The Better Boards Podcast Series

Jim Brown on overcoming boardroom silence and artificial harmony through psychological safety

26 min Listen to the original
Corporate GovernanceBoard DynamicsPsychological SafetyLeadershipOrganizational CultureExecutive Education

Summary

Jim Brown, CEO of OrgHealth, discusses how boardroom silence stems from interpersonal fears rather than intelligence deficits, creating a culture of artificial harmony. He argues that every director shares responsibility for meeting effectiveness, not just the chair. Brown advocates for leaders to model vulnerability to build trust and encourage robust disagreement. He warns against mistaking silence for consensus and emphasizes the need for chairs to manage dominant personalities and draw out quiet voices. The episode concludes with actionable advice for directors to notice what is not being said and take collective responsibility for judgment.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    Boardroom dynamics inhibiting sharing are interpersonal, not intelligence-based, requiring cultural fixes rather than just process changes.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) · 2:07

  2. 2
    Chairs have special responsibility to resist premature consensus and manage dominant personalities to ensure full participation.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) · 8:54

Episode sections

  1. 0:02 – 2:07

    Introduction and the Problem of Silent Boardrooms

    Dr. Sabina Dembkowski introduces the topic of missing conversations in boardrooms, noting that effective governance often fails due to a lack of psychological safety. Jim Brown joins to discuss how important discussions frequently occur outside the formal meeting setting.

  2. 2:07 – 4:37

    Root Causes of Boardroom Silence

    Jim Brown attributes boardroom silence to interpersonal fears rather than intelligence deficits, such as fear of looking uninformed or damaging relationships. He emphasizes that every director shares responsibility for the meeting's effectiveness, not just the chair.

  3. 4:37 – 8:33

    The Prevalence of Artificial Harmony

    Dembkowski notes that this issue affects the majority of boardrooms. Brown identifies this as a culture of insufficient trust and psychological safety, a concept popularized by Amy Edmondson. He warns against 'artificial harmony' where silence is mistaken for consensus.

  4. 8:33 – 11:00

    Leadership and Chair Responsibilities

    Brown outlines specific actions for chairs, including drawing out quiet voices, managing dominant personalities, and resisting premature consensus. He stresses that chairs must prioritize effectiveness over efficiency and encourage reflection.

  5. 11:00 – 16:02

    Modeling Vulnerability and Imperfection

    Brown advocates for leaders to model vulnerability to build trust, citing his books 'The Imperfect Board Member' and 'The Imperfect CEO'. He shares an anecdote about a chair who admitted his weaknesses and apologized for past mistakes to normalize imperfection.

  6. 16:02 – 19:20

    Director Actions and Behavioral Cues

    Brown advises directors to acknowledge their own limits of expertise and observe non-verbal cues like folded arms to detect discomfort. He suggests that any director can and should invite quieter members to share their perspectives.

  7. 19:20 – 23:19

    Signs of a High-Performing Board

    Positive indicators include energetic engagement, building on others' ideas, and productive disagreement leading to consensus. Brown argues that unanimous agreement without debate is less indicative of high performance than robust discussion.

  8. 23:19 – 25:32

    Key Takeaways for Listeners

    Brown concludes with three takeaways: notice what is not being said (silence is not agreement), make disagreement safe through trust, and take responsibility for collective judgment rather than individual scorekeeping.

Claims worth verifying

Jim Brown is the USA TODAY bestselling author of 'The Imperfect Board Member' (20th Anniversary Edition) and 'The Imperfect CEO'.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·1:02

How to verify: Check Amazon bestseller lists for Jim Brown's titles and verify publication editions via publisher records or ISBN databases. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Amy Edmondson made the concept of 'psychological safety' famous.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·5:25

How to verify: Search academic databases (e.g., Google Scholar) for Amy Edmondson's publications on psychological safety, such as her 2026 article in Administrative Science Quarterly. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Jim Brown has over 30 years of experience helping boards and executive teams.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·0:42

How to verify: Review Jim Brown's professional biography on the OrgHealth website or LinkedIn profile for career timeline details. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The speaker knows a chair of a Fortune 50 company who admitted his weaknesses to resolve a board stalemate.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·12:29

How to verify: This is an anecdotal claim. Verification would require identifying the specific company and chair, potentially through news archives or board appointment records, though the speaker explicitly states the name is withheld. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify Amy Edmondson's definition of psychological safety in her book 'The Fearless Organization' or Harvard Business Review articles.
  • Check Jim Brown's publications 'The Imperfect Board Member' and 'The Imperfect CEO' for his specific frameworks on vulnerability.
  • Review OrgHealth's methodology for measuring board effectiveness and psychological safety in boardrooms.
  • Look for case studies of Fortune 50 companies that have implemented psychological safety training and their reported outcomes.
  • Identify potential conflicts of interest if OrgHealth provides consulting services to the boards discussed.
  • Research the specific Fortune 50 company mentioned to verify the anecdote about the chair admitting weaknesses.
  • Compare Brown's views on 'artificial harmony' with other governance experts like Paul Appelbaum or David Strunk.
  • Check if the 'interpersonal vs intelligence' distinction is supported by academic research on board dynamics.
Full transcriptexpand

0:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The

0:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): conversations boards aren't having. Why trust, psychological safety, and constructive challenge matters more than ever. Boards can have experienced directors, well-structured agendas, and excellent governance processes, yet still fail to have the conversations that matter the most. Sometimes the most revealing discussions happen after the meeting when directors speak properly. privately about concerns they were reluctant to raise around the board table. Why does it happen? And what can boards do to create an environment where directors are willing to challenge assumptions, express uncertainty, and engage really in the candid conversations that lead to better decisions. I'm Dr. Sabina Demkowski, founder and managing partner of Better Boards. We make the boards of the most ambitious organizations more effective with an innovative way to conduct board effectiveness evaluations. My podcast partner today is Jim Brown. He's best selling author of the Imperfect Board member. It's a new release, the 20s anniversary decision exploring human dynamics that distinguish really effective boards. He's drawing on decades of experience in working with boards and executive

1:21leaders, and I think he is a great partner to discuss the subject. Jim, thank you so much for contributing to the BetterBots Podcast series.

1:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): It's a pleasure to be with you, Sabina. I've enjoyed your show and uh it's it's fun to be on it with you.

1:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): That's fantastic. Jim. And uh I think we are pretty aligned on some of of of the issues, but you have written extensively and uh I hope we can uh give um our listeners a good flavour of your thinking and and what you have written. We both observed that the most important conversations very often happen outside the boardroom rather than in inside the boardroom. Why why does this happen?

2:07Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I agree. Uh and and I think that the reason for that is that there's something about the dynamics in the boardroom that is inhibiting what people feel safe to share. I don't think it's about um intelligence, I think it's about interpersonal issues. So yeah, that means that there's something that needs to be addressed. And I want to underscore that a board meeting is the board's meeting, meaning every person on the board is responsible for that meeting to be effective. It's very common that people will quote. blame the chair if the meeting doesn't go well. And I agree that there's special responsibility in the hands of the chair, but it's inappropriate for anyone to complain about what didn't happen or didn't get said at a meeting when they were in the meeting.

3:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Exactly.

3:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): They could have brought it out, they could have said it, and yeah. it it's critical that we get the full conversation to happen in the meeting rather than in the parking lot after the meeting.

3:22Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): But I mean we both know the practice. What's actually happening in real life is very often different. And I asked myself very often, you know, So how can we help these boards? What actually prevents intelligent, experienced directors from speaking candidly?

3:44Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I think there's a combination of things. I I think mostly it's some kind of fear. So it could be a fear that if they were to say this they would look uninformed or foolish, or if they were to challenge somebody, that might damage the relationship they have with them. And they don't want to risk that, so they keep it to themselves. These thoughts that they have are preventing them from bringing the ideas, the questions, the concerns, maybe even the experiences into the conversation. And that means that we're not getting as much of the important information in the mix so the board can make a fully informed decision.

4:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And the sad truth is it happens so often in almost every boardroom. I think in in much more than half of the boardrooms, this is exactly happening. I mean, we identify in board evaluation. evaluations when we conduct the interviews always informations where people actually talk about you do find boards where it doesn't happen. Let's face it. But in the majority of boards, it is actually an issue.

5:05Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): And this this betrays a culture concern. I I would argue it's the culture of the boardroom where there isn't a sufficient level of trust, a sufficient level of psychological safety. That's the phrase that Amy Edmondson has made famous, and I think that she's done a great job of that. It's very important that we make it so that everyone in the room feels that they can share their perspectives without fear of being marginalized. or punished in some way for for saying what they were thinking.

5:45Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I mean we live in tough times, you know? It's it's really challenging for a lot of organizations at the moment. The changes going on in terms of technology, with the geopolitical risk, etc. And sometimes when you speak with people about psychological safety, they go, Oh my goodness, we have now really more important things to discuss in psychological safety. But Jim, don't you think in time particularly in times like this, there is so much challenge, so much to consider. It is particularly important and to make time for exactly this to have the right discussions.

6:22Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah. If we don't make time for it, we just go through the motion motions. And

6:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you

6:29Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): know, there are many times that boards have I'm using my fingers to do air quotes, efficient meetings. They go through the agenda, every topic is covered, every compliance is confirmed, but important things don't get said. Important questions don't get get asked. And so we haven't had the full conversation.

6:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

6:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): that comes back to a phrase that I often use, and I think that you will have heard this as well, Sabina, artificial harmony, where it feels like everybody's getting along just fine. But it's only a appearance, appearance of getting along. even appearance of agreement. When a chair s notices that nobody's uh objecting, I would argue, poor leadership to assume that that means we have consensus. What chairs can do, and really anyone could, is is ask, so who sees this differently if there's been two or three comments all along the same theme? theme? Or maybe what might we be missing? See, the objective isn't to win an argument in the boardroom. It's to reach better collective judgment. And we need to be comfort, become comfortable with a bit of discomfort in the conversation, a bit of disagreement. Disagreement doesn't mean there's a breakdown, it just means there's different perspectives that need to be talked through. And that kind of conflict is actually healthy. It requires a level of candor, of

8:16curiosity. And when we've got that happening, oh my goodness, now we can start to have more thorough understanding of the issues and the options. It's not about persuading people, it's about understanding things thoroughly.

8:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Let's talk a little bit. Let's start with the chairs. What can chairs really proactively do in order to ensure that they create an environment in which people can really talk openly?

8:47Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): As we said, this is crucial. Chairs have this space. Let me underscore: every director shares responsibility, but chairs have special responsibility. So they need to be doing things like drawing out the quieter voices and managing the dominant personalities. They also need to resist premature consensus. So that means they have to have the courage to slow things down, to ask questions, to cut people off if they've been saying too much or repeating the same thing as if, you know, if I just say this with more intensity, everybody will agree with me. And chairs Players need to manage all of that. They need to ask good questions. So

9:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what

9:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): haven't we talked about that we still should talk about? Did we have a conversation we needed to have? Like, ask these questions. Again, we we need to resist the pressure to be efficient and insist that we're being effective. So ask good questions. I'm gonna say even participation, but I don't want to let people think I'm saying that means you you need to take your turns, everybody takes their turn, they have an equal say. That's not what I mean at all. I mean we aren't just letting certain people dominate, we aren't letting certain people fade into the background. We're we're engaging all of them.

10:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

10:23Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): chairs can also ask for people to take time to reflect. So, hey, we just got to the end of what was probably the most important topic on our agenda in this meeting. Let's reflect for the next two or three minutes just on how do we all feel about this? Do we feel like we got everything on the table?

10:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Do

10:48Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): we feel like we got heard? You know. just draw those things out and invite people to reflect. And

10:55Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): what do you think can they do in between meetings to create this atmosphere?

11:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): So a really critical part for boards to play is modeling. And I'm going to come back to that idea of psychological safety again. We live in a strange time where there's just constant pressure on leaders to look like they've got it all figured out, they've got it all together, they're confident and certain. And chairs and CEOs especially have that stigma that they have to manage. Sabina, this is why I called my book the Imperfect Board Member, and then my follow-up book, The Imperfect CEO. Because corporate world's pressure is that we show up like we're perfect and nobody's perfect. We can't be perfect. And the best way that leaders like chairs and CEOs can help move the conversation to a better place is to model some. vulnerability. If a chair, in fact, I'll think of an example. I know a chair, a man who is a very accomplished corporate leader,

12:12C suite contributor in a couple of very large Fortune 50 companies in America. And he was on purpose brought to chair a board that had reached a stalemate.

12:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

12:29Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): one of the first things he did was declare: hey, uh, like all of us around the table, I've got a track record with things that I've accomplished, but I I want to lead with this statement. I want to clarify there are some things I'm good at, and there are a whole lot of things that I'm not good at. And I need to get to know each of you better so that I know who I can draw on to cover my weaknesses so that together we are the best board we can be.

13:03Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Super example.

13:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): So that's that's admitting incomplete understanding. That's admitting imperfection. He went on. The next meeting, he actually. led off with an apology. He said, Hey, before we get deep into our conversation, I want to say I'm sorry. Here's something that happened in our last meeting.

13:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

13:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): didn't handle that as well as I should have. I have spoken to Sally and Frank about it in the interim,

13:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and I

13:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): think we got we've it sort of. sorted out, but I want to make it very clear to the full board. I should have done a better job at this. And so he just explained the situation. And what's happening here, Sabina, is that he, his name is Brian, but nobody will know who I'm talking about. Brian was on purpose demonstrating to this room that it's okay. to make mistakes. It's okay to not do everything right, to not have all the answers. You need to expect that that's what's going to happen from me. And you need to know that I'm going to be fine when it happens from you. That just changes the environment so that people can participate with a little bit more confidence that they they're not gonna be made to look foolish or shamed or punished in any way.

14:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): This is completely in line. You know, I worked and supported the leadership programs at Lund Business School for a while. And uh there was a famous leadership professor, Professor Rob Goffy. Goffey. He wrote um an article that got a lot of attention in the Harvard Business Review. The title was Who Wants to Be Led by You? And he he exactly described what you just said, Jim, that it is important to basically also let people into your vulnerabilities. Do not even try to be perfect because nobody is, and certainly at the moment with AI, with geopolitics, etc. there is so much happening where nobody knows what's happening in in a week's time. Yeah. So to pretend this will sooner or later definitely crack. So I think this is a very, very important message.

15:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): It resonates with Sabina because we still have a pervasive impression that being vulnerable

15:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is

15:40Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): weak.

15:40Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Demonstrates weakness and almost demonstrates disqualification. I believe it's the opposite. It takes courage to be a vulnerable.

15:49Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And it shows also confidence. Hey, I'm uh confident enough to admit this because I know my value.

15:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yes.

15:58Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): In other areas where I can contribute. Absolutely.

16:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yes.

16:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And let's say you are not a chair, you are now an contributing director.

16:08Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yes.

16:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): What can you do in this whole mix to make this place safe so that everything can be talked about?

16:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Um again, become more comfortable with my own vulnerability.

16:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um

16:21Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): say, Hey, I've read the pre-meeting material. Here's an example. I I I like to try to make things practical. Sabina, the boards that I'm on, I get brought on because I've had a career focused on governance. So the kind of envelope or category of expertise that I bring is the governance category. I'm rarely a very informed about the context of the business. for the board that I'm on. So I have to learn that. And I will often find myself saying, hey, I know that we're surrounded by people who have a lot more experience in this sector than I will ever have. So correct me if I'm wrong. The impression I'm getting is this. And I'm just trying to frame that I know my limits of expertise. I still have a view, I've got a perspective, a question, or a a suggestion, and I I frame it with that qualification. It's partly so that everyone else realizes, yeah, that they maybe have

17:3640 years of experience in the sector, but not with this company because they were with other companies and they don't know at all either. So vulnerability is big. But changing my focus from only listening to words to watching behavior, this is important for every person around the table. If I see someone lean back in their chair and fold their arms, that is usually an unconscious indicator that something just happened that made them feel uh made them resistant or want to protect themselves. And we shouldn't miss that. So again, anyone around the table, not only the chair, could say. Andrew, it looks like you've got a little bit of discomfort with what we're talking about. I I would love to hear what you're thinking. Those kinds of questions are completely legitimate from anyone around the table, not only from the chair. Indeed, the more that that happens, the more that the dynamic is we're all drawing out the perspectives of each other. as opposed to waiting for

18:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it

18:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): to happen from the chair, the better the board will be. So those are a couple of things that uh jumped to my mind.

19:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, super. And it's really practical because we always like to give our listeners some really practical things they can do differently, or remind them of what they could actually do being in the room. Now, I always like to finish on a positive uh tone. What are signs that things are going in the right direction? So rather than looking at the cracks, but what what what are some encouraging signs where that you can say what you really think This in thing a boardroom? the What should directors look out for?

19:36Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): When there is energetic engagement in the conversation and people are not talking over each other but but eager to contribute their thoughts, then that is a positive. By contrast, when people are more silent, that's a signal that hmm there might be some kind of under under-the-surface the surface problem that isn't uh being dealt with. When people feel and show that they are able to disagree with someone else, and that is a productive exchange. I don't mean just between the two people, but others around the table as well. That's a beautiful dynamic where it's it's the group problem solving together. as opposed to two people debating or arguing with each other. We often think that unanimous and consensus decisions are evidence of a great performing board, but I would argue that uh some energetic disagreement that concludes with a full agreement.

20:51is actually a better indicator of a high performing board. But you've seen some of these too, Sabina. So so jump in. What are what are some things that you look for?

21:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I mean that people talk with each other, not about each other. That people build on what someone else has said. Because I'm also seeing that people simply come prepared, download their questions over or what they have to say. It's like separate conversations in a boardroom.

21:19Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yes.

21:20Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, that they build on each other and develop the arguments of each other. So I very much when I observe boards look for this build up that they really listened, placed their questions, but they listen to each other, they connect the dots that have been shared and bring it also all together. Those that were positive about something and those that were more critical, and they managed that way to resolve the issue. I think that's that's a really important part.

21:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): And I'm just I'm just thinking that as you say that, it would be especially powerful if someone just explained something well and uh I'll be that board member, and I I respond by saying, Thank you for that, Martha. Um, that is very insightful, and I have to admit I hadn't seen it that way. So you've really helped my understanding. Again, we are validating the point that just came forward, we are confirming that we've heard it, and we are exercising some. vulnerability by admitting we just learned something, we need each other and and we're better together.

22:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But

22:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you know, I'm currently sitting in London to all my British friends, British culture, it's not common that people praise each other or give each other actually a pat on the back.

22:47Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah.

22:47Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): It's so important. I encourage people to do this. Sometimes people look at me going, Are you serious? Yes. Do I need to say this? Yes, people feel good about it. Say it. Recognize also the positive things, yeah. Yes. And draw them out. Yeah.

23:05Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yes.

23:05Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Jim, we can talk for hours, but I look at the watch and we have to come to an end. But before we do, there's always this question at the end. What are the three things our listeners should take away from this podcast?

23:19Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Well, uh as I said, I've I've listened to your show, Sabina, so I I knew this was coming. That's

23:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): good.

23:25Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): The first one I would underscore is notice what is not being said.

23:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah.

23:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I underscore silence isn't usually agreement. More often it's a reluctance to express everything that people have on the

23:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): world.

23:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): their mind. What is not being said. Number two, make disagreement safe.

23:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

23:46Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): that's only going to happen when we've purposely built a level of trust and psychological safety in the group around the table. Number three, take responsibility for collective judgment. Let's just underscore governance is not an individual activity. Every director has a responsibility to help the full board think and decide better. So we need to take responsibility for that to happen. It's not enough to say that we made our point with great force, but those fools didn't understand and they didn't go with what I said. That's not collective judgment. That's uh me trying to get my score higher. It's a different thing to figure out how do we work together so that we've got best answers for the company. Yeah. So there you have three.

24:45Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Fantastic, Jim. Thank you so, so much for contributing to the BetterBots podcast series. It's

24:50Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): been a pleasure. I hope that uh we'll we'll stay connected, Sabina.

24:54Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Thank you for listening to another episode of the BetterBots Podcast series. There is no AI in this. It's real people talking with each other about what matters in boardrooms. If you are interested in our work, reach out. You can do so via LinkedIn or the email info at betterheifenboard. betterHenboards. So if you would like to see what we do, how we work with boards, if you have an idea about a podcast topic you would like to see covered, if you would like to come and contribute, we are always here to listen. Thank

25:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you.

This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights