Speakers analyze UPI's new 40-basis-point MDR, discussing cost recovery, ecosystem economics, and sectoral impacts.
Summary
Host and guests Naveen Chaluwadi, Tanya Naik, and Mohit discuss the September 15 introduction of a 40-basis-point Merchant Discount Rate (MDR) on UPI transactions. Chaluwadi and Naik argue the fee is necessary to cover infrastructure costs incurred by banks and fintechs after a decade of zero MDR, noting that fintechs require this revenue to sustain operations without bank balance sheets. Mohit critiques the flat percentage fee as inefficient for capital markets, where account-to-account transfers resemble P2P payments and brokers previously offered free equity delivery. The speakers predict that large merchants will negotiate lower effective rates, while smaller merchants may face friction or push customers toward cash. Success is defined by the ecosystem reaching profitability equilibrium and expanding financial inclusion to the remaining 40-45% of the Indian population.
Key takeaways
- 1 For capital markets, a 40-basis-point fee on a ₹5 lakh transfer equals ₹100, a significant cost for brokers who previously offered free equity delivery, creating a sustainability challenge for their business models.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) · 6:03
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 4:05
Introduction and Guest Backgrounds
Host introduces guests Naveen Chaluwadi, Chief Digital Officer at Yes Bank, and Tanya Naik, Head of Online and Omnichannel Business at Pine Labs. The discussion is triggered by the MDR rule introduced on 15 September on UPI.
- 4:05 – 5:23
Industry Reaction to MDR Announcement
Naveen Chaluwadi expresses relief that UPI is finally generating revenue after a decade of zero MDR. Tanya Naik notes that while the announcement was expected, the 40-basis-point rate was better than anticipated, providing much-needed ROI for fintechs that lack bank balance sheets.
- 5:23 – 7:27
Capital Markets Perspective on MDR
Mohit from Zerodha explains that the 40-basis-point fee is a significant cost increase for stockbrokers compared to the previous zero fee. He highlights the contention that capital market transactions (like buying stocks) do not consume the same value as retail purchases, making the percentage-based fee burdensome for brokers offering free equity delivery.
- 7:27 – 16:57
Bank's Role in UPI Ecosystem
Naveen Chaluwadi outlines the bank's role as an issuer/remitter bank, incurring costs for switching fees to NPCI, PSP fees to app banks, and interchange fees to beneficiary banks for real-time fund availability. He notes that while banks bear these costs, P2P transactions remain free for consumers.
- 16:57 – 23:06
Five Key Players in a UPI Transaction
Tanya Naik details the five-party architecture: 1) Payer's Bank (Issuer), 2) Payer's PSP Bank (Switch/Compliance), 3) TPAP/App (Customer Experience/Acquisition), 4) Merchant's Bank (Acquirer/Settlement), and 5) Payment Aggregator (Merchant KYC/Onboarding). She explains the split of the 40-basis-point fee among these entities.
- 23:06 – 25:37
Switch Costs and Infrastructure
Tanya Naik defines switch costs as the infrastructure connecting merchants to banks and NPCI, enabling transaction confirmation and dispute management. Naveen Chaluwadi adds that NPCI operates a central switch, and costs are incurred across issuer, consumer, merchant, and NPCI switches.
- 25:37 – 33:43
Economics and Right MDR Level
The speakers discuss the historical context of MDR, comparing UPI to credit/debit cards. Naveen Chaluwadi estimates the ecosystem's annual investment at 10,000-12,000 crores, suggesting the new MDR revenue pool will match these costs. He argues that UPI's high transaction frequency (50+ times per week for users) breaks legacy core banking assumptions designed for ~50 transactions per year.
- 33:43 – 38:16
Pricing Adequacy and Merchant Negotiation Dynamics
Tanya Naik argues that while UPI MDR is cheaper than debit cards, the 40-basis-point fee may not cover infrastructure costs for the 96% of transactions previously free. She predicts large enterprise merchants will negotiate lower effective rates by leveraging the 28 basis points available to banks acting as both issuer and acquirer.
- 38:16 – 41:13
Capital Markets Perspective on MDR Structure
Mohit Yan (speaker_1) critiques the MDR model as an inefficient, card-network-inherited construct unsuitable for capital markets, where account-to-account transfers resemble P2P payments. He argues that commercial arrangements should be negotiated directly rather than imposed via a flat percentage fee.
- 41:13 – 43:20
Sectoral Margin Variance and MCC Codes
Tanya Naik highlights that pricing should reflect industry margins, noting that a broker's margin is significantly lower than a jeweler's or insurer's. She questions whether Merchant Category Code (MCC) assignments will be applied correctly to prevent misuse or evasion.
- 43:20 – 48:56
Historical Context and Ecosystem Maturity
Naveen Chaluwadi explains that UPI's growth was fueled by demonetization and COVID-era zero-MDR policies, creating a habit of free usage. He suggests that the ecosystem is now mature enough to transition to a cost-recovery model, though consumer acceptance of paying for banking services remains a hurdle.
- 48:56 – 56:55
Merchant Behavior and Friction Points
The speakers discuss the hypothetical scenario of merchants rejecting UPI. Naveen Chaluwadi predicts minimal impact on small offline merchants but significant friction for mid-level merchants who may split bills or push customers to cash. Tanya Naik anticipates backlash in high-ticket offline segments like electronics and petroleum.
- 56:55 – 1:00:24
Success Metrics for the MDR Experiment
Naveen Chaluwadi defines success as the ecosystem reaching an equilibrium where participants feel fairly remunerated, even if perfect merit-based pricing is not achieved within 5-10 years. Tanya Naik adds indicators such as the cessation of subsidy requests, absence of bill-splitting evasion, and maintained or improved service standards.
- 1:00:24 – 1:04:34
Long-Term Ecosystem Evolution and Financial Inclusion
Mohit Yan views UPI as a massive success that will adapt to MDR changes without failing. Naveen Chaluwadi notes that only 55-60 crore Indians have used UPI, suggesting that the new revenue model could incentivize new players to onboard the remaining population, potentially increasing coverage to 60-75% in five years.
Claims worth verifying
MDR rule was introduced on 15 September on UPI.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·0:39
How to verify: NPCI circulars and press releases from September 2026 (contextual date correction: transcript says 2026 but refers to historical 2026 event; verify via NPCI archives for 'MDR on UPI circular September 2026'). For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Yes Bank was at the forefront of UPI innovation starting in 2016.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·0:20
How to verify: Yes Bank annual reports or press releases from 2016-2026 regarding UPI launch partnerships. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The MDR rate is 40 basis points.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·5:17
How to verify: NPCI circular regarding MDR on UPI transactions (September 2026). For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Capital markets MDR was previously 2 basis points (0.02%).
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·5:43
How to verify: Zerodha investor presentations or regulatory filings detailing transaction fee structures pre-2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceA ₹5 lakh transfer at 2 bips costs ₹100.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·6:03
How to verify: Calculation: 500,000 * 0.0002 = 100. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
There are 25 billion UPI transactions, with one-third being P2P.
Naveen Chaluwadi ·9:46
How to verify: NPCI monthly transaction statistics for the relevant period (contextual: likely 2026 data given the MDR announcement reference). For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
UPI ecosystem has a five-party architecture: Payer Bank, Payer PSP Bank, TPAP, Merchant Bank, Payment Aggregator.
Tanya Naik ·16:57
How to verify: NPCI UPI participant guidelines and ecosystem documentation. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Fee split for ₹1,000 transaction: ₹16 to Issuer Bank, ₹4 to Payer PSP Bank, ₹8 to TPAP, ₹12 to PA/Acquirer.
Tanya Naik ·20:35
How to verify: NPCI MDR distribution guidelines and industry analysis of fee splits post-September 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Credit card MDR was historically 1.6% to 2%.
Naveen Chaluwadi ·28:54
How to verify: RBI guidelines on interchange fees for credit cards (historical data pre-2026). For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Debit card MDR is 90 bps for transactions over ₹2,000 and 40 bps for transactions under ₹2,000.
Naveen Chaluwadi ·29:34
How to verify: RBI guidelines on interchange fees for debit cards (historical data pre-2026). For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Debit card MDR is capped at 0.9%, while credit card MDR ranges between 1.5% and 2.5%.
Tanya Naik ·33:43
How to verify: Check RBI Master Directions on Debit Card Charges and Credit Card Charges for the relevant period. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
96% of UPI transactions are below Rs 2000 and were previously free of cost.
Tanya Naik ·34:43
How to verify: Review NPCI transaction volume reports or RBI Payment Systems Reports for transaction size distribution. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Banks acting as both issuer and acquirer have 28 basis points to negotiate, while pure acquirers have 12 basis points.
Tanya Naik ·36:02
How to verify: Analyze the RBI's MDR framework document which splits the fee between issuer, acquirer, and switch. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Only 55 to 60 crore Indians have tried UPI at least once.
Naveen Chaluwadi ·1:03:42
How to verify: Check NPCI (National Payments Corporation of India) user base data or RBI Payment Systems Report. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
RBI imposes higher risk weights on online accessible funds compared to physical FDs.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·42:42
How to verify: Review RBI's Prudential Norms on Income Recognition, Asset Classification and Provisioning for Online Deposits. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
UPI was launched in 2016, followed by demonetization and a zero MDR announcement in 2020.
Naveen Chaluwadi ·44:00
How to verify: Verify UPI launch date via NPCI history and the 2026 zero MDR announcement via Ministry of Finance or RBI press releases. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The ecosystem spends approximately 10,000 to 12,000 crores on UPI transactions.
Naveen Chaluwadi ·45:19
How to verify: Estimate using NPCI transaction volume data multiplied by the average MDR/interchange rates. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Credit card transactions on UPI rails are paid for by merchants.
Naveen Chaluwadi ·52:05
How to verify: Check RBI guidelines on Credit Card payments via UPI which typically prohibit merchants from charging MDR on credit card UPI transactions. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Petroleum sector saw surcharges during the 2016 demonetization period.
Tanya Naik ·53:43
How to verify: Review news archives or government notifications regarding fuel price adjustments during November 2016. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Out of 1.4 billion Indians, only 55-60 crore have used UPI, leaving room for 60-75% coverage growth.
Naveen Chaluwadi ·1:03:42
How to verify: Compare NPCI active user data against India's population estimates from the Census or World Bank. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify NPCI's official fee structure and MDR allocation rules for the 40-basis-point rate.
- Check Yes Bank's and Pine Labs' latest quarterly filings for revenue impact from UPI MDR.
- Review Zerodha's or other major brokerages' disclosures regarding cost absorption or fee changes for equity delivery.
- Analyze RBI reports on UPI transaction volumes, specifically P2P vs. P2M splits and average ticket sizes.
- Investigate Merchant Category Code (MCC) assignment guidelines for financial services and retail sectors.
- Compare UPI MDR costs against traditional debit/credit card interchange fees for different merchant types.
- Assess NPCI's infrastructure investment reports to validate claims about annual ecosystem costs (₹10,000-12,000 crores).
- Monitor merchant acceptance rates and consumer behavior data for bill-splitting or cash migration post-MDR implementation.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Hello everyone, welcome back to another episode of Subtext. Today I am hosting this conversation with my colleague Mohit. We are hosting two folks in the industry, and what we're talking about is MDR on UPI. The first guest is Mr. Naveen, who's the chief digital officer at Yes Bank. Yes Bank has been one of the most innovative banks when it comes to payment solutions. Back in 2016, when UPS UPI started, from whatever anecdotes I have heard, Yes Bank was at the forefront on a lot. of these things. So I was really excited to host him. He has been at the bank for over a decade and been in the space for over two. The next guest is Ms. Tanya, who currently heads the online and omnichannel business for Mindlands. And she's been in the industry for over 18 years talking about payments. This conversation was triggered by the MDR rule that was introduced on 15 15th September. on UPA. And we've been meaning to talk about it a lot. And Mohit was kind enough to connect me with these two industry stalwarts. And here I have Mohit, who will explain what he does at Zirulha.
1:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
1:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I come from a traditional stockbroking background. Sandhi's been doing this for like three generations before me. So I'm the fourth one. My primary responsibility is around primary markets and IPOs, but payments have been something. I've been curious about. Uh been doing that also on the side. When it comes to MDR and how UPS worked and how it fits into the capital markets, that's probably some flavor that I'll bring in.
1:26Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): That said, here is our conversation with them.
1:28Naveen Chaluwadi: Good morning. Uh I am Naveen Chaluwadi, Chief Digital Officer at ES Bank. I take care of all the digital properties at A ES S Bank in terms of retail consumer consumer-facing facing applications, retail customers. customer journeys. And apart from that, at AS Bank, we have also been very keenly observing the emergence of payment space in India. So we have also had a privilege of understanding this place very closely and contributing to this space in terms of running a complete digital payments practice where we had the privilege of working with a lot of fintechs, large merchants, ecosystem players, and drive whatever is getting developed. uh with, say, uh Rupe, NPCI, Visa, MasterCard. How do we make sure that all these innovations are contextualized in our society and uh our consumers actually benefit, irrespective of whether they bank with us or not? That has been probably keeping us uh motivated, busy, and excited to keep going on a day-to-day basis. That's about me.
2:23Tanya Naik: Yeah, hi. Uh, I'm Tanya Naik. I lead the online and omnichannel business at Pine Labs. So put it very simply, everything which is non-POS is what I do. I've been actually in payments for as long as I can remember. So uh been a banker with City and then with PayPal and now with Pine Labs. So it's been almost about 18 years in just banking and payments. So the UPI topic and uh write from UPI, whether it was cards and NEFT and cash pickup. and check pickup and delivery, etc. etc., been there, seen it. So this is one more, I would say, you know, milestone in India's digital payments journey. And I'm uh as always super excited to see what happens next. Of course, uh on alongside it, I'm very happy to actually uh be in this panel with Naveen because yes, bank has been such an important proponent of what digital payments is today. given their early access into the whole UPI journey itself. So uh yeah, I'm very excited to talk about uh everything UPI in this podcast. And thank you for having me.
3:24Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): For context, I started my career in Phone Pay, and that really got me fascinated by the payments ecosystem. But I'll be honest, I never really understood as a 21-year-old trying to figure out okay how UPI works. It sounds very simple, but it isn't really. Ever since then, now I've I'm at Zaroda, still trying to understand the nuances of how it works. Privilege to talk to folks at Yes Bank and Pine Labs. That context said, I I want to break the ice by asking a very simple question. 15th September, NPCI comes out with the circular. What are the first reactions in the office at Yes Bank and Pine Labs? Are you relieved? Are you in a panic mode? Are you surprised? Or it's just another day because you guys knew it was coming. What were the first reactions in the office when this came out?
4:05Naveen Chaluwadi: So I can tell you from Yes Bank perspective, uh UPI has been moving money for last decade or so. We thought with this announcement, finally we are also talking about money to be made out of this particular ex efforts that have been in place. So for us, it was like finally we are talking you money.
4:22Tanya Naik: I think our initial reaction, like Naveen, this has been in the making for a while, but having seen this ecosystem play out this MDR topic for many years, uh, frankly speaking, and my personal opinion was that this may never happen. So the fact that uh, you know, the kind of intense uh lobbying that a lot of our industry folks, including banks, non-banks, all of us did, it was a sigh of relief. And uh, like Naveen said, it was also about time for many of the ecosystem players who have been building this infrastructure for years to realize value for that finally. And uh especially within the fintech space, because unlike a bank which has a balance sheet to support many of these initiatives, we pretty much work on backing of tech. So the fact that the tech could have a return on itself was obviously much awaited. And uh to be honest, the 40 forty bips was. an even better outcome than we expected.
5:17Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Uh that's from the payment ecosystem. As a merchant, what was the reaction?
5:23Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): It was a sad, sad day. No, no, I mean uh today, um the only perspective that we have on it is from the capital market. And um unlike normal merchants where the fee is higher, for the capital markets it was a differential price. It was at two bips or like 0.02% of the transaction value. The contention that most brokers had and um uh have been vocal about as well has been that somebody making a purchase on an online platform or maybe in a shop is for the entire value that they transfer. In the capital market ecosystem, be it mutual funds that you buy, stocks that you buy, uh if you're sending five lakh rupees to your broker, that is not service that you've availed from your broker. There are platforms like ours who give equity delivery for free. And essentially what is happening now is in case the two BIPs charge is there, a five lakh rupee transfer means a hundred rupee cost for the broker. Earlier it was none. Then the broker is like trying to figure out
6:23how that transaction become sustainable? Should there be a charge for the brokerage? Should the pricing be like rejected? Essentially, there are no answers yet. So we're still like waiting. But 15th September was a scary day for us.
6:36Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I think that sets us up to understanding in detail how this works and maybe me asking more pointed questions. All of us have a rough sketch of how UPI works, how different players are there. But if like both of you help me understand what does your institution play the role of in this whole UPI ecosystem? So the one when money is going from, let's say, a customer's account to a merchant's account, uh, maybe starting with a bank, okay, like what's the role of a bank here? That will help me better appreciate and understand what are the roles you're doing, what are the costs incurred in doing what you do, and eventually then make a case for okay, maybe charging on MDR is maybe not as bad as it's coming out. Assuming that's the case that a lot of the industry players are eventually building on. So maybe we can get that POV from a bank's perspective, and then maybe uh maybe Tanya can chime in, uh helping us explain how from a PA's angle that makes sense.
7:26Naveen Chaluwadi: So I'll just probably look at uh customer perspective when he's or she is working with the bank. Okay, so if a customer is holding an account with yes S bank, he or she would expect the money that is present in his or her bank account is usable in the UPI ecosystem, whether it is on their phone pay application, Google Pay application, or any other UPI application. It is used for fund transfers, it is used for purchases, it is used for transactions, mandates, capital markets, fuel, entertainment, daily morning chai, say evening lunch, all of that has to be usable. So the first role that the bank plays is to ensure that we give capability for our customers who are maintaining money in our bank account, a ability to use their money on the UPI ecosystem. That is, in simple words, the first role of the bank. There, we are often called as a remitter bank, issuer bank, or a payer, the consumer bank. So these are the terms which you probably hear prior. primarily as an issuer or a remitter bank. What we do here is while we are supporting the customers' balances that are there in his or her account to be used on UPI ecosystem, we also uh in this transaction make some payments to NPCI as a switching fee. We invest in technology. We also pay some uh bit
8:46of fees, which is we call it as a PSP fee, to the bank which has. facilitated this transaction on a UPI application. That UPI application could be directly built by the bank or it could also be supported by the bank. Right? And the third one is because the money is hitting the beneficiary account in real time, say my customer is sending money to the State Bank of India. The money credit in State Bank of India is happening instantly. There is no delay in terms of his or her beneficiary. realizing seeing this particular money. However, when it comes to actual movement of funds from Yes Bank to State Bank of India, it happens in batches. And hence we have something called as an interchange, which we need to make to the State Bank of India, which is helping the beneficiary to see their balance and use their balance instantly without waiting for the receipt of the funds. And in this particular journey, the consumer holds. hold, the consumer bank which is facilitating usage of funds, is indeed incurring the cost of supporting this particular transaction. But we have never charged customers. And even after this MDR announcement, these transactions will continue to be free. So, which means out of the 25 billion transactions, if you were to take about one-third one third of these transactions are primarily happening on the P. P2P space. These transactions, while we as an
10:06institution will continue to support uh after incurring all these costs, we will continue to offer it for free uh as per whatever uh mandates and guidelines or as per whatever loss at this point of time the country uh decided, right? So that is first part as a bank, I would say that we uh play a role. The second one, we could have stopped there, but uh we also have uh businesses, some of the businesses who directly work uh with us as a customer of current account or sometimes even a large wholesale uh customer. They enjoy uh various facilities from the bank in addition to the current account. Sometimes they also come to us and ask us, can you also help us to collect money from our customers using UPI? Right? That's where we have been providing uh various options within UPI, whether it is QR, whether it is intent, whether it is collect, whether it is uh merchant login, which even zero the coin had used. Many such uh cases we have been able to service our current account customers again, given that it was always a zero MDR resume, irrespective of what the technology cost or a switching cost or a compliance cost or a fraud charge. chargeback risk related cost, all of that was continuously being borne by the bank. But given the large relationship with these particular entities, we continue to offer those services. Now
11:25we could always argue whether they were offered only when the value existed or not. But normally we have to keep in mind that sometimes the cost incurred by the institution may outweigh the value brought in by the customer. Sometimes it could be vice versa. It is, it may end up being fair, but at the end of the day, it is not actually in isolation. It could have been better where, uh, in terms of whatever value each of us provide to each other, commensurately would have been paid by each other parties. As a bank, we could have stopped Stop there, but like we told, our enthusiasm uh in this space had also prompted us to. explore options beyond our uh bank account customers. That is where I think we had uh partnered with various entities, including uh Tanya, Spine Labs, or many other entities. Where we did, we explored uh can we actually go to each and every uh fintech which is solving a specific problem? They solve someone is solving a problem for consumers, someone is problem solving a problem for small
12:26money. merchant, someone is solving problem for enterprise merchants, someone is solving problem for SMA merchants. We knew that every segment which is involved in using UPI, there are nuances. There are investments in terms of understanding the customer needs, providing a good value proposition to that particular customer segment, and deeply connecting, understanding uh their behavior. and accordingly design a solution. That is where the expertise of fintechs have come in, in not only in terms of bringing the technology but also understanding of that particular uh ecosystem, which is uh important to solve the customer need. There, we saw potentially a reason to partner with the fintech uh ecosystem, where we believed that the expertise of customer hand holding can be done by the fintech. We can actually do the backend lifting in terms of connecting them to the payment rails, educating them about various options which are available, following the practices of risk management, fraud detection, whatever we could do as a regulated entity, we did. And we said the best is to partner with these institutions, uh, identify a problem, co-create Create solutions where obviously there has been a co-creation where we bring in uh say limited. budgets because we are an uh institution, we could not afford to have so much budgets. But budgets were brought in by the fintechs
13:46in terms of not only technology, you should also understand there is a lot of effort that goes into hand holding customer, building the customer behavior, educating the customer, awareness about that particular solution, and then finally drive adoption. So there's a lot of work that uh uh is involved before this particular payment instrument or a collection rail becomes uh uh prominent. That is where we played a role of both payer PSP and pay PSP, where we have supported uh fintechs who were going to consumers. We were the payer PSP bank behind those entities where people were going uh to serve merchant segment. We were working as a PE pay PSP. In these segments, we definitely uh made sure that as an institution which was also uh going through its own turbulences in terms of uh our own uh profitability, we made sure that we had a right approach in terms of having a capital light approach, bringing in a lot of innovations, and also having a uh model which is beneficial to both FinTech Tech and and on also the bank, where we have been able to showcase value to our internal stakeholders, our shareholders at the same time, drive innovation with FinTech partners. I think that's a balance which we have been trying to maintain. And uh when this announcement comes, while I know that this announcement also, like Tanya said, has been in
15:05making for a few years now, I think at least a couple of years. Uh, the choice that we had was to have a sustainable, uh predictable revenue versus uh a subsidy. which probably may or may not happen, or an incentive scheme which may or may not happen. Uh, that is where we thought predictable income would help us to have a clear ability to tell out what we can do to our internal stakeholders, also, whether it is board, whether it is our shareholders, or whether it is our investors, and then tell them this is how we want to go ahead on this space uh with a much more. support and much more backing of uh the shareholders.
15:42Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Honestly, Naveen, like whenever I've looked at a bank, you know, from an investor's point of view, I've always looked at it as a lending institution. And I've always felt that okay, payments is more incidental to what they do, which to some extent is right, but we cannot ignore the fact that lending as a service and transactions as a service both exist separately and both have to earn their right to win in the ecosystem. and be profitable in its isolated sense as well. That is a very, I think, myopic view I had as an investor. And now that you know explain it out, okay, what does it act? What is it, what goes into doing all of these? Um, MDR, we can argue with how much is too much and how little is too little, but MDR does make some sense. Which brings me to Tanya. I wanted to chime in, and I have a very stupid question, so please bear with me. When I was looking at you know the ecosystem, okay, how does the money flow? I see there were TPAPs. Okay, this phone pay, Google Pay. I couldn't realize okay, where is the payment aggregator here? Where do you fit in? And uh I just couldn't make sense. Again, a very naive question, but help me understand here. I I understand, okay, whenever I transact to a merchant through a Pine Lab, I see a UPI button there, but where do you fit in? How do you bear the responsibility in the ecosystem? And how does this MDR fit into your maybe revenue model and just helping you innovate more, as uh Naveenji was saying?
16:57Tanya Naik: Happy to maybe just draw out the whole UPI infrastructure for you. So typically there are five parties in a UPI payment, right? So the first and the most important one, which Naveen explained so beautifully, is the payers' bank, which is the issuer. That bank pretty much is the bank who does all the heavy lifting, the core banking. capacity, you know, which Aveen was talking about, every single debit which is accounted for, the frauds, the dispute, the call center, the work around resolution. I think that's pretty much the heaviest heavy lifting, as far as I'm concerned, and my objective view remains that is the issuer bank, which we call as the payers' bank. The second one is the bank behind the payer PSP app. So typically, like a phone pay or a Google Pay. And I know Naveen's team rightfully supports many of them today. These are the guys who actually sponsor the app onto the UPI infrastructure. So they are the ones who many a times run the switch associated with the UPI issuer TPAC side, the UPI handle, the issuance of that handle, which says at the rate, blah, blah, blah. And it answers the it's responsible for the ACS app's compliance as well. That particular institution or bank institution is typically responsible for the switch infrastructure. So you have the bank who's the issuer's bank who holds the balance, the debit, the fraud risk. Then you have the issuers PSP
18:16bank, which is the app PSP bank, which owns the switch infrastructure and owns the compliance. The third piece is the TPAP or the app itself, which is the Google Pay, Phone Pay. Red, and like in the case of Zeroda, let's say that that whole product where you allowed for the app handler to get issued within the app itself. This particular RT is responsible for the whole device binding, for the onboarding of the customer, the payment experience itself. And where many of the fintechs today have created world-class products, as we know. Their main, you know, the entity that creates this experience and is responsible for the product. experience, the support to the customer, and of course, most importantly, the acquisition of the customer itself. So that's the third party. The fourth party is actually the merchant's bank, which is when in a B2C transaction, the bank which actually owns the merchant's account and holds the merchant's relationship. So whether it is crediting the money to the merchant's bank, who's owning the merchant side disputes, whether it is a assigning the merchant category code, you would have heard this term MCC in many places. That is what the merchants acquiring bank does. So they own like the settlement risk and the merchant risk. And then last but not the least is the payment aggregator, which is the business that players like us, uh Pine Labs or a Razer Pay, etc., handle. Handry. Now that job is varied. So we are
19:36responsible for merchant KYC. K by C. We are responsible for underwriting, onboarding of the merchant. We're responsible for integrations, giving a good experience on the checkout to the merchants page. Everything that you let's say on a Zeroda or any of your uh you know uh co-players in that space, how does the UPI experience look for you as a merchant? That would be with us. Let's say, I mean, given the scale and size at which UPI operates, you would not be able to operate with just one merchant bank, right? We would want to have routing to multiple partners given the kind of success rates that we expect in the market. So routing to multiple banks to maintain success rates. Again, refunds, reconciliation, merchant support. The invisible arm of everything to do with the merchant then sits with us. What is visible so far is the merchant flow coming in from the customer to the merchant. What is invisible is us. So now if you look at the math. that's pretty much how the math works as well. So assuming it's what a thousand rupee transaction with respect to uh UPI, how does the 40 rupees get split? So the first 16 rupees goes to the issuer's bank. The bank, as Naveen rightfully said, holds the code banking platform and holds the bank account. The next four rupees goes to the payers' PSP bank, IECAS i.e. S bank who owns the phone pay's TPAP. The next eight rupees goes to the TPAP
20:55itself, which is let's say phone pay or any other partner. Then comes the aggregator and the acquirer share all baked into one. And that's the remaining 12 rupees. Now that 12 rupees as things stand, because within the NPCI infrastructure, the PA doesn't have a local stand standai I when it comes to the steering code. We actually get represented on our behalf with the bank who participates for us in the NPCI steer code. So all our acquiring banks then get 12 rupees. And then what we get out of the 12 is a negotiation driven by every player. And that honestly, I would have loved for that to have changed. I would have loved for that to be a sizable, tangible number given to us. But as things stand, given that that's not happening. we as PAs have to negotiate with every single one of our bank partners on what share we get out of the 12 rupees. And then, of course, depending on another MCC, it becomes that same five rupees goes into that same bracket of 40%, 30%, 20%, etc. So that's really how the whole math and how the parties in our UPI ecosystem work. Now,
21:59in certain cases, like where I would own as a PA, me would. own the switch infrastructure of the merchant's acquiring platform, I would be able to negotiate obviously higher because I'm owning the cost of the switch as well. Because there are switch costs at both sides, right? We spoke about the issuer switch, but there's also an acquirer switch which requires the transaction. Now, if I own that, I have a better negotiation power. If I don't own it, then I'm just responsible for bringing the merchant. But there is an invisible cost which I mentioned. of the merchant side dispute, the merchant side underwriting, the merchants, and actually acquiring the merchant itself is a cost, right? So all of that is invisible, not accounted for, and somewhere being negotiated by the PAs in the 12 rupees. That's really how the math uh you know works and how the ecosystem is expected Expect to it operate, assuming it remains at 40 bips. bits. I don't think it will change, but that's how it would work. So,
22:49Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Tanya, one small follow-up. question. You talked of switch cost. This is a term I came across while researching as well, but I don't think I understand it fully enough. I don't know any other person better enough than you too to briefly explain me, okay, what does this switch cost actually mean? What is it doing in the ecosystem?
23:05Tanya Naik: It's the infrastructure of setting up an acquiring platform. So when you set up an acquiring platform, how does a merchant connect to the bank? How does the bank connect to NPCI? All of that happens via via a switch, which means that every transaction, once it gets acquired by a PA, how does it go to NPCI from NPCI to the issuer bank, back from the issuer bank TPAP, back to us? How do we recognize the transaction successful or failed? It all happens via the switch infrastructure. So it's that switch infrastructure which connects to NPCI and gives us a confirmation whether a transaction is successful or failed. It gives us the ability to manage refunds. It gives us the ability to manage disputes. So it's pretty much the infrastructure on which UPI itself is set up for our acquiring systems. And I'm guessing the same thing is replicated on the issuing side as well, uh at the bank side. I mean, I don't know if you want to add anything there.
24:00Naveen Chaluwadi: So if I just may add to what Tanya said, she elaborated very well on how this is very important. I just wanted to bring back to uh our initial thought uh in terms of who are the players. We have consumer bank, we have consumer application, we have merchant. All three interfaces, whether it's a bank account, whether it is a consumer application or the merchant interface, which is built uh by various fintechs, all three things have to talk to each other through. a language which is understood, which is prescribed by the NPCA. NPCA has uh said that UPI is a protocol in which you speak to each other and exchange information first, subsequently, exchange money. This particular exchange of information in the language that has been prescribed by NPCI is what is uh made possible by switch. In short term, whatever money, what whatever you want to do on the interface, if that has to be uh brought into the UPI ecosystem, the switch is the converter. That is how I would put it in simple words. So there are three switches, there are three or four switches. One is uh what happens on the merchant side, what happens on the bank account side, what happens on the consumer side. And the fourth switch is what NPCA NPCI has set up in the in in the middle. So while each of them incur their cost, we also have to understand that NPCI incurs a cost, and hence this
25:20cost which is incurred by NPCI is also paid by one of the parties or two of the parties in the transaction. That is where the switch and switching cost. Switch cost is technology cost, switching cost is what we uh pay to NPCI CI for maintaining the technology at their level.
25:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Both of you have done a mode. more than enough job to help me understand okay, what goes behind it and why there is a case for MDR to be built. Which brings me to the next question. I am completely sold that okay, MDR should maybe be charged. But my next question is: what's the right MDR to be charged? And that's a question that's been bothering me for a while from a lot of angles. First being, do we look at it from purely a cost plus margin basis? But then how do we attribute costs? Second, we can look at it as an alternative basis. Okay, what's the alternative? Let's say debit card network, a credit card network, where MDRs are as high as one one point five two percent. Maybe that's a way to look at it. Another way to look at it, which I guess I was looking at an interview of Samir Negam
26:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): where
26:21Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): he was saying, Okay, in twenty 2023, twenty-three around thirty 3,900 nine hundred crores was disbursed uh through a subsidy. I don't understand. how that happened, but he said, okay, that's an X amount. But in past one, two years, that money has not been disbursed because as the UPI network has scaled, the requirement of that money has gone up so much that maybe introducing an MDR makes sense. I understand okay the operations behind it now. I want to talk money. What's the right amount? How do we decide it? And eventually maybe just figure out, okay, how is NPCI augmenting a lot of it in a zero? MDR situation? And how will it happen now? Maybe Naveen, so you want to start. And also, I'm asking since I'm asking a lot of questions, one more question. It was not that MDR was always zero. I was reading there was an MDR pre-2019 of 0.65%. I was too young to remember paying any of that amount. I was still back in high school, so I don't recall. But if you could help me understand, do we revert back to how it used to happen back in 2020? 2019? How did the money flow back then? Then in 2020 era where it was being cross-subsidized,
27:21some cost absorption happening at banks and fintechs and some NPCI and some subsidies coming in. What does happen now? A fully loaded question all around money. Uh, I'll let Naveen sir maybe start, talk a bit, and then maybe Tana Tanya, if you want to chime in.
27:34Naveen Chaluwadi: Okay, so I'll probably spend a couple of minutes in terms of telling Singhi why even MDR or any an interchange. If we have to go back in history, the first time the MDR interchange were introduced was when the credit card transactions were happening. Credit card transactions, you know that involved a credit cost to the institution which has given the credit card. There was a customer awareness, customer education, customer support uh efforts which were made by the bank. And subsequently, there is a uh infrastructure which was put in by the networks, whether it was Visa, MasterCard, subsequently Rupe. Then the third part is there is a significant amount of effort which goes into giving hardware to the merchant, giving connectivity to the merchant, and telling them how they can use this particular uh uh method to uh accept funds and then giving them reports, reconciliation support, all the day-to-day. things. I mean, while Tanya has been very, very kind in terms of saying there is some invisible layer in this entire system. Actually, if you go to the merchant, the only visible layer to them is the payment aggregator or anyone who is actually going and supporting and standing in front of the customer. So, this particular thing at that point of time was said that for a credit card uh scenario, at least the issuer bank. would have a cost of about 1.6%
28:54as a right fee to cover up for the credit cost, to cover up for the customer awareness, customer marketing, customer uh support. And subsequently, there was probably a five, ten basis points as a merchant network, uh, which is Visa MasterCard or a subsequently rupee. And then obviously, the person who is actually standing in front of the merchant also would expect a 10% to 15 basis points for the efforts that they actually are bringing in. That is where the rough number of 1.8 to 2% came as a MDR in cards world. But when it moved to debit card, one of the elements which got changed is only the credit cost because the funds are maintained by the customer. And hence, after a lot of mass, that number has been brought down to 90 basis points, 75 basis points and an average 90 for a transaction which is more than two. 2000 and 40 for a transaction which is less than 2000. Uh it was roughly around 0.7 is what I remember as a uh number which was coming at a portfolio level, right? UPI is more or less allowing you to use your money which is lying in your account in a much more efficient way. So if you have to have a comparative start, debit card is a comparable start. However, we also knew that unlike a a card transaction where it was primarily a three party model, this is the first time there is a flexible five party model. And hence there was also a experience, there was also a
30:13innovation. There is also a I mean if you ask me, this is in my mind innovation of the last decade, not only in India, but at least in the top ten 10 innovations within the world, I'm sure UPI will always try to find its place. And a 40 basis point for such an innovation is definitely an extraordinary deal from whatever has been happening historically. That is one way of looking at it. If you want to say you want to look at saying what is the cost of doing it, is it covering for the cost? Is it uh something which is subsidizing or helping the industry to further invest in this space? Yes, you can go by those HTTPs. estimates which are shared in the market saying every year on an uh average across the industry, the efforts would consume anywhere around 10,000 to 12,000 crores of money across the ecosystem. I mean, whether it is invested by the issuer bank, whether it is invested by the consumer app, whether it is invested by the pay PA, merchant uh facing bank, all of this combined the estimated amount is. say 10 to 12,000 crores, is the number. And that is the number probably you are also quoting saying he would have told you that in the last five years industry has invested about 50,000 crores or 60,000 crores. And if you look at the rough revenue pool also, which is uh being anticipated, the maximum capped revenue
31:33Venue pool, assuming that everything gets sold at MRP, which again I know Tanya will have more to offer. in terms of there'll be very few people who will actually end up paying 40 basis points. Uh so we believe that that number also would come to the same uh 12,000, 13,000 crores. And I think probably it will be an even Steven in terms of getting the money pool match with the total investments. Now, whether this money pool, whatever is coming, is rightly getting disbursed or not, is It's definitely a uh question to be. answered. But let's start. Maybe there is an imperfect start to this particular distribution of the money. But it over a period of time, we all believe that the point of equilibrium will naturally be attained. Whether it happens in 12 months, whether it happens in 18 months or 24 months. I am sure everyone is mature enough to find what is the right point of equilibrium where this new revenue which is coming. will be pent across different stakeholders. That is one thing that I wanted to tell. I also probably gathered that you were also telling saying can we look at alternate in terms of other modes? But alternate modes is also a function of customer behavior. See, today, because it is UPI, customer does 50 transactions a week or 30 transactions a day. If it was that he has to go to a
32:52bank branch or an ATM and withdraw cash, I remember ATM people used to go once a week. Bank branch people used to go only once a month. And hence it is also that frequencies have changed. It's not just that saying key uh you have uh uh changed the mode, but you have changed the customer behavior, and that is where I think one of the things that you also have to appreciate is all the core banking systems which were designed were designed. with an assumption maybe each customer on an average would do about fifty transactions a year because everyone would get one salary, would probably withdraw a couple of times and do some ad hoc payments, maybe fifty times in a year or sixty times in a year. But it is definitely true today that there are on an average, probably fifty 50 times a week is the right number, but there are power users who use fifty 50 times a day. And I don't think uh you should be surprised uh to hear that there are uh people who transact 50 times a day.
33:43Tanya Naik: Look, I think coming, I I'll further to some of uh Naveen's points. So, first things when you look at UPI, the obvious comparison is a rupee debit, right? And what whatever is happening on the on overall debit ecosystem. Now, if that has been capped at point 0.9 nine and you have a credit card which is anywhere between 1.5 to 2.5. this is sitting much lower. Obviously, from a DC debit card standpoint, this is cheaper. So the same transaction on a debit card turns out to be more expensive. So just on pure instrument to instrument, like-to-like comparison, MDR on UPI is still cheaper than what a debit card MDR is possible. On the point of whether it could have been priced better, is it priced well? Is it priced not? I think like look at even the whole debit card MDR, right? It was priced as per feedback from the industry on what the cost of running the transaction was. And then you know the ecosystem had capped it. So when the interchange got raised, it was a capping of up to point nine percent. I would think somewhere along the line, this would need to happen for UPI as well. Because one thing and Naveen highlighted that, why? while you're charging transactions above 2000 only, there is a cost infrastructure in every transaction. So even today, 96% of the transactions which are flowing through are going for as free of cost,
35:02but also have an existing infrastructure. So what you're hoping is that the 4% transaction compensates for the 96%, which to my mind, cost to cost. I am still not sure if the banks have done that, Math and will. it truly helps meet or beat that cost. So, first things first, I think cost comparison on whether the cost covers what the MDR charge is going to be. I don't think that has been done. So, ideally speaking, a ceiling should have been created on the basis of the cost review from the industry and then you know could would have come up with it. But I'm sure there has been research which have gone was gone into even the 40%. bips. So I don't want to talk about that. As far as the merchants' negotiation is concerned, look, you have a Moet sitting next to you who was, anyways, very disappointed with the price. And like him, there are all the large enterprise merchants who have come to us requesting for better pricing on this whole thing. Now, if you looked at that whole five-party ecosystem that we spoke about, any bank, which is also on the acquiring side and the issuing side suddenly has 28 basis points to play around with against a 12. If someone's just an acquirer, you're basically saying you can give away 12 if you want to acquire a large merchant. I'm not saying we're going to do it, but I'm saying that's available on the table. But someone who has the ability to subsidize from both the issuer and the
36:22acquirer side has 28 basis points to play with. And that to my mind is going to happen. So on the pricing and what becomes the final negotiation tactic, I think it's going to be uh wait and watch as far as I'm concerned. Because many of the large merchants will opt for honor rates, many of the large merchants will look at ways to subsidize it by you know working on the banking relationship side with the banks. So I think that's going to happen. And by the way, this has been happening for years on the credit card. front, right? It is nothing new that we have seen there is honest routing even in cards. Post tokenization, it actually was halted for a while, but it has come back again with issuer tokens. The same, I would say, opportunity will get repeated in UPI. So really speaking from a price standpoint, is 40 adequate or not? I would think that has been not discussed enough in the ecosystem because while you're paying only on 4%, you're charged you're not charging on the 96%. And as far as what the right rate is going to be, given the kind of negotiations that have happened in the CADS ecosystem and that could be replicated here, I would say that is again a wait and watch. So whether the ecosystem will end up paying 40 itself, to my mind, especially in the large merchants, is suspect. So I would genuinely see. uh how this negotiation will play
37:41out over the next few months as the ecosystem gets used to it. But yes, one thing is for sure, it's not going for free anymore, which is which is a welcome change. Now it is this part of the 12 versus the 28, which is up for negotiation, that we will see how that pans out.
37:56Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I I think I see it with a very different tangent. I mean, the entire premise of an MDR at itself, uh, I see it as a construct that got started with private networks building a certain way. And the private networks would have been a visa, a master card, started with credit. Today, when I look at any service, even the one that we provide as, let's say, in the capital markets, as a stockbroker, as mutual funds, there is a commercial arrangement that you enter into with your client that could be called by whatever name, it could be called a brokerage. There's a commercial arrangement that you enter into with your bank, with the exchanges, could be called by whatever name, could be called a transaction fee, could be called an account maintenance charge. And if today, let's say there were an MDR equivalent for the capital markets, if you were told to buy a stock, you pay a flat fee of 50 basis per. point, your broker collects it. Part of it goes to the clearing corporation, part of it goes to the stock exchange, part of it goes to the bank who's facilitating the transaction. That is a very inefficient non-Indian way of doing the like entire architecture. We've mostly like seen very efficient ways of uh doing transactions. So even the conversation around how uh there can be an MDR. of 40 bids, but
39:16the Indian way is not 40 bids. The Indian way is maybe to negotiate and figure a number. Uh, if that is anyhow going to happen, the MDR seems pointless. Uh again, uh this is so we don't sell like uh e-commerce products, we don't sell uh goods, we don't sell services which are going to be in that 40 bips range. For the capital markets, our contention has been this is an account-to-account account to account transfer. It is more a akin to a P2P transfer than it is to a P2M transfer because you fund your own account, you buy stocks, you buy mutual funds with that. So all of the views that I have on MDR, they come from a very first principles question. If there is to be a commercial engagement, if there is to be a technology reimbursement, if there is to be a fraud detection risk that has to be reimbursed to entities. That shows up in the commercial arrangements that entities enter into. I don't know if the MDR's work here is to only make sure that a commodity which multiple entities don't have a USP for are able to still make money from. And basically it's that's what is happening. You You can go to like maybe 20 banks. Uh, there would be a few, let's say, like yes bank who. would do that service really well. Uh, but fundamentally, can everybody else do the same thing? They can if that becomes the
40:35business preference. So the moat is very small. It makes for good reason to have an MD.
40:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Which which which actually like the question comes to my mind. Uh let's talk about non-UPI modes of payment, right? Maybe an in NEFT RTGS. I don't know how it looks like, but not every bank charges the same amount. if I'm not wrong, right? Which basically means that here it charge whatever amount is being charged by a bank or anybody in the ecosystem, either a negotiated amount or a function of okay, how much are they able to charge? But when we do a 0.4% flat, again, I'm not including the sectoral carve-outs or the exceptions or sub 2000 payments. It makes some sense, okay. It's not really the Indian.
41:12Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): It's If you show open up in the industry also, I
41:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): mean
41:13Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): uh it'll come down to negotiations that happen between the payment aggregators, the banks, the
41:19Tanya Naik: Actually to Mohit's point, and I was just thinking about it. So that same 50,000 rupee that a person's today, you know, spending at a jeweler, he's gonna pay 200 rupees at the jeweler's MBR. That same 50,000 rupees is gonna going be to at five 5 rupees at an insurer, and it's gonna going to be ten 10 rupees at a broker. So technically the pricing decision can vary from like 20x to 40x depending on where you're transacting. And that really then has to be commensurate with the margin that that industry is earning as well. So people who have the margins to give then can give 40. Whereas, like Moet said, in the Zeroda space where the broker is essentially doing a P2P transaction, is their there margin to give in the first place for a UPI. I think that part. I thought there was rationalization being done basis the MCC codes. But again, assignment of the MCC code, doing it in the rightful manner, all of that has to be, you know, that remains to be seen. It has to be done in the rightful manner as well, so that people don't misuse it at a later date and don't qualify something which it is not.
42:22Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): And there's one more thing changing. So uh when it comes to let's say B. behavior itself that Naveen was talking about. Today, and uh Krishna and I were talking about it like uh earlier today. If I were in 2015, I was probably withdrawing some cash, keeping with me, and then spending through the week, through the month. Right now, I do not withdraw cash. I keep it with my bank. The kafa balance is going up, uh, the uh amounts for the banks going up. I know that RBI today has a higher risk weight. for anything which is online accessible. So if a consumer keeps an FD with a bank, which is a physical FD, the amount of cash reserve the bank has to keep is lower compared to, let's say, an online FD or an online savings account access. But it still translates into a very different behavior and uh ecosystem for the uh banking industry as well. And the entire argument about if you can pay it should you pay it, seemed odd to me because who are you paying to? You're paying to the bank who's already sitting on a profit pool.
43:20Naveen Chaluwadi: If I can just probably uh comment uh on this, what Mohit mentioned, I think, is one of the principal tenants which we followed uh as a recommendation when I think RBI came up with this uh paper, discussion paper in terms of how do we go about charging digital payments. We also at that point of time. said that can we leave it to the merit of the relationship, which is saying if a consumer bank wants to offer a UPI, like we have debit card charges, I could also potentially tell that hundred rupees is the UPI you say charges. How many ever transactions you want to do, you do because that money is mine. I am not going to give it to anyone else. Similarly, consumer app can uh charge their own customers, merchant can be charged by their own I mean interface, whether it is a payment aggregator or a merchant bank, whatever may be the interface. However, I think that degree of maturity is absolutely possible when we have a perfect landscape. We'll also have to see that when UPI was launched in 2016, just after the launch, there was also a very uh big moment of demonetization and then complete digital push everywhere. There was need for moving money digitally. with at zero cost because already there was enough panic in the ecosystem in terms of saying key what will happen after uh demonetization or during demonetization. If you see the UPI picked up during demonetization, subsequently UPI
44:40has become a habit, right? There was also a list of steps that we have taken as an ecosystem at that point of time to create this habit where free UPI usage was while good, bad, ugly was. the starting point. Right. Then at the time of uh 2020, there was zero MDR announcement by the government of India, which again made it very difficult to create a perfect situation or perfect landscape to go and have a perfect solution. So that's why we said Sainki, we are definitely having an ecosystem which had a history of say demonetization, COVID, few other events where there were certain interval. interventions made to just promote this particular method of payment and collection. And then now, after 10 years, we are starting to see can it stand on its own? That's why I said saying the starting point is what is the money that the ecosystem is spending, maybe 10,000 crores or 12,000 crores. Can we bring that 10,000 crores or 12,000 thousand crores pros into the ecosystem first? I think that is a first-level first level problem that has been solved by this particular. scheme. Now, whether it is aptly reaching out to each and every stockholder as per the value that they deserve, that definitely is not uh I think uh can be ascertained on day zero. Everyone feels that they are getting less or more or even someone who is getting more would definitely not talk about it. Someone who is definitely getting less would always tell the inky Enki, this is where I think
46:00I deserve it more. And this conversation is important to uh be there because that is what will push the ecosystem to a point of equilibrium. But I agree to the uh fundamental thought process that uh Mohit brought in, saying should it be a merit-based commercial structure? But unfortunately, fortunately, the payment ecosystem had inherited a lot of concepts from the payment networks which have been operational uh. for 100 years in a different context, but the context is changing. This entire thing also will change. It won't happen overnight, but it may happen over a period of time. We'll have to give it that time because people also have to understand, be matured enough to pay. People are okay to pay 100 rupees for a movie ticket, 20 rupee rupees to a rail ticket. But when we tell that you have to pay something for your bank ticket, banking application or a consumer application, a UPI application, I don't know how they react. Someone has to try it out. Are we allowed to try it out? I think legally we are not allowed to try it out. So we will have to unfold, unravel uh this particular journey over a period of time.
47:08Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I think the conversation just took its own pace where there were uh the opinions coming in for everywhere. Do you wanna maybe wrap up on
47:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the?
47:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): this part so that I can ask you the next final question that I had in mind?
47:18Tanya Naik: I mean, look, I I on the cost front, uh, I have nothing further to add. I just feel that it should be the market forces should be allowed to congregate and further deliberate on the pricing as things evolve. Because I don't think we have still maybe we've not even arrived at the right benchmark yet. So it should be. discussed, deliberated every month in this tier coup to see whether it actually objectively meets the cost that the industry has incurred. And if not, what are better ways to then price or uh subsidize as well? Uh, because let me tell you, like, I don't know, I mean, I don't know if you mentioned this, but the subsidy from the sub 2000 has gone away, right? Uh so technically now that transaction. no longer exists as uh as a fund from the government. So now does that does this MDR enable it? The initial numbers seem to suggest so, but we need to wait and watch. So I would just say in summary to this whole pricing conversation, is that
48:18it needs to be deliberated every month to make sure that the market has are actually looking to or at least has managed to recover the cost. in the absence of that subsidy and in the absence of many such negotiations that are going to come to the fore as merchants start to get used to this potty bips concept in the first place.
48:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I have one last question, which is more of like a hypothetical game. I want both of you to empathize that my dear colleague Mohit Yan, who is bringing a perspective from merchants and the hypothetical being, and it's a very non-nuance. non-nuanced hypothetical that I'm putting out, which has been in the conversation. What if merchants no more accept UPI? That's a question out there. Very non-nuanced. I'm adding that caveat right away so that you don't come at me. But that's a possibility, saying, okay, maybe we'll go cashless, or maybe uh a 10,000 bill would be broken down into two, two 2000 thousand uh payments of five so that they don't have to pay. That's a question I had. And I want you to give me, give me your thought process on it. With the end goal in mind, if let's say it goes live on October 15th, which I'm not so sure it will happen because maybe we're expecting NPCI, maybe it gets delayed, whatever. Let's say from the day it goes live, one year, two years down the line, what does it mean for that experiment to have failed if the number of USB UPI transactions by volume has stagnated or gone down, do we consider that maybe charging on UPI was okay, a fair decision, but maybe we were wrong in how we implemented it, or maybe the pricing was unfair? Would we call that a policy failure, according to you? What would constitute a success in
49:56this case if the transactions continue to go up? So this is a hypothetical I have in mind. Look at it from a merchant's POV and whether or not it's a success or fa or a failure, one, two years down the line, what does that look like? Again, both from a perspective, I'm coming from a perspective, okay, I want financial inclusion for the country, but at the same time, I also want industry players to be profitable. I want more investor money to come in, more innovation. All of these are conflicting objectives and there are no simple answers, which is why I ask these very hard questions to you guys, the smart people to do the answering for
50:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): me.
50:26Naveen Chaluwadi: See, from our perspective, yes, uh, there could be initial anxieties, frictions, everything, but we believe that maybe three to six months from the date of implementation, whatever may be the date of implementation, we will have probably the right feedback in terms of whether what has worked, what has not worked. I don't think it will be like a binary answer. It may have worked in 90-95% of the situations or eight. 80% of the situations, maybe 5-10%. There could be some uh learning interventions which will be brought in subsequently. All of that definitely could be the uh end state that we look at. But if you look at uh whether uh what are the alternatives, I think online space, if you see any alternative to UPI, would always be costlier alternative to uh what an online space uh merchant could give, and hence we believe that the amount of friction there could potentially be lesser. I mean, what else would the merchant and consumer would do part from uh the lowest cost option that is available on the platform? Offline space, most of the offline small merchants definitely I believe that they will uh not be impacted because uh very small merchants, the number of transactions which they do more than 2000 itself will be very low. And uh I don't see uh that particular uh friction point there. The mid-level merchants, yes, they will be
51:45trying out all of those experiments that you're talking about. Can we do this? Can we do that? Can we uh create multiple bills? Can we pass on to the customer? When we can we try and persuade the customer to do an alternate mode. That probably learning process will be there, but I am sure the amount of convenience that the UP UPI would have offered, not just for uh uh completing the transaction, but also making sure that their books are reconciled, everything has happened in time. They are today also paying for credit card uh transactions on UPI. It's not that they don't pay anything on UPI. Credit card transactions when it is happening on a UPI Rails are definitely paid by this mid-level and other merchants where this probably this uh friction point could come. Uh the enterprise merchants, yes, uh they are completely aware of their maths, they will do their best in terms of doing their negotiations, they'll figure out ways to optimize, they will start somewhere, they will also try to optimize. Uh, friction again, I don't see. Friction I see only in the mid-level Level offline merchants. There will be certain feedbacks, of course, when this entire uh ecosystem. is looked, and we have probably bifurcated into three segments at this point of time: capital markets, industry, and non-industry segments. There could be one or two genuine pieces which are missed by the policymakers in terms of saying, Oh, this is
53:05something which we have not anticipated. Can we actually create a new uh or can we move them from one segment to another segment? So those learning curves probably will uh happen, but that will also happen uh in the first six months of uh implementation. That is my uh limited view on this, uh, how things will unfold.
53:23Tanya Naik: Yeah, I think my view is similar. So I don't think people will stop accepting UPI because obviously and I mentioned this earlier, 96% payments are still free. So you're not going to have this problem when it comes to under 2000. When it comes to over 2000, I think you are seeing some backlash, especially in the higher ticket size segments. So there is petrol, uh petroleum, as we all know. Even during the 2016 piece, this had come down and then it finally came up as surcharge. Uh, you may see something similar, I don't know. But uh uh that has already started to happen. You might see, as you rightly said, the splitting of the bill, uh, given you know anything which is over 2000. I do see electronics and maybe uh other high-ticket size items moving to car and back again or moving to cash. So some of that backlash is going to happen, but as as Naveen said, in the offline space, because there will be options to accept cash. When it comes to online, I think the ecosystem is very used to it. Most of these guys, in fact,
54:23don't even look at cash on delivery as an option. They are spent so much money incentivizing a prepaid order that it is difficult for that behavior to go back. And the ease with which you're able to do a UPI today in the online business, it you cannot take that away. So I do see that it will continue. Yes, there will be backlash in the offline space for sure. Or a Couple of segments, the high ticket size segments, whether it's petroleum, whether it's electronics, they are going to have to see. uh there will be backlash. Then we're already seeing that in the market with some of the protests. So uh I think that aside, with online, with the under 2000, you will still continue to see that growth. And it is very difficult to disrupt a technology like this, which has brought convenience for so many years to this market and has made us habituated. I mean, I don't uh I like so I think Muth mentioned it, I have not carried cash now. myself as a user for over one year almost. So I literally carry cash when I'm going abroad, which is uh, you know, uh quite counterintuitive. So yeah, that's the case with India. We're way too used to the digital way of doing things now. It's uh tough to go back for a tech savvy consumer for sure.
55:34Naveen Chaluwadi: I would just want to probably bring that point. I was actually glad that. Tanya brought that point. While merchant want to have a choice, but would customer want to give him that choice? That is also important. That is where I think Tanya's point that many people have stopped carrying cash uh for doing a transaction. If they have, they would have probably 100 rupees in their mobile or wallet or something. But otherwise, nothing. I mean, wallet also I don't think people carry. That is also something which you have to keep. in mind that merchant may try, but will customer also cooperate in their trials? And then what would be again the final outcome? I think all of this will be clear in three to six months' time from the time of implementation.
56:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I agree. Like U uh UPI has spoiled us as consumers, and we've just become addicted to that convenience. There's a price to that convenience which was being paid by the industry up until this MD. MDR comes in. This MDR would be a way to spread that price across maybe even the merchant and the consumer. It is an experiment. We'll see. I just still need one specific answer. When do you guys consider this experiment of MDR on UPI to have either failed or succeeded? What does that look like for you? So just give me a very short simple example. Okay, this is when you realize okay, maybe we could have done things differently, or okay, this was a successful experiment. Let's see what more we can do. What does that look like?
56:55Naveen Chaluwadi: So if you ask me, today uh we are starting with a pool where 4% of the transactions would fund the entire ecosystem. Do we go to that particular point of equilibrium which Mohit was mentioning that everyone pays values Use and pays for their own uh service that they are receiving from their interface? That end state. reaching, I don't think we'll ever reach in the next at least five to ten years. But if we are going very close to the fact, even when the ecosystem participants fail, that they are getting a fair deal or fair share of the deal that the new money is bringing in, I think that is the day we believe that this experiment, which is starting, has actually fulfilled the purpose. It should not so happen that the money is going into a uh say if. there are hundred players in the ecosystem, if the money is only getting uh split between five to six players and the other ninety-four, ninety-five players are still believing that they are uh doing a lot of hard work and they are not adequately commensurately remunerated. That is where I think uh that uh dissonance has to go in the next. That won't happen in six months, that will happen probably in the next two years. But within two years, if you are able to reach that state. I think definitely we believe that we had had a good start and then subsequently we'll um reach to a solution which is, I mean, real gas, ideal gas, this will be a real gas only, it will never be ideal gas situation.
58:14That is what I wanted to tell.
58:16Tanya Naik: I would just look at four or five key indicators on whether an experiment like this is successful. One is that one truly doesn't ask for subsidy because uh then you really believe that it covers your costs. cost, right? So for me, that's a very important indicator for the ecosystem as a whole. The second is I mean, look at initiatives around this whole splitting. And you mentioned that yourself. Are we really sitting looking at many transactions, sitting in that sweet spot of fifteen hundred, nineteen ninety-nine, the typical, you know, which will give you that indicator? So a lot of us in the industry will start to track that as well on whether there is real splitting happening. So that you
58:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know.
58:51Tanya Naik: there is evasion of that. And then, like I said, the whole negotiation, where does this negotiation stop? Does it stop at 40? Because market forces will decide what that final number is going to be. Is it going to be 40? Is it going to be 30? Is it going to be 38? We don't know. We'll see. So that'll again prove whether the 40 was a number that was uh achievable in the first place. Yeah, and finally, I would say last but not the least, does the consumer get a superior service? Is the service standard still held up now that people have the money to maintain the ecosystem? Are we able to keep the same levels of service standard or even improve them? I think to my mind, these four or five corollary indicators would show whether an experiment like this is successful.
59:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
59:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): think Tanya, you really added that last point, which even I was thinking now that the expectation is there that UPI is being charged for, the customer expectation with respect to downtimes, these uh intermittency issues, what all, the expectation from the customer would be much higher. And the consumers will be holding you guys more responsible and accountable for the UPI ecosystem, which I think is a good expectation to have. And I think that's a great way where we can end this conversation. You guys have been very patient with my questions. Uh so thank you for that. Uh, one last thing uh that I wanted to leave the f leave the floor to you guys. If there is one thing that in this discussion we didn't talk about, but something that you want audience to at least think about with respect to this whole ecosystem. One last closing remark of sorts. Uh maybe I'll start with Muhid this time. Uh maybe one question, one piece of idea that you wanna seed in the mind of the viewers here, maybe that becomes another rabbit hole that they get into when they're learning more about this UPI MDR thing.
1:00:24Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I'll just go back to the previous question and I think that is the headline statement I keep thinking about. The experiment was UPI, and that is a massive success. All of these changes that we're making to it are small tweaks here or there, trying to optimize it. A charge in the ecosystem, one way or the other, does not change the ecosystem that UPI has Is built. Everything around it sort of adapts to it. But the fears that we had was coming from a place of how do we adapt to the change as opposed to is the ecosystem going to suffer or not. That question never really came up too much in my mind. I never really thought that UPI will suffer because there's something uh changing today. There'll be tweaks here or there, even in the future. So I'm expecting whatever we sit on today with the MDR, with the ecosystem, the way it's functioning, with the number of entities which are involved. There might be more, less, things might change around in the next 10 years. It'd be a completely different beast compared to what it is right now. There could be UPI world over.
1:01:28So mostly, is it helping you in your everyday life? I mean, I know it's helping in mine. Is there a charge to it? Uh What are the alternatives I have in my life which I will use if something comes up? to me directly? I'll think about that as and when that happens. Today as a user, nothing changes for me at all.
1:01:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
1:01:45Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I go about my life as I would do like before the MDR, even after it. Uh this is from a uh curiosity point of view, good to understand, but um it doesn't change my life at all. Merchants across the board, including us, uh from that lens, things change. and we'll adapt to it. Pricing from the merchants might adapt slightly here or there because even though directly a merchant cannot be charging for the UPI transaction, they need to make sure that they're making enough margins also. UPI does not fail because of this. Uh UPI is a success, but maybe merchants find industries find their way around it.
1:02:24Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Perfect. That that really adds. Uh Tanya?
1:02:27Tanya Naik: Yeah, I mean, my only parting thoughts are um I'll like I'll end it with an anecdote. There is no such thing as a free lunch. So I guess the industry has finally learned that. And uh yeah, I mean post-September 15th, uh you finally know what the cost of a UPI transaction is. So as a consumer, if we don't believe that you know you can pay 40 rupees for a thousand rupee transaction. not for the consumer, but for the merchant, and that you know you're not able to pass on that cost, then everybody wins. And I think the job of the ecosystem is to make it an equitable win for everybody. That's all I'm saying.
1:03:02Naveen Chaluwadi: So, from my point of view, I think uh UPI operating at such efficiency, such scale, and such resilience Experience was uh happening despite all of this money. What I believe this will happen. uh what will happen now is the degree of innovation or the kind of new players who can probably also feel motivated to join this UPI ecosystem would definitely be one of the things that we believe will help the ecosystem. And I would also probably bring at this point of time that while we call this UPI as a phenomena which is like unprecedented success, we should also keep in mind that out of 1.5 1.4 billion uh Indians, I think so far if my go by NPCI data, only 55 to 60 crores or maybe 55 crore Indians have tried UPA at least once, which means there are so many more customers who can still be reached out, who can still be given benefits of this particular phenomena which has been created. I think the kind of players which may come to make this happen. uh, to go from a 40% coverage to say 60 or 75% coverage in the next five years is what I think will also be one of the key takeaways as an ecosystem.
1:04:13Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): It's been a lovely conversation, everyone. Thank you so much for your time. We'll hope that this eventually adds to the you know ideas that have been floating around. Uh this whole idea of MDR on UPI. And I hope uh we did our part well. explaining our point of view, adding to the conversation. Thank you so much guys.
1:04:30Naveen Chaluwadi: Thank you for having us here.
1:04:31Tanya Naik: Like mess. Thanks a lot.