Committed Capital

Preferred equity expands into structured finance via CFOs and NAV financing, offering debt-like economics without covenants.

17 min Listen to the original
Preferred EquityStructured FinanceCollateralized Fund ObligationsPrivate CreditFund FinanceNAV FinancingEvergreen FundsReal Estate Debt

Summary

Ross McConnell and Anthony Lombardi discuss the growing use of preferred equity in structured finance, particularly in Collateralized Fund Obligations (CFOs) and NAV financing. They define preferred equity as a bundle of contractual rights that mimics rated debt economics but lacks traditional covenants or collateral. The speakers explain how sponsors use these structures to leverage LP interests, attract credit investors, and meet rating agency thickness requirements. Key negotiations focus on control rights, tax-efficient hold co structures, and exit mechanisms like forced recapitalization or in-kind distributions. The rise of evergreen funds adds complexity, leading to demands for mandatory monthly redemptions to ensure cash flow.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    A CFO is essentially the financing of a pool of LP interests through rated debt, where the structured product uses cash to acquire or leverage underlying fund investments.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) · 4:25

  2. 2
    agencies to make the overall CFO structure work, there needs to be a certain thickness of each tranche and a residual equity position. So therefore, in order to meet those metrics and hit the rating requirements, sometimes you have to have a bigger slice of equity, and therefore you have to offer a larger slice of pref equity as a consequence.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) · 5:59

  3. 3
    Preferred equity investors are negotiating for the right to force a recapitalization after a certain period (e.g., 8-9 years) or to receive in-kind distributions to exit long-dated positions.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) · 12:37

  4. 4
    the sponsor to redeem a certain amount each month from the Evergreen Fund or to make sure that obviously there is constant flow of distributions coming from that fund or there's constant redemptions coming out for two reasons. Number one, because it's either you want to manage cash flow to be able to repay the notes or to be able to push money back up to equity.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) · 13:18

Episode sections

  1. 0:30 – 1:49

    Introduction to Preferred Equity in Structured Finance

    Ross McConnell introduces the topic, defining preferred equity as a negotiated priority over common equity while sitting behind debt. He notes its expanding role beyond portfolio companies into fund finance and structured finance vehicles like collateralized fund obligations (CFOs) and NAV financing.

  2. 1:49 – 3:39

    Structure and Rights of Preferred Equity

    Anthony Lombardi explains that preferred equity functions as a bundle of contractual rights within the equity tranche, mimicking the economics of a rated debt tranche but lacking covenants or collateral. Key rights include control over material decisions like debt restructuring or dividend payments.

  3. 3:39 – 4:38

    Collateralized Fund Obligations (CFOs) Explained

    Lombardi describes a CFO as a structured product that issues rated debt to finance a portfolio of LP interests. This structure allows sponsors to leverage fund investments to pay capital calls or buy new positions, effectively financing a pool of LP interests through rated debt.

  4. 4:38 – 6:17

    Rationale for Using Preferred Equity in CFOs

    Sponsors use preferred equity to attract a broader investor base beyond traditional common equity buyers like family offices, including credit funds. Additionally, rating agencies require specific thickness of each tranche and a residual equity position, often necessitating a larger slice of preferred equity to meet rating metrics.

  5. 6:17 – 8:02

    Hold Co Structures and Tax Considerations

    Preferred equity is often issued via a hold co structure to keep commercial terms separate from the rated debt and for tax efficiency. Investors may prefer this to avoid mixing their terms with note holders, and tax drivers may necessitate specific jurisdictions for the hold co that differ from the note issuer.

  6. 8:02 – 12:58

    Negotiating Control Rights and Default Protections

    Negotiations focus on ensuring preferred equity holders have reserved matters rights at both the hold co and issuer levels. Key protections include blocking distributions, removing the GP, and ensuring that hold co voting instructions are fed through to the issuer level to protect against senior debt control post-default.

  7. 12:58 – 14:11

    Market Trends and Evergreen Funds

    The rise of evergreen funds introduces complexity, leading to negotiations around mandatory monthly redemptions to ensure cash flow for note repayment and equity distributions. This helps avoid asset suspension or gating, which could impair returns for preferred equity holders.

  8. 14:11 – 17:28

    Exit Mechanisms and Liquidity Challenges

    Exit strategies include transfer rights after a 3-5 year lock-up, forced recapitalization after 5-8 years, or in-kind distributions after 8-10 years. While a secondary market is emerging, it remains small, and investors must negotiate the transfer of their specific rights to affiliates or new buyers.

Claims worth verifying

Preferred equity gives an investor a negotiated priority over common equity in receiving distributions and recovering its investment while sitting behind the debt.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·0:30

How to verify: Verify against standard private equity term sheets or legal definitions of preferred equity in portfolio company investments. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Preferred equity is being used across fund finance and structured finance, including in the collateralized fund obligation (CFO) space, the collateralized loan obligation (CLO) space, and within NAV financing structures.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·1:04

How to verify: Search for recent CFO, CLO, and NAV financing transaction announcements or legal articles from 2026-2026 discussing preferred equity tranches in these structures. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

In a CFO, dividing the equity into preferred and common layers helps a sponsor attract investors who want something other than a pure residual position while preserving common equity interest for the sponsor.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·1:21

How to verify: Review CFO prospectuses or offering memoranda that detail the equity capitalization table, showing separate preferred and common equity tranches. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Preferred equity is a bundle of contractual rights at the equity position which makes equity behave more like a rated tranche, providing similar economics to a rated tranche or loan but without the covenant package, collateral, or statutory enforcement rights.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·2:10

How to verify: Compare the rights and protections section of a preferred equity term sheet against a standard senior secured loan agreement or rated note indenture. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

A CFO issues rated tranches of debt to acquire or finance an underlying portfolio of fund investments, leveraging LP interests to pay capital calls or buy new positions.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·3:46

How to verify: Examine the structure diagram and capitalization table of a specific CFO transaction filing or press release. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Rating agencies require a certain thickness of each tranche and a residual equity position in CFO structures, which can necessitate a larger slice of preferred equity to meet rating requirements.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·5:59

How to verify: Review rating agency methodology papers for structured finance products like CFOs or CLOs regarding equity subordination requirements. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Hold co structures for preferred equity are sometimes driven by tax reasons, allowing investors to invest through multiple vehicles in a particular jurisdiction that may not work for the notes.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·7:15

How to verify: Analyze the organizational chart and tax jurisdiction of the hold co versus the note issuer in a specific CFO transaction document. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Preferred equity holders in hold co structures need rights at both the hold co and issuer levels, including procuring that the hold co's GP votes in accordance with their instructions at the issuer level.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·9:01

How to verify: Review the limited partnership agreement of the hold co and the indenture of the issuer to check for voting rights and instruction mechanisms. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Preferred equity investors are negotiating for the right to force a recapitalization after a certain period (e.g., 8-9 years) or to receive in-kind distributions to exit long-dated positions.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·12:37

How to verify: Search for recent legal commentary or term sheet examples from 2026-2026 detailing exit rights and forced recapitalization clauses in preferred equity agreements. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The secondary market for preferred equity interests in structured finance is growing but remains small, with limited movement.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·15:11

How to verify: Monitor secondary market transaction data from platforms like SecondMarket or PitchBook for preferred equity trades in structured finance products. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Review rating agency methodologies for CFOs (e.g., S&P, Moody's) to understand tranche thickness and residual equity requirements.
  • Examine specific hold co structures in recent CFO prospectuses to identify tax jurisdictions and voting instruction mechanics.
  • Analyze secondary market liquidity data for preferred equity interests in CFOs, noting the small size of the emerging market.
  • Check for mandatory redemption clauses in evergreen fund CFOs to assess cash flow predictability for note repayment.
  • Verify default protection provisions, specifically blocking rights on distributions and GP removal, in sample term sheets.
  • Compare the economics of preferred equity in CFOs against traditional senior secured debt in portfolio companies.
  • Investigate the impact of asset suspension or gating clauses on preferred equity returns in stressed market scenarios.
Full transcriptexpand

0:08Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Welcome to Deckert's Committed Capital, where private equity leaders open their playbooks to discuss today's trends.

0:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Good

0:18Ross McConnell: morning. My name is Ross McConnell. I'm a corporate partner in Deckert's Philadelphia office, and I'm here today with

0:25Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Ancy Lombardi from our London office, also based in the corporate team.

0:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

0:30Ross McConnell: we're here today to talk about preferred equity. Preferred equity is a familiar concept to many in private equity, but today we're looking beyond its use at the portfolio company level. At its core, preferred equity gives an investor a negotiated priority over common equity in receiving distributions and recovering its investment while still sitting behind. the debt. For sponsors, it can be a way to bring in additional capital without giving up all the residual upside. For investors, it offers priority within the equity class, but without the protections of a loan.

1:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): As

1:04Ross McConnell: we explored in a recent article, we're seeing preferred equity play a growing role across fund finance and structured finance, including in the collateralized fund obligation or CFO space. the collateralized loan obligation, or CLO space, and within NAV financing structures.

1:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): In

1:21Ross McConnell: a CFO, for example, dividing the equity into preferred and common layers can help a sponsor attract investors who want something other than a pure residual position while preserving common equity interest for the sponsor. Today we'll unpack how that works, why a sponsor may choose preferred equity over other sources of capital, and what sponsors and investors should focus on when negotiating the terms. So let's start at the beginning. Anthony, what is preferred equity and what exactly is preferred about

1:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it?

1:50Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): So I think Ross, you put it very nicely. Preferred equity is essentially if you think about a structured product, you issue lots of different rated classes of debt, each gets more subordinated, and then obviously you have the residual equity position at the bottom of your structured product. Now, what the preferred equity is, it's a preferred position within that equity tranche. Okay? So what does that really mean? You know, you talked a little bit about a preferred return that that equity provider might get. But really, the best way to think about it is it's a bundle of contractual rights, which is at the equity position, which makes equity behave more like a rated tranche. So you get the economics or very similar economics to a rated tranche or a loan, as you put it, quite nicely. But you don't get the covenant package or the collateral or the statutory enforcement rights that you otherwise would if you were a rated noteholder or if you were a loan provider to the relevant entity. In terms of what you might be looking to make it preferred, other than the preferred return. So the return that you would get ahead of the common equity. The other things that you might get is certain control rights when decisions have to be made by the entity, which may then look in through to the structured product by saying, for example, you can't increase the level of debt at the structured notes without getting the preferred equity consent. Or if you wanted to restructure the debt, you might need the

3:10preferred equity consent. Or if you wanted to pay a distribution or a dividend or you wanted to make some form of material decision in related to the either the issuer of the debt itself, or depending if the preferred equity and the common equity are held through some hold co-structure, if you wanted to make a fundamental change, that whole co-structure, replace a general partner, for example, those decisions would stick with the preferred equity holder.

3:32Ross McConnell: Thanks, Anthony. And for the audience in this call who's probably more familiar with traditional private equity investing. can you explain what a CFO is or a structured product like a CFO is in plain English?

3:46Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Sure. So when you're thinking about a CFO, it's quite helpful to sort of think about it almost like a secondary is nav finance, but you've put a structured product on top. So what do I mean by that? Essentially, what you're doing with the a CFO is you are issuing rated chances of debt to a acquire or finance an underlying portfolio of fund investments. So the CFO will either use the cash via the notice, raising the equity, to acquire a portfolio of LP interests, or it will already hold those LP interests. And what it's looking to do is lever them up and perhaps use it to pay capital calls or buy a bigger position in its underlying uh funds that's already invested. and or use that cash to buy new LP positions. So a collateralized fund obligation is essentially the financing of a pool of LP interest through rated debt.

4:38Ross McConnell: Thank you. That makes a lot of sense. If I'm a sponsor and I'm doing one of these CFOs, why might I bring in preferred equity rather than more junior subordinated debt? maybe unrated debt, or additional common equity, just expanding the thickness of the common stack?

4:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Obviously, as CFOs have grown larger into the billions, the slice of equity has had by its very nature become larger. And there are two then issues in terms of just the common equity position. The first is that traditionally, common equity has mainly been put in by the sponsor or affiliates of the sponsor. And as the size has grown, the sponsor may not either be able to meet that commitment or may simply want other investors. The other point with common equity has been that traditionally the buyers of common equity tend to be people like, for example, family offices, some sovereign wealth funds, and and therefore it's limited to the pool of investors that you can have in common equity versus those that might be interested in doing a preferred position. as well as holding some sort of tranche of the rated debt. So it opens it, for example, to credit fund investors and other types of investors that are more prepared to invest heavily into this area. The second reason, actually, is because of the rating of the notes. In order to have the notes rated and hit the particular rating that you need from the rating

5:59agencies to make the overall CFO structure work, there needs to be a certain thickness of each tranche and a residual equity position. So therefore, in order to meet those metrics and hit the rating requirements, sometimes you have to have a bigger slice of equity, and therefore you have to offer a larger slice of pref equity as a consequence.

6:17Ross McConnell: You mentioned earlier in your conversation a notion of a hold co or a preferred hold co. Um Practically, as these get negotiated. in the context of a CFO, for example, where does the preferred equity typically sit and what drives that decision? I can speak personally, just having spoken about this with you, we do sometimes see preferred equity issued by the issuer itself just within the same issuer of that common equity. Anthony, I believe your experience and the experience we have sort of across the platform often sees a hold co-structure. Maybe you can talk a little bit about why.

6:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Sure. One of the reasons that we see whole co-structures is actually because that's what the preferred equity investor would like for its own structural reasons. It doesn't want to go straight into the vehicle that's issuing the debt itself, or they prefer to keep themselves and the terms that they negotiate separate from the rated debt. Sometimes we see the whole co structures as tax driven because it may be that, for example, the other investors that are coming in through both the common and the PREF, because obviously the PREF investor might be a credit fund, but it may be investing through multiple different vehicles. It needs to have a hold co vehicle in a particular jurisdiction where it might not necessarily work for the notes to be issued or for the note holders. So sometimes it's driven by tax. And to your point, you know, we've actually seen whilst preferred equity can be sometimes issued via hold co vehicles, sometimes actually the preferred equity holder sits at a feeder vehicle going into the hold co-vehicle purely for tax structuring reasons. The other main reason that we've seen it is being driven purely by trying to keep the commercial terms of the PREF interest separate and from the rated note holders.

8:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): When

8:02Ross McConnell: you're negotiating preferred equity in these kind of structures, how do the rights typically compare with those of a noteholder? And then what are some of the key points for negotiation? Generally, in my experience, there's a controlling class construct where outside of an event of default, the equity is voting.

8:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

8:25Ross McConnell: then following an event of default, you move to

8:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the

8:29Ross McConnell: note holders or the debt holders voting, starting with the most senior class and moving on down. When you have preferred equity, how does it change things and how does it layer on top of that or other structures that we might see in the market?

8:41Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): What's interesting about this particular point is again, it really does depend on where the pref equity is structured. And that's quite important for two reasons. Number one because when we've seen hold co-pref equity structures put in place, you're right that there will typically be a controlling class mechanic within the issuer itself. But then what there will be is reserved matters where the holdco will need to vote or pass it above the of controlling class in order for the CFO issuer to take that particular action. And they tend to be like material things like, for example, reorganizing the debt, reorganising the capital structure, extending the maturity and blocking a distribution to equity in circumstances where there is residual cash available. And it might be, for example, GP removal rights. It might be removal of the manager. It might be default of the manager in terms of the way it's managed the CFO. And But what's really important is when you're thinking about hold co structures is the fact that you'll need those rights at both levels. So for example, the hold co itself normally is a limited partnership. It has its own independent GP. You will have to procure that that GP will vote in accordance with your instructions at the issuer level. And so you couldn't just have the rights

10:01in the indenture or whatever the governing document is to say that holdco will do this. You also need the rights feathered into the holdco document to make sure that it backs all the way through. And then what you're also thinking about as preferred equity holder isn't just what rights you need versus the debt, because the reality is the debt will control what happens at the issuer level. You also need to look at it as things like, for example, uh at the hold co-level, do you want to permit transfers of common equity and do you want control rights over common equity? Because you need to make sure that when those common equity investors are coming into the structure, they're able to meet their obligations to fund, for example, their common equity position, so the cash can be pushed down at the issuer level if there's a requirement made to call capital. The other thing you may look at, for example, is if there is a recallable distribution that's made up to Holdco via the issuer, is there some sort of blocker where the pref equity will say, you know, for the first two years it's a hundred percent recallable distribution, but anything we receive after two years, it's not recallable. And us is solely recallable on the common equity providers. So when you're thinking about pref equity, you're not just thinking about what control rights you might need at the issuer level. to protect your position as pref equity versus the senior, knowing full well that following an event default, the senior will

11:20control in full. You're also looking at what rights do you need at equity Hulk level to protect your position.

11:27Ross McConnell: Thank you. That actually sounds pretty similar in respect of the reserve rights that private equity sponsors would see in their portfolio company negotiations with respect to PREF.

11:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,

11:39Ross McConnell: you covered a lot of this when you were just describing your view of the negotiations, but from your perspective, are there any points that you think are important that seem to be short-shifted in some of the negotiations, either from a sponsor perspective or from an investor perspective?

11:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): So obviously, the sponsor wants to be able to manage the underlying portfolio. and the vehicles as freely as possible in order to maximize returns, not just for the pref equity, but obviously for itself as well, because it's holding a residual common equity. So for example, when you start putting restrictions in terms of things that the sponsor can do in the management of the vehicles, you will obviously get quite a lot of pushback from the sponsor. Equally, you know, when you're looking at it from a pref PRF equity equity position, position, something that's starting to come into the documents but is still being quite heavily negotiated, for example, is the right to force a recapitalisation after a certain period of time so that the PREF equity can get repaid. Or if certain metrics aren't met, because these tend to be long dated notes, tend to be fifteen years plus. After year eight or nine, the right to require, for example, a in in-kind kind distribution to the PREF equity. so that the PREF equity can obviously sell the position or the underlying fund asset and exit the position because these are long data notes.

12:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

12:58Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): guess the other thing that's been really interesting at the moment, which is still there's a little bit of tension between sponsors and investors as how this works, is you're obviously seeing a lot more evergreen funds come into the underlying pool of assets. So what you've seen, which is also helpful for some of the rated note holders particularly if they are insurance companies, is a requirement for the sponsor to redeem a certain amount each month from the Evergreen Fund or to make sure that obviously there is constant flow of distributions coming from that fund or there's constant redemptions coming out for two reasons. Number one, because it's either you want to manage cash flow to be able to repay the notes or to be able to push money back up to equity. But number two, you don't want to be in a position where there is a suspension or a gate because obviously that means that you potentially have an asset at a fund level that you can't make a return on. So there is a lot of discussion happening on how you deal with evergreen funds and these structures.

13:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,

13:54Ross McConnell: I think we can then skip into probably the last topic, which is how do you get out if you're a preferred equity holder? How do you get out? of these vehicles? And conversely, what happens if you're in for longer than you expected?

14:11Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): So I guess there's two things, which gets negotiated pretty hard. The first is transfer rights for pref equity investors. Now typically, obviously, in any normal equity vehicle or even in the notes themselves, you'll normally need consent. of the issuer or the equity hold co in order to transfer your position. And what you'll see is that for transfer positions in terms of getting out, there will be a bar on free transfers by the pref equity for, let's say, for the first three to five years of the CFO or the or the structure product. But after that point, the restrictions lift so that it gives you much more ability. Sometimes it's you can transfer to anybody on a whitelist. Sometimes it's you can't transfer to anybody on a black list. And you can do that without consent. So that's one way. The other way that you see the transfer restrictions being lifted, for example, is if there's been a default or if one of the metrics for your return hurdle hadn't been met, then it And accelerates your ability to transfer out of the deal. Now the reality is that we've just actually done one of these where there was a transfer of a pref equity position. So there is becoming a liquid market for these instruments, but it's still a growing secondaries market. So there isn't that much movement. And the other thing that you will see, which we touched on a little bit more, which is coming into deals, is

15:31the rights to, after, for example, five to eight years to force a recapitalization, or if you go through, there'll be certain trigger events. like, you know, your hurdle hasn't been met, or there's been a default by the GP because there's been some form of bad act, and that will force you to be able to try and push through a recap so you can get paid out and move on. And the other thing that we've talked about is after eight to ten years, sometimes you see the ability to try and get a distribution in kind of the asset so you can sell it and and and exit. I mean these are all points people are still working through how these would work logistically, but they are the kind of things that you see pref equity holders negotiating because they're obviously looking at a way to exit within, you know, sometimes their own fun life may be seven years, so they can't hold the paper for fifteen. And but that's also why it's very important when you're acting for a pref equity investor to make sure of two things. Number one, that there's a free transfer to any of your affiliates. Okay. But number two, that your rights as a pref equity holder also transfer. So any rights you have as a pref equity holder transfer to your affiliate or any of your other transferes. It doesn't just stop with you and that your transfer would just have normal common rights.

16:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

16:41Ross McConnell: hope everyone found this discussion enlightening. Preferred equity, which has been a staple in private equity investing, has been having its moment in structured finance. We would be happy here at Deckert to assist you thinking through ways to utilize and operationalize preferred equity throughout your structured finance investments.

17:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Thank you for listening to Deckert's Committed Capital. Please subscribe and for more information, visit Deckert.com.

This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights