Speakers analyze oil tech stocks using GICS filters and McKinsey AI data, highlighting SLB's digital segment.
Summary
Speaker 1 introduces a McKinsey report claiming AI can unlock $65 billion in annual value for upstream oil and gas, noting that efficiency gains might paradoxically reduce OFS revenues unless commercial models shift. The speaker outlines a methodology using GICS codes to filter the XLE ETF for 'Oil, Gas, Equipment & Services' companies, excluding non-tech firms like TechnipFMC and Tenaris. Fundamental analysis reveals Cactus has higher operating margins (~19%) than peers (~13%), while SLB and Baker Hughes show strong debt coverage. Speaker 2 evaluates tech exposure, noting SLB's dedicated 'Digital' segment accounts for 7% of revenue, whereas Baker Hughes and Halliburton lack granular reporting. Speaker 1 concludes that credible AI investment requires monitorable revenue metrics, highlighting SLB as the only clear example, while hinting at a premium subscriber pick.
Key takeaways
- 1 A McKinsey report claims AI can unlock approximately $65 billion in annual recurring value in upstream oil and gas, with a full potential of $230 billion using current and future autonomous operating models.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) · 0:57
- 2 OFCs may actually stand to lose revenues when they create these efficiencies because that will reduce their billable rig days, their service hours, their frack stages, or time and materials activities they perform. That's why a commercial model that shares the value upside can help to incentivize the use of efficiency creating AI.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) · 1:39
- 3 They charge eight basis points, which is fairly reasonable. And for that, you get focused, concentrated energy exposure. Now, what I've done here is I've taken all the stocks in this ETF, put them into Excel, and then used the simple Excel plugin to then render an industry association or classification for each one of these names. What you see here is they break down into two types. You have oil and gas. It's not what we're interested in, right? Oil companies, big boring oil companies, as we said. Interesting to see here, though, that Exxon and Chevron make up over 40% of this ETF, but we don't want the oil and gas companies.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) · 2:59
- 4 TechnipFMC was excluded from the shortlist because its business is project and equipment-driven rather than technology-focused.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) · 5:37
- 5 Cactus has an operating margin of approximately 19%, which is higher than the ~13% margin seen in the larger companies (SLB, Baker Hughes, Halliburton).
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) · 8:55
Episode sections
- 0:17 – 2:19
Introduction and McKinsey Report on AI in Oil
Speaker 1 states that oil consumption is increasing, requiring more engineering per barrel, and introduces AI as a solution. They cite a McKinsey report claiming AI can unlock $65 billion in annual recurring value, with a potential of $230 billion, primarily benefiting Oil Field Services (OFS) companies through production optimization, drilling, and reservoir management.
- 2:19 – 8:16
Methodology for Selecting Oil Tech Stocks
Speaker 1 outlines a process using the Global Industry Classification Standard (GICS) to filter companies. Starting with the XLE ETF, they isolate the 'Oil, Gas, Equipment & Services' sub-industry (GICS code 1010-1020). They use LLMs to identify companies in the MSCI World Index matching this code, filtering out non-tech companies like TechnipFMC and Tenaris, and adding Cactus AI to the shortlist.
- 8:16 – 10:41
Fundamental Analysis of Shortlisted Companies
The speaker analyzes size, revenue growth, profitability, and balance sheets. All four companies showed minimal negative growth recently due to sector cyclicality. Cactus has higher operating margins (~19%) compared to the others (~13%). SLB and Baker Hughes have strong free cash flow coverage for their debt, with credit ratings of AA, while Halliburton is BBB+.
- 10:41 – 12:39
Exposure to Digital Platforms and Technology
Speaker 2 evaluates each company's revenue exposure to technology. SLB has a dedicated 'Digital' segment (7% of revenue) which is highly profitable. Baker Hughes and Halliburton lack granular reporting for AI/digital revenue, making it hard to verify tech exposure. Cactus is described as a 'pick and shovel' play on US shale hardware rather than a pure AI play.
- 12:39 – 15:01
Conclusion and Investment Criteria
Speaker 1 concludes that credible AI investment theses require either strong top-line growth attributed to AI or a specific, monitorable revenue segment. SLB is highlighted as the only one providing a clear metric to monitor. The speaker hints at a specific stock pick available to premium subscribers.
Claims worth verifying
AI can unlock approximately $65 billion in annual recurring value across upstream oil and gas using today's technologies, with a credible path to $230 billion at full potential.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·0:57
How to verify: Search for the McKinsey report titled 'AI in upstream oil and gas' or similar on McKinsey.com; verify the $65B and $230B figures in the executive summary. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Top use cases for AI in oil and gas fall into three operational domains: production optimization, drilling activity, and reservoir management.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·1:15
How to verify: Check the same McKinsey report cited above for the listed use cases/domains. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Exxon and Chevron make up over 40% of the XLE ETF.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·3:39
How to verify: Check the current holdings and weightings of the XLE ETF on the State Street Global Advisors website or financial data providers like Yahoo Finance. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceThe GICS code for Oil, Gas, Equipment & Services is 1010-1020.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·4:17
How to verify: Consult the Global Industry Classification Standard (GICS) sector definitions provided by MSCI and S&P Dow Jones Indices. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
SLB's Digital segment accounts for 7% of total revenues and is its most profitable segment.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·10:41
How to verify: Review SLB's latest quarterly (10-Q) or annual (10-K) SEC filing for segment revenue breakdown and operating income by segment. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceBaker Hughes has less than half of its revenues from oil field services and equipment.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·11:21
How to verify: Review Baker Hughes' latest SEC filing (10-K or 10-Q) for revenue segmentation by business line. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceCactus has an operating margin of around 19%, while other large names sit at around 13%.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·8:55
How to verify: Calculate operating margin (Operating Income / Revenue) from the latest quarterly or annual financial statements for Cactus AI, SLB, Baker Hughes, and Halliburton. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
SLB and Baker Hughes have credit ratings of AA, while Halliburton is BBB+.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·10:14
How to verify: Check current credit ratings on S&P Global Ratings, Moody's, or Fitch Ratings websites for each company. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceBaker Hughes can pay off its debt in one year using free cash flow, and SLB in under two years.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·9:54
How to verify: Calculate the debt payback period (Net Debt / Free Cash Flow) using data from the companies' latest SEC filings. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceCactus has no net debt.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·9:35
How to verify: Review Cactus AI's latest balance sheet in SEC filings to confirm cash and debt levels resulting in zero net debt. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceDo your own research
- Verify the McKinsey report's methodology and assumptions regarding the $65 billion and $230 billion value unlock figures.
- Review the GICS classification definitions for code 1010-1020 to ensure accurate company categorization.
- Check SLB's latest quarterly earnings report for the specific revenue contribution and growth rate of its 'Digital' segment.
- Analyze the debt-to-EBITDA ratios and credit ratings for SLB, Baker Hughes, and Halliburton to confirm the stated coverage metrics.
- Investigate whether TechnipFMC and Tenaris have any recent strategic shifts toward digital or AI-enabled services that might contradict the exclusion rationale.
- Compare the operating margins of Cactus AI against peers to assess if the 19% margin is sustainable or driven by one-time factors.
- Look for counter-arguments regarding the 'efficiency paradox' in OFS, specifically how companies are adapting commercial models to value-sharing.
- Review the XLE ETF holdings and weightings to understand the exposure to large-cap producers versus equipment/services firms.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Welcome
0:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): to the Nanalize Podcast. We are a boutique media and research firm specializing in disruptive innovation. Visit Nanalize.com for more details.
0:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
0:17Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): world isn't using less oil. We're using more, which means oil companies need to run faster and faster just to stay in the same place. Every barrel now takes more money, more energy, more engineering than the one before it. The solution? That's right. AI something something. This video isn't about Exxon or Chevron or any other big old boring oil company. It's about four exciting companies using AI to help oil flow out of hard-to-reach places. So we have SLB, Baker Hughes, Halliburton, and Cactus. And they're absolutely going to print money by doing so. Check out this report from McKinsey. Talks about how AI can unlock approximately $65 billion in annual recurring value across upstream oil and gas simply using today's technologies. Says the report, there's a credible path to $230 billion. at full potential, including autonomous operating models that become more common as the technology matures. Top use cases, they say, fall into three operational domains: production optimization, drilling activity, and reservoir management. The key beneficiaries? OFCs or
1:35oil field services and equipment companies, but it's not that simple. OFCs may actually stand to lose revenues when they create these efficiencies because that will reduce their billable rig days, their service hours, their frack stages, or time and materials activities they perform. That's why a commercial model that shares the value upside can help to incentivize the use of efficiency creating AI. What we want to do here. is find the OFCs that can most likely benefit from the explosive opportunities that are waiting to be captured. Let's start talking oil and oil stocks. I like my coffee like my oil, dark, strong, and extracted under pressure, which is also how I like my women who also resemble my morning coffees. They start out hot and steamy, but they quickly become cold and bitter. Anyway, here's the exact process I use to find four stocks that will benefit from the technological transformation happening in the oil industry. So let's start at the top. So GIC
2:39stands for Global Industry Classification Standard, and it's a way to segment the world's companies into distinct categories based on what they do. So there are 11. sectors. One of these, which is called energy, and that largely includes oil companies. And the largest energy sector ETF in the world, you might have heard of, called XLE, and that gives you exposure to this exact sector. They charge eight basis points, which is fairly reasonable. And for that, you get focused, concentrated energy exposure. Now, what I've done here is I've taken all the stocks in this ETF, put them into Excel, and then used the simple Excel plugin to then render an industry association or classification for each one of these names. What you see here is they break down into two types. You have oil and gas. It's not what we're interested in, right? Oil companies, big boring oil companies, as we said. Interesting to see here, though, that Exxon and Chevron make up over 40% of this ETF, but we don't want the oil and gas companies. We're more interested in these oil and gas related equipment and services, right? Going back to that comment McKinsey made about the offseas. We want exposure to these pick and shovel digital providers. And what we then Then need to do is find
3:59a more granular way to classify these companies so we can start. finding the right ones. What you can do is look here at the further breakdown, the granularity of the energy gigs sector, and you see these sub-industries. One in particular we're interested in: oil, gas, equipment, and services. So that's under the code 1010-1020. And when we pull these six companies out of that ETF and ask an LLM to go out and find their proper GIX code. We see that three of them fall under the one that we're looking for. The other three are oil, gas, storage, and transportation. So that's not what we're looking for here. Now we have three names, but we need to do a little bit more digging. Okay, we can do better. Now, XLE is looking at all the energy sector companies in the SP 500, but what about all the companies? in developed markets that are classified, not in the energy sector, but in the specific GIX code we're looking at 10, 10, 10, 20. Now we would typically need to license this data from MSCI. So I worked there for around a decade, and that information costs money to license. What we can do is simply ask an LLM to go out there and find it for us. There's various sources. for this information for companies. You go and do enough digging, you
5:17can find it. It used to be a manual process, now it's a whole lot easier. So when we do that, we uncover two more names. What I did is I asked an LLM, go out to MSCI World, which is the large and mid cap companies in the world belonging to the 23 developed markets out there. It surfaced these two extra names. Well, we can then say is this the type of experience. exposure we're looking for? And you see that this first one, Technip FMC, it's more project and equipment driven rather than technology focused. Okay, drop that off the list. Then you have Tenaris Steelpipe Tubular Products Company. So more of a commodity oriented manufacturer, not an oil tech pure pureplay. play. All right, drop them off the list. Now what we can do is we could ask it, tell me all the companies with the 10, 10, 10, 20 code that are in MSCI World IMI. We've added small caps, all right, and it surfaces five additional names. Now, prior to doing this exercise, I had already probed some LLMs on particular companies and cactus came up. So we're gonna go ahead and add that to our shortlist. That gives us four names. They're a tech-enabled shortlist. shale equipment provider, and that's particularly interesting because that's what's led the United States to become the largest producer of oil and gas in the world, is largely
6:36shale. So exposure to that particular type of technology is interesting. Now, when we look at the other small cap names, we're gonna drop them off our list for the various reasons mentioned here. Now, one in particular, oceaneering. We covered them, I think it was eight years ago under the context of robotics. But when you look at the exposure you're getting there, it's largely exposure to oil equipment and services as opposed to robotics, even though they do some pretty cool stuff. So neither of these would really be considered a pure play on a digital oil field or AI or any of the sort of technology that McKinsey's referring to in that report. And what I also looked at is I queried an LLM to show me the same types of companies for the entire world. So I added in the 24 emerging markets out there basically querying MSCIAIMI. Didn't find anything overly interesting. And even if there was something interesting, we want to sort of stick with US listed companies to make it easier. easy for retail investors to invest in these names. Notice how we used a methodological approach to arrive at this list of four constituents. Now, we've established a very compelling investment theme and some viable candidates, and we haven't even opened a single
7:56investor deck. So to better understand this mini ETF that we've created here, we need to start looking at some basic fundamental data. What we can then do is take these four names and have a look at size. So we already have an indication of what's large cap and what's small cap, revenue growth across the board. And here's what's interesting. So because they're all selling into the same sector, they've all seen minimal negative growth last year as a result of just cyclicality within that particular sector. Now, in order to understand their growth trajectories, we can then look at a five-year revenue compound annual growth rate. Looking backwards, you see, wow, they're all from mid to high single digits. That's rather interesting, except for cactus, and they're a small cap, so they're probably moving faster than these other large companies. Then what we can look at is an indicator of profitability. And again, we see some similarities in operating margin. Look at that, it's nearly identical for the larger names on this list, and it's a bit higher there for cactus. So cactus sitting at around 19%, the other names sitting at around 13%. And then I think something that you need to pay attention to on the balance sheet that gets a lot of companies in trouble would be. debt.
9:15You want to look at net debt. So the thought process there is take the cash that you have on hand, take the debt that you have, add the two together, and that's net debt. In other words, if you took all the cash you had and tried to pay down your debt, what would you have left? And in this case, you can see net debt for the three larger names on our list. So somewhat sizable cash. cactus not having any net debt. But then what you want to look at is free cash flow. What this tells you is that after they've made all the investments they need to make, they have free cash flow ideally coming off their business. How long would it take them to pay back the debt that they have on their books using that free cash flow? It's very interesting, right? So take a look at SLB. You see, well, in two years they could pay. off their debt. That's quite quick. Under two years, really. Look at Baker Hughes. In just one year, they could pay off their debt. So this isn't really that sizable in terms of being able to manage it. So they're not likely to get in trouble. And another key indicator, instead of doing this analysis yourself, just look at the credit ratings agencies, right? So SP rating for SLB and Baker Hughes sitting at AA for each. right? And then for Halliburton, it's BBB plus. So these are high credit ratings. We don't have anything to worry about here. Now, before we
10:34consider investing in any of these names, there's a very important factor that many investors overlook.
10:41Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Exposure. For each company, we want to know what kind of exposure we're getting to digital platforms and technology. And thankfully, the first company, SLB, has done that for us. They have a segment called digital, which currently only accounts for 7% of their total revenues. However, it's also their most profitable segment, followed closely by all other, which includes their data center business. SLB investors can watch this segment over time for signs of growth, which is what we want exposure to for this thesis. As for Baker Hughes, it's a lot more difficult to determine what kind of AI digital platform exposure. investors are getting. Less than half their revenues come from oil field services and equipment, with the remainder coming from things like natural gas and power systems. That's not necessarily a bad thing, it's just not the pure play technology exposure we're looking for here. There's no specific segment that tracks recurring or technology sales, so it's really difficult for investors to monitor their progress. The same holds true for Halliburton. They have drilling technology platforms. that use machine learning to drill autonomously, which is pretty cool. There's even a whole slide in their investor deck that's dedicated to these digital solutions, but they don't provide that granularity in their revenue segments. So it's tough to say how much these exciting technologies are actually contributing. Finally, we have cactus, which sells tech equipment to the shale industry. Shale is a rock that contains elements of oil that can be converted into oil under
12:01heat. Cactus is safe. safe drill wellhead systems are installed in virtually every onshore unconventional shale well in the United States. So they're definitely a leader in this niche. They design, they manufacture, and service these wellheads. They also sell process control equipment, spoolable pipe technologies, and other equipment for Or onshore shale wells. Problem here is they're not actually doing a whole lot with AI and autonomy, so this is really more of a play on US shale than it is on technology. However, shale is what drove the US to become a leading producer of oil. So perhaps a pure play, pick and shovel play on shale is still worth considering.
12:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): When a company talks about all this cool stuff they're doing with AI, they need to show us one of two things. They either need to show us top top-line line strong revenue growth. though most companies provide segmentation. All right, they then need to point to one of those segments that's showing strong growth and say, that's attributed to AI something, something. All right, that's credible. Or they need to provide us with a specific segment that we can look at and monitor over time to see the progress they're are making in selling AI. That's very important. That's what SLB provides us, right? Is a very useful metric to monitor over time. And if you don't have something like that, then you're just trusting whatever the company says. It better at some point start being reflected in top line revenue growth, or what's the point of even having AI, right? Or in the case of internal efficiencies, in margin improvements. Now, this soil technology topic was raised by one of our premium paying subscribers, and frankly, I found it quite compelling. But one of these companies I found very compelling. I'm going to say which one that is on our Discord server. And for those of you not paying us money, I'm going to talk about that in a coming free newsletter. There's a link in the comments section for you to sign up for that. We help you become a better investor in this weekly newsletter.
13:59It's quite good. So sign up for that and support our channel. We're going to link gonna likely do a follow-up on one of these names, and you're not gonna want to miss it. It's really interesting. Now, we recently did a piece on all the turmoil in the Middle Earth with the Houthis and the Saudis, and there's one oil producer out there that we quite like that has none of these geopolitical risks. It's probably one of the safest ways to play oil right now, and our video on this topic became one of our most popular. Thanks so much for taking the
14:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): time. Thank
14:32Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you for listening to the Nanalize podcast. If you found this information useful, please share this episode with a friend. This helps us to continue to provide thorough research for you. Want more research like this? Want to know what we're invested in and what stocks we're avoiding? Head to Nanalize.com and consider becoming a premium annual subscriber. to get access to premium articles, webinars, and our extensive tech stock catalog. Thank you for your
14:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): time.