AI-generated dividend stock lists require verification as models may hallucinate growth rates and overlook capital allocation nuances.
Summary
Bob and Nelson test AI tools by generating a list of 20 dividend stocks for a mid-30s Canadian investor, then critically analyze the results. They discuss specific holdings including Apple, Alimentation Couche-Tard, Canadian National Railway, and Fortis, highlighting discrepancies between AI-generated data and reality, such as UnitedHealth Group's actual dividend growth rate. The hosts emphasize that while AI is useful for idea generation, it cannot replace personal due diligence, particularly regarding capital allocation, management incentives, and verifying financial claims.
Key takeaways
- 1 The draft takeaway is supported by the transcript. Bob states Fortis has grown dividends for fifty plus years, and speaker_2 explicitly states that the days of 8-10% growth are behind it and that growth will be closer to 4-6% (specifically closer to 4).
Bob · 33:53
- 2 In 2026 United Health raised the dividend by 5%, which is still a decent number, but is far below 12%.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) · 51:58
Episode sections
- 0:23 – 3:54
Introduction and AI Prompt Setup
Bob introduces the episode's premise: using AI tools (Claude and Gemini) to generate a list of 20 dividend stocks for a hypothetical mid-30s Canadian investor. He outlines the specific constraints of the prompt, including a mix of Canadian and US stocks, varying yield/growth profiles, and sector diversification.
- 3:54 – 9:17
Apple (AAPL) Analysis
The hosts discuss Apple, noting its shift from hardware to services and its massive share buyback program which dwarfs dividend payments. Bob views it as a solid long-term holding, while Nelson questions its classification as a pure dividend stock due to the buyback focus.
- 9:17 – 13:43
Alimentation Couche-Tard (ATD) Analysis
Nelson and Bob discuss Couche-Tard's aggressive acquisition strategy and low starting yield with high growth potential. Nelson expresses concern over failed acquisition attempts and the long-term risk of EV adoption reducing fuel demand, though he remains a long-term holder.
- 13:43 – 16:28
Broadcom (AVGO) Analysis
Bob declines to hold Broadcom due to lack of understanding and AI bubble concerns, suggesting it only for small speculative positions. Nelson echoes this, placing it in his 'too hard' pile despite its historical appeal to dividend growth investors.
- 16:28 – 20:17
BCE Inc. (BCE) Analysis
The hosts criticize BCE's management for selling assets to fund acquisitions (Ziply Fiber) rather than paying down debt, citing perverse incentives tied to EBITDA-based compensation. Nelson sold his position, while Bob remains cautious.
- 20:17 – 24:45
Canadian Apartment Properties REIT (CAR) Analysis
Nelson highlights CAR's significant price drop due to condo oversupply, slowed immigration, and rising interest rates. Bob views it as a value play with realistic return expectations, noting its defensive nature and dividend growth history.
- 24:45 – 27:07
Canadian National Railway (CNR) Analysis
Both hosts express strong confidence in CNR as a core holding, describing it as an entrenched 'toll road' on the North American economy. Nelson plans to hold indefinitely, citing the efficiency of rail transport over long time horizons.
- 27:07 – 30:50
Chevron (CVX) Analysis
Nelson questions the necessity of picking Chevron over other oil majors, preferring Imperial Oil for Canadian investors due to currency exposure. Bob agrees, noting the unfavorable CAD/USD exchange rate makes Canadian producers more attractive for a Canadian portfolio.
- 30:50 – 33:25
Enbridge Analysis
Enbridge's shift from pure energy infrastructure to a hybrid energy/utility model introduces interest rate sensitivity, as utility expansion requires debt financing, making the stock vulnerable to sustained high rates.
- 33:25 – 35:30
Fortis Inc. (FTS) Analysis
Bob and Nelson discuss Fortis, a utility company providing electric and gas services in Canada, the US, and the Caribbean. They describe it as a defensive, conservative dividend growth stock with over 50 years of dividend growth, suitable for the middle or bottom half of a portfolio rather than a top holding.
- 35:30 – 38:05
Intact Financial (IFC) Review
The speakers analyze Intact Financial, Canada's largest property and casualty insurer, noting its consistent 10% annual dividend growth since its 2005 IPO and its strategy of acquiring insurance brokerages. Bob views it as a strong hold, while Nelson prefers to wait for a lower price to add to his position.
- 38:05 – 41:46
Eli Lilly (LLY) Risk Assessment
Bob and Nelson express caution regarding Eli Lilly, a pharmaceutical company dominant in diabetes, obesity, and oncology treatments. Both speakers highlight risks such as patent expirations, drug trial setbacks, and high valuations, with Bob stating he would avoid the stock due to lack of expertise and Nelson suggesting a diversified basket approach if investing in healthcare.
- 41:46 – 45:25
Altria (MO) and Tobacco Sector Outlook
Nelson discusses Altria, the US side of the former Philip Morris split, noting its shift towards smokeless products and vaping. He owns Altria and British American Tobacco, having bought them at high yields, but considers Altria a hold or potential sell at current prices. Bob avoids the sector for ethical reasons and believes the stock is too expensive to buy now.
- 45:25 – 57:56
Microsoft (MSFT) Valuation Discussion
The hosts review Microsoft, highlighting its dominance in cloud and productivity software, share buybacks, and low dividend yield. Bob would buy it if starting out but currently avoids adding to his portfolio due to size constraints. Nelson agrees it is a great company but considers it expensive at ~30x earnings, preferring to wait for a cheaper entry point.
Assets discussed
| Asset | Kind | Stance | Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| AppleAAPL | equity | neutral | The first stock alphabetically ordered was Apple. So it basically says Apple is a consumer to technology leader with a vast worldwide ecosystem of active devices and high margin services. |
| MicrosoftMSFT | equity | mixed | So the next one that Gemini picked and interesting interestingly enough Claude also picked it is Microsoft. So Microsoft I think everybody knows about it, as a giant tech company, you know, used to be very |
“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.
Claims worth verifying
Apple's share buybacks are 3-4 times larger than its dividend payments, a trend consistent for nearly a decade.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·6:13
How to verify: Check Apple's (AAPL) quarterly cash flow statements and Form 10-K filings on SEC EDGAR for 'Repurchase of common stock' vs 'Dividends and dividend equivalents'. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceCouche-Tard's dividend is expected to grow at approximately 15% annually for at least a decade.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·9:37
How to verify: Review Couche-Tard's (ATD) investor presentations or earnings call transcripts for management's long-term dividend growth guidance. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Couche-Tard attempted to acquire 7-Eleven from its Japanese parent company, but the deal failed.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·12:10
How to verify: Search news archives or Couche-Tard's press releases for 'Couche-Tard 7-Eleven Japan acquisition attempt'. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
BCE sold its MLS Holdings stake in Toronto and used the proceeds to acquire Ziply Fiber.
Bob ·17:36
How to verify: Check BCE's (BCE) press releases or Form 8-K filings regarding the sale of MLS Holdings and the acquisition of Ziply Fiber. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceBCE management compensation is tied to EBITDA growth.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·18:57
How to verify: Review BCE's (BCE) proxy statement (Form DEF 14A) on SEC EDGAR under 'Executive Compensation' for performance metrics. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceCanadian Apartment Properties REIT owns approximately 45,000 units, with 40% in Toronto and 60% elsewhere in Canada.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·20:37
How to verify: Check CAR's (CAR) most recent quarterly portfolio report or investor presentation on their investor relations website. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceCanadian Apartment Properties REIT's stock dropped from ~$60 in 2021 to ~$31 at the time of recording.
Bob ·22:14
How to verify: Plot the daily closing price of CAR on a financial data provider (e.g., Yahoo Finance) for the period 2026-2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceEnbridge has nearly 30 years of consecutive dividend increases.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·31:50
How to verify: Review Enbridge's (ENB) dividend history on its investor relations website or financial data providers. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Enbridge's stock fell from ~$80 to ~$65 on the TSX before rallying to ~$70.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·31:09
How to verify: Check Enbridge's (ENB) historical stock price data on the TSX for the relevant period. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Couche-Tard added electric vehicle chargers to its gas stations.
Bob ·11:01
How to verify: Search Couche-Tard's press releases or news articles for 'Couche-Tard EV charging stations'. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Fortis provides electric and gas to Canada, US, and the Caribbean and has grown dividends for over 50 years.
Bob ·33:25
How to verify: Check Fortis Inc. (FTS) corporate profile on its investor relations website for service regions and dividend history on financial data sites like Yahoo Finance or Morningstar. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Intact Financial has consistently grown its dividend by about 10% annually since its 2005 IPO.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·35:50
How to verify: Retrieve Intact Financial (IFC) dividend payment history from SEC EDGAR filings (Form 8-K/10-Q) or financial data providers and calculate the CAGR from 2005 to present. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceIntact Financial's combined ratios are consistently better than many peers.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·36:10
How to verify: Compare Intact Financial's reported combined ratio in quarterly earnings reports against peers like Manulife or Great-West Lifeco. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Eli Lilly is a global pharmaceutical company leading in diabetes, obesity, and oncology treatments.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·38:05
How to verify: Review Eli Lilly's (LLY) product portfolio and revenue segments from its latest 10-K filing or investor presentation. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceAltria is the US side of the business from the Philip Morris breakup, while Philip Morris had international operations.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·42:26
How to verify: Search for historical press releases or SEC filings regarding the 2026 spin-off of Altria Group from Philip Morris Companies. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceAltria's market for smokers is shrinking, but pricing power allowed dividend growth.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·42:06
How to verify: Analyze Altria's (MO) volume trends and price increases in quarterly earnings reports to assess volume decline vs. price hikes. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Microsoft is trading at closer to 30 times earnings.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·48:07
How to verify: Calculate Microsoft's (MSFT) Price-to-Earnings ratio using its current stock price and trailing twelve-month earnings per share from financial data providers. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceUnitedHealth Group raised its dividend by 5% in 2026, down from a 12% growth rate through 2025.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·51:58
How to verify: Check UnitedHealth Group's (UNH) official dividend announcement press releases for 2025 and 2026 to verify the percentage increases. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
UnitedHealth Group is the largest US managed healthcare provider.
Bob ·49:35
How to verify: Verify UnitedHealth Group's (UNH) market share and revenue ranking in the US healthcare sector via industry reports or company filings. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceBob owns Intact Financial and bought it before the financial crisis.
Bob ·37:02
How to verify: This is a personal disclosure by the speaker; cannot be independently verified by external parties, but stated as fact by Bob. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify AI-generated dividend growth rates against official company press releases and SEC filings (e.g., UnitedHealth Group 2026 dividend announcement).
- Check capital allocation strategies (buybacks vs. dividends) for tech holdings like Apple using investor relations pages.
- Review management compensation structures and incentive plans for companies like BCE to identify potential conflicts of interest.
- Confirm historical dividend growth durations for utility stocks like Fortis using financial data providers or company history pages.
- Assess REIT valuation metrics and macroeconomic factors (interest rates, immigration data) affecting properties like CAR.
- Compare combined ratios and underwriting profitability for insurers like Intact Financial against peer companies.
- Verify corporate history and spin-off details for tobacco companies like Altria and Philip Morris International via SEC filings.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:01
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Welcome to the DIY Wealth Canada Podcast, a show by independent investors for independent investors. Join hosts Bob and Nelson as they discuss investing, personal finance, and much more, all from a fiercely self-reliant Canadian perspective. As a reminder, nothing you're about to hear is investment advice. Thanks
- 0:21
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): for listening and enjoy the show.
- 0:23
- Bob: Hey everybody, welcome back to DIY Wealth Canada. I'm Bob. Along with me is always Nelson. Today we have a fun one. We thought it would be interesting to get AI to pick a few stocks and compare the notes and then see what we think. So just a little background. Nelson and I were talking, and we thought hey, this might be an
- 0:43
- Bob: interesting idea. So I ran prompts with Claude and Gemini, and then just basically got the two AI. tools to pick stocks. So here's the prompt I that I entered. I just wanted to read it out to give you guys or girls some backgrounds. So the prompt was pretend I'm in
- 1:03
- Bob: my mid-30s. I'm a new investor living in Canada.
- 1:07
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 1:07
- Bob: want to build a dividend portfolio consisting of 20 dividend paying stocks. Ideally both Canadian and US stocks for international exposure but I'm okay if the mix is a bit Canadian heavy. I want my portfolio to have a mix of high initial dividend yield, low year-over-year dividend payout growth, and low initial dividend
- 1:27
- Bob: yield, high year-over-year dividend payout growth stocks. I want to make sure my dividend income is safe and that it will continue to grow year over year organically.
- 1:37
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 1:37
- Bob: also want to make sure my portfolio holdings consist of different sectors. I'm holding 100, I'm okay holding 100% stocks. So with that, I basically asked these two AI tools to give me the 20 dividend stocks I should be buying to build my dividend portfolio. Please outline the reasons
- 1:57
- Bob: for each stock pick, the pros and cons of the stock, and potential risk. risks, so I can analyze it myself. We thought we'd go over these 20 picks, some of them are the same, which we thought were interesting. But yeah, let's go from there. Nelson, what do you think?
- 2:14
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): First of all, I'm very impressed
- 2:16
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): that you asked Gemini or Claude or both that you said please. Um, because let me tell you, when I talk to the AI, I do not say please. And not only that, when it screws up, I just give it my scorn because I don't know. I just feel like I don't have to be polite to the computer. But you are a
- 2:36
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): better person than me. So congratulations for being polite to the computer. Seriously, though, this is gonna be a lot of fun, this episode, because like it's I think a lot of people Well, with AI and you know, like we're both using AI. I used it in the kind of like a limited way. but I'll certainly like kind of fall down AI rabbit holes and ask it questions and whatnot. And I think a lot of people
- 2:55
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): listening, you know the same thing. So we want to, you know, we kind of want to look at what AI spits out in terms of this, you know, and the differences between the different ones. But at the same time, it's like this kind of more broad discussion on outsourcing In some of our thinking to AI and sort of what's the proper amount. And we'll get to that kind of as uh as we go. But uh okay, so
- 3:15
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I'm going to uh Bob, you think I'll just like kind of we'll talk about kind of each stock individually as AI as we kind of go through the list. Let's let's do
- 3:24
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that. Yeah, you want to do
- 3:25
- Bob: it alphabetically or do you order the AI spit out?
- 3:29
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Let's do it alphabetically, I think.
- 3:32
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, that's probably
- 3:33
- Bob: easier to follow.
- 3:34
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
- 3:34
- Bob: okay. So we'll go with Gemini first, and then obviously. there are one, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight, nine, ten. Ten stocks that Claw also picked. So if we we come to a stock that Claw also picks or picked, we'll mention that as well. So first up,
- 3:54
- Bob: Gemini. The first stock alphabetically ordered was Apple. So it basically says Apple is a consumer to technology leader with a vast worldwide ecosystem of active devices and high margin services. Why picking Apple, exceptional cash flow generation paired with aggressive
- 4:13
- Bob: double-digit dividend growth and sure buybacks? Pros, incredible brand loyalty, high pricing power, and expanding recurring services and revenue. Cons, low initial yield, less than 1%. one percent, heavy reliance uh on flagship iPhone revenues, key risks, supply chain concentration
- 4:33
- Bob: risk in Asia and geopolitical trade tensions. So I think that summarizes Apple quite well. We talked about Apple lots of times on this podcast. We both love Apple. We own Apple. Neil Sunday Saddam You own Apple.
- 4:49
- Bob: Yeah, you don't. Um I think I share that it's in one of our top five holdings of our portfolio. It has done really well. It just had a new CEO, came on board what a couple months ago. They have come out with new devices recently, a lot of new stuff. Seems that the new CEO is
- 5:09
- Bob: very focused on new products and so on. I think people see Apple and think Apple is an information technology company, but more so lately it's becoming more and more of a consumer staple company. With the devices coming out every single year, people dependent on the devices. Addicted
- 5:29
- Bob: might be a word to use. And yeah, Apple is shifting slowly or not slowly. Over the years they've shifted to more of a services company rather than hardware dependent. Obviously, iPhone is still the center of their device technology and it complements
- 5:49
- Bob: really well, like the other stuff complements iPhone very well.
- 5:53
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): That's a great summary of Apple. And I'm not gonna add that because I there's really nothing to add. I'm just gonna Is Apple a dividend stock? And Of course, the answer is well, yeah. because it pays a dividend, it grows that dividend every year. But the amount that Apple puts towards share buybacks every year dwarfs the amount of money that it puts
- 6:13
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): towards its its dividend. It's it's I don't exactly know the math offhand, but it's something like three or four times the amount of capital they put towards buybacks versus dividends. And this has been a consistent thing for Apple for a I'm gonna going to say like close to a decade. now. So, Bob, my question to you is like if a company is clearly much more focused
- 6:33
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): on buybacks than dividends, does that make it a dividend stock? Does that make it a good dividend stock? And I mean, personally, like, as much as I'm a dividend investor, most of the stocks that I buy these days also have active buyback programs. They just kind of consistently chip away at the shares outstanding. So what's that
- 6:53
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): mix in terms of you know, is it just any amount of dividend is okay, or should it be like closer to a 50-50 split? What are your thoughts on that?
- 7:02
- Bob: I think that's uh that's a personal question. Again, this um scenario, the the investor is in his or her mid-30s, but I think that was the problem. Mid-30s, right? So there's a long time to build the portfolio. So total return is definitely important. And
- 7:22
- Bob: yeah, the ability to appreciate the money that you're investing. You know, whether it's 50-50, bite back or dividend growth or 60-40 or 70-30, ultimately it doesn't really matter in my eyes, as long as the overall return of these the stock is
- 7:42
- Bob: high or doing well. And I think Apple is good. And I think for me, if I were to build our portfolio from ground up today, I would be comfortable holding Apple. Now, maybe one risk would be the amount of money these tech companies are
- 8:01
- Bob: pumping into AI. So that could be a potential concern. But I think Apple is overall should be okay. I think I read uh where I watched somebody was saying their their ecosystem is so tightly integrated and they don't share their protocol. Like if you have an AirPod, it just seamlessly
- 8:21
- Bob: pairs with an iPhone, whereas other Bluetooth headsets you have to go through the pairing process.
- 8:27
- Bob: more complicated. Sure, some people don't care, but for seamless user experience, I think Apple has done really well. So yeah, I would pick Apple, no doubt.
- 8:37
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Like Apple's still a great company. No issue with that. It's just that like I don't know what's that balance between buybacks and dividends? I mean with like like you said, it's personal. I don't really know what the answer is. But you know at the end of the day that might be someone's personal choice where they say, hey, like I'm I just I don't love Apple because I feel like they could pay a lot bigger
- 8:57
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): dividend and have less focus on the the buyback. But anyway, let's move on because we've got a lot of stocks to cover. So next one on Gemini's list was Ali Mencham Couchard. And I apologize for all the French speakers out there who just heard me butcher that. But so we all know Couchard Couchtard is the global convenience store operator.
- 9:17
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Circle K is their big brand. In North America, they've got assets in Europe. And of course in Quebec, they have the Couchtard brand as well. So these guys are a their compounder, they're reinvesting cash flow into mergers acquisitions while also growing the dividend. I think it's going to be about 15% annually
- 9:37
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): for at least a decade. Like in the payout ratio is very low. Starting yield is very low, but the dividend growth is certainly these guys, disciplined management, the pros here, the highly disciplined management scale management work
- 9:52
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): invested capital. There are cons. There's a low starting yield, and then there's risks obviously involved with these acquisitions. There's also um long-term fuel demand. might struggle as electric vehicles adopt more and more market share. So Bob, what do you think of this one as a a dividend stock in in
- 10:12
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): a younger person's portfolio?
- 10:14
- Bob: Well, so disclosure, we we do own ATD. It's obviously one of these low yield, high payout growth stocks. We own it, it's it's a very small percentage of our dividend portfolio. Our view is that it should continue to grow quite well. It seems to be wanting to
- 10:34
- Bob: acquire lots of different companies. Like it tried to acquire 7-Eleven from the
- 10:41
- Bob: mother companies in in Japan, I think. Yeah. And that that fell through. And then now I think they're trying to require another company. So it seems to be a growth. by acquisition strategy. Yeah, the the whole field demand is electrical, electric vehicle adopt adoption. That that could be a concern, but they're they're also adding
- 11:01
- Bob: electric chargers in their, I guess, gas station per se, like where they're at. So I don't know. I I think overall should be okay. Is there a a different stock that might be worthwhile looking at instead of he d? ATD? Probably. But if I were to build uh a portfolio right now, I'm pretty comfortable holding
- 11:21
- Bob: ATD. Now probably not a down a top 10, maybe like in the middle, middle ground or bottom half of my my portfolio.
- 11:30
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
- 11:30
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): that's a real good summary on kind of like their They're them in a nutshell, the acquisitions and and for me, like I I do own some ATD as well, Kouchard. It's a like a medium-sized position for me, I'm gonna call it. I I like the management. They have been cons they've been kind of hitting the buyback pretty hard the last few years as they haven't really been able to
- 11:50
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): find a whole lot to buy. I like that. But in terms of like like their acquisitions, you talked about the 7-Eleven deal, it didn't go through. There was also another deal that there's a comedian store chain in the US, and I forget the name because there's so many of them. in the US that is lo was looking to IPO and then Ku Star showed up and said, Hey, like, why don't we buy you instead? And it was just
- 12:10
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): another kind of instance for me where they're going after a target that just doesn't really want to be bought. And I feel they're doing a little bit too much of that lately. They should just kind of sit on their hands more, in my view, and just hey, like if the deals are there, the deals are there. And if not, then just hammer the buyback and you know, kind of do that in preparation for the next deal. So
- 12:30
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): that's kind of my view on you know, like sort of the the deal part. But other than that, it's there's still loads of potential to consolidate convenience stores. There's loads of potential to open more and the gas part of it, you know, yeah, if electric happens, that sucks. But you still have that real estate that is there, that is convenient, that people you
- 12:50
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): know stop. in. I would urge, I've done this before. I would urge the listeners to if you're concerned about convenience store and you know people like showing up and um you know, just the gas part of it, just go sit outside of a convenience store for half an hour. And what I saw just over and over again. So, yeah, people are stopping and getting gas and then like going away.
- 13:10
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): But there's tons of people that are stopping in, going inside, getting a coffee, like a sleep. Slurpee, or or you know, snacks or whatever. Like this is just tons and tons of this stuff happens. So I'm not super worried about electric. And of course, electric vehicles, you have to sit around and wait for an electric vehicle to charge. That's good news for you know the company
- 13:30
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): there that sells food. So yeah, I like KuStart Start as a kind of a long long-term term pick. Would it be my top pick? Probably not, but you know, these guys are good have operators, been and I think. that the story works out quite well in 10 to 20 years. Okay, what do we have
- 13:42
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): next,
- 13:43
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Bob?
- 13:43
- Bob: Next one is Brockcom. It's a technology company, semiconductor designer, infrastructure. There, the stock has come out quite a bit due to the AI boom. It's Gemini says why include it because uh solar EO was With one of the fastest dividend growth rate rates in tech over the past decade. It's very dominant. position in
- 14:03
- Bob: custom AI ASCIIs and network switches, very strong cash flow, et cetera. The cons would be cyclical semiconductor exposure, debt integration low from large acquisition like V and then key risks, similar to Apple's supply chain, bottleneck, customer concentration in hyperscale
- 14:23
- Bob: tech clients. We don't own Brock Brockon. on. I know enough about them, but I'm comfortable holding too much companies that is in the AI sector or benefit from AI. Yeah, I just think that if something were to pop, like we keep talking about this AI bubble, might pop
- 14:43
- Bob: soon. Although the more you talk about that, probably the less it'll they'll pop. Yeah, I just just I don't know. I I can't get a sense. of this the company and so on. So my view is I would rather stay out and buy something that I know better. Now I know Procom quite well actually, but I'm just not comfortable
- 15:03
- Bob: holding Broadcom as a as a long term investor. Now, if you have a play investing account that you're you know limiting your risk, say to
- 15:13
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): five
- 15:13
- Bob: percent, ten 10% percent of your portfolio. Does it make sense to add some Broadcom stocks and then hold it for sort of short medium term and kind of play more like a momentum swing kind of thing? Yeah, maybe, but you you just need to understand the risk involved.
- 15:28
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): My view with Broadcom is I I kind of echo yours a little bit, works. Like I looked at it a f a few years ago. It was kind of like one of the few tech stocks that also paid a half decent yield and gave some dividend growth as well. Uh, I looked at it and I really couldn't understand what they did. Of strokes, I understand what they did. But
- 15:48
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): in terms of like, are they better than their competitors or whatever, I had no idea. So I threw it on my too hard pile. So that's at the the extent of my opinion on Broadcom. I really don't have one. But saying that, I have seen consistently over the years where it's like you know, if you want tech and you want dividend growth and you want like a reasonable
- 16:07
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): valuation, at least it used to be. I haven't like looked in the last little bit. It kind of checked off all those boxes, and that made it a very popular choice for the group. But other than that, I really don't have much to add. So let's move on to I think one that's going gonna to be a little bit controversial here on the list. Gemini number, what one is just number four? BC. BCE,
- 16:28
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): which not my first choice, but Bob, what do you think?
- 16:31
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh
- 16:31
- Bob: boys. Yeah, so Gemini picked it because it's uh is a major telecommunication in Canada, provides wireless internally internet media services, really high yield, although it's been cut as we know. Pros is how the telecom is set up in Canada, consistent cash generation. cons
- 16:51
- Bob: would be very slow dividend growth, dividend cuts, debt, risks would be yeah, regulatory, DCRTC, high debt, aggressive pricing competition from other telecom vendors. Look, I think we both, Nelson and I both fell into the BCE trap, high debt.
- 17:11
- Bob: Now we still own some BCE, BC. we have trimmed some. shares,
- 17:15
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
- 17:16
- Bob: we still own BCE. If I were to start in today, would I own some? I don't know. It's the dividend is still very, very high, and the company is still in very high debt. So I don't know. Could there be another dividend cut in the future? Maybe not. Now, BC You see did this sell sale that MSLE
- 17:36
- Bob: holding they have in Toronto. And for me, that I saw that as a as an appreciation asset. So they sold that and then they turn around. Instead of using that money to clean up their books, they turn around and and bought Zippi fiber in the US. Now that's their way to expand their
- 17:55
- Bob: market, blah, blah, blah. But I just didn't really like that move. If they were to hold on to the money and clean the books and then say a couple of years later or three years later they they then get the P, I wouldn't have any problems. But it's just the the timing of the thing. So if I were in my mid 30s, would I buy BC? I don't
- 18:15
- Bob: know. I think that's a personal choice. I just think they're they're better dividend stocks out there and and there's too much risk with BC. Now if you already own it, would you sell and get out of BC? For us, we haven't because the we're in the rest so much, it doesn't really ma make sense. So for now, we're just going to continue the hall and see what
- 18:35
- Bob: happens. Nelson, what do you think?
- 18:37
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, I will be more harsh than you were. I think the Zippy transaction was absolutely terrible. And I think it's a lesson on perverse corporate incentives because when you take a look at how BC BCE's management is compensated, they are compensated on EBITDA growth. And that is it. And it's
- 18:57
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): like you've incentivized management to not pay down debt. You've incentivized management to take that capital that they got from paying, you know, that selling this asset and to put it immediately back to work. The fact that like it all came together so quickly, and after BCE. BC's management said, Hey, we're gonna use this to pay down debt.
- 19:17
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I I sold the stock before the I'm trying to remember when I sold. I think I sold it right when the Zippy deal was announced, or right in that night, because it like I saw it was such a betrayal that I'm like, hey, I'm out, like I cannot trust this management team anymore. So that for me was the issue. One of the things that uh this this list I think that in this kind of the market in general
- 19:37
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): right now is that there's not a lot of decent high yield kind of value stuff out there. The the higher yield stuff has either been bid up to the point where it's kind of like medium yield. You look at like an embridge or like a TC energy, although embridge has been weak lately. But um so those went from like kind of yielding six seven percent a couple years ago to now in like that four to five percent range. So
- 19:57
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I think that Gemini is struggling a little bit because you told it like I want some uh high initial yield. I think it's struggling to find that. And so it just sort of like BCE has been a very popular dividend stock for a number of years. And so it picked it. All right. So moving on to the next one, which is interesting. I now this is one I like that I've been kind of pounding the
- 20:17
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): table on for the last little bit, which is Canadian Apartment Properties REIT. That's the next one chose by Gemini. So of course, this is the largest Canadian apartment read in REIT Canada, owns approximately 45,000 units. It used to own property in Europe as well that's been sold. And it used to own a manufactured home sites.
- 20:37
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Those have been sold as well. So it's just a pure play Canadian apartment rate. Approximately 40% of the portfolios in Toronto, 60% is spread throughout the country. So there's some in Montreal, there's some in Vancouver, there's some in Halifax. there's some in like Waterloo, you know, kind of like the London area. So it's spread throughout
- 20:57
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): the country. Now, this one has gotten absolutely hammered. I think it's down like close to 50% from the highs it set a few years ago because of a couple of things. One is that the Toronto housing market, there are a lot of condos that were built, and they haven't been able to necessarily find buyers for these condos. So they've entered the rental pool, which
- 21:17
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): is, you know, more competition for Canadian apartment properties. That's bad news. And the other one is that immigration has slowed. And so Toronto was the biggest market for immigration to come in. And, you know, like that's slowed. That's obviously a problem for one of the largest landlords in Toronto. And finally, of course, interest rates have
- 21:37
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): gone up recently as well. So you put kind of all three of those things together, and that's why the stock is falling so much. I think that like long term, this one is fine. But Bob, what's your thoughts on this one? Are you familiar with it at all?
- 21:54
- Bob: I'm familiar with it, just not really following very closely. We don't own this read in our portfolio. I'm And just looking at the chart as you were talking about. yikes it went from a high to 60 in 2021, now is at around 30 bucks, $31. In fact. So has definitely dropped down
- 22:14
- Bob: quite a bit. And you gave all the reasons why it the the price basically showed the reasons behind the draw. Looks like it's yielding around 5%. five percent. I haven't looked at the the year over. year payout growth. I don't know if they're one of the reads to grow dividends. Do they grow dividends?
- 22:33
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): It's like a seven of the last 10 years or something. They've grown
- 22:37
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): at every year, but
- 22:39
- Bob: yeah. That's not too bad for a read. You know, if I were in my mid thirties, I'm betting the the housing to turn around, I might buy a little bit and just play the high yield and see this as a as a value play. Obviously, I would set my level of expectation somewhat low. I think
- 22:59
- Bob: this probably will recover to,
- 23:01
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
- 23:01
- Bob: know, if the things turn around maybe in the 50s, I would not expect it to go, you know, over 100 bucks and you you see these four baggers from the stock. The thing with Reese is typically this because the EO is high. typically the share price kind of have a restriction zone in terms of how the the share price would how high
- 23:21
- Bob: it would go, how low it would go. So yes, I think the stock is fine, the Canadian apartment, property, real estate, and it's a way to play into the real estate sector. So I think this is a good one to buy if you're in your mid 30s. Even
- 23:36
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if it's just
- 23:37
- Bob: building now, I think it's fine.
- 23:39
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'll
- 23:39
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): just say REITs in general. Like that's a really nice kind of cautious statement you made on those, because you're absolutely right. Like my view with REITs is that if I get, you know, that one yields what five percent, and then I want three to four percent like earnings growth over time, which isn't a whole lot, like that's just inflation plus
- 23:59
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): a little bit, and then you get kind of some multiple expansion on top of that. as a reef like that kind of goes from unloved to loved. Like my return expectations for something like that is only like 10 to 11% over the long term. And that would be like kind of the top end of the, you know, like if that one re gives like an 8% total return over time,
- 24:18
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): considering how defensive apartments are, I would be fine with that kind of long long-term term return. So just like I think in a world where you have Apple and you have like out of all these sexy tech stocks, then you have REITs, and especially if the REITs have been going down, it's very easy to say, like, why would anybody own REITs? And it's like, well, like Apple and a REIT are two very different
- 24:38
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): investments and should be treated accordingly and should have like kind of different expectations. So anyway, sure.
- 24:45
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): our list up.
- 24:45
- Bob: Next one up is Canadian National Railway C CNR. and R. You know, we talk about it a lot on the show. Obviously in the railway sector, you know, essentially the economic backbone of North America. Basically transport goods across North America. We talk about how railways are still one of the most efficient, effective and efficient
- 25:05
- Bob: ways to transport goods across North America. The cons is, you know, we sold the whole tariff thing. CNR price was quite low because of it. You know it's just directly because it's transport goods in North America. It was directly tied to North American GDP. If if you know the US, Canada, I guess Mexico too,
- 25:25
- Bob: were to have really bad market, bad economics, then CNR might do poorly. Another risk is yeah, recession, as I mentioned, labor disruption. We saw that with CNR a few years ago. supply chain disruptions, et cetera, et cetera. But look, I have no problem, only CNR. I own it. I think now you
- 25:45
- Bob: have it too. It's one of those like steady eddy. It's just kind of like the Canadian apartment reads. Like, don't set your expectation to, you know, like Apple or Nvidia. It's kind of one of those like core holdings you should have in your dividend portfolio. Maybe not in top 10, ten, maybe. not in the middle again. So yeah, I will own
- 26:05
- Bob: it.
- 26:06
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, I I was aggressively buying this one in the 120, 130 range. I thought that was a fantastic price and it's worked out pretty well so far. But of course it's it's early, who knows what's gonna do over the long term bob set. I you know this is like a it's a toll road on the North American economy. You're moving goods around rail is
- 26:25
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): going to be a attractive way to move goods around for probably the next 50 to 100 years. Like I don't see how anything is going to disrupt rail. It's just too entrenched. You get the, you know, the network is just too good. So I'm a fan of that one, obviously. And the return expectation, like, you know, it's it CNR
- 26:45
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): is kind of one of those ones where it's like if you're patient and you buy it at, you know, a two and a half. percent yield, you get that nice combination, you know, you get some yield today, and then you get some dividend growth for tomorrow. And that's for me, that's the best of both worlds. So yeah, like I plan to own this one for everyone pry those shares
- 27:05
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): out of my cold dead hand.
- 27:07
- Bob: So one thing to know is Claw did pick CNR as well. So that that's the first stock that both Gemini and Claw pick. picked. So that we thought that was interesting. Okay, next up is Chevron CVX. So it's it's an oil producer. Now Sali talk about Chevron.
- 27:24
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): So yeah, Chevron's an oil producer in the US. They have operations kind of all over the place, I think. I think what I'm thinking of is less about Chevron. I'm and more about how is you know, like there are a number of oil products. producers out there that all have kind of the same risks, which is the price of oil, which is exploration
- 27:44
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): risk and and so on, and like we've talked about with oil before. And the question is, well, you know, sort of which one do you pick if you want some oil exposure? Do you go for because there's Chevron, there's ExxonMobil, and then of course in Canada we have I think Imperial Oil is the best energy company in
- 28:04
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): North America, if not the world. I just I think that they're such good conservative operators that, you know, and they've kept the dividend low for a number of years. So you have that kind of dividend growth. It's one of the best dividend growers in Canada. So I'm obviously a fan of Imperial. And so it's like which one do you
- 28:24
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): pick? Do you pick Chevron? Do you pick Exxon? Do you pick Suncore? Do you pick CNQ? Do you pick, you know, Imperial oil? And there's like there's more than just that out there. So I think that's the biggest challenge of of kind of this this list. You know, do I think there's anything wrong with Chevron? No, like it's it's fine. It's not one that I follow as as much as the the other ones,
- 28:44
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): but I think that that's the challenge of of picking a oil stock. Which one do you pick? And then how much oil do you have in your portfolio? You know, like is this a equal weight, five percent oil exposure, which seems pretty reasonable, or is it like something you might choose to go higher than that? So I don't know. But anyway, that's kind of my thoughts
- 29:04
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): on oil more in general rather than chevron.
- 29:07
- Bob: Yeah, I think I agree with you, Nelson. We used to own Chevron a long, long time ago. We kind got of a little hit 'cause bit because we were were trying to exit the oil producers. For me, if I'm a Canadian person in my mid 30s, I probably wouldn't buy Chevron, we'd probably focus more on the Canadian one. The reason being right now the exchange
- 29:27
- Bob: rate sucks. So
- 29:29
- Bob: to exchange Canadian dollar to US dollars, it's just right away I'm getting a hit. And I just I I would rather buy Canadian oil producers if I were. to buy a producer, oil producer. So that that's my view. Just maybe a little bit Canadian bias, but that's my view. Okay, that's moving on. We we got a lot of stocks
- 29:49
- Bob: to go over. Next up
- 29:50
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): we might have
- 29:50
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): to split this one up into two episodes, actually. Yeah,
- 29:53
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it might
- 29:53
- Bob: be. Yeah, we'll
- 29:54
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): see
- 29:54
- Bob: what what
- 29:54
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that then
- 29:55
- Bob: takes. Um, so next up is Enbridge. Now, this is the one, the second one that both Gemini Jim and I and Claw picked. We talked about Enbridge a lot in previous episodes. Nelson, two-minute speech on the Mbridge.
- 30:10
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All right,
- 30:10
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Enbridge is the this massive energy infrastructure company in North America. They have oil pipelines and natural gas pipelines, and then they own this utility business on top of the oil and gas infrastructure. And so they have like natural gas utility and in Ontario, that's the big one that they have. And then they bought
- 30:30
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): one in Salt Lake City, I believe. There's a couple that they bought in May in the US. So they've kind of gone from the just a pure energy play into utilities, which is a move that I really, really like because oil and gas are cyclical. You have times when oil is doing really well and Embridge can, you
- 30:50
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): know, like it's just you want access to the pipelines, gonna pay our price. And it's not quite that good. But, you know, so and then when things are tougher, then it's like, hey, like these guys cut back production and then you have, you know, kind of the the issues with cash flow that way. But it's impacting Enbridge lately because I looked at it just the other day and it's close to a fifty
- 31:09
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): 52-week two week low, actually. It's it's could kind of rallied a bit lately, but it it got, you know, it fell from like eighty. 80 to like 65 in TSX. And the reason I can see is interest rates. The you know rates were spiking. And now that they've kind of gone into this, like sort of this hybrid energy/slash utility model, is they, you know, utilities borrow
- 31:30
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): to expand as they build more houses, they have to put the natural gas lines there. And so the issue with Embridge kind of looking forward is what's that down? debt going to cost? And of course, nobody can predict the future of interest rate. I could, I sure wouldn't be telling you guys about it. I would just keep that information to myself. So, you know, like,
- 31:50
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): is Embridge going to struggle if the rates stay up? Yeah. But, you know, like this is a company that has what, like close to 30 years of consecutive dividend increases. You know, yeah, the payout ratio is high and your dividend. growth is going to be like two to three percent annually. But combine that with like a five percent initial yield, even when
- 32:10
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): it was cheap, like a six or seven percent initial yield, and that can be a lucrative kind of place for dividend investors to be. So yeah, overall, big fan of Embridge. I I'm just, you know, like at like $70, is I think approximately where it's at is where. as we're recording. That's maybe a little bit too expensive
- 32:30
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): for me. But at the same time, the last time I bought was in 2023 when it fell to like 43. So I might be anchored to that price. Bob, thoughts?
- 32:39
- Bob: Yeah, I I think we would own Embridge if we were starting out maybe 9 at 69 or 70 seventy bucks. I think that's a little bit too high. I think the magic yield EO number, if you look at the historical EO, I think north of six percent would be where I'd be like, Oh, that looks really good. I mean, same thing as you, Nelson. We were
- 32:58
- Bob: buying things when it was like north of six close to seven percent.
- 33:05
- Bob: And we were loading up because we thought, Oh, this is really good opportunity. So if you're starting now, definitely do that. You don't need to just deploy all your cash all at once. But at that that's a different discussion. That's because that's a dollar cost average versus a lump sum. But yeah, I would definitely pick Enbridge as one of these stocks in my dividend portfolio. No problem there. Moving on.
- 33:25
- Bob: The next up that Jim and I picked was Fortas. Claw also picked Fortas. Fortas kind of like Enbridge. It's not oil and gas, but it's a typical utility company, right? So regulate r provides electric and gas t in Canada, US, and the Caribbean. I think it's
- 33:45
- Bob: one of the bonus dividend growth companies. I think Canadian utilities may have be for this by less than five
- 33:53
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
- 33:53
- Bob: year or two. Yeah. So it's grown fifty plus years of dividends. So yeah, very, very defensive. Again, we talk talked about Apple. earlier. Fortas is probably on the opposite end, where it's like super defensive, super conservative. Look, I think every dividend investor should have Fortas in their dividend
- 34:13
- Bob: portfolio. And probably in the bottom half or even in the middle. I would not hold Fordas as one of the top tens, although if you only have twenty top tens ten is quite a well, maybe top five if you only have twenty dividend stocks. But yeah, no problem holding for this.
- 34:30
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, I agree. The it's days of eight to ten percent dividend growth are behind it. You're not gonna get that with four dish. You're gonna get kind of like four to six percent, and I would always probably say like closer to four. But at the same time, like this is a really solid operator with a lot of history behind it. And yeah, the balance sheet is
- 34:50
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): it's a little bit high, you know, but utilities are always a little bit high. So in terms of like the kind of the its group, it's fine compared to like kind of other parts of the market. And yeah, it's it's uh the debt's a little excessive. But I own four and as long as he keeps raising that dividend in that kind of four to six percent range, I am happy to just sort of sit back,
- 35:10
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): relax, and uh, you know, hold it. But would I buy more? Not right now. No. I would want it to get low and kind of like I'd look at that 10-year dividend, the average yield over 10 years and say, okay, like, am I getting a bargain based on that dividend yield? Okay, then at that point I'll add, but not right now. Okay, let's go to the next one on
- 35:30
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): the this is Gemini. Um also So Claude picked this one as well. So this is intact financial. We've talked about this one before. largest Canadian property and casualty insurer. They've made uh acquisitions into the United States and then into Europe, more like specialty lines in those um
- 35:50
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): countries. But it's one has consistently grown its dividend by about 10% annually since its 2005, I think, IPO. So it's just like a wonderful record of just sort of consistent. earnings growth, consistent dividend growth, fantastic underwriting. These guys take better combined ratios,
- 36:10
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): which is sort of like the how profitable your underwriting is. They're consistently better than a lot of peers. So I really like that about Intact. And the other thing I like about Intact is they're quietly buying up like hundreds of insurance brokerages across Canada to the point where there's all sorts of brokerages that you guys would probably deal with,
- 36:29
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): where it's like you have no idea that they're owned by intact. So one, I think brokerages are pretty good businesses because you do get the broker on your side to kind of like shop, you know, like the insurance policies for you and stuff. And two, what a convenient way to sell your own insurance policies through the broker that you own. If there are
- 36:49
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): four quotes that are about the same, the person there can kind of be steered to the uh pushing the intact one to the customer. So I like that as a long term for these guys. Bob, any thoughts?
- 37:02
- Bob: Yeah, we we own this one as one of when we got into intact before the financial crisis, held onto to it, It's done really well. Again, it's a it's a little different dividend than payer yield EO payer, but as has grown dividend consistently year over year. Yeah, no problem holding it. It's done really well. It's good. Right now
- 37:22
- Bob: it's, I think it's around 52 week low or close to it. So yeah, I would maybe buy more at current price. The only thing really maybe a risk is if we start seeing more and more severe weather events causing elevated claim payout. payouts, that could be quite detrimental
- 37:42
- Bob: to Intact Financial. But look, they they're really good underwriters. I'm sure the smart people were at Intact Financial would figure out how to update from that. So yeah, I would hold IFC no problem in my dividend portfolio. All right, next up that Gemini pick was Billy Financial, I
- 38:02
- Bob: think it's called.
- 38:03
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Eli Lilly is a
- 38:05
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Eli
- 38:05
- Bob: Lilly, sorry, my yeah. Eli Lilly. Obviously, I don't know that well, I'm I'm actually getting mistaken by another company. Uh yeah, it's a it's a global pharmaceutical company leading in diabetes, obesity, and oncology treatment. Gemini included because There's long-term revenue growth trajectory, robust dividend expansion
- 38:25
- Bob: capability, pros are
- 38:27
- Bob: very dominant in the in this weight loss market. Cons will be high earnings, valuation multiple, low EO due to very high stock price appreciation. The key risks are patent expirations, drug trial setbacks, government drug policies, et
- 38:47
- Bob: cetera, mandate. As as you could tell, I don't really know this technology. Well, we don't really play any healthcare too much because I'm not an expert in healthcare. So I tend to stay away from it. I haven't had the chance to look at the the chart yet, but for me, I don't know enough about it personally. If I were to build the portfolio
- 39:07
- Bob: even in my mid 30s or even early 20s, 20, I would not touch it. Plus with drugs, it just like one bad
- 39:15
- Bob: trial sets the company back so much. And that's super risky. And then it's like patents. Typically, drug companies have patents on their new drugs for a certain number of years. And then all of a sudden you start seeing generic brands coming out. Like titano is one example. You could see titanos, and then you can see like the store brand, basically the same
- 39:35
- Bob: thing. Oh, there's a better bit of risk there. I'm just not comfortable holding. a drug company long term.
- 39:41
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, that's a really great point because I 1% agree. Where it's like I look at an individual drug company and it's like, I don't understand, you know, Eli Lilly, the share price has gone up so fast, so quickly, because of the hype around their GLP one, the whatever their Ozepic Ozempic version is called. And it's like, I don't know
- 40:01
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): enough about that market to determine. who the winner is going to be. And, you know, another drug company I looked at more recently is one called Zotis. And that one is drugs for like animals. And it's like, okay, well, I like that kind of long term play. But then it's like, is their
- 40:19
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): drug for you know, like dogs better than like someone else's drug for dogs? And I just couldn't get around kind of that. like knowing, like having that comfort in that. So my view is that if you are going to hold drugs, like do a basket of them. You'll find like there's at least a
- 40:38
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): dozen kind of pharmaceutical stocks in North America. Um, it's always actually European, but it's like they trades in New York. That's one that, like, you know, do the basket, take kind of your chances, and then if one does blow. up and like their big drug kind of just doesn't work, then you're not totally screwed. And you might say, well, like if Eli Lily is
- 40:58
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): 5% of your portfolio, then you're protected that way as well. Which, yeah, okay, like that's kind of there's a bit of like a higher risk, higher reward thing there. Where if you take the You kind of every all of them put them in a basket, or maybe you like wait till they're cheap and they put them in a basket, then I think the long term upside would be better and you
- 41:18
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): get kind of the better dividend yield as well to start with. But like saying that, I don't own any any healthcare in my portfolio. No, that's not true. I do own a small bit of a small gap called DHT Healthcare, which buys royalties on pharmaceuticals. So that's my exposure. But yeah, Bobby nailed it with the risks. I would
- 41:39
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): be cautious when it comes to this one.
- 41:42
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All
- 41:42
- Bob: right. Next up. I'll send you on to
- 41:44
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): tell
- 41:45
- Bob: the reader what Gemini picked.
- 41:46
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, I just gotta find it here. Next one. Oh, this is a fun one. Speaking of kind of the opposite of Eli Lilly, which is Altria, the cigarette company. So the uh cigarettes have been like just this, and of course, like cigarettes for a long time were kind of this it's is sin stock, right? Where it's like you you felt bad for owning
- 42:06
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): it, but you owned it because the dividend felt good. And then you got a little bit of dividend growth on top of that. And yes, the market for smokers was slowly shrinking, which is good for society, good for everyone's health, but you know, potentially bad news for the dividends. But the pricing power was good enough that you could push that through. And of course, Altria had the uh was
- 42:26
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): part of the Philip Morris breakup. And so Altria was the US side of the business, which actually had the like the lowest growth, where Philip Morris, which had like the international operations, had a bit of higher growth because there are certain markets where actually smoking is increasing. One of them is Indonesia, interestingly enough, where like folks are picking it up,
- 42:47
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): which that's maybe not the best move for them. But so the the play now with tobacco though is the smokeless products, the pouches, the you know, vaping and things like that. That that's the growth kind of this for way to do it. And that gets more complicated because it's like now there are kind of
- 43:06
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): multiple players in this market. And it's a little bit harder to kind of figure out where it's like, you
- 43:12
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,
- 43:12
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): you picked a cigarette brand, you like that cigarette brand and you smoked until you died. It's a little bit harder for the kind of like this other stuff that they're expanded into. So that's kind of my only concern there. But saying that the combination of, you know, like if you are patient and you bought it, and I do own a little bit of Ultra
- 43:32
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): and I believe I locked walked in at like a seven or eight percent yield when it was like unloved, I got like dividend growth on top of that. I also own some British American tobacco, and that was the same thing where it's like I bought that at a 10% yield, and it's actually increased the dividend a couple times since I bought it. So, like that's the appeal of these tobacco stocks. Can you one
- 43:52
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): get over the part of it? And will they be able to continue that growth? Are these new products a growth market for them or are they a will they win here? Will they not win here? That's a tougher question for me.
- 44:08
- Bob: So if you were to build a dividend portfolio today, would you own Ultra?
- 44:13
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Woohoo who that's a good question. No, because I think one of those ones that you have to buy it when it's when nobody likes it. And then you know you get rid of it when everybody likes it again. So like I just like right now, I it's a hold for me and it could very well be a sell for
- 44:33
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): me because it is such a small position. We talked before about how I'm looking to consolidate a few of my positions, and it's quite a small one. So I'm just I'm not that excited about buying it today. So yeah, that would be my thoughts.
- 44:45
- Bob: Makes sense. For us, we don't look at the tobacco industry allergies for ethical reasons. I Like I I don't enjoy the smell of smoke or cigarette tobaccos in general. So I just stay away from it. And you know, there there's some other personal reasons. So, you know, I know who they are, just I I stay away from it. So that that would be my my
- 45:05
- Bob: reason. And and again, like what Nelson said, if you were to starting out today, the price I think it's too high to make it make sense to buy and hold it for long term. So for that reason I'm not buying and so on. So this is getting a little bit long. So maybe we'll just do a couple more and then we'll we'll split the the other the rest
- 45:25
- Bob: to a second part. We may even need to do three parts. We'll see how the second part goes. So the next one that Gemini picked and interesting interestingly enough Claude also picked it is Microsoft. So Microsoft I think everybody knows about it, as a giant tech company, you know, used to be very
- 45:45
- Bob: prominent with Windows, but they have now really into a lot of different things, like Cloud Office is one. And unlike previously, and I absolutely hate this with the software companies, instead of just buying all these software once, you now have to pay monthly subscription. fees. Terrible for
- 46:04
- Bob: consumers, but excellent for these software companies. It has done quite well, Microsoft consistently buy back shares, increasing dividends, and so on and so on. Very stronghold in terms of the productivity software. Really, the con is like very, very low dividend yields. Any of these high-tech companies, super low dividend yields. That's
- 46:24
- Bob: not, they're not there to pay you dividends extended. It's essentially just incentivize you to hold the company and give you a little bit of cash here and there. So yeah, I would I own Microsoft if I were starting out. We currently don't own Microsoft today. I looked at multiple times to get Microsoft, but our portfolio already has
- 46:44
- Bob: too many stocks to begin with. So I'm not looking to add another new one. That's probably the main reason why. we haven't added Microsoft. I guess the key risk with Microsoft today is again a lot of concerns with how much money they're pumping to to our AI. So that that's one concern. And there's very stiff
- 47:03
- Bob: competition when it comes to cloud, right? The Amazon, AWS, Google's cloud, Out. there's a lot of antitrust scrutiny with Microsoft. They went through that with EU, and so on. So would the company continue to grow and is a long-term hull? I think so. If I were starting out
- 47:23
- Bob: in my mid-30s, yeah, I would probably look into buy Microsoft if I have any US cash lying around. Yeah, I it would not be my top five I pick. Actually, no, I might I might swap Microsoft out for Apple. I think both of them would be pretty. strong. So if you have Microsoft in your top five, I wouldn't have my
- 47:44
- Bob: Apple in your top five and vice versa. Nelson, what about you?
- 47:47
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, that's a good summary. My view is that the Microsofts, the Apples, the like all the tech stocks are, you know, like, I'm not gonna say expensive because it makes me sound like you know, a Doomer who thinks that LNASEC's the NASDAQ's gonna fall 80%. And I don't believe that. These are very real. businesses, unlike in 1999. But my view is that like when you're
- 48:07
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): buying something like Microsoft at say closer to like 30 times earnings rather than 20 times earnings, more has to go right in order for you to win. And in their credit, to their credit, for the last 15 years for Microsoft, pretty much everything has gone right. Of course, I'm old enough, and Bob, you're old enough too. You can remember where like Microsoft bought Nokia, Microsoft bought.
- 48:27
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Skype. And these were deals that that at the time it was like, what are these morons doing? Like they were just universally disliked. And you know, Microsoft got to the point where it was very, very cheap. It was like 10 times earnings for years. You know, nobody wanted it. And to their credit, you know, like I said, they've done very well. But my view is that great company,
- 48:47
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): you just want to wait until it's maybe like not as expensive. as what it normally is, but that introduces the world of pissed out and you know, like I I know from experience that there's nothing worse than investing than being able to look back at some company that you liked a
- 49:07
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): long time ago at a cheap price, and it's like, hey, it's done fantastically well, and you just sat on your thumbs the whole time, just not doing anything. So I get it from that perspective. But in terms of Microsoft, like, you know, I would love to own it, just not at these prices.
- 49:21
- Bob: Great. All right. With I think we're
- 49:24
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in
- 49:24
- Bob: recording for a while now. So let's just do the last stock and then we'll we'll split the rest into the second part or put potentially third part. So the
- 49:34
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
- 49:35
- Bob: next stock that Gem Knight picked, let me just scroll down here. Not a stock that I really monitor. It's a United Health Group, UNH in the US. Just reading what Gem Knight spit out. So it's the largest US managed healthcare provider. Y Incula is very big scale
- 49:54
- Bob: in healthcare, benefiting from um data-driven data driven care delivery with 12% twelve percent plus dividend growth. So that's interesting. So pros demographically back tailwind, so people are getting older, sticky enterprise insurance contracts, cons would be complex regulatory environments subject to
- 50:14
- Bob: political shifts. That's always a concern with healthcare. So key risks, medical loss ratio spikes likes and regulatory policy changes in the US. So yeah, very heavy on on regulatory because if if the US government changes something, that's a direct impact to this company. Looking at the charts, looks like
- 50:35
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
- 50:35
- Bob: one year it's it's close to its fifty two week high. Yields is around two percent. Look, I don't know enough about this stock, so I probably wouldn't hold it Bit just for that reason. But if you were to bet on the the aging Asian population, population, maybe this would be a stock to hold long term. With US
- 50:55
- Bob: stock, you always have to consider the exchange rate, as I mentioned earlier. So that's another reason to rethink. Maybe there's some a similar stock in Canada. I don't know. But if I were to go into this Asian population sector and try to profit from that, I would pick take a US stock rather than Canadian. Canadians just because
- 51:15
- Bob: a way larger population in the US. Nelson, what about you?
- 51:19
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, and also Canada really does not have a lot of good healthcare stocks. Our our sector versus the US sector is just like there's nothing. You know, we do have um yeah, like like I can't even think of very many. Like we're but in the US, there's just there's so many. So yeah, I agree with you on on that aspect. But what I really find
- 51:39
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): interesting with United Health Group is that I want to talk about this great segue into how you can't just trust AI's kind of interpretation because Bob you mentioned Gemini told you that there's a United Health is a 12% dividend growth rate and that is true through
- 51:58
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): 2025. In 2026 United Health raised the dividend by 5%, which is still a decent number, but is far below 12%. And that could completely change the investment thesis. And it's like, so do you believe that United Health is going to increase earnings
- 52:18
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): by 12% annually? Because that's where dividend growth comes from, is earnings growth. We all know this. So, like, and that question is a lot harder to answer. versus looking backwards and saying, hey, like look, they've increased by 12% annually. Like, you know, look at this thing go. So that's the issue. And I look at you know like kind of medical insurance in the US, and we're Canadians, and you know,
- 52:38
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): like the majority of you listening are Canadians. So we really don't have a lot of experience with this world. But I just I see how it gets politically charged very quickly. You know, like of course the executive who was killed, unfortunately, you know, like that that's a he was targeted because he was an executive of this company. It didn't look like he did anything wrong.
- 52:58
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): He just like was a and that's the worry about United Healthcare for the but I think the like the more important point is not in United Healthcare. It's just hey, like AI is part of the tools that you can use to research by but verify this stuff yourself. Use it as like
- 53:18
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): idea generation. You know, let it help you, but like don't outsource your thinking to AI. And as much fun as it is to like, you know, we're kind of wrapping this up here right now, as but as much fun as it is for us to do this and like, hey, like this is fun. Let's see what AI has to say. I'm not putting my money into anything because
- 53:38
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): AI tells me to. I'm using AI as a generation idea generation tool, and then it's like, oh, that's interesting. Never considered that. And then I would go and research that on my own. And that's, you know, kind of for me the I think the important message that I want to make sure everyone knows. But yeah. Bob, any last thoughts here?
- 53:54
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
- 53:55
- Bob: I agree with you. I see AI as a tool, it's is not a tool that I would want to depend it on for decision making. It's good for pulling a lot of data and you know, do reduce your research time per se. You could give it like a, you know, a quality report and then try to ask
- 54:14
- Bob: AI to summarize it. Now there's always always a problem. I might summarize it wrong. So you you also have to have your own analytical skills to go through and do your own research, think for yourself. That's very important. So yeah I think so far, I mean, we we didn't name all these stocks, but you could see where this is going. It definitely had some very solid
- 54:34
- Bob: picks. Some are more questionable. So again, use AI as an idea generation and do your own research. But I think in part two of this episode FSO next week, I think we'll mention the rest and give you more idea. why why some of these stocks were picked and so on. So yeah,
- 54:54
- Bob: I think it this is interesting, interesting exercise. But I would not just blindly say if Gemini or Claw or even if I had my own AI agent just say, look, here's fifty thousand dollars, go buy 20 dividend stocks for me. I would not do that. I would even if I do a lot of back tests, I know some of my colleagues,
- 55:14
- Bob: ex-colleagues had built AI agents and where they're building models and they're back checking trades they have done and then try to analyze how they could do it better. Even with that and doing a lot of back checks, I would not be comfortable using AI or AI agents to trade for me. Because ultimately,
- 55:34
- Bob: I think you need to make your own minded decision. It's kind of like handing your money to a a management company. I guess you're paying them to manage your company, but you still you can't just be completely hands off. You still need to have interest in your own money and know a little bit about how your money is being invested. Don't just be like,
- 55:54
- Bob: oh, this is completely passive because I have an AI agent And trading for me that could go wrong. Very, very wrong. I mean it you could can also go very well. but just know the risks.
- 56:04
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah. I think it's like, for me, it's it's kind of the the like art of the craft. And it's like, what are you talking about, Nelson? Like it's money, it's not a craft. It's like, yeah, but it's like, it's your decisions. It's your, you know, like like the CFO of my household. I get to direct
- 56:24
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): things and I get to have some influence on that. And so if I take that responsibility and I outsource it to whatever AI agent, like it's like I don't even have to think for myself anymore. Like that's not how I want to go through life. I don't want to go through life like outsourcing important decisions to like a
- 56:44
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): computer. And as smart as like I know it's not on a computer, you know, I'm getting that wrong. But like like the point is is like, you know, there's there comes a point when you outsource so much of your thinking to these tools that you're not actually thinking for yourself anymore and you know like obviously I want to keep thinking for myself or else
- 57:04
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): like why else am I you know why else exist? It's kind of a bit of a bummer to end the episode on but here we are.
- 57:10
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah
- 57:11
- Bob: so with that I think we'll end the episode today we'll we could go for long rants about AI. But yeah, with that, let us know what you think about this idea. Obviously we'll finish the remainder of the Star Picks by Gemini and Claude. But yeah, as always, leave us a comment and let us know. With that, thank
- 57:31
- Bob: you very much for tuning in.
- 57:32
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): If
- 57:33
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you enjoyed the show, make sure you subscribe to never miss another episode. For more from Bob, visit his site. at tautan.com. That's T-A-W-C-A-N, all one word. Nelson can be found at Canadian DivdinBesting.com. They're both on Twitter as well, to search for Talkan or CDI newsletter. Thanks. See
- 57:53
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you next time.
More from DIY Wealth Canada Podcast
Ep 48 - Should You Pay off The Mortgage? Plus Dividends vs. Indexing and End of Year Financial Checklist
Episode discussion: DIY Wealth Canada Ep 48: Mortgage Payoff, Dividends vs Indexing, Year-End Checklist
Speakers’ claims: Bob and Nelson debate whether retirees should rely on dividends or sell shares, citing sequence of return risk and tax implications. They discuss the merits of paying off mortgages versus leveraging for investment, with Nelson sharing a personal experience of variable rate mortgage risks. The hosts outline an end-of-year financial checklist including tax-loss selling and account maximization. Additional speakers emphasize the importance of annual financial reviews, spousal communication, and tracking progress against goals using presentation templates.
Ep 47 - How Do We Decide When to Buy a Stock?
Episode discussion: Hosts discuss using 52-week lows, valuation metrics, and averaging strategies to identify stock buying opportunities.
Speakers’ claims: Bob and Nelson explore stock selection frameworks, starting with 52-week lows as a screening tool to identify undervalued assets while warning against 'falling knife' risks. They evaluate valuation methods including P/E ratios, dividend yields, the Chowder Rule, and Graham Number, noting sector-specific variations. The hosts contrast averaging down with averaging up, using examples like Apple and TD Bank to illustrate when each strategy is appropriate. They introduce a '10-year survival test' inspired by Warren Buffett to assess long-term holding suitability. Finally, they advocate for a flexible investment approach that combines multiple strategies rather than adhering to a single rigid rule.