The Coal Trader

Coal traders analyze seasonal price dips, Q3 earnings misses, and valuation opportunities in thermal and metallurgical coal equities

55 min Listen to the original Episode page
Thermal CoalMetallurgical CoalCoal EquitiesGeopoliticsEuropean GasEarnings AnalysisValuationSeasonal Trends

Summary

Hosts Joe Aldina and Matt Warder discuss the recent pullback in thermal coal prices, attributing it to easing geopolitical risk premiums and lower European gas prices rather than a structural bear market. They highlight that supply constraints from Indonesian river levels and tight European gas storage keep the market fundamentally tight. On the equity side, Warder notes divergent performance among U.S. producers, with Alliance Resources and NRG outperforming while Peabody and Core Natural Resources declined post-earnings due to cost inflation and operational issues. The analysts identify Australian miners like Whitehaven and Ramic as attractive accumulation zones ahead of seasonal restocking. Finally, they argue that current EV/EBITDA multiples of 2x-4x represent historically cheap valuations compared to cycle peaks.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    just total coal imports were down to 39.4 uh million metric tons, you know, 9% off of September levels.

    Joe Aldina · 5:03

Episode sections

  1. 0:46 – 1:27

    Thermal Coal Market Overview

    Hosts discuss the recent pullback in thermal coal prices as a normal seasonal occurrence during the October-November shoulder season rather than a structural bear market. They note that while prices have dipped slightly from recent highs, they remain elevated due to geopolitical factors and tight supply.

  2. 1:27 – 13:05

    Geopolitical and Supply Fundamentals

    Joe Aldina attributes the price decline to easing geopolitical risk premiums and lower European gas prices, while highlighting ongoing constraints from Indonesian river levels and Indian demand dynamics. He emphasizes that despite short-term softness, the market remains tight with limited downside risk.

  3. 13:05 – 15:41

    Metallurgical Coal Technical Analysis

    Matt Warder analyzes the PLV metallurgical coal curve, noting it has flattened and is approaching technical support levels around $240-$250/ton. He suggests the market is range-bound with a potential bottom near $220, expecting restocking to drive prices higher in late December.

  4. 15:41 – 23:29

    European Gas and Geopolitical Risk

    The hosts discuss European gas storage levels at 72% and the impact of reduced flows from Russia and potential disruptions in the Strait of Hormuz. They argue that these factors keep gas prices elevated, which supports thermal coal demand and limits downside in coal prices.

  5. 23:29 – 29:49

    U.S. Equity Performance: AMR, BTU, CNR, NRP

    Matt Warder highlights divergent performance among U.S. coal stocks, noting that Alliance Resources (AMR) and NRG (NRP) have outperformed due to strong earnings and royalty diversification, while Peabody (BTU) and Core Natural Resources (CNR) faced steeper declines post-earnings.

  6. 29:49 – 33:45

    Australian Equity Opportunities

    The hosts identify Australian miners like Whitehaven (WHC) and Ramic (METC) as attractive accumulation zones, arguing their recent sell-offs are driven by broader market momentum rather than fundamental deterioration. They view current price levels as opportunities ahead of the seasonal restocking cycle.

  7. 33:45 – 36:18

    Technical Analysis of US Coal Equities

    Matt Warder discusses selling calls on AMR after a 60% gain and analyzes technical indicators for Warrior Met Coal (HCC) and Core Natural Resources (CNR), noting RSI lows and moving average crossovers as buy signals.

  8. 36:18 – 38:57

    BTU Steel and Centurion Mine Ramp-Up

    Warder details the price decline of BTU due to slow production ramp-up at the Centurion mine, describing it as a buying opportunity for patient investors despite negative technical trends like a low Hearst exponent.

  9. 38:57 – 40:53

    Australian Coal Stocks: Whitehaven and Yancoal

    The hosts review Whitehaven Coal (WHC) and Yancoal (YAL), noting WHC's post-distribution consolidation and YAL's potential upside from the Kestrel acquisition and tight Indonesian supply.

  10. 40:53 – 43:14

    Thungella Coal and Seasonal Positioning

    Warder identifies Thungella (TGA) as a high-beta thermal coal play, suggesting re-entry after a 30% drop, while emphasizing that October and November are typically favorable seasonal periods for coal equities.

  11. 43:14 – 46:24

    Q3 Earnings Cost Inflation Analysis

    Warder breaks down Q3 earnings, highlighting that while revenue estimates were accurate, all major US producers (ARLP, CNR, BTU, HCC) missed on costs due to fuel surcharges and geological issues.

  12. 46:24 – 48:52

    Sticky Inflation and Global Cost Curve Shift

    The hosts discuss whether cost inflation is a temporary supply shock or a permanent baseline shift, with Warder arguing that global commodity inflation has raised the entire cost curve by approximately 4%.

  13. 48:52 – 51:15

    Valuation Metrics and Buying Opportunities

    Warder ranks miners by EV/EBITDA, noting that most are trading in the 2x-4x range, which he considers attractive buying territory compared to cycle peaks of 7x-9x, particularly for BTU despite Centurion issues.

  14. 51:15 – 54:48

    Market Outlook and Podcast Wrap

    Warder concludes that coal equities are undervalued and poised to rise, comparing the current setup to 2021-2022, while promoting upcoming tools and corporate services on The Coal Trader website.

Claims worth verifying

Newcastle thermal coal is down about one percent over the past week, while API 2 is down about two percent, yet both remain up more than ten percent from the prior quarter.

Matt Warder ·1:06

How to verify: Check Bloomberg or Reuters terminal for Newcastle API 2 and Newcastle Thermal Coal spot prices for the week ending 2026-11-13 and compare to Q3 2026 closing prices. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

European coal burn has increased by approximately twenty percent year-over-year in the last month.

Joe Aldina ·4:34

How to verify: Review European power generation data from Ember, Eurostat, or national grid operators for October/November 2026 coal-fired generation volumes compared to 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

China's total coal imports fell to 39.4 million metric tons in October, a 9% decrease from September levels.

Joe Aldina ·5:03

How to verify: Consult China Customs Administration monthly import data or GACM (General Administration of Customs) reports for October 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Indonesian sellers are asking Chinese buyers to accept new force majeure clauses related to government export limits.

Joe Aldina ·5:54

How to verify: Search Bloomberg News or Reuters archives for reports on Indonesian coal contract terms and force majeure clauses in October/November 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

PLV metallurgical coal is trading near the $240/ton level, which represents a 38.2% Fibonacci retracement from recent troughs to peaks.

Matt Warder ·13:59

How to verify: Calculate Fibonacci retracement levels using PLV coal price data from Argus or Platts for the period from mid-2026 trough to late 2026 peak. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

European gas storage is at 72% capacity.

Joe Aldina ·17:55

How to verify: Check Gas Infrastructure Europe (GIE) daily storage reports for the week ending 2026-11-13. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Alliance Resources (AMR) stock declined 14% over a one-month period.

Matt Warder ·24:02

How to verify: Calculate the percentage change in AMR closing price from 2026-10-13 to 2026-11-13 using Yahoo Finance or SEC filings. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Peabody Energy (BTU) stock declined 32% after its earnings call.

Matt Warder ·24:06

How to verify: Check BTU stock price movement on the day following its Q3 2026 earnings release (typically late October/early November) via SEC 8-K filings or financial news. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Whitehaven Coal (WHC) stock declined 6.5% over the month.

Matt Warder ·30:23

How to verify: Calculate the percentage change in WHC.AX closing price from 2026-10-13 to 2026-11-13 using ASX data or financial terminals. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Ramico (METC) stock declined 15% over the month.

Matt Warder ·24:06

How to verify: Calculate the percentage change in METC.AX closing price from 2026-10-13 to 2026-11-13 using ASX data or financial terminals. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Matt Warder bought calls on AMR when the stock bottomed and sold them for a 60% gain.

Matt Warder ·33:50

How to verify: Check SEC Form 4 filings for Matt Warder or his fund's 13F filings for AMR option transactions around the time of the podcast release (Nov 2026) or prior quarters. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Core Natural Resources (CNR) stock sold down into the low 70s, representing a four standard deviation move lower.

Matt Warder ·34:30

How to verify: Review CNR stock price history on Yahoo Finance or Bloomberg for the period leading up to Nov 2026 to identify the low price and calculate standard deviations from the moving average. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

BTU missed revenue estimates by about 7% and EBITDA estimates by 11% due to low Centurion production.

Matt Warder ·44:34

How to verify: Compare BTU's Q3 2026 actual earnings report (SEC 10-Q or press release) against consensus estimates from FactSet or Bloomberg available prior to the report. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

ARLP beat on cost, EBITDA, and EPS, with stock moving from $23 to $25.

Matt Warder ·43:59

How to verify: Review ARLP's Q3 2026 earnings release and compare reported EBITDA/EPS to consensus estimates; check stock price movement during the earnings period. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

CNR costs came in at $92, versus an expected $86-$87.

Matt Warder ·45:44

How to verify: Check CNR's Q3 2026 earnings call transcript or 10-K/10-Q filing for detailed cost breakdowns and compare to pre-earnings analyst consensus. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

BTU's C-Born Met costs came in at $162, versus an expected $137.

Matt Warder ·45:44

How to verify: Review BTU's Q3 2026 earnings report for specific cost metrics related to the Central Appalachia (C-Born) segment. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Warrior Met Coal (HCC) costs came in at $105, versus an expected $95.

Matt Warder ·45:44

How to verify: Check HCC's Q3 2026 earnings release for cost per ton metrics and compare to pre-earnings estimates. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Thungella (TGA) stock was down 30% from its peak.

Joe Aldina ·42:43

How to verify: Calculate the percentage decline of TGA stock price from its recent high to the price at the time of the podcast (Nov 2026) using historical price data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Global cost curve for metallurgical and thermal coal has gone up by about 4% over the past year.

Matt Warder ·47:23

How to verify: Compare average production costs reported by major coal miners in Q3 2026 filings against Q3 2026 filings to calculate the year-over-year change. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

EV/EBITDA multiples for coal miners are currently in the 2x-4x range, compared to cycle peaks of 7x-9x.

Matt Warder ·49:59

How to verify: Calculate EV/EBITDA for major coal equities (BTU, CNR, HCC, etc.) using current market cap/debt data and trailing/forward EBITDA from financial databases like Bloomberg or FactSet. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify European gas storage levels and Russian flow data via Eurostat or GIE public dashboards.
  • Check Indonesian river levels in Kalimantan and export volumes via Indonesian Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources reports.
  • Review Q3 10-Q filings for BTU, CNR, ARLP, and HCC to confirm cost inflation drivers and Centurion mine production metrics.
  • Analyze PLV metallurgical coal forward curves on Argus or Platts to validate technical support levels.
  • Compare current EV/EBITDA multiples for major coal miners against historical cycle data from S&P Capital IQ or Bloomberg.
  • Assess Chinese coal import data for October via China Customs or National Bureau of Statistics.
  • Monitor European coal burn rates via European Commission or industry associations like EUREC.
  • Check technical indicators (RSI, Hurst exponent) for specific tickers using financial data platforms like Bloomberg or Refinitiv.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): This is the Cold Trader Podcast on the Clear Commodity Network, your source for trading and investing in the coal market.
0:07
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hey,
0:07
Matt Warder: Cold Traders. Welcome to episode 27 of the Cold Trader Podcast. As per usual, I'm your host, Matt Warder, and joining me is my partner in Cold, Joe Aldina. Joe, how you doing, buddy?
0:17
Joe Aldina: Hey Matt. Um doing well. Uh doing doing well. Busy,
0:22
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
0:22
Joe Aldina: busy is good. Um, I and uh,
0:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
0:26
Joe Aldina: know, I think the coal markets are still pretty good. We we've had some price um a little little little bit of uh fall off in prices here, uh, but not not not too bad. Um so I was gonna I was gonna go ahead and give the uh the rundown on thermal coal um and then let you handle handle Met. Sounds sounds
0:46
Joe Aldina: good?
0:46
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
0:46
Matt Warder: that sounds fine. I mean we got uh we we're coming into the part of shoulder season where we generally start to see some decline. So this is a good point to um uh to actually go through and look. Um, I think the last time we talked about how October and November, not such a great time for stocks, too. And uh that's that's played out as well. We'll get into that in a minute. But um yeah, let me pull up the thermal
1:06
Matt Warder: coal prices. Uh here over the past week, Newcastle coal's down about one percent, API two down about uh two percent as well. Richards Bay kinda holding in there, uh a little bit weaker down further on the curve, but by and large, still up uh ten percent plus from where we were just a quarter ago, Joe. What's uh what's happening in the thermal
1:26
Matt Warder: coal markets?
1:27
Joe Aldina: Yeah, I mean I I think um we had strength all the way through October and and we're talking about just prices coming off in the last couple of weeks, but uh you know, people worry about these things. I gotta got a text message this morning from a good friend of mine who who um he runs some money and he he's got some coal equities and he's like, well, you know, what's
1:47
Joe Aldina: going on with prices? Um and I'm here to say, you know, don't don't worry. Um
1:54
Joe Aldina: I I think the big thing is that we had a lot of geopolitical risk in in prices with with high gas pricing. and you know we've got a a little less geopolitical risk it's not quite as combustible a situation and that's that's how these things happen you know they the prices get bid up and then they come
2:14
Joe Aldina: off um uh in the last couple weeks uh they they came off fairly fairly quickly but not uh not by a ton. I mean we lost a few bucks uh on Newcastle maybe ten bucks in Newcastle a handful of of dollars off the API two on lower oil and gas, right? Um,
2:34
Joe Aldina: you know, the the the TTF price um uh has come off a little bit. And so I think I think there's a there's a few fundamental things in the thermal markets I want to talk about, but I I think it's it's um less expensive gas, a little bit less. Middle East geopolitical risk. Um, but we
2:54
Joe Aldina: but we have still have Indonesian supply risk. Um we still have issues in India, um, although they're not as severe in terms of uh demand. Um uh and uh the ARB is open into China. So uh and we've got had cost inflation. I know you want to talk about that a little bit. So
3:14
Joe Aldina: so look. I mean, could prices come off a little bit with uh with warm weather? Uh maybe, but this is not a bearish market um by by any any stretch of the imagination.
3:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right.
3:26
Matt Warder: I went ahead and pulled up the chart as well. Uh this is the pullback that we've had basically coming down from $160 to a little bit below 140. But when you you see on the zoom out, we're still moving up and to the right at a pretty steady clip. and this movement right here you know if you go back and look at September to December this is seasonally normal uh to see prices decline
3:46
Matt Warder: during this period so they were elevated uh as a result of whoremes and now they're coming off with the season as it's probably normally going to do we should see a turn just from a seasonal perspective in late December mid-December uh something like that so I expect this to be a lower uh the uh uh a higher low rather uh
4:06
Matt Warder: and pushing off into the beginning of the year because we really don't see any uh end to uh the Hormoes conflict in site as of yet, right?
4:14
Joe Aldina: No. Um you know I think volumes the the gas volumes are improving um but there's still about 50% of normal flows for for cutter uh energy anyway. And uh yeah so so that so that's that keeping um coal burn tight. Um in in Europe um uh for sure uh coal
4:34
Joe Aldina: burn has been uh has been very strong. I mean we're talking up in the in the neighborhood of twenty percent year over year in the last month or so. Um
4:45
Joe Aldina: you know Colombia's been uh supplying that market um I had uh had planned to mention that a little bit later, but uh kind of just the uh the big things, you know. I always look at China and India. Um China had lower imports in in October.
5:01
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um uh
5:03
Joe Aldina: just total coal imports were down to 39.4 uh million metric tons, you know, 9% off of September levels. And I just think there's a little more uh um
5:16
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
5:17
Joe Aldina: positive uh feeling that um output in China can rebound um after the Shaanxi mine disaster. Um there's uh you know stockpiles are relatively comfortable um and um
5:34
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
5:34
Joe Aldina: and so that's re- reduced some urgency and prices were high, right? So you have buyers just sort of stepping back. Um and um but but Chinese prices remain pretty high. Uh the ARB is open. Um and and then there's the Indonesian issue. Um Bloomberg was reporting this week that Indonesia
5:54
Joe Aldina: uh Indonesian sellers are asking Chinese buyers to accept these new force majeure clauses around what happens if the government steps in and limits um limits exports, limits supply. So I think that tells you that both sides are a little bit worried about that. And I think I
6:14
Joe Aldina: think Indonesia and particularly the mid and high C V coal supply um has been um uh has been restrained by the low uh low uh water levels, low river uh levels in Kalimantan and uh and and so it's it's keeping uh keeping a lid
6:34
Joe Aldina: on the the high C V exports and Australia should be able to keep um step in and you know for those for those of you trading the stocks um uh you know uh I I uh I I I think that Australia benefits here from uh Indonesian supply issues particularly on the mid
6:54
Joe Aldina: and C V uh mid and high C V level. So some something to think about.
7:00
Joe Aldina: India, you know what's going on in India, we had imports uh strengthening uh in October, but I I think uh spot buying has I I know spot buying has cooled and I think the reason uh is just high price prices
7:17
Joe Aldina: and uh you know a little bit more positivity about domestic supply. Um we've been telling this story for a while. It was really rail issues. The pit head or mine level stocks were high, the power plant stocks still look very low. Um India had said, you know, boost imports as much as you can, and
7:36
Joe Aldina: now the the government is kind of walking back. on that a little bit. But in India's your most price sensitive um buyer that reacts uh pretty quickly. So um
7:48
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
7:48
Joe Aldina: know, nothing nothing that we haven't really expected uh there. Um you know, Australia supplies can pretty healthy, I would say. Um but uh uh high C V coal is always um uh the there's not a lot of spare capacity for that. So um but but with
8:07
Joe Aldina: Indonesia down, I think um I think Australia should step in. And we don't have the latest data from Australia, but uh exports are up in September
8:19
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
8:20
Joe Aldina: and uh exports to China in particular. So I think Australia is stepping in there and will be continue to be responsive on the supply side. And that's um,
8:31
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
8:32
Joe Aldina: that's a trend I would I would continue to look for in the in the equities. Um so the market, you know, is is supply tight. I mean, it is in pockets. Um, there's a little less geopolitical energy premium. Um, there's kind of hesitant Asian buyers here. We also had had DeWa. Diwali in
8:51
Joe Aldina: India. Um, you know, so uh I think weather now continues to to drive things. Um and uh but but I don't think prices fall off a cliff here. I think margins are fairly healthy and you know the top tier producers in Australia, but um you know the market the
9:11
Joe Aldina: market's not suddenly uh loosening and it's gonna is gonna gonna um have a lot of downside here. Um and then, you know, it's winter, so let's see what the weather does. Um, let's see what Indonesian supply does. I mean, the the supply has been constrained. I think it's running around seven hundred million um in exports for
9:31
Joe Aldina: the year. The government, of course, said they would like to limit it to six twenty. That's a good uh uh that's a good indication of how uh um how much uh credence you have to give to Indonesian government orders. Um but you know, it's it's still an issue because uh it's a contracting issue between the Chinese and the Indonesians and that wouldn't be hitting the news uh
9:51
Joe Aldina: on Bloomberg if if it weren't something that folks were worried about. So um you know, uh
9:59
Joe Aldina: downside should be modest if we have a warm winter and and then you know the the market is still fairly tight if we have higher demand this winter. So that's my that's my analysis. I'm I'm sticking to it. I think we've been been right on um
10:15
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
10:15
Joe Aldina: we kinda kinda said uh you know, I th I remember when I was about to head off to Gaz Tech in uh early September, we were talking about like, yeah, okay, you know, prices are are strong. here. What happens if you have the Super El Nino? And we had said um, you know, look, prices are going to be high through October,
10:35
Joe Aldina: uh, and then and then let's see what happens. Um and and I think uh I think we're in a good place here, but let's see what the what happens with winter winter weather and and you know limited downside. That's my call.
10:49
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yep, Yeah.
10:49
Matt Warder: no, it I think it makes sense And just to back you up, I'm going to pull up our thermal coal intelligence data tool
10:56
Matt Warder: here. Uh on the on the thermal coal intelligence tool, we have each port at uh in Indonesia, we're monitoring uh both the output levels and the water levels in the rivers. Uh and we have a weather forecast that's pulled in by uh from from local sources that is forecasting water levels going forward. And for the most part uh when we
11:16
Matt Warder: run down each of the ports, they've kind of gone according to where the forecast has expected them to be. If we look at Burrito, which is one of the more important ports, I think we mentioned on a previous podcast that it would start moving back up in November. It's already done that. Water levels are getting better there materially.
11:35
Matt Warder: Overall you mentioned how much total coal has been disrupted. It's about 16 million tons at the moment. There's probably about 3 million tons to come. But really, once we get into December proper, we should see those water levels start to normalize across the rest of the basin. And you mentioned stockpiles in India. There have been a number
11:55
Matt Warder: of headlines coming out in Bloomberg. I've seen them on Twitter talking about how low thermal coal stockpiles actually were at. Indone uh Indian power stations. Uh, but we've actually seen here over the past couple of days that that started to tick up. So there is some buying that's already happening uh in India. Uh monsoon season is completely over. So
12:15
Matt Warder: we would expect these numbers to start to to to come up. And although there will be softness in prices, I think for the next um for the next month or so, by and large, uh I I think. you're right. I think we're kind of range bound for a bit. If TTF and JKM continue to correct seasonally, that's a little bit further downside for thermal coal.
12:35
Matt Warder: But by and large, what you see, I think, is what you get in terms of pricing for the moment.
12:40
Joe Aldina: Yeah, I mean, I'd be hard uh I'd I'd be hard hard pressed uh to uh see anything like uh a ten 10% percent or more correction, you know, maybe ten percent. 10%, but beyond beyond that, uh
12:54
Joe Aldina: I I just think the the market's tighter than that. Um and and we're not gonna see it. Um so even if we have mild weather, you know, 10% 10% correction.
13:05
Matt Warder: Okay, for sure. Um I'll jump into the Met side here. I'll share the the current prices. There's really hasn't been a lot happening on the Met side in terms of price globally, at least for PLV. Prices have mostly hung in there over the past week. We're up a little bit on the front month, down a little bit on the forward curve. The
13:25
Matt Warder: curve has flattened. It's gone from about the $20 gap between $20 backwardation between the front month and uh one year, two years out. And now we're more in this like $17, $16, $15 range.
13:39
Matt Warder: which I think is probably indicative that we are approaching uh floor. When we look at the curve as it stands at the moment, I highlighted last time just the Fibonacci retracement from market troughs last year to recent market peaks. And the two uh levels that we called out were Where this $250 level, which we're still
13:59
Matt Warder: above on the front month, uh, and this two $240.
14:03
Matt Warder: level, uh 38.2% retracement, which the forward curve already kind of signaled, is going to be potentially a short-term bottom. And going back to the the to draw attention to the Dalian, the Chinese domestic prices, they've been falling as Shaanxi begins to restart operations. We do think there's going to be some more supply that comes
14:23
Matt Warder: on here. But by and large,
14:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
14:26
Matt Warder: I think. med coal is in a very similar position to thermal coal from a range bound perspective. I think the bottom is probably around, oh, let's call it 220. Uh probably not even 215 when we saw this last trough back in July. I think for the winter, probably 240,
14:46
Matt Warder: maybe a little bit below, is a good point to circle uh and expect uh markets to correct over the next couple of months. But once we get into late December, then restocking season begins in earnest and we should be back off to the races.
15:05
Joe Aldina: In your models, I think.
15:07
Matt Warder: Yeah, I think so. But we'll we'll start talking about the equities here in a second because we just got out of earnings season. But uh I think what you know the broader market is showing is that stocks, as they typically do, have kind of bottomed out ahead of where commodity prices might. Uh, and in general, I think we
15:27
Matt Warder: should see uh perhaps for the stocks themselves, a little bit of a better environment as we head into the back half of November and into December, which is generally a much better month seasonally for the stocks in general. But
15:41
Matt Warder: anything else on the on the gas front? I mean, that's really what's been not just uh causing thermal coal prices to stay elevated, global LNG prices to stay elevated, but it's also been driving up uh the cost at mines due to uh diesel fuel surcharges and those sorts of things, which we'll talk about during earnings. But um, what's uh how are TTF and
16:01
Matt Warder: JKM looking before we break your here uh and talk to our friends at the Clear Commodity Network?
16:06
Joe Aldina: Well, again, I I I think it's um it's a little there there was a lot of uh anxiety and geopolitical risk in those prices. Uh over 100 euro per megawatt hour uh on the TTF contract um was just pretty healthy. I mean, that's um that's severe shortage.
16:26
Joe Aldina: pricing. Not uh not the world is ending Russia war pricing, but it's pretty severe uh shortage pricing. And um you know I just think uh I I think you were kind of priced for maximum d um disruption in the market there. I don't know you Yeah, the fun fundamentally uh
16:46
Joe Aldina: there's not a ton more gas uh flowing um a little bit of uh uh uh of of weather playing in there, but uh eighty eighty seven on the front part of the curve for TTF is still pretty darn healthy. It's still pretty darn constructive
17:03
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): for
17:03
Joe Aldina: coal.
17:04
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, exactly. Um
17:05
Matt Warder: up fifty percent over the past quarter is a lot. Uh the
17:08
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): thing that I
17:09
Matt Warder: noticed was we started to see a little bit of seasonal contraction over in Asia. Uh JKM futures are down about 7% on the week. But still over the past month, and it's been a month since we've been able to do a podcast with all the travel, uh, we're still up relative to where we were the last time we spoke about this. So the the trend hasn't stopped. Uh just
17:28
Matt Warder: to me, you know, this little seasonal correction, which is normal, which we think should last maybe another month. Uh, but I think we're actually starting to see some signs of that bouncing and turning around. So we'll have to um
17:41
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
17:41
Matt Warder: see how the see how the specifics play out. But by and large,
17:45
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh,
17:45
Matt Warder: you know, I think thermal coal, uh uh gas and and even met coal are starting to look very similar. Like the whole complex is kind of coming together to some degree.
17:55
Joe Aldina: Yeah, we got EU gas stocks 72%, um still pretty combustible.
18:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
18:04
Joe Aldina: Europe does not have much of a storage cushion.
18:10
Joe Aldina: A little bit of increase in flows from cutter up to 50% of normal levels.
18:21
Joe Aldina: Um there's still a pretty tight inventory position on gas. Uh so this this could reverse. Um again, you know, be ready for some volatility with the weather here. Um you get cold weather in cold weather in Europe, they need to bid up um L and G cargoes above the JKM price, and bang,
18:41
Joe Aldina: we're back to to over 100 euro per megawatt hour. Easy. Um so
18:47
Joe Aldina: you know, that's uh that's part of the story too. Uh Um I think limited downside and you know there's there's probably the risks are still skewed a little bit towards uh towards the upside uh on on volatility here um based on based on where gas gas storage is. And maybe I've been
19:07
Joe Aldina: buying this whole uh Super El Nino story, but if it doesn't uh if that doesn't materialize, you know, you gotta you gotta say things are things are still tight in the gas market.
19:19
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
19:19
Matt Warder: mean you can see it uh I actually had to pull together some slides on European inventories uh not too long ago. Uh and look where we peaked. I
19:26
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): mean
19:26
Matt Warder: we peaked at a five year low. Uh and if the if the straight continues to be closed off uh and uh shipments are just now, this is pretty current, we're still at maybe 75% lower volumes through the Gulf uh in terms of LNG than there normally would be.
19:46
Matt Warder: If if the war were to stop uh on December 31st, uh we will have taken uh you know about 75, about 75,000 tons uh uh out of
20:00
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
20:00
Matt Warder: market, uh which is which is quite a bit. And then if if that if by chance we don't get uh a resolution of uh of the conflict in Hormuz, then this uh you know the the top line fill for European gas is going to continue to ratchet down the longer this conflict
20:20
Matt Warder: lasts. And when you move into seasonal drawdowns and we get deliverable um levels below uh 20%, then deliverability begins to become an issue in Europe as well. So, you know, in
20:32
Joe Aldina: yeah
20:33
Matt Warder: in my mind, that's uh we're we're playing a duration game here uh with the straits. And although it's a geopolitical outcome, we can't predict exactly what's when or what's uh going to happen as a result of it. But the the time is running out for us to for the world to be able to restock in a way that's gonna going be to uh be uh significantly meaningful for the next
20:53
Matt Warder: cycle.
20:54
Joe Aldina: Yeah, and I mean that that's a good point. It's uh the next cycle is still going to be tight. Um so that's why you just don't have much downside in in prices here. Um or you have limited downside in prices because uh Europe's gonna be they're they're gonna have a hard time refilling gas storage uh coming out of winter and next
21:13
Joe Aldina: summer and you know the the market uh this tightness is not going anywhere soon
21:19
Matt Warder: and uh that's that's pretty much the case I think for everything that's related to this trade whether that's diesel I think diesel's going to be elevated for a while uh that that actually dovetails nicely into bringing us into an equity discussion but before we get into all that let's take a break and hear from our friends at the Clear Commodity Network.
21:37
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): In mining the difference between a good project and a great investment often comes down to one thing: visibility. Terra Hutton is a Sweden-based online mining investor platform built to make the invisible investable. Because a great project without a story The is just
21:57
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): data, drill results, spreadsheets, and technical reports that never fully connect. And a great project that isn't online might as well not exist at all. Tara Hutton brings mining projects into the digital spotlight, combining data, narrative, and context in one place,
22:18
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): so investors can see not just what a project is, but why it matters. Whether you're evaluating early stage exploration, or more advanced development assets, Tara Hutton helps turn complexity into clarity and information into insight. Visit Tara Hutton online
22:38
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): and start discovering the stories behind the data.
22:41
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): If you're looking for daily commentary on commodity sectors, companies, and analysts, check out the Corlin Corland Economics Report. Search the KE report in your podcast player. I'm your host, Corey Fleck, and that's where you can find daily commentary, everything you want to know of how to trade
23:01
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and where to invest in the commodity space. All under the Clear Commodity Network.
23:07
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hey
23:08
Matt Warder: everyone. Welcome back to the Cole Coal Trader Podcast. Uh Joe, let's talk some stocks for a little bit.
23:13
Joe Aldina: Yeah, uh, let's do it. Um
23:17
Joe Aldina: you uh you you kick it off. What do you want to talk about? You know, you and I have been talking a little bit about U.S. coal um with uh with a client of ours. We've been talking Alliance Resources, um,
23:29
Joe Aldina: which is doing great, uh, which is a perennial favorite of mine. So easy to talk about. We can mention that. Um, you know, it's the most exciting story. It's just keeps churning out money. When we like money.
23:42
Matt Warder: It does. Uh, I'll pull up the I'll pull up the whole table here so we can kind of get a delay of the land a bit. But uh despite commodities prices being fairly robust here over the past uh few months, and and even over the past few weeks, the the stocks have just taken a beating uh in a lot of ways. Uh over a
24:02
Matt Warder: one-minute one month basis, uh AMR down 14%,
24:06
Matt Warder: uh Warrior down 7%, Ramico down 15%, Peabody got whacked after its earnings call down 32%. Uh core natural resources, again, this is our biggest position and one that we own. Um really due to the fact that it's less volatile than the others, um, down five percent. But uh, but but Alliance, I mean, look at
24:26
Matt Warder: Alliance. here, it's green across the board. To your point, uh, not only did they have a great earnings call where the only uh the only producer really not to show any deterioration on the cost side, uh, but they're uh they've been diversifying over into oil and gas royalties. And this latest one that they picked up, uh all alldale day, uh,
24:47
Matt Warder: has really added to the bottom line. It was a really, really excellent quarter from them.
24:51
Joe Aldina: yeah and uh likewise uh nrp they've been doing quite well um i actually bought a big slug at 114 before this latest uh run up um and uh that they they uh they did great they uh re reported um
25:11
Joe Aldina: higher dividends um not a lot of cash burn from the soda ash business um that is that is just gonna be um uh just a cash cash machine um
25:25
Joe Aldina: and
25:26
Joe Aldina: and i i really like it it's d-leveraged they they have um
25:31
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
25:31
Joe Aldina: i i think people got really concerned as did i with soda ash and it just hasn't um
25:38
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it hasn't
25:38
Joe Aldina: turned into uh that big a problem. Soda Ash kind of stabilizing. And then we think volumes can go higher. Um royalty volumes at NRP can go higher as they pick up. Um
25:51
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): production
25:51
Matt Warder: was production
25:52
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): was down
25:52
Matt Warder: for a lot of people this quarter so I agree with that. But I mean from a stock chart perspective but I'm going I'm gonna pull up ARLP here in a second but these look very different from the non non-income income play plays in coal. I mean, this is a straight line up and to the right for the most part with a little bit of volatility in here. But when you're when you're owning an income stock uh that's paying special dividends, this is the kind of
26:12
Matt Warder: behavior you generally want to see.
26:14
Joe Aldina: Yeah. Um and you know, so now and and dividends distributions are uh out of NRP um are gonna go higher. Um
26:24
Matt Warder: I'll pull up uh alliance here. Generally when when people have talked to us about what to expect from a from price behavior on this one, uh I've kind of just showed them this. Uh in general you want to be buying in the low uh the low 20s, below 25 is a is a good spot to jump in. Uh we've seen it go as
26:44
Matt Warder: low as 22 in the past, but honestly I think with this acquisition those days are over. Um we've seen also on the top end 27 tends to be the top end of the range that that alliance trades in, uh, but we've seen it go as high as 29. Uh, I think we're gonna, I think we're gonna see it in the 30s before this cycle's over. Um, they've they've really done a great job
27:03
Matt Warder: uh incorporating that uh that new all day royalty into their uh into their package and really just kind of showed how slow and steady can really win the race in a in a commodities market that is uh kind of waiting for broader signals from from the from the globe. Uh they're sitting back
27:23
Matt Warder: generating free cash flow, blocking and tackling like they always do, returning value to shareholders, which is what we want to see.
27:29
Joe Aldina: Yeah, I do I do wonder uh if there's a higher floor, um kind of a little bit higher floor for ARLP um given after the after the Q3 call was really uh solid and we think 27 is going to be really solid. So um I actually bought a little in the in in the
27:48
Joe Aldina: 25s. Um I got a little I got a little impatient there. Um but I had thought I had thought maybe uh maybe we were we were gonna have a little higher higher floor because I saw I thought thought uh ARLP was looking pretty good constructive for 27. Um you know it's just a good uh good bet uh good
28:08
Joe Aldina: savings account kind of bet uh as you always call it Matt nine and a half percent yield at current prices I think at the close yesterday last time I I I looked at it almost a nine per 9.6% yield um yeah pretty pretty nice uh it's nice to own that on a few of these recent trading days um
28:28
Joe Aldina: in the broader market here with uh with the Nasdaq sell-off. So um I I think those stocks are still poised to uh for for really good things. I mean ARLP is your your grade A kind of gold uh star company. So uh but but NRP people are still kind of um
28:48
Joe Aldina: they're a little hesitant, they're a little hesitant about coal. They don't know NRP. They're worried about soda ash. You know, they
28:56
Joe Aldina: not everybody uh knows that uh management has d-levered and done such a great job. And uh that stock uh I just think has higher to go. Um
29:07
Joe Aldina: and is gonna spin out a ton of cash. I
29:09
Matt Warder: I'm not worried about soda ash. Generally, you know, I'd I view be buying uh assets at cyclical trial. troughs uh pretty opportunistic. So I wasn't necessarily mad at that uh that increased acquisition there. You have to when those opportunities arise, you have to take advantage of them, uh, which makes it makes a whole lot of a difference when you know when the market's on an upswing.
29:29
Joe Aldina: I alluded to the fact that they're gonna have higher higher revenues coming uh because of some ramico royalty tons that they're poised to uh poised to. grab. So I'm surprised nobody's been uh pushing me on on with questions on that. Or maybe they haven't, I've been missing them, but uh NRP's gonna have a nice 27.
29:49
Matt Warder: Yeah, uh I agree. I agree as well. Let's uh let's take a look at the Australian boys uh before uh before we move on and and look at the stock prices themselves and get on to earnings. Um uh really the the volatility that has characterized the US
30:03
Matt Warder: did not necessarily make its way over to Australia. It's been a lot calmer in comparison. Now we have uh uh a little bit of move down here with New Hope uh with JKM, but you know we're not seeing negative 14, negative 15 percent uh on the on the larger companies here. Yankle Yanko down three percent on the month,
30:23
Matt Warder: Whitehaven down six point five percent on the month. Uh New Hope down, I guess they're down 12% on the month. But again, uh these this is pretty seasonal behavior. I don't I think all of these are buys at this point in time. And when I start pulling up these uh stock charts, you're gonna see they all kind of look the same. Like
30:43
Matt Warder: here's here's AMR. During the I think on the last podcast, I pulled up this range right here is to kind of gauge where the bottom was. and we put in a bottom right in the middle of it. Uh, and now we're back up, kind of in the middle of uh, you know, kind of zero standard deviations from where we've traded over the past 30 days. We do have uh the 50
31:03
Matt Warder: day moving below the 200 day moving average. So there's probably a cap here until we get into a point where medical med coal prices start moving back up. But I I I like these stocks down in here. And then if I switch to Ramico, we see sort of the same behavior right here. We had uh had a bottom down here right
31:23
Matt Warder: below six dollars, which for me I had had a trading position on, but uh this is now a core position of mine. Down below six dollars is just kind of a stupid place for uh for ramico to trade because to your point there earlier they're increasing low low-vol vol production production at their operations. And that is going to be a much higher
31:42
Matt Warder: value product. They've sold on their earnings scroll. They mentioned they sold a lot more high vol domestically. So they're capturing a higher price for the comparatively lower quality material that they have. And even just a few weeks ago, this stock was trading up over $9. So I don't see why there's any reason we shouldn't see this back around.
32:02
Matt Warder: probably topping out seasonally around 12. Uh and you know, at that point in time, I might consider uh, you know, trimming the position, making the rest of it free and making it a core hold for a much longer part of the cycle. But still, this this does not look fundamentally fundamentally different from AMR.
32:20
Joe Aldina: And that's not a fundamentally driven sell-off, right, Matt? man? I mean, uh, you know, a little little bit of stuff. tiny bit of weakness on the met coal price, but but but increasing volumes. I mean, is it uh is it a rare earth uh just uh momentum change?
32:37
Matt Warder: Yeah, I think so. One of the one of the difficulties with uh becoming either a diversified miner or a mining company that is associated with several different markets is that when when when one side catches a cold, your stock price is always going to catch it as well. So despite the coal business uh
32:57
Matt Warder: kind of kind of moving along okay here at uh what I would characterize for the US to be cycle troughs still, uh and much better things to come ahead. Uh they've they've been thrown in with the the the the the the the move down in broader critical material stocks. And that's really un unfairly punishing
33:17
Matt Warder: the MetCool business here. Uh and it just I it's hard for me to look at this stock at seven, six or seven dollars and not think it's a really good value. I think it could potentially triple if it catches uh a new cycle from its bottom here around six. Uh but I do think twelve is a pretty reasonable price target for for February or March when we
33:37
Matt Warder: get into that point.
33:38
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
33:39
Joe Aldina: Thank you to the uh rare rare earth DG's out there for uh
33:43
Joe Aldina: that's
33:43
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): right.
33:45
Joe Aldina: They give it the and they take it away, but uh right now they give it.
33:49
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
33:50
Matt Warder: I sent out a note to subscribers today. Actually I had uh I bought calls as well when the when the stock bottomed. I took those off today up 60% and that'll be cash in reserve for uh for us to go and buy more stock whenever we get another sell-off. But uh, let's take a look at Warrior uh as well. You're gonna see the same pattern. Uh we have this
34:10
Matt Warder: sell-off heading into November the 4th, and then uh a bounce uh pretty much immediately afterwards. Warrior, I expect to sort of trade sideways. They had some cost inflation as well, which we'll get to uh when I pull up the earnings slides in a second, but this is pretty well. characteristic of uh of the rest of the
34:30
Matt Warder: uh of the rest of the US. When I pull up core natural resources, you're probably going to see something a little bit similar. And there it is. Similarly, it uh on its earnings call, it sold off down into the low 70s, which again is just a completely stupid price for it. Um the volatility-based envelopes that I use to kind
34:50
Matt Warder: of gauge. standard deviation. This was about a four standard deviation move lower. And it's already recovered in the past week, uh up to about the the, you know, uh uh what I would refer to as kind of a normalized position. We have another situation up here where the 50 days moving below the 200, which is a key for a lot of
35:09
Matt Warder: algorithmic trading. I don't really care about this stuff, but some technical guys really do. I think most importantly for me, we saw this RSI hit 25 back when it sold off down into the low 70s. This is when this happens, it's a no-brainer buy signal. So I increased uh the core position at this point to uh usually at my top is about six percent.
35:29
Matt Warder: I moved it up to about seven and a half uh at the bottom and we're already up about 10% off of that. So good move on on uh on
35:38
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that part.
35:39
Matt Warder: Uh also I should point out the Hearst exponent here. Once we hit that bottom and the stock started moving up, the Hearst exponent is telling us that this trend should be relatively resilient. So a uh a Hearst exponent above 0.5, uh, particularly up here around 0.75, 0.8, uh indicates that this this
35:58
Matt Warder: trend is persistent. So we should see some some more follow-through. on that stock as we move forward but the one that did not uh hold the line as it were uh was our friends out in st louis at btu got really punished for for the run up in cost particularly the the
36:18
Matt Warder: slow ramp up at centurion this was a pretty big position for me so i got i got whacked on this and i've taken some time to kind of take a deep breath and reassess what I think. Uh the stock has been trading sideways. Um obviously this RSI down in the in the 16s. This this was a buying
36:37
Matt Warder: opportunity for those who are patient enough to allow Centurion to ramp up. Whether you think centurion is going to be at full production in 2027 or not, whether you're in the bull camp or the bear camp, this, if you don't have a position, it's worth looking at here at the moment and just being patient with them as they ramp that up. But you know, again, here the the the Hearst
36:57
Matt Warder: exponent is kind of in in insinuating that this downward trend might be persistent. And so I've just I've kind of held off. I I think at the end of the day, I'm gonna going top to off the position and get back up to about where I was. I just don't want to have that much coal in my portfolio. as we get toward Thanksgiving, which
37:17
Matt Warder: can be Thanksgiving week can be a nasty, nasty time for coal stocks. So
37:22
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
37:22
Joe Aldina: mean BTU's always had just a lot of beta to the global commodities complex. And um,
37:28
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
37:28
Joe Aldina: know, uh not surprising that it's sold off hard on a little bit of uh slightly tougher news. I don't even want to call it bad news.
37:37
Matt Warder: Well, I mean, if if I have had a criticism, it would be that uh, you know, A AMR pre-announced because they continued to have difficulties with the DTA stacker reclaimer. And, you know, Peabody'd had an analyst day at Centurion. Uh I think they've explained what's been going on at the mine and why it's been slow to ramp up
37:57
Matt Warder: relatively well. Uh, but you know, this was a quarter maybe they should have pre-announced, uh, just because. uh the the expectations of the street and even of of our numbers uh were just not at all congruent with what reality was. Um I I think just in my opinion, pre-announcing when that happens,
38:17
Matt Warder: ripping the band-aid off kind of at the beginning of the earnings cycle uh is a better way to address that. And you get to get a message out uh in addition to that, you accompanying your your press release when you pre-announce earnings, rather than wait until the day of and just surprising everybody who's been following you. That's um uh I I know the the notes we got
38:37
Matt Warder: from our retail subscribers were were were were not too pleased with that. But um you know as for me I think I'm just coming around to the idea that it's it's too low to uh to let linger down here and I'm just going to top gonna off top off the position and be patient with it as we go forward. Um let's take a let's take a walk through Australia. Uh I
38:57
Matt Warder: think what you'll find is these stocks kind of look similar as well. Um here's Whitehaven's uh dip down uh post distribution that's consolidating and is going to move its way up. Um it's uh 50 day already moved lower back down here and it's broken trend and all this goes to show you is just
39:16
Matt Warder: fundamentals catch up with these stocks uh and the technicals don't always work to analyze them. Um when when the markets when the markets go up, uh the stocks will generally uh go up with them because that will be the pervasive narrative. But let's look at um uh let's look at Yanko, which I think is also really interesting down here with the
39:36
Matt Warder: continued tightness in Indonesia. uh, with Indian, with the Indians coming back into the market, uh, in Yanko uh bottoming out similarly. This is all the same day, too. Uh down here around 536 Australian. Uh it's only moved back up to 570. I know that you know, post post the Kestrel acquisition,
39:56
Matt Warder: this stock has been punished for making an uh you know, making a purchase uh instead of returning value to shareholders. But um I think that that that I think that acquisition is going to work out really well for him. And this is just too cheap. Uh too cheap to have Yanko all the way down here. And then finally
40:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): good
40:14
Joe Aldina: production, good exports, you know, room to to fill in for for the lack of Indonesian high C V, mid-C mid C V coal. Um and then back to my comments earlier, limited limited downside on the um
40:30
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
40:30
Joe Aldina: the thermal price um uh if if any with with some asymmetrical potential with with weather and and still uh constrained gas. Um and yeah I think Kestrel is the is is probably the issue that's on folks' minds but uh but there's some good uh fundamental things to to support a position
40:50
Joe Aldina: uh in Yanko at these prices, I think.
40:53
Matt Warder: I think so too. And here's here's New Hope, uh, which has also uh been pushed down here into buy territory at 531. Uh the the moral of the story, I'm gonna pull up Thungella, which uh we we do have a position in and we were trimming at the peak. Um and uh I think we need to buy it again. I mean it's uh we were trimming up here when the
41:13
Matt Warder: gain was about 30 uh Um this is where we established a position. Uh we took some profits there. Um uh I didn't buy a little bit more on November because I was more focused on the US, but it hasn't really moved. And uh, you know, to that uh to that point, Tungella has really
41:33
Matt Warder: traditionally been the the high beta stock. It's been like the AMR or the or the Ramico. Ramaco of the thermal coal space. So when uh you know, although now gas prices are lower than they were, um, TGA is going to be the high beta way to play a run up in thermal coal prices. And Richards Bay has been has been really resilient relative to EI2
41:53
Matt Warder: as well. So, like, I you know, I hate to say it, but we're we're in this kind of market position, like we almost always are in October, November, where if you have a favorite, you can pretty much just play it. Uh and the seasonality is probably going to be your friend. Um we'll uh I have a chart on uh we'll talk about you know where where miners
42:13
Matt Warder: rank currently on you know EV to EBITDA for the next year or so. Uh but by and large everybody's kind of in the same you know three, four, five range. So rather than uh you know try to find some sort of asymmetric upside value, I think this is just one where if you're if you're comfortable riding a certain horse, saddle up.
42:33
Joe Aldina: Yeah, I agree. There's still um, you know, potential option upside on the on the thermal side as well.
42:38
Matt Warder: Right. And
42:39
Joe Aldina: Tungella was down what, twenty five twenty five percent but on that chart.
42:42
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
42:43
Joe Aldina: That's
42:43
Matt Warder: yeah. I I took off about half the position and went from, you know, three 3.5% point five percent up to about four something to my uh you know percent of my 401k. And I took it back down to two and a half. Uh and now it's back down 30%. I I'm probably just going to take it back up. It it it's seasonally not a point where I want to be too overweight the coal
43:03
Matt Warder: sector. But if the market is gonna, you know, hand these fastballs to us, then there's no reason I don't think why we shouldn't swing at them to some degree.
43:13
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
43:14
Matt Warder: but let's let let's talk about how the earnings season shaped up here in the US, especially, because I think this is really what the theme is going to be going forward. Like uh for ARLP, for CNR, for BTU, like you can see consensus and our estimates are all pretty close on the revenue side. Uh we
43:34
Matt Warder: didn't have wildly different ideas about what production was doing.
43:38
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh,
43:39
Matt Warder: we didn't have wildly different uh ideas between uh you know us in the street on what prices were doing. But where we both got hammered was on uh costs. So, you know, uh we mentioned that ARLP actually beat on cost, they beat EBITDA and they beat on earnings per unit pretty sizably. Uh and the stock has really only
43:59
Matt Warder: moved from 23 to 25 bucks. Uh so I think there's some appreciation that that's to come there. But
44:06
Matt Warder: costs for CNR went up quite a bit. And both consensus and us and us missed
44:13
Matt Warder: by a pretty wide margin. BTU's costs at their uh Cborne Met, because Centurion production was so low, we're way over what anybody expected, and they missed our uh you know estimate for for revenue by uh uh by about seven percent but on Ebada we were uh you know eleven percent
44:34
Matt Warder: too high uh and earnings were off by a pretty significant amount
44:37
Joe Aldina: uh
44:37
Matt Warder: as well. Um even Warrior, which has underground mine should be unaffected by diesel, uh doesn't have a whole lot of uh uh you know uh exposure to those types of commodities. Even they came in uh pretty hot on the quarter uh due to some geological issues, uh, which
44:57
Matt Warder: is which is the same thing that plagues CNR. So it just goes to show you, even if you're you're the type of operator that isn't uh that doesn't have exposure to some of these things that are happening globally, uh mining is hard and it can still jump up and bite you uh in the end. Um AMR, of course, pre-announced uh but we were we were pretty close
45:17
Matt Warder: on on our estimates there uh to say the least. Really what I want to talk about is
45:24
Matt Warder: what we what do we think about cost going forward. Right? So uh you know ARLP in in uh the Illinois basin and Appalachian Appalachia about 31 versus 46. We were uh you know about a dollar or so off But CNR was a big uh sort of unexpected uh change there.
45:44
Matt Warder: The MetCole costs I dialed in at about $86, $87, and they came in at 92. Uh when we look at BTU C-Born Met, I expected them to be expensive at 137, they came in at 162. Uh I expected Warrior to kind of be steady eddy at 95, they came in at 105. Ramico, I had at 98. They came in at 104.
46:04
Matt Warder: And universally, uh across the board, the the message was that it was those fuel surcharges and pass-through uh uh charges from vendors that was really what was driving the cost at the end of the day, into uh and also geology at CNR, geology at um uh at Centurion, and
46:24
Matt Warder: geology at Warrior. Um now I expect the geology to get better. Uh the question that I have that's uh uh that's really on my mind is are these vendors, you know, when we think about retail prices for normal things, when fuel prices push up the price of food, food will generally relax going
46:44
Matt Warder: forward, but it doesn't Don't go back to where it was just because diesel is relaxed or bunker fuel is relaxed. Um and that's what I kind of wonder for uh some of the cost components that go into the underground mines in particular. I know that long wall shields are more expensive than they used to be because steel is more expensive than they used to be. Um
47:03
Matt Warder: and so really what we want to look at over the next quarter or two is are these levels going to stay? Like, is this a new baseline? Uh and if it is, uh I'd argue that the the inflationary pressures that we felt in the U.S. have also been similarly felt around the world. Inflation, commodity inflation, uh
47:23
Matt Warder: broad-based inflation like that is not just the U.S. phenomenon. Uh, that is something that's felt by all. So if if it is sticky, if it is going to be persistent, then I think maybe over the past year we've just watched the entire global cost curve for both meta met and thermal go. up by about four percent. Any thoughts, Joe?
47:42
Joe Aldina: You know, some stickiness seems reasonable. I think, you know, as an economist, um uh it's supply side shocks tend to resolve themselves. Demand side shocks, I think, tend to be stickier. And um, I don't I I don't know if we're kind of looking at a supply side shock um on the
48:02
Joe Aldina: hormuz. situation. Um but there's it's a little more complicated than that when it's diesel. It's a question of refinery capacity, um and and those kind of things. And um this is this is a geopolitical supply side shock that doesn't doesn't show um
48:22
Joe Aldina: signs of of getting uh uh significantly better. Uh in fact there were there were signs that uh that things might get more combustible uh before they get less combustible. So you know that's always a hard hard hard question. Um but um you know I I I yeah I
48:42
Joe Aldina: I I mean I I think uh
48:45
Joe Aldina: I think a a a quarter or two of stickiness um seems pretty reasonable.
48:52
Matt Warder: Yeah. And uh we had we had someone, uh one of our subscribers actually ask us, this is as close as we're going to get to and ask me anything, uh, to actually go through and rank where where everybody is in terms of EB, EV to EBITA. You know, these are our next 12 months estimates for for EBITDA. Uh, I haven't completed one for Ramaco Ramako yet because I got to dial in
49:12
Matt Warder: uh Loval Low Val production at their. uh at their Maben complex before I come up with a number, but it's it's in the same range. Um BTU I mentioned got just absolutely whacked. Uh and on a on a value basis, this is probably where you want to look, despite uh despite how this past quarter's call looked with uh
49:32
Matt Warder: with Centurion. Even if even if Centurion uh doesn't get back to full production in 2027.
49:39
Matt Warder: as long as production goes up, that cost is going to come back. So I think this number is probably going to re-equilibrate to something that looks a little more like these over the next few months. But um generally at mining cycle peaks, we see this get up into like the sevens or eights or nines. Uh, and that's when you want to be selling. Right now,
49:59
Matt Warder: everybody's still in the twos and threes and fours.
50:03
Matt Warder: And uh, you know, by at least by my standards, that's a pretty comfortable level to to just begin buying and starting positions.
50:12
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
50:13
Joe Aldina: less than one EBIT uh one times EBITDA is pretty uh pretty cheap.
50:18
Matt Warder: Yeah, exactly.
50:19
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Does it get any
50:19
Joe Aldina: cheaper than that? I mean
50:22
Matt Warder: uh not usually, not unless something really terrible is going on. And and to be fair, like I don't I don't think that's the case uh at Centurion. Uh they had costs uh jump up in the Illinois Basin, they had costs jump up uh a little bit in PRB, but like their seaborne thermal business looked great. That's going to continue to be a bright spot for them. Uh really
50:41
Matt Warder: they just have uh I think the US costs will will pull back as well. Um, it's really just more of a case of trying to get centurion under wraps for. them. If they do that, then the stock's going back to $25 without
50:56
Matt Warder: without too much difficulty at all, I don't think. And as for everyone else, I think we're at pretty attractive multiples here in general. So, you know, hearkening back to me going through each chart and taking a look at what all look like similar uh uh you know similar companies from a from a technical setup
51:15
Matt Warder: standpoint. Um, I think the the moral of the story and a great way to end the podcast is just to say, uh guys, it's time to buy some coal.
51:22
Joe Aldina: Time to it's always time to buy coal, you know?
51:25
Matt Warder: But now in particular, like uh in October, November, uh it's when the dolderms happen. That is shaken out. Uh, but uh I it's hard for me not to be optimistic. Uh even with you know a market that may list sideways. into most of 2027. Um I just think from a from an equity perspective, we go up from here.
51:44
Joe Aldina: Yeah, no, I I I think it it's uh joking aside, uh there's there's a number of uh bets like BTU that are that look pretty asymmetrical here. Um, you know, the Australians are are down a bit and fundamentals are still uh um pretty good. Um, you know, maybe there's some uncertainties about
52:04
Joe Aldina: China, but uh
52:06
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
52:07
Joe Aldina: uh I I I think uh I think I think there's good good upside there um and not a lot of downside. So um you know I would just look at where what where things have come off where that where the E V to Ebada looks out of sync. Um it's not quite the uh the out uh the
52:27
Joe Aldina: asymmetrical picture that we saw when prices started going up uh this summer, but uh but you know, still still a nice time to buy.
52:37
Matt Warder: It's still it still looks a lot like twenty twenty one. And if I recall correctly, twenty twenty twenty twenty twenty two was a pretty good year uh as well for our boys. So
52:46
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
52:47
Matt Warder: yeah, yep, with that in mind, I think uh better things are ahead, but we'll uh we'll revisit that in a couple of weeks. Um and in the meantime, uh for all of you out there, please check out our work at thecoltrader.com uh or thecoltrader.substack.com. You could follow me on Twitter at mfwarder. Um and uh Joe, any any further thoughts before we
53:07
Matt Warder: sign off?
53:07
Joe Aldina: No, you know, I'm I'm kind kinda of getting back into the Twitter thing, Matt. I, you know, as people know, I have a day job, so I I go in. incognito, but um I'm Captain Com eighty three, C A P T C O M M eighty three. I'll try to put out some more uh thoughts on uh on the Twitter verse. Uh you know, it's
53:27
Joe Aldina: it's it's been uh it's been a little hiatus for for me uh on on Twitter, but it's uh or X dot com, but it's still a great platform. So um I'll try and try and get out there. And thanks, thanks guys for listening. Definitely check out the uh the website. Um more um more tools
53:47
Joe Aldina: and functionality coming and Matt and I have put in uh a lot of effort most mostly Matt but uh we both put in a lot of effort in the website recently so check it out.
53:57
Matt Warder: Yep we have a brand new short-term uh outlook for metallurgical coal uh which is currently uh viewable by all subscribers to the coaltrader.com website. Uh when we come up to the new year, that's going to move over into our institutional product base. Uh, but we have a thermal coal outlook coming out relatively soon too with a
54:17
Matt Warder: data tool. We have uh in following on that, we'll have a corporate service that will We'll look through pretty much all that we look looked through here today, looking at costs, looking at uh revenues, uh looking at the amount. them out on a on a one-year, two-year, three-year basis based off of our forecast. That's to come hopefully by the end of the year, definitely early January. But please come check out our work and also check out all of our
54:37
Matt Warder: friends at the Clear Commodity Network. But um uh for Joe Aldina, uh, I'm Matt Warder, and thanks for listening to the Cold Trader Podcast. See you guys next
54:46
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): time.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights