Revolve Commercial Property Podcast Australia

Case study: How due diligence on lease terms and land tax led to a $102K discount on a Clayton South industrial property

21 min Listen to the original Episode page
Commercial PropertyDue DiligenceLease AnalysisReal Estate InvestmentProperty ValuationCash FlowLand TaxNegotiation

Summary

Mish Daniel presents a case study of a commercial property purchase in Clayton South, Victoria, where his team negotiated a $102,000 (7.3%) discount off the $1.4 million asking price. The discount was achieved by identifying two critical discrepancies in the Information Memorandum: the tenant was incorrectly listed as responsible for land tax, and the lease option term was shorter than advertised. The property, a 398 sqm industrial warehouse, was purchased for $1.298 million, yielding 5.6% on the purchase price with $73,000 in annual net rent. Daniel emphasizes that Information Memorandums are advertising tools rather than binding contracts and advises investors to verify all lease terms, tax liabilities, and financials independently. He notes that while the property offers a 'set and forget' profile with a long-term national tenant, the primary value comes from accurate due diligence rather than market timing.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    A new lease with a conservative 3% annual rent increase may reflect negotiations made prior to significant market shifts, such as a federal budget.

    Mish Daniel · 4:24

  2. 2
    figure, every single fact. And the document tells you about the property, the tenant, the rental, the lease, and all things that make it looked look attractive to an investor. You have to understand that the information memorandum is there as a piece of information to sell. And that's what it does. It sells to you. It is not a binding contract, it is an advertising piece of material. Okay. It's an advertising brochure.

    Mish Daniel · 7:05

Episode sections

  1. 0:11 – 2:17

    Introduction and Case Study Overview

    Mish Daniel introduces a case study where his team negotiated a $102,000 discount on a commercial property in Clayton South, Victoria. He emphasizes that the discount resulted from finding two discrepancies in the selling agent's paperwork regarding land tax and lease terms, rather than market conditions.

  2. 2:17 – 4:24

    Client Objectives and Property Basics

    The client sought a 'set and forget' investment with a long-term tenant, good cash flow, and incremental rent increases. The property is a 398 sqm industrial warehouse in Clayton South, advertised at $1.4 million, occupied by a national trade supply tenant with over 30 years of trading history.

  3. 4:24 – 6:25

    Lease Structure and Location Analysis

    The property features a new lease with a conservative 3% annual rent increase, likely negotiated before the federal budget. The location is supported by established industrial businesses and major logistics companies like Toll and Magin Logistics, indicating strong commercial activity.

  4. 6:25 – 9:52

    Due Diligence: Information Memorandum Discrepancies

    Daniel warns that Information Memorandums (IM) are advertising tools, not binding contracts. His team found two critical errors: the IM stated the tenant was responsible for land tax (it is the owner's responsibility) and the lease had a 5+5 year option (it was actually a 3-year option).

  5. 9:52 – 14:24

    Negotiation and Financial Outcome

    Based on the corrected lease term (reducing secured rental from 10 to 8 years) and the land tax liability, the team negotiated the price down from $1.4 million to $1.298 million, a 7.3% discount. The property was purchased for cash, yielding 5.6% on the purchase price with $73,000 annual net rent.

  6. 14:24 – 16:12

    Financing Assumptions and Cash Flow

    For a typical 65% Loan-to-Value Ratio (LVR) purchase, the cash deposit would be $454,000 plus 6-8% in purchasing costs. The projected cash flow for a financed scenario is estimated at $11,193, though Daniel notes this is a projection, not a guaranteed return.

  7. 16:12 – 20:45

    Key Takeaways for Investors

    Daniel advises investors to: 1) Define their investment goals clearly; 2) Scrutinize all documents (lease, strata, financials) rather than relying on agent figures; 3) Verify that the numbers work by checking income, expenses, and lease terms before committing.

Claims worth verifying

The team negotiated $102,000 off the asking price of a commercial property in Clayton South, Victoria.

Mish Daniel ·0:31

How to verify: Check the property sale records or the specific case study details provided by Revolve Commercial; verify the asking price of $1.4 million and the final price of $1.298 million. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The property is a 398 square meter industrial warehouse in Clayton South, Victoria.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·3:45

How to verify: Check the land title registry or the property listing for the specific address and land size in Clayton South, Victoria. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The property was advertised for $1.4 million.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·3:45

How to verify: Review the original marketing materials or information memorandum for the property sale. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The tenant is a national trade supply business that has been trading at the location for more than 30 years.

Mish Daniel ·4:04

How to verify: Check the business registration records or the lease agreement for the tenant's name and start date of occupancy. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The lease includes a 3% annual rent increase.

Mish Daniel ·4:44

How to verify: Review the executed lease agreement for the rent escalation clause. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The Information Memorandum (IM) incorrectly stated that the tenant was responsible for land tax, when it is the owner's responsibility.

Mish Daniel ·7:31

How to verify: Check the local council land tax records and the lease agreement to confirm who is legally liable for the land tax payment. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The IM stated the tenant had a 5+5 year option (10-year lease), but the actual option was a 3-year option.

Mish Daniel ·8:48

How to verify: Review the executed lease agreement to confirm the actual option period and compare it to the IM. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The property was purchased for $1.298 million, a 7.3% discount from the $1.4 million asking price.

Mish Daniel ·10:31

How to verify: Check the contract of sale and settlement statement for the final purchase price and calculate the percentage discount. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The annual net rent was $73,000 with recoverable outgoings, resulting in a passing yield of 5.6%.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·11:52

How to verify: Review the rent roll and outgoings statements; calculate the yield by dividing the annual net rent by the purchase price ($1.298 million). For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

For a 65% Loan-to-Value Ratio (LVR), the cash deposit would be $454,000 before stamp duty and purchasing costs.

Mish Daniel ·14:37

How to verify: Calculate 35% of the purchase price ($1.298 million) to verify the deposit amount; check current stamp duty rates in Victoria for the specific property value. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify the actual lease option terms against the executed lease agreement, not just the Information Memorandum.
  • Confirm local council records or state revenue office guidelines regarding land tax liability for commercial properties to determine if it is the owner's or tenant's responsibility.
  • Review the Information Memorandum for any disclaimers stating it is not a binding contract or offer.
  • Calculate the net operating income by independently verifying all income streams and operating expenses, including insurance, maintenance, and management fees.
  • Check the tenant's financial stability and trading history through public records or credit reports.
  • Compare the yield and price per square meter against recent comparable sales in the Clayton South industrial submarket.
  • Assess the impact of the 3% annual rent increase clause on long-term cash flow projections relative to market rental growth.
  • Review the property's zoning and permitted uses to ensure the current tenant's operations are compliant.
Full transcriptexpand

0:11Mish Daniel: Welcome back to the show. I'm your host, Mish Daniel, of the Revolve Commercial Property Podcast Australia. So imagine getting $102,000 a hundred and two thousand dollars. discount before you even start buying a commercial property. Well, that's exactly what we do. We negotiated $102,000 off the asking price of a commercial property, and I'm going to show you how. Now that's a great result, right? But before we even got to the negotiation, we found two things in the paperwork. that didn't match what the selling agent was advertising. One about the land tax, and the other about the tenant's lease. Now,

1:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if

1:02Mish Daniel: you're buying a commercial property, these two things are absolutely, absolutely, you need to get right. And this is all about the numbers, guys. This is all about the figures. And that's what commercial property is all about. Because you can buy a beautiful property in a great area with a fantastic tenant. But if you haven't checked the lease properly, you could be buying yourself one massive problem. If you haven't checked the numbers, that's exactly where you're going to get stuck. And that's exactly what we do for you is we do the numbers. We do our homework before we go out. and buy those properties.

1:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

1:41Mish Daniel: today I'm going to take you through this actual commercial property purchase in Clayton, South Victoria, something that we've done very recently. We managed to negotiate a whacking 100,000 off the price, 102,000 to be exact. And I'm going to show you exactly what we found, what we negotiated, how the numbers stacked up for. our client, and what you should really be checking before you put your own money into a commercial property. All right, so let's just dive straight in. What did our client want? Something relatively set and forget without too much management. Now, this is very important. You need to know what you purchase. you're purchasing before you go out and purchase it. Our client was looking for uh a long-term tenant, good cash flow, uh, good rental income with incremental increases over time. He wanted to know that the property was gonna uh be making him money over time and not earning him money. All right. So um let's just say this was a set and forget. And I mean, I don't mean like when you're buying a set and forget property, that you're going and you

2:57you're just leaving it and forgetting about it. Okay. You need that good management behind it. You've still got to make sure that the tenant is paying, that the property is maintained, and that everything is operating as it should be, right? But the idea is that you've got a good asset with a good tenant and a lease that's structured to support your purpose, your growth, your plan, your strategy.

3:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

3:24Mish Daniel: this is where investors have to be very, very careful because you don't just go out there and buy any old commercial property, you see. You need to know exactly what you're buying. You need to understand the area, the tenant, the lease, the income, and most importantly. you need to make sure that the property is actually suited to what you're wanting to achieve.

3:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So,

3:45Mish Daniel: what did we find? Um, an industrial warehouse in Clayton South, South Victoria. The property was 398 square meters, um, and it was advertised for 1.4 million.

3:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It

4:00Mish Daniel: had a national trade supply as the tenant. So

4:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh

4:04Mish Daniel: great asset, good tenant. Uh the business had been trading there for more than 30 years. Bonus. Uh, and that is something that we love and something that we like to investigate. An established business with a long trading history, uh, that's a real positive sign. Uh, but it doesn't mean that it stops you from doing your homework. You still got to do your due diligence on the tenant, on the lease, and all the structures around it. You need to understand how it works. In this case, the property had a new lease. So we needed to question why. The rental increase was only 3% per year, which is quite conservative in today's market. However, bearing in mind that this was done before. government had uh had their federal budget. Now, think about it.

4:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): If

4:58Mish Daniel: you buy a commercial property for income, you want to know that you're earning every single day. But you also want to know and you need to understand what's happening to the income in three years, five years, and beyond. Okay. Um, and having fixed increases written into the leaf lease gives you a clear picture of what your cash flow is going to look like uh as your rent grows. The property was also in Clayton, which is near very established industrial businesses. Uh lots of commercial activity, including the Monash Precinct, Visi. Clayton South, Toll, Magin logistics, those are all plus signs. Alright. So we had that property that was we're looking at that property and we're saying, okay, this is worth investing. It's ticking all the boxes. We go through the list, tick, tick, tick. Um, good tenant, uh, surrounded by supported businesses on a great track traffic arterial, easily accessible.

6:08But, and this is the important part, just because the property looks good on paper doesn't mean that you should just rush out and buy it, do your homework. You've got to get into the detail, drill down, and that's exactly what we did. Now,

6:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): this

6:25Mish Daniel: is where it gets interesting. and this is where you need to know your stuff. If you're buying a commercial property, the selling agent will generally give you what they want you to hear, and that is the information memorandum. Now, I'm not saying every single information memorandum is incorrect, but question every single figure, every single fact. And the document tells you about the property, the tenant, the rental, the lease, and all things that make it looked look attractive to an investor. You have to understand that the information memorandum is there as a piece of information to sell. And that's what it does. It sells to you. It is not a binding contract, it is an advertising piece of material. Okay. It's an advertising brochure. They're not necessarily going to tell

7:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you all

7:20Mish Daniel: the things that you need to know. So we went through the paperwork, we started the due diligence process, had a look at the IEM information memorandum, and we found two discrepancies. Number one, land tax. The land tax in the IM was. supposedly the responsibility of the tenant. Well, actually, it wasn't. When we checked,

7:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it

7:46Mish Daniel: was the owner's responsibility. That made a huge difference on the bottom line. Why is this important?

7:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): If

7:53Mish Daniel: you're working out the numbers and you're assuming that the tenant is paying those particular expenses and they're not, that is falling into your budget. So you need to take that into consideration and deduct that off your net income. All right. So your calculation changes on that basis. If you're looking at this property and it's maybe a 6.5% yielding property, looks great. When you rework those those figures, they come down. And the question is, is it still a good asset? So let's just say you check things before you buy. Don't assume anything that's written, like I said, in the IAM, and you look a little bit deeper. Then we found a second discrepancy, and that was the lease option. So in the IAM, IM, it said that the tenant had a five plus five year option. That effectively is a 10. year lease. They'd just come into the

8:54commercial asset, where in fact we found out that the option was a three year option. Now, this is where it affects your whale and it affects your valuation because effectively you're going from 10 years down to eight years of secured rental.

9:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

9:13Mish Daniel: when you're buying this commercial, property, you want a long term as long as possible on your rental, even if it's a second option. That five years, they're saying five years, actually, it's three years. It's not right. Okay. How does that affect you? Let's have a look at

9:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.

9:32Mish Daniel: The lease is structured in such a way that it can affect your bottom line, it can affect your future income. And you don't know, let's face it, you don't know what's going to be happening in the future, right? Um, so

9:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): we

9:46Mish Daniel: looked at these two details, they were very different as advertised, and we decided let's keep moving with this property because getting things wrong can cost you big time, so we need to get things right, all right? So we went back. in and we looked at the purchase price. Now bearing in mind that the purchase price was 1.4 million. We started out at 1.4 million. We negotiated the price down to 1.298 million based on our findings and substantiating our discounted price. So that's 100%. $102,000 off the asking price, approximately 7.3%. That's a substantial reduction, don't you think? What would you prefer to pay? No brainer, stupid question. But there you go. Everybody wants a good price and a good reduction. So just before, just because you've negotiated a discount. discount doesn't automatically mean that you've bought a good investment. You need to keep investigating. You need to keep doing your due diligence. Um, yes, you negotiate

11:01100,000 off the property, but if you've bought the wrong asset in the wrong area with the wrong lease, you've still got yourself a problem. So you can't just stop there. You need to look further, dig deeper.

11:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We

11:18Mish Daniel: never get carried away with a discount. It's a bonus. Okay. It's a um it most certainly is to our advantage, but we got to make sure that everything else stacks up. In this case, we check the lease, identified the discrepancies, assessed the property against what our client was looking for. and

11:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): we

11:40Mish Daniel: were able to negotiate a lower price. Happy days. Let's have a look at what that means for the numbers. So

11:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): we

11:47Mish Daniel: purchased the property at 1.298. So it's almost 1.3 million.

11:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The

11:52Mish Daniel: annual net rent toll was 73,000 with recoverable outgoings. And that gave us a passing yield of 5.6%. Not too bad, being Victoria, there's growth in that great asset, a class asset, great tenant. In other words, the annual rent income compared to what we paid for the property before allowing financial and other relevant costs was fair enough. And remember, 3% annual increase, that's going to give you growth over that period of time. Come to the end of the lease at the end of the five-year, we could do a lease assessment, so a rental review and retweak where the market is at that time. Okay. So in terms of the finance, what does it look like? In this case, the buyer was buying cash. So he was happy to put that cash in, uh, which means that the buyer's buying bricks and mortar in an area that is gentrifying, growing.

13:05Plus he's getting that incremental increase on the value, which is going to push his yield up. Um and knowing that he's um buying a property that is giving him $73,000 in cash flow per annum plus GST and fully recoverable outgoings. Bonus. So you're buying bricks and mortar, you've got an asset that's growing in value, you're getting $73,000 cash per annum, addon and you've got recoverable outgoings. And that is the difference, guys. of buying an asset where you've got bricks and mortar with a roof over the top that you can do stuff with. It's very different to buying shares, let's say. And we've we've spoken about that before. I'm not going to go into it now. However, yeah, very good to have something like this in your portfolio. If you do have shares already, this is a great opportunity to. have a to diversify your portfolio let's say uh if you've got shares you're relying on somebody else doing all the calculations for you um if it's your own bricks and mortar you're in control that's what we like about commercial property so for the purpose of the case study I'm gonna show you because on average

14:24most people are gonna take a loan on this property and your average loan would be 65% LVR, which is loan to value ratio. All right. At 65% of the price, which would have been financed, that's 35% that you would have to put in as a cash deposit. Um, and how that works is it would be $454,000. before stab duty and before all your purchasing costs. And generally we work on purchasing costs generally between 6 and 8%, depending on the type of asset. And that covers all your fees, all your costs. All right. So the assumption used for this property and the projected cash flow for this would be $11,193. Now, bearing in mind, this is a property that you've purchased at 1.2 million, thereabout. So you're still coming out ahead of the curve on this one. Bearing in mind that is a projection. It's not a guaranteed return. There's all sorts of other factors that affect that.

15:31There's uh costs, there's tax, there's considerations that you need to take into account. But the point is. you've got a commercial property, bricks and mortar, with an established tenant that's been there for 30 years. They've got a long lease, fixed incremental increases, and you've managed to get that property for a hundred and two thousand dollars less than where the market is asking. Um you've got cash flow on this beautiful investment, and you know. you're not just looking at it and saying, hey, that looks like a great deal. I'll buy that. No, we've actually worked the numbers, we've done the hard yards, we've got you a discount, and now you're understanding more about what you're buying. And that's how I believe commercial property investing should be approached. So three things I want you to take away from this case. study. Number one, know what you're looking for. What do you want? Okay, what

16:32is the asset? What do you want to achieve basically out of what you want? Our client wanted a commercial property with a long term tenant, incremental increases, and that's exactly what we went out looking for. Um, and we chased the property down, scanned the market, gave him something that we need. know will work long term. Number two, check the lease, check the outgoings, check the strata. I cannot emphasize this enough. Don't just rely on what the agent is giving you. You need data. Data never lies. You need the actual facts. You need to read the documents. You actually need to scroll. scrutinize the documents. And I'm not just talking about the lease. I'm talking about the due diligence, the strata, the history, the the um, the the notes of past history of what's happening in um on strata management and uh

17:32financial um statements. You need to scrutinize it so that you know what your future looks like. Okay. And that's exactly what we did here. Make sure the numbers work. Number three, don't get excited about a property just because it's a great tenant and everything looks rosy. Look at your rental income. Look at the expenses, finance, lease. Scrutinize it. Drill down. Get as much information. Do as much due diligence as you can. You want to avoid buying a great asset that looks good but actually is not so good when you scrutinize it. So there you have it. A commercial property advertised at 1.4 million, purchased at 1.298 million. That's $102,000 of the asking price. How we did it? We used used data, we used the lease. We used all the information that we went out

18:35hunting for in order to negotiate. All right. But the most important part of this deal isn't just the discount. It was doing the homework, checking the documents, understanding the investment. before committing our clients' money. And that's something that we are very particular about at Revolve Commercial. We work for the buyer, we don't work for the seller. Okay. And we only buy properties for our clients that I would buy for myself. Would I buy that deal? 100%. I'd buy it all day. Great deal. It's a fantastic deal. to put in a portfolio. Relatively set and forget. You don't have to worry about it. You've got good management that's running that property, a reliable tenant that's just paying your rent every single month.

19:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

19:27Mish Daniel: if you're interested in seeing types of commercial properties, opportunities that we come across, look at our portfolio picks. Go to the website. Uh, We share opportunities in the VR. VIP list every single month. Click on the link, check it out, and reach out. If you're looking for help and you want to know more about securing a high-performing commercial property, visit Revolve Commercial or send us your questions. Go straight to Ask Mesh. And guys, don't forget if you've enjoyed this podcast and it's bringing value to your life. and you'd like to know more. We are constantly trying to bring value in education. This is all about education. I want to give you as much as possible. So hit subscribe. Keep building that cash flow. Let me know what you want to listen to. Give us comments, please. Please give us comments. Let us know if you've liked what you're listening to. If you've got any questions, reach out. And we'll see you on the next episode. Till then, cheers.

This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights