AI adoption in legal billing and real estate ethics discussed alongside property disclosure obligations
Summary
Michael and Patty discuss how AI tools are changing professional billing models, citing reports that 80% of lawyers now use AI, which challenges traditional hourly billing structures. They highlight ethical risks in real estate, including trespassing on unsafe properties and the prohibition against buyer's agents directing clients to use listing agents. The hosts emphasize the importance of accurate Property Condition Disclosure Statements (PCDS) and warn that hiding defects leads to litigation. They advise using counter offers to resolve PCDS discrepancies rather than pursuing lawsuits, stressing transparency to protect reputation.
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 2:15
Intro and AI Safety Warning
Michael and Patty discuss the local weather and Halloween costumes. Michael introduces a story about Meta's new AI assistant 'Muse' which accidentally shared a seller's home address and invited strangers over for tea during a test, highlighting safety risks.
- 2:15 – 3:42
Lawyers and AI Billing Models
Michael cites CNBC reporting that 80% of lawyers use AI, raising questions about hourly billing models when AI completes research in minutes that previously took hours. Patty discusses the ethical and practical dilemma of billing for time saved by automation.
- 3:42 – 10:08
Dangerous Property Showings and Trespassing
Patty recounts a listing where the house was structurally unsound and filled with fungus. She instructed agents not to enter, but two agents brought clients inside anyway, resulting in clients falling through the floor. Patty asserts this constitutes trespassing and warns agents to respect safety boundaries.
- 10:08 – 13:09
AI for Counter Offers and Valuation
Michael describes using AI (Claude) to convert handwritten notes into a formal counter-offer and to perform a comparative market analysis on an overpriced listing. Patty cautions that AI provides educational starting points but lacks the nuance of a professional appraisal.
- 13:09 – 19:16
Ethics of Buyer's Agents Using Listing Agents
The hosts discuss the ethics of a buyer's agent instructing a client to view a property through the listing agent to save time. Patty explains this violates the PEI Real Estate Association's Standards of Professional Excellence, as it undermines the buyer's representation and creates ethical conflicts.
- 19:16 – 28:47
Conflicts of Interest in Dual Agency
Michael shares a story of dropping a listing due to extreme conflict when two buyers from different agents within the same brokerage wanted to offer simultaneously. Patty advises listing agents to refer competing buyers to separate representation to avoid liability and maintain ethical standards.
- 28:47 – 31:56
Market Changes and Litigation Risks
The hosts attribute increased litigation and stricter documentation to the influx of out-of-province buyers and unlicensed agents post-COVID. They note a shift from handshake deals to formal, documented transactions to protect against lawsuits.
- 31:56 – 32:50
Property Condition Disclosure Statements (PCDS)
Michael explains that a PCDS is a checklist of property issues like water, roof, and electrical systems. He notes that sellers must update this form if defects are discovered during the listing process and must re-initialize it to confirm accuracy.
- 32:50 – 34:06
Handling Defects and Counter Offers
Patty advises sellers to use counter offers to correct discrepancies in the PCDS rather than suing buyers. She emphasizes keeping documents updated and using kindness to resolve issues, such as disclosing a known septic system problem.
- 34:06 – 36:24
Ethical Disclosure and Reputation
Michael argues that hiding known defects, like a failing septic system, leads to lawsuits and damages the seller's reputation. He suggests sellers disclose known issues with cost estimates and have buyers sign an acknowledgment.
- 36:24 – 37:44
Podcast Wrap-Up and Future Topics
The hosts conclude the episode, thanking listeners and promoting their podcast 'MAPS PEI'. Patty mentions upcoming 'Toolbox Tuesdays' covering topics like removing tenants or roommates in Prince Edward Island.
Claims worth verifying
CNBC reports that 80% of lawyers are now using AI.
Michael ·2:15
How to verify: Search CNBC's website or archives for articles from late 2026 containing the statistic '80% of lawyers use AI'. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
AI can complete legal research in 16 minutes that previously took 20 lawyers three weeks to do.
Patty ·2:29
How to verify: This is a hypothetical example cited by the speaker; verify the plausibility by checking legal tech case studies or AI performance benchmarks for legal research from 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The property Patty listed was filled with mossy fungus and had compromised floor integrity.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·5:04
How to verify: This is a specific anecdote; verify by checking PEI Real Estate Association disciplinary records or news reports regarding Patty Castle's listings and safety incidents in late 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Two agents brought clients into the unsafe property despite instructions not to enter, and clients fell through the floor.
Patty ·6:24
How to verify: Check for any formal complaints filed with the PEI Real Estate Association or legal records involving trespassing or negligence related to Patty Castle's listings. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
PEI Real Estate Association's Standards of Professional Excellence prohibit buyer's agents from suggesting clients view properties through listing agents.
Patty ·16:43
How to verify: Access the PEI Real Estate Association's official website and review the 'Standards of Professional Excellence' or Code of Ethics for current and past versions. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceReal estate licensing is provincial in Canada, and no provincial statutes require a property to be shown before an offer is written.
Michael ·18:02
How to verify: Review the 'Real Estate Trading Act' and regulations for PEI, Ontario, BC, Alberta, and Nova Scotia to confirm if any statute mandates property inspection prior to offer submission. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Michael dropped a listing because two buyers from agents within the same brokerage wanted to offer simultaneously.
Patty ·20:19
How to verify: This is a personal anecdote; verify by checking if Michael's brokerage has public records of dropped listings or if Michael has discussed this specific incident in other public forums. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
There was an increase in licensed real estate agents post-COVID who were not properly educated.
Michael ·30:25
How to verify: Search for data from the PEI Real Estate Association or other provincial bodies on the number of new agent registrations between 2026 and 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
A Property Condition Disclosure Statement (PCDS) is a checklist regarding property problems like water, roof, and electrical systems.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·31:56
How to verify: Review Prince Edward Island real estate transaction forms and PCDS guidelines provided by the PEI Real Estate Association or provincial government resources. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Sellers must re-initialize the Property Condition Disclosure Statement if defects are discovered during the listing process to confirm the information is current.
Patty ·32:50
How to verify: Check PEI real estate contract templates and standard forms for clauses requiring seller acknowledgment of updated disclosure statements. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Hiding known property defects, such as a failing septic system, can lead to lawsuits after closing.
Michael ·34:06
How to verify: Search Prince Edward Island court records for real estate disclosure litigation or review legal advice columns from PEI real estate lawyers regarding misrepresentation. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
A hypothetical septic system deficiency could require $35,000 for an engineered replacement system.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·35:55
How to verify: This is a hypothetical example stated by the speaker; verify typical costs for engineered septic systems in PEI through local septic contractors or provincial environmental ministry guidelines. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The podcast is produced by MAPS PEI.
Patty ·36:32
How to verify: Visit the MAPS PEI website or social media channels to confirm their association with 'The Michael and Patty Real Estate Show'. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceDo your own research
- Verify the CNBC report on lawyer AI usage statistics to confirm the 80% figure.
- Review the PEI Real Estate Association's Standards of Professional Excellence for specific prohibitions on agent conduct.
- Check local property condition disclosure statement (PCDS) requirements and legal obligations for defect updates.
- Research recent real estate litigation trends in Prince Edward Island post-2020.
- Confirm the structural integrity and safety protocols for vacant properties before entry.
- Review contract clauses regarding dual agency and conflict of interest disclosures.
- Investigate the capabilities and limitations of AI tools like Claude for real estate valuation.
- Check for any regulatory changes regarding unlicensed agent activity in the local market.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:00
- Michael: Hello, everybody, and welcome to the Michael and Patty Show. I'm Michael.
- 0:03
- Patty: And I'm Patty.
- 0:04
- Michael: And we're looking out on a very vacant Charlottetown waterfront yacht club. It looks like pretty well 100% of the boats have been removed for the water in preparation for the winter. It's a beautiful sixteen degrees and sunny here in uh towards the end of October. Halloween's coming up soon. What are
- 0:24
- Michael: you going out as? I
- 0:25
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Real
- 0:25
- Michael: Estate Broker?
- 0:26
- Patty: Yeah. it's pretty funny. I usually do dress up every every Halloween. I have since my kids were little. I used to surprise them every year.
- 0:33
- Michael: Well, there you go. So we're gonna get right into it here. We're gonna start with AI Corner. AI, even in the last week, has invol has evolved into so much. Recently, Meta has released their new Muse personal assistant, which will apparently do everything for. you, including if you're going to sell
- 0:53
- Michael: something, for instance, on Marketplace, you can put it on there, or more appropriately, have Muse put the item for sale on there. In fact, from what I saw on CBC this morning, I think it was on YouTube, Muse will even tell the buyer it's available, give them your home address and invite them over for tea.
- 1:11
- Patty: That is not good.
- 1:13
- Michael: That's what actually happened. He he was doing an experiment to allow AI to run his life and gave it basically cartbotch to
- 1:22
- Michael: basically run the whole process of selling this item. And and of course, uh News was quite friendly and said, Here's where I live, come on over and pick up the item and announce to him the seller. Aaron
- 1:32
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Powell
- 1:33
- Patty: Yeah, so you still have to use AI with caution and be mindful of things like that because now it's fine that, you know, it was a little bit of a light story, but it's also very serious because if you are somebody who, regardless of gender, i it that could be very dangerous. So
- 1:53
- Patty: use with caution is what I would say.
- 1:55
- Michael: With supervision. Next, CNBC. Switching over from CBC, the Canadian broadcaster. Broadcasting Corporation here in Canada, to CNBC, the business network in the U.S., says 80% of lawyers are now using AI, and they're a bit of a conundrum, or a can
- 2:15
- Michael: or there's a bit of a concern here because their whole business model is based on an hourly fee for work done. So, Patty, what are they going to do when they can take a job that took 20 lawyers three weeks? to do and AI can do it in 16 minutes?
- 2:29
- Patty: Yeah, and it is something. How do you bill? Because say this particular case in the past, prior to being able to utilize a tool like AI,
- 2:39
- Patty: would maybe be six to eight hours worth of research and putting things together as part of your representation. But now if they can put it through AI and it's completed in sometimes 15 minutes or so you'd have everything. And because there's going to be a little bit of back and forth, even give the grace of thirty
- 2:59
- Patty: minutes, because you might have to input and provide some answers in that, how do you how do you bill for that? Well
- 3:06
- Michael: that's going to be a good question. I would think they'd probably still bill for the full hourly
- 3:11
- Patty: So this say in this example, it would be
- 3:14
- Michael: joking.
- 3:15
- Patty: Yeah. Don't
- 3:16
- Michael: you know the lawyer's joke? If you can't bill twenty four hours in a day, you're not a very good lawyer.
- 3:21
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): No,
- 3:21
- Patty: I didn't know that joke.
- 3:22
- Michael: That's maybe it's an inside lawyer's joke that some of my lawyer friends told me, but that was the joke. If you couldn't b I think if you couldn't bill thirty, forty hours in a day you weren't a very good lawyer. On to other things. Actually this morning we we had a discussion because we were traveling a fair distance. and Patty had a property listed,
- 3:42
- Michael: and the property, the house was in complete disarray
- 3:46
- Michael: in the sense that it was going to implode on itself. It was going to rot into the foundation. Congratulations on getting that high-end listing, by the
- 3:54
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): way.
- 3:55
- Michael: And her instructions to the agents showing the property was: do not go inside the house. You do not have permission to. do so. And Patty indicated to them that it would be considered trespassing if they went into the house because they're only granted permission to walk the lands.
- 4:12
- Patty: That's not quite how the story went.
- 4:14
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well, why
- 4:14
- Michael: don't you tell us the story then? Aaron
- 4:15
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Powell
- 4:15
- Patty: Yes.
- 4:16
- Patty: So the house used to be a a sweet little spot. It wasn't always
- 4:22
- Patty: No, actually. it really was a sweet spot. And unfortunately.
- 4:27
- Patty: it turned into an estate sale. And then the family wanted to get as much money out of it. They did have an offer on the property, which the family turned down because they wanted more money out of it, because everyone has their hands in the pot, unfortunately, with estates. And the sad s part of
- 4:47
- Patty: this is that it never ended up generating. a an offer. This place was uh loitered, it was broken into, it was, I was back and forth with RCMP on this property. So it started to,
- 5:04
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 5:04
- Patty: guess, rot out. And I knew the floor, the integrity of the floor, because I'd been down in the basement my one last time, and it was filled with like. a mossy fungus. It was not a safe place any any longer, and the house was rotting because it just sat vacant for so long.
- 5:24
- Patty: And the showings, I did have this listed. I did make it very clear to every showing agent who requested to go in because it seemed like a steal of a deal, and every buyer wanted to, oh, I'll be able to, you know, refurbish this property and just do some. renovations. They didn't realize the undertaking. It would have been fine if they had purchased it earlier,
- 5:44
- Patty: but now that years had gone by, unfortunately, this is the condition that the property was in. So very specific instructions that I had said, you can uh, you know, I understand your clients want to see the property. They can look at the property, they can look at the structure through the windows. I was very explicit on this. You could
- 6:04
- Patty: look through the windows, but you cannot because the floors are compromised, you cannot enter this this property. You cannot enter the the structure. And they chose to go in anyways. They disregarded I had it documented. They went into this property anyways with their
- 6:24
- Patty: client to look and I had two separate agents that sent me a little bit of a complaint text message saying that they they went in and their client's foot went through the floor and that they also almost went through the floor. And so I called them up and I said, You were
- 6:44
- Patty: instructed to not go inside of this this property. There was a reason. Well, my client still wanted to get in. And I said, it doesn't matter what your client wants to do. This house is is structurally compromised and it's dangerous to go inside. And that's why I said that. And then they still were trying to point fingers at
- 7:04
- Patty: me, like what was I going to do because I allowed them into the home or this happened to them as a result of them taking their own initiative to go through this home.
- 7:16
- Patty: I instead of accepting responsibility because I know I did what I was supposed to do, and that was do not go inside of this structure, this house,
- 7:28
- Patty: I let them know when they kept speaking at me was Is you trespassed. So if you if you want to have your clients, if they're gonna file some complaint, please be aware the seller will be informed that your clients and yourself trespassed inside the building because you were not given
- 7:48
- Patty: permission to do that, to do so. To which you and I had a bit of discussion, Michael. Is it actually called trespassing? And back to AI, we threw the question out to them, and they were running. uh the trespassing laws here on Prince Edward Island. And yes, it could be deemed as
- 8:08
- Patty: trespassing.
- 8:09
- Michael: Incremental trespassing. So you could give someone permission, let's just say it's a farm property, to go inside every single building except for the one that's painted blue, assuming there's only one that's painted blue. And if they entered that one building without your permission, that could be deemed to be trespassing. And that was
- 8:29
- Michael: one of the many exciting topics we discuss in real estate from day to day.
- 8:34
- Patty: Yeah, so just be aware. If somebody says you are not to go inside of a building, it is compromised or it's unsafe without getting into drama saying it's dangerous. But this was a dangerous situation because they could have felt fallen right through and uh who knows what they could have landed
- 8:54
- Patty: on in the basement underneath. They could have seriously hurt themselves. Listen to them. And if you're a buyer's agent out there and you have a buyer that's pushing and insisting, say no. If you've been advised to not enter that property, do not enter that property. And if your client is not listening and
- 9:14
- Patty: they're trying to push back, I would say it's probably best to find a new client, that one that respects the process, respects the seller, respects your safety because this agent followed this buyer in. They obviously opened the door for them because there was a lockbox on this property. So they had to go through the formality of actually unlocking this
- 9:33
- Patty: property in order to enter it. And they set themselves and this buyer up for failure.
- 9:41
- Michael: So the bottom line is if you have a property that's about to be condemned and you're gonna fall through the floor, call Patty Castle.
- 9:48
- Michael: Your slum lord, your slum property expert.
- 9:52
- Patty: Uh, that's pretty funny.
- 9:53
- Michael: On to other AI things. Here's something that's kind of interesting that I experimented with about a week or so ago. I received an offer on a property, and typically what I do is I handwrite notes.
- 10:08
- Michael: But what I decided to do is take my notes, scan them. I always write on graph paper, as do you, for
- 10:15
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): some
- 10:15
- Michael: weird, bizarre reason.
- 10:16
- Patty: I know, it is odd.
- 10:17
- Michael: Maybe we're genetically linked or something. We should check twenty-three and me, but I've always used graph paper for notes. I put it in the scanner and I said to
- 10:27
- Michael: AI, I believe I use Claude at this point, take my notes, put them into a counteroffer form,
- 10:35
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
- 10:35
- Michael: basically write up the form. And it actually did that. I was totally impressed. Not only did it do it, but it did it far beyond what I would have done as far as how it worded the clauses. I showed it to you. You were
- 10:47
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): impressed.
- 10:48
- Patty: Yeah, it
- 10:48
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): was
- 10:49
- Patty: impressive.
- 10:49
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 10:49
- Michael: I think the addition of Happy Fire. face emojis is just that
- 10:52
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): extra
- 10:53
- Michael: little touch that I wouldn't have done.
- 10:55
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 10:55
- Patty: don't think there was a happy face emoji on that.
- 10:58
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That's
- 10:58
- Michael: something to consider.
- 10:59
- Patty: Okay. Trevor
- 10:59
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Burrus It
- 11:00
- Michael: made your counteroffer a little hat. Maybe someone will accept it because they see the happy faces and they think, this is happy. We're going to accept this offer, even though it's 20% more than we offered. Trevor
- 11:09
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Burrus
- 11:09
- Patty: Yeah. So you're making all these we're not we're not doing this, we're not accepting your price, we're we're taking this the way. away, you're not having that, but we're still happy and we still want you
- 11:19
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
- 11:19
- Patty: feel good.
- 11:20
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): With a
- 11:20
- Michael: thumbs up.
- 11:21
- Patty: With a thumbs up emoji. That's actually kind of fun.
- 11:23
- Michael: And lastly, looking for property. I'm always looking at real estate. I've looked at markets in San Diego. I was in Yuma, New Mexico the other day, uh, California, Florida.
- 11:37
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 11:37
- Michael: we were looking at New York last night. New York City. And one of the things I noticed in all these markets, and there's one in Ontario I'm looking at, is I there's always the outliers, these people that think their house is worth 80% more than it is. And I thought, well, maybe this is just in my mind. So what I decided to do is I took AI, again,
- 11:57
- Michael: I use Claude in this case, I said, look at this listing and tell me if you think it's overpriced. And it did kind of a a comparative market analysis, which an agent or appraiser would do with the data that it had available, and it confirmed, yeah, this is overpriced.
- 12:14
- Patty: Or this appears to be high. Because to make a definitive statement without actually having a real estate professional, and unless it actually went through and was aware of maybe all the finishes in that, like I still use that with caution. I wouldn't say that is a black and white. If AI says this is overpriced,
- 12:34
- Patty: it's overpriced. However, it does give you a little bit of insight and a starting point to maybe, okay, well, what at that price point could I expect or should I expect to get? So education, I think to start the conversation.
- 12:49
- Michael: There's no reason why you couldn't. just ask your AI agent to supply the data and the comparables, just like you would do in a CMA or appraisal. Something to think about. I just thought it was neat. It worked. Let's move on. Patty, this next topic is all yours, and I'm really interested to hear what your response is.
- 13:09
- Michael: Real estate agent A decides to, or I let me rephrase. this. Real estate agent A is representing a buyer. The buyer phones real estate agent A and says, Real estate agent B, the listing agent, has a property for sale. So the buyer's agent, real estate agent A, says to his buyer,
- 13:29
- Michael: Why don't you just go through the property and have the listing agent show it to you, and then I'll write rate the offer.
- 13:37
- Michael: Anything wrong with that? other than the blatantly obvious?
- 13:40
- Patty: Well, yes, it it is.
- 13:44
- Patty: And I know we've discussed this on previous episodes where as a buyer, you should have your agent representing you. And as a buyer, if you're having conversations with each listing agent, if it's a good listing agent, again, listing agent represents the seller, please keep that in mind. They're going to try to
- 14:04
- Patty: get little pieces of information from you so that it positions and their seller is able to leverage that to get you to pay more. So if you think you're going to get a better deal because you're going through the listing agent, you need to rethink your
- 14:21
- Patty: business, your negotiation strategy with regards to that. But to get down to the point of what we were going to end up discussing on this, so this is happening more and more. I mean, I know it used to happen a lot before, but buyers now, because of like even what we just discussed, Michael, is this property
- 14:40
- Patty: overpriced? The consumer is relying on AI to give them their answers so they don't feel that there's real estate agents. I can do all this myself. I'll do my own research, and I've got AI to help me and and AI says this is, you know, overpriced, which is why I say proceed with caution. It's for education only
- 15:00
- Patty: and maybe a starting point for a conversation. Because if you are a consumer listening to this and you think that that ha they have all the tools, there's things that a real estate agent can do that are that's being missed. in the whole process. But the point of this topic, I will say, can
- 15:20
- Patty: a listing agent show a buyer a property? Yes, they can. Should the buyer go through the listing agent? Probably not, unless, again, in my opinion, if the listing's been on for a little while, then it's not a matter of not working or representing your seller client. So whatever the buyer presents,
- 15:40
- Patty: and as long as you're not disclosing your seller's permission without their consent permission, and you're not going, ps, my client will accept a lesser price offer. Or if you can come up to this price, you know what, I might be able to put this together. These are things that listing agents are not allowed to do. And as a buyer's agent, you shouldn't say to the
- 16:00
- Patty: listing agent, if you do have representation.
- 16:03
- Patty: hey, uh, my client will come up to X. Like we work collaboratively, but we shouldn't be sharing each other's negotiation positions. We should be doing our business practice honest and ethically. So can a buyer go through or be instructed by their buyer's agent
- 16:23
- Patty: to go through the listing agent? Because the buyer's agent's big busy and doesn't have time. It is within our rules and regulations on Prince Edward Island. It's within the section called the Standards of Professional Excellence for the PEI Real Estate Association Realtors. And what that looks like is a member suggesting to a
- 16:43
- Patty: prospect buyer that he or she inspect the property with another member with the intention or instructions or implied instructions. to return to the original member for the submission of any offer to purchase on any one of such properties, a member suggesting to a prospective buyer who has viewed a property through another member
- 17:03
- Patty: that the buyer should purchase the property at fair price through him or her. So we're You're it's it's an ethics issue. It's not a a a a rule, but it's within that can that section within our rules and regulations. So if you're a buyer listening and you're wondering, well, is this allowed? Can I
- 17:23
- Patty: do this? Why is my buyer agent telling me I didn't think it was anything wrong? Who shows you the property should be the one who writes your offer. And again, it is it's a code of the
- 17:34
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah. thing. Unless they're
- 17:35
- Michael: an agent of that agent or broker, you
- 17:38
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): can't.
- 17:38
- Michael: using the word agent different as
- 17:41
- Patty: a limited doing.
- 17:42
- Michael: Definitively different legally. Basically, I'll put it to you this way. Patty represents the purchaser, but Patty has her own buyer's agent which gets people through properties. In that particular instance, that buyer's agent isn't going to write the offer, they're just showing the property. But the original question is, do you have to show a property in order to write an
- 18:02
- Michael: offer for a purchaser? And the answer is no, from what I found. Real estate licensing is provincial in Canada and none of the provincial statutes or regulations, PEI, Real Estate Trading Act and regulations, Ontario's, BCs, Alberta's, Nova Scotia's, all of them say no,
- 18:22
- Michael: you do not have to show the property. So it comes down to an ethics thing. Would you agree? Yes.
- 18:26
- Patty: If it was suggested or implied that you you let them show you the property, and if there's no understanding between these the two agents, the buyer's agent, listing agent, and you're just gonna get sneak this in to have them show it and then go back to your buyer's agent, that's just wrong and we shouldn't do that. Trevor
- 18:44
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Burrus, Jr.
- 18:44
- Michael: What if the buyer's representation phoned the listing agent and said, Would you mind running these people through? Because this is like three hours from my office and you live next door. And
- 18:55
- Patty: that's what I said. Without their permission, they should have a conversation.
- 18:58
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Fine.
- 18:58
- Michael: Yes.
- 18:59
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): As long as
- 18:59
- Michael: they're not giving away any leverage or any anything at all. So you walk in there, you don't say anything, the agent says, So, how do you know? And you just wave. Don't say anything.
- 19:08
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 19:08
- Michael: we're gonna Going use to it against you. Patty, there's here's another interesting little story, and I know what I do with it. this stuff,
- 19:16
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
- 19:16
- Michael: it's cost me a ton of money. Is your listing agent? You get two phone calls simultaneously that say, I want to offer on this property. What do you do? Now I know you have commission breath, and all you can taste is that double ending. Double ending basically means you're going to receive double the normal commission
- 19:36
- Michael: because now you're getting a the listing side and the buyer side.
- 19:39
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
- 19:39
- Michael: I know what I've done, I've actually dropped listings because of this, because this just screams conflict and lawsuit.
- 19:48
- Patty: So what do you mean that you've dropped listings because of it?
- 19:51
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Do you mean you dropped
- 19:51
- Patty: a buyer?
- 19:52
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I had
- 19:53
- Michael: a situation once where I listed a real estate broker's property, and she had a friend that wanted to buy it and wanted
- 20:02
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to buy.
- 20:03
- Michael: write the offer through me. And at the same time, there is an agent in my office, which is under the same brokerage umbrella, and he had a buyer that wanted to write an offer, and I just dropped it because I was co-listed, and I just I'm not getting into this right now. Because there's just too many levels of conflict here.
- 20:19
- Patty: Yes.
- 20:19
- Michael: You guys all need your own representation. Presentation And for the vendor to send me their friend to rate write the offer through me, and I'm the listing agent, she was a listing agent or listing broker. Plus, we had the listing broker. The listing broker also had the listing, held the license of the another purchaser's agent that was offering. It was just like, I'm running out the door.
- 20:39
- Patty: I think someone listening to this would need a little notepad and start who's on first, what's on second, and I don't
- 20:45
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know what's on
- 20:45
- Patty: third.
- 20:46
- Michael: If it sounds like a conflict, wipe your hands of it, tell everybody you get their own response. representation. In this particular case with this this listing agent, it's common sense. You got two buyers phoning the same property at the same time that want to offer on it. Get your own agent. If you don't have one, we can probably suggest someone for you
- 21:06
- Michael: to use.
- 21:07
- Patty: Yeah, and and uh so I can understand like today, as our days on market are longer, you're a listing agent, you're a seller you're as a seller, you feel, well, you know, you're my listing agent. Why haven't you shown the property? You should be showing my property. But I always say to my seller, well, then who am I representing? Yes, I'm
- 21:27
- Patty: representing you, but then is that fair representation to the buyer? Because now I'm under limited dual. So I try to always say, My job is to market and promote your property and to represent you. So I don't I don't typically think a seller is educated and informed when they sit there and they make that statement. So I try my best to educate them with
- 21:47
- Patty: regards to that. So now that we're probably in 2027, it's an assumption, but we'll be probably traversing towards more of a buyer's market. We're in a balanced market right now for most markets, residential properties and areas on Prince. Edward Island. But as we traverse more to a buyer's market, as
- 22:07
- Patty: a listing agent, you may find you end up showing the property some little bit more. You're looking to generate more business and you've got a buyer, you know, potential and they happen to like your property listing. And yes, you do feel like you were saying, Michael, that you could end up double-ending double ending it. And I say that in quotations. because
- 22:27
- Patty: now you get double the commission, but you still have double the work. So don't think it's an opportunity if you're a seller. Well then that should be discounted because you have more, if not, you have more work as a limited dual agent because now you're walking both parties through to the closing and trying to play that little dance. I can't say this,
- 22:47
- Patty: I can't say that, I gotta make sure where where am I kind of in the middle here. to make sure each party has that fair representation. But as a listing agent, you've shown it to one buyer and you never expected 24, 48 hours later, another buyer comes along, reaches out to you, and like, oh, this is exciting. I got some activity and I'm generating
- 23:07
- Patty: some buyer, you know, clients potentially here. But what if those both those buyers as a result of those showings now want to write the offer? and they think you're going to be the one representing them and writing the offer? You have to disclose in writing that I am writing an offer for another buyer. So each buyer needs to be informed. And then I ask
- 23:26
- Patty: you, how can you fairly write a competitive offer when you know what this com the competitive conversation you had with this buyer number one? And now you're having a comp trying to have a competitive conversation with buyer number two, you just can't. It's too taxing, it's too
- 23:46
- Patty: stressful, you will age very, very quickly. You need to refer them out to somebody, even within your office, because you're at least at arm's length. Lengths. So I know as days on market start to increase, listings will sit on the market. longer. You do have a higher probability of two
- 24:06
- Patty: buyers coming to you to show you the property. And I mean, if you're a consumer listening to this, going, well, why would they do that? Well, maybe one of the buyers seen it and it's not for them, but you can you agree to show it to the next, you know, inquiry on the property, and they're the ones that actually happen to be the buyers. It is not common that both
- 24:27
- Patty: buyer clients that you've shown the property, whether it's within a couple days or a week or two even apart, will end up coming at the same time to write the offer, but it is something that happens. So refer them out, keep your business clean, watch the overlapping conflicts, like you were saying, Michael, in your
- 24:46
- Patty: example. It's just not worth it to get greedy and try to take a larger, larger piece of the pie.
- 24:54
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
- 24:54
- Michael: what you're trying to do is you're trying
- 24:56
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
- 24:57
- Michael: minimize your liability. And when you're representing two buyers and a seller, there's going to be some confusion as to who represents who. And what's going to happen is if this does turn into a lawsuit, is they're going to ask for all your communications, that being
- 25:16
- Michael: texts and emails. And you will have to turn over absolutely everything, with the exception of those documents that are privileged, which would be between you and a lawyer. In this particular case, there probably wouldn't be anything that's privileged at this level. But in order to
- 25:36
- Michael: eliminate the liability, just don't get into this. Because there's going to be something that you've said, because you know how it is. You and I will send a quick email back and forth. It's five or six words.
- 25:48
- Michael: But we understand sort of what's around that basis where someone else could take that sentence and manipulate it and say, well, you didn't disclose this. You said this and it meant that. And next thing you know, you get a $30,000 thirty thousand dollar legal bill because you're trying to double end to property.
- 26:04
- Patty: Yeah, I prefer
- 26:06
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): 70
- 26:06
- Michael: cents.
- 26:07
- Patty: I yes, it does. I stay you predominantly I'm a listing agent and I typically stay on the listing agent side. I do deal with buyers and I do enjoy working with buyers, but I would rather just represent one client, whoever the client is, because
- 26:27
- Patty: it keeps things simple. I know the communication, I know the education that I'm providing to them, and I don't have this overlap. Well, I found out through so-and-so and this person that you said this, and they had more information than the other person had. And I just keep it simple and clean. And if you get
- 26:47
- Patty: any sense of of um anxiety. that am I doing the right thing? That should be a red flag that you need to pump the brakes and maybe change how you are looking after or or the situation that you're almost in the process of agreeing to enter into.
- 27:06
- Michael: And that is why in some provinces provinces and states disallow agents to represent both sides, and that's also why many agents, including myself, unless it's really super, super clean, will not represent both sides.
- 27:22
- Patty: Yeah, I'd have to have a listing for, and that's why I said at the beginning, kind of a a period of time, because I know I've given I know my sellers aware that we've offered this property. You know, I'm not, here's the buyer's position, this that's is what they're looking to offer. I'm only typically comfortable. And I guess that's just having gotten
- 27:42
- Patty: into real estate back in uh the, you know, 2010 before the market all took off. And just the the game, I mean, it's the same game. It's just a little bit of some of the rules changed a little bit in the sense of and and the type of buyer and the different demographics of buyers and and and sellers. So
- 28:02
- Patty: keep it simple. I would say stay on one side if you can, refer out the business, let somebody else keep your side and your business practice clean. And please, if you're a seller, just because an agent double-ends something or does happen to be the one on both sides doesn't mean it is grounds for
- 28:22
- Patty: discounting because there is double the amount of work and quite the dance to do.
- 28:27
- Michael: So I think what you're trying to say in your own little patty way is prior to COVID, we're basically dealing with the local audience, which weren't litigious. But when we started to have people coming in from other provinces particularly, every time you turn around they're suing somebody for this or suing
- 28:47
- Michael: somebody for that, because they all feel like they're done wrong by somebody. and they weren't, and they didn't understand the culture, so of course they phone up a lawyer. Would that be a fair statement? Aaron
- 28:58
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Ross Powell, Jr.
- 28:58
- Patty: I I would say that.
- 29:00
- Michael: So be careful because lawsuits are happening more now because of the out-of-province buyer. Aaron
- 29:05
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Ross Powell
- 29:05
- Patty: Yeah. Well, because they bring their where they're from, their expectations, the the way of life, the business practice and then I mean part of the charm of Prince Edward Island has always been that like stepping back in time.
- 29:21
- Michael: We do business on a handshake.
- 29:23
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 29:23
- Michael: honestly.
- 29:24
- Patty: And that can still take place. I just find it's less and less. And maybe it's for the best that everything is far more documented, but it was a little bit more, I don't know, it just felt far more relaxed and laid back. And you knew that both sides, you had a buyer that wanted to buy, a seller that wanted to sell,
- 29:44
- Patty: and the agents would work collaboratively and do our best to make sure that, oh, you kind of messed up here, here, don't worry, I'll help you out, or my seller's aware that you missed a PID. We're just going to put it in. That stuff, that's the charm of living here. And and I find it's getting a lesson less and less of that and
- 30:04
- Patty: sometimes it's sad.
- 30:05
- Michael: Well, it's also the influx. You know, during COVID in every market, there was an increase in licensed real estate agents which really weren't educated, weren't doing this fall time, and just didn't know what they were doing. And that's happening everywhere. I mean, you you're were telling me the other day you were looking at a listing cut sheet from an I think it was
- 30:25
- Michael: like their first list. listing, and the stuff they're indicating on this cut sheet, which are just a bunch of checky boxes, was all in error.
- 30:34
- Patty: Yeah, they and
- 30:37
- Michael: you know where the water's coming from. This is not rocket science. Is it a well? Does it come from the community? Is it municipal? Like, where does it come from? It's a checkbox. It's not a 500-page 500 page essay.
- 30:48
- Patty: And just because an oil tank is in the base of the basement doesn't mean it's underground.
- 30:52
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
- 30:53
- Michael: An underground oil tank doesn't mean the oil tank is in the basement. It means it's under the ground.
- 31:00
- Patty: It's
- 31:01
- Michael: buried, which
- 31:01
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
- 31:02
- Michael: typically would find at a gas station or maybe an older commercial property, not a residential one. Typically, I don't think I've ever seen a buried oil tank in any residential property. I've
- 31:14
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): seen
- 31:14
- Michael: commercial properties.
- 31:15
- Patty: I have, I'm sure.
- 31:16
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, but we
- 31:17
- Michael: know what kind of properties you deal in based on our first subject here.
- 31:22
- Patty: No, but I have had that situation come up. But now again, because of the period of time that I got into the real estate business as a courtesy, I I was able to say these are all the things that you should go back and have a conversation and maybe change
- 31:42
- Patty: and correct your PCDS. But someone else might take that as an opportunity to go, well, you misrepresented, you said this, I want that. And again, I'm of the old school belief that I'm I tried to help that agent out and I gave you
- 31:56
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a lot of people. But then a
- 31:56
- Michael: different story. You're talking about well, first of all, PCDS, or in some markets have called a property condition statement, a PCS, basically, again, is just a bunch of checky boxes about have you had any problems with your water? How's your roof? Is your electrical system faulty? Have you upgraded
- 32:16
- Michael: it? Stuff like this, stuff that buyers may want to know. And what Patty's talking about is circumstances where you point out defects with the property that they knew about. For instance, let's just say hypothetically it's a septic system. The listing agent was told by the septic company that this septic system
- 32:36
- Michael: is shot, it needs to be removed and replaced, and then they just play dumb and pretend that conversation never happened and didn't get their lister, their seller, to put it on the property condition disclosure form, the PCDS.
- 32:50
- Patty: Yeah, and that should be updated if things are discovered throughout the listing process. And that's why the sellers have to go back and actually initial the property condition disclosure statement to say that yes, I agreed this was the condition that I disclosed the property to be in when I first
- 33:10
- Patty: listed it. And this is still accurate today. So if you are a seller and you're like, oh, that's why I have to go back and initial it as part of a contract agreement as long as the buyer included it, that is the reason for it. And if there is any discrepancy, that is your opportunity to say, oh, wait a minute. I had checked this
- 33:30
- Patty: box and I this happened. So now I need to make sure. And you can do this in a counter and just say, you know, as per property condition disclosure statement and then disclose what the actual correct answer or what might be a deemed an issue with or a deficiency within the property. So you
- 33:50
- Patty: you just want to make sure that you do your your due diligence. You keep these documents up to date. But if you find a mistake, help each other out. It's not an opportunity to go, well I'm going gonna to sue you. I just again kindness.
- 34:06
- Michael: Treat people, the buyers, the way you would want to be treated, even though you're the seller. And in the instance where
- 34:15
- Michael: the septic system is deficient, and you know it is, and the listing agent know it is, but you guys aren't conveying this, isn't this is what Patty's Piety's talking about lawsuits, and now the buyer buys the property, you end up in court because they find out that you knew that it was deficient. What I would do as a seller is acknowledge, and I'd probably do it in the form of an acknowledgement,
- 34:35
- Michael: and on the TCDS and just say, Yeah, the septic system doesn't work. This is the company that told us this. This is how much it's gonna cost to fix, and just disclose that and have them sign off on that.
- 34:47
- Patty: Honesty is the best policy and uh it will come out. It always finds a way to come out. And yes, you should treat others the way you would want to be treated. And yes, this is business, but this is going to be someone's home. And
- 35:07
- Patty: your reputation, I also feel sometimes can be connected with the property. You've moved on. Your neighbors have always thought you were a wonderful person. And now this new property owner comes in and says, Do you realize the owner of this property did this, this, and this? Like I've had sellers who have said, No, I have to make sure because I
- 35:28
- Patty: and they want to make sure that they put the right buyer into their property because they are so connected to their communities and they want a good reputation.
- 35:36
- Michael: But more importantly, if you have a single couple that's young that's slaved away and worked for free, four, five, six, eight years to save up the down payment for a house to raise a family, and then they just barely have enough money to buy this house and they have it inspected, the home inspector says everything's good, and then they find out
- 35:55
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
- 35:55
- Michael: year after, oh, by the way, the septic company disclosed two years ago the system's bet and we need $35,000 thirty five thousand dollars to put a an a men an engineered system and that's not very fair. We're gonna close her down here.
- 36:07
- Patty: Yeah, because you never know which direction our
- 36:11
- Patty: these conversations 'cause this is not the direction that we were gonna go.
- 36:15
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So an
- 36:16
- Michael: afternoon session too. We're
- 36:17
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): gonna start
- 36:18
- Michael: in this first thing in the morning 'cause we've been driving for hours to get here just to put on this podcast.
- 36:24
- Patty: Yes.
- 36:24
- Michael: So we're spinning it a little differently. but we are going to shut it down because it's time to uh to get
- 36:30
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): some
- 36:30
- Michael: fresh air and out of a vehicle.
- 36:32
- Patty: And we respect our listeners' time as well. So thanks again for listening to another episode of the Michael and Patty Show, otherwise known as MAPS PEI's podcast, that helps guide you through the buying and selling and a little bit of Prince Edward Island. And if you're looking for an extension of this, we do have the moving to Prince Edward Island from
- 36:52
- Patty: the Michael and Patty podcast, which will give you a lot of additional information. We have toolbox Tuesdays, and one of the exciting toolbox Tuesdays that are going to be coming up are how do you get rid of a tenant? And then part two to that is how do you get rid of a roommate, perhaps, that you
- 37:12
- Patty: just didn't turn out to be a
- 37:14
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): good situation.
- 37:17
- Patty: Yes. So the legalities in that as it pertains to Prince Edward Island is what these toolbox Tuesdays are going to be all about that are upcoming. And again, lots of information, fun fact Fridays, and just other hopefully engaging conversations and questions, and other people who also uh pose
- 37:37
- Patty: questions in there looking for some support and guidance.
- 37:40
- Michael: Have a great day everyone. Thanks for listening.
- 37:42
- Patty: Thanks for listening. Have a great day.