Steamboat Real Estate & Investing With Ryan Cox

YVHA reports 80% sales at Cottonwoods while highlighting wage-AMI disparity in Steamboat housing market

26 min Listen to the original
Real EstateHousing AffordabilityNonprofit DevelopmentRegional EconomicsConstruction Costs

Summary

Alyssa Cartmill of YVHA reports that The Cottonwoods project has sold 69 of 86 units, marking an 80% sales velocity for YVHA's first for-sale development in two decades. She highlights a significant affordability gap in Routt County, where Area Median Income (AMI) rose 54% from early 2020 due to out-of-state tax filers, while local wages increased only 17%. YVHA is addressing this through down payment assistance programs, having deployed over $500,000 across 18 transactions, and the Home Base Steamboat program which supports local employees without AMI restrictions. The discussion covers upcoming infill projects like Hilltop and Slate Creek, noting that high construction costs and building codes continue to hinder private sector supply.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    So we've definitely seen that get skewed heavier mostly since the pandemic, as you have more out of state people that are filing their taxes within Route County.

    Alyssa Cartmill · 2:15

  2. 2
    Hopefully, all of that can be lined up by the end of this year. And then we can start kind of acting on it in 2027.

    Alyssa Cartmill · 10:30

Episode sections

  1. 0:34 – 1:35

    Cottonwoods Sales and YVHA Development Pipeline

    Alyssa Cartmill reports that The Cottonwoods, YVHA's first for-sale project in 20 years, has sold 69 of 86 units. YVHA is also advancing two infill projects (Cottonwoods Phase Two and Hilltop with the US Forest Service) and the long-term Slate Creek project.

  2. 1:35 – 4:45

    AMI vs. Wage Growth Disparity

    Cartmill explains that Routt County AMI rose 54% from early 2020 to present, driven by out-of-state tax filers, while local wages increased only 17% in the same period. The AMI is calculated based on taxable income filed within the county.

  3. 4:45 – 8:35

    Down Payment Assistance Programs

    YVHA has spent over $500,000 on 18 transactions offering up to $20,000 in down payment assistance, with options to stack for up to $40,000. A new state-level program for teachers and first responders offers lower interest rates, though its interaction with YVHA funds is still being evaluated.

  4. 8:35 – 9:51

    Home Base Steamboat Program

    YVHA administers the City of Steamboat's Home Base funds, which provide funding to local employees for home purchases without AMI restrictions. The program uses deed restrictions to maintain local inventory, with seven closed transactions ranging from single-family homes to townhomes.

  5. 9:51 – 12:47

    Slate Creek and Hilltop Development Updates

    The Hilltop project is located behind Yampa Valley Bank and involves the US Forest Service and the city. The Slate Creek neighborhood roadmap is in final processing steps, aiming for completion by end of year to begin action in 2027, following a 2019 land donation by anonymous donors.

  6. 12:47 – 14:08

    Affordability Gaps and Market Comparisons

    Cartmill notes that the 'missing middle' (e.g., teachers/firefighters earning $150k-$200k) faces significant affordability gaps. YVHA benchmarks against Eagle, Summit, and Routt counties for deed restrictions, and Denver/Boulder for LIHTC financial stacking.

  7. 14:08 – 21:36

    Construction Costs and Private Sector Role

    High construction costs and building codes hinder private sector supply. YVHA suggests employers and developers collaborate on technical support and land use, noting that YVHA is sales tax exempt up to certain AMI levels, which can subsidize material costs.

  8. 21:36 – 25:37

    Long-Term Vision and Community Impact

    Failure to address housing could strain community bonds and tourism due to workforce loss. Success metrics include annexing Slate Creek, preserving mobile home parks (e.g., Whitehaven), and ensuring diverse product types for mobility and retirement.

Claims worth verifying

The Cottonwoods has 86 total units, with 69 sold as of the interview.

Ryan Cox ·0:44

How to verify: Check YVHA press releases or sales tracking data for The Cottonwoods project; verify unit count and sales status via YVHA website or local real estate records. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Routt County AMI increased 54% from early 2020 to present.

Alyssa Cartmill ·2:15

How to verify: Compare HUD Area Median Income data for Routt County, CO for the years 2020 and 2026; calculate the percentage change. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Local wages increased 17% in the same period AMI rose 54%.

Alyssa Cartmill ·3:03

How to verify: Analyze Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) Local Area Unemployment Statistics (LAUS) or Census ACS wage data for Routt County for the specified period. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

100% AMI for a single household is $97,100.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·2:03

How to verify: Check HUD's published Area Median Income tables for Routt County, CO for the relevant year. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Home Base Steamboat has had seven closed transactions.

Alyssa Cartmill ·9:15

How to verify: Check YVHA program reports or press releases regarding Home Base Steamboat closings. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Slate Creek land was donated by anonymous donors in 2019.

Alyssa Cartmill ·11:48

How to verify: Review YVHA board meeting minutes or press releases from 2019 regarding land acquisition for Slate Creek. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

YVHA is sales tax exempt up to a certain AMI level.

Alyssa Cartmill ·20:37

How to verify: Check Colorado Department of Revenue regulations or YVHA tax status documentation regarding sales tax exemptions for affordable housing development. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

YVHA published a housing and market demand study in 2025.

Alyssa Cartmill ·23:15

How to verify: Search for the 'YVHA Housing and Market Demand Study 2026' on the YVHA website or public records. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

YVHA purchased Whitehaven mobile home park.

Alyssa Cartmill ·22:52

How to verify: Check county property records or YVHA press releases confirming the acquisition of Whitehaven. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify Routt County AMI trends using IRS Public Use Data Files or local assessor records to confirm the 54% increase attributed to out-of-state filers.
  • Check YVHA's annual financial reports or IRS Form 990 for details on the $500,000+ down payment assistance deployment and specific transaction counts.
  • Review the City of Steamboat's official website or municipal code for the Home Base Steamboat program's deed restriction terms and eligibility criteria.
  • Confirm the status of the Slate Creek and Hilltop projects through the City of Steamboat Planning Department or US Forest Service project trackers.
  • Compare local wage growth data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) for the Steamboat Springs, CO MSA against the reported 17% increase.
  • Investigate construction cost indices for Routt County via the RSMeans Data or local contractor associations to assess the impact of building codes on private sector supply.
Full transcriptexpand

0:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Welcome

0:07Ryan Cox: back to Steamboat Real Estate and Investing. Today I am joined by Alyssa Cartmill, the sales and asset manager at the Yampa Valley Housing Authority. Alyssa, how are you?

0:16Alyssa Cartmill: I'm great. How are you doing?

0:17Ryan Cox: I am doing very well, thank you. Thanks for joining us today.

0:19Alyssa Cartmill: Yeah, happy to be here.

0:21Ryan Cox: So you were just telling me you've been with the Yampa Yamp Valley Housing Authority for ten 10 years. And obviously. you've seen a lot of change, transition, growth. Can you just give everybody a quick state of the union on what's going on with the Imp Valley Housing Authority right now?

0:34Alyssa Cartmill: Yeah. So we definitely have a lot going on at the Housing Authority right now. Some of the high level pieces are we are in our final stages of selling the Cottonwoods, which is our first foresale project that we've done in the last twenty years.

0:44Ryan Cox: Congrats.

0:44Alyssa Cartmill: Yeah, that's very exciting. There's eighty 86 six units total and we just closed on our sixty 69th ninth last week. So wow.

0:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That's very

0:52Alyssa Cartmill: exciting.

0:52Ryan Cox: 80% sold through thereabouts. Yep. Amazing.

0:54Alyssa Cartmill: Yep, with more under contract currently. We just kind of finished up and are gearing up for the next kind of legislative session. So working on kind of the advocacy work that we like to do to help affordable housing and create more, whether that's in development or preservation. And then we're working on development projects. Project. So we've got the one infill, well, two infill projects, kind of Cottonwoods phase two. our project with Hill on Hilltop with US Forest Service and the city. And then obviously Slate Creek is kind of a longer term project that we're still working through.

1:23Ryan Cox: Amazing. Lots of momentum.

1:25Alyssa Cartmill: Yeah.

1:26Ryan Cox: What is the AMI for Route County? And I guess

1:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is

1:31Ryan Cox: the AMI based on the county or the city, or how do you specifically look at that?

1:35Alyssa Cartmill: Yeah. So area median income is the general standard that we use in affordable housing. It's calculated based on taxable income.

1:41Ryan Cox: Okay.

1:42Alyssa Cartmill: So we've definitely seen that get skewed heavier mostly since the pandemic, as you have more out of state people that are filing their taxes within Route County. So you're seeing that gap separate between what local wages actually are and what's being earned in Steamboat and the money. So the money coming in. So for a hundred percent AMI for a single household, it's

2:03Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): $97,100.

2:06Ryan Cox: Have you seen that AMI increase considerably year over year over the last several years?

2:15Alyssa Cartmill: Yeah, so before 2019, on average you were seeing like a two to four percent increase, which is great because that matched what wages were increasing by. In early in 2020 till now, we've seen a 54% increase. Wow. So it's we saw years where it was 9% up to even just over 12% increase.

2:33Ryan Cox: And that increase is that does that tie back to the taxable income and having out-of-state incomes affect the calculation? Is that

2:43Alyssa Cartmill: yeah, it's not necessarily out of state because it's all route counties.

2:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

2:47Alyssa Cartmill: if you file your taxes in Route County, those are the numbers that are coming. coming.

2:52Ryan Cox: Okay. To

2:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): determine

2:53Alyssa Cartmill: those numbers.

2:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,

2:54Ryan Cox: interesting. And the context of my question was simply to try to understand how are wages keeping pace here with inflation, which of course is

3:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): challenging.

3:03Alyssa Cartmill: It is. So with the AMI increasing just over 50%, wages have only increased 17%.

3:09Ryan Cox: Okay. Understood

3:11Alyssa Cartmill: in that same time frame.

3:12Ryan Cox: Okay, great. All right. That is excellent baseline.

3:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): information.

3:15Ryan Cox: Perfect. Thank you. So as we talk about the housing authority, you've given us some of the upcoming development, but just big picture, generally speaking, how would you describe the housing landscape in the Yampa Valley today? And you mentioned you've been here 10 years or with the Housing Authority 10 years. How's it changed from the last five to 10 years?

3:36Alyssa Cartmill: I think it's

3:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): when I

3:38Alyssa Cartmill: first started. the housing authority, I think it was kind of a slow roll change. You could see that it was coming. In the last five years, it's definitely ramped up a little quicker than I think some people would have liked it to have. The affordability gap is growing, you know, definitely between the product types that are out there. I think we're behind in development regardless of income level.

3:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

3:58Alyssa Cartmill: town is just it's just changing a little bit. And it's not just Steamboat that's feeling that pressure. I think our neighborhood communities. also, Oak Creek, Hayden, look at the developments that are happening out there. The housing landscaping is definitely increasing and dramatically compared to over the last five, 10 years.

4:13Ryan Cox: And who who is impacted most by those challenges?

4:17Alyssa Cartmill: I would have to say our local workforce is probably first and foremost with the affordability and the rising prices, a lot of our anything. from dishwashers, teachers, firefighters, our social workers, tradesmen, they're they're feeling that pressure.

4:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The

4:34Alyssa Cartmill: prices are just outpricing what they're currently getting paid. So the affordability, therefore, they're leaving town, which also has the economic impact of where they're spending their money and what we're seeing in that kind of natural way of life of steamboat.

4:45Ryan Cox: Yeah. I I had Chris Magnata from Elevate Home Loans on the sh the last episode. and one of the things that he shared with me that I suspect I'm sure you're aware of is that down payment assistance program for both teachers and first responders. Are you familiar with that program?

5:01Alyssa Cartmill: Yeah, so CHAPA just actually launched this program. I'm great, I'm glad that Chris saw that because I shared it with a bunch of the local lenders a couple

5:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of

5:07Alyssa Cartmill: weeks ago. Yes. But there's definitely that program at the state level. The Housing Authority also has two different down payment assistance programs. Okay. We were awarded just over a million. dollars. We've through the sales of the Cottonwoods have actually helped. We've spent just about just over $500,000 on 18 different transactions. So that's someone can qualify for up to $20,000, or you can even double stack our down payment assistance for up to $40,000 to help with closing costs and build some of that gap, especially with interest rates being so high. It helps to bring that cash in where someone may not have that.

5:37Ryan Cox: Absolutely. So that that would what you just described is the Yappa Valley Housing Authorities program. Yep. Can you share a little bit about what that state level program looks like?

5:47Alyssa Cartmill: Yeah. So they just launched it. We haven't utilized it yet.

5:50Ryan Cox: Okay.

5:51Alyssa Cartmill: But it's just a component where depending on what your job is, they've identified kind of first responders and teachers. It's a lower percentage interest rate on it. So

6:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

6:01Alyssa Cartmill: don't know exactly what it is, probably two

6:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): or

6:02Alyssa Cartmill: three. percent,

6:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but

6:03Alyssa Cartmill: it's just a lower component

6:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to

6:05Alyssa Cartmill: access that funding and you get priority based on your occupation.

6:09Ryan Cox: And can people stack that state level plus the Yemp Valley Housing Authority incentive together? Have you guys looked at that or considered that?

6:18Alyssa Cartmill: I think like our program guidelines are open enough that they would be able to. A lot of times with Colorado Housing Finances and Authority's Authorities programs, they require that the lending comes through them also. So I'll be interested with this pilot program if you have to use a chaff alone to access their down payment assistance, or if like the local lenders can utilize their loan and then you could double-stack a YVHA and a state component.

6:38Ryan Cox: Okay, interesting. So a lot unfolding as that's just been rolled out. Yeah. More to explore. If if someone wants to explore those opportunities, what's the what's your recommendation on how they do that?

6:50Alyssa Cartmill: So there's kind of two steps to that. Number one, I would meet with your local lender, find out where your initial buying power is to then kind of help navigate through that down payment assistance. Your local lender will be able to tell you which programs are going to dovetail best depending

7:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): on

7:02Alyssa Cartmill: which what loan product you're utilizing. Uh from there, I would reach out to the housing authority. We have in-house a housing navigator. RSLE is phenomenal and she'll then be able to walk you through the steps who those contacts are, whether it's the state or the housing authority component. Okay. to help you navigate that and have all that information.

7:17Ryan Cox: Awesome. That's great. I mean, I think for people trying to solve the the equation to be able to speak with a lender and then you guys may spur some creative thinking and creative solutions to to get those folks into housing. Where do you see the greatest unmet need in housing right now? Is it simply the local workforce? Is there a particular pocket

7:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

7:40Alyssa Cartmill: think given how the AMIs have been skewed recently, I think our lower income individuals, we definitely need to find more product type for them. Currently speaking, there's not a lot of foresale opportunities for them. So rentals are still really important in that. That's why the Housing Authority has tried to kind of create that mobility. We started with our low-income income tax credit properties, the reserves, Alpin Alpinglow Glow Village and Anglers 400. And then some sunlight came around and now the Cottonwood. So that we've tried to be able to allow folks to save

8:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): so

8:09Alyssa Cartmill: that they can make those mobility steps. But I don't think that we have enough inventory for those lower population or AMIs to satisfy the need right now.

8:18Ryan Cox: Obviously that that's what you guys are working on, right? With those projects that you referenced. Where let's just dive in a a little bit deeper on those next steps and kind of what the what the path forward looks like for you guys.

8:31Alyssa Cartmill: For development steps?

8:32Ryan Cox: For for yes, for development. So creating new inventory.

8:35Alyssa Cartmill: Yeah. So right now is exciting. There's so many different programs out there, and we currently administer the city of Steamboat's home base Steamboat funds. That's been a great opportunity to allow families in Steamboat to receive funding

8:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to

8:49Alyssa Cartmill: help get them in, but into a product type that. they want. You know, the Housing Authority and most other developers, it's hard for us

8:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to

8:55Alyssa Cartmill: create that supply. A lot of what we've done has been that high des high density condo component that doesn't meet everyone's lifestyle needs, right? Sometimes families are three, four children. That doesn't work in a condo environment. So home base has been really exciting. We've had seven transactions that have closed everything from single family homes to town homes. So that's been a great piece to it. We're working

9:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Can I

9:17Ryan Cox: can I just ask a couple questions on that?

9:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.

9:18Ryan Cox: That's a program I was not aware of. So that somebody comes to you guys, talks to your housing navigator, and they're looking at AMI and vetting the criteria that that family, couple, individual is looking for and trying to pair them with solutions. Is that in essence what that looks like?

9:34Alyssa Cartmill: Yeah, the home home-based based program is actually simpler than that. Okay. There's no AMI restriction. The only component is you need to work for a Route County employer.

9:41Ryan Cox: Okay.

9:42Alyssa Cartmill: And then whatever property you choose to buy, we put a deed restriction onto it to help maintain kind of that local inventory for employees here

9:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in

9:50Alyssa Cartmill: town.

9:51Ryan Cox: Okay, I understand. Yep. So the the home base program is overlaying property with a deed restriction to contribute to supply.

9:58Alyssa Cartmill: Yep.

9:58Ryan Cox: Understood. Okay.

9:59Alyssa Cartmill: And then on the development side, our development team has been working really hard with the city of Steamboat Springs as well as US Force service for the Hilltop project. Um that's located kind of right off of Hilltop behind Yampa Valley Bank there. So that's kind of meeting an employer's needs as well as opening some up for the general community. So that's an exciting piece. And then the city, county, and YVHA have all partnered together to try and find creative solutions and distinguish a roadmap that everyone can be training. open and it can be transparent for the Slake Creek neighborhood.

10:29Ryan Cox: Yeah.

10:30Alyssa Cartmill: So they're kind of in those final processing steps to identifying what that roadmap looks like. Hopefully, all of that can be lined up by the end of this year. And then we can start kind of acting on it in 2027.

10:42Ryan Cox: So it sounds like that's there's a there's a lot of unknowns still to be released. What else about that neighborhood? Because I think, of course, that's the one that has garnered the most attention. and publicity and you know potentially controversy in the past. Yeah. What what other updates can you provide as people are interested in tracking along?

11:00Alyssa Cartmill: Yeah, I think the Slate Creek neighborhood has been kind of an it's an amazing opportunity and we're very blessed to have been given that land to do so. But in the process of it, it's also opened up like a plethora of other issues that it creates, right? You've got community concern. you've got the financial stacking, the product type, the annexation component, the utility piece, making sure that whatever you build out there is going to be sustainable and what the community needs for the next 30, 40, 50 years of planning is that's a big task to take on.

11:29Ryan Cox: Major task. And of course you guys are being super thorough and thoughtful on how you bring that next concept to to the public. Can you share the story? I'm kind of rewinding here to receiving the land for Brown's Ranch now or soon to be Slate Creek. Can you just share that story with us? What did that look like?

11:48Alyssa Cartmill: So back in, I guess it would have been 2019 was when the conversation started. We were blessed with the anonymous donors who came to town and they fell in love with Steamboat Boat for the character it had and what they saw. They could have chosen other mountain communities, but

12:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the

12:01Alyssa Cartmill: Ampa Valley, the Ampa Valley curve. curse, right? Just got a piece of your heart and you don't, you don't want to leave. So they quickly identified the housing challenge. I think just from going out and the staffing challenges and hearing from local employers.

12:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

12:13Alyssa Cartmill: they kind of set a meeting and said, How do we help? And we arranged kind of a list of components, smallest to largest. What could we do? And we were blessed that they chose the largest. I was

12:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): gonna going say to that

12:24Ryan Cox: must have been at the top of the list. Yeah. On the larger side.

12:27Alyssa Cartmill: Yeah.

12:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Wow. Um,

12:28Alyssa Cartmill: so then they made that donation for us to purchase that land.

12:32Ryan Cox: Incredible.

12:32Alyssa Cartmill: Yeah.

12:33Ryan Cox: That's amazing. Yeah, people are excited to hear more about the Slate Creek project.

12:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): What

12:38Ryan Cox: are some of the biggest misconceptions about the housing authority, the work you guys do, affordable and workforce housing here in Steamboat?

12:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,

12:47Alyssa Cartmill: I think some of the biggest misconceptions are that affordable housing is only for low income. low-income households. While it does affect them drastically because they just don't have as in as many financial opportunities, we've seen it impact what we consider the missing middle, which is equivalent to, if you will, your teacher firefighter combo, who's still making decent money, you know, $150,000 to $200,000. But that next home ownership piece is it just keeps coming just that much further out of reach for them.

13:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

13:13Alyssa Cartmill: we don't want that to get lost. I think the other thing is that the housing market will correct itself naturally, that naturally affordable housing is just going to filter back into the pipeline. And so I think we really need to be advantageous and like really work towards as a community, not just the housing authority, but employers, the city, local governments, to like how do we address this the situation to to s

13:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to

13:37Alyssa Cartmill: identify and stop how like this. affordability gap is growing year

13:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): over year?

13:41Ryan Cox: Yeah. And I mean ultimately it's supply, right? That it's it's all about supply. And this concept of

13:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it

13:48Ryan Cox: will correct itself. Having been in construction, having built a lot of projects, it's very expensive. And it's only getting more expensive, of course, with inflation. And then also building codes. So we're doing some smart things with building codes. making homes more efficient, wildfire resistant. But of course, with all of those changes, there's substantial cost. So to build product and to think that the private sector is going to make up that gap, I think is that is a big assumption, an unlikely or unrealistic wish or thought, I would say.

14:22Alyssa Cartmill: Yeah, I would agree. I think from the housing authority's authorities perspective, it would be great to have a little more collaboration. across those entities.

14:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): When

14:29Alyssa Cartmill: we are doing a new development, how do we make that more efficient? What are we missing in a construction plan? Or what needs to be added in? Or realistically, is you know, having some some prefab brought in, like is that the solution moving forward? Because at the end of the day, the two by four for Maribou Maraboo and the two by four for an affordable housing unit cost the same. That's

14:49Ryan Cox: true.

14:49Alyssa Cartmill: So where do we find that extra funding to then subsidize to then lower those costs? Because it's not coming from those,

14:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it's

14:55Alyssa Cartmill: not coming from the land component, the construction, the trade skill. It's a it's a hard challenge. It's a big challenge.

15:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It's

15:03Ryan Cox: a big challenge. What what other cities, towns, markets do do you guys look to as comparables or examples? I'm not as close to it. So I don't know. But I mean I often when talking about steamboat, I often say we're we're doing a really good job. Of course there can always be there always is more work to do. Yep. But what other markets and towns do you guys collaborate with and and brainstorm with and also kind of look to who've in implemented intelligent, effective solutions?

15:33Alyssa Cartmill: Yeah, I think it depends on the area that we're trying to expand in. So for the Cottonwoods for a for sale product. we really leaned on Picking County, Eagle County, and Summit County.

15:42Ryan Cox: Okay.

15:43Alyssa Cartmill: Those three, they all have over a hundred, if not a thousand, deed restricted properties. So what did they learn five, seven years in? How did that deed restricting carry on? What did it help or hurt from an affordability or equity piece years down the road? So we really leaned on them when we started to work through the deed restriction phase. Mountain communities have have been successful with Litech, the low low-income tax credit component. I haven't seen as much of them there. So we lean more on the front range. They seem to be a lot more popular with Denver, Boulder, Longmont, and Fort Collins. So asking them how do you do that financial stacking? Where do you find the subsidy to come in?

16:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It's kind of

16:16Alyssa Cartmill: all that you're everywhere.

16:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): When

16:18Ryan Cox: you look at those other markets like Aspen, which is probably at the most extreme end of the spectrum or Vale, veil.

16:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): how

16:25Ryan Cox: are we pacing? with them? Right? We're our market is certainly at a different price point.

16:31Alyssa Cartmill: Yep.

16:31Ryan Cox: How would you say our affordable housing supply and production is pacing with those markets?

16:39Alyssa Cartmill: I think our production is increasing. Eagle Counties is increasing also. They have the space for it. I think Aspen's trying to find some more creative ways. I don't, I think they're a little more tapped out for the construction standpoint. Yeah. Yep. Um, so they're in the preservation phase, which has been great. I think we are on the right track. The fact that the STR fund was passed and we have money to utilize this is helpful. Aspen has something similar and that's how they're able to do a lot of it.

17:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

17:04Alyssa Cartmill: Eagle County, they just they've got quite the the balance sheet also to do all of that stuff. Eagle County has not done rentals, they've solely focused on the homeownership piece.

17:14Ryan Cox: Okay. Okay.

17:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

17:16Ryan Cox: what do you think some of the biggest obstacles to creating more housing here are? We talked a little bit about construction.

17:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You

17:23Ryan Cox: guys have land, costs, infrastructure, funding, regulations. What what what is what are the top two biggest constraints?

17:33Alyssa Cartmill: I think like everything, where's the money coming from to build it? That's that's probably the first thing, right? So funding would be a big piece to it. I think we've witnessed through some of it community concern, some NIMBYism. Yes. Uh affordable housing, it kind of ri correlates back to the misconception that affordable housing is going to change Steamboat's character. I think it's actually what holds Steamboat's character to what it is. Yes. The people that make the community run are most of the time the heart and soul of the community. Cause Because then you get to experience it at its peak. its peak environment for everything that's done. I think City of Steamboat has been working hard towards their building regulations and the expedited process for affordable housing. So that's helpful because a development project takes a long time from paper to when you actually get that shovel in the ground.

18:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yes.

18:19Alyssa Cartmill: And a lot of things can change.

18:21Ryan Cox: Yeah. It's it's amazing. I mean, it's a recurring theme, as I said before we started recording, whether I'm speaking. I mean, mainly entrepreneurs. I hear it a lot from the entrepreneurs or employers here in town. And it's a story about how they had an employee leave who moved to the front range. They're working remote because they couldn't afford to buy a home here. Yeah. Um and I think I was talking to Travis Campbell, who is the owner of Eagle Creek. Okay. And he used a great word. What he doesn't want to happen in Steamboat is to have a monoculture, right? Have Having a diverse demographic, economically, professionally, racially, o all of the categories, right? That diversity and uh vibrancy I think is what makes Steamboat unique and it's a common theme that that we talk about

19:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): here

19:08Ryan Cox: on the show. So it's really great to hear what you guys are up to and what you're doing.

19:12Alyssa Cartmill: Yeah.

19:12Ryan Cox: To help keep those people here.

19:15Alyssa Cartmill: Yeah.

19:16Ryan Cox: So what role you talked a little bit about it, collaborating with the private sector, but what role should the private sector developers, employers, and the real estate community play in solving this problem? I think there are some things in place, but what what's the housing authorities' view on how the private sector can move the needle as well?

19:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

19:35Alyssa Cartmill: think it obviously depends on like some of the employers employees are already kind of taking this into their own hands. Yeah. But

19:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the

19:40Alyssa Cartmill: housing authority isn't solely going to be able to solve the affordable housing crisis. So I think for us it would be to offer some technical support and help the employers who have the who already have land also. How do they build it to maintain their employment and offer those components? If they've had something that's worked really well, how do you replicate that or share that with other larger or smaller employees? How do you scale that for the community need? I think land, just being aware of what land is available, you know, Steamboat, the infill is is getting minimal, right? People are buying it up, big developments are coming in. So how in some of those big developments can you take a portion for affordable housing or for the workforce that even is just helping create those larger developments?

20:22Ryan Cox: Are are there any incentives for developers or landowners? You know, there's probably tax incentive, but are there any incentives that that you

20:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that

20:32Ryan Cox: you want to make sure people are aware of as they might be thinking about a project?

20:37Alyssa Cartmill: Yeah. So with the Housing Authority, when we've partnered with developers, the Housing Authority actually up to a certain area median income level are sales tax exempt. So that can help save funds if you're not paying sales tax on your on your lumber or any. of those other materials. That can help then subsidize to create that deeper affordability for the project.

20:56Ryan Cox: Okay. And that can look like, I mean, I think from a planning standpoint, depending on the size of the development, there might be a requirement to provide a deed restricted product, right? But above and beyond that, that could be earmarking a certain number of units in a project to be deed restricted. And then they can tap into that. sales tax credit.

21:16Alyssa Cartmill: Correct.

21:16Ryan Cox: Got it. Okay. So then we we talked a little bit about some of the past guests and their concern about having a monoculture here in Steamboat. What's your take? If we don't meaningfully address the housing concerns over the next decade, what is what does Steamboat and the Yampa Yamba Valley look like? What does that look like for the workforce, for businesses?

21:38Alyssa Cartmill: Yeah, I think it's gonna change the sense of community drastically. I think it's gonna affect the way you interact with your neighbor, the people that you see, friendships are gonna be strained because you're not gonna be able to see them walking down the street. They're gonna be, sorry, I have to leave, I've got to drive back to Hayden or Craig or one of our neighboring communities. I think economically it hurts us not having as many people in town. I think it affects our tourism base, right? If you're coming here on vacation and you have to wait 'cause the restaurant doesn't have enough people to work, that's gonna change kind of your vision or your feeling about steamboat. And it's maybe not quite what what you thought it was or what your expectation was. So I think it changes on multiple levels.

22:20Ryan Cox: Yes. Yeah, I agree. And and for the housing authority, what does success look like? as you look forward for the next five to ten years?

22:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,

22:32Alyssa Cartmill: I hope we have Slate Creek annexed and a clear pathway for the neighborhoods that we'd be building out there. I think we would continue to work strongly to preserving some of the mobile home parks. Um we've offered some technical help for both Milner and then we obviously purchased Whitehaven. So I think maintaining some of those pieces, I think continuing to advocate for the affordable housing and increasing the product types that we're able to offer, not only through the housing authority, but through continued program evolution such as home base,

23:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what

23:02Alyssa Cartmill: UC Health is doing with Air Creeks and just kind of adding to that.

23:05Ryan Cox: What other highlights or key messages would you want to convey to people about the Housing Authority and and what you're up to right now?

23:15Alyssa Cartmill: Yeah, I think one of the big things is housing in any development doesn't happen overnight. So we're trying to be very conscious with, you know, we've done a multiple housing studies. I know the city just released theirs. We had our housing and market demand study that was published last year in yeah, twenty twenty five. Making sure that what we're building is what the community needs, that we're not doing knee jerk reactions. We're building product types that people want to live in. We're hitting that affordability component. We've got enough low-income and middle income housing, whether that's rental and for sale, would be ideal. We want to be able to meet the mobility needs of the ever-changing household for someone who wants to downsize, whose kids have graduated and gone off to college and don't need that single family home anymore. How do we help them downsize and save for their retirement piece? How do we help that family save enough money so that they're comfortable expanding their family or feeling comfortable having kids and moving? up into that product type that they want. I think also that comes with creating strong partnerships throughout the community

24:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and

24:09Alyssa Cartmill: just having Steamboat maintain its

24:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): its

24:12Alyssa Cartmill: Western character.

24:13Ryan Cox: Yes. Yeah. I mean I think that's why people choose to come here, right? Is that the feeling uh obviously that that donor.

24:20Alyssa Cartmill: Yep.

24:21Ryan Cox: The feeling, the diversity, it it's unique and special. It's

24:26Alyssa Cartmill: very special.

24:27Ryan Cox: And I think it's something worth protecting. So thank you guys for all of the work that you're doing. Yeah, thanks. I know it's hard work, difficult work, and not everybody agrees on everything, but you guys keep forging ahead. So thank you. If people want to learn more, chat with your housing navigator, they want to get involved. Where's the best place for folks to reach out and get in contact with you guys?

24:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,

24:49Alyssa Cartmill: so probably the best place would be. to start at our website, so yvha.org. From there, we've got a couple of great interactive tools so that people are put in contact with who is best able to address their needs. Um, our housing navigator is phenomenal, everything from

25:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): kind

25:04Alyssa Cartmill: of housing counseling needs to questions about rental units, even if they aren't YVHA IVHA managed, or just what is does the pathway to home ownership look like? That's a great resource. We have a great development. team to help with technical assistance if you are in whether it's mobile home park preservation, curious about a live tech property, or general missing middle developments. So

25:24Ryan Cox: awesome. Yeah. Amazing. Well, thank

25:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you so much. Yeah, thank

25:27Ryan Cox: you so much for all the information and for your time.

25:29Alyssa Cartmill: Yeah. Thanks.

This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights