Lazaroff argues state-specific muni funds offer negligible tax advantage over national funds due to diversification risks
Summary
Peter Lazaroff challenges the conventional wisdom that state-specific municipal bond funds are superior to national funds, arguing that the tax break is often minimal or non-existent. He illustrates that high local demand for tax-exempt bonds compresses yields, sometimes making national funds more attractive after taxes. Lazaroff highlights significant diversification risks, citing examples where local economic shocks or cross-state corporate guarantees led to correlated downgrades. He suggests that Separately Managed Accounts (SMAs) may offer a better alternative for investors seeking both tax efficiency and broader diversification.
Key takeaways
- 1 A separate public power authority issued those bonds, but LA's power system was responsible for more. than 90% of the project's obligations. So even though the wind farm was hundreds of miles away, the bonds depended heavily on the health of the utility in Los Angeles.
Peter Lazaroff · 4:41
- 2 particularly for people who are working, which are also typically the people who are in those higher tax brackets who are considering munis, is that you really need to think about how much of your household's financial life already depends on the local economy. For example, if you own a local business and a downturn hits, you might need to draw from the portfolio just as some of your local bonds are under pressure. So again, just another side point as it pertains to your personal balance sheet
Peter Lazaroff · 6:19
Episode sections
- 0:02 – 3:41
Intro and Tax Break Math
Peter Lazaroff introduces the topic of state-specific municipal bonds versus national funds, questioning if the tax break is worth the risk. He presents a hypothetical $1 million investment comparison showing a home-state fund yielding $35,000 tax-free versus a national fund yielding $38,000 pre-tax, resulting in only an $800 annual difference after a 10% state tax.
- 3:41 – 5:01
Diversification Risks and LA Wildfires Example
Lazaroff argues that bonds are primarily for volatility reduction and warns against concentrating risk in one state. He cites January 2025, where S&P downgraded Utah wind farm bonds due to the financial health of the Los Angeles utility that guaranteed over 90% of the project's obligations, illustrating cross-state contagion.
- 5:01 – 10:08
NY Transit Example and SMA Alternative
He references 2020 New York, where collapsing transit ridership led to simultaneous downgrades of transit, city, and state debt. For high-tax residents, he recommends a Separately Managed Account (SMA) over a state-specific fund to allow managers to buy out-of-state bonds for diversification while maintaining home-state preferences.
Claims worth verifying
Home-state municipal bond funds often have lower yields because high demand from local investors seeking tax exemptions pushes bond prices up, reducing the initial yield for the investor.
Peter Lazaroff ·1:42
How to verify: Check historical yield data for state-specific vs. national muni funds in high-tax states (e.g., CA, NY) using Bloomberg or MSCI data to confirm the 'tax exemption effect' on yields. For recent events, verify 2026-08-11 through 2026-11-11. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
In a hypothetical scenario with a 10% state tax rate, a national muni fund yielding 3.8% generates more after-tax income ($34,200) than a home-state fund yielding 3.5% ($35,000), resulting in only an $800 annual advantage for the home-state fund on a $1 million portfolio.
Peter Lazaroff ·2:41
How to verify: Verify the arithmetic: $35,000 (home) vs $38,000 * (1 - 0.10) = $34,200 (national). The difference is $800. This is a mathematical claim based on the speaker's hypothetical numbers. For recent events, verify 2026-08-11 through 2026-11-11. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
S&P downgraded bonds tied to a wind farm in Utah in January 2025 because the Los Angeles utility was responsible for more than 90% of the project's obligations.
Peter Lazaroff ·4:41
How to verify: Search S&P Global Ratings press releases or credit opinions for 'Utah wind farm' and 'Los Angeles utility' dated around January 2026 to confirm the downgrade and the specific obligation percentage. For recent events, verify 2026-08-11 through 2026-11-11. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Moody's downgraded the New York Transit Authority's revenue bonds in September 2020 and cut ratings on NYC and state debt in October 2020.
Peter Lazaroff ·5:21
How to verify: Search Moody's Investor Service press releases for 'New York Transit Authority' and 'New York State/City' downgrades in Sept/Oct 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-11 through 2026-11-11. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceNew York municipal bonds trailed the national municipal bond index by approximately one percentage point before investor taxes in the first 11 months of 2020.
Peter Lazaroff ·5:39
How to verify: Compare the total return of a NY-specific muni index (e.g., Bloomberg Barclays NY Muni) against the Bloomberg Barclays National Muni Index for Jan-Nov 2020. For recent events, verify 2026-08-11 through 2026-11-11. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Peter Lazaroff is the Chief Investment Officer at Plain Corp.
Peter Lazaroff ·0:02
How to verify: Check the Plain Corp website or LinkedIn profile for Peter Lazaroff's title. For recent events, verify 2026-08-11 through 2026-11-11. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Peter Lazaroff is an employee of Plan Corp and Brightplan.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·9:41
How to verify: Check the podcast show notes or Plan Corp's disclosure documents for employment details. For recent events, verify 2026-08-11 through 2026-11-11. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify current yield spreads between national and state-specific municipal bond ETFs/mutual funds using sources like Bloomberg or Morningstar.
- Review the top 10 holdings of state-specific muni funds to assess concentration risk in specific issuers or sectors.
- Check credit rating reports from S&P, Moody's, or Fitch for recent downgrades in your home state, particularly in transit, utilities, and general obligation debt.
- Analyze personal income sources to determine if your employment or business revenue is correlated with your home state's economic health.
- Compare the expense ratios and tax-efficiency metrics of Separately Managed Accounts (SMAs) versus mutual funds for high-net-worth investors.
- Research historical instances of cross-state contagion in municipal bond markets, such as the Utah wind farm/LA utility example cited.
- Assess the tax bracket and state tax rate of the investor to calculate the actual after-tax yield difference between national and state-specific funds.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:02
- Peter Lazaroff: Welcome back to the Long Term Investor, where we distill complex financial matters into easily digestible lessons. I'm Peter Lazaroff, Chief Investment Officer at Plain Corp, and two weeks ago, I described how the rise in interest rates makes it a good time to revisit how your fixed income assets are invested. This week I want to
- 0:22
- Peter Lazaroff: focus on state-specific municipal bonds, because if you live in a high-tax state, keeping all your municipal bonds close to home can feel like an easy decision. But how much extra income do you actually keep? And what risk are you taking to get it? That's what we are going to get into today. But before
- 0:42
- Peter Lazaroff: we do, I wanted to let you know that I'm carving out some extra time from now until the end of the year to speak with listeners just like you who are interested in. becoming clients of Plan Corp. I do this once or twice a year, so if you're interested, there's a link at the top of the episode description, or you can visit callwithpeter.com.
- 1:02
- Peter Lazaroff: Now, let's just start with the basics of how municipal bonds work. A municipal bond is a loan. A city might borrow to build a school, or a utility might borrow to upgrade its water system. The borrower promises to pay interest and return the money it's borrowed. Some bonds are backed by a government's general resources. Others are
- 1:22
- Peter Lazaroff: backed by a specific source of revenue, like the bills people pay for water. The interest on most municipal bonds is exempt from federal income tax, but qualifying bonds from your home state can offer a state tax break too. And that's the appeal of a home state fund. But the tax break can affect the yield you start with.
- 1:42
- Peter Lazaroff: When more local investors want the same bonds for the exemption, their demand can push prices up and yields down. So before putting all your munis in one state, you should want to know how much extra income you'd actually keep for the additional risk you're assuming by not diversifying nationally. So let's run some numbers.
- 2:02
- Peter Lazaroff: There is a table in the show notes at the longterminvestor.com that you can use to follow along, but I'll try to keep this pretty simple. Let's say you have $1 million in munis and you're comparing funds with similar credit quality and interest rate sensitivity. In this hypothetical, yields are after fund expenses, and both bond
- 2:22
- Peter Lazaroff: funds have their income federally tax exempt. Now, the home state funds. income is going to be fully exempt from state tax, while the national funds income is going to be fully taxable in your state at 10% with no federal deduction on the state tax. Now, again, there's a table at the longterminvestor.com, but I think I can
- 2:41
- Peter Lazaroff: simplify this pretty well for you listening in. The Home State Fund generates $35,000 a year and you keep all of it. The national fund generates $38,000. So after a 10% state income tax, you'd keep $34,200. So in this example of your million dollars in a muni fund, going
- 3:01
- Peter Lazaroff: all in on your home state puts an extra $800 into your pocket for the year. But that is not a huge difference. And as I mentioned before, the difference in the after after-tax tax return might be smaller than. you expect because other investors want that same tax break. And if you want to get into the nitty-gritty, I have
- 3:21
- Peter Lazaroff: linked out to the research that shows how their demand can push up the price of local bonds and bring down the yield. You might think, but it's still a higher yield. And I hear you, but I'd encourage you to think about the diversification risks you accept for that nominal amount of additional return. So let's not forget the main reason we own
- 3:41
- Peter Lazaroff: bonds is to reduce the overall volatility of your portfolio, which in turn I think makes it easier to stick with stocks when they experience the inevitable downturns. I think that's always helpful to remember whenever we're talking about squeezing more returns out of our bond portfolio. Sure, a home state munifund can hold
- 4:01
- Peter Lazaroff: hundreds of bonds, but it's not unusual for a single event to put pressure on several of them at once. And sometimes it can even reach bonds you'd never think to connect. So the example that I find myself pointing to all the time these days is January 2025, after the Los Angeles wildfires had led
- 4:21
- Peter Lazaroff: to SP downgrading the city's utilities water and power bonds. At the time, the rating agency was weighing whether the utility had enough cash and insurance to cover potential liabilities, and it also raised concern about how well the water system was prepared for emergencies. But here's what surprised most people: SP
- 4:41
- Peter Lazaroff: also downgraded bonds tied to a wind farm in Utah. A separate public power authority issued those bonds, but LA's power system was responsible for more. than 90% of the project's obligations. So even though the wind farm was hundreds of miles away, the bonds depended heavily on the health of the
- 5:01
- Peter Lazaroff: utility in Los Angeles. And I think that is just such a good example because it crosses state lines in a way that most people don't think about. Now, I think the more common situation that people are going to think about is going to be more local. localized. For example, think back to 2020, when New York commuters stayed home, which led to transit
- 5:21
- Peter Lazaroff: ridership collapsing and falling fare revenue. The broader slowdown also put pressure on New York City's and New York State's budgets. So Moody's downgraded the transit authority's revenue bonds in September, then cut its ratings on the city and state debt the following month.
- 5:38
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All
- 5:39
- Peter Lazaroff: three came under pressure at the same time, even though they had different ways of paying their debts. And while New York munis gained over the first 11 months of 2020, they trailed the national municipally a percentage point before investor taxes. The point for people considering state-specific munis is that the next surprise could come from anywhere.
- 5:59
- Peter Lazaroff: By spreading your Muni holdings across the country, less of your bond. portfolio depends on what happens in any one region. So if something unexpected puts several local borrowers under pressure at once, it's likely to affect a smaller share of the money you're counting on for stability. A similar, somewhat related topic that I feel like I have to point out,
- 6:19
- Peter Lazaroff: particularly for people who are working, which are also typically the people who are in those higher tax brackets who are considering munis, is that you really need to think about how much of your household's financial life already depends on the local economy. For example, if you own a local business and a downturn hits, you might need to draw from the portfolio just as some of
- 6:39
- Peter Lazaroff: your local bonds are under pressure. So again, just another side point as it pertains to your personal balance sheet, but back to the comparison of national municifunds munifunds and state-specific munis. munifunds. In addition to this risk management side of diversification that we've been talking about, I don't wanna lose sight of the fact that there is a broader
- 6:58
- Peter Lazaroff: opportunity set of a national munifund that allows an investment manager to pass on bonds in your home state that look expensive and look for comparable bonds elsewhere. Think back to the state tax break. If enough people want the same local bonds, they can bid up the price. When you pay more for the same payments, you earn a lower
- 7:18
- Peter Lazaroff: yield. Prices can also change depending on what's for sale that week. Say several cities and utilities all bring new bonds to the market at once. Some may have to offer a little more yield to find enough buyers. A national manager can take a look, even if there's very little worth considering buying in your home state that week. Sometimes the
- 7:38
- Peter Lazaroff: best deal will be. in your home state, but you want to give your manager the ability to shop around. So perhaps you're wondering do state specific municipal bonds ever make sense? If you're in a high state tax bracket in somewhere like California or New York, maybe the extra tax break can be worth a
- 7:57
- Peter Lazaroff: closer look. But in those situations, rather than going with a state state-specific specific Muni bond, fund, I would prefer to utilize a separately managed account or an SMA. In a Muni SMA, you're gonna own the individual bonds in your account and a manager's going to buy and sell them for you, kind of like a mutual fund, but just for yourself. But you can give
- 8:17
- Peter Lazaroff: home state bonds a preference and still give the manager room to buy elsewhere. So say the manager finds a bond in another state that pays just as much. after state taxes and carries similar risks. That bond may earn a spot because it spreads some of your exposure outside your home state. When it comes to SMAs,
- 8:37
- Peter Lazaroff: where you live is obviously one factor, but when you'll need the money and what you already own is also going to factor in how that portfolio gets built for you. So let's say if you expect to use some of that money in five years, the man manager can look for bonds that come due around then. And if you already own a lot of debt from a particular borrower, you
- 8:57
- Peter Lazaroff: can ask the manager to limit how much more they buy. As always, an SMA is going to add a hint of complexity to your portfolio, but it's one of those things where if it makes sense for you, it can add quite a bit of value. That's all I have for today, but if you'd like help evaluating. your bond allocation as part of a
- 9:17
- Peter Lazaroff: complete financial plan, you can visit callwithpeter.com to schedule a conversation with me and my team at Plan Corp. As always, thanks for listening, and until next time, to Long Term Investing.
- 9:29
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Thanks for listening to the Long Term Investor Podcast. To access free financial resources and submit questions to be answered on the show, visit the Long longterminvestor.com. Term Investor Podcast.
- 9:41
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Peter Lazaroff is an employee of Plan Corp and Brightplan. All opinions expressed by Peter and any podcast guests are solely their own opinions and do not reflect the opinions of Plan Corp or Brightplan. This podcast is for informational purposes only and should not be relied upon as a basis for investment decisions. Clients of Plan
- 10:01
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): PlanCorp Corp and Brightplan and Bright may Plan maintain positions in the securities discussed in this podcast.