The Money Show

SA election aftermath, EU auto probe, and JSE decoupling from local economy

1h 13m Listen to the original Episode page
South African PoliticsJSE Market AnalysisEU Trade PolicyAutomotive IndustryAI InvestmentInfrastructureCoalition Governance

Summary

Speakers analyze the instability of multi-party coalitions following South Africa's local elections and the challenges of metro service delivery. They discuss the EU's safeguard investigation into hybrid vehicles, which threatens South Africa's automotive sector despite bilateral agreements. The episode highlights the structural decoupling of the JSE from the local economy, driven by internationally exposed giants like Naspers and mining stocks. Finally, speakers debate the sustainability of AI valuations and the lack of a 'wealth effect' in South Africa due to low household stock ownership.

Episode sections

  1. 0:00 – 7:22

    ANC decline and coalition dynamics

    Discussion on ANC's loss of township support, blame games, and the instability of multi-party coalitions in municipalities like Johannesburg.

  2. 7:22 – 15:42

    Metro service delivery timelines and political constraints

    Outline of a 36-month plan for metro stabilization, prioritizing revenue collection, and analysis of vote fragmentation necessitating complex coalitions.

  3. 15:42 – 18:55

    Market reaction to US midterms and commodity prices

    Analysis of JSE Top 40 rally driven by falling oil prices and gold strength, despite negative earnings from Goldfields and True Value.

  4. 18:55 – 30:35

    High-growth tech and AI investment themes

    Discussion on Optasia's growth, US market reaction to midterms, AI CapEx boom, and regulatory/financing challenges for hyperscalers.

  5. 30:35 – 31:25

    Market Rotation and Defensive Shifts

    Observation of tech/semiconductor declines and capital rotation into defensive sectors like consumer staples and healthcare.

  6. 31:25 – 35:43

    EU Safeguard Investigation into Hybrid Vehicles

    Details on the EU safeguard investigation into hybrid imports from China, affecting South Africa regardless of bilateral agreements.

  7. 35:43 – 44:05

    Low Consumer Adoption of AI Shopping Tools

    Analysis of low consumer adoption of AI agents for shopping due to security concerns and preference for simple interfaces.

  8. 44:05 – 46:21

    South African Local Government Election Aftermath

    Focus on complex and protracted coalition negotiations in key metros like Gauteng and eThekwini.

  9. 46:21 – 54:43

    Infrastructure and Productivity as Economic Constraints

    Argument that poor infrastructure hampers SME productivity, contrasting SA with Morocco and highlighting administrative inefficiencies.

  10. 54:43 – 1:02:31

    Decoupling of JSE from the Local Economy

    Discussion on why JSE performance no longer reflects the local economy due to internationalization of listed companies.

  11. 1:02:31 – 1:04:01

    Disproportionate Impact of Internationally Exposed Companies on the JSE

    Analysis of how mining and dual-listed firms drive the JSE, with nearly 50% of earnings from outside South Africa.

  12. 1:04:01 – 1:07:12

    Market Anchoring and the AI Valuation Debate

    Debate on AI stocks lacking 'real economy' anchoring and the risk of corrections if hype outpaces demand.

  13. 1:07:12 – 1:09:31

    Household Stock Ownership and the Wealth Effect Disconnect

    Explanation of low household stock ownership in SA preventing a 'wealth effect' and exacerbating inequality.

  14. 1:09:31 – 1:13:08

    Retail Participation and the Future of the JSE

    Argument that JSE decoupling is permanent unless retail participation increases, contrasting with US consumer-driven markets.

Assets discussed

AssetKindStanceContext
GoldcommodityneutralGold prices much higher.
Crude oilcommodityneutralThe bigger story, perhaps, is what's been happening with oil prices.
S&P 500indexneutralUm, you know, uh over half of the index SP is AI or AI related.

“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.

Claims worth verifying

ANC lost the township vote, which is described as the 'heart' of the ANC, in areas like Atredville and Tembisa.

Unidentified speaker ·1:12

How to verify: Check official election results from the Independent Electoral Commission (IEC) for specific wards in Atredville and Tembisa.

ANC support is projected to drop below the 40% level achieved in 2024.

Unidentified speaker ·1:54

How to verify: Compare projected local government election results with the 2024 local government election results.

CSIR is not providing specific predictions for election outcomes in Ekurhuleni, Johannesburg, or Tshwane.

Unidentified speaker ·2:24

How to verify: Review CSIR publications or statements regarding the 2026 local government elections.

Johannesburg's municipal turnaround requires a 36-month window to stabilize finances, maintenance, and capital budgets.

Unidentified speaker ·8:57

How to verify: Analyze Johannesburg's municipal budget and service delivery reports over a 3-year period post-election.

The DA is projected to get 23% of the vote and the ANC 30%, totaling 53%, compared to 80% for the top two parties 10-20 years ago.

Unidentified speaker ·10:16

How to verify: Compare current CSIR/SABC election projections with historical election data from 2006-2016.

Goldfields had a significant over 20% increase in all-in costs and slightly low production.

Unidentified speaker ·16:37

How to verify: Review Goldfields' latest quarterly or annual financial results and production reports.

True Value retail sales were down 2.2% and cash sales down 8-9% in the UK and locally.

Unidentified speaker ·17:50

How to verify: Review True Value's latest trading updates or financial results.

Optasia reported a 45% increase in revenues for the nine-month period.

Unidentified speaker ·19:24

How to verify: Review Optasia's latest trading update or financial results.

The US midterms resulted in Congress being in the hands of the opposition, constraining Trump's legislative power.

Unidentified speaker ·24:15

How to verify: Check the composition of the US House of Representatives and Senate following the 2026 midterms.

Anthropic is planning an IPO in the next couple of weeks, trying to raise $1.5 to $2 trillion.

Unidentified speaker ·30:01

How to verify: Check SEC filings or official announcements from Anthropic regarding an IPO.

The EU has started a safeguard investigation into hybrid vehicles due to a surge in imports, largely from China.

Unidentified speaker ·31:25

How to verify: Check European Commission press releases or WTO notification documents for 'safeguard investigation' on hybrid electric vehicles.

Safeguard investigations under WTO rules apply to all countries equally and cannot target specific nations like China alone.

Unidentified speaker ·32:25

How to verify: Review WTO Agreement on Safeguards Article 2.1 regarding non-discriminatory application of measures.

Volkswagen is currently 'battling' in the EU market due to import competition.

Unidentified speaker ·33:53

How to verify: Check Volkswagen AG quarterly earnings reports or EU automotive sales data for 2024/2025.

Only 39 out of 257 municipalities achieved clean audits in the 2022/23 financial year.

Unidentified speaker ·51:43

How to verify: Access the South African Auditor-General's Annual Report on Local Government for the 2022/23 financial year.

Volkswagen has invested over R10 billion in the South African automotive value chain since 2011.

Unidentified speaker ·53:45

How to verify: Check Volkswagen Group South Africa's corporate responsibility reports or press releases regarding investment figures.

Uber reported that only four consumers used AI bots to order during the Halloween weekend.

Unidentified speaker ·40:03

How to verify: Search for Uber earnings call transcripts or press releases from late October 2024/2025 discussing AI feature adoption metrics.

More than 60% of JSE-listed companies' earnings do not come from South Africa.

Unidentified speaker ·59:12

How to verify: Analyze the geographic revenue breakdown in the annual reports of the top 40 JSE-listed companies by market cap.

Morocco's economy grew by over 4% due to prioritized infrastructure investment.

Unidentified speaker ·52:45

How to verify: Check World Bank or IMF economic data for Morocco's GDP growth rates for the relevant period.

The Trump administration confirmed removing the US from a G20-related agreement or process (transcript says 'Goa', likely G20 or similar trade mechanism).

Unidentified speaker ·31:25

How to verify: Search US State Department announcements or White House press releases regarding US withdrawal from international trade bodies or agreements in late 2024/2025.

The Electoral Commission chair, Musutu Meepia, stated that all votes had been counted but not collated.

Unidentified speaker ·45:04

How to verify: Check South African Electoral Commission (IEC) official statements or news reports from the 2026 local election results announcement.

Last year, mining stocks drove the South African stock market index up 40 odd percent.

Grant Nader ·1:02:47

How to verify: Check the performance data of the FTSE/JSE All Share Index or the Mining Index for the calendar year prior to the broadcast date (2025) via JSE or S&P Global Market Intelligence.

South Africa's GDP last year was about just over 1%.

Grant Nader ·1:02:53

How to verify: Consult Statistics South Africa's quarterly GDP release for the relevant year (2025) or IMF World Economic Outlook data.

Less than 10% of earnings for Naspers, Richemont, and British American Tobacco come from South Africa.

Grant Nader ·1:03:20

How to verify: Review the annual financial reports and geographic revenue breakdowns for Naspers, Richemont, and British American Tobacco.

The top 10% of people in the US own 88% of the stock market.

Grant Nader ·1:07:59

How to verify: Check Federal Reserve's Distributional Financial Accounts or Survey of Consumer Finances data on household wealth distribution.

The NASDAQ is down nearly six percent on the day of the broadcast.

Grant Nader ·1:11:29

How to verify: Check historical closing prices for the NASDAQ Composite Index on the broadcast date (2026-11-05) via financial data providers like Bloomberg or Yahoo Finance.

Do your own research

  • Verify the specific scope and timeline of the EU safeguard investigation into hybrid vehicles and its application to South African exporters.
  • Review the latest Auditor-General reports to confirm the percentage of municipalities achieving clean audits and identify administrative inefficiencies.
  • Analyze the earnings breakdown of major JSE constituents (Naspers, Sasol, Mining stocks) to quantify the proportion of revenue derived from international markets.
  • Check recent data on South African household direct stock market participation rates versus institutional ownership.
  • Assess the financing capabilities and regulatory headwinds facing US hyperscalers and AI CapEx projects.
  • Review Volkswagen's investment commitments in the Eastern Cape to evaluate multinational confidence in South Africa's infrastructure.
  • Monitor US midterms' impact on geopolitical risk premiums and oil prices to gauge inflation risks for South African equities.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00
Unidentified speaker: Let's get some views.
0:01
Unidentified speaker: The main story today, really, probably, is the decline in support for the ANC.
0:06
Unidentified speaker: Some surprising changes.
0:19
Unidentified speaker: Robone Tao's a political commentator written about the ANC.
0:23
Unidentified speaker: I suspect more writing to come from Robone over the next little while.
0:27
Unidentified speaker: Mirlani Choleni, the group chief advisor at Inter Consulting Group, both with me now.
0:32
Unidentified speaker: Robone, let me start with you.
0:34
Unidentified speaker: Good evening.
0:35
Unidentified speaker: Do you expect a blame game in the ANC after this?
0:38
Unidentified speaker: Does this in any way shake uh President Sura Ramaporza's leadership of the party?
0:43
Unidentified speaker: Absolutely.
0:44
Unidentified speaker: I see uh a blame game that is going to play out because uh I've been also talking to some of its leaders, you know, and you can see they're very angry, you know, and and I and I think no one wants to take accountability.
0:57
Unidentified speaker: Uh we saw this in 2016.
0:58
Unidentified speaker: So for us to be here, it's nothing surprising because we saw it in 2016, 2021, 2024, and ultimately now, and I think what has uh upset them is that township vote that they've lost.
1:12
Unidentified speaker: Uh the DA and the EFF failed to get the township vote.
1:17
Unidentified speaker: Actually, it shocked many people.
1:19
Unidentified speaker: I mean, uh, we're just talking right now uh at Rejville, where Hochi Ramochopa, Minister of Uh Electricity, is from Gwen Ramochopa is originally from Atredville, you know, big uh prominent people within the ANC.
1:34
Unidentified speaker: Uh, you've got Tembisa, uh, Panyazalu is from Tembisa, they've lost it to actually say.
1:38
Unidentified speaker: I'm told in so in Sowe to uh in one of the zones, I think zone eight, um, they've lost two words, you know.
1:46
Unidentified speaker: Um and and and and I mean this is the hub, the the beat, the heart of the ANC, you know, and and they are going to blame each other.
1:54
Unidentified speaker: And and I think 2027 is going to be very difficult going to that elective conference uh for them, the current sitting leadership, because they dropped 2024 and now they're going to drop below that 40% in 2024.
2:08
Unidentified speaker: May Alani Khalani, um, some places are going to see wholesale change.
2:12
Unidentified speaker: We don't yet know which places those are.
2:15
Unidentified speaker: So it's too soon to call, um, despite the fact that the votes are counted, as the electoral commission chair reminds us, they still have to be collated, they have to go into the system.
2:24
Unidentified speaker: And from what I can see, even the CSIR, brave mathematicians as they are, is not going to tell us what's happening in in Etequini or in Joburg or in Tswane.
2:33
Unidentified speaker: But if there is big change to come in a metro, is that quite disruptive to the actual service delivery?
2:41
Unidentified speaker: So in Mangung, for example, the ANC got the is probably going to get 35%, but they haven't had rubbish collected in regularly for a long time.
2:49
Unidentified speaker: We've had huge problems with some who.
2:52
Unidentified speaker: In Johannesburg, you have a change of government.
2:54
Unidentified speaker: What happens to services?
2:56
Unidentified speaker: Well, I think the wholesale change is certainly coming.
2:58
Unidentified speaker: And I think, you know, from what uh Rebon is also citing, we are seeing at least, you know, uh the changes that uh are coming through.
3:06
Unidentified speaker: Uh you spoke about the US, you know, Texas, you know, turned blue.
3:10
Unidentified speaker: I'm not sure if the color blue has something to do with the uh changes that are coming into also, you know, the South African municipalities.
3:18
Unidentified speaker: That's maybe remains to be seen.
3:20
Unidentified speaker: But what we are seeing is the narrowing of uh votes, you know, in between, you know, who the traditionally big parties are, as well as the up-and-coming parties.
3:28
Unidentified speaker: So the permutations in terms of you know a coalition is I would hope that it would have been two, maximum three parties that can form a coalition.
3:38
Unidentified speaker: Then you don't have a disruption, that much of a disruption in terms of governance, because then it's within at least a smaller uh uh uh court of you know parties.
3:49
Unidentified speaker: But the moment you look at you know how, for instance, the DA leads in other places and it may just need one more party who has the right numbers, then it's a coalition of two.
3:59
Unidentified speaker: If it's not the DA in some of the places, then it's five or six other parties.
4:03
Unidentified speaker: Then you start to now uh pull uh the the coalition into many different you know splinters, difficult to manage, uh lots of ifs and buts, uh and and and second guessing and and vying for positions and so on.
4:18
Unidentified speaker: And that is the very heart of where service delivery is because if there is not co no coherence at the management or the governance, that's where it spills into uh service delivery, it spills into issues of budgeting, it spills into issues of uh you know the finances.
4:35
Unidentified speaker: You don't have a clear message of how that municipality should be running itself.
4:39
Unidentified speaker: Robone, um, both Helen Zilla for the Democratic Alliance, the the Jerobock Merrill candidate and the ANC chair, Gueda Mantashe, also of course a minister in the cabinet, have been doing the rounds of television and radio studios today.
4:52
Unidentified speaker: And what I got from them uh was Gueda Mantashe saying they don't want to work just with the DA because they feel the DA is both in government and in opposition at the same time.
5:01
Unidentified speaker: Hard to fault him on that analysis.
5:03
Unidentified speaker: Um Elon Zilla says they want they don't want to work with many parties because they don't want to be held to ransom.
5:10
Unidentified speaker: They see that as very difficult.
5:12
Unidentified speaker: Um, do you think there's any way that they can find a way to kind of manage those differences in approach?
5:18
Unidentified speaker: No, absolutely.
5:19
Unidentified speaker: And and and I want us to go back to 2021.
5:22
Unidentified speaker: You know, if you remember in 2021 the EFF, for example, said we won't go into coalition, but we're going to beg you to get the mayoral um positions across all the metros in Houten, for an example, right?
5:37
Unidentified speaker: And uh there were too many role players, and that's why we saw uh immediately they all lost those metros at the same time.
5:48
Unidentified speaker: Um Johannesback, uh Tuani, and and and Ekorulen, you know, because in Ekorulen then you had AIC coming in, in Tuany you have Dr.
5:57
Unidentified speaker: Moya, and in Johannesburg, I think you had um Al Jama coming in.
6:03
Unidentified speaker: So I think they are trying to avoid that as the DA because they have learned from that that it became very difficult when you have too many political parties.
6:11
Unidentified speaker: So it will depend.
6:13
Unidentified speaker: I mean, the the also the the issue of the PRCs, because I think we are looking at the wars now.
6:19
Unidentified speaker: Where we we are waiting to see the PR.
6:21
Unidentified speaker: You know, the NC might have lost, but they might surprise us with the PRCs where they might get a sizable number, you know.
6:27
Unidentified speaker: So it that it's going to be very interesting that the next 14 days, you know, after the announcement, how the negotiations are going.
6:35
Unidentified speaker: Because I fully agree with him.
6:36
Unidentified speaker: Um you don't want a situation where there's too many political parties because that brings instability and and because the parliament has not passed that bill, uh, which I think they they delayed because they've seen the instability uh at local government, you know, and and and and rightfully as you say it.
6:52
Unidentified speaker: I mean, some people have accused the DA sometimes of being too arrogant and quite a mantache in that they are they're reverie and the play at the same time because they're part of the GNU.
7:00
Unidentified speaker: And I think also, Ilaw when I was talking to one of the uh actu uh DA leaders, you know, and we were asking them, is there a possibility for them to go into coalition with Action SA?
7:09
Unidentified speaker: Because if you look at the numbers, they can actually form a government of nation.
7:14
Unidentified speaker: And their interests are very similar in many ways.
7:16
Unidentified speaker: Um, Mirlani, um I'm gonna sketch a uh scenario and you tell me if it's possible.
7:22
Unidentified speaker: Say, best case scenario in terms of governance, party A and Party B, just two parties form a coalition.
7:28
Unidentified speaker: They take over a place like Joburg, which has so many complex problems.
7:33
Unidentified speaker: I mean, if you look at how difficult it was to solve Eskim, I think City Power is like almost on the same level in terms of uh the same for Johannesburg Water.
7:41
Unidentified speaker: With the best possible governance in the world, how long would it take for someone to take over a metro of that size and for residents to notice the difference?
7:50
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, I think the world turns, you know, quite slow uh slowly at metros.
7:54
Unidentified speaker: Joburg is even complex because it has municipal-owned entities.
7:59
Unidentified speaker: So if you then take the municipal-owned entities that are dealing with trading services, electricity, water, waste, you have now the bulk of the municipality.
8:10
Unidentified speaker: Then you have the rest, you know, in terms of including pick it up, I I must add.
8:14
Unidentified speaker: You're dealing with the trading services, which is the core of where service delivery is.
8:19
Unidentified speaker: But then there's also other aspects, you know, in terms of you know the transport, uh, the the PRTs and all of those, you know, other areas.
8:27
Unidentified speaker: You have still huge departments in terms of uh IT.
8:31
Unidentified speaker: So so so if you were to divide up, you know, a metro and literally start turning it around.
8:36
Unidentified speaker: And where the city of Johannesburg is, even their finances are not in good shape.
8:41
Unidentified speaker: So you need to get you know the finances in good shape so that you know you start you know driving the collections and you can have a funded budget.
8:49
Unidentified speaker: Once you have a funded budget, you can have now a maintenance budget.
8:52
Unidentified speaker: Once you have a maintenance budget, you start building up again the capital budget.
8:57
Unidentified speaker: So out of all of those efforts, you know, you you you have to have you know a 36 months you know type window.
9:03
Unidentified speaker: And if you can at least you know get all of you know the moving parts together, it's it's a 36 months you know uh plan.
9:10
Unidentified speaker: So you can't do it in 12 months, especially if it's going to be an unstable uh type of you know coalition.
9:16
Unidentified speaker: So if party A and Party B definitely can hold hands together and and start to prioritize your metro trading services, uh prioritize the revenue value chains, and then you can start moving to the smaller uh municipal-owned entities, your JPCs, your JDAs, George Cores can run on their own if you want, you know.
9:37
Unidentified speaker: So you have at least a divide and conquer type, you know, which you can at least break it across, you know, the three years to get the trading services going, and then you can get the next you know cohort of those municipalities that are not necessarily uh making a huge difference, but BRT is making a huge difference.
9:55
Unidentified speaker: Then the smaller ones, you know, your uh your theaters and your and so on.
9:59
Unidentified speaker: You can then at least you know get them also to contribute to the lot.
10:03
Unidentified speaker: It's so interesting uh to watch all of this play out.
10:06
Unidentified speaker: Uh Robone, um if we look at the numbers, you will actually see uh that the DA is projected to get around sort of 23% of the vote.
10:16
Unidentified speaker: The ANC is projected to get around 30% of the vote.
10:19
Unidentified speaker: These are the CSI, R, SABC predictions.
10:21
Unidentified speaker: Which means together across the country, the two biggest parties are getting 53% of the vote.
10:27
Unidentified speaker: Now, if you went back 10-20 years, the two biggest parties would be sitting on 80% of the vote.
10:34
Unidentified speaker: There are a lot of smaller parties, and we've all watched this happen, MK, EFF, etc., taking a larger percentage of the vote.
10:43
Unidentified speaker: And doesn't that mean that the future of South Africa is a governance which is much more complicated than it is now?
10:50
Unidentified speaker: The future is much more national coalition with lots of parties than it is two-party coalitions.
10:56
Unidentified speaker: No, no, no, absolutely.
10:58
Unidentified speaker: Um that that's going to be very interesting, especially going to 2029, you know, um, because I mean if you look at, I was saying to someone, uh, some of this parties, how they ran this elections.
11:09
Unidentified speaker: They ran it uh as 2026 elections instead of 2029 um um um local national elections, you know.
11:16
Unidentified speaker: And and I was giving an example that uh the ANC might struggle in 2029 because if you look at the campaign trail, it was focusing more on the metros.
11:26
Unidentified speaker: You know, they left the rural vote, which in the long run might be a problem for them, and that means that we will see that decline um in in 2029, and we'll see also a lot of small parties um emerging with uh Morse.
11:40
Unidentified speaker: And and and I mean right now if you look at the GNU that is there, it does have uh small parties.
11:48
Unidentified speaker: But we then also need to have a conversation about the small parties.
11:53
Unidentified speaker: They are contesting a democratic process and most of them have not gone to their own elective conferences, you know.
12:00
Unidentified speaker: And I mean ACDP's had the same leader since I don't know, before we had a democracy.
12:05
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, the IFP had the same leader for nearly 50 years, the Action SA, um UDM UDM, yes.
12:12
Unidentified speaker: And and and MK doesn't believe in a constitution.
12:17
Unidentified speaker: Uh Raismus answered uh I don't think that they will also go to their conference.
12:20
Unidentified speaker: So that this is then becoming very interesting, you know, um, in terms of w where does this uh also take us?
12:28
Unidentified speaker: Uh but we need that's why this local government bill, for me it must not only about be local government, it must be holistically about coalitions because we don't want uh instability that we've seen at local government.
12:43
Unidentified speaker: Uh we don't want uh policymakers must not be reactive.
12:47
Unidentified speaker: Sure.
12:48
Unidentified speaker: They must be proactive, you know, and prepare that uh we're going to have more coalitions.
12:53
Unidentified speaker: Um if we look um at the uh at particularly the ANC and the DA, it's it's not even 24 hours since polling stations closed.
13:04
Unidentified speaker: And one of the things I've observed in my brief time covering elections is that uh people's emotions go up and down.
13:10
Unidentified speaker: They everyone's tired.
13:12
Unidentified speaker: Um sometimes they're quite generous towards each other, sometimes they're quite angry, goes in different directions.
13:18
Unidentified speaker: Monday morning, everyone gets a bit of sleep, the dust starts to settle a little bit.
13:23
Unidentified speaker: From that moment, if the election is proclaimed on Sunday, they have 15 days.
13:26
Unidentified speaker: So call it, you know, not the first Tuesday, but the second Tuesday, councils have to meet.
13:32
Unidentified speaker: Do you think the a do you think the bigger parties start to make decisions about staying in power, or do you think emotion is still going to be a big part of it?
13:41
Unidentified speaker: I think there's two things, right?
13:43
Unidentified speaker: Um the NC is also bleeding from the view of the constitutional court, remember of the release process.
13:51
Unidentified speaker: And they were saying that uh the DA, you know, being a GNU partner was against, you know, them, you know, fielding of fixing their mistakes or with the IEC in terms of their candidates, you know.
14:03
Unidentified speaker: So you you you have uh and I was saying to someone earlier on, by the way, you're going to have in different municipalities, you might have those who want to engage with the EFF MK, right, P.
14:14
Unidentified speaker: And then in other municipalities you might have those that want to engage with the DA.
14:18
Unidentified speaker: So it's also going to be about personalities in the different municipalities.
14:22
Unidentified speaker: Even if, let's say Nistal imposes and says, we're not going to work with uh the DA, right?
14:28
Unidentified speaker: Uh we don't want the DA at local government.
14:31
Unidentified speaker: And you find that the candidate of the NC, because the NCA has not even also pronounced its own candidates at this point, then the candidate does not have a good relationship with MKP and EFF.
14:41
Unidentified speaker: So in you know, in two months or three months, we might see difficult tensions within council.
14:47
Unidentified speaker: So I think it has to do, they will have to look at who are they fielding the different municipalities and who is likely to engage uh in a nice uh political um I mean you look at, for example, Gauteng and KwaZul Natal, the composition is too different, yeah, you know, of of of the GPUs, you know, and and and and the one of KwaZulu Natal is similar to National, but in Gauteng it's the opposite, you know.
15:11
Unidentified speaker: So that's going to be interesting.
15:12
Unidentified speaker: But I think uh it's going to be about different personalities in different municipalities and and and and and it might if if national wants to enforce uh that's disastrous, uh they must really apply their mind and analyze because it can't be one size fit all for every municipality uh if you want stability.
15:29
Unidentified speaker: Robonetal, thank you so much.
15:31
Unidentified speaker: Good to talk to you again.
15:32
Unidentified speaker: Really do appreciate the time.
15:33
Unidentified speaker: The analyst and commentator, also writer on the ANC.
15:36
Unidentified speaker: Twenty-six minutes after six o'clock, you're listening to The Money.
15:39
Unidentified speaker: The Money Show.
15:40
Unidentified speaker: The Markers.
15:42
Unidentified speaker: Graham Connor is uh Market Commentary at the Connor Perspective.
15:46
Unidentified speaker: Graham, uh, good evening to you.
15:48
Unidentified speaker: We've seen some broad rallies in our time, but wow, Donald Trump's rebuke really did set something off.
15:54
Unidentified speaker: Well, the local market sort of just powered ahead off its best, but uh yeah, a wonderful day.
16:00
Unidentified speaker: What a lovely day to be able to say you know, the top 40, I think, was up four percent, nice best, um up ten percent.
16:07
Unidentified speaker: You know, financials, uh, local industrials, uh, local economy stocks, um, all looking strong.
16:13
Unidentified speaker: So the precious metals, miners also on the back of stronger metal prices.
16:18
Unidentified speaker: Very strong earlier days, but still up five, six percent.
16:21
Unidentified speaker: So a lovely day.
16:23
Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
16:24
Unidentified speaker: We need another 15 of these 15 years, Graham.
16:29
Unidentified speaker: Um, goldfields, I mean, they had an update today.
16:32
Unidentified speaker: Uh, their gold production was down slightly.
16:34
Unidentified speaker: They all in costs were a little higher in dollar terms.
16:37
Unidentified speaker: Uh, but obviously, with a stronger gold price today, people will be looking for it.
16:42
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, I think that's exactly right, Stephen.
16:44
Unidentified speaker: So um, it was up, but again, all of its base levels up I think three and a half percent or thereabouts.
16:49
Unidentified speaker: Um I was a little bit troubled when I saw that just very significant over 20% increase in the cost when you dig a little bit deeper, obviously slightly low production, royalties being paid away.
17:01
Unidentified speaker: Um and then also obviously you know currencies like Iran actually uh firmer all of that compliance.
17:08
Unidentified speaker: So not as bad as as as you would think.
17:10
Unidentified speaker: But as I say, I think this result was kind of ignored and irrelevant.
17:15
Unidentified speaker: Everybody's looking forward and saying, well, you know, if oil carries on falling and energy prices fall the way they have in the last week, uh suddenly that inflation risk has gone.
17:25
Unidentified speaker: And then I think the thing that was holding precious metals back could very well catapult them forward again.
17:30
Unidentified speaker: So I think that's really what's capturing the imagination of the market today.
17:34
Unidentified speaker: True words talking today, um, they had an update as well as a 17-week update.
17:38
Unidentified speaker: Their sales were down slightly, both here and in the UK, perhaps far more in the UK, and like everyone else in their market, they're blaming the strained consumer.
17:48
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, well it's true.
17:50
Unidentified speaker: I mean, the reality is um I think account sales were down, oh sorry, were up by oh sorry, down by 2.2 of a percent, uh retail sales down 2.7, cash sales down a very significant eight or nine percent.
18:03
Unidentified speaker: Um in the UK office UK actually rose ever so slightly, but then um you know, just so that they could really get cut, um, you know, the RAND uh obviously took that down so uh sales in RAM terms down six point nine.
18:18
Unidentified speaker: But again, market looking forward and saying, you know what, the consumer's been under a lot of pressure.
18:23
Unidentified speaker: If this eases, if rates come off, if disposable incomes back in the pocket of the consumer, you know, these very, very low levels you could see a rally.
18:31
Unidentified speaker: So I think true words on the day was up for almost five percent.
18:34
Unidentified speaker: Uh the likes of Fushini also.
18:36
Unidentified speaker: So um yeah, market really was very, very cheered by uh a little bit of good news.
18:41
Unidentified speaker: And I think Stephen, we've spoken about this, you know, there's a lot of value in SA equities, particularly uh locally focused and you know, like the financials and uh the retailers as we're discussing.
18:51
Unidentified speaker: So a little bit of good news can really um unleash them.
18:55
Unidentified speaker: And then Optaisia, I mean, they were up very strongly, 9% today, very strong update.
19:02
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, I mean it's a company that's really um you know flying, uh obviously new to the market and will disclose our our interest.
19:09
Unidentified speaker: We've followed it for a long time through ethos um and hold for clients, you know, a company that's growing revenues by 45% in this kind of environment, sort of pan-African, into the Middle East and other markets.
19:22
Unidentified speaker: Uh it really is a very, very exciting story.
19:24
Unidentified speaker: So somewhere between you know uh technology and and finance, it really looks very, very compelling to us anyway.
19:31
Unidentified speaker: Um and it you don't have a hell of a lot of these really exciting high growth stories in essay.
19:36
Unidentified speaker: So um a good value elsewhere and very solid markets, but uh Octasia I think gives you something unique.
19:42
Unidentified speaker: So market loved that update.
19:44
Unidentified speaker: Um, I think for the nine months they're talking 45% increase in revenues, um, and they were rewarded with almost a 10% rally on the day.
19:52
Unidentified speaker: Graham Kenneth, thanks so much.
19:54
Unidentified speaker: Our market commentator tonight at the corner perspective.
19:58
Unidentified speaker: What's happened even on 072 702 1702 22 minutes now to seven the time, live of course from the National Results Operations Centre.
20:11
Unidentified speaker: And all we've been doing here is adding a little bit of spice to the numbers that make up the political recipe of the area in which you live.
20:19
Unidentified speaker: We don't yet know what exactly is being baked for you, but some suggestions today, and Sipumulele Zondi's been looking at this, he'll tell us more in about half an hour from now, that when it comes to shopping, people actually aren't that interested in using AI.
20:34
Unidentified speaker: So, in other words, you're not saying uh to something, you know, to some bot or whatever it is, that actually we're going to use uh AI to do that.
20:43
Unidentified speaker: Now you would think that maybe it would be quite useful.
20:47
Unidentified speaker: I mean, if you are going to order the same burger every Friday night, or you're going to have, you know, the 17 wings and two thighs, well then surely AI would be able to do that for you.
21:00
Unidentified speaker: I would also think it would be entirely likely that someone like me, who perhaps quite quite likes to eat lemon meringue pie, don't like to make it, might just say, Hey Google, uh give me a recipe for lemon meringue pie and please order all of the goods uh from ShopRite or Pick and Pay or whatever.
21:17
Unidentified speaker: And I know that Pick and Pay have been using AI to help people draw up shopping lists.
21:22
Unidentified speaker: Shopright not so much from my understanding and experience of it.
21:26
Unidentified speaker: Are you prepared to use AI to do shopping?
21:29
Unidentified speaker: You aren't?
21:30
Unidentified speaker: Why not?
21:31
Unidentified speaker: 072 7021702.
21:34
Unidentified speaker: Um, I wonder if it's partly because we like a bit of control, partly because I think there's something else which I find really interesting.
21:41
Unidentified speaker: I've been expecting, if you consider how many deliveries there are to people's homes, that for the delivery services, the people who do it, so your spas, your shop rights, your pick and pays, that it is a golden way to get advertised products into someone's home, particularly sources.
21:57
Unidentified speaker: You know, someone's not going to try a new thing unless they know they like it.
22:00
Unidentified speaker: If you put it in the thing as a freebie, they'll try it and therefore they'll buy more.
22:04
Unidentified speaker: And you can think of the potential, but I haven't seen that happening either.
22:08
Unidentified speaker: Your thoughts, please.
22:09
Unidentified speaker: 072 7021702.
22:12
Unidentified speaker: What would you like AI to bake for you?
22:16
Unidentified speaker: The latest development.
22:17
Unidentified speaker: Results and analysis from the local government election section.
22:22
Unidentified speaker: The Money Shell with Stephen Crotez on 702 and Cape Talk.
22:28
Unidentified speaker: Just gone a quarter to seven, where we, of course, still live from the National Results Operations Centre here.
22:33
Unidentified speaker: And for the moment, with results still coming in, the results of our local elections aren't having much of an impact on our market or dare I say global markets.
22:42
Unidentified speaker: However, they're certainly jumping to the tune of the US midterm results yesterday.
22:47
Unidentified speaker: The JSE ending up around 3.5%, was up 5% at one point.
22:51
Unidentified speaker: Gold prices much higher.
22:53
Unidentified speaker: The bigger story, perhaps, is what's been happening with oil prices.
22:56
Unidentified speaker: Yesterday, US markets jumped at the news, uh, down quite significantly in some cases today.
23:02
Unidentified speaker: John Stopford is the head of multi-asset income at 91.
23:06
Unidentified speaker: John, uh, good evening.
23:07
Unidentified speaker: Really do appreciate the time.
23:08
Unidentified speaker: I know there's a lot going on.
23:10
Unidentified speaker: I'm presuming that the global market reaction to the US midterm result is the presumption that Donald Trump is going to have some more uh boundaries around his behaviour.
23:21
Unidentified speaker: Uh good evening.
23:22
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, I think so to some extent, although potentially some of what we're seeing also um reflects some of the results at a more local level or at a state level.
23:33
Unidentified speaker: So in terms of constraining his room for maneuver, probably the the biggest takeaway so far, I would say, is that threats of escalating uh post-election in Iran look to have diminished, that the risk of that.
23:49
Unidentified speaker: So we've had a number of people on his own side um coming out and essentially blaming the war for um the loss for the swing to the Democrats.
24:00
Unidentified speaker: Um and he even sort of uh gestured to that himself, although clearly it wasn't uh his fault if he'd been on the ballot, they would have won, apparently.
24:09
Unidentified speaker: Um so yeah, I think there's there is that aspect.
24:12
Unidentified speaker: Clearly, Congress is now in the hands of the opposition.
24:15
Unidentified speaker: So his ability to pass uh legislation to get appointees uh in office, etc., is more curtailed.
24:22
Unidentified speaker: But I think a lot of the noise we're seeing also reflects um generally a distaste or distrust for uh data center build out uh build outs in in um states, particularly Texas, uh and the swing uh at the local level, particularly uh the governorships in Texas and other states, uh has made it maybe more problematic for the hyperscalers and others to roll out such large uh um data center investments because they're they're pretty unpopular, and part of the reason that the Republicans I think lost uh lost ground.
25:01
Unidentified speaker: What I haven't seen is any kind of market fear of a lashing out by Trump.
25:05
Unidentified speaker: I mean the the idea, the phrase of the week was sort of Trump could be an angry duck.
25:09
Unidentified speaker: Um we haven't seen any fear of that.
25:11
Unidentified speaker: He would still have control of the US armed forces and therefore over uh to an extent the situation around the Strait of Humuz.
25:18
Unidentified speaker: But that fear seems to have receded.
25:20
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, I I think people are weighing up probabilities.
25:23
Unidentified speaker: So, you know, that that risk, I guess, was partly in the price uh coming into this.
25:28
Unidentified speaker: So we've had elevated uh oil prices.
25:31
Unidentified speaker: I I think um the fact that you know some of his key lieutenants and and and that some of the sort of leadership of the Republican Party have come out fairly strongly blaming the war for um the electoral uh defeats, um, I think that does make it more problematic for him.
25:50
Unidentified speaker: Um also apparently there is you know lots of stories circulating that Pete Hegseth, the Secretary of War, um who was his sort of um front man or right hand man in in uh prosecuting the the attacks on uh Iran that he might be for the chop to move sideways.
26:09
Unidentified speaker: Um so there's definitely a lot of pressure, I think, on him to de-escalate.
26:12
Unidentified speaker: And there's been a lot of mood music going on for a while, that um there is some concrete progress in negotiations.
26:20
Unidentified speaker: So there's clearly you know plenty of opportunity for that to fall down.
26:25
Unidentified speaker: Um, but it does appear as though both sides essentially are probably looking for an off-ramp now, although, as you say, Trump is is quite unpredictable and he could turn round and do something different.
26:38
Unidentified speaker: Well, so the outlook over the medium term, and let me say for the next two years until the US presidential election, um I mean, Reuters and others are suggesting there'll be uh some bloodletting in the Republican Party, Pete Hexeth could well be part of that.
26:52
Unidentified speaker: All of that would make sense.
26:54
Unidentified speaker: Um, but if we've seen some of what Trump did early on in his term, the tariff announcements in particular, yes, there will be constraints about him around him, and I accept all of that.
27:04
Unidentified speaker: But two years is a long time to have an angry president sitting in the White House.
27:10
Unidentified speaker: I I I completely agree.
27:12
Unidentified speaker: I mean, Trump, as we know, likes to make headlines.
27:15
Unidentified speaker: Uh, he's got a massive ego, he he's not very good at sort of admitting when he's wrong.
27:20
Unidentified speaker: Um, and you know, the last two years has felt like a lifetime.
27:24
Unidentified speaker: I'm sure the next two years may as well.
27:27
Unidentified speaker: I guess the issue is, you know, he is now a lame duck.
27:30
Unidentified speaker: Um his colleagues will be starting to look, you know, jockey for position in terms of who could run uh as the Republican presidential candidate next time round, because he can't.
27:42
Unidentified speaker: Um, and obviously the Democrats to some extent will try and restrain him.
27:46
Unidentified speaker: And cost of living was the biggest issue in the election.
27:51
Unidentified speaker: That was partly about the war and partly about tariffs.
27:54
Unidentified speaker: Um, and so pushing on either of those, which arguably are the sort of two areas he can do stuff because he doesn't need um congressional approval in the short run uh to uh take some military action for a limited period.
28:09
Unidentified speaker: Um and the sort of trade side of things, again, he has powers that he can exercise, although they have been challenged to some extent in the courts.
28:17
Unidentified speaker: So, yeah, I think it it probably will remain noisy, it will probably remain messy, but the bigger themes underneath all of that will be, you know, what happens to inflation, what happens to growth, what happens to interest rates, um, and ultimately what happens to the AI CapEx boom, because those are probably gonna decide where markets go over the next two years and beyond, rather than um Trump's tantrums and noise in the White House.
28:47
Unidentified speaker: So the AI Capex boom would be the next big issue because okay, maybe there's a peace deal of some kind or just an interactive hostilities around the Strait of Humus, and lots of things take care of themselves after that.
28:59
Unidentified speaker: Oil prices go down, gas prices go down in the US, inflation goes down, interest rates go down.
29:04
Unidentified speaker: But the AI boom's really driven US stock markets.
29:07
Unidentified speaker: I would presume there is a higher potential now for more regulation around AI than there was when the Republicans controlled all three arms.
29:16
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, absolutely, and there's more scope for um data centers not to get approval in what were formerly um red um Republican states.
29:27
Unidentified speaker: Um but also um you know there's been a lot of churn going on underneath the stock market for some time now, so we're beginning to see more questioning of how the weaker players can finance themselves, even how some of the larger players can uh issue as much debt or equity as they're they're hoping to.
29:47
Unidentified speaker: And so, you know, there's there's been a bit more doubt.
29:49
Unidentified speaker: I think people are questioning is there enough return going to be made on some of these investments?
29:55
Unidentified speaker: How a sort of slower rollout plays out and who benefits from that and who loses, we'll have to see.
30:01
Unidentified speaker: But certainly the stock market, if you look at look at the overall market, something like 25% of the Nasdaq is made up by five tech stocks.
30:10
Unidentified speaker: Um, you know, uh over half of the index SP is AI or AI related.
30:17
Unidentified speaker: If this if if the cracks start to widen, and we've got potentially anthropic uh planning an IPO in the next couple of weeks, um, trying to raise you know one and a half to two trillion dollars, uh an enormous amount, uh on on hope rather than any real data or numbers.
30:35
Unidentified speaker: You know, if if the cracks start to widen, this thing could get uglier.
30:39
Unidentified speaker: It's obviously had a pretty ugly day to day led by tech, led by the semiconductors who led the trade on the way up and are now leading it to some extent on the way down.
30:48
Unidentified speaker: And the only reason the headline indices don't look that bad is because some people are rotating and fleeing into defensive.
30:55
Unidentified speaker: So, you know, consumer staples, healthcare, that kind of thing, um, utilities.
31:01
Unidentified speaker: John Stopford, really appreciate the time tonight.
31:03
Unidentified speaker: Thank you.
31:03
Unidentified speaker: Head of multi-asset income at 91.
31:07
Unidentified speaker: You're listening to the Money Show with Stephen Cruetis, proud host of the APSA Champagne in Africa Festival.
31:14
Unidentified speaker: Limited tickets available at cricket.
31:18
Unidentified speaker: Four minutes now to seven the time.
31:20
Unidentified speaker: Well, just before the US midterms earlier this week, quite a few things have happened this week.
31:25
Unidentified speaker: I don't know if you've noticed.
31:26
Unidentified speaker: The Trump administration confirmed it was removing us from a Goa.
31:30
Unidentified speaker: Now, the EU starting a process that could exclude hybrid cars made here from their market.
31:36
Unidentified speaker: Donald Mackay is the director at XA International Trade Advisors.
31:41
Unidentified speaker: Donald, uh, good evening.
31:42
Unidentified speaker: The EU is starting what they call a safeguard investigation into hybrids.
31:47
Unidentified speaker: What on earth is that?
31:49
Unidentified speaker: Hi, Stephen.
31:51
Unidentified speaker: So uh a safeguard is an instrument under the WTO that allows a country or region to impose a tariff or a quota uh in order to deal with the surge in imports that was unexpected, which is kind of the definition of what has happened in the EU.
32:09
Unidentified speaker: So they've seen a huge influx of hybrid vehicles, largely driven out of China, but but there are others as well.
32:17
Unidentified speaker: And um they really would like to stop that.
32:21
Unidentified speaker: And that is what this investigation is all about.
32:25
Unidentified speaker: Does it matter that the influxes from China are not really from us?
32:29
Unidentified speaker: I mean, their production is unbelievably much higher than ours.
32:34
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, if they if they had brought an anti-dumping investigation, they could have targeted China, but um safeguard safeguard investigations don't allow that to happen.
32:45
Unidentified speaker: So it's it's got to apply to everyone.
32:48
Unidentified speaker: There are some exceptions to that, which are quite technical, but those exceptions don't affect us.
32:53
Unidentified speaker: So we would be caught in in the same group as China and everyone else should this proceed um in the normal fashion.
33:03
Unidentified speaker: I was under the impression they had already signed some sort of deal or agreement or something with China with relate in relating relation to the uh the import of hybrid vehicles or the Chinese export of hybrid vehicles into the EU.
33:16
Unidentified speaker: If that's uh flow of cars from China to the EU were to slow down, would that then change the result of their safeguard investigation?
33:24
Unidentified speaker: I mean, one would like to think it would.
33:27
Unidentified speaker: It can't.
33:28
Unidentified speaker: Um that's it's far too early to tell.
33:31
Unidentified speaker: They they have certainly would have the option to do that.
33:34
Unidentified speaker: Whether they would do it is is a different question, of course.
33:37
Unidentified speaker: Um we just don't know at this point.
33:41
Unidentified speaker: Um we can see, I mean, just from sitting in, you know, Santon most of the time, you can see the impact that the big uh number of cars being imported into the EU has had.
33:53
Unidentified speaker: Volkswagen is absolutely battling at the moment.
33:56
Unidentified speaker: I mean, if you were to do that investigation, I'm no expert on trade, as you know, Donald, but it would seem fairly likely that, yes, there is something to safeguard.
34:05
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, yeah.
34:06
Unidentified speaker: The EU have a case.
34:08
Unidentified speaker: Uh there's, you know, there would appear to be no doubt about that.
34:12
Unidentified speaker: Um the question is what South Africa can do in order to find ourselves in uh at some sort of preferential position.
34:20
Unidentified speaker: Now, Stephen, I haven't yet had sight of the application that was brought, so I'm unable to comment on the technicalities of the case.
34:28
Unidentified speaker: But um, safeguards are an emergency measure, which means we have to move really, really quickly.
34:35
Unidentified speaker: Um, that would mean that the South African car manufacturers uh plus government and you know everyone else involved in this value chain.
34:44
Unidentified speaker: Because if this is not addressed, the impact of this would would really make losing a go around the error.
34:52
Unidentified speaker: I mean, is there much we were able to do?
34:54
Unidentified speaker: Would we be consulted as part of that investigation?
34:58
Unidentified speaker: Yes.
34:58
Unidentified speaker: Um and in fact, the government has an automatic um right to participate.
35:04
Unidentified speaker: Um, yes, uh arguments would be considered.
35:07
Unidentified speaker: We you know, if you don't participate in the case, you're gonna lose by default.
35:11
Unidentified speaker: So we can't do nothing.
35:14
Unidentified speaker: But uh, you know, we're not yet in a position to know what those arguments will be until we have sight of the facts that drove the case, which have not been made available yet.
35:25
Unidentified speaker: Donald McHybe, thanks very much indeed, Director at XA International Trade Advisors.
35:30
Unidentified speaker: Well, another threat looming.
35:31
Unidentified speaker: Uh Donald really do appreciate the time.
35:34
Unidentified speaker: Uh, in a moment, AI and shopping, or rather, why no one is using AI to do their shopping.
35:39
Unidentified speaker: You with the money show, live from the National Results Centre, it's 7 o'clock.
35:43
Unidentified speaker: The Money Show, tech Thursday.
35:47
Unidentified speaker: Well, it seems that despite the fact that there are plenty of AI agents available to help you do your shopping, people are avoiding that.
35:55
Unidentified speaker: Uber is one of the big companies that's found this.
35:57
Unidentified speaker: DoorDash, which is a big delivery firm uh in the US, has found the same thing.
36:02
Unidentified speaker: Sipumalele Zandi is our tech expert, joins us now.
36:05
Unidentified speaker: Sipumalele, oh good evening.
36:07
Unidentified speaker: I was really astonished by this.
36:09
Unidentified speaker: I mean, you would think online shopping is doing so well, so many people use an app to shop.
36:14
Unidentified speaker: Next thing would be the app doing it itself.
36:18
Unidentified speaker: Uh hello, Steven.
36:19
Unidentified speaker: I'll talk to you, that's the thing, right?
36:21
Unidentified speaker: Because uh what happened in Microsoft everything that uh no one is really picking up uh AI when it comes to their shopping experience.
36:29
Unidentified speaker: Um, no one is using the AI.
36:51
Unidentified speaker: Uh the AI in the tool button and then we're not interested in talking to AI or getting AI to carry out the order.
37:06
Unidentified speaker: I mean, what can AI actually do?
37:08
Unidentified speaker: Shopping's a pretty repetitive experience.
37:10
Unidentified speaker: Most of us order the same kinds of things or buy the same kinds of things on a regular basis.
37:15
Unidentified speaker: I mean, shopping's almost made for AI.
37:20
Unidentified speaker: But also remember that the security concerns actually when it comes to um doing anything online and sharing your um your information that now you have to share information with AIDS, right?
37:32
Unidentified speaker: And they have to keep them and load them into those uh AIDs.
37:36
Unidentified speaker: Like AI can help you think about anything.
37:38
Unidentified speaker: So for example, let's say you're buying AIDS.
37:43
Unidentified speaker: Can you show you what it's going to look like?
37:47
Unidentified speaker: For example, I might have something like your five like AI can actually help with that how people go to your house if you buy how much that helped with how that's ordering different things for you or that's different, um what you're going to be eating at your grocery shop.
38:18
Unidentified speaker: So, um, I mean, I wonder, I mean, I I take your point about people very nervous about um sort of n, you know, their information.
38:27
Unidentified speaker: But if you look at what ShopRights or Pick and Pay must know about you from your orders, from your purchases, from the fact that uh they would have the inf the information about what you've bought and about um the and they would know it's you because of your card.
38:42
Unidentified speaker: Um surely that would be I mean that would be information we've already given up.
38:47
Unidentified speaker: That would be another way, right?
38:48
Unidentified speaker: Uh where um you where uh it's different shops, like as you say, chicken bay has a card and sometimes shops have append data or what you find all the time.
38:58
Unidentified speaker: I'm not sure if people realize that when you find a card, um it's basically keeping data of what it is that you are purchasing every single time and it's creating a profile of the end, what it is that you are interested in.
39:11
Unidentified speaker: So um in order for either something to figure out that you usually find this that you would have to like in the hand.
39:22
Unidentified speaker: Um then maybe that's why you can maybe that you that you can find that could be another way of uh doing it.
39:40
Unidentified speaker: And figuring out like you connect to it.
39:42
Unidentified speaker: And also that's also another thing.
39:46
Unidentified speaker: Because they feel like that actually shows that they clearly are enough people who want to get out of the house and go into the experience of the time.
39:58
Unidentified speaker: Okay, um so so I mean these things are are always interesting.
40:03
Unidentified speaker: But I mean, Uber says only four consumers used AI bots uh to order during the Halloween weekend, they will have spent a fortune on AI.
40:11
Unidentified speaker: I mean uh this would be a huge waste of money.
40:16
Unidentified speaker: You see, that's also um and the buttons the thing is the tech industry itself um has okay, I think they put a lot of money.
41:10
Unidentified speaker: So, I mean, there's so many things that you can think of.
41:12
Unidentified speaker: I mean, I did wonder if part of it is because using the current systems that these companies have is actually pretty simple.
41:20
Unidentified speaker: The company already knows a lot about you, knows where you're going to go, you don't need AI for that, knows what you're going to buy, don't even need AI for that.
41:27
Unidentified speaker: Maybe we just don't need it.
41:28
Unidentified speaker: It doesn't actually add any value.
41:30
Unidentified speaker: Could that be the problem?
41:32
Unidentified speaker: And that is a problem, especially um I'm thinking about like retailers if they're thinking because um all these tech companies are talking about why you need to adopt their AI.
41:42
Unidentified speaker: Actually, making the experience for the I think we might be losing you there, unfortunately.
41:53
Unidentified speaker: Uh let's just see if you're still with us.
41:54
Unidentified speaker: Sipumalele Zondi, are you there?
41:57
Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
41:58
Unidentified speaker: Okay, sorry.
41:59
Unidentified speaker: Um so I mean yes, I can.
42:03
Unidentified speaker: If you're a local retailer, and I mean some companies are going to be investing in this quite heavily, uh, what would you be looking at before we implement any AI in your shopping systems?
42:12
Unidentified speaker: Um so what you need to be looking at is whether it's going to make the customer experience um or easy.
42:24
Unidentified speaker: Is it better to start getting someone?
42:26
Unidentified speaker: Look at it or around the platform and make the point something.
42:36
Unidentified speaker: Um that's particularly the main thing.
42:40
Unidentified speaker: Especially as a retailer, because sometimes a lot of people left as a tech that had a waiter line.
42:51
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, it's so interesting to see how all of this is gonna play out.
42:54
Unidentified speaker: Right, sipumalele zondi.
42:56
Unidentified speaker: Uh thank you very much indeed.
42:57
Unidentified speaker: Our tech expert do appreciate that.
42:59
Unidentified speaker: Um unfortunate that uh we lost the line there, but I'm always intrigued by what we're gonna use uh AI for and what we aren't going to use it for.
43:08
Unidentified speaker: You would think, just as a starting point, that shopping would be such an obvious one.
43:13
Unidentified speaker: And yet, hmm, I think I just thinking aloud, I think there are a few things to it.
43:18
Unidentified speaker: The one is I quite like the control.
43:20
Unidentified speaker: Do you remember when you used to go and shop in the store?
43:23
Unidentified speaker: And there was always this concern, you know, a lot of people want to feel the fruit.
43:26
Unidentified speaker: That is still the case.
43:27
Unidentified speaker: Otherwise, the uh, you know, the shops wouldn't be as busy as they are at certain times.
43:32
Unidentified speaker: You still want to go and select things for your f for for yourself.
43:35
Unidentified speaker: Well, I look good in this.
43:36
Unidentified speaker: And then, of course, there's the shopping as an experience uh for clothes or cosmetics or whatever it may be.
43:41
Unidentified speaker: Um at the same time, I just wonder if maybe the apps are so simple that actually uh it really doesn't matter anymore.
43:48
Unidentified speaker: And so there's just no point.
43:50
Unidentified speaker: Just something to ponder, I think, uh, as we look at why AI isn't being picked up on shopping apps.
43:56
Unidentified speaker: Your thoughts, please, on 072 702 1702.
43:59
Unidentified speaker: The Money Show with Stephen Cruetes.
44:02
Unidentified speaker: On 702 702.
44:05
Unidentified speaker: So many people have been looking at some of the big um kind of hotspots in this local election, and I'll suggest they're really two.
44:13
Unidentified speaker: Uh the first is the three Houteng municipalities, and I group them together because it is difficult to know how who is going to work with who, but I also think that the potential is there for one deal.
44:25
Unidentified speaker: In other words, one deal that is all three uh municipalities, or certainly by some of the bigger parties involved, one set of guiding principles so that would affect them all.
44:34
Unidentified speaker: And then you've got the situation in Etequini, where M.
44:38
Unidentified speaker: Conto Wassizu, as we know, has been in the lead and almost certain will get uh the highest number of votes in Etequini.
44:44
Unidentified speaker: You do wonder if the three Gauteng Metros could affect each other, could, I don't know, the Etequini Metro affect the others?
44:50
Unidentified speaker: Who knows?
44:50
Unidentified speaker: And this is where things start to get incredibly complicated.
44:53
Unidentified speaker: The point I'm trying to make is that with the Electoral Commission saying, you heard at the start of the show, the Electoral Commission chair Musutu Meepia making the point that all the votes had been counted.
45:04
Unidentified speaker: What they hadn't been done was actually collated.
45:08
Unidentified speaker: They hadn't been added into the system.
45:10
Unidentified speaker: So the votes being counted is one thing.
45:12
Unidentified speaker: The actual result is another thing, but that's not the result that we're looking for.
45:18
Unidentified speaker: The result we're looking for is the outcome of the coalition negotiations, and that we don't know.
45:24
Unidentified speaker: And so we are in a moment of people going up and down as they look at numbers coming through.
45:30
Unidentified speaker: There will be lots of thoughts and emotions and quite complex processes going through people's minds.
45:37
Unidentified speaker: People will be tapping each other on the shoulder and saying, let's talk, and the next day, completely ignoring that person.
45:42
Unidentified speaker: Today they'll be completely ignoring that person, and today and tomorrow saying, I shouldn't have ignored you yesterday.
45:47
Unidentified speaker: Let's have a quick chat.
45:49
Unidentified speaker: This is going to go on for at least 14 days, and I wouldn't be surprised if, in fact, in some cases, the councils simply aren't ready to meet, despite the constitutional obligation that they have to be ready to meet after a very certain time.
46:02
Unidentified speaker: So I think this is going to be a very interesting couple of weeks.
46:05
Unidentified speaker: I wouldn't say anything until mayors have been sworn in.
46:11
Unidentified speaker: At that point, you'll really know what's going to happen.
46:14
Unidentified speaker: You're with the money show 20 minutes after 7.
46:17
Unidentified speaker: The Money Show, Small Business Focus.
46:21
Unidentified speaker: Small Business Focus is brought to you by Capitech.
46:24
Unidentified speaker: Start up or scale up with CapyTech, the business bank for everyone.
46:28
Unidentified speaker: So this morning I was on my way to the election centre and I realized it was taking me quite a long time.
46:32
Unidentified speaker: I was in the middle of uh morning rush hour traffic, and that was simply because of how difficult and expensive our transport systems are, wasteful too.
46:40
Unidentified speaker: If you think about how difficult it was for me to get here, think about how difficult it would be for someone who relies on minibus transport, which is in fact most of us.
46:48
Unidentified speaker: The point I'm getting at is how difficult it is to work.
46:52
Unidentified speaker: Loncredo in Twente is the managing director at Vantage Advisory.
46:55
Unidentified speaker: Uh Loncredo, good evening.
46:57
Unidentified speaker: Good to chat again on Small Business Workers.
46:59
Unidentified speaker: You've been looking at why it is so difficult for us to actually work.
47:03
Unidentified speaker: What do you mean by that?
47:07
Unidentified speaker: Uh Stephen, uh, good evening.
47:09
Unidentified speaker: Great talking to you again.
47:11
Unidentified speaker: Um, yes, you you ask bottom.
47:13
Unidentified speaker: Uh one of, I mean, as we try to question and find solutions to grow this economy uh from 1% uh to three to five percent, uh, we have to think about different factors that will contribute to that.
47:29
Unidentified speaker: And um my argument is centrally just around one of those factors that is very important, which is productivity and um competitiveness as a country.
47:40
Unidentified speaker: And therefore, that ends up really affecting how businesses are operating.
47:44
Unidentified speaker: Are we competitive enough for us to be able to export goods that can be, that can compete uh with other countries there?
47:52
Unidentified speaker: So, therefore, it becomes very central to say, look, if for us we want to grow this economy, we have to find a way that the environment where our businesses are operating at or on, they create an environment where it's not going to be difficult for us to work, it's not gonna be difficult for the SMEs to be able to produce goods that can be affordable at the end of the day.
48:16
Unidentified speaker: And one of those, for instance, you will recall last week, you know, and I mean it's a good example as well.
48:22
Unidentified speaker: Last week, there was quite a big issue in Cape Town.
48:26
Unidentified speaker: As a result of that, that was not only just a transport issue, it ended up becoming an economic issue because your Cape Town international airport was not able to operate as it's supposed to be, based on what one of the sectors that is not operating, well, the environment where it is actually situated, even the port itself.
48:45
Unidentified speaker: And therefore, that becomes a very much of a big economic cost that we have to look at.
48:50
Unidentified speaker: So for me, it's very important that we start to look and question whether are we really promoting productivity?
48:58
Unidentified speaker: Are we efficient enough?
48:59
Unidentified speaker: Are businesses really competitive?
49:02
Unidentified speaker: Can they compete at a global scale if the environment doesn't allow them to be?
49:09
Unidentified speaker: Okay, I mean, so many of these problems are deep-seated, and and this really is about the nature of an economy and governance.
49:15
Unidentified speaker: For an economy to grow, a certain group of things that are all interconnected to each other need to work.
49:20
Unidentified speaker: We all know the obvious ones electricity, your logistics, your railways, your roads, uh, your ports, all of these things.
49:26
Unidentified speaker: If you don't have them, they're called the enabling conditions.
49:29
Unidentified speaker: If you don't have enabling conditions, your economy is not going to grow, and a small business can't even get started.
49:35
Unidentified speaker: You could argue, Lorenzo, uh, this is what the local government elections are actually all about.
49:42
Unidentified speaker: Absolutely, Steven.
49:44
Unidentified speaker: Um the cost of the inefficiencies is not only something that affects only big businesses.
49:53
Unidentified speaker: Uh Steven.
49:54
Unidentified speaker: Um big businesses can be able to absorb some of those costs, right?
49:58
Unidentified speaker: If, for instance, there's no water, they can be able to have plan B.
50:02
Unidentified speaker: If there's no electricity, they can be able to uh get, I mean, plan B generate and all of that.
50:08
Unidentified speaker: But for small and medium businesses, those reserves are non-existent.
50:12
Unidentified speaker: So therefore, it becomes a huge economic cost that affects the growth of the SMEs.
50:20
Unidentified speaker: And therefore, I mean, I mean, the results, of course, in some of the metros, they do reflect that, I'm sure, as we start to see that there is a sense of the sentiment around the delivery of the basic infrastructure to the businesses.
50:36
Unidentified speaker: And at the end of the day, the people who really incur those costs are entrepreneurs themselves.
50:42
Unidentified speaker: And therefore, so we're looking forward to me just to get to see at the end of the day how the entrepreneurs themselves have come through and the voice that they will have uh going forward.
50:53
Unidentified speaker: We spend a lot of time worrying about our infrastructure, and we always look um at gross capital fixed formation.
51:00
Unidentified speaker: In other words, how much money is being spent on infrastructure?
51:03
Unidentified speaker: Luncledo, lots of promises on this over the years.
51:07
Unidentified speaker: But I mean, let's be blunt.
51:09
Unidentified speaker: We're not exactly seeing it in most of the country, are we?
51:13
Unidentified speaker: In other words, it's not going to get easier for a small business to start, is it?
51:19
Unidentified speaker: No, not not at all.
51:21
Unidentified speaker: Um, look, I've still been one of those infrastructure without infrastructure.
51:26
Unidentified speaker: Um as a business, it becomes extremely difficult for you uh to produce or to run a business or to be competitive.
51:33
Unidentified speaker: But one of those uh there's a report that I usually refer people to look at if we are progressing or not, especially at the municipal level as well.
51:43
Unidentified speaker: Your auditor general usually issues a report each and every year.
51:47
Unidentified speaker: Stevie, you'll recall that I mean for 225 initial years, um, out of 257 municipalities, only 39 were able to achieve clean audit, right?
51:58
Unidentified speaker: That is about 15% of municipalities that were able to achieve clean audits.
52:03
Unidentified speaker: And therefore, what does that say?
52:04
Unidentified speaker: At the end of the day, it means even the service delivery, therefore, the rest of those municipalities that are not able just to meet or run the administrative function in a proper way.
52:17
Unidentified speaker: Somehow somehow service delivery becomes a very, very uh big issue.
52:22
Unidentified speaker: For the countries that have developed, that have done pretty well, the investment that they've made in infrastructure is what has set them apart.
52:31
Unidentified speaker: I attended one of the events with Busar last month.
52:34
Unidentified speaker: I mean, one of the aspects raised a very important point about the investment, for instance, in some of the northern African countries, the likes of Morocco, how much they've treated infrastructure investment as a priority, and that has led them to a point where I mean the economy grew up about over 4%.
52:53
Unidentified speaker: Um, I mean, we've also seen uh Volkswagen in the Eastern Cape.
52:58
Unidentified speaker: I mean, they've been invested there for a long time and invested in all sorts of ways.
53:03
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, look, uh VW has been in the country for for years, and I mean we must commend them as well uh with the conviction that is coming in in the in the in the industry.
53:15
Unidentified speaker: But they've remained and they've committed to say, look, we will continue uh to invest in South Africa, we'll continue to really support some of the plants in the Eastern King.
53:24
Unidentified speaker: And it's one of those provinces that I've spoken about before we, I mean, a region before at a manufacturing level.
53:32
Unidentified speaker: It was one of those manufacturing places for South Africa, and therefore that has eroded for quite some time.
53:37
Unidentified speaker: But I mean, to have a multinational as well really having confidence in terms of where it's at and the investment they've made.
53:45
Unidentified speaker: I mean, from since 2011, over 10 billion has been invested within the value chain.
53:51
Unidentified speaker: And therefore, that is something that is very promising.
53:53
Unidentified speaker: And therefore, we have to continue then in that particular drive in terms of how to attract more or really incentivize some of the industries to stay in South Africa.
54:05
Unidentified speaker: At the end of the day, it's all about what we're talking about today, these elections and providing proper infrastructure and support and incentives to businesses.
54:14
Unidentified speaker: And therefore, we are able then to have an economy that is thriving.
54:17
Unidentified speaker: But without those incentives, the support, um, crime, you know, and all of these kind of things that are not being attended to urgently, we'll find ourselves in a very difficult corner in the next few years.
54:36
Unidentified speaker: The money show.
54:37
Unidentified speaker: Investment school.
54:40
Unidentified speaker: Twenty-three minutes now to eight the time tonight.
54:43
Unidentified speaker: Well, we are still live from the National Results Operations Centre.
54:47
Unidentified speaker: And to look around, you would think that nobody had anything better to do this Thursday evening.
54:52
Unidentified speaker: And that tells you how much people, how much time, effort, and resources people are spending on investing in the information that is coming through here, and therefore, really, on the future of our metros, on all of our councils and of the country.
55:05
Unidentified speaker: It's a fascinating way, I suppose, of looking at it.
55:09
Unidentified speaker: One of the features of the current time is what's happening in markets and what's happening in our economy.
55:17
Unidentified speaker: Now, if you were to look at American markets for just a moment, you would think that our economy would be roaring along.
55:23
Unidentified speaker: And in fact, that's not the case.
55:25
Unidentified speaker: If you'd be to look at the JSE, you would think that many people had a strong day in their businesses today.
55:30
Unidentified speaker: Uh, presumably most people didn't.
55:32
Unidentified speaker: Why is it that we're in a situation where markets and economies are decoupled?
55:39
Unidentified speaker: Uh, very interesting to remember, of course, uh what John Stopford said uh earlier today on the show.
55:45
Unidentified speaker: We were talking about uh the midterm results in the US and how important AI stocks have become in the US and their tech shares and the impact that has on the actual market indices.
55:56
Unidentified speaker: Tonight, Makwe Masalela is the founder and chief investment officer of Makwe Fund Managers.
56:01
Unidentified speaker: Grant Nade is portfolio manager at Benguela Global Fund Managers.
56:05
Unidentified speaker: Gentlemen, uh good evening to you both, and thank you very much indeed.
56:08
Unidentified speaker: Makwe, good evening.
56:09
Unidentified speaker: To someone who is not uh involved in markets and not involved in the economy, it's almost completely understandable to think, well, the JSE had a strong year like it did last year, therefore our economy should have a strong year.
56:24
Unidentified speaker: Why is there not such a strong linkage between the two?
56:29
Unidentified speaker: It used to, and good evening to you, and that is opposite, because ordinarily the market should be an indicator of the expectations that going forward we expect that things will be okay, hence we see the markets going up or maybe the markets going down.
56:46
Unidentified speaker: Meaning it gives you an indication of the expectation of the main economy.
56:51
Unidentified speaker: But yes, now lately it's a different story.
56:54
Unidentified speaker: It's no longer an indication of what has been happening in the main economy.
56:58
Unidentified speaker: And for various reasons, you know.
57:01
Unidentified speaker: I mean, I think people before, when they were getting involved in markets, they were mainly investing based on fundamentals.
57:08
Unidentified speaker: And fundamentals basically look into a macro environment and micro.
57:13
Unidentified speaker: That okay, if this is what is happening, then definitely this particular sector and all these particular companies in the particular sector should do well.
57:22
Unidentified speaker: So that was giving you more of an indication.
57:25
Unidentified speaker: But we know now late with markets that we've got all forms of investors, speculators, algorithms, you know, all these other things, you know, other uh decisions are made out of fear, you know, of losing out, stuff like that.
57:39
Unidentified speaker: So maybe hence we see the decoupling of the markets compared to what is happening with the main economy.
57:47
Unidentified speaker: But yes, that's how it used to be.
57:50
Unidentified speaker: And I think maybe we should find a way to be able to go back there if possible, but I doubt that markets will ever get back to what it used to be like before.
58:01
Unidentified speaker: So I'm fascinated by the fact that it used to be like that.
58:04
Unidentified speaker: Grant, would you agree with that?
58:05
Unidentified speaker: I mean, I'm really interested that it's sort of changed so much in, I presume, a relatively short period of time.
58:13
Unidentified speaker: Good evening, Stephen.
58:15
Unidentified speaker: Uh, I would I would partially agree.
58:17
Unidentified speaker: I think the the stock markets have mostly been constructed in the same way.
58:22
Unidentified speaker: You've had the biggest companies by earnings and market cap that comprise the index.
58:27
Unidentified speaker: The index is made up of the value of these companies.
58:30
Unidentified speaker: And the small people in the street, the smaller part of the economy uh isn't really reflected in the stock market.
58:37
Unidentified speaker: But I suppose it's been exaggerated more and more as globalization over the last few decades has really taken off.
58:44
Unidentified speaker: And now you've got these global mega caps, you've got companies earning money from every single country in the world, but only listed on one exchange, and that exchange benefits from those earnings.
58:55
Unidentified speaker: So yeah, I think there is a I think it's as extreme as it's ever been.
58:58
Unidentified speaker: That that's probably a 100% fair to say.
59:01
Unidentified speaker: Um, our market is unique as well in that so many of the companies listed on the JSC don't even earn money in South Africa or don't earn a lot of their money, or the majority in South Africa.
59:12
Unidentified speaker: So you can't judge our economy looking at the earnings of probably more than 60% of the of the JSC's earnings.
59:20
Unidentified speaker: Um things have really evolved, and uh I certainly think it's a function of the world we live in.
59:26
Unidentified speaker: Yes, I agree.
59:27
Unidentified speaker: We won't go back to the way it used to be.
59:31
Unidentified speaker: Um Makwe, I'm fascinated by the internationalization of it because it's on one level quite a good thing.
59:38
Unidentified speaker: You can live in South Africa, you can invest in international markets through uh the JSE, um, and that's that's very useful.
59:48
Unidentified speaker: Why is it that South Africa is so unique?
59:50
Unidentified speaker: And this leads me to my next point, which is where I'm going with this.
59:53
Unidentified speaker: Is does that mean that our JSE, our stock exchange, um is is is uh less coupled, more decoupled from our actual economy than in other places?
1:00:05
Unidentified speaker: Or to put it another way, is the difference between the US markets and the US economy as big as ours?
1:00:12
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, I think we're more decoupled, and I think for obvious reasons that you look into our big companies, you know, the Proxas, the NASPAS of this world, you're also looking into our mining companies.
1:00:23
Unidentified speaker: They managed to expand outside the country and they got involved in other countries and others bought shares in other companies, countries.
1:00:33
Unidentified speaker: For example, take your likes of Proxas, you know, or NASPAS with the exposure that they have in Tencent, you know.
1:00:39
Unidentified speaker: If anything happens with that company, that other side of the world, then that has an impact on the share per community.
1:00:47
Unidentified speaker: And but the point I think maybe I need to raise with current is that, you know, one way or the other, whether it's percom here or wherever in the world, that particular company operates in the main economy.
1:00:59
Unidentified speaker: I'm saying a share will go up, says NASPAS, because we think 10 cents is gonna maybe have good earnings or they discovered something new.
1:01:08
Unidentified speaker: But it's more on that do we really see the actual discovery being happening in that particular part of the world and generating the necessary earnings?
1:01:18
Unidentified speaker: I think most often than not, we don't tend to see that.
1:01:22
Unidentified speaker: We expect that it will ultimately happen.
1:01:26
Unidentified speaker: But yes, our guys, after making good money, they went out of the country and got involved in other countries, buying other companies, or maybe actually operating in those particular companies, buying a mine here and there.
1:01:39
Unidentified speaker: And some were not successful.
1:01:40
Unidentified speaker: We know others went into Africa, they bent their fingers, they had to come back home.
1:01:45
Unidentified speaker: But yeah, and maybe I'm not sure what it was, a question of sanctions at some point that guys didn't have an exposure for the quite for the longest time.
1:01:53
Unidentified speaker: And now when things started opening up, they had so much on their balance sheet and they decided to diversify because sometimes it's not for wrong reasons, it's trying to diversify your revenue streams.
1:02:06
Unidentified speaker: Um so if we look at the um nature of of of the sort of big uh bigger companies grants, so if you look at your NASPAS and your process and your mining houses, um is our is our market, is is the JSE and I know for example in in South Korea you have an entire Cosby index which is really sort of made up of two companies, not quite like that, but they have such a such a big impact.
1:02:31
Unidentified speaker: Um do are we in a situation where we have a much bigger disproportionate impact of a few big internationally exposed companies are our index than most other places?
1:02:43
Unidentified speaker: It certainly feels like that, Stephen, and you can take last year as an example.
1:02:47
Unidentified speaker: The mining stocks drove our index up 40 odd percent.
1:02:51
Unidentified speaker: The rest of the economy barely grew.
1:02:53
Unidentified speaker: The GDP last year was about just over 1% in South Africa.
1:02:57
Unidentified speaker: Yet the stock market had an unbelievable year, and that was driven by the commodity prices, and all of those are set by things happening overseas, um, and the Rand dollar exchange rate, and so uh and a lot of mines overseas as well, not even in South Africa.
1:03:11
Unidentified speaker: So there certainly is a large dichotomy if you add other dual listed, like you said, Naspace Process, Richmond, uh, and BTI British American Tobacco.
1:03:20
Unidentified speaker: I mean, not even 10% of their earnings come from SA.
1:03:23
Unidentified speaker: Same with Richmond.
1:03:24
Unidentified speaker: So we've probably got in the space of the mining stocks and a handful, Naspace Process, and a couple of other stocks.
1:03:32
Unidentified speaker: Already you're talking close to 50% of earnings that don't really have anything to do with South Africa.
1:03:38
Unidentified speaker: But I must say that we shouldn't be too quick to criticize that because fortunately every South African has the chance to buy into some of that benefit and get that diversification.
1:03:47
Unidentified speaker: And it's really helped the sort of pension fund system, if you like, provided you're in the loop.
1:03:54
Unidentified speaker: No, well, I'm gonna get to that in the loop because there's a there's a whole thing going on with with sort of our inside-outside economy.
1:04:01
Unidentified speaker: Um, Makwe, uh, an interesting point that's come out of this conversation is that at some point a company has to be involved in the real economy.
1:04:08
Unidentified speaker: And I would like to make this suggestion that in the US, the AI stocks that we've seen are, yes, hugely attractive, massive valuations, but not really involved in the real economy because they're all involved in what might happen to a large extent.
1:04:25
Unidentified speaker: And I'm not saying that it's a bubble, but certainly we've seen some markets entering almost correction territory quite recently because of concerns about this.
1:04:34
Unidentified speaker: So you have to be anchored in something, even as a market.
1:04:38
Unidentified speaker: Does that still hold that a market does, that a market and the companies on it and the share valuations have to be anchored in something?
1:04:46
Unidentified speaker: And if they're not, if it turns out the AI companies in the US are not anchored in something, what happens then?
1:04:53
Unidentified speaker: Then it's going to be priced for perfection, and one slight mistake, you'll see that crashing.
1:04:59
Unidentified speaker: Because even before the AI companies, remember the IT stocks, you know, IT companies mainly they had the human capital, the IP more than anything, and they were mainly anchored around that.
1:05:11
Unidentified speaker: And now, compared to maybe a company that can sell something physically or mining something, that tomorrow you can have something tangible or more of an asset.
1:05:22
Unidentified speaker: So it has to have a bit of a caution.
1:05:24
Unidentified speaker: And as I said, Eda, you are right, you know, one way or the other, a company has to operate in the main economy, you know, directly or indirectly, because how else will that company be making money?
1:05:36
Unidentified speaker: They have to have something that they offer people to be able to sell it.
1:05:40
Unidentified speaker: And yes, we can also see that people get to reprice things.
1:05:45
Unidentified speaker: Look into AI, you know, that it's important that the distinction between the demand, what is still there, of whatever that you will be selling, versus our expectation of what is it that we'll be expecting uh what you call it, spending the money on, you know, and the financing thereof.
1:06:03
Unidentified speaker: So that distinction matters because sometimes we have to differentiate between is there a real demand of that particular product or service, you know, versus what we think.
1:06:14
Unidentified speaker: Is it the hype or is it kind of how much we think you'll make money going forward?
1:06:18
Unidentified speaker: The point is, I agree with you, Steven, you have to operate one way or the other in the main economy.
1:06:25
Unidentified speaker: And main economy will include sending things to the moon as a SpaceX.
1:06:30
Unidentified speaker: You operate some.
1:06:33
Unidentified speaker: The moon.
1:06:33
Unidentified speaker: Why are you thinking so close, Makwe?
1:06:35
Unidentified speaker: Makwe Masalele is the founder and chief investment officer of Makwe Fund Managers.
1:06:40
Unidentified speaker: Grant Nader is portfolio manager on Benguela Global Fund Managers.
1:06:42
Unidentified speaker: We'll discuss more on this.
1:06:44
Unidentified speaker: Uh, the boom in the stock market, why it doesn't mean much for the local economy.
1:06:48
Unidentified speaker: An important conversation, I think.
1:06:50
Unidentified speaker: You're with the money show, you're with investment school, still live from the National Results Operations Centre.
1:06:54
Unidentified speaker: It's 10 minutes today.
1:06:56
Unidentified speaker: The Money Show.
1:06:57
Unidentified speaker: Investment School.
1:06:59
Unidentified speaker: Nine minutes to eight the time.
1:07:02
Unidentified speaker: The uh big decoupling that we see between markets and the real economy.
1:07:05
Unidentified speaker: Makwe Masaledes, founder, chief investment officer of Makwe Fund Managers, Grant Nader, his portfolio manager, Penguela Global Fund Managers.
1:07:12
Unidentified speaker: Uh, Grant, I've been thinking a little bit about the nature of our society.
1:07:15
Unidentified speaker: We were talking about pension funds earlier.
1:07:17
Unidentified speaker: Um, you can, of course, through a pension fund invest in um shares in South Africa in companies listed on the JSE that are then operating somewhere else.
1:07:27
Unidentified speaker: But um in some markets, the US is a good example, millions of people really participate directly in the stock market.
1:07:33
Unidentified speaker: They buy and sell shares.
1:07:36
Unidentified speaker: We don't do that here.
1:07:38
Unidentified speaker: Is that uh add to this disconnect?
1:07:42
Unidentified speaker: It means that if the market goes up or down, that doesn't actually affect the wealth of South Africans for good or ill.
1:07:49
Unidentified speaker: Yes, Stephen, uh good evening.
1:07:51
Unidentified speaker: Uh you know, I think that's 100% right.
1:07:53
Unidentified speaker: So the US is at record household um stock investment levels.
1:07:57
Unidentified speaker: Having said that, it's still highly concentrated.
1:07:59
Unidentified speaker: The top 10% of people in the US own 88% of the stock market.
1:08:04
Unidentified speaker: However, they are the big spenders.
1:08:06
Unidentified speaker: They the stock market goes up, you get the wealth effect, they've all got more money, at least in their net asset value, and you see them spending and supporting that economy.
1:08:15
Unidentified speaker: South Africa, unfortunately, is woefully underinvested.
1:08:18
Unidentified speaker: Uh, and it's of course because of our large informal economy, our large unemployment.
1:08:22
Unidentified speaker: Uh, and I think it's a real problem because you have the is they are not able to benefit from this potential wealth creation, from the benefit of saving.
1:08:31
Unidentified speaker: It's something we really need to work on.
1:08:33
Unidentified speaker: Uh, and I think it is a massive disadvantage.
1:08:35
Unidentified speaker: And just to take a simple example, if you took a Shopright listed company and they went and opened a store next to every spaza shop or every cash and carry uh around the country and put those companies out of business, you'd get a lot of informal job losses and you'd get a lot of people losing money or um, let's say jobs jobs lost.
1:08:56
Unidentified speaker: While ShopRite's earnings could grow.
1:08:57
Unidentified speaker: They could cut costs, they could lay off staff and grow their earnings.
1:09:00
Unidentified speaker: Those holding those shares could do well and could benefit from that.
1:09:04
Unidentified speaker: But that's a microcosm of the broader economy and that impact, that negative impact that you're not seeing happening at the same time.
1:09:11
Unidentified speaker: So it's a structural problem and it's uh it's obviously house uh inequality in any country is is a similar problem, but we have extremes in South Africa that we need to really think about.
1:09:24
Unidentified speaker: Sure, I'd never thought about it like that.
1:09:26
Unidentified speaker: That's a really interesting point, Grant.
1:09:27
Unidentified speaker: Uh yeah, fascinating to think about it in that way.
1:09:31
Unidentified speaker: Um Makwe, if we then look at our current situation, we have a market that seems to be decoupled primarily from our economy.
1:09:39
Unidentified speaker: Um you made the point earlier it would never it would never go back.
1:09:43
Unidentified speaker: Um and I'm and I am beginning to see why it probably never will go back, unless there's some kind of massive economic boom related to some kind of investment on markets, and sort of they start to drive each other, which maybe is what's happening in the US with AI, um, like this is never going to change.
1:10:01
Unidentified speaker: It is probably always going to be this way.
1:10:03
Unidentified speaker: The horses bolted.
1:10:06
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, unfortunately so.
1:10:07
Unidentified speaker: But as Grant said, you know, the more people start understanding the market, the importance, and also have the know-how, and also more importantly, stop associating the market with the rich and famous.
1:10:17
Unidentified speaker: Also be made aware that they can be participants themselves, then probably that will help as well.
1:10:23
Unidentified speaker: And hence we will find a situation where you have very few people like Become here, I think less than 5%, you know.
1:10:30
Unidentified speaker: We've got we have retail investors, then the rest institutional investors.
1:10:35
Unidentified speaker: But the main thing here is if people understand that their actions are the ones that basically at the end of the day drive the economy.
1:10:42
Unidentified speaker: And I don't see why we couldn't be more or less like the US, you know.
1:10:47
Unidentified speaker: We happen to be part of those economies that where more than 60% of our economy is driven by consumer demand.
1:10:55
Unidentified speaker: So we as consumers, we are the very same investors if we understand our behavior that this is actually what is going to be driving the market.
1:11:02
Unidentified speaker: I mean, the economy then ultimately drives the market because we'll see the earnings of those particular companies going up, and then the market will then also see their share prices going up.
1:11:14
Unidentified speaker: Um, Grant, we've been talking um all the way through about how sort of bad this is, um, and it is uh primarily, and I think you're you're you your and Makway's point is absolutely correct about not being able to share the wealth.
1:11:26
Unidentified speaker: But as I talk to you now, I've just happened to glance at the NASDAQ.
1:11:29
Unidentified speaker: The Nasdaq is down nearly six percent on the day.
1:11:33
Unidentified speaker: This is all about really AI.
1:11:36
Unidentified speaker: Um there can be a plus side because if you were to run an economy in anywhere like that, the the pits, the the the the the the heels and troughs would just be too much.
1:11:44
Unidentified speaker: Um so I mean it's not always the bad thing, is what I'm trying to ask.
1:11:49
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, I guess there's the the the people need to understand the volatility and the but I would say overall they've gained a lot more uh over the last couple of years from AI than they than they've lost in the last couple of weeks, where they have felt pain, but the bigger picture uh growth is is really there.
1:12:06
Unidentified speaker: Um and I think what I would also say is we've painted it as bad, but in reality, the broader South African savings pot is better off for this foreign um earnings and these these heavily weighted companies on the JSC because they've contributed to the broader collective savings, which would have been the included and excluded in the economy, would have been there anyway.
1:12:28
Unidentified speaker: But at least you've got a broader savings pool which ultimately trickles down into the economy in a in a more indirect way, but overall it's still better than having a small, uh irrelevant stock market that's not creating wealth for anybody in the country.
1:12:45
Unidentified speaker: Grant Nader, Portfolio Manager, Penguela Global Fund Managers, Makwe Masalela, founder and chief investment officer at Makwe Fund Managers.
1:12:52
Unidentified speaker: Thank you to you both uh for your time tonight.
1:12:54
Unidentified speaker: I found that really useful um and uh helps me to understand issues that I hadn't actually understood before.
1:13:00
Unidentified speaker: Thank you.
1:13:01
Unidentified speaker: Both uh Grant and Makwe, of course, for you with you on Investment School on the money show tonight.
1:13:07
Unidentified speaker: So
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-GGUF:UD-Q4_K_XL. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.

More from The Money Show

The Money Show

Why MTN wants to buy Telkom & M&G pushes for major Spar board shake-up

Episode discussion: MTN-Telkom acquisition talks, M&G Spar board battle, PPC results, and port crisis discussed

Speakers’ claims: Stephen Grootes interviews Dobek Pater about early-stage discussions for MTN to acquire Telkom, citing regulatory shifts following the Vodacom-MASIF deal. Damon Buss of M&G outlines efforts to appoint new directors to Spar to restore profitability, while Sierra Mbarat analyzes operational challenges. Matthias Cardarelli reports on PPC Cement's earnings growth and concerns over dumped imports, and Dr. Juanita Marais details the Durban port crisis under new operator ICTSI. James Hodge explains Competition Commission investigation processes, and Wandile Sekobolo discusses agricultural trade policy.

Telecommunications M&ACorporate GovernanceCement Industry
1h 11m1 assets25 claims to verify
The Money Show

The Best of The Money Show: The cost of CEO scandals and SA's athlete funding crisis

Episode discussion: South African athlete funding crises, deposit insurance, and CEO scandal risks discussed

Speakers’ claims: Stephen Grootes and Gorbilan Gulville discuss systemic governance failures in South African sports federations, citing Tatjana Smith's switch to the Netherlands and modest government allocations. Warren Ingram outlines the new Corporation for Deposit Insurance, explaining the R100,000 guarantee and timeshare exit strategies. Andrew Woodburn analyzes how CEO scandals like Jinsen Huang's erode investor confidence and corporate governance. Malungelo Zilimbola shares his background at Mazi Asset Management, advocating for diverse hiring and private sector infrastructure investment amid government capacity issues.

South African Sports GovernanceDeposit InsuranceCorporate Governance
53 min0 assets14 claims to verify
All insights