The Urban Property Investor

Sam Sagas argues Melbourne's property market is undervalued due to political shocks, presenting a buying opportunity.

36 min Listen to the original Episode page
Australian Real EstateMelbourne Property MarketInvestment StrategyPolitical RiskRental YieldsLand TaxValue InvestingDemographics

Summary

Sam Sagas characterizes Melbourne as a 'problem marketplace' where political and regulatory issues have caused property prices to stagnate relative to other Australian capitals. He argues that this divergence creates a value investing opportunity, as 'gradient capital flow' from saturated markets like Perth seeks higher yields in Melbourne. The speaker attributes Melbourne's underperformance to a 'confidence shock' from Victorian policies, including land tax and rental reforms, compounded by pandemic lockdowns. Despite this, he highlights strong long-term demographic fundamentals and rising apartment yields of 6% as signals of undervaluation. With a state election approaching, both major parties have pledged to repeal the land tax, which Sagas views as a catalyst for restoring investor confidence.

Episode sections

  1. 0:00 – 0:25

    Introduction: Melbourne as a 'Problem Marketplace'

    Sam Sagas introduces the concept that real estate wealth is generated by buying 'problems' or undervalued assets. He identifies Melbourne as a 'problem marketplace' where political and financial issues have caused it to underperform compared to Perth, Adelaide, Brisbane, and Sydney, creating a buying opportunity for those willing to pay less.

  2. 0:25 – 0:51

    Market Divergence and Wealth Impact

    The speaker notes that Melbourne has stalled while other major Australian markets have grown exponentially over the last five years. This divergence means households in Perth, Adelaide, and Brisbane have gained significant equity, whereas Melbourne households have seen little to no wealth increase from property ownership.

  3. 0:51 – 1:16

    Gradient Capital Flow and Value Investing

    Sagas explains 'gradient capital flow,' where investors from high-growth markets (like Perth) seek undervalued markets like Melbourne for better returns. He highlights that Melbourne offers city-adjacent properties at a fraction of the cost of other capitals, allowing investors to buy below intrinsic value.

  4. 1:16 – 1:36

    Historical Context and Recovery Stalls

    The speaker details how Melbourne's recovery has been repeatedly broken by COVID-19 lockdowns under Premier Dan Andrews, followed by interest rate hikes and federal tax disruptions. He contrasts Melbourne's recent stagnation with its strong 30-year growth trajectory, noting median prices rose from $131,000 in 1996 to over $1 million today.

  5. 1:36 – 1:55

    Long-Term Demographics and Supply Constraints

    Sagas argues Melbourne has unique long-term potential due to its land availability, capable of supporting a 20-40 million population, unlike Sydney or Brisbane which are land-constrained. He suggests that despite current political scars, Melbourne's demographic fundamentals remain strong.

  6. 1:55 – 2:03

    Landlord Exits and Rising Yields

    Due to regulatory changes and tax shocks, many individual landlords have sold their Victorian properties, reducing rental supply. This has driven apartment yields up to 6%, which Sagas identifies as a signal that assets are underpriced and presents a counter-cyclical buying opportunity.

  7. 2:03 – 2:21

    Regulatory Shock and Investor Confidence

    The speaker attributes lost investor confidence to a 'confidence shock' from various Victorian policies, including land tax, vacant land tax, short-stay accommodation levies, and over 150 rental reforms. He argues these regulations, combined with COVID trauma, have created a negative feedback loop suppressing demand.

  8. 2:21 – 3:30

    Election Stakes and Policy Reversals

    With a Victorian election approaching, both major parties (Labor and Coalition) have promised to roll back the land tax to attract investment. Sagas suggests this political shift, along with potential incentives for foreign investment, could stimulate capital flow and improve the economic mood in Victoria.

  9. 3:30 – 35:52

    Circular Flow of Capital in Neighborhoods

    The 'circular flow' of capital in specific Melbourne neighborhoods (knockdowns and rebuilds) indicates localized construction activity and capital inflow, even if broader city-wide growth is stalled.

Claims worth verifying

Melbourne has not grown in the last five years, while Perth, Adelaide, and Brisbane have grown exponentially.

Sam Sagas ·0:45

How to verify: Check median house price index data from CoreLogic or RP Data for the period 2026-2026 for Melbourne, Perth, Adelaide, and Brisbane. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Melbourne's median property value was $131,000 in 1996 and is now over $1 million.

Sam Sagas ·1:36

How to verify: Check historical median house price data from CoreLogic or ABS for Melbourne for the years 2026 and 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Melbourne has land capacity to support 20 million people, whereas Sydney and Brisbane are constrained.

Sam Sagas ·1:36

How to verify: Review urban planning documents or geographic analyses from the Victorian Government or major real estate research firms regarding land availability and population projections. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Apartment yields in Melbourne are hitting 6% due to landlord exits.

Sam Sagas ·1:55

How to verify: Check rental yield data for Melbourne apartments from Domain, CoreLogic, or realestate.com.au for 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The 18-year property cycle runs from 2027 to 2045.

Sam Sagas ·3:30

How to verify: This is a theoretical framework claimed by the speaker; verify by checking Sam Sagas' published 'Forex Growth Plan' or related investment literature for his specific cycle definitions. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Melbourne is currently ranked sixth in price ranking behind Sydney, Brisbane, Perth, Adelaide, and Canberra.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·1:16

How to verify: Check current median house price rankings from CoreLogic or similar real estate data providers for Australian capital cities. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Dan Andrews attended a Chinese Communist Party Red Army March in Beijing.

Sam Sagas ·1:36

How to verify: Search for news reports or official records regarding Victorian Premier Dan Andrews' attendance at events in Beijing during his tenure. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify current Melbourne median house and unit price trends against national averages using CoreLogic or RP Data.
  • Review the specific details of the Victorian Land Tax Act and proposed repeal legislation to assess fiscal impact.
  • Check ABS data for net overseas migration and internal migration flows into Victoria to validate demographic claims.
  • Analyze vacancy rates and rental yield trends for apartments versus houses in Melbourne using domain-specific property reports.
  • Assess the financial health and policy platforms of both the Victorian Labor and Coalition parties regarding property investment incentives.
  • Compare Melbourne's price-to-income ratios and affordability metrics against Perth, Adelaide, and Brisbane to confirm the 'undervalued' claim.
  • Review historical property cycles in Melbourne post-2008 and post-2020 to understand recovery timelines.
  • Check for any recent changes to short-stay accommodation levies or rental regulations in Victoria.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00
Sam Sagas: To become wealthy out of real estate, you need to buy problems.
0:04
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Houston, we have a problem.
0:05
Sam Sagas: Melbourne is a problem marketplace. The first way to create capital growth is deal growth. And the best way to get a deal is to go to a market with a problem and pay less for the real estate. Melbourne has stalled, it has not grown as much as Perth, Adelaide, Brisbane, or Sydney,
0:25
Sam Sagas: and that's reflected. in its price ranking. Typically, the markets are not this far apart in value. So Melbourne will grow. Melbourne can grow. Melbourne and Victoria gone through an interesting period of both political issues
0:45
Sam Sagas: and also financial issues.
1:04
Sam Sagas: Welcome to the Urban Property Investor. I'm your host, Sam Sagas, here to help you crack the code of real estate wealth. Today's show, code cracking stuff. Yes, we're gonna dig into.
1:16
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
1:16
Sam Sagas: election down in Victoria. It's certainly going to be an interesting one. Will it actually mark a change of government and maybe a change of how households are feeling around the country? Is the federal government about to
1:36
Sam Sagas: also get a wake-up call? Of course, we'll we won't know. The election itself is later in the month. But I thought I'd do a bit of a podcast just to talk about some of the challenges in the Victorian economy. Some of the challenges around
1:55
Sam Sagas: real estate in Melbourne. Certainly being been one of those marketplaces which has been. left out of the party and never got invited. It uh it is the poor cousin to the rest of Australia. So let's uh have a chat about it because
2:16
Sam Sagas: uh it is an interesting market to invest in, but there are pros and cons. There are trade-offs to investing in Melbourne,
2:26
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
2:26
Sam Sagas: certainly. if the government was to potentially change, will that actually create a brighter future? Melbourne has been misfiring and it's also had an element of bad luck over the last couple of years. Some timing which
2:46
Sam Sagas: hasn't really worked out in its favor. But there's a lot of
2:51
Sam Sagas: growth that should get unleashed from Melbourne at some point, which is one of the reasons I think it's an incredible place to buy. If you love buying your locations close to the city for yeah, prices which you can go back and turn back the clock, then
3:10
Sam Sagas: Melbourne's the market to uh definitely jump on. But hey, welcome back, regulars. Play the program in double speed, get your life back. All the episodes I've done are lessons on real estate. So uh, you know, go back and check out some past shows. But I tell you what, uh, my area is now a
3:30
Sam Sagas: construction zone. I literally live in a street where houses just seemingly get knocked down and uh people are rebuilding, and this is known as circular flow. There is a lot of capital coming into my neighborhood. It's great for property values, but it's uh horrendous
3:50
Sam Sagas: to live in. Potentially, I will move my studio. Yes, at the moment I am uh podcasting in my study in my house, but uh I might actually put it in a sneaky little room. I also have a cave, because
4:10
Sam Sagas: I can no longer handle the construction noise. And then if it's coming through on the mic, well, uh I am sorry about that. It is uh not easy. Living the modern world, working from home. In fact, uh I think I need an office.
4:27
Sam Sagas: But uh Melbourne's property market has lost some ground compared to its uh compared to its peers.
4:35
Sam Sagas: Perth, uh Adelaide, Brisbane, as we know from the 18 year property cycle, are the markets which produce results later in that cycle, uh dynamic. So we're closer to growth. in Melbourne and Sydney, but certainly when measured over
4:55
Sam Sagas: the last five years, Melbourne has basically not grown. Sydney's done a little bit of growth, and of course, Brisbane, Adelaide, Perth have grown exponentially through the start of COVID and all the way up until the current
5:15
Sam Sagas: correction in the marketplace. So the last four or five years, if you've bought real estate in your Brisbane's Perth, your Adelaide, you've done extremely well. And certainly
5:30
Sam Sagas: from my business's perspective, we've done a lot of buying on the Gold Coast and Brizzy. Um, And people have done really, really well. And that has been a market which has been driven off the surge of momentum. We've also, though, helped people invest at the bottom of the market
5:49
Sam Sagas: before the growth, pre-growth, in Melbourne. And one of the reasons I love Melbourne is it's as clear as day that at some point.
6:03
Sam Sagas: you are buying real estate below its intrinsic value. You can pick up real estate on the doorstep to the city with city views, park views, river views
6:19
Sam Sagas: for a lot less than you can buy uh in Adelaide or Perth or even Brisbane.
6:27
Sam Sagas: And so uh Melbourne's fallen behind.
6:33
Sam Sagas: And uh that cost of underperformance, of course, unless you follow diversification strategies, means people in Melbourne are feeling less wealthy. And this is one of the reasons why it's very important to own a portfolio across. Australia.
6:52
Sam Sagas: Typically, there's always one market, major market, Perth, Adelaide, Brisbane, Perth, uh, Sydney, or Melbourne, doing well. And that means your
7:05
Sam Sagas: household wealth, your personal wealth, is continuing to grow. But if you just own owned
7:15
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
7:16
Sam Sagas: real estate in Melbourne, or you're from Melbourne and you don't own investments and you own your own home,
7:23
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh,
7:24
Sam Sagas: your household wealth has not increased. You personally are not wealthier. However,
7:33
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh,
7:34
Sam Sagas: citizens of Perth, Adelaide, Brisbane, even Sydney are actually. wealthier if they just own property. And they don't even need to own investments, just their own home. Over the last five years, people in Perth have additional household
7:54
Sam Sagas: wealth of half a million dollars. People in Adelaide and Brisbane, circa $400,000. People in Sydney have a gain of household. wealth of over $100,000.
8:06
Sam Sagas: However, Melbourneites
8:10
Sam Sagas: really have nothing to show for waking up and owning real estate. In fact, you've probably gone backwards. And so that in itself creates a challenge because there's no equity in the market. marketplace. And so for people to upgrade,
8:30
Sam Sagas: for people to transition properties,
8:34
Sam Sagas: they need to, unless they've owned real estate for maybe 10, 15, 20 years, they need to use their wages to upgrade. They need to
8:47
Sam Sagas: use their personal wealth, not equity from the property. because there is no equity in the property. But eventually this unlocks. And when you get uh the first stages of growth, you get the first stages of equity, then people use equity to upgrade, and you start to get this kind of capital flow effect.
9:07
Sam Sagas: But as it stands against Perth, Adelaide, Brisbane, Sydney, there's a lot of wealth in other markets. And of course, that means those
9:18
Sam Sagas: investors will be at some point targeting Melbourne. And this is known as gradient capital flow. Where a person from Perth goes, Wow, the market's done so well. My property's doubled in value. You, I can't see it doubling in value one more time over the next four or five years.
9:37
Sam Sagas: Where's a market which is underpriced? Oh, I'm going to go there and invest. And of course, when you get this outside money coming in, it creates extra uh capital flowing into a marketplace. It means locals are competing with people from other
9:57
Sam Sagas: areas. It means more demand. It means less supply, and it means price. prices rise off the back of it. And we saw that uh clearly unfold as well
10:10
Sam Sagas: late in the 18-year property cycle in Adelaide, Brisbane, and Perth. So Melbourne has grown more slowly than everywhere else. It effectively has not grown. I've been investing in Melbourne. I am very proud to
10:30
Sam Sagas: say I'm an investor in Melbourne because I love buying value real estate. I love buying someone else's pain to create a gain. Real estate is not also just about getting capital growth from the market, it's also about hammering an incredible deal.
10:51
Sam Sagas: and uh effectively creating growth from other people's problems.
10:58
Sam Sagas: To become wealthy out of real estate, you need to buy problems. And Melbourne is a problem marketplace. And all that means if you go back to the Forex growth plan, which is just four ways to create capital growth. The first way to create capital growth. is deal growth. And the best way
11:18
Sam Sagas: to get a deal is to go to a market with a problem and pay less for the real estate. Melbourne, certainly one of those marketplaces. I just bought a property down there and uh picked it up around 12% below a valuation.
11:35
Sam Sagas: So that in itself is the creation. of money. I created around a hundred and forty thousand dollars on that uh purchase by buying the property well. The growth from the market will eventually come, but what I
11:55
Sam Sagas: also got was I bought What a great location. Sometimes when markets grow exponentially. people late to the party are forced out to the more speculative areas. When you're early to the party, you get to buy the best locations.
12:14
Sam Sagas: But Melbourne has stalled, it has not grown as much as Perth, Adelaide, Brisbane, or Sydney, and that's reflected in its price ranking. If there was a scroll, scoreboard when it comes to house prices, it's Sydney, Brisbane, Perth, Adelaide,
12:34
Sam Sagas: Canberra. And in sixth spot, it is now Melbourne, which kind of doesn't make sense. You would think Melbourne would be more in line with uh Brisbane. And even it has a delta. against Sydney. Typically, the markets are
12:54
Sam Sagas: not this far apart in value.
12:58
Sam Sagas: So repeatedly, Melbourne's recovery has been broken.
13:04
Sam Sagas: In 2020, it got broken off the back of COVID. And obviously, it is well
13:13
Sam Sagas: spoken about. just how hostile COVID was for Victoria. Some uh lockdowns by Dan Andrews
13:25
Sam Sagas: that still to this day seemingly haven't had a royal commission. Um, it'd be very interesting to unpack what really went on with Dan Andrews. Um, I'm always like I find that guy very, very strange. I think it's strange that
13:45
Sam Sagas: he appeared in
13:48
Sam Sagas: uh a Red Army March in Beijing in a photograph with some of the uh most communist
14:01
Sam Sagas: and uh some of the craziest dictators that have ever walked this planet.
14:08
Sam Sagas: I think
14:09
Sam Sagas: personally that was
14:12
Sam Sagas: unbelievable to see that
14:16
Sam Sagas: a premier of a capitalist country is actually Uh proud to go to watch the Chinese Communist Party's red. Army do a parade.
14:30
Sam Sagas: Mental. Mental. So I have no idea
14:34
Sam Sagas: what went on behind the scenes there, but I can tell you from a property perspective, it cooked things. And as we know, Melbourne's recovery got broken through COVID. In fact, in 2020, or 2019, just before the pandemic,
14:55
Sam Sagas: there were some great auction clearances in Melbourne. There was prices starting to grow, and then bang, COVID, and it all broke down. The megalomaniac took hold. Big Dan.
15:10
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
15:10
Sam Sagas: of course, uh, there has been also.
15:15
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
15:15
Sam Sagas: other green shoots, and uh, you know, most notably,
15:21
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
15:22
Sam Sagas: we had a better 2023, but then in 2024, it sort of broke down as interest rates we went through uh a cycle of interest rates. And then of course, now off the back of uh higher rates. and of course, the disruption from
15:42
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
15:42
Sam Sagas: the federal government when it comes to taxes,
15:47
Sam Sagas: the recovery of Melbourne has once again been broken.
15:52
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
15:52
Sam Sagas: of course, this is creating more opportunity for people to put their foot in Melbourne and buy some real estate because you're not buying growth. you're buying location. And real estate has a famous phrase: location, location, location. When markets are skyrocketing,
16:12
Sam Sagas: you typically miss out on buying the best locations because they become unaffordable. But where markets are
16:20
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
16:21
Sam Sagas: basically where Melbourne's at, you can buy incredible pockets and I wouldn't buy anything in Melbourne. I would be specific about your value chances in certain locations.
16:36
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now,
16:36
Sam Sagas: Melbourne's had fantastic growth over a 30-year period. If you go back to 1996, the median property value in Melbourne was 131,000. a hundred and thirty-one thousand. Now it's well over a million dollars. So Melbourne will grow. Melbourne can grow.
16:56
Sam Sagas: Melbourne has
16:59
Sam Sagas: just gone through and Victoria gone through an interesting period of both political issues and also
17:12
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
17:13
Sam Sagas: financial issues. Obviously, 71%
17:19
Sam Sagas: of Victoria's growth is driven through migration. And again, like it is a Melbourne will be a 20 million person city. If you look at all of the major land masses around urban areas, only Melbourne.
17:39
Sam Sagas: has land
17:40
Sam Sagas: that can home twenty million people. Sydney cannot do it. Sydney would have to become a very vertical city. I don't know if the NIMBY's will allow you to get there. Brisbane is
17:56
Sam Sagas: capable of
17:59
Sam Sagas: not much more than eight million. people, maybe. Uh it's got it's it's a very, very disorganized place at times. It's got
18:11
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um,
18:12
Sam Sagas: you know, uh the river down the middle,
18:15
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um,
18:15
Sam Sagas: and it hasn't got you know huge amounts of of flat land that are close to water sources. And then you've got uh you know Perth and and Adelaide. Um but certainly from a
18:31
Sam Sagas: come back when you're extremely old and what will be Australia's biggest is going to be Melbourne. It's gonna have 2030, it could have 40 million people in it by 2100, 2200. It'll It will be huge. It will be a colossal place.
18:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So just
18:51
Sam Sagas: knowing that if you buy some real estate
18:54
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): for
18:55
Sam Sagas: circa a million bucks, and you're picking up city views and you're five kilometers from the city, you're gonna do well. You are gonna do well. That real estate, if it was in Brisbane, Melbourne, Perth, Sydney today, would be two million bucks. That's kind of the advantage of Melbourne right now.
19:16
Sam Sagas: But
19:17
Sam Sagas: investors have certainly lost confidence in Victoria and Melbourne.
19:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
19:26
Sam Sagas: and
19:28
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
19:28
Sam Sagas: lot of investors that own real estate in Victoria sold. They got out. And of course, this means there's less landlords, individual landlords in Victoria.
19:39
Sam Sagas: today. And when there's less landlords, there's less properties for rent. And of course, that means you have more market opportunities if you are a landlord in Melbourne today. And some of the yields are becoming quite good. We're starting to see
19:59
Sam Sagas: some of the apartment yields hit 6%. six percent, which is a telltale sign the actual assets are
20:10
Sam Sagas: underpriced. And so yields are certainly improving down in Melbourne by virtue of landlords leaving. Again, this is counter-cyclical buying, counter-cyclical concept. concepts. There are fewer rental bonds at the
20:29
Sam Sagas: bond board. That's how we know that. That's how we know that.
20:35
Sam Sagas: But if we look at some of the policy shocks that have really annoyed people in Melbourne,
20:43
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh,
20:44
Sam Sagas: or annoyed the investor community from buying in Melbourne, the first one is that sort of land tax threat. threshold that has really annoyed people.
20:54
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
20:54
Sam Sagas: again, it's not a huge amount of money in the scheme of things. It's like a, you know, from what most investors spend below a million dollars,
21:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
21:02
Sam Sagas: know, it's anywhere from a thousand to two thousand dollars per annum. It's an annoying amount of money, but it's it's not really a deal breaker. But what it has done is because people don't really research into it, they just hear about it, it shocks the market and it creates this kind of like confidence shock. I'm
21:22
Sam Sagas: not going there, I'm not paying $1,500 a year in land tax.
21:28
Sam Sagas: But if you actually do the maths, it's kind of just
21:34
Sam Sagas: it's it's it's not as accurate as uh, you know, for example. example, if you buy a property in
21:43
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
21:44
Sam Sagas: Brisbane in uh in Australia scheme, there's management rights. And what that means is typically you're paying an extra fee to have your building managed. Uh there's if you buy in
22:01
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
22:01
Sam Sagas: tropics, you've got Darwin, uh you've Cairns Towns, but you've got Cyclone insurance, which is way more than the land tax. Some council rate areas on the Gold Coast, the actual council rates are proportionately much higher than the
22:21
Sam Sagas: land tax in Melbourne. So if you took the land tax, the council rates,
22:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
22:26
Sam Sagas: if you buy you're buying strata, the strata fees, and you added them together, is still actually more affordable in Victoria than other areas. But it's the shock of confidence it creates. And the land tax obviously was thrown into the system to pay for
22:46
Sam Sagas: Dan Andrews COVID while whilst Dan Andrews. now attends Chinese Communist Party rallies.
22:55
Sam Sagas: So
22:57
Sam Sagas: the the uh issue with that is it it creates a a level of what the hell is going on for people.
23:06
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
23:07
Sam Sagas: of course there were other taxes the vacant land tax so if you don't use your property you get taxed short stuff stay accommodation levy of 7%, which again is actually not too bad. New South Wales, for example, you can only rent your property on Airbnb for six months out of
23:26
Sam Sagas: 12. There's no tax. Victoria, you can rent it all year round, but you pay a short stay accommodation levy. But there's so many reforms down in Victoria, over 150 rental reforms, and that also annoyed a lot of people. So people
23:46
Sam Sagas: become very political, people become very righteous, people become that their civil liberties are being uh, you know, uh challenged, and they take umbreach. And so a lot of confidence was people just.
24:04
Sam Sagas: yeah, sick of it, just sick and tired of overregulation. And of course, I get it. Um, you know, I see regulations that make no sense and it's too much governance, and what that does is it strips away free market economics,
24:25
Sam Sagas: and uh this is why the this election is going to be very, very interesting. Will the current sitting government, which is a labor government, be replaced by an alternative government? And how much of that replacement is due to the
24:44
Sam Sagas: overregulation Regulation of just too much taxes, too much? red tape, too much
24:54
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
24:55
Sam Sagas: scarring from uh what has unfolded in Victoria from COVID to also some of the corruption that has unfolded, things like the CMFEU FEU
25:11
Sam Sagas: overcharging for the big build, and no one seeing. seemed to being on the hook for it. Yes, the uh current sitting government has replaced their premier
25:23
Sam Sagas: uh because of popularity, and now we're into this typical election period where politicians are starting to bribe the electorate with offers. And so you know.
25:39
Sam Sagas: there is really no real uh statesman when the the whole political thing comes down to to offers.
25:51
Sam Sagas: But if we look at the negative feedback loop, it's definitely taxation, it's economic underperformance,
26:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it's
26:03
Sam Sagas: also obviously the rates today are much higher. There was a weak CBD recovery.
26:13
Sam Sagas: It took a very long time for Melbourne's CBD to recover from COVID.
26:18
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh,
26:18
Sam Sagas: and of course, there was no economic circulation in the CBD because people weren't going there. Certainly uh okay now. COVID, though, created a lot of scarring. A lot of scarring. And, you know, you saw it in the people. We you met people, and they honestly, I
26:38
Sam Sagas: think there's a lot of trauma in human beings, the actual mental experience of living through such a long lockdown. And so,
26:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
26:51
Sam Sagas: the
26:53
Sam Sagas: people inside of Victoria are only just now starting to shake off that um that mental scar, if you like. And certainly small businesses copped it
27:08
Sam Sagas: because you know you can't live off a job keeper. So there was just so much that came at this, you know, city. And I'm I'm talking generally about Melbourne, because actually, when you go outside of Melbourne to Ballarat to Geelong, those marketplaces have performed very, very
27:28
Sam Sagas: nicely because they were not trapped through that COVID era. In fact, they became the beneficiary of people escaping the Iron Dome of Dan Andrews. And again, I think there should be some Royal Commission into this, and how on earth
27:48
Sam Sagas: there isn't makes no sense to me because it is one of the most uh difficult times in um recorded history, and we don't stop and debrief on how wacky it was. and if there was ultimately misgovernment in place.
28:08
Sam Sagas: But uh weaker demand, which effectively happens when people aren't interested in a market, creates less confidence, creates
28:20
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
28:21
Sam Sagas: weaker levels of growth.
28:24
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
28:24
Sam Sagas: again, that's been the story of Melbourne. Do I believe that that story will last forever? I certainly don't.
28:34
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
28:34
Sam Sagas: of course, one of the
28:37
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
28:37
Sam Sagas: conversations, which is now electoral promises from government, and the Victorians go to the govern government go to the poll at the end of the month.
28:49
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And the
28:49
Sam Sagas: reason I wanted to do this podcast was to maybe highlight uh that
28:55
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
28:56
Sam Sagas: Victoria, and if you are a Victorian listener, you don't have to live like what is going on.
29:05
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
29:05
Sam Sagas: it's interesting because I travel, you know, Sydney, Melbourne,
29:09
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
29:10
Sam Sagas: Brisbane, uh, Perth, Adelaide, and you know. it's it they're like different countries now. And again, I would uh suggest before you even vote as a Victorian, go and check out the mood in Brisbane, go and check out the mood on the Gold Coast, come to Sydney and see how we're rolling.
29:31
Sam Sagas: Because I can assure you, life can be better. Life can be a lot better.
29:37
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh,
29:38
Sam Sagas: where you you've got yourselves to, maybe it's time to uh have a think about seriously where your state is headed. Because uh maybe a bit of change may just uh create a bit more of that household wealth, which
29:58
Sam Sagas: is now lacking compared to other people.
30:02
Sam Sagas: If you thought about it as Europe,
30:08
Sam Sagas: and you thought, well, Germans are richer than Romanians,
30:14
Sam Sagas: today
30:16
Sam Sagas: Sydney people, Brisbane people, Perth people are richer than Victorians. Victoria's. And again, it does not need to be that way. So if we look at some of the policies, the Labor Party through uh through their candidate basically
30:36
Sam Sagas: wants to remove the land tax. Wow. So the land tax that Dan Andrews put in, well, that premier
30:46
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is
30:46
Sam Sagas: going to roll it back. Same team, same
30:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
30:51
Sam Sagas: same party. But again, like it's so interesting that these uh concepts, when they become so unpopular,
31:03
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um,
31:04
Sam Sagas: you know, it's it's it's the the the hypocrisy of of of our political class is just unbelievable.
31:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
31:14
Sam Sagas: You know, you should stand by the policy. Your party um rolled it out, so stand by it. Stand by it. But no, they're not standbying it. They're just going to uh repeal it. Um, and uh hopefully that gets them some votes.
31:33
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh and
31:34
Sam Sagas: this is what you see in Australian politics today. Obviously, the coalition has already um, or the opposition
31:44
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
31:44
Sam Sagas: has also said, well, they're gonna roll it back as well. And so, um
31:52
Sam Sagas: from an irritant to investor perspective,
31:57
Sam Sagas: after the election, there should be a clearer picture on where. the land tax finds itself. It'll get rolled back over the next couple of years, according to both political parties. Which I know is uh one of the things which certainly irritates people from investing in Melbourne.
32:17
Sam Sagas: So maybe by removing that, you will
32:21
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
32:23
Sam Sagas: you will encourage more people to invest in Melbourne. the Victorian marketplace. Other things that are also earmarked is to allow foreign investment back into Victoria without the extra land
32:43
Sam Sagas: tax that has been flagged by the Property Council.
32:47
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
32:47
Sam Sagas: you can imagine
32:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
32:50
Sam Sagas: Victorian government's going, well,
32:53
Sam Sagas: we need uh revenue, we need
32:57
Sam Sagas: uh activity, we need to make it more appealing for outside money to come in to help circulate economics. And so a lot of that will be through making it easier to invest in. Victoria, but also not only for
33:17
Sam Sagas: locals, but for internationals. And international money is quite interested in Victoria because of the global
33:27
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
33:28
Sam Sagas: value proposition. From a global perspective, Melbourne is very underpriced compared to your London's, your New York's, your Singapore's. It's
33:39
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
33:40
Sam Sagas: seen as from a global wealth management perspective, as very good value. Very good value. And again, um, some of that money coming in would stimulate activity, it would create jobs, it would create
33:57
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
33:58
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
33:59
Sam Sagas: further
34:00
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um uh
34:02
Sam Sagas: circular activation of capital flow into the Melbourne marketplace.
34:08
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So,
34:09
Sam Sagas: guys, I don't know what's going to happen. I don't like to make the show too political. I like to point out real things like Dan Andrews going to a Chinese Communist Party rally. But equally, I think it's incumbent upon us as property investors.
34:27
Sam Sagas: to let Victorians know they are falling behind and they don't have to live that way. And potentially, off the back of the election, will green shoots appear on the horizon for the Victorian housing marketplace?
34:47
Sam Sagas: Whether it does or it doesn't, I am still investing there. because I love buying value.
34:53
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
34:54
Sam Sagas: the best value, which is circa half the price of many other marketplaces today, is Victoria. And eventually it will grow. When I analyze the 18-year property cycle, Sydney and Victoria, Sydney and Melbourne,
35:10
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
35:11
Sam Sagas: after this period of downturn economics. will absolutely be the best value on the uh recovery food chain of the next 18-year cycle, which goes from 2027 to 2045. Meaning those areas will get uh the
35:31
Sam Sagas: next level of growth, the next wave of growth. And if you
35:35
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
35:36
Sam Sagas: want to listen to that episode, it's a few episodes. ago. So go back and check that out.
35:42
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All
35:42
Sam Sagas: right, folks, that's it from me. Uh we will talk again soon. Um yeah, catch you on the next uh next podcast.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.

More from The Urban Property Investor

The Urban Property Investor

Would You Rather Have More Super or No Mortgage?

Episode discussion: Sam Saggers questions if Australia's $4.77T super system aids retirees or funds government debt via bond purchases.

Speakers’ claims: Sam Saggers argues that Australia's superannuation system, holding $4.77 trillion in assets, primarily serves as a domestic funding source for government debt rather than maximizing retiree wealth. He highlights legislative changes that restricted Self-Managed Super Funds (SMSFs) from leveraging residential property, removing a key wealth-building tool. The discussion notes that super funds are major buyers of government bonds, effectively lending to the federal deficit. Politician Gerard Rennick is cited as proposing alternative access to these funds to help with housing affordability. Finally, the episode suggests that redirecting the 12% contribution toward mortgage repayment could achieve debt-free status faster than super accumulation.

SuperannuationAustralian Real EstateGovernment Bonds
23 min0 assets10 claims to verify
The Urban Property Investor

4 Forces That Could Reshape Australian Real Estate

Episode discussion: Sam Sagas outlines four macro forces reshaping Australian real estate: population growth, AI/energy infrastructure, deglobalization, and demographic shifts.

Speakers’ claims: Sam Sagas argues that Australia's property market is driven by unique demographic and economic trends, specifically a projected population of 40 million and strong immigration. He introduces a 'Three Ps' framework (Population, Participation, Productivity), noting that while population and participation are high, productivity remains a weakness. The episode identifies four key forces: AI-driven energy demand, deglobalization boosting industrial real estate, the 'silver economy' wealth transfer, and changing household sizes. Sagas claims these factors will drive specific property typologies and sectors, particularly industrial and healthcare-related assets, between 2027 and 2045.

Australian Real EstateDemographicsAI Infrastructure
40 min0 assets10 claims to verify
All insights