The Hurdle Rate Podcast

Credit stress and Bitcoin valuation complexities discussed on The Hurdle Rate Podcast

53 min Listen to the original Episode page
Credit MarketsBitcoin TreasuryValuation ModelsDigital CreditMarket Liquidity

Summary

Hosts Matt Cole and Jeff Walton analyze rising credit spreads, noting Triple C yields surged 400 basis points to 17.8% due to AI capital demand and Treasury liquidity issues. They argue digital credit instruments like SATA are mispriced as investment-grade assets offering attractive yields. The speakers critique static valuation metrics for Bitcoin treasury companies, advocating for discounted cash flow models based on Bitcoin growth assumptions. They also address market volatility, attributing price drops to technical factors like warrant exercises rather than forced selling, and highlight the high beta nature of leveraged trading vehicles.

Episode sections

  1. 0:24 – 2:56

    Market Overview and Recent Events

    Discussion of market environment on Election Day, November 3, 2026, including Bitcoin acquisitions by Strategy, Strive, and Tether, and Binance hack coverage.

  2. 2:56 – 7:42

    Credit Market Stress and Liquidity

    Analysis of rising credit spreads, Triple C yields surging 400 basis points to 17.8%, and AI sector capital demand driving up costs.

  3. 7:42 – 11:03

    Digital Credit as a Solution to Credit Stress

    Argument that digital credit instruments like SATA are mispriced relative to their investment-grade risk, offering yield alternatives.

  4. 11:03 – 23:22

    Bitcoin's Role and Market Perception

    Discussion on Bitcoin's perception as a risk asset and its stability evidenced by market resilience after the Binance hack.

  5. 23:22 – 28:15

    Valuation Methodologies and DCF Modeling

    Proposal to use discounted cash flow models based on Bitcoin growth assumptions for valuing preferred equity streams.

  6. 28:15 – 30:40

    Investor Framework and Conclusion

    Advice on balancing complex math with faith in Bitcoin appreciation and management execution for digital credit growth.

  7. 30:40 – 33:05

    Valuation Methodologies for Bitcoin Treasury Companies

    Argument that valuation requires active management of financial instruments beyond simple balance sheet metrics.

  8. 33:05 – 35:50

    Discrepancies in Valuation Metrics

    Illustration of conflicting signals from MNAV and Bitcoin value multiples, highlighting valuation complexity.

  9. 35:50 – 42:15

    Critique of CEBE Framework and Gross/Net MNAV

    Demonstration that simplistic metrics like Gross MNAV and CEBE can be broken by extreme financing decisions.

  10. 42:15 – 46:40

    Market Reaction to ATM Issuance and Binance Event

    Denial of ATM issuance for loss coverage, attributing volatility to technical factors and external events.

  11. 46:40 – 52:40

    Trading Dynamics of ASST and High Beta Exposure

    Discussion of ASST's high volatility, perpetual leverage, and beta fluctuations based on hedging activities.

Assets discussed

AssetKindStanceContext
BitcoinBTCcryptomixedOver the past week, Strategy acquired 811 Bitcoin. Strive purchased 124. And Tether now has 150,000 Bitcoin.
AlphabetGOOGLequityneutralThis is just how preferred equity works, whether you're Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, whether you're Bank of America, whether you're Google issuing preferred equity, whether you're Striver or Strategy, you ain't gonna declare bankruptcy.

“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.

Claims worth verifying

Strategy acquired 811 Bitcoin in the past week.

Unidentified speaker ·0:38

How to verify: Check Strategy's (MicroStrategy) public Bitcoin holdings report or SEC filings for the week ending November 3, 2026.

Strive purchased 124 Bitcoin in the past week.

Unidentified speaker ·0:42

How to verify: Check Strive Asset Management's public Bitcoin holdings report or press releases for the week ending November 3, 2026.

Tether holds 150,000 Bitcoin.

Unidentified speaker ·0:45

How to verify: Check Tether's official proof-of-reserves reports or blockchain analytics firms like Glassnode for Tether's Bitcoin holdings.

Binance experienced a $6 billion hack across several cryptocurrencies.

Unidentified speaker ·1:23

How to verify: Check Binance's official incident reports, security announcements, or major news outlets covering the event in late October/early November 2026.

US 10-year Treasury yield was around 4.92% at the time of recording.

Unidentified speaker ·3:27

How to verify: Check US Treasury yield data from the Federal Reserve Economic Data (FRED) or Bloomberg for November 3, 2026.

Triple C yields increased by approximately 400 basis points since the beginning of September.

Unidentified speaker ·4:05

How to verify: Check high-yield credit spread data from ICE BofA Index or Bloomberg for Triple C rated bonds between September 2026 and November 2026.

The all-in yield on Triple C risk was about 17.8% at the time of recording.

Unidentified speaker ·4:15

How to verify: Calculate the sum of the risk-free rate (US 10Y) and the Triple C credit spread from ICE BofA Index data for November 2026.

Triple C yields were around 12.5% in November of the previous year.

Unidentified speaker ·4:41

How to verify: Check historical high-yield credit spread data from ICE BofA Index for November 2025.

SATA was the fifth most traded preferred equity late last week.

Unidentified speaker ·17:46

How to verify: Check trading volume data for SATA from the exchange where it is listed (e.g., Nasdaq or OTC) for the week prior to November 3, 2026.

Fannie Mae preferred equity (FNMA) trades at approximately $8 with a par value of $25.

Unidentified speaker ·19:40

How to verify: Check the current market price of Fannie Mae Preferred Stock (FNMA) on financial data platforms like Yahoo Finance or Bloomberg.

The company is trading at a 1.5x multiple on Net Asset Value (MNAV) as of the close of the previous day.

Unidentified speaker ·33:35

How to verify: Check the company's latest 10-Q or 10-K filing for total assets, preferred equity at face value, and market cap to calculate MNAV.

The company's market cap is 0.8x the fair market value of its Bitcoin holdings.

Unidentified speaker ·34:19

How to verify: Divide the company's current market capitalization by the total Bitcoin holdings multiplied by the spot price of Bitcoin at the time of the statement.

The implied compound annual growth rate (CAGR) for Bitcoin, based on current stock price and zero intrinsic business value, is 25%.

Unidentified speaker ·34:54

How to verify: Perform a discounted cash flow analysis using the company's current stock price, expected Bitcoin yield, and assuming zero terminal value for the business structure to solve for the Bitcoin growth rate.

A preferred equity instrument paying 100% interest could result in a positive net Bitcoin yield if the interest rate exceeds Bitcoin's expected cost of capital.

Unidentified speaker ·36:19

How to verify: Calculate the net yield by subtracting the cost of capital (100%) from the expected Bitcoin return; verify if the resulting yield is positive under specific Bitcoin return assumptions.

ASST had $40 million in volume in the first 10 minutes of trading on the Friday following the Binance hack.

Unidentified speaker ·48:52

How to verify: Check ASST's trading volume data from a financial data provider (e.g., Bloomberg, Yahoo Finance) for the specific trading session following the Binance hack event.

ASST's 90-day beta to Bitcoin was approximately 1.84-1.85 before the warrant period and dropped to 1.18-1.2 during the warrant period.

Unidentified speaker ·49:56

How to verify: Calculate the 90-day rolling beta of ASST stock returns against Bitcoin returns for the specified periods using historical price data.

The first drain of the Binance hack started on a Friday morning.

Unidentified speaker ·47:46

How to verify: Review news reports and blockchain analysis from Binance regarding the timeline of the hack and the first detected unauthorized transactions.

SATS was launched with a ~16% cost of capital (interest rate).

Unidentified speaker ·43:54

How to verify: Check the prospectus or offering documents for the SATS preferred equity issuance to confirm the stated interest rate or yield.

Do your own research

  • Verify current Triple C yield spreads and 10-year Treasury yields via Bloomberg or Federal Reserve H.15 data.
  • Review Strategy (formerly MicroStrategy) and Strive Technologies recent Bitcoin acquisition filings (8-K) for balance sheet impact.
  • Check Binance official announcements and audit reports regarding the $6 billion hack coverage and user fund safety.
  • Analyze SATA prospectus and credit ratings to assess the 'investment grade' risk classification versus junk bond spreads.
  • Compare DCF valuation models against MNAV metrics for Bitcoin treasury companies using independent financial data.
  • Examine ASST trading volume and warrant exercise disclosures to understand volatility drivers during market events.
  • Review Fannie Mae preferred equity dividend history and regulatory capital requirements to understand recapitalization expectations.
Full transcriptexpand
0:24
Unidentified speaker: Welcome back to the Hurdle Rate.
0:26
Unidentified speaker: It's election day in America.
0:28
Unidentified speaker: It's November 3rd, 2026.
0:30
Unidentified speaker: This is episode 80.
0:32
Unidentified speaker: I'm Tim Kotzman.
0:33
Unidentified speaker: I'm here with Matt Cole, Jeff Walton, and Ben Workman.
0:38
Unidentified speaker: Over the past week, Strategy acquired 811 Bitcoin.
0:42
Unidentified speaker: Strive purchased 124.
0:45
Unidentified speaker: And Tether now has 150,000 Bitcoin.
0:49
Unidentified speaker: Jeff, what are your thoughts on this beautiful election day?
0:54
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, uh, you know, there's so much going on.
0:57
Unidentified speaker: And uh Matt and Ben and myself, we were we were on a call for about uh two hours prior to this, uh just talking about the market in general.
1:05
Unidentified speaker: We're here recording, this is Election Day, it's Tuesday, November 3rd.
1:08
Unidentified speaker: Uh so we wanted a day to absorb you know what's happened on Monday and and so we could talk about what's going on in the market today as we're um you know digesting all of the all of the changes in the marketplace.
1:20
Unidentified speaker: Uh obviously there was a a big hack last week as well.
1:23
Unidentified speaker: So Binance largest hack in Bitcoin history, six billion dollar hack on Binance across several different cryptocurrencies.
1:31
Unidentified speaker: Uh the big story there is that uh no uh users of Binance are losing any funds.
1:39
Unidentified speaker: Apparently Binance is taking care of that 100% on balance sheet, which is I I think just really good for the entire broad crypto industry, uh, that we're not seeing a huge failure of one of the largest exchanges out in the marketplace.
1:52
Unidentified speaker: But it also just showing um some of the uncertainty out there with business models and the power of AI to disrupt businesses.
2:00
Unidentified speaker: I think Elon Musk has dubbed it every day a zero day.
2:03
Unidentified speaker: And I think we'll continue to see different types of events like that, but it it will likely happen in several other places of uh broader global business.
2:13
Unidentified speaker: Uh and then on top of that, uh VIX is continuing to spike higher.
2:17
Unidentified speaker: There's a lot of volatility in markets, not just in the Bitcoin Treasury land, but across the general broader uh equity and credit ecosystem.
2:25
Unidentified speaker: And this is something we've been watching very closely.
2:27
Unidentified speaker: We we've been watching as triple C spreads, so high yield credit spreads are blowing out and they're shifting higher.
2:34
Unidentified speaker: Uh, and it's something that we're acutely focused on.
2:37
Unidentified speaker: And Matt, maybe I'll pass it over to you to dive into the thought process around credit spreads, thinking about the discrepancy between high yield and investment grade and what kind of signal that is for the market and like the difference between liquidity and credit quality and how how we start to think about those components.
2:56
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, there's this is a really important thing.
2:59
Unidentified speaker: And I think when you think about strategy and strive as digital credit issuers, that we are obviously active in income markets, that it's probably one of the most important places to always be looking about what's happening.
3:12
Unidentified speaker: And so there's three different things that are happening.
3:16
Unidentified speaker: One, we've already been covering this, but you have the liquidity issues in the long end of the treasury markets, which right now you have long end rates that are that are coming down a little bit.
3:27
Unidentified speaker: Right now, the the US 10 years around 4.92.
3:31
Unidentified speaker: And I think it's been coming down partially because of stress in the broader markets and actually a hunt for safety, which is kind of funny because the risk-free rates obviously have not been a great uh place to go for safety.
3:45
Unidentified speaker: But right now I think there is a little bit of that trade happening.
3:48
Unidentified speaker: Um, but you know, you have, I would say, worse than average liquidity conditions and long-in rates.
3:54
Unidentified speaker: You compare that also with your point, Jeff, on triple C yields.
3:58
Unidentified speaker: So basically the yields that where people view the credit risk to be uh the worst.
4:05
Unidentified speaker: Um and what's interesting there is that over the course of the last two months, so let's say since the beginning of September, triple C yields are up about 400 basis points.
4:15
Unidentified speaker: So the the all-in yield, so the credit spread plus the risk-free rate right now is about 17.8% on triple C risk.
4:25
Unidentified speaker: If you were to go back to the start of September, it was less than 15%.
4:30
Unidentified speaker: Uh so that is a a real credit stress event.
4:33
Unidentified speaker: Um, and if you look at it before that, so before September, call it back to November of last year.
4:41
Unidentified speaker: So call it when when SATA IPO'd, um, it actually back in November of last year was around 12.5%.
4:47
Unidentified speaker: So it went from like 12.5% to 14.5% over, if we're called last November to September, and then blew out about 400 basis points over a couple months.
4:56
Unidentified speaker: So it is real credit uh stress.
4:59
Unidentified speaker: You also talked about the VIX, and so there's a a volatility event.
5:03
Unidentified speaker: Um, and when you look at at yield markets, debt markets, there's really two different places to look.
5:12
Unidentified speaker: One is the data centers.
5:13
Unidentified speaker: And so on the data centers, you basically have infinite demand for capital.
5:18
Unidentified speaker: Uh Fong, I think just before we started recording, put out a post on capital raising and how last year strategy was the biggest capital raiser.
5:27
Unidentified speaker: And then this year, the AI companies, uh, most notably SpaceX, but um, you know, other ones as well, have been where the capital has been flowing.
5:37
Unidentified speaker: And what's interesting about that capital, and a lot of people in our space have covered this, is that they're not yield sensitive because the return opportunity that they see is so high that they're basically just like, give me capital at any cost.
5:51
Unidentified speaker: And so their cost of capital is rising.
5:53
Unidentified speaker: There's obviously stress and concern in that market right now if the AI bubble is over or not.
5:59
Unidentified speaker: Um, I think that that it's going to continue to get funded at scale.
6:03
Unidentified speaker: But regardless, the the rates there are going higher.
6:06
Unidentified speaker: Then on the other side, you have companies in the AI boom that are that their models at risk.
6:12
Unidentified speaker: So, like software companies.
6:13
Unidentified speaker: And so their credit risk has gone up.
6:15
Unidentified speaker: So, but on both sides, you have credit spreads going higher and you have treasury yield liquidity worsening.
6:21
Unidentified speaker: That's just a, I would say, a difficult environment for uh credit spreads generally.
6:26
Unidentified speaker: And I think it likely has some staying power when you look at the individual components in each of those three dimensions.
6:34
Unidentified speaker: And and Matt, just to hit on that real quick there, for for people following along, there's a huge demand, right?
6:40
Unidentified speaker: So you're effectively saying that there's there's a limited supply of capital.
6:44
Unidentified speaker: There's a huge demand for capital.
6:46
Unidentified speaker: So if you have limited supply and a ton of demand, the price goes higher.
6:50
Unidentified speaker: So the the cost of capital goes higher, particularly for um new business ventures or or financing new things.
6:57
Unidentified speaker: And that capital is going to wherever it's treated best or wherever there's the uh outsized opportunity.
7:05
Unidentified speaker: Would you put it that way?
7:07
Unidentified speaker: That's fair.
7:07
Unidentified speaker: Um, definitely on on where the most of the capital is flowing, which is the data center side, right?
7:12
Unidentified speaker: Which is just like, give me capital, I don't care the cost, the cost goes up.
7:15
Unidentified speaker: Then on the triple C side, you just have business models getting worse, right?
7:20
Unidentified speaker: The models that are getting disrupted from AI.
7:21
Unidentified speaker: So the triple C are worse goes up, but they're kind of both going up together, but for two fundamentally different reasons, right?
7:29
Unidentified speaker: One, the credit risk is increasing.
7:31
Unidentified speaker: The other is there's just more demand, uh, more demand for capital, which means if you want to take more capital, you got to pay a higher rate.
7:39
Unidentified speaker: But on two different sides, those those rates move up.
7:42
Unidentified speaker: And I think the the reality, and I think the good news for us is that Bitcoin, and I think you've seen this with how we've treated SATS as an example, where we've said the amplification ratio of our company is going to be the driver of total returns more so than cost of capital, right?
7:56
Unidentified speaker: That we're seeing this environment play out and you got to be competitive in it.
8:00
Unidentified speaker: And I think one of the great things for our model is that these private deals, these 144A deals, are not available to the average investor, even if you're a high net worth investor.
8:11
Unidentified speaker: And so when you see these data center deals get repriced, well, only institutional investors typically can access most of that capital.
8:19
Unidentified speaker: Um, and so what's left for retail, even high net worth retail, is you know, bank deposits, US treasuries, basically all the crap, or uh triple C, which basically is having their business models attacked.
8:31
Unidentified speaker: And so none of that's attractive, which is why I think you still see the massive ability to grow the size of digital credit, right?
8:39
Unidentified speaker: To let the average investor be able to uh benefit from this rise in yields.
8:45
Unidentified speaker: But make no mistake, from an institutional perspective, the yields are just rising everywhere, right?
8:51
Unidentified speaker: And and so the the nice thing about our companies and is and you know, underwriting Bitcoin is that the risk is mispriced, right?
8:58
Unidentified speaker: That the risk has historically traded.
9:01
Unidentified speaker: I mean, if you were to look at a chart of the spread of SATA versus triple C yields, what you would find is that historically they've kind of traded pretty similar.
9:12
Unidentified speaker: I view I view our risk to be investment grade risk.
9:14
Unidentified speaker: Um, I think strategy's balance sheet is like basically unbreakable, right?
9:18
Unidentified speaker: And and ours is, I would say, is definitely investment grade, if not better, when you look at it, but it's priced at a different spread.
9:24
Unidentified speaker: But that, but the triple Cs have gone up and and ours hasn't.
9:28
Unidentified speaker: I think there's a couple of different reasons for that.
9:30
Unidentified speaker: One, because the average investor doesn't have access to that type of of yield products.
9:34
Unidentified speaker: But two, I think that it's actually our our risk has been repriced better.
9:39
Unidentified speaker: And I think that might be different than the narrative that the average person sees.
9:43
Unidentified speaker: That you look at, you know, the stretch repricing, struggling to hit par, you know, the buybacks of, you know, is is there um what's happening here?
9:52
Unidentified speaker: I actually think that it's been a smashing success when you look at the broader credit markets, which really have been uh struggling.
9:59
Unidentified speaker: And I think in our industry, we we tend to look within our own bubble, but we don't look at what's happening in the bigger picture.
10:04
Unidentified speaker: And the bigger picture, it's it's actually really, really bad.
10:08
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, we'll we'll have to post this, uh, post the image that we're talking about.
10:11
Unidentified speaker: It's the triple C option adjusted spread.
10:14
Unidentified speaker: And we'll we'll put digital credit against it so you can see how the spreads have changed over time.
10:17
Unidentified speaker: It's really vertical.
10:19
Unidentified speaker: The last couple of months, triple triple C spreads have gone vertical.
10:23
Unidentified speaker: And this is kind of what we were talking about a couple of weeks ago when we issued and launched SATS.
10:26
Unidentified speaker: We were out in the market when uh credit investors were literally telling us that, hey, you know, high yields are blowing out.
10:34
Unidentified speaker: Like, are you sure you're gonna get this deal done?
10:36
Unidentified speaker: And ultimately we got it over the finish line.
10:38
Unidentified speaker: And I think the fact that it is a differentiated um business model, I think also does help us relative to the data centers.
10:46
Unidentified speaker: I've thought for a long time that uh the digital credit instruments would help reset the cost of credit capital for the entire market.
10:52
Unidentified speaker: Turns out it's it's digital credit and data centers at the same time.
10:56
Unidentified speaker: It's really this kind of AI digital capital future uh that it's that is truly resetting the the cost of credit capital.
11:03
Unidentified speaker: Well, I I think that you're seeing that as large as the steps have been made to reposition Bitcoin as capital in the market, anytime that there's stress out there in the market, it defaults back to the risk bucket.
11:16
Unidentified speaker: And so when you're starting to see all these credit spreads blow out, you know, in different sectors of the market, I do think people still look back to Bitcoin and they see it as a risk asset.
11:26
Unidentified speaker: So if you're building credit on top of it right now, I don't think the markets had that sentiment shift where they view this the same way we do, you know, where we would look at this and say investment grade, look at the strength of the balance sheet.
11:36
Unidentified speaker: I think they still throw it into the risk category.
11:38
Unidentified speaker: But I think that changes over time, right?
11:41
Unidentified speaker: I do think it's partially going to be a track record component here to changing that narrative out there in the market.
11:48
Unidentified speaker: Because what you're probably gonna see is with a lot of this disruption out there, you know, they're pricing in the disruption of all of the cash flows from all these other businesses.
11:56
Unidentified speaker: The difference is we're building these products on top of a balance sheet that's already holding, you know, more than a decade of the asset needed to service the obligations that we have out there.
12:06
Unidentified speaker: So as the speed of disruption picks up and you start to see those high yields pricing higher and higher, clearly we're in a stress event right now because, to your point, Jeff, of how fast those rates moved up, you know, right at the time we were launching SATS out there in the market, which is actually a huge testament to the way that investors were seeing these products, right?
12:25
Unidentified speaker: The stress in that segment of the market is gonna force investors to start to look elsewhere, right?
12:31
Unidentified speaker: They're gonna have to look at what they see as stable.
12:33
Unidentified speaker: And stable is gonna be built by a track record, right?
12:36
Unidentified speaker: So if you've got these digital credit products out there in the market, they've been meeting their dividend obligations, they've maintained robust coverages and reserves on their balance sheet, the assets performed and held up.
12:48
Unidentified speaker: And I think the stress events you talked about in Bitcoin recently, Jeff, with the Binance hack.
12:53
Unidentified speaker: You know, we had the Cold Guard Act a little while ago.
12:55
Unidentified speaker: These were all failures of corporations, not a failure of Bitcoin.
13:00
Unidentified speaker: And you're seeing the reaction in Bitcoin, I think, start to reflect that because the scale of that Binance hack was so significant.
13:08
Unidentified speaker: You would have expected a much more, a much deeper drawdown and a much more sustained drawdown.
13:13
Unidentified speaker: And that just didn't happen.
13:15
Unidentified speaker: And you're now also starting to see these companies being better stewards, they're holding the capital, the liquid network that also had that hack, they've replaced all of the funds that were removed from there as well.
13:24
Unidentified speaker: So you're starting to see that rebuilding of all these events.
13:28
Unidentified speaker: But what you're not seeing is any structural flaw directly in Bitcoin.
13:32
Unidentified speaker: And so for the companies that are building their balance sheet on the basis of Bitcoin and we're structuring these products around that balance sheet, that strength is going to shine through over time.
13:42
Unidentified speaker: These are all very new, right?
13:43
Unidentified speaker: We're hardly over a year into this.
13:46
Unidentified speaker: We're just coming up on a year for SATA.
13:49
Unidentified speaker: And so we're slowly building that track record.
13:52
Unidentified speaker: A lot of these other credit products have been around for many, many years and they're well-known categories.
13:57
Unidentified speaker: But I do think that as this trend continues and you see more and more disruption, which is gonna cause those yield spreads to likely go even higher, that eventually those institutional investors are going to look for what has been stable in this market and what's been stable at attractive rates, right?
14:16
Unidentified speaker: That's gonna be really important because the rates that are out there on these digital credit products are very attractive no matter how you look at them.
14:23
Unidentified speaker: And when you pair that with a track record of stability, I think ultimately that institutional capital does start to take notice and move this direction.
14:30
Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
14:30
Unidentified speaker: And and it kind of gets to a fundamental thesis that I believe is true, but is actually the inverse of what a lot of people in the digital credit space think will play out.
14:42
Unidentified speaker: And so what I think is going to happen to what you just hit on, Ben, is that the credit spread of digital credit is going to compress relative to other credit products out there.
14:55
Unidentified speaker: And we're seeing this to your point, Jeff, on the triple C versus digital credit, right?
14:59
Unidentified speaker: That that we're actually seeing the digital credit spread relative to junk actually improve, um, which I think if you were to ask the average person just looking in our industry, they would think the opposite is happening.
15:11
Unidentified speaker: Um, but when you think about Elon's uh thing that he said about every day will be day zero, that we are moving into an environment with a debt crisis in the United States, um, exploding technological advancements in AI, a likely more volatile world with credit spreads broadly um moving up with us with you know stress on US treasuries, that is likely going to be an environment with elevated credit yields.
15:42
Unidentified speaker: So the the thought that yields in aggregate are going to move lower, I think the opposite's gonna happen, that yields are gonna move higher, like forget digital credit, just yields overall will move higher and sustain higher.
15:55
Unidentified speaker: Right now we might be in more of a stress environment versus where it ultimately plays out.
16:00
Unidentified speaker: But I think the the thesis of that is that I I don't agree with the notion that as digital credit succeeds, you're going to see the interest rate paid on digital credit move to like seven or eight percent.
16:14
Unidentified speaker: Because I think that the overall macro conditions of US treasuries and all credit are going to be sustained higher yields.
16:21
Unidentified speaker: And so that's just how it you would expect a debt crisis, which is the whole thesis of the whole company and Bitcoin that we're underwriting, right?
16:29
Unidentified speaker: The debasement trade of how it would play out.
16:31
Unidentified speaker: The good news is that that is the most bullish environment for Bitcoin that you could ever imagine.
16:36
Unidentified speaker: It's like the whole thesis of the debasement trade playing out in real time, right?
16:40
Unidentified speaker: The the furthering of the weight of a debt crisis on sovereign nations, obviously the United States being one of them, potentially not even the, you know, not as bad as some of the other ones, like we've talked about Japan pretty repeatedly, of how Japan's situation is much worse than the United States.
16:56
Unidentified speaker: Um, but when you think about underwriting a business in that direction, you have to understand the broader macro conditions, which I think is why we've been so clear-minded of how we think about issuing products, of like what is you think about a product, what is the product that people need during a debt crisis?
17:15
Unidentified speaker: They're going to need a really high yield because because the fiat currency uh roller coaster is going to be picking up steam as that weight becomes worse and worse.
17:25
Unidentified speaker: And so um, what do people need?
17:28
Unidentified speaker: You know, do they need stability in a time of crisis or they just need a yield?
17:32
Unidentified speaker: I think I believe that people are just going to need a yield to survive.
17:36
Unidentified speaker: Um, and and we're seeing this in kind of some of the early success where, you know, SATS, I believe, was the fifth most traded preferred equity um late last week.
17:46
Unidentified speaker: Uh put out some metrics on that.
17:48
Unidentified speaker: Um, and it hasn't even paid a dividend yet.
17:49
Unidentified speaker: It's its first record date is later this week.
17:52
Unidentified speaker: Starts paying, I think it's Thursday.
17:55
Unidentified speaker: Um, and then it starts paying a dividend.
17:56
Unidentified speaker: Is that right, Ben?
17:58
Unidentified speaker: Friday's the record date.
17:59
Unidentified speaker: So Thursday would be the last day to buy it because the T plus won't settle that.
18:03
Unidentified speaker: Got it.
18:04
Unidentified speaker: Yes.
18:04
Unidentified speaker: You gotta buy it by Thursday to get the record date on Friday, it starts paying dividends Monday, with the first dividend being, you know, a much larger dividend than it gets into the daily dividend cadence.
18:14
Unidentified speaker: And it's already seen that that demand profile rise up.
18:18
Unidentified speaker: Um, and anyways, I just think it's um it's important to set that framework to understand as a company that's main product is digital credit, how we are going to be operating, right?
18:28
Unidentified speaker: Is we are going to be focused on having a high amplification ratio, paying a higher cost of capital because we believe it's justified and it's kind of the thing that makes the products attractive, I think, to the broadest range of people.
18:41
Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
18:42
Unidentified speaker: And and Matt, I I want to add one thing here, or I would love to get your additional perspective because you were you were telling this story a little bit earlier, and to your point on um expectations, underwriting broader macro environment.
18:53
Unidentified speaker: This is happening everywhere all the time with all assets.
18:56
Unidentified speaker: All institutions are doing this on everything.
18:58
Unidentified speaker: And you brought up a really good anecdote with uh Fanny and Freddie, uh preferred equities that haven't paid a dividend since the great financial crisis.
19:06
Unidentified speaker: Can you just share that story again?
19:08
Unidentified speaker: Because I it's just so unique that this instrument is out there and it's not paying a dividend yet, but it's all based on expectations.
19:16
Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
19:16
Unidentified speaker: So uh Ben Workman and I both come from the world of uh mortgage-backed securities and understand kind of what's been happening at Fannie and Freddie since the great financial crisis.
19:26
Unidentified speaker: And so um Fannie and Freddie have a few preferred equity securities.
19:31
Unidentified speaker: Probably the most well-known is FNA, F Fannie Mae, F N M A S, um, which is uh uh one of the preferred equities of Fannie Mae.
19:40
Unidentified speaker: Um these are non-cumulative preferred equity, and they haven't paid a dividend since the great financial crisis.
19:47
Unidentified speaker: Uh, non-cumulative.
19:48
Unidentified speaker: And right now the Fannie Mae preferred equity trades a little bit above $8 a share.
19:53
Unidentified speaker: Its par value is around $25 a share.
19:56
Unidentified speaker: So it's you know, basically about a third of its par value.
19:59
Unidentified speaker: And it trades effectively as an option that Fannie Mae will be reprivatized in the future because they both make a lot of operating profits today.
20:08
Unidentified speaker: Um, but what's what's important about this in terms of how you think about underwriting the credit risk of RSpace.
20:16
Unidentified speaker: So you think about SATA, SATS, STRC, uh Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac have never declared bankruptcy.
20:23
Unidentified speaker: Uh it's they haven't paid a dividend for going on 20 years.
20:27
Unidentified speaker: Um they still haven't declared bankruptcy.
20:29
Unidentified speaker: Um, and so I think it gets into some of the underwriting and and why we've continually fundamentally pushed back against the kind of the net claims position and underwriting thesis is that the reality is that as a preferred equity investor, you just need to be underwriting if you're going to get paid a dividend.
20:48
Unidentified speaker: Because you should not expect the company to declare bankruptcy if amplification ratio hits 100% or 110% and just liquidate and pay you back, because that would actually be a violation of the company or company's fiduciary duties to the common equity investor, which is where the the fiduciary duties sit.
21:07
Unidentified speaker: And so it's not that there's something funny going on.
21:10
Unidentified speaker: This is just how preferred equity works, whether you're Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, whether you're Bank of America, whether you're Google issuing preferred equity, whether you're Striver or Strategy, you ain't gonna declare bankruptcy.
21:22
Unidentified speaker: You're not gonna liquidate, you're not gonna pay out the claims, you will pay the dividends, and you'll pay the dividends hopefully into perpetuity.
21:29
Unidentified speaker: And we've talked kind of continually about why that risk is mispriced.
21:33
Unidentified speaker: Um, but it gets to the valuations of the equity that if you're not going to liquidate, then looking at the company from a net claims perspective fundamentally misses how the cash flows and the assets of the company will be distributed both to the downside but also to the upside.
21:52
Unidentified speaker: Right.
21:52
Unidentified speaker: And so there's obviously right now, I think there's a huge debate, which I think we should get into of just, you know, valuations, mnavs, and and the reality is that it's really evolving as as really everyone in, but I would say there's absolutely no consensus.
22:08
Unidentified speaker: There's not a consensus amongst the institutional investors, there's not a consensus among the retail investors, there's probably not a consensus among the different Bitcoin treasury companies.
22:18
Unidentified speaker: And so um I think that anytime, forget the issue, whether it's MNAV or anything, if there's that big of a broad array of opinions across basically every type of uh stakeholder and investor that you could find, I think it's it's fair to say that you know, you really have to get back to first principles and you have to continually expect that this industry is evolving.
22:41
Unidentified speaker: And I think that that evolving nature is is good.
22:44
Unidentified speaker: Um, but maybe I could kick it back over to you, Jeff, on this is that, you know, there's and and I would say we're just we're putting in a ton of work and there's a ton of different metrics.
22:55
Unidentified speaker: And um really ultimately trying to underwrite the best way to make capital decisions, obviously, for the common equity investor.
23:04
Unidentified speaker: Um, there's the gross MNAV metrics, there's the net claims metrics, there's maybe something in between.
23:10
Unidentified speaker: I think um, you know, you've been kind of exploring something in between.
23:12
Unidentified speaker: Maybe you could uh kind of tease out, which I I think is fundamentally ultimately going to be the best way, but I think no one is looking at at the in-between right now.
23:22
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, it it it asks the question is uh, you know, how do you how do you view valuation in in several different directions, right?
23:30
Unidentified speaker: You've got different, you've got EV MNEV, you've got uh Bitcoin fair market value MNEV, uh how do you value EV?
23:39
Unidentified speaker: Like do you back out cash?
23:40
Unidentified speaker: What is the value of the preferred claims?
23:41
Unidentified speaker: How do you value the preferred claims?
23:43
Unidentified speaker: And one of the one of the ways I've been starting to go about this is looking at the present value of future cash flows as a function of the value of the preferred equity.
23:55
Unidentified speaker: So what is the value of the preferred equity?
23:58
Unidentified speaker: Uh, thinking about the present value of future cash flows discounted using the company's view of uh Bitcoin compounding annual growth rate into the future.
24:09
Unidentified speaker: So if you're if you subscribe to this concept, uh you would discount uh those future cash flows pretty heavily because you would we're underwriting Bitcoin going up 30 to 50% compounded annually into the future, depending on your horizon or your view.
24:26
Unidentified speaker: So by taking that uh conceptual framework, you're able to back into a pure valuation model on what is the valuation of the balance sheet if you discounted the the future cash flows back to today based on the size of the balance sheet, the amplification, the relativity of the preferred on the balance sheet.
24:46
Unidentified speaker: Now that is in isolation, giving zero additional value for uh the operational structure, the team, uh, the securities that are in the environment, uh the other business assets, and effectively the operating business associated with it.
25:05
Unidentified speaker: So I I think that's probably one of the more efficient ways to look at a valuation metric is uh putting a putting an assumption on your Bitcoin Kagger into the future, which we're we're underwriting, discounting the stream of future cash flows to that perspective, uh, and then having some additional uh kicker for everything else, the the additional value of a business that sits on top of it.
25:32
Unidentified speaker: And and I think that starts to give some framework of um this may be a uh you know, the price of the security, the price of the common stock may be trading cheaply, the price of the common stock may be trading uh more rich, and it may give some framework around decision making.
25:48
Unidentified speaker: So I think that the reality is that the the net, I call it the C E B E metrics or the gross metrics, they're too crude.
25:56
Unidentified speaker: And you would never value any traditional business just based on something that's that crude in either direction, right?
26:02
Unidentified speaker: This is not a criticism in either thing as being the right direction.
26:06
Unidentified speaker: Any traditional company, you would look at the tradition the future cash flows, you would make assumptions, you would have an operating model, you would discount them back to the present, and that would present a valuation of the company.
26:19
Unidentified speaker: Um, I think when you when you take your framework, it's kind of applying traditional corporate corporate valuation structure of kind of discounted cash flow modeling into a Bitcoin model.
26:31
Unidentified speaker: And so it's to be clear, it's not pretending that there is no cost to preferred equity.
26:36
Unidentified speaker: You are actually explicitly underwriting the actual cost of the preferred equity in this instrument, but as a stream of cash flows, a stream of dividends, not as a liquidation preference that will never happen, right?
26:48
Unidentified speaker: Like the like you're actually underwriting the actual thing that will happen, which is the dividends are going to be paid, right?
26:53
Unidentified speaker: To every extent that you possibly can.
26:55
Unidentified speaker: And then you're also have to look into your expectations of the future price of Bitcoin, because that really matters in the structure.
27:04
Unidentified speaker: Um, you you really, if you want to invest in a company like Strive or Strategy, you need to be bullish on Bitcoin.
27:12
Unidentified speaker: If you're not bullish on Bitcoin, the structure doesn't make any sense, right?
27:17
Unidentified speaker: Like um because there is a cash flow stream associated with, so you put those two things together.
27:23
Unidentified speaker: And I guess the the TLDR is that if you even think Strive's bear case is true, you would look at our common equity right now and say it's cheap.
27:32
Unidentified speaker: It's cheap to the fair market value of the Bitcoin.
27:34
Unidentified speaker: There is assumption after assumption after assumption in these things.
27:39
Unidentified speaker: And I think it's why people need to really think about their own assumptions of the price of Bitcoin, their their holding period, you know, all of these different things.
27:49
Unidentified speaker: But as a company, when I look at you know, our stock today, it's at like 21 bucks a share and Bitcoin's at $77,000.
27:59
Unidentified speaker: I view our stock to be trading at a discount to its fair market value today, under a future forward-looking valuation model of the dividend stream of our future expectations to Bitcoin.
28:09
Unidentified speaker: Um, and and it's important to understand that because there's kind of two competing things here.
28:15
Unidentified speaker: One, you know, the stock trading at a discount, but two, the business model, and I think this is a real thing that's part of the decision making matrix, and I think sometimes people also mix, miss, is that the business model hinges on being able to successfully grow digital credit, right?
28:34
Unidentified speaker: And sometimes you have to invest in making a win for digital credit in a way that in in in the interim, you know, may not be the just like ignore the fact that there are real people, there are real investors, and you have a real product out there and just say, like, look at the math and like do you know what the math says.
28:53
Unidentified speaker: The reality is that if you if you if you only viewed that, you would likely end up over time turning off different investors to the detriment of the overall long-term vision of the company, right, which would then impair the shareholder value.
29:07
Unidentified speaker: And so I would just say that like this whole thing is complex, but I but I think that to kind of bring it back to reality is for people that there's our our hurdle listeners span the spectrum of the biggest of math nerds that would want to just go deep with us on this for two hours to like the just like I'm just living my life and I want to make an investment.
29:28
Unidentified speaker: And and I'd say for the people that are on the I'm just living my life, I want to make an investment, if you're investing in SpaceX, you don't need to understand how to build a rocket.
29:38
Unidentified speaker: Like what you need to have is a high level faith in the thesis.
29:42
Unidentified speaker: So for Strive, a high level faith in Bitcoin's gonna go up, and then trust in the management team to execute.
29:49
Unidentified speaker: And if you have those two things, you really have enough.
29:52
Unidentified speaker: You don't need to understand all of the calculus that underlies it.
29:55
Unidentified speaker: But I think as a company, we want to give a transparent view into our minds.
30:02
Unidentified speaker: But the reality is that this is going to be getting more complex.
30:07
Unidentified speaker: The math here is more complex, not simpler.
30:11
Unidentified speaker: But the math to you know, to for Elon to make a rocket that gets successfully into space, it's more complex as well.
30:17
Unidentified speaker: And I think that's a that is a good thing, not a bad thing, but you have to kind of understand how deep you want to go.
30:23
Unidentified speaker: If you want to go deep, you know, we're gonna get we're gonna go deep with you guys, but if if you're also kind of glazing over, I don't think you have to understand the depthness to feel comfortable with the investment.
30:33
Unidentified speaker: I think what we're learning is this is both the simplest and most complex model to value that's out there at the market, right?
30:40
Unidentified speaker: We've been seeing this debate going on for years.
30:42
Unidentified speaker: It's part of the reason why I look at the conversation around what is a pure play Bitcoin treasury company.
30:49
Unidentified speaker: And I don't think that exists, right?
30:51
Unidentified speaker: I think that there was this notion back in the day that when the model was simply going to be issue common equity at a premium and that made you a pure play Bitcoin treasury company.
31:01
Unidentified speaker: This has evolved so much further now, where you're creating new product categories out there in the market, you're activating your team to go out there and be the sales force to effectively educate the market on the risk structure around this type of a model and helping to show why the instruments that we're creating, enabled by a balance sheet full of Bitcoin, is the right product for a lot of investors that are out there that are seeking income.
31:27
Unidentified speaker: And when you think about that, and then you blend it with the need to manage all of your metrics to optimize for the best total returns over time.
31:37
Unidentified speaker: That's where this becomes a lot of art, right?
31:40
Unidentified speaker: It's art and science both meshed in at once.
31:43
Unidentified speaker: But you need to be able to have a team that's gonna be able to actively manage that and understand it at a very deep level to figure out what are the optimal levels at different at different times within the Bitcoin cycle to capture the maximum amount of excess return for the shareholders.
32:00
Unidentified speaker: And that's where I think that these new models are really gonna come into play because if all you're doing is valuing a company on the basis of the asset sitting on the balance sheet and edited of all the claims today, you know, you're you're evaluating something that has absolutely no structure to produce future returns.
32:18
Unidentified speaker: And in this model, there's the structure of putting on the amplification.
32:23
Unidentified speaker: You've got the carry from what we see from the KAG or Bitcoin relative to the cost of capital.
32:28
Unidentified speaker: But also along the way, you do still have the tool where you may get these premium events on the common equity that you can capture, which is additionally adding intrinsic or book value to your shares at the same time, which is another component to add into that valuation model.
32:44
Unidentified speaker: And so it's very complex and you have to measure it and you have to be monitoring the markets constantly to figure out when is the right time to make each move.
32:52
Unidentified speaker: This is a very active strategy.
32:54
Unidentified speaker: Well, I think a lot of people actually look at it and feel like it's a passive one and it's anything but.
32:59
Unidentified speaker: So just for perspective, I'm gonna get a little into the math because Matt talks about, you know, we get a little bit nerdy here.
33:05
Unidentified speaker: So I just want to explain like the conundrum, right?
33:08
Unidentified speaker: So the different discrepancies in the views.
33:12
Unidentified speaker: So if you took the preferred equity at face value and you took uh the total treasury, so if you if you thought about typical MNAV, multiple on net multiple of net asset value, you take your total treasury assets plus the preferred equity at face value, and then it's what is the market cap of the company trading relative to that net number, total assets minus the preferred equity at face value.
33:35
Unidentified speaker: As of today, uh, or as of close yesterday, that number is that a multiple of 1.5x.
33:44
Unidentified speaker: So from that perspective, you would say the company is trading at a premium because it the market cap of the company is trading at a premium relative to the net asset value.
33:53
Unidentified speaker: Now, as Matt mentioned earlier, uh we we think it it's trading cheaply.
33:58
Unidentified speaker: So, okay, like what's the discrepancy?
34:00
Unidentified speaker: How do you get to the discrepancy?
34:02
Unidentified speaker: Okay, let's go to the complete opposite end of the spectrum.
34:04
Unidentified speaker: You could think about what is the multiple of the market cap relative to just like Bitcoin fair market value.
34:10
Unidentified speaker: That's another way you could potentially look at the company, is just like the assets that sit on the balance sheet.
34:15
Unidentified speaker: Is the company, what is the company's valuation relative to the assets that sit on the balance sheet?
34:19
Unidentified speaker: If you took that perspective uh on just a Bitcoin value, that multiple is 0.8.
34:26
Unidentified speaker: Okay, so now you got two different views.
34:28
Unidentified speaker: One says you're at a premium, one says you're at a discount, and one says you're cheap.
34:32
Unidentified speaker: Okay, now let's let's try to think about in between.
34:36
Unidentified speaker: What if you discounted uh the stream of future cash flows to what the market says the the mark the value of the company is today?
34:44
Unidentified speaker: What is the implied compound annual growth rate used as a discount to get what the stock market the stock is implying today?
34:54
Unidentified speaker: And as of today, that implied market value is 25% compound annual growth rate for Bitcoin's future, assuming zero additional value for the intrinsic value of the business itself, the structure, the management team, the ability to accrete more additional value or utilize the capital into the future.
35:12
Unidentified speaker: So that would be a conservative view on Kagger valuing the value of the company at zero, and just looking at that asset spread between the two.
35:20
Unidentified speaker: So that I mean, if I were to sum it up, there's a wide variety of different viewpoints.
35:27
Unidentified speaker: Um, and there's some really good statistical math where you can rely on your fundamentals or our house view of Bitcoin in the future.
35:37
Unidentified speaker: One of the ways that I've always liked to challenge ratios, valuation models, is to present a scenario that's basically so laughable and see if it breaks.
35:50
Unidentified speaker: Um, and so you could do this with any metric out there.
35:54
Unidentified speaker: I'm gonna do it with the gross MNAV and the net MNAV.
35:57
Unidentified speaker: I'm gonna do both of them and I'm gonna break both of them just to show it.
36:01
Unidentified speaker: Um so if you if you used the gross metric, which I think is some of the criticisms that's kind of resulted in the CEBE framework, I could technically issue a preferred equity that pays a 100% interest rate, and I could have a net positive Bitcoin yield today.
36:19
Unidentified speaker: So I could I could do SAP B, the new strike preferred equity pays 100% interest rate, um, greater than our Bitcoin expected cost of capital, and I go sell a billion dollars of it and I report a net Bitcoin yield today.
36:32
Unidentified speaker: Um that would clearly be an a very not clearly, it would very likely be a dumb financing decision to pay 100% interest rate perpetually into the future, but I could generate a Bitcoin yield.
36:43
Unidentified speaker: And so the CEBE minded people would say, well, you're that pretends that there's no cost, which there's some truth to that.
36:52
Unidentified speaker: Um then the other side would say, Well, if I sold the preferred equity at if I'm and I'm gonna take down the CEB frame framework for a second, if I sold the preferred equity with a 0.5% interest rate, but I sold it at 99 cents on the dollar, so my effective price was you know 0.55% perpetually into the future, it would have a negative C E B E yield on its face.
37:19
Unidentified speaker: It would look like a bad decision because it would take the full cost of it today.
37:23
Unidentified speaker: It would, it would, it would on a claims adjusted basis re reduce your Bitcoin per share per investor.
37:29
Unidentified speaker: That would clearly be a super smart decision to have to never pay a a pay back the principal and basically be borrowing for free.
37:37
Unidentified speaker: Um, but it would look bad on a on a claims adjusted basis.
37:41
Unidentified speaker: Frankly, even if the interest rate was zero, if I sold something with 0% interest rate, but I sold it at 99 and I had a liquidation preference at 100, I put it all into Bitcoin, it would reduce the CEBE claims, even though I have no interest obligation.
37:56
Unidentified speaker: And so you could clearly see how both of them on their own, they break down because they're too crude of a metric.
38:03
Unidentified speaker: And so you have to do something in between to actually underwrite the true expected value to the company.
38:10
Unidentified speaker: And I think that to be fair to the people that have moved towards a CEB framework, that you can break the gross metric framework.
38:18
Unidentified speaker: And so clearly it was not exclusively right on its own, but then there's like a pendulum swing.
38:24
Unidentified speaker: And so then the pendulum swings to the other direction, it creates the exact opposite problem.
38:29
Unidentified speaker: And then the right answer from just like a how you value a company perspective is in the middle because clearly, if our thesis is right, selling digital credit at a, you know, call it a 13, 15, 16% type sort of a yield, if the whole thesis around Bitcoin is right, it's a good decision.
38:49
Unidentified speaker: And so that should accrue value to the company if you're a Bitcoin bull.
38:53
Unidentified speaker: Um, but you need a metric that actually shows it.
38:55
Unidentified speaker: Um, and the reality is that a lot of math, a lot of assumptions have to be made to go into that if that's true.
39:02
Unidentified speaker: But I think that it would be incorrect to try to simplify things to just for simplicity's sake.
39:09
Unidentified speaker: That would result in bad decision making and it would result in the net destruction of value.
39:14
Unidentified speaker: You can't uh, you know, you can't, you can't to, you know, like they say, you can't pump, pump people's bags if you're uh you know, if you're focused on arithmetic, but you need calculus to actually provide value, right?
39:26
Unidentified speaker: Like you actually have to be uh good at the at the type of decision making that you need to to accrue value to the common equity shareholders.
39:34
Unidentified speaker: And that the reality is that that requires um great execution in in deep math.
39:40
Unidentified speaker: And I think that as an industry, I think people underestimated that.
39:44
Unidentified speaker: And I think it's created kind of a you know, teams with less and less people, less rigorous math work, and and the result is, you know, I think fragile structures.
39:55
Unidentified speaker: Um and you know, we're obviously trying to do something completely different.
39:58
Unidentified speaker: We're also watching a very natural evolution, I think, particularly when you look at an industry that's gone through the cycles that the treasuries have.
40:06
Unidentified speaker: You know, at the first time, I think that it swung way in the aggressive valuation frameworks.
40:12
Unidentified speaker: And then when you saw the drawdown, and particularly what rewind to a year ago when you had kind of the blow-off top in the entire treasury sector, people swung way the other direction.
40:22
Unidentified speaker: And now they're only willing to attribute value to net assets on the balance sheet.
40:28
Unidentified speaker: And the reality is this has evolved significantly over the last year.
40:33
Unidentified speaker: The models that are being put into place, the way value is being delivered down to the shareholders.
40:38
Unidentified speaker: And because of that, it's gonna require more nuance in order to find what is that right middle ground where you can actually capture the engine that's delivering the value as a thesis plays out, right?
40:51
Unidentified speaker: Yes, you're gonna have to make assumptions, you're gonna have to have a position on how you view the future performance of Bitcoin because there's no way around the fact that these strategies are tied to Bitcoin, right?
41:02
Unidentified speaker: We are underwriting the long-term success of Bitcoin and we're putting in a structure that's meant to capture as much of that as possible and deliver it to those common shareholders.
41:11
Unidentified speaker: And because of that, it takes a different type of thinking to value that engine, right?
41:18
Unidentified speaker: It can't be that the value of that engine is simply the balance sheet net of all claims today.
41:23
Unidentified speaker: That's not the appropriate way to capture that.
41:27
Unidentified speaker: But it's also not conducive, I think, in the market to have people have to go into spaces.
41:32
Unidentified speaker: And I've heard this a bunch of times just over the last couple of weeks, where they go in, and it's like the introductory conversation to Bitcoin Treasuries is well, there's an MNAV.
41:41
Unidentified speaker: Well, actually, there's three MNAVs, right?
41:43
Unidentified speaker: And it just you you lose people in that conversation because they don't know what it is they're trying to capture, and several of them aren't net of anything, right?
41:50
Unidentified speaker: So MNAV kind of became this catch-all term that was being used to assign different multiples to different components of the business.
41:58
Unidentified speaker: And so I think that the way, even the way that we saw those MNAVs evolve over time, I think the valuation framework in terms of how do I view a company as cheap or expensive today is now going to change because the value delivery engine is different than it's ever been.
42:15
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, that there was a lot of noise last week uh around, you know, common stock ATM and it was all completely wrong.
42:23
Unidentified speaker: I think they uh uh failed to recognize that we're all very uh that we're all shareholders and we all value the common stock very highly.
42:35
Unidentified speaker: And we're we're thinking about all of this math and data at the same time.
42:38
Unidentified speaker: We're looking at the price of Bitcoin, we're looking at the credit, we're looking at how all of these things are trading, we're looking at the equity, and we're observing the broad market ecosystem and using advanced algorithms to inform us uh at any given point in time.
42:52
Unidentified speaker: And that may change minute to minute um or hour to hour, depending on the data that's available to us.
42:59
Unidentified speaker: So um to add to that, Jeff, you know, I I think one of the things that gets missed out there is there's probably nobody in the market that values our shares the same way that we do.
43:09
Unidentified speaker: Right.
43:10
Unidentified speaker: We see the engine we're building, we see the structure we're putting in place, and we look at the market and say, this is really cheap.
43:15
Unidentified speaker: We don't want to be issuing shares if we don't have to.
43:18
Unidentified speaker: And so you're seeing that during these periods.
43:19
Unidentified speaker: You know, I made a post where it said, you know, there's times to be aggressive and there's times to, you know, ease up.
43:25
Unidentified speaker: And I think that last week was one of those, and particularly because for us as a company, we'd really been pushing very aggressively over the last several weeks.
43:33
Unidentified speaker: You know, we had all the warrants that we're exercising that created a significant amount of additional balance sheet capacity that gave us the ability to get SATS out there in the market.
43:41
Unidentified speaker: We had a successful launch on SATS.
43:43
Unidentified speaker: But when you do that, it does introduce a lot of other technical factors that people need to be aware of.
43:49
Unidentified speaker: You know, one of the questions I kept getting was well, why didn't you issue a lot more SATS last week, right?
43:54
Unidentified speaker: Is 16% too high of a cost of capital with Bitcoin here in the high 70s?
43:58
Unidentified speaker: And my answer to that was absolutely not, right?
44:01
Unidentified speaker: It's not too high of a cost of capital.
44:03
Unidentified speaker: But what you have to take into account is that you just launched a new product into the market, right?
44:07
Unidentified speaker: So you're issuing these new shares to the investors that came in in the IPO.
44:11
Unidentified speaker: You get this distribution phase of these shares where they're now trading hands in the open market, right?
44:16
Unidentified speaker: You get some of the fast money guys that are in there that buy things for IPO discounts, and then they're transferring those shares to the new buyers in the open market, whoever they may be.
44:26
Unidentified speaker: And so you're trying to facilitate the healthiest trading environment around all of your products that you possibly can, right?
44:33
Unidentified speaker: I'm sure there was some rotation from SADEN to SATS because of the interest rate change.
44:37
Unidentified speaker: Some people want the fixed interest rate, the higher interest rate there.
44:40
Unidentified speaker: And so you do have to allow a little bit of breathing in the market to see where is the natural settling point for all of these products as they change hands to their new owners, as the market finds its footing.
44:52
Unidentified speaker: And in the middle of all that, you've got the turmoil that was happening around the Binance activity.
44:57
Unidentified speaker: So there are times where it's the best move to sit and observe and wait because you don't have to force actions, right?
45:06
Unidentified speaker: I think that there's this sentiment out there a lot that people have to be forcing actions.
45:12
Unidentified speaker: And when you're watching, you know, like our common stock draw down like it did, particularly after the Binance event happened, and the talking point becomes, well, you know, they're hitting the ATM.
45:22
Unidentified speaker: Like, that is not a chart pattern where we're hitting the ATM.
45:26
Unidentified speaker: There's just no world where I would be seeing that stock price drawing down like that.
45:30
Unidentified speaker: And I would say, I want to sell more of it.
45:32
Unidentified speaker: Like, no chance, right?
45:33
Unidentified speaker: I've never once seen someone out there on X actually correctly call ATM usage in the market, right?
45:40
Unidentified speaker: And I think the reason is because people are fitting narratives to what they're seeing, right?
45:46
Unidentified speaker: They see something, they want to be able to explain it.
45:49
Unidentified speaker: It's natural to want to be able to point to a direct cause.
45:52
Unidentified speaker: And the easy outlet here is ATM activity, right?
45:55
Unidentified speaker: But it's far more nuanced than that.
45:58
Unidentified speaker: You're always trying to, you know, sell when there's really strong liquidity and strong price action in the market.
46:03
Unidentified speaker: You know, you heard Saylor, it was at one of the Vegas conferences.
46:06
Unidentified speaker: There's been so many that I can't remember exactly which one it was, where somebody asked him, and he goes, you know, if the stock's going down and it's red, it's never me.
46:14
Unidentified speaker: Right.
46:14
Unidentified speaker: I think people miss that is that we want to be selling in the best conditions that we possibly can.
46:19
Unidentified speaker: We want the trading environment to remain healthy, and we value those shares likely higher than anybody else the market does because we see what the potential is and what we're building here.
46:30
Unidentified speaker: So it is a very nuanced conversation.
46:32
Unidentified speaker: And I think it gets distilled down to something that's overly simplistic that's you know meant to fit what people are seeing happening out there in the broader trading environment.
46:40
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, it's it's a great point, Ben.
46:42
Unidentified speaker: And there's just so much going on at all times.
46:44
Unidentified speaker: And the market is all knowing.
46:46
Unidentified speaker: Everybody's front-running everybody all the time, and there's information arbitrage everywhere.
46:50
Unidentified speaker: And and we've built what we've built is uh just a really fascinating trading vehicle for for perpetual leverage against the underlying asset that is on our balance sheet, Bitcoin.
47:00
Unidentified speaker: Um, for perspective, uh the volatility on ASST is higher than many other two and three X leveraged ETFs that have daily resetting mechanisms, which is just a really fascinating um instrument to uh to trade against, especially against an underlying asset that's trading 247,365 with arbitrage between um weekends and uh when the market is closed.
47:29
Unidentified speaker: So, what I'm sharing on my screen right now, I did a timeline analysis of the Binance hack to identify like was there any trading that maybe front run or preceded uh the particular event?
47:41
Unidentified speaker: And the uh the first drain started here on um line two, so the second line.
47:46
Unidentified speaker: And I did find it fascinating that there was a pretty big deviation kind of earlier in the morning here between ASST and Bitcoin and MSTR.
47:54
Unidentified speaker: MSTR is the blue, uh Bitcoin or Bitcoin is the yellow, and the red is ASST.
48:00
Unidentified speaker: So you you have to wonder, right?
48:02
Unidentified speaker: Like whoever hacked Binance knew it was happening, right?
48:06
Unidentified speaker: They're like, I'm gonna go in, I'm gonna hack Binance on Friday morning.
48:10
Unidentified speaker: They probably knew it was there.
48:11
Unidentified speaker: So if you were to do that, where like what positions would you want in like where would you want to position yourself?
48:18
Unidentified speaker: Um I would want to position myself where I had leverage and liquidity to take advantage, like the the most advantage of this event as possible.
48:28
Unidentified speaker: Uh and you know, d did that actually happen?
48:32
Unidentified speaker: I don't know.
48:33
Unidentified speaker: But it it's a data point that you can start to think about how this could be used in both directions.
48:39
Unidentified speaker: That perpetually leveraged exposure that doesn't have a daily resetting mechanism, that doesn't pay a dividend, that pr plays a really uh unique role in the broad global ecosystem.
48:52
Unidentified speaker: And and then last Friday the first 10 minutes of trading, there was 40 million dollars of volume on ASST.
49:01
Unidentified speaker: That was double the volume of all of the other peers, excluding MSTR, combined for the entire day in the first 10 minutes of trading on ASST.
49:13
Unidentified speaker: So like it just shows you that there's so many other players that are out in the market doing different things that you don't necessarily know, uh, but they're but they're there.
49:25
Unidentified speaker: And we've also got a high amplification profile on now, right?
49:29
Unidentified speaker: When we went out and did SATS, we got the investors comfortable with us holding, you know, in a 60 to 70 percent amplification range out there.
49:37
Unidentified speaker: And I think during the period of the warrants, obviously you had a lot of technicals happening there.
49:42
Unidentified speaker: You've got different hedging activities that were happening with all those warrants that were coming up to expiration while they were in the profit, which impacts the trading environment that's out there in the price action that you're gonna see.
49:52
Unidentified speaker: And I think what you're seeing now is we used to have a really high beta to Bitcoin during that period.
49:56
Unidentified speaker: So before that, I think the 90 day was something like 1.84, 1.85 beta to Bitcoin.
50:02
Unidentified speaker: During the warrant period, it dropped down to I think 1.18 to 1.2.
50:07
Unidentified speaker: And now you're seeing that beta re-emerging again now.
50:10
Unidentified speaker: And we're amplifying the moves of Bitcoin in a big way, which is what you would expect because we have high amplification on.
50:16
Unidentified speaker: So relative to the rest of the sector and the rest of our peers, I would always expect that our common stock is moving in a more exaggerated way than what other people are seeing.
50:25
Unidentified speaker: So, you know, it's it's healthy to see that type of activity in the market, right?
50:30
Unidentified speaker: There's no way to amplify where it's not also amplified down, right?
50:34
Unidentified speaker: It's amplified in both directions.
50:36
Unidentified speaker: And particularly when there's unrest in the market, I think that it can be even more amplified than it would have been to begin with.
50:43
Unidentified speaker: And I think you probably saw a lot of that out there.
50:45
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, I I think there's there's been a ton of alpha in this conversation for some of our uh modeling friend nerds, uh fellow modeling friend nerds.
50:55
Unidentified speaker: If you if you really unpack this with that high beta to Bitcoin that you're talking about, Ben, you would expect that that volatility to bring vitality and optionality to astute investors that are willing to actually underwrite this.
51:12
Unidentified speaker: And obviously, you know, we're gonna be pretty transparent in how we view the world, but we're not gonna also tell you exactly what we're gonna do, when we're gonna do.
51:21
Unidentified speaker: That would not be smart from a corporate perspective.
51:24
Unidentified speaker: But I would say that just looking at the trading volatility of our stock, that there is for people that really have a strong finger to the pulse, I think that there is some potential for some real alpha because of this uh this wide array of views from every investor that we're talking about and how they view the world and lack of a consensus, that creates real options for people that are willing to really dig in, which is you know, kind of like the true North 101 of the day, right?
51:52
Unidentified speaker: Of always kind of trying to be one step ahead of an evolving landscape.
51:57
Unidentified speaker: And if you are, um, man, what a what a great opportunity for uh for investors.
52:03
Unidentified speaker: I mean, obviously we're talking about long-term capital allocation, multiple years, but just seeing kind of how this is playing out and this lack of consensus, I do think that, you know, within the the poker table, uh, there will be a few astute investors that are really going to be able to take advantage of some real opportunities that are emerging here.
52:22
Unidentified speaker: That's it.
52:22
Unidentified speaker: That's a wrap.
52:23
Unidentified speaker: Thanks everybody for joining us for episode 80 of the Hurdle Rate, volatility and optionality.
52:30
Unidentified speaker: I think those might be the words of the day.
52:32
Unidentified speaker: For Matt Cole, Jeff Walton, and Ben Workman.
52:35
Unidentified speaker: I'm Tim Kotzman.
52:36
Unidentified speaker: We'll see you back here next week for another edition of the Hurdle Rate.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-GGUF:UD-Q4_K_XL. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights