The Finance Plan

Historian Joseph Moore argues American wealth-building is easier today due to lower costs and better access, despite housing pressures.

46 min Listen to the original Episode page
Historical FinanceWealth BuildingHousing MarketInvesting AccessibilityPersonal Finance PsychologyWomen in FinanceCredit Cards

Summary

Historian Joseph Moore joins Carly to discuss findings from his research into 300 years of American financial advice, asserting that the American Dream is more accessible now than in the past. Moore disputes claims of stagnant wages, citing a 25-30% rise in median wages since the 1970s, while attributing financial anxiety to housing costs outpacing income growth. He contrasts modern investing accessibility with historical barriers, noting that passive income strategies were destroyed by inflation and that early investors in new trends often lost money. The discussion also covers the psychological aspects of wealth, including the importance of meaningful work post-financial independence and the historical role of women in managing household finances and investments.

Episode sections

  1. 0:00 – 1:04

    Introduction and Thesis

    Carly introduces historian Joseph Moore, who researched 300 years of American financial advice to test if the American Dream is dead. Moore claims it is easier than ever to get rich, having achieved financial independence in his 40s on a $65,000 salary.

  2. 1:04 – 5:46

    Wages and Cost of Living

    Moore disputes the claim that wages have been stagnant since 1970, stating median wages have risen 25-30% since his birth in the 1970s. He attributes the perception of stagnation to wage inequality and housing costs outpacing income growth.

  3. 5:46 – 9:27

    Historical Poverty and Expenses

    Moore notes poverty rates have dropped from one-third of Americans in the 1920s to 10-16% today. He highlights that in 1870, 92% of income went to food, clothing, and housing, with food costing over a third of income compared to 10-15% today.

  4. 9:27 – 11:30

    The 'Next Big Thing' Trap

    Moore argues that early investors in trends like beet farming or canals typically lost money, while those working in the industries profited. He advises that to profit from new trends, one should work in the industry rather than invest as an early adopter.

  5. 11:30 – 13:17

    Fast Time vs. Slow Time

    Moore introduces 'fast time' (volatile, crisis periods) and 'slow time' (normal periods). He asserts most financial life occurs in slow time, and decisions made then (career, marriage, basic investing) are stress-tested during fast time.

  6. 13:17 – 18:30

    Real Estate Experiment and Housing Shortage

    Moore details his failed initial real estate experiments due to bad tenants and legal issues. He concludes that while real estate is active and risky, the current US housing shortage means prices are unlikely to crash, unlike in the 1920s.

  7. 18:30 – 21:35

    The Death of Passive Investing

    Moore explains that passive investing (5% bonds/dividends) worked in the 19th century due to zero inflation. Post-WWI inflation destroyed these returns, and modern 'passive' stock market returns are actually speculative.

  8. 21:35 – 28:13

    Ease of Modern Investing

    Moore argues investing is easier now than in 1929 due to lower fees, fractional shares, and digital access. He notes that buying an index fund in 1929 was logistically impossible for most due to high capital requirements and transaction costs.

  9. 28:13 – 29:07

    Navigating Spousal Alignment in FIRE

    Speaker_0 describes a failed attempt to pursue Financial Independence with his wife, who rejected the simpler lifestyle. He emphasizes that couples must compromise and find shared meaning, as dragging a spouse along often fails.

  10. 29:07 – 31:02

    The Necessity of Meaningful Work Post-FIRE

    Carly and Speaker_0 discuss how early FIRE participants often return to work for meaning. Speaker_0 cites historical examples like Sylvester Judd and modern bloggers, noting that without purpose, financial freedom can lead to self-destructive behavior.

  11. 31:02 – 32:39

    Historical Reality of Women's Economic Participation

    Speaker_0 challenges the narrative that women were only recently liberated to work, stating that for the bottom 80% of Americans, women have always worked and managed household finances. He argues that historical data obscures this by excluding self-employment income like home production.

  12. 32:39 – 34:28

    Women as Primary Financial Managers and Investors

    Speaker_0 asserts that women historically handled budgeting, mortgage payments via house-hacking, and investing. He claims women owned half of AT&T shares in the 1890s and that Abigail Adams achieved ~17% lifetime returns, comparable to Warren Buffett's ~19%.

  13. 34:28 – 37:36

    Credit Card Points as a Historical Scam

    Speaker_0 compares modern credit card points to historical store stamp programs, arguing both are designed to increase spending. He claims retailers embed a ~3% fee into prices to fund rewards, meaning consumers effectively pay for the points they earn.

  14. 37:36 – 45:46

    Psychology of Rewards and Opportunity Cost

    Speaker_0 critiques the psychological trap of chasing small rewards (e.g., 1-2% cash back), comparing it to historical stamp collecting. He suggests that the time spent optimizing points is better spent on part-time work, as the 'house always wins'.

Claims worth verifying

Joseph Moore reached financial independence in his 40s with a $65,000 salary.

Carly ·0:25

How to verify: Primary source: Joseph Moore's book 'How to Get Rich in American History' or his personal website historyhelps.com. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Wages for the median worker are up 25 to 30 percent since the 1970s.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·4:23

How to verify: Dataset: US Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) Historical Unemployment Tables or Current Population Survey (CPS) data on median weekly earnings. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

In the 1920s, one out of every three Americans was at or below the poverty line.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·5:54

How to verify: Dataset: US Census Bureau historical poverty statistics or historical economic surveys from the 1920s. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

In 1870, nine out of ten cents earned went to food, clothing, and housing.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·7:01

How to verify: Historical source: US Department of Labor Bureau of Labor Statistics historical cost of living data or contemporary economic histories. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Today, food costs are roughly 10 to 15 percent of a paycheck.

Carly ·8:33

How to verify: Dataset: US Bureau of Labor Statistics Consumer Expenditure Survey. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

In 1870, the average American had one and a half shirts.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·8:02

How to verify: Historical source: Historical clothing consumption statistics or economic histories of the 19th century. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

In the 1920s, a gallon of milk in New York City cost 24 cents.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·18:50

How to verify: Historical source: US Bureau of Labor Statistics historical price data or contemporary newspaper archives from 2026-2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Index funds are a product of the 1970s.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·22:47

How to verify: Primary source: Vanguard Group history or John Bogle's writings on the creation of the first index fund in 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

In 1929, buying the S&P 500 index would have required $100,000 to $1 million in capital.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·23:07

How to verify: Calculation: Historical stock prices from 2026 multiplied by the number of constituents in the S&P 500 (or its predecessor index) to determine total market cap/cost. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The average age in the Old West was 45 years old.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·3:30

How to verify: Dataset: Historical US Census data or demographic studies of the American West in the late 19th century. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Women owned half of the shares in AT&T in the 1890s.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·33:59

How to verify: Search historical records of AT&T (formerly Bell Telephone Company) shareholder registries from the 1890s; consult historical accounts of women investors in the late 19th century such as 'The Women's History of the Stock Market' by Bethany McLean or academic papers on gender and finance history. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Abigail Adams' lifetime investment returns are right at 17%.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·33:59

How to verify: Review Dr. Joseph Moore's book 'History Helps' or his published essays on historyhelps.com for the specific calculation methodology; cross-reference with historical biographies of Abigail Adams detailing her management of the Adams estate during John Adams' diplomatic service. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The number one mortgage payoff strategy before WWII was renting out rooms (house-hacking).

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·32:39

How to verify: Consult historical housing data from the U.S. Census Bureau or Federal Reserve historical data on household debt; review historical accounts of American housing practices in the 19th and early 20th centuries. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Store stamp programs caused consumers to spend more money than they needed to.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·36:11

How to verify: Search historical economic studies or retail industry reports on the impact of loyalty stamp programs (e.g., S&H Green Stamps) on consumer spending behavior; review bankruptcy records of stamp companies like Blue Chip Stamps. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Poverty levels in America have dramatically decreased historically.

Carly ·44:08

How to verify: Access U.S. Census Bureau data on official poverty rates from 2026 to present; compare historical poverty statistics with current figures. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

90% of people's pay goes towards necessities (food, housing, clothing).

Carly ·44:27

How to verify: Review Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) Consumer Expenditure Survey data on average household spending percentages for housing, food, and clothing over time. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify median wage growth data using Federal Reserve Economic Data (FRED) or Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) to confirm the 25-30% rise since the 1970s.
  • Check current US housing inventory and price-to-income ratios against historical data from the National Association of Realtors to assess the 'housing shortage' claim.
  • Research historical inflation rates from the 1920s onward using the Bureau of Labor Statistics CPI calculator to validate claims about the destruction of passive income.
  • Investigate the historical ownership of AT&T stock in the 1890s using NYSE historical records or academic financial history sources to verify female investor participation.
  • Analyze credit card merchant fee structures and average consumer spending patterns to determine if the ~3% cost embedding claim holds true for typical users.
  • Review academic literature on the 'K-shaped economy' to understand the divergence between median and top 10% wage growth cited in the episode.
  • Look for counter-arguments regarding the 'fast time' vs 'slow time' framework in behavioral finance literature to assess the validity of stress-testing life decisions.
  • Check for any conflicts of interest or sponsorships related to Joseph Moore's book or consulting services mentioned in the episode.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): If you want to get ahead today, it's easier than it's ever been.
0:03
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Are
0:03
Carly: you joking me? The cost of living has skyrocketed. This generation has it harder than previous generations. Or at least that's what we're told. What does history actually say? Meet historian and PhD Joseph Moore. He was curious and researched over 300 years of American financial advice and put it to the test.
0:20
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): What if I took the things everybody else did and I tried them today to see if they work?
0:25
Carly: He even tried by buying Jim Kramer's. daily stock picks. Here's the crazy part. In an effort to prove the American Dream was dead, he found himself rich. He reached financial independence in his 40s with a professor's salary of $65,000. Hi, hello, my yellow groupers. I'm Carly, a finance grad, and the creator of Best Money Class Ever Personal Finance Class, where I teach how to pay
0:45
Carly: off debt, invest, and stress less about money. Rob Grab a seat, I'm about to spill financial tea. Are you ready for it? Give me 40. 46 minutes. You'll see why everything you've been taught about the American dream being dead is completely wrong. We dive into why it's easier to get rich now versus any generation before, how wages are increasing and the cost of living is down. Everyone says
1:04
Carly: wages are stagnant since 1970. That
1:07
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): said is wrong.
1:08
Carly: What wealth building Soling strategies worked over the last 300 years versus what's hype, how he personally got rich and you can. too. Hello, Joseph. Welcome
1:16
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
1:16
Carly: the show. I'm so excited to have you here. Just finished reading this book, How to Get Rich in American History. This is 300 years of financial advice that worked and didn't work. I'm so excited to dive into it. I'm a finance girl. I studied finance. I've read so many books, and never ever have I read a finance book where I was just
1:36
Carly: shocked the entire time. Thank
1:38
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you, Carly.
1:39
Carly: Why did you almost obsessively geek out over financial history? And why did you want to prove the gurus wrong?
1:46
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I'm a historian, right? I'm the lefty humanities professor. I'm giving lectures to freshmen about how the American dream is mostly a scam, to take your eyes off your chains. The working man can never get ahead. It's all the elliptic. The more I study, the more I research, the more I go out to try to show people that history proves. that you really can't get ahead, the more I see people getting ahead. If you want to get ahead
2:06
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): today, it's easier than it's ever been. Over and over, I could not dodge the overwhelming evidence that getting ahead in America was possible, is possible, and it's actually getting easier compared to early eras. And
2:18
Carly: you said there is nothing about modern personal finance that is harder than it used to be. Not only is it possible to get ahead, what why is it easier now than ever to get ahead?
2:31
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
2:31
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): say that, and people, of course, recoil like I'm at a dinner party, I need to get away from this guy. Let me first start with sympathizing and empathy. It's not easy. I didn't say that it's there's no work required. There is assembly required to build the future you want to build in America today. There is. I'm not saying there isn't. Let's talk about what earlier generations had to do to get where they wanted to be. For a hundred plus
2:51
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): years of American history, the US government didn't issue money. Private individuals and banks and organizations did. If you go to work and you get paid in Dogecoin, and I go to work and I get paid in Fartcoin, which is, by the way, a real cryptocurrency, the first thing I'm gonna do is get it out of my crypto wallet and into something else. I'm gonna spend it as fast as possible because I know sure it could go up. It could also go down, it could go to zero. That
3:11
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): happened all the time. When people showed up in America, they were stunned. Your money fluctuated. fluctuates in value and it can just crash to zero overnight. Yeah, that was normal. The advice that grandparents would give their grandkids was he sat his grandson down and said, Whatever you do with money, don't you dare save it. Now, if my father walked in and told my kids that, I'd be like, Dad, step away from the bottle. Something has
3:30
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): gone very wrong because we trust that the money that we earn, it'll lose two to three percent in inflation, but it'll mostly hold its value. Your banks are not gonna. go under, you're gonna live twice as long. The average age in the old west was 45 years old. If you're listening to this and you're a grown-up, you're gonna live to about 80 or more. You're gonna live not one American life, you're gonna live two. In that time, you're gonna make more money
3:50
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): than we've ever made. Our incomes are up.
3:52
Carly: That is shocking. Let's break that one down. Because everyone says that, quote, wages are stagnant since 1970. That
4:00
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): stat is just wrong. Here's what that stat actually
4:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is.
4:03
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): says. That stat says that wages for the median or average worker are down compared to the top one in 10. In other words, the people at the top of the K, right? K-shaped economy discussions, the people there have made a lot more. The K-shaped idea makes it look like some are going down and some are going up. From the 70s forwards, I was born in the 70s. Wages are up no
4:23
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): matter how you count it, at least 25 to 30 percent. since when I was born.
4:27
Carly: And that shocks people. People pick up the news and everybody sees the stat. How is that just so wrong, though? Yeah,
4:35
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): it's politicized for one thing, but spinning those stats in a certain way serves a purpose for people in a political discussion. I'm not getting involved in the politics of it. I'm just saying that's that's been very politicized. The actual underlying stats show that median wages have risen. Wages at the bottom, 10% of Americans. and this stat is, I think, from the 1990s forward. In every US state,
4:55
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): wages at the bottom 10% are up since the 1990s. There's only one state where it's tied, and that's Michigan, which is where all those auto jobs left in the 90s. And so that accounts for why the bottom 10% has basically stayed flat. But in 49 of 50 states, it's up at the bottom, it's up at the middle, it's way up at the top, and that causes a lot of issues politically. at
5:15
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): anger. It's not, it's just factually untrue. Where a lot of people get upset is have wages tracked the cost of housing. And in that instance, housing has outgained the growth in wages. When the biggest thing you have to pay for in your life outpaces your wages, you really don't care how cheap the TV is. That's
5:35
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): where a lot of the angst is coming in. We do have a housing shortage, and I'm not making light of it. We can learn from history what to do with it. Wages are up. They may not be as up as we want them to be. Maybe they could be up higher, but they're not down.
5:46
Carly: Let's simmer on this a little bit, and we will get into housing. I do want to talk about that. Break it down poverty levels then versus now.
5:54
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Start
5:54
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): with poverty. I hate poverty. Everybody should hate poverty. If I go back to nineteen 1920s. twenties, let's go back in time a hundred way back machine, a hundred years. One out of every three Americans is below at a or right barely above the poverty line.
6:04
Carly: Roaring 20s.
6:06
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yes. Now, fast forward to the 1950s, it's still one in five, which is roughly 20%. People forget when John F. Kennedy ran for president. We remember him for the space race. That's after he's elected. When he's running for president, his number one campaign issue is poverty. He goes all around West Virginia and Appalachia and he he like with TV cameras. He says, Look at this poverty people are
6:26
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): dealing with we have. to address this. Poverty was a grinding issue. Today it's depending on how you count it, 10 to 16, but it's way down from what it's been historically. My theory on this is the poverty we see upsets us so much because we have so much less of it. When you think normal doesn't involve a world with poverty, any poverty you
6:45
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): see is deeply troubling. If you go to 1900, go to the turn of the 20th century, you would struggle to find any. anyone in the world arguing that they had a plan to end poverty. The idea that you could eradicate poverty was not a dream that someone had.
6:59
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
6:59
Carly: many people were in poverty.
7:01
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Nine out of 10 cents in every dollar somebody earned in America in 1870 had to pay for one of three things: food, clothing, housing. That was 92 cents. You had eight cents left over for everything else. Nobody's going RV. RVing in 1900. Where would you find the money? Things like vacations, this idea that you would have education for your kids,
7:21
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): piano lessons. That has to come from the other eight cents. Just to survive.
7:27
Carly: It was surprisingly the food and clothing. Let's talk about how expensive that was.
7:32
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All
7:32
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): clothes were made by hand. Keep that in mind. Now there were some factories are coming online. There are some mass-produced mass produced garbage. garments, but they're pretty new. Um, there's nothing like nylon and a chemical revolution that's gonna happen in the 20th century to make the fabric cheaper. So it's all gonna come from the land. The labor intensity of clothing. Walk into your closet and count the number of clothes. Count
7:52
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): it, just count it, just straight up how many shirts, how many pants. The average American has somewhere in the neighborhood of 80 to 100 pieces of clothing. Average. There's people I know, I'm married to one of
8:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): them,
8:02
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): who have. more. 1870, the average American had one and a half shirts. One guy has three and one guy has one. That is a legitimate historical statistic. Having a shirt was expensive. You might at best have one that you worked in every single day. Think how it's gonna smell. You might have what you hear, remember the old phrase Sunday best clothes? You might have one pair of clothes for very special
8:22
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): occasions. That's it. That's what you had. We can't fathom a world in which it's so expensive just to clothe fit. food, wildly more expensive than today. Today, food costs in America is roughly 10 to 15% of your paycheck.
8:33
Carly: Everybody now is complaining about food. Oh countries. What percentage was it back then?
8:37
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It
8:38
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): was over a third of your income. Now let's go to how boring it was to eat in the 1800s. I don't know about you. I have picky kids and I have a wife who cannot eat the same thing twice. If we had it Tuesday, we're not having it Wednesday. In the 1800s, you ate the same meal every day. single of the week. Then you had the same meal again next week. Eating was boring, except at like festival times. You can have
8:57
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Mexican tonight, Korean, Jamaican food. It's all within reach. Credit to uh Dee Jer McCloskey who pointed this out to me. In Huntsville, Alabama, there are not one, not two, but three Korean places, Ethiopian, uh, Japanese restaurants, Chinese restaurants, uh, pretty much every ethnicity of food that you can imagine is. in Huntsville, Alabama. You have so much
9:17
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): variety in your diet today, and you have it cheaper.
9:20
Carly: That's amazing. People overlook that. You have an entire chapter about the next big thing is a bad idea.
9:27
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah.
9:28
Carly: When everyone wants to get rich, they always look towards what's trending in the news, cryptocurrencies, or whatever is that next big thing. What is history? does history say about this?
9:41
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Great question. Every generation has one, two, or three things that everybody is sure will change the world. It's gonna change it tomorrow. You better get in today. The real lesson of history is that most of those things are very bad for early average investors, very good for the people who work in those industries. If you want to make money in the next big thing, the usual way to do it is to work in that industry, not to invest in that industry.
10:01
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I'll give you a couple of quick examples. In the early 1800s, the next big thing that people could not wait to get their money into was beet farming, B-E-E-T, sugar beets. Sugar was much more expensive than it is today. And everybody wanted it, right? Everybody likes sugar. How do you get sugar in 1800? Slaves have to grow it on a Caribbean island, which is morally deeply
10:20
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): problematic. It's also very expensive. Sugar's just not cheap. It's tainted with all these moral issues. Enter beet sugar. People figured out, especially in France, that you could grow beets and squeeze them out and get sugar from them. Napoleon invested huge amounts of money in France to get a beet sugar movement going. And Americans could not wait to get in front of them.
10:40
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Americans were crazy for beet farms. Every single one of them went bust. It took until the late 1800s for a single American beet farm to turn profitable. All those early investors went up. Tell you another one of the 1800s. The other one was canals. Erie Canal connected New York to the Great Lakes. New York suddenly is booming. Every mayor and every city council in every American city thought,
11:00
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): we need our own canal. Boston, New England cities, Baltimore, Charleston, they're all gonna build a canal and connect themselves to the Mississippi River. They all went bust right where they ran out of money, digging somewhere in the middle of nowhere in South Carolina. I It was like, I guess we're not gonna make it to the Mississippi. All those investors lost their money, who made money? The people digging the canals who were suddenly in really high demand.
11:20
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Whether it's the tech boom, technology does not move as fast as you think it does. When a technology gets introduced, that doesn't mean that it's gonna change the world tomorrow. Tomorrow takes its time to get here.
11:30
Carly: Let's talk about your one idea that I had never really heard about. If you want to get rich, you have to understand fast time, it's and slow time. What if is this concept? Explain it.
11:40
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Fast
11:41
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): time and slow time is my attempt to make some of the deeper theoretical work that's in some of these conversations more accessible. Can we just understand it at an everyday person's level? It's based on the mathematics of Benoit Mandelbro. Here's the idea. If most people think about financial time at all or financial history at all, what's the big short? Everything is happening everywhere all at once. It's always 2008, it's always
12:00
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): 1929. When we think about financial history, we think about the booms and the busts. The idea is you just don't want to get left behind and you don't want to get wiped out when everything goes crazy. Here's the reality: that is not most of financial time. Most of your financial time will be lived in what I call slow time. The decisions that you make in slow time, what career you pick, how you invest, who you marry, what do you get
12:20
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): addicted to, those are the things that are going gonna to get stress tested when fast time comes. Everybody's going to spend gonna all of Slow Time telling you that it's fast time right now, and it rarely is. We were at FinCon together, right? I put up on the board New York Times headlines telling you that the world is about to go under, the markets are gonna crash, and then it's gonna be great. They're all from one of the most boring years in American history.
12:40
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And wherever I go, I pick different years: 1948, 1952. Name me something interesting financially in 1952. Nothing. Everybody in 1952 thought they were about to have a depression. When you're in slow time, it's loud, people are screaming at you. It's easy to get confused and upset and worried. And you get on a plane and you watch the big short and you land and you think, I gotta get out of stocks or
13:00
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): whatever. Most of your time is going to be slow and most of the decisions you make in slow time. Now, when fast time comes, if you're in a good position and you're concentrated in the right ways, you have the chance to take off. And a lot of people get rich in those fast times. A lot of people go broke in those fast times. But they're very rare. Don't make your whole life a plan for fast time.
13:17
Carly: How did you get rich when you were trying all the different things?
13:22
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I failed upwards is the real answer. Let's just be extremely honest about how this occurs. I was a history professor. They don't pay us in money, they pay your professors in prestige. They give them just enough to live on, and then they tell them that they can fly around and get to talk to people and be called doctor. So I didn't have a lot of money, but I'm doing all these experiments. when I was researching the book. What if I took the things
13:41
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): everybody else did and I tried them today to see if they work? As an example, in the middle of the 20th century, as people started to think about going to the moon, the initial thought was who owns it? Well, what if I could claim I own it? And there's all these rushes to law to courthouses to try to claim ownership over the moon. Two of these organizations still exist. They still claim to own
14:01
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the moon. I bought it. an acre on the Sea of Serenity from one of these that was described as having phenomenal earth views and zoned for tourism. Is that going to make me any money? Almost certainly not. Will it hold up at court? No. But it was funny. I wanted to see like what did people do? One of the things that happened in the 70s and 80s, by the way, we have had housing crises before. Remember that,
14:21
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): is inflation is going through the roof. It's 8%, 10%, 12%, which means if a house was use easy numbers, if a house was $100,000 today, it's going to be $110,000 next year. People had this rush to buy real estate with as little down as you could because you just wanted to own it. And if it was going to be worth $10,000 more next year, or $15,000 or
14:41
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): $20,000 more in a few years, then you could just sell it and make your money. To try to experiment Of with this, I convinced my wife that I was going gonna to go buy one rental property with very little money. down to run this experiment. And I said, How bad can it be? The answer was very, very badly. I go on this trip, I find this air of North Carolina I want to focus on. I bought a
15:01
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): house and a four-plex apartment building. My wife was like, I said you could buy one. And I was like, it was a good deal because this is after 2008, right? After 2008, house prices had collapsed. I had a couple of basic instincts. Number one, they weren't gonna go to zero. so I'd be okay. Number two, we had suddenly stopped building houses. Let's step back and hit pause on my story and go back to the
15:21
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): to America story right now. We do have a housing shortage in this country. It is real. Anyone who tells you it's fake is it is doesn't do how to read the data. We have a housing shortage. Young people are staring at these housing prices with big eyes going, How am I supposed to get a down payment for this? If you study history, we've done this before. The statistically worst housing shortage in American
15:41
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): history is 1948, when it's roughly two to one the shortage we have today. All these GIs are coming back. Terrible back then. In the late 1940s, a young man comes back from World War II and he decides to run for Congress. His number one issue is housing affordability. His name is John F. Kennedy. That launches JFK into politics is the housing shortage his generation is
16:01
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): facing. We know the answer. The answer is build more houses. In every housing shortage we've had, the only way out is to build your way out of it. I'm a big advocate of yes, in my backyard, let's build more houses. You live in Austin, y'all are ground zero for solving the problem of we're just gonna build more houses. Now, unpause my story. I'm looking around, realizing we don't have enough
16:21
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): houses. They're not gonna going go to to zero. I'll buy a few, it'll be an experiment. This will be fun. It was not. I really renovated the house. Some lady shows up. She works for a temp agency, which should have been my cue. Uh, she rents the house. I never see her again. They immediately start moving in 20-something illegal immigrants who are working the lithium mines of North Carolina. They are human trafficked. Go to the cops, end up
16:41
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): on a conference call with the FBI, and they're like, Will you please let us sit on this house so we can track this human trafficking ring? And I gritted my teeth. I was like, that sounds like the right thing to do. They destroyed that house. but they did catch the human traffickers, which was good. The fourplex had a hoarder in it. I told them they can't hoard stuff right because it's just not sanitary. And they pulled a shotgun on me and I had to run out the door, leap off the steps, running for
17:01
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): my my Volvo, going, I think I might have made a mistake. So I was driving away and contemplating all this, was like, huh, this is not going well. I guess it can't go much worse. I come from a very working class background. My dad worked in the trades. I was just like, you know what? I don't want to concede defeat on this. I should have just sold everything and admitted it was a mistake and it made some funny stories for the book. I just decided I think my
17:20
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): underlying thesis is correct. We don't have enough houses, they won't go to zero, and it can't get worse. I just started getting really good at real estate investing. Everybody tells me, Oh, well, of course you got rich in 2011 and 12, and everything was you could say I have a stick of gum in five bucks, give me the house. To be fair, some of that's true. I'd I I bought some houses pretty cheaply, but you couldn't find anybody to live. lend you the money. Banks were
17:40
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): terrified of real estate. You had to get real invented on how you could find a way to get the money to buy the house for so cheap. There's always something wrong in real estate. Either the prices are too high, but they'll lend you money all day long, or nobody will lend you money and the prices are low. You just have to figure out what to do in each part of the cycle. I got good at it. One thing led to another, before I knew it, I've owned over 40 total units and houses and apartment buildings.
18:00
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): That made me enough money to walk away from academia.
18:02
Carly: You were on a one of those trendy streets interviews. What's your income?
18:07
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): That Instagram got a lot of uh love on that that one. Yeah.
18:10
Carly: You did mention in that my salary is sixty-five thousand dollars. You tried the whole real estate path, and that did actually work for you. I would assume in your experiment you were trying to bust the myth of passive investing. What did you learn? history says about passive investing?
18:30
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Passive investing used to be real. Then somebody killed it, and the murderer is still on the loose. If we go back 100 years, you can buy a 5% bond or a 5% dividend stock, and grandma can sit by the fire in peace if you have enough of that. They lived in a world with no inflation. If I go to 1912, say a gallon of milk in New York City cost costs 24 cents a gallon. Now, if I go back to
18:50
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): 1820, 1812, Napoleon rules France. A gallon of milk in America is 24 cents a gallon.
18:56
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It's
18:56
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the same price.
18:57
Carly: That was a shocking, mind blowing thing that I saw in your book was a hundred years, zero inflation.
19:03
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Prices stayed roughly the same. There were a few spots when wheat prices would go up and come back down. There's no sustained inflation. It's not the system. Then in the 19 teens, we get a handful of things. We get the Federal Reserve, we get fiat currency backed by the federal government again, and we get the income tax. Even though the income tax didn't affect most people at first, it eventually starts to kind of get bigger and bigger. Then you have World War I. When the 19th, 1912,
19:23
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the 0% inflation, it goes 8%, 18%, 17, 15%, 15 in five years. Prices doubled. There was not a person, there was not a grandmother or a great great-grandmother grandmother who had ever seen this happen. Nobody knew what to do. Inflation completely
19:39
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): destroys what passive income was, which was you get 5% bonds, you get 5% returns. Now, the people who bought liberty bonds for World War I were promised 4% returns, and then the inflation went 8%, 18%, 17%, 15, 15. This you're losing money on a bond. That model dies a very hard death. We experimented
19:59
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the 20th century with these different ways to find it back. But What we've settled on today. is we have it, we believe that we have a stock market that will just always steadily go up by seven to eight percent a year on average. And so if you just buy into the stock market, there's gonna be your 7% real return. That might continue for the rest of our lives, but it's not a promise. No one on Wall Street owes you that return. That's just what's been happening.
20:20
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Speculative return. If you if you buy something because you are sure the price will go up, if it goes up, you win. If it goes down, you lose. That's a speculative return. speculation. So what we call passive income today is actually speculation. On the flip side, on real estate, real estate, I'll tell you from experience, there's nothing passive about real estate. It is an active investment. You have to deal with
20:40
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): tenants. I have tenants right. I still have several rental properties. I have one right now that hasn't paid. And that's just life. You have to go do things, you have to fix things, you have to interview tenants. You have you have all kinds of active roles in real estate. If you want passive real estate, you're going to get passive returns. And the passive returns on American real estate are
20:59
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): four to five percent over US history. You're not going to get tremendous returns in real estate unless you work tremendously hard at real estate. That's a myth that gets propagated of like, oh, if you just buy rental properties, you get
21:10
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): checks
21:10
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): in the mail. No, you don't. You also get checks that bounce.
21:15
Carly: Right. Let's talk about the stock market for a little bit. Right now, the last 100 years is what people look at. And historically, you're gonna earn 10%. Invest in low cost index funds, and it's a win. So for the last hundred years, the stock market has been amazing. Let's look at why now it is actually easier
21:35
Carly: to get rich with the stock
21:36
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): market
21:37
Carly: versus 300 three hundred years ago. What were the big barriers to people investing two hundred, three hundred years ago?
21:45
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I would actually argue that that difficulty was high, even into our lifetimes is when it's gotten so much easier. My favorite example of this is it y everybody who has sat with a financial advisor has had what I just call the chart put in front of 'em. The dates change, the point is always the same. The one I remember that was given to me was ten $10,000 thousand dollars in nineteen. 1929. Reinvesting all dividends
22:05
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): would today be worth $10 million. The guy steps back, waiting for me to just like cannot wait to be rich in 50 years, right? I severely disappoint this guy because I'm like, wait a minute, houses didn't cost $10,000 in 1929. So somebody invested their life savings,
22:19
Carly: right?
22:20
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Promptly lost 80% in the crash, fought Nazis, feared nuclear Armageddon, cried when Ross and Rachel got back together.
22:27
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): never touched the money. That's not real life. The underlying assumptions of that we when we look back at history in stock investing and we kind of take our world and we port it over there, but that's not how it was. So let's look at: could you have bought the S P index? You could not, because you there, for one thing, you didn't buy an index. Index funds are a
22:47
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): product of the 1970s. You could buy a mutual fund. Those were really expensive. So fees on those are going to be five to six percent. So if you give a hundred dollars to your lose six dollars, then you have to make that back up. That's not in that chart, by the way. The second thing that's not in the chart is if you wanted to buy the index on your own, okay, I'll just buy it myself. I'll buy all the things. You
23:07
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): would have to have 100 shares of every stock in that index. It'd been a million dollars back then. It's like 12 to 20
23:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): million
23:14
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): dollars today. You're already rich. You don't need the money. The third thing is reinvesting all dividends. That wasn't easy to do. The dividends actually have to get sent to you, and then you have to take them back to a broker and buy new shares, but they don't sell fractional shares. So you got to wait till you have the right amount of money to buy just that amount. Then you have another transaction for you of 4%.
23:34
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): When you reinvest the dividend, you also lose money. These concepts that if I go on Robinhood and buy an index fund, I don't see any of this. But they did. So they couldn't do what you could do today. That's another reason. It's never been easier. The friction for the average person to get off work, go home, pull up their laptop, and buy and invest in the stock
23:54
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): market has never been lower. That was not true until really my lifetime. I still remember the e e-trade trade baby ads where uh it's like so easy a baby could do it. was the idea. Those stock trades were still $15. When people heard that you could trade for $15, they were like, are you kidding me? One trade for $15? Even Schwab was like $40 to $50.
24:14
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): It's this drive down of cost of investing, the ease of it, the security of it. It's all easier than it used to be.
24:21
Carly: 100%. There was just so many mind-blowing ideas that came from that. Logistic. Logistically speaking, how would someone actually have that money in 1929 to buy the SP 500? Thanks for breaking that down and really truly outline how it is so much easier now to get rich with
24:41
Carly: stock market investing and index funds. Since we're talking stocks, let's talk about the financial independence retire early movement. People think that this is a new movement. It is not. Let's look back at history. What does history say about financial independence?
24:55
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): The idea of the fire movement is that it's a bunch of tech bros working in San Francisco, making gobs of money, and they put half of it away and they retire at 38. The reality is that people were retiring early and financially independent pretty much in every town in America for most of American history. histories. I have a guy in the book named Sylvester Judd. He's like born the year of the Constitutional Convention. He dies
25:15
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the year before the Civil War. He lives every year at Bannabellum America. He works for half of it. He had a printing business. He sold it when he's in his 40s, 30s, and he was like, well, I
25:24
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): have
25:24
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): enough. He's not wildly wealthy, but he had enough. This was common. A lot of the histories that were written, a lot of the science that was done in the 1800s was done by people who had enough. Now, they're not going on Instagramming Instagram in Buenos Aires and Instagramming their best life. That was not a goal anyone had. But they were like pursuing other things that just weren't monetary.
25:44
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): There's also people selling you the dream of financial independence all the way back to the 1800s. Thoreau leaves home and goes to the woods and packs a cabin out of the woods. Emerson, who's his best friend, travels around Europe writing essays. You shouldn't let work own your life. There we go to the 20th century. There's a couple named Helen and Scott Nearing. They moved to Vermont. start a maple
26:03
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): farm, and they say they work four hours a day. It's the original four-hour workweek book. It's four hours a day. Huge bestseller. The New York Times drools over them. They found the way back to Walden Pond and independence. All right, let's go back over that. Thoreau, his mom brought him food to the cabin so he wouldn't starve. And Emerson is worse. Emerson's
26:23
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): wife died, but she left a trust fund. He sued her. parents to get the trust fund. The day he won the lawsuit, quits his job, and goes to Europe to write essays about not working too hard. The Nearings had not told anybody that they had not one but two massive inheritances they were living on. All these people read their book, flock to
26:43
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Vermont to learn from them and start to starve in Vermont in winter because they don't have inheritances they're living on. and you can't do a maple farm on four hours a day. Here's what I tell people the reality of financial independence is very old and very real. Selling you financial independence, that's a different thing. Just be careful of what they put in the fire because it can get toxic. But if you
27:03
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): just want to set back and say, can you actually work hard enough, save aggressively enough to live a life where you choose what you do? People have been doing that for three centuries. And you can too.
27:15
Carly: Totally. I want to do a side tangent. I want to talk about women and money and history. There's so much that we could dive into. First, I do want to hear your wife's initial reaction when you were like, hey hun, I want to retire early. What did she say?
27:33
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I start try tr I think I'm selling it, right? Like I'm trying to sell like this dream that I have that she doesn't. Uh, because she she likes working and she likes what she does and she likes the energy of the career and she likes the money and she likes to spend, you know, not nothing against her, by the way. She's not like flippant. My wife is an incredible woman, incredibly deep, thoughtful person. But she has no problems working. I, on the other hand, was like, let's
27:53
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): get out, let me outrun this thing, spend my time reading books and writing and doing all the fun things you get to do as a writer. I'm pitching it, I'm I'm selling it. It becomes the dinner table topic. I can tell she's getting annoyed. Then I think, well, let me get somebody else to sell her on this. Around somewhere in the midst of this, there was a documentary that came out about a couple in California living a very consumer culture. He's a filmmaker, and they decide
28:13
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): to pursue financial independence. They they go out and live with their parents for a while. They go to Oregon and live close to Ben to try to back then Ben was affordable. They're succeeding. They're gonna do it. They're gonna make it into financial independence. They're living a simpler life in a much smaller home, all these things. And I'm like, she's gonna love this. Somewhere in the movie, my wife just bursts into tears. My wife is not a crier. She looked at me,
28:33
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): she says, if this is what you want, I would hate every minute of it. Okay, well, there went that idea. The idea that I was going to earn and then under consume and then live a much, much simpler life. That wasn't what she signed on for. We're at that point, point we're for 15 years into marriage. I think when people get excited about the fire movement, it's very easy to think you can just drag your spouse along. drag other people with you. They aren't
28:52
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): excited about your dream. You have to figure out, especially in couples, how you're going to navigate not always seeing that the same way. And is there a way that you can compromise? Is there a way you can kind of find a path that works together? I was a bad salesman for the fire movement. They would not hire me to sell the fire movement.
29:07
Carly: In your findings in the book, you pointed out the more recent pioneers who retired early actually do want to work as well. Oh,
29:17
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): yeah. There are a handful of the early fire movement people who just truly were like, Well, I've got enough now, I'm good. But most of the people in that early movement found out what people found out in the 1800s, what Sylvester Judd found out when he had enough and could do whatever he wanted. Well, you can only take so many walks, right? You can only play so much golf that At some point you're like, I want to do something
29:37
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): meaningful with my life. So Sylvester Judd went around writing histories of New England and researching the history of his towns. A lot of the fire bloggers, the early ones, are in fact doing something productive because at the end of the day, you're a human being and you want to do something meaningful with your life. If you're into the fire movement, that's great. It's wonderful. On the other side of it, highly recommended. But you have to have something
29:57
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that gives you meaning with to do with all that freedom. Otherwise, you will become self-destructive. And I've met some of those people too. For me, it's writing. I'm a writer. I love to write. I love to talk to people. I love to share ideas. I don't have to do it, but it gives my life meaning. That's one of the things people don't factor in. I just want out of this grind. I hate this job. I hate having the the name of the company on my shirt every day. Fine,
30:17
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you get free from that and you got your own name on your shirt. Now what? It's good to know what that meaning is gonna be.
30:23
Carly: Right. Yeah, and I totally love that. I'm all about financial independence. I feel like it's not the modern day of save twenty-five times your annual expenses, boof, you're gonna sit at home and do nothing. I am totally big on whatever life you envision, once you have that magical number, why not start living that life right now? Right. And it seems like you and your wife kind of found
30:43
Carly: that happy mix where she's like, Hey, I actually love my job and you love writing, even though you personally reached with your real estate. portfolio, you still are doing work that you enjoy and find meaning with. I think that's a great message of the book looking back at Americans' history as well. I do want to touch on women and money. We look
31:02
Carly: back at the 1960s and often pinpoint that as the time that women were liberated and they started working. That's not the case. History says women have always been very efficient business savvy people. What does history truly say about women and working and investing?
31:19
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): The history of America was largely written as a history of the middle class, quote unquote. But middle does not mean middle third. Middle income was the top 10 to 15% of Americans. The histories of what people did and what women did were largely of elite women, wealthy women, well well-to-do, to do, well well-educated educated families. They left out the bottom 80% of Americans. If you look at the history of the bottom 80%
31:39
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): of Americans, women were working all the time and handling money all the time. We have this illusion created by just focusing on kind of the upper crust of society that women were stuck at home in the parlor, playing bridge, talking gossip. Then they got the right to have credit lines of their own in the 1970s. Sigourney Sigorney Weaver went
31:59
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and did Working Girl, and now we can all take over the world. For 80% of women, that wasn't their life. Every woman I was raised around had worked. Every woman I was raised around usually handled the family money. I knew stories of grandmothers and great grandmothers who had worked. I was like, are we weird? No, actually, we were normal. Women were working throughout all history. Now, the reason those graphs look like they go up and up and
32:19
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): up is because a lot of women's work was what we would call today self self-employment employment income. If a woman is at home churning butter and raising chickens and taking eggs. into the marketplace early in the morning, you don't count her as employed, but she's doing self-employment income. That's one of the reasons this gets obscured. Another reason, the number one mortgage payoff strategy, this is one of the takeaways from the book. If you go through
32:39
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): American history, the number one way people paid off their mortgage before World War II was renting out rooms, house hacking, bigger pockets came up with the term, but other than that, that's been happening forever. Women are running all of that. They're handling the money from the renters, they're handling cleaning up, they're handling the food, they're all of it is coming from women's labor. But they're not counted as
32:58
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): employed. Women are working all the time. What I found and what other historians have started to discover is that men would come home with a literal pay envelope. You didn't get a check, you got an envelope with cash in it, and they would usually hand it to their wives, who then had to do all the work of budgeting it and allocating it. and spending it and putting it in savings. Men might show up for like
33:18
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): really big moments, like signing mortgage documents. Women were doing a lot of that labor. This is not a well see, women were always empowered. No, no, no. Women and men both hated this. You can find essays in good housekeeping, the magazine in the 1870s 70s and 80s, complaining about having to do the budget. It was like a game of hot potato, and the usual rule of
33:39
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): thumb was husband or the wife, the one who would do it was the one who hated it the least. Right? If the if the wife hated it less than he did, she had to do the budget. And if he hated it less than she did, he would do the budget. The budget was really a family thing. Women were usually in charge of it, especially for working class families. Oh, women were also investing. Women were very active investors in
33:59
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the stock market. They owned half of the shares in ATT in the 1890s. Half of the shares were owned by women. Abigail Adams, the first lady of the United States, was one of the most successful investors in American history. Her lifetime investment returns are right at 17%. Warren Buffett's or 19%. Think about just a woman's life. She's constantly seeing the economy. She's
34:19
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): constantly seeing what money does. She's constantly seeing what things cost. And she's constantly seeing where the opportunities are. Women were always and everywhere active investors. in American history.
34:28
Carly: Yeah, I absolutely love that. One thing that I wanted to talk about was credit cards and credit card points. Card points are not a new idea, and you say they are a scam. Why is that?
34:42
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I think this is one of the most fascinating things I discovered in the book. Before there were credit card points, there were store stamp programs. You would go to the department. store, they would be signed up for a loyalty program. For every dollar you spent, you got so many stamps. You'd collect them in a stamp book, and when you got enough stamp books filled, you could send them in for whatever you
35:02
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): wanted to order, like a special item that was only available through the stamp program. There were competing stamp programs. It was a red, a blue, a green. If you got a blue stamp from one store, you couldn't use it as a red stamp. Some places were like, we'll honor blue stamps. at our store, but only this month. Other places were like, we're gonna give two stamps or five stamps. Like people were playing the stamp game the same way
35:22
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): today. People are running around playing the points games. Like, I'm gonna get this card and I'm gonna get three X on food, but I do my travel because I get five X on travel. People are doing the same thing with stamps. It was so popular. The blue stamp or the red. One of them went under. They went bankrupt. When the news hit, women fled. flooded into their warehouse to like, I have stamps
35:42
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and you better redeem them. The New York police department tried to hold them back and failed. These women rushed into this place and got and got what they got for their stamps. I've been saving my points forever for this vacation and you're taking it away from me. It's the same phenomenon we have with credit card points. It's not an accident. The company that figured out how to move from stamps to points was Sears, who's a
36:02
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): retailer. who knows how people love their stamps.
36:05
Carly: With the stamps, the findings were even though people thought they were getting stuff, they actually ended up spending how much more?
36:11
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): People would spend more to get more stamps, which is of course what the retailers understood. They knew that, like, we're literally getting people to spend more money than they need to spend because they're chasing these stamps for these quote unquote free rewards. That is the same psychology that underlies credit card points. So if I go and I swipe it, I'm like, I'm getting one and a half percent back because
36:31
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Samuel L. Jackson told me that's cool. But they charged you 3% more at checkout. That's the swipe fee.
36:38
Carly: Prices increase because
36:40
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of
36:40
Carly: the stamps and because of the points. Exactly.
36:43
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That's
36:43
Carly: something that people in this economy people don't understand, right?
36:47
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yes. Yes.
36:48
Carly: Explain how prices have increased. because of credit card points. Let's dive into that a little deeper.
36:55
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): If you go, and you'll still see this in some places, they would give you the choice. You could either pay cash for it or you could pay with a car, but you had to pay a little bit more. Some gas stations still to this day will have a cash price and a credit price. That credit price is about 3% more. That's Visa, MasterCard, American Express, Discover. That's their fee on top of.
37:15
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that for the convenience. Now it's a great convenience, but it is three percent. Three percent of everything we spend is a lot. That one to two percent you're getting back is because you're getting charged three percent more.
37:24
Carly: Yeah. One thing that you pointed out in the book is people hear one percent cash back and their brain automatically goes to, I'm gonna get one dollar. How much is one percent cash back? Yeah,
37:36
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): ecology studies on these are really interesting. When people hear one percent, they hear what one percent on your money every dollar you spend. Notice how often you'll hear for every dollar you spend, you get one percent. They hear I'm getting dollars. No, you're getting one penny. You're getting one penny for every dollar you spend. How many pennies do you have to uh rack up? Just
37:56
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): as people were doing stamps in the middle of the 20th century? Spin, spin, spin to get those stamps. Gotta collect those stamps. I was going to dinner one. night with a really successful developer. This guy's millions and millions of dollars. And we get out, you got to get gas in his massive car. And he stops and he pulls out, like he goes through a bunch of credit cards and he says, Ah, here it is. It's his credit card for just gas. He's like,
38:16
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): gotta rack up those points. I'm like, dude, it's two pennies. Like it's two extra pennies. What are you doing? You could buy the gas cast station. Why are you worried about this? It's embedded in our psyche. that we have to play this game to quote unquote win, but the house always wins. The points, guys, and some of those shows, there are ways if you really want to really game it, if you want to
38:36
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): gamify it, a handful of people can figure out all the dots. My challenge to you would be: how much would you get just working a part-time job? If you put But all the same hours that you're putting into like mastering the point system into like a shift at star. Starbucks, do you come out ahead? Is it really getting you where you want to go?
38:54
Carly: Exactly. I totally agree. Um, it's not popular opinion, but I'm just like, the points are a hack. It's totally a hack. Everyone thinks they're they're beating the house, but they are not. At the end of the book, you outline out of all of your years and years of research, your PhD in And history, the conclusions, you have the real lessons of financial history. You lie
39:14
Carly: them out. very clearly of what didn't work and what does. We don't have time to go through all of them. I highly recommend everyone grabbing this book. There's so much goodness in here. I created Best Money Class Ever. My mission is to help educate people about money. One thing that I did actually love, especially from someone who came from a standpoint of
39:34
Carly: financial gurus or scam, you did the research. And one thing that you said is if you want to get ahead, find your guru. Why is that?
39:43
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): People
39:44
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): like you who could help them pay down debt. Let's think about this. Gurus get a really bad rap. There's this sense that, like, oh, they're scamming you, they're selling you something. Some of that's true, by the way. There are some people out there just scamming people. Let's not dismiss that. At the very highest level, the gurus who are consistently in your feed have of successful shows who've been doing this forever. What they really offer is a set of consequences. common sense
40:03
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): strategies and practical ideas that you kind of need to hear packaged in a way you can understand it. If I pivot to to the finance professors at Yale who have these wonderfully long, complex equations about how to perfectly master a financial life. And I compare gurus to finance professors that people are going to go, gonna oh, well, the finance professors must be better. I
40:23
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): have yet to see a financial equation that models a midlife crisis. or a child with special needs. Those are the things that you're gonna hit. Whereas a guru understands Super Bowl ads work, birthday sex leads to baby number three, jobs go overseas. You're gonna live in this complicated world. You're never gonna be able to figure out all those equations and how they perfectly line up to your life, because they're all designed for a life that looks like
40:43
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): a finance professor's life. What you really need is some common sense principles when you don't know what to do. At that level, most gurus, even the ones you might not like, are pretty pretty okay for giving a general hey, it's complicated and scary out here. I need to know which way to turn. For the people who could say, Hey, turn this way, not that, you're gonna end up in a better place. People giving you basic common sense advice and then
41:03
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): practical ways to implement it, are gonna do you more good than all the finance professors that you can't understand and you can't call them when your dad gets Alzheimer's. I'm a bigger fan of gurus than most people are.
41:12
Carly: Definitely. One specific thing that I like. and I try to model for my business and what I'm doing is you say buy the books, spend twenty, thirty dollars versus the thousands of dollars seminars. Yeah. For me, with my I have it's called literally the name of the finance plan. It's a simple roadmap, step one, two, three, four. You also say
41:33
Carly: get the free stuff, the free and listen to the podcasts, the guides, all that.
41:37
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): People like you who could co who lay things out. for people. You literally solve somebody's problem. You are helping them navigate the complexities of financial life. You're doing it in ways they can understand. People are happy to support people who help them solve their problems. People who are like, I want to help you solve your problem. I have steps to do it. Here's how we're gonna go about it. Not only is it is it useful, it's actually very people have been doing that for a long time.
41:57
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And it's it's really helpful for people.
41:58
Carly: Thank you so much. Let's leave on your final biggest tip. If someone wants to get rich in America, what does history say the best thing to do is?
42:09
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): In
42:09
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the book, I've got like 25 lessons from history that work in every era, seven that fail in every era. So don't do those. I can boil something down to five kind of basic ideas. Number one, solve somebody else's problems. The biggest money is not made solving your problems, it's solving somebody else's. Number two is take a take more risks. Not talking about gambling, not talking about sports betting, not talking about crypto. I'm talking about take
42:29
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): risks on you and your success and your ability to advance your own career, invest in something. Three, move more. A lot of American uplift is about going where the opportunity is. You're gonna raft faster if the water's with you, right? Go where all the energy is. It's okay to move and go where the opportunity is. Fourth is uh uh is marry well. That doesn't just mean marrying rich, it means marrying into
42:49
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): somebody who's gonna be on a life journey that you has the same values for success that you have and responsible behavior to do it. And then finally, to believe that you can. And I know that sounds so self helpy and so guruy. I'm not naturally the optimist. The more history I studied, the more I've found that optimism outperforms so many other factors in the people who succeed.
43:08
Carly: Thank you so much for being on. I definitely feel like there's so much insight. I think that people can be very pessimistic. like childcare, housing, food. This is such a message of you can build wealth. And I love that the human capital aspect of what you're saying is that you need to invest in yourself and take
43:28
Carly: the risks and build the life you've envisioned. Thank you so much for all the insight. If people want to grab the book and find more of you, where can they connect with you? Yeah,
43:37
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): historyhelps.com is my website. You can find essays that I write there. You can find the uh links to the book. Historyhelps.com is the best place to find me.
43:45
Carly: Thank you so much, Joseph.
43:46
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Thank you so much. I've really enjoyed it.
43:48
Carly: I am with Dr. Joseph Moore. I do believe that you can get rich in America today. There are things specifically about this moment in time that are tricky, like student loans, housing, childcare, but if it's easier than ever to invest in the stock market. There's assessing accessibility to building wealth. Historically, the poverty levels have dramatically decreased.
44:08
Carly: We wish they were zero, but they're way lower than they used to be. When you look at basic things like the 90% of people's pay going towards the necessities, food, housing, and clothing, right now, things aren't quite as bad as they used to be. If you feel like things are tough, this is not in any way to invalidate your experience. This is to
44:27
Carly: instead give you hope. I hope that you turn things around. If he can get rich, I believe you can too. I'm really curious and I would love to hear from you. Do you think it's easier now than ever to get rich in American history? What are your thoughts? Do you think previous generations had it easier than we do now? Spill Fill your financial tea and leave a comment below if you're
44:47
Carly: watching on YouTube or listening on Spotify. Thank you, my yellow group. groupers, for listening. Every show has a dope name. They call their listeners. I'm calling you my yellow groupers. We have slow start. We feel behind. Life does not go as planned. The cards are stacked against us, the hands we are dealt are not ideal. We don't ever, ever give up. That is where our grit is born. Our trials, our adversities, that's what makes
45:07
Carly: us stronger. Did you like this episode? If so, like it and subscribe. Share it with a friend who also geeks out over money. If you are listening on Apple or Spotify, make sure and follow and leave me a review. Are you tired of figuring this money stuff out on your own? You can turn things around in a month. I will show you exactly
45:23
Carly: how.com or the link below to get on the wait list. You'll instantly get a free 20-page downloadable guide to start the finance plan. My signature four-step. system to gain financial independence. As always, remember you only live once. Be
45:43
Carly: smart with your money now. I will catch you next week. Bye.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights