 32:01 – 33:52

    The Myth of Standard Contracts

    Roumanos asserts that there is no such thing as a standard contract in property transactions, despite what real estate agents or builders might claim. She emphasizes that every contract carries unique risks and that buyers must determine their own risk exposure with professional legal support.

  9. 33:52 – 38:12

    Pre-Settlement Inspections and Defects

    The speakers discuss the critical importance of conducting pre-settlement building inspections to identify major defects or safety hazards before settling. Roumanos advises buyers to withhold settlement if major defects are found, as settling transfers power to the vendor and makes rectification difficult.

  10. 38:12 – 40:29

    Statutory Warranties and Insurance Claims

    Roumanos outlines the difference between contractual defect periods (typically 90 days) and statutory warranties provided by homeowner's warranty insurance, which covers major defects for seven years in houses. She notes that this insurance does not apply to apartments and that buyers can make claims through NCAT if builders fail to rectify issues.

  11. 40:29 – 44:31

    Personal Insurance Loss and Lessons Learned

    Roumanos shares a personal story of her new home burning down five months after moving in due to being significantly underinsured. She highlights that construction costs rose post-COVID, leaving her with a $500,000 shortfall, and stresses the need to review insurance coverage annually.

  12. 44:31 – 46:34

    Importance of Professional Insurance Brokers

    The speakers advise against using low-cost, generic insurance providers and instead recommend engaging specialized insurance brokers. They suggest obtaining Quantity Surveyor (QS) reports to accurately determine rebuild costs and ensuring policies cover building, contents, and landlord-specific risks appropriately.

Claims worth verifying

Renee Roumanos states there is a slowdown in the market due to fear surrounding borrowing capacities and government budget changes.

Renee Roumanos ·1:03

How to verify: Cross-reference with recent Australian property market data from the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) housing loan approvals or CoreLogic/Domain market reports for the period 2026-08-10 to 2026-11-10. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Bathla is a large developer that sold apartments, houses, and build contracts, and went into voluntary administration.

David Hamilton ·6:25

How to verify: Search ASIC Insolvency Notices or the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) register for 'Bathla' or 'Bathlaw' to confirm voluntary administration status and date. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

There are over 22,000 contracts or houses underway for Bathla at the time of its collapse.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·6:39

How to verify: Review the administrator's reports or press releases issued by Bathla's administrators regarding the number of affected contracts. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Off-the-plan contracts are conditional upon an occupation certificate and the registration of the subdivision of land.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·8:27

How to verify: Check the Conveyancing Act 2026 (NSW) or standard off-the-plan contract templates used in New South Wales for statutory conditions regarding settlement triggers. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Deposits for off-the-plan purchases must be held in a trust account and not released until settlement.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·10:05

How to verify: Refer to the Conveyancing (Sale of Land) Regulation 2026 (NSW) or the Real Estate and Business Agents Act 2026 (Qld) regarding trust account requirements for deposits. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Homeowners Warranty Insurance is required by the Home Building Act for build contracts and home and land packages.

Renee Roumanos ·12:38

How to verify: Consult the Home Building Act 2026 (NSW) or equivalent state legislation (e.g., Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 2026) regarding mandatory insurance certificates. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Developers cannot automatically rescind off-the-plan contracts due to market rises; only buyers have the right to rescind at the sunset date.

David Hamilton ·19:29

How to verify: Review amendments to the Conveyancing Act 2026 (NSW) regarding sunset clauses, specifically provisions preventing vendors from rescinding without court order or buyer consent. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

In New South Wales, time is not of the essence until a notice to complete is served, whereas in Queensland, time is of the essence.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·24:49

How to verify: Compare the Real Property Act 2026 (NSW) / Conveyancing Act 2026 (NSW) with the Property Law Act 2026 (Qld) regarding the legal status of time in contracts and notice to complete procedures. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Contracts typically allow for variations in size or dimensions of up to 5%.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·29:25

How to verify: Examine standard off-the-plan contract special conditions for 'variations' or 'tolerance' clauses, commonly found in NSW and QLD property contracts. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Easements for water, electricity, and retaining walls on draft plans are proposed and can move, potentially requiring buyers to move house plans.

Renee Roumanos ·30:51

How to verify: Review standard off-the-plan vacant land contracts (e.g., NSW Fair Trading standard form or developer-specific contracts) to check clauses regarding easement variations and purchaser obligations. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

There is no such thing as a standard contract; contracts consist of standard conditions plus conditions that take away purchaser rights.

David Hamilton ·32:01

How to verify: Compare the 'Standard Conditions' section of a residential contract of sale with the 'Special Conditions' section to identify variations and waivers of common law rights. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Contracts typically require the purchaser to produce one defect report within 90 days of settlement.

Renee Roumanos ·35:06

How to verify: Examine the 'Defects' or 'Warranty' clause in a sample off-the-plan contract of sale to confirm the timeframe for reporting defects post-settlement. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Statutory warranties via homeowner's warranty insurance provide 2 years for minor defects and 7 years for major defects.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·38:21

How to verify: Check the Home Building Act 2026 (NSW) or equivalent state legislation for statutory warranty periods and the Home Building Compensation Fund guidelines. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Homeowner's warranty insurance (statutory warranties) applies only to houses (dwelling) and not to apartments.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·38:21

How to verify: Review the definition of 'dwelling' and exclusions in the relevant state's Home Building Act or Home Building Compensation Fund policy wording. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Renee Roumanos bought a new home in 2022 that burnt down five months after moving in.

Renee Roumanos ·40:29

How to verify: Verify via public records or news archives for fire incidents in Renee Roumanos' residential address in 2022, or check her professional website/social media for public mentions of this event. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Construction prices rose significantly post-COVID, leading to underinsurance for Roumanos' rebuilt home.

Renee Roumanos ·41:03

How to verify: Compare Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) Building Activity data for construction cost indices between 2026 and 2026 to verify the trend. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Quantity Surveyors (QS) can provide rebuild cost estimates for a few hundred dollars.

David Hamilton ·43:54

How to verify: Contact a Quantity Surveying firm (e.g., via the Australian Institute of Quantity Surveyors directory) to request a quote for a preliminary rebuild cost assessment. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify the developer's status (voluntary administration vs liquidation) via ASIC or state government insolvency registers.
  • Review the specific contract clauses regarding deposit holding (trust account requirements) and sunset date rescission rights.
  • Check for statutory Homeowners Warranty Insurance certificates for build contracts and confirm coverage limits.
  • Engage a Quantity Surveyor to obtain rebuild cost estimates for accurate insurance valuation.
  • Conduct a pre-settlement building inspection to identify major defects before settling.
  • Review insurance policies annually to account for fluctuating construction costs and avoid underinsurance.
  • Consult a qualified property lawyer rather than relying on consumer AI tools for contract interpretation.
  • Check state-specific laws (e.g., NSW vs Queensland) regarding 'time of the essence' and notice to complete procedures.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00
David Hamilton: Alrighty, welcome back to the Everything Property Podcast. I thought we would address some prevalent current events in the market, and that is around buying off the plan, uh builders andor developers going uh bust and what it means for us as the potential purchasers and consumers. Uh thought I would reach out
0:20
David Hamilton: to an old friend of the podcast who was on a couple of years back, uh, get her back on. I know she's done some, she's helped me um with some stuff lately. So thought we'd bring her back in, get it accumulated back into the city. Uh Renee Romanos, welcome to the Everything Property Podcast.
0:34
Renee Roumanos: Hi, it's so great to be here. Thank you for having me.
0:37
David Hamilton: Good to have you. Look, um, first and foremost, I think for your business, which is law and legal, want to get an understanding for what you guys are seeing in the market at the moment. So is that like
0:51
David Hamilton: with the work that you're doing, um be interested to see if you've seen sort of like a slowdown. I know like many mortgage brokers and buyers agents and stuff are seeing a slowdown in the market. So are you guys seeing that on your end?
1:03
Renee Roumanos: Absolutely. I find there's a lot of fear in the market at the moment. People are really scared to make that move, whether it's borrowing capacities change. whether there is a lot of fear about what they're purchasing, whether it's the budget and our government, we blame everything on the government. But there's
1:23
Renee Roumanos: definitely been a shift of the market since the budget, since all these changes. And there's so much fear in the market for people making that big step. So I find that we're absolutely holding hands and supporting them. And sometimes I feel like I'm pushing them. across that finish line a little bit as well. Like that that's you know part of the role, I
1:43
Renee Roumanos: guess.
1:43
David Hamilton: And are you seeing seeing a slowdown still, or is it more so people are being a little bit more hesitant and safer with their decision making when they're reaching out to you guys?
1:55
Renee Roumanos: No, there is a slowdown.
1:56
David Hamilton: Slowdown, Slow down
1:57
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): still.
1:57
Renee Roumanos: there's a big slowdown. And I we can blame the negative gearing rules, we can blame blame Bathlon. Bathlaw. We can there's there there's so many different reasons why things have shifted, but we've definitely shifted the market and people are taking longer to make decisions.
2:12
David Hamilton: I got a question for you. The rise and rise and rise, and we're talking about a little bit offline, which is what what makes me ask a question. But the rise of AI, especially in um
2:24
David Hamilton: I I feel like uh someone's, you know. talking to someone every day about this. But yesterday was talking to someone that was using Chat GPT for legal advice. What are you guys seeing being uh I'm surely
2:37
David Hamilton: I'm sure very frustrated? But
2:40
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what
2:41
David Hamilton: are you seeing?
2:41
Renee Roumanos: My key message stop using AI as your lawyer. I'm so sick and tired of people talking to Chat GPT about what. they're doing and their legal issues and asking it to give them advice.
2:56
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
2:56
Renee Roumanos: the worst part is when they ask Chat GPT to ask their lawyer questions. And I received this email that's seven pages long with seven billion questions about unrelated Related topics, and all it's doing is creating confusion. So there is a significant
3:16
Renee Roumanos: rise of everyday people using AI and also using it wrong and not giving it the appropriate prompts and causing more confusion for themselves and more work for us in identifying and answering some of these questions. And what I've had to do is set boundaries and say to
3:36
Renee Roumanos: clients, I'm happy to answer your questions. Don't send me questions from AI. I can absolutely see the difference. And I I I think it just causes a whole bunch of like ah moments because what should be a really easy transaction has caused confusion for this poor client because
3:56
Renee Roumanos: AI has told them all these other things that are completely irrelevant. And
4:01
Renee Roumanos: with that, I think people it creates more fear. So people need to realize AI is great. It has a purpose. But you're paying a lawyer. You don't need AI. Ask the lawyer every question you have, but your questions. Not the questions that Chatty G has prepared for you.
4:20
David Hamilton: Chatty G.
4:23
David Hamilton: Interesting. Okay. Well uh are you guys do you guys use it as as lawyers? I've got some um other friends that are working in like planning law and stuff, and um it's been interesting to see
4:34
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I do, yeah.
4:35
Renee Roumanos: I do. There there is a time and a purpose for it, and definitely Claude has some advantages in doing things faster or preparing basic things, but there is a time and a place. There is also AI, um it's called Harvey. and it's really good for lawyers because it connects with Aussie and the legal
4:55
Renee Roumanos: cases and things like that. So if I'm looking for a particular case on a particular thing, definitely AI comes in handy in those circumstances.
5:03
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
5:04
Renee Roumanos: there's a time and a place for all of those things.
5:06
David Hamilton: Yeah, okay. Interesting. Good to know. Well, what I wanted to a uh bit of context around the episode. So obviously uh it's probably a few months. back. You've been busy trying to get you in on the pod, but a few months back we we saw the collapse of uh Bathla, which was a Southwest Sydney uh developer. With it, we've had a lot
5:26
David Hamilton: of people that uh have put down deposits, have bought off the plan. Um I even read one the other day about uh they were buying a block of land off a gentleman for twenty nine million and then failed to settle. Then they took him to then he took Bathur to court. Bath the court said you have to pay him um and then
5:46
David Hamilton: he ended up having to fund them some of the deal. Anyway, it's there's a lot to talk about so I thought look let's get some legal advice on this and
5:55
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
5:55
David Hamilton: guess I want to just talk around those people now that are buying off the plan because sometimes a house on an established block is our out of reach. So sometimes people will opt for off the plan, they will opt for, you know, lifestyle amenity, something that's probably well located and it's starting to pop up everywhere. So I think if we can and if you
6:15
David Hamilton: can sort of give us a brief explainer of sort of like an off the plan contract and what that typically looks like and how that should sort of play out.
6:24
Renee Roumanos: Absolutely.
6:25
David Hamilton: Yeah.
6:25
Renee Roumanos: Let's go back a step. So for those that don't know what happened with Bathler, Bathler is a large developer that sells apartments, houses, and also build contracts. So they construct houses, they sell home and land packages and they also sell off
6:39
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
6:39
Renee Roumanos: plan apartments. There are over 22,000 contracts out there or houses that are underway. Bathler Bathla went into voluntary administration, which is not liquidation, it's voluntary administration, which basically means they can't pay their debt. They put their hands up, they've told administrators to come in and help them. Now, what
6:59
Renee Roumanos: does this mean for a buyer? It's pretty crabby, let's be real. Basically, it means your project's on hold. Nothing further can happen on your project today. That contract is on hold. Unless another builder comes come in and take over that project. it is very hard for that person to be able to complete that project with Bathlon.
7:19
Renee Roumanos: And depending on the type of contract will depend on the type of risk. So purchases that have entered into a contract which is an off-the-plan nature, I'll explain that in a moment, is very different to those that have a build contract with the builder to construct a a dwelling on their block of land. Okay. It's
7:37
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
7:37
Renee Roumanos: two very different elements
7:38
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): here.
7:39
David Hamilton: Now
7:39
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): so
7:39
David Hamilton: that would be if I'm getting a house and land package because they were doing them. And off the plan would be if I'm buying like one of their apartments.
7:45
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Correct.
7:45
David Hamilton: Cool. Now
7:46
Renee Roumanos: with house and land, there's two different potentials. I could have one contract, which is home and land package. You settle when the house is finished. Or the second option is a split contract. You own the land,
8:00
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
8:00
Renee Roumanos: builder's build is building the dwelling. Mm-hmm.
8:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right?
8:03
Renee Roumanos: So the land might be yours, but the build might be midway.
8:06
David Hamilton: So
8:06
Renee Roumanos: there's an obviously an obvious element of risk there. Now, when we look at off-the-plan apartments, the easiest way to think of what is an off-the-plan is it's a contract that is conditional upon something else. So it's naturally a contract conditional upon construction, or a contract conditional upon the subdivision of land.
8:27
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Right
8:28
Renee Roumanos: now, if you were buying an off-the-plan apartment, that contract would be conditional upon two things. Obviously, construction, but what that actually means at the end is an occupation certificate from an independent certifier that that dwelling has been constructed according to code, and we have a fancy occupation certificate to
8:48
Renee Roumanos: confirm it's been done properly.
8:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
8:50
Renee Roumanos: second element is the registration of the subdivision of land. Now, imagine I had a large parcel of Play-Doh here, right? And
8:58
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): this is
8:59
Renee Roumanos: our large parcel of Play-Doh. I should have brought some in. And when we're talking about our parcel of land, this could be one parcel of land that will eventually be 50 units, right? So imagine they come in, they build their 50 units. Now, originally there's one land identifier number. However, after they construct and after they subdivide the land, each
9:19
Renee Roumanos: unit will have its own individual land identifier number, which is what we call a lot SP number or a lot DP number. Now, once these two things happen, so occupation certificate and the land has been registered, meaning the subdivision's taken place. At that time, settlement can occur. Most of the off plan
9:39
Renee Roumanos: contracts have a clause that says once we give you these two documents, you must settle within two weeks
9:45
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): or
9:45
Renee Roumanos: sometimes three weeks. Now, the element of protection in these contracts is our conveyancing act. Now, in the conveyancing legislation, the way that the off off-the-plan the plan conditions have been prepared are to protect both developer. vendor, as well as purchaser.
10:05
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): So
10:05
Renee Roumanos: there are elements in there that protect everyone. Now, once we pay a deposit under these contracts, they should be held in a trust account and should not be released until settlement. So one of the things I would always say to anyone buying an and off-the-plan off the plan and putting a deposit down is: where is that deposit held?
10:25
Renee Roumanos: Is it safe? And my question I've asked a lot of Bathler purchasers who have come to me for legal advice is where is your where is your deposit?
10:33
David Hamilton: Okay.
10:34
Renee Roumanos: Who has your deposit? Is it safe? Has it been
10:36
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): released?
10:37
David Hamilton: The purchaser where's that, where that would be going?
10:39
Renee Roumanos: It should be in the same account you transferred the money in. So whether it was in the lit the solicitor's trust account or the real estate agent's trust account. It should always be transferred into trust, and no one has. authority to debit money from trust except the person who put the money in there. Okay, so if I bought something and I gave you $50,000 for
10:59
Renee Roumanos: that purchase, that money is held in trust until settlement can occur and then the money is released. Unless there's a sneaky special condition.
11:08
David Hamilton: What would it be?
11:09
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
11:10
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): mean, this is it. nice.
11:12
Renee Roumanos: Naturally, every contract has standard. conditions.
11:15
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah.
11:16
Renee Roumanos: And a whole bunch of special conditions that just take away all the rights that conditions gave us.
11:20
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Oh, I wonder who put them in there. Yeah.
11:22
Renee Roumanos: Right. And naturally, whoever prepared the contract has prepared it for
11:27
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
11:27
Renee Roumanos: benefit of their client. So the vendor would naturally prepare a contract that's in their favor. Now, when we talk about the deposit, there could be a conditioning condition in there that says, upon the exchange of contracts, the deposit will be unconditionally released to the vendor to do whatever the hell he wants with. That is like red flag, red flag, red
11:47
Renee Roumanos: flag, like big no no. I don't or I don't like the idea of a toazit being released because that is your only element of a protection. Right? Now, depending on what type of property you're buying, there should also be what's called an homeowner. homeowner's warranty insurance certificate. So if we're buying a home and land
12:07
Renee Roumanos: package, and my contract is I'm buying that block of land and you're building me that house on that land,
12:14
Renee Roumanos: there must also be homeowners warranty insurance. Now, what that insurance certificate has is an element of statutory warranties attached to the construction of
12:24
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that
12:24
Renee Roumanos: particular dwelling. So my money is safe. That certificate also comes when I enter into a build contract. So if I'm entering into a build contract with you and you're going to build me my dwelling,
12:38
Renee Roumanos: before I pay you a dollar, the home building act says you must give me an insurance certificate for this contract. So not natural, it's not your public liability insurance, it's not anything else. it's a policy created for this contract. So when I'm paying you your deposit under the contract, you're in in
12:57
Renee Roumanos: exchange giving me an insurance certificate, which is homeowner's warranty for that build.
13:04
David Hamilton: Yeah, which the builder would have.
13:05
Renee Roumanos: Absolutely.
13:06
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay.
13:06
David Hamilton: And bathroom the builder and developer. Yep.
13:09
Renee Roumanos: Exactly. If the builder has homeowners warranty insurance, and if they go bust, the buyer is protected. That is the element of protection. And often clients come to me and they want contract reviews for a build contract or for a conveyancing contract. And often I look at
13:29
Renee Roumanos: the contract and my first question is, where is the insurance? And sometimes they're cheeky and they say, we'll give you the insurance two weeks before we commence construction. Uh, no, you'll give it to me today. Because that is the only protection for the deposit that I'm handing over in consideration of that contract.
13:48
Renee Roumanos: So, my question to anyone who is purchasing or building or going through a large, exciting, risky milestone is where am I protected? And unfortunately, we live in this day and age where people are looking for the cheapest, fastest legal
14:08
Renee Roumanos: representative. And to me, this is like the biggest no-no.
14:12
Renee Roumanos: The person who you instruct to help you in your legal matter needs to be someone who gives you the most comprehensive legal advice, undertakes the most due diligence, provides you written advice, spends time with you explaining all of these things.
14:29
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
14:29
Renee Roumanos: if someone asks for a free contract review, what do you think you're gonna get for a free contract review? You're not getting all the bells and the whistles,
14:37
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
14:37
Renee Roumanos: most importantly, the due diligence that you need. So key message for anyone buying is firstly call me, we'd love to help you.
14:47
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): We'll
14:47
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): put
14:47
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): the contact
14:48
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): details in the
14:48
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): show notes. Yeah.
14:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
14:50
Renee Roumanos: undertakes undertake thorough due diligence. There's no need to rush, there's no need to look for the cheapest human to help you. Do it properly. Take your time. Understand, educate yourself first. Because these transactions are risky and there are protections. It's about making sure that they are within the document you're signing.
15:09
David Hamilton: So if I am the if I'm the potential purchaser, I'm for what I'm hearing from you is I want to make sure that. I can and I'm engaging that uh developer builder. I'm making sure that I'm getting the homeowner's warranty insurance, but I'm probably also asking my solicitor, legal representative, what is happening with
15:29
David Hamilton: that deposit and making sure that it is held in a trust account and it is not released. Is there any is there any circumstance where you or I as the purchaser would agree to release that deposit?
15:43
Renee Roumanos: Not in and off the plan.
15:45
David Hamilton: Okay.
15:45
Renee Roumanos: Absolutely not.
15:46
David Hamilton: Yep.
15:47
Renee Roumanos: However, in standard residential purchases and sales, it is quite common for the deposit to be released for the purpose of purchasing another property. That means it's going from one trust account to another trust. account, conditional upon another contract, and usually they would then
16:07
Renee Roumanos: settle simultaneously. That is the only time. There are circumstances where to sweeten a deal, people say, I'll give you the release of the deposit.
16:18
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): And
16:18
Renee Roumanos: that is okay in some circumstances, but it's all about insurance.
16:22
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well, I've just
16:22
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): used this, so that's why I asked.
16:24
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right? It's
16:25
Renee Roumanos: just it's a pro it's it's so important. that it's appropriate at the time. So if I'm selling a property and my buyer comes to me and says, I want six months settlement
16:34
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
16:34
Renee Roumanos: sweeten the deal, I might say, Yeah, sure, but I want the 10% deposit released so I can go and use it for
16:40
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): whatever the hell
16:41
Renee Roumanos: I want. Now, naturally and in accordance with the contract, that deposit should be in trust until settlement.
16:49
David Hamilton: And where they've gone wrong, like where people have gone wrong with these, is that because both of those weren't there? Like from those clients that you're looking in terms of the Bathler case? Have people missed this and that's why?
17:01
Renee Roumanos: There is so many different circumstances with the Bathler.
17:05
David Hamilton: Yeah.
17:06
Renee Roumanos: And
17:07
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
17:07
Renee Roumanos: don't want to say too much because they're online, but where people find themselves in risks,
17:14
David Hamilton: yeah.
17:14
Renee Roumanos: is in circumstances where contracts are pre poorly prepared, where there's no statutory warranty insurance, where their deposits have been released and they've agreed to for
17:24
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
17:24
Renee Roumanos: to be released because there's a clause in the contract that says so. Or sometimes developers are a little bit naughty and they do the naughty thing and they take things that don't belong to them at times that is too early. So that definitely happens to too.
17:37
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): be. What are
17:37
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): you talking about?
17:39
Renee Roumanos: But when that happens
17:41
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
17:41
Renee Roumanos: we're dealing with a company who is in voluntary administration, we can't just click our fingers and say, hand me back my deposit. Technically, the buyer is in an unconditional contract with the vendor. The contract doesn't say if we go bust, contract comes to an end. The contract does not say if we go in
18:01
Renee Roumanos: voluntary administration. contract's at an end. That doesn't happen.
18:05
David Hamilton: Okay.
18:05
Renee Roumanos: That's not in the contract. So naturally, that contract still stands until someone mutually agrees to allow the purchaser to exit. And where the element of risk lies with
18:17
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a lot
18:17
Renee Roumanos: of these large developments is you've entered into a contract with the developer for an apartment, let's say. So we've got a large development. Now, within that contract, you're locked in. The buyer is locked in. When you sign an unconditional contract, you are locked into that transaction. Now, in
18:36
Renee Roumanos: off-the-plan contracts, they have a thing called a sunset date.
18:40
David Hamilton: Good
18:40
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): old. Sunset clause.
18:43
David Hamilton: Took my uh notes from my notepad. And yeah, perfect.
18:47
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
18:48
Renee Roumanos: for those that don't know, a sunset clause or a sunset date, technically, is the last indicative date that the vendor can hand that property over to the buyer. And if they don't, that is the only time a buyer can say, I want out. That is it. In off-the-plan contracts, in
19:07
Renee Roumanos: unconditional contracts. Purchasers don't have easy rights of rescission. It's very hard. The leverage now. naturally sits with the developer. However, many years ago, developers used to be able to say, Oh, I'm so sorry, we've hit the sunset date, we won out, and then they could go sell it for more money.
19:26
David Hamilton: I was gonna say
19:27
Renee Roumanos: that they can't do that anymore.
19:29
David Hamilton: Yeah,
19:29
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that was my
19:29
David Hamilton: next question.
19:30
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay,
19:31
Renee Roumanos: so developers can't do that anymore. The laws changed several years ago, and with a sunset date, the right of rescission is for the buyer. It's not automatically to the vendor. The developer, the vendor, they can't just say, sorry guys, we've hit the sunset day. Can't we're just going to end the contract now.
19:47
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): They don't have that right unless they get
19:49
Renee Roumanos: a Supreme Court order allowing them to. And that's only in extreme circumstances where they're not proceeding with the development.
19:57
David Hamilton: Me being in the industry, what I've seen uh way too many times is yeah, they'll go. out and potentially sell 100, 150 apartments, let's say, have it all sold or m most of it sold, get to the end. And in that, that's great when it's in a falling market. But when it's in a rising market, if I've think about
20:17
David Hamilton: it this way: if I've sold all those apartments for an average of 700 grand, and then the market jumps up to 800 grand and I can pick up a $100,000 hundred thousand dollars. per apartment, $100,000 per apartment, and I've got a hundred apartments, that's that's um what 10 mil?
20:36
Renee Roumanos: It's a lot of money.
20:37
David Hamilton: Yeah, so it's a it's that that's where the developers get out. So if I'm the purchaser now and I have a feeling that maybe it's underpriced, or maybe by the time that I've bought it and when they come up to settle. set them the market's moved, and I know that that value has jumped up heaps.
20:55
Renee Roumanos: Yeah.
20:56
David Hamilton: Does the developer have um, and I can say this confidently because I'm not doing apartments, but where can the developer screw away out of that at the end if they don't hit that sunset date?
21:08
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
21:08
Renee Roumanos: right
21:09
David Hamilton: can they?
21:10
Renee Roumanos: It's very hard.
21:11
David Hamilton: Yeah.
21:11
Renee Roumanos: It is very hard for the developer to turn around. and say, I'm really sorry. Thanks, but here's your deposit back. We're going to
21:19
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): go sell it to someone
21:20
Renee Roumanos: else. They don't get that automatic right. The way they do it is a little bit cheeky.
21:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
21:25
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): know it is.
21:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): There's lots of ways. Okay. It can
21:27
Renee Roumanos: be a little bit cheeky. Sometimes they might do things where they say, Oh, the plan has varied. Something in the plan has varied. We've varied the plan. And something about what you've purchased differs.
21:39
Renee Roumanos: Don't know what that is. Might
21:41
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): be
21:41
Renee Roumanos: something. Then they might say something along the lines of, we've hit the sunset day, but due to unforeseen circumstances,
21:49
Renee Roumanos: life, economy, COVID, whatever it is, this is going to take approximately another two years. Do you want to sign to stay on? Or do you want to sign this other document that lets you exit early? So they they do have the ability to.
22:03
Renee Roumanos: politely encourage or persuade different cheeky ways of getting people out of contracts.
22:11
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
22:11
Renee Roumanos: in some circumstances, it makes sense because if I'm buying this property for a residential reason and I then find out that maybe it's not the same thing that's in the contract, or maybe it's going to take another two years or another year.
22:27
Renee Roumanos: or there's some unforeseen delay because something hasn't been constructed according to the plan,
22:33
David Hamilton: and
22:33
Renee Roumanos: we can't get the occupation certificate because something's gone wrong. Naturally, there are ways in which they can persuade, solicit, encourage people to walk away, or sometimes people want to walk away because they don't want to wait, or they don't want the element of risk. However, if I'm an investor and I've
22:53
Renee Roumanos: purchased that property because I'm an investor and I want to make money on it and I've already waited three years, huh? What's another year? Right? I'll wait. But I guess it all depends on individual circumstances at that time. Now, the complexity here is the conduct of a
23:12
Renee Roumanos: developer,
23:13
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): right?
23:14
Renee Roumanos: And when I talk about conduct, they don't have to give updates. They don't have to tell you that the plan has registered. They don't have to tell you they have an OC until they're ready to serve it on you. Developers can be cheeky. They can do certain things that gives them an element of benefit. And I've seen it.
23:33
Renee Roumanos: And naturally, a developer or a vendor does not have to update a buyer when a thing happens. Eventually, they do have to give them the update, but it doesn't have to be immediately upon their knowledge. So, if, for example, I wanted your contract to fall over,
23:51
Renee Roumanos: what I would do is give you minimal notice about anything. I wouldn't tell you the land has registered, I wouldn't tell you that we're obtaining the OC and we're nearly at the finish line. I wouldn't give you the valid notice that your client needs to be able to go and get their paperwork sorted. And when you're sitting on a contract that you've had for three years,
24:11
Renee Roumanos: most of the time you don't have your approval ready to go. You're waiting on this paperwork to come forward in order to get your finance approval. If developers' lawyers give me an occupation certificate and a registration of land. and say, you've got 14 days to settle, how many people
24:31
Renee Roumanos: can settle within 14 days with no notice?
24:34
David Hamilton: If they don't have finance approval,
24:36
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): which
24:36
David Hamilton: they wouldn't, yeah.
24:37
Renee Roumanos: Think about it. Some brokers can do it, some banks can do it. But if your paperwork is not ready, the amount of people that would find themselves in an element of risk
24:49
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
24:49
Renee Roumanos: they'll end up paying. penalties and they might even have contracts come to an end because they can't settle in time. Now, in New South Wales, we're really lucky that we don't have time is not of the essence. So what that means is when settlement is due, it's just a due date.
25:09
Renee Roumanos: That's it. It's just a due date. Yes, if you don't settle on the due date, there are penalties. that can be charged daily. However, if a vendor, a seller, or a developer serves a notice to complete, that gives 14 days. The clock starts to tick
25:28
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): once I serve
25:29
Renee Roumanos: you a notice to complete.
25:30
David Hamilton: Okay.
25:31
Renee Roumanos: That's it. When we get to day 14 at 5 p.m., contract's at an end. You've lost your 10% deposit. They can then go sell it to whoever. whomever they want for whatever they want, and that is it. However, if we're looking at other states who are not so nice,
25:48
David Hamilton: tell me.
25:48
Renee Roumanos: Queensland. Queensland time is of the essence. Your penalties, your notice to complete, they're harsher. I have I've seen circumstances very similar to this one where a buyer has entered into a contract. didn't get their notice that settlement was happening, they didn't understand that
26:08
Renee Roumanos: time was of the essence and that if you didn't settle on the settlement day, contract would be at an end. So the element of risk varies from state to state. And it's so important to anyone entering Bring into that contract that they know their risk. Where does my risk lie in this contract? So if anyone is looking
26:28
Renee Roumanos: to purchase property, my recommendation is pause, understand the element of risk, understand where you're protected in the transaction, and then move forward confidently so that when the occupation certificate comes, you know exactly what needs to happen, you're ready to go. So I think it's all about understanding
26:48
Renee Roumanos: where the element lies. in a particular transaction so that people have the confidence and not the confusion around what happens when.
26:57
David Hamilton: Yeah. And I think putting down as little money as possible because in case you get dragged through, I'd hate to have 20% deposit uh tied up in a trust account for two, three, four, five years, that's for sure. A question that I'm gonna ask you as well is what about changes and how
27:18
David Hamilton: do
27:19
David Hamilton: they work with the contract? Because obviously, when I buy something off the plan, um, or even a house and land package, I'm buying it based on a floor plan that that developer will give me.
27:31
Renee Roumanos: Yep.
27:32
David Hamilton: Looks cool. Then maybe I get into the apartment and then hang on a second, there's this. massive column right in the middle.
27:41
Renee Roumanos: Yep.
27:42
David Hamilton: Or right on the balcony. Or
27:45
David Hamilton: it's a lot smaller than the plan, and then you measure it and all that kind of stuff. So where um what are the purchases options here? And I feel like this is almost going against, like, you know, apologies for my other developers. They're probably at this guy's ratting everyone out as the developer, but
28:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
28:02
David Hamilton: I think you always gotta do you gotta do and deliver what you say you're gonna do. So there's people out there that do that and exceed expectations, and then I think there's developers out there that kind of take the piss and um
28:12
Renee Roumanos: absolutely
28:13
David Hamilton: yeah, run the run the gamble. So what what happens with changes to
28:17
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
28:17
David Hamilton: the floor plan or that kind of stuff?
28:19
Renee Roumanos: So let's go back to the contract. Yeah, it all depends on special conditions in that contract.
28:24
David Hamilton: Okay.
28:24
Renee Roumanos: Naturally, those conditions will say something along the lines of the vendor promises to give the purchaser the thing that's in the contract. So they're developing or they're constructing the dwelling, or they, you know, that there will be terms and conditions that identify what we're getting,
28:42
David Hamilton: and
28:43
Renee Roumanos: it will refer to the layout plan. It will refer to the approved plans in the contract. It will refer to the enclosed scheduler finishes. So those are the things we're getting. Now, naturally, there's always these other cheeky pauses.
28:57
David Hamilton: 100%.
28:58
Renee Roumanos: Cheeky lawyers always causing problems. But there's cheeky conditions that then say that there can be variations. There can be small changes. There can be
29:10
Renee Roumanos: cosmetic differences, or there can be variations. However, the element of protection comes into the second condition that will say something along the lines of the quality won't be varied, or the colours may vary slightly, but you're
29:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): going to
29:25
Renee Roumanos: end up with the same quality. But then the 5% rule comes in and they say they can vary the size or the dimensions by up to 5%.
29:36
Renee Roumanos: Now, if we thought the bedroom was 4x4, but it's not 4x4, it's 4x3.9,
29:44
Renee Roumanos: with respect, there's gonna be very little that can be done. However, if we thought the room was four by four and now we have this massive column in the middle, we didn't know about it. It's a meter column and it's big, ugly and scary. And if I had known about it, I would not have purchased. Then there is
30:04
Renee Roumanos: an element where two things could potentially happen. One of those things is an element of compensation. The other element is a rescision. To get a rescission on these types of contracts, the variation would have to be quite substantial. And you would have to likely prove that you wouldn't have
30:24
Renee Roumanos: purchased this property had that thing. not been there or been there. And that isn't not an easy
30:30
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): bar
30:30
Renee Roumanos: to reach because at the end of the day, the contract protects the vendor. It's there to protect them. It has all the conditions in there that basically say you're buying this, something may be varied. And one of the things I see on a lot of off-the-plan vacant land contracts. So when we're talking about just
30:51
Renee Roumanos: land, nothing else on them. Naturally, we look at a draft plan and it shows us where the easements will be. Okay, there's an easement for water, easement for electricity. Oh, we've got a retaining wall over here, this is over there, oh, there's this electricity box there. That is all proposed. There is nothing that's
31:11
Renee Roumanos: that identifies that those things. can't move and they can and they do.
31:17
David Hamilton: So
31:18
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): sometimes
31:18
Renee Roumanos: when I look at a block of land and I can see that there is an easement for electricity on the border, sometimes I warn people that thing can move. It can move left
31:29
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to right,
31:30
Renee Roumanos: up, down. Obviously, if it's in the middle of your block, we've got a big problem. But if it's moved a meter, and this just means you have to move your house. plans a meter, most of the time it's tough cookies. Because the way in which those contracts are prepared are very developer friendly. Now, don't get me wrong,
31:49
Renee Roumanos: I've seen lots of these and I have had so much fun with compensation claims. Plenty. But they're very hard. And these contracts are there to identify what you're getting.
32:01
David Hamilton: But if you
32:02
Renee Roumanos: don't get it, exactly what the contract says, some of the time, the way these conditions are written waive or take away rights that purchasers otherwise would have had. And this is a friendly reminder to make sure you're getting comprehensive legal advice when you're entering into these contracts. And if I hear anyone
32:21
Renee Roumanos: say the but contract was standard, I'm going gonna to lose it because they're not standard. there's no such thing as a standard contract there are 50 standard conditions and another 50 conditions taking away all the standard conditions there is nothing there is no such thing as a standard contract when a real estate agent says oh but it's standard it's just the same thing just sign it
32:42
Renee Roumanos: no it's not when a builder says it's a standard HIA contract just to sign it's not it is not this is my free legal advice for the day It is not. There's no such thing. Every contract comes with risk, and it is up to the person signing that contract and putting the money down to determine what that
33:02
Renee Roumanos: element of risk is for them. And if you're buying, if you're building, if you're putting money down, just make sure you have the best team around
33:12
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you,
33:13
Renee Roumanos: the best lawyer, the best mortgage. broker, the best humans to help this transaction be as seamless as possible. And I'm gonna be one of those humans, so call
33:22
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): me.
33:23
David Hamilton: All right. Well, but tell me, let's just say we've got to the finish line. Um, whether it's good or it's bad, we know what we can change and we have that 5% tolerance. Um, let's just say we decide to settle on that problem. property.
33:39
Renee Roumanos: Yeah,
33:39
David Hamilton: the next step that we have there, um, and if we're going on the theme of bath or something I've seen personally firsthand, something I've heard a lot about is going to be defects.
33:51
Renee Roumanos: Yep.
33:52
David Hamilton: Building off the plan, it can happen in um it can happen if it's a house and land package and it can happen if it's an apartment.
33:59
Renee Roumanos: Absolutely.
34:00
David Hamilton: What do I do? I've moved into the apartment. What should I do be doing around defects? And how does that play out
34:07
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): for
34:08
David Hamilton: everyone out there?
34:09
Renee Roumanos: Before you settle, before you drop your money down, before you take the keys, you do your inspection. Before.
34:18
Renee Roumanos: Now, naturally, if I'm doing a building inspection or a pre-settlement inspection, I'm gonna have zero idea of what the hell I'm looking
34:24
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): at.
34:25
Renee Roumanos: But
34:26
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): this
34:26
Renee Roumanos: is where you bring in the expert, the right person in your team to help you. And we have building inspectors who we love and trust who help our clients with this exact moment. And when they're undertaking their pre-settlement inspection for the off-the-plan property they bought three bloody years ago, I'll re resay say that, three
34:46
Renee Roumanos: years ago, in that circumstance, it's important that we've got the right
34:51
Renee Roumanos: person
34:52
Renee Roumanos: reviewing, inspecting, looking at all the things, and determining if there are any major defects, if there is any safety hazards. Now, naturally, these contracts will have conditions in them that say
35:06
Renee Roumanos: the vendor will fix defects within a reasonable period of time. The purchaser must produce one defect report. within 90 days of settlement, and the vendor will come back and rectify. Then there'll be a whole bunch of other clauses that say an occupation certificate is evidence that there are no
35:25
Renee Roumanos: defects and all these other fun things. So naturally, when you look at these conditions, they're there to protect both sides. However, this is where the quality building inspection defect report will
35:38
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): assist. a buyer.
35:39
David Hamilton: You have to pay for the
35:43
Renee Roumanos: spending money on the purchase, you spend a few hundred dollars on the building inspection.
35:48
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
35:48
David Hamilton: have to.
35:48
Renee Roumanos: Old mate will come, he'll inspect, he'll give you a report. If there is a major problem, my advice is don't settle. Wait. Ask for a demand that it gets rectified. If those defects are minor, naturally there is an element of
36:03
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
36:03
David Hamilton: scuffs and all that kind of stuff. But
36:06
David Hamilton: even the even non-compliances with like there's just so many the I think the the building codes or whatever that like they're thousands of pages. There is no way that you're gonna be looking at a bathroom and be able to tell that that shower screen is actually uh too small or too small and it needs to be bigger for that
36:26
David Hamilton: gap. that you need to walk out of, or that there's no water stop on the edge of that tiled bathroom. So it means that if you get a leak, it's gonna go through your apartment. There is no way that anyone listening to this, if you're just a normal person not in the construction industry, that you're gonna know any of those. So please, please, please. If you take one thing from this episode, is that you pay good
36:46
David Hamilton: money to get a building report done and not just the cheapest someone that is gonna be the best to do.
36:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.
36:51
Renee Roumanos: Absolutely, someone qualified. And often when buyers are purchasing off the plan,
36:57
Renee Roumanos: that report is your saving grace. Do it early, do it as soon as you're allowed to do it. And if something serious is in there, I would be saying I'm not settling until such time that that thing is rectified. And this is where your strong legal representation is very
37:15
Renee Roumanos: important because the minute you settle, you lose the power.
37:21
Renee Roumanos: The minute you hand your money over, you've lost your power. Whereas if I'm saying I'm not settling until such time that that major defect is rectified, because that major defect is quite serious, and
37:32
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm
37:33
Renee Roumanos: not moving in and the silicon hasn't been done on the bathroom. The minute we go and use the water, we're going. to cause a problem. And
37:41
Renee Roumanos: power is really important in these transactions and knowing when to do certain things. Now, naturally, in these contracts, having a defect liability clause is very important. We know we've got this protection that if something isn't perfect, I've got the ability to ask Builder to come back and fix.
38:01
David Hamilton: And how long does it last in terms of how long can I go back and say, like from moving in to calling it a defect to calling it say wear and tear of a property?
38:12
Renee Roumanos: Yeah. So naturally the contract for sale, so your conveyancing contract for sale will usually have a 90-day defect period.
38:21
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
38:21
Renee Roumanos: I'm talking in usual circumstances. Obviously, this isn't legislated, it's whatever the developer wants. in that contract. However, we also have statutory warranties. Now your statutory warranties come with your homeowner's warranty insurance, which is only for a dwelling. So it's only for a house. You don't get this with an apartment.
38:41
Renee Roumanos: Now naturally with a house, you have your homeowner's warranty insurance. You've got two years for minor, seven years for major defects. That's an element of protection. Builder, come back, something isn't working, something's broken. Now, naturally, some builders come back and some don't answer your phone
39:01
Renee Roumanos: calls.
39:01
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yep.
39:02
Renee Roumanos: And if that happens, that's what the insurance policy is there to do. That is your protection. You've got an ability there to make a claim in NCAT,
39:11
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): which
39:11
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is
39:11
Renee Roumanos: civil tribunal, and ask builder to come back. But again, it all depends on a range of circumstances and a range of people's element of risk. Sometimes, if you're three years down the track and the window starts to leak, you've also got your home insurance. And that is why you have home insurance, is for circumstances where
39:31
Renee Roumanos: things go wrong. Because sometimes it is wear and tear, sometimes it was the heavy storm, sometimes it was something else not related to the way. that property
39:39
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): was
39:39
Renee Roumanos: constructed. So there's all these other elements, and I think I have to highlight that because we've got a lot of builder friends, we've got to be friendly to them
39:45
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): as well. Yeah, I was
39:46
David Hamilton: gonna say, not coming to the Christmas party.
39:49
Renee Roumanos: Invite me to the Christmas
39:50
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): party.
39:51
Renee Roumanos: But the way we look at it is it all depends on the circumstances. And if in the situation we've had a heavy storm and all of a sudden a roof tile's moved and water's now coming in, that is a time where you ring your home insurance and do not underestimate the power and the importance of adequate home insurance.
40:09
David Hamilton: Yeah.
40:10
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um You've
40:11
David Hamilton: learned this one the hard way.
40:12
Renee Roumanos: Sure have.
40:13
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, we
40:13
David Hamilton: talked about this on um give it give everyone a little bit of context.
40:17
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): If they haven't
40:18
David Hamilton: listened to the the convo two years ago.
40:21
Renee Roumanos: Yeah.
40:21
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
40:21
Renee Roumanos: Give
40:22
David Hamilton: us high level. I know it's painful to talk about, so I apologize, but it's your your moment, your line in the sand.
40:29
Renee Roumanos: Yeah. So as I always say, it takes courage to be vulnerable. So let me be vulnerable for a moment. In 2022, I bought my dream home, brand new, big builder.
40:41
Renee Roumanos: And five months after we moved in, our big brand new home burnt down.
40:47
Renee Roumanos: And we lost everything.
40:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
40:50
Renee Roumanos: remember running out of that home with my two babies. My little kids were one and a half and three at the time. I had just started my business. I just moved in, and we lost everything.
41:03
Renee Roumanos: What we later found out was that we were significantly underinsured. And not by our fault, just by way of life circumstances. It was post corruption. post-COVID. Building prices rose significantly. What was appropriate a year ago was no longer appropriate.
41:23
Renee Roumanos: And we were about half a million dollars in the red. By the grace of God, God is great. We brought it down. We demolished a slab. We rebuilt Built back up under a home owner, a homeowner builder permit. Builders would not touch that site. because it
41:40
David Hamilton: nightmare. Yeah.
41:41
Renee Roumanos: Right. We end up keeping the existing slab. We brought it all down by hand. That was not fun. And a whole lot of skip bins. And
41:51
Renee Roumanos: rebuilding it was like rebuilding my life. And I'm very pleased that I'm on the other side of what was a really ugly journey.
42:01
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
42:01
Renee Roumanos: in that journey, my key message to anyone is do not underestimate the importance of valid insurance. It should be checked every 12 months. What you think your house costs to rebuild today and what it will be 12 months from now
42:18
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): will
42:18
Renee Roumanos: vary. And it's important that that insurance policy has every bell and whistle that it needs
42:26
David Hamilton: because it's
42:26
Renee Roumanos: in our circumstance, there are so many things our policy did not have, and those did not have really hurt.
42:35
Renee Roumanos: And
42:37
Renee Roumanos: I think the way I look at it is there are so many learnings and that experience, and I love bringing those learnings into my practice and delivering them to my clients, and making sure my clients have a whole nother level. of education around what they're buying, where they're protected, where their risk lies.
42:57
Renee Roumanos: If something goes wrong, what do we do? And
43:01
Renee Roumanos: as I say, insurance is it's your protection.
43:04
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
43:04
Renee Roumanos: in everything we do, where are we protected?
43:06
David Hamilton: I know, I know that I I know and I've heard even on podcasts that there's investors out there that for the insured amount, they'll drop that all the way down so their insured. insurance premiums are really low. I personally think that is the way to have the worst sleep for the rest of your life. So for what I actually do is I'll add on a bit more. I'm probably more dialed in
43:26
David Hamilton: on construction rates and numbers than most people, but even for um, you know, properties that I've finished, you've got to get them insured from when you finish them to when you sell them. And I know what my building contract was. to be able to rebuild them. And I was putting on like 50 to 100 grand more just to be safe. And that's how you get the best sleep of your life. So what Renee's
43:46
David Hamilton: talking about is if you have a home, if you have any investment properties, I think you can even get a QS report
43:54
David Hamilton: for a couple hundred bucks where they come out and they'll quantify buy it how much it'd be to rebuild.
43:59
Renee Roumanos: Yeah.
44:00
David Hamilton: I'd just be looking at that number and just yeah, you can update. every 12 months to make sure it's online because the last thing you want to do is have a really nice house, get to your insurance poll and you see and you see that they've um you're covered for 400 grand, which would do, you know, your your your slab and frames.
44:16
Renee Roumanos: If you're lucky.
44:17
David Hamilton: Yeah.
44:18
Renee Roumanos: The way I see it with these things is there are experts in different areas who are there to help you. And I'm not saying call cold. Coles and ask Coles, the place you buy your growth through is from for insurance. And there's no, I'm not
44:31
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): just saying
44:31
Renee Roumanos: Coles insurance, but what I'm saying is go to the right person for the right advice. This is where an insurance broker is the person to speak to. They are low cost, they are amazing, they are there to help you when something goes wrong. From my learning lessons, I now have an excellent more insurance broker who does all of
44:51
Renee Roumanos: my insurance from my house to my car to my business to my cyber insurance. And the key message is making sure what you have is insured properly. Now, with home insurance, there is insurance for building, there is insurance for contents. If you're a landlord, so if the property is an investment, then you need landlord
45:11
Renee Roumanos: insurance. So just having the right insurances for the right purposes should be the key takeaway.
45:17
David Hamilton: 100%. Well, look, Renee, I appreciate the the wisdom from not only your own lessons, but from your experience in practice for anyone that's looking to purchase anything off the plan, house and land, apartment, that kind of stuff. I feel like we've covered some stuff that even I was like, oh shit, she's, you know, to t
45:37
David Hamilton: um, you know. uh I guess going against the developers, but uh it's good to know and it's good information. We'll put your contact details on the show notes, but one thing I'll leave you with uh one thing I'll ask you, I'll usually ask for advice, but I think we've we've covered that a few times on on what your advice would be. But what is a quote that you live your life by?
45:57
Renee Roumanos: Oh anyone that knows me knows I love Disney and a recent quote that I've over
46:01
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): got to do. the case. No, you said this last time. No,
46:03
Renee Roumanos: it's a different one.
46:04
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay. It's
46:04
Renee Roumanos: not the same. That was a Mickey Mouse quote.
46:06
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): This one
46:06
Renee Roumanos: is not.
46:06
David Hamilton: Okay.
46:07
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So this is
46:07
Renee Roumanos: a Cinderella quote. And the Cinderella quote is have courage and be kind. And I think this is the way that I try and approach law and life and the crazies of life. So you can still be compassionate, but stand your ground.
46:22
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
46:22
David Hamilton: appreciate it. Well, look, Rene Renee Romanos, Ronos, thank you for joining us on the Everything Property Podcast. And um we'll have to go out and see the office.
46:30
Renee Roumanos: You are so welcome. I look forward to it.
46:32
David Hamilton: Perfect. All right, talk soon.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights