Markets Plus

Panelists discuss industrial sovereignty, processing challenges, and government support for critical minerals at Toronto Global Forum

35 min Listen to the original Episode page
Critical MineralsMiningIndustrial PolicyNova ScotiaSupply ChainGovernment RegulationLabor MarketGeopolitics

Summary

Speakers at the 20th annual Toronto Global Forum argue that Canada's industrial sovereignty depends on rebuilding midstream processing capabilities for critical minerals, which have been lost to foreign acquisitions. Colton Blanc of BMO Capital Markets, Alden Greenhouse of Agnico Eagle, and Mark highlight that while exploration is active, refining and processing face profitability challenges due to global competition from China and Indonesia. They emphasize the need for government intervention to support niche mineral markets and address labor shortages, citing Nova Scotia's regulatory reforms and tax incentives. The discussion concludes that sovereignty requires allied cooperation with the US and a holistic approach to building mining ecosystems rather than focusing on single commodities.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    Colton Blanc states Nova Scotia doubled exploration licenses and approved five new mines in the past year.

    Colton Blanc · 3:04

  2. 2
    Mark identifies the Timmins Nickel District as a potential hub for midstream processing due to low-cost energy and expertise.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) · 11:35

Episode sections

  1. 0:00 – 2:04

    Introduction and Sovereignty Objectives

    Alden Greenhouse introduces the discussion at the 20th annual Toronto Global Forum. Raheem Bapoo of BMO Capital Markets frames critical minerals as a geopolitical choke point and highlights opportunities in space, AI, and robotics. He asks panelists about their objectives regarding industrial sovereignty.

  2. 2:04 – 4:18

    Nova Scotia Government Perspective

    Colton Blanc, Minister of Nova Scotia, outlines government roles in partnering and streamlining processes. He notes that Nova Scotia has doubled exploration licenses and approved five new mines in the past year, aiming to create competitive and transparent conditions for industry while maintaining environmental protections.

  3. 4:18 – 8:59

    Mining Ecosystem and Public Perception

    Alden Greenhouse of Agnico Eagle discusses the hollowing out of Canada's mining culture through foreign acquisitions. He argues for building the entire mining ecosystem rather than focusing on single minerals. Colton Blanc adds that public acceptance of mining has improved, but refining and processing face challenges due to profitability issues and global shifts toward China.

  4. 8:59 – 14:09

    Nickel Industry History and Processing Challenges

    Mark details the loss of Canadian mining champions like Inco and Falconbridge, and the ceding of processing control to China and Indonesia. He states that global nickel production outside China and Indonesia has shrunk by more than half in 30 years, leaving Canada producing the same amount as in the mid-1990s. He identifies the Timmins Nickel District as a potential hub for midstream processing due to low-cost energy and existing expertise.

  5. 14:09 – 17:11

    Labor Availability and Indigenous Participation

    Colton Blanc identifies indigenous participation and labor availability as key lessons from success stories. He notes that while capital is available, skilled labor is scarce. Alden Greenhouse shares that Agnico Eagle relocated drillers from Mexico to Canada, requiring significant support for housing and schooling. He predicts Timmins' population could grow 50-100% by 2040 to support new assets.

  6. 17:11 – 21:26

    Government Support and Financing Models

    Colton Blanc highlights Nova Scotia's 'More Opportunities for Skill Trades' program, which provides tax rebates for workers under 30. Alden Greenhouse argues for front-loading government investment in social infrastructure, citing Inco's creation of the city of Thompson as a model. He criticizes current grant structures that require companies to spend money before reimbursement, noting that modern companies lack the balance sheets of past giants like Inco.

  7. 21:26 – 27:18

    Redefining Sovereignty and Value Chains

    Alden Greenhouse questions if building mines equates to sovereignty. Colton Blanc argues sovereignty must include allies like the US due to geographical synergies and lack of independent financial capacity. Mark explains that nickel is used in stainless steel and specialty alloys, and losing processing steps abroad erodes value. He suggests coordinated Canadian efforts to attract downstream battery and steel makers.

  8. 27:18 – 28:57

    Critical Minerals Market Economics

    Alden Greenhouse asks how to make returns work for small-market critical minerals. Colton Blanc explains that while gold and copper markets are huge, niche minerals like rare earths ($18 billion globally) and cesium ($200 million revenue for CCM in 2024) are small. He notes Agnico's Avenue Minerals has invested $130 million across 14 opportunities in seven minerals to learn about these sectors.

  9. 28:57 – 29:51

    Market Size and Government Support for Small Critical Minerals

    Colton Blanc argues that small critical mineral markets (e.g., $200M total) are unattractive to large companies due to high permitting and environmental costs relative to potential revenue. He asserts that government support is necessary to manage risks for these smaller sectors, as pure capitalist models cannot sustain them against state-sponsored competitors.

  10. 29:51 – 30:49

    Processing Challenges and Technology Maturity

    The speakers distinguish between established processing methods for nickel and phosphate versus immature technologies for rare earths and lithium hydroxide outside of China. They note that building plants is not enough; the technology must be economically viable and proven to work.

  11. 30:49 – 32:26

    Strategic Approach to Processing and Infrastructure

    Speaker_2 outlines a three-part strategy for competitive processing: using proven technology, leveraging market knowledge to target specific customer segments, and locating resources near infrastructure (e.g., Timmins, Ontario) rather than remote areas like Nunavut. This combination allows for cost-competitive operations.

  12. 32:26 – 33:41

    Capital Allocation and Government Leverage

    The discussion highlights a capital mismatch where 99% of developer-stage capital in 2025 went to copper, gold, and silver, leaving little funding for niche metals like cesium or tantalum. Consequently, government leverage is needed to support these specific commodities.

  13. 33:41 – 35:18

    Government Initiatives and Future Outlook

    Colton Blanc mentions Nova Scotia's use of NovaMine for streamlined permitting and AI-driven digitization of 700,000 meters of core samples. He defines future success as economic 'acceptance' of mining/refining and a magnitude shift in output across sectors.

Assets discussed

AssetKindStanceContext
GoldcommodityneutralBut if you look at the size of minerals markets, gold is enormous, right? Gold will be four or five hundred billion dollars globally.
CoppercommodityneutralCopper is the next. biggest one, aluminum, potash.
SilvercommodityneutralThe reality is 2025, of all of the developer stage capital, not cash-flowing companies, but developer stage capital, 99% of that capital went to copper, gold, and silver.

“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.

Claims worth verifying

Nova Scotia doubled exploration licenses and approved five new mines in the past year.

Colton Blanc ·2:44

How to verify: Nova Scotia Department of Natural Resources annual reports or press releases for the relevant fiscal year. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Nova Scotia has less than three percent of Canada's population and less than one percent of its land mass.

Colton Blanc ·3:24

How to verify: Statistics Canada population and land area data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Agnico Eagle is Canada's largest company by market cap.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·4:24

How to verify: Stock market capitalization data from Bloomberg or Reuters. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Public perception of mining in the general public has gone up.

Colton Blanc ·7:42

How to verify: Survey data from organizations like Nanos Research or Angus Reid on mining attitudes. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Global nickel production outside of China and Indonesia has shrunk by more than half in 30 years.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·10:51

How to verify: USGS Mineral Commodity Summaries for Nickel historical production data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Two-thirds of nickel globally is used to make stainless steel.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·23:25

How to verify: International Nickel Study Group (INSG) or World Nickel Association usage statistics. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Canada has one small mill in Welland, Ontario producing specialty nickel alloys.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·23:25

How to verify: Company filings or press releases from the operator of the Welland mill. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Agnico's Avenue Minerals has invested about $130 million across 14 different opportunities in seven different minerals.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·28:02

How to verify: Agnico Eagle quarterly reports or press releases detailing Avenue Minerals investments. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

CCM generated $200 million in global revenue in 2024.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·28:34

How to verify: CCM financial statements or annual reports for 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

If a company controls 10% of a $200 million market, that is $20 million of revenue.

Colton Blanc ·28:57

How to verify: Mathematical calculation based on the figures stated in the transcript. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The market for small critical minerals is bifurcated into large minerals (nickel, lithium, zinc) and small ones requiring government support.

Colton Blanc ·29:17

How to verify: Market research reports on critical mineral market capitalization and segmentation. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Processing technology for rare earths was unknown outside of China until the last five to ten years.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·30:02

How to verify: Historical industry reports on rare earth processing patents and production facilities outside China. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

In 2025, 99% of developer-stage capital went to copper, gold, and silver.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·32:50

How to verify: Financial data from mining investment databases (e.g., S&P Global, Bloomberg) tracking developer-stage capital allocation by metal for the year 2025. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Nova Scotia is digitizing over 700,000 meters of core samples.

Colton Blanc ·33:41

How to verify: Nova Scotia government press releases or NovaMine program documentation regarding data digitization metrics. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Nova Scotia is using NovaMine to streamline permitting and approval processes.

Colton Blanc ·33:41

How to verify: Nova Scotia government website or NovaMine program description detailing its functions. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The podcast is part of the Markets Plus series from BMO Capital Markets.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·34:48

How to verify: BMO Capital Markets website or podcast directory listings for 'Markets Plus'. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify Nova Scotia's mine approval statistics and exploration license data through the Nova Scotia Department of Natural Resources and Energy Reports.
  • Check Agnico Eagle's (AEM) filings for details on the Avenue Minerals investment portfolio and specific mineral exposures.
  • Review Inco's historical corporate structure and current ownership status to assess the 'hollowing out' claim regarding Canadian mining champions.
  • Analyze global nickel production data from the US Geological Survey (USGS) Mineral Commodity Summaries to verify the shrinkage of non-Chinese/Indonesian output.
  • Examine Nova Scotia's 'More Opportunities for Skill Trades' program guidelines and recent tax rebate disbursement figures via provincial government publications.
  • Assess the technological maturity of rare earth and lithium hydroxide processing outside China by reviewing technical papers and industry reports on pilot plant viability.
  • Check capital allocation trends for developer-stage mining projects in 2025 from mining finance databases like S&P Global Market Intelligence or Bloomberg.
  • Verify CCM's 2024 revenue figures and cesium market size through CCM's annual reports or independent market research on rare earth elements.
Full transcriptexpand

0:00Alden Greenhouse: The following episode is based on a discussion from the 20th annual Toronto Global Forum on the critical role minerals will play in advancing energy security, industrial competitiveness, and the next era of economic growth. Let's join the conversation.

0:18Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Welcome to Markets Plus, where leading experts from across BEMO discuss factors shaping the markets, economy, industry sectors, and much more. Visit Bimocm.com/slash markets plus for more episodes.

0:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): My

0:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): name is Raheem and I'm a managing director at BIMO, leading our critical minerals practice. Critical minerals have been a key part of the discussion around global geopolitics,

0:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): as

0:48Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): they've emerged as a choke point in our economy. Now, we're at a moment in time that we at BMO think is one of great optimism. There is a lot to

0:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): do.

0:59Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): There are enormous opportunities in front of us. There's space, there's AI, there's robotics. And we're already starting to see some of the enormous impacts that these industries are going gonna to have on our lives.

1:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): One

1:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): of the choke points,

1:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): one

1:17Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): of the friction points that's emerged in that discussion over the last few years in particular, has been the level of concentration of critical minerals that are required for each of these industries. Now, today's conversation is titled one about sovereignty. So I'd like to start with a question. just about objectives. And each of you have slightly different perspectives coming from different parts of the industry and government.

1:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

1:48Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I'd like to understand, as you think about this question in the context of sovereignty, what is the objective that you're looking to solve for? Maybe, Minister, we'll start with the government perspective. And if we could start with just a little bit of an introduction of what you're doing in November, Nova Scotia as well, that would be great.

2:04Colton Blanc: Yeah, for sure. Thank you, Colton Blanc, the Minister of Growth, Development and Defense Industries, as well as Acadian Affairs and Francophonie for the beautiful province of Nova Scotia. And really appreciate the opportunity to take part in this panel with such esteemed folks. And certainly from a government perspective, I'll speak to the Nova Scotia perspective, but we're finding ourselves with significant opportunities at home, the need, the imperative for all of this as well. And so for the role of government, sometimes the role of governments to get out of the way, sometimes the role of governments to partner, the role of government is to help create those conditions about timelines and sometimes perhaps the uncertainty that it creates that the sector creates or that are created rather for the sector. Our government recognizes what we have at home is needed around the world, needed here in Canada. And so we look at how we can contribute to those solutions. This year alone, in the past year alone, we've doubled the exploration licenses in Nova Scotia. We've approved five new mines. in Nova Scotia. Now, five mines may not sound like a lot, but for a region with less than three percent

3:24of our country's population, less than one percent of our country's land mass of five thousand square kilometers, that is significant. And it speaks to the ambition of government to partner with industry to streamline processes, recognizing that we must maintain strong environmental protections, all the while creating an environment that is competitive, that is transparent and clear for industry, and turning the potential into investment by creating those conditions of confidence and certainty that we are trying to achieve. in Nova Scotia.

4:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Okay. Alden, we've heard from the minister. Government's ready to get out of the way.

4:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

4:10Colton Blanc: let you do what you need to do.

4:11Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): From the seat of Avenir is part of one of Canada's largest mining companies. What's the play? What do you do from here?

4:18Alden Greenhouse: Yep. Thanks and thank you for inviting me here. It's a pleasure to be here. I'm Alden Greenhouse.

4:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

4:23Alden Greenhouse: wear a bunch of hats.

4:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

4:24Alden Greenhouse: work for Igneco Agniko Eagle as Raheem mentioned, Ken. Canada's largest company by Market Cap.

4:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But

4:29Alden Greenhouse: I run our subsidiary called Avenue Minerals, which we started about a year ago to focus on exactly this challenge. But yeah, from our perspective, it's an interesting one, right? We have a very strong mining history and mining culture in Canada. It's been hollowed

4:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): out

4:42Alden Greenhouse: over the last couple decades with foreign acquisitions, but we still are the place for junior mining companies like Mark's uh Ken the and Nickel here to raise. capital, just forgetting about where the mines are, the capital and the expertise is here to raise that capital. But we felt that, and the people that asked me to start this job obviously had a little bit of foresight on that. We thought this was a huge opportunity for Canada

5:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and

5:05Alden Greenhouse: for the mining industry as a whole. And one of the things that we've been really happy to see is that as governments have focused on critical minerals, it has evolved to be focusing on supporting. mining as a whole. Because the ecosystem doesn't exist if you're just looking at lithium or just looking at tungsten or rare earths. You have to build the whole mining ecosystem as one. Because as people are learning, very rarely do you get a mine that produces one specific mineral. There's they're generally multiple minerals. And so you have to look at the ecosystem as a whole.

5:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): And actually on that point, and Mark, I'm gonna come back to you on nickel in a second, but just on that point, one thing is producing a mineral. The next is producing something that you can actually put into an electronic part or a car or a satellite. Minister, all the how are you guys thinking about that part of the value chain? Because we've got lots of minerals in Canada. What are we going We're to turn them into?

5:58Colton Blanc: Yeah, certainly mining is more than just the extraction story. There's a lot more to it. It is the economic security story. It's part of the the broader value supply chain. It's the infrastructure that supports it. It's the skill trades that support it. It's the downstream. It's the processing. It's the advanced manufacturing. It's the research and development, whether it's in batteries, that type of research underway in Nova Scotia. And what's being extracted. and processed and applied will be used in future applications such as defense, which is a key pillar to our provincial economy, about six percent GDP with 130 plus companies that support that, including satellites with Galaxia Space Mission Systems, for example, and Halifax. in But it is to create again those conditions, understanding. what the potential is today, trying to understand where and what we need for decades to come, looking inward, but also, and I'm not gonna pretend that I'm any investment or financial guru by any means, but the principle of having a diversified

7:06investment market is important. And I think the potential and the necessity rather of having a diversified mineral market as a country that recognizes recognizing that not one province, one mine, one processing facility can do it all, that we have to look from coast to coast, what we have here, how we're going to use it as a country, and how perhaps we can partner with our allies as well.

7:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,

7:29Alden Greenhouse: and to add to that, and you've probably got one of the best guys to talk about midstream processing in the room. Mark has a long history in that. But just before

7:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you

7:37Alden Greenhouse: jump to Mark, I

7:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): think

7:38Alden Greenhouse: the kind country has done a really good job at shifting the tone on

7:42Colton Blanc: acceptance from the general population on mining.

7:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

7:45Colton Blanc: don't ever remember the stats, but you look at surveys, I've heard people reference surveys where the perception of mining in the general public has gone up. I don't think that's there yet on refining and processing. And that industry is really challenged. I can unbiased say this because we don't own any refineries, but you look at what's happened the last five, ten years. those things don't make money. They're end producers of the stuff we need, but the way the system has shifted and the global system has shifted in China, and again, Mark knows this better than I do, you don't make money at the trail smelter. You don't make substantial amounts of money at the horn smelter in Ruen. So the next conversation we need to have is either one, are we going to build these ourselves?

8:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

8:24Colton Blanc: that I'm not sure the public acceptance there, or two. when we talk about sovereignty, is it Canada or is it Canada and its allies? Because I think there is the capacity and start to keep hyping you up here, Mark, but I hope you'll answer this. I believe the capacity is there, but if we want it here in Canada, we're gonna have to change the conversation.

8:42Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Okay. So Mark, you are sitting on one of the generational assets that exist inside Canada. Enormous scale. Really big. Can make a difference. I'm hearing from the minister that the government's ready to get out of the way and let you do what you need to do.

8:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

9:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): he's put his money where his mouth is, too,

9:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that

9:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): there's interest from some of Canada's biggest companies as well. Tell me about Nickel in Canada. Tell me about what you've got, Scott, and tell me if these guys are right. Are we at a moment where we can get these things built?

9:13Colton Blanc: Yes. And all Alden the news, my is my largest shareholder. So he's

9:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): obviously talking his book here. So

9:18Colton Blanc: thank you. Yeah, in terms of sovereignty, and then specifically around nickel, in terms of seizing the moment that we have today, I think it's first important to give people the context of where we've come from as an industry in terms

9:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): of seeding that sovereignty. So sovereignty one, in terms of headquarters and capital allocations. I joined the mining industry as part of the scene. senior management team at Inco 25 years ago, tried to merge with Falcon Bridge to create a big competitor to the BHPs of the world. During that five year time period, we lost Inco, Falcon Bridge, Rio Algum, Naranda, and several other companies. Those are companies that built integrated, they built and operated integrated processing assets that the type that we want to get back to. And not surprisingly, a lot of the assets that they've had have now closed down. And those capital allocation decisions are being made outside Canada today. So we need to build new Canadian champions, number one. Number two is in in terms of processing, the entire industry is guilty of somebody showed up and came and said, Oh, we can do it for half the price. And each year came back and said, Give us more and we'll keep doing it cheaper. And in the meantime, we've shifted control of production and all of that processing, you know, to China. And again, there's a lot of minerals we used to produce, and to Alden's point, it shouldn't be just Canada, it's Canada and our allies. That's been now almost 100% ceded to Indonesia. We've lost the ability to process. And then finally, around mining, just to give you an idea of how much in the nickel space it shifted, in 30 years, production outside of China and Indonesia has

10:51actually shrunk by more than half. We are now producing the same amount of nickel as we did in the mid-1990s. A friend of mine found a trivial pursuit card from the early 1980s that the answer to the question was who was the world's largest nickel producer? And that was Canada at that time. We have the resource base to be able to start to get back there. So we've made a a lot of d decisions that have taken us to where we are today. In terms of going forward, part of the challenge with the processing, the midstream processing assets that we have today, is they were built for the right reason 70 or 80 years ago. Steel mills were built where they were for the right reason seventy to eighty years ago. Base metal processing plants were built where they were the right idea seventy 70 to eighty 80 years ago. And so again, with assets that have scales, what we have in the Timmins Nickel district with not nine separate resources, hopefully a whole pipeline of nickel development. That's where we can start to look again about this is where, because we have a hundred years of resource plus, these are the locations where you can start to build that midstream processing capacity again and compete

11:55successfully. We've got low-cost natural gas right at our doorstep. We have low-cost low cost energy right at our doorstep. And those are two very scarce commodities and having those advantages. And we still have the know-how. Again, some of those midstream processing experts, no joking. We're working with people who are 70, 80, 85 years old because they're the people who still have that knowledge to be able to be in a position to build these assets going forward. And again, we have a tremendous opportunity to be that source of critical minerals, source of finished critical minerals. that can be used by downstream customers. And we just need to move quickly and aggressively. We've done a great job on permitting. I can tell you that from someone who's permitted a big project last decade and this decade, and we're the first company to permit underneath the twenty nineteen legislation. That's how few new big projects have been built. But now if we can unlock the pace of financing that we need to do to get these things actually built, shovels in the ground and built. but we need to move from talk to actually getting dollars into the ground.

12:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm still

12:54Alden Greenhouse: getting over that the world's largest nickel producer, Canada.

12:57Colton Blanc: So

12:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

12:58Colton Blanc: guess

12:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Mark,

12:58Alden Greenhouse: taken from one lens,

13:00Colton Blanc: that could be a tragedy.

13:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We

13:03Colton Blanc: allowed

13:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): ourselves to to go from being the

13:05Alden Greenhouse: world's largest to

13:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to a bit more of a footnote.

13:07Alden Greenhouse: And now people ask

13:08Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): questions like how can processing assets even ever make money? Taken from another lens, actually there's a great success story. Indonesia has lifted itself out of poverty by building the world's largest nickel industry. China has built a steel industry that is

13:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the

13:26Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): envy of the world. And even more recently, you might turn around and say, We've had good success stories in North America. The US has gone off and started to mobilize enormous amounts of capital and write deals and build mines again. And here at home in Canada, we're doing the same thing. We've got big investments by the Canada Growth Fund. We've got the announcements that came out on the Steel Initiative and building infrastructure. So I guess my question for each of you as we look forward and we think about the path towards a more optimistic future, what are the lessons that we can learn from the success stories?

14:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): What

14:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): are the things that have worked well that we need to do more of?

14:09Colton Blanc: Look, the first thing that popped to mind when you said that is it's not necessarily the most natural segue, but is indigenous participation, First Nations participation. If you look at what we did twenty years ago, thirty years ago, it wasn't part of the conversation. And now that definitely is. And if you extend that, expand that from those rights holders. to other stakeholders, communities, we've done a much better job as an industry

14:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of

14:32Colton Blanc: building those relationships and building that acceptance. Labor availability. Mark, I hate to keep pumping up Mark, but Mark's project is looking at building a lot of big things.

14:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We

14:43Colton Blanc: need a lot of people to build those big things. So I think what we need to do differently is it's a different conversation around communities, around First Nations. which is great. And we really need to focus on labor availability. And whether that's building houses, building schools, building hospitals, whether it's focused immigration, capital is a challenge, but good projects will find capital. It's hard to get, especially if you're trying to build multiple things, it's hard to get labor.

15:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Agico's Ignico's enormous presence in the north.

15:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): What

15:13Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): does it take to get people

15:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to

15:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): decide to move?

15:17Colton Blanc: The short answer to that is a good kitchen. If you have bad food, nobody wants to come work at your mine. No, but it look, it takes a lot of work.

15:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We

15:26Colton Blanc: were closing one of our operations in Mexico at Agniko, and we had a real shortage of good quality diamond drillers up at Kirkland Lake

15:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): at

15:34Colton Blanc: the Macasa mine. So we relocated five of our best. drillers from Mexico with their families up to Kirkland Lake.

15:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It

15:42Colton Blanc: took one or two full-time employees a year to make that work. We had to worry about ESL, we had to worry about schools, we had to worry about housing. It's not an easy thing to get the skills. Mark talked about it before. You go to the rare earth industry as an example. The expert in the rare earth industry is a guy called John Good.

16:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I don't

16:02Colton Blanc: know how old John is, but he's got to have a seven on the front of it. This is not an industry where we have a lot of people that have focused on this and built that expertise. That is really where I think governments can help us policies that encourage that people moving into our sector and then the support behind that. Because unfortunately, the mines aren't in Toronto and Vancouver and Montreal.

16:21Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Minister, I couldn't imagine a better transition. I'd say that governments are across our country are challenged with the question about skilled labor. And at home, we've taken a number of measures to address that. We have world-class academic institutions that are nimble and agile and help us address the pipeline that we have built and that we will continue to need for decades to come, whether including our community college. Fundamentally, we have a role and responsibility. to create those opportunities for our youth for the next generation, but also the training opportunities for them as well, complemented by immigration and looking at labor mobility and reciprocity, which in itself in Canada is a challenge, continues to be a challenge, one that our Premier Houston introduced legislation last year to start breaking down these barriers on internal. trade. And I think we're making progress. Are we there yet? No, but we are gonna get there, I'm confident. But whether it be creating the conditions for 5,000 new apprenticeship positions by 2026, meeting and exceeding that. Whether it's the grants for tools for and things

17:31like that for our skill trades, we're doing that. If it's streamlining some of these approval processes for skill trades, we're doing that. In fact, we recognize the need, the core need of skill trades across the board that our government imp implemented a program called the More Opportunities for Skill Trades program, which is a tax return on the first 50,000 of provincial income tax for youth under 30 or workers under the age of 30 for a number of skilled trades. And we're over 68 million dollars back. into the pockets of workers. It is one that whether it be in this sector, whether it be for the defense sector, in energy sector, right across the board. And I don't think governments should shy away from that. But I also see there's some overlapping that there could be some shared skills and shared talent that will be essential potential to foster as we continue on this for decades to

18:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): come. Yeah,

18:26Alden Greenhouse: and build building on the comments in terms of with Alden, at the end of the day, real reconciliation with First Nations only happens with real economic participation,

18:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): not token economic participation. And I've been very proud of the number of initiatives that we've done with the local communities in the area on the labor side on that issue. If you look in the Timmins area, between Agniko Eagle's plans to build out the their asset base in the area, we have Tony McCooch and Discovery Mining, who is looking to have significant growth in the area. And then we want to build a bunch of assets all in the same area. You could easily see Timmins, Cochrane, and the region's center's population go up by fifty to a hundred percent by twenty forty. We'll need that if all of us wants to do what we need to get done. So that's hospitals, schools, social infrastructure. And those things you just can't turn them on immediately. So I think one of the challenges with the money, there's been lots of money announced, but unfortunately, some of that money is migrated to the last money in, which again is the least risky part of that capital. And again, as a taxpayer, yes, I want to make sure overall that we get a return on some of that investment. But I think the investment focus does need to shift early on. We do need to choose some winners. and then start to build the infrastructure to be able to ensure that those winners are successful, can operate in a low cost competitive way. And we do that by building resilient communities that can support those assets and those development.

19:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Do

19:53Alden Greenhouse: you have examples of where that's worked well? Like front end loading some of that investment by policy and government.

20:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Again. getting back to the big companies that we lost, a lot of companies built company towns, right? They built not just the housing, they built the social infrastructure. Inco is a great example. The third largest city, I think, in Manitoba for a long time was the city of Thompson, which they carved was a desolate area at that point in time. And they built a community of twenty thousand people that delivered vast amounts of economic value for the province and anchored the entire north. northern part of the economy. We kind of need to get back to a little bit of that mindset if we want to grow the critical minerals base that we want to grow to.

20:34Colton Blanc: Yeah, but Mark, it's a little different. And I agree with you, but they had the capacity and the balance sheet to

20:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): be able to

20:39Colton Blanc: do that. Right. You were talking about financing. One of the things that's frustrating in this industry, and I share your thoughts as a taxpayer, but you see these grants. I'm on the board of a company called Electric. Electra Battery Materials. We have grants from the U.S. Department of War. We have grants from the Canadian government, but we have to spend the money

20:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and

20:58Colton Blanc: then send the bill in and get reimbursed. So you still have to have the money to spend it, right? So there's these challenges. The ideas are there, but sometimes the execution is a little act.

21:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): No, and building on that point, that's the challenge is we don't have the Incos and the Falconbridges and the Narandas today. who have that financial capacity to do it. Governments unfortunately are the only people who have that balance sheet to help facilitate making that happen.

21:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So maybe

21:25Alden Greenhouse: shifting the conversation a little

21:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): bit. The

21:26Alden Greenhouse: title here is Sovereignty.

21:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

21:29Alden Greenhouse: I'd like to explore a little bit about what that means. And Alden, you started talking about it,

21:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but Mark,

21:35Alden Greenhouse: you've got a nickel mine.

21:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Alden

21:37Alden Greenhouse: you've bought got a phosphate mine.

21:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Let's

21:39Alden Greenhouse: cast our minds, I'm gonna be ambitious,

21:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and

21:42Alden Greenhouse: three years into the future and imagine that both of these mines are built.

21:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Is

21:46Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): that what sovereignty looks like?

21:48Colton Blanc: This is a conversation that could go for hours. I think the current, say the larger tone about focusing more on ourselves and decoupling from the US economy, I think that's a net benefit, right? I think the error we would make if we took that too far was to realize that mines, like Mark was saying, his mine if and when build will

22:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): be

22:07Colton Blanc: hundreds of years, right? That's going to be past this administration, past the next administration. But the geographical alliances that we have to have, the NAFTA or CUSMA as it's now called, or USMCA, if you want to talk about it in Washington, that is born not because we've got similar values. That is part of it. but it's born because we've got geographical synergies. And it's easy for us to ship a bar of gold to Zurich or to somewhere else to be processed. A lot harder to ship tons of nickel concentrate somewhere. So I think coming back to your question about sovereignty, it's got to be considered in a broader context, not just Canada, because we don't have, as we talked about, we don't have the human resources, the workforce to be able to build. to the scale that Canada and its allies need. We don't have the financial capacity to be able to fund it all by ourselves. And we all benefit more if we specialize. So I think the sovereignty concept has to be larger than just Canada, it has to be our allies.

23:05Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah. And I think in terms of if we get there in three years, that is a very first necessary step, but there's a a bunch more steps that have to happen. Again. in the nickel space, two-thirds of nickel globally is used to make stainless steel. We depend almost entirely on the United States. We we don't produce any of it at home. We have one small little mill in Welland, Ontario that produces a fraction of what we need, specialty alloys that go into a whole range of high-end industrial applications. And because nickel was always a very expensive metal, it is used in a bunch of high-end applications. And if we suddenly got cut off from those specialty alloys, you'd have huge, very important segments of our industrial economy have to close. So our mine is one step. The downstream processing plant is the second step. We make the first saleable product that we can ship out, and we ship it out. The thing we lose as soon as we do that is there's a next stage of value add, there's another stage of value add. there's another stage, and sometimes multiple stages of value add beyond that. Once that first step leaves the country, you lose that entire value created by each of those multiple steps. So by adding one more step in country, which is what we want to do, it creates the opportunity to have that next stage happen and the next stage after For that. And that's where I think the country's done a good job promoting

24:24individual products. The other role, I think, for government. is I shouldn't be competing against there's a good project in BC, there's a good project in Quebec, there's other good nickel projects. We should be working in a coordinated fashion in Canada to go to the Korean battery makers, to go to the Japanese battery makers, to go to European specialty steel maker and say, Hey, why don't you build your next plant down the road from somewhere in Canada that we can all provide you the feed that you need to start to build that ecosystem? And again, once you start that ball rolling down the hill again, it's not going to happen overnight. We got in this position over 50 years, but I'm optimistic that if we start the ball rolling in 10 or 15 years, I think we could have a very exciting economy once

25:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the ball moving downhill is something that you talk about, Minister, in the context of Nova Scotia and where you're gonna participate in the downstream parts of this value chain.

25:18Colton Blanc: You want to

25:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): talk a little bit

25:19Colton Blanc: about

25:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that? I mean,

25:21Colton Blanc: despite

25:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the massive challenges that

25:23Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): we're

25:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): facing as a country and the geopolitical environment, I'm

25:26Colton Blanc: incredibly optimistic for the future of this

25:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): country

25:29Colton Blanc: and for our Atlantic Canadian region, and of course for the province of Nova Scotia

25:34Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): that can

25:34Colton Blanc: help us move the economic needle at home.

25:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Moving

25:38Colton Blanc: the ball down. downhill is

25:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a

25:39Colton Blanc: heck of a lot easier than going uphill.

25:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And I

25:41Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): think

25:41Colton Blanc: we have momentum has been referenced.

25:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The

25:44Colton Blanc: imperative for perhaps on the buy inside

25:47Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): is

25:47Colton Blanc: what's in it for Canadians,

25:49Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): why I

25:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): have

25:49Colton Blanc: a mind

25:50Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): in my community or in my region, what's in it for me. So of course the jobs, but I think certainly Dove Feeling on Mark's point is on the midstream processing and what can that unleash, the growing, the growing ecosystem. It's like a new industrial park and you want to build like a shopping district. You need an anchor tenant. You need a Costco to set up shop and then everybody else starts falling in. And so your big Costco store or I don't want to single them out, but you know they're gonna draw a lot of traffic and important traffic. But all the other small ones, all the other smaller stores draw important traffic as well. And so I think part of that ecosystem is having certainly in a smaller region for like in the Atlantic Canada or in Nova Scotia, where we're not big, but we have big opportunities, is having that big anchor tenant and then having that ball continually gain speed, rolling down the hill and really helping us build on the existing ecosystem that we have, which quite frankly is difficult to replicate. We are close proximity to deep water ports, direct market access, and some of our projects may not be as big as some in central Canada or other parts, you know, including in the north, but it is a time to look at and recognize that East we have real potential and we have governments that want to partner and want to work together

27:10for the betterment of this entire country that we're proud to call home and that ties into the discussion about our sovereignty as

27:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): well.

27:18Alden Greenhouse: Alden, one of the things that that we've talked about over time is there are a lot of these critical minerals, right? It's not just nickel.

27:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Nickel, lithium,

27:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): germanium, iridium, neudinium, dysprosium can go

27:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): on. And they all

27:35Alden Greenhouse: have

27:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): their own unique

27:37Alden Greenhouse: markets.

27:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Some of them are very small. And and oftentimes when you look at the economics of extracting them, first blush doesn't seem that great. And certainly the economics of processing them are challenging. You've been a professional investor in the space. How do you think about that? How do you make the returns work?

27:57Colton Blanc: Yeah, when we look at the critical minerals space, so just to give some context to your comment,

28:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): we

28:02Colton Blanc: started the concept that was Avenue about four years ago. We've invested about $130 million across 14 different opportunities, seven different minerals, mainly with the intent to learn about these minerals. And

28:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the

28:14Colton Blanc: way we look at it, I joke that I should have this chart tattooed on my chest because I reference it almost every day. But if you look at the size of minerals markets, gold is enormous, right? Gold will be four or five hundred billion dollars globally. Copper is the next. biggest one, aluminum, potash. Then you get down into the nickels and the lithiums and the phosphates. You referenced, we bought a phosphate asset recently.

28:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But

28:34Colton Blanc: when you get to the other end of that chart

28:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and

28:37Colton Blanc: you're looking at some of these small market minerals, we hear a lot about rare earths, but all of those rare earths together is about $18 billion globally, which sounds like a lot of money, but it's not from a global economic perspective. CCM, we just made an investment, a joint venture in a cesium CCM project. in Manitoba. CCM in 2024, the global revenue is $200 million. And why is that important? Well, two things. One, large companies don't really get that interested in markets where the whole market is $200 million, right? If you control 10% of that, that's $20 million of revenue. If you've got to build a mine, you've got to deal with the permitting, the environment, you've got to do all that stuff for $20 million of revenue. Not really there. So, but that's why we're in this position. So we kind of bifurcate the market. You've got the large critical minerals, the nickels, the lithium, zincs, and then you've got the small ones.

29:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

29:25Colton Blanc: the small ones are really going to need government support. And this isn't industry asking for a handout. This is

29:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the

29:31Colton Blanc: mining sector saying if you want supply chains built in these minerals, you've got to help us manage that risk. Because on a pure capitalist outlook, you wouldn't take that risk because the market is so small. One large mine, one state-sponsored cap economy can basically put you out of business. So yeah, there's a million of them. I think you need to differentiate between the two sides. I guess the other thing I would point out, while there are challenges in processing some of these things like nickel,

30:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that

30:02Colton Blanc: process is established. Phosphate, making phosphate fertilizer out of phosphate rock, that process is established. Nobody knows how to do rare earths or nobody knew how to do rare earths outside of China until the last five, 10 years. Lithium carbonate, lithium hydroxide, we're still having a lot of challenges being able to do that economically outside of China. So it's not just we have to build the plant. Sometimes it's we have to figure out how to make the plants work.

30:26Alden Greenhouse: Mark, you you talked about this a little bit too in the context of processing nickel. And my question related to Alden's point is

30:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): how

30:36Alden Greenhouse: much of this can be solved by technology? Like how much of this is just invest and we can become competitive and bring our costs down and we can make that refinery make money? Is that possible or do we have a different problem?

30:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I think

30:49Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): the key to making it happen. is really threefold. The one piece is if ask a lot of engineers and to say how do we do that, they're gonna look for, okay, we have to come up with this new whiz-bang technology that's never been tried before, and we're gonna make several leaps, and that way we're gonna get to the promised land in terms of a cost competitive product. That's in reality, that's highly risky, and mining is littered with all kinds of quote, easy new technologies. that didn't quite work.

31:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

31:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): think it's a combination of three things. You need to look at the technology. So the technology that we're looking to implement with our processing plants is proven, demonstrated in a bunch of different areas. Two, we're able to position that top technology because our team has a deep understanding of the markets, right? In terms of how this product is used. So we can leverage existing technology. technology to target customer segments with products that this technology can unlock. And then the third thing is again having the right resource in the right place. If we were in a remote part of Nunavut with a deposit, the ability to actually build that processing capacity right nearby would not make sense. But we're sitting in Timmins next to a highway, we'll have a rail line that we can bring inputs in and ship our product out. And so the combination of each of those things together does create those unique opportunities where you can really make processing capacity that can generate value and generate value for decades to come because of the resource base that's there. Because of the unique set of infrastructure and uh capacity in Northeast Ontario, we can build it and be competitive in today's market. Although we're

32:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): not going to be able to do that, you wouldn't mind

32:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): higher prices,

32:28Colton Blanc: right? They would be okay. Oh

32:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): no, I would love to have a better process, but yeah, no, just the risk associated with it. And just to underscore all Alden's point in turn in terms of capital, and where again governments, I think if we want to produce some of the smaller metals, we talk about the TSX as this wonderful source of mining capital. If anyone has a decent project, you can just go and list on the TSX and there'll be hundreds. of investors lined up to give you all the capital you need to develop a project. Copy mo. Exactly. The reality is 2025, of all of the developer stage capital, not cash-flowing companies, but developer stage capital, 99% of that capital went to copper, gold, and silver. We have an investment ecosystem that knows and understands. copper, gold, and silver. And then whatever the flavor of the month is, whether it was lithium, which was there a few years ago, and you have some die-hard uranium bowls that come and go as uranium market cycles. But the reality is for things like cesium

33:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): or

33:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): tantalum, there's virtually no capital and almost no incentive for most investment funds to get into those businesses. In terms of where governments may need to provide extra leverage, it's definitely a on those particular commodities. And just quickly,

33:41Colton Blanc: if I may, from a government perspective, we're using technology to improve and streamline our permitting and approval processes through NovaMine to clearly set out benchmarks for companies. And then on the geoscience data side, creating a hub where we're digitizing over 700,000 seven hundred thousand meters of core samples that are in a our warehouse in a rural rural nose. Nova Scotia that will be enabled with AI applications to make it even easier to understand what we've been exploring for generations in Nova Scotia.

34:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All right, guys. And just to close it out, I'm gonna ask one last question, which is in one sentence. If we were out here ten years from now, what does success look like? One set? sentence.

34:22Colton Blanc: That's a good question. I think it looks I'll just say

34:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): one

34:25Colton Blanc: word, acceptance. And I mean

34:27Alden Greenhouse: that in terms of across all parts of economy, just acceptance of mining and refining as a real part of our economy.

34:34Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): A magnitude shift in output across all sectors.

34:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Of

34:38Colton Blanc: course, more mines in Nova Scotia, but also that building out of that ecosystem

34:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that

34:44Colton Blanc: we've been talking about.

34:45Alden Greenhouse: Thank you all.

34:48Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Thanks for listening. You can follow the this podcast on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or your favorite podcast app. For more episodes, visit BimoCM.com slash markets plus.

35:00Alden Greenhouse: The views expressed here are those of the participants and may not necessarily represent those of Bimo Capital Markets, its affiliates, or subsidiaries. For BEMO disclosures, please visit bmocm.com bmocm.com/slash slash podcast slash disclaimer.

This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights