Banks must prioritize revenue generation over speed and address structural compliance friction to leverage AI effectively
Summary
Ron Shevlin and Stacey Bryant argue that financial institutions should shift their primary AI metric from 'time to market' to 'time to revenue,' as delays in campaign launches directly result in lost income. Bryant identifies a structural conflict between marketing and compliance teams, estimating this friction costs the industry $5.5 billion annually due to manual review bottlenecks. Shevlin highlights implementation barriers including inaccessible qualitative data and insufficient AI authority, while citing a credit union case study that successfully automated campaigns using transactional triggers. The hosts also critique a recent ABA-commissioned survey on fraud trust, arguing it measures perception rather than actual performance, and emphasize that trust is multidimensional, requiring proof of protection rather than just personalized service.
Key takeaways
- 1 But the idea of the report was that no, it's you really want to be focused on time to revenue. How long does it take to actually generate revenue? Because I think one of the key findings in that report, Stacey, Stacy, was that I think a lot of marketing departments don't realize, especially in the bank and
Ron Shevlin · 4:55
- 2 But number one, we don't have access to the right data to do it, and that's IT's job to do. The second though is that a lot of the data that's needed to enable this isn't transactional data or financial data, it's qualitative data, it's policies.
Ron Shevlin · 12:15
Episode sections
- 0:15 – 3:58
Introduction and Upcoming Events
Stacey Bryant discusses her upcoming speaking engagement at the New York Bankers Association conference in Marco Island, Florida, focusing on AI experimentation and execution for 2027 initiatives. Ron Shevlin announces that the next episode will be recorded live in Nashville, Tennessee, marking the first time the hosts will be in the same room.
- 3:58 – 6:05
Shift from Time to Market to Time to Revenue
Ron Shevlin highlights a Cornerstone Advisors report arguing that financial institutions should prioritize 'time to revenue' over 'time to market.' He contends that delays in launching marketing campaigns result in lost revenue opportunities, a metric often overlooked by marketing departments focused solely on launch speed.
- 6:05 – 12:00
Structural Friction and the Cost of Compliance Bottlenecks
Stacey Bryant identifies the root cause of slow speed as a structural conflict between marketing and compliance, citing a $5.5 billion industry cost. She notes that simply adding compliance staff to marketing teams does not solve the bottleneck, as compliance capacity cannot scale linearly with the increased output generated by AI-enabled marketing teams.
- 12:00 – 22:05
Implementation Requirements and Credit Union Case Study
Ron Shevlin outlines three barriers to implementing AI agents: lack of access to the right data, qualitative data (like policies) being in the wrong format, and insufficient authority granted to AI tools. Stacey Bryant provides a case study of a $3 billion credit union in Michigan that implemented always-on campaigns triggered by transactional data without manual setup.
- 22:05 – 25:25
Critique of ABA Fraud Trust Survey
Ron Shevlin critiques a Morning Consult survey commissioned by the American Bankers Association, which found 44% of Americans trust banks most for fraud protection. He argues the survey is flawed because it only measures perceived trust rather than actual fraud prevention performance or relevance of advice, and notes low trust in government and fintech providers.
- 25:25 – 34:49
Multidimensional Nature of Customer Trust
The hosts discuss the complexity of customer trust. Stacey Bryant defines trust through dimensions like protection, fairness, dependability, and respect for control, rather than just personalization. Ron Shevlin agrees that trust is multidimensional and that financial institutions must understand how different consumer segments value these specific dimensions rather than relying on simplistic survey data.
Claims worth verifying
Ron Shevlin is the Chief Research Officer at Cornerstone Advisors.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·0:15
How to verify: Cornerstone Advisors website or LinkedIn profile of Ron Shevlin. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Stacey Bryant will speak at a New York Bankers Association event in Marco Island, Florida, about AI experimentation and execution for 2027 initiatives.
Stacey Bryant ·1:06
How to verify: New York Bankers Association event schedule or press releases from late 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The next podcast episode will be recorded live in Nashville, Tennessee.
Ron Shevlin ·2:43
How to verify: Podcast release notes or announcement for the episode following this one. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Financial institutions are losing revenue by taking six weeks to launch marketing campaigns instead of one week.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·5:32
How to verify: Cornerstone Advisors research report on 'AI Agents in Marketing' (referenced in transcript). For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The structural friction between marketing and compliance costs the industry $5.5 billion.
Stacey Bryant ·8:07
How to verify: Cornerstone Advisors research report section 'From Adversaries to Architects'. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
A $3 billion asset credit union in Michigan implemented always-on campaigns triggered by CD maturity, auto loan maturity, and attrition signals using HubSpot and predictive analytics.
Stacey Bryant ·17:11
How to verify: Cornerstone Advisors case study or press release from the specific credit union (unnamed in transcript) regarding their 2026/2026 tech implementations. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
A Morning Consult survey commissioned by the American Bankers Association found 44% of Americans trust banks most for fraud protection.
Ron Shevlin ·22:54
How to verify: Morning Consult report 'Trust in Fraud Protection' commissioned by ABA, published around November 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
In the ABA-commissioned survey, 8% of Americans selected the government, 6% non-bank fintech, 5% AI providers, and 1% cryptocurrency/telecom providers for fraud protection trust.
Ron Shevlin ·23:14
How to verify: Same Morning Consult/ABA survey data cited above. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceRon Shevlin published a book titled 'Smarter Bank' in January 2015.
Ron Shevlin ·13:14
How to verify: Book publication records or Amazon listing for 'Smarter Bank' by Ron Shevlin. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Stacey Bryant moderates panels on tokenized deposits, stablecoins, and C-suite talent at the New York Bankers Association event.
Stacey Bryant ·1:46
How to verify: New York Bankers Association event agenda for the Marco Island conference. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Review the Cornerstone Advisors report cited by Ron Shevlin regarding 'time to revenue' vs 'time to market' metrics to verify the financial impact analysis.
- Examine the specific methodology and full results of the Morning Consult survey commissioned by the American Bankers Association to assess potential bias in the 44% trust figure.
- Investigate the operational structure of marketing and compliance workflows at target institutions to identify the $5.5 billion friction cost claim's validity.
- Verify the technical capabilities of the Michigan credit union's HubSpot integration and predictive analytics stack to replicate the always-on campaign model.
- Analyze the qualitative data accessibility in target banks' policy documents to determine feasibility of AI agent implementation as described by Shevlin.
- Check for conflicts of interest in the Cornerstone Advisors report and the ABA-commissioned survey to ensure independence of the cited data.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:15
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hey
- 0:15
- Ron Shevlin: everybody, welcome back to another episode of What's Going On in Banking. I'm Ron Chevlin, Chief Research Officer at Cornerstone Advisors, here of course with my co-host Stacy Bryant. Stacy, what's going on?
- 0:27
- Stacey Bryant: How are you doing, Ron? I'm I'm listening I am living the dream. I uh I am in basketball mode right now. Just want to let you know, I know we touched on that a couple of weeks ago, but my girls are in AAU, and it has I uh it's anything I'm speaking about, it's basketball these days, particularly because the New York Knicks are up. We
- 0:46
- Stacey Bryant: smashed by 30 some odd points uh Chicago Bells. Bulls. So, you know what? I know you love when I speak about that. And and I am on Cloud9. Apart from being on that sports cloud nine, Ron, um, I'm gearing up to head down to, I believe it's Marco Island in Florida. Never been there before. But shout out to Claire Cusack.
- 1:06
- Stacey Bryant: She is a president and CEO over at the New York Bankers Association. And uh they invited me to speak about AI. And uh um, this time around, we're not we're going to go beyond the AI 101, but speak about experimentation and execution. What does that look like as folks are thinking about their 2027 initiative? So super
- 1:26
- Stacey Bryant: excited to have that conversation. Also, I'll be moderating two panels, so a trifecta of sorts. I'll be moderating a panel on um tokenized deposits and stablecoins. stable coins. Our guy, Peter Glyman, he's gonna be gonna be one of the panelists. So super excited to just hear about what's going on with him and
- 1:46
- Stacey Bryant: everything that he's doing. And then also another panel just really discussing uh what the C suite role and what talent looks like uh going forward, a few other uh what talent, what the future of talent looks like in banking, um, and what is actually keeping them up at night and so um i'm a geek and nerd
- 2:06
- Stacey Bryant: in what we do and i'm very very curious i uh i'm going to resurrect my biggie smalls from brooklyn new y'all mad question asking hat cannot wait to see if they entertain me or if they kick me the moderator off the stage but nonetheless um that's how I'm doing how are you doing
- 2:23
- Ron Shevlin: I'm doing great and uh so uh you've done an got exciting sketchy schedule coming up. I've got really exciting stuff too. Next week I'm gonna be mowing the lawn. And um, but but seriously, week after next, and uh we'll be pretty close to when people actually get to listen to this. Stacey, I am super psyched, and I want everybody who
- 2:43
- Ron Shevlin: subscribes to this podcast to know that after this one, the next episode you hear will have been recorded live. and in person in Nashville, Tennessee. Um, we are doing a live broadcast as a as a keynote presentation in a in a conference, which is really amazing. It's not like we're just sitting off on the side and doing this.
- 3:03
- Ron Shevlin: But you know, Stacy, this is I I hope you're getting really nervous for this because this will be that will be the first episode we do where we're actually going gonna to be in the same room at the same time. sitting at the same table doing this. So I am super excited for that. Really nervous doing it live,
- 3:21
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh,
- 3:21
- Ron Shevlin: or at least recording it live, I should say. Um, so maybe there'll be some editing. Maybe we'll need some editing after that. But uh really looking forward to that. And so um
- 3:31
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 3:31
- Ron Shevlin: don't know. Can't wait to see you in Nashville.
- 3:34
- Stacey Bryant: You know, I'm not nervous. Is that a bad thing? Uh should I be nervous?
- 3:38
- Ron Shevlin: Yeah, we need to talk. It's uh it's good to be nervous. Anyway, let's get into some topics because there's a couple of things that I I really wanted to talk to you about. Um, and I obviously some of it's kind of self-serving. We published a a re published a bunch of research lately. We've got to really cover some of this stuff. But one one in
- 3:58
- Ron Shevlin: particular I really wanted to kind of highlight for folks who are listening in because I I think there's some really important ideas in the report. Obviously, the whole topic of AI agents is huge. You can't um you know look at any website that has anything to do with banking or web uh or fintech without seeing millions of AI agents this and AI
- 4:18
- Ron Shevlin: agents that. And yes, we did a report on AI agents in in market in marketing. But for me, Stacy, the the importance of the report. wasn't about AI agents. It was about how speed
- 4:33
- Ron Shevlin: becomes such an important revenue driver and strategy for, and it's not just about marketing. And for me, the the real key message in that report was look, look, everyone's focused on has been focused in them, the especially in the marketing world, on time to market, right? How long does it take you to get a product into
- 4:53
- Ron Shevlin: market or a message into market?
- 4:55
- Ron Shevlin: But the idea of the report was that no, it's you really want to be focused on time to revenue. How long does it take to actually generate revenue? Because I think one of the key findings in that report, Stacey, Stacy, was that I think a lot of marketing departments don't realize, especially in the bank and
- 5:15
- Ron Shevlin: credit union world, don't realize that, yeah, okay, you know, you took three weeks to or maybe six weeks to get a campaign out the door, and then you start measuring the campaign performance, you know, based on response rate and conversion rate and all that kind of stuff.
- 5:32
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
- 5:32
- Ron Shevlin: what they're not realizing is that by not getting the campaign out the door in a week,
- 5:39
- Ron Shevlin: in six weeks, they've lost revenue. So they're looking at the wrong aspect and getting things into market. But how long does it take you to actually generate revenue? That and it's enabled by AI agents, but there's a business aspect to it. Uh, and that's why I thought the report was important, because of that
- 5:59
- Ron Shevlin: speed-to-revenue speed to revenue idea, not just speed to market. Your thoughts, what what what were you what was your takeaway?
- 6:05
- Stacey Bryant: Yeah, I think I told you earlier, uh, before we hit record here, uh this is my favorite research paper of the year. And I'll tell you uh I'll answer your question regarding speed, and that's the obvious premise of the research paper, Ron. But the one of the main reasons why I really enjoy this is because it it there's so much good material as far
- 6:25
- Stacey Bryant: as what's currently happening today. how are financial institutions level like how are these, particularly the marketing departments, what that process looks like today to start campaigns and what have you, and what's standing in the way. I really appreciate where we're also, you know, providing what that could potentially look like so that we, you know, we at
- 6:45
- Stacey Bryant: Cornerstone, we always pride ourselves in that like smarter bank. How to become that smarter bank, how to become that smarter crediting credit union through twenty. 2030. And so we really discuss breaking it down the root cause of speed and why speed isn't that metric. Um, I'm hearing, you know, I told you on the last episode um at the American Bankers Most Powerful Women Conference.
- 7:05
- Stacey Bryant: The one of the main themes, Ron, from these big financial institutions were agentic AI. And I'll be quite honest, while we a lot of the conversation was focused on governance, I didn't get any use cases. I didn't really understand or get what that looks like today. And what
- 7:25
- Stacey Bryant: are we breaking? How are we shifting from from different workflows? And again, if for all of our listeners and viewers, this is creme de la creme, especially as we gear up, as I mentioned a few minutes ago, into the planning of 2027 and what that's. going to look like. I really want to get to the root of speed. Again, we speak about speed and how the lack of
- 7:45
- Stacey Bryant: speed is really
- 7:47
- Stacey Bryant: taking a huge bite out of the out of how credit unions and community banks can really scale, can absorb market share, whatever it may be, growth, right? The growth is a component. But the root cause of the speed is this $5.5 billion beef. Okay. From new again, Ron, you know this, but for our listeners, I'm
- 8:07
- Stacey Bryant: originally a Brooklyn's Brooklyn, New York girl. All right. When you have beef with someone in New York City, you know what that is? There's a problem. All right. And so, and so you
- 8:17
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): got a
- 8:17
- Ron Shevlin: problem with me?
- 8:18
- Stacey Bryant: You got a problem with me. And the problem here is $5.5 billion. I took this out of the research paper and from the section from adversaries to architects. the friction is structural. Now we speak about how marketing and compliance they operate as adversaries today instead of partners, breaking it down to marketing creates
- 8:38
- Stacey Bryant: versus compliance reviews. Marketing revises versus compliance red lines again. Again, back to the friction being structural and how this, I mean, you laid it out. I I was going to question you on these metrics, but you laid it out. where you produce where the the friction produces a six exchange um five hour per five hour
- 8:58
- Stacey Bryant: per message dynamic six week rather six week exchange five hour per message dynamic that cost the industry 5.5 billion in essence what does that mean what are we getting to you know there's a um a financial institution not named here but there's a financial institution that believes that if we that they're particularly
- 9:17
- Stacey Bryant: hiring, if we add a compliance person, a compliance team member to be part of the marketing team, specifically building these marketing campaigns from the very beginning, it will reduce the amount it takes for us, and I speak us as a collective, it will reduce the the amount of
- 9:37
- Stacey Bryant: um time that it takes. for us to really capture um that that share, that that market share, that that customer. Again, let's look let's get down to the nitty-gritty. What does that mean in layman's terms? Let's set up a comment, uh, you know, let's set something up here. And I mentioned this example a little while ago. But if I'm a member of ABC Bank and I'm using
- 9:57
- Stacey Bryant: my debit card constantly to go to Home Depot, to go to Lowe's, they There's a lot of home construction supply purchases. You know, wouldn't that be an ideal time to run some sort of campaign quickly to call my attention of, hey, this may be a particular home equity line of credit or
- 10:17
- Stacey Bryant: home equity perspective loan of sorts. This is one out of many scenarios. And so how beautiful would it be if someone, if they're seeing these purchases. you know, in the past week or the weekend, it would be amazing to see that populate in my email from my very own financial institution. What does this mean? Stickiness,
- 10:36
- Stacey Bryant: retention, differentiation. And so again, uh, contesting to the brilliance of this paper because it really lays out a plan of what everyone's trying to attack for 27 and beyond. Thoughts?
- 10:50
- Ron Shevlin: Well, I'm glad you liked it. That's always a a good sign. I'm I'm happy to see that. Um there's a couple of things that that I I I got kind of got struck with in when we when we were writing this. Is first of all, you know, if you go back 40 years, and and I know no one wants to hear this thing, okay, Boomer, tell us about 40 years
- 11:10
- Ron Shevlin: ago.
- 11:11
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um you
- 11:12
- Ron Shevlin: know, it's not even quite 40 at this point. really 35-ish years ago. The hot management topic of the day was business process reengineering. Re-engineering. And that was a result of really the adoption of personal computers and microcomputing, the move from mainframes down to microcomputing. And as that
- 11:32
- Ron Shevlin: happened, smart people started saying, hey, we should be really rethinking the business process. processes here in terms of how they can adapt to this new um computing paradigm.
- 11:45
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 11:45
- Ron Shevlin: so they said, hey, you know, it takes us six weeks to do this process. We could use PCs and get that down to three weeks, which was a huge, huge impact.
- 11:55
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
- 11:55
- Ron Shevlin: we're at a point in time, Stacy, where the technology around AI and AI agents in particular means taking those processes from three weeks down to literally three minutes. But there's a bunch of things that are stopping institutions from being able to do that. The
- 12:15
- Ron Shevlin: technology is available. The technology is here to do it. But number one, we don't have access to the right data to do it, and that's IT's job to do. The second though is that a lot of the data that's needed to enable this isn't transactional data or financial data, it's qualitative data,
- 12:34
- Ron Shevlin: it's policies. How does this thing work? What's the right who's the right? No, we don't want to bring who's the right person because that's the human in the loop. That's a big fallacy. But the it's the data is in the wrong format, and then number three is we're not giving the tools. and the software the authority to make the relevant decisions.
- 12:54
- Ron Shevlin: But we're sitting at a point in time where, you know, we talk a lot, and this is going to get me in a lot of trouble with uh with my boss and and his peers. But you know, we've been adopting at Cornerstone the whole smarter bank mantra, and that came from a book I published close to 12 years now. It's January 2015 when that came.
- 13:14
- Ron Shevlin: up, and we're a hell of a lot closer to January 2027 than we are 2026. And you know, if I were to write another book now, it wouldn't be called Smarter Bank, it'd be called Faster Bank. And the idea that that the uh what we're trying to attain is a smarter bank, I I think we've
- 13:34
- Ron Shevlin: passed that. Stacy, I think it's it's the new
- 13:38
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): goal.
- 13:39
- Ron Shevlin: is fastest bank. Faster for sure, fastest bank.
- 13:44
- Stacey Bryant: Right, right. A few things, a few thoughts that came up to mind. You know, and I said it at the top of this call, I mentioned it. I think I mentioned this at almost every recording of ours. But I am obsessed, obsessed, Ron, with what the future workforce looks like. in
- 14:03
- Stacey Bryant: banking. And so I'm I'm really, and I'm thinking now about our annual what's going on in banking report that we release every January, where we survey hundreds of community bank and credit union leaders, speak about what's keeping them up at night, how are they doing it, what's their appetite, risk appetite here and there, and so on and so forth.
- 14:23
- Stacey Bryant: And it makes me think I'm sure that we're in the work. workings of this. I mean, again, we're recording this in early November, but I'm so curious if you, if we can, can I ask you to make an exception and add this as a as a question in this report? I want to hear from all the financial institutions participating. What does
- 14:43
- Stacey Bryant: not only the future work for for force, us, but let's think about the org chart and not about who does what, but which organs
- 14:50
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): are the same.
- 14:50
- Stacey Bryant: who within your org chart collaborates heavily with one another. I want to know that collaboration because it comes down to this. I really, I guess to the to to you know, to the root of it is I would love to understand and identify real data with who which financial institutions um
- 15:10
- Stacey Bryant: really work hand in hand on a regular basis with. their marketing and compliance teams. Because again, you speak about speed and how to be that smarter financial institution. And when we think about the future of banking and the new plumbing of banking, it's going to be the new plumbing of the workforce and which department heads will
- 15:30
- Stacey Bryant: need to rely and depend on one another for the common goal for growth. So that's that's one remark that I wanted to say. And then I also, you speak. we spoke about this before when we were chatting about MetaMuse and how now these personal AI agents of sorts, you know, are being used by a good amount of folks and I don't know what that number is when I say good
- 15:50
- Stacey Bryant: amount of folks and being very liberal here. But again, hey, I'm Stacy. I'm in this particular area of the United States. I have about, you know, $75,000 I want to go ahead and invest to Tell me who has the best rate. I don't want to go to NerdWallet. I want GPT, one of the LLMs, or even in this case, one of my agents, to
- 16:10
- Stacey Bryant: take care of this. And so I say I bring this up because I'm in the middle of working with a lot of financial institutions, or handful rather, where again, they they're speaking about growth and how to stay relevant in their market, obviously how to go ahead and capture the younger audience. They're thinking about how they can be one of
- 16:30
- Stacey Bryant: the folks that come up on a search, whether it's from agents or whether it's on a large language model. And, you know, again, back to this research paper where we speak about journey orchestration. I wanted to really quick point out, and I have it on here, but just for the for the sake of our viewers here, uh, bear with me.
- 16:51
- Stacey Bryant: So I want to give an example that was stated here. So after an eight-month implementation project connecting a predictive analytics platform to core transactional data and HubSpot, a 3 billion asset credit union in Michigan now runs three to four always-on, always on campaigns triggered by CD C D maturity, auto
- 17:11
- Stacey Bryant: loan maturity, and attrition signals without manual list pulls or campaign. setup for each send. So I'm talking while I'm speaking about two different things, how can a financial institution come up and have all the buzzwords and all the offerings for that particular person that's mandating their agent? Number one, that differentiation.
- 17:30
- Stacey Bryant: While um while a lot of folks are also using agentic, a lot of financial institutions can use agentic AI to go ahead and use it as a marketing um campaign of sorts to capture these particular members. So again, we're thinking about exit we're speaking about existing members and we're speaking about prospective new members in
- 17:50
- Stacey Bryant: this case. And so I I think that right now uh we speak about the cleanliness of data. We're speaking about getting um making sure that your infrastructure and a financial institution can integrate, you know. you have that smart infrastructure. So I I'm now that I'm speak thinking out loud here, while I may seem a little
- 18:10
- Stacey Bryant: all over the place, I really want this focus to be for our community bank listeners and credit listeners. We're talking a $3 billion financial institution. This is doable. And so so often I hear, well, we're not JP Morgan, you know, we don't we're not these big banks. Like, how are we possibly going to do this? And this is where we think about whether it's
- 18:30
- Stacey Bryant: fintech collaboration. Like, there are solutions when we think about how can we um uh you know prevent churn and how can we uh grow the market. So I just wanted to call that out because it's so, so important that it's doable. And I guess my last comment here, Ron, would be
- 18:50
- Stacey Bryant: a little biased. I get the opportunity to be on the road and to go to conferences and speak about AI in different in different phases of sorts. And I still hear, I complained about this last year, but I still hear from certain, respectfully, guys, don't kill me, from certain older leaders that, you know, they don't know,
- 19:10
- Stacey Bryant: again, they're not these large financial institutions with these big budgets, and they're c they're uh just. discounting the potential of their own financial institution to reach these new heights. And so again, I guess I'm like really, really trying to kind of like break it into it is doable and this is how it could be done.
- 19:28
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay,
- 19:28
- Ron Shevlin: I'm trying to figure out w what's what's the best way a couple of responses. Uh one, I want to address your your comments about the sort of the cross cross-functional functional aspect
- 19:38
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
- 19:39
- Ron Shevlin: to the issue and the problem and marketing and compliance. You know, one of the things that cut came out of the research that we did was that it isn't simply about putting a compliance person in with marketing, Stacey, because the reality is that compliance The department has its
- 19:58
- Ron Shevlin: limitations in terms of the number of people it can have. And so if it says, okay, great, you market marketing, you have here's Stacey, she's a dedicated compliance person. But the AI tools, and it's really not necessarily AI agents, but just generative AI, is giving marketing the capability of creating, well, I'll just put a number on it,
- 20:18
- Ron Shevlin: twice as much content as it has in the past. But if the if the compliance constraint
- 20:27
- Ron Shevlin: uh or resource availability does not grow with that, you you've created a situation in which marketing is developing or you know turning out twice as much output and hitting a bottleneck in compliance. And it doesn't matter if there's a dedicated person or two dedicated people. People have
- 20:47
- Ron Shevlin: resource constraints. We we have we we
- 20:52
- Ron Shevlin: We have capacity that we can only handle X amount of work. And reality is, is that if you double the number of campaigns and content that marketing is developing, you can't expect compliance to double its resources to meet that, which is why the importance
- 21:12
- Ron Shevlin: of the AI agents becomes important.
- 21:15
- Ron Shevlin: because effectively there's not a lot of for for all practical purposes there's not a lot of resource constraint or capacity issues with that you just keep throwing more and more stuff at those agents and man they're handling it just as almost as fast as you can throw it out them. So the the problem we get with a lot
- 21:35
- Ron Shevlin: of of technology development in banks and credit unions is the technology development happens within certain functional areas. Oh, there's the marketing tech stack, there's the finance and accounting, there's the operation, here we got branch. But once you start crossing organizational departmental lines,
- 21:57
- Ron Shevlin: it It it it's nothing's addressing that. And that's the opportunity with the with the agents. I also wanted to um
- 22:04
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): well
- 22:05
- Ron Shevlin: all right, I'll let it go. I was gonna I said I thought I had a comment about your uh older um
- 22:09
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): your
- 22:10
- Ron Shevlin: your the older folks and their pushback, but um all right.
- 22:14
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 22:14
- Ron Shevlin: think we may have beaten this one to death a little bit. Uh we got a few more minutes um before we our our self imposed time limits on on these uh episodes. But I wanted to um I wanted to bring up another topic uh research um thing, not our research that we did, but uh saw recently that uh a survey conducted by Morning
- 22:34
- Ron Shevlin: Consult, a very well respected research firm, um, was commissioned by the American Bankers Association. So credit unions don't get mad, that's really not about the bankers uh per se. Uh but they found they were looking at fraud efforts and fraud protections. protection. And the big headline of the study was
- 22:54
- Ron Shevlin: that it found that almost half, about forty-four percent of Americans, trusted banks most to protect them from fraud, compared to just eight percent who selected the government, six percent who chose non-bank fintech Tech providers, five 5% percent who picked AI providers, and one one 1% percent who
- 23:14
- Ron Shevlin: who uh selected cryptocurrency companies, saying that uh and to and telecommunication providers, and about three out of 10 said they didn't know or had no opinion. So, first of a couple of thoughts on this one, Stacy. First of all, I can't imagine that only 44% percent of Americans
- 23:34
- Ron Shevlin: said banks and really financial institutions. The eight percent who said the government are definitely smoking something that we don't smoke. The six percent who chose non bank fintech providers clearly did not understand the question. And the one percent who picked cryptocurrency and telecommunication providers were clearly not even paying
- 23:54
- Ron Shevlin: attention and just clicking off anything in that survey. And the twenty nine percent who said they didn't know or had no opinion, God bless them they told the truth. Um so I got some more thoughts on it, but before I delve into all of that, what was your take uh on hearing this? Well,
- 24:08
- Stacey Bryant: before I give you my take, Ron, I want to you uh let's go back. You you're saying what I heard was some these survey respondents are not really answering the the question ahead. And I just want to make sure I'm on the same page.
- 24:21
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): No,
- 24:21
- Ron Shevlin: no, no, no. I'm I'm making fun of the fifty s well, the the people who who said that the government was doing the most to protect them from fraud, or that fintechs were doing the most to protect them from fraud, or those who thought cryptocurrency providers were doing the most to prevent them from fraud. I'm just
- 24:41
- Ron Shevlin: making fun of them because I'm like, no, there's no way. Um
- 24:45
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I mean
- 24:45
- Ron Shevlin: I think it's a given. I couldn't believe that not a hundred percent
- 24:50
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): didn't
- 24:50
- Ron Shevlin: say. banks.
- 24:51
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 24:51
- Stacey Bryant: so let me ask you a question. You you you may you always mention, you mentioned it early, like, you know, forty years ago with mainframe. I mean, you've been around the block to know I you you also have um you're very privy to, you know, what banking looks like from a bank's perspective, what that looks like now uh nowadays with the government government
- 25:11
- Stacey Bryant: reliance and fintechs. What does customer trust me? You are a customer somewhere, or in a lot of places, what does trust mean for you today
- 25:21
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in
- 25:21
- Stacey Bryant: the in the realm of hanging as a consumer?
- 25:25
- Ron Shevlin: So I'm glad you brought this up because it's it's kind of where I wanted to go with this conversation.
- 25:30
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): A
- 25:31
- Ron Shevlin: couple of reason I I thought that this was worthy enough for us to bring up is that I I think the importance of this goes well beyond. just the headlines of this survey. Because number one, it was commissioned by the American Banking Association. So sure, they're gonna they're going to harp on the fact that banks were the number one most
- 25:51
- Ron Shevlin: selected provider hoping to protect consumers from fraud. But what it didn't do
- 25:59
- Ron Shevlin: ask people how well a job are the banks doing? How well are the fintechs and cryptocurrency providers and how well is the government doing? And I think the reality so here's the ABA and boy am I gonna okay, this is not gonna make them happy, right? But screw them. Hey, um they're not
- 26:18
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): gonna be.
- 26:21
- Stacey Bryant: It's just a conversation. Go ahead.
- 26:24
- Ron Shevlin: They're not pr they're not supporting this. um podcast. As a matter of fact, nobody externally other than Cornerstone support supports this. So we can talk told truth about anything we want around here, Bryant. So the American Bankers Association, of course, is gonna beat their chest. Well, look, banks, you know, are most uh doing the most.
- 26:44
- Ron Shevlin: But Well, reality is is few, if any, are doing a good job at providing.
- 26:51
- Ron Shevlin: uh better protection uh from fraud. And that wasn't asked in the survey. So that was one of my one beef. And then the second is so what's gonna happen? Banks are gonna you know take this stuff and then take these stats and go out and beat their chest. Oh, look what a great job we're doing. We were voted most. It's like
- 27:11
- Ron Shevlin: wrong conclusion. This is this is not. building trust with consumers. The trust comes from
- 27:21
- Ron Shevlin: bottom line impact, whether it's we say we Stacy, imagine your bank coming to you at the in next month in December and saying, Stacy, here are the thirty-three 33 fraudulent attempts that we prevented this year.
- 27:39
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 27:39
- Ron Shevlin: you'd be like, oh my gosh, this is amazing. Thank you, thank you, thank you. And you would feel a level of trust that you don't have with anybody else. And now, here's the other aspect to this I wanted to bring up. So let's say your bank did that.
- 27:57
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 27:57
- Ron Shevlin: And you said, Well, that's great. Hey, but hey bank, here are the 17 seventeen irrevolutions. irrelevant offers you pitched at me this year wanting me to refinance my home and I live in an apartment, or get home equity and I live in an apartment, or get a credit card that's nowhere near as good as the six I
- 28:17
- Ron Shevlin: already have, and you'd say, Well, okay, you're doing a great job at pretent you know protecting me from fraud, but you're doing a horrible job at helping me better manage my financial life and there's a or being relevant in terms of advice. So that's an aspect of trust too.
- 28:37
- Ron Shevlin: So the problem with this whole world is that we we rely too much on a simplistic view of what trust is, and it's so multidimensional. And that's that's kind of where I wanted to go with this. Is
- 28:54
- Stacey Bryant: all right. I got a little beef with you. Okay. Since that's the conversation the the the word of the episode. So you so you're talking about what I'm hearing is, Ron, that personalization is part of trust. Whereas I believe while personalization is very important and it and it
- 29:14
- Stacey Bryant: perhaps can be thrown into the pot of trust stew. Again, I I asked, I asked, okay, what does trust look like for you or to you, particularly as a banking customer or a banking member? I could tell you, protect me. I want you to protect me. You know, notice when something doesn't really look right.
- 29:34
- Stacey Bryant: Um, I want you to treat me fairly. You know, don't make your profit, your profits. depend. Um, I guess what I'm trying to say is like don't don't do
- 29:44
- Ron Shevlin: what's right for me,
- 29:45
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): not just what's right for you.
- 29:46
- Stacey Bryant: Thank you. Be dependable. I want to be able to access my money at any time. Um, respect my control. My information is not permission to anything you anything you do that you want to do, which again can come, can kind of tie into personalization, but let's just stay with. me here. And then lastly, you know, take responsibility. Don't make me
- 30:06
- Stacey Bryant: manage uh your departments when I have a problem. And so when we I think what I would have really appreciated from this from this ABA commission survey was okay, you have X amount of people that trust banks. Now I want to hear from them same respondents, what is trust for you? If you trust these banks, and
- 30:26
- Stacey Bryant: then I probably wouldn't would have wanted to hear the same for all the other respondents for the all the other categories for government and so on and so forth. And so I really I again I'm I'm pushing back because while personalization is very important and it and it gears up to how well do you know me, I can see why you're saying that, but we're talking two
- 30:46
- Stacey Bryant: different values here, very important values, but two different values. I think. we can't, uh I think the word you use you usually use is convolute. Like we can't two separate things here. So reactions.
- 30:58
- Ron Shevlin: Well, my first reaction is that believe it or not, I don't think we're disagreeing. I actually think we're agreeing because you've done a couple things here. Number one, you you've established what some of the other dimensions of trust are. And and I'm not even I don't even want to pollute it with like terms like personalization.
- 31:19
- Ron Shevlin: It's look, it's a multidimensional thing, and you identified some really good dimensions there, but you also brought up the other really important point, which listen, I know people love when we disagree, but man, I I am a hundred percent on board with
- 31:32
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): this.
- 31:33
- Ron Shevlin: We there different people place different levels of value on each of those three. dimensions of trust. You may be a whole lot more worried about fraud and stuff than some of the other
- 31:47
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 31:48
- Ron Shevlin: types or dimensions of trust. Um and I might care more about something else. And this is the problem. We we
- 31:58
- Ron Shevlin: we convo what was the word convoluted? Well not that not the right word, but we you
- 32:02
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know we
- 32:02
- Ron Shevlin: We mix it all into one big pot and it's just not the way the world works. And
- 32:07
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
- 32:07
- Ron Shevlin: we're reacting to these
- 32:10
- Ron Shevlin: simplistic surveys
- 32:12
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of
- 32:12
- Ron Shevlin: consumers without doing the work we need to really understand A, what are the dimensions of trust? And B, how do different segments of consumers value each of those dimensions? And you know, nothing drives me by the way, um our colleague Brandy Gregory and I
- 32:32
- Ron Shevlin: will be doing a webinar. I did not mean to do like a whole commercial for this, but we're gonna be doing a webinar next month on this uh thing about trust. So to me, this is just me working out some of the thoughts ahead of time on this. But um anyway, okay, I'll stop my my rant here and and uh
- 32:50
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): throw.
- 32:50
- Ron Shevlin: it back to you and let you decide. Do we go more on this or are we ready to wrap this one up?
- 32:55
- Stacey Bryant: No, I I think I think it's safe to say that the type of beef that we have is not the chuck steak, you know, it's the filet mignon medium rare. You know what I mean? It's it's that's the beef that we have. And I I think in essence, going back to that quick ABA article, my very last comment is uh it it's it's funny when you really understand the surveys. these
- 33:14
- Stacey Bryant: surveys, the immediate question as you're reading more and more surveys to prove whatever you want to prove or to argue whatever you want to argue, first thing that comes up in my mind was who who were the respondents? How many were the how many respondents were there? Where are these respondents? Because that plays a part. We think about uh as far as who,
- 33:34
- Stacey Bryant: where, the socioeconomic of it, and so on and so forth. And so to our listeners. who use a lot of survey data for their strategic planning for to support any strategic initiatives, I know you know this is common sense, but I've the I've I've learned that common sense perhaps is not that common, Ron. And so uh make sure that we always vet that um
- 33:54
- Stacey Bryant: because it helps tell a story and it's very and it's very important, especially when we're using members' money and stakeholders' money. So that's it. Apart from that, I think. we're ready to rock and roll. And I cannot wait to rock and roll with you at the honky tonks in Nashville. Look at us.
- 34:11
- Ron Shevlin: All right. Listen, you um good luck with your conferences the next couple of weeks. Safe travels, and I will see you in Nashville. And for everybody else, thank you for joining us. And I hope we'll see you at another episode of What's Going On in Banking.
- 34:25
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): If
- 34:25
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): you enjoyed today's episode, of What's Going On in Banking, make sure you hit that follow button and subscribe wherever you listen, whether it's Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or YouTube. We've got more witty, gritty conversations coming your way, and you won't want to miss them. Stay tuned.