Analysts recommend selling Westfarmers, REA Group, Technology One, and Pinnacle while holding BHP for long-term growth.
Summary
In this episode of Buy Hold Sell, hosts Patrick Polk, Nick Pashius, and Luke Larative evaluate five ASX stocks to determine which are suitable long-term holds. The panel unanimously recommends selling Westfarmers (WES), Technology One (TNE), and Pinnacle Investment Management (PNI) due to high valuations, governance risks, or market headwinds. They disagree on REA Group (REA), with Luke recommending a buy based on historical cash flow growth and Nick advising a sell due to cyclical property risks. BHP Group (BHP) is the only stock held, with Nick citing strong fundamentals in copper and potash, while Luke remains underweight due to valuation concerns in the iron ore sector.
Episode sections
- 0:38 – 2:26
Introduction and Criteria for Long-Term Holders
Host Patrick Polk introduces guests Nick Pashius and Luke Larative. Nick outlines criteria for compounders including stable revenue and strong governance. Luke states that governance breaches are immediate reasons to sell.
- 2:26 – 4:59
Westfarmers (WES) Analysis
Both analysts recommend selling Westfarmers due to high valuation (28-30x earnings) relative to low growth (~5%) and housing downturn pressures. Luke prefers retailers with proven store rollouts like Universal Stores and La Vista.
- 4:59 – 8:36
REA Group (REA) Analysis
Luke recommends buying REA at 16x EV/EBITDA, citing cash flow growth from $2 to $7 per share since 2015. Nick disagrees, calling it a cyclical stock with falling property volumes and questioning its pricing power.
- 8:36 – 11:02
Technology One (TNE) Analysis
Both analysts recommend selling Technology One due to a high valuation of 60+ times earnings. Luke compares it unfavorably to US/European tech stocks like Oracle and NVIDIA which offer better multiples and ROE.
- 11:02 – 16:20
BHP Group (BHP) Analysis
Nick holds BHP as a buy, citing copper constraints, low-cost iron ore (C1 ~$20), and the Jansen potash project. Luke is underweight due to expensive valuation (7x EV/EBITDA) and prefers coal and uranium.
- 16:20 – 19:54
Pinnacle Investment Management (PNI) Analysis
Both analysts recommend selling Pinnacle due to contagion risk from the Merrick fund scandal and headwinds in a bear market. Luke notes PNI is expensive (16x earnings) compared to alternatives like Regal (6x earnings, 13.3% yield).
Assets discussed
| Asset | Kind | Stance | Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| BHP Group LtdBHP | equity | mixed | It's a hold from me, and it's uh probably uh speaks to the fact that we're a benchmarked active manager, so we have to kind of hold BHP almost always at 10.6% of the ASX 200 at the moment. |
“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.
Claims worth verifying
Westfarmers (WES) is trading at 28-30 times earnings.
Nick Pashius, Luke Larative ·2:56:36
How to verify: Check current market data for WES on the ASX for Price-to-Earnings (P/E) ratio.
Bunnings and Kmart are growing at about 5% per annum.
Nick Pashius ·2:56
How to verify: Review Westfarmers' latest annual or half-year financial reports for revenue growth rates of Bunnings and Kmart divisions.
43% of Westfarmers' earnings come from Bunnings.
Luke Larative ·3:36
How to verify: Review Westfarmers' segment reporting in their latest financial statements to verify the earnings contribution of the Bunnings division.
REA Group is trading at 16 times EV to EBITDA.
Luke Larative ·5:13
How to verify: Calculate REA Group's Enterprise Value divided by EBITDA using current share price and latest EBITDA figures from financial reports.
REA Group's cash flow per share increased from $2 in 2015 to $7 currently.
Luke Larative ·5:53
How to verify: Review REA Group's historical financial reports from 2015 and the most recent report to compare cash flow per share metrics.
It is the first time in 15 years that home prices in Australian capital cities are falling.
Nick Pashius ·7:02
How to verify: Check Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) housing price indices or major real estate data providers (e.g., CoreLogic, SQM Research) for capital city dwelling price trends over the last 15 years.
Technology One (TNE) is trading on 60 plus times earnings.
Nick Pashius ·8:55
How to verify: Check current market data for TNE on the ASX for Price-to-Earnings (P/E) ratio.
BHP is trading at 7 times EV to EBITDA.
Nick Pashius ·11:46
How to verify: Calculate BHP Group's Enterprise Value divided by EBITDA using current share price and latest EBITDA figures from financial reports.
BHP's iron ore C1 costs are around $20.
Nick Pashius ·14:49
How to verify: Review BHP Group's latest quarterly or annual production and cost reports for iron ore C1 cost guidance.
Freight rates from Brazil to China are around $35 a ton.
Nick Pashius ·15:20
How to verify: Check Baltic Dry Index or specific iron ore freight rate indices (e.g., Platts) for Brazil-China route rates.
Do your own research
- Verify Westfarmers' (WES) current P/E ratio and compare it to historical averages and peer retailers like Universal Stores and La Vista.
- Check REA Group's (REA) latest quarterly property transaction volumes and compare EV/EBITDA multiples against competitors like Domain.
- Review Technology One's (TNE) revenue growth rates and compare its valuation multiples against global software peers such as Oracle and NVIDIA.
- Analyze BHP Group's (BHP) latest C1 cost guidance for iron ore and the projected production timeline for the Jansen potash project.
- Investigate the details of the Merrick fund scandal and its potential impact on Pinnacle Investment Management's (PNI) fund flows and performance fee structures.
- Compare Pinnacle's (PNI) current earnings multiple and yield against alternatives like Regal Asset Management.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:00
- Unidentified speaker: Hey listeners, it's James Marley, co-founder at LiveY Markets.
- 0:04
- Unidentified speaker: In 2014, we had an idea.
- 0:06
- Unidentified speaker: What if we brought Australia's leading investors into one room and put their best ideas on the table?
- 0:12
- Unidentified speaker: That first event sold out, and every year since we've raised the bar.
- 0:16
- Unidentified speaker: This September, LiveWire Live returns for its milestone 10th edition.
- 0:20
- Unidentified speaker: It's taking place on the 22nd of September at the Art Gallery of New South Wales.com to secure yours.
- 0:38
- Unidentified speaker: Hello and welcome to LiveWires Buy Hold Sell.
- 0:41
- Unidentified speaker: I'm Patrick Polk, managing editor at LiveWire Markets.
- 0:44
- Unidentified speaker: With Spring Racing Carnival upon us, today we're looking for the stayers, businesses that could keep delivering for shareholders over the long haul.
- 0:52
- Unidentified speaker: But even a proven performer can be a poor investment at the wrong price.
- 0:56
- Unidentified speaker: Joining me to assess the five contenders are Nick Pashius from Antares and Luke Larative from Seneca.
- 1:03
- Unidentified speaker: Nick, what separates a true long-term compounder from a business that simply had a few good years?
- 1:10
- Unidentified speaker: Yeah, it's a good one, Patrick.
- 1:11
- Unidentified speaker: Ideally, what we're looking for are companies that have recurring stable revenues, that they have a variable cost base, because if you're going to own it for the long term, something will invariably go wrong over that period.
- 1:22
- Unidentified speaker: We want to have a strong balance sheet, not just low debt, but strong liquidity.
- 1:26
- Unidentified speaker: That sometimes causes companies to come unstuck.
- 1:29
- Unidentified speaker: And I guess the final one is not so much about management, but more perhaps around governance.
- 1:34
- Unidentified speaker: I think having strong governance is an important criteria for those compounders.
- 1:38
- Unidentified speaker: So they're the criteria.
- 1:39
- Unidentified speaker: Luke, what would make you sell a business that you'd bought intending to hold it for the next decade?
- 1:45
- Unidentified speaker: Very rarely do we hold or intend to hold a business for a decade.
- 1:50
- Unidentified speaker: But certainly I think when we've got a thesis breach, the things that are really kind of easy sells for us, I think Nick touched on it, governance is critical.
- 2:02
- Unidentified speaker: I think businesses that you can't trust, businesses that aren't transparent with their investors, businesses that don't have their shareholders and stakeholders and the wider community kind of in their acting in their interests, I suppose, is always a real sort of red flag for us and kind of an immediate recalibration, I suppose, on how we think about that business and value it, and that usually results in us being willing to dump that stock pretty quickly.
- 2:26
- Unidentified speaker: Nick, first up is West Farmers.
- 2:28
- Unidentified speaker: Bunnings, they can help you build a deck, but can they help you build a portfolio?
- 2:32
- Unidentified speaker: Buy, hold, or sell?
- 2:34
- Unidentified speaker: Well, no doubt West Farmers is a great conglomerate, been doing it for a long time, have a very good business governance, all of those things.
- 2:43
- Unidentified speaker: But as you've almost touched on earlier, a great business is not always a good investment, and now is one of those times.
- 2:50
- Unidentified speaker: We're going into a housing downturn that's undeniable.
- 2:53
- Unidentified speaker: Bunnings and Kmart are struggling to grow.
- 2:56
- Unidentified speaker: They're growing at about 5% per annum, and for that you're paying 30 times.
- 2:59
- Unidentified speaker: The overall business is growing a bit faster than that, but it's the lower PE businesses in WESF that are growing, that are giving you that 7.5% growth.
- 3:07
- Unidentified speaker: So for us at this point of the cycle, it's a sell.
- 3:12
- Unidentified speaker: It's got a strong position, but can it hold on to that position, especially given the size of the business?
- 3:18
- Unidentified speaker: Buy, hold, or sell for you, Luke?
- 3:20
- Unidentified speaker: It's going to result in my Western Australian passport getting revoked, but it's a sell for me.
- 3:26
- Unidentified speaker: I sort of think quite similar to Nick, like great business in theory, but it is on 28, 30 times earnings, depending on your numbers.
- 3:36
- Unidentified speaker: And you know, it's 43% of the earnings come from Bunnings.
- 3:40
- Unidentified speaker: So, you know, you're in a cost of living crisis, you're not going to be out there spending squillions on renovating your house or doing major spending at Bunnings.
- 3:49
- Unidentified speaker: Bunnings will take 200 bucks off you as soon as you walk in the door.
- 3:51
- Unidentified speaker: So kind of want to avoid, you know, I think I think that's you know at risk in terms of its growth profile.
- 3:56
- Unidentified speaker: And then you think about what Kmart does, which is kind of I think 25% roughly of the rest of their revenue.
- 4:02
- Unidentified speaker: Um, like I sort of think that that what I call Chinese TAT essentially just you know, all random bits of sort of discretionary spend is a pretty competitive marketplace and getting increasingly competitive with the sort of the TMU's and obviously Amazon and almost every other kind of internet internet retailer at the moment.
- 4:22
- Unidentified speaker: So I think it's a pretty hard place for Kmart to be.
- 4:25
- Unidentified speaker: Um I also think there's value in retailers, and I think that you know, whilst the consumer is stretched, there are kind of these pockets of really interesting parts of retail.
- 4:33
- Unidentified speaker: We look at like health and wellness, we look at places like the little treat economy, um, and also I think the travel sector more and more as well are kind of places where people are still willing to spend money.
- 4:44
- Unidentified speaker: And so, you know, it's not like we don't have any retailers in the portfolio.
- 4:47
- Unidentified speaker: We are, you know, sort of long universal stores, we are long La Visa.
- 4:51
- Unidentified speaker: These kind of businesses that have got a proven format of store rollouts.
- 4:54
- Unidentified speaker: Um, but I just don't think that um you know it almost double the multiple West Farms is the best buy.
- 4:59
- Unidentified speaker: Well, next up is REA Group, the business behind realestate.com.au, of course.
- 5:05
- Unidentified speaker: Dominant position in the Australian property advertising market.
- 5:08
- Unidentified speaker: Undoubtedly.
- 5:09
- Unidentified speaker: Is that a buy, hold, or a sell for you?
- 5:11
- Unidentified speaker: It's a buy at these prices for me, Patrick.
- 5:13
- Unidentified speaker: Um 16 times EV to EBADA is compelling.
- 5:17
- Unidentified speaker: I think you have to ask yourself, though, do you think property volumes uh are going up from here or they're going down from here and it's going to get worse?
- 5:25
- Unidentified speaker: Our view at Seneca is it's not gonna get a lot worse.
- 5:28
- Unidentified speaker: I'm not saying it's not gonna get worse, but um it definitely isn't, and I think that the REA valuation typically just trades with those volumes.
- 5:35
- Unidentified speaker: So uh from an investment perspective, you have to take a view on that kind of, I suppose, major data point.
- 5:41
- Unidentified speaker: Um, and I think from our perspective, the sort of is skewed to the upside and definitely it's skewed to the not gonna get a lot worse.
- 5:49
- Unidentified speaker: Um this is a business that you can buy now on a 2015 valuation.
- 5:53
- Unidentified speaker: Back in 2015 it was doing $2 a share of cash flow per share.
- 5:57
- Unidentified speaker: It's now doing $7 cash flow per share.
- 5:59
- Unidentified speaker: Um it's a business where the buy yields up from three up 3.7 times over that period.
- 6:04
- Unidentified speaker: So, you know, a thousand bucks uh spent on the platform in 2015 is now $3,700 per listing.
- 6:11
- Unidentified speaker: So it's a really, really good business.
- 6:13
- Unidentified speaker: It's grown dramatically, it's grown market share, and you know, it's seen really no competition.
- 6:18
- Unidentified speaker: I mean, I think data out today shows domain's doing even worse than ever.
- 6:22
- Unidentified speaker: So despite the big investment that was made in them.
- 6:24
- Unidentified speaker: So I think REA is a buy.
- 6:26
- Unidentified speaker: It is counter-cyclical, it's a little bit contrarian at the moment, it's certainly not on the um momentum tray, that's for sure.
- 6:32
- Unidentified speaker: Um, but at these levels, I just don't think you get to buy business in this sort of competitive position too often at these prices.
- 6:39
- Unidentified speaker: REA group, of course, they they have a dominant position in their market, much like West farmers.
- 6:45
- Unidentified speaker: Do you think they still have room to grow?
- 6:47
- Unidentified speaker: I think it's a cyclical stock masquerading as a growth stock.
- 6:51
- Unidentified speaker: And we're about to find out.
- 6:53
- Unidentified speaker: Because this is the ego.
- 6:55
- Unidentified speaker: I know.
- 6:56
- Unidentified speaker: Lucky you're between us.
- 7:00
- Unidentified speaker: I might have to hold you back.
- 7:02
- Unidentified speaker: It's the first time in 15 years that home prices in the capital cities across Australia are falling.
- 7:07
- Unidentified speaker: It hasn't happened before.
- 7:08
- Unidentified speaker: So it's going to be a real test for them to see whether they can generate that pricing power that they have historically enjoyed that was touched on there by Luke.
- 7:16
- Unidentified speaker: That's that I think is the key.
- 7:18
- Unidentified speaker: Um, you know, we're we're not, and I understand the um the looking forward aspect, but we are um observational investors in a sense, OI, not AI.
- 7:27
- Unidentified speaker: We look at things now, and right now volumes are falling and they're continuing to fall.
- 7:32
- Unidentified speaker: And their recent um update of last week showed again a deterioration in those volumes.
- 7:37
- Unidentified speaker: So we're just not we don't think we're through the other side.
- 7:40
- Unidentified speaker: We still think we're heading down, um, and their pricing power that they have enjoyed historically is certainly under question.
- 7:46
- Unidentified speaker: And I get that you know the domain numbers that they released literally last night were not great, but they are a more invigorated competitor, they are um spending more on marketing, they are holding pricing at 4% capped, whereas um REA are grow are trying to grow at a double digit.
- 8:04
- Unidentified speaker: Um and if you look historically, and it was came out in their result or their investor day pack last week, a large part of their pricing growth uh historically has been because house prices have gone up.
- 8:15
- Unidentified speaker: That may not be the case, at least for the next you know, six, twelve months.
- 8:19
- Unidentified speaker: So just a bit of caution at this point in time.
- 8:21
- Unidentified speaker: Looking for a better entry.
- 8:22
- Unidentified speaker: How's that?
- 8:23
- Unidentified speaker: Can we agree on that?
- 8:24
- Unidentified speaker: Yeah, I guess if you if if you're getting an extra $20,000 off over the price that you expected, paying an extra $500 or $1,000 for your listing doesn't seem so hard.
- 8:34
- Unidentified speaker: Yeah, now that's all gonna start to hurt.
- 8:36
- Unidentified speaker: Yeah, from property advertising to enterprise software, their customers rely on them for running their businesses.
- 8:44
- Unidentified speaker: Would you put technology one at a buy, hold, or sell?
- 8:48
- Unidentified speaker: It's a sell purely because of the valuation.
- 8:51
- Unidentified speaker: The business model is great.
- 8:52
- Unidentified speaker: Um, it's on 60 plus times earnings.
- 8:55
- Unidentified speaker: You get mid-teens growth, so it puts on a PE to growth ratio about three and a half, which is pretty hard to make a return on.
- 9:02
- Unidentified speaker: No doubt they are one of the best managed IT companies on the boards, but they just haven't derated to the extent that others have.
- 9:10
- Unidentified speaker: And maybe that's because of their customers.
- 9:12
- Unidentified speaker: They have um government, semi-government bodies as their customers, which are more stable, but we would just prefer to see it at a lower multiple, and we're just not there at this stage, so not for us.
- 9:23
- Unidentified speaker: Luke, how do you weigh up the recurring revenue that they have versus the high multiple that we've just discussed?
- 9:30
- Unidentified speaker: Um, yeah, you can look at lots of businesses that are trading with recurring revenues that don't trade on 50, 60 times earnings.
- 9:37
- Unidentified speaker: So again, you know, your job as an investor is to find the best expression of an idea, the best alternative to it, you know, available to you.
- 9:45
- Unidentified speaker: And I just don't think kind of as Nick said, uh tech one on that kind of price for mid-teens growth is a great deal.
- 9:52
- Unidentified speaker: I mean, we only got to sort of need to look internationally.
- 9:55
- Unidentified speaker: If I went, I went and had a quick look at US and European stocks that are trading with similar kind of long-run growth profiles and similar sort of 15% plus ROE numbers.
- 10:06
- Unidentified speaker: You know, you can buy Oracle, Keysite, Netflix, Caterpillar, ASML, NVIDIA, all Meta, all on lower multiples with higher ROE.
- 10:14
- Unidentified speaker: So, and better growth.
- 10:16
- Unidentified speaker: So, from my perspective, it's just not a great deal.
- 10:19
- Unidentified speaker: I'm not an international investor, but you kind of catch my gist here, right?
- 10:22
- Unidentified speaker: So I think there's a whole litany of decent, recurring revenue, large addressable market, um, software or technology adjacent businesses on the ASX at five times EV to sales at the moment, rather than paying, you know, 20 times for this at the moment.
- 10:40
- Unidentified speaker: So, yeah, sell from me, plenty of other good tech stocks to own the ASX all around the world.
- 10:45
- Unidentified speaker: Pretty crazy when you put it in the context of being cheap, uh more expensive than ASML.
- 10:49
- Unidentified speaker: That's uh that's it's quite the quality business there.
- 10:53
- Unidentified speaker: Yeah, so you know, we think technology one is a decent business, but I think people think it is much more high quality than we do, at least, anyway.
- 11:02
- Unidentified speaker: Alright, let's go to the miners.
- 11:04
- Unidentified speaker: We've got BHP, the big Australian.
- 11:07
- Unidentified speaker: Their assets they last for decades, but can a cyclical miner like BHP earn a place in your portfolio for the long term?
- 11:15
- Unidentified speaker: Buy, hold, or sell?
- 11:17
- Unidentified speaker: It's a hold from me, and it's uh probably uh speaks to the fact that we're a benchmarked active manager, so we have to kind of hold BHP almost always at 10.6% of the ASX 200 at the moment.
- 11:29
- Unidentified speaker: That being said, we are sort of materially underweight at the moment.
- 11:33
- Unidentified speaker: Um copper's still trading at all-time highs, and I think there's a lot of people still excited about BHP's copper prospects.
- 11:39
- Unidentified speaker: But the main game with BHP is always iron ore, and iron ore does look like it's about to go through a cyclically weak period.
- 11:46
- Unidentified speaker: Um at seven times EV to EBDAR, BHP's not cheap, sort of by you know anyone's metrics.
- 11:51
- Unidentified speaker: That's like one time standard, uh, one standard deviation above average, sort of for some context.
- 11:56
- Unidentified speaker: Um and it really does come down to flows and and where you think the money's gonna go next.
- 12:01
- Unidentified speaker: If you think the next sort of sort of bull market on the ASX is gonna be driven by lower and falling interest rates, it's probably gonna be the banks that are gonna be the winners in that environment on one end of the barbell.
- 12:12
- Unidentified speaker: Um if you think it's gonna be a growth-driven rally, maybe an end in the war, increase, you know, decreasing freight rates, decreasing in um sort of fuel rates, then maybe it will be more than miners and the BHPs and Rios will do better.
- 12:23
- Unidentified speaker: Uh, we don't have a particular view on that.
- 12:25
- Unidentified speaker: Um, I suppose from our Australian shares you know portfolio perspective, we're just more constructive on maybe other companies sort of in the resources sector across the ASX 300 in you know, coal, uranium, base metals, gold, than um than BHP at seven times EV to EBITDA.
- 12:41
- Unidentified speaker: Do the projects coming online in Africa at the moment factor into that for you in terms of how they might affect the global market for iron ore?
- 12:50
- Unidentified speaker: Yeah, definitely.
- 12:51
- Unidentified speaker: I think the supply side story is sort of much talked about and much hyped.
- 12:55
- Unidentified speaker: Um I'm always reticent to get too carried away with short-term supply.
- 13:00
- Unidentified speaker: My experience working in the sort of mining industry is that the market starts to price these projects like they're fully ramped up and work and everything goes smoothly.
- 13:09
- Unidentified speaker: Um in reality, building a mine, particularly a large-scale iron ore mine, um, has significant challenges even in Tier 1 jurisdictions, um, let alone you know in some parts of Africa.
- 13:21
- Unidentified speaker: So um while I wouldn't get too carried away with my bear with bearish sort of thoughts around iron ore pricing on the back of some huge immediate impact of onto supply, um I think there's enough cause for concern there that prices stay, you know, below average, I suppose, um, or definitely below recent prices for a year or two from here.
- 13:41
- Unidentified speaker: Nick, where do you see the next decade of growth coming for BHP?
- 13:46
- Unidentified speaker: Is it a buy, hold, or sell?
- 13:48
- Unidentified speaker: We think it's a buy.
- 13:49
- Unidentified speaker: Um share uh Luke's sentiment there on a number of things, but let's just go through them.
- 13:54
- Unidentified speaker: Copper is the you know the zeitgeist of the current market, it's where everybody wants to be.
- 13:59
- Unidentified speaker: Um, and BHP has a significant endowment of copper.
- 14:02
- Unidentified speaker: They obviously produce out of Escondita and also Copper South Australia, but they've got this Vacuna project which will come online towards the end of uh this decade, into next decade, that will give them significant growth.
- 14:14
- Unidentified speaker: Um and the copper story is not just around AI and demand, it's also a supply issue.
- 14:21
- Unidentified speaker: And you saw just last night Freeport, one of the world's biggest producers of copper, just downgraded its production guidance again.
- 14:26
- Unidentified speaker: This is this is a global phenomenon.
- 14:29
- Unidentified speaker: They've all done it over the course of the last few years.
- 14:31
- Unidentified speaker: It's just not that easy to mine things out of the ground, um, let alone copper.
- 14:36
- Unidentified speaker: So we think that the copper price is well supported.
- 14:39
- Unidentified speaker: Um, in terms of iron ore, um BHP enjoys a privileged position right at the bottom end of the cost curve, particularly on a free cash flow basis when you look at it after CapEx.
- 14:49
- Unidentified speaker: So there's C1 costs of around 20, there's freight rates on top of that and a few other costs, but it's a long way from the even $80 iron ore price that we see today.
- 14:57
- Unidentified speaker: They're going to make great margins out of that business.
- 15:00
- Unidentified speaker: And you know, I was just meeting with one of the majors earlier today.
- 15:03
- Unidentified speaker: There's already supply coming out of the market, so it's coming out of the it's coming out of the market from the Chinese suppliers, given at these prices they can't make money.
- 15:11
- Unidentified speaker: Also, some of the high-cost Brazilian mines are starting to come out of the market.
- 15:15
- Unidentified speaker: Um, freight rates, obviously, freight fuel is a big input to that cost.
- 15:20
- Unidentified speaker: Freight rates from Brazil to China are like um $35 a ton.
- 15:24
- Unidentified speaker: Um, that's a big hurdle to jump over for some of those high-cost producers.
- 15:29
- Unidentified speaker: So we think iron ore is is going to be okay.
- 15:32
- Unidentified speaker: Hopefully it won't fall much further.
- 15:33
- Unidentified speaker: I shouldn't say hopefully.
- 15:34
- Unidentified speaker: We don't think it'll fall much further for than these levels.
- 15:38
- Unidentified speaker: Um, and then you've got Janssen.
- 15:39
- Unidentified speaker: So Jansen is this troubled project that BHP has spent far too much on, but it's in the price.
- 15:45
- Unidentified speaker: And it's not contributing a cent to earnings today, but it will in 12 months' time, 12 to 18 months.
- 15:50
- Unidentified speaker: It'll start to ramp up.
- 15:51
- Unidentified speaker: And and Janssen is a uh a potash production club.
- 15:56
- Unidentified speaker: It's it's uh really global scale, low cost, and what it does is it introduces a new commodity to the BHP suite, which should diversify their revenue base.
- 16:06
- Unidentified speaker: And we think that over time that will lead to a re-rating of BHP because it's more diversified, it won't have the significant ups and downs that a you know uh just a pure play lithium or copper producer will have.
- 16:17
- Unidentified speaker: So that's our thesis over the long term.
- 16:20
- Unidentified speaker: Why don't we turn to the asset management industry, one that we're all familiar with here?
- 16:24
- Unidentified speaker: Uh Pinnacle.
- 16:26
- Unidentified speaker: Uh it's in the name.
- 16:27
- Unidentified speaker: Has it got further to climb, or is the name tell us where we're at at the moment?
- 16:32
- Unidentified speaker: Good way to put it.
- 16:33
- Unidentified speaker: Uh buy, hold, or sell.
- 16:34
- Unidentified speaker: Yeah, we we think it's a sell.
- 16:36
- Unidentified speaker: Um, and we're just worried about the contagion risk that Merrick brings to the group because they all sit on this wonderful distribution platform, and we just worry that maybe there's a bit of contagion that's filtering in.
- 16:51
- Unidentified speaker: And so we just prefer at this stage to stand back.
- 16:53
- Unidentified speaker: It's it's had a it's had a fall, we're looking at it, but we're just not convinced that uh all of it's in the price.
- 17:00
- Unidentified speaker: We're also going, it's let's not kid ourselves, this is a high B to play on markets.
- 17:04
- Unidentified speaker: You know, we've got interest rate rises, we're having choppy markets, it makes harder to gather farm, it makes harder to generate performance fees.
- 17:12
- Unidentified speaker: These are the things that this low sort of um capital-intensive business has benefited from historically, um, and hence the high multiple, but now we just see some of those headwinds still with us.
- 17:24
- Unidentified speaker: So just sell for the moment.
- 17:26
- Unidentified speaker: Luke, how much do you think they really rely on the ability to generate those performance fees in order to remain profitable and grow their profits?
- 17:35
- Unidentified speaker: Is it a buy, hold, or sell for you?
- 17:37
- Unidentified speaker: To sell for me, I don't think they need performance fees to stay profitable.
- 17:41
- Unidentified speaker: Um, as Nick kind of touched on, this is a very kind of capital light model.
- 17:45
- Unidentified speaker: The the idea, the concept of kind of distribution for fund managers is real smart.
- 17:50
- Unidentified speaker: You know, you essentially you get all of the benefits of being a fund manager without any of the costs.
- 17:55
- Unidentified speaker: So uh let's not get it twisted.
- 17:57
- Unidentified speaker: Um, but I do think that there's a lot of value in fund managers at the moment because the market's in a bear market at the moment.
- 18:04
- Unidentified speaker: So, as Nick kind of touched on, um, it's hard to get an inflow, um, it's really hard to generate a performance fee.
- 18:11
- Unidentified speaker: Um, and as a result, pinnacle's come down from 37 times to 16 times.
- 18:15
- Unidentified speaker: Now, in a vacuum, that sounds pretty good to me, and I'd probably be sniffing around thinking, okay, here's a counter-cyclical buy.
- 18:21
- Unidentified speaker: But it's still a sell for me, and I tell you why, is because a similar business in Regal is trading on six times earnings at the moment, a 13.3% dividend yield, and to me, that is a much better alternative.
- 18:32
- Unidentified speaker: So I I just think here that you know there's pinnacle's great, but it's still expensive relative to your sort of other alternatives on the market that we can compare it to.
- 18:40
- Unidentified speaker: Um, and I'd be much more comfortable uh with the idea that you know Regal can manage a Phil King exit than I am maybe of uh BDMs being unable to sell other funds now after torching people's capital with metrics.
- 18:56
- Unidentified speaker: Do you think the diversified nature of the business accounts for that difference?
- 19:01
- Unidentified speaker: I think the diversified nature of businesses like this is actually I suppose less of a benefit than the market, I think, likes to talk about.
- 19:11
- Unidentified speaker: At the end of the day, investor confidence is investor confidence.
- 19:14
- Unidentified speaker: What they get confident in changes all the time.
- 19:17
- Unidentified speaker: Um, but typically inflows across every asset class are pretty correlated.
- 19:22
- Unidentified speaker: Uh it's just a question of volume.
- 19:24
- Unidentified speaker: So uh from my perspective, I don't think uh Pinnacle's got a particular advantage over a Regal, say for example, which also has a range of asset class exposures.
- 19:33
- Unidentified speaker: Um I just think that Pinnacle have maybe sold a better story for a bit longer and they don't employ the PMs.
- 19:38
- Unidentified speaker: Well, that's our field of five.
- 19:40
- Unidentified speaker: Luke, Nick, thanks for joining us.
- 19:43
- Unidentified speaker: Subscribe to the LiveWire YouTube channel or visit LiveWireMarkets.com for more content like this and let us know in the comments which business would you like to own if you had to hold it for 10 years?
More from Buy Hold Sell, by Livewire Markets
Buy Hold Sell: 5 ASX stocks flying too close to the sun
Episode discussion: Panel discusses valuation discipline and rates five ASX stocks: Codan, NextGen Energy, Life360, Monadelphous, and Hub24.
Speakers’ claims: Speakers outline a bottom-up valuation methodology based on five-year cash flow forecasts, selling when prices exceed intrinsic value. They analyze Codan (ASX:CDN), noting strong earnings growth from metal detection and communications, with mixed ratings due to cyclical risks. NextGen Energy (ASX:NXE) is highlighted as a low-cost uranium project benefiting from baseload power demand, receiving buy/hold ratings. Life360 (ASX:L36) is discussed regarding its user base and advertising expansion, with divergent views on valuation and churn. Monadelphous (ASX:MDP) is rated a hold due to full valuation despite operational excellence. Hub24 (ASX:HUB) is analyzed for its wealth platform migration and budget impacts, with mixed ratings based on historical multiples versus peer comparisons.
Buy Hold Sell: 5 ASX fallen angels prime for a comeback
Episode discussion: Analysts identify ASX fallen angels like Aurora, Ramsey Health Care, and SiteMinder as potential turnarounds based on balance sheet fixes and management changes.
Speakers’ claims: Matt Riordan and Marcus Burns discuss criteria for identifying genuine stock turnarounds versus value traps on the ASX. They analyze Aurora Limited (AUR), noting its core business trades cheaply while Savourglass faces headwinds. Ramsey Health Care (RHC) is highlighted for new leadership and a demerger plan to de-leverage. IDP Education (IOD) is held despite political risks due to low valuation. SiteMinder (SMT) and Cochlear (COH) are picked for cash flow recovery and product innovation respectively.