Chanticleer

Anthropic IPO success contrasts with Australian retail collapse and rising recession risks

31 min Listen to the original Episode page
RetailUnemploymentAnthropic IPONVIDIAShort SellingAustralian EconomyConsumer Sentiment

Summary

Joyce Moullakis and Anthony MacDonald discuss the administration of General Pants as part of a broader retail decline, citing a shift to experience-led formats. They analyze rising unemployment to 4.9% and RBA forecasts of a 5.25% peak, highlighting significant job cuts in banking and retail. The episode covers Anthropic's strong IPO debut despite poor allocations for Australian investors and NVIDIA's earnings beat accompanied by leadership changes. Record short selling against the AUD and ASX 200 is noted, alongside discussions on consumer sentiment trading down to cheaper goods.

Episode sections

  1. 0:50 – 3:28

    General Pants collapse and retail trends

    Anthony MacDonald and Joyce Moullakis discuss the administration of General Pants, citing it as part of a broader retail decline alongside David Jones and Q. They attribute the shift from bricks-and-mortar to online shopping and the rise of experience-led retail formats like Luxury Escapes and potential TK Maxx expansions.

  2. 3:28 – 6:41

    Australian unemployment and recession risks

    The speakers analyze the unemployment rate rising to 4.9%, a post-pandemic high, citing significant job cuts across sectors like banking, retail, and professional services. They discuss RBA forecasts predicting a peak of 5.25% and the political challenges facing Treasurer Jim Chalmers regarding spending cuts amid rising recession risks.

  3. 6:41 – 16:06

    Anthropic IPO and AI trade dynamics

    Joyce Moullakis details the Anthropic IPO, noting its strong debut despite a soft Wall Street night, but highlights poor allocations for Australian investors. The discussion covers the concurrent private placement, the upcoming OpenAI float, and the impact of NVIDIA's earnings and leadership changes on the AI sector.

  4. 16:06 – 28:56

    Short selling in Australia and economic outlook

    The hosts examine record levels of short selling against the Australian dollar and ASX 200, totaling approximately $90 billion. They discuss the implications of these bets on the Australian economy, the government's fiscal stance, and the potential for a recession, concluding with a listener question on high inflation.

  5. 28:56 – 29:42

    Consumer sentiment and inflation dynamics

    Joyce Moullakis argues that rising pessimism is beginning to impact consumer spending, which the RBA desires to see in order to curb inflation. She illustrates this with an anecdote about consumers trading down from premium goods like porterhouse steak to cheaper alternatives like mints.

  6. 29:42 – 31:06

    Podcast wrap-up and sponsor read

    Anthony MacDonald congratulates Joyce Moullakis on her new role and closes the interview segment. The transcript includes a standard outro directing listeners to the AFR app and subscription page, followed by production credits.

Assets discussed

AssetKindStanceContext
NVIDIANVDAequitymixedAnd meanwhile, you've got this private placement that was happening at the same time, concurrent to the IPO, where Nvidia and Microsoft and others got 26 billion US dollars in shares. So I think retail and wholesale investors in Australia are feeling. uh a little bit ripped off this morning.

“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.

Claims worth verifying

General Pants' private equity owner, Alchemi, called in administrators on Thursday.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·0:50

How to verify: Check ASIC insolvency registers or Alchemi's public statements/news reports from the week of 2026-11-20 for General Pants administration. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Unemployment jumped to 4.9% from 4.7% in October, setting a post-pandemic high.

Joyce Moullakis ·3:48

How to verify: ABS Labour Force, Australia, Final Estimate, Oct 2026 (Cat. 6202.0). For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

NAB cut 2,800 jobs, David Jones 1,500, Bunnings 350, Qantas 800, Canva 1,000+, KPMG 600+.

Anthony MacDonald ·4:02

How to verify: Company press releases and news reports for NAB, Wesfarmers (David Jones/Bunnings), Qantas, Canva, and KPMG regarding job reduction announcements in 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

UBS expects unemployment to peak at 5.25%.

Joyce Moullakis ·5:26

How to verify: UBS Australia economic research reports or press releases from November 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Anthropic raised US$81 billion in its IPO.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·6:41

How to verify: Anthropic S-1 filing or prospectus summary available on SEC EDGAR or company investor relations page. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Anthropic stock rallied 7.17% to close at US$97.17, hitting a high of US$115.10.

Joyce Moullakis ·7:46

How to verify: NYSE trading data for ANTH (or relevant ticker) for the first trading day post-IPO in November 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Australian investors received only 7% of applied shares in Anthropic IPO; some JB Weare customers got zero.

Joyce Moullakis ·8:24

How to verify: Broker allocation notices or news reports detailing retail allocation ratios for the Anthropic IPO. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Nvidia and Microsoft received US$26 billion in shares in a concurrent private placement.

Joyce Moullakis ·8:49

How to verify: Anthropic prospectus or press release detailing the concurrent private placement terms and investors. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Anthropic was almost seven times oversubscribed for the main offer.

Joyce Moullakis ·9:10

How to verify: Bloomberg reports or Anthropic IPO marketing materials citing subscription levels. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Goldman Sachs says ASX 200 short interest is 2.6% of the overall market, a record high.

Anthony MacDonald ·18:02

How to verify: Goldman Sachs research report on Australian equity short interest, November 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

The RBA wants to see people pulling back their purchases to address inflation.

Joyce Moullakis ·29:16

How to verify: Review RBA monetary policy statements or speeches by RBA Governor Michele Bullock regarding inflation targets and consumer demand management. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Joyce Moullakis will track the stock of Anthropic with the ticker ANT.

Joyce Moullakis ·30:08

How to verify: Check the transcript text for the explicit mention of the ticker ANT associated with Anthropic. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify General Pants administration status via ASIC registers or company announcements.
  • Check UBS Australia economic forecasts for unemployment projections.
  • Review Anthropic's S-1 filing for IPO size, allocation details, and risk factors.
  • Examine NVIDIA's Q3 10-Q filing for revenue guidance and management commentary.
  • Analyze Goldman Sachs or Bloomberg data for current short interest ratios on ASX 200.
  • Monitor RBA minutes and statements for inflation targets and consumer spending indicators.
  • Compare consumer price index (CPI) data with anecdotal evidence of trading down.
  • Assess job vacancy and unemployment data from the Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS).
Full transcriptexpand

0:04Anthony MacDonald: Hello, I'm Anthony MacDonald, Deputy Editor at the AFR. Welcome to our weekly news breakdown of all things business, finance and markets. With me today, and a huge congratulations is warranted here. She's the newest chook and first ever hen in the AFR's Fast Chook Chuck House. It's our brand new Chanticleer colonist, columnist, Joyce Mularkis. Mulakis. How are you, Joyce?

0:27Joyce Moullakis: Thanks for the great introduction and excited to be here. Thank you.

0:30Anthony MacDonald: It's fantastic to have you

0:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): here. This

0:34Anthony MacDonald: week we dive deep into the deal of the year and the pinnacle of the AI trade. We worry about the big short on Australia and what it says about where we're going, and we take an interesting question on inflation from someone who literally is on the shop floor.

0:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But

0:51Anthony MacDonald: first, Joyce, let's go back to your youth. Remember General Pants? Surely you

0:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): got

0:55Anthony MacDonald: some keppers or overalls or something there back in the day. It's gone broke. Its private equity owner, a firm called Alchemi in Sydney, called in administrators on Thursday, having been on the brink of collapse for years. Joyce, General Pants has gone under, David Jones has gone under, Q's gone under, Rick Curlona KMD nearly went bust. What's happened to all these big Aussie retail brands of yesteryear?

1:18Joyce Moullakis: Yeah, it's really tough out there, Ann. I fondly do remember General Pants being the go-to place for Lee jeans, funky t-shirts,

1:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): or

1:27Joyce Moullakis: overalls. Of course, in my younger years, which uh was a long time ago. But yeah, obviously the cost of living crisis has hit some areas of discretionary retail really hard. And I think there's more to calm as well.

1:40Anthony MacDonald: Absolutely, Joyce. I just remember General Pence was where all the cool kids worked. You know, one of the coolest kids I went to primary school with, name was Richard Penny, General Pence Macquarie Centre. There was just something about it. You walked into that shop. We grew up at sort of the similar time, so like it was just cool, right? That's

1:55Joyce Moullakis: right. It was the place to go to get your funky threads. Yeah.

1:59Anthony MacDonald: So I wonder what's happened. Do you reckon what's cool back then just isn't cool anymore? Do you reckon the format's changed? Do you reckon young people are shopping online? What do you think?

2:06Joyce Moullakis: Well, I think online is a big part of it. I mean, Instagram and the younger generation shopping on what they see on their reels, you know, being able to order it online and have it delivered in record time, that really makes a big difference. It's probably displaced quite a lot of these bricks and mortar retailers.

2:24Anthony MacDonald: So, question without notice if you think of it. what a shopping centre looks like, you've got, you know, David Jones is closing half its stores, might shut even more. You know, Q's obviously are really in trouble. General Pants is going to be closing more stores. What do you think ends up taking all this space in shopping centres?

2:42Joyce Moullakis: Well, that's a really good question. I think we will also start to see more experience-led experience led type stores, like in the Bonai Bondi Junction Westfield. I'm not getting paid by Westfield by the way to say this. Um Luxury Escapes is actually turned up in

2:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): where

2:58Joyce Moullakis: the Lego store was. And it's sort of a more of a it's not a traditional travel agent's it's more of an experience to go in there. You know, they've made it look really brand spanking Banking new with big screens up and it's really inviting. I think we might start to see more of those sorts. of stores in our retail shopping centres.

3:17Anthony MacDonald: Yeah, and maybe more food courts or like quasi food courts, you know, little pockets of like restaurants and cafes. Yep. Feels like that's where Westfield and whatnot are gonna be making their money.

3:28Joyce Moullakis: And TK Maxx is the other one that's been rumoured to be taking up some space that David Jones might be giving up in the next couple of months, obviously after Christmas. Cool. And Anthony, what about the job? jobs number this week? Unemployment jumped to four point nine percent from four point seven percent in the October numbers, and that set a new high for the post-pandemic period.

3:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We

3:50Joyce Moullakis: shouldn't be surprised with all the job cuts going around at the moment. Our sister podcast The FIN did a really good wrap-up this week. What do you think about the unemployment rate? And is it anywhere near its peak?

4:02Anthony MacDonald: No. Like all these cuts, like we've written about them all week, Joyce, or the past few weeks. Like we had NAB, 2,800 job cuts, DJs, 1500, Burnings, 350, Qantas, 800, Canva, 1000 odd, KPMG, 600 or so.

4:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The

4:16Anthony MacDonald: looming job cuts at General Pants, no doubt. I mean, none of those are in these numbers, right? Then they're

4:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): all

4:22Anthony MacDonald: they're all coming. They're all sort of happening.

4:23Joyce Moullakis: Still to come.

4:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,

4:24Anthony MacDonald: in the next few weeks or next few months. You know, the impact of the fourth and fifth rate rises we've had this year, September and November, they're not in the numbers yet because bosses are slow to cut jobs, but we know that. Usually they wait for things to get very tough. They try to raise prices, they cut back hours, they do what they can to save other costs before sacking staff. So I think we're only really at the start of these, you know, economies economy softening cuts. Then you have the AI, and companies need to. show they're getting some savings from AI spending as well. That's going to equal more job cuts. And I think it's really hard to see how the unemployment rate doesn't keep rising in the short to medium term. 4.9%, yeah, post-pandemic high. Look, historically, it's not that bad. 4.9%. You know,

5:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I mean,

5:07Anthony MacDonald: it's probably about where the economy is almost in equilibrium in terms of the jobs market and whether

5:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it's

5:12Anthony MacDonald: too hot or too tight. But 4.9% four point nine from percent where we were in the low threes like it's it's a big increase. The trend is really up and to the right. It's scary. And I just wonder what's going to turn that around. What's going to turn the economy around? What's going to turn the interest rates around?

5:26Joyce Moullakis: UBS were saying yesterday they expect unemployment to peak at five point two five percent. So we're not at the end of it yet. Get through the Christmas period and then we may see more.

5:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah

5:35Anthony MacDonald: this Christmas period shapes up to be fascinating. Like I reckon two things could happen. One, people like us would go all out in Christmas and just spend everything, way more than we should, right? And then we'll have a hangover the first half of next year. We'll have no money left. We're paying off our credit cards. Or two, it's just a really quiet Christmas. Either way, I think the retail sector, like the sort of consumer sector, is in trouble, right? In if you take like a six month view. So where where the job's gonna come from? I mean,

6:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): like

6:01Anthony MacDonald: sure, maybe there's a few more. in mining, but apart from the sort of like the government hiring more people, more government services, yet remember it's also feeling pressure to cut costs. Where where's the hiring gonna come from? It's just so hard to see. It's not banking, it's not law firms, it's not accounting firms. Maybe the supermarkets will hire a few more people. Yep. It's just not easy to see that big employer coming in and turning around that job's number.

6:23Joyce Moullakis: Yeah, I think Cole's already this week said they're um fast. tracking some of the DJ staff to come across during this frenetic pre-Christmas food binge, perhaps. But uh yeah, it's really difficult to see, Anthony. I agree.

6:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay,

6:41Anthony MacDonald: Joyce, there's only one contender for our first topic this week, and it's AI company Anthropics IPO. Anthropic raised US $81 billion. It added another 10% to its price only a day before listing this week, and it still popped 30% when it debuted on Thursday night or Friday morning Australian time. What made its performance more remarkable is that it started trading on a soft night for Wall Street. The SP 500 was down 1.5%, the Nasdaq was down 1.5%, and these indices are now down more than 5% in the past few days. Yet

7:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it

7:14Anthony MacDonald: didn't really. seem to matter to Anthropic the way it traded. So investors read the 90-odd pages of risks in its prospectus. They clearly weren't worried, nor were they worried about traditional valuation metrics like price to earnings ratios. They are backing the sales of Anthropic's clawed AI model to surge and keep surging well into the future. Joyce, you followed this one closely all week. Great week to start on, Sean's Clear, a big topical. deal. You're a deals reporter from way back. On a scale of one to ten, how do you think Anthropics IPO week went?

7:46Joyce Moullakis: Well, for them, I think it went swimmingly, probably 10 out of 10. But for investors, it's probably closer to a seven or so, especially Australian investors who didn't get very much at all in the allocations. You're right, we did see the stock, you know, rally seven. 17% or so to close at 97.17 US dollars. It hit a high of 115.10 during the day. So stag profits are there. They're basically just made when you quickly flip stock in an IPO, if the stock goes up, of course. But for Australian investors, some who applied for 100,000 a hundred thousand shares, you

8:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,

8:24Joyce Moullakis: may have received 7% maybe. I was speaking. to one this morning who received nothing

8:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): because

8:29Joyce Moullakis: they uh applied through JB Weir. So that's really disappointing from that perspective. And meanwhile, you've got this private placement that was happening at the same time, concurrent to the IPO, where Nvidia and Microsoft and others got 26 billion US dollars in shares. So I think retail and wholesale investors in Australia are feeling. uh a little bit ripped off this morning.

8:53Anthony MacDonald: Okay, let's just pick up on what you said just there. All right, so Anthropic, the IPO went really well, but it spent time marketing in Australia and it was, you know, trying to lure in Australian investors. They got a heap of bids for shares, right? But they ended up saying what? Oh, thanks anyway. We like that you bid, but I mean there's no room for you?

9:10Joyce Moullakis: Yeah, well, I mean the demand was huge. Bloomberg at one stage was saying that it was almost seven times oversubscribed for the main offer. And then they had the different jurisdictions which were also getting their own different pots of shares. Anthropic raised 107 US billion if you include the concurrent share placement. So basically, within that huge pot, Australian investors only got US 110 million. So it's a tiny tiny proportion. And I think that's really disappointing. Some of the retail brokers and private wealth firms are having to make those explanations to uh investors this morning, and it's not an easy conversation for them to have.

9:51Anthony MacDonald: Similar on the institution side as well, Joyce. Good stories on AFR.com today about some of the fund managers in Sydney and Melbourne that bid for stock and got zero. You know, which which they're not used to that. You

10:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,

10:02Anthony MacDonald: these are supposed to be the kings of our market here. They're supposed to be able to beat their chests and get these shares. They just got completely overlooked.

10:09Joyce Moullakis: Yeah. Yeah. The brokers are uh at pains to say that uh it's the company that made the allocation decision. So uh yeah.

10:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

10:16Joyce Moullakis: Anthony, it did trade well on day one. It was up. What do you think happens next?

10:22Anthony MacDonald: Well, I think this is the golden child of the AI Frontier Labs, I think. Enthropic's the one we've been hearing about all year. Like Clawed. There's a lot of love out there for Clawed. And I think investors do want to own this thing. They do think that it's ahead of the others in the race.

10:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The

10:38Anthony MacDonald: big question now is what it means for OpenAI. We've got these sort of three whopper AI floats. We had SpaceX in June, we've had Anthropic now in November, and the third one is open OpenAI. AI. And it's supposed to be worth, you know, a trillion dollars or who knows? A lot of money, right? And it wants to come out and raise a lot of money. The question is like, how much capacity is there still in public equity markets for them to come out and do that IPO for me? It's tough, right? Like it's hard to fit these three gorillas in the market. So SpaceX was really smart getting out in front. Enthropic was always going to get demand because, like I said, it's the one that is seen to have the best model and the best.

11:16Joyce Moullakis: Emoti's been also very vocal about the safety element as well. So that may give uh investors a little bit of um comfort that they're proceeding with a little bit of caution.

11:25Anthony MacDonald: Yeah, but the one that hasn't jumped out is OpenAI, right? And that's Chat GPT. They were out in front and it feels like they're not as in front as they used to be. They want to float, that's now looking like a next year thing. But I mean, is there US fifty billion dollars, US $100 billion for them? Because while we've got SpaceX and Anthropic already listed, there's heaps and heaps of investors in those things from when they're private companies who are sitting on massive gains, who will be wanting to sell bits and pieces into the market in the coming twelve months, two years. So there's going to be new money coming into SpaceX Exanthropic and Anthropic to account for those sell downs. How much room is there for the third one in open OpenAI? AI? I I don't know. I'm really interested to see that. And for me, that's one of the big capital market stories going into next year. But Joyce, like what a week for the AI trade. Anthropic floats going on as we've had NVIDIA's Jensen Wang spy affairs chip story happening at the same time. This week there was a push to get Jensen back in charge of NVIDIA. Its board said no. The stand-in CEO Colette Crest did a first earnings called. call. NVIDIA released third-quarter third quarter earnings, which were pretty gangbuster.

12:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You

12:28Anthony MacDonald: listened to that call on Wednesday morning. What was it like? What was the sort of investor feeling towards NVIDIA in the post-Huang era?

12:35Joyce Moullakis: Well, before I say that, I mean, you know, affairs, spies, chips into China. Yeah. This story's got it all really.

12:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You

12:43Joyce Moullakis: know, there were a lot of people listening intently to the Nvidia earnings call. I'd have to say it did sound quite. scripted. The chairman Harvey Jones ruled out the return of Jensen and said the board wouldn't be rushed on finding the next CEO. I mean, that's what a lot of people were waiting to hear, clarity around that. And Crest delivered a set of results that not only beat expectations but also increased revenue guidance by five percentage points. So the result itself was really, really strong, but the shares actually fell to 2.9%. So there is still a lot of skepticism around where this company goes to from here. Let's not forget that US interest rates are probably going to rise in December. Some in that market are saying by as much as 50 basis points. So there are still challenges ahead. We had the blue wave in the US midterms. There's a lot going on and a lot for these big companies to navigate. It's a big job for Crest. The chair did say they're um looking at both internal and external candidates. So it's going to be an interesting time for this company in the months ahead.

13:49Anthony MacDonald: Sure is. Now, Joyce, you mentioned the blue wave. Let's bring a quick question in here from John in Queensland, who says a few weeks ago you were talking about Elon Musk and key man risk at SpaceX. Could the combination of key man risk due to Jensen Huang's exit and the democratic sweep in the midterms change the AI trade? How much do you think that will reverberate through the global economy?

14:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Do

14:12Anthony MacDonald: you have any views?

14:13Joyce Moullakis: Well, it is a good question from John. And as any good chair would know, succession planning is the biggest role a chair plays in a company's next phase, the most important. But what that also includes is planning for moments like this. these, unexpected events, you know, being hit by a bus scenario. What if

14:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the

14:31Joyce Moullakis: CEO got hit by a bus? What would you do? And then companies need to be prepared for those scenarios. I mean, they're very rare, but they happen. Illness, in this case, scandal. But um it does feel as though Nvidia was caught very flat-footed Flat footed here, even though some of the speculation around the alleged affair with the suspected. a suspected Chinese spy had been doing the rounds in the US for months. And we've also heard a lot about the blue wave and how that may slow the pace of the AI infrastructure rollout in the US and elsewhere. So conditions are far from ideal. AI-related stocks have come under a lot of pressure in the last sort of six weeks or so. That has implications for capital investment and of course economic growth in the US and here domestically, where AI investment has actually been uh buoying economic growth in terms of business investment. So

15:24Anthony MacDonald: I think what John's asking Joyce, and we just need a quick answer for him here. Are we at the peak of the AI trade?

15:31Joyce Moullakis: Well, I did a column on this this week, and I personally don't think that conditions are conducive. for the AI trade to be revived at this stage. I mean, probably not in the short term, but I could be proven wrong. It's really hard to know after this huge demand for anthropic and the wave of demand and support for that IPO. It's really hard to say. But I just don't think the broader external conditions really warrant a big revival in the AI trade.

16:01Anthony MacDonald: Well

16:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): said. Well,

16:07Joyce Moullakis: let's come home for our second topic, Anthony, and talk about Australia's big short. Our colleague, Cecile LaFort, had a great news yarn this week. Big investors are shorting the pants off the Australian dollar, the Australian share market, and basically anything else they can get their hands on. Betting that our slowing economy, falling house prices, rise rising interest rates, and non-existent productivity growth means that Australia will seriously underperform other developed countries in the short to medium term. Anthony, it's looking pretty grim. These short bets, just the ones that we can quantify on the Australian dollar and Australian shares, are worth about $90 billion, which is a record level. It shows just how big the big bearish bets about Australia's outlook are. Can you explain to us a little bit about what short selling is, what these bets say, and whether there's anything else we can do to kind of stop them?

17:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,

17:02Anthony MacDonald: sure. Now this short selling, it's someone's betting the price of something will go down. So they borrow an asset. Let's talk about Commonwealth Bank shares, for example. They might borrow one million Commonwealth Bank shares, they pay a shareholder a small fee to borrow that stock. they sell the shares into the market, then they hope the price goes down. And at some stage, they buy the shares back and give them back to their owner. And they make money so long as the price of those Commonwealth Bank shares that they're buying back is less than what they sold them for in the first place. You know, there's a little bit of holding cost to account for as well. But hedge funds will often use leverage or debt to do these trades as well, which really sort of can amplify the returns for them. But right now it was Cecil Rote, and this was one of my favorite yarns this week. I thought we under-treated it a little bit at the fin review, which is now my fault as much as anyone's. That asset managers, I mean, they've got a record $15.7 billion worth of shorts against the Australian dollar. So they're betting it'll go down and go down quite a lot. And it's working, right? The Australian dollars at US 67 cents. That's a 10-month 10 month low. And there's another 72%.

18:02billion in bets against companies in the ASX 200 via short selling their shares. And Goldman Sachs says that's 2.6% of the overall market, a record high. So basically, it doesn't matter whether you're talking currency, it doesn't matter whether you're talking shares. People are lining up to say, Australia, you are cooked. Your asset prices are going down, and we're going to try and make money off them going down. And that's not a good thing for us here in Australia. I mean, there's things a regulator could do to try and stop the short selling, but it's not advisable. You might remember, I mean, it's been banned before, like in the GFC. But this isn't anything like that. I mean, the best way to blow these shorts away is to just improve

18:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): performance. Yeah,

18:40Anthony MacDonald: it's the only way, you know, get the economy firing, get productive growth, get our mojo back, get the exports firing, earnings, company profits, all that stuff. If you do that, the hedge funds will run away just as quickly. as they've appeared and they'll run away really hurting. They won't come back for years and we'll be on our merry way and they'll be the last thing we're thinking about. And

18:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): we've also

18:59Joyce Moullakis: got a lot of MA happening as well in Australia, Anthony. So um, you know, that sort of attracts hedge fund interest too. And broker actually on the back of Cecile's story Dory sent me some numbers on notional short interest in the ASX twenty 20 and put it at 40.2 billion

19:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): as

19:16Joyce Moullakis: at November 11. And that was up from 17.2 billion in January. So more than double. It's it's quite phenomenal. Yeah,

19:25Anthony MacDonald: it sure is. Now let's go back to the unemployment number this week, 4.9%, Joyce. It was a shocker, but one that RBA says needs to happen. The obvious question when you see that, you see rates up five times this year, you see the economy slowing even more into next year. Are we headed for a recession?

19:40Joyce Moullakis: It's a possibility. Like the risks have increased. And I think the jobs numbers yesterday really had economists sitting up and saying, well, if this continues, if job cuts continue, if the government doesn't pull back on spending, then there is a real risk that we get a recession. Whether that is the technical definition of a recession, which is two consecutive quarters of negative. growth, who knows? But it is feeling like a recession. And Michelle Bullock even went as far as saying that in her November press conference. She was sort of saying, you know, with rates where they are, some households will be feeling as though we're already in a recession. Now, Anthony, this is really terrible news for the government. Jim Chalmers is under immense pressure to cut spending. Government spending is part of the inflation. problem. Yet we're also in a problematic cost of living situation, and now we've got a soggy jobs market as well. With a sharp downturn in the housing market, pullback in credit growth, retail collapses, and job cuts across the economy. As you said earlier, sectors including banking, retail, and even the big accounting firms are cutting jobs. And there does appear to be, you know, growing risks within the economy. How much do you think Jim Chalmers can cut spending in the upcoming My EFO budget update?

20:56Anthony MacDonald: Oh, good question, Choice. It's sort of the question that's been overhanging the economy for the past four weeks now. Jim Chalmers, he spoke at the ASIC Forum this week. You were probably out there, were you?

21:05Joyce Moullakis: Yes, I was actually. Yeah,

21:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you d

21:07Anthony MacDonald: well you tell us, you heard it. What what did he say? Was it anything interesting?

21:09Joyce Moullakis: Well, strangely, he did sort of come out and he said, you know, the government would cut enough, but not too much.

21:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.

21:15Joyce Moullakis: You know, the business community is pushing for the government to get behind the monetary policy tightening and tighten its own spending so that it can tame inflation. But Jim almost seemed to be sort of hedging it a little bit. So I suppose he's trying to be measured in saying we will cut, but it may not be a severe cut that eats into consumption in a way that might hurt the economy. Yeah,

21:37Anthony MacDonald: those words of his cut enough but not cut. too much were really interesting. Like

21:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): he

21:42Anthony MacDonald: obviously feels under pressure that he has to talk about spending cuts. I mean, that case is being made by business, markets, etc., everywhere, right? Like with government spending's been a big problem, big contributor to inflation, and inflation is bad for everyone. Michelle Bullock tells us that eight times a year in her press conferences and many more times in her appearance. appearances. The problem is though, clearly he knows the message to cut needs to be out there, but there doesn't seem to be much desire from the government and around him, other parts of the government, to actually cut. And it's such a fine line for him because it's almost like he's become this outcast in the government where colleagues of his are willing to throw him under the bus and blame him for the problems with the economy. Yet there is no evidence that these colleagues of his want to cut spending

22:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): one

22:29Anthony MacDonald: IOTA more than Jim does. In fact, it feels like they want to increase services and increase spending, which will only make the problem worse. And yet he's become the face of the problem. And I mean, we saw unemployment rate rising this week, and we know this government likes jobs, and we know they're willing to spend a lot to save jobs. The big danger, I think, is they try to spend to bring the unemployment rate. down, which would only pour fuel on the inflation fire, which is already burning, and make the RBA's problem even worse.

22:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

22:58Anthony MacDonald: give them little but no choice to raise again. And then you know

23:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, it

23:02Joyce Moullakis: could be a vicious cycle.

23:03Anthony MacDonald: We could be sitting here this time next year, we're in a recession, inflation's still high, unemployment's higher, and the RBA hasn't cut rates yet because they can't, 'cause can't because inflation's too high.

23:12Joyce Moullakis: Part of it is ideological and you've got to take note of the electoral cycle as well. We've got an election coming up in Victoria. We're midway through uh federal election cycle. You know, these politicians are always thinking about where they are in the electoral cycle in terms of being able to execute some of their policy measures and particularly some of the harder ones like spending cuts.

23:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hey,

23:35Anthony MacDonald: a quick question here for you, Joyce, from Steve in Sydney, who says that later. Labour indicated no or mild downturn when they promised their budget. Is anyone admitting they got it wrong?

23:45Joyce Moullakis: Well, Anthony Governments seldom, if ever, admit that they got it wrong. And uh, you know, I think we're probably in that boat now. Uh although, you know, the government did to their credit outline that there were challenges ahead externally for the economy back at the budget. Oil prices are spiking. We have had some respite on the oil price front in recent weeks. But yeah, governments tend to say that they're right and and uh that's all part of the electoral cycle and where they're sitting and they spin the message to benefit them. So no, I don't think they're gonna admit they got it wrong.

24:22Anthony MacDonald: And how do you feel for those first home buyers out there that might have bought their house a year ago? now seeing negative equity? Do you think there's anything the government can do for them, or do you think the government should even do anything for them? Like what's their future hold?

24:34Joyce Moullakis: Well, you know, the 5% deposit scheme and the CGT and negative gearing reforms which are coming into effect next year, you know, that sort of modelling can be skewed and there typically are unintended consequences with policy change. For those first home buyers, you'd have to hope that they didn't stretch. themselves that far that they're going to be impacted in the short term because housing tends to be a longer term decision. The scheme does help in terms of the size of the deposit, but because of higher interest rates, don't forget their mortgage repayments are going to be higher. So there is a trade-off, and I think some of these first home buyers are going to be doing it really tough at the moment. Yeah,

25:12Anthony MacDonald: they sure are, Joyce. We're just going to take a quick break. and we'll have a look to see whether there's any good news for homebuyers next week.

25:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): If

25:30Anthony MacDonald: you want to know more about what we're talking about today and a whole lot more, AFR subscribers can sign up to the Chanticle Chanticleer newsletter at join.afr.com. forward slash shontacleer. Every Saturday morning you'll get the best Chanticle articles of the week delivered straight to your inbox, including some crackers from Joyce Mulakis for the first time this week. Alright Joyce, it's always a big week coming up here on the Chanticle podcast. Next week's no exception, there's a bit of economic data. 1130 a.m on Wednesday, Australian CPI data out for October. The economists are talking about some pretty big numbers, unfortunately. I think Westpac's talking about 4.8% on a year-on-year basis for CPI. Pretty ugly. Trim mean 3.7%, so far above the RBA's range. See any good news in it?

26:18Joyce Moullakis: The only good news that you can take from that is that the jobs market was soft in this week's unemployment data, and therefore the RBA. is likely to pause at the very least. That's what a lot of the economists were saying yesterday after the uh job print. The RBA are gonna have to sit on their hands now and just wait to see how the other two rate rises filter through the economy. It's hard to see many positives at all in the CPI data. Perhaps we might see some respite in the oil price.

26:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right,

26:48Anthony MacDonald: on Wednesday night with the AFR's annual business. person of the year awards.

26:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm

26:53Anthony MacDonald: not allowed to tell you who the winners are, but I can tell you a little bit about them. I think. Yeah,

26:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): tell us about it. We've got to

26:58Anthony MacDonald: give our listeners something here on the podcast. Yeah,

27:00Joyce Moullakis: a few snippets. Come on.

27:01Anthony MacDonald: We've got a bit of everything. There's a bit of corporate, bit

27:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of

27:03Anthony MacDonald: start ups, some founders, quite a few founders actually. A real sort of underappreciated but very, very solid CEO, some big names, some that will cause a bit of a stir.

27:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Like

27:14Anthony MacDonald: I said. mixed bag. It should be a good night.

27:16Joyce Moullakis: Can't wait, can't wait. I'm I'm heading along, so it'll be a fun night and uh a lot of high-profile people and deserving winners, I assume.

27:23Anthony MacDonald: Next Thursday, US time. So that's at the end of next week for us. Thanksgiving holiday in the US. Does that one feature on your calendar, Joyce?

27:30Joyce Moullakis: Well, Anthony, I might have to uh head to Coles or Woolies and get myself a turkey, but uh

27:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): we'll

27:35Joyce Moullakis: see, we'll see, we'll see. All

27:36Anthony MacDonald: Alright, right, Joyce, we love brief questions on the shot. Shanticlear podcast, and this week's question is from Anthony Dutton in New South Wales. If you have a question you want to send us, you can email us at shunterclear atafr.com, or you can be brave and send through an audio question. Just record a voice memo on your phone, include your name and where you're from, and email it to us. Or you can always submit a question via the widget at the bottom of our Shanticlear ShantiClick articles, or Joyce's Shanticlear Shanticlick articles, at AFR.com. I'll ask our producer Mandy to read it for us.

28:05Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Thanks, And. As

28:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): a CEO of a national franchise business in the retail food and beverage space, the reality is that inflation is much higher than the RBA numbers. Double is a conservative number. How can we operate in what seems to be reality versus a reported RBA set of figures that are so vastly different? Love the podcast. There

28:27Anthony MacDonald: you go, Joyce. You heard it there. From the shop floor, inflation's running double what the official figures say.

28:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That's

28:33Joyce Moullakis: worrying. That's

28:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): extremely

28:35Joyce Moullakis: worrying, yeah. Yeah,

28:36Anthony MacDonald: for sure. And I'm I'm inclined to believe someone that's actually there on the front line doing it. I mean, if Anthony's right,

28:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what

28:43Anthony MacDonald: what do you think that says about his customers? His customers are paying, how business is feeling. It sort of explains why consumer confidence is in the toilet. It explains

28:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): why

28:51Anthony MacDonald: business confidence is in the

28:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): city. A lot of

28:53Joyce Moullakis: pessimism.

28:53Anthony MacDonald: Huge, huge pessimism.

28:56Joyce Moullakis: I think that pessimism will start to filter into spending. And I think that's what uh you know companies are waiting for. Because there has been a bit of a disconnect in recent months around the level of pessimism, but people have still been keeping up with spending, perhaps not at bumper levels, but they're still spending. So if that pessimism starts to translate into, and that's this is what the RBA wants to see, by the way, in people sort of pulling back their purchases, that's uh where the consumer spending and the economy will sort of really pull back. But inflation, yeah, big part of the problem because people are sort of assessing their purchases more closely and thinking, you know, maybe I can't afford this, maybe I need to trade down to mints instead of uh pouring. porterhouse steak. You know, it's uh it is a concern.

29:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That

29:42Anthony MacDonald: is concerning, Joyce, and I really hope you're not having to trade down to the three star mints.

29:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh

29:48Joyce Moullakis: well, five star all the way in my household, uh Anthony, but you never know, you never know.

29:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All right,

29:53Anthony MacDonald: well, it's been great having you on the Sean's Clear podcast, Joyce. Congratulations on your promotion to Sean's Chant's Clear Columnist. Very well deserved. I Think you do a fantastic job. Kenichua to James Thompson, who's on holidays this week. He'll be back next week. But Joyce, thanks very much for coming in.

30:08Joyce Moullakis: Thanks for having me, Ant. And I'll keep a close eye on the ant stock being anthropic with the ticker ANT for next week as well and keep you updated.

30:17Anthony MacDonald: Thanks for listening, and we'll see you next week.

30:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): If

30:20Anthony MacDonald: you like the podcast, liked share it with a friend. And if you want to read more about anthropic interest rates and everything else to do with inflation or anything we've talked about today, check out the links in the show notes. And don't forget you can listen to this and all AFR podcasts on the AFR app. At the Financial Review, we investigate the big stories about markets, business, and power. You can subscribe to the Financial Review, the daily habit of successful people, at AFR.com/slash Dot com slash subscribe. Sean SeanClear Clear was hosted by me, Anthony MacDonald, McDonald and Joyce Mulakis, Mulakas. who was It produced by Mandy Cullen. Our theme is by Alex Gao, and head of premium content is Fiona Buffini.

31:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The

31:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Australian Financial Review

This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights