Charity Pulse discusses trustee recruitment, AI governance, and sector consolidation
Summary
The episode covers trustee recruitment strategies, with speakers noting that only 6% of trustees found roles via adverts and urging broader community outreach. Panelists debate the role of AI in governance, dismissing fears of 'zombie boards' while acknowledging its utility for administrative tasks. The discussion also addresses employer support for volunteering, with arguments against mandatory leave, and the future of charity infrastructure bodies, citing data on potential consolidation. Finally, the panel touches on the independence of charities versus state service provision, particularly regarding hospice funding models.
Key takeaways
- 1 Yeah. And the comment was made um only six 6% percent reported that uh as trustees that they had applied for their role via an advert.
Catherine Rostonggi · 3:30
Episode sections
- 0:27 – 1:07
Microsoft Global Outage and Sector Resilience
Catherine Rostonggi notes a global Microsoft outage on Friday, November 13, highlighting concerns about over-reliance on single providers for critical communications like email and Teams. She frames this as a broader question of sector resilience and risk management for charities.
- 1:07 – 6:22
Trustee Recruitment and Diversity
The panel discusses Charity Commission Chair Julia Unwin's call for charities to advertise trustee roles more broadly in communities rather than relying on closed networks or headhunters. James Saunders and Charles Mosquita debate the balance between formal, fair processes and the voluntary nature of trusteeship, noting that only 6% of trustees found their role via an advert.
- 6:22 – 9:33
Employer Support for Volunteering
Catherine raises Julia Unwin's comment that businesses and civil service often do not grant leave for trustee duties. James Saunders argues against making volunteering leave mandatory, citing potential abuse and the importance of individual goodwill, while Charles Mosquita suggests government encouragement could highlight wellbeing benefits for employers.
- 9:33 – 14:37
Board Meeting Formats and Youth Engagement
The discussion touches on Christopher Dayson's view that formal board meetings deter younger people. Charles Mosquita shares his experience of flipping board meetings to focus on strategic conversations rather than formulaic reporting, and references Charity Path's efforts to connect financial professionals with charities to overcome young people's self-doubt about their qualifications.
- 14:37 – 16:06
AI and the 'Zombie Board' Myth
Catherine introduces the concept of a 'zombie board' where AI replaces trustee decision-making. Both Charles Mosquita and James Saunders dismiss this as unrealistic, viewing AI merely as a tool for content or meeting management rather than a substitute for human governance and legal responsibility.
- 16:06 – 18:02
Charity Independence and Hospice Funding
James Saunders highlights Julia Unwin's concern about charities becoming state service providers rather than independent bodies. The panel discusses the funding model for hospices, with Charles Mosquita arguing that public funding provides greater autonomy than government funding, which could lead to less favorable outcomes.
- 18:02 – 24:45
Infrastructure Bodies and Consolidation
The panel addresses the future of charity infrastructure bodies, citing a 360 Giving statistic of 700–750 such organizations. Charles Mosquita suggests mergers (e.g., AkiVO with CFG) might make sense for efficiency, while James Saunders warns that bodies that 'speak truth to power' may struggle with funding and popularity compared to those that support the status quo.
Claims worth verifying
Julia Unwin, Chair of the Charity Commission, urged charities to advertise trustee roles closer to communities and stated she is 'tired of people saying it is expensive to advertise' because LinkedIn is now a professional advertising platform.
Catherine Rostonggi ·1:27
How to verify: Search for Julia Unwin's speech transcripts or Charity Commission press releases from November 2026 regarding trustee recruitment guidance. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify the 6% trustee recruitment statistic cited by Catherine Rostonggi against Charity Commission or sector-wide surveys.
- Check the current membership and merger status of AkiVO and CFG to assess infrastructure consolidation trends.
- Review 360 Giving's latest data on the number and funding of local vs. national infrastructure bodies.
- Investigate Charity Path's current programs and success metrics for placing financial professionals in charities.
- Look for recent Charity Commission guidance on trustee diversity and recruitment best practices.
- Examine case studies of hospice funding models to compare public vs. government funding autonomy.
- Search for employer policies on volunteering leave to assess the prevalence of mandatory vs. goodwill approaches.
Full transcriptexpand
0:07Catherine Rostonggi: Hello everyone and welcome to the latest edition of Charity Pulse. My name is Catherine Rostonggi. I'm a charity's partner at Shakespeare Martineau and I'm joined today by my regular co-host Charles Mosquita, Charity's Investment Director at Quilts Quilterchieviate Achieviate, and James Saunders, Charity Audit Partner at Moor Moore Kingston Smith. I almost feel like it sounds a little bit echoey, and I feel like I'm the last person on the planet because today is Friday, the 13th of November. We have a global outage from Microsoft. So no emails pinging, no Teams messages. We are cut off. Some might say this is bliss. I've seen a lot of posts about this is an adult snow day where you can go out and play and do whatever you want rather. than be stuck and glued to your emails. Um but I suppose there is a bigger picture question, isn't there, about whether this is an over-reliance on one provider and you know perhaps thinking of our charity clients um and others in the sector and how they're coping with challenges like this. Um so something to think about, I suppose, as we're talking about the latest stories um that have been reported. about the sector this week. So the first story I was going to come to was the Chief Executive, sorry, the Chair of the Charity Commission, Julia Unwin, spoke at
1:27an event this week and urged charities to find ways of advertising for trustee roles closer to the communities in which they're working. She gave specific comments saying, I'm very tired of people saying it's expensive to advertise. LinkedIn is now a place where professionals advertise. I think we need to find other ways of doing it in communities and different places. Interesting comments. James, I'll come to you first. Whether you think LinkedIn is the place, as I suppose well as just one comment, but also whether advertising in general is something that charities are not doing and should do more of?
2:09James Saunders: Um I think LinkedIn could be a place. I think the the wider you can spread your uh your applications, if you like, or your vacancies, the better. Um I I think there is often a bit of a tendency to think that using headhunters, for example, for chair of trustees roles is fulfilling your duty to run a professional and even an appropriate process.
2:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
2:43James Saunders: of course, that costs money. Um
2:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
2:48James Saunders: it's a bit of a mixed bag, really. I I I I can't help feeling that most charities are in a position where they could be accused of not running the right process if a party who you know wasn't successful didn't get what they wanted. Whether that was because it was too closed, whether that was because it wasn't open to the right sectors. whether it was, you know, there was premeditation, whether it was whispering in people's ears, all that sort of thing. You know, there's there is it's very difficult to see how you can satisfy all people at all times.
3:30Catherine Rostonggi: Yeah. And the comment was made um only six 6% percent reported that uh as trustees that they had applied for their role via an advert. Um, and then the article does go on to comment about uh diversity on charity boards and how we should reflect that in terms of it not only being a tick box exercise. Um, Charles, any thoughts from you about diversification and and widening the pool of how we get more people volunteering as trustees?
4:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
4:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I mean I I get really worried. about this because uh I and I can't remember what the stats are, but there is a h very high proportion of charities that have a vacancy of at least one on their board. So, you know, I think and and the one thing that I hear from a lot of people is how difficult it is to find trustees. So you know, I don't think there's any golden bullet in this. I I mean, you know, in in the organizations I've been involved with, we've done some of it for advert uh through advertising. uh, some of it by uh, you know, um meeting somebody who's suitable and inviting them onto the board. I don't think there's any right and some with using actually headhunters. I think I think you just got to be very specific about what you're looking for. With the using a headhunter, actually, we wanted somebody with a with a finance background who could chair the finance committee. And actually, we ended up with somebody who was absolutely exceptional. The bit that I think we need to be really careful with is this is not a job interview. Um, and therefore the way that we handle this should not be in that sort of process, and in my mind, should not be uh formulaic because you know, I I don't know about you, Catherine, or you, James, but I would not apply uh if I felt it was Is going to be that formulaic. I want to get involved with it because I want to volunteer uh and everything else. I'm very happy to. go and have a chat. I'm very happy to be part of a pool. And if I'm not the right person, then that's fine. But let's be very
5:21careful in the respect and remember that everybody who is a trustee, or most people, are volunteers and giving up their time freely. And the other thing I just don't think we spend enough time on is actually telling people about how wonderful it is, how beneficial it is. I know my from a from a career on a personal basis, I have benefited massively from my various roles on on boards that I've been involved with.
5:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): There
5:47James Saunders: is, Charles, isn't that there there is a danger that you conflate um formulaic or you you you confuse formulaic with fairness and you say we've got to have a formulaic formulae process to make sure that we're utterly fair. in how we deal with everyone. It's a very easy step to make, you know. Um we want to make this process fair to everyone. Here you go, there's a m online portal that you up you everyone answers the same questions to, everyone's in the same boat. But that is that is formulaic, isn't
6:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it?
6:21Catherine Rostonggi: Yeah.
6:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It
6:22Catherine Rostonggi: is an interesting point. And uh another comment that um Julia Unwin mentioned was that it was shocking that the civil service local government, and the bit I query, she says, and most businesses, and I just query whether it is most, did not give leave for trustee duties such as meetings. Um whereas I would hear of that regularly, that employers do give, for instance, one day a year, two days a year, three days a year for volunteering. and that people can use that in whatever way they want to. And then following on from that, she also says that she doesn't think we do enough to explain why governance is good for people's careers, which is something I think we've talked about before in terms of what we learn from being trustees and how it is a two-way um issue. But I suppose, yeah, looking at the barriers to time commitment and and when meetings take place.
7:17James Saunders: So the the the the latter point, absolutely. Um uh the the former point which was the one about shocking that businesses and the civil service don't give time, I agree, uh Catherine. I think that an awful lot of businesses will do it. But I also don't think it should be down to businesses to do it. I think it's goodwill of businesses business or all the other list of employers. You know, it's a good thing to do for a business. But it shouldn't be compulsor. I don't think it should be compulsory because I otherwise, I mean, firstly, I I I'm I'm sure there would be some some abuse of it. But more importantly, it should be I think it should be down to the individual to want to do it and and the and the employer to say absolutely it's what we encourage you to do, not for the employer to go, here's some time, go and do anything you want with it. It just doesn't work that way. It shouldn't work that way around to me. If a business is struggling, I I I don't really see that it is incumbent upon that business, that employer, to then say,
8:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
8:19James Saunders: know, employers can have even it can have more time off than than we have to give them. It will be a nice to have, and I think in times, let's put it this way. I think I think if a business is doing well, they will probably be more open to doing it. Whoever that business is. I mean but for the vast majority of regular employers, I I think that you know they're gonna draw pull the drawbridge up in times of strife, understandably. Um But uh
8:45Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I but I think but uh the problem is I think that if if you don't and this probably does have to come from from government is setting the tone of what we should expect and also actually I think that the the benefits because there are I know studies out there that show that those that volunteer actually from a wellbeing point of view and everything else uh have a much better and c positive contribution towards businesses. And I think businesses don't necessarily think about it, so therefore being encouraged to do so is a good thing. I I fully accept that you could you you don't really want to make it hard and fast because if if a business is struggling uh and they can't truly afford it,
9:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
9:25Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): then um
9:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
9:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): then obviously uh th they should have the latitude to do that.
9:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, I
9:33Catherine Rostonggi: thought there was an interesting comment about meetings as well. I mean there are two points actually. There was um Christopher Dayson, Dyson, who's directed director of the Centre for Charity Effectiveness at Bayes Business School, said that formal board meetings put off some people, especially the young. And then he went on to say some people don't want to sit around a square table or a square zoom meeting,
9:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): which
9:53Catherine Rostonggi: made me think, what about an oval table then, or a round table, or a different is it the shape? Why is it we're focusing on square? But also his comment was they have found that people do want to be involved, but want to be involved in a different way and through a different format. But when I hear that, I think, well, then not as a charity trustee.
10:11James Saunders: Exactly.
10:11Catherine Rostonggi: Because as a charity trustee, it's warts and all. You have full legal duties and responsibilities. You can't just be saying, I don't want to come to meetings because I don't really like them.
10:20Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): However, however, I do think that uh that board meetings can become quite turgid, particularly in if people are just going through the formulaic process. I mean, I have to say, where I chair it where I chair one board and about to chair another, I've actually flipped it on its head. So when I talk to uh the chief executive before the board meeting, you know, two or three days before, we try and identify two or three things that we want to really discuss. You put them up front and center, and then come back. And that actually has created a much different app, at more different atmosphere within the board meetings. And I've noticed that people want to come to them because they are having what I call a real conversation about the long-term strategy. So I do think that's changed. Just on younger people, um, Catherine, you and I were up at um a fantastic uh charity conference in Leeds uh earlier this week, were we not? Their lead uh keynote speaker, uh Laura Walker. from Charity
11:18Catherine Rostonggi: Path, yes.
11:19Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Charity Path, which is
11:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
11:20Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): fascinating organization where effectively what what they're doing is uh trying to connect uh um financial professionals into into charities. But the beginning of the story I thought was really interesting where they'd the person who had started it up where she was delivering I think food and everything else was a um somebody who'd newly qualified at PWCs, but where where she was really enthusiastic, energy, and energetic, everything else. And the finance director had turned around to her and said, Would you like to become a trustee of the of the organization she was okay? And she didn't feel that she was qualified or had enough to contribute, which was clearly absolutely the wrong thing. And I I think how I think it'd be quite interesting to think about how can we we change that. persp perspective for younger people. Because I suspect that is, I certainly, when I, you know, two or three years into my career, would uh wouldn't have thought in any thing that I was qualified to sit on a trustee board.
12:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
12:15Catherine Rostonggi: I thought it was interesting. I thought of you actually, James, the particular comment was about imagining people with financial skills, if they could volunteer an hour a month uh two hours to be on a subcommittee or to help a charity be better organised almost, or be able to analyse figures and just thinking about how you apply your knowledge rather than having to come all in and do everything.
12:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It's
12:42James Saunders: an odd one, really. I mean, I think I've mentioned before, we've done um my firm's done volunteering over the the years and we've done volunteering days, and we've gone out and painted fences and painted walls and and it's and it's it's good fun and it's you and it is useful to uh um the other parties. But I wonder if they are really getting the best out of, you know, a firm of accountants offering them some volunteering time. And whether it I whether it could be there could be a cleverer way of doing it. And um and and and contributing more than what you know what frankly anyone could do, anyone could paint uh a wall or or or do a bit of decorating. I mean you know I suppose that it is it's as much us saying is there anything you want us to do or yeah we'd quite like to do something useful but it it's definitely there's definitely scope for um for more targeted and useful skills to be put to good use, I think, from volunteers.
13:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
13:43Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I think there are different things here, aren't there? So you've got um where when you're going off and painting a wall or whatever it may be, you can have a team uh sort of slightly bonding session of doing something as a team for volunteering if you've got a group
13:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of
13:55Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): you working together, versus and and I think that's the point, isn't it, with this with this lady who'd uh been two years qualified that I actually it was the FD who turned around and said, actually, yes, you have got a lot to offer. Um, and just needed to get over that sort of apprehension, apprehension hurdle such that she wasn't wasn't qualified to sit on that board.
14:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
14:18Catherine Rostonggi: isn't that interesting though, that there's tap on the shoulder trustee recruitment that we're told is never a good thing, and that that's not how you get diversification, particularly on young people as well. And I think sometimes that is more of a model. Um, and the final point that came up, I was intrigued by this um reference to charities being at risk of having a zombie board, which I had never heard of. Um, so a zombie board, the thought being that the use of AI in particular replaces the input of charity trustees and that they're not. having discussions and they're not making decisions anymore because they are just letting AI do it. I couldn't picture that at all for any of the boards I sit on or any of the charities I work with, actually. But I suppose there is a piece there around the use of AI. And maybe Charles, as your kind of chair of trustees, are you thinking of having a zombie board or getting AI to sit around your round table?
15:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): No, I yeah, I read this as well. I was just sort of slightly um bemused by the comment because I just don't see how how I is ever going to uh turn your your board into a into a uh uh of effectively not making any decisions because I've never met a group of people getting together who's just gonna say, Oh, we'll just get onto AI and ask them that question. So yeah, it's a tool, not a thing. So I was sort of slightly surprised and not really quite sure where that came, came, where that was coming from.
15:45Catherine Rostonggi: Yeah, use of AI, James, are you feeling it breathing down?
15:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I think
15:48Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): I think it's just more about the the content or the the the meeting that's being run than than than anything else. I mean if you've if you've got content and meetings that can be replaced by AI, then you're not running the right meetings in the first place, are you?
16:02Catherine Rostonggi: Yeah. Getting the best out of people.
16:05James Saunders: Yeah.
16:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Catherine, one of the things I thought in that article was which wasn't actually to do with trustees, but I thought was quite interesting is that Julia Unwin um has certainly put a marker in the sand about the independence of the regulator from government and also uh she commented on uh charities um over the last twenty five to thirty years. um becoming sort of providers of service of the state, which I thought was and and um rather than independent bodies. So I thought that was something that people should be aware of.
16:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
16:40Catherine Rostonggi: I suppose there it immediately makes me think of the hospice movement and say, Well, what is that if not delivering services that the state should be providing and and they should be fully funded for? So I think it's it's tricky there, isn't it, to say, well, are they being fully funded? Is that a question of independence? Or is that a question of exploiting by the state? Um
17:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): I think the answer quite clearly is no. There's a just this morning, uh you said with it's the Friday the thirteenth today, news this morning of another hospice um struggling about to lay people off, perhaps closing, you know, and and that that unfortunately is a weekly event in that sector.
17:19Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I mean, I I mean we could debate about how much funding should come from government to NHS hospital hospices, and it varies across the the country. So there's there doesn't seem to be any particular consistency there. Uh and if you're children's hospices, you're getting even less. But actually having a reasonable amount of uh majority of their fund. funding coming from the general public gives them incredible autonomy about how they go about looking after their beneficiaries. Um, and I think we should be very careful about wanting the whole lot to be funded by government because I suspect we'll end up with something that we that is not as good as what we've got at the moment.
18:00Catherine Rostonggi: Interesting.
18:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay, so
18:02Catherine Rostonggi: I'm moving us on, chaps, to another article we'd seen recently. And this, I suppose, the theme being: what is the role of umbrella bodies in the charity sector? Perhaps are there too many? Is there duplication? Um, and this was referenced in an article by Deborah Alcock Tyler, um, chief executive of the Directory of Social Change, that has recently announced its closing. And it was linking that there's an infrastructure review that will be put underway. And the article headline was that this review should not confuse closure with failure. And then going on to say, you know, is there a suggestion that a Kivo, for instance, should merge with NCVO, other environments? umbrella bodies in the sector? Should they merge? Is that the answer? Um,
18:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): so
18:55Catherine Rostonggi: I suppose coming to you first, Charles, any thoughts on the umbrella bodies generally in the sector and how they work?
19:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
19:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I have to say I did Google about how many umbrella bodies or infrastructure bodies there were. Um, and 360 give giving gave a number of 700 to 750, which slightly surprised me that there was. were as many as that. Um, and that for the split between local and national, it's 519 local, 180 uh national. Hopefully that adds up to sort of around about that number. Uh I think this is a really difficult one, isn't it? In the respect that generally the problem that um these infrastructure bodies have is is around finding suitable funding, uh, but actually yes, they do provide uh invaluable um I I think uh support for individual charities. But I but the problem is I don't think charities are necessarily willing to pay for that support. So you have got a real conundrum. So for the charity commission to come and say we need to have a look at it, um I suspect mergers will probably be part of that process. I didn't know actually ever think that Akivo should have should um merge with NCVO. I thought it would be much more sensible to actually merge with uh CFG, although I suspect neither organization will appreciate me saying that, but having one for senior management does make sense. Um, but there are some very successful, I mean,
20:21we've just been talking about hospices, they've got a very successful umbrella body, um, of which I think is. a useful conduit for
20:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): them.
20:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Uh so I I I I think it's good to have the review. I think Deborah is right in the respect that this this this shouldn't be about failure. This should be actually what is it that we want and how we're gonna fund it.
20:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
20:41Catherine Rostonggi: James, any thoughts on infrastructure?
20:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, it's
20:44Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): obviously a a a hot topic, this infrastructure at the moment, isn't it? Um one of my colleagues uh I work with um
20:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
20:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): consultant with uh Morkinson Smith, Alex Evans, wrote an article
20:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um uh
20:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): a few days uh
20:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
20:59Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): um prior to Deborah's post, I think, about you know i infrastructure. And I I think what he says is infrastructure uh sometimes feels as though it's made in the image, uh quoting here, made in the image of those who pay for charity work, not those who deliver it. which was I thought was an interesting point, and quite who
21:17James Saunders: infrastructure works for. In terms of the infrastructure bodies, yeah, I mean again, uh the Alex talks about um quite often unfortunately it seems that the the the
21:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
21:31James Saunders: the infrastructure bodies that get lost are those that are most uh h his phrasing I think is the most likely to speak truth to power. So those that are very vocal tend to find themselves, unfortunately, less successful in terms of support and and maybe fundraising. And that's perhaps because they make themselves unpopular. But um
21:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that
21:53James Saunders: that's I suppose that's the kind of the argument. Whereas those that go along with the status quo and are a bit less vocal seem to get along a bit better. Now, whether that's quite accurate or not, I don't I don't really know. But I can see that that would be a threat when we're talking about independence and the whole infrastructure and the support uh organizations that that that exist.
22:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
22:15Catherine Rostonggi: it's a good point, isn't it? I think referencing that previous point about whether charities are risking their independence, because I I I would agree entirely. I think sometimes the messaging is is painful for those on the receiving end of it. But I agree. If that's a popularity contest, you know, where are some of these infrastructure infrastructure bodies going to get their funding from?
22:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um it
22:35Catherine Rostonggi: it's always interesting, I think, isn't it, when these reviews come around in terms of what the remit is, what are they considering, who are they talking to?
22:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
22:45Catherine Rostonggi: yeah, maybe more to follow on this one.
22:47James Saunders: And when the whole wider sector has funding problems. it might there be a
22:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): an
22:55James Saunders: uh an an upset, if you like. Um,
22:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
22:57James Saunders: know, uh might it be uh there be um grudges held against money being diverted to infrastructure organisations rather than delivery organisations. I mean that you know, that there is always that threat very and and it's only ever heightened by a lack of or a decrease in funding, which of course we're in right now.
23:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I I think it would also be quite interesting to know what the uh what the role of the charity commission is, because obviously they produce a lot of guidance and everything else, of which how much of that is being duplicated by umbrella bodies. Because part of, you know, if you look at these umbrella bodies, part of it is they sort of give up the the sort of educational and training, and then part of it is actually advocacy, isn't it? it? Um, and I'm not sure how clear, you know. So if you went to a CFG member or an Akibo member or whatever and asked them specifically what the organization had done, would they be able to articulate that? I don't know the answer to
23:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.
23:53Catherine Rostonggi: Yeah, it's interesting. I thought it was a good final point in Deborah's article. She says um, perhaps we should ask what kind of charitable sector we're creating if we allow the organisation. organizations that help everyone else survive to disappear. Umber note to finish on, but I'll try not to leave us in doom and gloom on Friday the 13th. Do do do do. But um thank you for joining us today. We've had an interesting discussion. Do feel free to disagree agree with us firmly, strongly, passionately if you wish, or to agree entirely, which we like each
24:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): other.
24:27Catherine Rostonggi: even more. And feel free to like and follow and share this podcast with others that you think might find it useful. Thank you for joining us and we hope you'll tune in for another session in the future.