Debate over India's poverty reduction claims and IndiGo's Q2 losses amid fuel costs
Summary
Host Dakshara and guests discuss the controversy surrounding World Bank data claiming 50 crore Indians escaped extreme poverty, citing methodological changes in India's Household Consumption Expenditure Survey (HCES) that may inflate spending figures. The episode contrasts these claims with stagnant real wages and the lack of an official poverty line since 2014. It then shifts to IndiGo's Q2 financial results, highlighting a loss driven by a 67% surge in jet fuel costs despite a 34% fare hike. The segment covers IndiGo's strategic decisions, including returning leased Boeing 787s and avoiding government fuel subsidies to maintain pricing freedom. Brief updates cover telecom penalties, Razorpay's IPO approval, and cybersecurity developments.
Key takeaways
- 1 Poverty measurement relies on household consumption expenditure surveys (HCES) rather than income, as spending is more stable and measurable than irregular earnings in rural economies.
Dakshara · 1:22
- 2 India did not conduct a 'bridge survey' to compare old and new HCES methodologies, leaving the World Bank unable to conclusively measure the distortion caused by the new sampling design.
Dakshara · 6:31
Episode sections
- 0:03 – 0:23
Intro and India Poverty Debate Overview
Host Dakshara introduces the episode's two main stories: an analysis of whether 50 crore Indians escaped poverty based on World Bank data, and a financial review of IndiGo's recent performance. The segment highlights the controversy surrounding poverty measurement methodologies and the economic pressures facing Indian airlines.
- 0:23 – 7:00
World Bank Poverty Data and Methodological Disputes
The speaker details World Bank figures showing a drop in extreme poverty from 27.1% to 2.6% between 2011-12 and 2023-24. However, economists dispute these numbers due to changes in India's Household Consumption Expenditure Survey (HCES) methodology, including a longer recall period and expanded item list, which may artificially inflate reported spending.
- 7:00 – 15:57
Poverty Line Definitions and Economic Stagnation
The discussion covers the history of India's poverty lines, noting the lack of an official government line since 2014. It contrasts the World Bank's $3 and $4.2 daily lines with higher benchmarks, highlighting that while extreme poverty may have fallen, a large portion of the population remains vulnerable near the $4.2 threshold, with stagnant real wages for farm laborers.
- 15:57 – 19:47
IndiGo Q2 Financial Performance and Cost Pressures
IndiGo reported a loss in Q2 despite raising fares by over 34% per passenger-kilometer. The loss was driven by a 67% surge in jet fuel costs to Rs 9,970 crore and rising fixed costs due to reduced flight volumes. New CEO Willie Walsh attributes fuel price spikes to refining disruptions rather than crude oil prices alone.
- 19:47 – 26:12
Regulatory Environment and Strategic Shifts at IndiGo
The segment examines the regulatory landscape, noting new aviation rules effective January 2027 that limit government intervention in pricing. IndiGo chose not to join a government fuel subsidy fund to maintain pricing freedom. Strategically, IndiGo returned leased Boeing 787s to cut costs, impacting cargo revenue, and will use Airbus A321 XLRs to retain international slots until A350s arrive in 2028.
- 26:12 – 28:00
Tidbits: Telecom Penalties, Razorpay IPO, and Cybersecurity
The episode concludes with brief news items: TRAI imposed a Rs. 89.16 lakh penalty on Vodafone Idea; Razorpay received SEBI approval for an IPO targeting a $5 billion valuation; CERT-In is testing Anthropic's Mythos model; Geo Platforms is negotiating with US cable operators; and Indus Towers aims to double its solar-equipped sites by 2028-29.
Claims worth verifying
Between 2011-12 and 2023-24, about 49.6 crore Indians crossed the poverty line and extreme poverty fell from 27.1% to 2.6% according to the World Bank's India Poverty and Equity Brief.
Dakshara ·0:43
How to verify: World Bank India Poverty and Equity Brief (latest edition); verify against World Bank's global poverty database for India-specific metrics. For recent events, verify 2026-08-05 through 2026-11-05. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The World Bank's extreme poverty line is $3 a day per person, roughly Rs. 58 a day in 2021 prices, and the lower-middle-income line is $4.2 a day, roughly Rs. 82 a day.
Dakshara ·2:23
How to verify: World Bank Poverty and Inequality Database (PID4) or World Bank's official poverty line methodology documents; cross-reference with RBI exchange rate data for 2021. For recent events, verify 2026-08-05 through 2026-11-05. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
India's share of the global prosperity gap (shortfall from $28/day) grew from 15.7% in 1990 to 18.5% in 2026, the largest of any country.
Dakshara ·4:02
How to verify: World Bank Poverty, Prosperity, and Planet Report 2026; compare with historical World Bank data on global income distribution. For recent events, verify 2026-08-05 through 2026-11-05. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
India's 2011-12 HCES used a single recall period, while the 2022-23 survey used three visits and expanded the item list from 347 to 405.
Dakshara ·5:21
How to verify: National Sample Survey Office (NSSO) methodology notes for HCES rounds 2026-12, 2026-23, and 2026-24; compare survey questionnaires. For recent events, verify 2026-08-05 through 2026-11-05. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
In 2011-12, the HCES captured about 63% of household spending recorded in GDP data, falling to 59% in 2022-23.
Dakshara ·10:18
How to verify: National Accounts Statistics (NAS) by CSO; compare Household Consumption Expenditure from HCES with GDP-based consumption estimates. For recent events, verify 2026-08-05 through 2026-11-05. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
IndiGo's fuel bill jumped about 67% to Rs 9,970 crore in Q2, while total income rose 24% to Rs 24,300 crore.
Dakshara ·17:38
How to verify: IndiGo (InterGlobe Aviation Ltd) Q2 FY2026 Financial Results filing on BSE/NSE; verify against company investor presentations. For recent events, verify 2026-08-05 through 2026-11-05. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceNew aviation rules effective January 2027 allow government intervention only in extraordinary situations and require airlines to show charges separately from taxes.
Dakshara ·20:27
How to verify: Ministry of Civil Aviation (MoCA) notification on Civil Aviation Requirements (CAR) regarding fare regulation; verify effective date and provisions. For recent events, verify 2026-08-05 through 2026-11-05. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Razorpay received SEBI approval for its IPO after confidentially filing draft papers in June, aiming to raise Rs. 5,500-6,500 crore at a $5 billion valuation.
Dakshara ·26:32
How to verify: SEBI filings on the public issue; Razorpay's Draft Red Herring Prospectus (DRHP) filed with SEBI; verify valuation claims against market reports. For recent events, verify 2026-08-05 through 2026-11-05. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceIndus Towers aims to double its solar-equipped tower sites to 100,000 by 2028-29, up from 50,000.
Dakshara ·27:31
How to verify: Indus Towers Limited annual report or press release regarding sustainability goals; verify current solar site count against company disclosures. For recent events, verify 2026-08-05 through 2026-11-05. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify the World Bank's 'Poverty and Shared Prosperity' report for the specific 2011-12 to 2023-24 poverty rate changes and methodology notes.
- Check the National Statistical Office (NSO) India's 2022-23 Household Consumption Expenditure Survey (HCES) methodology paper for details on the recall period and item list changes.
- Look for independent academic studies or reports from the Centre for Monitoring the Indian Economy (CMIE) on real wage trends for farm laborers between 2014 and 2024.
- Review IndiGo's Q2 FY2024/2025 quarterly earnings report for the exact breakdown of fuel costs (Rs 9,970 crore) and fare increases (34% per passenger-kilometer).
- Examine the DGCA's new aviation rules effective January 2027 regarding government intervention in pricing and IndiGo's public statements on the fuel subsidy fund.
- Search for TRAI's official order document confirming the Rs. 89.16 lakh penalty imposed on Vodafone Idea.
- Check SEBI's IPO approval letter for Razorpay and its prospectus for the $5 billion valuation targets.
- Verify CERT-In's announcement regarding the testing of Anthropic's Mythos model for cybersecurity applications.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:03
- Dakshara: In today's episode, we'll do one deep dive and cover another story for the day. First, we'll talk about whether 50 crore Indians really escaped poverty, and then we'll talk about Indigo finding out higher fares aren't enough. Welcome back to the Daily Brief by Zero Da, where we cut through the noise to help you understand what's actually
- 0:23
- Dakshara: happening in the most important stories from business and markets. I'm your host, Dakshara. Today is Thursday, 5th November. Coming to the first story. So last week, India got a number most governments only dream of. The World Bank's India Poverty and Equity Brief said that between 2011-12 and 2023-24, about
- 0:43
- Dakshara: 49.6 crore Indians crossed the poverty line and extreme poverty fell from 27.1% of the population. to just 2.6%. And yet, India's poverty economists have spent over two years fighting about numbers like this one. That's because nobody, including the World Bank, can say for
- 1:03
- Dakshara: sure how much of that drop is real progress and how much is a change in how India measures it. So let's build this up from scratch. When economists count the poor, they can't judge how anyone's life feels. They do arithmetic by picking a number, say rupees X a day per person, and calling it the poverty line. Anyone whose
- 1:22
- Dakshara: daily spending falls below it gets counted as poor. Now notice the word spending, not income. In a country where most people don't draw a monthly salary, income is a slippery thing. So a farmer may earn nothing for months and then everything at harvest. What are households? a household spends on food, rent, fuel, and school fees moves far
- 1:42
- Dakshara: more steadily, and people can actually tell you about it. So counting poverty takes exactly two ingredients. First, a giant survey that asks lakhs of households what they spend, and in India, that's the Household Consumption Expenditure Survey or HCES run by the Government Statistics Office. Second, a line to measure that.
- 2:03
- Dakshara: spending against, which means deciding how much a person needs to spend to not be poor. Now, this entire fight is about both of them going wobbly at the same time. So the World Bank counts poverty for every country, so it needs one yardstick for everyone. But the trouble is that a dollar buys a lot more dal in Patna than in Paris. So
- 2:23
- Dakshara: the bank converts money using purchasing power parity or PPP. an adjustment for what money actually buys in each country. And then it sets two lines that matter for India. The extreme poverty line sits at $3 a day per person, which works out to roughly Rs. 58 a day in 2021 prices. The second, meant for lower middle income countries like
- 2:43
- Dakshara: India, sits at 4.2 dollars or about Rs. 82 eighty-two a day in 2021 prices. A third line, 8.3 dollars. is the bar for upper middle-income countries, the club India hopes to join. Now the $3 line is a floor built for the world's poorest countries, which is why the bank itself considers it a poor fit for a
- 3:02
- Dakshara: middle-income country like India. So last month, the World Bank put out two documents. The first, the Poverty, Prosperity, and Planet Report 2026, is its big global report card and it reads like a warning. So about 81 crore people, which is 1 in 10, still live on under $3 a day. And this share hasn't budged since
- 3:22
- Dakshara: 2019. Now, without faster growth, it expects even more extremely poor people by 2030. And its prescription for this is jobs. More of them and better paid ones. Not a new idea, but one the world still hasn't cracked. Now the second, the India brief. reads like a victory lap. At the $4.2 dollar line,
- 3:42
- Dakshara: India's poverty rate fell from 57.7% to 16.1% between 2011-12 and 2023-24. That's where the 49.6 crore comes from. But the same global report carries a less flattering number. The bank also tracks a prosperity gap. How far people fall short of about $28 a
- 4:02
- Dakshara: day, which is roughly what a typical person earns in a country that has just turned rich. In 1990, China accounted for 37.5% of the world's total shortfall, and India for 15.7%. By 2026, China's share had shrunk to 7.9%, and India's had grown to 18.5%,
- 4:21
- Dakshara: the largest of any country. So the world seems stuck. While India is progressing, at least at the bottom. Now that contrast is why India's number deserves a closer look. So to see why that number is contested, go back to the two ingredients, because both have quietly broken since 2011. Let's start with the first: the survey.
- 4:41
- Dakshara: So India ran its consumption survey in 2011-12, withheld the 2017-18 round over data quality concerns, and didn't publish another. until the back-to-back 2022-23 and 2023-24 rounds. That left an 11-year hole in the one data set India uses to count its poor.
- 5:01
- Dakshara: Leaked findings from the withheld round suggested real spending per person had actually fallen 3.7% since 2011-12. Now, when the new survey finally arrived, it had changed a lot. In 2011-12, an interviewer visited a household once and asked about everything in a single sitting. And starting in 2022-23,
- 5:21
- Dakshara: interviewers visited three times, each time covering one category: food first, then consumables and services, then durable goods like phones and fridges. Now, the list of items they asked about grew from 347 to 405. Interviewers swapped paper for tablets. and even the way households got picked for the
- 5:41
- Dakshara: sample changed. So think about how you'd answer if someone asked you what you spent last month. Asked once in a go, you would forget things. The chai, the auto ride, the phone recharge. But asked three times, item by item from a longer list, you would remember far more, and your spending would look higher even though
- 6:01
- Dakshara: you didn't spend a rupee extra.
- 6:03
- Dakshara: Survey research has consistently found exactly this. And when reported spending goes up, measured poverty goes down.
- 6:11
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now,
- 6:11
- Dakshara: to be fair, the World Bank tried to adjust for this. Back in 2011-12, the survey had quietly run a second version of its questionnaire on a separate set of households using the same recall periods as the new survey, but it couldn't undo everything else that changed. Its own methodology note admits the new sampling design is likely to push spending
- 6:31
- Dakshara: estimates up and understate inequality. Now, the standard fix for this kind of problem is a bridge survey where you run old and new methods side by side on similar households and measure the gap. But India never ran one. Without it, the World Bank concedes there's no way to conclusively measure how much the changes distort the comparison.
- 6:51
- Dakshara: Now coming to the second ingredient: the line. So India has never found this easy, and every attempt has ended in a fight. In 1979, a planning commission task force tied the line to food, whatever it costs to buy 2,400 calories a day in villages and 2100 in cities. That held
- 7:11
- Dakshara: until Angus Deaton and Jean Drez showed that Indians. were eating fewer calories even as their real incomes rose, possibly because their work had become less physically demanding. So calories stop telling you who was poor. So in 2009, the Tendolkar Committee dropped calories altogether and built its line around a broader basket of
- 7:31
- Dakshara: spending. It put poverty in 2011 2011-12 12 at 21.9%. And then in 2011, the Planning Commission told the Supreme
- 7:38
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Court.
- 7:39
- Dakshara: that anyone spending more than 32 a day in a city or 26 a day in a village wasn't poor and the country erupted. A member of the National Advisory Council called it a starvation line. So the government handed the job to a new committee under former RBI governor C. Ranga Rangarajan, Rajan, which in 2014
- 7:59
- Dakshara: proposed roughly 47 rupees a day in cities and 32 rupees a day. in villages, counting 29.5% of Indians as poor in 2011-12. But the government never adopted it. Aniti Ayog task force tried again in 2016 and couldn't reach a consensus. So for over a decade, India has had no
- 8:19
- Dakshara: official answer to the most basic question: How much does a person need to spend to not be poor? Into that vacuum, everyone brought their own answer. Some updated the Tendulkar or Rankarajan lines for inflation, some rebuilt one from scratch, and some borrowed the world banks. A changed survey plus a choice
- 8:39
- Dakshara: of lines means widely different answers. And estimates of India's poverty in 2022-23 alone run anywhere from 2.4% to 26.4%. Same country. same year, but a tenfold gap. So which number should you believe? This argument didn't start last week. It began when the
- 8:59
- Dakshara: 2022-23 survey came out, and the new brief simply extends the same contested method to 2023-24. At its heart is one question: how much to trust the new survey? And on that, economists have split into two camps. The first camps camp says poverty has collapsed. Its most forceful voices are the
- 9:18
- Dakshara: economists Surjid Bhala and Karan Bhasin, and Bala is a veteran of the first great Indian poverty debate two decades ago. They trust the new survey as it is, and in their numbers, fewer than 1% of Indians lived below the international extreme poverty line by 2023-24. They had already declared back in 2024 that India had eliminated.
- 9:39
- Dakshara: extreme poverty. Reacting to the new data, Bhalla said that coming from the World Bank, its credibility is beyond question. So their answer to the comparability worry is also straightforward. The new survey, they argue, is simply a better survey that catches spending the old one missed, which makes it closer to the truth, not further from
- 9:58
- Dakshara: it. And they also have a neat check. India measures household spending. in two separate ways. The survey asks families what they spent, and GDP data estimates the same thing from the other end using what the economy produced and sold. The survey always comes in lower because families forget things and rich households rarely answer fully. In
- 10:18
- Dakshara: 2011-12, it captured about 63% of what GDP data recorded. So if the new questionnaire had artificially inflated spending, that share should have jumped. But instead, in 2022-23, it fell to about 59%. Measured against an independent benchmark, the new survey isn't overcounting. An
- 10:38
- Dakshara: SPI research using updated Tendulkar lines puts 2023-24 poverty under 5%. And this camp points to everything else that improved alongside free grain, electricity, toilets, bags. bank accounts. The second camp agrees poverty fell. It just doesn't believe it fell by that much, or that the World
- 10:58
- Dakshara: Bank's method can tell us. Its sharpest critiques come from Himanshu at JNU and Gaurav Dat at Monash University. Reacting to the new numbers, economist Santosh Mahrotra asked why While the government no longer sets its own poverty line or counts its own poor. Himanshu Himansho argued. argues that the World Bank made a string of changes to its method,
- 11:18
- Dakshara: some unique to India, and departed from the principles its own expert commission had laid down for measuring global poverty. That's dissection gets specific. For both years, the World Bank strips out spending on durable goods, hospital bills, and things like jewelry and furniture on the grounds that these aren't really everyday consumption. Together, they make up
- 11:38
- Dakshara: only about three. 3.5% of total spending. But richer households spend a far bigger share of their budgets on them. Remove those items, and the rich look poorer than they are. So the gap between top and bottom shrinks on paper. Dutt thinks this is why the World Bank's numbers give India a genie inequality score of around 0.25,
- 11:58
- Dakshara: which the government promptly turned into a claim that India is the world's fourth most equal. country. Now, to sidestep the new questionnaire, a Tin Belgen Institute paper predicts household spending from details captured in India's employment surveys instead. Their model puts 2022-23 poverty at roughly 18% on the $10 line,
- 12:18
- Dakshara: down from 22% in 2011-12. Poverty kept falling, but far more slowly than in the decade before. Even taking the new survey. at face value, the same researchers find that inflating the official lines put 2022-23 poverty much higher than what the World Bank suggests. So if you rebuild the Rangarajan line from scratch,
- 12:38
- Dakshara: instead of just inflating it, you land at 26.4%, or roughly one in four Indians. And then there's the jobs puzzle, which may be this cap's strongest card. The World Bank's own belief acknowledged acknowledges that real earnings stayed broadly flat and that most new jobs came in low productivity work. Economists found that
- 12:58
- Dakshara: farm laborers' real wages grew just 0.8% a year over the past decade, which they called virtual stagnation. Cores of workers moved back into farming, which is the opposite of what usually happens as the country gets richer. And much of the rise in women's employment came through unpaid work. on family farms and in family businesses. Now
- 13:18
- Dakshara: we've covered before why India's job market is broken. If wages stagnated and workers retreated to the farm, what drove a historic leap in spending? Part of the answer is welfare itself. Free rations and subsidies count as spending in the survey, valued at what they would have cost, and they free up cash for families to spend on other
- 13:37
- Dakshara: things. Almost nobody is arguing that India got poorer, but the real argument boils down to three narrower questions. The first is size. Did extreme poverty shrink from 1 in 4 Indi
- 13:50
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
- 13:50
- Dakshara: 1 in 40, or did poverty fall from about 1 in 5 to somewhere between 1 in 10 and 1 in 6? Both describe progress, but very different countries. The second is speed. and this is where the politics lives. Even on the bank's numbers, about 23 crore Indians still live below $4.2 a day.
- 14:10
- Dakshara: And as one editorial asked this week, if 49.6 crore people escaped poverty, why does the government still hand free grain to over 80 crore? Raise the bar to $8.3 and the picture flips. By the World Bank's 2024 estimates, 79% of Indians fall below it, and India is
- 14:30
- Dakshara: home to 30% of everyone on the planet below that line, against just 4% of those below $3. Compare it with its peers, and the same flip shows up. India beats Bangladesh and Indonesia at the bottom with 2.3% below $3 to their roughly 5%, but trails them at the top, where they sit near
- 14:50
- Dakshara: 68%.
- 14:51
- Dakshara: Vietnam at just 18% is in another league. So most Indians, in other words, live just above the floor. In a simple test on the World Bank's data, cutting everyone's spending by 10%, which is the kind of hit a bad harvest or an illness can deliver, pushes the share below $4.2 from about 15% to
- 15:11
- Dakshara: 23% and nearly doubles the share below $3.2%. $3.
- 15:15
- Dakshara: On the bar itself, the camps quietly agree. Bala and Basin, the loudest voice declaring extreme poverty over, argue that a sensible new Indian poverty line would count somewhere between 25% and 33% of the population as poor. So here's the bottom line. The way out isn't mysterious. India just
- 15:35
- Dakshara: needs a bridge survey to measure how much the new questionnaire in inflates spending and a fresh committee to draw an official poverty line for the country India has become. Until it does both, every new report will reopen the same fight, just with fresher numbers.
- 15:57
- Dakshara: Coming to the second story.
- 15:59
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): In
- 15:59
- Dakshara: the second quarter of this financial year, Indigo charged its passengers a lot more than it did a year ago. You would expect this to improve profits, but instead, the airline ended the quarter with a loss. And once you look past some accounting effects, the business is doing worse than it was a year ago. This was also Willie Walsh's first quarter as
- 16:19
- Dakshara: Indigo's chief executive. So Walsh earlier ran British Airways, and his first earnings call as part of Indigo has not been short of. changes. With that, let's dive into the Q2 earnings of Indigo. So, Indigo went into July with a problem. Jet fuel had become far more expensive, and July to September is a quiet time for
- 16:39
- Dakshara: travel in India. When fewer people are traveling and fuel is costly, every extra flight burns money without filling up. So Indigo cut back on variable costs. It kept its domestic freedom. flying at last year's level and trimmed international flying by about 3%. Other airlines did the same, and the number of seats on offer across the
- 16:59
- Dakshara: industry fell about 5%. So with fewer seats to go around, every airline could charge more. Indigo earned over 34% more from each passenger for every kilometer flown, partly through fuel surcharges. But some travelers walked away and Indigo filled about two percentage points fewer of its seats. So once
- 17:19
- Dakshara: you count the empty seats too, revenue per seat rose a little less by 31%. Impressively, that still beat Indigo's own forecast of the same metric of over 25%. Unfortunately, though, this revenue growth wasn't even close to matching the rise in jet fuel costs. So Indigo's fuel bill jumped about
- 17:38
- Dakshara: 67% to about Rs 9,970 crore, while Indigo's total income only rose by 24% to approximately Rs 24,300 crore. So jet fuel prices have risen far faster than that of crude oil, which trades at around 110 to 115 dollars, which is roughly Rs 10,500
- 17:58
- Dakshara: to 11,000 a barrel. But Walsh's justification for it? confirmed what we saw in our own recent oil roundup. The gap came from refining.
- 18:08
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now,
- 18:08
- Dakshara: normally, jet fuel costs a little over 20% more than the crude oil it's made from, which is the refiner's margin. But this year, Walsh expects that gap to spike because some refineries have been disrupted. This quarter it also spent nearly Rs. 3,600 crore on aircraft upkeep, approximately. Rs. 3,100 crore on the
- 18:28
- Dakshara: wear and tear of its planes, nearly Rs 2,300 crore on staff, and approximately Rs. 1,700 crore on airport charges. Spread across every seat it flew, these non-fuel costs came to Rs. 3.45 per seat per kilometer, up about 15% to Rs. 3.01 last year. Now
- 18:48
- Dakshara: part of that rise came from a weaker rupee and an airline's maintenance and rent bills are paid in dollars. Suppliers also raised their prices by the usual few percent a year. But the main reason the jump was so sharp this quarter was the same capacity cuts that helped cut indigo's variable costs. After all, many of an airline's
- 19:08
- Dakshara: costs are fixed. Salaries and rent won't change no matter whether the plane flies five trips a day or four. Fewer trips increase the fixed component of what it costs to service a seat. Now it's also very reasonable to believe that Indigo was aware of this trade-off, which should only tell you that this was no easy decision to make in the face of a
- 19:27
- Dakshara: crisis. Now, all of this added up to a loss of about Rs 1880 crore. That's smaller than the loss of the same quarter last year, but only because last year's loss was switched. swollen by currency swings. Set those aside, and indigo went from a profit in Q2 of last year to a loss of about 700 crore
- 19:47
- Dakshara: this time. Now, with costs being this high, raising fares has been Indigo's main way to protect itself. But fares have become a sore point across the country. Fares across Indian Airlines spiked ahead of Diwali, with some routes costing several times their. usual price. Now, a plea in the Supreme Court claimed fares had risen by up to
- 20:07
- Dakshara: 700%. But the court declined to hear it urgently, suggesting the petitioner could simply choose not to fly. Earlier this year, the same court had called festive fare hikes exploitation and pushed the government to act. That push led to new aviation rules effective from January 2027. So they let the government step in. only in an
- 20:27
- Dakshara: extraordinary situation for a limited time and make airlines show their own charges separately from government taxes. So, in a way, they're softer than the old rules, which let the regulator act directly against excessive pricing. Now, Walsh made it clear Indigo won't give up pricing freedom easily. When asked about the government's plans to curb fare surges,
- 20:47
- Dakshara: he said he didn't expect them to affect Indigo. In fact, between April and June 8th, the government capped domestic jet fuel prices at 25% above March levels. When the cap ended, it set up a Rs. 10,000 crore fund to help state run oil companies sell jet fuel to airlines at fixed prices. And the catch was that
- 21:07
- Dakshara: airlines joining it had to buy their fuel only from those companies for up to three years. Indigo chose to stay out and pay more. market prices. And this ties down to its unwillingness to give up pricing power. Now, Walsh did praise the fund as an innovative idea, but expressed doubts about its terms. Now, Indigo doesn't think today's
- 21:27
- Dakshara: fares can last. In Walsh's long international experience, airlines can't hold on to high prices once fuel gets cheaper. And the boomerang will certainly swing back the other way if fuel prices come. down. Now, Indigo isn't just merely pursuing an expansion of the seat fare, it's also trying to create new offerings to create more growth.
- 21:47
- Dakshara: And one such avenue is its premium stretch seats, which offer more room at a higher price. Stretch made only a small difference this quarter, but Walsh expects it to grow. A second offering is extras such as seat selection and meals. Indigo earned about Rs. 590 per passenger from these in the quarter, up from about Rs.
- 22:06
- Dakshara: 525. And Walsh compared this with Ryanair, Europe's biggest budget airline, which earns 5 to 6 times as much per passenger. Now the third is Indigo's Blue Chip Loyalty Program, which is nearing 20 million members. So Walsh wants to run it like Avios, the points program of the parent company of British Airways.
- 22:26
- Dakshara: In his experience, active members spent several times more than casual flyers, and he sounded very positive about this opportunity. Now, while fares can't stay high forever, Indigo had to find a spot where they could cut some expenses. And we know that fixed costs remain the chink in the armor. But that's also where the quarter's biggest strategic
- 22:46
- Dakshara: call comes in. Starting November 1st, Indigo stopped flying the Boeing 7. 787s it had been leasing from North Atlantic. And these are the large two-ale jets that had been flying to Amsterdam, London, and Copenhagen. Indigo had rented the plane along with part of the crew. Now, this was a quick way to launch long-distance routes while Indigo waited for its own
- 23:06
- Dakshara: white-body jets or A350, which are due to arrive only in 2028. So Indigo always saw this as temporary. In the previous quarter, itself, Indigo had already returned 13 such aircraft, and on top of the rent, big jets also burn a lot of fuel compared to smaller ones. And Walsh called ending the lease an easy
- 23:26
- Dakshara: decision. But there is one downside to this move. Passenger planes also carry cargo in the hold below the cabin, and a big jet like the 787 has far more room than Indigo's smaller planes. Cargo has been a brand bright spot on Indigo's business, with revenue up 37% year-on-year this quarter. Without the 787s, Indigo
- 23:46
- Dakshara: will carry less cargo on long routes, though Walsh said the wider cargo trend still looks good. Now for its international flights, Indigo will lean on the Airbus A321 XLR, a single-isle plane that's much smaller than a Boeing 787, but built to fly unusually far. The XLR's job is to protect something valuable. At busy
- 24:05
- Dakshara: airports like Amsterdam, airlines get fixed time windows to take off and land called slots. So an airline that stops using its slot can lose it to arrival, and getting it back isn't easy. So Indigo is flying the XLR to Amsterdam to keep its slot until the A350s arrive. Now Walsh insists this isn't a retreat. He sees
- 24:25
- Dakshara: India's international market. as vastly underserved. But he also knows how airlines have stumbled at this before. Many big airlines often design their short domestic flights around feeding passengers into their long international ones. But that hurts the timings of the domestic flights. And Walsh said Indigo won't make that trade because its cheap
- 24:45
- Dakshara: domestic network is what gives it an edge. For now though, international flying has taken a strategic. backseat. In the October-December quarter, Indigo plans to fly only about 3% more than a year ago. Walsh said that holding back will fall more on international routes than domestic ones because the festive season makes this the busiest time for
- 25:05
- Dakshara: travel within India. So whether it's fares, costs, or On new sources of income, the first real test of Walsh's plan comes in the October October-December December quarter. with Diwali and the winter holidays. Indigo expects to fly a few percent more than a year ago, earn over 25% more per seat, and fill about the same share of seats
- 25:25
- Dakshara: as last year. That forecast leans heavily on festive pricing. At the very moment, cohorts and the government are watching fares most closely. But for the full year, Indigo expects non-fuel costs per seat to rise by high single. digits to low double digits. And it's kept its target of mid-teens growth in flying next year, and Walsh said
- 25:45
- Dakshara: he still sees the airline's long-term goals as achievable. But fuel remains the big unknown, and Walsh didn't pretend otherwise. So Indigo holds about Rs. 39,900 crore in cash it can freely use. But in the airline business, where margins come hard fought, even with without a crippling oil crisis,
- 26:05
- Dakshara: no amount of cash is ever enough.
- 26:11
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now
- 26:12
- Dakshara: coming to the tidbits. One, TRIE has imposed a Rs. 89.16 lakh penalty on vodaphone idea for alleged violations of rules governing unsolicited commercial communications for the quarter ended December 2024. The telecom operator said its reviewing the order, which marks its second try penalty in two months. FinTech Unicorn
- 26:32
- Dakshara: Razor Bay has reportedly received approval from the Securities and Exchange Board of India for its initial public offering after confidentially filing draft papers in June. The Bengaluru-based payment gateway is aiming to raise between Rs. 5,500 500 crore and Rs. 6,500 crore at an expected valuation of $5 billion. 3.
- 26:51
- Dakshara: CERTIN has gained access to Anthropics Mythos model through Amazon Bedrock and will begin testing its cybersecurity capabilities in a cautious paced manner. The agency plans to assess how the model can help identify vulnerabilities while limiting exposure of sensitive government systems and code. 4. Geo Platforms is reportedly negotiating with US cable
- 27:11
- Dakshara: operators Comcast and Character Communications to license. its unlicensed band wireless broadband technology in exchange for equity stakes. The strategy aims to leverage GEO's intellectual property for global expansion following the breakdown of similar docs with South Africa's MTN Group overvaluation. 5. Indus Towers aims to double its solar footprint,
- 27:31
- Dakshara: targeting 100,000 solar-equipped Solar equipped tower sites by the 2028-29 financial year. The planned expansion from its current 50,000 solar equipped sites is part of the telecom infrastructure provider's broader effort to reduce operating costs and cut diesel consumption. That's all the news I have for you. Thank you so much for watching and see you in the next
- 27:51
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): one.
More from The Daily Brief
Coal India’s largest subsidiary goes public
Episode discussion: Coal India subsidiary MCL IPO details, regulatory risks, and Indian wire market dynamics discussed
Speakers’ claims: Speakers analyze the upcoming IPO of Mahanadi Coalfields Limited (MCL), noting it is an offer-for-sale transaction where proceeds go to parent Coal India rather than MCL itself. They highlight MCL's operational efficiency and low costs but warn of lower coal quality and significant regulatory risks, including a potential 31,000 crore rupee tax liability in Odisha. The discussion also covers the Indian wire market, where new entrants like Ultratech Cement are challenging incumbents like Polycab and Havells. Incumbents are responding by shifting focus to high-voltage cables and exports to mitigate competition in the wire segment.
India’s food inflation story gets worrisome
Episode discussion: India's food inflation rises to 7.7% amid weak monsoon and El Niño, pressuring rural economy
Speakers’ claims: The speaker reports that India's retail food inflation jumped to 7.7% in September 2026, driven by sharp increases in vegetable, pulse, and cooking oil prices, despite headline inflation remaining within the RBI's target band. This rise is attributed to a weak monsoon, El Niño effects, and soaring global energy and fertilizer costs, which threaten both summer and winter crop yields. The episode highlights that rural inflation crossed 6% for the first time in the financial year, while national combined inflation stood at 5.5%. In the pharma sector, strong sales growth is offset by declining profits due to acquisition costs, pre-launch spending, and regulatory pressures. The segment concludes with updates on a 62,370 crore rupee fertilizer subsidy, RBI transfer rules, and Adani Group investments.