Derek May discusses bankruptcy strategies, homestead exemptions, and foreclosure postponement in California real estate
Summary
Derek May, a bankruptcy attorney, outlines how Chapter 13 filings are rising to stop foreclosures, noting a surge in cases compared to 2020-2022 levels. He explains that California's homestead exemption protects equity up to a county-specific cap, but recording it is necessary to create a legal presumption of primary residence. May advises against using new debt to pay off judgment liens before filing, as it complicates exemption claims. The episode also covers the mechanics of lien avoidance, the high cost of reopening cases, and the 45-day foreclosure postponement available under California law via listing agreements.
Episode sections
- 0:01 – 1:04
Introduction and Practice Overview
Derek May introduces himself as a bankruptcy attorney and certified specialist in San Bernardino County with 20 years of experience. He notes a recent surge in Chapter 13 filings to stop foreclosures, averaging four to five per month over the summer, compared to two or three annually between 2020 and 2022.
- 1:04 – 5:04
Client Demographics and Debt Trends
Ryan Orr and Derek May discuss clients who bought recently with little down payment and faced income shocks like job loss or reduced overtime. Many high-income earners carry large unsecured debts, such as a couple earning $500,000 annually with $500,000 in unsecured debt.
- 5:04 – 7:12
Business Bankruptcy and Chapter 11
May explains that he primarily handles consumer bankruptcy but takes on Chapter 11 cases for sole proprietorships or small LLCs, often to terminate leases or shut down businesses with ongoing litigation. He cites a restaurant case where lease liability was reduced from $600,000 to $230,000.
- 7:12 – 9:21
Automatic Stay and Foreclosure Prevention
The automatic stay stops collection activities immediately upon filing. May emphasizes the critical need to notify the foreclosure trustee directly via phone or fax, as failure to do so may result in the sale proceeding despite the bankruptcy filing.
- 9:21 – 13:50
Discharge and Non-Dischargeable Debts
A discharge is a federal legal excuse to not pay debts, not a taxable forgiveness event. Non-dischargeable debts include most taxes, student loans (unless undue hardship is proven), ongoing HOA fees for retained property, and debts from fraud.
- 13:50 – 14:07
Chapter 7 vs. Chapter 13 Mechanics
Chapter 7 is for individuals and businesses to liquidate or shut down, while Chapter 13 is for individuals to repay debts over 36-60 months using disposable income. Plan length depends on median income, and payments are based on disposable income, not necessarily full debt amounts unless income is high.
- 14:07 – 25:21
Homestead Exemption and Equity Protection
California's homestead exemption protects up to $497,000 in equity (as of the recording). May advises recording the homestead to create a presumption of primary residence, which helps prevent forced sales by judgment creditors who must prove otherwise by clear and convincing evidence.
- 25:21 – 28:25
Judgment Liens and Forced Sales
Judgment creditors can force a sale if equity exceeds the exemption amount, whereas the IRS typically does not force sales. May warns against taking on new debt like home equity loans to pay off judgments, as it may complicate the situation if the judgment lien remains.
- 28:25 – 29:37
Judgment Liens and Title Searches
Ryan J. Orr explains that judgments are against the person or entity, not the property, and require a statement of information to identify. Escrow agents request this upfront to determine if liens apply to the specific title holder.
- 29:37 – 32:08
Reopening Bankruptcy to Avoid Liens
Derek May states that judgment liens are not automatically removed by a discharge. If not addressed initially, the case can be reopened to file a motion to avoid the lien based on the property's value at the time of the original filing.
- 32:08 – 33:14
Costs and Timeline for Lien Avoidance
Reopening a case to remove a lien takes about thirty days and costs approximately $2,000, including attorney fees, filing fees, and historical appraisal costs. The court does not treat this as an emergency.
- 33:14 – 35:02
Bankruptcy Filing Trends and Chapter Types
Bankruptcy filings in the Central District of California are 15% higher than the previous year, though still below pre-COVID levels. Chapter 7 cases remain the majority, but Chapter 13 filings are increasing year-over-year.
- 35:02 – 37:44
California Homestead Exemptions and Retirement Accounts
California law protects homestead equity up to a cap (e.g., $743,681 in LA/Orange County) and fully protects qualified retirement accounts from creditors. Funds cannot be transferred into retirement accounts immediately before filing to avoid creditors.
- 37:44 – 54:52
Using Chapter 13 to Delay Foreclosure
Chapter 13 can stop foreclosure temporarily. Derek May notes that while trustees may view filing and dismissing Chapter 13 as misuse, it is a common strategy to gain time to sell or refinance, costing about $1,500-$1,800 in attorney fees.
Claims worth verifying
Judgments are against the person or entity, not the property, and are revealed via statement of information.
Ryan J. Orr ·28:31
How to verify: California Civil Procedure Code Section 680.160 and Title Insurance standards (ALTA/CLTA) requiring statement of information. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Reopening a case to avoid a lien takes about thirty days and costs approximately $2,000.
Derek May ·32:13
How to verify: Derek May's fee schedule and local court processing times in the Central District of California. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Bankruptcy filings in the Central District of California are 15% higher than the previous year.
Ryan J. Orr ·33:14
How to verify: Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts (AOUC) Quarterly Statistical Reports for the Central District of California. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
California homestead exemption cap is $743,681 in LA and Orange County.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·36:58
How to verify: California Code of Civil Procedure Section 460, adjusted annually by the Judicial Council based on median home prices. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Bankruptcies remain on credit reports for eight years because creditors have seven years to report.
Derek May ·41:56
How to verify: Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) Section 605(a)(5) and Federal Trade Commission (FTC) guidelines on credit reporting. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Chapter 13 filings are increasing year-over-year more than Chapter 7 filings.
Derek May ·34:31
How to verify: AOUC Quarterly Statistical Reports for the Central District of California. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Delivering a listing agreement to the trustee 5 business days before sale postpones foreclosure for 45 days.
Derek May ·51:39
How to verify: California Code of Civil Procedure Section 2924g (Listing-Based Foreclosure Postponement Act). For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Only one in five Chapter 13 cases go all the way through to completion.
Ryan J. Orr ·41:18
How to verify: AOUC Quarterly Statistical Reports for the Central District of California, comparing filed vs. dismissed/completed cases. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
California's listing-based foreclosure postponement is not as strong as a bankruptcy automatic stay.
Derek May ·53:52
How to verify: Compare California Civil Code provisions on foreclosure postponement with 11 U.S.C. § 362 (Automatic Stay) in legal databases like Westlaw or LexisNexis. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
A bankruptcy judge can reverse a transaction if state rules are violated, and they usually do it themselves.
Derek May ·54:03
How to verify: Review case law in the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the relevant district regarding enforcement of the automatic stay and remedies for violations. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Potential remedies for violating foreclosure rules include a suit for wrongful foreclosure.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·54:23
How to verify: Search for California case law defining the elements and remedies for wrongful foreclosure actions. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
A trustee may face issues with their license if they do not abide by the rules.
Derek May ·54:44
How to verify: Check the California Department of Business Oversight (or relevant regulatory body) guidelines for licensed trustees and potential disciplinary actions. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify current California homestead exemption caps for specific counties (e.g., LA vs. Riverside) via the Judicial Council of California or local court websites.
- Check the Central District of California bankruptcy statistics for recent filing trends using PACER or the Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts.
- Confirm the 45-day foreclosure postponement rule under California Code of Civil Procedure Section 2911.5 and local trustee rules.
- Review IRS Publication 908 for details on student loan discharge standards and undue hardship definitions.
- Consult a local bankruptcy attorney to assess the cost-benefit of reopening a case for lien avoidance versus filing a new case.
- Verify credit reporting timelines for bankruptcies (7-10 years) with major credit bureaus (Equifax, Experian, TransUnion).
- Check if qualified retirement accounts are fully protected under California Code of Civil Procedure Section 704.110.
- Review the specific requirements for recording a homestead declaration to ensure it creates a valid presumption of primary residence.
Full transcriptexpand
0:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hello
0:01Derek May: everyone, my name is Derek May. I'm a bankruptcy attorney. I'm also a certified specialist. If you look it up, most likely on the state bar, I'm the only certified specialist in San Bernardino County with bankruptcy off.
0:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
0:13Derek May: you can feel comfortable that you're sending them to probably the most qualified person with 20 years in bankruptcy as of December 2026. So
0:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
0:26Derek May: can file compile certain chapter 713s in my sleep. I can stop that foreclosure a day before that type of thing. I like doing that. That's my one of my favorite things is stopping foreclosures with chapter 13.
0:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I've
0:42Derek May: been doing a lot more of those lately. I would say Uh over the summer, I was averaging four or five uh chapter 13s 13 to Sissawal soft more. closures a month.
0:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
0:53Derek May: which uh 2020 to 2022, I think I had like two or three for that whole period. So that's kind of I mean, still not crazy, but it's it's it's a lot more than
1:04Ryan J. Orr: can you reference the call that we had when you mentioned as to who you said, I said, Are you busy? You said, Yeah, normally that's not a good thing for the real estate marketplace. And I said, Well, who's who's calling you? And you described like who was calling you most at that time.
1:18Derek May: Yeah. I'm trying to remember now what I said.
1:28Ryan J. Orr: No, it was more, I think you were talking about when they bought, what the situation was. I the the call I remember was you said that your phone was ringing, and the majority of people at the time, in regards to the scenario. was people that bought in the last few years and then that something uh maybe they didn't put much money down and um they had some kind of life event happen. So maybe it was a loss of job, maybe it was a a sickness or an injury or whichever else, and now they're having a hard time making making ends meet. And so this this was one or that are parts of the conversation that we had had.
1:59Derek May: Yeah, and it's uh um it's not necessarily a loss of a job. but um a lower. Like, you know, they don't offer me any overtime anymore.
2:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
2:08Derek May: I was relying on that overtime. You know, that that type of thing is very common. So you have
2:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
2:15Derek May: people that bought recent recently, they're stretching themselves already on housing, what they're paying as a portion of their income. So anything that happens, it kind of tips it over and you know, a lot of those people start relying on credit cards to bridge the gap, and then they'll get extra debt to pay the minimums on the other debt. And it snowballs quickly on people coming in saying $400,000 in debt. They make good money, but they just keep on increasing the debt. And so the bankruptcy process of the
2:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the the
2:49Derek May: big example I have of that is
2:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
2:52Derek May: between husband and wife they made made about 500,000 a year, but they had about 500,000 unsecured debt. 18,000 a month with that minimum payments.
3:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Equality debt between the husband and the wife, or was it?
3:09Derek May: It was it was kind of spread. Um and it was interesting because I could only refile for one of them because there's debt limits. And if I file if I put all the debt of both spouses in there, it was the student loans that put 'em over. So I kept the wife's student loans down, didn't disclose those. And we were to qualify the the husband. And he went from eighteen thousand in minimum payments to nine thousand a month in and bankruptcy chapter thirteen 13 payments over a five five-year year period with no interest. So but then I got two or three more like that. You know, so it's kind of a trend. And these are folks, you know, high income but high high expenses.
3:52Ryan J. Orr: So this is like a real scenario. So as we're taking notes and training today, make sure you're taking your nuggets. We want to make sure that we're sharing, I believe, in our industry in any portion of sales, one of the most powerful questions. we can ask is who do you know? So he gave you a really big deal. Like, who do you know that's kind of struggling right now? That maybe they were getting overtime before and now they're not and now they're like there's options. Like let's not because remember we're not talking just about house the house, the ownership. We're talking about relationships, we're talking about marriages as well. And as much as we're real estate professionals, we're also counselors in many cases, if that's fair. And so there is times when these types of things, these pressures can break people and/or marriages. And you know, if we can try and find a way to be knowledgeable about what he does to help educate and walk people through or point in the right direction, uh, this might be that that that valve, that that pressure valve that could help maybe save a marriage, maybe keep families together. Uh, Um and so again, I'm thinking bigger picture. stuff on it. Obviously at the end of the day, like us being able to do a real estate transaction is what pays our bills. And if that's what it ends up to, awesome. But if we can try and help people through the process at the same time, I think that's winning for all parties. So I apologize if you're
5:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): doing business and personal.
5:06Derek May: I do I do business. Um so for for my business it's it's mainly consumer focused, but there's people that are self-employed, right? So they'll come in, they have a business. Most of those folks they don't really need a bankruptcy for their business per se, but they have some debt from the business, and maybe we we throw that into the bankruptcy. As far as business, when I file for actual like corporations or LLCs, that's usually at chapter 11. Or if we're just shutting down the business, and there's like I would say if there's ongoing litigation, like multiple. lawsuits against them, sometimes it makes sense to throw that into a seven. Have a trustee look at the assets and say, Yeah, there's really nothing here. They're shutting it down, and it gets the creditors off their back in the future. Because if you don't file a bankruptcy for the business, they're always wondering: well, maybe the business had these assets, maybe they transferred them to you, or something like that. You have a trustee kind of looking over their shoulders and can kind of do that research for the creditors.
6:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
6:02Derek May: but yeah, um I'm not a a huge law firm, I have one staff person, so I don't do any like big chapter 11 business reorganizations with multiple employees. The ones I take on are usually like a single sole shareholder entity, maybe a couple employees. Uh That's an example, I filed for a restaurant um a while back to uh get rid of a lease liability that they had. I think they've switched location. There was an early lease termination. So they had about 600,000 in early lease termination damages potential and we reduced it to like 230,000 for bankruptcy because of the rules that you can adjust claims, lease claims like that. So my my main focus is consumers though, chapter seven and chapter 13s. I usually only have a couple chapter 11s pending at any given time just because there's a lot of work involved in chapter 11s. And uh I don't really like that much. I like chapter seven and thirteen so I can do more of them and I can do them easier. So how do we advance?
7:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It's
7:08Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): just a forward arrow. air.
7:12Derek May: So the the main kind of power that I have as a bankruptcy attorney is the automatic stay. It's created by statute.
7:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): For
7:21Derek May: the most part, as long as it's your first filing, it's triggered immediately upon the filing of the bankruptcy. It stays or stops collection activities and attempts to repossess uh cars or close on property
7:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): right
7:34Derek May: when nothing that's when filing happens. So as long as the as as long long as as the the bankruptcy bankruptcy is filed. was filed before the foreclosure sale takes place, you're gonna stop that sale. Also, you you kind of want to make sure the foreclosure trustee knows about the bankruptcy.
7:49Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): That's the big thing, guys. Um doing the automatic stay is awesome and filing is awesome to be able to stop it, but you have to make sure the trustee is notified. And if you don't, there's a high likelihood that that is still gonna going to go to sale. And the next question typically is: well, how do I find the trustee information? So on the notice of trustee sale that's recorded,
8:09Ryan J. Orr: there's going to be a trustee sale number, there's going to be a phone number, and/or a website. You don't want to go just to the automated. You need to call and reach someone and say, look, we filed bankruptcy on this property on our personal. uh, Where do I need to send in the documentation? So you can send it in, and that should should buy you some time in order to uh do what you gotta do.
8:31Derek May: Worst case scenario, I send my assistant to the sale, and she'll tell this her trustee at the sale hey, this person file me cursing approved.
8:39Ryan J. Orr: So that's another aspect.
8:40Derek May: So that's like last minute. I don't like doing those on last minute. I'm sure my staff person doesn't like
8:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.
8:46Derek May: But if you can't reach anybody, um at the very least you want to have uh s fact process. a record of a fax notice sent to their fax number. Um
8:54Ryan J. Orr: still have fax machines that it's which is crazy.
8:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
8:56Derek May: yeah, I usually fax the notice. I find out what their fax number is and most don't have it, some make it hard to find, but
9:02Ryan J. Orr: we found out a couple years ago when all the hacking was happening with different companies and emails that uh fax is probably the most secure method of being able to send something because it's so old school that nobody can hack a fax machine at this point. Uh so it's crazy. Uh when you what you gotta do, what you gotta do, fax machines still work. So
9:20Derek May: yeah.
9:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
9:22Derek May: the main reasons for filing bankruptcy, one is the automatic stay, the second one is is the discharge, which you get typically at the end both about chapter seven and chapter thirteen. Chapter seven usually takes about four months, then you get a discharge. Chapter 13 can take three to five years. Uh you have to kind of complete your payments before you're given the discharge. Does
9:41Ryan J. Orr: one of the sites show the difference between a seven and thirteen?
9:44Derek May: Yep. Okay.
9:45Ryan J. Orr: Sorry.
9:46Derek May: And um kind of the similarities. Both of them have these, so I'm going over these and I'll explain what's different about the two. Um, discharge is a federal legal excuse. Uh you don't have to pay the debts anymore. Uh It's sports more just by an uh discharge injunction against the creditors. Uh people a lot of times will say, Oh, my bankruptcy wipes out my debts. That's not necessarily true. Debts are still there. You just have a legal excuse, you don't pay them anymore. So it doesn't create a taxable event. Like if you know if you settle the debts, say with a creditor who said $1,200 for a $12,000 debt, well, you got the forgiveness of debt income potentially on your taxparents, that you pay tax on its income. None of that type of taxable event happens in a bankruptcy. There are some debts that that don't re that aren't affected by the discharge. So most taxes, recent income taxes, sales taxes, payroll taxes, any taxes that are withheld from either a customer or your employee, if you don't turn those over, those are never dischargeable from bankruptcy. They're called trust taxes. Student
10:57loans, unless you can demonstrate to the court that the debts impose an undue hardship on the debtor and the debtor's dependence, and that's a very tough standard to meet. One of the things that has made it difficult is is all the income-based repayment plans that you have. You're like, well, how can $100 a hundred be dollars an undue? unjust burden if they you know you got it? And they show that that's the only thing. So they the creditors kind of the student loan creditors use that to their advantage, say, well, they can at least afford $100 a month, and so you can't discharge any of it. Uh there's been some inroads that like partial discharge of student loans, they look at that, what what they can't can afford to pay on a monthly basis, and then they reduce the student loan debt to that amount.
11:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
11:39Derek May: but generally when I tell my clients, most clients that have an income of any sort, it's gonna be difficult to discharge the student loans. Unless you have over a hundred thousand, it's probably not worth it to pay me to attempt to do
11:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.
11:52Ryan J. Orr: Have you seen the average cost of tuition per year these days? It's like sixty, seventy, eighty grand.
11:56Derek May: Yeah. It's
11:57Ryan J. Orr: not hard to have over a $100,000 hundred thousand dollars in student loans.
12:00Derek May: The tough ones that I see are are folks that are on. a fixed income now, but they still have $500,000 retired.
12:08Ryan J. Orr: And they're retired?
12:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
12:10Derek May: the issue with that is they take some of your social social security. If you've
12:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): been
12:15Derek May: rolling.
12:16Ryan J. Orr: That's formal.
12:17Derek May: So ongoing HOA fees, if you still own the property, that's one that a lot of people don't think about, but like um and this was is more prevalent back in back when we had the you know
12:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
12:28Derek May: underwater properties like 2009-2010 where the lender wasn't foreclosing. You were still the owner of the property, HOA fees were accruing. Uh we can we can discharge anything that accrues prior to the bankruptcy, but if you still own the property after the bankruptcy, uh you're responsible for those fees. Uh they're not part of the discharge.
12:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
12:46Derek May: and then fraud or legal willful form malicious conduct, we don't want people to defraud people then. that escape the bankruptcy and get a discharge. So that one's pretty obvious. It's it's for honest folks, not fraudsters.
12:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
12:58Derek May: then chapter seven, bankruptcy. So here I'll talk kind of the differences. Individuals and businesses can file uh chapter seven, but only individuals get a discharge. So um it's really just for businesses, it's an alternate way to shut down the business. Um for the most part, businesses that come to me, I'm honest with them. I'm like, you probably don't need a bankruptcy, most of them. You just need to terminate the business. If you want to shut it down, just terminate it formally with the Secretary of State. Or if if you're feeling lazy, you can just let it go into suspended status. And that's kind of the end of it.
13:32Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): By terminating your business with the estate state, that involves you all whole debt.
13:37Derek May: It does not absolve you all. any debt you personally guaranteed. So a lot of those folks they're shutting down their business. They still need to file a seven, a personal seven, but they don't need to do anything with their business. And then
13:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
13:50Derek May: property of the debtor becomes property of the chapter seven bankruptcy estate. So you technically don't own any property unless you file a bankruptcy. It's property of your bankruptcy estate. It then reverts back to you after the case is over as long as the trustee doesn't. administer anything. That's like sell something, turn it into cash, and pay your creditors with it.
14:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
14:07Derek May: the vast majority of my cases are no asset cases. That means I can protect all the property with exemptions provided under California state law. The big exemption in California is in this it's fairly large and most most people get protected by it. It's the homestead exemption. So for San Marino County, it's four 497,000 hundred and ninety-seven thousand currently. currently. It'll adjust, I'm not sure what it'll adjust to in January, but it'll adjust the first of every year. And it's kind of a countywide. There's a floor, the lowest it can be, and then there's a ceiling the highest it can be. So LA County's exemption is higher. LA County and Orange County exemption is higher. But basically the exemptions are designed so you don't lose everything. when you file a bankruptcy. You have a fresh start. Majority of the people keep all their assets and then they discharge the liability. So it's an asset protection type of device. Chapter 13 bankruptcy is only available to individuals. Companies can't file a chapter 13, but you can file a chapter 13. if you're a self-employed individual. It would still be a personal filing. Instead of paying creditors through liquidation, the debtors use their monthly disposable income to pay creditors over the course
15:26of 36 to 60 months. This is an old slide because it says the CARES Act now allows 700 plans. That was true in COVID times, but not anymore. Uh Disposable disposal income is calculated by deducting reasonable and necessary living. expenses from the total household take-home pay. So this is after you pay your mortgage, your car payment, your utilities, food, all that good stuff. Yeah.
15:48Ryan J. Orr: So on this year, um, you're obviously in a payment plan. Are these usually or what percentage of the time is it like negotiated? Is it like reduced or is it the full amount or they're just paying over three years?
15:59Derek May: So whether to determine the how how long the payment plan is, or whether it's 36 or 60 months, it's based on someone's um whether their household is above or below the median income for their household size. So for a household one, median income is $79,000. So if you make more than $79,000 in a year and they look back six months to get a monthly average and they multiply that by 12,
16:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if
16:24Derek May: they're under $79,000, you can do a three-year plan. And then the most you can do is five years. If you're trying to catch up on a mortgage, it doesn't make sense a lot in a lot of cases to do it over 36 months, even if you qualify for 36 months, you spread that out over 60 months. The other thing that's interesting is people that say your disposable income is $5,000, but to pay 100% of your creditors back over five years, you only have to pay $2,500 a month. You can do that. So you can still spread it out. Like uh
16:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): so
16:54Ryan J. Orr: this is the full amount, or is it typically a negotiated lower amount? Or is it just you're not paying any interest?
16:58Derek May: So if your disposable income is enough to pay your creditors in full, there's no negotiation, you have to pay that. You pay them in full over the five-year period.
17:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So,
17:07Derek May: like the example of my guy who makes $500,000 thousand a year, he had more than $9,000 of disposable income. So he had a to pay 100% of his creditors.
17:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
17:18Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): then how are they negotiated if you don't have that?
17:21Derek May: So the the the negotiation to the extent negotiation absent in chapter 13, it's what the plan payment amount is and it'll be, you know, there'll be arguments like this expense that your client playing claim for for food is too high. You know, the national standard for this. And you'll go back and forth on
17:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what
17:42Derek May: the plan payment amount is going to be and ultimately what the percentage to your cutters
17:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is.
17:47Derek May: Ideally, as an attorney, you know, and you can't do it all the time, but you want that percentage to be low. Um, you don't want it necessarily to be at zero because there's no flexibility in a plan like that. That means anything happens or they can't make their payment, then you know.
18:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
18:03Derek May: kind of falls out of bankruptcy. Because if if it's a zero percent plan, all they're doing is catching up on a mortgage. So if they have any drop in income and they can't make that payment, it's gonna fall out, they'll be in a seven, their house will be in jeopardy again foreclosure. So um
18:18Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): So from what I'm hearing is that in order for someone to uh qualify for something like this, they have to have some income to coming come in.
18:27Derek May: Yes.
18:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): If there's no income, or what happens if their income is, let's say, for example, real estate, right? You go by commission. How does that how do they work on that if you don't get paid ever seen in time or on a monthly basis?
18:42Derek May: Yeah, for for self-employed individuals in real estate, um, same thing. Uh we look back six months, what were the total commissions that they got in the last six months? Then we get an average monthly over those six months, and that'll be kind of what we're income as the term. So the timing for those folks, maybe you had a really good last six months.
19:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): If
19:03Derek May: you have the luxury of being away, like there's not a foreclosure or something, you may want to wait until your commissions are a little less than that six six-month month look back period, so you can kind of adjust. Um,
19:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but the
19:14Derek May: other thing the trustee does as far as the negotiations go, they'll say, Well, yeah, the last six months were bad, but the six months before that it was really good. And what they'll do is they'll build into the plan. If you get a certain amount of gross revenues above a certain level, those are pledged to the plan as well. So they kind of build it in that way. And ultimately, what you have to do a lot of times is modify the plan.
19:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Because
19:38Derek May: say if you're you're getting more of those commissions and your gross is going higher. Well yeah, it's going higher, but that's because you spent $5,000 on marketing and your expenses were higher. So you could go in and modify that part of the plan too usually after the fact. You know, I usually tend to I tend to propose a plan that I think the trustee will accept. I don't like proposing low-all plans, because you can put any number you want in your plan that you because it's the debtor's plan they submit. But if you put a $500 a month plan and the trustee objects to all these expenses that you claim and said, actually it needs to be a fifteen hundred dollar a month, that's a tough conversation to have with your client. It's a thousand dollars more in payments than what you said it was going gonna to be. So I always try to get it under reasonable amount.
20:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It says that you can remove the second voltage. Meaning that you can
20:36Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): recharge it through the DK or you can still make payment, or you can still make payments on the screen.
20:42Derek May: So
20:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): this
20:44Derek May: is this is somewhat old too. Yes, technically you can still do that, but the only way when only time you can do that, if it's a second mortgage, a voluntary mortgage, um, and there's no equity in the property supporting it, that means it's a fully unsecured junior. You can remove it and basically treat it like a credit card. And if you're doing a 0% plan, that means you don't pay it at all and it gets removed. We were doing a ton of those in like 2009-2010. 2009, 2010. I don't think we've done one of them for a long time. now. But yes, technically you can do that on seconds.
21:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You know,
21:18Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): the chapter seven you said that if you have a first and second or a third, as long as you are eaten the four hundred and ninety seven thousand, you can see a file through the chapter six.
21:30Derek May: Yes. Yeah, they they consider the second and third as long as they're they're you know deep to trust. Um you have to be careful sometimes if you have a second and especially a third that there's not a relationship. Like an insider relationship where they didn't actually loan the money, but they're trying to
21:46Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): get you a water. Yeah.
21:55Derek May: So you can um
22:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
22:00Derek May: just have to be careful uh as an attorney. um that those leans are actually legitimate. Um and a lot of times some sometimes people look at bad advice before they come to me and they're like, this is what you need to do to protect the property. When in actuality um
22:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what
22:16Derek May: they've done is they've exposed that property because they've transferred their equity really to that lender and there's no um consideration supporting it. The trustee can remove that line, and you can't claim an exemption on it. So it impairs your exemption a little bit. Usually that opens the house up for sale. So but legitimate seconds, thirds,
22:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
22:43Derek May: they they are not part of the homestead calculation.
22:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
22:49Derek May: So
22:50Ryan J. Orr: homestead in different states is different amounts, if you didn't know that. California hasn't uh adjusted the homestead or home primary residence exemption probably since 1976. And you only get $7,000 of a homestead exemption here in California. In Texas, if you're under $65, you get the first $140,000 property tax exempt. And if you're $65 sixty five or older, you get the first $200,000 two hundred thousand dollars tax exempt. It's something I think our our our local and state officials should look at readdressing because when it was done it was about ten percent of the home's value. And now it's what's what's seven percent of like the average sales price or m or of an entry level home it's seven hundred thousand. Is that like one percent I guess? Um so the numbers don't fully add up. So the homestead in different states and different areas does does change. And
23:36Derek May: he's talking about the reported recorded homestead, you know for to claim a homestead exemption in Bankruptcy, you don't actually need a recorded homestead. It's it's called automatic homestead.
23:45Ryan J. Orr: So in California you have to record a specific document and if you go to do anything you actually have to abandon that homestead for your primary residence. In Texas you go into the local tax office and you literally fill out a form and in an application and just file for it and then they take that dollar amount off your tax bill. It's it's pretty well.
24:15Derek May: So if you you jointly own the property with a spouse, it's gonna be four ninety seven uh for the for that total equity.
24:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
24:22Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): mean you said that a homestead does have to be recorded before you were actually modified.
24:28Derek May: That
24:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): is correct.
24:29Derek May: There are some pipe people that maybe they got rentals or something like that, so I do recommend on those that you record. So that it's very clear which one you're saying is your homestead, because it could be unclear if you guys
24:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): have to.
24:45Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): You could do that in rentals.
24:46Derek May: You can't. That's why I'm saying you want to make sure.
24:50Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): I just want to make sure
24:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that's the same thing.
24:51Derek May: Doesn't have a good argument that you you you switch because this one had more equity. Because
24:54Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): you have to know when you file the
24:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): homestead,
24:56Ryan J. Orr: you have to file who's head of household and it's supposed to be just for your primary residence. And um maybe you can provide some extra clarity on that, because that's one of the things. Homesteads are supposed to be like a something that protects some of your equity in your home that creditors can't come back and and take it as much. But from my experience I feel like it's been more of a speed bump. bug. If a creditor really wants to go after it, it just kind of delays the process. Is that true?
25:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh so
25:21Derek May: the only time a creditor can force a sale of a homestead property is if you you have a lot of equity in the property. So say you have 700,000 equity in your property, but you don't only have the $497,000 exemption. They can force a sale, pay that's that sale would pay you your $497,000 so you could get a different residence. They'd take the $200,000 after cost.
25:47Ryan J. Orr: Well, think about this anybody that's owned a house for three to five years or more, chances are like when we run our farm data and we're running it through Fidelity Property Pro, you're looking at most areas, and 50 fifty plus percent uh of the people owning homes in all of the farm areas that I've been running and in the last two years have at least forty percent equity. So it's crazy. And the the number of people that have a hundred percent or show no open deeds of trust is pretty wild. So it begs the question as to would this be good content for us to be able to share, even if people aren't selling their house right now about educating themselves about recording a homestead. What's what's your take on that? No,
26:26Derek May: I'm recording the homestead, I think I mean you get some savings on your sales on your property taxes. So it makes sense to do that, but it creates a presumption that that's your homestead. Uh so when they try to do that forced sale, they're up against a presumption where they have to prove that that's not your homestead, you know, by clear and convincing evidence. So um
26:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): so
26:47Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): is it recommended or
26:49Derek May: definitely definitely recommended. All
26:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): right.
26:50Ryan J. Orr: Alright, so nugget for the day is to do more research on the homestead and potentially create content educating homeowners uh about recording homesteads on their property. What
26:59Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): creditors could force a sale?
27:00Derek May: They're judgment creditors. Um those are the ones that will typically force a sale. Your IRS, your state, uh they'll put a lien on the property, but they don't typically force a sale of the property. because the judgment creditors and they're patient, so they'll sit. You know, uh, I had one where it was a deficiency judgment on uh on a repossession of a car that a guy co signed for his his uh nephew like 15 years ago, and it was small and it turned into like a $70,000 judgment. And he he had enough equity and they were gonna force a sale on his house. Well, he had to go, he basically went out and got a home equity on. line.
27:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It's
27:39Derek May: okay to do it to it off. But he waited so long, you know, they made it it was a much larger problem. Um but yeah, they were they got it, they had him in a spot where he had to do that. I mean he came to me because he was like, Do I need to fuck bankruptcy to save my house? And I you know, because of the equity that's dropping, I
27:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): said,
27:56Derek May: No, you You probably know, shouldn't do
27:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that,
27:57Derek May: you should shouldn't get a loan and pay it off or so.
28:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): make a credit card could be a car loan, credit cards, almost any type of cards?
28:05Derek May: Yeah, and I I found lately a lot of people that they they're surprised. So when they come in, when they come in with a lawsuit, they're like, I didn't know the creditors could do this. They can sue me, they can get a judgment against me. I was like, Yeah, once they get the judgment, they can put a lien on your house, they can garnish your wages. A lot of people are like, oh, I thought if I just didn't, I mean I thought it was just bad for my credit score if I didn't pay it back, but okay. Um people get surprised and that's when it's a lot of times the first time they've ever been sued in their life, they get lawsuit from credit.
28:31Ryan J. Orr: Now keep in mind, because you brought up the word judgment. Judgments are not necessarily directly against the property itself, but when we run a prelim and we're running the research on it, we're gonna request the statement of information. And that will reveal anything that's against the name or and social security number of the owners on the property. And if it's an entity, it'll be against the entity or the the business um identity number as well. So when we run the original searches from a title perspective, we're running everything directly attached to the property. And we don't always show, we normally we don't, until we confirm as to what does and what doesn't apply to that person or person's on title. And that's why escrow is always gonna going to ask for that step up front in advance.
29:12Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): So if I have a bankruptcy and all their predators, you know, I mean the clients are a little blind. They're just desperate and they're going in there for some help and they're saying, Oh my gosh, my 25 predators are included in this discharge. You get to escrow, they go to sell their home, and there's all these things, and they don't have an order to avoid lien. Why is that not addressed Address at that time? Or how do they how do did they address that so
29:37Derek May: for
29:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): an
29:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): attorney saying you still are gonna have to deal with it down the line?
29:41Derek May: I always ask if people have judgments or lawsuits against them. And then I address it in my retainer agreement. I say that's extra. Like I quote a flat fee, and I say if you have judgments that you need to remove, I can remove them. It's an extra fee, and you have to pay that fee. Some folks will say, Well, I'm I don't really want to do that at this time. Uh especially back in 2009, 2010, the house was in underwater. the water, they weren't sure. whether they were going to keep it or not. So in a lot of those cases, they just left them there. They got the discharge, but they left the liens there. We can reopen the case and get an order avoiding the lien later. It's based on the value of the property at the time you file the bankruptcy. So you don't have to look at the equity on the property. Maybe now there's a ton of equity, but back then there it was not none. So you can remove those. Um A lot of times people don't know, they don't really have judges.
30:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): They don't know
30:29Derek May: and I don't run a title record in every single of my cases. Um if they think they might have them, then sometimes I'll do a name search and the Grant Choro Grantee Index in San Bernardino County. That one's the easiest riverside's pretty easy too. Um LA is a little bit more difficult. I have to actually go to LA to the recorder's office. I mean, I'm I might be able to use Ryan for those situations, but I actually
30:51Ryan J. Orr: can see on the surface. If it needs a title report, we can run that piece as well. Obviously, everyone's in trying to figure out covering costs and expenses and so forth. If it's outside of a transaction going to happen, a lot of times for a full report, we can absolutely do it. It's called a condition of title guarantee, formerly known as a freelan-only. it For the full search on it, but um that's where needed. Some of the basic stuff we're able
31:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to do.
31:15Ryan J. Orr: see
31:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): basically probably with any attorney it's another fee and maybe people at that point don't want to pay that and they probably don't even have the understanding of what that's gonna look like down the line.
31:25Derek May: Yeah
31:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that's what
31:25Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I like I just had a reply that didn't go through these people have I mean tons of debt she was trying to call she's like we file BK we file BK and I said yeah but you you've never got this
31:37Derek May: yeah yeah And a lot of them think that, oh, I got the discharge so that gets
31:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): me,
31:41Derek May: but it doesn't uh you have to do that.
31:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So then they
31:43Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): were just desperate and then have feel sick and they're just like, What do you do now? And I said you're gonna have to go back to your attorney or another attorney decision who's trying to do
31:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that
31:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): to get the
31:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): case.
31:52Derek May: Which means a lot of times their attorney says, Oh, I'm gonna do that. So I get those cases, a lot of cases. The attorney will either refer them to me or they'll say, Well, my attorney didn't want to do it. I'll I'll do it. There it's a form. Um you just have it attached documents and and file it. No one ever opposes it.
32:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
32:08Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): what is term on time for something like that? Once
32:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they give it a
32:12Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): desperation.
32:13Derek May: Yeah, once they give me all the documents and I have everything I need to file it, I file it, it takes about thirty days. It's not an emergency in See the court's eyes that you had a judgment lien lean from ten 10 years ago and you're reopening your case. And they get annoyed by me if they try. Like you know, we have escrow that's closing next week. We need to do this now. Uh and that doesn't usually
32:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): be.
32:38Derek May: If I wasn't the initial attorney, probably two thousand dollars. Because I couldn't usually get a historical appraisal, which is four hundred to five 500 hundred bucks. There's recording fees that I would pay,
32:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
32:49Derek May: filing fee to reopen and all. that's included in 2000. So really a thousand in attorney's fees and the rest is kind of.
32:55Ryan J. Orr: Well let's talk about reopening and so forth. Um, and I'll probably still let's just do this. I'll come back to it. We'll let you finish your step with
33:02Derek May: yeah, we actually have slide it out probably until we kind of skip ahead skipped ahead. This is just a little um people always ask me asked like what's the is our bankruptcy up, so I just kind of have this for uh where's
33:14Ryan J. Orr: that repair? comparison to like for example last year
33:16Derek May: yeah so this is this is compared to previous
33:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): oh this is
33:21Derek May: four like fifteen percent higher from last year um as far as what
33:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): was like
33:25Ryan J. Orr: twenty five
33:26Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): last year very low further we or was it normalized
33:30Derek May: it's been historically low since COVID right it's just it's been creeping up every year since COVID. Yes Uh yeah, I would say it's getting it's still not pre-COVID levels. Like 2019 still hasn't reached that, but it's getting closer to that.
33:46Ryan J. Orr: Is that because there were so many bailouts and exceptions and provisions to
33:51Derek May: uh there's that and you know how I said a lot of the drivers, people bringing in lawsuits. They people just thought it was like a bad look to sue people during COVID, so I didn't get those. And that was drives people. out.
34:06Ryan J. Orr: Yeah.
34:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
34:08Ryan J. Orr: Gotcha.
34:10Derek May: So um you can see the majority of the cases filed are chapter seven cases, very few chapter 11s. Uh chapter 12 is family farmer and fishermen. It's a pretty niche each category with of one of those. And then chapter 13 13s. is uh again. Again, I mean chapter 13s are up year over year more than chapter sevens. So that's kind of in line with my practice too, and why I'm a lot more sevens than I was before, or I'm a lot more 13s than I was before, but still a majority of my practice is sevens. I would say, you know, 10 chapter sevens every one in chapter 13.
34:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And then
34:46Derek May: it's just a grand total of 15%.
34:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now
34:49Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): that's City of California, Southern California, where
34:51Derek May: that is Central District of California. That's just um that's that covers LA, Santa Ana, San Bernardo counties, Riverside County.
35:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
35:02Derek May: Santa Barbara's. Uh one of the largest uh and I we kind of went over this, uh largest in California claim Lame is the on their prior priority end residence. The other really large exemption that you claim is on your retirement. So I'll bring this up because this is another kind of sad thing that I see is people will use their retirement and spend it all to make the minimum payments on their debt. Okay? And it's protected 100% under California law from your creditors. So if you had a million dollars in your retirement account, you could can file a bankruptcy, get a discharge, and still have. that for when you retire. So two of the safest places to put your money as far as investments go, retirement and your house. But I would say retirement seemed safer. Floor, um
35:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in
35:55Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): the retirement conversation about assets, it has to be a retirement account on a highway or a forward or something. you provided by the employer, it can't be your your stand-alone securities and investments.
36:08Derek May: No, it can't. It has to be a retirement account, and that's a good question. Yeah, it has to be a qualified retirement account. The other thing you can't do is you can't say, Well, I have 200,000 in the bank account, I'm just gonna put it in the retirement account. It's gotta be, you know, over time you built that up, not like something you just shove your money into a your last minute.
36:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Really?
36:26Derek May: So oddly though, the you uh the trustees usually don't ask those types of questions. They see your retirement account and they saw that they soon. It's uh but I wouldn't want to take that risk. All right, and the so the floor of equity coverage, this is where house values are low, is It's three 371,841. hundred and seventy-one thousand eight hundred forty-one. Um Uh so we're above that floor uh at four 497, ninety-seven. 497,000. And then the cap, the highest it can be in California is 743,681.
36:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
36:58Derek May: we got Riverside at 590 and San Bernino County at 497. Those are the main counties in LA and Orange County are the cap. And they're adjusted annually based on the prior rear mean home home price. We don't actually know that number on January 1 because the numbers for the California Realtors Associations where we get it, they're usually a couple months behind on that reporting. So we have to just kind of guess based on what what the sales were in the last eight months of the year. And then we kind of have a solid number about March or following year I don't know what that number is. And that's kind of something we go back and forth with the Chapter 7 trustees on. a few times earlier in the year.
37:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
37:44Derek May: we got practical uses for bankruptcy in real estate. Stopping the foreclosure of a house, stay in the house while the bankruptcy is pending. So that's that's where you know you're you really can't afford the house, but you want to stay in it a little while longer. You file a chapter seven. and then once the bankruptcy is over or they get relief from staying the bankruptcy, they can they can still foreclose. But it gives you two or three months in the house to kind of figure out where you're doing, maybe save up a little bit for a positive rental or something like that. Or you you can even potentially stop a foreclosure at the seven after the seven is over, sell it. Uh if you if you can sell it before foreclosure. the sell. Um but the way to save the house and save your equity is definitely chapter 13.
38:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): So
38:32Ryan J. Orr: if they file a chapter of 13, get that cover page or whatever go on. Did they have to actually go through the full chapter 13, or is that just something that that they can do and work with you on, stop the foreclosure to reorganize their own stuff? And I hypothetically speaking, I don't know if that's copacetic or not copacetic, but what what does that look like? What does that cost to file the chapter? thirteen? So if they have someone trying to stop foreclosure so we can get the property sold or whatever it is?
38:57Derek May: Yeah, they they can file a chapter thirteen and and not intend on going through with it. Chapter thirteen's very easy to dismiss.
39:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
39:05Derek May: typically the the folks that are are are gonna do a chapter thirteen 13, kind of a temporary basis, they um they may have a loan escrow open or uh or uh home escrow, like sale escrow open. And the recent changes in law allow allow you to extend it without filing to bankruptcy in a lot of cases. If you notify the foreclosure trustee, man, I have a slide about that. But if you if you kind of waited too late and you noted all time to notify the trustee of that that pending escrow or the or the listing, um sometimes bankruptcy is the only option to give you that. extra time.
39:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
39:40Ryan J. Orr: if the realtors in the room were wondering like what would that cost?
39:43Derek May: Yeah, as far as
39:44Ryan J. Orr: what would
39:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it cost?
39:45Ryan J. Orr: Approximately I don't know if it's a general number or if it uh all depends on
39:49Derek May: if if I know it's not going any further, the issue is I don't always know. Like maybe this escrow doesn't go through after all or something like that. Um but if I know, I would say 1800, basically 1500. plus the filing fee, other than another 13. Um, and
40:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
40:07Derek May: what I do is I still build it if it does go through, then all there'll be additional money paid through the plan payment.
40:13Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Right.
40:14Derek May: That type of thing. But that 1500 would be pretty much earned when I file a case.
40:18Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Right.
40:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
40:20Derek May: and I can tell you the US Trustees Office doesn't like me doing those. I don't like doing I don't like doing those on an off-based. often basis because they they kind of see that as kind of a misuse. Like if you're five, thirteen, you're supposed to go through the relief.
40:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
40:34Derek May: but in the right situations I'll do it. I I'll I'll explain it to the US trustee. Hey, this is what the the issue was, this is why they did it this way. You know, we
40:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): don't know.
40:44Ryan J. Orr: What is the difference like for example, if someone's up against foreclosure and they're just trying to get their escrow and so forth closed, what percentage of those people that file complete? Like, is it is it common, is it uncommon, is it copacetic, is it not copacetic?
40:57Derek May: Uh as far as you know, and there's there's a judges that will talk about success rate of chapter 13. I view the one where they they file a 13 and it gets dismissed and they are able to close the transaction you were trying to close as a success. But a judge would say that that was a failed case, it got dismissed incomplete. and completed. So yes, I guess
41:18Ryan J. Orr: it's pretty
41:18Derek May: much thirteen thirteens uh all the way all the way through, fairly rare. Um I would say maybe one in five of the cases go all the way through.
41:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
41:28Derek May: it doesn't mean they're failures. It's like, well they got the house caught up and they dismissed the case. They don't really cared about the other things. Maybe So
41:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what step is the case
41:36Derek May: filed
41:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of
41:36Derek May: file seven.
41:37Ryan J. Orr: If they initiated a chapter thirteen 13 or one of these, then it gets dismissed. And maybe this is more of a you question. Does that do they still have to uh disclose that they filed chapter or bankruptcy? Because there sometimes it comes through because it didn't actually go through, it didn't finalize. Is that is that a ding on them at that point, other than what them potentially already missed in payments or what's a
41:56Derek May: bankruptcy firearms? So yeah, it would have a negative effect. I would say a 13 thirteen that doesn't go all the way through probably has less of a negative. effect than a seven that's discharged, but it's still a negative effect on the credit and it'll be on the credit for eight years.
42:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Eight years?
42:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
42:12Ryan J. Orr: that's another obviously factor is do you file that or do you not? Because it's now gonna rent a foreclosure. I think only a seven at that point. It's a year better, I guess, at that point. But
42:21Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): mention of two years FHA, yeah, can I imagine it's seven year rule? FHA is two years.
42:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
42:27Ryan J. Orr: wait, so
42:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): FHA allows you to have it within a two year period.
42:30Ryan J. Orr: So you
42:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): can still get
42:31Ryan J. Orr: alone in the future, it's just
42:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
42:32Ryan J. Orr: different two years. Got it. Okay.
42:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah. Yeah,
42:36Derek May: I'll be able to say
42:36Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): if I file vacancy,
42:37Derek May: I I'll never be good alone alone. That's not true. It's two year wait. I thought it was four years coming. Few
42:43Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): FHA.
42:46Ryan J. Orr: Say it again.
42:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Fear for FHA, we have a nice commander to the one.
42:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Well, non came we have one day.
42:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
42:56Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): uh big down payment high rates and of course, yeah, it's been my way.
43:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So I thought
43:05Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): you still own second and walk away from
43:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
43:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): wasn't was it ten years before?
43:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Ten
43:12Derek May: years on credit?
43:13Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah.
43:14Derek May: The way I the reason I say eight years is because creditors report cred the bankruptcy court doesn't report that you filed bankruptcy on your credit court. It's creditors that are reporting it. And they have seven years to report. So they'll continually report that you filed a bankruptcy and discharge it at wrong. And then it falls off as they're not reporting it anymore. So that's why it's eating. eight.
43:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
43:34Derek May: don't know where the ten tin came from, but
43:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
43:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): that's the change.
43:40Derek May: So um removing judgment judgment means we talked about that practical, another practical way of bankruptcy, and you don't have to have a current case. And to do that, you can reopen a case. I've gone back as much as I think 10 ten years. So
44:00Ryan J. Orr: we've had to reopen, uh ask for attorney. attorneys to reopen cases. Have you guys ever come across an escrow? I'm sure you have, um, where somebody had filed bankruptcy and they had a whole bunch of debt discharged and they said, Well it was it was already there, it was discharged. See, here's my discharge. Uh but they missed one step because the initial discharge, if done, only relieves the uh personal responsibility of that debt. The second piece of that is
44:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
44:27Derek May: the liens. The secured debt, the liens aren't removed in a bankruptcy. They're
44:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): not
44:33Ryan J. Orr: removed
44:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in the government.
44:36Derek May: It doesn't remove the parlour, right? And so it's similar a similar thing for the house. It's not going to remove your mortgage, it's not going to remove any judgment liens.
44:44Ryan J. Orr: It can, however, you have to file a
44:47Derek May: you have to file the proper procedure of 522 F motion. to remove the lien. And the reason that you can remove it is because it impairs your homestead exemption. It makes your homestead exemption smaller because you have this lien that you're gonna have to pay.
44:59Ryan J. Orr: If you've already had that debt discharged personally, is it what's the likelihood of them getting it stripped from the property with the order of avoidance or motion motion to avoid lien?
45:08Derek May: I'd say as long as the numbers work out, basically that it does actually impair your home set setting, exemption, so you don't have too much equity. It's like 100%.
45:16Ryan J. Orr: No, that's at the time of filing. So remember this, not all bankruptcy attorneys are created equal, and not all things are are are being necessarily shared, or maybe people don't understand this other piece of it. But if they don't and they don't record or get that motion to avoid lean, um I think I'm saying that right, right?
45:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
45:34Ryan J. Orr: it's still there. And if it's five years later or three years later and they go to close a the transaction and it comes up, that money is still okay because it's still physically attached to that property at that point. Like their personal if the property forecloses, then it's kind of wiped out in its own and you're already personally relieved of it. But if you stayed in the house and it's still against that, you either need to reopen that bankruptcy with your attorney and see if what if the case was at the time they didn't have it. But now here we're three, five years later and they have three, four hundred thousand dollars worth of equity. Uh did will they still uh issue that order to avoid lien? Or
46:07Derek May: yeah, it's based on when the case was filed, the equity when the case was filed, which always will be lower in most cases because you know you paid down the mortgage and the property files are gone. So it's based on the date you file. That's why you kinda have to get a special appraisal, historical appraisal.
46:23Ryan J. Orr: What is the reason people don't file the that motion to avoid lien up front?
46:26Derek May: Because a lot of them don't know about it or they can't afford it or they they're not sure what they're gonna do with that property ultimately, 'cause it doesn't make a lot of sense for a people lien on the property if you're just gonna let it go. Like that was a lot of people in two thousand nine, two thousand ten, they weren't sure whether they could afford to keep it.
46:40Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): But at that point, 'cause it would that now it would be ten years later, so that wouldn't be impacting now. I
46:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): mean 'cause
46:45Ryan J. Orr: Because most judgments are valid for ten years unless they're they're renewed. And I think you could renew it one time?
46:51Derek May: You can renew it if
46:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you're not. So
46:53Ryan J. Orr: if they forget to renew it after ten years, it's you you can walk away from that that judgment that was there. But um
46:59Derek May: That's the other thing, though they can renew it after you file bankruptcy to preserve their violation of the discharge.
47:07Ryan J. Orr: So these are things to take into consideration, and having someone to call or run these scenarios by is a big deal. If you take a listing and do something and someone somebody is in an active bankruptcy or needs to be there, there is additional documentation that would probably be needed. Uh the discharge paperwork at the end is a massive deal from us from a title perspective. Um can can our realtors close a real estate transaction while the bankruptcy is active?
47:31Derek May: Yes, they have to get approval of the bankruptcy court.
47:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
47:35Derek May: it's it's much more difficult in chapter seven to close a transaction. You in that situation, um, I usually typically say wait till the bankruptcy is over because it's only a four-month.
47:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
47:46Derek May: but to do it in a chapter seven, you have to get the trustee to abandon the property, and so it's no longer property of the estate. It's so uh, I can tell you title companies don't like us doing it that way.
47:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We
47:57Ryan J. Orr: only we prefer it with court approval if it's gonna happen. So we know that we can close them, but again, it's not just an open. open-closed case. It's not just yes, we can sell the house. It's the court has to sign off on it, and usually they tell us where the monies need to go, or there's holding account
48:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): or
48:11Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): trust account with the attorney's office.
48:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
48:13Derek May: and the issue the issue is in chapter seven, the trustee can get approval of a sale in chapter and chapter seven from the court. But once we get the trustee fee to abandon it to us so we can sell it, the court technically loses jurisdiction over that property. You can't approve a sale. if it's not a state property of of a debtor that you know so it
48:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what
48:32Derek May: the title wants, we can't really give them so that that's the issue.
48:36Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): For those of clients that they have a great amount of equity in their house, but they also have a great amount of debt and they consider would it be better to just list up the property and pay it off to the debt instead of losing or filing a bank bankruptcy? receipt? And another question attached to that. If the trustee uh sells the property and paid off the debt, but there's still money remaining, what what happened to the money where it goes? So you and you're
49:06Derek May: a person that has a lot of unsecured debt and they have equity in their property, uh, would it make sense to file the bankruptcy or sell the property and use that money to pay off the debt? debts? I would say it makes much more sense to file the bankruptcy in that situation if they qualify for a chapter seven. So that'll definitely get them out of debt. Say maybe they're high income, they don't qualify for a seven. Yeah. In a lot of cases that that makes sense. Also, if you have Yeah, unsecured on security debt, that doesn't necessarily mean out of the close of escrow, you have to turn that money over to the predators. You can get that, you can use it, you can reinvest it in six months on another property, maybe a more affordable property, and still still keep the extent proceeds.
49:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
49:48Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): you mentioned that you could reopen cases within 10 years.
49:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Oh that's
49:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): there's not
49:53Derek May: really a time limit on it, but you know, it gets to the point where we don't have the information on outlet the comparable compared with sales firm. program.
49:59Ryan J. Orr: So those it's two things kind of wrapped into one. So the 10 years is if there's a job. judgment filed against someone, it's only valid for 10 years unless it's renewed. The part about reopening is for those people that filed bankruptcy but didn't do the motion to avoid lien, and now they're going to close the transaction, they may want to reopen whether it's the original attorney or whether it's someone like Derek if it wasn't him. They can reopen the case, they can submit to the courts for. the motion to avoid lien. Once that is done and filed, now all of a sudden it's now closed again. We get that documentation for the motion to avoid lien, and we don't have to um uh we don't have to pay those debts. They we cannot remove those from the from the prelim to be able to close.
50:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
50:45Derek May: had a guy this year that had eight judge judgment commands. liens. I removed all eight of them. Probably six hundred thousand.
50:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That
50:54Derek May: was an interesting one. Can't remove a voluntary lien like that. Only in the chapter 13, and only if there was no equity supporting it at the time of filing.
51:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
51:14Derek May: Yeah. Wipe out excess debt to assistant qualifications. These are for the lenders. You know, you have someone that they've got a ton of debt, their debt-to-income ratio, it's all auto back.
51:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Have
51:24Derek May: them file the bankruptcy and come back to you in two or two to four years. Remove a second mortgage lien from real estate. Again, that's not likely here, but you can do that without needing need a to check. check. Protection of homeowner equity statute. Um, how many people have heard of this, the where you can show a listing to the trustee and delay the foreclosure?
51:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
51:51Derek May: have to have a valid listing, so you open up a you you have your potential client sign And a listing agreement with you, you deliver the listing agreement to the trustee at least. five business days before the for before the scheduled sale. So you can't do this a day before the sale, that will work. But with some proper planning, you're notified of that your that snow is going to foreclosure 120 days before it actually goes to foreclosure. So as long as you list it soon enough and you properly deliver it certified mail or overnight contracting trackings. the signature,
52:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
52:28Derek May: trustee has to postpone the sale for 45 days. This is no bankruptcy involved. This is just outside of bankruptcy under California law. And then if you secure a buyer and there's an open escrow, you get another 45 days to close the escrow. So this is new.
52:43Ryan J. Orr: We just took advantage of this as well. We had a transaction where they were trying to get the foreclosure sale stopped. It was three days away, they needed a bona fide buyer that could do it. We were able to uh make a cash offer on the property. Um, and it was I got a call Wednesday at 12 30. We walked the property two hours later, uh, made the offer, um, opened up escrow, submitted the money into it. Uh foreclosure sale was on Monday, LA County, so transaction would have had to have closed by funded by Thursday, closed on Friday to be able to have the payoff. Uh but because we had a bona fide transaction with monies deposited into escrow, uh we were able to stop the foreclosure sale. Um and there in that case there was an active BK and it took us thirty days. They said it could take up to thirty days to get the documentation we needed. I think the twenty-fourth day we got the uh uh documentation and we closed it like two days later. So yeah.
53:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): So just question this. So this is by law, right? That they have to abide by that if you have a listing agreement five to ten days before the uh the sale, the trusty sale.
53:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yes
53:50Derek May: it's California. I would say it's not as strong as a bankruptcy stay, but it is California law. Um I don't know what the remedy is if they don't abide by that, probably a suit for wrongful foreclosure. Whereas a bankruptcy you get a bankruptcy judge to reverse that transaction if they violate the state very quickly. Usually they'll do it themselves.
54:12Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): So there's steps just in case they want to abide by the law of the rules. Yes.
54:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Then
54:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): you get a friend that can enforce that. So what would the progressions against Against them the
54:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): M if they
54:22Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): don't abide apply by the rules limit?
54:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in that?
54:23Derek May: Uh I would say a wrongful foreclosure technically. I mean the sale that gets set aside there's probably certain sanctions that w would apply. I haven't looked into what the remedies are under this if they don't but I imagine it's the same stuff that people that sue them for wrongful foreclosure can can
54:40Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): maybe lie.
54:43Derek May: Um I guess the trustee he could could have some issue with with their license.
54:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All
54:51Derek May: right.