The Perth Property Show

Trent Fleskens identifies April 2026 as Perth property peak, citing 5-15% price drop and brick shortage

36 min Listen to the original Episode page
Perth Property MarketInterest RatesConstruction CostsTax PolicyHousing Supply

Summary

Trent Fleskens argues that April 2026 marked the peak of the Perth property market, with median dwelling values falling from over $1 million to $942,000 due to sentiment and affordability rather than structural economic issues. He contrasts this downturn with the mining boom bust, noting that population growth and rental demand remain strong despite a buyer's market dynamic. Fleskens highlights a critical brick shortage exacerbated by inflation, which the state government is attempting to mitigate through subsidies and kiln reopenings, potentially driving up construction costs. He clarifies upcoming tax changes, stating that CGT discount adjustments and negative gearing limits apply only to gains and properties acquired after mid-2027, with grandfathering for earlier purchases.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    For nearly every quarter of the last forty years they have anyway, and there's no reason why that won't happen again.

    Trent Fleskens · 33:35

Episode sections

  1. 0:55 – 4:20

    Market Cycle and Price Correction

    Trent Fleskens identifies April 2026 as the likely peak of the Perth property market, noting median dwelling values have fallen from above $1 million to $942,000. He attributes the 5-15% price decline to sentiment and affordability rather than structural economic issues, contrasting it with the mining boom downturn.

  2. 4:20 – 12:34

    Listings and Buyer's Market Dynamics

    The host explains that rising listings (9,500 to 10,000) reflect fewer buyers rather than seller panic, as new listings remain 10% below the five-year average. This shift has created a buyer's market with vendor discounting at 4.7%, offering greater choice and negotiation power.

  3. 12:34 – 15:05

    Interest Rates and Bank Forecasts

    Fleskens discusses the RBA's five rate hikes and the uncertainty surrounding a potential sixth hike, noting split forecasts among major banks like CBA, Westpac, ANZ, and NAB. He advises borrowers to seek rate reductions from their current lenders rather than refinancing.

  4. 15:05 – 22:27

    Capital Gains Tax and Negative Gearing Changes

    The speaker clarifies that CGT discount changes apply only to gains accrued after July 2027, not pre-existing gains. He also outlines that negative gearing will be limited to new builds from July 2027, with grandfathering for properties purchased before May 2026.

  5. 22:27 – 26:59

    Rental Market Resilience

    Fleskens argues that the rental market remains tight with a 1.7% vacancy rate and median rents of $750 for houses and $700 for units. He uses this stability to assert that the property downturn is driven by affordability and sentiment, not a lack of demand or population decline.

  6. 26:59 – 28:58

    First Home Buyers and Market Timing

    The host encourages first home buyers to enter the market now, citing significant price drops (10-15%) and increased choice. He advises against panic selling for those who bought at the peak, emphasizing that owner-occupiers should focus on utility and long-term holding.

  7. 28:58 – 33:35

    Brick Shortage and Construction Impact

    A critical brick shortage is expected to reduce completions to 16,000-17,000, worsening the housing deficit to nearly 60,000 homes. This will force builders to use alternative materials, potentially lowering construction prices due to reduced labor costs but increasing replacement costs for brick homes.

  8. 33:35 – 33:54

    Brick Shortage and Government Response

    Trent Fleskens discusses the brick shortage, noting that inflation and administrative costs are driving prices up. He explains that while house prices have historically risen year-over-year for four decades, current fixes from the state government are insufficient for short-term relief.

  9. 33:54 – 34:37

    Government Subsidies and Brick Costs

    The state government allocated $4 million to reopen a shuttered brick kiln near Armadale, with production not expected until mid-next year. Additionally, a $5 million subsidy was introduced to help acquire bricks from overseas, reducing costs from $3.60 to $2.90 per brick, though this remains nearly double the previous price.

  10. 34:37 – 35:37

    Impact on Construction and Market Innovation

    Higher brick costs will either be absorbed by builders under fixed-price contracts or passed on to clients, increasing home replacement values. Fleskens suggests this pain may force builders to innovate and diversify the trade base, though it causes short-term frustration for buyers.

  11. 35:37 – 36:23

    Podcast Conclusion and Next Episode

    Trent Fleskens concludes the Q&A segment after answering eight questions over 40 minutes. He announces that Brendan Ptolemy will return next week to provide further market thoughts, followed by standard podcast outro instructions.

Assets discussed

AssetKindStanceContext
GoldcommodityneutralYou think about gold, gold's now down from the five thousands to the three thousands in US per ounce.

“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.

Claims worth verifying

April 2026 was the peak of the Perth property market cycle.

Trent Fleskens ·1:15

How to verify: Check CoreLogic Perth property price indices for April 2026 to confirm the local peak relative to subsequent months. For recent events, verify 2026-08-15 through 2026-11-15. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

CoreLogic median dwelling value is $942,000, down from above $1 million in April.

Trent Fleskens ·1:54

How to verify: Access CoreLogic's Perth Median Dwelling Value dataset for the relevant months in 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-15 through 2026-11-15. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Property values across Perth suburbs have fallen 5-15% from the peak.

Trent Fleskens ·2:21

How to verify: Compare CoreLogic suburb-level median prices from April 2026 to the current date in the transcript. For recent events, verify 2026-08-15 through 2026-11-15. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Vendor discounting is 4.7%.

Trent Fleskens ·7:00

How to verify: Check REIWA or CoreLogic vendor discounting statistics for Perth for the relevant period. For recent events, verify 2026-08-15 through 2026-11-15. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

New listings are 10% lower than the five-year average.

Trent Fleskens ·7:00

How to verify: Compare REIWA new listing volumes for the current period against the five-year historical average. For recent events, verify 2026-08-15 through 2026-11-15. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Stock on market is 9,500 properties, heading to 10,000.

Trent Fleskens ·6:20

How to verify: Check REIWA stock on market data for Perth. For recent events, verify 2026-08-15 through 2026-11-15. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Vacancy rates are 1.7% with median rents of $750 for houses and $700 for units.

Trent Fleskens ·24:29

How to verify: Check REIWA rental market reports for September 2026 for vacancy rates and median rents. For recent events, verify 2026-08-15 through 2026-11-15. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

CGT discount changes apply only to gains accrued after July 1, 2027.

Trent Fleskens ·15:25

How to verify: Review Australian Taxation Office (ATO) guidance or legislation regarding the 2026-2027 budget changes to capital gains tax. For recent events, verify 2026-08-15 through 2026-11-15. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Negative gearing is limited to new builds from July 1, 2027, with grandfathering for purchases before May 2026.

Trent Fleskens ·17:28

How to verify: Review Australian Taxation Office (ATO) guidance or legislation regarding the 2026-2027 budget changes to negative gearing. For recent events, verify 2026-08-15 through 2026-11-15. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The widow's tax fix passed both houses in August.

Trent Fleskens ·17:08

How to verify: Check Australian Parliament House records for the passage of the relevant legislation in August 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-15 through 2026-11-15. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The state government put $4 million into Austel to reopen kilns near Armadale.

Trent Fleskens ·33:54

How to verify: Check Western Australian state government press releases or budget allocations for 2026 regarding infrastructure or housing subsidies, specifically mentioning Austel or Armadale. For recent events, verify 2026-08-15 through 2026-11-15. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Brick production from the reopened kiln will not begin until mid-next year (mid-2027).

Trent Fleskens ·34:14

How to verify: Monitor Austel's operational announcements or construction industry news reports for the start of production at the Armadale facility. For recent events, verify 2026-08-15 through 2026-11-15. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The state government allocated $5 million to subsidize brick acquisition from overseas.

Trent Fleskens ·34:34

How to verify: Review Western Australian government financial disclosures or housing policy documents for the $5 million subsidy program details. For recent events, verify 2026-08-15 through 2026-11-15. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Brick costs rose from $1.70-$1.80 to $3.60, then were subsidized to $2.90.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·34:37

How to verify: Cross-reference with construction material price indices or supplier quotes from Australian brick manufacturers and importers for the 2026 period. For recent events, verify 2026-08-15 through 2026-11-15. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

House prices have risen for nearly every quarter in the last 40 years.

Trent Fleskens ·33:35

How to verify: Analyze CoreLogic or ABS housing price data for Perth/Australia from 2026 to 2026 to calculate the percentage of quarters with year-over-year price increases. For recent events, verify 2026-08-15 through 2026-11-15. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The brick shortage will push builders to innovate and diversify the trade base.

Trent Fleskens ·35:16

How to verify: Track industry reports on construction method innovations (e.g., prefabrication, alternative materials) and labor market shifts in Western Australia post-2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-15 through 2026-11-15. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Brendan Ptolemy will appear in the next episode.

Trent Fleskens ·35:57

How to verify: Check the Perth Property Show episode 417 release notes or podcast feed for guest listings. For recent events, verify 2026-08-15 through 2026-11-15. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify Perth median dwelling values and price trends using Real Estate Institute of Western Australia (REIWA) monthly data.
  • Check current RBA interest rate decisions and major bank forecasts (CBA, Westpac, ANZ, NAB) for rate cut expectations.
  • Review Western Australian government budget documents for details on the $4 million kiln subsidy and $5 million brick import subsidy.
  • Confirm the specific legislative text for proposed CGT discount and negative gearing changes to verify grandfathering dates and applicability.
  • Assess local building permit data and completion statistics to validate the claimed reduction in housing completions due to brick shortages.
  • Compare current brick prices and construction material costs against historical averages to quantify the impact on replacement values.
  • Monitor vacancy rates and median rent figures from state rental bond boards or property portals to assess rental market tightness.
  • Investigate the financial health of major Perth-based builders to understand their capacity to absorb fixed-price contract cost increases.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): You're listening to the Perth Property Show, Australia's only weekly property podcast by West Australian experts for West Australian listeners. Catch your latest episode every Monday at 7am.
0:15
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Good
0:15
Trent Fleskens: morning everyone, welcome to the Perth Property Show. My name is Trent Fleskins, your host as always. This week it's time for a QA. I think it's been really way too long since the last one. I usually try and get them done once a quarter. and time's flown away from us. So the list is a little bit longer than usual, I believe. We'll get through them as quickly as possible. But some really pertinent questions have actually
0:35
Trent Fleskens: loved over the years looking back at how sophisticated and pointed our questions are getting. And I'd like to think that some of that has to come from the journey a lot of the listenership has gone on themselves in learning about the market, about their investment strategies, and the fundamentals that push each market and each city in the direction that they're going over time. Now, usually
0:55
Trent Fleskens: I would give a market update, but the question is this time around really do I think paint a picture to the whole market and hopefully the answers I think will do the job for us. So I'll get straight into it. Uh Rich O says Perth went from boom to bust in six months, Trent. Was April the top? Righto, let's take the emotion out of this. I believe the answer is going.
1:15
Trent Fleskens: to be in hindsight, yes. April 2026 for this part of the cycle, before obviously a sustained or material drop is evident. The numbers already show that April was the top of most markets. If you weren't getting your property sold and unconditional in that time, it's very likely that your
1:34
Trent Fleskens: expectations will have to be lower than they were at the time. So anyone who got lucky and picked the top of the market in March April this year, congratulations, you have timed it perfectly. For the rest of us, we crack on with understanding exactly what property investment is all about, and that is the medium to long term. And
1:54
Trent Fleskens: we invest, own, develop, renovate Innovate with that in mind. Cotality has our median dwelling value now at 942,000. Many people will remember that it was actually about a hundred grand higher in April. We were above a million dollars, and the amount of suburbs in our million dollar median club was starting to get silly, and places like
2:13
Trent Fleskens: Bayswater, Hammersley joining the crew on the way out.
2:21
Trent Fleskens: Across suburbs in Perth from 5 to 15%, I'd say for the most part, and of five being on the blue chip suburbs, and the 15% being on the outer fringe or suburbs or areas or even asset types that are more uh investment focused. And that was a huge part of that uh sentiment driven from the
2:41
Trent Fleskens: budget. Uh but it was already turning, as per our conversations with Shane Beaumont, with Tom Mishak at the investor grade uh earlier in the year, uh, that the data was already coming. through on the ground. And that was more driven by our interest rates and affordability as well as a pullback from East Coast investors who'd already started to struggle in their own markets,
3:00
Trent Fleskens: Melbourne, Sydney and Brisbane respectively. So yes, April historians will look back and will we'll see April as the top, but I guess the unasked part of that question is uh what's next? and how long and how we characterize the downturn that we're currently in. I think
3:20
Trent Fleskens: the most important thing to remember here for everyone is that this downturn is very different to the last one we experienced. The once burnt, twice shy relationship we've had with property since the end of the mining boom is one that I understand, I recognise and will drive people's sentiment in Perth
3:40
Trent Fleskens: to jump back in anytime soon when it comes to being ambitious about their property goals, either owner-occupied or investor. But I would spell out very clearly that this is not the same downturn. This is not an economic downturn. This is not one where we've built too many homes and we've got people
4:00
Trent Fleskens: leaving, and we've got less work and less. economic activity in the state and we're just a less fruitful place to be. That was the reality from 2015 onwards. That is not the case here, and there's many reasons and there's many signposts that will demonstrate that and I think the conversation we'll have over the next few questions that are being posed to me will certainly uh spell
4:20
Trent Fleskens: that out for people. Next question we have is from Sam. Sam says listings have blown. out. Is this a buyer's market or are sellers simply panicking? I think it's a bit of both. I think there's been a conditioning over the last few months that's had to happen. The agents with a bit more experience have done that a bit quicker and more effectively, and the agents who have only been around
4:40
Trent Fleskens: for a few years probably been caught behind the eight ball or stuck with a bunch of listings they haven't been able to move and have often gone to other agents or come back off the market. If you've been watching rewind. Riwa's stats come out, and I hope everyone who listens avidly has been, then you've watched a wild ride over the last eleven months and to be frank over the last
5:00
Trent Fleskens: six years. And most specifically the last two, uh people be laughing at me saying that, but it it really has been one to watch history books have been rewritten many times since COVID, uh and we've broken that many records on the way up, on the way down, on the way sideways. But the reality is we got down to the lowest amount of properties on the market per person by a long shot last
5:20
Trent Fleskens: Christmas. 1850 properties is not sustainable. It's like having an unemployment rate of point one percent. It's like having an interest rate in Australia of was zero percent. It's just not something that our market is set up for and therefore it was an inevitability that the amount of properties on the market had to go up in order for the market to work efficiently.
5:40
Trent Fleskens: It was market failure at that point. People couldn't buy without taking on massive amounts of risk because they hadn't done their due diligence. And that is not a market that we want to be in. So of course we expected to see listings increase, but to be frank I don't think many of us expect, including myself, listings to increase this aggressively. but We are still under what many would
6:00
Trent Fleskens: agree is an a balanced market with regard to regards the to properties on market. But again I've said this before, I've said this on radio many times. Most of us aren't bothered about the current state, we're bothered about the trajectory. We want to know where it's come from, where it's going, and that impacts our sentiment and the reality that it's not only been the lowest amount of properties on the market ever this year in January,
6:20
Trent Fleskens: but also the highest acceleration of increases to the stock on market number, which now sits at 9,500 properties. We will hit 10,000 in the next couple of weeks, I think. That's what people are feeling. That's what's created the dynamic of a buyer's market because there's choice now. There's no longer competition for the most part, except for those really high-end
6:40
Trent Fleskens: homes that stand out in each suburb across Perth in their price point. And therefore without competition, agents struggle to be able to do their job of bidding prices up. Buyers recognize recognise that they've got the upper hand and they start lobbying in low ball numbers. That's where you see discounting, that's where you see a lack of price growth, even in those suburbs. What we understand is that vendor
7:00
Trent Fleskens: discounting now sits at 4.7%. But is it panic? No. New listings are actually only still sitting at about 10% lower than the five year average. So it's not really a sell-off sell off here. More sellers have come to mark, market, but not that many more. Certainly not to characterize the increase in properties they have on market. The increase in stock is
7:19
Trent Fleskens: because there are simply less people buying. A year ago, about nine hundred people were taking property off the market each week, nine hundred properties were coming off, and therefore if you're only bringing seven hundred or eight hundred to market, then the stock on market drops every single week. It's what we saw four or five years. You switch that, you flip it on its head, you've only got six. hundred and thirty
7:39
Trent Fleskens: properties being taken off the market each week, and you're still adding seven eight hundred properties to market. Then of course you're going to see the exact opposite happen with stock increasing each week. Now, what we're looking for as property owners is that equilibrium of getting not properties coming to into market any lower because we want
7:59
Trent Fleskens: choice, we want that flow of transactions through the industry. It's good for everyone, it's good for the state government with taxes, it's good for the federal government at GST. The multiplier effect helps everyone. We want more economic activity. That's great. What we really want to see is buyers come back. And obviously we recognize that a big portion of that is just investors
8:19
Trent Fleskens: leaving the market because of the tax changes. But also sentiment from first homeowners who are supposed to be helped to here you who are just gun gunshineer. shine now. I think there's some time that needs to play out in that space, but also the big change, the big inflection point will be the point in time where the market believes where it will see rates drop as our
8:39
Trent Fleskens: next direction rather than rates increase. Doesn't necessarily have to see the drop yet, but the expectation of a drop drop-in in rates will be, I think, the catalyst for sentiment change, not only in Perth but across the country. Yeah, it's a buyer's market, and what I would say to everyone in that sense is given the fact this is not
8:59
Trent Fleskens: an economic downturn, it is not a population demand-supply downturn, like the last one, as I said, the amenity offering of the property you were looking at, if you hadn't pulled the trigger yet, hasn't changed. Perth is still just as amazing place as it was six months ago, nine months ago.
9:15
Trent Fleskens: two years ago. And for the first time in five, six years, as a buyer, you have the prerogative. You have the ability to take your time, negotiate, and extract the best value you can from the highest amenity property you can find over a period of time. And I've been saying this to a couple of mates. Imagine looking in West Laderville for the last few years.
9:35
Trent Fleskens: The price of property's gone up from a million to two and a half. three mil in that time frame. It's a very high amenity suburb and it hasn't dropped in amenity. In fact, it's probably increased with upgrades to the hospital and amenity increases in Subiaco on a daily basis. Therefore, you'd expect prices to rise, but they've risen to a point obviously where many can't afford it.
9:55
Trent Fleskens: If you were looking and just couldn't find anything because nearly nothing was available in January, February, March, or even last year, and you hadn't made that transaction, and you were getting more and more depressed about it and frustrated about it, then the greatest gift the world could have given you was the sentiment change. To the extent that you can afford the loan for that
10:15
Trent Fleskens: property, that property now costs you ten to fifteen percent than it would have only six months ago. And not only that, instead of fighting over one old character home that may or may not have been renovated, you may or maybe have five or six options to look at on the weekend now. That choice is what people have been begging for for a few years now, and an ability to see some
10:35
Trent Fleskens: value relative to where you've been over the last year with your numbers also makes you feel just a bit better about the decision you're making for you, for your family going forward. So enjoy this time. As I said, because it is not a structural issue in our market that is impacting prices right now. it is affordability coming from inflation issues and tax settings, which
10:55
Trent Fleskens: to be frank, I think will on large be flipped in 2028 with the next election if a right-wing party gets in. Uh then for those actively seeking to be a part of our market, this is the best thing that could have happened to you. For those who are invested into their properties for the medium to long term, this is a part of the cycle you need to recognise recognize is a necessary shedding. of
11:15
Trent Fleskens: fat is never not going to be part of our market given the latency of supply-demand and the many factors globally that impact investment in asset classes. And by and large, won't impact the outcome of your transaction value in 10 years. The people that I really feel for are those who had purchased their
11:35
Trent Fleskens: property with a timeline that would have lined up with about now. They were thinking of selling, they just didn't, they maybe got a little bit greedy, things got in the way, and they're now suffering to the tune of for most properties, a hundred to hundreds of thousands of dollars with regards to the opportunity cost of just making the call. But recognise again, it's nearly impossible to pick the top of a
11:55
Trent Fleskens: market. And if you've owned your property for three plus years, you've done very well in Perth owning real estate. compared to any other asset class. You think about gold, gold's now down from the five thousands to the three thousands in US per ounce. Cryptos down from $123 to $70,000 US
12:15
Trent Fleskens: per token. Tech stocks are down double digits over the last few months as well. So this is actually one of the less painful corrections off of peak numbers, especially after a period of six months. that you could have been in if you had your money invested this year. Next question comes from Mick. Mick asks five rate hikes this year, Trent. Is the
12:34
Trent Fleskens: RBA finally done? To be frank, I think a lot of us thought the RBA was finally done five rate hikes ago. Melbourne Cup day was a really easy one for the RBA to slide this one under people's noses Moses whilst they were watching the races, but everyone knew they didn't have to watch the TV T to V know it was going to happen and the reason for that is the RBA has lost confidence
12:54
Trent Fleskens: in the government to manage the books, to fight inflation from a fiscal perspective, so they've just got to do the heavy lifting with a really blunt tool that doesn't work very well or very equitably, but eventually does the job in lieu of a responsible and competent government knowing what they're doing with regards to their own
13:14
Trent Fleskens: spending. Is there another one coming? Very possibly. The bonds markets have priced in the answer probably being a no, with rate drops probably happening next year, assuming that the economy is going to be hurting enough over the last few months. We have seen the Bank of Canada, Bank of England also
13:34
Trent Fleskens: suddenly starting to increase their rates again for a second increased cycle simply because their governments also haven't tamed inflation along with the US. So a lot of economies are seeing that pressure from the monetary side. And in addition to a bit of a downturn in the tech space which has been a the unicorn for the last couple of
13:54
Trent Fleskens: years keeping a propping up of the stock market, I think the story is just going to be for a while doom and gloom and again a necessary doom and gloom Shedding of the fat in our market where those who really weren't making good decisions or over leveraged are going to be in a little bit of pain and those who have got solid investments for the medium term
14:13
Trent Fleskens: recognise the necessity of this part of the cycle. Now don't just ask me, I'd be looking at the banks as well. The banks are split. C V A NAV and Westpact Westpac expect a hold in December. Well, ANZ thinks there will be another hike in December or Feb. So again, none of us know. The banks don't know. I think a lot of it will come out in the next pieces of data in the next
14:33
Trent Fleskens: couple of weeks. Really, the sentiment of those board members who were split in the Melbourne Cup decision. So yeah, very possibly a bit of reprieve in December, but that doesn't mean it isn't coming in February as well. If you're already feeling the pinch, to be frank, I'd say this is the time to r if you haven't already call your mortgage broker, do what you can to see what you
14:53
Trent Fleskens: can do about even saving 0.1, 0.15% off your loan. A lot of the time, a phone call to your broker to have a phone call with your lender without even having to refinance can make the difference for you.
15:04
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Alright,
15:05
Trent Fleskens: next question comes from Dimitri. Dimitri asks, Should I sell my investment property before the CGT discount changes? Now, to be frank, this is probably the number one question in my inbox right now, and I need to clear this up. For most people, I'd say not for this reason alone. And this is what a lot of people are missing. And I understand why, it's confusing.
15:25
Trent Fleskens: Gains accrued before the 1st of July 2027 are assessed under the current rules. If you sold your property anytime before next July, any gain two to eight based on the sale price, still under the 50% discount, right? Only gains after that fall under the new framework. So you're not losing the 50% discount on everything up to now or up to next July. It's just that
15:45
Trent Fleskens: a valuer will make a decision as to what it was worth next July. And then from that point, gains made, let's say you sell in seven years' time, they would then apply indexation Taxation based on the cost base and ensure that you're at least paying 30% on that. real gain after
16:04
Trent Fleskens: indexation. For a lot of people, that actually may not have any impact. It might turn out better for you depending on how the inflation rate goes as well. I wouldn't be too concerned if you're owning a property for the last 40 years and you were planning to sell it in four years' time. Don't just decide because of this to sell it now. If there
16:24
Trent Fleskens: are real gains you think can be made in the industry
16:28
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): with
16:28
Trent Fleskens: regards to your specific property between now and 2030, then you might end up paying a bit more tax on those gains. But they're still gains. Unless you've got something better to do with that money, which will also be impacted by the same indexation rules, the same minimum 30% tax rules, then nothing really should be changing. It's not like you're gonna pull the money
16:48
Trent Fleskens: out of a property and putting into shares. because the shares will be impacted by the same rules anyway. If you didn't think shares were your investment strategy before, then this is not a reason to make it your strategy going forward because you'll be under the same regime regardless. So that would be the tail wagon the dog. And for those who
17:08
Trent Fleskens: were worried about this widow's tax, just whilst I'm thinking about it, the fix past passed both houses in all August. So the bottom line is before you do anything, I'll be sitting down with an accountant. Next question comes from Jackie. Jackie asks, negative gearing now only works for new builds. Trent, is off the plan the play then or is that a
17:28
Trent Fleskens: trap? Because I know you've been speaking about that in the past. Jackie, good question. The rules are locked in. From the first 1st of July 2027, negative gearing is limited to just new builds. with properties bought before May this year, grandfathered. So if you owned a property, whether it was an investment or your home before May this year,
17:48
Trent Fleskens: and then you rented out past May this year, that's grandfathered. And again, whether it was an owner-occupied property and you turn it into a rental, or if it was already a rental and it's still a rental, that's grandfathered, you still have the negative gearing, right? Anything you buy from May will be negatively geared until July
18:08
Trent Fleskens: next year. And then after that won't be able to be negatively geared. And then from after that, it'll only be the new builds
18:16
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that
18:16
Trent Fleskens: you bought from May this year that will be able to be negatively geared. I hope that makes sense. There are some carve-outs carve outs as well that like build to rent. That doesn't really affect many people listening, I don't think. And investors in government housing programs like Enras stuff, that's been carved out. But again, very small amount of people would be invested in that stuff. But really the whole point of this is, and
18:36
Trent Fleskens: ironically, because it's operated the opposite way to date, given the sentiment issues, they're trying to say, hey, we're not going to give you a safety net anymore for buying and investing and crowding out first home buyers in the established market. But if you go and build a new house, then we will. What that does lead you to is a few
18:56
Trent Fleskens: options. It's not just off-the-plan apartments, it's also off the plan on the urban fringe in new suburbs, and that has historically been where a lot of people get pushed with investment strategists, wealth sprookers, sprukers, all that. But it's also off-the-plan off the plan products or brand new. builds that haven't been lived
19:16
Trent Fleskens: in yet that have been developed by infill developers. Think about someone developing an infill property, Triplex in Warwick, Bayswater, Willagey, Coolbulup. If they're selling that house to you after they've just gone and built it and that triplex unit is brand new, you'll get negative gearing
19:35
Trent Fleskens: benefits from it. If however you want to sell that property, the next person won't get those benefits. So just recognize the implications with regards to that, that your property just becomes eventually an established property. Now, is this a trap? I think at the end of the day, you need to make your own decision based on your strategy. Are you
19:55
Trent Fleskens: chasing yield? Are you chasing capital growth? Do you want a mix of both because yield is an issue for you in terms of cash flow? Not every urban fringe development is a bad development, is a bad investment, is oversupplied, is saturated with investors or first home buyers. Many are,
20:15
Trent Fleskens: but not all are. In the same way that not all apartment developments are bad developments, bad investments, bad opportunities with regards to saturation of investors.
20:27
Trent Fleskens: and boom bust cyclical risk.
20:31
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): In
20:31
Trent Fleskens: the same way that not every infill outcome is a great one. Not every infill investment is going to provide you the rental returns or the capital returns of the established home next to you. Ideally most of us would like to own and buy as many mansions on the water as possible. It's just not a reality. What I would still rather do though is own
20:51
Trent Fleskens: property than not own property. So with the money you have and the risk profile you have and the cash flow you have with regards to your income, your serviceability with a loan, because invariably you'll have a loan, buy the highest value property you can as close to the city, the water, good school zones, and good activity centers as you can afford. If that ends up being a
21:11
Trent Fleskens: new property in a triplex triple X development or a townhouse development or an apartment or an urban fringe house and land package because that's what you can afford with a Keystart loan, then that is still better than not being in the market. Especially in a time now where you've got choice. You have time to make your own rational decisions, and most of the
21:30
Trent Fleskens: assets you're looking to buy are cheaper than they were a few months ago. Certainly the same value hierarchy with regards to investment. strategy sticks. However, if your risk profile requires you to have that negative gearing safety net, then it means you will have to buy new, and that is your
21:50
Trent Fleskens: prerogative. If it doesn't, because you've got great cash flow, your income's really high, your costs are really low, then the established market is one that isn't necessarily going to give you better return. returns. It will still come down to the property you buy in the segment you buy and the location and the amenities that it provides. I'd rather buy a
22:10
Trent Fleskens: brand new property off the plan in a great suburb with great amenity than an established property in a poor suburb. Next question comes from Geraldine. Geraldine Gerald Aiden asks, prices are falling, Trent, but rents aren't. When did do tenants get a break? and what's going on? Now this talks further to
22:30
Trent Fleskens: my responses before about the nature of this downturn. If it was a structural downturn, you would have seen rents dropping a year ago. I've always called the rental market the canary and the coal mine. You would have seen vacancy rates increasing because people are leaving, because the rental market is the more
22:50
Trent Fleskens: agile market. of the two. And you would have seen therefore rents dropping. Vacancy rates go up. Landlords have to drop their pants to get people to fill the house, and therefore rents dropping. We aren't seeing that. We're seeing a bit of in many suburbs a capping out of affordability. But that is different to rents
23:09
Trent Fleskens: dropping. Rents aren't dropping. In many suburbs where affordability hasn't been hitting ceilings. rents are still rising because the reality is stock on market and the rental market is dropping. It's nearly as low as it's ever been. And so for me, that is the big acid test, the big confirmation for me that this is not a structural. There's so
23:29
Trent Fleskens: many more things I'll talk to in a minute, but this one is one of the big tenants, tenets, the big pillars of knowing this is not a structural downturn in Perth. It's a sentiment and a affordability downturn, and they're linked together by incompetence at a government level with regards to managing inflation. When that is fixed, either through pressure or change of government,
23:50
Trent Fleskens: then the fundamentals will take over because at some point in time they always do. Liken the sentiment side to insulin, diabetics are having massive swings in their energy levels based on their insulin levels. And the structurals being the blood flow. At the end of the day, you need the blood flow, but the
24:09
Trent Fleskens: insulin levels for diabetics will actually determine in the short term whether you've got the energy or not. That's the best way I guess I can characterize the relationship between demand and supply, being the fundamentals of the constitution of this market, versus that sentiment affordability side, which is modulates outcomes around the fundamentals. Now let's look at the stats a little bit.
24:29
Trent Fleskens: I wish I had better news for renters. I really do. On RealWa's numbers, vacancies were at 1.7% the end of September, which means median rents for houses are at 750 and units 700. Both are unchanged over the quarter, so we're not seeing them drop. Remember, 3% is a Subbalance balanced market in terms of vacancies. We're at 1.7. So we're nowhere
24:49
Trent Fleskens: near it. The one positive. is that rents, as I said, have plateaued based mainly on affordability, not based on anything else. If renters could afford more, rents would be going up more simply because of the demand supply relationship I was talking about. Now, the interesting part of all this is the government programs with regards is the tax changes the governments have implemented are supposed
25:09
Trent Fleskens: to incentivize more new homes, more investment from investors focusing on negative. gearing, and therefore bring rents down. Now, that's the theory
25:19
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): at
25:19
Trent Fleskens: the moment. As I just said, the sentiment is making it go the other way. At some point in time, you'd expect there'd be more supply at some level from investment stock. That won't be for two, three, four years based on what's going on right now. It takes a while to get people to want to do what the government's trying to ask them to do, which is build more houses based on the sentiment. kicking the
25:39
Trent Fleskens: nuts they've pushed here, and then you have to actually build it. So it's going to take a while before anything comes in. And what we actually also know is that modeling has shown that after all of this broader package when it comes to capital gains tax as well, and removing the incentive to invest, the modeling modelling shows we'll have
25:59
Trent Fleskens: 35,000 thirty five thousand less homes across Australia, so 3,500 thirty five hundred less homes across. WA on average. So as I think about it, there really isn't anything in the package or in the forecasts that suggests that we are anywhere near seeing tenants getting a break, as you ask Geraldine. And I I'm sorry to s to explain that, but
26:19
Trent Fleskens: that is our reality and another reason why my confidence in the Perth market's growth for investors looking for some steady kill conversation and commentary here about where their investment's going is positive, it's upside. I'm very resolute on that. I'm not saying I'm happy about it or unhappy about it, it's just the
26:39
Trent Fleskens: facts. Next question comes from PJ. PJ asks: First home buyers are hopeful about the slump. I guess that means you're happy that you've got an opportunity with regards to price and try. choice and I totally understand that and agree with you. Are they right to jump in? Is the question. A hundred percent. As I've said over the last thirty
26:59
Trent Fleskens: minutes, this is your opportunity. If you've been sitting on your hands because you haven't found the property, the dream home, you haven't been able to compete at negotiations with ten 10 other investors and second homeowners. I get it, I get why. And you haven't bought this is it. And thank your lucky stars and pat yourself on the back for
27:19
Trent Fleskens: holding out, not paying more. You're probably buying that $900,000 house now for $780, or that $1.5 million house for $1.2, or that $600,000 house for $520. All those price points have I've seen that sort of drop, and that's real money that you'll save. Now, anyone who bought in that
27:39
Trent Fleskens: time from October through to April, those people are probably in negative equity right now, and I really feel for them. But I would always remind them that you didn't buy to trade, you didn't buy to have a live view of your property value, and it doesn't impact you in any way because your mortgage doesn't go up because your
27:59
Trent Fleskens: LVR is now at 100%. As long as you can pay that mortgage, which buffer rates tell you. you should be covered for another 2% increase in interest rates, which I don't expect, by the way, then write it out, enjoy that beautiful house that you've just bought, and come back and have a conversation in a couple of years about where things were at and might be positive for
28:18
Trent Fleskens: you at that point in time. For everyone else, we're back at prices in the mid 2025s, twenty twenty five, switch which, if you gave it a five year scope and said, Hey, prices will be what they were in mid twenty twenty five, most people would go, get in, get me ten of them. And the reality the only thing that people are now concerned about is the trajectory and hoping it
28:38
Trent Fleskens: doesn't end up being mid twenty twenty four or mid twenty twenty three and going backwards. Final question comes from Craig. Craig asks What's going on with the brick shortage? And what does it mean for builders, tradies and prices? Great question to finish on, Craig, and this is the final piece of my rounding out with regards to that
28:58
Trent Fleskens: conversation around the structural side of our market. As we know, the fundamentals not only talk to demand and the sustained requirement for properties through immigration, WA having the highest immigration growth as a percentage on its current population. across the country still. It also talks to the
29:18
Trent Fleskens: supply side. We really haven't spoken much about the drivers for supply.
29:23
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
29:23
Trent Fleskens: really, it's the ability to get houses out of the ground. The demand's there.
29:26
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
29:26
Trent Fleskens: funny thing is though, even though we demand all these properties, we want them, we need them, we're in a deficit of 50,000 homes, which will get worse next year because of what we're talking about right now.
29:36
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We
29:37
Trent Fleskens: can't build them quick enough. And this has come at the worst time possible. Of all the times where we were struggling to build homes, of all the times where we were going to run out of the main building material that 70% of our houses use as a critical path requirement for getting our house built,
29:57
Trent Fleskens: this was about the worst time to have our only brick supplier suggest that. rationing World War Two England style is coming in and that not only are the big builders gonna be about fifty percent down on what they expected they were going to need this year, but the little guys aren't even going to get a look in because they don't have an a
30:16
Trent Fleskens: allotment in the first place. They don't have a an apportionment, a rationing. And so what it does is a few things. It makes a number of the big guys, like Summit, for example, have to push even further away from building with brick. Summit says half its homes were double brick about three years ago. Now it's around a third. So some of the builders are more
30:36
Trent Fleskens: nimble than others. And it's going to move the rest of them to have to at least look to brick veneer or timber or steel outcome with some sort of cladding on the outside. Now, there's nothing wrong with those products, it's just that Western Australians for generations. have believed them to be inferior. Or at least just preferred the feel of having a brick
30:56
Trent Fleskens: home. I certainly have a number of bricks in my house and I wouldn't have chosen anything else. But again, the way I've been brought up and my own taste and preferences have led me to making that decision. But for many people, over the next few months, if you want your house built, you will have received an email from your builder saying we can move to Brick Veneer or we. can move to timber, but it's going to cost you.
31:16
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
31:17
Trent Fleskens: that's a bit of a kick in the nuts, but for the most part, the downside risk is that if you wait six months, they also can't guarantee your price for the rest of the build will be the same as well. So I think a lot of people will be pushed to make that decision just so they can get things going. But a lot more people, even if they would have liked the opportunity to say yes, put me on to an
31:36
Trent Fleskens: alternative building method, they're unfortunately with a builder that doesn't even have bricks for him, doesn't have carpenters available, and doesn't have the skill set to make that transition. So where we thought we were maybe gonna have twenty, twenty-one thousand completions next year, it'll probably be more like sixteen, seventeen thousand, which is a backward step on last
31:56
Trent Fleskens: year, a backward step on the year before. And therefore it'll increase our supply deficit another nine tenths. ten thousand homes up to close to sixty thousand homes. What it means for builders is less work, even if they've got more people demanding their work. They just won't be able to provide the services. And
32:16
Trent Fleskens: because they've learned their lessons from five years ago, they're not going to take on more and more contracts and more and more deposits. They're simply just going to close their doors to all that new work knowing that they they're not going to have a horizon over the next six months to move forward with that. So less income, they're going to be stuck with a lot of slabs and slab down payments, but no
32:36
Trent Fleskens: ability to move to the next stage. For tradies, it means having to negotiate and reprice their services down for the first time since COVID. Builders are already saying, Ha, it's time, buddy, that you've tripled your rates in the last five years, now it's coming. down. And then it doesn't actually just affect the bricklayers, it affects everyone else
32:56
Trent Fleskens: behind them on the critical path because they also therefore don't have a house to put a roof on, a house to put electricity in, or plumbing. So there'll be a big chasm of residential work just putting people into pastures for a little while there. And for prices, it's an interesting one. We're hearing on the grapevine, some builders are actually dropping some of their
33:15
Trent Fleskens: prices because the sentiments dropped, but also because they're able to start negotiating with their tradies, their subbies, lower rates. So that'll be interesting to see. But we also know that there's been many builders pricing in increases for those changes. They're going to have to go back to council, get recertification from energy
33:35
Trent Fleskens: efficiency, from engineering, all those things cost money and time from the administration of their. business for no more profit. And we also know that inflation is pushing prices up, irrespective of this anyway. Will house prices be higher this time next year than last? Yes. For nearly every quarter of the last forty years they have anyway, and there's no reason why that won't happen again. Are there any
33:54
Trent Fleskens: fixes coming forward? Is this a forever thing? No. But the fixes that come twofold from the state government so far, one, they put four million bucks in the pocket of Austel to come back and reopen the kilns down past Armadale in their card up facility which has been shuttered for years. So gotta turn the lights on, get staff
34:14
Trent Fleskens: again, start uh firing those kilns up and that's gonna take time. We won't see those bricks out of the ground until mid next year at the very least, and that's not a solution for us in the short term. And the second policy or measure that's come out from the state government is they've thrown five million bucks at helping to subsidize the acquisition of bricks
34:34
Trent Fleskens: from Over East and internationally.
34:37
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
34:37
Trent Fleskens: all that's done is take a bit of this thing out of the tail. A maxi cost $1.70, $1.80 a couple of months ago per brick. To get it from somewhere else is more like $3.60, and they're bringing it back with this subsidy to about two nine. 290. So again, the cost of bricks is nearly double for this period of time anyway. Either the builder's gonna have to cop
34:57
Trent Fleskens: it if they're in a fixed price contract already, or the price of the new contract coming through to the client is going to be higher than it would have been. None of it's good news, and at the end of the day, uh all it does is increase the replacement value of homes, and we know the replacement value theory. on real assets is that
35:16
Trent Fleskens: eventually the established market has to come to it. And I've spoken many times and explained many times why that is. So I think the only good thing that will come out of this is that it will push builders to innovate. It may lead to more diversification in our trade base, more carpenters getting structural work that aren't just roofs, but uh in the meantime,
35:37
Trent Fleskens: a lot of people with some short short-term term pain display. discomfort, frustration, and delaying of their uh life goals. Guys, that's been eight questions I've answered over about a 40 minute period. I hope you've enjoyed listening to it. Uh, I hope it's been insightful. And uh next week we'll have our main man Brendan Ptolemy back in the studio to give his thoughts on where
35:57
Trent Fleskens: things are at. out. Cheers.
35:58
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Thank you for listening to another episode of the Perth Property Show. If you've only just joined the conversation, you can catch up by heading over to our website, Perth Propertieshow.com.au, subscribing to the podcast, or joining our Facebook page. Don't forget to tune in next Monday at 7am for more expert insights,
36:18
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): local analysis, and suburb spotlights. Happy hunting!
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.

More from The Perth Property Show

All insights