George Riddell discusses WTO plurilateral agreements as a workaround for multilateral stagnation
Summary
George Riddell, former UK WTO representative, explains that geopolitical fragmentation and the WTO's consensus requirement have stalled multilateral rulemaking. He advocates for plurilateral agreements involving subsets of members as a practical alternative to achieve progress on issues like e-commerce and AI. Riddell highlights the legal mechanisms for integrating these agreements, noting that Annex 4 integration is currently blocked by lack of consensus. He urges businesses to lobby for specific commercial benefits in these emerging areas despite inclusion concerns for developing nations.
Key takeaways
- 1 agreement is something that is less than the full WTO membership. So the WTO has 160 plus members. That number keeps getting bigger every couple of years as more countries join the organization. And the agreements where everyone has signed up to the same rulebook. are called multilateral agreements. The last big round of multilateral agreements came out of the Euro round in 1994, which led to the creation of the World Trade Organization. And there's been a couple of standalone multilateral agreements that have been agreed since then. A case in point is a trade facilitation agreement back in 2013
George Riddell · 1:43
- 2 Developing and least-developed countries often lack the negotiating capacity in Geneva to participate effectively in multiple plurilateral negotiations, raising inclusion concerns.
George Riddell · 11:14
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 1:23
Introduction and Guest Background
Valerie Picard introduces George Riddell, Founder of Goyder Limited and former UK WTO representative, who co-authored an ICC policy paper on plurilateral agreements.
- 1:23 – 4:22
Defining Plurilateral vs Multilateral Agreements
Riddell defines plurilateral agreements as involving fewer than the full 160+ WTO members, contrasting them with multilateral agreements like the 1994 Uruguay Round or the 2013 Trade Facilitation Agreement.
- 4:22 – 6:00
Reasons for Shift to Plurilaterals
Riddell attributes the shift to plurilaterals to geopolitical fragmentation among major economies and the WTO's consensus requirement, which allows any single member to block progress.
- 6:00 – 8:25
Legal Integration Mechanisms
Two routes exist for integrating plurilaterals: unilateral schedule amendments or Annex 4 agreements. Riddell states that consensus is currently blocking the legal integration of the e-commerce and investment facilitation agreements.
- 8:25 – 10:45
Business Perspective and Urgency
Riddell argues that while businesses prefer multilateral rules, they must push for progress via plurilaterals given the current reality, highlighting evolving trade issues like AI and digital economy.
- 10:45 – 14:14
Concerns Regarding Fragmentation and Inclusion
Riddell addresses skepticism around plurilaterals, citing concerns about inclusion for developing nations with small negotiating teams and political economy factors where countries block progress to protect domestic interests.
- 14:14 – 19:29
Promising Initiatives and Future Topics
Key priorities include updating the Information Technology Agreement (ITA) to cover modern products and exploring environmental goods. Riddell places AI in a 'future issues' bucket, noting negotiations are not yet ready.
- 19:29 – 27:45
Role of Private Sector and Myths
Riddell asserts businesses are best positioned to identify trade barriers and must lobby governments with specific commercial impacts. He debunks the myth that plurilaterals are 'one size fits all,' emphasizing their variety and flexibility.
Claims worth verifying
The WTO has 160 plus members, and the number keeps getting bigger every couple of years.
George Riddell ·1:43
How to verify: Check the WTO website's 'Members' page for the current count and accession dates. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The last big round of multilateral agreements came out of the Uruguay Round in 1994, which led to the creation of the WTO.
George Riddell ·2:03
How to verify: Review WTO historical documents on the Uruguay Round and the establishment of the WTO in 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
A trade facilitation agreement was agreed in 2013.
George Riddell ·2:23
How to verify: Search for the 'WTO Trade Facilitation Agreement 2013' in WTO official publications. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The fisheries subsidies agreement was agreed more recently.
George Riddell ·2:23
How to verify: Check WTO records for the 'Fisheries Subsidies Agreement' adopted in 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The Information Technology Agreement was a sectoral agreement to eliminate tariffs on IT products.
George Riddell ·3:12
How to verify: Review the 'Joint Declaration on Trade in Information Technology Products' and its product coverage list. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The Joint Statement Initiative includes three new agreements: e-commerce, investment facilitation for development, and domestic regulation for services.
George Riddell ·3:31
How to verify: Check the WTO Joint Statement Initiative website for the three specific negotiations. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The Buenos Aires Ministerial Conference in 2017 saw countries launch plurilateral negotiations on e-commerce, investment facilitation, and domestic regulation.
George Riddell ·5:41
How to verify: Review the 'Buenos Aires Declaration' from the WTO MC10 in December 2017. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Only Singapore has ratified the e-commerce agreement as of the recording.
George Riddell ·18:22
How to verify: Check the WTO's 'e-commerce Joint Statement Initiative' page for the list of ratifying members. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The e-commerce agreement was launched in 2017.
George Riddell ·24:47
How to verify: Verify the launch date of the Joint Statement Initiative on E-Commerce at the WTO MC10 in Buenos Aires. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The Uruguay Round took place in 1994.
George Riddell ·2:03
How to verify: Confirm the dates of the Uruguay Round (2026-1994) via WTO historical archives. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify WTO membership lists and agreement texts to distinguish between plurilateral and multilateral frameworks.
- Review WTO decision-making procedures and recent ministerial conference outcomes to assess consensus barriers.
- Examine WTO legal texts and ratification statuses for the ITA, Domestic Regulation, and e-commerce agreements.
- Assess WTO member delegation sizes and participation records in plurilateral forums to evaluate inclusion for developing nations.
- Compare ITA product coverage lists with current global IT trade data to identify gaps in modern product regulation.
- Review ICC policy papers and business surveys on trade barriers to understand specific commercial impacts.
- Check the WTO's e-commerce joint statement initiative ratification tracker for current adoption status by member states.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:00
- Valerie Picard: Hello, my name is Valerie Picard, and I am going to be your host for today's episode of Trading Thoughts, where we're going to be talking about one of the liveliest debates in trade policy right now, plurilateral agreements, and what they mean for the future of the WTO. I'm really pleased to be joined today by George Riddell. So
- 0:20
- Valerie Picard: George is the founder and managing director of Goiter Limited, a boutique trade advisory firm that helps multinationals navigate. geopolitical tensions and build supply chain resilience. George previously represented the UK at the World Trade Organization and the United Nations and led trade strategy teams at two of the big four consultancies.
- 0:40
- Valerie Picard: And also, very importantly, George also worked with us on ICC's paper, What Next for Plurilateral Trade Agreements. George, thank you for joining us.
- 0:49
- George Riddell: Thanks, Valerie, and it's an absolute pleasure to
- 0:50
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): be here.
- 0:51
- George Riddell: today.
- 0:52
- Valerie Picard: Great. Thank you. So some of our listeners will remember an earlier episode that we did with Hamid Mamdu, where we talked about the challenges facing the WTO. This was in the lead up to the last ministerial, and we talked, among other things, around issues facing decision making, plurilaterals, and a number of other
- 1:12
- Valerie Picard: issues. For listeners new to the topic. when I refer to plurilateral agreements, what are these exactly and why have they moved to the debate about the WTO's future?
- 1:23
- George Riddell: Thanks, Valerie. And and it's such an important question at the moment, as you say, it really is at the heart of a lot of the big questions around the future of the World Trade Organization and what its members can do in order to move trade negotiations. forward. I think for me, the simplest way of thinking about a plurilateral
- 1:43
- George Riddell: agreement is something that is less than the full WTO membership. So the WTO has 160 plus members. That number keeps getting bigger every couple of years as more countries join the organization. And the agreements where everyone has signed up to the same rulebook. are called
- 2:03
- George Riddell: multilateral agreements. The last big round of multilateral agreements came out of the Euro round in 1994, which led to the creation of the World Trade Organization. And there's been a couple of standalone multilateral agreements that have been agreed since then. A case in point is a trade facilitation agreement
- 2:23
- George Riddell: back in 2013, and more recently, the fisheries subsidies agreement. In parallel, and this really does have a long history of within the WTO and its predecessor, the GATT, of agreements among subsections of WTO members. So really
- 2:43
- George Riddell: around coalitions of the willing looking to advance rules or market access in very specific areas.
- 2:51
- George Riddell: of trade. And this has a long history going back all the way to the 1960s and the Tokyo round with different agreements on technical barriers to trade and subsidies and things like that. The ones that I think people really have focused on and businesses are really most aware of, I would say,
- 3:12
- George Riddell: is something called the Information Technology Agreement. which was a sectoral agreement that a bunch of WTO members decided to eliminate tariffs on information technology products, sort of does what the name says on the tin. More recently, there's been something called the Joint Statement Initiative. So those are
- 3:31
- George Riddell: three new agreements around e-commerce, investment facilitation for development, and domestic regulation for service. services. And I think going into a bit more detail on those is probably where we want to take the conversation next because that's really where some of the big disagreements are happening in the organization today.
- 3:52
- Valerie Picard: Thanks, George. So
- 3:53
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 3:54
- Valerie Picard: think plurilaterals are less than the full membership, as you said, but they've always been a part of the system. So this is nothing new. And I think they've just perhaps what we can say is that they've gained in importance today because they're becoming the primary route to new rules. And I guess that is a question, sort of in terms of
- 4:14
- Valerie Picard: why have they moved to the center? Why aren't we going through
- 4:19
- Valerie Picard: having agreements with 166 members?
- 4:22
- George Riddell: If anyone um among under the listenership has an answer to that question, why aren't we doing it? And and has a viable solution on how to fix it, you know, I think there's a lot of ambassadors in Geneva and and trade ministries around the world who would love to hear those ideas. I think fundamentally, though, we're at a
- 4:41
- George Riddell: geopolitical point in a global economy, in geopolitics, where it is very, very difficult for the US, China, EU in India, all of the big countries to come together and agree a common rule book. That just fundamentally is very difficult at the moment, particularly in a
- 5:01
- George Riddell: system at the WTO, which requires consensus. So something where all WTO members need to agree on it. If even you have one who disagrees, then it doesn't pass, it doesn't go through. So that has been a consistent frustration around the multilateral discussions. That and you tend to always get cross
- 5:21
- George Riddell: linkages starting to occur between different negotiating files. So certain countries will want to trade agriculture off e-commerce, as what happened at the most recent BTO ministerial conference back in March in Yehunde, Yogunday, Cameroon. So the multilateral discussions do end up being really difficult, particularly in the
- 5:41
- George Riddell: current environment. So what you've had, and this really started back in 2017 at the Buenos Aires Ministerial Conference, where you had a host of countries, coalitions of the willings looking to advance negotiations, as I said, on e-commerce, investment facilitation, and domestic
- 6:00
- George Riddell: regulation for services. And they said we're going to do that plurilaterally. Where we start to get into some really crunchy issues around how the legal framework of the WTO operates is you basically have two routes at the moment of how to integrate plurilateral agreements into the legal
- 6:20
- George Riddell: framework. The first is around sort of where each WTO member amends their market access schedule, whether that's on the tariff side for goods or on the services side, where any country can do that unilaterally. So in the case of the information technology agreement, all the countries who were part
- 6:40
- George Riddell: of those negotiations unilaterally committed to the agreement as part of their WTO schedules, their market access, and it was given effect. practical effect that way. Same for domestic regulation for services. It was up to each of those countries to really do it themselves and
- 7:00
- George Riddell: sort of their own legal commitments. And, you know, there there's a couple of bits of paper and ministerial declarations that sit on top of that. But what really matters that how you integrate it into the schedules. Each country can do it themselves on their own. The other way is what's known as an Annex 4 agreement, which
- 7:20
- George Riddell: essentially allows new plurilateral agreements to be integrated into the framework. That, unfortunately, to add a new Annex IV agreement requires consensus. And today that is what is being blocked in the WTO with the e e-commerce commerce agreement and the investment facilitation for development agreement, that
- 7:40
- George Riddell: there's not this ability to get them into that Annex four. Because even though they're plurilateral agreements, even though that subsection of WTO members really, really wants them to be WTO agreements, there is this consensus requirement to get it legally integrated.
- 7:55
- Valerie Picard: So there are a number of legal issues facing all this. We're going to come back to the role of business and and what business wants, but if we're speaking to some of our SMEs sitting in countries and we start to explain to them all this at the moment, what we're hearing from them is we need to move forward with the rulemaking. And
- 8:15
- Valerie Picard: I wonder to what extent that debate, that very legal debate is now confronting sort of the real need to move forward with new rulemaking.
- 8:25
- George Riddell: Yeah, it is absolutely what we hear from business and even my own clients. When you try and say you're mired in this big debate around the future of the WTO and procedural rules between ambassadors as to how certain things get integrated into what is effectively a rule book that
- 8:45
- George Riddell: sort of sits on the desk. That is not what impacts businesses. That's not what allows them to trade That's not what really allows for market access and international growth opportunities. I think the the headline is that business would obviously like a multilateral agreement. It's obviously easier to have one
- 9:05
- George Riddell: agreement where the majority of countries around the world have signed up to a single set of rules. Given we don't live in that world, I think that it is businesses. role to say we want to see progress wherever that may be possible and certainly push their governments in order to look in those directions. And I
- 9:25
- George Riddell: think that is also reflective of the fact that the global economy continues to change. The trade issues that businesses face are very real and evolving, whether that's around environmental goods and sustained. sustainable technologies, incredibly important for many businesses today. We've obviously got the impact of
- 9:45
- George Riddell: the digital economy and artificial intelligence. And then also more prosaic issues like agricultural tariffs continue to be a big barrier for many businesses around the world. So wherever there is possibilities for countries to move forward as coalitions of the willing on. particular issues, I think that is
- 10:05
- George Riddell: incumbent on the business community to be making those arguments. It's not for business to be saying, and here are the legal technical solutions. That really is for WTO members and their trade lawyers to figure out. It's us as businesses to say we want progress and however we get there, new governments need to go in those
- 10:25
- George Riddell: directions.
- 10:25
- Valerie Picard: Completely agree. agreed. And you mentioned coalition of willing members moving things forward, but we know that that not everyone and not all members have been fans of of plurilaterals. There is some movement now within perhaps. That's a debate. But what are their concerns? Are there legitimate concerns? And I think the other issue that we often hear around this is the risk of fragmentation,
- 10:45
- Valerie Picard: right? So is just is plethora of plurilateral agreements going to fragment the system? So maybe you can walk us through that.
- 10:54
- George Riddell: As with everything, I think there's a bit of a range of views when certain countries express skepticism about the value of plurilateral agreements. One is definitely inclusion. For many developing and least developed countries, they don't necessarily have the negotiating capacity to be involved in lots of different
- 11:14
- George Riddell: negotiations. at the same time, particularly in Geneva. They have very small teams. So there is this point around if it's not happening within the formal structures of the WTO negotiating function, are they going to really be able to have their voices heard, advocate on their own behalf, and really understand the
- 11:33
- George Riddell: negotiations and what they're signing up to? With very targeted support, we have. seen really positive instances, particularly in the investment facilitation for development, negotiations around how it's possible to build an inclusive process from the beginning for those countries to make sure that they feel comfortable with where
- 11:53
- George Riddell: the direction that the negotiations are going. And I think needs to be built into to any future plurilateral negotiations. Then there's an argument that some make around slippery slope, particularly if we do move into this world of just negotiating plurilaterally.
- 12:13
- George Riddell: It reduces the incentive for countries to pursue multilateral negotiations because they won't necessarily have to make some of those trade-offs between the negotiating files that that I was talking about earlier. And there's sort of a principled stand that no the WTO is for multilateral negotiations. And again, in an ideal
- 12:33
- George Riddell: world I would absolutely agree with that. However, I think there is just the reality of the moment that we're in currently where multilateral progress isn't really possible on some of the big ticket items. So how do you move forward given some of those pressing business concerns that we spoke about? But The final one is where maybe it's
- 12:53
- George Riddell: less less of a valid argument, and this is rarely said out loud, but certainly underlines some positioning, is where it is not in a country's interest to advance plurilateral or indeed multilateral rulemaking that due to the specific political economy within their country at a
- 13:13
- George Riddell: particular time, that they just don't want to see progress. So we'll find ways of blocking those negotiations moving forward. And we certainly in the past have seen instances of that, usually resulting in quite heavy lobbying from other WTO members to try and get a shift in the position to varying degrees of success.
- 13:32
- Valerie Picard: I think that inclusivity is a real issue. And I sometimes also think about what we and we'll we'll come back to this as well. around the role of business as well and supporting supporting their governments as well. I think it's that's something we need to dig into a little bit. But let's let's make this a bit more concrete, especially as we talked about earlier in terms of what business actually
- 13:52
- Valerie Picard: wants. And you had mentioned already the information technology agreement. So what are we hearing? What do we see in terms of what we think are the most promising? plurilateral initiatives that we that could be taken forward at the moment? And maybe digging into, you know, why is this so important to the private sector that
- 14:12
- Valerie Picard: we make progress on this agenda?
- 14:14
- George Riddell: So, in terms of where we see businesses really wanting to see progress, I think there is almost an updating of the current plurilaterals that we have, particularly, you know, when it comes to the information technology agreement that was last agreed in in 2013. It doesn't contain a lot of the
- 14:34
- George Riddell: IT products that that businesses currently use. So there's certainly a push to see that updated. And that applies to to a number of the other tariff sectoral deals, whether that's pharmaceuticals, whether that's chemicals. There's a couple of other instances where those agreements could be updated from sort of previous incarnations. There's
- 14:54
- George Riddell: also an updating of the trade facilitation agreement. So this was a landmark multilateral agreement from 2013, really designed at cutting red tape at the border, and the ICC and others have been instrumental in seeing that implemented over the last 10 to 12 years. However, we know that there
- 15:14
- George Riddell: continue to be issues in the services of trade facilitation, whether that's maritime logistics, there is a huge amount more that we can do to cut red tape at the border and seeing what the next generation of those issues has and codified at the WTO, I think, would be really helpful for you know reducing the amount of
- 15:34
- George Riddell: time at borders. And then you've got sort of the new issues where so certain countries, whether, you know, around environmental goods, some countries have been really pioneering in their free trade agreements for liberalizing the trade in environmental goods and services. Can we see that
- 15:53
- George Riddell: expanded in the context of the WTO? I think that would be absolutely fantastic to see. There's obviously services market access, you know, a lot of services firms. would love to see those negotiations restarted. And then I would then have a third category of really out there future issues and maybe
- 16:12
- George Riddell: putting AI and some of the other more advanced trade topics in that bucket. We're definitely not ready to launch negotiations on those yet, but we know the the just fundamental impact that they're going to have on global trade and how does the global rule book respond to that, I think is going to be some really fascinating questions moving forward over the
- 16:32
- George Riddell: coming months and years.
- 16:34
- Valerie Picard: So basically we've got opportunities to deepen existing agreements that you've mentioned. And in particular, you know, we've already mentioned the information technology, but the trade facilitation agreement, which is an extraordinarily important agenda for the private sector. It's spoken about a little bit less, but it actually if when we speak to businesses, it remains
- 16:53
- Valerie Picard: absolutely top of the agenda is trade facilitation. You've also got sort of I tend to think in in buckets, I mean, you know, there's the trade and environment agenda, there's the services and market access, and as you so said, those future areas. And we've gone through these in the paper in that way. George, let's say you've got two minutes with your trade minister. So you you
- 17:13
- Valerie Picard: used to represent uh the UK at the WTO. What do we say to the minister at this point to make him understand or her how important this is?
- 17:22
- George Riddell: It's absolutely a a critical issue, I think, in terms of capturing your minister's attention. And for a lot of trade departments, that's hard at the moment. When you've got, you know, some of the big issues, whether that's US tariffs, Chinese export controls, new environmental measures coming out of Europe. you've got some big ticket items that getting attention at the moment's
- 17:42
- George Riddell: hard. I think there's three core messages that I would certainly want, hope that they're focusing on. One is without progress, the value and relevance of the WTO does get heavily diminished. We know from the ICC's excellent work in this area around sort of the economic cost of not having
- 18:02
- George Riddell: the WTO. or it disintegrating. That remains true and even more so in the context of this discussion around plurilaterals. The second message would absolutely be around let's get the current crop done. So that means ratifying the e commerce agreement. Currently, only Singapore has ratified the the agreement
- 18:22
- George Riddell: with the European Union potentially following up soon towards the end of this year. But we have a lot of other WTO members who haven't yet started that process. So that absolutely has to be there, as well as, you know, starting to do feasibility studies around what they need to do for the investment facilitation for development. And then the third is start
- 18:42
- George Riddell: talking to your business community around which of these, you know, the ICC and and the paper that that we wrote together has put out some absolutely fantastic. ideas. It's for governments to start saying, this one appeals to me, and really taking that forward around, okay, how do we actually structure some negotiations on these different
- 19:02
- George Riddell: topics? So those would be my three key messages. I never like going to a minister with more than three, so I'll stop there.
- 19:09
- Valerie Picard: It's very wise. I think it's a good transition because we've already spoken about this a bit, but I want to really dig into this. now is the role of the private sector in all of this. These agreements are obviously negotiated by governments. That's absolutely normal. But what should the private sector role be in all of this? I mean, we obviously know, but in
- 19:29
- Valerie Picard: particular in this current environment, what role should business be playing? What needs to be happening in countries around the world? And I think you've touched on some of this, but also in Geneva. where the negotiations would be happening.
- 19:42
- George Riddell: So business is really the only one who knows the challenges that they're facing, the trade barriers that they experience on a day-to-day basis. And unless they're telling their governments, hey, this is an actual commercial problem for me, I am not trading as much, or my trade is being impeded because of these different issues, they're the only ones who know.
- 20:02
- George Riddell: So unless they're vocalizing that lived experience, I think, you know, government officials aren't going to necessarily understand, have the expertise or the sectoral knowledge to be able to do that work. So I think it is incumbent on the business community to make their voice heard on real issues that are impacting them
- 20:21
- George Riddell: every day. In terms of big macro sort of political economy. in each country, for many trade ministers, a outcome or a trade-off on WTO reform alone isn't going to necessarily get them out of bed hum the next WTO ministerial meeting. It is a very
- 20:41
- George Riddell: important discussion, but it's not one necessarily that is going to drive jobs, investment, growth domestically, versus if there are plurilateral negotiations, whether they're being launched, concluded, whatever the case may be, and they have business leaders calling them up and saying, get this done, because it will benefit X
- 21:01
- George Riddell: sector in our economy. We will gain so many jobs, we will develop new industries off the back of it. That will incentivize them to really show up in Geneva and make some of those harder calls that will result inevitably out. of sort of this broader WTO reform process. And that brings us to the point, what do you do in
- 21:21
- George Riddell: Geneva? And I think quite often, as as we saw at the beginning of this conversation, the discussion can get really esoteric and completely moved away from the people who actually trade on a day-to-day basis and use the rules, whether that's the information technology agreement, whether that's the licensed licensing requirements around the domestic
- 21:41
- George Riddell: regulation for services. It's businesses who use these rules every day in the current plurilateral agreements. So they're the ones who should be reminding those WTO ambassadors that that's the case and what more needs to be done as a result.
- 21:55
- Valerie Picard: And thanks, Jrett and I think also from the ICC perspective, we've been talking a lot about having a structured role for business at the WTO which at the moment there is no path. It's informal. But either way, we're encouraging the kickstart of negotiations and certainly think it's really important for there to be, even if it's an informal dialogue,
- 22:15
- Valerie Picard: but something that is continuous to support the negotiations, to ensure that it's grounded in what business actually needs and delivers a result that is actually commercially meaningful. But maybe from your perspective, what are some of the myths around the discussion or um or things that people tend to misunderstand
- 22:34
- Valerie Picard: around plurilaterals that we need to clarify to be able to move forward?
- 22:39
- George Riddell: I think the biggest myth is that it's a one size fit all thing that you say plurilateral agreement and they all appear in the same way, in the same form and all have the same sort of problems with them, and particularly if you're talking to governments that perhaps are a little bit more skeptical of these types of agreements. Whereas, you know,
- 22:59
- George Riddell: as this conversation has demonstrated, you have a huge amount of variety within the types of agreements that that can be called plurilateral. So really fine-tuning, you know, the the outcome to what you want is really possible and it's not going to undermine sort of
- 23:19
- George Riddell: the existing WTO rule book if you know these agreements go ahead, primarily because a lot of them designed to support the existing framework, whether that's through the schedules or whatever else the case may be. So for me, that's probably the biggest myth is that they're not one size fit all. In fact, there's yeah, just this huge variety of
- 23:39
- George Riddell: potential options moving forward.
- 23:41
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 23:41
- Valerie Picard: I think that's really an important point, especially in the current environment with what ICC and and the discussion today around the future of the WTO or the WTO of the future, around introducing more flexibility. And already I think it's around that flexibility that needs to be, but when it comes to plurilaterals, which are the natural expression of that
- 24:01
- Valerie Picard: flexibility, which has always been there. So it's also using the flexibilities that are already there without having to necessarily create new ones. But when we talk about plurilaterals in the reform agenda, on the one hand, we're saying we can move forward right now. We don't need to wait for a full reform agenda. So how do we clarify what that means?
- 24:21
- Valerie Picard: How can we move forward if we need to reform on the same time?
- 24:24
- George Riddell: I think this is one area where.
- 24:28
- George Riddell: we in the business community, and certainly I know from working with the ICC, we like outcomes. And you know, we're talking about the eventual outcome and the benefit to business from these agreements. Whereas trade negotiators tend to take a little bit of time, a lot in certain instances, to get these up and running. So
- 24:47
- George Riddell: if we look at the whether it's the e-commerce agreement or certain services domestic regulation, you know, that was launched in twenty seventeen. The processes aren't even concluded today in many instances that, you know, fine, we have the legal text in the case of the e commerce agreement. Um countries have started ratifying it. We have an interim arrangement while
- 25:07
- George Riddell: sort of some of the big reform discussions go on in the WTO. But that's taken effectively nine years to to happen. I think for businesses, even if WTO members were to launch these processes tomorrow, that we've still got quite a lot of time as they're negotiated as, you know, for them to come into effect. So for
- 25:27
- George Riddell: me, it's when we're saying start now, it's you don't need anyone's permission to launch a negotiation, to launch an initiative to to start moving forward. Fine, you might need to deal with how to legally integrate it on the back end, but nothing stops the discussion starting today.
- 25:44
- Valerie Picard: And I think that's really what we hear from our members and our members are in and across from businesses that we speak to every day. They would say is underscoring the urgency of starting those processes because standing still is not an option. And so we absolutely have to move forward. George, is there anything that I haven't asked or that we haven't discussed that in a
- 26:04
- Valerie Picard: discussion on plurilaterals that we that we should have touched on?
- 26:08
- George Riddell: I think it is, you know, it's a hugely exciting area. And, you know, if we haven't plugged the ICC report enough, you know, I'm gonna take one more opportunity to to do so. And for the reason that of how many ICC CC members and different types of businesses engaged in the process, I think really was you know. fantastic to
- 26:28
- George Riddell: see, but also how rich some of the ideas in it are, because it draws from so many different sources as a result. So definitely another plug for the report, but also how it's, you know, going to be the foundation for future work. And hopefully businesses choose to to pick
- 26:47
- George Riddell: up, you know, even if it's only one of the ideas and say and, you know, take it to their government and say, Hey, this would actually really help my business, my international trade operations, if we saw easements happen in whatever the the area of trade might be. So that that would be my sincere hope from not
- 27:07
- George Riddell: only a report bit but also So this conversation. Yeah,
- 27:10
- Valerie Picard: no, I think that's the really important point that we saw this as the foundation and actually we're starting now work as well on our side to come with concrete proposals into some of these ideas that we've mentioned in the paper. So we're starting that work so that we can bring something even more concrete to the table. Well, maybe we'll end there. George, thank you very
- 27:30
- Valerie Picard: much for joining us today, um, for the collaboration on the paper, and of course, to all of our listeners for tuning in.
- 27:37
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That
- 27:37
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): was Trading Thoughts, a podcast.