Property Magic Podcast

Property Magic Podcast: How to Shield Your Property from Rogue Renters

15 min Listen to the original
UK PropertyLandlord InsuranceTenant VettingLegal CostsHMO Investing

Summary

Simon Zucchi recounts a case study of a Bolton HMO tenant who caused significant legal and financial distress despite being a struck-off solicitor. The tenant exploited administrative errors in Section 21 notices and filed frivolous claims, leading to prolonged eviction proceedings. Zucchi highlights that legal costs can exceed annual profits, emphasizing the need for robust preventative measures. He recommends implementing strict due diligence, including online searches for tenant backgrounds. Additionally, he advocates for rental guarantee and landlord insurance to protect cash flow and cover legal fees during disputes.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    Rental guarantee insurance can kick in after 30 days of non-payment, covering rent and legal/bailiff costs for eviction under Section 8.

    Simon Zucchi · 10:42

Episode sections

  1. 0:01 – 1:02

    Introduction and Case Background

    Simon Zucchi introduces a cautionary tale about a litigious tenant in a Bolton HMO. He notes that while most tenants are good, bad tenants can be emotionally draining and expensive, necessitating protective measures.

  2. 1:02 – 3:03

    The Dispute and Failed Section 21

    A tenant moved in July 2024 and caused antisocial behavior. A Section 21 notice issued in February 2025 was invalidated due to a minor administrative error, allowing the tenant to remain.

  3. 3:03 – 5:45

    Council Complaints and PRS Claim

    The tenant complained to Housing Standards in July 2025, but the council found the property compliant. The tenant then claimed £10,000 compensation via the Property Redress Scheme, which was dismissed.

  4. 5:45 – 9:14

    Legal Battle and Eviction

    After hiring a solicitor, a valid Section 21 was issued. The tenant, a struck-off solicitor with mental health challenges, appealed. The landlord won possession in February 2026, but the tenant was ordered to pay £8,000 in costs despite having no money.

  5. 9:14 – 14:34

    Preventative Measures: Due Diligence and Insurance

    Zucchi advises Google searching tenants, especially those with unusual names, to check for red flags. He now requires rental guarantee and landlord insurance for all new tenancies to protect cash flow and cover legal fees.

Claims worth verifying

The Bolton HMO property generates approximately £2,600 to £2,700 in total monthly rent with a profit of about £1,000 per month.

Simon Zucchi ·12:39

How to verify: Verify by checking the landlord's self-reported financials or tax filings for the specific property if available; otherwise, treat as anecdotal claim. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Legal costs for the eviction of the Bolton tenant reached approximately £12,000.

Simon Zucchi ·12:59

How to verify: Check court records for the case or request invoices from the solicitor/barrister involved. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The tenant was a struck-off solicitor who was fined £25,000 in May 2025 for wasting court time.

Simon Zucchi ·8:34

How to verify: Search the Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) register for the tenant's name and check UK court judgments for the May 2025 fine. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The tenant claimed £10,000 compensation from the Property Redress Scheme (PRS), which was thrown out.

Simon Zucchi ·4:54

How to verify: Contact the Property Redress Scheme to verify if a complaint was made and its outcome, though specific case details may be private. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Section 21 notices were available in February 2025 but are not available now (as of the podcast release in Nov 2026).

Simon Zucchi ·3:03

How to verify: Check UK government legislation on Section 21 evictions and the Renters (Reform) Act timeline. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The tenant was ordered to pay £8,000 in costs and fines after losing an appeal.

Simon Zucchi ·8:04

How to verify: Search UK court judgments for the case name and date (post-Feb 2026) to confirm the cost order. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Rental guarantee insurance paid the rent and legal costs for a tenant in Bromley who stopped paying after February 2026.

Simon Zucchi ·10:42

How to verify: Review the insurance policy terms and claim history with the specific provider mentioned in show notes (not in transcript). For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The Bolton property is a licensed HMO that met all housing standards upon inspection by Housing Standards.

Simon Zucchi ·4:03

How to verify: Check Bolton Council's HMO license register for the property address. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The tenant used AI to find incorrect case law in a May 2025 court appeal.

Simon Zucchi ·8:34

How to verify: Review the judgment from the May 2025 court hearing for the tenant's struck-off status appeal. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The tenant was struck off for lying to courts and not having the right insurance.

Simon Zucchi ·7:15

How to verify: Search the Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) disciplinary records for the tenant's name. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify the current validity of Section 21 notice requirements under the Renters (Reform) Bill or current UK law.
  • Check the terms and conditions of rental guarantee policies, specifically regarding exclusions for tenants with prior legal disputes or mental health issues.
  • Research the Property Redress Scheme's jurisdiction and whether it applies to the specific type of tenancy agreement in question.
  • Review court records or public fines for the struck-off solicitor mentioned to verify the £25,000 penalty and AI case law incident.
  • Calculate the break-even point for landlord insurance premiums versus potential legal defense costs for HMO properties.
  • Investigate the definition of 'minor administrative error' in Section 21 notices to understand common pitfalls.
  • Assess the financial impact of prolonged eviction proceedings on cash flow using historical data from similar cases.
  • Confirm the current average legal fees for possession orders in the Bolton area to validate the £12,000 cost estimate.
Full transcriptexpand
0:01
Simon Zucchi: Welcome to the Property Magic Podcast. My name is Simon Zucchi, and in this podcast, I'm going to deep dive into the property investing strategies and investor mindset for my book Property Magic. I will also share real estate investing hints, tips, and tricks, which I normally only share on my property mastermind
0:21
Simon Zucchi: mentorship.
0:22
Simon Zucchi: Hello and welcome to this week's episode of the Property Magic Podcast. in which I want to give you a cautionary tale and tell you about a really bad experience I've had with I'm still having with a bad tenant, and more importantly, how you can protect yourself to make sure you don't have bad experiences like the one I'm going through at the moment. Now, obviously, property investing can be
0:42
Simon Zucchi: amazing. I just want to say the vast majority of tenants are fantastic, they pay the rent on time, they look after the property, they just want somewhere decent to live. But if you have enough properties, occasionally you will unfortunately come across a bad tenant. And it can be emotionally draining, it can be very expensive, but there are things you can do to protect yourself, which I'll mention towards the
1:02
Simon Zucchi: end of this podcast. So let me give you a little bit of background and history to understand this situation. So one of my properties, one of my HMOs, is a property up in Bolton. I have a past masterminder. who has a letting agency up there. Um, confidence property who are really good. They look after it, do a fantastic job for me, which is
1:21
Simon Zucchi: awesome. And um
1:24
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
1:24
Simon Zucchi: to give you a bit of background here, it's a a working
1:27
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
1:28
Simon Zucchi: HMO, it's not a high end professional HMO. The rent's about £500 per month. Um, it's not all full on suited. There are, I think it's one on suite room and a couple of people share a bathroom, etc. So it's not a high-end HMO, but it works for the people who live
1:43
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): there. Now
1:45
Simon Zucchi: I had a tenant move in in July 2024, and they moved in, all reference checking was done, no problem at all. Then in February 2025, so after their six-month contract, um, the tenants had been complaining about this. person who was a little bit
2:04
Simon Zucchi: antisocial, didn't really understand the um the ways of living in a shared house. So you would take over the kitchen when he was in the kitchen, and he was in a shared bathroom. Now, the bathroom has an over shower overbathed shower, and as you know, if you go to a hotel, you often have a curtain that So it needs to sit inside the shower to stop the
2:24
Simon Zucchi: water from the shower going on the floor, makes it all go into the bath. And this person just repeatedly would not bother to do that, and so water would flood onto the floor whenever he'd have a shower, and of course it would then work its way through and drip down into the room below. And the room below would complain, they knew it's only happened when he was in the shower, he just didn't quite get it or didn't quite care.
2:44
Simon Zucchi: They complained. And so the letting agents put in a antisocial behaviour letter to him advising him, look, you need to adhere to the house rules and be a better housemate, or unfortunately, we're gonna have to get you to come out of the property. Unfortunately, he didn't take heeding of that warning, and there's a very good reason why, which I'll explain later. Um, so they
3:03
Simon Zucchi: issued a section twenty-one. Now, back then, obviously, we could use section twenty-one's uh they are not available now, but back then in twenty 2025 twenty five we could do that. Uh unfortunately. they made one small mistake on the application, and so the section 21 was thrown out. It wasn't valid.
3:23
Simon Zucchi: So, interestingly, in the July of 2025, this particular tenant decided to write to the council to say that this property was not suitable as an HMO. They said there were various things wrong with it, and it wasn't suitable. And they complained to housing standards, which is kind of strange when you think about it. Strange behavior, because
3:43
Simon Zucchi: if housing standards decided the property wasn't suitable, then all the tenants would have to get out of the property because it couldn't be an HMO anymore. So he would have made himself homeless. Very strange behavior. Didn't quite work this out. Didn't know why at the time, but it became apparent later on.
3:58
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
3:58
Simon Zucchi: anyway, myself and the SEA, we got a call
4:01
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): from
4:01
Simon Zucchi: Housing Standards. We were very surprised by this.
4:03
Simon Zucchi: When we knew who the tenant was, we thought, oh, okay, yeah, he's a bit of a trouble tenant. Maybe he's just trying to cause a bit of uh disruption here. So the council went and inspected, came back and said, Yeah, no problem at all. They made one or two suggestions, but yeah, absolutely fine. Wasn't in breach of the HMO license, and obviously had been previously inspected for an HMO license in the first place, met all the minimum size uh
4:23
Simon Zucchi: requirements, etc. Uh and in fact, we had have applied for a new license. in August 2025, which was fully granted. So the property meets all the standards up to spec, no problem at
4:33
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): all.
4:34
Simon Zucchi: The tenant, who obviously didn't get anywhere with the council, decides to then take the letting agent to the property redress scheme and claims £10,000 compensation for living in these terrible living living conditions. Now, of course, £10,000. was actually more than this person had paid in rental income
4:54
Simon Zucchi: during the time they had been there. And also there were all this inconvenience and uh and he said there was a really bad atmosphere in the house, and he didn't really realise that he was actually the one causing this bad atmosphere.
5:07
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
5:07
Simon Zucchi: anyway, um it went to I the PRS, the PRS threw it out and said, No, this is what we're talking about, it's a waste of time. And then this tenant decided to issue a money claim against me for £10,000 of compensation for the same reasons because it was a substandard property and all these things were apparently wrong with it. So I had the uh emotional um
5:27
Simon Zucchi: uh pain and time um vacuum of responding to this, replying to this, and eventually it went to court and it was thrown out of court because the HMO is fully licensed, meets all the standards. But it's still it was just a real drain on my energy to have to deal with this. Um
5:45
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): so
5:45
Simon Zucchi: we decide in August, you know, we really need to get rid of this guy. So I go to a solicitor rather than get the letting agents do it themselves, go to a solicitor, and um they then do the section 21. And uh the obviously tenant, we we finally get to court. in February 2026. It's been dragging
6:05
Simon Zucchi: on for a long time. And for quite a long time, the tenant was actually paying the rent. He's not paying the rent now. He stopped about six months ago paying rent, but he is was paying at the time. And uh the judge and he was saying, Oh, this is retaliation, section twenty-one, which obviously you can't do. And it wasn't retaliation because we'd already issued a section twenty-one prior to him
6:25
Simon Zucchi: complaining to the council.
6:27
Simon Zucchi: And then um
6:28
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): so
6:29
Simon Zucchi: we were granted possession, we won. Uh he was claiming he wasn't served certain papers and things, but it was all done on uh digital systems, so he had to have seen the papers before he actually signed. So the judge realized that and we were granted possession and he had to pay I think five hundred pounds of fees. And now the fees actually were thousands and thousands of pounds, and there's a way for
6:49
Simon Zucchi: you to avoid this, which I'll share with you. later on. So
6:53
Simon Zucchi: um
6:54
Simon Zucchi: this gentleman who we then subsequently found out used to be a lawyer. I say used to be because he was struck off. He was struck off for lying to the courts, he was struck off for not having the right insurance in place, um, and he unfortunately has some mental challenges. Um he's delusional.
7:15
Simon Zucchi: Uh he's sent all sorts of emails about me and and other people, my solicitors. He seems to think that we bribed the judge in order to get the section twenty one uh come in our favour, and he actually s admitted in an email that he'd sent that I was copying in on that he's actually unfortunately um
7:32
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
7:33
Simon Zucchi: schizophrenic.
7:33
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
7:34
Simon Zucchi: And um this will make you laugh. He uh had a law practice in the UK. He left that your practice went back to India because he was under the illusion that he'd been asked to go back to be the deputy prime minister of India. Uh it's quite funny really when you think about it, and actually this guy kinda needs help. Um but uh
7:54
Simon Zucchi: unfortunately that means he is just doesn't see any reason. And so um he decided, although we won the event, eventually he decided to appeal that.
8:04
Simon Zucchi: So I had to then get a barrister involved and my solicitor, and they went to appeal. And again, he's just making stuff up, just not true.
8:14
Simon Zucchi: And um guess what? We won at court. He didn't win his appeal, and he was ordered to pay £8,000 Pounds in and fines. Now, there's a slight problem here. You might think, well, that's a great result, but he doesn't have. any money. And the reason he doesn't have any money was we found out that one of the reasons he had actually decided to complain about the house in the first
8:34
Simon Zucchi: place and then try and put in the money gov order was because in May 2025 he had gone to court again, appealing decision for him to be struck off. And he had used some AI to find some cases that were actually incorrect. And the judge said that you're wasting court time. and fined him £25,000. This was
8:54
Simon Zucchi: in May 2025. So the reason he decided to come after lessing agent and me, and we've learned about four or five other organizations who are apparently have treated him unfairly, etc., is because he's desperately trying to raise money to pay his court fees. So, um, what's the lesson from all of this? Well, first of all, he is an
9:14
Simon Zucchi: Indian general. gentleman, an unusual name, uh as my name is unusual. If you had Googled, if we had my letting agent had Googled this person, they would have found out that he had been a solicitor, struck off, claimed to have um schizophrenia. So my get first point is if you're finding tenants and you're putting into your properties, or
9:34
Simon Zucchi: if you're letting age put a people in, I would suggest that you Google the people. Now, they might have very common names, and you know, you can't find anything about them, but if they have an unusual name, there might be something there that maybe actually you don't really want to have them as a tenant in your property. So that's the first thing. Secondly, with the advent of the Renters Rights Act, where tenants
9:54
Simon Zucchi: have a lot more rents than they used to have. What I'm now doing on all of my properties, and obviously this was before that, but I have a property in Bromley
10:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that
10:03
Simon Zucchi: is a house we converted over 10 years ago into three flats. Um they're quite expensive uh for the area. Uh well, something expensive area. So rental income uh for one month is 1900 pounds. So um in February 2026, when a new tenant was going in, the letting agent said to me, Uh, Would you like to have
10:22
Simon Zucchi: rental guarantee insurance? And I said, Well, yes, please. So now on all of my new tenancies, I always put rental guarantee insurance. And especially on a high value property, high rental income of 1900 pounds, that's expensive if they don't pay. I'm very pleased I took out that insurance, which doesn't actually cost that much to be honest. But um the tenant
10:42
Simon Zucchi: paid their first month's deposit and their first month's rent. They moved in in February, and that's all they've ever paid. Now the insurance policy as long as they pass all the credit rating, will kick in after about 30 days and start paying the rent. So, luckily, the insurance company has been paying the rent, and the insurance company have picked up the cost of taking
11:02
Simon Zucchi: that person to court under a section eight because they're not paying the rent, and also has um will take the bailiff cost to get them evicted for the buttons. book. We actually now have a date for them to be evicted from the property.
11:15
Simon Zucchi: But it's taken probably best part of eight months to go to court and to get them evicted as well. All of that time the insurance company has been paying the rent. If I didn't have that insurance in place, I'd be probably at least fifteen thousand pounds down on the rent and probably several thousand pounds down on the cost of getting them out of
11:35
Simon Zucchi: the property. So the reason I'm telling you this torrent torrid tale.
11:39
Simon Zucchi: is that unfortunately there are some bad tenants out there who will take advantage, even if you've been lucky so far. I think with the Renters' Rights Act and people becoming far more aware of their rights and also how to abuse the system and take advantage of ill-educated, ill-informed landlords. My strong recommendation to
11:59
Simon Zucchi: you would be to make sure you have landlords. landlord insurance in place. So I highly recommend you do that. You can't do it retrospectively for old tenants, but hopefully old tenants have been paying you rent there, hopefully good. But moving forward, I'm doing it for every single new tenant. As long as they pass the credit checking, you should be able to get landlord insurance. Um, there are lots
12:19
Simon Zucchi: of companies out there who do it. I'm gonna going to give you a link in the show notes of to the company that I use if that's useful for you. But make sure you have insurance. moving forward on all your properties. Don't make the expensive mistakes that I have made. This had a real impact on my cash flow. If you think about that tenant in that Bolton property, the property has got five tenants, brings in about 2,600,
12:39
Simon Zucchi: 2,700 a month in total. The profit's about a thousand pounds. I believe the total cost costs so far, and it's still going up, is it's probably about 12,000 twelve thousand pounds. So the tenant only pays 500 five hundred pounds. in rent, and obviously there's rents being lost there. But just just my legal costs, because barristers and things, twelve thousand pounds, because you had so many
12:59
Simon Zucchi: appeals and going back and having to go back to court all the time. Um that's basically an entire year's profit. It makes about a thousand pounds profit a month. So twelve months profit with of twelve thousand, a thousand uh so twelve thousand pounds profit, a full year's profit's profit speed been lost. because of the legal cost of fighting this one tenant. And I really don't want you to have to
13:19
Simon Zucchi: make that mistake. So please, please go and get wherever you want to get it from. If you want to click on the link in the show notes, you can, but go and get some landlord insurance to make sure you are protected and be very careful who you put into your property as tenants. Of course, you cannot discriminate against anybody, but you can absolutely have the right to choose. who you
13:39
Simon Zucchi: put into your property. I hope that hasn't put you off renting too much.
13:43
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It's
13:43
Simon Zucchi: still a great thing to do, and more and more landlords selling up, there's less stock available. Unfortunately, for the tenants, rents are going to go up. If you do your numbers, you do your research, still it's a very good thing to be investing in property. So until next time, as ever, I encourage you to invest with knowledge, invest with skill.
14:00
Simon Zucchi: Thanks for listening to the Property Magic Podcast. To get this week's show notes, please visit www.propertymagicbook.co.uk forward slash podcast. You can contact me via LinkedIn, you can follow me on social media, and I highly recommend you subscribe to my YouTube channel to watch loads of valuable
14:20
Simon Zucchi: property training Trading for free. All of the details are available in the show notes. Until next time, investment. invest with knowledge, invest with skill.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.

More from Property Magic Podcast

All insights