Eli Schwartz argues SEO should measure revenue over traffic as AI reduces value of generic search terms
Summary
Eli Schwartz, author of Product-Led SEO, argues that traditional SEO metrics like rankings and traffic volume are becoming obsolete due to the rise of AI search platforms. He contends that businesses should shift focus to 'user empathy' and revenue, citing examples where losing low-quality traffic led to increased profits. Schwartz suggests that AI platforms like ChatGBT and Claude fulfill user intent without clicks, making generic keyword targeting less effective. He recommends redirecting large SEO budgets toward brand building or paid search, as content alone cannot justify high spend in an AI-dominated landscape.
Key takeaways
- 1 Schwartz lists LinkedIn, Anthropic, Tinder, Coinbase, and Shutterstock as companies he has consulted for, indicating his client base includes major tech and media entities.
Eli Schwartz · 1:33
- 2 A car insurance lead aggregator found that 40% of their conversions came from a specific demographic: women aged 30-40 in urban areas like New York City, contradicting their initial broad targeting.
Eli Schwartz · 4:02
- 3 Schwartz claims that AI platforms like ChatGBT, Claude, and DeepSeek know user attributes (age, gender, budget, current provider) because users plug in emails and bills, making generic keyword searches less effective for conversion.
Eli Schwartz · 4:51
- 4 He advises against targeting 'super top of funnel' keywords that AI Overviews can answer, stating that early adopters prefer getting information from AI rather than clicking through to websites.
Eli Schwartz · 8:18
Episode sections
- 0:10 – 1:21
Intro and Guest Background
Aneta Samkoff introduces the episode theme regarding SEO traffic decline and its potential positive impact on business metrics. She introduces guest Eli Schwartz, author of Product-Led SEO, noting his work with major tech companies.
- 1:21 – 3:40
User Empathy vs. Keyword Volume
Eli Schwartz argues that SEO has historically focused on vanity metrics like rankings rather than user empathy. He emphasizes understanding the specific buyer persona, citing examples from LinkedIn, Anthropic, Tinder, Coinbase, and Shutterstock.
- 3:40 – 4:33
Case Study: Car Insurance Lead Aggregator
Schwartz details a case study with a US car insurance lead aggregator. While the company initially targeted 'people with cars,' analysis revealed 40% of conversions came from women aged 30-40 in urban areas like NYC, highlighting the need for demographic-specific content over generic terms.
- 4:33 – 5:26
AI and the Decline of Generic Traffic
The speaker explains that AI platforms (ChatGBT, Claude, DeepSeek) possess rich user data (age, gender, budget), making generic search terms like 'car insurance' less valuable for conversion compared to long-tail, personalized prompts.
- 5:26 – 7:06
Revenue vs. Traffic as KPIs
Schwartz shares an experience at a company that lost significant spam-driven traffic due to Google algorithm updates but saw revenue increase. He argues that SEO performance should be measured by revenue, not rankings, as losing low-quality traffic can be beneficial.
- 7:06 – 11:13
AI Overviews and Zero-Click Searches
The discussion covers how AI Overviews fulfill user intent without clicks, meaning companies may maintain rankings but lose traffic. Schwartz suggests that if the user's wish is fulfilled by the AI overview, the lack of click-through is not a failure of SEO performance.
- 11:13 – 18:10
Blue Ocean SEO and User Empathy
To find 'Blue Ocean' opportunities, Schwartz advises against relying solely on keyword tools which lead to 'Red Ocean' competition. Instead, he recommends using user empathy to identify underserved niches, such as the car insurance example focusing on drivers with prior violations.
- 18:10 – 26:52
AI as a Brand Channel and Budget Allocation
Schwartz posits that SEO is becoming a brand channel, similar to billboards, where direct attribution is difficult. He suggests that a large SEO budget should be redirected to brand building or paid search, as content alone cannot effectively absorb a million-dollar spend in the short term.
Assets discussed
| Asset | Kind | Stance | Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| Anthropic | private company | mixed | The ones that I think were the most interesting projects. were your companies like LinkedIn, Anthropic, Tinder, Coinbase, Shutterstock. |
| AmazonAMZN | equity | neutral | So that's why Amazon will always be number one because it's a great user experience. They offer the most products. |
| AlphabetGOOGL | equity | neutral | So that's why Amazon will always be number one because it's a great user experience. They offer the most products. So they don't offer the product. Google is there's no risk to Google and showing Amazon. |
“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.
Claims worth verifying
Eli Schwartz has worked with LinkedIn, Anthropic, Tinder, Coinbase, and Shutterstock.
Eli Schwartz ·1:33
How to verify: Check Eli Schwartz's LinkedIn profile or professional portfolio for client case studies or endorsements from these companies. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
A car insurance lead aggregator found that 40% of conversions came from women between 30 and 40 living in urban areas like New York City.
Eli Schwartz ·4:22
How to verify: This is a specific anecdote; verification would require access to the specific company's internal conversion data or a published case study detailing this demographic split. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
AI platforms like ChatGBT, Claude, and DeepSeek know user attributes such as age, gender, car type, budget, and current insurance provider.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·4:50
How to verify: Review privacy policies and data collection practices of these AI platforms; verify via technical documentation or user account settings that show stored preferences. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
A company Schwartz worked with saw revenue increase after Google algorithm updates removed spammy content.
Eli Schwartz ·5:52
How to verify: This is a specific anecdote; verification would require the company's financial reports or public statements linking algorithm updates to revenue growth during that period. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
AI Overviews are causing traffic to drop while rankings remain stable for many sites.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·7:45
How to verify: Analyze third-party SEO data platforms (e.g., Semrush, Ahrefs, Moz) for trends in CTR (Click-Through Rate) vs. ranking positions for major keywords over the last 12-24 months. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
AI mode will likely become the default Google search experience.
Eli Schwartz ·26:00
How to verify: Monitor Google's official product announcements, press releases, and search interface updates for the rollout and default status of 'AI Mode' or 'Google AI Overviews. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Amazon remains number one in Google search results because it offers a great user experience and low risk for Google.
Eli Schwartz ·15:54
How to verify: Perform a search for common commercial terms on Google to observe if Amazon appears in the top position; review Google's patent filings or public statements regarding ranking factors for e-commerce. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceEli Schwartz wrote a book titled 'Product-Led SEO'.
Eli Schwartz ·1:21
How to verify: Search for the book 'Product-Led SEO' by Eli Schwartz on Amazon, Goodreads, or the publisher's website to confirm authorship and publication details. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Eli Schwartz's newsletter is located at productcloud.seo.com.
Eli Schwartz ·26:30
How to verify: Navigate to productcloud.seo.com to verify the existence of the newsletter and its association with Eli Schwartz. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
SurveyMonkey was Eli Schwartz's last full-time job.
Eli Schwartz ·6:46
How to verify: Check Eli Schwartz's LinkedIn profile under the 'Experience' section to confirm his employment history with SurveyMonkey. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify Eli Schwartz's client list and case studies via his company's website or LinkedIn profile to confirm the car insurance aggregator example.
- Check Google's official documentation on AI Overviews and Search Generative Experience (SGE) to understand how they impact click-through rates.
- Analyze your own web analytics to compare traffic volume vs. revenue trends following any algorithm updates, testing Schwartz's claim that low-quality traffic loss can boost profitability.
- Review competitor content strategies to see if they are shifting budget from SEO to brand building or paid search as suggested.
- Assess your own content's dependency on generic, top-of-funnel keywords that AI can answer, identifying potential risks if AI takes over those queries.
- Investigate the specific demographic data of your current conversions to validate the need for 'user empathy' over broad keyword targeting.
- Read 'Product-Led SEO' by Eli Schwartz to understand the methodology behind his 'user empathy' framework.
- Check recent industry reports on AI search adoption rates to gauge how quickly 'zero-click' searches are becoming the norm.
Full transcriptexpand
0:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): In
0:10Aneta Samkoff: fast-moving markets, growth isn't luck. It's Bill. Welcome to Odyssey Podcast, the High Stakes Growth Show. This is where operators, founders, and investors break down how businesses grow, compete and win in brutal markets. I'm Aneta Semkov. let's get into it. SEO traffic is falling. But what if losing it is actually good for your business? Eli Schwartz argues that much of the organic traffic SEOs are fighting to save was never worth having in the first place. In this episode, we talk about why Google updates can wipe out traffic while revenue goes up, why AI overviews and AI mode will keep taking more of the traditional search journey, and why SEO teams should be measured on revenue, not rankings or clicks. We also get into low volume, high converting keywords, blue ocean SEO opportunities, whether GEO is really anything
1:12new, and what Eli would do with a 1 million SEO budget. His answer, he wouldn't spend it on SEO. Let's get into it.
1:21Eli Schwartz: Today we're
1:21Aneta Samkoff: recording at Shenzhen SEO, and my guest is no other but Eli Schwartz, who's author of Product Led SEO and a consultant who worked with a lot of great companies. Can you name just a couple?
1:33Eli Schwartz: First of all, happy to be here. Excited to be here in Shenzhen. Uh The ones that I think were the most interesting projects. were your companies like LinkedIn, Anthropic, Tinder, Coinbase, Shutterstock. So the the bigger companies always have the more interesting problems, which we'll we'll dive into.
1:49Aneta Samkoff: Yes, because we have a a controversial topic for today. SEO traffic is dying, and you think that might be actually good for business. You actually stated that the SEO traffic will decline, will continue to decline, and in many cases it should. What traffic are you happy to lose?
2:07Eli Schwartz: So I think that many people have done SEO incorrectly. The focus has always been on keywords and rankings and the vanity aspects of SEO without really get digging into and understanding the users behind it. So my whole approach is around user empathy and understanding. of the user. So it's not a user focus and saying that I'm a user-centric or I the user is at the center of my strategy. I really, really always put the user, the buyer, the person we're going to generate some sort of conversion from at the really at the center of that strategy, which means deeply understanding them. So no matter what the scenario is and what the client is, I have to understand the product. So I buy it. I worked with a company
2:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): where
2:55Eli Schwartz: the founder wrote a book. I read her book. I signed up for her product. I worked with a company that sold uh vintage to me used women's clothing. I didn't understand it, but I did my best to ask questions, and this is pre-AI, to ask questions to understand the mindset. So I wasn't going to make assumptions that maybe. when it came to something that was pre-used, the focus was going to be on cheap. So therefore I was going
3:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
3:21Eli Schwartz: say cheap, whatever it was. I really understood the mindset behind it. So it was actually the focus was unique. So when understanding the empathy part of it, understanding the buyers, they didn't care that it was that it was used or that it was vintage. It was the fact that it was hard to find. So they were looking for something that was unique. So many people have been doing SEO without looking at that at all. They were just focused on the keyword. One of my favorite conversations in the last couple of years was with a company that they uh are a lead aggregator for car insurance. So when I asked them who their buyer was, they're focused on the United States. Who
3:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): their
3:54Eli Schwartz: buyer was, they said people with cars. So I said, kept asking, and they're like, Nope, everyone with cars. Where
4:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): do
4:02Eli Schwartz: they? live? They live in the United States. What kind of cars? They have cars. But I kept going and I kept saying, why would someone use you? Where do you generate the most revenue? And by digging into that, someone finally piped up and said, Well, there's women between 30 and 40 that live in urban areas like New York City. 40% of their conversions came from that. So suddenly, instead of having a page that that's just focused on the word car insurance, 40% of their conversions came from a very, very specific demographic. That also led into what kind of keywords we should think about.
4:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
4:33Eli Schwartz: when I say it's good SEO is dying, it's because well SEO should not die, but it's good that SEO traffic is declining. It's because this kind of thing is no longer effective anymore. When someone searches car insurance on Google or ChatGBT or Claude or DeepSeek or whatever platform they're using,
4:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the platform
4:51Eli Schwartz: knows that their age, their gender, their kind of car they're looking for, what their budget is, who their current insurance provider is, because all of it's there, right? We plugged in all of our emails, they know who you pay a bill to every month. So it's not about car insurance, it's about that long prompt. So the word car insurance, Terms, if you Google that or uh Gemini it or ChatGBT it, you're gonna get a definition. But that's no longer converting term.
5:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
5:16Eli Schwartz: that kind of traffic should never have existed, but that goes away.
5:19Aneta Samkoff: So if a company loses like 40% of its organic traffic but revenue stays flat,
5:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
5:26Aneta Samkoff: lot of people would say, oh, probably the performance of SEO declined. But is it really the case?
5:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
5:32Eli Schwartz: performance of SEO declined because that's the way they measured themselves. There was a company I worked with in the past, they had two aspects. of their company. They had a a part of their company that produced some horrible spam, like really, really bad spam at scale, programmatically. And then they had a part of the company that generated great revenue without spam. Every time there was a Google Algo update, they lost portions of spam, like significant amounts of spam, but the revenue went up. So I had to recenter the way they thought about SEO to revenue because Google algo updates. were good. They were good
6:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): for the
6:04Eli Schwartz: bottom line. Bad if you were measuring rankings and traffic. So if you're measuring rankings and traffic, SEO performance, like you said, is declining. That's not a it's not a happy meeting if that's the way you're being judged. It is a fantastic meeting if the revenue that comes out of it has gone up or stayed flat. Because then you can point to it and say, look,
6:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): our
6:23Eli Schwartz: traffic declined, but our revenue is the same, or our revenue's even gone up.
6:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
6:26Eli Schwartz: that's something I learned accidentally where uh my last full-time job I was working at SurveyMonkey and I had to send these weekly reports. And a lot of times there was nothing to say. But I would be able to send a report saying there's been a Google algo update. We're good. We survived. Traffic is the same. So that was positive. So being able to turn nothings into positives is the same way SEO should be focused and say look we lost 40% of our traffic. but we make more money. We make the same amount of money.
6:53Aneta Samkoff: How do you determine whether the traffic you lose to AI overviews was of low value, like informational traffic, or actually commercially valuable or a mix of both?
7:06Eli Schwartz: It's much easier for me to determine because I'm an outsider. So I come into companies as an outsider and I say, Oh great, you lost all your terrible traffic. Now someone is tied to that, someone is very disappointed. They built the content, they reported
7:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): on
7:18Eli Schwartz: the rankings. They're not happy. So
7:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
7:22Eli Schwartz: takes an honest look. As an outsider, I can take an honest look. As an insider or an agency that has worked on this, it's hard to have that honest look. Okay. So it's really like again for a car insurance company, if you've lost car insurance, you didn't deserve it to begin with. If you lost something important, that would be a problem.
7:40Aneta Samkoff: But how do you determine it if you're the insider?
7:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
7:43Eli Schwartz: need to take that honest look. You need to
7:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): say,
7:45Eli Schwartz: did we really deserve that traffic? And in many cases, and this is something I see very frequently, the traffic is gone. It has disappeared. However, the company is still where it was. They're still at position two, position five, even position one. But no one clicks because the answer is now in an AIR. AI overview. So nothing has changed from their performance. It has changed from the user standpoint. The user is getting their wishes fulfilled in a better way.
8:12Aneta Samkoff: Which categories of keywords would you recommend for companies to stop fighting for?
8:18Eli Schwartz: Anything that's super top of funnel. So as a uh as a user, I mean I'm sure you're doing the same thing I'm doing. We're we we're tech board and we do things as early adopters. So as a user, I'm getting everything top a funnel from an AI overview. I want it from an AI overview. I don't want it coming from having to click results. So anything that you think an AI overview could answer, that's probably something that you're going to want to not focus on.
8:46Aneta Samkoff: So many SEOs believe that the mid-funnel uh queries and commercial searches are protected from AI overviews. And we're okay to lose it, like just going uh we prefer even just as you said. But what changes when AI answers actually will start bringing more comparisons, recommendations, and evaluations? Is that a risk?
9:09Eli Schwartz: Uh Absolutely. If it's something that you think AI could be answering for you and it doesn't do it today. it probably will do it in the very near future. So where we are, we have the worst AI we will ever have right now, and it's always going to improve. So maybe we don't have AI mode as default, but eventually we will have AI mode as default. And and that's the way I would think about it. If AI can do it, it will take it away from you. So just don't focus on today, focus on where the capabilities are going.
9:36Aneta Samkoff: So if uh traffic is uh no longer good KPI to report, what what should teams report?
9:43Eli Schwartz: It should be revenue, but it should be a logical buyer's journey. So traffic can be included and say we're getting we're visible here, we're getting clicks, and it's turning into revenue. So ideally you're measuring your SEO channel by revenue, but you can report on how that traffic turns into revenue. And if it doesn't, if it creates this parallel channel or parallel path and say, oh, this does not. convert then why would you even bother
10:05Aneta Samkoff: and you gave us the um example of the organic big organic traffic that actually didn't bring revenue to the uh car insurance company can you give us an opposite example of real relatively low organic traffic that brings a lot of revenue
10:21Eli Schwartz: so there are things that a company will do that that's very very specific to their brand So it could be a branded keyword or it could be their product keyword. Sometimes those aren't measured in keyword tools. However, that's going to be their best converting term. So if we're focusing on conversions, it should be that low valve the low volume, perfect thing that's just for what they do. So when someone searches it, they're the best fit. So it could be there actually there's it was a this is a current car chair insurance and this example from a very, very long time ago. This it was a lead aggregator again. They were very good at like problematic car insurance, like people that had problems with their driving. And that's where they got the most conversions. Now, if you looked at any keyword tool, there was no volume for people that had previous drunk driving or lots of problems with their driving. However, that's what they converted at. So I encouraged encourage them to do more of that and drive more conversions because they were good at that.
11:13Aneta Samkoff: But like if every SEO team uses the same tools, like sees the same keywords, and studies the same competitors, we're being pushed toward Red Ocean. How do we find these blue ocean opportunities?
11:30Eli Schwartz: So it it's a challenge because you have to convince the people asking you for these things to let you be in a blue ocean. But let's say you're able to accomplish that and you can convince
11:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the colour.
11:39Eli Schwartz: them that there's another path. Sometimes the easiest way to convince them there's another path is it all goes to zero. Once it's at zero, everyone's willing to just try anything. So say you're able to convince them you should be focused on a blue ocean. That's where user empathy comes in. That's where deeply understanding your users and saying, look, this is what our users want, or this is what our users are already doing. We don't have the content for it, we're not focused on it. Let's do that. and now we will have the visibility and get the clicks. So say Blue Ocean is for this car insurance company, focused on the problematic drivers. That's their Blue Ocean. They already knew it worked. No one else did it. They just had to be convinced that they should give it a try.
12:18Aneta Samkoff: So would you say actually there is like one playbook you could apply to different niches for searching for blue ocean opportunities? or it has to be case by case?
12:29Eli Schwartz: No, no, no. If there was one playbook, SEO would truly be dead. So I think, especially with AI, what AI is doing is it's lifting the floor. Everyone has to have the basics now. So content needs to be very good. You are assumed to understand your customers, you're assumed to have good landing pages. So now we need to better understand our customers. And that's where user empathy comes in. If you understand your customers, it's not what you do well at, it's what you do uniquely good at. Like I my business was founded for this purpose, and I am the right solution for this, and therefore I'm gonna do my SEO and all my marketing around it. It's one of the most interesting things I see when I talk to companies where they do something, like let's say they're a startup. they're able to raise money because they came up with some sort of innovation
13:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
13:18Eli Schwartz: they got millions of dollars. But then when it comes to their SEO, they're just generic. Yeah. So I need to convince them, like, do that thing, do that thing that was in your pitch deck. That should be your marketing. And then they'll respond and say, But there's no search fine.
13:31Aneta Samkoff: And
13:31Eli Schwartz: I'm like, there was not necessarily a business that wanted to do what you did, but you convinced someone to give you money. Do your SEO around that. If you are passionate. about it, if you have the conviction that people want what you're doing, create your SEO around that.
13:45Aneta Samkoff: But how do you actually distinguish if the keyword you're targeting that has like no volume is the genuinely blue ocean opportunity, or it actually does not have the this strategic? technique.
13:59Eli Schwartz: It's a business thing. So I'm not
14:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): even
14:00Eli Schwartz: thinking about is there search volume, is it a blue
14:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): thing?
14:03Eli Schwartz: ocean search volume? I'm thinking, is this what the business is meant to do? Is this what the business is already converting customers at? So if you don't have conviction about the business, then we shouldn't do blue oceans. But if you are of conviction about your business, and again, let's keep with the car insurance, they had they didn't have conviction. It worked. They already knew that this is who was converting for them, then there was almost no risk in doing that for SEO. They ultimately didn't do it. So if anybody wants to steal that business, go for it. But it's it's not that you're defining a blue ocean for SEO. It's that you're matching what the business already does. And that's again a failure of most SEO teams where the business does one thing, let's say it's SaaS. The business solves a very particular SaaS problem, and then SEO is generic. They're using generic SaaS keywords like payment portal or you know analytics tool.
14:51Aneta Samkoff: Does AI make uh this problem worse?
14:54Eli Schwartz: Finding blue oceans? So AI makes everything worse and AI and makes everything better. So the way AI makes everything worse is is unfortunately there are going to be some people that are gonna watch it, listen to this podcast, and like, all right, I'm not asking users anything. I'm gonna go to AI and I'm gonna say, develop an ICP for me. Now, how does this ICP think? Now
15:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that's
15:14Eli Schwartz: that's a shortcut. That's you take that shortcut, you can build stuff, you can pretend you know your customer, but you don't. The real way to know your customer is to know your customer. So AI makes it worse because we think there's a shortcut, but it also makes it better because one of my favorite things about AI is it creates diversity for brands. So one challenge Google has always had is that Google needs to only show brands, show the best brands and search results because they care about spam and they care about user experience. So that's why Amazon will always be number one because it's a great user experience. They offer the most products. So they don't offer the product. Google is there's no risk to Google and showing Amazon. When it comes to AI, they can show one particular website, and if they get it wrong, and that website does doesn't ship the product, steals the customer's money, it's only one person. So Google and ChatGPT and Claude and DeepSeek are able to have more diversity because the risk is lower. So that's
16:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): my
16:12Eli Schwartz: favorite part of that. Everything with AI. So diversity grows is a better experience for users, but for marketers they're gonna get lazy.
16:20Aneta Samkoff: What can a company build that uh chat GPT or other LLMs cannot just generate as an answer?
16:30Eli Schwartz: So ChatGPT or Google or any LLM can't generate services and experiences. So one of the things that, like, you know, we're in China. I did a lot of searching before I came to China. It couldn't do the things. It couldn't get me the visa. It could tell me a lot about visas. It couldn't get me to the destinations I wanted to do. It could tell me about them. So if you're in an information publication niche, you probably will lose traffic to AI. However, if you're in a delivery niche where you deliver products and services, again it could be a service too, a plumber is not going to get disrupted by AI. They're going to get their information will get disrupted by AI. How to do things will get disrupted by AI. Their business actually might decline in a different way. Like there are things that I do in my house that I use AI that I might have hired a professional for. Well, maybe those things were so easy that I should have always been doing it, but plumbers took advantage because no one knew how to do it. If it's beyond my capabilities, there's still demand for that product. Now the plumber will lose traffic. If I don't know a lot of plumbers that measure their traffic, but they'll lose traffic.
17:39So that's where all of this changes. If you are providing products and services, your products and services are still in demand, but it happens in a second level. After I've discovered that I can't do that thing, or I'm now more educated, that's when I go to the service provider.
17:57Aneta Samkoff: And there is the big debate in SEO community now where half of them are essential. selling uh GEO, another half believes it's just good SEO. Where do you stand on that debate?
18:10Eli Schwartz: Neither. Like I said, I
18:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): think mo
18:11Eli Schwartz: most people didn't do I I think a lot of what you do for AEO GEO is based is SEO best practices. But I think most people weren't doing SEO correctly because they weren't focused on the user. So if you're doing SEO incorrectly, now you're very excited because you have this new thing to do incorrectly. And still sell prompts and still sell visibility. But if you're doing SEO correctly, I don't know, and I've been doing been in this industry for a long time. I don't know anybody that said, oh no, our jobs are dead because now people can Google on phones. Oh no, our jobs are dead because people can speak to Google in their Tesla. It changes. AI is a different interface and it's a great interface for users. However, if you weren't focused on using users to begin with and all you cared about was measuring your keywords, which, as we discussed, might not have even driven revenue, your job has changed. So then you get excited by this new thing where SEO is dead. I'm now an AEO GEO specialist because you have something else to sell and confuse people by. Don't do that.
19:07Aneta Samkoff: So actually whether your brand gets cited by LLMs, but uh you don't get referral traffic from it. How do you decide whether it has any value that visibility has value?
19:20Eli Schwartz: So another one of my favorite things about AI is that marketing is now a full cross-functional effort. So I've been in-house and I've worked with a lot of teams. A lot of times it's marketing teams, sometimes it's product teams. And the marketing team does one thing, and
19:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): then
19:38Eli Schwartz: SEO. team does a completely different thing. So let's say the performance marketing team, paid search, they have their keywords they know they need to buy. And I've never met a paid search marketer who says, Look how many impressions I get. I'm number one for all these terms. Or look at all the clicks. I've never seen them do that. They talk in language of LTV and CAC and all really performance metrics. And then we have SEO, it's like, I'm focused only on being number one. I don't know how many people click. I don't care how many people click because you haven't known how many people clicked in a long time because when you know people click, but you don't know how many people convert because all that went away. So now the metrics move and in order to really show that you're providing value to the marketing team, we need to think about marketing. So I think it's great that SEO teams are going to create and help create visibility, but it's a brand channel. So being visible and having your brand visible is good as a branding effort, and now you're supporting the brand team because you'll never know whether someone actually clicked that result. Google
20:43will give some sort of fake fluffy report, but we don't know. So we need to think about it from a marketing standpoint. So it's good to be there if it's some sort of follow-up action. So one of the things that I do with every client I work with is come up with their their search user journey.
20:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now
20:58Eli Schwartz: I've worked with B2B companies and they don't have a search user journey. So I'll keep asking, like, okay, what makes someone search? Oh, they don't search. Then I'm like, so why are we having this conversation? Why would you want to hire me? And I usually tell them not to do SEO. Why would you want to have someone provide an SEO strategy? if every way I've asked this question you told me that it's not a performing channel for you? You drive performance from salespeople, you drive performance from going to events, you drive performance from advertising, but you can't envision why someone's gonna search for you. Why would you invest in this channel? So I I think this this is really important to really go through this year's journey and find out how it's gonna work. So now you asked about brand visibility. If I have if I'm visible in an LM and they say, Well, now that the LLM suggested me, the next thing that is likely to happen is someone might say my brand versus another brand, or go directly to my website. If that makes sense to you, that's good brand visibility, not measurable, but good.
21:58If you say, Well, I don't know, now they know we exist, then why would you invest in that channel? And just to add on to this point, if it's a brand channel, I've again I've worked with many, many marketers. I've never met a brand marketer who got their company to spend a lot of money on a billboard or a radio ad or a TV ad and just said, I did it. They usually have follow-up questions of like, Well, how'd it work for you? So this is a brand channel. You need to have that, like we got, I don't know, estimated number of eyeballs. direct traffic groups, something had to have happened.
22:30Aneta Samkoff: It's but it's very difficult nowadays to track
22:33Eli Schwartz: Impossible.
22:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Exactly,
22:34Aneta Samkoff: impossible.
22:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You would
22:35Eli Schwartz: just have to be able to at least have that logical conversation on how it it would benefit you.
22:39Aneta Samkoff: Although you cannot provide the hard numbers.
22:42Eli Schwartz: Cannot. We
22:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): won't be
22:43Eli Schwartz: able to.
22:43Aneta Samkoff: So if you had a million dollar SEO budget for the full year today, um where would you put the first hundred K? How would you divide it? And what would you totally refuse to fund?
22:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): If
22:57Eli Schwartz: I had a million-dollar budget, I would probably become really good friends with the brand team and give all the money to them. Because the bigger a brand is, the more likely they'll perform with search. I I used to ask this as an interview question. I don't know how to spend a million dollars on SEO.
23:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
23:13Eli Schwartz: write content, but content is in value. So maybe hire the smartest employee, but I don't think there's any direct way to spend a million dollars on SEO effectively without it going towards people. I would do it on and again, assuming that the company, the million dollars is meaningful to them, I would spend it on brand, maybe paid search, because again, that's going to build that entire brand funnel. The interview question I used to ask was if you have a million dollars and you have four. days until the end of the quarter, how do you spend it? And because I was interviewing SEO people, they usually came up with something really dumb. And then I would say, okay, um can you write content in four days? And they'd be like, oh okay maybe I won't cut. So all the things, my my point was I wanted to see how creative they were. I didn't want an SEO answer. And I I got sometimes the people I hired had great answers. One person said they were gonna fly over to the Super Bowl. and they were gonna drop
24:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
24:04Eli Schwartz: with their logo on it. I'm like that's a great use of again for assuming that something happens is a great use of million dollars with four days into the end of the quarter.
24:13Aneta Samkoff: Yes. I
24:14Eli Schwartz: don't know a way to do it on on SEO.
24:16Aneta Samkoff: Yeah, four days that's a really short time paid search. Even
24:20Eli Schwartz: and Ray, so I once got that as an answer. I'm like, can you spend a million dollars on paid search? Like yeah, as much as Google wants to take your money. they won't allow you to say the the click should be fifty cents, but
24:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'll
24:30Eli Schwartz: let you pay ten dollars because you really want to give me money.
24:33Aneta Samkoff: Yeah, it really depends on your click, right?
24:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Exactly. So you
24:36Eli Schwartz: it's hard. So that that was my point. I wanted to
24:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
24:38Eli Schwartz: wanted the creative answers.
24:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh, so that
24:40Eli Schwartz: would be, you know, I someone said uh they were gonna put a logo on a an airplane, like stuff
24:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): like
24:46Eli Schwartz: cost money. Maybe it was good, maybe it wasn't. I just wanted out out-of-the-box of
24:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
24:48Eli Schwartz: box answers.
24:49Aneta Samkoff: Yeah, awesome. So what is the biggest uh mindset shift that you think SEOs should take coming into 2027?
25:00Eli Schwartz: It's a mindset shift that I've been promoting for the last six years since I wrote my book. It's really about building experiences around users, deeply understanding your users. So when when marketers, not just SEOs, take off. their their uh their business hat and now they become consumers, we know how we want to experience technology. We know how we want to experience LLMs, and it's not the way we create content for it. We would not be consuming our own content. We want fast answers, we don't want gamed LLM responses. I have definitely, since AI came onto the scene, walked into places that had great reviews recommended by Reddit. from the LLM and discovered that it was gamed and it did not deserve the great reviews. As consumers, we don't want this. So align yourself with consumers. Think about how would a consumer look for this? And that's the way that we should be marketing. And again, not just SEO. And that's the big mindset shift. Because AI is going to continue to improve. It's going to get better. Traffic will continue to decline because inevitably, as AI gets better, it will go away. I think ultimately AI mode will become the default Google search experience.
26:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
26:08Eli Schwartz: there's nothing that we can do to stop that. So just figure out where do you fit in that journey after AI mode gives that comparison, after AI mode tells you the story, where do you add value?
26:19Aneta Samkoff: Awesome. Thank you so much, Eli, for this conversation. And if you enjoyed this episode, then don't hesitate to subscribe and like and try. channel. And to learn more, follow Eli on LinkedIn and
26:30Eli Schwartz: subscribe to my newsletter, productcloud.seo.com.
26:33Aneta Samkoff: Exactly. Thank you so much, Eli.
26:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Thank
26:35Eli Schwartz: you for having me.
26:35Aneta Samkoff: That's it for this episode of Odyssey Podcast, The High Stakes Growth Show. Follow us, leave a review, and share the show with someone who plays to win. Stay curious, Yes, stay ahead.