DoorDash agrees to $17B Instacart acquisition amid antitrust scrutiny; other M&A rumors discussed
Summary
Hosts Asif and Dhmanas Surya discuss four potential corporate transactions. The primary focus is DoorDash's $17 billion all-cash acquisition of Instacart, which carries a wide 13% deal spread due to regulatory concerns. The hosts also cover a $39 per share buyout offer for Dine Brands, rumors of Marvell acquiring Lumentum for over $75 billion, and potential spinoff rumors for S&P Global's CapIQ unit. They note that most rumored deals fail to materialize and highlight specific regulatory risks facing the DoorDash-Instacart merger.
Key takeaways
- 1 Approximately 58% of rumored deals that do not result in a signed definitive merger agreement fail to materialize, meaning only 42% of rumors become actual deals.
Asif Surya · 1:12
Episode sections
- 0:06 – 0:52
Introduction and Disclaimer
Hosts introduce Episode 75, outlining four stories: Dine Brands, Lumentum/Marvell, DoorDash/Instacart, and S&P Global CapIQ spinoff. They disclose potential positions and state content is not investment advice.
- 0:52 – 8:46
Dine Brands Global Potential Acquisition
An investor group including Cobbler's Cove Capital and Ark House Management offers $39/share cash for Dine Brands (DIN), trading at ~$35.51. The group holds 20% exposure via swaps. Dine Brands adopted a poison pill provision in response.
- 8:46 – 13:25
Marvell Technology and Lumentum Holdings Rumored Deal
Rumors surface that Marvell Technology (MRVL) is in talks to acquire Lumentum Holdings (LITE) in a deal valued at over $75 billion. Lumentum's optical components are sold out through 2029. Marvell's stock dropped below $200 on the news.
- 13:25 – 21:07
DoorDash Acquires Instacart (Maplebear)
DoorDash (DASH) agreed to acquire Instacart (MAP) for $17 billion, offering $65/share cash (11.26% premium). The deal faces a wide 13% spread, reflecting regulatory antitrust concerns. Expected close late 2027 or early 2028.
- 21:07 – 30:25
S&P Global CapIQ Spinoff Rumors
S&P Global (SPGI) is considering spinning off its Capital IQ business, following the recent separation of its Mobility segment. The Capital IQ unit includes financial data platforms like SNL and Visible Alpha. S&P Global trades at a lower valuation multiple than Moody's.
Assets discussed
| Asset | Kind | Stance | Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| DoorDash, Inc.DASH | equity | neutral | we felt as though the acquisition of Instacart, which publicly trades as Maple Bear by Doordash was far too big of a deal, and pun intended on both ends there to not mention. Now on october twenty ninth, DoorDash entered into a merger agreement to acquire Instacart in a deal valued at seventeen $17 billion. |
“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.
Claims worth verifying
Only 42% of rumors or potential deals translate into actual deals.
Asif Surya ·1:12
How to verify: Internal data analysis by Inside Arbitrage; verify via their proprietary database or published reports on deal completion rates. For recent events, verify 2026-08-02 through 2026-11-02. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Dine Brands Global stock rose from ~$32 to $35.51 per share after the buyout offer was made public.
Asif Surya ·5:32
How to verify: SEC EDGAR filings (Schedule 13D or 13D/G) and historical stock price data from Yahoo Finance or Bloomberg for DIN. For recent events, verify 2026-08-02 through 2026-11-02. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceDine Brands has a market cap of about $450 million and debt of about $1.1 billion, resulting in a $1.6 billion total deal value.
Asif Surya ·5:52
How to verify: S&P Capital IQ or Bloomberg terminal for DIN market cap, debt, and equity value calculations. For recent events, verify 2026-08-02 through 2026-11-02. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Cobbler's Cove Capital is a relatively new firm and Ark House Management has a little over $100 million in assets under management.
Asif Surya ·6:55
How to verify: SEC Form ADV filings for Ark House Management to verify AUM; news archives for Cobbler's Cove founding date. For recent events, verify 2026-08-02 through 2026-11-02. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceCobbler's Cove secured a $1 billion investment commitment from Oaktree Capital.
Asif Surya ·7:14
How to verify: Press releases from Oaktree Capital or Brookfield; SEC filings if disclosed as a material investment. For recent events, verify 2026-08-02 through 2026-11-02. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceBrigade had previously partnered with Ark House Management to take Macy's private for $21/share, increasing to $24/share.
Asif Surya ·7:54
How to verify: SEC EDGAR filings for Macy's (M) regarding the 2026 activist campaign and bid history. For recent events, verify 2026-08-02 through 2026-11-02. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceMarvell Technology generated nearly half a billion dollars of free cash flow each quarter.
Asif Surya ·12:24
How to verify: Marvell Technology (MRVL) quarterly earnings reports (10-Q) filed with SEC EDGAR. For recent events, verify 2026-08-02 through 2026-11-02. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceDoorDash entered into a merger agreement to acquire Instacart on October 29th for $17 billion.
Dhmanas Surya ·13:44
How to verify: SEC EDGAR filing of the Definitive Proxy Statement (DEFM14A) or Merger Agreement between DASH and MAP. For recent events, verify 2026-08-02 through 2026-11-02. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceInstacart completed 338 million orders last year; DoorDash completed more than 3 billion orders.
Dhmanas Surya ·14:23
How to verify: Company press releases or investor presentations from MAP and DASH detailing operational metrics. For recent events, verify 2026-08-02 through 2026-11-02. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The $65 per share cash offer represents a premium of 11.26% over Instacart's last closing price.
Dhmanas Surya ·15:22
How to verify: Calculation based on the $65 offer price and the closing price of MAP stock on the day prior to the announcement. For recent events, verify 2026-08-02 through 2026-11-02. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Review the definitive merger agreement (if filed) or proxy statements for Dine Brands (DIN) to verify the poison pill terms and investor group details.
- Check SEC filings (Schedule 13D/G) for Marvell (MRVL) and Lumentum (LITE) to confirm or deny the rumored $75 billion acquisition talks.
- Analyze FTC enforcement actions and recent merger approvals in the food delivery sector to assess regulatory risk for the DoorDash-Instacart deal.
- Verify S&P Global's (SPGI) recent segment reporting and investor presentations regarding the potential spinoff of Capital IQ.
- Compare the deal spread and regulatory commentary for DoorDash-Instacart against historical precedent for similar-sized tech acquisitions.
- Review Oaktree Capital's (Brookfield) public disclosures to confirm the $1 billion commitment to the Dine Brands deal.
- Check Lumentum's (LITE) earnings calls and supply chain updates to validate the claim of sold-out capacity through 2029.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:06
- Asif Surya: Hello and welcome to episode seventy-five of the Special Situations Report, a podcast by Inside Arbitrage covering the most intriguing event-driven activity over the past week. My name is Asif Surya.
- 0:19
- Dhmanas Surya: And my name is Dhmanas Surya.
- 0:20
- Asif Surya: And to help us spread the word about this podcast, please take a moment to like and subscribe to this podcast on whatever platform you may be listening on.
- 0:29
- Dhmanas Surya: Today we wanted to focus on four key stories, including two potential deals, Doordash's acquisition of Instacart, and SP Global considering a separation of its CapIQ business. Before we begin, we want to state that nothing on this podcast is meant as investment advice. We or our clients may hold a position in any of the stocks discussed today, and
- 0:48
- Dhmanas Surya: please refer to our full disclaimer at the end of the podcast for more details.
- 0:52
- Asif Surya: Let's kick this podcast off by talking about a potential deal where a buyer group is willing to pay $39 per share in cash and the stock is just trading a little over $35 per share. So there's almost $4 per share of potential profit left if the deal materializes. The buyer group has also indicated that they're
- 1:12
- Asif Surya: willing to negotiate a higher price. So the potential profit could be even more. But as we all know, potential deals don't always translate into a signing definitive merger agreement. And so, based on our data, we've seen that only 42% of these rumors or potential deals translate into actual deals. With that caveat, let's talk about this
- 1:32
- Asif Surya: deal, which is actually quite interesting. These days it feels like there is more drama with casual dining chains than. we've seen anytime in the past. First, there was the whole rebranding of Cracker Barrel from last year that supposedly alienated its customer base after the logo was redesigned and they attempted
- 1:52
- Asif Surya: to redesign their restaurants to appeal to younger customers. I've been to Cracker Barrel a few times and I can see why its customers would be upset when that you know familiar, home. homey, warm atmosphere is changed to something else that they weren't quite used to. That whole strategy backfired on the company after conservative
- 2:11
- Asif Surya: commentators and even President Trump spoke out against the redesign. More importantly, traffic at their restaurants fell 8% after the logo redesign was announced. The other hand, Cheesecake Factory, which has the wonderful ticker cake, announced. strong third-quarter earnings that handily beat expectations. And the stock
- 2:31
- Asif Surya: is now up 137% over the last year. Similarly, Brinker International, which has the equally cool ticker Eat and operates the Chili's brands and Margianos Little Italy, has seen its stock price rise raise 102% over the last year. The reason I bring all of this up. is because
- 2:51
- Asif Surya: there's another casual dining company that has not done quite as well as Cheesecake Factory or Brinker International. And it is now facing pressure from an investor group that wants to buy the company.
- 3:03
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
- 3:03
- Asif Surya: company is Dine Brands Global. And while you might not have heard about this company, it does operate some very familiar brands, which is Applebee's and iHaw. The ticker, however, is a little less exciting, and the ticker is a D-I-N or Diddy.
- 3:20
- Dhmanas Surya: Interestingly enough, I don't think I've ever been to a restaurant operated by Dine Brands. But that being said, that might actually be an issue with myself because for the first time in 20 years, I had Denny's this summer. So perhaps this is just me and my In restaurant and experience. I'm curious though, how has Dine Brands compared to Brinker and Chicago? Cheesecake over a longer term? Because in the
- 3:40
- Dhmanas Surya: short term, it seems like these two are performing far better. Yeah,
- 3:43
- Asif Surya: compared to Brinker International, which has seen its stock price increase nearly 400% over the last five years, as it has managed to attract a younger customer base. And even Cheesecake Factory, which is up 165% over the last five years, Dyne Brands has seen its stock decline by nearly
- 4:03
- Asif Surya: 60% over the same time period. And this is despite a gain of 47% over the last year. So despite this one-year gain, it's down 60% over the same time period. Which brings us to the potential deal situation or a deals in the works situations, as we like to call them. An investor group, including
- 4:23
- Asif Surya: Cobbler's Cove Capital, and Arch Ark House Management, offer offered to buy Dyne brands for $39 per share in cash. The group already has economic exposure to 20% of Dyne brands through swaps and other instruments. What is absolutely fascinating is that this group of investors, even
- 4:43
- Asif Surya: willing to increase the price, pending due diligence. So that's not something you often see when bids are made for companies. You know, they make a bid and they hope they get it for the same price, or they might pay a slightly higher price once they get into negotiations. But to open and say, hey, we are willing to pay $39 and we're we might even pay more than that is highly
- 5:02
- Asif Surya: unusual.
- 5:03
- Dhmanas Surya: Interesting. So given how the investor group seems to be open to engaging with the company, how did Dyne brands engage with this investor group? What Who do they consider the offer at all?
- 5:13
- Asif Surya: They did the exact opposite. And instead they adopted a poison full provision, which, as you know, is a method to dilute the stake of an investor that is trying to buy a company by issuing additional shares to the other investors who are not involved at a discount. We've seen this over and over again. People soft tried this with Oracle to try to
- 5:32
- Asif Surya: stop them. And more often than not, it doesn't always work. Dyne brand brands stock rose from about 30%. $32 per share to $35.51 per share last Friday after this buyout offer was made public. Dyne Brands has a market cap of about $450 million, and this offer is around a half a
- 5:52
- Asif Surya: billion dollars of equity value. So this is important. It's not a half a billion dollar total value for the company. Once you include the debt of about $1.1 billion as you should when you consider acquisitions, the total deal value increases to $1.6 billion. According to generally accepted accounting
- 6:12
- Asif Surya: principles, you should also include about half a billion dollars of capital lease obligations that Dyne carries on its balance sheet. But I'm an old school investor and I'm not including those lease obligations in my debt calculations to come up with the $1.6 billion deal. value.
- 6:27
- Dhmanas Surya: Okay, so that's a pretty sizable deal. I'm wondering, does the investor group that wants to take Dyne Brands private have the money to complete this sort of deal?
- 6:35
- Asif Surya: Yeah, it's always about show me the money. So this is a very important question. And I looked into both Cobbler's Cove Capital. I just love that name, Cobbler's Cove Capital. Yeah. And Ark House Management. It turns out that Cobbler's Cove is a relatively new firm and Arkhouse Ark House Management only has a little over $100 million in assets under management.
- 6:55
- Asif Surya: So, how can these two firms, a new firm and one with not a very large amount of AUM, manage to buy a company for $1.6 billion? Where it gets really interesting is that Cobbler's Cove has secured a $1 billion Dollar investment commitment from Oak Tree Capital, which is now owned by the massive firm Brookfund.
- 7:14
- Asif Surya: Brookfield. Oak Tree has also indicated that it would be open to co-investing with the firm. So maybe there's a billion dollars that has committed, and maybe, you know, because Oak Tree is a credit-focused firm, they might be willing to take on some of this debt that sits on Dyne's balance sheet. Coblo's Co. was started by Matt Perkhile, who previously served as the head of
- 7:34
- Asif Surya: special situations at Brigade, a credit-focused firm that has over $30. $31 billion in assets under management. And this is where it gets even more interesting. Brigade had previously partnered with Arkhouse Management, the same company that Cobbler's Co. was working with this time, to try to take Macy's private for $21 per
- 7:54
- Asif Surya: share. And then, just like they offered with Dyne, they increased their price to $24 per share in cash. Macy's turned down that offer. claiming that they were not sure that the bidders had sufficient financing to close the deal. More than two years later, Macy's still trades around that same $25 offer price. Getting back to fast
- 8:14
- Asif Surya: casual dining restaurant chains, this whole situation reminds me a little bit about what you talked about. You've tried Denny's for the first time earlier this year. And so Denny's was taken private earlier this year for $620 million.
- 8:26
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
- 8:27
- Dhmanas Surya: it'll be interesting to see if Dyne Brand continues and follows the trend of Denny's in terms of getting private. Dobbs a Macy's approach.
- 8:34
- Asif Surya: Indeed. And the whole situation here with the poison pill provision gives me a little bit of pause. Otherwise, you know, the stock being available for 35, the offer on the table is already $39. This would have been exciting.
- 8:46
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
- 8:47
- Asif Surya: let's switch to something else that I'm actually less excited about. This is another potential deal situation. We have held a position in the custom chipmaker Marvel Technology for a little over a year and a half in the Inside Arbitrage model portfolio. And I also personally own a position in the company. Marvel Technology, unlike the
- 9:06
- Asif Surya: superhero focused company with a similar name that Disney acquired, focuses on building custom AI and networking. chips for companies like Amazon and Meta. The stock is up 114% in the model portfolio, but it was up a whole lot more before the big semiconductor and AI-related
- 9:26
- Asif Surya: pullback that we experienced last month. We picked up Marvel when it was trading around $92 per share and held through a drop that took the stock down to the $50 level. Marvel, in many ways, was the unloved stepchild of custom semiconductor chip companies. And the love and adulation usually flowed
- 9:46
- Asif Surya: towards Nvidia and Marvel's much larger competitor, Broadcom. All of that changed over the last year as the revenue growth at Marvel started accelerating. And at one point, Jensen Huang mentioned that Marvel Marvell is positioned to become the next trillion dollar company. Euphoria soon came into play and that pushed
- 10:06
- Asif Surya: the stock up to $300 per share in June, but it weakened in subsequent weeks. So unfortunately, we did not sell at the $300 per share level and we're still holding on. The drop in tech stocks last month hit Marvell, but it was hurt even more last week when rumors surfaced that the company is in talks to acquire
- 10:26
- Asif Surya: optic. optical equipment maker Lumentum Holdings in a massive deal. Lumentum has seen its stock increase nearly 900% over the last five years, and its enterprise value is now over $75 billion.
- 10:41
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 10:41
- Asif Surya: mean, that whole Dyne Brands International deal at $1.6 billion dollars pales in comparison to the $75 billion potential deal.
- 10:49
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): In
- 10:50
- Asif Surya: contrast, Marwell's enterprise value is $173 billion. Why is the market so fascinated with these companies? Lumentum's revenue grew triple digits last quarter, and the company has finally started reporting real gap earnings as demand for its optical components
- 11:09
- Asif Surya: used in data centers has exploded.
- 11:12
- Dhmanas Surya: Okay, so I'm hearing that they're finally reporting real. earnings. I'm hearing there's optical components being used in data centers. But what exactly does this company do and why is it that Marvel seems to be so interested in them?
- 11:24
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
- 11:24
- Asif Surya: Lumen has a very cool ticker symbol light, but the interest goes beyond that cool ticker symbol. I wish it was just cool ticker symbols that drove up stock prices, but usually it's a little bit more than that. They make high-speed lasers that generate the light. used in optical connections to move. Lumentum also makes optical circuit
- 11:44
- Asif Surya: switches. In the article Bloomberg published about this acquisition, they mentioned that Lumentum's products are sold out through 2029. And the company mentioned it's unable to meet about 70% of demand for some of its products next year. I can see how the acquisition makes sense. as it integrates two
- 12:04
- Asif Surya: key components that are used in AI-focused data centers: custom chips and then the optical networking part of it and other optical components. But I am concerned that the deal could distract Marvel from its core business, which is finally seeing great momentum and generating nearly half a billion dollars of free cash flow each
- 12:24
- Asif Surya: quarter. This potential deal pushed down. the stock of Marvell below 200 bucks and current it trades at $193 per share. I plan to continue holding Marvel through this downturn and be interesting to see if a deal with momentum finally materializes.
- 12:40
- Dhmanas Surya: If it does, given the size of the deal, it will turn out to be one of my favorite words, It's a bonanza for all the investment banks involved. But even more than that, I wonder what the regulatory hurdles might look like.
- 12:51
- Asif Surya: You know, I given how different the business is for both these companies, Marvel and Lumentum, I don't see it being a big issue with the FTC or the DOJ.
- 13:02
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
- 13:02
- Asif Surya: if Lumentum's products are used worldwide, I often see that, especially with semiconductor deals, it takes a really long time for those approvals to come through and the spreads on the deal can be quite wide. Overall, as a Marvel, shareholder, I'm not happy about the short-term hit,
- 13:17
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
- 13:18
- Asif Surya: if Jensen Huang is right and Marvel is going to become a trillion dollar company, then maybe this momentum deal helps them get there.
- 13:24
- Dhmanas Surya: Indeed. We'll move away from potential MA into announced MA, and we can start off by talking about this week in general. It ended up being a week very ripe with special situations news. We had a lot of trouble narrowing down what exactly the story. stories for the week would be. And while this episode may seem a bit heavy on the MA side of things,
- 13:44
- Dhmanas Surya: we felt as though the acquisition of Instacart, which publicly trades as Maple Bear by Doordash was far too big of a deal, and pun intended on both ends there to not mention. Now on october twenty ninth, DoorDash entered into a merger agreement to acquire Instacart in a deal valued at seventeen $17 billion.
- 14:03
- Dhmanas Surya: While I feel like most people would know what DoorDash and Instacart are, a quick recap of both businesses is as follows. Founded in 2012, Instacart specializes in grocery convenience store deliveries across the US and Canada. The company has around 600,000 independent contractors, known as shoppers, who completed
- 14:23
- Dhmanas Surya: 338 three hundred and thirty-eight million orders last year. DoorDash is another online food and convenience delivery platform, but it operates on a much larger scale, with operations in over forty different countries, and completed more than three billion orders last year through a network of nine million independent delivery workers. The deal is
- 14:42
- Dhmanas Surya: DoorDash's biggest acquisition to date and It will help the company expand beyond restaurant deliveries into groceries and other retail categories. It will also strengthen the ability to compete with major players such as Walmart and Amazon, which have extensive networks of stores, warehouses, and delivery services. Under the agreement, Instacart
- 15:02
- Dhmanas Surya: stockholders can elect to receive cash, stock, or a combination of both. However, the stock portion of the consideration is capped at 25% twenty-five percent of the total deal value, with certain perforation agreements applying. The sixty-five dollars per share cash offer represents a premium of eleven point two six percent over Instacart's last
- 15:22
- Dhmanas Surya: closing price, and the deal spread currently stands at thirteen percent, with an annualized return of roughly eleven percent. The acquisition is expected to close at the end of 2027 or in the first half of 2028.
- 15:35
- Asif Surya: That's an unusually large spread. Usually these days we've been seeing spreads of 2 or 3%. A 13% spread on a deal tells us something doesn't quite seem right. But what do you think is going on that's causing a spread of 13% on this deal?
- 15:50
- Dhmanas Surya: Yeah, absolutely. The unusually wide deal spread reflects uncertainty over whether or not the acquisition will actually be completed, with the regulatory approval likely to be a key hurdle. Online grocery delivery has become increasingly popular as consumers place greater value on convenience. Now it makes sense that Instacart and DoorDash would want
- 16:10
- Dhmanas Surya: to merge, as Instacart's advertising and technology businesses which generate higher profit margins could further strengthen DoorDash's efforts to expand its services for restaurants and retailers. These include providing technology tools for in-person in person dining and retail advertising management. Instacart already works with major retailers such as
- 16:29
- Dhmanas Surya: Costco, which uses its technology to support online ordering in parts of North America and Europe. Now Instacart has been looking to sell itself for quite some time. Last week, Bloomberg reported that Instacart had explored a potential sale with a process that initiated discussions with Uber technologies. However, though Uber was approached by
- 16:49
- Dhmanas Surya: Instacart, the ride hand Hailing company eventually walked away from the discussions, especially considering that they had recently announced the $14.8 billion deal to acquire the German food delivery company, Delivery Hero. Now, Instacart and DoorDash began discussing a possible deal over this summer, and in early September, Instacart's CEO informed
- 17:08
- Dhmanas Surya: DoorDash's Dash's CEO that the company was considering various strategic options, as Roitos Reuters reported. Now, this is not the first time the two companies have explored a potential deal. They held acquisition talks in 2021, but the discussions reportedly fell apart over differences in valuation and concerns about possible antitrust hurdles, which
- 17:28
- Dhmanas Surya: it looks like the market has similar concerns about antitrust this time around, hence the widespread.
- 17:34
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
- 17:34
- Asif Surya: and I'm not sure the antitrust hurdles will alleviate anytime soon. I was just thinking about the fact that DoorDash, just in September, acquired Grubhub Campus Dining. Are you familiar with that program?
- 17:46
- Dhmanas Surya: No, it's not here at ECLA, at the very least.
- 17:49
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
- 17:49
- Asif Surya: so Grubhub Campus Dining supposedly allows college students to order for a zero dollar delivery fee from restaurants near campus. And that business, Grabhub Grubhub Campus Dining, was acquired by DoorDash Duodash last month. So, you know, you see some of these things where consolidation has been going on for quite some time, with Uber buying,
- 18:09
- Asif Surya: if I'm not mistaken, Postmates a long time ago. And a lot of these delivery companies have already consolidated. So I think the antitrust hurdles will continue to remain. And it'll be interesting to see how this plays out over the next year.
- 18:22
- Dhmanas Surya: And yeah, and it looks like antitrust concerns remain at even the state-based level. New York City's Department of Consumer and Worker Protection said that the proposed merger was part of a worrying trend of more companies joining together and reducing competition. New York mayor Zaran Mandani also stepped into question the acquisition, pointing to DoorDash's
- 18:42
- Dhmanas Surya: $131 million in penalties that were recently issued related to unpaid wages for delivery workers. On a more national scale, the FTC is another potential source of scrutiny. The agency, which regularly reviews mergers of involving retail and grocery businesses, has increasingly focused on issues affecting consumer spending
- 19:02
- Dhmanas Surya: and has closely examined food delivery platforms. It is currently pursuing a case against Uber over subscription practices and is considering adding a new rule to prevent food delivery companies from charging customers unexpected fees. However, DoorDash has built some connections in Washington. Earlier this year, the company supported President Strump's proposal to eliminate
- 19:22
- Dhmanas Surya: taxes on tips and delivered food to the White House to highlight how the policy had benefited its drivers. However, given that the deal between the two uniform rental companies, Cintas and Unifirst, has been thrown for a massive loop by the FDC FTC after they indicated that they would sue to block the transaction. due to concerns surrounding the competitive nature of the market.
- 19:42
- Dhmanas Surya: I'm not incredibly hopeful that this one will work out in favor of Doordash or Instacart. Perhaps the Warner Brothers deal was a regulatory exception and not the new norm after all.
- 19:52
- Asif Surya: I have to say that this FTC after Lena Khan moved on has been a little bit more accommodating of mergers and acquisition than the previous regime was. Otherwise the spread would have been even wider than it is. But that said, I agree with you. I think the consolidation in the sector has gotten to the point where this deal could get blocked. And
- 20:12
- Asif Surya: it makes sense that the FTC stepped in with Cintas and Unifirst, because other than West is there isn't too many other competitors, whether it comes to uniform rentals or towel services. I don't know if you knew that, you know, gyms and other places can get their towel. towels replaced by these companies as well. So fascinating businesses overall.
- 20:31
- Dhmanas Surya: Looks like it. And yeah, in the case of Centas and Universe, I think that was a concern going into the deal. We knew that they would have regulatory hurdles because that's the FTC's job to create these
- 20:40
- Dhmanas Surya: policies to prevent any sort of like competition elimination or any of that.
- 20:44
- Asif Surya: As long as they don't go overboard and try to stop luxury handbag makers from merging or a failing airline or a
- 20:55
- Dhmanas Surya: You're still a little burned by Capri Tapestry then I'm assuming.
- 20:59
- Asif Surya: Yes, long term investors you carry a lot of these cars and you look at every new situation with that lens, unfortunately.
- 21:07
- Dhmanas Surya: Absolutely. We'll move now to our spin spin-off off section. And while last week was quite the week for MA activity, it was perhaps all the more exciting for one of my favorite places, Spinoff Land. Madison Square Garden Sports just completed the spin-off of MSG Rangers and renamed the remaining company MSG Knickerbockers. MSGK will
- 21:27
- Dhmanas Surya: now own the New York Knicks, which is an NBA league, fresh off their championship win this summer, and the G League basketball team, the Westchester Knicks as well. MSGR instead focuses on hockey teams, holding the New York Rangers and the NHL, the Hartford Wolfpack and the AHL, and the MSG Training
- 21:46
- Dhmanas Surya: Center, which is a 100,000 square foot multi-sport practice and performance facility that serves as the training ground for many of these sports teams. We also got more information about the proposed separation of SF HF Sinclair's lubricants and specialties business.
- 22:01
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
- 22:01
- Dhmanas Surya: Refiner confirmed plan. plans to distribute at least 80.1% of the segment to shareholders, with separation expected to be largely completed in 2027.
- 22:10
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
- 22:11
- Dhmanas Surya: segment generated $924 million in Q3 revenue and $174 million in adjusted EBITDA, up from $78 million a year earlier. So we've been seeing some pretty impressive growth group at the segment. The CEO of HF Jesse Sinclair, Frank. Franklin Myers, will also transition to the executive chair role starting in
- 22:31
- Dhmanas Surya: January 2027, and will oversee the separation, while Steve Ledbetter will take over as CEO. But the spin-off news that I want to focus on for this week is actually a rumored spin-off, and it's that SP Global is toying with the idea of separating out its capital IQ or Cap IQ business.
- 22:49
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): On
- 22:49
- Dhmanas Surya: a surface level at R. I'd argue that SP Global requires no introduction. All investors know what the SP is, what the Dow Jones is, or what CapIQ is, but there's actually a lot more to the company, and thus it's somewhat worth diving a bit deeper into the different aspects of the business.
- 23:05
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
- 23:05
- Dhmanas Surya: company is divided into five main segments: market intelligence, ratings, energy, indices, and mobility.
- 23:13
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But the
- 23:14
- Dhmanas Surya: mobility business segment originated from the whopping $44 billion acquisition of IHS Market that SMB Global completed in February 2022. IHS Market was a large London headquartered information services company that was formed in 2016 from the merger of two other firms:
- 23:33
- Dhmanas Surya: IHS, which was a data analytics and solutions provider that spanned expanded multiple industries. including energy, transportation, and finance, and then Market, which was a financial data business itself.
- 23:44
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
- 23:45
- Dhmanas Surya: key business lines that SP Global absorbed from this acquisition of IHS Market, included what became the current commodity insights and energy segment. It also massively expanded the market intelligence segment as well as the mobility segment, which included Carfax, but then added the POLK Automotive Data System. segment and other
- 24:04
- Dhmanas Surya: automotive forecasting and advisory businesses that had operated for decades under the IHS Transportation Division. The deal gave SP Global the number one position in commodity benchmarks, but more or less bolted an automotive data business onto a financial markets infrastructure company. And that mismatch was the main reason that the mobility
- 24:24
- Dhmanas Surya: business segment was spun out of SP Global. at the start of July 2026. Post spin, the parent is up 12.4%, while mobility is down about 10%. Though some level of selling pressure post a spin-off is to be expected, and we often see the stock price drop after a spin-off. However, what is a bit more concerning about
- 24:44
- Dhmanas Surya: mobility is the fact that revenue for Q2 2026, which was the company's first earnings release cycle, was slightly lower than management expectations, and revenue guidance for the year was cut as well.
- 24:57
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
- 24:57
- Dhmanas Surya: moving back to SP Global the Parent Company, Islampin compared to the only other publicly traded data analytics and ratings agency, Moody's. Moody's operates in two segments: investor service, which is the credit ratings business, and analytics, which provides data analytics, research and risk management. software. The key structural
- 25:17
- Dhmanas Surya: difference is that SP Global is more diversified. Even post-Mobility Spin, it still owns the SP 500 index franchise and various commodity benchmark businesses. Moody's, on the other hand, is a pure play ratings and financial analytics business, which is why the market seems to price these two businesses somewhat
- 25:37
- Dhmanas Surya: differently.
- 25:37
- Asif Surya: Absolutely. And that's why you often find that both companies like Moody's and SP Global are in portfolios like Chris Holmes C CI fund. And Moody's also has been a long-term holding for Berkshire Hathaway. I don't know if they still hold it, but I know Buffett held it for a very long period of time. I personally am
- 25:57
- Asif Surya: invested in SP Global pre-spin pre-spin-off of mobility, so we have mobility shares as well. So I'm actually looking forward to the spin-off. I think SP Global becomes a much better company because of these spin-offs. But I plan to be holding both the parent and these two child spin-offs, if you will.
- 26:13
- Dhmanas Surya: Absolutely. And you can see how much Moody is favored and the differences in valuation. It's come down a bit actually post mobility spin. Span. I was looking at the company both pre and post, and the valuation gap seems to have collapsed slightly, but Moody Moody's trades at a trailing PE of around 30 and an EV by EBITDA of around 22, compared to
- 26:33
- Dhmanas Surya: SP Global's PE value of around 26 and an EV by EBITDA of around 18. It seems as if the market is affording Moody's a more premium valuation, and again, a lot of that is tied to how much more focused focus Moody's is on ratings and financial analytics. Both businesses with a stronger moat and higher margins.
- 26:53
- Dhmanas Surya: However, times might be changing, and as you hinted at, there's news of another spinoff. During its Q3 2026 earnings call, SP Global announced a strategic review of Capital IQ and associated data businesses within Kensho data and platforms, including a potential separation. The businesses under review would include the big platform
- 27:13
- Dhmanas Surya: Capital IQ, financial. Financials, SNL, and Visible Alpha. SP Global would remain the parent, or the Remain Co., and retain the Ratings segment, SP Dow Jones indices, the Energy segment, Enterprise Solutions, Ratings Direct, and Ratings Express as well. The CEO of the company said that separate
- 27:32
- Dhmanas Surya: ownership could give Capital IQ businesses more dedicated investment and focus, while allowing SP S ⁇ P Global to concentrate on
- 27:38
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the company.
- 27:39
- Dhmanas Surya: its core positions in credit, equities, and commodities. The exact separation perimeter and structure are still under review, with no spin code name or ticker announced yet. There is no definitive timetable and the company said the earliest meaningful update is expected around February 2027, around the time of their Q4 2026
- 27:58
- Dhmanas Surya: earnings haul.
- 28:00
- Asif Surya: Very interesting overall, yeah. Capital IQ I thought was a wonderful business. But given what's happening with AI and data at this point in time, I can see why SP wants to double down on its core business instead.
- 28:12
- Dhmanas Surya: And it's a lot to think about, especially in terms of like the indices and ratings. Those do have a very, very strong moat against AI because it's not as if any AI is going to start rating stocks for you just yet, because it's of the credibility of SP and Moody's that carries the big. business, not a third-party AI system.
- 28:29
- Asif Surya: Absolutely. At least maybe not for the next decade. Who knows what's to come with AI and the next set of models that are released next year?
- 28:36
- Dhmanas Surya: Absolutely. Maybe even five years from now, I'll look back on this and be like, well, everything's rated by AI these days.
- 28:42
- Asif Surya: I was at an investor conference last week, and one of the person attending, his son works for OpenAI. And when he asks asked his son, what do you think happens when the next set of models come out? And he had one word, and he said, We are all cooked. And so I've been hearing this from multiple people in the Bay Area as well, that the next set
- 29:02
- Asif Surya: of models are going to be even more powerful. And so that can cause some significant disruption going forward.
- 29:07
- Dhmanas Surya: And on that slightly frightening note, which is honestly fitting considering this is the episode filmed right after Halloween, we can wrap up episode. seventy-five of the Special Situations Report. What we've covered today is just a brief overview of the Special Situations landscape. So if you'd like to access a more comprehensive weekly overview of all event-driven activity, go ahead and visit our website, the Special
- 29:27
- Dhmanas Surya: Situations Report.com. For daily updates and alerts on the Special Situations world, as well as access to tools to help you identify opportunities, such as the merger arbitrage tool, check out InsideArbitrage.com.
- 29:39
- Asif Surya: And if you enjoyed this scary episode, please take a moment to like and subscribe on whatever platform you may be listening on, and especially share it with your friends who are interested in special situations. Thank you.
- 29:50
- Dhmanas Surya: We also wanted to provide a brief reminder that this podcast is for general informational and educational purposes only. The content does not constitute financial, investment, legal, or tax advice. We do not warrant the completeness or accuracy of the content or data provided in this podcast. We or our clients may hold a position in any of the companies discussed today. Nothing discussed in this podcast
- 30:10
- Dhmanas Surya: should be interpreted as our recommendation to buy, sell, or hold any investment or security. Investing involves substantial risks, including the potential loss or principal. You should conduct your own research and due diligence before making any investment decisions. Thank you.