The Rob Berger Show

Rob Berger discusses the impact of 1% fees on withdrawal rates and inherited IRA spending strategies

32 min Listen to the original
Retirement PlanningInvestment FeesTax StrategyFixed IncomeCash ManagementFinancial Planning

Summary

Rob Berger addresses five listener questions, starting with the impact of advisory fees on the 4% safe withdrawal rule. He cites Michael Kitces' research to argue that a 1% fee reduces the safe withdrawal rate to 3.6% due to a 'self-mitigating impact' where fees decline as balances drop. Using FI Calc, Berger demonstrates that while the rule may still succeed, ending wealth is significantly lower with fees. He also advises on spending from inherited IRAs versus taxable accounts, compares money market fund expense ratios, explains TIPS fund volatility, and recommends password managers.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    The 4% rule is based on the worst-case 30-year retirement period starting in 1966, not an average of all historical periods.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) · 4:50

  2. 2
    A drop from a 4% to 3.6% withdrawal rate represents a 10% reduction in annual spending power (e.g., $40,000 to $36,000 on a $1M portfolio).

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) · 9:11

Episode sections

  1. 0:00 – 3:16

    Intro and Question 1: 4% Rule and AUM Fees

    Speaker introduces Five Question Friday and the first topic: whether the 4% safe withdrawal rule is calculated before or after advisory (AUM) fees. Speaker notes that AUM fees are deducted from the investment account balance rather than billed separately.

  2. 3:16 – 6:50

    Michael Kitces Research on Expense Impact

    Speaker cites Michael Kitces' 2012 article, which claims a 1% expense ratio reduces the safe withdrawal rate from 4% to 3.6%, not 3%. This is attributed to the 'self-mitigating impact' where fees decline as account balances drop during market downturns.

  3. 6:50 – 13:03

    FI Calc Analysis: 1966 vs 1985 Scenarios

    Speaker uses FI Calc to show that while the 4% rule succeeds 92% of the time with a 1% fee in the worst-case year (1966), ending wealth is significantly lower ($376k vs $548k) compared to no fee in a good year (1985). Speaker argues fees massively impact ending wealth even if the withdrawal rate remains technically 'safe'.

  4. 13:03 – 17:22

    Advisor Fees for Small Balances

    Speaker notes that advisors may charge more than 1% for smaller balances (e.g., $100k-$200k). Cites Focus Partner Wealth's Form ADV showing fees starting at 1.25% with a $5,000 minimum, which equates to 5% on a $100k account.

  5. 17:22 – 20:42

    Question 2: Inherited IRA vs Taxable Account Spending

    Speaker addresses whether to spend from an inherited IRA or taxable account first. Concludes there is no rule of thumb; the decision depends on specific tax consequences (ordinary income vs capital gains), state taxes, and annual tax bracket management.

  6. 20:42 – 24:35

    Question 3: Money Market Expense Ratios (SPAXX vs VMFXX)

    Speaker confirms expense ratios matter for money market funds. Compares Fidelity's SPAXX (42 bps expense ratio) to Vanguard's VMFXX (11 bps). Recommends Vanguard for yield/fee efficiency but notes Fidelity's auto-liquidation feature for cash management accounts.

  7. 24:35 – 29:58

    Question 4: TIPS Fund Volatility (FIPDX)

    Speaker explains that Fidelity Inflation-Protected Bond Index Fund (FIPDX) volatility is due to interest rate changes affecting its 6.47-year duration. Recommends the fund for long-term buy-and-hold investors but advises against it for short-term cash needs (1-4 years).

  8. 29:58 – 32:07

    Question 5: Password Managers

    Speaker recommends Apple Passwords (free, Apple ecosystem only) and 1Password (paid, cross-platform) as top choices for storing and organizing passwords.

Assets discussed

AssetKindStanceContext
S&P 500indexneutralIn the 94 paper, he assumed that stocks were invested in the SP S P 500.

“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.

Claims worth verifying

A 1% expense ratio reduces the safe withdrawal rate from 4% to 3.6%, not 3%.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·3:58

How to verify: Check Michael Kitces' 2026 article 'The Impact of Investment Fees on Safe Withdrawal Rates' at kitces.com. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The 4% rule is based on the worst-case 30-year retirement period starting in 1966.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·4:48

How to verify: Review William Bengen's 2026 paper 'Optimizing Withdrawals During Retirement' or his subsequent updates on retirement income planning. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

A 1% AUM fee reduced the final portfolio value from $548,000 to $376,000 in a 1985 retirement scenario using FI Calc.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·11:22

How to verify: Run the scenario on ficalc.app using a 65/35 stock/bond allocation, 2026 start date, and comparing 1% vs 0% annual fees. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

A 2% total fee structure (1% AUM + 1% fund fees) drops the success rate of a 4% withdrawal strategy from 92% to 74%.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·12:03

How to verify: Run the scenario on ficalc.app with a 2% annual fee assumption. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Focus Partner Wealth's Form ADV shows fees starting at 1.25% with a $5,000 minimum.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·14:42

How to verify: Search SEC EDGAR for Focus Partner Wealth's Form ADV Part 2A, specifically Item 5 (Fees). For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

SPAXX has an expense ratio of 42 basis points and a yield of 3.27%.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·21:42

How to verify: Check Fidelity's fund research page for SPAXX or its most recent prospectus. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

VMFXX has an expense ratio of 11 basis points.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·21:42

How to verify: Check Vanguard's investor page for VMFXX or its most recent prospectus. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

FIPDX has a duration of 6.47 years and a weighted average maturity of 7.1 years.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·25:32

How to verify: Check Fidelity's fund research page for FIPDX or its most recent prospectus. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Apple Passwords has a 4.7 rating in the App Store after 763,000 ratings.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·30:38

How to verify: Check the Apple App Store listing for 'Passwords' by Apple. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

1Password family plan costs at least $44.90.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·31:14

How to verify: Check 1Password's pricing page at 1password.com. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify Michael Kitces' 2012 article on expense impact and the 'self-mitigating impact' claim.
  • Run personal retirement scenarios in FI Calc or similar tools using historical data (1966, 1985) to test fee impacts on ending wealth.
  • Review specific advisor Form ADV filings (Item 5) for fee schedules and minimums to calculate effective rates on small balances.
  • Compare current yield and expense ratios for money market funds (SPAXX vs VMFXX) on provider websites.
  • Check Fidelity Inflation-Protected Bond Index Fund (FIPDX) duration and interest rate sensitivity.
  • Evaluate tax consequences of spending from inherited IRAs vs taxable accounts using current tax brackets and state laws.
Full transcriptexpand

0:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hey

0:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): everybody, welcome back to another edition of Five Question Friday, where I do my best to answer questions you all have sent in while I secretly try to drink a cup of coffee. And here are the five topics. First, the 4% rule and AUM fees. How do investment fees affect the 4% rule? Then we'll look at uh inherited IRAs versus taxable accounts, particularly uh as we think about spending either or both in retirement. Money market expense ratios, do they matter? TIPS funds that you've maybe invested in and now they're like losing money. Should that be a concern? And then finally, password managers. Anything that I might recommend. And so, yes, we'll take a look at that. All great topics. Now, if you want to send in a question, just subscribe to the newsletter with a link below this video. It's free, it goes out every Sunday morning. And then reply to any email you receive from me and ask your question or share a topic you'd like me to talk about. Would love to hear from you. All right, so with that, let's dive right into the questions.

1:04The first one today comes from a viewer named Kathleen. She says, Can you please address whether the 4% rule is before or after AUM fees? That stands for assets under management. Some investment advisors will charge a percent of the amount they're they're managing for you, and they call that uh asset under management or AUM fees. Uh Kathleen writes: Since AUM fees are deducted from investment accounts rather than dispersed by the investor, in other words, they don't bill you when you send in a check or or or give a credit card, they take it right out of your investments. This has an impact on planned withdrawals and spending. A 75 or 0.75% AUM fee would make the 4% rule more like the 3.25% rule for these investors when they are estimating withdrawals available for spending. Well, a great question. Whoops, sorry about that. Got ahead of myself. It's a great question, uh Kathleen. I'm going to use 1% AUM just because it's sort of an industry standard, and I'll be honest, it makes the math a little easier. But here's the thing that may surprise you: it turns out that if you're paying 1%

2:13uh AUM fee, that doesn't actually reduce the safe withdrawal rate from 4% to 3%. Now, I should back up here. When we talk about the safe withdrawal rate, there are a gajillion different ways to calculate the safe withdrawal rate. For our purposes, we'll use Bill Bingin's 1994 paper that concluded it was 4%. But you need to understand why it is that you can calculate it in different ways. Well, you can use us, you can make different assumptions about how your money is invested. In the 94 paper, he assumed that stocks were invested in the SP S P 500. bonds were invested in intermediate uh 10-year treasuries. But of course, those aren't the only two options, right? There are an infinite number of combinations of ways to invest your money, including different stock bond allocations. He assumed a 30-year retirement, but you could assume something else. He assumed you adjust your inflation, your spending by inflation every year, but you can assume something something else.

3:16So the list really goes on and on, but we'll just sort of use his his 4% paper as a starting point. And this question was at least the first time I had ever seen it addressed. It was addressed by Michael Kitsis in this 2012 article. Yes, I'll link to it below uh the video. And I want to just we'll just look at the executive summary in particular. this paragraph where he says the reality of the research is that while investment expenses do have a real cost, it is far less, it has far less of a spending impact than most assume. A 1% expense ratio might reduce, and this was based on his research, a 4% withdrawal uh rate, not to 3%, but instead to 3.6%. This pres uh surprising result occurs because of the what he calls self-mitigating impact of investment expenses that are recalculated based on the client's account. When accounts are declining, the fees decline as well, while inflation-adjusted spending goes up. Now that

4:21may be counterintuitive, but if we think about it, the 4% rule. was determined based on the absolute worst time to retire in the last hundred years. When Bill Bingham did his research, he was looking at 30-year retirements that began in 1926, and then he'd look at another 30-year retirement that began in 1927, 28, all the way up. He'd looked at 51 different 30-year Year retirement periods. The 4% rule is not an average of all of those. It's the worst case. And it turned out, and this can vary a little bit depending on what data you use, but it turned out that 1966 was a really bad year to retire. And when he looked at it, he said, you can really only start with 4%. Adjust that for inflation. After 30 years, you run out of money, more or less. Again, it can vary a little bit based on exactly what investment data you use. But in every other 30-year retirement period, you did better. Your safe withdrawal rate was higher than 4%. Again, there's almost an unlimited number of ways to recalculate the safe withdrawal rate. In fact, more recently, he's used other asset

5:30classes like small cap and international. He actually has raised what he thinks is the safe withdrawal rate to 4.7%. But going back to Michael Kitz's article, he says, look, if we just focus in on 19, effectively 1966, some put it at 1968, yeah, a 1% AUM fee doesn't reduce the 4% safe withdrawal rate to 3%, but instead of 3.6%. And the reason is your investment balances were were folding like a lawn chair. I mean, they were going down. and down for two reasons. Some really bad stock markets, 73, 74 is an example. That was just a one two punch for retirees. But inflation was high. So as your balance was going down, your spending on an after inflation basis was going up by a lot, sometimes double digits in a single year. And yeah, that that sort of one one-two two punch not only reduced your balances. but it reduced what you in theory would be paying your investment advisor. Because remember, they're getting 1% of however much they're investing on your behalf. And if that balance is going down every year, as it certainly was almost every year, they're getting a smaller and smaller paycheck. Now, let's look at this visually, and then I want to talk about a couple of things

6:50that uh Mr. Kitzis didn't cover in this article that I think are important. So, to do that, we're going to look at FI Calc, it's a free tool that I think is great to just sort of run through some numbers in terms of safe withdrawal rates. And I assumed a Um 6535 allocation. Remember, we've got to make that assumption. That's one of the many factors. And you can see for annual fees, I have 1.04 and 1.05. This assumes 1% goes to your advisor on a 1% AUM fee. And then the 0.04 and the 0.05 are basically just index fund fees. But that's important because you may have an advisor that's putting you in expensive funds that charge 50 basis points or 75%. basis points or 100 basis points. And so if that's the case, you'd want to use this tool and adjust those numbers accordingly. And if we look at the results, this still succeeds 92% of the time.

7:57And so it still succeeds most of the time. But what I want to do. is go down here and I want to actually look at 1966. There are other bad times, 68, 67. But if we look at this and we look at the portfolio balance, I mean it's just dropping like a rock. And so each time it goes down,

8:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh,

8:21Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and this is the spin chart, I guess. But no, it's portfolio value. That's right, it's portfolio value. We started at 100,000. Each time it goes down, and by the way, you can see 73, 74, it really fell. If you're paying your advisor 1% of your balance, well, they're getting a lot less each year, right? And so it turns out, and I think Michael Kitsis Kitsus is absolutely right. This doesn't affect your safe withdrawal rate, maybe as much. as you might think because of this scenario. Now, a couple of things I think to keep in mind here. First of all, a drop from 4% to 3.6% is huge, right? It's a 10% drop in what you can spend. At 4,000, I guess it goes to 3,600. If you've got a million dollar portfolio, instead of spending 40,000, in year one, you're spending 36,000. And so you're losing, you know, 10% of your spending power in exchange for a 1% AUM fee. So it really is much bigger than you might think. But here's the other thing to think about. Let's

9:31go back to FICalc. We've been focused on 1966. one of the worst, if not the worst, times to retire. And that's exactly what you should focus on if your question is: how does this affect the safe withdrawal rate? But that's not the only question we can we can ask. We could also ask, and I'll go back to the overview here. We could also ask, well, what does it do in maybe a good year? Right? I mean, sure, we we want to focus on the safe. withdrawal rate, but that's not the only thing we want to focus on because the odds of us retiring in the equivalent of a 1966 are not very good. Could happen. I guess we could retire in an even worse year. But remember, 1966, they've taken this data back to 1871. So we're really cherry-picking the absolute worst time to retire. Again, if we're focused on safe withdrawal rate, that makes sense. But what happens? in a year, maybe that's not quite as bad. So I wanted to look at 1985,

10:33which was actually a good time to retire from a financial safe withdrawal rate perspective and what will happen to our portfolio perspective. But again, we're looking at this, which has a 1% annual fee plus some a minor fee for index funds. This was a really good year to retire, 1985, and we ended up with a final portfolio value of 376,000. It's right here. Remember, we started with 100,000. So we're 30 years into retirement, and we've trip more than tripled our money, you

11:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,

11:05Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): gone from 100,000 to 376,000. But what would that number be if we didn't pay the 1% AUM fee? Well, I've got it right here. So here it's the same stock bond allocation, but no 1% AUM fee.

11:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We

11:22Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): can go down to 1985 and we're at over $548,000. So we went from $376 ending value to $148,000 ending value without that 1% AUM fee. A huge, huge difference. And in fact, by the way, if we come back to the fee version of this, and we just make this 2% because your advisor puts you into really expensive funds, not all, not all advisors do, but many of them do. That 376 drops to 256. And by the way, if we go back up to results, our 92% success rate drops to 74%. So I go through all of this in some detail because while I think while I think Michael Kitts' analysis is useful, it's not the whole picture at all. We need to look beyond just the safe withdrawal rate. We want to look at the impact of fees on our portfolio, even if we maybe retire in a good year. It's it The

12:23point is, a 1% AUM fee has a massive effect on our wealth, a massive effect on our wealth over time. If we look at just the safe withdrawal rate, it reduces our spending by 10%, which is huge. If we look at ending wealth, again, we just again I cherry-picked a good year. So you can use FI Calc to run the numbers for all kinds of years, but it really reduces our ending wealth. And and if your advisor puts you into expensive. funds, it really clobbers your wealth, right? So that's really important to keep in mind. Now, one other thing, I used a 100% or a $100,000 portfolio in my analysis. One of the reasons I've done that is because a lot of folks email me and say, Rob, I appreciate that some people retire with millions of dollars. But can you use examples with smaller retirement? balances? And so that's why I just picked 100,000 in today's video. But if you're at maybe at the lower end, you've got 100,000 or 200,000 and you're using this 1% AUM as an example, like we've done today. One thing to keep in mind is that depending on your balances, uh, you might not find an uh an AUM advice advisor willing to. charge you just one percent. A lot of them charge more than that

13:43for what I'll call smaller balances. I still think 100,000 or 200,000 is a lot of money. Uh but a lot of advisors, you won't find them willing to charge you one percent. So I looked up Michael Kitz's current employer um just as an example. And here it is. They um it's called FO Focus Wealth. I've never really heard of them. Let me go back to the top. Focus Wealth uh advisors. Is that what it's called? No, focus. I guess it's focus. Oh, here we go. Focus partner wealth. So this is what's called their their ADV, uh, their form ADV, I think two. I went to their website and couldn't find um information on their their their fees. Maybe it's there. I just missed it, but they did give a link to this form. And you can go to item five, and I'll show you the um this is true by the way of any investment advisor. This is not unique to focus. If they're if they're registered with the SEC, they've got to fill out this form. And you go to fees here, and we can see their fees. Their fees start as high as 1.25%. Now, again, I don't know any details beyond that. Uh so maybe if you've got 100,000.

14:51maybe your fee is lower. I don't know. But it starts at 1.25. Also, it says here they tend to have a minimum fee of $5,000. So if you had $100,000 and their minimum fee applied, again, maybe there's exceptions, I don't know. But that would be 5%. So the the the but the real point is not so much about this particular firm. I know nothing about it other. than looking at this ADV form. Uh uh but you may not be able to find an advisor that charges an AUM that's willing to charge you just 1% if you've got $100,000 or $200,000 to invest or some uh at least in the business, some relatively small amount uh of money. So keep that in mind.

15:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All

15:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): right, it's

15:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): probably more. than Kathleen asked for, but I I thought it was important to put it all of this into perspective. There's just no escaping it. A 1% or a 0.75% AUM fee has a very significant impact on your portfolio, whether you want to look at it from a safe withdrawal rate perspective or just an ending value perspective. Now, before we go to the next question. whenever I talk about a 1% AUM fee, I get a lot of folks that say, well, Rob, that's great and all. But if it if it helps you not sell in a market crash, it's worth

16:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.

16:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I think that's the wrong perspective. I suppose I can't argue with that. But the question is what is helping you survive, maybe, in a market crash, is not the 1% AUM fee. It's the financial advisor, maybe. If you've got a good relationship, they're doing their job. And so the answer might be, yeah, maybe you should use an investment advisor. That's great. The question is: should you be charging, should you be paying them a percentage of your wealth every year? Because there are plenty of uh advisors that charge an hourly rate or a flat fee. Uh, there's advice only that don't manage your money, they let you do the actual trades, but they'll walk you through everything. That's Mark Zorel, largely, who I've talked about in the past. So I hear you. Yeah, I think for a lot of folks, having an investment advisor is a really important thing.

17:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

17:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): just don't think we need to give away 1% of our wealth every single year for the rest of our lives, or 0.75% of our wealth every single year for the rest of our lives to have uh that kind of help. All right. Let's go. to question number two from Nico. My spouse recently inherited a small IRA, and our understanding is we have 10 years to take the money out, but can allow it to continue to grow, hopefully, during that time. We happen to have a taxable account with a similar balance. We'll need to spend uh approximately the amount in either one of those accounts in the next one to three years. We'll likely need to spend the rest. of the money in the following five to ten years. From your perspective, is it more advantageous to spend the IRA or the taxable account of first, assuming the assets within each are identical? Don't worry, I'll ask our CPA as well. And I think that's a great caveat because I'm not a tax professional or expert. But here's my take on it, and that is there's no rule of thumb, there's no heuristic.

18:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

18:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): don't know why I use that word. Rule of thumb is a better way to think about it, that can answer this question for us, in my opinion. We have to look at the specific situation, not only right now, uh, but as the years go by. And what do I mean by that? Well, one is what are the tax consequences? We know the tax consequences, at least to begin with, of pulling money out of an inherited IRA. Whatever you take out is going to be treated as ordinary income for tax purposes. What about a taxable account? Well, first of all, it's gonna depend on what you sell. You might have multiple investments in your taxable account, each with different tax ramifications. Some could be at a loss. So there's uh you don't pay any taxes, and you get a you get to uh report a loss on your taxes. Uh some could be at a gain, some could be at a short-term gain where you're going to be taxed at ordinary income rates, some could be at a long-term capital gain where you get the benefit of long-term capital gain. So that's the first thing we need to understand. What are the consequences of taking money out of the taxable account? And again, it could vary based on which investments you sell if you have more than one. And of course, we have to look at your the implications for state income.

19:16tax and where you live and what the implications are there. And then we have to look at it year by year. There could be some years where maybe you're in a really low tax bracket and you actually want to incur some more taxable income to fill up those low brackets. On the other hand, you could be in a situation where if you if you get taxed too much, it it uh reduces or eliminates your ACA tax. credits if you have uh uh uh um if you're using you know healthcare that's um that can get you those tax credits uh from for the marketplace or you could be worried about Irma and Medicare uh charges so there's just too many variables to give you a rule of thumb. Uh I think you've just got to do an analysis based on your current situation, your taxable account, where you live. and then think through as best you can the next 10 years and plan it that way where you again, depending on your tax situation, you might want to keep your taxable income down in some of those years. You might want to increase it in some of those years. And at the end of the day, the the the best answer uh

20:20in a given year could be that you pull from both, some from the inherited IRA and some from the tax. taxable account. So uh yeah, you either have to do the tax analysis yourself, or in Nico's cases, they've indicated they've got a CPA, so I don't have to worry about my answer because they're gonna check with them. That's my take on it. That's how I would think through uh the issue.

20:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All

20:40Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): right, question three

20:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): from

20:43Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Robert. Recently you discussed Fidelity's cash management account uh and its uh money market account, which has a ticker of SPAXX. versus Vanguard's money market fund and VMFXX. By the way, both Fidelity and Vanguard have other money market funds, but these are just the two we're going to look at here in Robert's question. Unless I missed it, you did not discuss Fidelity's expense ratios compared to Vanguard's. Fidelity's has an expense ratio of 42 basis points while uh Vanguard's is just 11. Is this something we should be taking into account? The answer is absolutely. You should be taking expense ratios into account. When it comes to money market funds, in addition to looking at what they specifically invest in and the tax implications, because if it's a federal money market fund, uh it could be uh you you might not have to pay state income tax on the interest. But you actually absolutely want to look on at the expense ratios, but ultimately what I look at is is is uh the yields. on an after uh expense basis. We can look at both of them. Here's SPACs, has a current yield of 327. And as Robert pointed out, and it's small type, but it's an expense ratio of 42 basis points. Vanguards is better, no question about it. It's got a higher seven-day yield, expense ratio is lower. So between these two funds, I would certainly pick Vanguards. Now

22:03there could be an issue here. You may have all of your funds at Fidelity or some other broker, by the way, where you can't invest in VMFXX. You've got to be at Vanguard to invest in it, maybe, right? I haven't actually confirmed that you can't invest in this elsewhere. Uh but that the the other issue could be you could be in Fidelity's cash management account. So even if you are invested in a Vanguard fund, and I'm going to give you an example of one in a minute that you absolutely can invest in pretty much anywhere. At Fidelity, if you want to write a check off of that cash management account or a debit card or a bill pay, they're not going to automatically sell a Vanguard fund to cover that payment. But if you're in a Fidelity money market fund, like SPAXX, they will. So I find myself keeping money in SPAXX that I use as sort of the equivalent of our checking account. But if I have money that I know I'm not going to need to spend, but it's in the cash management account, I tend to put it in this ETF V V-Bill. bill. Whoops, let me make it a little bigger, not smaller. There we go. It's got a similar yield to Vanguard's money market

23:17fund. It's actually three basis points higher. It's got a lower expense ratio. And so I use V-Bill a lot and other brokerages when I want to hold cash for a while. But again, if I'm in if I'm in Fidelity's cash management account and I need to spend the money, Uh, Fidelity won't automatically sell shares of this ETF. to cover the the payment. I've got to make sure I've got enough. It could be a different Fidelity money market fund, but but a Fidelity Money Mar like SPAXX, because Fidelity will automatically liquidate what it needs to from this fund to cover the payment. So short answer: absolutely it matters. I think the yield probably is what I tend to focus on, but generally in my experience, Vanguard has the best. Um, yeah, there could be other exceptions. I've certainly not looked at every single fund out there, but uh I I I think Fidelity, uh, I mean Vanguard tend to has have the best, uh highest paying money market funds and and funds like this, uh, V bill. Um, there are others, right? Uh Schwab has SGOV, but but it's it tends to be a couple of basis points lower in terms of the yield and uh than V-Bill. Again, certainly a reasonable

24:30fund, but the the long and short of it is expense ratios always matter.

24:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

24:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): there you go. Great question. Number four from Nancy. I recently added a TIPS fund to my Fidelity IRA. I don't fully understand TIPS, and the fund is F-I-P-D-X, F I P D X, we'll look at that in a minute, or bond funds, just a different fund, FXNAX. The TIPS fund has been in the red since I added it. Did I make a mistake? And specific questions are do I buy and hold it? Did I make a mistake adding it now? Or should I dollar cost average into a TIPS or other bond fund, like with equity? So great question. And let me go to the Fidelity Fund. Here it is. And I've owned this fund. In fact, I own it now. And uh it is an intermediate term TIPS fund, meaning the average duration/slash maturity of the tips it owns are in the six to seven year range. Let's see here. If we go to composition, all this text is small, so you're gonna have to trust me on this. Here's duration down here. Yeah, it's six and a half years, six point four seven years. The weighted average maturity a little longer, seven 7.1 seven point one years. So it's an intermediate term

25:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): tips.

25:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): a bond fund. What's the significance of its, you know, I I come down here and I point out duration, I point out years. What's so what? What's this significance? What that means, uh among other things, is that if interest rates go up, this fund, at least in the short term, will lose some money. And if rates go down, uh at least in the short term, it'll it'll have some gains. Uh certainly more so interest rates will affect this fund uh more than say a short-term tips fund. And we can see this in action if we go to performance. I actually want to just look at this chart here. Uh, and I wish I could make it bigger. Maybe there's a way, but any in any event, maybe I can. Let's see if I go. Yeah, not really, a little bit bigger. This is the performance year by year since 2020. 20, I guess, 16. 2022 was the really bad year. It went down. But you can look at every year, even a year that it ends on a high note. During the year it's gone down in value. Take this 24. It ended up higher at the end of the year, but during the year it went down, went down here, went down towards the end of the year, then it went back up. This year it went up, then went down, then it went back up. Now it's going down a little bit. That's all interest rate. rates. That's what's happening. Interest rates are changing and it's affecting the value of the fund. Here's my view on a fund like this.

26:59For a long-term buy and hold investor, I think this is a great fund as a way to get TIPS exposure. Could you get less volatility? Sure. You could invest in a shorter-term shorter term TIPS fund. And that might be a reasonable option too. Because it's shorter term, shorter duration, shorter maturity, interest rates won't affect it as much. Long term, you would expect an intermediate-term TIPS fund to outperform a short-term TIPS fund. Although, as we've seen, for long periods of time, it doesn't always work out that way. That's just the reality of investing. But welcome to the world of investing. But I think this is a perfectly reasonable fund for long-term investors. including those people in retirement who pull from their portfolio every year. And so let's say you're taking out 4%. You've got stock funds, you've got bond funds, you've got TIPS funds. I think it's perfectly reasonable to have a fund in like this included in that portfolio. Yes, you're going to withdraw from it a little bit each year, assuming you're rebalancing everything. And so in some years, you might end up selling some shares of this when it's down a little bit, in some years when it's up a little bit.

28:08If, you know, I think some people get really troubled by that. I don't. I think, particularly when you're rebalancing, so that you're effectively selling high and uh selling the funds that are up and buying the funds that are down. I think this is perfectly reasonable. Now, if you said to me, No, well, that's not what I'm doing, I need money three years from now. or I need to spend money over the next four years, maybe to bridge Social Security as an example. I probably wouldn't use this fund. I might use a short-term TIPS fund or I might build a TIPS ladder, but I probably wouldn't use an intermediate term fund for a specific need where I need a certain amount of money three years from now, or I want to spend a little bit over the next three, four years. By the way, that would be true of just a regular bond fund as well. I wouldn't use B and D for that kind of specific situation. Now, Nancy's last question was what about dollar cost averaging? But by the way, I guess to answer the second question, I don't think you made a mistake at all. Assuming you're a long term investor, this is part of a diversified portfolio. Um, I in my view, that I think this is a reasonable. fund. Can you dollar cost average into a tips or bond fund like you can

29:18with equities? Absolutely. In fact, I think a lot of people do that. You know, they've got money, maybe they got a bonus or inherited some money. They've got whatever 60-40 portfolio, 70-30 portfolio, and they want a dollar cost average. They want to take that lump sum that they got and move it into their overall portfolio over the course of the next six months or year? I think it's perfectly reasonable. Dollar cost averaging can apply to really just about any kind of investment. So you could dollar cost average into REITs, stocks, bonds. Yeah. I think it's all kind of the same concept, just applied to a different kind of investment.

29:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All

29:58Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): right,

29:58Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Deedra. Didra. Any suggestions for a tool or app to store organized passwords? I do. I'll give you two. The first one is Apple's password utility. It's free, but but you have to have all Apple. Macs, iPhone, tablets. It won't work in Windows. I think it's it's free, and I think it does a really good job. I don't, I don't think it at times I have I've used this. At times I have trouble getting it to work on certain websites. and uh in certain circ circumstances. Although that's probably true with just about any password manager. But I think this is a really good uh choice. You can see it's got a 4.7 rating uh in on the App Store after 763,000 uh re uh ratings. It's got a 4.7 out of five. I think it's a great free option. The other one I like, uh not a free option, but really um I think inexpensive is It's one password. I've used this as well. I've used a lot of them. But

30:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you

30:54Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): know, if a if a friend or family member called me up and said, What's your recommendation? I tell them the same thing I tell you guys in these videos. One of these two I think uh would do it. Are there others? Yes, there could be others that are just as good, but um let's see, for personal compare plans. This one for family is at least right now. 449. Um, so they're technically an affiliate, uh, but uh I'm not gonna put the affiliate link below the video. I'll just put a straight link to one password. Uh they're one of those programs I signed up for, but I've never ever mentioned them. I don't know. Uh that's just I don't know why I do that, but I'll just put a straight link in there. So there this will not be an affiliate link below the video. Um, and of course, uh Apple's password uh manager is free. So there you go. Yeah, those are the two that I uh would recommend that I like. Again, there could be others. Maybe if you have some that you like, you can leave a comment below the video. But those are the two uh that I would recommend. Well, there you go. Thanks for listening.

31:54Hopefully, you found this useful. Remember to send in a question, just subscribe to the newsletter, hit reply to any email you you you've receive received from me, and uh would love to hear. from you. Until next time, remember, the best thing money can buy is financial freedom.

This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights