Making Money

UK Budget Analysis: Fiscal Drag, Debt Interest, and Structural Tax Critiques

1h 16m Listen to the original
UK Fiscal PolicyGovernment DebtTax ReformPublic SpendingEconomic GrowthHousing Market

Summary

Helen Miller of the Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) and other speakers analyze the UK government's recent budget, noting it contains 98 measures characterized by 'fiddling' rather than structural reform due to manifesto constraints on raising major tax rates. Miller highlights that debt interest consumes one in every 13 pounds of spending, while 'fiscal drag' from frozen tax thresholds is projected to raise £70 billion by the end of the decade. Critics argue the budget's 'scattergun' approach, including changes to Founders Relief and ISA stability, creates confusion and fails to address long-term growth drivers like housing market liquidity and skills alignment. The discussion also covers the sustainability of public expectations for crisis support, the trade-offs between NHS and defense spending, and the bond market's indifference to increased borrowing.

Episode sections

  1. 0:01 – 4:38

    Budget Overview and Constraints

    Sponsor read followed by Helen Miller's overview of the 98-measure budget, highlighting fiscal constraints and manifesto pledges.

  2. 4:38 – 8:22

    Fiscal Constraints and Debt Interest

    Miller details that debt interest consumes 1 in 13 pounds of spending, exceeding £100 billion, and discusses the impact of the Middle East war on energy costs.

  3. 8:22 – 12:45

    Impact on Households and Living Standards

    Discussion of direct household support (£100 council tax rebate, VAT cuts) versus expected fuel bill increases, noting living standards face their worst decade on record.

  4. 12:45 – 15:28

    Precedent for Government Support

    Miller expresses concern that public expectations for direct cash support during crises are unsustainable given the country's reduced purchasing power.

  5. 15:28 – 21:33

    Student Loans and Tax Rises

    Speakers discuss the lack of changes to student loans and highlight 'fiscal drag' as the biggest tax-raising measure, projected to raise £70 billion.

  6. 21:33 – 23:16

    Borrowing Plans and Future Taxes

    Miller notes the government's borrowing reduction plans are delayed and will require continued tax rises and public service cuts, including a 'mansion tax'.

  7. 23:16 – 24:24

    Government Spending Constraints and NHS/Defence Trade-offs

    Critique of spending plans, noting NHS costs rise faster than inflation and defense pledges create budgetary pressure, forcing cuts to other services.

  8. 24:24 – 27:54

    Skepticism of Budget Credibility and Political Timing

    Speaker expresses skepticism about the delivery of spending plans and suggests the government may be avoiding tough decisions until after a potential snap election.

  9. 27:54 – 32:00

    Market Stability and Tax Policy Critique

    Discussion on the economic costs of pre-budget speculation and criticism of the 'tweaky' approach, with calls for structural tax reforms like scrapping stamp duty.

  10. 32:00 – 34:49

    Triple Lock Pension Reform and Social Care

    Analysis of the triple lock pension change as a modest saving (£4bn/year) that is insufficient to fund a full national care service.

  11. 34:49 – 40:20

    Bond Market Reaction and Debt Sustainability

    Bond markets shrugged off the budget, having already discounted higher borrowing; speaker warns of reduced fiscal capacity for future shocks.

  12. 40:20 – 47:32

    Growth Ambitions and Mayoral Devolution

    Speaker finds little in the budget to drive growth but highlights income tax devolution to mayors as a potential long-term positive, despite regional inequality concerns.

  13. 47:32 – 53:11

    Entrepreneurs' Relief and Founders Relief

    Critique of 'Founders Relief' for distorting behavior and incentivizing early sales, benefiting only a small number of successful founders.

  14. 53:11 – 1:16:23

    ISAs and Tax Stability

    Discussion on the reversal of recent ISA changes and concerns over policy instability creating confusion among retail savers.

Claims worth verifying

The recent UK budget contained 98 measures, a number the speaker claims is larger than any previous budget list.

Unidentified speaker ·2:18

How to verify: Check the official UK Government 'Budget 2026' document or the Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) analysis of the budget for the count of fiscal measures.

One in every 13 pounds the UK government spends is going on debt interest.

Unidentified speaker ·4:52

How to verify: Calculate the ratio of UK Government Debt Interest expenditure to Total Public Spending from the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) or HM Treasury fiscal data.

The UK government spent approximately £75 billion over two fiscal years supporting households during the 2022 Russia-Ukraine conflict energy crisis.

Unidentified speaker ·13:17

How to verify: Review UK Treasury spending reports or IFS analysis on the 'Energy Bills Support Scheme' and related household support packages from 2022-2023.

The average household will receive a benefit of £120-£140 from the budget measures over the next nine months, while facing fuel bill increases of over £400.

Unidentified speaker ·9:15

How to verify: Consult the Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) distributional analysis of the budget, specifically their household impact models for energy and council tax changes.

Fiscal drag (frozen tax thresholds) is projected to raise approximately £70 billion by the end of the decade.

Unidentified speaker ·20:00

How to verify: Check the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) 'Economic and Fiscal Outlook' for projections on tax revenues from frozen thresholds.

UK tax as a share of national income (tax-to-GDP) is rising from a historical average of 33% to over 38%.

Unidentified speaker ·19:40

How to verify: Review HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) or OBR data on 'Tax Ratio' or 'Tax as a percentage of GDP' over the last few decades.

UK national debt is 'not that far off' 100% of national income (GDP).

Unidentified speaker ·21:45

How to verify: Check the Office for National Statistics (ONS) or OBR data for 'Gross Debt as a percentage of GDP'.

The UK government has raised over £60 billion in taxes since coming into office.

Unidentified speaker ·16:35

How to verify: Sum the revenue impacts of tax changes announced in the 2024 Autumn Statement and subsequent budgets, as reported by the IFS or OBR.

Vanta claims its tool cuts audit preparation time by 82%.

Unidentified speaker ·19:05

How to verify: Check Vanta's marketing materials or case studies referenced in the podcast transcript (sponsor read).

USwitch customers save about £1,000 a year from switching, with an average initial setup cost of £8,000-£10,000 for solar.

Unidentified speaker ·17:43

How to verify: Check USwitch's published savings data or the podcast sponsor read claims (note: these are advertiser claims).

The NHS budget rises faster than inflation, consuming resources quickly.

Unidentified speaker ·23:30

How to verify: Check UK Office for National Statistics (ONS) data on NHS expenditure growth versus CPI inflation over the last 5-10 years.

The government has a pledge to raise defence spending to 3% of national income.

Unidentified speaker ·23:40

How to verify: Review UK Government official statements or the Autumn Statement 2024 budget documents regarding defence spending targets.

The triple lock pension change will save approximately £4 billion per year in the middle of the next decade.

Unidentified speaker ·34:14

How to verify: Check Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) or Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) forecasts for the fiscal impact of the triple lock modification.

UK national debt has tripled since the Gordon Brown era (2000s) when it was capped below 40%.

Unidentified speaker ·37:05

How to verify: Compare UK Debt-to-GDP ratios from 2007 (approx. 40-45%) with current ONS figures (approx. 100%+).

The UK is one of the most regionally unequal countries in the developed world.

Unidentified speaker ·44:41

How to verify: Review OECD or World Bank data on regional GDP per capita disparities across developed nations.

Stamp duty gums up the housing market and makes people less likely to move.

Unidentified speaker ·30:16

How to verify: Review academic economic literature or government impact assessments on the elasticity of housing mobility relative to transaction taxes.

The price cap on energy bills will rise in January, leading to higher bills.

Unidentified speaker ·26:47

How to verify: Check Ofgem announcements regarding the energy price cap setting for the upcoming winter period.

The triple lock pension indexation is linked to average earnings.

Unidentified speaker ·33:59

How to verify: Review the statutory definition of the UK Triple Lock pension policy, which includes the earnings link.

Founders Relief offers a preferential 10% rate of capital gains tax for early investors in rapidly growing companies.

Unidentified speaker ·48:37

How to verify: Check UK Government HMRC guidance on 'Founders Relief' and the Finance Act 2026/2027 for the specific tax rate and eligibility criteria.

The average person benefiting from the relief will receive a benefit of £500,000.

Unidentified speaker ·50:34

How to verify: Search for HMRC or OBR (Office for Budget Responsibility) estimates regarding the average value of Founders Relief claims.

The total cost of the Founders Relief is a few hundred million.

Unidentified speaker ·51:27

How to verify: Review the UK Government's fiscal impact assessment for Founders Relief in the Budget 2026 documents.

ISAs have seen no changes to their core structure over the speaker's six-year career as a YouTuber, despite constant speculation.

Unidentified speaker ·53:24

How to verify: Compare ISA lifetime limits and contribution caps from 2020 to 2026 using HMRC records.

The UK is a relatively rich country internationally with highly educated people and strong universities.

Unidentified speaker ·1:06:44

How to verify: Compare UK GDP per capita and education rankings (e.g., OECD PISA, World Bank data) against international peers.

The financial crisis and COVID were significant negative shocks to UK growth.

Unidentified speaker ·1:08:49

How to verify: Analyze UK GDP growth data from the Office for National Statistics (ONS) for the periods surrounding 2008 and 2020.

The government's fiscal rules are based on a three-year-ahead borrowing target.

Unidentified speaker ·1:03:54

How to verify: Review the UK Government's fiscal framework and charter published by HM Treasury.

The recent budget contained 93 to 98 changes.

Unidentified speaker ·1:10:42

How to verify: Review the official UK Government budget document or press releases from HM Treasury for the specific number of legislative or policy changes announced in the 2026 budget.

Do your own research

  • Verify the IFS report on the UK budget to confirm the number of measures (98) and the characterization of 'fiddling around the edges'.
  • Check HM Treasury data or OBR forecasts for the current debt interest-to-expenditure ratio and the £100 billion figure.
  • Review OBR projections for 'fiscal drag' revenue generation to validate the £70 billion estimate by the end of the decade.
  • Examine the specific text of the 'Founders Relief' legislation to assess the eligibility criteria and average benefit (£500,000) claims.
  • Consult UK government bond market data (e.g., gilt yields) to analyze the market reaction to the budget's borrowing plans.
  • Review the details of the 'Triple Lock' pension policy change and the associated £4 billion annual savings estimate.
  • Check the status and findings of the 'Tim's Review' on disability and the 'Milburn Review' on youth not in education or training.
  • Analyze the proposed 'mansion tax' and changes to salary sacrifice rules to understand their impact on high-net-worth individuals and corporate structures.
Full transcriptexpand
0:01
Unidentified speaker: Our sponsor today is Take the Next Step, Invest.
0:05
Unidentified speaker: Inflation is a funny concept.
0:07
Unidentified speaker: It can be really difficult to really internalize because it normally happens in small enough increments that we don't really notice it the price of something in a supermarket goes up by 15p.
0:17
Unidentified speaker: But inflation is one of the most corrosive forces in finance.
0:21
Unidentified speaker: It's been brought home by the cost of living crisis in recent years because the price jumps have been so drastic.
0:27
Unidentified speaker: The best lever that most people have to outrun inflation is investing.
0:31
Unidentified speaker: So if you have solid savings and money you won't need for the next five years, then think about it.
0:36
Unidentified speaker: Take the next step, invest.
0:38
Unidentified speaker: It's been a few days since the budget, so we've had a bit of time to get past the headlines and work out what it actually means for you.
0:45
Unidentified speaker: Unfortunately, Tomain couldn't join me today, so it's just going to be me and Helen Miller, the director of the Institute for Fiscal Studies.
0:51
Unidentified speaker: They're widely seen as the independent referee when it comes to government spending and taxation.
0:55
Unidentified speaker: So I wanted to get her take on what the budget really means for you and your money.
1:00
Unidentified speaker: Thank you for joining us, as always.
1:02
Unidentified speaker: This one's remote, so no biscuits this time.
1:04
Unidentified speaker: But how are you feeling?
1:05
Unidentified speaker: Have the last few days been?
1:07
Unidentified speaker: Well, the honest answer is tired.
1:09
Unidentified speaker: I mean, I had a weekend without doing too much work, which was a lovely change, but I'm still recovering from last week.
1:15
Unidentified speaker: Um the budget is always a is always a big day for us.
1:18
Unidentified speaker: And I think I think I did something like 44 hours straight, um, with only a kind of a quick rest in a dark room in the middle.
1:24
Unidentified speaker: So I think I'm still recovering from that from that budget bonanza.
1:27
Unidentified speaker: I mean, that is shocking.
1:28
Unidentified speaker: That's like are you guys just in in the documents just trying to decipher it?
1:34
Unidentified speaker: Or is that press for you?
1:35
Unidentified speaker: You know, is it are you on on air the whole time?
1:39
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, so for me it's a lot of press.
1:41
Unidentified speaker: I um I'm basically on air all the afternoon off the budget, trying to analyse the immediate stuff that of what happened.
1:46
Unidentified speaker: Then I'm back to the office and the guys here are crunching numbers and we're doing the analysis.
1:51
Unidentified speaker: That runs into the early hours of the morning, and then most of the team go and get some sleep.
1:55
Unidentified speaker: Um, but I'm up again fresh and early to do the the morning media.
1:58
Unidentified speaker: Can't bet you love budget then.
2:00
Unidentified speaker: Um, what was your reaction when you first saw it all coming out?
2:04
Unidentified speaker: What did you think of the budget?
2:06
Unidentified speaker: So, initial reaction is that I think it's what most people expected, in the sense that it was relatively small, not a huge amount of stuff, at least the big picture changed, but actually very, very fiddly, had 98 measures in the budget document.
2:20
Unidentified speaker: I don't remember ever seeing a budget like list of measures that was that was bigger.
2:24
Unidentified speaker: So, despite the fact that actually at the high level, not a great deal changed, just actually quite a lot of fiddling.
2:30
Unidentified speaker: So, my impression is yeah, the big picture what I expected, the government's doing more borrowing, the war in the Middle East is bad news, living standards are struggling.
2:36
Unidentified speaker: That was kind of the big picture.
2:38
Unidentified speaker: But just surprised at how much sort of tinkering around the edges there was, actually.
2:42
Unidentified speaker: Were you disappointed at all?
2:44
Unidentified speaker: Like with a lack of ambition or a lack of like big things within the budget.
2:50
Unidentified speaker: Oh, I th I feel like I think you know, I I watched lots of budgets with disappointment.
2:54
Unidentified speaker: Um, I think worth saying there are a couple of things in there that I think were more ambitious.
2:58
Unidentified speaker: So the government has is uh going to sort of devolve some tax revenues, it's going to assign some revenues to mayors.
3:04
Unidentified speaker: On day one, that doesn't look hugely different, but I think that's a that's a pretty big thing.
3:08
Unidentified speaker: So I think there was a bit of that in there.
3:10
Unidentified speaker: Um and there's a bit of a mood music that there are bigger things to come.
3:14
Unidentified speaker: Actually, I think the government is basically delaying some big decisions to the reviews it's got coming up on young people and disability, it's got uh its 10-year plan.
3:23
Unidentified speaker: I think it's loading quite a lot of expectations onto that.
3:26
Unidentified speaker: So there's a bit of a sign that there's more ambitious stuff to come.
3:29
Unidentified speaker: But just looking at this budget in isolation, it wasn't particularly ambitious.
3:33
Unidentified speaker: I think that partly speaks to the government clearly feels really constrained.
3:37
Unidentified speaker: It's constrained because it's already borrowing a lot.
3:40
Unidentified speaker: It's constrained because it's got these pledges not to increase the big rates of tax, it's constrained because it wants to do quite a lot of public services.
3:48
Unidentified speaker: So it looked to me like a government that's not doing very much right now because of its constraints and hoping that it can get around some of those constraints in future years.
3:56
Unidentified speaker: Do you think that's possible?
3:57
Unidentified speaker: What I mean by that is one way that people have characterized Andy Burnham is big on like big promises light on the detail.
4:05
Unidentified speaker: And I'm and I'm not sure that that budget really helps that reputation or answer any of the big questions.
4:10
Unidentified speaker: And do you think that this budget you would characterize that then as just kind of kicking all the big stuff down the road?
4:16
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, I think there's certainly a lot to that.
4:18
Unidentified speaker: A lot of the big decisions have been kicked down the road.
4:20
Unidentified speaker: That's partly the stuff on the welfare reforms maybe to come, on the 10-year plan, on the spending review next year, which is when departments uh have to argue over their budgets for coming years.
4:30
Unidentified speaker: That'll be a hugely difficult spending review if you take the budget numbers at face value.
4:34
Unidentified speaker: So I think there are lots of lots of cans that have been kicked down the road.
4:38
Unidentified speaker: In terms of the constraints and whether the government could do things to get around them, I think the answer is it could do lots of things, but there are some real constraints.
4:45
Unidentified speaker: So borrowing is really high, and we are spending an eye-watering amount of money on debt interest.
4:52
Unidentified speaker: Something like one in every 13 pounds the government spends is going on to debt interest.
4:55
Unidentified speaker: That's money that we can't spend on doctors, nurses, teachers, whatever else we want to spend it on.
4:59
Unidentified speaker: Um that problem's not going away anytime soon, I don't think.
5:03
Unidentified speaker: So the government could not make it worse, but it's gonna have a tough time actually getting away from that constraint.
5:08
Unidentified speaker: Similarly, on tax rises, the government could choose to uh you know ignore its manifesto pledges and break them, it could have another election.
5:15
Unidentified speaker: Um, but if it sticks to them, then it's gonna have a tough time raising big sums of money.
5:19
Unidentified speaker: The government could also, it could trim back the size of the state.
5:22
Unidentified speaker: We think that on if you take the budget at face value, then to make it all work, they're gonna have to implement some pretty big spending cuts to some departments in coming years.
5:31
Unidentified speaker: They they could do that in principle.
5:33
Unidentified speaker: I'm not convinced the Stable Government wants to do it, but they could do it.
5:36
Unidentified speaker: And then to your point, Damien, about this government having big ambitions, I think worth remembering there are a whole bunch of things that governments can do that don't include lots of you know tax and spend measures.
5:45
Unidentified speaker: So it could take more control of utilities, it could do more to regulate the water industry, for example, it could do more to uh kind of impose itself in housing.
5:54
Unidentified speaker: So there are things the government could do, but those things take time to pay off.
5:58
Unidentified speaker: So I think it needs to sort of you know chop chop, hurry up and get going because before they know it, there will be another election and they won't necessarily have seen the benefits of whatever it is they want to want to change.
6:08
Unidentified speaker: I remember when Rachel Reeves was Chancellor and that first budget, people were expecting big things, and it felt very kind of like, is that it?
6:15
Unidentified speaker: Do you were you expecting bigger things from this budget?
6:20
Unidentified speaker: Well, perhaps the Rachel Reeves budget, in some ways it did feel big, right?
6:23
Unidentified speaker: Because he had that huge, big tax right rise, you know, in it.
6:26
Unidentified speaker: So I think it that one felt big in the sense of uh something big happened, but it was it was big on the just let's raise more money.
6:33
Unidentified speaker: Actually, behind the scenes, there were also some big things there, like increasing money on investment and there's industrial strategy that that autumn.
6:38
Unidentified speaker: So I think actually that was that was a fairly big budget.
6:43
Unidentified speaker: Um, this one, I think it could have been bigger.
6:45
Unidentified speaker: And again, I think the government could have done more.
6:47
Unidentified speaker: One thing to remember is that they haven't been in office very long.
6:50
Unidentified speaker: I think I think it was hundred days uh on the day that the Chancellor gave his budget.
6:54
Unidentified speaker: It just takes time to get your ideas through, you know, through the civil service and through the machine and worked up to actual policy.
7:02
Unidentified speaker: So, in some ways, I think partly the lack of ambition is just a mechanical effect of not having been in power very long.
7:08
Unidentified speaker: But I think if the government wants to do more, it is going to have to be bolder.
7:12
Unidentified speaker: Um, we're in a position where there's not just one easy growth lever.
7:15
Unidentified speaker: I think politicians are often on this quest to like find the thing that drives up growth.
7:19
Unidentified speaker: I mean, obviously, if it was as simple as finding a policy, everyone in the Treasury would have found it and then have pulled that lever.
7:24
Unidentified speaker: What you have to do is the hard yards across a whole range of policy areas.
7:28
Unidentified speaker: And then to do enough of the you know relatively small things, it starts paying off.
7:32
Unidentified speaker: Um and of course, the challenge for any government, but particularly this one, is that you're trying to do all those growth things while having other ambitions too.
7:39
Unidentified speaker: So we've got a chancellor who also wants to increase defence spending.
7:42
Unidentified speaker: And we've, you know, living standards, this looks like the words, the worst decade for living standards on record.
7:47
Unidentified speaker: So he's gonna be trying to do lots of different things all at the same time.
7:50
Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
7:51
Unidentified speaker: Um, we're gonna go through each section of this, if if that's okay, so that we can dig into it in a little bit more detail.
7:57
Unidentified speaker: I think when I when I'm what I meant by a big budget was not the tax rising, so the ambition point, we were expecting, say, tax reform, things like this.
8:03
Unidentified speaker: We we saw none of that.
8:04
Unidentified speaker: We've seen none of that really this time, or lots of little measures.
8:08
Unidentified speaker: I want to dig into those.
8:09
Unidentified speaker: So we had a question from Andrew, who's part of the audience, and he basically said, I tried to look at it and it just seemed like loads of waffle.
8:16
Unidentified speaker: I don't really know what it means for working people.
8:19
Unidentified speaker: So could you try and summarise that if you can?
8:22
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, let me have a go.
8:23
Unidentified speaker: Um, I mean, I think budget documents are always always a bit hard to read if you're, you know, if you're just a normal person at home.
8:28
Unidentified speaker: I think there's two ways to think of how a budget affects you.
8:30
Unidentified speaker: One is the sort of the individual measures that will immediately either give money to people or take money away from people.
8:36
Unidentified speaker: And the other is the kind of the backdrop: how's the economy running?
8:39
Unidentified speaker: How's that gonna affect you?
8:40
Unidentified speaker: So on the immediate bit of it, um, you know, your listeners are absolutely right, there isn't very much in there that's gonna directly affect households.
8:46
Unidentified speaker: Obviously, the most important thing is this sort of direct support for households.
8:51
Unidentified speaker: So most people, eight out of ten, will get £100 through their council tax bill in the new year.
8:56
Unidentified speaker: Um, there's also going to be VAT taking off of electricity bills, that'll take bills down a little bit, and fuel duty is not going to rise.
9:03
Unidentified speaker: So you won't see that saving in a sense that it's a tax rise that never came.
9:06
Unidentified speaker: Um, but that will take the pressure off people.
9:08
Unidentified speaker: But for some context, we reckon that for the average household, and there's going to be some variation across them, but for the average household, you might get a benefit of something like 120 to 140 pounds in the next nine months.
9:20
Unidentified speaker: But your fuel bills are going to go up by over 400 pounds.
9:23
Unidentified speaker: So sadly, for all of us, what we're going to see most is those big increase in gas and electricity bills, even though the government's trying to, you know, chip them away a little bit.
9:31
Unidentified speaker: Um, other things there, if you're a landlord, more bad news for you because your tax rate's going to go up in April.
9:36
Unidentified speaker: Um, if you're a saver, maybe a uh bad news, a bit higher rate there.
9:39
Unidentified speaker: But for most people, not very much direct in there.
9:42
Unidentified speaker: On that bigger picture point, um, again, there's nothing really that moves the dial, in my opinion, on living standards.
9:48
Unidentified speaker: And living standards or growth is the big challenge we face.
9:51
Unidentified speaker: I mean, that we put it's a remarkable chart we put together that just shows kind of growth in incomes over decades, across all the different decades.
9:58
Unidentified speaker: And for many decades, we got used in this country to having living standards, incomes growing over the decade quite strongly.
10:05
Unidentified speaker: Then in 2010s, that was much weaker, and we looked at that decade and thought, oh, that's bad.
10:09
Unidentified speaker: This decade now looks to be even worse.
10:12
Unidentified speaker: So I think people out there are feeling pretty rotten because um incomes aren't rising quickly and people are finding it hard to pay those bills.
10:19
Unidentified speaker: And the government can't fix that with any temporary measure.
10:22
Unidentified speaker: You can't just take money and shove it at people to fix that.
10:24
Unidentified speaker: You've got to do the underlying work to try and make sure we're all more productive and we can earn higher wages and that we can um you know grow our way out of these problems.
10:32
Unidentified speaker: And nothing I saw in that budget is really going to move the dial on that, sadly.
10:36
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, and uh the £100, obviously, it is an amount of money, but it is it is it going to be that impactful for individuals?
10:44
Unidentified speaker: I mean, you you basically just said that it's not going to solve the problem.
10:47
Unidentified speaker: So why do it?
10:50
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, well I think the challenge the government had here is that so what's happening underneath this is that war in the Middle East has just obviously been bad news for the UK.
10:57
Unidentified speaker: It's driving up oil prices and fuel prices and gas prices.
11:01
Unidentified speaker: And collectively as a country, we are poorer because we have to spend more money importing stuff that we really need.
11:06
Unidentified speaker: So the government was never going to be able to help all of us cover those costs.
11:10
Unidentified speaker: It was always a case of taking money from some people to help other people.
11:13
Unidentified speaker: And there are just loads of different views on exactly how you should do that.
11:17
Unidentified speaker: Should you do a little bit of support for everybody, which is kind of what they've done, or should you have targeted a higher level of support at maybe poorer people, for example?
11:25
Unidentified speaker: Um, I think honestly, it's just a it's a political choice.
11:28
Unidentified speaker: And the government have chosen to do it this way.
11:30
Unidentified speaker: One thing I can't resist the urge to say is that we said after the 2022 big spike in prices that what the government should have done is been collecting data on people.
11:40
Unidentified speaker: So basically on the combination of who has low incomes and high electricity bills, so that if this happened again, they could target support more directly.
11:48
Unidentified speaker: They didn't bother to do that.
11:49
Unidentified speaker: So now they face this kind of unsatisfying situation where they could either help people through the benefit system or they could help it through council tax, but you can't really target it at people who are struggling most as a result of those energy shocks.
12:02
Unidentified speaker: But for now, the government chose basically a broad-based, everyone gets a little bit rather than focus on on poorer families.
12:08
Unidentified speaker: Reading between the lines there, you said it's a political choice.
12:11
Unidentified speaker: Do you mean it's like designed to make them popular rather than it is to design to provide the support that with the energy crisis?
12:19
Unidentified speaker: No, I didn't really mean that.
12:20
Unidentified speaker: Although I think let's make two of that.
12:21
Unidentified speaker: But no, what I meant is it's a choice about redistribution.
12:23
Unidentified speaker: So there's not a right and a wrong answer.
12:25
Unidentified speaker: So I can't sit here with my economics hat on and say, you should have done this because that would have been better.
12:29
Unidentified speaker: It's just some people will want to have a wide, you know, broad-based support package, some people want to focus help on poorer people, and it's just a choice about redistribution.
12:38
Unidentified speaker: You know, people can disagree about the right answer, and the government's made a choice, but not everyone will like that choice or would have made the same choice.
12:45
Unidentified speaker: How what kind of precedent do you think it forms within the UK public where if we have a crisis, they expect an amount of money to land in their bank account, essentially?
12:55
Unidentified speaker: Do you think that that's a dangerous road to go down?
12:57
Unidentified speaker: I've worried about this more in recent years, actually.
13:00
Unidentified speaker: So, especially because we had COVID, which was obviously just an extraordinary situation.
13:05
Unidentified speaker: You look back at it and it's kind of hard to believe what we all went through.
13:07
Unidentified speaker: Um, and the government intervened at a massive scale at that point in time.
13:11
Unidentified speaker: Then we had the 2022 Russia-Ukraine conflict, and that had this big package of support.
13:16
Unidentified speaker: I mean, really, really big.
13:17
Unidentified speaker: The government spent something like 75 billion over two uh fiscal years on supporting households, really huge.
13:24
Unidentified speaker: Um, and now this one is much, much smaller in comparison.
13:28
Unidentified speaker: It's only uh just under 3 billion, but but still um, you know, still a package.
13:34
Unidentified speaker: So I do worry about the precedent if if every time a shot comes along, we say don't worry, the government can make it all okay.
13:41
Unidentified speaker: They can't, at least not in the short run.
13:42
Unidentified speaker: They can't make it all okay by shoving money at us all because fundamentally we're poorer.
13:46
Unidentified speaker: What they need to do is, you know, the the longer run work to make the economy grow harder.
13:51
Unidentified speaker: I guess I'm thinking a little bit better because it's a smaller package and therefore we're not repeating the 2022 exercise of you know really throwing money at people.
13:59
Unidentified speaker: Um, but I also know that there are already calls in some quarters for the government to go further and come back again this winter uh with even more help.
14:06
Unidentified speaker: So um I think there has been a bit of a move towards people expecting the government can sort of just make it all okay and they can't fundamentally, not in the short run.
14:14
Unidentified speaker: Are we in danger as well of saying to individuals that are meaningfully struggling with their to support their bills because they're gonna go up by, you know, £400.
14:21
Unidentified speaker: So they're £300 net worth off just on the energy stuff.
14:24
Unidentified speaker: But well, we gave you £100 towards it, so you know, you can't moan.
14:28
Unidentified speaker: You know, we we we helped.
14:32
Unidentified speaker: I mean, that would be pretty unsympathetic, wouldn't it?
14:34
Unidentified speaker: So I suspect their comms people won't let them be saying that kind of thing.
14:37
Unidentified speaker: I mean, no, I think I think they everyone in Treasury knows this is gonna be a difficult uh winter for lots of families.
14:44
Unidentified speaker: Um, and I think they'll talk about this as a as they did, as some breathing space.
14:50
Unidentified speaker: We can't make it all okay today.
14:51
Unidentified speaker: We're gonna do some breathing space while we focus on the longer term.
14:54
Unidentified speaker: I think the challenge actually is to demonstrate to people what's in the middle ground.
14:58
Unidentified speaker: So they've got the kind of like the short-run breathing space.
15:00
Unidentified speaker: They're gonna hear the longer run, lofty ambitions about maybe joining the EU or social care or uh rolling back neoliberalism, whatever that means.
15:08
Unidentified speaker: Um, I think what people want to know is like, okay, but what happens in the next like one, two, three years?
15:12
Unidentified speaker: What are the concrete steps they're gonna take?
15:14
Unidentified speaker: Can the people actually start seeing what the government's going to do?
15:17
Unidentified speaker: So that if, you know, they're not there yet, but they can feel like they're moving towards something.
15:21
Unidentified speaker: I think people don't yet, no, I don't know uh how the government, what what what the next concrete steps are.
15:27
Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
15:28
Unidentified speaker: I'm sure there was demand for support around energy because it affects so many people.
15:31
Unidentified speaker: Another thing I saw, a lot of demand for leading up to it and a lot of um pushback since was around student loans.
15:40
Unidentified speaker: There just didn't seem to be much there.
15:42
Unidentified speaker: Um there was an interview afterwards as well with the Chancellor and the Prime Minister where they asked about student loans and they said, Oh, we've we froze the interest rate at six percent, and that's one to come back to was the line uh which angered a lot of students.
15:54
Unidentified speaker: Why do you think they didn't touch that when it seems to have been very it seems to have been everywhere for me in the debate, the student loan thing?
16:01
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, I think the answer is lack of cash.
16:04
Unidentified speaker: I mean, the uh it's it would cost money uh to uh reduce, either reduce the interest rate or unfreeze the threshold at which you start paying, or you know, basically giving more money to students in any form is going to cost money, and they are they are strapped for cash.
16:19
Unidentified speaker: So effectively what they've done is raised a bit of money for this um this support package and a few other little uh tweaks, uh, but not done much else.
16:28
Unidentified speaker: And of course, it is getting harder and harder to raise taxes, partly because they've locked down the big taxes, partly because they've already raised taxes by over 60 billion since coming into office.
16:38
Unidentified speaker: Just mechanically, it's getting harder to find big sums.
16:40
Unidentified speaker: So if you want to, you know, reform student loans, you've either got to raise some taxes or you've got to cut some other, some other uh spending.
16:48
Unidentified speaker: And I think the government obviously didn't want to do that.
16:50
Unidentified speaker: And again, I think the broader context here is important that student loans you mentioned, you've seen that everywhere.
16:54
Unidentified speaker: Every group I speak to has got their own version of that.
16:57
Unidentified speaker: You know, some people are talking about disability or young people, some people at defence, or the NHS saying that actually it's you know, winter is coming.
17:04
Unidentified speaker: I mean the NHS always think winter is coming, but but it being a difficult winter, um, you know, everywhere every sort of every area's got its own version of the thing that it really thinks is important.
17:13
Unidentified speaker: And and there's just no more money to cash around.
17:15
Unidentified speaker: So you basically have to work out what are you gonna cut or which tax are you gonna rise if you want to give more to students.
17:21
Unidentified speaker: So T, how often do you think about your energy bills?
17:25
Unidentified speaker: 24-7.
17:26
Unidentified speaker: Like I'm literally running around the house turning off lights that my missus leaves on.
17:29
Unidentified speaker: At night time, I turn off my Wi-Fi.
17:31
Unidentified speaker: Like I'm trying to save money however I can.
17:33
Unidentified speaker: Every night I turn off the Wi-Fi.
17:34
Unidentified speaker: That's wild, mate.
17:36
Unidentified speaker: We're now living in a time where there can be a personal finance case for moving to solar energy, which is why we're happy to be partnering with USwitch.
17:43
Unidentified speaker: Their customers save about a thousand pounds a year from switching.
17:46
Unidentified speaker: But they have to spend about eight to ten grand initially for the battery and the setup.
17:50
Unidentified speaker: That's the average though.
17:51
Unidentified speaker: And for a third of people, the payoff is much quicker.
17:54
Unidentified speaker: Plus, there are financing options, which means some people are cash flow positive on their loan from month one.
17:59
Unidentified speaker: Clearly, there's a few things to consider.
18:01
Unidentified speaker: But the good thing about USwitch is that they let you see whether solar power might be better for you with just a few clicks.
18:06
Unidentified speaker: You enter a few details, things like where you live, a bit of information about your house, and in a minute or so you can see how much you can save each month.
18:14
Unidentified speaker: USwitch also offers deals and discounts you can't get elsewhere.
18:17
Unidentified speaker: So if you want a clear view on how much you could save from switching to solar, then check out the calculator in the description.
18:24
Unidentified speaker: We don't know yet who the winners and losers of AI are going to be, but we know that AI is probably here to stay.
18:30
Unidentified speaker: And that's going to have massive implications on businesses.
18:33
Unidentified speaker: As AI adoption grows, so do the security risks and the requirements for your company.
18:38
Unidentified speaker: New frameworks, audits, and needing to prove that you're compliant with standards.
18:42
Unidentified speaker: Protocols like GDPR, SOC2, and ISO 27000 and one.
18:46
Unidentified speaker: Keeping up with that is a massive pain, which is why we love Vanta.
18:50
Unidentified speaker: Most security compliance tools promise to automate your work away, but you still end up doing most of it by hand.
18:55
Unidentified speaker: And then you have this big panic when the audit comes around.
18:58
Unidentified speaker: Vanta's different because it's built to scale with you, not slow you down.
19:02
Unidentified speaker: They have over 1,400 automated tests across more than 400 integrations, which cuts your audit prep by 82%.
19:10
Unidentified speaker: Plus, you can access Vanta's agent wherever you work, like Claude or Cursor.
19:14
Unidentified speaker: Over 16,000 of the best companies in the world use Vanta.
19:17
Unidentified speaker: If you're interested, you can learn more at vanta.com slash making money.
19:21
Unidentified speaker: That's V-A-N-T-A.com slash making money.
19:26
Unidentified speaker: You say taxes haven't been rising, but they kind of have through the fiscal drag, right?
19:30
Unidentified speaker: So no, no, they've been rising a lot.
19:32
Unidentified speaker: No, absolutely, they have been rising a lot.
19:33
Unidentified speaker: This has been a huge, I mean, this decade is um remarkable.
19:37
Unidentified speaker: You look at the chart, and then for years, for decades, really, our tax to GDP, our tax as a share of national income, hovered around about 33%, so about 33 in every pound.
19:47
Unidentified speaker: Um now it's going up to like 38, a bit over 38p in every pound taken in tax.
19:51
Unidentified speaker: The tax has gone up loads.
19:52
Unidentified speaker: And you're right, it's still happening.
19:54
Unidentified speaker: So the threshold freeze, there's been a whole series of freezes in the thresholds in the personal income tax system.
20:00
Unidentified speaker: By the end of the decade, that'll be raising something in the order of 70 billion pounds.
20:04
Unidentified speaker: If you think of that, all those freezes as one policy measure, it's been the single biggest tax policy raising measure ever in the history of the UK.
20:12
Unidentified speaker: So for sure, taxes are going up a lot, but that's kind of the point because they're already going up a lot, and that money's already been earmarked.
20:17
Unidentified speaker: It's been earmarked for spending on more, more public services, on more debt interest.
20:22
Unidentified speaker: If you want to go even more, you've got to go even further.
20:26
Unidentified speaker: I mean, stepping back, one thing that um your, you know, people listening might be interested in is that at a high level, why is it the case?
20:33
Unidentified speaker: It sounds really counterintuitive that you have taxes rising to historic highs, and yet I'm sitting here talking about how things are really tight and there's no money to go around.
20:41
Unidentified speaker: Why is that?
20:42
Unidentified speaker: I think there's two really important bits of context.
20:44
Unidentified speaker: One is for decades, basically the government was cutting defence spending relative to the size of the economy and channeling that money into the NHS.
20:52
Unidentified speaker: So we had this growing uh healthcare system without the overall state growing because we were basically doing a switcheroo.
20:59
Unidentified speaker: Those days are gone.
21:00
Unidentified speaker: We're now in this unprecedented situation of trying to increase healthcare, welfare, and warfare.
21:06
Unidentified speaker: So trying to do all those three big things, we should expect to have to be paying more for it.
21:10
Unidentified speaker: So partly that's the point about we are getting more money, but it's been spent on defence, for example.
21:14
Unidentified speaker: The other thing is this debt interest cost.
21:16
Unidentified speaker: Debt interest is huge.
21:17
Unidentified speaker: It's now something, you know, over 100 billion.
21:20
Unidentified speaker: If it were a government department, it would be the second department outside of the NHS.
21:23
Unidentified speaker: So partly a lot of that extra money we're raising is going straight into paying off uh off the debt.
21:28
Unidentified speaker: And again, is not leaving money for helping people with student loans or whatever else is we want to be doing.
21:33
Unidentified speaker: We're continuing to borrow as well, though, aren't we?
21:35
Unidentified speaker: So loads.
21:37
Unidentified speaker: The debt interest will be getting worse as a result.
21:39
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, we're still borrowing loads of money.
21:41
Unidentified speaker: Um we've got high debt, debt's um, you know, not that far off, really, 100% of our national income.
21:46
Unidentified speaker: Borrowing, we're still borrowing quite a lot.
21:48
Unidentified speaker: And interestingly, the government have a plan to bring down borrowing.
21:52
Unidentified speaker: And in fact, we got patted on the back by the IMF for having these, you know, particularly impressive plans compared to our G7 counterparts.
21:59
Unidentified speaker: And the Chancellor was very happy about that.
22:01
Unidentified speaker: But importantly, they're just plans at the moment.
22:03
Unidentified speaker: And in this budget, what the government did was borrow more this year and then delay the point at which it's gonna start bringing down borrowing.
22:09
Unidentified speaker: And we have seen Chancellor after chancellor after chancellor say, I promise I'm gonna cut borrowing tomorrow.
22:14
Unidentified speaker: Then tomorrow comes and they're a bit like, oh, actually, that's a bit difficult.
22:17
Unidentified speaker: I promise I'm gonna cut borrowing tomorrow.
22:19
Unidentified speaker: And we keep playing this game over and over again.
22:21
Unidentified speaker: So on paper, the plans look pretty impressive.
22:24
Unidentified speaker: If the government really can deliver a cut in borrowing, that would be good news for us.
22:28
Unidentified speaker: But back to the same problem, to deliver that, they've got to keep taxes rising and they've got to cut some public services.
22:33
Unidentified speaker: Uh and if they don't do that, borrowing is gonna keep uh keep on its current path.
22:38
Unidentified speaker: Um, and so that their plan to cut borrowing is to reduce public services and to increase taxes, but not the big three taxes inside of this parliament.
22:47
Unidentified speaker: Is that right?
22:48
Unidentified speaker: So have a year mark what taxes that would be.
22:50
Unidentified speaker: Well, so I'm pack that a bit.
22:52
Unidentified speaker: So the the tax rises basically are the ones that are already baked in.
22:54
Unidentified speaker: So part of it is the one we already talked about, is that because uh thresholds are frozen, that's gonna bring in more money over time.
23:01
Unidentified speaker: So actually, it won't be a new tax rise announced every year, but it's still gonna bring in money.
23:05
Unidentified speaker: There are also changes, to example, there's a new mansion tax, which is a new council tax for high value properties.
23:11
Unidentified speaker: There's some fiddling around with salary sacrifice, pension uh contributions.
23:14
Unidentified speaker: So there are other taxes still to come.
23:16
Unidentified speaker: And on the spending side, I think important to say overall spending, so the total amount the government spends on its departments, health, education, defence, and so on, is still rising relative to prices in the coming years of the parliament.
23:30
Unidentified speaker: But the minute you take account of the fact that the NHS never gets rises that line just in line with inflation, they always get a bit more than that.
23:37
Unidentified speaker: And the NHS is huge and it gobbles up resources very quickly.
23:40
Unidentified speaker: So the minute you take account of that, and you think about the government wanting to get defence to 3% of national income, that just takes up so much of the increase that to achieve that, you would have to cut back some other services in other departments.
23:52
Unidentified speaker: So it's it's not that the overall the government is still gonna be growing the state, but relatively slowly uh relative to prices.
24:00
Unidentified speaker: And therefore, again, you have to choose.
24:01
Unidentified speaker: You could hold back the NHS, you could say NHS, that's it.
24:04
Unidentified speaker: You're gonna just, your budget will line up, you know, will rise with inflation, but no more.
24:08
Unidentified speaker: But if you're doing that, then you certainly shouldn't be expecting to radically slash waiting lists or do more on prevention because we've also got an aging population that demands more and more expensive healthcare.
24:18
Unidentified speaker: So again, you're just you're really up against the constraints here.
24:21
Unidentified speaker: You have to choose with a budget where to put it.
24:24
Unidentified speaker: You called those spending plans the Achilles heel of this budget.
24:28
Unidentified speaker: So you you feel they're shaky or at least maybe not credible.
24:34
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, I think they're the weak point basically.
24:36
Unidentified speaker: I said this consolidation rely is underpinned by these spending plans.
24:39
Unidentified speaker: I think it's important to say they would be deliverable in the sense that a government who wanted to deliver them could absolutely deliver them.
24:44
Unidentified speaker: There's no law of nature that says that every department has to rise and grow over time.
24:49
Unidentified speaker: That's you know, that's that's not true.
24:51
Unidentified speaker: Um, but I am sceptical about whether this government wants to deliver them for a few reasons.
24:56
Unidentified speaker: One is just history, you know, caution skepticism, because time after time after time we've seen Chancellors promise to get borrowing down until the hard choices come and they then they delay it.
25:06
Unidentified speaker: I also, I think if the if this government, if John Healy, the Chancellor, actually wanted to deliver the plans implied by his budget, I would have expected him to be doing more pitch rolling, more warming us all up for this idea that, you know, tough choices are ahead, that we can't do everything we want to do, while the economy is suffering from war in the Middle East and so on.
25:24
Unidentified speaker: I'm gonna prioritize health and defence.
25:26
Unidentified speaker: We are gonna make savings elsewhere, that's gonna be tough, but we've got this long-run plan that's gonna make it all okay in the long run.
25:32
Unidentified speaker: I didn't hear any of that.
25:33
Unidentified speaker: And actually, in interviews that I've seen him do since, I don't think he's really setting people up for expectations.
25:39
Unidentified speaker: Makes me worry that they're plans he doesn't want to sort of own and deliver.
25:42
Unidentified speaker: Now, I could be wrong, obviously, um, but my concern is that if we don't get those plans, then we'll have to get other plans.
25:49
Unidentified speaker: And again, my concern is that what'll happen when the time comes is that we'll just borrow more money and we'll be stuck in this situation where we keep having to spend tons of our national income servicing the debt.
25:59
Unidentified speaker: Do you do you think um the lack of warming us up might be a nod to the fact that we get a snap election, say?
26:05
Unidentified speaker: And that they try and come in on a new manifesto instead?
26:09
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, possibly.
26:10
Unidentified speaker: I get asked.
26:12
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, possibly.
26:12
Unidentified speaker: I get asked this question almost daily now, and obviously, I'm not a politician, so I don't know what they're gonna do.
26:18
Unidentified speaker: One thing I would say is if you look at next spring at least, next spring does not look economically to me like a time to be calling the election.
26:25
Unidentified speaker: I mean, this this year, the economy has actually done a bit better than most people expected.
26:29
Unidentified speaker: That's partly because so far, the shock coming out of the Middle East, the oil prices wasn't as bad as some people thought it might be.
26:36
Unidentified speaker: There's also been some more investment in ANR in AI that looks like it's sort of holding things up a little bit.
26:41
Unidentified speaker: But going into next year, most economists think that actually things will get worse before they get better.
26:47
Unidentified speaker: Partly because the price cap will rise in January.
26:49
Unidentified speaker: We're all going to see those new higher bills.
26:52
Unidentified speaker: We're probably gonna, some of us at least, have to rein in um to our spending to accommodate that.
26:57
Unidentified speaker: I think growth will get worse before it gets better.
26:59
Unidentified speaker: And therefore, going into next spring, do you want to run an election where inflation is high, growth is falling?
27:05
Unidentified speaker: Not obvious to me.
27:06
Unidentified speaker: Um, but the the big the big thing on the horizon now is this spending review.
27:10
Unidentified speaker: It's the point where the government has to, yeah, rubber hits the road, the government has to take a budget and allocate it to all the departments.
27:16
Unidentified speaker: So that means all the ministers sitting around the cabinet table arguing about who gets what.
27:20
Unidentified speaker: That does look really tough.
27:22
Unidentified speaker: So maybe you want an election to avoid that.
27:24
Unidentified speaker: But another thing I'd say, and this is your personal opinion, it's not clear to me that voters want to have another election so soon after the last one.
27:34
Unidentified speaker: And we we keep changing chancellors and prime ministers and having elections.
27:37
Unidentified speaker: I think at some point, what we need a party to do is say that there are some long-run decisions that need to be made here.
27:43
Unidentified speaker: You need to kind of crack on and get things in place rather than keep uh switching who's who's running the show.
27:48
Unidentified speaker: And do you think that this budget cycle has has delivered a little bit, a little bit more stability versus previous?
27:54
Unidentified speaker: Do you think from that perspective it's been successful?
27:56
Unidentified speaker: Maybe in the eyes of businesses, investment, bond markets?
27:59
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, I do actually.
28:00
Unidentified speaker: And actually, one thing I criticized last year was the speculation around the budget was off the charts.
28:05
Unidentified speaker: I mean, people spent months and months and months uh speculating about what taxes were going to rise.
28:10
Unidentified speaker: And that's that's that's a real problem because people start doing things like selling their assets to realise their capital gains or changing their retirement plans because they're worried about tax rises.
28:18
Unidentified speaker: So that speculation has a real economic cost.
28:21
Unidentified speaker: We got less of that this year, I think partly because John Healy ran the treasury differently and they had uh you know fewer, uh fewer leaks to press, um, partly because it was just a smaller budget and there were no big tax rises coming.
28:32
Unidentified speaker: Um but if you speak to businesses, a lot of what they say is that whatever the tax rate's gonna be, they just don't want a tax regime that changes every autumn because you have to get you know get used to the new regime.
28:42
Unidentified speaker: So actually a bit of stability, um only changing tax policy when you know it's for the best, when you've got a plan, when it's pop a bigger picture, and not this constant tweaking and fiddling would be better for all of us, I think.
28:53
Unidentified speaker: Well, but you said 96 lucrat changes or tweaks, 98 tweaks.
28:58
Unidentified speaker: So it is quite tweaky.
29:00
Unidentified speaker: Oh, this one, yeah, exactly.
29:01
Unidentified speaker: I mean, I think that's the part of the problem.
29:02
Unidentified speaker: It's it's um it was better that was no speculation and better that people have sort of shrugged their shoulders and moved on.
29:08
Unidentified speaker: Um, but it didn't resist this fiddly urge.
29:10
Unidentified speaker: I think what we want is a budget that has the not loads of speculation, not loads of fiddling, a smaller number of measures that actually might move the dial, where they're well thought through, we know what they're trying to achieve, they're they're well designed, and they're part of a broader plan where people can say, okay, I see that happening, but I see that's where we're going, as opposed to it feeling like this sort of scatter gun, like, oh, that took me by surprise.
29:33
Unidentified speaker: What's that?
29:33
Unidentified speaker: So, yeah, I still don't think this is the right approach.
29:36
Unidentified speaker: Better that there's less speculation, but still to be fiddly.
29:38
Unidentified speaker: What would some measures have been off the top of your head?
29:41
Unidentified speaker: I know you guys do loads of research into this on your side, but do you have anything that you thought if I'd have seen that, I'd have been like, yes, this is good.
29:47
Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
29:48
Unidentified speaker: Well, yeah, loads and loads of it in some sense.
29:49
Unidentified speaker: That's part of the frustration that I don't think the problem is we don't know what to do.
29:52
Unidentified speaker: So, I mean, let me give you one, but I really we could we could talk about this all day.
29:56
Unidentified speaker: So, property taxes uh RMS in this country.
30:00
Unidentified speaker: We are have we have a council tax system that's still based on valuations from 1991.
30:05
Unidentified speaker: I I was still in primary school in 1991.
30:07
Unidentified speaker: Some of your listers won't even have been born in 1991.
30:09
Unidentified speaker: It's absolutely crazy.
30:11
Unidentified speaker: Um, at the same time, we've got stamp duty, which in my opinion has absolutely no place in a modern tax system.
30:16
Unidentified speaker: Basically, it means it just gums up the housing market, makes people less likely to move, either because they want to move to be happier, to be closer to family, or they want to move for a job.
30:24
Unidentified speaker: So I think actually, rather than tweaking and bolting on a new bit of council tax on the top, which is what they've done, just revalue it.
30:31
Unidentified speaker: Work out what properties are currently worth, set the tax properly.
30:34
Unidentified speaker: Um, and I would scrap stamp duty altogether and raise the money instead through uh through council tax.
30:40
Unidentified speaker: Now that would have winners and losers, and that speaks to the politics of this.
30:43
Unidentified speaker: Whenever, because we've got a broken tax system, there are some beneficiaries of that.
30:47
Unidentified speaker: There are some people getting benefits they probably weren't really intended to get, but taking away is always painful.
30:53
Unidentified speaker: But unless we're willing to do that kind of thing, it's not going to help.
30:55
Unidentified speaker: But stamp duties, just take that one.
30:57
Unidentified speaker: That would, again, make us happier.
30:58
Unidentified speaker: It would make us more able to move for our jobs, it would increase productivity and it wouldn't solve all of our problems.
31:04
Unidentified speaker: But if we had that kind of holistic approach, tax after tax after tax, I think we could, I think we could move the dial.
31:11
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, I mean, I I won't move house because of stump duty.
31:14
Unidentified speaker: So and you know, and I'm just one person, right?
31:16
Unidentified speaker: And well, me neither.
31:17
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, I feel like I've got to wait until because I've got a small family, I've got to wait until I can actually buy a family home because I can't what I should be able to do is just move to sort of take the next step and then move again.
31:27
Unidentified speaker: But I don't want to be faced with two of these whacking great tax bills.
31:30
Unidentified speaker: So I'm gonna wait in my in my extremely cramped living space until I can actually uh you know reasonably think I've found where I want to live, and it's madness.
31:39
Unidentified speaker: And Andy Burnham going in is like I'm going to make the decisions that I need to make, the unpopular decisions.
31:46
Unidentified speaker: There was a lot of signal around, you know, I don't care if it's gonna ruffle some feathers, and then this budget hasn't done some of the obvious things that you say have been sat on the f sat around the table for a long time.
31:57
Unidentified speaker: Why is he not making that choice?
32:00
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, well, I think there's a couple things to say there.
32:01
Unidentified speaker: I think one is actually to his credit, what they have announced is a change to the triple lock, which is how the state pension is indexed over time.
32:08
Unidentified speaker: You can chat about that if you want.
32:09
Unidentified speaker: But I think that was one where lots of people were saying that's untouchable, no one can change it.
32:13
Unidentified speaker: And he's announced a change that I think is a good one.
32:15
Unidentified speaker: So that was an example, and that became kind of totemic in kind of bond market circles.
32:19
Unidentified speaker: People thought it was an example of if the government can't even touch that, because in the short run, there are no losses, it's just in the long run.
32:24
Unidentified speaker: If you can't even touch that, you can't do anything.
32:26
Unidentified speaker: So that's that's one where he could point to and say, I did do that.
32:29
Unidentified speaker: The other thing I think it's worth saying is that there are so many problems the government could choose to fix, it won't ever be able to do all of them.
32:36
Unidentified speaker: So I think what it has to do is pick its battles.
32:38
Unidentified speaker: Now, I'd love it to pick the tax system and pick reform of the tax system as a way forward, but it might just want to pick battles somewhere else, like in further education or in competition policy or in public control of utilities.
32:48
Unidentified speaker: But I think importantly, it's got to pick a battle and sort of just doggedly stick at that and find a way to change it.
32:55
Unidentified speaker: So what we don't yet know really is so take welfare, is the government gonna take uh benefits for disabled people as the battle it's going to try to win?
33:03
Unidentified speaker: Is it gonna have some bigger, overarching strategy for public control of utilities?
33:09
Unidentified speaker: Is that what it's gonna do?
33:10
Unidentified speaker: And we don't yet know what it's gonna pick, but it it definitely needs to pick something and then really run with it, I think.
33:15
Unidentified speaker: Well the the triple lock thing seems it's it would be past an election by the sounds of it, down to like a double lock.
33:22
Unidentified speaker: It sounds like he read maybe the IFS paper on this because it seems to be uh a double lock with maybe an earnings kind of link.
33:30
Unidentified speaker: Then but then he floated the social care point, which was kind of like, I'll take away the triple lock, but I'll give you the social care, which might even be a bigger black hole.
33:38
Unidentified speaker: You know, like it's not clear cut to me that the savings that from the triple lock are are even savings because it's an unsustainable promise.
33:45
Unidentified speaker: And then there's this promise around social care, to which is the carrot to the stick that yeah, so I mean personally, I looked at it, I was I thought you're opening another one on the other side, basically.
33:56
Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
33:56
Unidentified speaker: No, no, I agree.
33:57
Unidentified speaker: I think the triple lock is still best thought of as a triple lock.
33:59
Unidentified speaker: It's still got an average linked to average earnings, but just uh with a different mechanism protecting people from inflation.
34:06
Unidentified speaker: Um, but you're right.
34:07
Unidentified speaker: I mean, our our numbers suggest that you know you might be saving something like four billion a year in the middle of the next decade.
34:14
Unidentified speaker: You might save nothing because of how how the way it works.
34:17
Unidentified speaker: Um and you certainly aren't saving enough to do a full fat national care service if that's what you want.
34:22
Unidentified speaker: So I think the point of it is it's better to have it gone rather than not.
34:26
Unidentified speaker: And we've now got a more sensible policy, hopefully, coming in.
34:29
Unidentified speaker: Um but if you want to do social care, then you've got to firstly design the system properly.
34:34
Unidentified speaker: Um, but also if you do want something big, you need more money for that.
34:38
Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
34:39
Unidentified speaker: You mentioned the bond markets and and saying that the the the triple up was this kind of like totemic thing that if you can't touch that, you can't do anything.
34:45
Unidentified speaker: And he suggested that we might.
34:47
Unidentified speaker: How have the bond markets reacted to to this budget?
34:49
Unidentified speaker: Are they being nice to us now or yeah.
34:52
Unidentified speaker: So I think they've basically shrugged their shoulders and moved on, which I think is a good thing.
34:56
Unidentified speaker: But really importantly, I think for everyone, for all of us at home, we shouldn't take really any comfort from that for the following reason that you know you don't want to you don't want to shock the bond market.
35:07
Unidentified speaker: Um, because if you if you try to borrow more than they are expecting effectively, then they charge us more to to lend money to us, and that's bad for all of us because more of our tax money goes on that.
35:18
Unidentified speaker: But keeping them, I'm happy is the wrong word because they're not really happy or unhappy, they're just trading.
35:22
Unidentified speaker: But you know, keeping the interest rates reasonable is is necessary, but not sufficient.
35:27
Unidentified speaker: They don't, people who are trading and lending to the government don't care about the quality of our public services, don't care about our infrastructure, don't really care about um, you know, how things are gonna pan out in coming years.
35:37
Unidentified speaker: They just care about how much, what's that supply and demand, how much is the government trying to borrow, how much does the market want to buy, what does that mean about the price?
35:44
Unidentified speaker: And I think what's happening here is that a lot of traders already didn't expect the government to be cutting borrowing as fast as it said it's gonna do in current years.
35:51
Unidentified speaker: They've sort of discounted that.
35:53
Unidentified speaker: They already thought there'd be more borrowing this year on the back of the war in the Middle East.
35:57
Unidentified speaker: So the fact they didn't respond to the budget just means they got what they expected, which is another slug of borrowing, but that's already been in the price.
36:05
Unidentified speaker: So it was it was a small enough increase in borrowing that they didn't really react.
36:09
Unidentified speaker: But it's still big enough that we should all care, because again, it's delaying the point where we can actually start getting the debt stabilizing.
36:15
Unidentified speaker: Is it credible for the for us to sit here as a nation and say we can always just kind of borrow if we need to?
36:21
Unidentified speaker: You know, that the that will always be there, that facility, in the in the in the way that we use it at the minute, which is we rely on it heavily every single year.
36:29
Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
36:29
Unidentified speaker: I mean, the extreme, no, absolutely not.
36:31
Unidentified speaker: I mean, that's not to say we're anywhere close to a pan like like a crisis.
36:34
Unidentified speaker: When we're not, we can still, you know, the government could go out and borrow a load more money.
36:38
Unidentified speaker: And in the short run, what would happen is that you'd have to do it at a higher price.
36:41
Unidentified speaker: So if we wanted to borrow enough money to, I don't know, fund the defence pledge, for example, we should expect to have to do that at a higher interest rate.
36:49
Unidentified speaker: The same way, in some ways, that having a bigger mortgage often comes with a higher interest rate, but we could we could pull it off.
36:54
Unidentified speaker: The danger is that as we have debt, so debt basically, just to rub back a little bit, you know, before in goal in Gordon Brown's time in the in the 2000s, he had this big thing about national debt not rising above 40%.
37:05
Unidentified speaker: That was the that was the kind of the cap we couldn't go above.
37:07
Unidentified speaker: It's tripled since then.
37:08
Unidentified speaker: It ratcheted up in the financial crisis, it ratched up against again in the pandemic, and it's been rising ever since.
37:15
Unidentified speaker: Um, so clearly we have been able to sustain that level of debt, but I'm pretty confident that other shocks are going to come along.
37:20
Unidentified speaker: I don't know which ones, I don't know whether it'll be a financial crisis or a pandemic or an AI boom and bust or something else.
37:27
Unidentified speaker: Something will come along.
37:28
Unidentified speaker: And what's important is that when that something comes along, we have the capacity to say, okay, now we've got a big fat recession.
37:34
Unidentified speaker: Now we've got to borrow a load of money and pump money into the economy.
37:37
Unidentified speaker: You don't want to get to that point and be like, oh dear, we've run out of capacity, or we can only do this at really high interest rates.
37:43
Unidentified speaker: So it's kind of a fix the roof while the sun's shining.
37:46
Unidentified speaker: I know that today doesn't feel like the best of times, but we're not in the in the midst of a huge crisis.
37:51
Unidentified speaker: Now should be when we're at least stabilizing the debt so that we have a bit of capacity for the future.
37:57
Unidentified speaker: Because if you keep going, but we will hit a point at some point where actually investors look at us and say, no, thank you.
38:03
Unidentified speaker: We don't want to lend any more money to you.
38:05
Unidentified speaker: The other thing to remember is that with this stock of debt, we're not actually ever going to pay it off in the sense of literally, you know, you pay a pound off every year.
38:12
Unidentified speaker: What we need to have is an economy that's growing faster so that for a nominal stock of debt, as the economy grows, the the debt stock becomes less important.
38:21
Unidentified speaker: Um, but we should make that easier in the short run by stopping have the debt growing.
38:25
Unidentified speaker: We at least need to sort of stabilize it, ideally getting it nudging down uh to make that uh make that easier to achieve.
38:31
Unidentified speaker: So you don't think we're stuck in like a bit of a a kind of terminal spiral or anything with this?
38:35
Unidentified speaker: Because you're saying that it's consuming one in 14 of all the tax pounds, we're continuing to borrow.
38:40
Unidentified speaker: It's not that it's just going to keep getting bigger and bigger and swallowing more of the economy.
38:45
Unidentified speaker: It could actually still be a sensible thing to do to continue to borrow.
38:50
Unidentified speaker: Yes.
38:51
Unidentified speaker: So I'm still optimistic about the UK in that I think there's nothing, there's nothing here that's inevitable.
38:55
Unidentified speaker: I don't think it's inevitable that we just have ever, ever rising debt.
38:59
Unidentified speaker: Um, I also don't think we should be complacent and therefore think whatever we do, it will be fine, because I don't think that.
39:04
Unidentified speaker: I think a world in which we keep having borrowing at this high level permanently, that would create problems.
39:11
Unidentified speaker: Um if we don't get the growth rate up, that's going to create problems.
39:14
Unidentified speaker: So I do think we need to both, you know, not overreact and panic.
39:18
Unidentified speaker: Borrowing some amount of money now is fine.
39:20
Unidentified speaker: I think we're borrowing too much, but borrowing some amount of money, for example, to invest in infrastructure is okay.
39:27
Unidentified speaker: And if we can get that borrowing down to more reasonable levels and actually achieve the consolidation that the IMF has patting us on the back for planning, then I think we would be in a better state.
39:38
Unidentified speaker: But that's again, we shouldn't underestimate how hard that is.
39:40
Unidentified speaker: The government needs to simultaneously consolidate public finances, which is some combination of spending restraint and tax rises, while trying to address living standards in the short run, which is really hard, while trying to drive up growth in the medium run, while also dealing with global shocks and an aging population and net zero and everything else.
40:00
Unidentified speaker: So it's it's a tough set of things to do, but I do think there's a way in which, with better policy, more consistent policy, a sort of a laser focus on just keep not fiddling around the edges, but actually picking an area, finding a fix, implementing it, leaving it alone.
40:14
Unidentified speaker: I'm still optimistic about the UK.
40:16
Unidentified speaker: I think it's a way to summarise that.
40:19
Unidentified speaker: That's good to hear.
40:20
Unidentified speaker: So was there anything within this budget that you think is going to support that growth ambition then?
40:25
Unidentified speaker: Because you you can't raise taxes meaningfully.
40:27
Unidentified speaker: We can't borrow into forever.
40:30
Unidentified speaker: We're chasing growth, but we need to use the taxation and the borrowing to deliver that growth if we can.
40:35
Unidentified speaker: So yeah, did you see anything within this budget that gives you confidence that it's going to lead to more growth?
40:41
Unidentified speaker: The short answer, sadly, is no.
40:42
Unidentified speaker: I think there's nothing in here really move the dial.
40:46
Unidentified speaker: So the one thing I mentioned earlier that the government did, which again might eventually help on the margins, is decide to uh allocate some of our national revenues to uh to mayors.
40:56
Unidentified speaker: So at the moment, all of income tax is set at the national level and sort of spent at the national level.
41:02
Unidentified speaker: It will still be set at the national level, so the tax rates are all set in Westminster still.
41:06
Unidentified speaker: But going forward, the mayors in different areas will lose some grant funding, they'll get a share of income tax revenues instead.
41:14
Unidentified speaker: And over time, if their areas do particularly well, they'll get a bigger share of the funding, effectively.
41:20
Unidentified speaker: That in principle gives mayors uh more incentive to uh you know invest in local areas, to try to grow their tax bases.
41:27
Unidentified speaker: That could, and that is part of, I guess, Andy Burnham's vision for how do we get growth in the UK, we get stronger regional areas doing growth.
41:35
Unidentified speaker: So it's not it's not guaranteed to work, it could be a complete flop.
41:38
Unidentified speaker: But the process the government had around that policy seems pretty good.
41:41
Unidentified speaker: Where they've landed seems pretty sensible.
41:44
Unidentified speaker: So that's not going to pay off, you know, this this decade, but that could put in train one of the things that might that might at the margins help.
41:51
Unidentified speaker: But that that's a there's not much else in there, I don't think, other than that.
41:55
Unidentified speaker: The you say a share of income tax, do we know how that would be allocated?
41:59
Unidentified speaker: Is that based on like population, on what's raised in that local area, or is it just, oh, you need more help, so we'll give you more money?
42:06
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, so we don't know all the details yet, but what we do know is it'll be based on where people live.
42:10
Unidentified speaker: So there'll be a kind of mayoral area, they'll look at who lives in that area, um, and then on day one, there'll be a share of that revenue.
42:18
Unidentified speaker: And then over time, if if the revenue grows more strongly, you'll get more.
42:22
Unidentified speaker: If it grows less strongly, your your area will get less.
42:24
Unidentified speaker: So it's it's it's two ways.
42:26
Unidentified speaker: Um, but basically about people in your area.
42:28
Unidentified speaker: So the mayors will have an incentive to both get incomes up for people in their areas and to attract people uh to come to their areas.
42:37
Unidentified speaker: Does that not entrench um inequality if it if it's based on the revenues generated in your area?
42:42
Unidentified speaker: Because like a place like Westminster is gonna generate significantly more w revenue than Wigan.
42:47
Unidentified speaker: Or like Greater Manchester, that would be probably a bad example.
42:50
Unidentified speaker: But pick pick a, you know, pick an area that a mayor looks after, they're gonna say, well, well, we need more to catch up, not a share of what we generate, because the problem is we're not generating enough.
42:59
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, absolutely.
43:00
Unidentified speaker: So one of the things I think there's two things to say.
43:02
Unidentified speaker: One is that local areas will still get a big chunk of their money through grant funding from the cut central government.
43:09
Unidentified speaker: And that funding is tied to need, basically.
43:12
Unidentified speaker: So areas that are more needy because they have, I don't know, a population that needs more support, then they'll still get a bigger share of that.
43:19
Unidentified speaker: So that that is still the biggest thing going on in the background.
43:22
Unidentified speaker: It's also the case that for this uh revenue assignment, what's going to happen is there'll be a, we think, there'll be a kind of an allocation on day one, but there'll be tariffs and top-ups.
43:33
Unidentified speaker: So actually, if you gave London the same share of its revenue that you gave to Manchester, it would have a huge pile of money, but you'll have a tariff uh to take some of that away, basically, so that they offset the starting points.
43:44
Unidentified speaker: And then over time, we were worried they were going to design it in such a way that London would just pull ahead.
43:50
Unidentified speaker: Actually, they've done something more sensible than that.
43:52
Unidentified speaker: So we think that areas will pull ahead if they grow stronger than their neighbours, but not just because they have a big tax base.
43:59
Unidentified speaker: So it's it could still be the case that areas in the north could be the biggest winners from this uh if they grow faster than London.
44:06
Unidentified speaker: But underlying your question, the more simply, is there is absolutely this trade-off between you want to give incentives for growth and let some areas pull ahead, but you also want to uh redistribute between areas.
44:16
Unidentified speaker: And therefore, there's going to be some, at some point there'll be some kind of reset effects when you'll move money from the rich areas to the poor areas.
44:22
Unidentified speaker: And you kind of can't get around that trade-off.
44:24
Unidentified speaker: You have to decide how much incentive do you want to give an area to grow and how much do you want to ensure it against um against bad days.
44:31
Unidentified speaker: Worth remembering perhaps that the UK is unusual internationally in how centralized its tax revenue is.
44:38
Unidentified speaker: We also already have very high regional inequality.
44:41
Unidentified speaker: The UK is one of the most regional unequal countries in the developed world.
44:45
Unidentified speaker: So the current system we have is not leading to lots of equality at the moment.
44:49
Unidentified speaker: So this the new system could be worse, but it's not obviously going to be worse.
44:53
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, the one thing I I worry about is um the allowance for mayors to fail, because you know, when you look at Germany and the devolutionaire, they basically run these experiments or they did, and s some cities would get it right, some, you know, mayor may mayoral constituencies would get it wrong.
45:08
Unidentified speaker: And it's important that we don't beat them over the head or go, oh look, the whole thing's failed because this mayor here has just blown a load of money.
45:14
Unidentified speaker: And you can look at certain areas, and there has been massive wastes of of money on, you know, projects in certain areas.
45:21
Unidentified speaker: So hopefully we we allow people to fail, and then we pick up the this, you know, you you look at the Manchester project and then you go, okay, well, this has worked here, so we should roll that out across everywhere.
45:31
Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
45:32
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, I think again, there's there's a trade-off.
45:33
Unidentified speaker: So I think they will there'll need to be a you need to do a little bit of allowing them to fail.
45:37
Unidentified speaker: Because if you completely back everything up, then people will take silly risks.
45:40
Unidentified speaker: It's kind of a moral hazard.
45:42
Unidentified speaker: But you need to also not allow some areas, obviously, to completely fall in the gutter because we care about our fellow citizens.
45:47
Unidentified speaker: So again, there's this, there's sort of a safety net built into the system.
45:50
Unidentified speaker: So you can an area can fail and fall somewhat, but it can't fall below some basic standard, is kind of how they're going to do it.
45:58
Unidentified speaker: For someone who doesn't live in central London, how would you expect that devolution to show up in their community?
46:03
Unidentified speaker: Would you know what kind of things might they see over the coming years?
46:06
Unidentified speaker: You said a decade there, but hopefully a bit sooner.
46:10
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, well, I hope a bit sooner.
46:11
Unidentified speaker: I think what it means for people is that mayors in their area have more capacity and more incentive to do things, and in particular to do things related to economic policy.
46:21
Unidentified speaker: So that could be uh building commercial spaces, it could be investing in transport infrastructure, it could be in supporting people into work, kind of thing.
46:29
Unidentified speaker: So I think there's a I think the takeaway is look more at your local policy.
46:34
Unidentified speaker: I mean, one of the one of the things I think we need to do in this country, if we're going to have these more devolved policies, is actually get better at local scrutiny.
46:41
Unidentified speaker: We are so used to just looking at national policy, things like local newspapers have basically disappeared.
46:46
Unidentified speaker: So as as as our local areas become more important for setting policy, we should all be trying to scrutinize that local policy and paying attention to what are mayors doing.
46:54
Unidentified speaker: If they're borrowing money on your behalf, what are they investing in?
46:57
Unidentified speaker: What's their theory if they invest in some kind of commercial space, what are they hoping is going to happen as a result?
47:02
Unidentified speaker: So I think you'll probably see a bit more building and a bit more mayors uh doing things in communities, and we should all be, you know, watching what they're up to.
47:10
Unidentified speaker: Maybe the local election becomes even more important.
47:14
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, it might be.
47:15
Unidentified speaker: And also which mayor you elect might be more important.
47:17
Unidentified speaker: So picking a mayor that you think's got a good vision for your area, where you think he that they've got a vision for how they could make things better, I think would be more important.
47:25
Unidentified speaker: Okay, thank you.
47:26
Unidentified speaker: I know entrepreneurs seem to be okay or happy with the budget.
47:30
Unidentified speaker: Can you explain what's gone on there?
47:32
Unidentified speaker: Because I know in the in previous budgets they've they've they have not been happy.
47:35
Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
47:36
Unidentified speaker: So there's a whole there's a whole set of things.
47:38
Unidentified speaker: So I think the two the two to mention most stand out is there is something something currently called business asset disposal relief.
47:45
Unidentified speaker: It used to be called entrepreneurs' relief.
47:47
Unidentified speaker: Um, I have for, I don't know, more than a decade now complained about that relief.
47:51
Unidentified speaker: I think it's very, very poorly designed.
47:53
Unidentified speaker: In fact, I spent much of my sort of career before being director deep in the wheeze of the HMRC tax data, looking at how this relief affects people.
48:00
Unidentified speaker: And the part of the problem is you can find some entrepreneurs, some genuine, like you know, innovative, doing renewed stuff, people who benefit.
48:07
Unidentified speaker: There are also a lot of people that are doing completely respectable, great things like IT consultancy, who were also getting this big capital gains tax break.
48:14
Unidentified speaker: They weren't really the intended um beneficiary, and they're shoving loads of money in their company and keeping it there rather than spending it elsewhere.
48:20
Unidentified speaker: So the bad relief, that's becoming less generous.
48:23
Unidentified speaker: And I was pleased about that.
48:25
Unidentified speaker: But we also got this new relief called Founders Relief, which again is a new preferential 10% rate of capital gains tax for people who are early investors in companies that go on to grow very quickly.
48:37
Unidentified speaker: And on the face of it, that might sound great.
48:39
Unidentified speaker: But I spent a lot of the last few days poring over the details of that.
48:43
Unidentified speaker: And I think it's absolutely bonkers.
48:45
Unidentified speaker: And I think it's bonkers for a cup for a whole laundry list of reasons, but to give you sort of two high-level ones, one is that a lot of the activity that will end up getting a tax break is stuff that would have happened anyway.
48:56
Unidentified speaker: So you're not really getting more stuff, you're just handing a tax break to some people.
49:00
Unidentified speaker: A lot of entrepreneurs that need support, who need to help uh finding financing or who need to like uh not be put off by putting money into a new company, they're not really getting much here.
49:10
Unidentified speaker: And at the same time, there are all these really bizarre criteria that I worry are going to distort genuine entrepreneurs' behavior.
49:17
Unidentified speaker: So, for example, you've got an incentive to sell just after your company's been really quickly growing.
49:21
Unidentified speaker: What you might want, you might not want to do that.
49:23
Unidentified speaker: You might want to go for that really rapid period of growth, then let your company mature and maybe sell a bit later.
49:28
Unidentified speaker: But no, this relief thinks you should sell, you know, quite early.
49:31
Unidentified speaker: And there's just endless, endless uh sort of bizarre behaviour changes.
49:35
Unidentified speaker: So, big picture, not very much change.
49:38
Unidentified speaker: There's the the numbers on the on the scorecard, the list of policy measures were very small.
49:42
Unidentified speaker: But this just smacks to me of another chancellor who wants a new relief, who's tweaked around the edges and actually made things worse.
49:49
Unidentified speaker: So I'm actually feeling pretty grumpy about um about the entrepreneurs' relief stuff.
49:54
Unidentified speaker: So the relief is at the point that you get like a like a sale, a liquidation event, you like a load of money comes in, you get you get a favorable tax rate at that point.
50:05
Unidentified speaker: Do you know how many entrepreneurs or founders, because the whole founder community are optimists, right?
50:11
Unidentified speaker: They all think that they're gonna sell a business probably because that's why they do it.
50:14
Unidentified speaker: How many actually get a point to a point where they might benefit from that relief?
50:18
Unidentified speaker: Do you know like the percentages at all?
50:20
Unidentified speaker: Um, I don't know the percentages.
50:22
Unidentified speaker: Um, and I forgot the government have an estimated number of people who think who they think is gonna benefit.
50:28
Unidentified speaker: Um, I can't remember that number.
50:29
Unidentified speaker: What I do remember is I think the average person who benefits will get a benefit of £500,000.
50:34
Unidentified speaker: So if you're getting the money, that's you know, you'd much rather have £500,000.
50:38
Unidentified speaker: So that's a big tax break to a few people.
50:41
Unidentified speaker: But as you were saying, importantly, a lot of founders, if you're starting out a business today, you're not thinking, well, maybe in 15 years' time, I'll get an even lower tax rate than I thought I would get.
50:52
Unidentified speaker: I'm gonna work even harder.
50:54
Unidentified speaker: If you're a founder, you're you're just you're just going for it, right?
50:56
Unidentified speaker: And if you do have a problem, it's probably a problem where you can't get enough money up front or you can't deduct the full cost of your investment.
51:02
Unidentified speaker: Actually, what you need is more relief up front.
51:04
Unidentified speaker: And by the time you've got a business that's going really, really well, um, whether you're not you sell it or not, is not just about, it shouldn't be just about the tax, right?
51:12
Unidentified speaker: It should be about, you know, are you should you be still investing in it?
51:15
Unidentified speaker: Should you be selling it?
51:16
Unidentified speaker: Should you be investing in a new business?
51:17
Unidentified speaker: And I write this new relief is is adding this tax complication into that, not in a way that's going to make better commercial decisions, but that's going to distort decisions.
51:25
Unidentified speaker: So look, there'll be a bunch of people, it's relatively small.
51:27
Unidentified speaker: The whole relief only costs, well, I think it's going to cost a few hundred million.
51:31
Unidentified speaker: So it's not big in the aggregate sense.
51:33
Unidentified speaker: Most founders won't end up benefiting.
51:35
Unidentified speaker: Um I don't know the number, but it'll be most won't.
51:37
Unidentified speaker: Um, for those who do, it's a huge tax break.
51:40
Unidentified speaker: I still don't think it's one that's very well targeted at getting more entrepreneurship or more growth in the country.
51:45
Unidentified speaker: It's certainly not a wealth tax either, is it?
51:47
Unidentified speaker: It's an it's an anti-wealth tax, but the point that someone's the opposite.
51:50
Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
51:51
Unidentified speaker: You take the people who you take the people who've been most successful, they've made it, that you know they've got a great idea, they're growing strongly, they're doing great.
51:58
Unidentified speaker: They're the ones that, you know, actually good, but but you're now giving them a big tax break.
52:03
Unidentified speaker: Whereas if you wanted actually more, you want more new entrepreneurs, you want to help the people who actually are kind of struggling, who've got a great idea but can't finance it, who can't upscale.
52:13
Unidentified speaker: You want the, I think you want the reliefs up front at the point where you're putting money into a company, not at the point where you've you're sitting on a big pile of cash and wondering what to do with it.
52:21
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, you you you should you should tax people at the point that they win so that you can incentivize more people to start.
52:27
Unidentified speaker: Like, because people they've say, oh, entrepreneurs are leaving the UK.
52:31
Unidentified speaker: It's not because they won't stay because they think, oh, I'll get this relief at the end.
52:34
Unidentified speaker: If you made it easier for them to start their businesses, to find financing, to scale, blah, blah, blah, they we would have more entrepreneurs, right?
52:41
Unidentified speaker: So I think so.
52:42
Unidentified speaker: It's also the case if you're looking at if you're looking at the UK at the moment thinking, should I come here?
52:46
Unidentified speaker: These reliefs change so often.
52:47
Unidentified speaker: Have you have you got any faith that in 15 years or 10 years even, it's gonna still be there?
52:53
Unidentified speaker: I wouldn't I wouldn't be banking on that.
52:54
Unidentified speaker: So again, I think better to give people relief upfront when they're making the investment, rather than the promise of some tax relief at some future date if they meet some bizarre, complex criteria.
53:05
Unidentified speaker: Okay, perfect.
53:06
Unidentified speaker: See a lot of the audience are a personal finance audience, so that they're interested in investing and things like this.
53:11
Unidentified speaker: And there's been changes to ISIS or promise changes to ISES.
53:15
Unidentified speaker: I would characterize the changes to ISES over my professional career as a YouTuber over six years of we're going to make changes and then not making those changes.
53:24
Unidentified speaker: And actually, over the time that I've done my job, there has been no changes to ISIS.
53:30
Unidentified speaker: Um, just this constant cycle of, oh, we're going to introduce a Brit ISER or we're going to change the lifetime ISE, we're going to reduce the cap and we're going to bring it up.
53:38
Unidentified speaker: What do you think of this latest round of potential changes to ISES?
53:42
Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
53:42
Unidentified speaker: Well, it sounds like what's what's actually happened?
53:44
Unidentified speaker: The government were going to cut back how much you can put into an ICER, and now they're not going to do that.
53:49
Unidentified speaker: Um, I think so that would be good news for lots of people saving.
53:53
Unidentified speaker: Um, to your point about the const speculation, I actually really worry about that.
53:57
Unidentified speaker: I mean, obviously some of your listeners will be, you know, actually deep in the weeds on this and advising other people, but a lot of people just going about their day don't really understand this stuff.
54:05
Unidentified speaker: They don't really understand the different products.
54:07
Unidentified speaker: They certainly don't understand stocks and shares ICE as often.
54:10
Unidentified speaker: And the more we talk about changing and this and that and the licer, I think it just adds to this sense of like, oh, I don't really know what I'm doing.
54:15
Unidentified speaker: It's all a bit, it's all a bit scary.
54:16
Unidentified speaker: I think what you want, especially for savings products where people are tucking away money often for a very long period of time to buy a house or to retire or to save for college or something.
54:25
Unidentified speaker: You want that nice, predictable, stable framework so that people get to know what they're doing.
54:30
Unidentified speaker: So, you know, ICIS have been a big success in lots of ways because they they take a bunch of savings out of tax, and I think that's good.
54:37
Unidentified speaker: Um and I hope that we have a more stable regime going forward.
54:42
Unidentified speaker: Um, but I do think that that constant speculating about changes is a problem for people out there trying to tuck their money away.
54:49
Unidentified speaker: But do you think the the the temptation to tax savers, investors, is just too high when we're talking about the other angles being shut off?
54:59
Unidentified speaker: I think partly it is, yeah.
55:00
Unidentified speaker: And I think there's another tricky thing about saving, which and I'll resist the ocean start a tax lecture, but I think the tricky thing on the sort of conceptually is that not all tax not all savings are created equal.
55:11
Unidentified speaker: So in my mind, and I'm gonna simplify, but in my mind, if you're just tucking money away in a cash ICE or in a bank account and you're not doing anything particularly special, you're basically just getting a return that's like equal to inflation, roughly.
55:23
Unidentified speaker: So your money's not losing value, but you're not getting these high returns.
55:26
Unidentified speaker: I don't want to tax that at all, actually.
55:28
Unidentified speaker: If I'm just if some people just want to spend their money tomorrow rather than today, I don't think the government should be putting you off from doing that.
55:34
Unidentified speaker: So I want you to leave you alone.
55:36
Unidentified speaker: So I like the cash ICE model because I think actually, let people do normal savings, no tax, jolly good.
55:43
Unidentified speaker: Um, on the other hand, some people, their returns to savings are very, very big.
55:48
Unidentified speaker: Now, it could be because they've been very, very lucky and they've picked a really great set of stocks, or it could be because actually they're putting loads of time and effort into investing, for example, and they're getting a big return.
55:59
Unidentified speaker: And it's sort of a return on labor, basically.
56:02
Unidentified speaker: They're getting much more than you'd have got if you just shoved it in a bank.
56:04
Unidentified speaker: In those cases, I do want to tax some of those returns, still not the inflation bit of it, but some of those returns.
56:10
Unidentified speaker: And the problem is because we don't, and we could distinguish between that in the tax base.
56:13
Unidentified speaker: You could kind of say, look, if you only get a certain level of return, you get no tax, and above that you start getting taxed.
56:18
Unidentified speaker: But our tax doesn't do that.
56:19
Unidentified speaker: It sort of lumps everything into the same category.
56:22
Unidentified speaker: And then you have these horrible trade-offs and tweaks.
56:25
Unidentified speaker: So I am I I think basically the government has yet to grapple with what it's trying to do.
56:30
Unidentified speaker: It needs to be trying to fix the underlying structure of what we tax rather than just keep thinking, oh, I need some money, let's go and let's go and nudge that rate up a little bit.
56:38
Unidentified speaker: Because every time you nudge that rate up, you make some problems better.
56:42
Unidentified speaker: So you have less unfairness between people who get their income from savings and people who get it through work, but you make some problems worse because now you're taxing inflationary gains at a higher level.
56:50
Unidentified speaker: So I think the whole debate about the taxation of savings is actually very confused at the moment.
56:56
Unidentified speaker: So would you would you have um gone after CGT then, capital gains tax?
57:04
Unidentified speaker: Put an indexation in it for inflation or something like that, and raise the rate of capital gains tax so that you capture some of that savings?
57:14
Unidentified speaker: Because that's essentially what you're saying there, aren't you?
57:16
Unidentified speaker: You want to capture that return above the rate of inflation.
57:19
Unidentified speaker: Absolutely.
57:19
Unidentified speaker: So, in short, yes, actually I'd I'd give a rate of, and there's different ways to do this in practice, but I would give an allowance that actually for kind of an interest, an interest rate rather than inflation rate.
57:28
Unidentified speaker: So pick like a medium-run government bond yield as a measure of the interest rate, let people earn at least that much money, tax-free, and then above that, um, tax it more in line with earned income.
57:41
Unidentified speaker: In the background, there's lots of other things I would do as well.
57:43
Unidentified speaker: For example, more generous relief for losses.
57:45
Unidentified speaker: So if you do have a new venture and you try something and you and you um and you fail, basically, I think the government should take, you know, it takes a big share of the profits, it should take an, you know, as equal as possible share of the losses.
57:56
Unidentified speaker: So I'd do other things to that tax base as well.
57:58
Unidentified speaker: I'd stop the forgiveness of capital gains at death.
58:01
Unidentified speaker: I think that's absolutely bizarre.
58:02
Unidentified speaker: So I, you know, I think you shouldn't be able to avoid tax by dying effectively.
58:06
Unidentified speaker: Um and with that in place, I think you could have higher rates.
58:09
Unidentified speaker: The international mobility bit is harder because obviously some people do move out of the country for capital gains.
58:13
Unidentified speaker: So I think you have to start thinking about what do you want to do for the very wealthy people who are mobile?
58:18
Unidentified speaker: And do you want to start, you know, having taxes on entry and and exit?
58:22
Unidentified speaker: Um, but again, I think the important thing of all of that is start with the tax base.
58:26
Unidentified speaker: If you just put up rates, then you are disincentivising investment because some of the returns to investment are now, including the inflation ones, are now lower.
58:36
Unidentified speaker: So I sort of think until they until they touch the fix the base, they should leave the rates alone.
58:42
Unidentified speaker: But but but are you you you mentioned a couple of carb outs there.
58:45
Unidentified speaker: People would say their own home should have a carve out, you know, like their main residence.
58:48
Unidentified speaker: Do you do you get to a point where you just end up carving out all these things that it wouldn't be even be that meaningful?
58:53
Unidentified speaker: And and what would you do about ICEs and pensions within that regime?
58:57
Unidentified speaker: I don't want you to flesh out your policy fully here, but there's 80k a year I can stick into a pension and an ICE, right?
59:02
Unidentified speaker: So most people can tax wrap everything.
59:04
Unidentified speaker: Would you change that?
59:07
Unidentified speaker: So that's a huge question.
59:08
Unidentified speaker: So I'll try and get the quick version.
59:10
Unidentified speaker: So ICEs I'm actually quite relaxed about.
59:12
Unidentified speaker: Um so I think we'll leave them alone.
59:14
Unidentified speaker: I think pensions, there is there is a reason for the government to sort of um actively encourage retirement savings.
59:20
Unidentified speaker: Although I think they should be actively encouraging people to use their pensions as the pot that you draw down over retirement, not as the pot that you spend all for a big holiday at 50 or that you bequeath to your heirs.
59:31
Unidentified speaker: So I think it should be a retirement product that you're trying to encourage.
59:35
Unidentified speaker: Um I think there's still good reason to sort of cap how much tax relief people can get into a pension once you have such a big pen that you can stop getting tax relief, but but I think that's that's okay.
59:45
Unidentified speaker: Umes is a tricky one.
59:47
Unidentified speaker: You know, sort of economic theory suggests actually you should be taxing capital gains on main homes.
59:52
Unidentified speaker: But the political economy of that is so disastrous that I think actually you just kind of can't get there.
59:56
Unidentified speaker: Because if a one party says, right, I'm swacking capital gains on a house, then the next party's gonna say, the minute I come into office, I'm gonna remove that.
1:00:03
Unidentified speaker: And that just completely grinds the housing market to a halt.
1:00:05
Unidentified speaker: So I think there's a just a political reality of being able to get taxes on main homes.
1:00:10
Unidentified speaker: Um, but outside of that, all of the other gains on property, the second homes, um, uh business ventures, I think should be taxed, but with this much more generous base.
1:00:20
Unidentified speaker: I mean, effectively, one way to think about what I'm saying is that I think some gains are taxed too highly and they should, that rate should be brought down.
1:00:25
Unidentified speaker: Some are taxed too lowly, that rate should be bought up.
1:00:28
Unidentified speaker: But importantly, you need to do both of those things and not just not just reduce all rates or put all rates up.
1:00:34
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, and it starts with a broad conversation about how we want to tax things in the economy, not just like kick that rate, tweak that rate, basically.
1:00:41
Unidentified speaker: Exactly.
1:00:41
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, that's true.
1:00:42
Unidentified speaker: Broad tax reform, which you've been saying to me for how long have I been speaking to you?
1:00:46
Unidentified speaker: Maybe two to three years now.
1:00:47
Unidentified speaker: So you've you've been saying the same and the predecessor said this.
1:00:51
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, we've had there are generations of people at the IFS who've been saying this stuff.
1:00:54
Unidentified speaker: And I think this is the frustrating thing.
1:00:55
Unidentified speaker: The problem here is not that we don't know how to make some of these things better.
1:00:59
Unidentified speaker: It's about finding the political will to be bolder and actually change, you know, a whole bunch of things for a principled reason and not just, like you said, not just this sense of, oh, I needed a billion today.
1:01:08
Unidentified speaker: I've I found down the back of the sofa, I found the billion here, let's just do that.
1:01:11
Unidentified speaker: Or like landlords is another great example about this.
1:01:14
Unidentified speaker: They get they get regularly swacked because they seem to be a popular group to hit without any consideration of the fact that actually their the tax regime for them is bizarre.
1:01:22
Unidentified speaker: They're actually quite highly tax relative to only occupiers.
1:01:24
Unidentified speaker: And even if you hate them, putting higher taxes on them leads to higher rents for renters.
1:01:28
Unidentified speaker: So even if you're in the camp of people who don't like landlords, this is not obviously a good way to go, but they get whacked regularly because they're, I think they're an easy political target.
1:01:38
Unidentified speaker: It's a specific type of landlord as well.
1:01:40
Unidentified speaker: We say landlords, but if you're inside of a limited company structure, you you tend to avoid a lot of the targeting.
1:01:46
Unidentified speaker: So typically it the landlord that it's targeting is accidental landlords, you know, more normal people, not these people that own hundreds of Bitalettes, which might be what people think is happening.
1:01:57
Unidentified speaker: It it tends to be like a couple that have moved in together and they've still got a flat and they just have that flat because they thought, oh, that can be our retirement, and then you're hammering them.
1:02:04
Unidentified speaker: Absolutely.
1:02:05
Unidentified speaker: So they're not not professional landlords.
1:02:07
Unidentified speaker: I think um if I was to summarise the budget, it's basically tweaks around the edges because they're fairly constrained, with a lot of big questions coming down the line that you know I'm not sure that they can avoid.
1:02:19
Unidentified speaker: If we get to down the line, maybe that's in one or two years, and things haven't materially improved, is it is is a tax rise the only way that that we're gonna square the circle?
1:02:32
Unidentified speaker: So it doesn't have to be the only way for sure.
1:02:34
Unidentified speaker: I think this is like for us, for all of us, you know, voters, ignoring the government that's in power, um, I think we've got a really big choice.
1:02:41
Unidentified speaker: So we I say if you want to ingrow the size of the state because you want to do healthcare and welfare and warfare, if you want that, then you need to have higher taxes, you've got to work out who's gonna pay.
1:02:52
Unidentified speaker: But there are plenty of people who also don't want that.
1:02:54
Unidentified speaker: They want a smaller state and they want lower taxes.
1:02:56
Unidentified speaker: That's fine too.
1:02:57
Unidentified speaker: But you've got to work out what are you gonna cut?
1:02:59
Unidentified speaker: Are you gonna hold back the NHS?
1:03:01
Unidentified speaker: Are you, and if you if so, which bit of the NHS?
1:03:03
Unidentified speaker: Are you gonna hold back defence spending?
1:03:05
Unidentified speaker: Are you gonna cut welfare?
1:03:07
Unidentified speaker: And actually, even if you cut disability benefits, you'll need to do a lot more than that if you really want to free up resource.
1:03:11
Unidentified speaker: Are you gonna stop the government doing, I don't know, childcare support or something else?
1:03:15
Unidentified speaker: So what what is it you don't want the government to do?
1:03:17
Unidentified speaker: But that that's the big choice for all of us.
1:03:19
Unidentified speaker: Like, what size of government do you want?
1:03:20
Unidentified speaker: What do you want the government doing and how do you want to pay for it is the big choice.
1:03:23
Unidentified speaker: Within this government, because they have all these constraints, I think if they if they don't want to cut public services by the by the level it looks like they'd need to to meet their fiscal rules, um, they don't want to cut welfare, then they do have basically two options.
1:03:37
Unidentified speaker: One is to raise taxes substantially, but they are gonna find that hard without meeting, without breaking the manifesto because they've already done so much.
1:03:44
Unidentified speaker: Or frankly, they can increase borrowing.
1:03:47
Unidentified speaker: And what's gonna happen is that the fiscal rules, so the rule that says we want to get borrowing down, is based on three years ahead.
1:03:54
Unidentified speaker: Come next autumn, it will roll forward by a year.
1:03:56
Unidentified speaker: So in that year, what you can do, I think it's a very bad idea, but you can do it, is say, I'm still gonna pencil in cuts for in three years' time, but I'm gonna borrow more today.
1:04:04
Unidentified speaker: And then the next year, you can just play the same trick.
1:04:06
Unidentified speaker: You borrow more today, and then you say you're gonna cut it in three years' time.
1:04:08
Unidentified speaker: So you could end up having a situation where the government does borrow more than it's currently saying it's going to to pay for all the stuff that we like getting as citizens.
1:04:16
Unidentified speaker: Um, but there's a cost to that because that that debt interest bill is gonna stay high, our debt's gonna carry on going up, and that I think exposes us all uh to being more vulnerable as a as a as a nation.
1:04:28
Unidentified speaker: So it's an option.
1:04:29
Unidentified speaker: I I wouldn't be surprised if the government does it, but I think the better option is to get real about what kind of state do you want and who's gonna pay for it.
1:04:37
Unidentified speaker: And if you're not willing to pay for it, don't do it.
1:04:38
Unidentified speaker: And if you are willing to pay for it, great, decide who's gonna pay.
1:04:42
Unidentified speaker: Well, Andy Burnham's vision seems to be a higher state spend because social care is a massive spend potentially.
1:04:48
Unidentified speaker: And yeah, funded potentially through the through the triple lock, but that seems to be the version that we have.
1:04:54
Unidentified speaker: And that would imply then further tax rises down the line.
1:04:58
Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
1:04:58
Unidentified speaker: Well, unless I mean, look, there is a world, it's it's always really hard to forecast the future.
1:05:02
Unidentified speaker: There is a world in which growth really picks up.
1:05:05
Unidentified speaker: So let's imagine a world in which actually AI ends up being a great thing.
1:05:09
Unidentified speaker: It makes us all more productive, we produce more national income.
1:05:12
Unidentified speaker: With a kind of a bigger national pie, we can have more of everything.
1:05:16
Unidentified speaker: We can have more public spending, more private spending, you know, happy days.
1:05:20
Unidentified speaker: But if you want to be increasing the size of the state before that pie has got bigger, then yeah, you've got to take it from somewhere else.
1:05:26
Unidentified speaker: You've got to take it from other bits of government, or you need to take more pub more private consumption, basically, and turn it into government consumption.
1:05:33
Unidentified speaker: It's also worth saying that although I am optimistic and I think, you know, think growth could be picked up, it could also get worse.
1:05:39
Unidentified speaker: So what if actually the war in the Middle East rumbles on longer than we think and prices go up by more and that drags on our growth?
1:05:46
Unidentified speaker: What if actually AI ends up maybe boosting demand in the short run, whether investment, but actually ends up displacing lots of workers and leading to higher and higher unemployment?
1:05:55
Unidentified speaker: That could be really bad news for lots of us and make the economy uh weaker.
1:05:59
Unidentified speaker: So I think it's I worry a little bit the government's got this like hope for the best strategy.
1:06:03
Unidentified speaker: And although that's not strategy.
1:06:05
Unidentified speaker: I mean, hoping for the best is good.
1:06:06
Unidentified speaker: We should all hope for the best.
1:06:07
Unidentified speaker: But I think you have to hope for the best plan for the worst.
1:06:09
Unidentified speaker: You have to obviously, you know, be optimistic, try and make the world a better place, try and get growth up, while in your back pocket, knowing, well, if that doesn't happen, I'm gonna have to make a tough choice.
1:06:20
Unidentified speaker: Is that tough choice gonna be tax rises or spending cuts?
1:06:23
Unidentified speaker: What are the numbers that you're seeing though that are making you optimistic about this?
1:06:28
Unidentified speaker: Because I know I know you I know you you don't just work on hopium.
1:06:31
Unidentified speaker: I know that you'll be seeing data points that you think, oh no, that that looks positive.
1:06:35
Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
1:06:36
Unidentified speaker: Well, I think one thing to say is that it's not just the kind of the new data coming in.
1:06:39
Unidentified speaker: But if you look at if you look around the UK, we are still a relatively rich country internationally.
1:06:44
Unidentified speaker: We have people who are highly educated working in you know high value added industries.
1:06:50
Unidentified speaker: We invest a lot of money in science and we have strong universities, we have lots of uh great businesses, we have lots of entrepreneurs doing great things out there.
1:06:59
Unidentified speaker: So I'm sort of optimistic that the UK's got the kind of fundamental, underlying core ingredients, if you like.
1:07:06
Unidentified speaker: We have strong property rights.
1:07:07
Unidentified speaker: We um, you know, I complain about lots of things in the country, but we do have things that work.
1:07:12
Unidentified speaker: I also think there are some obvious things that could be better.
1:07:14
Unidentified speaker: I mean, infrastructure is the one that always jumps out at me.
1:07:17
Unidentified speaker: It seems so obvious to me that we could do better with infrastructure.
1:07:19
Unidentified speaker: If we could get the trains to run on time, if we could close the potholes, if we could sort at rush hour, um, that seems to me like it would unlock so much potential that that's an obvious we could we could do better.
1:07:29
Unidentified speaker: So I'm optimistic both on the raw ingredients and that I can see things that could get better.
1:07:35
Unidentified speaker: Um, on the AI stuff, I honestly haven't decided where I sit on that yet, partly because the data's still really early and still really patchy, and because there are these sort of two very broadly different scenarios.
1:07:46
Unidentified speaker: One where AI does make us all more productive, and that could be great.
1:07:50
Unidentified speaker: The other where actually it just wipes out a lot of jobs, um, especially for younger people and for the graduate intakes.
1:07:56
Unidentified speaker: And then even eventually it's okay, that kind of transition is um often really difficult.
1:08:02
Unidentified speaker: So I don't, I don't yet know.
1:08:04
Unidentified speaker: And nobody really knows.
1:08:05
Unidentified speaker: People have different guesses, but nobody knows yet what AI is really going to do to the economy.
1:08:09
Unidentified speaker: Everyone's just guessing and waiting.
1:08:11
Unidentified speaker: But um I think there is more uncertainty about that broader economic piece than there has been for um, well, certainly since I've been doing this kind of stuff.
1:08:19
Unidentified speaker: We've maintained those ingredients throughout the last couple of decades, though, and we we have not seen the growth.
1:08:24
Unidentified speaker: And do you think that is just victims of circumstance?
1:08:27
Unidentified speaker: Financial crisis, which I mean we we were right at the centre of that, but then COVID and the other things, if those points hadn't been there, would we, you know, would we have thrived?
1:08:38
Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
1:08:39
Unidentified speaker: It's a question everyone wants to know the answer to.
1:08:40
Unidentified speaker: Um basically nobody knows.
1:08:43
Unidentified speaker: I think there are things, I think it's a combination of things.
1:08:45
Unidentified speaker: Obviously, the financial crisis was bad for us, obviously, COVID was bad for us.
1:08:49
Unidentified speaker: Obviously, uh, you know, foreign wars that drive up prices are bad for us and they hold back uh things.
1:08:54
Unidentified speaker: So there are clearly in a world without those things, yes, I'm I'm certain we would have been uh richer.
1:09:00
Unidentified speaker: Um I also don't think policy has always been great.
1:09:03
Unidentified speaker: Again, if you look back over the last decade and a half, um ignoring the kind of big picture about size of the state stuff, just actually quite a lot of fiddling, quite a lot of not necessarily getting good bang for our buck on investment.
1:09:15
Unidentified speaker: We've got a horrible reputation for actually delivering on infrastructure projects, on time, on budget, you know, in ways that that improve productivity.
1:09:22
Unidentified speaker: Um I think we change policy too much.
1:09:24
Unidentified speaker: I mean, I've looked talked a lot about tax.
1:09:26
Unidentified speaker: I pick another one, further education.
1:09:28
Unidentified speaker: We feel like we're always changing.
1:09:29
Unidentified speaker: Is it O levels, T levels, U levels?
1:09:31
Unidentified speaker: I've forgotten what the levels are called now, but there's always some other policy being changed.
1:09:34
Unidentified speaker: So I think it's not it's not just external shocks.
1:09:38
Unidentified speaker: I think it's actually that policy um hasn't hasn't been good enough.
1:09:42
Unidentified speaker: And that it's hard to say if if better policy would have meant that we're everything was, you know, rosy, it probably wouldn't have been, but I think it could be better.
1:09:50
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, I mean, I don't understand the grades that my sister gets at school.
1:09:55
Unidentified speaker: Which is, you know, and we're like one generation, two generations apart, and I'm like, I have to have this little table to and you know, there's just an it's just a my it's just a what was wrong with A's and A pluses?
1:10:05
Unidentified speaker: I don't I don't know.
1:10:06
Unidentified speaker: Maybe you would know that it's not a good idea.
1:10:07
Unidentified speaker: Because it's not just no, but yeah, I don't know the answer to that.
1:10:10
Unidentified speaker: But it's not just that we have struggled to know what what an eight or whatever it is nowadays means.
1:10:14
Unidentified speaker: It's also that employers that are trying to work out what grades people have or what qualifications they've got or trying to work with local FE colleges to work out what kind of skills they need.
1:10:24
Unidentified speaker: When you're changing the system all the time, it's just hard for a system to bed in.
1:10:28
Unidentified speaker: So parents, you need students and parents and employers all to understand the system so they can sort of like indirectly work together uh to find the matches between people.
1:10:38
Unidentified speaker: And when systems are always changing, it's just really hard to get to get that working really well.
1:10:42
Unidentified speaker: Well, then on that basis, it seems like this budget has not achieved any of that because 93, 98 changes, is it 98?
1:10:49
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, that's just more more confusion, you know, uh more more small changes.
1:10:55
Unidentified speaker: I'm not sure anyone, maybe your team, after you've worked 44 hours straight, have got a grasp of all of them.
1:10:59
Unidentified speaker: But I don't think most people are going to be able to figure out what those things are.
1:11:02
Unidentified speaker: No, they're not.
1:11:03
Unidentified speaker: And some of them, I mean, some of them really are quite bizarre, and you know, it's gonna be only like three or four people who need to work out what they are.
1:11:08
Unidentified speaker: But no, you're right.
1:11:09
Unidentified speaker: I think there's a and look, I I have some sympathy for the idea that there are some small things that we can do that make things better.
1:11:15
Unidentified speaker: So if the government can find small, kind of it's like it's like Andy Burnham's everyday vibe, everyday fixes vibe.
1:11:21
Unidentified speaker: If you can find small things that make things better and you chip away at them, great, that's fine.
1:11:26
Unidentified speaker: The problem is there are some things there that maybe go in the right direction, but too many that's just like, what is this?
1:11:30
Unidentified speaker: Why are you doing this?
1:11:31
Unidentified speaker: You're chipping away at something, but in a way that's like bad for the tax system, or it feels like you're doing it to get away with some tax revenue raising, or it's again, it's like it's not lots of like progressively little things going in the right direction.
1:11:42
Unidentified speaker: It's it's a scatter gun of like, oh, a bit here, a bit there, a bit there.
1:11:44
Unidentified speaker: And it just adds to, I think the accountants will be happy because they're the ones that get to get paid to figuring all this out.
1:11:50
Unidentified speaker: But I think for the rest of us, it's um it's a distraction, and actually we want the government focused on more important things.
1:11:56
Unidentified speaker: And uh I'll let you go because you've got to go in a second.
1:11:59
Unidentified speaker: But uh is the Treasury sitting down with Andy Burnham and having that conversation and they're saying these are all the things on the table, so let's just pick a few bits.
1:12:06
Unidentified speaker: Like, how are they getting to that scattergun approach and not having this just general sense of direction forwards?
1:12:11
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, it's a good question.
1:12:12
Unidentified speaker: I mean, obviously, I you know I assume that the Treasury will be briefing their ministers.
1:12:15
Unidentified speaker: That's what they're that's what they're you know there for.
1:12:18
Unidentified speaker: And as I said earlier, that there are always there are always more things that could be done than any given government can do.
1:12:23
Unidentified speaker: So I think part of it is about choosing your battles.
1:12:26
Unidentified speaker: Again, you could pick any tax, and we could have had this whole episode be about why that tax, you know, how that tax could be fixed.
1:12:31
Unidentified speaker: So I think part is you need the political will to pick an area, decide what you want to do, and really resist the urge to do fitting.
1:12:39
Unidentified speaker: Like we talked about founders' relief and it's capital gains tax relief.
1:12:42
Unidentified speaker: That just I can't imagine.
1:12:43
Unidentified speaker: I mean, I really hope the civil service didn't advocate for that because it is bonkers.
1:12:47
Unidentified speaker: But it looks like a chancellor who wanted his name on something, wanted to have a new relief and that put this in, as opposed to a, okay, guys, capital gains tax, let's fix capital gains.
1:12:56
Unidentified speaker: This wasn't a let's fix capital gains tax.
1:12:58
Unidentified speaker: It was a, I want something for this group, get dream me up a new relief.
1:13:02
Unidentified speaker: So I think, again, I think a lot of the problem here is not the underlying, do we know what to do?
1:13:07
Unidentified speaker: It's the appetite to say, I'm gonna do something bigger picture for a kind of a, I'm gonna be on the on the moral high ground, I'm gonna do it because it's the principled, reasonable thing to do, and I'm gonna burn some political capital along the way.
1:13:18
Unidentified speaker: I think until you get a politician that's willing to stand up and take on the losers, because there will be losers from some of these big reforms, then you're gonna, you're sort of, you're, you're back into the fiddling again.
1:13:27
Unidentified speaker: Well, Andy Burnham literally said that that's what he was, that he would he was the guy that was gonna make the hard choices.
1:13:32
Unidentified speaker: Do you think the spending review is where we'll get a view of the hard choices?
1:13:36
Unidentified speaker: And that's the more, almost the more important fiscal event on the horizon.
1:13:40
Unidentified speaker: Well, I think it will be super important.
1:13:42
Unidentified speaker: I mean, 2027 and the spending review looks like it's gonna be a huge event.
1:13:45
Unidentified speaker: So um I think that will be uh one to watch.
1:13:48
Unidentified speaker: I think I'll get even less sleep for that one.
1:13:50
Unidentified speaker: But um I think with some moments before that, though.
1:13:52
Unidentified speaker: So we've got um what's called the Tim's Review looking at disability, and we've got the Milburn Review looking at uh young people who aren't in education or training, they're due to report uh later this month.
1:14:02
Unidentified speaker: I think that will be a moment for the Prime Minister and the Chancellor.
1:14:05
Unidentified speaker: Are they willing to talk to the Labour backbenchers and say we're gonna reform welfare, for example?
1:14:11
Unidentified speaker: And even if they think they've got a better system, which I presume they will, there'll be losers there.
1:14:14
Unidentified speaker: So are they willing to front up to that?
1:14:16
Unidentified speaker: Then you've got this 10-year plan that the government's talked about.
1:14:20
Unidentified speaker: I think that's gonna drop, they're we think that's gonna drop in like mid-December.
1:14:23
Unidentified speaker: That's slightly odd timing, if you ask me, because at that point you're basically competing with Santa.
1:14:27
Unidentified speaker: Everyone's happy, they want to go for their Christmas holidays, they want to get, you know, some rest, they're thinking about Christmas presents, and suddenly you drop them a 10-year plan.
1:14:35
Unidentified speaker: Um, uh, you know, you've got to, yeah, and you've put a lot of ambition on that.
1:14:38
Unidentified speaker: You've put a lot of, like, this is gonna be the moment where we tell you what our vision is.
1:14:42
Unidentified speaker: So they're really building that up.
1:14:43
Unidentified speaker: There'll be a real question of can that deliver the the answers to the kind of questions you're asking, like what is Andy Burnham's vision?
1:14:48
Unidentified speaker: Like, what is he gonna change radically that makes the UK look different in in 10 years' time?
1:14:52
Unidentified speaker: Like what, and and concretely, how are we gonna get from here uh to those sunny uplands?
1:14:56
Unidentified speaker: So I think that that'll be there'll be a few big moments this year before Christmas, um, and then the spending review next year will be a massive fiscal event if you believe the current numbers.
1:15:06
Unidentified speaker: Okay, well, thank you so much for your time, and we'll we'll look out for those and probably tap you up if you've if you've got any sleep around that.
1:15:12
Unidentified speaker: But yeah, weird, weird Merry Christmas.
1:15:15
Unidentified speaker: Here's a spare 10-year spending review, and then you're up for three days straight.
1:15:18
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, yeah.
1:15:20
Unidentified speaker: Well no, thank thank you so much for your time, and you'll get some sleep now, hopefully.
1:15:23
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, good.
1:15:24
Unidentified speaker: Thank you.
1:15:27
Unidentified speaker: This episode was sponsored by Take the Next Step, Invest.
1:15:31
Unidentified speaker: People often think that investing is only done by professionals, but it's something normal people can do, and consistently investing can transform lives over the long term.
1:15:39
Unidentified speaker: So if you have solid savings and money you don't need for the next five years, then think about it.
1:15:44
Unidentified speaker: Take the next step, invest.
1:15:49
Unidentified speaker: Normally, this is where we'd say this isn't financial advice, and it really isn't.
1:15:54
Unidentified speaker: But if you want to speak to a good financial advisor, then we might be able to help.
1:15:58
Unidentified speaker: We've partnered with a few advisors to offer a range of services from one-off flat fee guidance to ongoing advice.
1:16:03
Unidentified speaker: I'm actually using the guidance service to sort out my finances.
1:16:06
Unidentified speaker: If you'd like to understand your options, there's a link in the description where you can answer a few questions and then book a free call with my colleague Will so you can figure out what might be right for you.
1:16:15
Unidentified speaker: This episode was produced by Ruth Edwards, and it was filmed and edited by Ben and Jack at Flowspire.
1:16:21
Unidentified speaker: See you next week.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-GGUF:UD-Q4_K_XL. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.

More from Making Money

Making Money

⁠I Won the Lottery, Here's What Happened Next

Episode discussion: Matt Myles details lottery win, early spending mistakes, and lessons in wealth preservation

Speakers’ claims: Matt Myles recounts winning £1 million in 2014 and his subsequent financial journey, beginning with aggressive spending on travel and luxury goods. He discusses early investment attempts, including a Prudential annuity, property conversions, and a missed Bitcoin opportunity, which he now regrets. Myles highlights the erosion of returns in buy-to-let properties due to fees and interest rate hikes, leading to a shift toward capital preservation. The episode concludes with advice on tax-efficient pension strategies and the psychological challenges of maintaining wealth after a windfall.

Lottery winningsProperty investmentCryptocurrency
56 min2 assets19 claims to verify
Making Money

⁠Is the 4% Rule Too Cautious?

Episode discussion: Abraham Okusanya argues the 4% rule is too cautious and advocates for dynamic withdrawal strategies based on equity allocation and sequence risk.

Speakers’ claims: Abraham Okusanya, author of 'Beyond the 4% Rule', explains that the traditional 4% rule was derived from worst-case US historical scenarios and may be overly conservative for modern portfolios. He argues that higher equity allocations allow for higher initial withdrawal rates, such as 4.5% to 5%, and that the rule ignores critical factors like taxes and fee structures. Okusanya emphasizes 'sequence of returns risk' as the primary threat to retirement portfolios, suggesting dynamic adjustments rather than static rules. He also critiques the FIRE community's application of the 4% rule to shorter horizons and highlights behavioral risks like panic selling as major detractors from long-term wealth.

Retirement PlanningWithdrawal RatesSequence of Returns Risk
1h 16m3 assets25 claims to verify
All insights