Speakers warn unconsented home additions risk insurance exclusions and mortgage finance
Summary
Zibunisa Olimova and Megan Love discuss the risks of unconsented building work, such as conservatories, in property transactions. They explain that insurers may exclude unconsented structures from coverage or require formal consent within a temporary period. The speakers emphasize that hiding unconsented work is risky because insurers investigate claims using council records and LIMs. Non-disclosure can lead to policy voidance, leaving homeowners liable for mortgage debt. Buyers are advised to include insurance conditions in contracts and accurately calculate full replacement value to avoid underinsurance.
Key takeaways
- 1 Overinsuring a property does not increase the payout in a total loss scenario; insurers pay the assessed replacement value, so accurate valuation is critical to avoid paying unnecessary premiums.
Zibunisa Olimova · 7:41
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 1:23
Introduction and Unconsented Conservatory Scenario
Zibunisa Olimova introduces the topic of unconsented building work, specifically a conservatory at an open home. Megan Love shares a buyer's concern that an unconsented conservatory would prevent them from obtaining finance due to lack of insurance.
- 1:23 – 2:39
Insurance Coverage and Exclusions for Unconsented Structures
Olimova explains that insurers often cover the main house but may exclude the unconsented structure or require consent. Coverage depends on factors like whether the structure is attached and the materials used, such as fireproof walls.
- 2:39 – 3:06
Temporary Coverage and Consent Requirements
Insurers may provide full coverage for 90 days while the buyer obtains consent. If consent is not secured within this period, exclusions are applied to the policy, particularly for high-risk items like electrical work.
- 3:06 – 5:38
Disclosure Obligations and Claim Investigations
The speakers emphasize that hiding unconsented work is risky. Insurers investigate large claims by checking council records and LIMs. Non-disclosure can lead to the insurer paying only the premium back, leaving the homeowner with a mortgage on an uninsurable property.
- 5:38 – 7:20
Due Diligence and Insurance Conditions in Contracts
Olimova notes that banks often have property records and that agents must disclose known issues. Buyers should add an insurance condition to the sale and purchase agreement to allow withdrawal if insurance is difficult to obtain.
- 7:20 – 9:39
Full Replacement Value and Under/Overinsurance
The discussion covers the importance of calculating full replacement value. Overinsuring does not guarantee higher payouts, as insurers pay the actual assessed value, while underinsuring leaves gaps. Buyers are advised to consult advisers rather than relying solely on cheap online calculators.
Claims worth verifying
Insurers may cover the full house but exclude the unconsented conservatory from coverage if it burns down.
Zibunisa Olimova ·1:43
How to verify: Review standard New Zealand home insurance policy wording for 'unconsented building work' exclusions or 'additions' clauses in policy documents from major NZ insurers (e.g., IAG, AXA). For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Insurers may provide full insurance for 90 days while the buyer obtains consent for the unconsented work.
Megan Love ·2:39
How to verify: Check sample insurance offer letters or policy schedules from New Zealand insurers that include 'conditional cover' or 'temporary cover' clauses pending consent. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Insurance claims are often caused by electrical malfunctions.
Zibunisa Olimova ·3:01
How to verify: Review annual fire and electrical safety claim statistics published by New Zealand insurers or the Electrical Workers Registration Board (EWRB). For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Insurers investigate claims by checking council records and LIMs.
Zibunisa Olimova ·4:45
How to verify: Observe standard claims investigation procedures outlined in insurance policy terms and conditions, which typically grant the insurer the right to access council records. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
In cases of non-disclosure, insurers may pay only the premium back.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·4:08
How to verify: Review New Zealand case law or insurance ombudsman decisions regarding 'non-disclosure' or 'misrepresentation' in home insurance policies. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
99.9% of the time, banks do not decline lending due to unconsented structures if disclosed.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·6:30
How to verify: Review New Zealand banks' (e.g., ASB, ANZ, BNZ) lending criteria documents regarding 'unconsented building work' and their risk appetite. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Insurers pay only the assessed value, even if the insured amount is higher.
Zibunisa Olimova ·7:41
How to verify: Review the 'Sum Insured' and 'Indemnity' clauses in New Zealand home insurance policies, which typically state that payout is limited to the actual cash value or replacement cost. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Review specific policy wording for exclusions regarding unconsented structures.
- Check local council records and LIMs for any unconsented work on the property.
- Verify if the insurer offers temporary coverage periods and their specific consent requirements.
- Consult a qualified insurance adviser for accurate full replacement value calculations.
- Review the sale and purchase agreement for insurance conditions allowing withdrawal.
- Investigate the insurer's claims investigation process and data sources.
- Confirm disclosure obligations signed at policy inception regarding known defects.
- Check bank lending criteria for properties with unconsented additions.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00Zibunisa Olimova: You're listening to that home loan hub. I'm Zibunisa Olimova here to make home loans and property investing simple, smart, and stress-free. Let's get you closer to your property dreams. This one is an interesting one for those that are buying properties and there might be something unconsented. I had a question come through from our in-house agent specialist. Agent Love is in the house. Hello, Agent Love.
0:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hello.
0:26Zibunisa Olimova: I never know how to introduce you, and I just try to spin it around.
0:30Megan Love: I I love that. I feel like very James Bond.
0:32Zibunisa Olimova: For those that haven't listened to our previous episodes, was Megan. Megan Love is Harcourt's real estate agent, and she is a phenomenal human being, and I love her so much. So we're actually more than just Agent Brocker relationship here. We've become friends.
0:47Megan Love: We have, yeah.
0:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
0:48Zibunisa Olimova: it's beautiful, right? So you had something in interesting come through this month's.
0:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Mm,
0:52Megan Love: yes. So a question from a buyer who was in an open home and there was an unconsented conservatory. And of course we disclose all of this. It's not a secret. And they turned around and said, Oh, well, we won't be able to get finance because we won't be able to get insurance because the conservatory is unconsented. And I had this little moment of thinking, well, the house has insurance right now, so that's probably not true. But I thought, let's ask you, as an insurance person as well, as a lender, what are your thoughts on that?
1:23Zibunisa Olimova: This one is interesting. And obviously, case by case, and this is not the financial advice or insurance advice, but in our practice and what we've seen is usually you can get full house insurance, but there might be various ABCs, right? So let's look at the A. Insurance. company might come back and say, we're gonna insure the full house, but we may not insure the work that has been done, which is unconsented. So if the conservatory burns down, we're not gonna cover that. Or why is it unconsented? Can you get consent on it? And if you can get consent on it, then insurance will just tick it all off. There won't be any special exclusions or conditions. So normally you can still get full house. insurance, but it's just a conservatory that may have special exclusions or not. Also, it depends whether conservatory is attached to the house fully or not. In this case, is it fully attached to the house?
2:15Megan Love: There was a wall in between the lounge and the conservatory.
2:19Zibunisa Olimova: So it will depend, you know, what sort of wall wool is it? Is it fireproof? Is it not fireproof? Like insurance may want separate reports on it. The other cases we've seen is insurance might come back and say, look, go and see if you can get consent. We will still give you full insurance for the next 90 days.
2:39Megan Love: Oh, that's good. All right.
2:41Zibunisa Olimova: But you need to give us within this 90 days, you need to go and get the stuff sorted. And if you get it sorted, tickety boo, you give us the proof. And if it's not sorted, then we'll put exclusion on it. So I've seen that happen before as well. Often it's to do with electrical work, to be honest, because that's where the most c causes for insurance claims is that if there is electrical malfunction and then there's a whole thing burns down.
3:05Megan Love: That would not be good.
3:06Zibunisa Olimova: That would not be good at all. And that's where insurance could turn around and say, Look, you didn't tell us. The worst thing that you can do is not tell insurance.
3:13Megan Love: Oh, I was gonna ask you that because there's some theories of like, oh, but don't tell them. And you know, I get very anxious when I hear things like that. And I'm always like, No, do tell them.
3:22Zibunisa Olimova: Exactly.
3:22Megan Love: It's better to find out.
3:23Zibunisa Olimova: They'd rather know, and that's what I always say to my clients as well, is that we'd rather know and tell the insurance company everything and get it signed off than you trying to be sneaky, not tell them. And usually that doesn't fly past me, usually they go direct online and get it. a cover and don't tell anyone. But then when something goes wrong, insurance does investigation, especially if it's a massive claim, like let's say the house burned down and they need to pay you out 500k. Do you think they're just gonna roll it over and give you 500k check with no questions asked?
3:53Megan Love: That would be so worrying if somebody had hidden that and then didn't get paid out.
3:57Zibunisa Olimova: Yeah.
3:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): They
3:59Megan Love: still have a mortgage, right?
4:00Zibunisa Olimova: Yeah. And there have been precedents for that. So what insurance will probably do in those cases is they'll just pay you back your premium because they will say, Well would
4:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): we
4:08Zibunisa Olimova: should have never insured you in the first place. So you may get five K back off your insurance premium, but that's it. Yeah. And then what you're gonna do? You suddenly have a mortgage on something that no longer is livable or rentable.
4:23Megan Love: No house, no furniture.
4:25Zibunisa Olimova: So exactly. So I suggest never ever try to be sneaky because insurance will find out they will put the, you know, they will open up the cases for from the council records, from the limb. There are insurance investigators. There is also insurance fraud investigators out there that will look into it. So you are so much safer to declare things to your advisor. Even with you know flood flooding zones. Like we in Carpeti, half of our properties that we need to insure are in the flooding zone.
4:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
4:58Zibunisa Olimova: what we normally say to the insurers is look, it isn't a flooding zone, but you know, it's part of the 100-year pond area, whatever, whatever. Are you happy to insure? And most of the time, I don't think we've ever had a case declined where because you're in the a ponding zone or a flooding zone, you will be declined insurance. So it's better to it's part of your disclosure. You actually sign when you take out insurance that you've disclosed everything that you know to your knowledge. And if you go into a property and the agent is clearly telling you there is a conservatory and it doesn't have a consent, you need to declare that to the insurance.
5:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Do
5:38Megan Love: you ask for the disclosures from the agent as part of your insurance or a lending
5:44Zibunisa Olimova: area? Yeah. So often I know you guys usually attach it with sales and purchase agreements. There's usually like another disclosure document. And I know the bankers are looking through those as well. So it's part of our due diligence as well to make sure that we're passing on everything we can. Because we're a bit of a meat in the sandwich. Yeah,
6:02Megan Love: that's true. We
6:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): are between the
6:03Zibunisa Olimova: clients and the bankers and we're sort of at the mercy of whoever. But in if you've given us that, we cannot hide it.
6:11Megan Love: Yeah, we can't not see it.
6:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We
6:13Zibunisa Olimova: we can't unsee it.
6:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We're
6:15Megan Love: the same. We if we know about an issue, we have to disclose it. Yeah.
6:18Zibunisa Olimova: So we have to pass it on. Yeah. And as I say, like 99.9% Ninety-nine point nine percent of the time the bank's like, yep, sweet, let's go. Like that's not a big problem. Because some of the banks might already have the property on their records. It's already a problem.
6:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I already
6:31Megan Love: know.
6:31Zibunisa Olimova: Exactly. You know? So uh I think in your particular situation, if the buyers are raising those concerns, they haven't done enough due diligence.
6:40Megan Love: Yeah. I mean, I straight away said, Well, why don't you phone find out? The other thing we do is add a condition for insurance. And
6:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): we've
6:48Megan Love: had that a few times recently. Would that cover them? in the in this situation if there was an unconsented conservatory?
6:54Zibunisa Olimova: Yeah, absolutely. Look, if they've gone away, done their due diligence and realized that it's going to be way too hard to get insurance, then yes, they can pull out based on that clause. But if they haven't put that clause in, then it's going to be harder for them to pull out. But if they've got the finance clause, they can still pull out because finance is dependent on insurance.
7:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That's
7:10Megan Love: what I was thinking, because you can't get lending without insurance, can you? And it's not contents or colours. car insurance, it's house insurance,
7:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): right?
7:17Zibunisa Olimova: We are talking house insurance. Absolutely.
7:20Megan Love: Full replacement value.
7:21Zibunisa Olimova: Full replacement value. Yeah. And there are some sure calculators online that you can use. If if you're confused, reach out, we'll send you the link that will help you to calculate how much you should be insured for. Because the last thing you want to do is underinsure or overinsure. Yeah. I've seen a lot of people overinsure overinsuring. What they don't realize is that, yep, it looks great on paper. You've insured yourself for 700K. But if the house burns down and the assessor comes out and says, look, the house is only worth 500, you're only going to get 500, even though you've been insured for 700. Yeah.
7:53Megan Love: So
7:54Zibunisa Olimova: you've got to be careful there as well. You don't want to be overpaying for something that you're not going gonna to use.
7:58Megan Love: So maybe if in doubt, if there's anything complicated or un your you're unsure about, actually talk to a person.
8:06Zibunisa Olimova: Absolutely talk to a person. And this is where it really rubs me when you know all and and I get it, it's convenience, but there's so many companies online that just go, Oh yeah, just go online, click some buttons and you can get insurance and tickety boo, you know, and it's all good. But It's all good and it's cheap. It's cheap for a reason.
8:24Megan Love: Yeah.
8:24Zibunisa Olimova: You know, and we've seen it time and time again. when people buy those online insurances, it's cheap for them in that moment. They're saving a lot of money, but it's a big ticket item. You don't want to be cutting corners on the biggest purchase of your life.
8:39Megan Love: Yeah. And I mean half the time the questions that they ask you like, well, I hope I'm answering them right. But talking to somebody like yourself, you could say, Oh, in this case, what about this? Or in this case, what about that? Or what if I buy a new couch or if I have a piano? Yeah. Yeah.
8:54Zibunisa Olimova: Yeah, exactly. So so yeah, we often talk our clients through options. And because we've got a direct line with our insurer, I can always call them and be like, Hey, would you be able to do this and that? And uh and they're fantastic to deal with. So yeah, back to your clients' purchases for a moment. If there is an unconsented structure, we just need to understand a little bit. more. And 99.9% of the time we can insure the full house. It's just that unconsented structure may need to have certain further investigation of how we're going to insure it if we are.
9:25Megan Love: Amazing. Thank you so much.
9:27Zibunisa Olimova: Thank you for this question, Megan. Come back again. And that's a wrap on that Homeland Hub. Don't forget to hit subscribe and join me next time for more property tips and tricks. Your next smart move starts here.