Mark Higgins argues private markets face structural risks from a 40-year cycle end and unsustainable US fiscal deficits
Summary
Mark Higgins argues that private markets are at the end of a 40-year cycle, with retail migration signaling potential structural risks. He criticizes the Federal Reserve's September 2024 pivot as a strategic error comparable to the Great Inflation. Higgins highlights that US fiscal deficits have become structurally unsustainable, deviating from historical Hamiltonian principles. He warns that semi-liquid private funds face run risks due to liquidity mismatches. The episode concludes with advice for financial professionals to accept uncertainty and improve their processes.
Key takeaways
- 1 Financial history provides better context for market shocks than recent data alone; the book was written to fill a gap in single-volume U.S. financial history.
Mark Higgins · 4:38
- 2 The Fed's September 2024 pivot risked credibility by ignoring the lesson that persistent inflation requires decisive, prolonged tightening.
Mark Higgins · 9:45
- 3 Bubbles form via 'speculative supply chains' where local rationality (e.g., volume-based fees) aggregates into collective irrationality.
Mark Higgins · 25:42
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 4:18
Private Markets Cycle and Retail Migration
Mark Higgins argues that private markets are at the end of a 40-year cycle, not a new era. He notes that allocation has shifted from under 10% to over 30% in public pensions and is now migrating to retail investors, signaling potential structural risks.
- 4:18 – 6:33
Book Origin and Historical Context
Higgins wrote his book, 'Investing in U.S. Financial History,' after being caught off guard by the March 2020 market crash. He realized no single volume summarized U.S. financial history from 1790 to present, so he spent three and a half years researching and writing it, publishing in February 2024.
- 6:33 – 9:45
Behavioral Patterns and Speculative Supply Chains
Higgins observes that language used during financial panics (1837, 1873, 1907) remains identical, indicating human behavior does not evolve with technology. He introduces the concept of a 'speculative supply chain' where rational local incentives aggregate into collective irrationality.
- 9:45 – 10:45
Federal Reserve Inflation Mistakes
Higgins criticizes the Fed's September 2024 pivot to accommodative policy as a strategic error comparable to the Great Inflation. He argues that failing to decisively crush inflation risks losing central bank credibility and invites political pressure.
- 10:45 – 17:24
US Debt and Fiscal Sustainability
The most dramatic change in 230 years of U.S. finance is the growth of unsustainable fiscal deficits. Unlike the post-WWII era where debt was paid down, current attitudes treat debt as permanent, driven by entitlements rather than just war.
- 17:24 – 19:23
Private Market Structural Risks
Higgins views current private market issues as structural, citing a 40-year cycle starting with David Swenson's 2000 book. He warns that semi-liquid private funds face run risks due to mismatches between illiquid assets and redeemable capital promises.
- 19:23 – 32:23
Investment Trusts and Democratization
The narrative of 'democratizing' private markets echoes the 1920s investment trust boom. Higgins notes that marketing focuses on fund manager opportunities rather than genuine scarcity of capital, suggesting a speculative excess similar to past cycles.
- 32:23 – 33:38
Hamiltonian Debt Principles
Higgins references Alexander Hamilton's 1790 principles: debt is for public dangers (war) and should be paid down when danger subsides. The U.S. followed this for 150 years until WWII, after which deficits became permanent due to entitlements and reserve currency status.
- 33:38 – 34:11
Unsustainable Fiscal Deficits
Mark Higgins argues that the US has abandoned the Hamiltonian principle of using debt only for emergencies and paying it back, having run deficits for 80 years. He states that as global spending has caught up, it has become unsustainable.
- 34:11 – 36:02
Advice for Financial Professionals
The host asks for advice for young professionals entering the industry. Higgins advises accepting uncertainty, acknowledging what is not knowable, and being comfortable with being wrong to improve one's process.
- 36:02 – 36:58
Book Promotion and Sign-off
The host promotes Higgins' book 'Investing in US Financial History' and thanks him for the conversation. The episode concludes with production credits for host Ignacio Ramirez.
Assets discussed
| Asset | Kind | Stance | Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gold | commodity | neutral | We had 70% of the world's gold and we had the new reserve currency. |
“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.
Claims worth verifying
Private markets represent a 40-year cycle that is ending, not a new era.
Mark Higgins ·0:00
How to verify: Check historical allocation data for private equity/credit from 1980s to present via Preqin or Cambridge Associates reports. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Public pension plan allocation to alternatives rose from less than 10% to over 30%.
Mark Higgins ·0:49
How to verify: Review NACUBO-TIAA Commonfund Study of Endowments or Pensions data for historical allocation trends. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The book 'Investing in U.S. Financial History' was published in February 2024.
Mark Higgins ·5:15
How to verify: Check publisher records or ISBN database for publication date of Mark Higgins' book. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The Fed pivoted to accommodative policy in September 2024.
Mark Higgins ·9:45
How to verify: Review Federal Reserve meeting minutes and FOMC statements from September 2024. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
David Swenson published 'Pioneering Portfolio Management' in 2000.
Mark Higgins ·17:44
How to verify: Check library catalog or publisher records for the publication date of David Swenson's book. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Public pension allocations to alternatives plateaued after reaching over 30%.
Mark Higgins ·18:24
How to verify: Analyze NACUBO-TIAA data for recent years showing stagnation in alternative allocation percentages. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The Fed's credibility is damaged if inflation reignites after early loosening.
Mark Higgins ·16:27
How to verify: Review academic literature on central bank credibility and inflation expectations post-2026-2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Alexander Hamilton established debt repayment principles in 1790.
Mark Higgins ·32:23
How to verify: Review U.S. Treasury historical records or Hamilton's 'Report on Public Credit' (1790). For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The U.S. ran deficits for entitlements after WWII, unlike the post-WWII debt reduction era.
Mark Higgins ·33:18
How to verify: Check historical federal budget data from the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) for post-WWII spending trends. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Higgins works for Index Fund Advisors and manages about half a billion dollars.
Mark Higgins ·3:24
How to verify: Check IARD filings or Index Fund Advisors' website for assets under management and firm details. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceThe US stopped following the Hamiltonian principle of using debt mainly for emergencies and paying it back 80 years ago.
Mark Higgins ·33:38
How to verify: Check US federal budget data from 2026 (80 years prior to 2026) to 2026 for persistent structural deficits versus surplus years; consult historical analyses of US fiscal policy shifts post-WWII. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Global spending has caught up with US spending, making current fiscal paths unsustainable.
Mark Higgins ·33:38
How to verify: Compare US federal debt-to-GDP ratios and deficit levels against other major economies (e.g., China, EU, Japan) using IMF or World Bank datasets from 2026-08-03 to 2026-11-03. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Most things in finance are not knowable in terms of prediction.
Mark Higgins ·34:54
How to verify: This is a philosophical assertion; verify by reviewing academic literature on market efficiency and the limits of predictive modeling in finance. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The book 'Investing in US Financial History' is available for purchase on Amazon.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·36:02
How to verify: Search Amazon.com for the title 'Investing in US Financial History' by Mark Higgins to confirm availability and publication details. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify the Federal Reserve's September 2024 policy decisions and subsequent inflation data via FOMC meeting minutes and CPI reports.
- Check the asset allocation percentages of public pensions to private markets using NACUBO or similar pension survey data.
- Review Alexander Hamilton's 1790 Report on Public Credit for historical context on debt principles.
- Analyze the liquidity terms and redemption structures of semi-liquid private funds to assess run risk.
- Read Mark Higgins' book 'Investing in U.S. Financial History' for the full historical framework presented.
- Compare current US deficit-to-GDP ratios with post-WWII levels using Treasury Department data.
- Investigate the 'speculative supply chain' concept by examining fee structures and capital raising trends in private equity.
- Look for counter-arguments to the 'end of cycle' thesis from private market managers and institutional allocators.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:00
- Mark Higgins: People investing in private markets are underestimating. They don't see that this is a 40-year cycle. Retail investors and and people marketing to retail investors feel like this is like a new era. Whereas if you look back 40 years, it seems more like the end of an era. I know enough that I wouldn't invest in it.
- 0:16
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Hello everyone and welcome to a new episode of The Blunt Dollar. Today's guest is Mark Higgins. Now, if you've spent any time in markets, you've probably heard some version of the phrase this time. is different. Mark Higgins has spent years studying more than two centuries of US financial history, and his conclusion is simple. It usually
- 0:36
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): isn't. Mark is a CFA charter holder, CFP professional, author of the book Investing in US Financial History, and one of the most thoughtful voices connecting financial history to what's happening in markets today.
- 0:49
- Mark Higgins: Trillions of dollars have been invested. in private markets. Public pension plans were less than 10% allocated to alternatives. Now they're over 30%. Now it's migrating to retail investors. The signs that I see is that we are on the crest of a multi-decade cycle. I'm not willing to say that decisively, but it doesn't look
- 1:08
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): good.
- 1:14
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): This is the Blonde Dollar
- 1:17
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): with
- 1:17
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Ignacio Ramirez.
- 1:23
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Quick disclaimer the views and opinions expressed in this podcast are those of the speakers and do not constitute financial investment or legal advice. This content is for informational and educational purposes only and should not be relied upon as a substitute for professional advice. Always do your own research and consult a quality qualified advisor before making any financial decisions. All investments involve risk, including the
- 1:43
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): potential loss of capital. And now let's get started with the episode.
- 1:48
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Hello everyone and welcome to a new episode of The Blunt Dollar. Today's guest is Mark Higgins. Now, if you've spent any time in markets, you've probably heard some version of the phrase this time is different. Mark Higgins has spent years studying markets. more than two centuries of US financial history, and his conclusion is simple.
- 2:08
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): It usually isn't. Mark is a CFHR holder, CFP professional, former investment consultant, author of the book Investing in US Financial History, and one of the most thoughtful voices connecting financial history to what's happening in markets today. His work traces the evolution of American finance from Alexander. Hamilton's
- 2:28
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): first financial reforms in 1790 all the way to inflation, private markets, and the challenges facing investors today. Along all the way, he covers a recurring pattern. Every generation believes it's living through something unprecedented, only to discover that history has seen a remarkable similar movie
- 2:47
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): before. In this conversation, we'll explore what two hundred and thirty years of financial history can teach us about markets, bubbles, debt, inflation, private equity, and why understanding the past may be one of the most underrated advantages an investor can have. Mark, it's an absolute pleasure to have you on the show.
- 3:07
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Welcome to the Blunt Dollar.
- 3:09
- Mark Higgins: Oh well thank you for having me, Ignacio I've been looking forward to this for a while.
- 3:12
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, I mean it's such an honor to have you on I've seen you all over the internet. So really excited about this conversation. But first thing first, tell our uh listeners what is it that you're doing today?
- 3:24
- Mark Higgins: So I I I mean I do a couple things. During uh during my day job, I'm an investment advisor for uh index fund advisors. I work with institutions and high net worth individu individuals, uh manage about a half a billion dollars. And second, and this has become increasingly important
- 3:43
- Mark Higgins: lately, is I mean, I guess the way I would describe it is applied financial history because of the amount of work that I've done writing the book and and also a lot of follow-up articles since the book came out, applying some of the lessons of financial history to understand what's going on today. And uh it's been very
- 4:03
- Mark Higgins: useful and I I I do I spent a lot of time on that as well.
- 4:06
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Mm-hmm. Yeah. So let's talk a little bit about that about the book because I I think it's pretty cool what you what you've done and what you've accomplished. What pushed you to to write this book? Where where did the idea come from?
- 4:18
- Mark Higgins: So I never aspired to be an author. I mean I always I always wrote a lot. That was always part of my job, but I was never just exclusively a writer. And what happened was in March 2020, when COVID hit, I, like everybody else, was completely caught flat footed in I was advising large institutional investors at the time. And I just started reading financial
- 4:38
- Mark Higgins: history to try to get my bearings. And the more I read, the more I realized similar things had happened before, which can can help you contextualize it and predict what what are some potential scenarios. And I was just shocked that nobody had written, at least in a single volume, the financial history of the United States. And I I thought it would,
- 4:57
- Mark Higgins: given that it was very helpful in it in actually advising clients and getting my bearings, and there was no book out there that really summarized the whole story. I thought there was a need for it. And I thought I'd take a shot at it. And after about three and a half years of I cannot tell you how much I read, it was mostly reading, not writing.
- 5:15
- Mark Higgins: and um really mapping out how we got from seventeen ninety to here and teaching people lessons along the way that are still applicable, I did it and it was published in uh February twenty twenty four and uh it's been it's been very useful.
- 5:30
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, congrats. Especially because you
- 5:32
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): did all
- 5:32
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): of that pre Chat GPT and Claude claw
- 5:35
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): times, which uh makes it extra extra uh um hard, I would say.
- 5:40
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, and
- 5:42
- Mark Higgins: it's interesting on that, because I I do use AI to for mainly for editing and and and really pressure testing things. But it it's still not to the point. The thing about AI is it repeats what's known for the most part, but a lot of what I did was synthesizing things that hadn't been synthesized before. And I
- 6:02
- Mark Higgins: think I it has a harder time doing that.
- 6:04
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Interesting. So tell us a little bit about your findings. Because as I said in the introduction, we all believe that what is happening to us is truly unique. But as a matter of fact, most of the times it isn't. So after studying more than two centuries of financial history, what are some of the main things that you realized? What do investors
- 6:24
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): consistently overestimate about the present? and underestimate about the past? And what are some of the main things that surprised you in your uh in your research?
- 6:33
- Mark Higgins: Well, what's surprised I guess what was surpr it's hard to talk about it now because I've kind of internalized it, but I I think what was surprising as I started reading myself from 1790 very, very slowly, over literally over three and a half years, until I got to today. And what was surprising was just how many times people were
- 6:53
- Mark Higgins: saying the same things. When and and it I really concentrated on major turning points because those are the most important things in history. And before a mania, during a mania, and after the crash, you just hear the same language. And that that actually is very interesting because a lot of times when and and we'll probably
- 7:13
- Mark Higgins: get to this later, one of the blind spots of academia and in practice, frankly, is that people are so focused on the recent data that that they miss the war the data usually is a lagging indicator. And a leading indicator is how are people talking about things? Is there, um, we may talk about this later, Or what's
- 7:33
- Mark Higgins: called a speculative supply chain when you're when you're when you're moving into a bubble situation. or or a main a speculative episode. And that's something that history helps you catch. And it was just shocking when uh I'm reading about the the panic of 1837, the panic of 1873, the panic of nineteen oh seven. They
- 7:53
- Mark Higgins: they all use the same language. And you can kind
- 7:55
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of see
- 7:56
- Mark Higgins: it coming.
- 7:56
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): And why why do you think uh we behave like that as uh collectively as as investors? Why do we focus so much on on current data and try to, let's say, uh use uh f forecasts
- 8:08
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 8:09
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): for investing rather than looking at the past and uh and and financial history?
- 8:14
- Mark Higgins: Yeah, I mean I think there are a lot of reasons, probably at the root is people people confuse the advancement of society in terms of technology with the advancement of human humans in terms of evolution. And the behaviors actually don't change that much. The situations in which they're applied may evolve,
- 8:34
- Mark Higgins: but the behaviors don't change that much. And I think people confuse technological advancement with human evolution advancement in terms of behaviors. And
- 8:44
- Mark Higgins: the latter tends to lag the former.
- 8:47
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): So how would you convince like a an investor today, particularly a young investor uh that's studying uh Hamilton's writings and for example the panic of nineteen oh seven or the great inflation can actually improve their decision making in the current setup? What would you tell them?
- 9:05
- Mark Higgins: I mean, I I I think it is extremely valuable to read history. Obviously it's gonna sound self self-promotional, promotional, but uh I I think starting with my book would be a a good starting point to read through the to get a very high level overview of the history of this country and then dig down appropriately when something appears familiar. So
- 9:25
- Mark Higgins: uh what what's interesting about the book is there's something uh some things I didn't necessarily focus on as intently as I should have that I'll probably do in the next edition. But the more histories you study, the more of the the present that seems familiar. I I don't know how to say it on the any other way. I mean a good example is the Fed when they pivoted
- 9:45
- Mark Higgins: toward more accommodative monetary policy in September of 2024, having read extensively, because it's a big event, about the great inflation, that was instantly recognizable in my opinion as a as a major strategic error. Because the main lesson from the great inflation is when inflation
- 10:04
- Mark Higgins: persists for too long, several years, and it starts coming back down to the target, you kind of have to you have to distinguish it decisively. That usually requires an accession, recession, and deterioration in labor markets because you risk having it bounce back up, losing credibility, and having it be hard of Heart this the next times.
- 10:25
- Mark Higgins: That may not be understood by by really uh immersing yourself in the financial history of this country and the world for that matter.
- 10:33
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): So now that you have this super comprehensive overview, uh in your opinion, what has changed the most in financial markets over these last 230 years and what hasn't changed at all? Aaron
- 10:45
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Powell
- 10:45
- Mark Higgins: Well I think the most it's more public finance, but I think that the the thing that is the most dramatic. dramatically different and legitimately unprecedented is the growth of the US debt and the unsustainable fiscal deficits that we have. That in really the medium term at this point, hopefully not the short term, but at least the medium term is the most
- 11:05
- Mark Higgins: concerning thing. And and the most and the attitude towards debt is very different today than it was actually for most of US financial history.
- 11:13
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): So one of the the interesting ideas in your work is that markets don't exist in uh completely isolated, but they are deeply connected to the to the rise and decline of nations and and empires for that matter.
- 11:27
- Mark Higgins: Yeah.
- 11:28
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): What are the common ingredients that create a great financial empire and what ultimately causes uh it to weaken or disappear?
- 11:38
- Mark Higgins: That's a big question. I mean it's not easy to answer that uh uh with
- 11:43
- Mark Higgins: with a single statement, but uh if you look at the United States, we did have a lot of natural advantages. One chapter in the book is on what was called the American commercial invasion in the end of the eighteen hundreds, or the turn of the the twentieth century. And the United States
- 12:03
- Mark Higgins: has ample access to natural resources. It's protected by oceans and relatively friendly neighbors surrounding it. And it just has a I I don't know exactly where it comes from, probably the way the nation was founded. But there is just this thirst for entrepreneurship, a drive for innovation that has been present in
- 12:23
- Mark Higgins: the United States for over 200 years. And so there's a cult cultural aspect to our competitive advantage as well. Now, that's not gonna necessarily last forever. It needs to be preserved, but there's a lot of pessimism right now about the United States. I actually don't share that, having lived through vicariously 235 years. I think
- 12:43
- Mark Higgins: those are still present. The rest of the world has caught up a bit, which we can talk about in terms of the uh that that relates to the the debt. But I actually think the United States is is is still very strong.
- 12:55
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Mm-hmm. Uh so yeah, but talking about the United States and those factors that put it in a in an exceptional position for a number of years, for the more let's say skeptical investors out there, why do you think the Federal Reserve misunderstood the inflation surge search that began in twenty 2021 twenty one, that uh some so many people uh have
- 13:15
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): criticized over over time.
- 13:17
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 13:17
- Mark Higgins: th this is an important point. I wrote a paper on this that I posted on a site called SSRN and it's called Applied Financial History. The
- 13:25
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): there
- 13:25
- Mark Higgins: is a blind spot that I believe is is really costly in mainly in throughout practice and academia and policy making, where there seems to be too much focus on models. that are based on equilibrium. So it explains things in normal conditions. But the problem with those
- 13:45
- Mark Higgins: models is they can last for decades and they can work well for decades. But then you have some type of regime change or major shock and they and they break. And it's at those points that history can be much more valuable because you can rewind the clock 200 years and see if you can find something that. was similar and may explain what's
- 14:05
- Mark Higgins: happening better than the equilibrium-based models that have broken. And I think that's the trap that the Fed got caught in. I think the best comparable for post-COVID inflation initially was we had a similar event. It lasted about two years after World War One and and the Great Influenza ended simultaneously at the end of 1918
- 14:25
- Mark Higgins: and early 1919. And it required a very aggressive response from the Fed. It caused a a recession and and brief period of of deflation, but then things recovered. So I think they missed that by calling it transitory. But that was a little understandable because it happened almost a hundred years earlier. But the bigger miss was once inflation had persisted for several years,
- 14:45
- Mark Higgins: the new comparable was the great inflation that the Fed needed to be aggressive, which they were. and they needed to maintain that aggressiveness to decisively contain inflation because the risk, if you don't, and it reignites, it deteriorates the Fed's credibility, which we've seen, and it makes it harder to contain the next time because
- 15:05
- Mark Higgins: political pressure tends to amp up. So it was hard to watch because it there was a very clear precedent for that uh pivot that the Fed did in
- 15:15
- Mark Higgins: August or September 2024 and um and it it it wasn't it was ignored and uh I think it was a big mistake.
- 15:23
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): So when we talk about central banks d credibility is often described as one of its most valuable assets.
- 15:30
- Mark Higgins: Yeah.
- 15:30
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Why is credibility so important in monetary policy and and how does a central bank earn earn it or lose it? Hey there quick favor to ask. If you enjoy the blunt dollar, the unfilter takes, the stories, and the laughs, the easiest way to support the show is by tapping that subscribe button right now while you're listening. And
- 15:50
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): here's my promise:
- 15:52
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if
- 15:52
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): you do, I'll keep bringing you honest conversations, fresh perspectives, and the kind of finance talk that's engaging, insightful, and worth your time. Thanks so much for being here. And let's keep these great finance conversations going.
- 16:07
- Mark Higgins: Well, specifically with regard to inflation, it's important because once people lose faith that the Fed is going to be committed to its commitment to maintain price price stability, expectations change and behavior changes. And once they lose credibility, they become less equipped to resist political pressure, which happens
- 16:27
- Mark Higgins: a lot. I mean, it it it's intense now. It's very intense now, but trust me, it's happened before. That was if the Fed underestimated anything, they underestimated the loss of credibility. If they loosened monetary policy too early and inflation reignited, that was going to be extremely damaging to their
- 16:47
- Mark Higgins: credibility. And in my opinion, it wasn't a worth it wasn't a risk worth taking. And they took it and um and look what's happened.
- 16:53
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): So let's pivot now away from central banks and and let's talk about private markets, which I know is a uh a topic very close to your heart. For years I feel this part of of this corner of finance was marketed as one of the smartest ways of investing, and now we're starting to see some headlines around redemption gains,
- 17:13
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): liquidity concerns, quite questions around valuations. Are we witnessing a a temporary growing pain in private markets, or are we seeing the early stages of something much
- 17:24
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 17:24
- Mark Higgins: think it's structural? And the reason I think it's structural is just the sheer number of red flags. And I've written pretty extensively about this, both in my personal newsletter and with the CFA Enterprising uh CFA Institute Enterprising Investor publication. and all and also actually with the Museum of American Finance. And the reason I I feel like it's more structural
- 17:44
- Mark Higgins: mainly is if you look it this is one of those long wave cycles. So the amount uh trillions of dollars have been invested in private markets really starting in two thousand after David Swenson published his book, Pioneering Portfolio Management. And then it followed a typical cycle, right? He he showed how
- 18:04
- Mark Higgins: a a key driver, not the only driver, but a key driver of Yale's the Yale University Endowments exceptional returns was getting in early in venture capital and buyouts and to some extent hedge funds. And everyone started copying it. And you saw just as as a metric, public pension plans were less than 10% allocated to alternatives. Now they're over 30%. They're kind of
- 18:24
- Mark Higgins: they've kind of plateaued. And now it's migrating to retail investors. And this is a cycle. You saw it with railroads, saw canals. You see the cycle repeatedly. So it with whaling, but they usually last several decades where there's some type of disruption that require that there's a shortage of capital in a certain area. Bold capital providers generate
- 18:44
- Mark Higgins: exceptional returns. That attracts imitators. The imitators eventually erode the excess return to the extent to the extent that it becomes negative expected return, you know, on a relative basis. And there's a crash and it kind of re it it kind of reboots. And the signs that I see is that we we are on the
- 19:04
- Mark Higgins: crest of a multi decade cycle. And this may be the the end point here with what we're seeing in semi semi-liquid liquid private markets funds. I'm not willing to say that decisively, but it doesn't look good.
- 19:15
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): One of the things that uh what we've been saying over the past few years is that private markets are being democratized.
- 19:23
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): It's definitely become one of the industry's favorite uh narratives to some extent. When you hear that phrase, what what are you most concerned about?
- 19:32
- Mark Higgins: I'm concerned because I heard the same thing in the 1920s. Uh And when um you know, there the the the investment investment trust, IR. ironically, it's not that much different. The investment trusts or investment company movement started in the mid uh 1920s. What concerns me is you hear a lot of
- 19:51
- Mark Higgins: opportunity from the fund manager's perspective with getting into DC plans and and targeting the retail market. You don't hear so much in in terms of, I can't believe these. companies that have unbelievable financials can't get money. And that's what I would want to hear if it was opportunity driven. That's not what I hear.
- 20:11
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, to me, what is uh what is interesting uh after reading some of the stuff that you wrote is that throughout history, some of the biggest crises seem to have started when you have a mismatch between a promise, like a liquidity promise, and and the the actual nature of the underlying assets. Why is the idea of funding illiquid
- 20:31
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): assets with redeemable capital so dangerous?
- 20:33
- Mark Higgins: Because they're run they're vulnerable to runs. And that that actually was the topic. One of the one of the things I hit on at the SEC panel is after 235 years, you start to develop a sensitivity to structures. Destructures. What are some mechanisms that are reappearing that I've seen before? And it may look a little different, but it's the same mechanism. And the semi-liquid
- 20:53
- Mark Higgins: private markets funds is a very well-known mechanism where you have investments in
- 21:01
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): ill
- 21:01
- Mark Higgins: liquid, you have illiquid investments, and they can't be sold at whatever value they're marked to easily in the market if they need to in a short period of time. And then there's some type of promise of liquidity that is shorter duration. and you don't have a lender of last resort, i.e., the Fed. And when that happens, you're you're vulnerable to run
- 21:21
- Mark Higgins: dynamics. We saw this with lightly regulated state charter banks in the mid-1800s. We saw it with trusts in the early nights. And I think we're seeing it now with semi-local private market funds. And the key vulnerability is that when you reach a th certain threshold of redemptions, people stop thinking. about um, you know,
- 21:41
- Mark Higgins: just do I need my money personally? They start thinking about, well, if everyone starts getting out, then I'm not going to be able to get out. And if those assets are impaired, I'm going to get out at a lower value. So I better get out now. And that's what that's what causes a run and that's what causes a run to spread. And often hear that, well, gates are, you know, they've worked as intended, that uh, people
- 22:01
- Mark Higgins: aren't doing it for sale. Well, they it's very early. It's been about three months, it's still getting worse. And having witnessed a lot of runs, and gates, by the way, are not a new thing. They there have been things like this used before. And we'll see if it works. The verdict's out. And um, I I think people have underestimated the risk here.
- 22:20
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Definitely the jury Jerry is still out. Another thing that you've you've written about that I find interesting is that uh private markets may. be suffering from too much success. Capital for for for for some time was floating into a space that was originally working because capital was scarce or not accessible to to everyone. Yeah.
- 22:40
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): And now obviously that that has changed. How does an asset class which is private already Can become a victim of its own uh popularity?
- 22:48
- Mark Higgins: This happens repeatedly, Throat. right? I Again, you said saw it with canals, you saw it with railroads, you saw it with industrials, you saw it with internet stocks. These things repeat where it's a cycle of there's some type of real disruption and real opportunity. It it generates above average returns for the the early capital
- 23:08
- Mark Higgins: providers. Then all of the imitators follow it, and you is eventually had have just too much capital. for to and they start funding opportunities that aren't attractive. And it's just it's a cycle that repeats over and over. And I I don't see the difference here.
- 23:24
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): And if we fast forward, let's say ten, fifteen years down the road and we look back to this period, what do you think people will say about these years? What do you think the story will be? What will the mark of the future be saying of the the things we're leaving in 2026?
- 23:41
- Mark Higgins: You know, I I I don't that that's a hard prediction generally. I'd I'd probably have to make it more narrowly on certain things. I think the odds are that I'm not saying the private markets are gonna collapse and be a GFC type event. I haven't seen the evidence that the traditional banking system has enough exposure to do that. That doesn't mean they
- 24:01
- Mark Higgins: don't. I just haven't seen the evidence of that. But I think looking back, that people will be very disappointed. Well, let's just focus on private markets because that's easier. I think people are going to be very disappointed with the returns. Some will be catastrophic potentially. But I think generally it's just going to be very disappointing.
- 24:16
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): So let's let's change topics. Let's talk about speculative manias now, bubbles, FOMO, a topic that obviously is recurring across history. Every generation believes it's smart. smarter than the previous one, and yet every generation creates its own bubble in some ways. Why do why do intelligent
- 24:35
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): investors repeatedly fall into these speculative manias despite having centuries of financial history available to them?
- 24:43
- Mark Higgins: The this is something that I thought a lot about, and because there's there seems to be a common perception that these things aren't predictable. And I actually think they are a little predictable. And but the warning sign is is the formation. I don't know if it's the best term, but I just call it a speculative supply chain. And the
- 25:03
- Mark Higgins: reason these manias happen is because locally it actually seems rational. If you have the real estate crisis, it was a perfect example. You had loan originators who were motivated by volume. They got paid on volume. They would pass off the mortgages to investment banks, which would package them into structured products and and sell them to the next
- 25:23
- Mark Higgins: link in the chain. Everybody locally has believes what they're doing. They they think it makes sense. It they have incentives to do it and they pass the risk on. And by the time you get to the end, and the and the media is in on it, that you know, everyone's making money. So the media media's is highlighting people who are making money, trade. organizations are are are supporting it as well. And so you
- 25:42
- Mark Higgins: have these situations where everybody is acting rationally locally, but it's aggregating into something that is irrational collectively. And then it only becomes obvious how absurd it was when it breaks, or you have people who are out who can see the whole supply chain. And and the Big Short was a great example of that. The what was really real they were smart people, but you know, the Mike Burries
- 26:02
- Mark Higgins: and the Steve Icemans, they were smart people. But more than anything, they pulled back, viewed the entire supply chain, and could see how that it was collectively creating things that didn't make sense. That's very hard to do. If you if you can extract yourself from a speculative supply chain and see what's happening objectively, you I believe you can see these things
- 26:22
- Mark Higgins: in advance. And my belief is we are we are more likely than not in one right now with private markets.
- 26:28
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): One of the fascinating things about bubbles, as as uh you were saying, is that yeah, locally they make sense as as as you alluded to. They often begin with something real, something tangible, some sort of innovation. How can how can we distinguish between a genuine technological revolution
- 26:48
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): versus just like a a speculative speculative frenzy around it. Hey there! Quick ad break. Do you work in the finance industry and have a genuinely interesting story to share? I'm always on the hunt for great guests who bring raw unfiltered insights to the table. Or maybe you know someone with a story worth telling? Please put us in touch.
- 27:08
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
- 27:08
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): can reach out to me directly via LinkedIn. I'd love to hear from you. And now, back to the show.
- 27:19
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
- 27:19
- Mark Higgins: I mean, you can have both, but uh and you usually do have both, right? I mean, with with a with the internet for for example, it was that's what makes it harder to detect, right? Because there is a a real element to it. But if you looked at the supply chain, because the it's it was a s it was a spectrum spectral of the supply chain as well during the dot-com boom. But if you
- 27:39
- Mark Higgins: looked at the entire chain and and it just the absence of skepticism, you know, like there's there's usually just no skepticism in these things. You can you can detect the probability. You don't know for sure, though. You honestly don't. But if you identify a speculative supply chain when everyone's running in the same direction, I think you can say with quite a bit of
- 27:59
- Mark Higgins: confidence that the likelihood is more more than in normal time. times. And and that's what it really that's usually what I'm doing. I I don't know if private markets are in a I mean, I I don't know how you define a bubble, but I personally think the odds are they are in a period of significant speculative excess and but I don't know for sure.
- 28:19
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 28:19
- Mark Higgins: know I know enough that I wouldn't invest in it. Let's let's say I suspect enough that the risk doesn't warrant investment from my perspective.
- 28:26
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): So let's talk now about the the next generation of investors, because a lot of our listeners are probably starting their career in in finance, or a lot of the listeners are investors that are are just starting to get their hands into financial markets. From your point of view, what do you think modern investors know too much about and
- 28:46
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): what do they know nearly not enough about? Well
- 28:50
- Mark Higgins: you're not gonna be surprised that. at this answer, but I think people focus too much on their own life experience and the very recent past to make decisions that that very recent past and their life experience may not be relevant to. And I I think we've talked about a couple examples already on this podcast with the Fed
- 29:09
- Mark Higgins: underestimating some very important lessons from a 100 hundred years ago and uh forty-five 45 years ago at this. point. I think that people investing in private markets are underestimating. They don't see that this is a 40 year cycle. A lot of them of retail investors and people marketing to retail investors feel like this is like a new era.
- 29:29
- Mark Higgins: Whereas if you look back 40 years, it seems more like the end of an era. So
- 29:34
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 29:34
- Mark Higgins: wish I had it in front of me. Charlie Munger had a great quote about just how. powerful it can be to supplement your memory with the memories of those people that came before you. There's so many lessons, so many principles that they learn through very hard experiences that we just neglect. And I always
- 29:54
- Mark Higgins: tell people that I I have a CFA, a CFP, and an MBA. And by far, I it's not even close. The most valuable thing I did was. read hundreds of maybe it's not hundreds, over a hundred books and tens of thousands of pages of studies, newspapers. I used to read newspapers for for years. Like I
- 30:14
- Mark Higgins: I randomly select a week around major events to to see what it felt like. And that was by far more valuable than anything I've ever done.
- 30:23
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): That's cool. I thought about doing that, but I never did it. Like uh going in the past and selecting specifically
- 30:30
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): like reliving.
- 30:31
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And I think that's
- 30:32
- Mark Higgins: it's i because I thought a lot about why the financial history of the United States was never written. And I think it's because of what academia is generally rewarded for. They're they're generally rewarded for putting together more comprehensive data sets or really digging deep on an event. But nobody when I what what
- 30:52
- Mark Higgins: drove me to write a book on financial history was I was trying to figure out everything seemed unprecedented. Models seemed to be breaking and there there was no explanation for what was going on. So the way I read history was to really just figure out what's happening and sharing that once I realized that there hadn't been a book written on it. And it seems like that was just a very different
- 31:12
- Mark Higgins: way of approaching it. And um I don't know. I think that's why it was probably more valuable. I was I was trying to re-experience history, not just study a a specific period or put together a a more comprehensive data set.
- 31:24
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Got it. So we're getting close to the end of the conversation. Couple of last questions, maybe more forward looking now. If you look at today's environment, what is the most important historical pattern? If you had to select one that investors should be paying attention today to they right now. to learn and try to predict what's gonna happen in the future.
- 31:43
- Mark Higgins: In terms of the bigger uh shorter term, I think inflation, needless to say, is is popped back up for reasons that were historically understood. And I hope policymakers realize that yes, did did the war in Iran amplify it a bit? Yes. Same thing happened in the seventies, but that wasn't really the cause.
- 32:03
- Mark Higgins: It made it a little worse, but it wasn't really the cause. And I think policymakers really need to come to terms with the fact that they made a mistake. I I I think they made a very big mistake, and I think that's I suspect that's gonna be Pal's legacy, and I hope they I hope I hope they think about that. And then this is for the American people generally, and and for a lot of people in other countries too, because of America United
- 32:23
- Mark Higgins: States is not alone in this. And we didn't talk about this a little, but this uh uh that much. But when Alexander Hamilton repaired the debt in 1790, he established two principles. One is the debt is primarily
- 32:38
- Mark Higgins: needed for public dangers, mainly mainly war, foreign war. And then once the danger subsides, it's important to pay it back. And we actually did that for about 150 years. We did it after the War of 18. We ran up debt during the War of 1812, paid it back, ran up debt during the Civil War, paid it back. World War I,
- 32:58
- Mark Higgins: same thing. And then World War II hit. And after World War II, the United States exited as the had we were only intact industrial infrastructure. Most of the world was destroyed because we were protected by the oceans. We had 70% of the world's gold and we had the new reserve currency. And that really
- 33:18
- Mark Higgins: gave us such an advantage that we started we felt empowered to pretty soon to run deficits both in terms of both during times of peace and and during public dangers. And mainly th with entitlements, the the gradual expansion of entitlements. And I've written an article for the Museum of American Finance on on that cycle. And
- 33:38
- Mark Higgins: we've gotten to the point where we just run deficits. It's not we have lost sight of the Hamiltonian principle of the debt is supposed to be mainly used for emergencies and then paid back. And we stopped doing that 80 years ago. And as the world has caught up, the the spending has just become unsustainable. And um it's a it's a big problem.
- 33:57
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah. And the topic of a podcast of its own, because uh indeed many policymakers have said it repeatedly. that uh many countries are on on unsustainable fiscal paths. Uh maybe we can do another episode of that. I have a last question for you.
- 34:11
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Sure
- 34:11
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): to wrap this up, uh if you had to give a piece of advice for the young listeners that are entering the industry today, not investors, but just like the professionals of of of today and tomorrow, in order to uh not only survive but thrive. in this beautiful industry over the next 30, 40, 50 years, what would your advice be?
- 34:31
- Mark Higgins: Accept uncertainty. That even you can study things until the end of time, there will always be uncertainty. And the more you acknowledge uncertainty, it forces you to keep pressing to incrementally reduce that uncertainty and become more effective. And I think there's a lot of temptation. in
- 34:51
- Mark Higgins: finance to
- 34:54
- Mark Higgins: overstate certainty and not be humble about what you don't know. And at the end of the day, I think history can be very valuable. Most things are not knowable in terms of prediction. And even when you have very good precedent, something could be different. And then you if it is, you update your model. And I think people, the more you
- 35:14
- Mark Higgins: become comfortable. with being wrong and knowing that it's fine, as long as you have a solid process and solid methodology for for predicting what you did, the more you're comfortable with that, the better, the better you will get. And I think that's something that is I see missing a lot where people are just afraid to be wrong.
- 35:34
- Mark Higgins: And if your goal is to just constantly improve your process and get better, being wrong is just not not a big deal.
- 35:41
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Mm-hmm. Yeah. And if there's anything I learned from my years in the industry is the importance about being humble and nimble at the same time, because chances are that you're gonna be wrong very, very often. And the important thing is to learn from your mistakes and keep moving forward. Mark, it's been an absolute pleasure to have you on the show. Thank you so much for sharing
- 36:02
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): all these insights. I mean, it's it's super interesting to be talking to you. We don't get to talk to finance history experts every day. For those of you that haven't read it, please make sure to head to Amazon and purchase the book Investing in US Financial History, where Mark talks about all of this in a lot more detail. Mark,
- 36:22
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): it's been an absolute pleasure to have you on the show. Thank you so much. And we can't wait
- 36:26
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
- 36:26
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): continue reading. the stuff you produce.
- 36:28
- Mark Higgins: Yeah, thank you for having me. It's been a good conversation and um hope to talk to you again.
- 36:33
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
- 36:33
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Blunt Dollar is written, produced, hosted, and edited by me, Ignacio Ramirez. Everything you hear, concept, script, sound design, and production comes straight from my desk and occasionally my kitchen table. Thank you so much for listening and join me in the next episode of the Blunt Dollar. for more raw, honest finance
- 36:53
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): conversations.