The Puck: Venture Capital and Beyond

Historian Helena Rosenblatt argues liberalism historically emphasized civic duty over individual rights.

48 min Listen to the original Episode page
HistoryLiberalismCivic DutyRousseauEducationMediaPoliticsPhilosophy

Summary

Historian Helena Rosenblatt argues that modern liberalism has lost its historical emphasis on civic duty and generosity, shifting instead to a focus on individual rights during the Cold War. She contends that this shift has contributed to political polarization and a decline in civic engagement. Rosenblatt highlights Jean-Jacques Rousseau's influence, noting his distinction between individuals as a mass and as a community of citizens with obligations to the common good. The discussion also covers the role of media algorithms in fostering anger, the importance of humanities education, and the need for charitable interpretation in public discourse.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    He says if I could just give one word of advice, it's interpret. And I think that's so lovely. Absolutely. Interpret one another charitably. You're saying ask the person to find, explain what you mean. Don't assume the person is has bad will or is a bad person.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) · 46:59

Episode sections

  1. 0:18 – 3:12

    Introduction and Guest Background

    Jim Baer introduces Helena Rosenblatt, a historian at CUNY and author of 'The Lost History of Liberalism.' Rosenblatt shares her background, including growing up in Sweden, living in Peking and Beirut, and her appreciation for the American public school system and civic culture.

  2. 3:12 – 4:32

    Redefining Liberalism: Duty vs. Rights

    Rosenblatt argues that modern liberalism is wrongly viewed as solely about individual rights. She asserts that historically, liberalism emphasized duty, generosity, and civic obligation, a core principle that has been lost in contemporary discourse.

  3. 4:32 – 7:35

    The Cold War Shift to Individual Rights

    The speaker identifies the Cold War as the period when liberalism shifted focus. To distinguish Western democracies from fascism and Stalinism, Anglo-American ideology emphasized individual rights and property rights over the state, sidelining the concept of civic duty.

  4. 7:35 – 12:01

    Etymology and Values in Political Discourse

    Rosenblatt explains that the Latin root 'libre' means both freedom and generosity. She observes a potential resurgence in political discourse where figures like Tim Walz and Stephen Covey use values-based language to appeal to community and family rather than just entitlements.

  5. 12:01 – 14:20

    Healthcare as Civic Duty vs. Individual Choice

    The guest critiques the framing of healthcare legislation as a matter of individual choice, arguing instead that it should be articulated as a civic duty and obligation of citizens in a liberal democracy to ensure the well-being of their co-citizens.

  6. 14:20 – 22:42

    Civic Education and the Decline of Humanities

    Rosenblatt expresses concern that young people are disengaged from democracy and the humanities. She argues that without understanding history and the fragility of liberal democracy, citizens are vulnerable to authoritarianism and lack the critical thinking skills to defend their system.

  7. 22:42 – 30:04

    Campus Diversity and Critical Thinking

    The discussion turns to higher education, with Rosenblatt advocating for diversity of political perspectives on campuses. She suggests that engaging with diverse texts (e.g., Rousseau, Burke, Marx) and encouraging devil's advocacy fosters better critical thinking than echo chambers.

  8. 30:04 – 36:34

    Media Incentives and Polarization

    Baer and Rosenblatt discuss how modern media algorithms and the lack of gatekeepers incentivize anger and fear. They contrast this with the more moderated news of the past, noting that current political campaigns and news cycles rely on demonizing opponents to drive engagement.

  9. 36:34 – 37:35

    Historical Parallels and Institutional Void

    Speaker_0 argues that the decline of religious institutions has created a void filled by rampant materialism, drawing a parallel between the current era and the Roaring Twenties regarding wealth creation and lack of balance. Speaker_1 identifies Jean-Jacques Rousseau as a key intellectual influence, noting his dissertation and first book focused on him.

  10. 37:35 – 42:35

    Rousseau's Social Contract and Civic Duty

    Speaker_1 describes Rousseau as a complex thinker who distinguished between individuals as a mass and as a community of citizens. She explains that in The Social Contract, Rousseau argues citizens must vote and think for the common good rather than individual interests, framing this as a conversion-like experience rather than mere horse-trading.

  11. 42:35 – 44:03

    Civic Education and Reading Groups

    Speaker_1 advocates for reading groups discussing foundational liberal texts to foster deep thinking and civic understanding, contrasting this with short-form media like TikTok. Speaker_0 agrees, sharing a personal anecdote about learning the value of reading full texts like Tolstoy and Dostoevsky rather than summaries.

  12. 44:03 – 48:27

    AI, Communication, and Charitable Interpretation

    The speakers discuss Pope Leo's encyclical regarding AI, using the Tower of Babel metaphor to describe modern communication failures where words are used without shared meaning. Speaker_1 shares advice from her brother to 'interpret' one another charitably, suggesting this charitable interpretation is key to resolving conflict and fostering progress.

Claims worth verifying

Helena Rosenblatt is a Professor of History at the CUNY Graduate Center and a Guggenheim Fellow.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·0:22

How to verify: CUNY Graduate Center faculty directory; Guggenheim Foundation fellowship database. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Helena Rosenblatt is the author of 'The Lost History of Liberalism: From Ancient Rome to the Twenty-First Century'.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·0:41

How to verify: Publisher catalog (Yale University Press); ISBN search. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Rosenblatt lived in Peking, China, attending the French embassy school.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·1:47

How to verify: Biographical details in 'The Lost History of Liberalism' author bio; interviews with Rosenblatt. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Liberalism shifted focus to individual rights during the Cold War to distinguish Western democracies from fascism and Stalinism.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·4:32

How to verify: Historical analysis in 'The Lost History of Liberalism'; academic reviews of the book's thesis on Cold War ideology. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The Latin root 'libre' means both freedom and generosity.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·7:35

How to verify: Etymological dictionaries (e.g., Oxford English Dictionary, Merriam-Webster) for 'liberal' and 'liberty'. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Stephen Covey wrote 'The Seven Habits of Highly Effective People' and was Mormon.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·9:11

How to verify: Book publication details; Stephen Covey's biography. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The Catholic Church was adamantly against liberalism for centuries.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·10:30

How to verify: Papal encyclicals such as 'Syllabus of Errors' (1864) or 'Quanta Persona' (1864) which condemned liberalism. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Jonathan Haidt wrote about how different groups define concepts like 'purity' differently.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·29:14

How to verify: Jonathan Haidt's book 'The Righteous Mind' or 'The Coddling of the American Mind'; academic papers on moral foundations theory. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Speaker_0 claims that the Roaring Twenties and the current era share similar characteristics of extreme wealth creation and a lack of societal balance.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·36:59

How to verify: Compare historical economic data from the 1920s (e.g., Gini coefficient, stock market indices, wealth concentration metrics) with current economic data from 2026-2026 using sources like the World Inequality Database or Federal Reserve Distributional Wealth Accounts. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Speaker_1 states she wrote her dissertation and first book on Jean-Jacques Rousseau.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·37:55

How to verify: Check academic records or publication history for Helena Rosenblatt at CUNY Graduate Center; verify her first book title and subject via library catalogs or publisher databases. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Speaker_1 describes Rousseau's The Social Contract as 'the most radical text practically of all times.'

Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·38:15

How to verify: This is a subjective assertion of influence; verify by checking historical analyses of The Social Contract's impact in academic literature or citation indices. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Speaker_1 states Rousseau wrote a best-selling novel that was so popular people rented chapters from bookstores in the 18th century.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·38:35

How to verify: Verify Rousseau's bibliography for novels (e.g., Julie, or the New Heloise) and check historical records of 18th-century publishing trends and borrowing practices in French bookstores. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Speaker_1 states Rousseau wrote an autobiography called The Confessions and a pedagogical treatise called The Emile.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·38:46

How to verify: Check Rousseau's bibliography for the existence and titles of The Confessions and Emile, or On Education. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Speaker_0 references Pope Leo's encyclical discussing a choice between constructing a new Tower of Babel or building a city where God and humanity dwell together.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·44:03

How to verify: Identify the specific encyclical by Pope Leo (likely Leo XIII or a recent Pope Leo if the date is 2026) and locate the text discussing technology, the Tower of Babel, and human flourishing. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Speaker_0 mentions the expression 'when a student is ready, it will appear' and attributes it to Wayne Dyer.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·46:08

How to verify: Search Wayne Dyer's published works, speeches, or quotes databases for this specific phrase to verify attribution. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Speaker_1 states she was recently remarried and her brother flew in from Sweden to give a speech.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·46:59

How to verify: This is a personal biographical claim; verify through public social media profiles or recent public appearances of Helena Rosenblatt if available. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Read Helena Rosenblatt's book 'The Lost History of Liberalism' to verify her historical claims about the evolution of liberal thought.
  • Review primary texts by Jean-Jacques Rousseau, specifically 'The Social Contract', to assess the accuracy of the speaker's interpretation of his views on civic duty.
  • Examine historical economic data from the 1920s to verify the comparison between that era and the current period regarding wealth creation and societal balance.
  • Analyze academic studies on the impact of humanities education on critical thinking and civic engagement to evaluate the speaker's concerns about the decline of such studies.
  • Research the influence of media algorithms on political polarization to understand the mechanisms behind the 'anger and fear' incentives discussed.
  • Look for counter-arguments to Rousseau's philosophy from other political theorists to gain a balanced view of his influence on modern liberalism.
Full transcriptexpand

0:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): My

0:18Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): guest today is Helena Rosenblatt.

0:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): She

0:22Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): was born in Sweden. She came to America for graduate school, and she so fell in love with the country that she never left. She's a distinguished professor at CUNY Graduate Center in New York, and she's a Guggenheim Fellow. She's one of the foremost historians alive today on liberalism. And her book, The Lost History of Liberalism, argues that liberalism did not begin as a creed of individual rights. It began as a call to duty, generosity, and civic obligation.

0:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): If

0:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I was to sum up her argument in one line, it would be: we didn't lose liberalism because it failed. We lost it because we forgot what it was for. Eleanor Rosenblatt. Welcome to the puck.

1:12Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Thanks. Happy to be here.

1:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So I've been excited to do this interview. And one of the things I have to ask you is, from my understanding, you came from Sweden and you've never left. You know, what did you see in America that Americans today have stopped seeing?

1:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Oh wow. Well, you know, actually my father was a diplomat, so I traveled um uh as a child to many uh different places and lived in some amazing places when I was just born. my parents were in Moscow, but I'm Swedish. But then what I remember is Beirut, Lebanon, first to third grade. And I actually lived in Peking, China for a few years. In Peking, China, I went to the French embassy school and I just hated it. And so when I came to America, don't want to spend time on telling you why I hated it so much, but when I came to America and went to a just an American public school in Maryland, near Washington, DC, my father was with the Swedish embassy, Chevy Chase, Maryland, Somerset Elementary. And I just said, Wow, this is the greatest place on earth. I just love the school, the way things were taught. And that's where my love of of learning and reading was really kindled. And so I think it was that. There was something happy, there was something,

2:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah,

2:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): very people-oriented. So that's as a young, as a child. After that, I've I've learned to appreciate so many more things. I love the educational system. I think Americans in general are really friendly, generous people. When you meet them abroad, Odd. they're unassuming, they're unpretentious. So yeah, I feel a real affinity. I love New York City. So that's not exactly America, but I feel at home here more than anywhere else.

2:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): That's terrific. Well, so let's shift a little. You wrote a book called The Lost History of Liberalism. And it says almost everything we think about liberalism, we get wrong. What what is the biggest thing that we get wrong?

3:12Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I think the biggest thing that we get wrong today. is that it's really all about individual rights and individual choices. I think we hear that a lot. And as a society, we have become a bit obsessed with this, a way of seeing the world. I sense that something is starting to change right now, which I think is a wonderful thing. But liberalism, and in my book, as as you know, I go all the way back to ancient Rome before there was something called liberalism. But I speak about values, about the ideas that to be liberal was to aspire to something unselfish, something almost anti individualistic, if you will, to be generous, to think of the community. And I think that has dropped out of our conversation. conversations. So it's kind of surprising to some people to read my book and find that this has been such an important core principle of liberalism from the beginning, this idea that you are a citizen and things are expected of you, that you have duties to your community and your country and your fellow man.

4:23Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): When you say that there's been this change. is there a time where this flipping took place? And if so, why do you think it changed?

4:32Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I say that it basically changed in the most obvious way during the cold war. We had one kind of liberalism before that, the New Deal kind of liberalism. But during the Cold War, something happened where the rise of where you have fascism first and then Stalinism made people very anxious to prove why we, that is the West, that is America, was not them, was not Russia, was not, you know, fascist Italy or Nazi Germany or Stalinist Russia. We in America and in England mainly the Anglo-American Alliance, if you will, were not statists. We were for the individual, in a way to actually accentuate the differences between the systems of government and the ideologies. And with an a special emphasis, I would say, on property rights. And you can understand why that is the case when you're dealing with, you know, totalitarianism and Stalinism, that we wanted to say, this is what the we fought for, liberal democracy. Liberalism and liberal democracy stands for protecting the individual against the

5:51state. And so rights, individual rights became really primary, a kind of a self-definition. I'm not trying to say that individual rights weren't. there from the very beginning of the invention of liberalism. They were. But they were very also balanced with this idea, what I just referred to as kind of the other side of duties or obligations to the Commonwealth, to your to your state, to your s to your city, if you go all the way back to antiquity. So this idea of citizenship and what it meant to be a good citizen, I feel dropped out of most discussions around then in the Cold War. And I don't know if they're making a bit of a comeback now. I kind of hope so.

6:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I love the fact that you're saying you're seeing a little bit of a comeback. What are you seeing that's giving you this hope as a historian?

6:45Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I'm seeing people referring to values more. I just noticed somebody like Tallerico, I I'm not a m pundit, but he draws on his values and he he's not ashamed to talk about them. And this is very often something that I think liberals and and Democrats have conceded almost to Republicans and to conservatives, that they're the ones who are, you know, patriotic, of loving of family, community, all those things. And then the liberals and the Democrats get get stuck with this thing, oh, we're for the individual entitlements and like this thing, which isn't really it's just a way of even in a sense of articulating what we stand for and explaining that no, actually these principles are for the community, are for the family. As I describe in my book, there there's is the core of the word liberal is Libre, liber. and it means from from Latin, it means both freedom and generosity. So to be liberal is not just to want freedom for yourself, but it's also to be generous. And so throughout history I feel there's been this

7:55rearticulation in different circumstances of what that actually means. What does it mean to be generous to your family? to your community, to your nation? You know, I think I'm really happy when I hear politicians and public intellectuals drawing on these ideas, these beautiful ideas, and allowing them to kind of inform the platform, if you will, to kind of explain ourselves in those words. Words matter. And the word liberal has had this rhetorical. power from the very beginning. People have fought over the word liberal, you know, which I also explained in my book, which is kind of funny in a way, because for many years, liberals have been shying away from the word liberal, right? They've been frightened to, you know, call themselves that. And I think there again, maybe something is changing where it's not so bad to be a liberal. But let's see, let's see. I tend to be an optimist.

8:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And I think it's interesting when you, because you're referring to the Texas Senate race, you're talking about these values. And what he has done, I think, uniquely, is bring back a discussion of religious Judeo-Christian values, but in a way that is not as alienating the people. I remember Stephen Covey did this when he he was a Mormon and he wrote a book called The Seven Habits of Highly Effective. Affected People, and he talked about principles and he talked about values, but he didn't use the G word because he saw it as so polarizing. And it is interesting as a historian, how do we have a discussion about values, but do it in a way that's not so alienating?

9:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Well, that's right. Well, the people I I focus on, although they tended to be Protestants, Protestant, and you know, Protestants are overrepresented in relation to their actual numbers in liberal movements and liberal pro in liberal parties. And that's an interesting fact. But it was a certain kind of Protestant. It was one more or almost unitarian. Many of them were kind of Unitarian, so not terribly doctrinal, not a lot of emphasis at all on dogmas and rituals and ceremonies. and so on. Some of them you hardly hear them mention Jesus Christ. Sometimes it's really more about God and providence and being a good person, that that's what God wants us to do is to be a good person, very tolerant, all of them big on top, sometimes not so much against Catholicism, not too happy with Catholicism because of the stance of the Pope. But you know, I hasten to say that there have been plenty of Catholic. Catholics who've been liberal too and totally on board. But in general, the Pope and the Catholic Church was for centuries uh adamantly against this thing they called liberalism. And they defined that in a certain way. But back to your question, it's really a way to accentuate, you know, in language that can appeal to everyone, frankly, about goodness, but you know, human beings.

10:51they want good things for their family. They basically want happy relationships, marriages, partnerships, a good environment, a good community, and to speak to that and not to, you know, dogmas and doctrines. So there was that was the religious vocabulary. Now, I imagine Telerico, I'm not following him daily, is using that kind of language that is one that is uniting and not dividing the very various forms of of of religion.

11:17Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And I think he is trying to do that and I think it is resonating with people. There are some people that as soon as you hear the word religious, they turn off. But again, if we can have a discussion of values in a way that unites us as opposed to dividing us, it seems like that would move us in a better direction.

11:36Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I feel that there is a kind of yearning for something we might call values, something a little bit other than, you know, consume ramp and consumerism or worries about money and jobs, vocational training. I think that there is really room in our in our society and in our conversation for these kinds of discussions about values. and being a good person basically, you know, is is it a terrible thing to to say that I'll just throw out there that I find so interesting when Hillary Clinton and and so when they were talking about getting healthcare legislation passed, I remember, you know, it's discussed as a matter of choice, you know, people should have choice. People should get, you know, healthcare health care up and they're all about choice. and individual choice and all this. I'm saying, like, how about the fact that we have like a duty and obligation as citizens of this biggest, w wealthiest liberal democracy in the world to make sure that

12:41all our co-citizens have health care? Are we good people? Are we citizens? Are we gonna do that? Or we're just gonna let people be sick? and die? I mean, that's pretty stark. It seems like the language there, I mean, I'm sure of course Hillary and all the people who are for it have the best intentions. I'm not saying that their program was wrong. I'm just saying the way it's it it's articulated is not doesn't inspire. I think we can just do better in terms of articulating democratic principles, liberal democratic principles. why they matter, why we should embrace them, not just the policy.

13:19Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Whether it's the new atheism or humanism or in general, being able to talk about what makes a better society. And I I use the term on the puck character-based capitalism. Yeah. And I was recently saying to someone regardless if you're religious, when you look at the world of AI and you look at the algorithm. algorithms and you look at how much time we spend on our phones, the notion of bringing back the Sabbath, you know, a 24 hour break from technology, not because God demands it, but rather because if you try it, you'd be happier. And so it's like some of these Judeo Christian practices, instead of looking at them as obligations per se, look at them as opportunities to have a better life.

14:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, absolutely.

14:08Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So you've said that you think that liberal democracy is under threat, not just under stress. What are you seeing that gives us concerns so that we really can work on this?

14:20Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Well, I always like to say, first of all, that I'm a historian, so I'm not an expert. at contemporary politics or or or such, but I do feel that, you know, besides the problem with with our president I say our because I feel American even though I'm I'm still a Swedish citizen as well. But this is this is the country I really feel most connected to. But I think that the real problem is that a lot of young people seem not very political. Like they're not voting in large numbers. They don't seem to I've seen some very scary statistics about young people thinking that democracy doesn't matter much. They feel like maybe, maybe just getting, you know, this this was part of the reason we got Donald Trump is that people think maybe we just need a a strong man, a businessman who can just fix things for us. And that students are very concerned with getting jobs, and understandably so. It's very competitive out there. It's scary right now with AI and everything. But they're focused more on this the decline of the humanities. My personal grip. Obviously, I'm a history professor. And so it's it's sad, but it's also dangerous, I think, that students are not. and young people are not really

15:40learning their history, how hard with the battles that have been fought to bring them where they are, to bring us all where we are, and learning the lessons of how vulnerable liberal democracy is and what happens when you don't defend it. What the other system is like. Do they even know? Do they understand? I don't think so. You know, I lived in China as a young girl. I was there o under Mao, and I mean, wow, that made an impression on me even as even as a twelve year old. And then as I said, then coming to America and feeling like, wow, this is just such a positive, optimistic country. What makes it that? Well, it's a system of government. You know, uh uh very much that. There's other things involved, the economy, of course, but it that's all related. So this is it. How engaged are people? How committed are people to support and participate in this thing we call liberal democracy? So it's not just a question of who's in power, but it's also understanding the system, the

16:40constitution, respecting it, even revering it. I was recently, strangely, I was strange because it's not really my my expertise. I was asked to be on a debate, open debate, it's called. It's it's a podcast, I think, where I was in a debate about should should we stop idolizing the founding fathers? And I said, we don't idolize. The thing is nobody idolizes the founding fathers anymore. It's been the uh going in the opposite direction for so very, very, very long. I'm for respecting them, admiring them, putting them in their context, and looking at this amazing document that they put, this amazing system of government that's lasted for all these years, and that, yeah, it's not perfect. They were not perfect. And I I'm afraid maybe young people don't uh there are exceptions, of course, but don't quite understand their history and and therefore might just make a big mistake and we lose it all.

17:41It's fragile.

17:42Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): It it is fragile. And as you said, it's gone on a long time. I want to talk about colleges, but before we do, let let's talk about congress for a second, because it is one of the branches of government. You talked about the cynicism. A congressman friend of mine, when I pushed him on, for instance, things like the deficit and getting our house in order, at at the end of the call, he finally broke down and he said, Jim, here's the problem. When you do a poll, seven or eight out of ten Americans want their taxes to go down, and seven or eight Americans want their benefits to go up. And so absent some form of obligation on the part of Congress and people doing the right thing, how do we set the example? for young people that our government does work?

18:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I can only come to it from from my perspective perspective, which is, you know, the education side, schools and universities need to play a role, a role that they've perhaps not been very good at at inspiring citizenship. You know, talking about the things I I've spoken about, the the importance of being getting involved and the important importance and once you get involved and once you understand the history and once you understand the the political system and and all of this, I think that will kindle something in them that will make them want to be better people and spread the word, be better citizens. I'm not saying they're not good people. They're just like understand that citizenship is something very exciting and important. and will give them a lot of feeling of satisfaction. Right? I I think so. Studies have been made, you know, and and here again I'm going into fields that aren't really mine, but from what I understand, you know, people are happy when they give things. It gives you a feeling of happiness when you do something good for someone else or you're generous. Much more even than, you know, buying yourself another. handbag or, you know, an expensive car. And so by encouraging these sorts of activities for young people, whether it's joining some kind of

19:50uh, you know, pre-political organization, get out the vote camp things, or or even student councils and those kinds of things, encouraging them can I I would think help. I'm very gladdened by how many of these civic institutes are sprouting around the across the country. They tend, I think, to be happening in more conservative states, which is interesting, but I've been invited to many and I don't see an ideological sort of trend to them. They they read classes classical texts with students. You know, it's like uh understanding what a liberal arts education is really about, but really with a lot of focus on history and the great texts. I'm a big believer in the great big texts. Let's get away from this idea that we shouldn't study dead white men because they had a l, they were they were far from perfect, but the the texts that have survived are truly great and wonderful to grapple with, problematic, of course, but also super interesting to discuss. And that's where you in discussion and reading these great texts, I think it cultivates a kind of very positive optim

21:09Optimistic form of critical judgment.

21:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You

21:12Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): know, yeah, we should scrutinize our politics, our history, aim to improve it, but be respectful, understand our responsibilities to make it better, not just to not just to criticize, but also to improve.

21:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Love it. And you know, when we had Frank Bruni on the puck, we talked about the importance of critical thinking. And, you know, I went to a liberal arts school, and I remember the the founder of the school is a guy named Paul Cummins, and he was a big Robert Frost fan, and talking about the two paths diverge in the wood, and I took the one least traveled. And he really wanted, he's a humanist, and he really wanted us to think about values and commitment. And I went to a very liberal UC college, and they there were mostly liberal professors, but there were more conservative professors. Now, you were with a large system of colleges in a fairly liberal state, and you made the comment about that there's some of these changes taking place in the more conservative states. And so what I would say to you is if we're going to have a balanced citizensry and we're going to have critical thinking discussions, the university universities have to play their part. And if every professor thinks alike, we're not challenging our students and we are fostering this

22:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): kind

22:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): of sameness. I'm just saying, what do you think needs to change in higher education?

22:42Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I think we do need diversity of political perspectives on on campuses and in classrooms. And I I think that's that my colleagues, historians in general, are probably more prone to that since we look at the past with critical eyes and so on. But I think there's a a way that we can be, you know, I'm back again talking about being overly critical. I like to, in my class, for example, I like also to play devil's disciple and I'll tell them that. I'll say even something as crazy as, you know, you come across some sexist comment, I'm and going like, well, can we defend it in some way? I mean, you know, because there's some just like put yourself in that person's shoes. Why is that person saying that? We can have discussions like that. And I make a big deal. My students will tell you that at the beginning of class, I say that, you know, in this room, we are going to be allowed to try out ideas. And we can say something and then take it back or change our mind. Okay. So let's just think of like trying out stuff and not be worried. This is a safe space, if you will, because you know we're just in the sense that we're not going to jump at each other's throats if we say something that came out wrong. But it's the only and we actually talk about that. Like it's the only way we're really going to learn from each other. Having said that, most of my students pretty agree on most

24:02things. So it doesn't cre we don't have very, very vibrant debates. How do you encourage a diversity of political perspectives on a campus? How do you do that with our system of advertising positions? And you're supposed to say, oh, we're looking for a Republican? I mean, maybe somebody smarter than I has a as way, but I do think it would be a good idea. I prank, you know, I feel that, and I'll come back to you know, the great texts are wonderful way because they aren't all saying the same thing. And then you can grapple with people on the right, people on the left have said this. What does it mean to take this kind of position? What did you know, y you want wanna to read Rousseau? Do you want wanna to read Edmund Burke? Do you want to read wanna read Marx? And then balance the curriculum and have conversations like that. You know, John Locke and Marx. Like imagine, you know, the different contexts. Do we understand what they were dealing with, what they were trying to say? You know, sometimes I find it's really weird, but when you get really deep into context and a text. of well-meaning, brilliant people, you start to say, hey, they kind of want the same thing.

25:20Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): It is interesting that we do sometimes want to keep people in an echo chamber. And yet, if you really are asking yourself what's best, what's the goal? Is it to really create smart thinking people? You would come to the conclusion that you need diversity. of thought. You need debate. And so even if there's a majority of liberals on campus, the notion that you wouldn't bring in conservatives to have that heated debate and let the students engage with that, that's coming from a place of fear, not courage.

25:56Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, and and disrespect. You know, just also disrespect because and and yeah I I think most people would would agree though that like with with a lot of the liberals I talk I I discuss and John Stuart Mill and so on that truth is out of of debate and and of battle of of opinions. It's the only way, you know, we're going to progress is uh I mean if we just speak to people who believe what we believe, where are we going? We're psh you know, we're We're not we're not making any kind of progress. And and also to build a a a good community.

26:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Obviously you have different audiences. You have your students that you're teaching,

26:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you're

26:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): on Ezra Klein, you're putting it out there, but you're also writing for the National Review lately. Is there something about that audience that attracts you and how does that fit into your message?

26:50Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I'm like what we just said. I want to reach and have conversations with people of different perspectives. And in some ways, in some ways I may even without getting too personal, I may be conservative in some ways. That's the other thing. You can be conservative in some ways and more liberal in other ways. I saw something really interesting in the New York Times the other day with these graphs where it was showing that people really are. not divided a hundred percent according to some kind of party line. Like you can be like Republican or cons on some issues and not on other issues. And so they were showing it's a c it's a really cool diagram that kind of moves. And and that's so true. So I don't feel myself one 100% hundred percent aligned with I haven't found the person I'm a hundred 100% percent. aligned with exactly. So you know and and to us to a certain extent I also find it interesting to listen to people who have different views. I mean with some you know with some exceptions or restrictions on what is acceptable.

27:56Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I think that words are finite and they divide. And if you go back and you look at a lot of literature and a lot of ways in which we communicate, there's a theory that really deep conversations should be had one on one. If you go to an atheist and you say, Do you believe in God? The answer is no. But if you talk about the watchmaker, or you talk about the deist way of looking at the universe, or do you think it's all random, they'll say think no. There's an order to the universe, there's physical. physics, there's a law of the universe. Oh, well, is that immutable? Is that higher than us? And you realize we're not as divided as we think we are.

28:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): There's this really, you know, Jonathan Haidt, who writes really interesting, interesting books.

28:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Absolutely.

28:43Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah. And when we talk about the internet and we talk about, you know, the algorithms and the importance of Shabbat, for instance, he comes to mind because. he is talking about the dangers. So absolutely.

28:54Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Something else that he wrote, I think one of his early maybe his earliest book, he talks about how how certain concepts, so like like that we that we agree on certain concepts like purity, right? But then we define them differently. Like if you're maybe with a very conservative person, they're really in into purity, but that means no, no premarital sex. And purity for a liberal might be, you know, organic food.

29:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Do

29:24Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): you know? I'm I'm I hope I'm not totally massacring his point there and that it is Jonathan Heid I'm talking about. But I found that so very interesting that we have we we agree on certain like frameworks or principles. I'm sure there's agreement. Of course there's agreement.

30:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I think there is, but I think one of the challenges. is that when you look at the economic incentives around the way we get news today, it's dramatically changed. And I said this to someone when we were watching the three networks and we got 20 minutes of news with commercials at six o'clock with Walter Cronkite, they were pitching to Republicans and Democrats alike. And so the message was more moderated because you didn't want to alienate anybody. And there were pluses and minuses to that.

30:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): In

30:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): a world where everyone gets to buy their own media, in the same way when Alexander Hamilton fought his duel, there were all these pamphlets with different biases. It's so easy to pick and choose your news now, and people are feeding you what. you want to hear to make you angry and afraid. And so the notion of really stopping to think and understand the similarities, we're we're constantly being manipulated to do just the opposite.

31:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I know. And I I actually I have f close friends and people I I respect and even love who are so alienated by the news, newspaper. newspapers, that they seem to be getting their news off of Instagram and places like this. And which I think makes it even worse, because they're just getting these sort of, I don't know, who's nowadays, I mean, they can just totally make up stuff and make it look like people are saying things that they're not really saying. I mean, you know, the Th the th there's got gotta to be gatekeepers. There are no gatekeepers at all, right? When you go to the and so they just get more and more polarized and more and more angry and worried and scared. And then when that happens, you feel like there's no point. What can I do anyway? It's just like we're heading towards disaster and I'm out of control. A lot of people, I think, feel out of control like

31:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they

31:56Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): don't know what to do.

31:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I couldn't agree with you more, and that's why I brought the concept of the Sabbath, because the reality is we don't even take a breath to reflect on the fact that we are being manipulated and that we do have free will and we don't have to give up our free will and we can turn off the algorithms and actually, you know, look at both sides of an argument. I'm forced to do it because when I do the podcast, I really have to do research. And so I listen to both sides. of the aisle. And it's amazing to me how we take an issue and we use purposely inflammatory words to make our point on either side of the aisle. Yeah. And you can't help but be manipulated by that.

32:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): No, absolutely. And and you when you watch these political campaigns now, they have to demonize the the other person and uh both sides do it. I guess it's very hard not to to kind of sometimes delay deliberately miss adversary. You know, I see I see that's done political thinkers, the people I read you know, do that as well in debate. You know, you take something out of context, you make the other person look stupid, whatever. But it's like a strategy to to to get elected. And then I you know, I was listening to one of I think it was one of your ear earlier podcasts about the short election cycle. You know, four years only doesn't give people much chance. They've got to start campaigning again. So it's this endless, you know, people have like headlines. We hear snippets of things and then a lot of insults. Anyway, this is going to be depressing.

33:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): On

33:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): a more optimistic note, let me ask

33:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you

33:32Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): a question. You really are someone that is in it. I mean, whether or not you're teaching in a university, you're writing for more conservative media, you're doing these podcasts, from my perspective, you have a pretty balanced perspective and an open-minded perspective. Where did you get this sensibility from? How did you understand the importance of obligations versus just freedom? What informs who you are?

34:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): My parents were not political. at all. My mom I I never heard her say anything, you know. She was a a doc medical doctor and totally uninterested in politics, would read crime novels, you know. Very bright, very bright, wonderful woman, but not politically oriented at all. My father died very young. I think it was through school, and and I think really at Columbia University, actually Barnard College, I went to and I stumbled into this. classroom. Literally, just just I'd seen uh, you know, it in the catal course catalog, and you know, for the first week or so you can kind of experiment and go try out classes. And so there was this wonderful course in intellectual history by uh a wonderful professor Lauren Sticky. And I think that it was reading great texts, reading that this is maybe, you know, probably worth why I really recommend it. Grappling with this great text of people thinking very deeply about human problems and what are they, and what is human nature, and what is a human being. And is it possible to change? Are we sinful? Because a lot of this, you know, the early stuff is is a lot of Christian thinkers, is a lot of original sin, and there's a lot of discussion about what. is what is human, what is the human? Are we capable of good? Are we

35:20just nasty? What is a a good society looks like? How do we build it? All of this. So I became fascinated by that. And then you can't, and I love America, but I also see, you know, all this commercialism. You know, so maybe the contrast between the two made me think about this. Have you noticed there's one little thing, since we're having just this conversation back and forth, there's a little thing that really irritates me. And it's like everywhere you go now, you're considered like a consumer or a, you know, like you're no longer a passenger. Have you noticed? Like you get on, you get on an airplane and they say, what's the word they use? Not passengers anymore. You're like consumers or something else they're calling you. It's I'm I'm blanking out right now. But and you go to the doctor's office, you get an opinion poll or something to answer afterwards about like a consumer satisfaction thing. And like, what is this? The only place where I'm actually a customer, you know, like in a grocery store, I'm called a visitor.

36:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You

36:22Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): know, I I'm not a guest. I'm called a guest at at this local supermarket. When they call you forward to the cashier, they say, next guest, please. I said, like, I think I'm a customer here. Thank you very much.

36:34Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I think when there's a void, I think, for instance, government had balances separation of church and state. Well, that person presupposed that there was a church and there was a state. If there's mostly a state, because we've gotten rid of our institutions and we've dethroned religion, so to speak, until something replaces that, i.e., some type of way of passing down these values, it leaves room for what I would call rampant materialism. And I think when you look at what happened in the roaring twenties and you look at what's going on now, they say history rhymes. I mean, I've never seen the wealth creation and the the lack of balance in in my entire life. You said you read these great texts, and I want to press you a little because I have certain favorites and they've changed over the years. But what were the things that you think had the that you grappled with that there were the most interesting texts that you read when you were starting on this journey?

37:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): In this class where I was actually an undergraduate where were German thinkers prior to Marx, the young Hegelians, but super interesting people, complex, deep thought. But I also, I mean, one of my favorites. I wrote my dissertation as Jean-Jacques Rousseau. And that was my my dissertation and my first book was on Rousseau. And like a more challenging and interesting and important thinker is hard. to imagine. He was such a uh broad ranging uh genius, frankly, famous for his social contract, a book called The Social Contract, which is considered like the most radical text practically of all times. Of course, like everything that these great thinkers produce, it's debated exactly what he meant, and you can read it in different ways, but that he's very radical is is certainly true. But he also wrote a blockbuster best-selling novel. I mean it was in in again in the 18th century when the novel was just just sort of becoming a thing. And it was so popular that people were renting it from bookstores, uh renting chapters.

38:46And he wrote an autobiography called The Confessions. He wrote a pedagogical treatise called The Emile. And in each of these range genres, he kind of blew up blew up the conventions and just was so innovative and so mind-opening. He was considered a man of paradox. He called himself a man of paradox because he seems to say contradictory things. And that makes him difficult, but it also makes him incredibly mind opening in a way, because he really forces you to give up any kind of simplistic thinking, understanding the complications, but if of true philosophy, of these deep questions of right and wrong. And everybody else, after you've read Rousseau, seems like easy peasy.

39:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Is there a favorite example you can give us that that may tie into liberalism and this idea of obligations versus rights? I mean, how is there a way to fit him into this discussion? If he was here with the

39:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): reason why

39:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): we're

39:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): going to have a question, I'll just

39:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): give you one little sort of sentence or snippet of a sentence, which will give you an idea. In the social contract, at one point, he says, and when the people becomes a people, and then he goes on.

40:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

40:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): it's just so bizarre. Like when the people becomes a people, and what he's doing there is you take two words and the same word and you just suppose it like that. And in the context, you realize that he's creating a tension and causing you to say, like, what is a people? A people becomes a people when they come together, a bunch. of individuals, separate people, come together and decide we are going to be a people, meaning a community, a group of citizens. It's different. It's like uh uh any number of individuals. That's one thing, that's a mass, Us. that's a kind of way of looking at people, but then they come together and that's something something happens when they decide to do that. They become citizens as opposed to just. He he recognizes also that you still have this, you're still an individual, but you take on this other public persona of being a citizen.

41:07Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): You know, when you think about on the extremes, cults, when you think about the chosen people or people choosing

41:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to

41:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): be. Jewish, or people deciding to be Catholic, or people to be a Mason, or people to be deciding to be a Dodger fan, a Republican, a Democrat. I mean that that there are certain ideas and commitments that you're fostering when you make the choice to commit to being part of a group.

41:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): And he explains it almost like it's almost like a kind of a conversion experience. I mean not it's not too spiritual or anything. It's very straightforward and I it's very easy to to understand the social contract if you pick it up. But he really kind of explains that you come in there and then you really decide that from now on you are going to think or vote for the common good and not for your individual interests. So this is one of the reasons I like to think about this and read it with students, which is really that it's not about horse trading. It's not like for Rousseau, it's not like, oh, our individual interests will all fight it out and then the majority interest wins. No. He says there's something that should happen to you when you go into To that voting booth or that forum. And that is that you start to think for the common good. not for your own personal interest. So reading a text like that and discussing it can kindle thoughts in someone, right? I think it

42:35can be a really good experience just to deal with that text and to think what could he possibly have meant? And is that even possible to institute today? Does it make sense? If so, how do we make it happen? You know, you can have these conversations. I love the idea of getting together with people. There was a reading group here, and I was invited to talk about my book. Somebody had kind of like a salon, you know, and invited people every month or so to discuss a book. Everybody reads it and comes together. I just love those. I know people do it all the time, but they do it sort of also with fiction. And sure, that's great. But how about taking some of these amazing texts in the in the great liberal tradition and discussing them together?

43:18Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Hopefully the younger generation will continue to be inspired by your curiosity and wisdom. Because again, it's so easy to just watch a 30 second TikTok video, but you get so much more when you immerse yourself into things. And I I remember when

43:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

43:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): was young, I had a friend that was reading Tolstoy and Dostoevsky, Dostoyevsky. and I

43:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): was

43:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): like, well, I could just read the Cliff Notes. Why why do I have to read the book? Boy, did I learn my lesson when when I endeavored to read those texts and realize, oh my God, there's a whole world out there that I needed to to dive into. So could not agree with you more.

43:55Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): And we need to like slow down, right? Take the time to slow down and sit and read a book from cover to cover, you know?

44:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): On the Sabbath.

44:03Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): On the Sabbath. Why not?

44:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So I know we talked a little bit about Protestantism. I know we talked a little bit about Catholicism. I do want to touch on AI for a sec. And I think when we talked before, I mentioned that when Pope Leo's encyclical talked about a choice that we face, that either as a society we construct a new Tower of Babel or we build a city in which God and human humanity can dwell together. I thought when I raised that with you, you said fabulous. What about that intrigued you?

44:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I guess just on a very superficial level, I like this idea of the Tower of Babel and the confusion of languages and of words, because we're all we're using words, but we're not really communicating. We're sometimes using the same words meaning different things. with them. Yeah. So this does not create harmony. This doesn't create progress. We're just talking past each other or getting angry with each other. So I think I just took it like that. Trevor

45:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Burrus, Jr.

45:03Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Just whether or not we can work to build a world where he used the word word God and humanity can dwell together. But because the word God is so polarizing, I would try. change the word to say a world where values and something bigger than yourself that you live for, that are these universal principles and values something that we can live with in a secular world where freedom is so important.

45:34Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I remain an optimist. So I think this is just something we have to make happen. You're helping to make it happen in our my little way, I'm trying to make it happen. And you know, history is funny. Sometimes surprising things come out of catastrophes, right? Crisis.

45:49Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I remember when COVID took place and you know, we talked about the expansion. So one person is exposed to two people, two people are or to four, eight. And you look at geometric growth, there's also an expression that I think it was Wayne Dyer that said that when a student is ready, it will appear. I think that these values we're talking about, and just the idea that words matter, but that they really are divisive and finite, and yet there is an infinite, broader way of looking at things. That if somehow we can open up ourselves to listening and when somebody uses a word like God or being a coward, what do you mean by that? Define that for me. If we could just do that one thing, I think we'd make infinite progress.

46:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah. Give the other person the benefit of the doubt. You know, this makes me I mean I'm having Have such a wonderful conversation with you right now. Stuff is coming out that I don't normally talk about, but I was just recently remarried. And so my brother flew in from Sweden and gave this speech. And one of the things he said just stuck with me. Uh he's been married for a very long time. And he just said, If I just have one word of advice, and it was not a like a judgmental, judgy kind of talk at all. It was sweet, it was light, it was fun. He says if I could just give one word of advice, it's interpret. And I think that's so lovely. Absolutely. Interpret one another charitably. You're saying ask the person to find, explain what you mean. Don't assume the person is has bad will or is a bad person.

47:32Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): That is a beautiful, beautiful way to end this wonderful conversation. I have thoroughly enjoyed it. You are a pleasure. and an inspiration. Your students are lucky to have you and keep up the fight.

47:45Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Wow. Really enjoyed it. Thank you so much.

47:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The

47:48Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Fuck Venture Capital and Beyond is brought to you by CMBG Advisors. If you enjoyed the conversation today and haven't yet subscribed, you can find us on YouTube, Spotify, and Apple Podcasts. Feel free to leave a review while you are there. and maybe even a five-star rating. Follow us on socials at Puck Venture Pod or the Puck Venture Capital and Beyond. You can find us on TikTok, Instagram, Facebook, LinkedIn, and YouTube for updates, highlights, and more content from our team.

48:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Our

48:19Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): website is thepuckpodcast.com. Thanks for listening. We'll be back soon with a new episode.

This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights